8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 1/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
THE EARLY YEARS ADOPTION OF COST OR
REVALUATION MODEL FOR PROPERTY, PLANT AND
EQUIPMENT IN INDONESIA
ADAM ZAKARIA SE. Ak. MSi.
Accountin L!ctu"!" #t Accountin D!$#"t%!nt F#cu&t' o( Econo%ic)
St#t! Uni*!")it' o( +#k#"t#, Inon!)i#
M#i& #"!))- F#cu&t' o( Econo%ic), St#t! Uni*!")it' o( +#k#"t#
ui&in R, +#&#n. R#/#%#nun Muk#, +#k#"t# Ti%u", Inon!)i#
P0.- 123 34 5634336 F#7- 123 34 568239:
E;%#i& #"!))- #<!&i%#='#0oo.co%, ##%=(!un>.#c.i
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 2/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
THE EARLY YEARS ADOPTION OF COST OR REVALUATION MODEL
FOR PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT IN INDONESIA
Te !e"ised Indonesian #ccoun$ing S$andard for %roer$'( %)an$ and E*uimen$
+%S#, 1-. /ic is fu))' ado$ed from I#S 1- ro"ides o$ions for comanies $o
a)' cos$ or re"a)ua$ion mode) I$ /as effec$i"e)' sa)) a)ied for eriods
beginning or af$er anuar' 1( 2008 Te obec$i"es of $is researc are $o e3)ore
$e use of $ose me$ods and i$s effec$ $o financia) erformances a$a ga$ered
for 400 comanies )is$ed in Indonesia S$oc5 E3cange from 2008 $o 2009 Te
resu)$ so/s $a$ comanies refer using cos$ me$od for rac$icab)e( no$
significan$)' differen$ and cas f)o/ considera$ion ra$er $an re"a)ua$ion mode)
K!'/o")- I6!S( Cos$ or !e"a)ua$ion ode)( 6inancia) %erformance
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
2
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 3/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
THE EARLY YEARS ADOPTION OF COST OR REVALUATION MODEL FOR
PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT IN INDONESIA
4. Int"ouction
esi$e accoun$ing o)ic' di"ersi$' and deba$es o"er armonia$ion of g)oba)
accoun$ing s$andards( $e gro/$ of mu)$icoun$r' economic a))iances as encouraged $eir
members $o )essen differences for $e benefi$ of regiona) goa)s Euroean nion and #SE#N
are a)so concern abou$ $is ma$$er !efer $o Te Euroean Commission decision in 2000 and
!egu)a$ion 1-0-;2002 )is$ed comanies re*uired $o ub)is financia) s$a$emen$s using I6!S
from anuar' 1( 200< on/ards Curren$)'( around 1<0 coun$ries are a)'ing I6!S or
na$iona) accoun$ing s$andards com)' /i$ I6!S Te )e"e) of I6!S com)iance mig$ "ar'
in e"er' coun$ries bu$ con"ergence rogram is s$i)) /or5ing on Euroean nion re*uired a))
comanies )is$ed in Euroean S$oc5 E3cange $o a)' I6!S for conso)ida$ed financia)
reor$ing s$ar$ed in 200< #ccording $o $e officia) informa$ion for 200<( $ere /ere 8(000
comanies reared $eir financia) s$a$emen$s in $e firs$ 'ear of ado$ion +=uges( 2007.
oreo"er( in No"ember 2008 SEC resen$ed $e roadma indica$es $a$ SEC /i)) re*uire a))
S comanies $o use I6!S in 2014 +Scanner and S)a$er( 2008. bu$ fina) decision /ou)d be
made in 2011 regarding mo"ing $o I6!S +i)man( 2009.
Te roadma of I6!S com)iance in #SE#N coun$ries as been se$$)ed Indonesia
and a)a'sia /ou)d fu))' com)' $a$ s$andards in 2012 mean/i)e ano$er members mig$
s$ar$ differen$)' Some o)ic' recommenda$ions regarding financia) accoun$ing s's$em a"e
been addressed in ursuing #SE#N armonia$ion +Saudagaran and iga( 1998.: broad aims
of financia) accoun$ing( ins$i$u$iona) mecanism for acie"ing #SE#N armonia$ion( na$ure
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
>
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 4/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
of secific measuremen$ and disc)osure re*uiremen$s In si$e of differences in coman' )a/
re*uiremen$s( securi$ies mar5e$ regu)a$ions( accoun$ing s$andardsse$$ing rocedures and
accoun$ing s$andards con$en$( $e simi)ari$ies among #SE#N coun$ries are concern /i$ $e
ar$icia$ion of ri"a$e sec$or in accoun$ing s$andards se$$ing and enforcemen$ +!usse) and
iga( 199-.
Te armonia$ion s$andards $o I6!S is a)so sread $o ano$er #SI#N coun$r' suc
as aan( Cina( Iran( India( ,aa5s$an( %a5is$an( Bang)ades e$c eba$es o"er s$andard
se$$ing rocess norma))' occurred during mee$ings and seminars I6!S is no$ on)' benefi$ for
i$s ad"an$ages $o $e coun$r' bu$ disad"an$ages mig$ faced esecia))' if cer$ain I6!S
s$andards is irre)e"an$ $o financia) s$a$emen$ users and $end $o offer more benefi$s a$ $e
e3enses of o$er ar$'
#)'ing cu)$ura) fac$ors for ins$ance a secrec' and )ac5 of $ransarenc' +?ra'(
1988.( gi"en Indonesia@s )o/er )e"e) of indi"idua)ism( rofessiona)ism and )arge o/er
dis$ance( i$s accoun$ing rofession )i5e)' $o ran5 ig)' in $erm of bo$ conser"a$ism and
secrec' Tese accoun$ing "a)ues /ou)d resu)$ in a )o/ )e"e) of $ransarenc' in financia)
reor$s Te gro/$ of Indonesian econom' is a)so e3ec$ed $o s$reng$en $e ro)e of $e
accoun$ing rofession in se$$ing and im)emen$ing financia) reor$ing s$andards S$ruc$ura)
issues in socie$'( inade*ua$e regu)a$or' and enforcemen$ mecanism( cron'ism as /e)) as
)anguage fac$ors mus$ be considered +%erera and Ba'doun( 2007. !esearc as been done
regarding de"e)omen$ of accoun$ing s$andards and disc)osure rac$ice $a$ a$$erned b'
cange in cu)$ura) norms Te associa$ion be$/een na$iona) cu)$ura) and accoun$ing "a)ues in
Indonesia /as conduc$ed re"ious)' +Sudar/an and 6ogar$'( 199-.
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
4
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 5/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
Te goa) of I#S 1- a)' for beginning or af$er anuar' 1( 200< is $o rescribe $e
accoun$ing $rea$men$ of $angib)e fi3ed asse$s( so $e users of financia) s$a$emen$ ma' 5no/
informa$ion abou$ $e in"es$men$ $a$ $e ins$i$u$ion as in i$s roer$' and e*uimen$ as /e))
as $e canges $a$ a"e occurred in $a$ in"es$men$ #ccoun$ing informa$ion is ref)ec$ed b'
i$s ins$rumen$s so $a$ can affec$ firm@s "a)ue 6air "a)ue informa$ion is "a)ue re)e"an$ for $e
users of financia) s$a$emen$ Terefore( measuring ins$rumen$s a$ fair "a)ue can assis$
in"es$ors for be$$er decision Indonesian #ccoun$ing S$andard Board re"ised 6inancia)
#ccoun$ing S$andard S$a$emen$ 1- +%S#,;?##%. re)a$ed $o %roer$' %)an$ and E*uimen$
+%%E. in 2007 and effec$i"e)' sa)) a)' for annua) eriods beginning or af$er anuar' 1(
2008 Ta$ s$andard as fu))' ado$ed I#S 1- for cos$ or re"a)ua$ion mode) Ta$ s$andard
as re)aced rior 6inancia) #ccoun$ing S$andard S$a$emen$ 1- +%S#,. /ic on)' a))o/ed
cos$ mode) for re)iabi)i$' considera$ion during eriods before 2008
Tis aer discusses $e im)emen$a$ion of re"ised %S#, 1- in $e ear)' 'ears of
ado$ion for a)) comanies )is$ed in Indonesia S$oc5 E3cange Since $is ne/ accoun$ing
s$andards is $o$a))' differen$ /i$ re"ious one( man' asec$s /ou)d be co"ered suc as : 1.
=o/ far does coman' s$ar$ $o im)emen$ $a$ ne/ s$andardA 2. a$ $e reasons bac5ed
$eir decision in coosing $a$ ne/ s$andardA >. a$ is $e obs$ac)e in a)'ing $a$ ne/
s$andardA
3. Lit!"#tu"! R!*i!/
3.4. Int!"n#tion#& Fin#nci#& R!$o"tin St#n#") ?IFRS@
In$erna$iona) 6edera$ion of #ccoun$an$ conduc$ed a sur"e' /ic s$a$ed $a$
con"ergence $o a sing)e se$ of in$erna$iona) accoun$ing s$andards is a 5e' $o economic
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
<
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 6/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
de"e)omen$ aori$' of resonden$s find com)iance /i$ I6!S is "er' imor$an$ +I6#C(
2007. $er researc found $a$ $e use of I6!S is e3ec$ed $o imro"e $e comarabi)i$' of
financia) s$a$emen$s( s$reng$en corora$e $ransarenc' and enance $e *ua)i$' of financia)
reor$ing +as5e e$ a)( 2007. /i)e con"ergence $o/ards I6!S reor$ing can faci)i$a$e cross
border in"es$men$ and $us $e in$egra$ion of cai$a) mar5e$s +Co"rig e$ a)( 2007.
6our rimar' benefi$s ou$)ined based on ad"oca$es of accoun$ing armonia$ion
+I#SC( 198>D #i$5en and Is)am( 1984D %ur"is e$ a)( 1991D IC?( 1992.: cos$ sa"ing accruing
$o mu)$ina$iona) comanies( enanced comreensi"eness and comarabi)i$' of cross
na$iona) financia) reor$s( /idesread dissemina$ion of ig *ua)i$' accoun$ing s$andards and
rac$ices( and ro"ision of )o/ cos$ financia) accoun$ing s$andards $o coun$ries /i$ )imi$ed
resources e"e)oing na$iona) s$andards $a$ armonie /i$ I6!S a)so ad"an$ages in $e
asec$s of cos$s reduc$ion in rearing financia) s$a$emen$s( $e e)imina$ion or reduc$ion of
se$u cos$s in de"e)oing na$iona) accoun$ing s$andards( $e o$en$ia) of raid na$iona)
imro"emen$ in ercei"ed *ua)i$' and s$a$us of financia) reor$s( increase in financia) mar5e$
efficienc' $roug $e ro"ision of more unders$andab)e( comarab)e and re)iab)e financia)
s$a$emen$s +#sraf and ?ani( 200<D Be)5aoui( 2004D Cand)er( 1992D Coi and u))er(
1984D ur'( 2000D Nobes and %ar5er( 200-.
n $e o$er and( na$iona) cu)$ure is $e )arges$ obs$ac)e indering $e armonia$ion
of accoun$ing s$andards !esearc as been done in $ir$'$ree na$iona) s$oc5 e3canges
found $a$ accoun$ing disc)osure is significan$)' affec$ed b' cu)$ura) dimensions of o/er
dis$ance( indi"idua)ism and uncer$ain$' +!iaiBe)5aoui( 199<. 6ur$ermore( na$iona)
accoun$ing s$andards is unsui$ed or irre)e"an$ $o na$iona) need $a$ )eads $o s$andards
o"er)oad +Coi and u))er( 1984.( e3ceed business re*uiremen$ in com)e3i$' +Be)5aoui(
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
-
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 7/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
2004. and $end $o faci)i$a$e )arge in$erna$iona) accoun$ing firms a$ $e e3ense of )oca) firms
in bo$ de"e)oing +Coi and u))er( 1984D !adeboug e$ a)( 200-. and de"e)oed coun$ries
+oson( 200-.
!o)e of cu)$ure cer$ain)' imac$s na$iona) s$andards Tis conc)usion can be dra/n
from re"ious researc Cu)$ura) "a)ues are associa$ed /i$ our di"ergence inde3 and ma$$er
e"en more $an )ega) origin in e3)aining di"ergences from I#S i$ regard $o absence
inde3( $ere is no significan$ re)a$ionsi ei$er cu)$ura) "a)ues or )ega) origin +ing e$ a)(
200<. #f$er $a$( in $e area of comarabi)i$' and con"ergence( $e obs$ac)e of comarabi)i$'
mig$ be genuine comarabi)i$' mean/i)e cu)$ura) is an obs$ac)e a$ a ig )e"e) of *ua)i$'
+eff( 2007. Economic mo$i"e is a)so a de$erminan$ in s$andardse$$ing Te associa$ion
be$/een )obb'ing osi$ions and bo$ $eir ome coun$r'@s $a3 and financia) accoun$ing
s$andards /as found !esonden$s oose cange in $e s$a$us *uo ar$icu)ar)' $ose canges
$a$ $e' ercei"e mig$ cause $em ad"erse economic conse*uences in $e fu$ure +Farson
and Bro/n( 2001. i)e rimari)' us$ifica$ions for $e increasing recogni$ion $o I6!S is
economicD $e o$er fac$ors suc as socia) and o)i$ica) are a)$erna$i"es e3)ana$ion for $e
origin and diffusion of I6!S +Cua and Ta')or( 2008.
#ccoun$ing s$andard se$$ing is a foca) oin$ for cri$ica) accoun$ing Te rocess as
o$en$ia) $o inf)ic$ )arge )osses and 'ie)d /indfa)) gains for $e ar$ician$s +6ogar$'( 1998.
Tus( $e accoun$ing rofession and )arge $ransna$iona) corora$ions refer accoun$ing o)ic'
$o be de$ermined according $o $e rocesses of se)fregu)a$ion T/o in$erre)a$ed remises:
g)oba)ia$ion imac$s on so"ereign$' of $e na$ion s$a$es and accoun$ing is im)ica$edD $o
manage $e g)oba) commons in"o)"es democra$iing organia$iona) re)a$ionsi and in"o)"es
/or5ing $o comba$ $e ad"erse imac$s of g)oba) cai$a)ism +Feman( 200<. Te ossibi)i$'
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
7
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 8/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
of come$i$ion as ser"ed us /e)) b' de"e)oing efficien$ frame/or5s in an' fie)ds
Come$i$i"e in$erac$ion among s$andardse$$er( business firm and in"es$ors across $e g)obe
/i)) )ead us $o be$$er accoun$ing rac$ices and s$andards and $o )o/er cos$ of cai$a) +Sunder(
2002.
Te raid congruence is a)so aen in ano$er #SI#N coun$r' Con$inued gro/$
and $e a$$rac$ion of foreign cai$a) $o domes$ic "en$ures /i)) deend on $ransarenc' of $e
financia) dea)ings Cina( as an emerging mar5e$ econom'( as a"e been successfu) in
issued four se$s of accoun$ing regu)a$ions +1992( 1998( 2001( 200-. and /as considered $o be
$e grea$er conformi$' /i$ I6!S +I#SB( 200-. Te significan$ imro"emen$ in com)iance(
consis$enc' and comarabi)i$' indices on $e 1999 and 2002 annua) reor$ of Cinese )is$ed
firms as ro"en $e con"ergence of Cinese ?##% /i$ I6!S +%eng e$ a)( 2008. India is
s$i)) mo"ing for/ard in )ine /i$ I6!S bu$ o)i$ica) and socia) imedimen$s need $o be $ac5ed
in order $o imro"ed comarabi)i$' for financia) s$a$emen$ users +%erumra) e$ a)( 2009.
ean/i)e( as an emerging coun$r'( ,aa5s$an ad )i$$)e coice bu$ $o roceed /i$ I6!S
and $a$ I6!S re)e"ance is )i5e)' $o increase as ,aa5 economic de"e)omen$ con$inues
Im)emen$a$ion of I6!S is ro"ing rob)ema$ic bu$ i$ $a5ing )ace s)o/)' +T'ra)) e$ a)(
2007. ,aa5s$an as acie"ed ou$s$anding success res$ruc$uring i$s econom' from cen$ra)
)anning $o mar5e$ based s's$em #do$ion of I6!S is rema$ure ac$ion b' $e o)ic'ma5ers
and is )i5e)' $o carr' )i$$)e benefi$ for economies in $e foreseeab)e fu$ure %o)ic'ma5ers
sou)d a more )anned and gradua$ed aroac $o ado$ing I6!S in emerging economies $o
meaningfu))' ado$ of I6!S and benefi$ from $e ado$ion e3ercise +=ossain and !aman(
2007.
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
8
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 9/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
Te o$er fac$s in Iran are $e ne/)' reorganied s$andards se$$ing board ma5e use of
$e ro"ided oor$uni$' $o se$ in$erna$iona))' armonied accoun$ing s$andards /i)e
ma5ing a))o/ance for )oca) socioeconomic en"ironmen$ oreo"er( go"ernmen$ ambi$ion
for s/if$ economic de"e)omen$ ersuading foreign and )oca) ri"a$e in"es$ors $ended $o
con$inue $e ressure on ig au$ori$ies $o begin $e $ird /a"e of ri"a$iing /ic
roduces more ca))enges for in$erna$iona) armonia$ion in accoun$ing s$andards se$$ing
+!ouda5i( 2007. In Ira*( accoun$ing s's$em mig$ be usefu) for ne/ Ira* is in$erna$iona)
accoun$ing s$andards I$ aears more sui$ab)e for $e ne/ mar5e$ based econom' )i5e Ira*
ra$er $an e3erimen$ing /i$ o$er coun$ries@ s$andards %re"ious e3osure $o #merican
and Bri$is accoun$ing ru)es in bo$ rac$ice and educa$ion /ou)d ease $e rocess of
ado$ing $e in$erna$iona) accoun$ing s$andards +#)Naar( 2008.
In order $o ensure *ua)i$' financia) reor$ing rac$ice in %a5is$an( i$ re*uires roer
moni$oring and enforcemen$ mecanism Te s$a$u$or' regu)a$ors mus$ a"e ade*ua$e o/er(
caaci$' and au$ori$' $a$ mus$ be indeenden$ of accoun$ing rofession in %a5is$an /i$ a
"ie/ $o s$reng$ening $e enforcemen$ mecanism and au$ori$' $o imose )ega) sanc$ions for
$e "ia)a$ors +=ossain and E)Sa)'( 1997. Te ins$i$u$e of Car$ered #ccoun$an$s of
Bang)ades /or5ing on $e ado$ion of I#S bu$ com)iance /i$ $e accoun$ing s$andards is
no$ )ega))' re*uired Te s$andardse$$ing rocess ado$ed b' IC#B is e"en$ua))' a c)osed
door rocess and in$eres$ed users of accoun$ing informa$ion do no$ a"e an' cance $o
ar$icia$e in $e s$andardse$$ing rocess +=ossain e$ a)( 1997.
!esearc re)a$ed com)iance /i$ I#S found $a$ $ere is a significan$ e3$en$ of non
com)iance( esecia))' in resec$ /i$ I#S disc)osures( and $a$ 5e' fac$ors associa$ed /i$
)e"e) of com)iance inc)uding )is$ing s$a$us( being audi$ed b' Big <G2 firms( $e $'e of
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
9
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 10/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
reference $o I#S and coun$r' of domici)e +S$ree$ and ?ra'( 2002. #no$er researc found
$a$ foreign o/nersi is a osi$i"e de$erminan$ of iger I6!S com)iance and $a$ iger
I6!S com)iance is osi$i"e)' re)a$ed $o sare $urno"er Tus grea$er foreign o/nersi and
imro"ing $e *ua)i$' of a domes$ic firm@s financia) s$a$emen$s fo))o/ing manda$or' I6!S
ado$ion ma' )o/er a firm@s cos$ of cai$a) +Bo"a( 2008.
3.3. A))!t) R!*#&u#tion
Te goa) of I#S 1- a)' for beginning or af$er anuar' 1( 200< is $o rescribe $e
accoun$ing $rea$men$ of $angib)e fi3ed asse$s( so $e users of financia) s$a$emen$ ma' 5no/
informa$ion abou$ $e in"es$men$ $a$ $e ins$i$u$ion as in i$s roer$' and e*uimen$ as /e))
as $e canges $a$ a"e occurred in $a$ in"es$men$ #ccoun$ing informa$ion is ref)ec$ed b'
i$s ins$rumen$s so $a$ can affec$ firm@s "a)ue 6air "a)ue informa$ion is "a)ue re)e"an$ for $e
users of financia) s$a$emen$ Terefore( measuring ins$rumen$s a$ fair "a)ue can assis$
in"es$ors for be$$er decision
Te cange of asse$s "a)ue can be caused b' genera) rice )e"e) of cange for
ins$ance $e magni$ude of S /ar and os$ /ar bu$ a)so b' o$er d'namic e)emen$s in $e
economic s's$em suc as cange in ub)ic $as$es or bu'ing abi$s Tis /i)) cause e3ansion
of sa)es in some indus$ries re)a$i"e $o o$ers Conse*uen$)'( $e "a)ue of )an$( maciner'(
)and( re$ai) ou$)e$ )oca$ions( e*uimen$ /i)) rise in suc indus$ries( dec)ine in o$ers a$a on
asse$ re"a)ua$ions comi)ed from S 272 )arge indus$ria) corora$ions from 192<19>4 Tis
fac$ /as based on $e c'c)ica) increase of /ri$eu in roseri$' eriods before S grea$
deression in 1929 and /ri$edo/n in deression eriods $en Sound rinci)es of asse$
ro"ide a basis for aro3ima$ions of curren$ "a)ue Ins$ead of difficu)$ies of rac$ica)
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
10
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 11/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
im)emen$a$ion( re"a)ua$ions of asse$s $a5e )ace in rac$ice +es$on( 19<>. Te need $o
dear$ from cos$ basis origina))' bac5ed b' a a)f cen$ur' e"en$s /ic is address $o S
econom' suc as or)d ar I( ear)' 20@s reco"er'( )a$e 20@s re"ersa) $rend( $roug ou$ >0@s
and $e 40@s again re"ersed $e c'c)e Cos$ or i$s e*ui"a)en$ as been $e $ime onored basis
for $e "a)ua$ion of fi3ed asse$s on $e ba)ance see$ bu$ re"a)ua$ion under cer$ain condi$ions
can a)so be denied +,emner( 19<2. Bo$ $e accoun$an$@s and economis$@s measure of "a)ue
and income are needed !e$ain origina) cos$ as a basis of accoun$abi)i$' and $o a"e a
mone$ar' measure of income based on cos$ offer fo))o/ing considera$ions: $a3 re$urn and
go"ernmen$ reor$( ub)ic unders$anding( managemen$ erformance measuremen$( basic for
adus$men$ $o ref)ec$ economic "a)ues and economic income n $e o$er and( $e
su)emen$ar' s$a$emen$s so/ing economic income and $e condi$ion of $e business as
e3ressed in curren$ do))ars are "er' usefu) for $e economis$ and $e businessman +Be))(
19<>.
easuring roer$'( )an$ and e*uimen$ in S# is s$ric$)' using is$orica) cos$ bu$
re"a)ua$ions $o fair "a)ue are acce$ab)e rac$ice under in$erna$iona) and na$iona) accoun$ing
s$andards suc as I6!S( ,( #us$ra)ia and Ne/ ea)and In 19>0s( SEC discouraged asse$
/ri$e us $o fair "a)ue for ub)ic offering regis$ra$ion SEC essen$ia))' remo"ed $e o$ion of
u/ard re"a)ua$ion of roer$'( )an$ and e*uimen$ in 1940s $roug $e enforcemen$ of
financia) s$a$emen$ informa$ion fi)ed /i$ SEC regis$ra$ion s$a$emen$s +=ermann e$ a)(
200-. SEC /as using i$s regis$ra$ion o/ers $o Hcensor@ financia) s$a$emen$s /ic referred
$o es$ima$es of curren$ "a)ues( regard)ess of e"idence used $o arri"e a$ $ose es$ima$es
+a)5er( 1992. Tis ban con$inued in 19<0s( disc)osure of fair "a)ues in $e foo$no$es $o
financia) s$a$emen$ /as e3$ended
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
11
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 12/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
#ssumed $e ,orea econom' in s$abi)i$'( $e %roer$' !e"a)ua$ion Fa/ of 19<8 +Fa/
No 4-8. /as enac$ed in anuar' 19<8 esi$e i$s comu)sor' and rice con$inued $o rise(
maori$' of $e business corora$ions and rac$ica))' a)) so)e rorie$orsis did no$ ado$
re"a)ua$ion rocedures Ten( b' $e $ime $e' began $o rea)ie $e ad"an$ages and necessi$'
of re"a)ua$ion( $e o)i$ica) si$ua$ion ad become com)ica$ed Te Fa/ 19-2 /as sim)er
$an $e 19<8 Fa/ since firms /ere gi"en coice of re"a)uing or no$ re"a)uing roer$ies
using genera) rice )e"e) inde3 +Fee( 19-<. uring and immedia$e)' af$er or)d ar II(
aan e3erienced in a /i)d inf)a$ion %rice inde3 increased fourfo)d from 194< $o 194- and
$ri)ed again in $e fo))o/ing 'ear Tis e3$raordinar' rise of rices raised man' economic
rob)ems eisei Singi5ai %)an /as re)eased and fi3ed asse$s and )and cou)d be re"a)ued as
of une >0( 1949 Ten( uon re*ues$ of $e Sureme Commander of $e #))ied %o/er(
recommenda$ions made b' #merican economis$s and $a3 secia)is$s $o aan inis$r' of
6inance #f$er economic reco"ered i$s roseri$'( ano$er s$es $a5en: $e !e"a)ua$ion Fa/
19<0( $e 19<1 amendmen$ and $e 19<> amendmen$( $e Fa/ 19<4 and 19<7 Te aanese
demons$ra$es successfu) e3eriences +a"idson and asuba( 19-0.
sing frame/or5 of *ua)i$a$i"e carac$eris$ics of accoun$ing informa$ion in S6#C
No 2 +6#SB( 1980.( academic researc as so/n $a$ fair "a)ue for roer$'( )an$ and
e*uimen$ are more re)e"an$ $o decision ma5ers for e3am)e in redic$ing s$oc5 rice( fu$ure
earning( di"idend o)ic' e$c 6air "a)ue measures for roer$'( )an$ and e*uimen$ are
suerior $o is$orica) cos$ based on redic$i"e "a)ue( feedbac5 "a)ue( $ime)iness( neu$ra)i$'(
reresen$a$ion fai$fu)ness( comarabi)i$' and consis$enc' Jerifiabi)i$' aears $o be so)e
*ua)i$a$i"e carac$eris$ics fa"oring is$orica) cos$ o"er fair "a)ue +=errmann e$ #)( 200-.
$er s$udies a"e found simi)ar)'( fair "a)ue disc)osures a"e incremen$a) e3)ana$or'
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
12
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 13/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
o/er +Bub)i$ e$ a)( 198<D urdoc( 198-D =a/ and Fus$gar$en( 1988. Con"erse)'( se"era)
s$udies resu)$ed differen$)' +Bea"er e$ a)( 1982D Bea"er and !'an( 198<D Bernard and !u)and(
1987.
In financia) indus$r'( re*uiring fair "a)ue as $e reor$ed measure ma' no$ imro"e
$e *ua)i$' for informa$ion o"er is$orica) cos$ measure of a)) ban5 o)ding comanies un)ess
aroria$e es$ima$ion me$ods ; guidance for $e mar5e$ ins$rumen$( $a$ are no$ $raded in
ac$i"e mar5e$( are used b' firm /i$ )ess sois$ica$ed informa$ion s's$em +,urama and
,im( 200>. ?erman ban5ers gran$ed significan$)' iger )oans $o comanies reor$ing
roer$'( )an and e*uimen$ a$ fair "a)ue( /i)e S ban5ers gran$ed significan$)' iger
)oans $o comanies reor$ing using is$orica) cos$ +Nico)s and Buerger( 2002. =is$orica)
cos$ figures domina$e curren$ and re)acemen$ cos$ disc)osures +Bea"er and Fandsman( 198>D
Bea"er e$ a)( 1982D Bea"er and !'an( 198<D Bernard and !u)and( 1987. Te o$er s$udies
found $a$ fair "a)ue disc)osures a"e incremen$a) e3)ana$or' o/er +Bub)i$ e$ a)( 198<D
=a/ and Fu$sgar$en( 1988.
era$iona)ising $e fair "a)ue for $e conce$ of accoun$ing and )ega) uroses
some$ime faces difficu)$' esecia))' in $e si$ua$ion /ere $e roer$' being "a)ued is
subec$ $o imerfec$ or incom)e$e mar5e$s Tis can resu)$ in uncer$ain$'( ambigui$' and
measuremen$ error in accoun$ing "a)ua$ion #ccoun$an$s and audi$ors can )oo5 $o $e "arious
)ega) decisions +cCa$ie( C)ifford and a))e$D !amsa'D SairD urdocD Turnbu)). for
guidance on o/ $e cour$s a"e dea)$ /i$ "arious "a)ua$ion issues +Be$$s and ines( 2004.
!es$ruc$uring coman' $roug asse$ re"a)ua$ions can as5 )oca) urisdic$ion for )o/er
roer$' $a3 "a)ua$ions in case $e roer$' is /or$ )ess "acan$ because i$ )ef$ em$' +in$(
2009.
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
1>
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 14/28
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 15/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
accoun$ b' non re"a)uing firms( asse$s are no$ of a $'e aroria$e $o re"a)ue ans/er /as
se)ec$ed b' mos$ C6s Te use of cai$a) rofi$ reser"e and asse$ rea)ia$ion reser"e sread
re)a$i"e)' simi)ar /ic is for cai$a) rofi$ on)'( rea)ied re"a)ua$ion sur)uses on)' e$c Tis
aer conc)uded $a$ boo5 "a)ues inc)uding asse$ re"a)ua$ion reser"es are more a)igned /i$
$e mar5e$ "a)ue of $e firm $an boo5 "a)ues e3c)uding asse$ re"a)ua$ions Tus( asse$
re"a)ua$ion reser"es as reor$ed under #us$ra)ian ?##% e) $o ro"ide a be$$er summar' of
$e curren$ s$a$e of $e firm +Eas$on e$ a)( 199>.
!esearc associa$ed asse$ re"a)ua$ions and fu$ure erformance resu)$ed in
significan$)' osi$i"e)' o"er one( $/o and $ree 'ears subse*uen$ $o $e re"a)ua$ion Con$ro)
$es$ for fu$ure cange is in erformance( ris5( gro/$ and sie ore findings are re"a)ua$ion
ba)ance is significan$)' osi$i"e)' associa$ed /i$ rice incremen$a) $o ne$ income and boo5
"a)ue of e*ui$' Curren$ 'ear u/ard re"a)ua$ions are significan$)' osi$i"e)' associa$ed /i$
re$urns +#bood' e$ #)( 1999. #no$er researc as been done regarding re"a)ua$ion amoun$
and sare rices and or re$urns +#mir e$ a)( 199>D Eas$on e$ #)( 199>D Bar$ and C)inc(
199-D Bar$ and C)inc( 1998.D and osi$i"e mar5e$ reac$ion $o u/ard re"a)ua$ion
announcemen$ +S$andis and ng( 1982D Sare and a)5er( 197<.
sing da$a from #us$ra)ian ub)ic comanies /ic announced u/ard asse$
re"a)ua$ions during 19-01970( i$ /as associa$ed /i$ subs$an$ia) u/ard mo"emen$s in
s$oc5 rices and genera))' sus$ained in $e os$announcemen$ mon$s 6ur$ermore( s$oc5
mar5e$ aears $o diges$ $is ne/ informa$ion *uic5)' in$o s$oc5 rices as $e adus$men$ /as
a)mos$ com)e$e a$ $e c)ose of $e announcemen$ mon$ #sse$s re"a)ued inc)uding Fand
and bui)ding /ic is more re"a)ued $an )an$ and e*uimen$ Tis researc found $a$
mar5e$ regards as announcemen$ of an asse$ re"a)ua$ion as informa$ion significance( $e
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
1<
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 16/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
mar5e$ aears $o absorb $e informa$ion con$en$ of asse$ re"a)ua$ions *uic5)' in$o securi$'
rices( and fina))'( $ere is )i$$)e e"idence $o suor$ $e "ie/ $a$ $e announcemen$ of asse$
re"a)ua$ions is associa$ed /i$ s's$ema$ic canges in $e "o)a$i)i$' of a s$oc5@s re$urn re)a$i"e
$o $e mar5e$ +Sare and a)5er( 197<. ue coman'@s asse$s is grea$)' in e3cess of figures
so/n on $e boo5( $e effec$ is e*ui$' of sareo)ders as been unders$a$ed and a more
correc$ of $e sares as no$ been disc)osed #s a conse*uence( coman' mus$ consider
issuing s$oc5 di"idends or bonus sares +Cambers( 19<8.
sing da$a of Bri$is comanies )is$ed in $e eriod 19-4197> $e e3amina$ion
resu)$ed in a osi$i"e u/ard mo"emen$ in $e cumu)a$i"e a"erage residua) around $e
announcemen$ da$e of asse$ re"a)ua$ion I$ a)so aears $a$ re"a)ua$ions associa$ed /i$
une3ec$ed osi$i"e re$urns /en $a5en b' $e cai$a) mar5e$ as a oin$er $o o$er fa"orab)e
signa)s from a coman' and $o increase fu$ure benefi$ of s$oc5o)ders #sse$s re"a)ua$ion
/ou)d be seen b' $e cai$a) mar5e$ in $e fo))o/ing circums$ances: $e coman' es$ima$es
$e resen$ "a)ue of asse$s as grea$er $an $eir reor$ed boo5 "a)ue( gi"en e3ec$a$ion of
fu$ure earnings suc as di"idendD reducing deb$;e*ui$' ra$io /ou)d raise o$en$ia) fur$er
deb$D re"a)ua$ion common)' fo))o/ed b' announcemen$ of di"idend a' ou$ ra$io( earnings
increases( increases in $e di"idend ra$e er sare n $e o$er and( re"a)ua$ions cou)d be
regarded unfa"orab)e in $ese circums$ances: u/ard re"a)ua$ion roduces an increase of ne$
boo5 asse$s and a dec)ine in $e ra$e of re$urnD re"a)ua$ion under$a5en as a defense agains$
$a5eo"er bids Te disc)osure of asse$s re"a)ua$ion is mos$)' announced on $e re)ease of
annua) reor$ $en fo))o/ed b' re)iminar' earnings and di"idend reor$ bu$ rare)' informed
in merger announcemen$ or cai$a) recons$ruc$ion +S$andis and ng( 1982.
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
1-
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 17/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
#us$ra)ian firms can base re"a)ua$ions on direc$or or indeenden$ araiser "a)ue
es$ima$es In mos$ cases( re"a)ued asse$s based on direc$or and indeenden$ araiser
"a)ua$ions are significan$)' osi$i"e)' associa$ed /i$ rice Bu$ $ere is a )i$$)e e"idence $o
indica$e $a$ direc$or and indeenden$based "a)ua$ions are "ie/ed differen$)'( sugges$ing
direc$or@s ri"a$e informa$ion enance "a)ue es$ima$es desi$e $eir o$en$ia) se)fin$eres$ed
financia) s$a$emen$s managemen$ incen$i"es +Bar$ and C)inc( 1998. Te dis$inc$ion
be$/een direc$or and indeenden$ "a)ua$ions is unc)ear and $e regression resu)$ of eac
sources a"e simi)ar e3)ana$or' o/er +Eas$on( 1998. uring $e)eone sur"e'( indica$ed
$a$ man' direc$ors@ "a)ua$ions /ere suor$ed b' indeenden$ /ic is $en for disc)osure
urose of ba)ance see$( indeenden$ "a)ua$ions re"ie/ed b' direc$or and $is regard as
direc$ors@ re"a)ua$ions +Eas$on e$ a)( 199>. Te o$er s$ud' found $a$ indeenden$
araisers are more )i5e)' $o be used for re"a)ua$ions of )and and bui)ding and direc$ors are
more )i5e)' for in"es$men$( )an$ and e*uimen$ and iden$ifiab)e in$angib)es Tis is as
e"idence of firms arnessing direc$ors@ 5no/)edge of asse$ secifici$ies 6irms /i$ )ess
indeenden$ boards are more )i5e)' $o use indeenden$ araisers as e"idence subs$i$u$abi)i$'
be$/een go"ernance mecanisms +Co$$er and !icardson( 2002.
sing a , sam)e o"er eriod of 19941998( researc as done for re"a)uers in
$iming issue !e"a)uers a"e significan$ iger indus$r' median deb$$o$o$a) asse$ ra$io(
)arger $o$a) sa)es and fi3ed asse$ in$ensi$' and are )ess )i5e)' $o be in a ig $ec or !&
in$ensi"e indus$r' !e"a)uers a)so a"e iger re$urn in $e 'ear before( 'ear and $e 'ear
af$er re"a)ua$ions 6indings s$a$ed $a$ a curren$ u/ard re"a)ua$ion is associa$ed /i$ as$
sare re$urn indica$e u/ard re"a)ua$ions are no$ en$ire)' $ime)' 6ur$ermore( in"es$iga$ion
finds re"a)uers are domina$ed b' firms /i$ bo$ a iger sare re$urn in $e as$ $/o 'ears
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
17
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 18/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
and iger indus$r' )e"erage indica$ing , firms de)a' $e recogni$ion of increased asse$
"a)ues un$i) $is good ne/s as been confirmed b' $eir suerior mar5e$ erformance( and
/en indus$r' )e"erage is ig +Ceng and Fin( 2009. , firms a)so de)a' $eir u/ard
asse$ re"a)ua$ions because $e' can reduce fu$ure rofi$( re$urn on $o$a) asse$ and e*ui$'
during economicreco"ering eriod +Fin and %easne))( 2000.
3.. Accountin St#n#" (o" P"o$!"t' P&#nt #n EBui$%!nt in Inon!)i#
Indonesian Ins$i$u$e of #ccoun$an$ +II#. es$ab)ised in ecember 2>( 19<7 #$ $a$
$ime( $e obec$i"es /ere $o suer"ise( guide accoun$ing rofession( $o acie"e iger
s$andard of accoun$ing educa$ion and iger accoun$ing ser"ice *ua)i$' Tese a)so concern
/i$ $e na$iona) de"e)omen$ obec$i"es /ic is inc)udes $e *ua)i$' of uman resource
Tus( rofessiona) come$ence of accoun$an$ a$ )as$ /ou)d be in )ine /i$ re"ious
s$a$emen$s II# "ision@s is $o be $e )eading rofessiona) organia$ion in de"e)oing
5no/)edge and accoun$ing( business managemen$ and ub)ic rac$ice /ic is e$ic( socia)
resonsibi)i$' and en"ironmen$a))' orien$ed in na$iona) and in$erna$iona) ersec$i"e
Te is$or' of accoun$ing rofession in Indonesia can be di"ided in$o $/o ases
+Tuana5o$$a( 2007.: 6irs$( %reIndeendence da' on #ugus$ 17( 194< $o $e end of Indonesian
firs$ residen$ era( Ir Soe5arno in 19-- In $is ase( Indonesia /as occuied b' u$c Tis
condi$ion ob"ious)' inf)uenced $e )a/ and accoun$ing infras$ruc$ures Toug is eroic
fig$ing( Indonesian ne/ go"ernmen$ s$rugg)ed in o"ercoming 'er inf)a$ion rob)em and
eo)e suffered from economic crisis un$i) $e end of Soe5arno era Second( ne/ Indonesian
econom' during Indonesian second residen$ era( Soear$o and fo))o/ed b' $e o$er
residen$ia) go"ernmen$ u $o no/ =uge cai$a) inf)o/s and foreign deb$s financed $is
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
18
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 19/28
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 20/28
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 21/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
Tab)e 1 u)$i Indus$r' a$a 2008
NO INDUSTRY CLASSIFICATION TOTAL MODEL
1 #nima) 6eed and =usbandr' 1 Cos$
2 ining 1 Cos$
> Cons$ruc$ions 1 Cos$4 6ood and Be"erages 1 Cos$
< e$a) 1 Cos$
- E)ec$ronic and ffice 2 Cos$
7 #u$omo$i"e > Cos$
8 %o$ograic 1 Cos$
9 Transor$a$ion - Cos$
10 Te)ecommunica$ion 2 Cos$
11 o)esa)e 7 Cos$
12 Ban5ing 17 Cos$
1> Credi$ #gencies 4 Cos$
14 Securi$ies < Cos$1< Insurance 2 Cos$
1- !ea) Es$a$e and %roer$' 1> Cos$
17 =o$e) and Tra"e) 4 Cos$
18 =o)ding and In"es$men$ 1 Cos$
19 $ers < Cos$
To$a) 77
Tab)e 2 u)$i Indus$r' a$a 2008
NO INDUSTRY CLASSIFICATION TOTAL MODEL
1 ining 2 Cos$
2 Cons$ruc$ion 2 Cos$
> 6ood and Be"erage 1 Cos$
4 e$a) 1 Cos$
< E)ec$ronic 1 Cos$
- #u$omo$i"e 2 Cos$
7 Te)ecommunica$ion 1 Cos$
8 o)esa)e 1 Cos$
9 Ban5ing > Cos$
10 Securi$ies 1 Cos$11 Insurance 1 Cos$
To$a) 1-
5. Di)cu))ion.
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
21
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 22/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
In $e ear)' 'ear ado$ion of %S#, 1-( 2008 and 2009( comanies cose cos$ mode)
ra$er $an re"a)ua$ion mode) an' differences in financia) reor$ and $a3a$ion urose a"e
discouraged comanies in a)'ing re"a)ua$ion mode) Tis fac$ is e3)ained b' fo))o/ing
reasons:
1. Comanies are s$i)) considering re"a)ua$ion mode) /ic is us$ offered in $erm of
ad"an$ages and disad"an$ages I$ is no$ rac$icab)e $o es$ima$e $e effec$ of comonen$
aroac and residua) "a)ue of asse$s oreo"er( $e ado$ion of ne/ s$andard as no$
resu)$ed in cange significan$)' for roer$'( )an$ and e*uimen$
2. Comanies a"e $o ro"ide e3$ra mone' for araiser ser"ice and 10 K $a3 )iab)e of
u/ard re"a)ua$ion of asse$s
>. Too man' i$ems of roer$'( )an$ and e*uimen$ can a)so be rob)ems for re"a)ua$ion
because fair "a)ue is no$ easi)' and re)iab)' a"ai)ab)e and robab)' no$ of a $'e
aroria$e $o re"a)ue
4. True and fair financia) s$a$emen$s uroses( and o$er mo$i"es i$ is no$ considered so far
and re)iabi)i$' is more focus ra$er $an re)e"an$ for *ua)i$a$i"e carac$eris$ic of
accoun$ing informa$ion
<. Comanies /o /an$ $o re"a)ua$e $eir asse$s mus$ a"e ermission from ?enera)
irec$or of Ta3 according $o 6inance inis$er !u)e No 79;%,0>;2008 /ic /as
re)eased sor$)' af$er %S#, 1- 2008 Te rocess i$se)f some$imes $a5es $ime )onger $an
e3ec$ed
-. 6inance inis$er !u)e No 79;%,0>;2008 s$a$e $a$ a)) $'es of asse$s inc)uding )and
mus$ be re"a)ua$ed( mean/i)e %S#, 1- a))o/ comanies $o re"a)ua$e on)' a grou of
asse$s Tis cause comanies mus$ reare 2 scenarios for asse$s re"a)ua$ion
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
22
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 23/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
7. 6inance inis$er !u)e No 79;%,0>;2008 offers comanies $o re"a)ua$e in e"er' <
'ears( bu$ refer $o %S#, 1- comanies ma' re"a)ua$e $eir asse$s e"er' 'ear as )ong as
$ere is a significan$ difference be$/een carr'ing cos$s and mar5e$ "a)ue Tis basic
difference rea))' bo$ers comanies /ic in$end $o re"a)ua$e $eir asse$s $oug $ime
difference can be se$$)ed $roug fisca) reconci)ia$ion
8. # 10 K $a3 mus$ be aid from $e increase of mar5e$ "a)ue in 12 mon$s /ereas
re"ious)'( 6inancia) inis$er ecree No 48-;,,0>;2002 a))o/ $a$ a'men$ in 2<
'ears ins$a))men$ Comanies /ic suffer cas f)o/ rob)em mus$ consider $e effec$ of
asse$ re"a)ua$ion decision
:. Conc&u)ion
In summar'( comanies so far s$i)) "ie/ $ere are difficu)$ies in a)'ing re"a)ua$ion
mode) for financia) accoun$ing and $a3a$ion urose i$ou$ considering $e mo$i"es and
effec$ of asse$ re"a)ua$ion( comanies )oo5 s$i)) refer cos$ me$od
2. Li%it#tion #n Su!)tion
6ur$er researc sou)d consider as5ing comanies for mo$i"es or reasons of no$
re"a)ua$e $eir asse$s $roug *ues$ionnaire as /e)) as using more sam)es and obser"a$ion
'ears Tis can ro"ide deeer ana)'sis and iger )e"e) of confidence using s$a$is$ica) $es$s
6. R!(!"!nc!)
#bood'( a"id( Bar$( ar' E and ,ani5( !on +1999. !e"a)ua$ions of 6i3ed #sse$ and
6u$ure %erformance: E"idence from , ourna) of #ccoun$ing and Economics( 2-:149
178
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
2>
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 24/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
#i$5en( and # Is)am 1984 ise))ing #rgumen$s #gains$ In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing
S$andards In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing and Educa$ion !esearc( 8+2.:21>2
#)Naar( 6ouad , +2008. #)ica$ion of In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing S$andards in Ira* #sian%acific Conference on In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing Issues
#mir( E( =arris( TS( Jenu$i( E, +199>. # Comarison of S and NonS ?##% #ccoun$ing
easures sing 6orm 206 !econci)ia$ions ourna) of #ccoun$ing !esearc( 21:>20>7<#sraf( and ?ani +200<. #ccoun$ing e"e)omen$ in %a5is$an in #sian #ccoun$ing
=andboo5: ser@s ?uide $o $e #ccoun$ing En"ironmen$ in 1- coun$ries( edi$ed b'
Saro5 Saudagaran( Tomson In$erna$iona) Business: Singaore 72<7<2Bar$( E( and C)inc( ? +199-. In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing ifferences and Teir !e)a$ion $o
Sare %rices: E"idence from ,( #us$ra)ian and Canadian 6irms Con$emorar'
#ccoun$ing !esearc( 1>:1><170
Bar$( E( and C)inc( ? +1998. !e"a)ued 6inancia)( Tangib)e and In$angib)e #sse$s:#ssocia$ions /i$ Sare %rices and Nonar5e$ Based Es$ima$es ourna) of #ccoun$ing
!esearc( >-:1992>>
Bea"er( =( ?riffin( %#( and Fandsman ! +198>. Te Incremen$a) Informa$ion Con$en$ of
!e)acemen$ Cos$ Earnings ourna) of #ccoun$ing and Economics( <:1<>9Bea"er( =( !'an( S? +198<. =o/ e)) S$a$emen$ No >> Earnings E3)ain S$oc5 !e$urnsA
6inancia) #na)'s$ ourna)( 1>:--71Be)5oui( # +2004. #ccoun$ing Teor'( <$ Ed Fondon: Tomson
Be))( #)ber$ F+19<>. 6i3ed #sse$ and Curren$ Cos$ Te #ccoun$ing !e"ie/( 29+1.:44<>
Bernard( J( and !u)and( ! +1987. Te Incremen$a) Informa$ion Con$en$ of =is$orica) Cos$ andCurren$ Cos$ Numbers: Time Series #na)'sis Te #ccoun$ing !e"ie/( -2:710722
Be$$s( ennifer and ines( ?raeme +2004. #)ica$ion of 6air Ja)ue Conce$: E"idence 6rom
#us$ra)ian Fega) ecisions( #us$ra)ian #ccoun$ing !e"ie/( 14+1.:->78
B)ac5( EF( Se))ers( ,6 and an)'( TS +1998. Earnings anagemen$ sing #sse$ Sa)es: #nIn$erna$iona) S$ud' of Coun$ries #))o/ing Non Curren$ #sse$ !e"a)ua$ion ourna) of
Business 6inance and #ccoun$ing( 2<+910.:12871>17
Bo"a( 6rancesco +2008. Te e$erminan$ and Conse*uences of =iger I6!S Com)iance6o))o/ing anda$or' I6!S #do$ion in Emerging ar5e$ #sian %acific Conference on
In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing Issues
Bro/n( %( Ian =( and Fo( # +1992. 6i3ed #sse$ !e"a)ua$ion and anageria) Incen$i"es#bacus( 28+1.:>-<7
Bub)i$( B( 6rec5a( T( and c,eo/n( C+198<. ar5e$ #ssocia$ion and 6#SB S$a$emen$
>> isc)osures: # !ee3amina$ion ourna) of #ccoun$ing !esearc( 2>+Su).:12>
Cambers( ! +19<8. #sse$ !e"a)ua$ions and S$oc5 i"idends ourna) of #ccoun$anc'(10-:<<-8
Cand)er( !# +1992. Te in$erna$iona) armonia$ion of accoun$ing: In searc of inf)uence
In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( 27+>.: 2222>>Ceng( CS #gnes and Fin( S$een +2009. en o Te' !e"a)ue Teir #sse$s /ardA
E"idence from $e , In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing and Informa$ion anagemen$(
17+2.:1--188Coi( 6 and ue))er( ? +1984. In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing Ne/ erse': %ren$ice =a))
Cua( ai 6ong and Ta')or( S$een +2008. Te !ise and !ise of I6!S: #n E3amina$ion of
I6!S iffusion ourna) of #ccoun$ing %ub)ic %o)ic'( 27:4-247>
Co$$er( +1999. #sse$ !e"a)ua$ion and eb$ Con$rac$ing #bacus( ><+>.:2-828<
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
24
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 25/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
Co$$er( u)ie and !icardson( Sco$$ +2002. !e)iabi)i$' of #sse$ !e"a)ua$ions: Te imac$ of
#raisers Indeendence !e"ie/ of #ccoun$ing S$udies( 4:4><4<7
Cour$ne'( S and Caan( S +2004. Te imac$ of eb$ on ar5e$ !eac$ion $o !e"a)ua$ion of Non Curren$ #sse$s %acificBasin 6inance ourna)( 12: 21924>
Co"rig( J( I e6ond and =ung +2007. =ome Bias( 6oreign u$ua) 6und =o)dings(
and $e Jo)un$ar' #do$ion of In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing S$andards ourna) of #ccoun$ing!esearc( 4<( 41L70
Craig( !usse) and iga( ose)i$o ? +199-. 6inancia) !eor$ing !egu)a$ion in #SE#N:
6ea$ures and %rosec$s Te In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( >+2.:2>92<9Cu))inan( C +1999. In$erna$iona) Trade and #ccoun$ing %o)ic' Coice: Teor' and Canadian
E"idence Te In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( >4+4.:<97-07
as5e( =( F =ai)( C Feu( and Jerdi !S +2007. #do$ing a )abe): =e$erogenei$' in $e
economic conse*uences of I6!S ado$ions or5ing aer( ni"ersi$' of %enns')"ania and ni"ersi$' of Cicago #"ai)ab)e a$: $$:;;ssrncom;abs$rac$M979-<0
a"idson( S'dne' and asuba( asu5ici +19-0. #sse$ !e"a)ua$ion and Income Ta3a$ion in
aan Na$iona) Ta3 ourna)( 1>+1.:4<<8
ing( uan( eanean( Tomas and S$o/o)'( =er"e +200<. ' o Na$iona) ?##% iffer from I#SA Te ro)e of cu)$ure Te In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( 40:>2<><0
Eas$on( %e$er +1998. iscussion on !e"a)ued 6inancia)( Tangib)e and In$angib)e #sse$s:#ssocia$ions /i$ Sare %rices and Nonar5e$ Based Es$ima$es ourna) of #ccoun$ing
!esearc( >-:2><247
Eas$on( %( Edde'( %=( and Tre"or( =S +199>. #n In"es$iga$ion of !e"a)ua$ion of Tangib)eFongFi"ed #sse$s ourna) of #ccoun$ing !esearc( >1:1>8 +su)emen$.
6inancia) #ccoun$ing S$andards Board +1980. ua)i$a$i"e Carac$eris$ic of #ccoun$ing
Informa$ion S$a$emen$ of 6inancia) #ccoun$ing Conce$s No < Nor/a)5( Conn 6#SB
6inancia) inis$er !u)e No <9;200< !eub)ic of Indonesia +200<. #ccoun$ing S's$em andCen$ra) ?o"ernmen$ 6inancia) !eor$ing
6inancia) inis$er !u)e No 79;%,0>;2008 !eub)ic of Indonesia +2008. 6i3ed #sse$
!e"a)ua$ion for Ta3a$ion %urose6ogar$'( Timo$' +1998. #ccoun$ing S$andard Se$$ing: # Ca))enge for Cri$ica) #ccoun$ing
!esearcers Cri$ica) %ersec$i"es on #ccoun$ing( 9:<1<<2>
?)en( Feman +200<. # cri$ica) %ersec$i"e on $e =armonisa$ion of #ccoun$ing in a?)oba)ising or)d Cri$ica) %ersec$i"e of #ccoun$ing( 1-:97<992
?ra'( S +1988. To/ard a Teor' of Cu)$ura) Inf)uences on $e e"e)omen$ of #ccoun$ing
S's$em In$erna$iona))'( #bacus( 24+1.:11<
?riffi$( I +1990. Crea$i"e #ccoun$ing Fondon: n/in %aerbac5s?o"ernmen$ !u)e 24;200< !eub)ic of Indonesia +200<. ?o"ernmen$ #ccoun$ing S$andards
No 7: 6i3ed #sse$
?o"ernmen$ !u)e 0-;200- !eub)ic of Indonesia +200-. S$a$e and Foca) #sse$=a/( I and Fus$gar$en( S +1988. E"idence on Income easuremen$ %roer$ies of #S! No
190 and S6#S >> a$a ourna) of #ccoun$ing !esearc( 2-:>>1><2
=errmann( on( Saudagaran( Saro5 ( and Tomas( a'ne B +200-. Te ua)i$' of 6air Ja)ue easures of %roer$'( %)an$ and E*uimen$ #ccoun$ing 6orum( >0:4><9
=ossaim( oniru) #)am( Cooer( ,a$ie and #ndre/( ane +2007. Enforcemen$ and
Com)iance #ccoun$ing S$andards in Bang)ades: # 6rame/or5 #sian #cademic
#ccoun$ing #ssocia$ion Conference
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
2<
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 26/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
=ossaim( oniru) #)am and E)Sa)' Sam +2007. #ccoun$ing S$andards in %a5is$an #sian
#cademic #ccoun$ing #ssocia$ion Conference
=ossain( oniru) #)am and !aman #se* +2007. 6inancia) !eor$ing b' ecree$e Case of ,aa5s$an #sian #cademic #ccoun$ing #ssocia$ion Conference
=uges( SB +2007. # S anager@s ?uide $o ifference Be$/een I6!S and S ?##%
anagemen$ #ccoun$ing uar$er)'I5a$an #5un$an Indonsia( !oadma ,on"ergensi I6!S(OOOO
I5a$an #5un$an Indonesia +2007. %S#, 1-: #5$i"a Te$a
In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing S$andards Commi$$ee +198>. bec$i"es and %rocedures Fondon:I#SC
In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing S$andards Board +200-. Cina #ffirms Commi$men$ $o Con"ergence
of I6!S I#SB #nnouncemen$ and Seec
In$erna$iona) Cai$a) ar5e$ ?rou +IC?. +1992. =armonia$ion of In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ingS$andards Fondon: IC?
In$erna$iona) 6edera$ion of #ccoun$an$s +I6#C. +2007. ne se$ of in$erna$iona) s$andards
imor$an$ for economic gro/$ +ecember >. #"ai)ab)e a$ ///ifacorg;g)oba)sur"e'
Inoue( T and Tomas +199-. Te Coice of #ccoun$ing in aan ourna) of In$erna$iona)6inancia) anagemen$ and #ccoun$ing( 7+1.:12>
aggi( B( and Tsui( +2001. anagemen$ o$i"a$ion and ar5e$ #ssesmen$: !e"a)ua$ion of6i3ed #sse$s ourna) of In$erna$iona) 6inancia) anagemen$ and #ccoun$ing( 12+2.:1-0
187
oson( B +200-. Number Crunc: ' $e ominance of Big 6our #)arming !egu)a$ors6inancia) Times( 1<
,emner( ac5 +19<2. !e"a)ua$ion and erecia$ion of %)an$ #sse$s Te #ccoun$ing
!e"ie/( 27+4.:<0-<1>
,urana( Inder , and ,im 'ungSung +200>. ourna) of #ccoun$ing and %ub)ic %o)ic'(22:1942
Farson( !ober$ , and Bro/n( ,aren F +2001. Fobb'ing of $e In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing
S$andards Commi$$ee: Te Case of Cons$ruc$ion Con$rac$s #d"ances in In$erna$iona)#ccoun$ing( 14:477>
Fa/ 01;2004 !eub)ic of Indonesia +2004. S$a$e Treasur'
Fee( Samue) S +19-<. ,orean #ccoun$ing !e"a)ua$ion Fa/s Te #ccoun$ing !e"ie/(40+>.:-22-2<
Fin( C and %easne)( ,J +2000. 6i3ed #sse$ !e"a)ua$ion and E*ui$' e)e$ion in ,
ourna) of Business 6inance and #ccoun$ing( 27+>4.:><9>94
i))man( ? +2009. E3ecs ai) ar' Scairo for fo)ding I6!S roadma I6!S !eor$er!e$rie"ed une 8( 2009
$$:;;///ifrsreor$ercom;inde3Ao$ionMcomOcon$en$&"ie/Mar$ic)e&idM<2:e3ecs
ai)mar'scairoforfo)dingifrsroadma&ca$idM>-:sec&I$emidM<>in$( S$een F +2009. ?e$ !ead' $o !es$ruc$ure ourna) of #ccoun$anc'( 208+>.: 2-
urdoc( B+198-. Te Informa$ion Con$en$ of 6#S >> !e$urn on E*ui$' Te #ccoun$ing
!e"ie/( -1:27>>87ur'( #B +2000. Te imac$ of ado$ing in$erna$iona) accoun$ing s$andards on $e
armonia$ion of accoun$ing rac$ices In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( ><+4.:47149>
Nico)s( Finda and Buerger( ,ur$ = +2002. ourna) of In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing( #udi$ing
and Ta3a$ion( 11:1<<1->
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
2-
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 27/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
Nobes( C and %ar5er( ! +200-. Comara$i"e in$erna$iona) accoun$ing( 9$ Ed =ar)o/( Eng)and
%earson Educa$ion
%eng( Song)an( Tond5ar !asou) =( Smi$( o'ce "an der Fan( and =ar)ess( a"id +2008.oes Con"ergence of #ccoun$ing S$andards Fead $o $e Con"ergence of #ccoun$ing
%rinci)esA # S$ud' from Cina Te In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( 4>:4484-8
%erera( = and N Ba'doun +2007. Con"ergence i$ In$erna$iona) 6inancia) !eor$ingS$andards: Te Case of Indonesia #d"ances in In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing( 20:201224
%eruma)( Sarini E( E"ans( ar5( Sana'( #gar/a) and #men5ienan( 6e)i3 +2009. Te
e"o)u$ion of Indian #ccoun$ing S$andards: I$s =is$or' and Curren$ S$a$us i$ !egard $oIn$erna$iona) 6inancia) !eor$ing S$andards #d"ances in #ccoun$ing( Incorora$ing
#d"ances in In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing( 2<:10-111
%iera( issonier 6ranc5 +2007. o$i"es for 6i3ed#sse$ !e"a)ua$ion: #n Emirica) #na)'sis
/i$ S/iss a$a In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( 42:18-20<%ur"is( SEC( = ?ernon and iamond +1991. Te I#SC and I$s Comarabi)i$' %roec$:
%rere*uisi$es for success #ccoun$ing =orions( <+2.:2<44
!adebaug( F( ?ra'( S( and B)ac5( E( +200-. In$erna$iona) accoun$ing and mu)$ina$iona)
en$errises( 4
$
Ed Ne/ erse': on i)e' and Sons!iaiBe)5oui( #mad +199<. #ccoun$ing in e"e)oing Coun$ries es$or$( Cr: uorum
Boo5s!ouda5i( ama) +2007. In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing S$andards =armonisa$ion: $e Case of Iran
#sian #cademic #ccoun$ing #ssocia$ion Conference
Saudagaran( Sa5ro5 and iga( ose)i$o ? +1998. #ccoun$ing =armonia$ion in #SE#N:Benefi$s( ode)s and %o)ic' Issues ourna) of In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing( #udi$ing and
Ta3a$ion( 7+1.:214<
Scanne)( , and S)a$er( +2008. SEC o"es $o %u)) %)ug on S #ccoun$ing S$andards Te
a)) S$ree$ ourna)( #1Sare( I? and a)5er( !? +197<. #sse$ !e"a)ua$ions and S$oc5 ar5e$ %rices ourna) of
#ccoun$ing !esearc( 1>:29>>10
S$andis( % and ng( S +1982. Corora$e Signa)ing( #sse$ !e"a)ua$ions and S$oc5 %rices of Bri$is Coman' Te #ccoun$ing !e"ie/( -2:70171<
S$ree$( onna F and ?ra'( S'dne' +2002. 6ac$ors Inf)uencing $e E3$en$ of Corora$e
Com)iance /i$ In$erna$iona) #ccoun$ing S$andards: Summar' of a !esearc onograourna) of #ccoun$ing( #udi$ing and Ta3a$ion( 11:<17-
Sudar/an( and 6ogar$'( +199-. Cu)$ure and #ccoun$ing in Indonesia: #n emirica)
E3amina$ion Te In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( >1+4.:4->481
Sunder( S'am +2002. !egu)a$or' Come$i$ion #mong #ccoun$ing S$andards i$in and#cross Na$iona) Boundaries ourna) of #ccoun$ing and %ub)ic %o)ic'( 21:2192>4
Tua5o$$a( Teodorus +2007. Se$enga #bad %rofesi #5un$ansi Edisi %er$ama( Sa)emba
Ema$ a5ar$aT'ra))( a"id( ood/ard( a"id( and !a5imbe5o"a( #)magou) +2007. Te !e)e"ance of
In$erna$iona) 6inancia) !eor$ing S$andards $o a e"e)oing Coun$r': E"idence from
,aa5s$an Te In$erna$iona) ourna) of #ccoun$ing( 42:82110a)5er( !? +1992. Te SEC@s Ban on /ard !e"a)ua$ions and Te isc)osure of Curren$
Ja)ues #bacus( 28+1.:>><
es$on( 6red ( +19<>. !e"a)ua$ion of 6i3ed #sse$s Te #ccoun$ing !e"ie/( 28+4.: 482490
une 2728( 2011Cambridge( ,
27
8/10/2019 Adam Zakaria
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/adam-zakaria 28/28
2011 Cambridge Business & Economics Conference ISBN : 9780974211428
i$$red( ?( and Can( +1992. #sse$ !e"a)ua$ion and $e i$iga$ion of nderIn"es$men$
#bacus( 28+1.: <874
eff( # S$een +2007. Some bs$ac)es $o ?)oba) 6inancia) !eor$ing Comarabi)i$' andCon"ergence a$ a =ig Fe"e) of ua)i$' Te Bri$is #ccoun$ing !e"ie/( >9:290>02