SANDAG Roadmap Program: Overview · SANDAG Roadmap Program Project Highlight: City of Carlsbad Energy Working Group Item 5 | March 28, 2019 SANDAG Roadmap Program: Overview •SDG&E

3/28/2019

EWG Item 5 1

SANDAG Roadmap Program

Project Highlight: City of Carlsbad

Energy Working Group Item 5 | March 28, 2019

SANDAG Roadmap Program: Overview

• SDG&E Energy Efficiency Funding: Local Government Partnership (LGP)

• SDG&E LGPs: Cities of Chula Vista and

San Diego, County of San Diego, Port of

San Diego, SANDAG

• SANDAG LGP:• SANDAG Roadmap Program

• 16 SANDAG member agencies without

LGPs

• Began in 2010 with energy efficiency

• Integrated climate action planning in 2015

• Current agreement through 2020

2

3/28/2019

EWG Item 5 2

Roadmap Program – Project Highlight:

City of Carlsbad

• 2014Carlsbad Energy Roadmap* completed

• 2015Carlsbad Climate Action Plan adopted

• 2018Carlsbad Feasibility Study*completed

3

* Prepared by the SANDAG Roadmap Program

City of Carlsbad Project Objectives

• Energy cost savings

• Reliability and resiliency

• Climate Action Plan implementation

• Innovation and clean technology

4

Public Safety and Services Complex

3/28/2019

EWG Item 5 3

Feasibility Study: A Layered Approach

• Energy Efficiency:• Interior and exterior lighting

retrofits • Boiler replacement • Controls for air conditioning

units for advance scheduling and programming

• Demand Side Management:• Advanced building

management• Solar panels• Battery energy storage

• Microgrid

5

Feasibility Study: A Layered Approach

6

New Solar PV

SAFETY CENTER (SC)

(FUTURE) ORIONCENTER (OC)FLEET

MAINTENANCE CENTER (FMC)

SAFETY TRAINING CENTER (STC)

Rooftop Solar PV

New Battery Energy Storage System (BESS)

New Solar PV

NEW ELECTRICVEHICLE (EV) CHARGERS

SDG&E

Loads

Medium Voltage AC Bus

Utility Grid

Low Voltage Switchgear

1st line of defense DER (up to 12 hours (minimum of 4 hours) of islanding capability)

2nd line of defense DER (up to 10 days of islanding capability)

3rd line of defense DER (indefinite islanding capability)

Energy Efficiency Measures Proposed for the building

Building controlled by a Building Management System (BMS)

Asset’s operation optimized by BESS controller

Asset/Load communicated to or operated by Microgrid Controller

Existing Backup Gen

SDG&E

A.T.S.

ExistingBackup Gen

FIRE STATION 5 (FS5)

A.T.S.

A.T.S.

ExistingBackup Gen

Utility Switch

Utility Switch

New Natural Gas Gen

3/28/2019

EWG Item 5 4

Feasibility Study: A Layered Approach

7

➢ Energy Savings and Reduced Environmental & Economical Impact

Utility

Grid

Energy 51%

Peak

Load34%

N. Gas

Usage31%

GHG

57%

SO2

& NOx50%

Utility

Bills

($) 55%

➢ Improved Energy Resiliency & Reliability

➢ Support Clean Energy Market Transformation

➢ Improved Cybersecurity

$6,698,35915 yr

➢ Additional Community & Societal Benefits

*Renewables resources for half of the state's electricity, California Energy Commission, 2015

➢ Project Cost

Many design alternatives to reduce cost

Many project financing solutions

➢ Show City’s Commitment to the CEC* 2030 climate and energy goals

SANDAG Roadmap Program Next Steps

• SANDAG Roadmap Program will continue to offer energy and climate action planning activities primarily funded through the Local Government Partnership with SDG&E through 2020 and will explore additional funding opportunities to support these activities for member agencies in the future.

8

3/28/2019

1

Port of San Diego

Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal Renée Yarmy, Program Manager – Energy & Sustainability

22

Coronado

San Diego

National City

Chula Vista

Imperial Beach

Port of San Diego Jurisdiction

34miles of waterfront

2,403acres of land

3,535acres of water

Port Tidelands

Submerged Tidelands

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019

2

3

The Port Act and Tidelands

Trust Doctrine

Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal 3/28/2019

Promote commerce,

navigation, recreation and

fisheries

Manage San Diego Bay and

the Waterfront ‘Tidelands’

Details responsibility on behalf

of the people of the State of

California

44

Climate Action Plan

10% Reduction by 2020

25% Reduction by 2035

CAP 2006 Baseline Emission Sources(581,750 metric tons CO2e)

117,526

162,556

137,664

131,597

13,169 19,239Electricity

Natural Gas

Transportation: On-road

Transportation: Off-road

Water Use

Waste

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019

3

5

2030 2050

1,200,000

1,100,000

1,000,000

900,000

800,000

700,000

600,000

500,000

400,000

300,000

200,000

100,000

0

2006 2016 2020

Metr

ic T

on

s C

O2e/y

ear

Baseline

581,750

2006 CAP Baseline

Business as

Usual

Projections

688,984731,878

839,113

1,053,582

Reduction

Targets

Future Emission Target

523,57510% reduction

314,14540% reduction 104,715

80% reduction

Note: Timescale is drawn for illustrative purposes.

504,5542016 GHG Inventory

2016 CAP

Inventory

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

Climate Action Plan – Status

66

• Approved a Redevelopment Plan

in 2016

• $10M Transportation Investment

Generating Economic Recovery

(TIGER) grant

• Quadruple cargo throughput

• Requires emissions reductions

• Enhancements of Shorepower

system

• Electric Cargo Handling

Equipment

Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal—An Innovation Hub

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019

4

7

Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal – An Innovation Hub

Tenth Avenue

Marine Terminal

CalEnviroScreen 3.0

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

88

• Adjacent to the

disadvantaged community

of Barrio Logan.

• Projects at TAMT aimed at:

o Reducing criteria air

pollutants;

o Reducing greenhouse

gas emissions;

o Public benefit; and

o Improving terminal

efficiency.

Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal—An Innovation Hub

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019

5

99 3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

Demonstrate Business Case for Advanced Microgridsin Support of California's Energy and GHG Policies

Grant Funding Opportunity-17-302

Project Title Grant RecipientEPIC Funding

(Match )

Port of Long Beach Microgrid Port of Long Beach $5M ($2.12M)

Camp Parks Microgrid Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory $5M ($11.41M)

Miramar Marine Air Station Microgrid University of California, San Diego $5M ($6M)

Port of San Diego Microgrid San Diego Unified Port District $4.98M ($4.63M)

Port Hueneme Server Farm Building Microgrid Electric Power Research Institute $4.99M ($3.5M)

Chemehuevi Indian Reservation Microgrid Handbook Holdings, LLC $4.99M ($8.4M)

Virtual Wide Area Urban Microgrids Gridscape $4.99M ($3.28M)

Rialto Microgrid Rialto Bioenergy Facility $5M ($6.66M)

Redwood Coast Airport Microgrid Humboldt State University $5M ($6.32M)

Santa Rosa Junior College Microgrid Sonoma County Junior College District $4.99M ($8.69M)

Total AwardEPIC - $49.97M

Match - $61.02M

Electric Program

Investment Charge Program

• 17 microgrid projects at 23 sites.

• Total: $75.6 million CEC funds

and $71.4 million match funds.

• Projects are located in the CA

Investor Owned Utility territories.

1010

Project Overview – Goals of Microgrid Grant

Electrification

Resiliency

Technological Advancement

Replicability

Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019

6

1111

• 1 of 17 U.S. Department of

Transportation Strategic

Ports

• Supply of Emergency

Goods / Services

• Critical Infrastructure:

o Jet Fuel Storage for San

Diego International

Airport

o Security Gates/Facilities

o Site Lighting

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

Port of San Diego – Strategic Port

1212

Microgrid Project Overview

• Project Partners

o Burns & McDonnell (BMcD) – System Design

o Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) – Cyber Security Assessment,

Testing/Evaluation, and Knowledge Transfer

o UC San Diego (UCSD) – Project Evaluation and Knowledge Transfer

• Application Ask

o CEC Funding: $4,985,272

o District Match: $4,427,973

o UCSD Match: $201,963

• Overview

o Solar PV power, battery storage, and microgrid controller

o Energy Efficient Lighting Retrofits

o Decrease electricity costs 60%

Estimated Project Budget $9.6 M

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019

7

1313

Microgrid Preliminary Site Plan

858,000 kWh

Reduction

Solar 700 kW

Battery Storage

700 kW / 2,500 kWh

280,000 kWh

Reduction

Energy Efficient Site

Lighting Retrofits

Estimated Reduction

360 MTCO2e

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

1414

Overview of Value Proposition

Cost Effectiveness

Emission

Reduction

Potential

Low

Value

High

Value

Site

Lighting

Retrofit

Solar

PPA

Battery

Storage /

Microgrid

Controls

Battery

Storage /

Microgrid

Controls

With Grant FundingWithout Grant Funding

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

3/28/2019

8

1515

Microgrid Technical Tasks

1 – General Project Tasks

2 – Microgrid Design

3 – Microgrid Construction

4 – Operation and Maintenance

5 – Testing and Evaluation

6 – Evaluation of Project Benefits

7 – Technology/Knowledge Transfer Activities

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

60% Design Phase

Technical Advisory Committee

Consultant Role:

UCSD, EPRI, and BMcD

Committee:

San Diego Gas & Electric

City of San Diego

Navy Region Southwest

California Air Resources Board

San Diego International Airport

San Diego Refrigerated Services

(TAMT Tenant)

1616

Technology / Knowledge Transfer Activities

ImplementationProject AnalysisAnticipated

Board Action

Jan - Mar Apr - JuneOct - Dec

Mic

rog

rid

Pro

ject

Project

Analysis

Grant Agreement

Development

FY 18

Grant

AgreementDesign

July - Sept Jan - Mar Apr - JuneOct - Dec

Tasks

1 – General Project Tasks

2 – Microgrid Design

3 – Microgrid Construction

4 – Operation and Maintenance

5 – Testing and Evaluation

6 – Evaluation of Project Benefits

7 – Technology/Knowledge Transfer

Activities

July - Sept Jan - MarOct - Dec

FY 19

Apr - June

FY 20

ConstructionEnergy Efficient Site Lighting

Roof Replacement

Anticipated Project Schedule

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

Testing,

Evaluation

and

Reporting

ConstructionBattery Storage / Microgrid

Control System / Solar /

Associated Electrical

Infrastructure Upgrades

3/28/2019

9

17

Microgrid

Emissions Capture System

-

5

10

15

20

25

30

Port Grants Tenant Grants

Mil

lio

ns

TIGER

Corridor Study

Urban Greening

Electric Vehicles and Equipment

MD/HD

Drayage Truck

Grant Funding – Beyond the Microgrid

Port Grants Underway:

• Transportation Investment Generating Economic

Recovery (TIGER): Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

Modernization – Phase 1 Underway

• Federal Highway Funds: Harbor Drive Multi-Modal

Corridor Study

• Natural Resources Agency: Urban Greening Grant

• California Transportation Commission SB1 Grant:

Emissions Capture System

Tenant Grants Underway:

• CEC (PON 14-605): Medium- and Heavy-Duty (MD/HD)

Advanced Vehicle Technology Demonstration

• California Air Resources Board: Drayage Truck Grant

• CEC (GFO 15-604): Freight Transportation Projects at

California Seaports

3/28/2019Port of San Diego – Resiliency in Terminal Operations at Tenth Avenue Marine Terminal

Thank you!

Questions / Discussion