7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
1/18
Challenges encountered in the catalytic converter industry:
Today, the most fuel efficient engines run with excess air and hence cannot be used with the
proven three-way catalysts which reduce pollutant emissions by 96%. This poses the problem of
developing catalyst concepts that can work with fuel efficient engines while retaining the low
pollutant levels reached by three-way catalysts (1). It is known that three-way catalytic
converters are a good and efficient method to control the emissions of pollutant. However, for
lean burn engines the large amount of oxygen in exhaust gas, and the low temperatures of the
exhaust gas negates the use of the three-way catalysts and lead to a negative impact on engineenergy efficiency. Also, it was found that all after-treatment systems are not reliable or efficient
without a proper operating temperature and an accurate flow control (6). Furthermore the need
for a development of a technology for an efficient catalytic combustion of lean gaseous fuels is
needed in industrial practice (17). In summary catalytic converters play an important role in
reducing pollutant emissions from cars however the converters present a various number of
limitation including that they do not perform very well in oxygen rich conditions, they are
susceptible to poisoning by impurities in the fuel mix, they are not active at cold start conditions,
the formation of undesirable products such as N 2O or ammonia, instead of the N 2 desired is
another concern in operating catalytic converters. It has been found that a detailed knowledge of
the underlying catalytic chemistry can also help in finding and building better catalytic
converters (24). Because there is challenging combination of physical and chemical processes in
a catalytic converter, improvement in the design of the monolith require a good understanding of
the influence of the many designs and operating variables on the performance of the reactor;
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
2/18
even more particularly, the ability to determine the light-off location and the thickness of the
light-off front. Let's explain what light-off location and light-off front means:
When an automobile equipped with a catalytic converter is turned on, the initial response of the
converter from cold has two stages. During the first stage, the converter heats up because of the
presence of the hot inlet gas, but no chemical reaction occurs. After short amount of time the
temperature in the converter rises and becomes sufficiently high for chemical reaction to occur.
This generates heat faster than can be swept away by the gas stream. The converter then divides
into a region upstream where the gas flow makes the temperature high and the reaction rates are
large. The narrow transition between these regions is called the light-off front. The second stageof the response is a relatively small slow movement of light-off front towards the converter inlet.
Because this process can take some time up to several minutes for the catalytic converter to get
to a working temperature, an understanding of this initial phase is crucial in the control of
pollutant emissions. And from an environmental point of view it is clear that how to cope with
motor vehicle exhaust emissions is an increasing concern in automobile engineering (23).
Determining the light-off front can help in minimizing cold-start emissions from three way
catalysts, and hence improving their design, but developing a method or model to do this is a
challenge (3). Overall, catalyst efficiency depends on the cold start behavior and the conversions
at normal temperature above the ignition temperature, which represent the operating temperature.
It has been found that cold start emissions, which means the emissions of pollutants when the
catalyst has not reached normal operating temperature represented 80% of the total emissions;
for this reason, to improve the design of catalytic converters researchers have been focused on
improving the low temperature activity. However the design and improvement of a catalytic
converter is not an easy task because of the complex interaction between transport phenomena
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
3/18
and chemical reactions (17).This complexity led to the development of mathematical models to
solve the problem through the use of numerical solutions. However, the fact that numerical
solutions of such detailed models with complex catalytic chemistry is possible with present day
computers; it may be difficult in terms of time and memory requirements, to solve them. This is
especially true for real time simulations that may be needed in the control and optimization
schemes; in addition, detailed solution , even when available, have to be coarse grained to obtain
quantities of practical interest, such as the average exit conversions of a reactant; added to this it
was shown that for strongly linear reactor models showing multiple solutions and boundary
layers, determination of the different types of solutions that may exist in the multidimensionalparameter space may be computationally prohibitive (28)./
Even though catalytic converters are used to reduce emission of pollutants such as CO,
hydrocarbons, and NOx by converting those to less toxic gases, it has been found that catalytic
converters are a source of pollution due to the platinum group elements contained in them.
Platinum group elements are a new kind of pollutant concentrated in earths core. Platinum
group metals for example are critical metals whose extraction is associated with a high
environmental burden (14). Environmental concentrations of these metals now exceed geogenic
background concentrations by factors of 10 5 to 10 6 and they are continuing to grow. However,
some metals are more harmful than others. For example a low concentration of palladium causes
more serious effects to cells and organisms than platinum, yet it has been found that palladium is
now being used as a substitute of platinum and rhodnium in catalytic converters (15). This is
because it is very difficult to analyze and trace palladium in complex systems, and other
analytical techniques such as graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry are not sensitive
enough to detect palladium in biological samples (15). Platinum group elements have been found
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
4/18
in roadside dust, airborne particles, soils, plants, sediments, and snow which confirms the fact
that they are emitted from converters. Hence, these platinum group elements were considered to
be harmless, but recent studies have shown that some species have high level of cytotoxicity and
mutagenicity and can lead to significant negative effects on human health after chronic exposure
at very low level (4). Moreover due to the increasing price of noble metals (Pt, Pd, Rh) different
methods for catalytic oxidation have to be found (11). Also, due to the scarcity and the high
value of these metals, there is an increased interest towards their recovery from wastes such as in
three way catalyst. Concentration of platinum in catalysts ranges from 300 to 1000 g g -1; in the
case of palladium. Concentration can vary from 200 to 800 g g-1
; and for rhodium concentrationin catalyst have been found to be between 50 to 100 g g -1; even though these are very small
quantities, they are richer than those found in mined ores (20). Because used catalytic converters
are usually disposed of in landfills, which represent a great waste in terms of the minerals
contained in it; a method to exploit and recover the precious metals left in it should be
developed. The amount of platinum present in earth's crust is estimated at a concentration of
5g/kg in the upper 16km of the crust. Platinum is the 76th most abundant element and can
occur in oxidation states, and in solutions. The reason why platinum are used in catalytic
converters is because when it is finely dispersed it exhibits excellent catalytic properties. Even
though platinum are used in various application such as in the manufacture of jewellery and in
the chemical and petrochemical industry, studies have shown that most of the platinum produced
in the world is utilized to manufacture catalytic converters (21). A study showing the level of
exposure of people working in the fabrication of catalytic converter would be useful to set
standards regarding the wellbeing of these individuals. For other metals used in catalytic
converters such as gold, hardly nothing is know about the consequences of exposure to it and
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
5/18
there is every small information on the background levels of exposure to gold in the general
population. The only negative effects that have been found include allergies and skin
sensitiveness. However, this does not rule out the fact that gold element present in catalytic
converters have to be retrieved after the use of the converter at least for economic purposes.
Investigations to determine platinum group content in general populations could be of interest to
study their harmful effects in more details. Accurate methods to determine the content of these
platinum group elements in urine, blood, and plasma in the concentration range which occurs as
a result of ecological exposure or exposure at the workplace must also be developed (22). /
Even though much research has been done in developed countries such as in Europe and northAmerica, there are some countries that do not have much data concerning the emission factors of
pollutants, oil rich countries for example that are experiencing rapid industrialization and
expanding urbanization do not have this information available besides their significant growth
(30). Research in the emission of pollutant is very important to be able to reduce pollution and
protect our environment, but it also has some other uses: indeed, nowadays there are global
budget accorded to the emission of pollutants. Let's take the example of the emission of N 2O on
the environment. There is a global N 2O budget that is not yet completely understood, and the
reason is that nitrous oxide emissions from vehicles have only been estimated based on fuel
consumption, and emission factors, and that amount is nearly equal to those obtained from a
simple global extrapolation of the nitrous oxide emission factor deduced from observations in
roadway tunnels (31). So, it is clear that the emission factors presented are taken from limited
studies and there for are not much reliable. Hence, the behavior of nitrous oxide isotopomers in
automobile combustion and subsequent catalytic treatment must be studied with respect to other
factors such as driving conditions, temperature and aging of catalysts so that estimated values
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
6/18
can be used to distinguish automobile source of nitrous oxide from other sources and to be able
to determine an accurate global nitrous oxide budget (31)./
As it is indicated in the literature, hydrogen is a potential energy source for the future, so its
production could help reduce the emission of pollutant caused by catalytic converters. From
various investigation that were made, one of the byproduct of catalyst converters is hydrogen ,
and hydrogen production from synthesis gas for fuel cell applications has become a big focus of
attention. All this attention lead to the need of developing new catalysts that can obey strict
safety requirements while improving water-gas shift reactions for on-board hydrogen processing
(9).Another challenge that faces the development of improved design is regulations. A historical
case study has shown that outcomes such as the adoption of a new design are determined by
factors largely beyond the control of innovators (16).
Proposed solutions to the challenges faced in the catalytic converter industry:
Special types of catalysts have been developed and these catalysts can remove NOx from lean
exhaust. This could solve the problem or starts to solve the problem of catalytic converters not
being able to work with fuel efficient engine. Three methods were proposed to reduce the
emission of NOx in lean exhaust; and they include: NOx absorber catalysts, selective catalytic
reduction (SCR) of NOx by ammonia, and Nox reduction by hydrocarbons (HC-DeNOx). Due to
technical problems associated with the DeNOx method, it has not been used in serial
applications. Regarding the NOx absorber catalyst, the major technical problem with it is the
accumulation of sulfur on the catalyst and consequently the lowering of the NOx adsorption
capacity. The selective catalytic reduction seems to be the best methods since it can be used with
ammonia, with vanadium, or with zeolite-Based SCR catalyst; the reason why this method is
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
7/18
better is because a technical issue encountered with ammonia for example is solved by using
vanadium, and a technical issue encountered with vanadium is solved when Zeolite is used.
However the specific method and the most common after treatment system used for fuel efficient
engine is a three-way catalyst combined with a NOx absorber catalyst as shown in Figure 1.
Other systems based on SCR catalysts are being researched. Even though the system shown in
Figure 1, only describes the aftertreatment system for a gasoline direct-injection engine, it is also
assumed that it can be used with fuel efficient engine due to the fact that these so-called direct-
injection gasoline engines face the same NOx reduction problems as Diesel engines and do
require a special catalyst for lean NOx removal (1).
Figure 1
Furthermore, to solve this problem of lean engine catalytic converter an innovative active flow
control has been researched and proposed to maintain a proper thermal window for energy-
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
8/18
efficient aftertreament and to reduce the need for additional fuel. this new method is based on
reversed flow systems and also on the control of the exhaust gas flow path through the
aftertreament mechanism Figure 2. What happens is that the exhaust gases are periodically
switched between the two system ends by using valves, with a cycle consisting of forward and
backward operations, the cycle is defined as symmetric reverse flow when the two consecutive
processes last the same time and asymmetric reverse flow when it is the opposite.
Figure 2
To better understand underlying catalytic chemistry that can help in developing better catalytic
converters, detailed kinetic models consisting of elementary reaction steps have been used,
however these detailed kinetic models are only useable in a limited set of operating conditions,
so to solve this problem validated reaction mechanism consisting of several steps, such as in
microkinetics models, consisting of a sequence of detailed elementary reaction have been
developed with a focus on reduced reaction rate models (24).
To cope with motor vehicle exhaust emissions various mathematical models for the study of
interphase heat-transfer problems in catalytic converters have been developed and one of them is
the one suggested by Leightion and Chang where the vehicle temperature and the converter
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
9/18
temperature are governed by a coupled system of a first-order partial differential equation as
indicated below (23).
On a simplified form, the equations in above become:
When we let:
As we can see developing a method or model to minimize cold-start emissions from three way
catalyst is not an easy task, however mathematical modeling and simulations are useful in
identifying the optimal designs and reducing the amount of experimentation needed to achieve
this goal (3).
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
10/18
Because it is difficult in terms of time and memory requirements of present day computers to
solve complex mathematical models of catalytic chemistry, it is desirable to have simplified low-
dimensional models having same qualitative behavior as the full partial differential equation
models and sufficient accuracy for practical applications (28). Taking consideration of this fact,
simpler models were developed, including 1-D two phase models, models including detailed
kinetics along with washcoat diffusional limitations, and models that solve the full 3-D
governing equations for a single representative channel. Figure 3 gives the example of a detailed
mathematical model of a catalytic monolith, it depicts one of the assumption used to derive the
models; here it is that the cross section of the channel is invariant with the axial position, with avariable washcoat thickness.
Figure 3
Investigations were also done to reduce the environmental pollution of some platinum group
elements. For palladium for example, in the electronics industry the development of multilayered
ceramic capacitors that can work with nickel or silver were developed. From this observation it is
projected that similar investigation will be developed for the automotive industry (14).
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
11/18
To solve the problem of analyzing and tracing platinum group element such as palladium,
techniques such as the combination of graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry with
modified selective separation and preconcentration procedure were developed (15).
To further understand the harmful effects of platinum group elements studies are constantly
determining and updating information on platinum group elements concentration and enrichment
on urban areas. These studies often investigate the spatial distribution of platinum group
elements in different functional districts (4). Figure 4 shows the sampling sites of an
investigation that was performed in Beijing, China.
Figure 4
Regarding the issues related to the increasing price of noble metals, and the need for different
methods for catalytic oxidation, a promising reaction that has been developed in the literature is
CO oxidation over metals and studies have examined it over simple and mixed oxide catalysts
(11). Table 1 shows the heat of chemisorption values of CO on metals including platinum,
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
12/18
rhodium and palladium. We observe an increase in chemisorption for platinum, rhodmium and
ruthenium, and other behavior for the other metals.
Table 1
To recover precious metals from used catalytic converters, several methods were developed and
studies focused on recovering the metals from the synthetic effluents and the industrial effluents.
The methods to recover precious metals from used catalytic converters include ion exchange
methods, a system that combines two hollow-fiber liquid membrane, and one that uses supported
liquid membrane that contain a selective carrier. Some other methods include Sorption by
chitosan, selective dissolution in aqua regia, and many more. But the methods that are preferred
are the ones that recover the metal in an economical and environmentally friendly way. The
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
13/18
apparatus depicted in figure 5 for example shows the apparatus of an extraction method that uses
sc CO2 modified with a complexing agent (20).
Figure 5
Even though most studies show that the pollution of platinum group elements is most ubiquitous
in vehicles, because it is these vehicles that carry catalytic converters, some other studies have
focused on the places where these converters are made, and the amount of exposure people
working in these place were subjected to was determined. Table 2 shows the results of platinum
determination in the urine of people who are occupationally exposed to platinum (21).
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
14/18
Table 2
A more detailed study was also done to look at the exposure level of platinum in the workplace
the summary of the findings are shown in table 3 (22).
Table 3
Data concerning emission factors of pollutants is increasingly being generated around the world,
even in countries where similar research was non-existent. The country of Kuwait where there
was very limited information available regarding pollutant emissions from the transportation
system has pursued similar investigation as in Europe and the United states (30). In this case a
very elaborate investigation was done including the speed profiles of different types of drivers,
full cycle emissions profile for different types of vehicles. A summary of the statistic is collected
in table 4.
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
15/18
Table 4
To better understand the global nitrous oxide budget the behavior of N 2O isotomers in car
combustion and the following catalytic treatments of exhaust have been studied with respect to
driving conditions, temperature, and aging of catalysts. The analysis showed that N 2O is
consumed in three-way catalysts at a rate that is similar to the rate at which it is produced (31).
The estimated values presented in table 5 can then be helpful in distinguishing automobile source
of nitrous oxide from other sources and hence help us deduce its contribution to the global
nitrous oxide budget.
Table 5
To solve the problem of emission of pollutant, some other route besides the improvement of the
design of catalytic converters is being pursued; one of these routes is the route that leads to the
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
16/18
production of hydrogen as an energy carrier. And one of the most promising ways of achieving
that is through the water-gas shift reaction. The water-gas shift reaction is related to the
production of usable gas when steam is passed through a bed of incandescent coke (9). The
method was then developed through the years till it was used as part of the Haber-Bosch process
to make ammonia as shown in figure 6. More investigations showed that there were some pretty
good perspectives regarding water-gas shift reaction including the improvement of catalytic
activity on precious metals and development of new formulas.
Figure 6
Some other area of study that would help in developing catalytic converter is the area of
regulations. As it was indicated in the literature, outcome such as the adoption of new
technologies or design do not only depend on the innovator but it is also largely affected by
regulations. It can be government regulation or states regulations. A look at these regulations and
their impact on development could also help innovators understand the proper method to apply to
navigate through all of them in a minimum amount of time. Figure 7 shows the development of
catalytic converters through the years and some of the entities that were involved in it.
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
17/18
Figure 7
Conclusion:
We conclude from our literature review and the research we conducted that there are three main
challenges facing the catalytic converter industry and its development:
A problem of efficiency:
o Catalytic converters are not very efficient during the first couple of minutes of
their run. This poses a big problem because most of the pollutants that are
supposed to be reduced by catalytic converter are emitted on the environment
during that small window of time. Hence, the development of new technologies to
reduce this time is required.
o Catalytic converters are not efficient when used with fuel efficient engines
because of the oxygen rich conditions. Consequently, the creation of a catalytic
converter that could be used with lean engines should be underway.
7/30/2019 Catalysts Paper
18/18
Catalytic converters are used to reduce pollutant emissions, but research found that the
converters themselves pose a threat to the environment, due to the platinum group
element they contained.
From a historical perspective, regulations could slow down the adoption of new designs
and technologies
The solutions that were investigated to solve these problems are various and include:
The development of novel system to use catalytic converters in fuel efficient engine
The development of mathematical models to better understand the mechanism of
conversion and hence attempt to reduce cold start emissions of pollutant
Various investigations aimed at better understanding the effect of platinum group
elements on the human body and on the environment for the purpose of developing future
regulations.