ASSIGNMENT COVER
Course code: MBA 510
Course name: Law and Economics for Global Business
Assignment title: Country Report – The expansion of BCD in FYROM
Instructor’s name: Mr. Vesselin Todorov
Student’s name: Georgia Lalakou
Date: April 21, 2014
Comments:
Grade: /100
Country Report
2
Country Report
Georgia Lalakou
MBA 510, Law and Economics for Global Business
Vesselin Todorov
Country Report
April 21, 2014
Country Report
3
Contents Page
1.0 Introduction 4
2.0 Evaluation of the Market of Skopje 5
3.0 Advantages and Entry Opportunities in the Market of Skopje 12
4.0 Selections of the Entry Strategy in the Market of Skopje 14
5.0 Emerging Market Potential Index 17
References 20
Country Report
4
1.0 Introduction
This paper focuses on the process of FDI through the study of the company BCD
Travel and its intention to enter the market of Skopje. Essentially this essay will be a
country report, which will seek to identify and evaluate the specific intent of the
company to enter this market. Specifically, the development of this theme will be based
on four sections of analysis.
The first section will study the external environment of the country, with special
reference to the economic and political data to be taken into account by the company in
order to enter the market. The second section will discuss the advantages and
opportunities of company by expanding its activities in the selected country. Then, there
will be an evaluation of the selected method of entering the market and of the risks that
need to be considered by engaging in this country. Finally the author will describe all
the elements that will influence the final decision to enter the market.
Country Report
5
2.0 Evaluation of the Market of Skopje
The market analysis of Skopje which will describe the economic and legal conditions
of the market to be taken into account before the company enters the market of Skopje
is the STEP analysis. Specifically, according to this model, the Skopje market is
analyzed as follows (Thompson, & Strickland, 2001):
Economic environment: Initially and before the analysis of the economic factors
affecting the operation of the market, a table with the key financial figures of the
country for the years 2012-2013 will be presented, which should be taken into account
by the company when entering the market of Skopje.
Table 2.1 Key financial figures of the market of Skopje
Skopje EU
GDP 462,8 16,584
GDP growth rate -0.3% 0.1
Industrial production
growth rate
-7,4% -1.6%
Unemployment 28,7% 12.1%
Revenue budget in dinars
and Euros
138 dinars
2,23 Euros
139 540.5
Source: Secretary of Finance and Trade, Greek Republic (2012). Annual Report for the
Economy of FYROM and it Bilateral Economic Relations with Greece. Retrieved from
the MFA website:
http://www.agora.mfa.gr/agora/images/docs/rad25B75etisia%20ekthesi%202012.pdf
Country Report
6
0 200000 400000 600000 800000 1000000
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
100000
600000-800000total w orforce
400000-employed persons
200000-unemploed persons
Figure 1. Correlation among workforce, employed and unemployed persons,
Source: State Statistical Office in the Republic of Macedonia, Labour Force Survey 2000-
2013
Figure 2-Unemployed persons in regions in Republic of Macedonia by gender, 2013
Source: State Statistical Office in the Republic of Macedonia, Labour Force Survey
Country Report
7
According to the above, it is observed that the economy is experiencing a relative
growth but of course there is still much room for improvement. The key is the
relationship between dinar-dollar, yen-dinar, dinar-euro, and dinar-ruble. Specifically
these are the following:
Table 2.3- Currency exchange rates with major currencies
Dinar - Euro 1=0.0163
Dinar - Dollar 1=0.0225
Dinar - Yen 1=0.80
Dinar - Ruble 1=2.36
Based on the table above, at all exchange rates with countries that the examined
company BCD can have an activity, the currency exchange rates are in favor of the
interests of its customers at the level of corporate and business trips. Specifically, the
cost of accommodation, food, rooms and everything else that the company may need to
organize such activities is very low for the guests, and so there is a direct interest for the
companies that organize such trips for their employees if they choose Skopje as a
destination.
The country showed a continuous growth until 2008 that reached about 5%. In 2009
everything changed since the country was affected by the crisis resulting in a recession
rate of 0.9%, which continued until 2011. In 2012 the GDP decreased by -0.3% (KPMG.
2013).
The country’s economy was badly affected in relation to the private sector, where
many companies were driven into bankruptcy, which affected the overall operation of
the domestic market, reducing the market dynamics for a company like BCD regarding
the organizing of conferences for the companies that are already active there. The level
of unemployment in the country is 30.6%, which is an incentive for the country in
relation to foreign direct investment in order to allow entry to foreign companies to
invest there and create jobs that would support the domestic economy. The wages are
low and the basic wage does not exceed 342 Euros, while there is a good level of
Country Report
8
education, especially in large cities (see Table 2.3) (KPMG. 2013; PWC. 2014).
Table 2.3- Financial data 2009-2012
Economic indicators 2009 2010 2011 2012
GDP $ M 9313.6 9338.7 10395.2 9617.4
Growth of GDP % -0.9 2.9 2.8 -0.3
Inflation (CPI) % -0.7 1.6 3.9 3.3
Unemployment % 32.2 32.0 31.4 -
Foreign direct investment % of GDP 2.8 3.2 4.8 3.4
Export growth % -15.8 23.6 11.3 -
Import growth % -14.3 9.5 14.1 -
Current account balance $ M -609.6 -197.8 -310.6 -385.2
Public debt % of GDP 23.8 24.4 28.2 33.3
External debt $ M 5696.0 5986.4 6286.4 -
Total debt service $ M 552.3 652.5 948.5 -
Cash surplus or deficit % of GDP - - - -
Tax Revenue % of GDP - - - -
Country Report
9
Economic indicators 2009 2010 2011 2012
Government consumption % of GDP 19.1 19.1 18.3 18.3
Public expnd. on edu. % of GDP - - - -
Public expnd. on health % of GDP 4.2 4.1 4.0 -
R&D expenditure % of GDP - - - -
Military expenditure % of GDP 1.7 1.4 1.3 1.4
Source: KPMG. (2013) Investment in Skopje. Retrieved from
http://www.kpmg.com/MK/en/IssuesAndInsights/ArticlesPublications/Documents/2013
-Investment-in-Macedonia-website.pdf
The country now attracts many companies from around the world and especially
from Greece and in general the Balkans. Many large and well known companies such as
major banks (i.e. Piraeus), telecom companies (i.e. Vodafone), large Supermarkets etc.
invest in the country (Euro Business Center-Skopje, 2012). This means that BCD, despite
the economic problems plaguing the country and the wider disadvantages from the
crisis, has the opportunity to enter the market and the perspective of cooperation and
development in relation to its action area since the country’s economy presents the
necessary entry conditions. Based on the above, the key elements that the company is
required to consider before and during the entering of the market are as follows (ΒΤΙ.
2014):
1. High unemployment, which drives the country to provide benefits to companies
that entering the market, like low taxation, specific areas for the establishment of
business with low rents, etc. The 30% unemployment leads the government of the
country to provide special opportunities for companies in terms of employee insurance.
What needs to be given weight is that 75% of the workers in the country are members of
labor unions with which the company must establish good relations in order to avoid
problems.
Country Report
10
2. The country provides opportunities for investment and large companies take
advantage of this when entering the market. Despite that the private sector is in
recession, continuous investments provide the right opportunities for BCD to have a
market for engagement in this country.
3. Finally, all currency exchange rates are favorable for the company in relation to its
activities, since it can provide affordable packages to the companies in the market for
cooperation and organization of business trips.
Political environment: The state consistently promotes foreign direct investments
with special and relative bills. Specifically, in Skopje the tax on corporate profits is 15%
and the government has announced that it will further reduce it, following the example
of Serbia (ΒΤΙ. 2014). At the same time the state has set the so-called free economic
zones with tax exemption of ten years for corporate profits, value added taxes, duties
and other charges. According to the Agency for Foreign Investments in FYROM
(MacInvest), the country offers some the most competitive labor costs in Europe, in
addition to the skilled and trained workforce. The basic facts at the political level that
should be taken into account by a company when entering this market are the following
(Kosmos, 2013):
1. The high investment and political risk in FYROM, was offset by the effects of
privatization of strategic enterprises of the state sector, which constitute a major
percentage of FDI attracted by this country in recent years.
2. In an effort to strengthen the market, the Government has passed a bill that allows
entrepreneurs who invest over 40,000 Euros a year to be able to apply for citizenship,
while those who invest over 400,000 Euros and employ more than 10 employees are
granted citizenship and passport.
3. The state is in turmoil given the conflicts between the political factions, the
problems with the minorities and of course the name issue, which causes instability in
the country (Fuere, 2013).
4. There is also a problem in transportation, with non-frequent flights, lack of
accessibility of various countries, inadequate air flights, and generally the country lags
behind in infrastructure.
Country Report
11
Social Environment: In terms of social environment, the country is constantly
showing improvements at the social, cultural and tourism level, with local regions to
have emerged as international tourism destinations. In 2012, tourism influx exceeded
the 660,000 tourists. The country has 2.2 million residents who speak the south-Slavic
and the Albanian language. The main problem of the country is its many nationalities,
lack of identity and the existence of many nationalities including Turks, Romanians,
Greeks, Bosnians, and Albanians. In general the standard of living has been improved.
The company can take advantage of the multi-ethnicity character of the country and
make Skopje the center of the Balkans and a host country of companies from around the
world at the level of conferences, business meetings, conventions, combining vacation
and work that many companies would prefer. The residents are open towards foreigners
and seek to support the local communities and their country in general (PWC, 2014).
Technological environment: The country is technologically developed, but lags in
several areas that would be of major interest for the entry of foreign companies. The
country’s accession in pipeline agreements would help meet the energy needs and
strengthen the country and help it at the financial level, lead to growth in terms of
telecommunications and the entry into the market of large companies would help to
upgrade the Internet etc. This means that if the company decides to establish a unit
there, it will be able to have a relatively good communication with the target markets.
Country Report
12
3.0 Advantages and Entry Opportunities in the Market of Skopje
Having analyzed the market, there will be a brief presentation of the company before
making reference to the advantages and opportunities of the market entry. The company
covers all the needs and demands for professional/business travel individually or in
groups. There is also the ability of organizing meetings, conferences and corporate
incentive trips.
The company may also offer consulting in regards to travel services, helping the
customer to develop and better understand the costs and the procedures of a journey.
The company is the intermediary for any service that can be requested concerning
travels or be connected to it. It is a travel management company (air, ship, train, hotel,
car, food, transportation, etc.) (BCD, 2014). The advantages of entering this market are
the following (PWC, 2014):
1. Low tax rates, economic zones without taxation and other charges.
2. Low labor costs and reduced insurance rate to be paid to the state by a company,
which helps to reduce operating costs and to provide low prices in the market.
3. Good workforce that has been trained in tourism services, which means that the
company can have access to qualified staff and develop its activities in the country.
4. Large companies that have already entered the market constitute potential
customers.
5. Benefits to companies that invest in financial terms, granting of citizenship.
6. Multiculturalism may cause turmoil in the country, but it can also turn into an asset
for a company since the country can become the center in the Balkans.
The opportunities for the examined company from entering this market are the
following:
1. Skopje is a growing market and although strongly influenced by the crisis and
especially the private sector, it slowly reverses this unfavorable situation, and the need
for greater financial support with the vision to enter the European Union, certainly
shows a market with perspectives.
Country Report
13
2. Improvements in the future in terms of the transportation infrastructure in the
country, will give additional investment incentives to companies already operating
there.
3. Skopje is a host country of foreign investment, given the additional measures for
foreign direct investment that have been implemented by the government. The entry of
large companies means more potential customers for the examined company, companies
that will want to organize conferences, business meetings and business trips to and from
Skopje. Especially companies with branches there, would want to cooperate with local
companies that know the market, and so BCD would benefit from establishing activities
in this country.
4. Another future opportunity is the development of tourism, which will make the
country known worldwide, and raise the motivation of companies to organize their
business trips there, combining work with professional obligations.
Country Report
14
4.0 Selection of the Entry Strategy in the Market of Skopje
Internationalization is the business process by which a company commences its
international economic activities (Source: article notes). Internationalization of the
markets requires radical changes in the perception of the businesses regarding the
overall image of their products. The base, the core of operations of an international
business is the product or the service.
The final success of the business relies on the quality and the ability of differentiation
from the competing products – services (Levitt, 1980). A company is led to the
international arena when there are opportunities for high profits, to increase the
customer base, to establish large economies of scale and to minimize risks. Decisions in
International Marketing are defined by the following steps (Kotler, 2001):
Figure 3.1 The key decisions in international marketing
Source: Kotler P.(2001) Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, Implementation
and control, 11h edition. Prentice Hall
The company has decided to internationalize by entering the market of Skopje,
seeking to serve as a company that organizes meetings, conferences and provides travel
services. At the same time, it will provide travelling services as a consultant again to
businesses or organizations, like arranging transportation, accommodation, the
organization of activities on behalf of the local companies and businesses that intend to
develop such activities in the market of Skopje, given all the facts mentioned above and
in relation to Skopje and the country’s progress in the recent years.
In this section we will determine the most appropriate entry strategy for the company
so as to achieve its objectives and to implement this entry strategy with success. Given
the three stages of internationalization that characterize every entry strategy of a
company into a market, and also because the company provides B2B services, it is
Selection of a market
to enter
Selection of the entry
method
Decision on the marketing
plan
Decision on
internationalization
Country Report
15
suggested that the company should spend some time in getting to know the domestic
market, finding a travel agency there and develop a partnership in providing the services
in the country and then, after about a year of having acquired the full picture, the
company could proceed in making a foreign direct investment (Robins and Coulter,
2002). The options at the level of foreign direct investment are as follows:
1. Wholly owned subsidiary: The wholly owned subsidiary is a new company created
by the parent company in a foreign market. The subsidiary can refer to an entirely new
business or an existing acquired local business (Mayrhofer Ul, 2004). The parent
company retains the full control of the subsidiary, an element often crucial to the
decision of the parent company between the methods of penetration in the global market
and international expansion (Papadakis, 2007).
2. Acquisition: Acquisition is the purchase of the ownership of an existing business
entity at a percentage sufficient to confirm the change of control of the company, with a
minimum of 10% ownership. The acquisition method is the fastest method of entering a
foreign market, since the acquired company is been operating, normally, in the business
sector of the acquiring company. Therefore, no major capital investments are required
for the operation of the acquired company under the new management.
3. Joint Venture: Joint venture is the collaboration between companies or groups of
companies of the same or different nationalities, to establish a new or to acquire an
existing business. It is an alliance in which the partners contribute inputs that usually
make up their competitive advantage, and share, not necessarily on an equal basis, the
assets. It is, namely, the collaboration of different forces to achieve a common goal in a
target market, which is probably unfamiliar to the parties of the agreement (Prahalad and
Lieberthal, 1998).
Strategic Alliance: Strategic alliance is a cooperation agreement between two or more
independent companies that adopt a perspective of mutual benefit and contribute the
necessary funds or other resources for its success. Essentially, this is a kind of a longer-
term joint venture with a strategic nature. The shared ownership that is established by
strategic alliances, may involve ordinary productive and financial resources, exchange
of shares or even mutual ownership.
Country Report
16
Based on the above and in order for the company to exploit the market dynamics, the
absence of taxation, the low labor costs, the general lower management costs within the
company but also in terms of the organization of the business trips, which will create
profits, it should be introduced in the market with the safest entry strategy which is to
acquire a local business. The company should retain the staff and the manager, and in
this way it will enter the market directly through the market knowledge of the local
workforce, will utilize the existing clientele and the government directives in relation to
taxation and the benefits the government provides to foreign companies that invest in
the country and hire staff helping to reduce unemployment. The advantages of this
strategy for the company are the following (Cavusgil et al., 2011):
1. The company will have full control of the subsidiary in the market there by
utilizing the resources, staff, clientele, market share.
2. The company will fully take advantage of the local company’s profits, which
cannot be done with the original alliance, which will be developed temporarily and only
in order to know the local market.
3. Given the knowledge of the global market its existing strategy will be diversified
and the company will be able to differentiate itself from the wider competition.
The disadvantages refer to the cost of the investment which will be high for the
company, but given that this type of strategy will better help the company to achieve its
goals and realize the benefits provided by the state, the cost of this investment will be
covered over a reasonable period of time and the company will achieve direct profits.
Country Report
17
5.0 Emerging Market Potential Index
This section, based on the Emerging Market Potential Index, the decision to enter this
market will be evaluated. In particular, the variables of this standard evaluation method are as
follows (Cavusgil, 1997):
Table 5.1 Emerging Market Potential Index
Dimension Weight Measures Used
Market Size Urban population (million) -2011 (World Bank )
Electricity consumption (billion kwh) – 2010 (U.S. Energy Information Administration )
Market Growth Rate
Average annual growth rate of primary energy use (%) - between years 2006-2011 (World Bank )
Real GDP growth rate (%) – 2011 (World Bank )
Market Intensity GNI per capita estimates using PPP (US Dollars) - 2011
Private consumption as a percentage of GDP (%) - 2011
Market Consumption
Capacity
Percentage share of middle-class in consumption/income (2010) (Kharas, 2011)
Commercial Infrastructure
Main Telephone lines (per 100 habitants) – 2011 (International Telecommunication Union )
Cellular mobile subscribers (per 100 habitants) - 2011
Number of PC's (per 1000 habitants) - 2012
Paved road density (km per million people) - 2012
Internet users (per 100 habitants) - 2011 Population per retail outlet – 2012
(Euromonitor International ) Percentage of Households with TV - 2012
Economic Freedom Economic Freedom Index – 2013 (Heritage Foundation )
Political Freedom Index – 2012 (Freedom House )
Market Receptivity Per capita imports from US (US Dollars) - 2012
Trade as a percentage of GDP (%) - 2011
Country Risk Country risk rating - 2012
Country Report
18
Source: Cavusgil S.T.(1997) Measuring The Potential of Emerging Markets: An Indexing
Approach" -, Business Horizons, Vol. 40 Nο.1, pp.87-91
For each of the above indicators we will present evidence below that will justify the
ratios that characterize Skopje (the indicators are rounded in the larger or smaller
figure).
1. Market Size: Skopje, based on the latest data, has a population of 2,200,000
residents, while the level of the net consumption of electricity is 2.55. In combination
with the low index in the population, the country’s ratio is close to 3/50.
2. Market Growth Rate: This indicates the average of primary research in Skopje
which is 6.95 in combination with the real GDP growth rate which is 6.892, the average
is 6.921, which means that the ratio is about 7/50 .
3. Market Intensity: Based on data from 2011, the index is 11.540 compared to GNI,
while with respect to the GDP the index is 9.613, the average is 10.57, which means that
the ratio is 11/50.
4. Market Consumption Capacity: The ratio is 9/50.
5. Commercial Infrastructure: By looking at the International Telecommunication
Union indicator, the ICT Indicators, Euromonitor International, Global Market
Information Database, we have the following data:
Main Telephone lines (per 100 habitants) 2011 (International Telecommunication Union )
1.9
Cellular mobile subscribers (per 100 habitants) 2011
1.06
Number of PC's (per 1000 habitants) 2012 0.7
Paved road density (km per million people) 2012
-
Internet users (per 100 habitants) 2011 0.7
Population per retail outlet 2012 (Euromonitor International )
0.5
Percentage of Households with TV 2012 1
Based on the above, the ratio is 2/50.
6. Economic Freedom: According to the indicators of Economic Freedom, the index is 6
Country Report
19
and the political Freedom is around 5, the average ratio is 5/50.
7. Market Receptivity: The GDP is at 1.3, while the average index of import is around 5.6,
the average here is 4/50.
8. Country Risk: The country risk is at 4.2, which is not very high.
Table 5.3 presents the Emerging Market Potential Index of FYROM on the basis of the
above:
Dimension Weight
Market Size 3/50
Market Growth Rate 7/50
Market Intensity 11/50
Market Consumption Capacity 9/50
Commercial Infrastructure 2/50
Economic Freedom 5/50
Market Receptivity 4/50
Country Risk 4/50
It is observed that the country has generally low indicators, does not have particular
dynamics in the global market, but presents some advantages like the low risk, the growth
potential of the market, and in general it is an economy geared towards growth. The market is
small but for the company it can turn out to become the center for the wider Balkan market,
at attracting companies in connection with the organization of business travels. Skopje is a
country with future perspectives for the considered company and given the analysis so far,
the evaluation of the investment decision is regarded as positive for BCD.
Country Report
20
References
BCD.(2014) Profile of the Company, Retrieved from http://www.bcdtravel.com/
Cavusgil S.T.(1997) Measuring The Potential of Emerging Markets: An Indexing Approach" -,
Business Horizons, Vol. 40 Nο.1, pp.87-91
Cavusgil, S. T., Ghauri, P., Knight, G., & Riesenberger, J. (2014). International business: Global
edition (3rd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice-Hall
Euro Business Center-Skopje. (2012). 200 Largest Companies. [spreadsheet]. Retrieved from
http://www.eurobc.com.mk/download/vk_lista_najgolemi_2012_EN.xls
Euromonitor International, 2014, Global Market Information Database
Freedom House, Survey of Freedom in the World, 2014
Fuere, E. (2013, September 13). Macedonia – A Country in Crisis (No. 299). Retrieved from CEPS
website: http://www.ceps.eu/book/macedonia-country-crisis
Heritage Foundation, The Index of Economic Freedom, 2014
International Telecommunication Union, 2014, ICT Indicators
Kharas, H.(2011) The Emerging Middle Class in Developing Countries, Brookings
Kosmos.(2013) Residence permit to foreigners who invest in property and citizenship to those who
make large investments, Retrieved from: http://www.iefimerida.gr/apenews
Kotler P.(2001) Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, Implementation and control, 11h
edition. Prentice Hall
Country Report
21
KPMG. (2013) Investment in Macedonia. Retrieved from
http://www.kpmg.com/MK/en/IssuesAndInsights/ArticlesPublications/Documents/2013-
Investment-in-Macedonia-website.pdf
Levitt, T.(1980) “Marketing Success through Differentiation of Anything”. Harvard Business
Review, Vol.58
Mayrhofer Ul. (2004), The Influence of National Origin and Uncertainty on the Choice between
Cooperation and Merger-Acquisition: an analysis of French and German firms, International
Business Review, Vol.13, No.1, pp. 83-99.
Papadakis M.V. (2007), Corporate Strategy: Greek and international experience, Vol. A, 5the ed.,
Benos Publications, p. 397.
Prahalad C. K. and Lieberthal, K., (1998), The End of the Corporate Imperialism, Harvard
Business Review, pp. 83-99.
PWC. (2014). Guide to Doing Business and Investing in Macedonia. Retrieved from
http://www.investinmacedonia.com/sites/invest/files/content_resources/PwC%202014%20-
%20Guide%20to%20Doing%20Business%20and%20Investing%20in%20Macedonia%2020
14.pdf
Robins S.P. and Coulter M.(2002) Management, Prentice Hall, 7th edition
Thompson, A.A. & Strickland, A.J. (2001): Strategic Management, McGraw-Hill, Irwin.
U.S. Energy Information Administration, International Energy Annual
World Bank, World Development Indicators
ΒΤΙ. (2014). Macedonia Country Report. Retrieved from http://www.bti-
project.org/reports/country-reports/ecse/mkd/index.nc?tx_itaoreport_pi1[action]=show