7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 1/21
Abstract
The objective of this experiment is to determine the eect of a pulse
input in a tubular ow reactor and to construct a residence time distribution
(RTD) function for the tubular ow reactor. So there was two experiment
were conducted which are pulse input and step chane in a tubular ow
reactor (!"#$#). The dierences between these experiment is either for a
short interval (%impulse function&) or at a selected instant' a sudden chane
from one feed to the other is made for a continuous period (%step function&)
and the concentration chanes with time in each vessel is measured. n this
experiment the procedure are same except for pulse input' there is a step
where is at constant owrate of salt at $$ ml*min was allowed to ow for #minute then' the timer is started. The readin of conductivit+ is ta,en for
time interval -$ seconds. or step chane' the conductivit+ were ta,en after
-$ seconds also until the readin is constant at - times.
#
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 2/21
Introduction
Tubular Reactor
/ tubular reactor is a vessel throuh which ow is continuous' usuall+
at stead+ state' and con0ured so that conversion of the chemicals and
other dependent variables are functions of position within the reactor rather
than of time. n the ideal tubular reactor' the uids ow as if the+ were solid
plus or pistons' and reaction time is the same for all owin material at an+
iven tube cross section. Tubular reactors resemble batch reactors in
providin initiall+ hih drivin forces' which diminish as the reactions
proress down the tubes. low in tubular reactors can be laminar' as with
viscous uids in small1diameter tubes' and reatl+ deviate from ideal plu1
ow behavior' or turbulent' as with ases. Turbulent ow enerall+ is
preferred to laminar ow' because mixin and heat transfer are improved.
or slow reactions and especiall+ in small laborator+ and pilot1plant reactors'
establishin turbulent ow can result in inconvenientl+ lon reactors or ma+
re2uire unacceptabl+ hih feed rates.
Tubular reactors are often used when continuous operation is re2uired
but without bac,1mixin of products and reactants. The Tubular Reactor is
speciall+ desined to allow detailed stud+ of this important process. t is one
of three reactor t+pes which are interchaneable on the Reactor Service 3nit'
the others bein 4ontinuous Stirred Tan, Reactor and !atch Reactor.
Reactions are monitored b+ conductivit+ probe as the conductivit+ of the
solution chanes with conversion of the reactants to product. This means
that the inaccurate and inconvenient process of titration' which was formall+
used to monitor the reaction proress' is no loner necessar+.
The bac, mixin created b+ turbulence and diusion in a tubular reactor
produces a conversion which is lower than predicted b+ the plu1ow model.
Since bac, mixin is not as extensive as in a stirred tan,' conversion in a
tubular reactor is often hiher than conversion in a 4STR.The tubular ow
5
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 3/21
reactor application are for lare scale reaction' fast reactions' homoenous
or heteroeneous reactions' continuous production and hih temperature
reactions.
6ih temperature reactions residence time distribution (RTD) anal+sisis a ver+ e7cient dianosis tool that can be used to inspect the malfunction
of chemical reactors. Residence time distributions are measured b+
introducin a non1reactive tracer into the s+stem inlet. The concentration of
the tracer is chaned accordin to a ,nown function and the response is
found b+ measurin the concentration of the tracer at the outlet. The
selected tracer should not modif+ the ph+sical characteristics of the uid
(e2ual densit+' e2ual viscosit+) and the introduction of the tracer should not
modif+ the h+drod+namic conditions. n eneral' the chane in tracer
concentration will either be a pulse or step.
The residence time distribution of real reactor deviated from that of an
ideal reactor' dependin on the h+drod+namics within the vessel. / non18ero
variance indicates that there is some dispersion alon the path of the uid'
which ma+ be attributed to turbulence' a non1uniform velocit+ pro0le' or
diusion. f the mean of the 9(t) curve arrive earlier than the expected time(t) it indicates that there is stanant uid within the vessel. f the residence
time distribution shows more than one main pea, it ma+ indicates
channelin' parallel paths to the exit' or stron internal circulation.
-
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 4/21
Objective
Experiment 1: Pulse Input In A Tubular Flow Reactor
#. To examine the eect of a pulse input in a tubular owreactor
5. To construct a residence time distribution (RTD) function for
the tubular ow reactor.
Experiment 2: tep !"an#e Input In A Tubular Flow
Reactor$
#. To examine the eect of a step chane input in a tubular ow
reactor
5. To construct a residence time distribution (RTD) function for
the tubular ow reactor
T"eor%
/ tubular reactor is a vessel throuh ow is continuous' usuall+ at
stead+ state' and con0ured so that conversion of the chemicals and other
dependent variables are functions of position within the reactor rather than
of time. n the ideal tubular reactor' the uid ows as if the+ were solids
plus or pistons' and reaction time is the same for followin material at an+
iven tube section. Tubular reactors resemble batch reactors in providin
initiall+ hih drivin forces' which diminish as the reaction proress down the
tubes. Tubular reactor are often used when continuous operation is re2uired
but without bac,1mixin of products and reactants.
low in tubular reactors can be laminar' as with viscous uids in small in
small diameter tubes and reatl+ deviate from ideal plu ow behavior' or
:
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 5/21
turbulent' as with ases turbulent ow enerall+ is preferred to laminar ow'
because mixin and heat transfer are improved. or slow reaction and
especiall+ in small laborator+ and pilot plant reactors' establishin turbulent
ow can result inconvenientl+ lon reactors or ma+ re2uire unacceptabl+
hih feed rates.
Tubular reactor is speciall+ desined to allow detailed stud+ important
process. The tubular reactor is one of three reactor t+pes which are
interchaneable on the reactor service unit. The reaction are monitored b+
conductivit+ probe as the conductivit+ of the solution chanes with
conversion of the reactant to the product. This means that the inaccurate
and inconvenient process of titration' which was formall+ used to monitor the
reaction proress is no loner necessar+. The residence time of an element
of uid leavin a reactor is the lenth of time spent b+ that element within
the reactor. or a tubular ow reactor' under plu ow reactor conditions'
the residence time is the same for all of the element.
;ass balance
or a time element <t and a volume of element <=' the mass balance for
species >i? is iven b+ the followin e2uation@
A/4/ B v <t C A/4/ B v <v <t C r/ <=<t E $
Fhere A/ @ volumetric owrate of reactant / to the reactor ' G*s
4/ @ concentration of reactant /' mol*G
t/@ rate of disappearance of reactant /' mol*G.s
the conversion H is de0ned as'
HE (initial concentration 1 0nal concentration)
The s+stem is stead+ state so'
C A/<4/ C I/ <v E $
J
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 6/21
d4/*d=E 1d4/*r/
at the entrance @
=E$
4/E4/o
/t the exit@
=E=R (Total reactor volume)
4/E4/ (exit conversion)
1=R*A/E Kd4/*r/
;ean residence time' tm E ∫0
∞
t ( E )dt
Second moment' =ariance' L5 E ∫
0
∞
(t −tm ) ᴧ 2 ( E )t dt
Third moment' S,ewness' s- E #* L-*5 ∫0
∞
(t −tm ) ᴧ 3 ( E )t dt
M
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 7/21
Apparatus
The iure #.$@ The Tubular low Reactor !"#$#
Tubular ow reactor (!"#$#)' deioni8ed water' sodium h+droxide and eth+l
acetate.
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 8/21
Procedure:
#. The eneral start1up procedure were performed.5. =alve =N was opened and pump "# was switched on.-. "ump "# ow controller was adjusted to ive a constant ow rate of
de1ioni8ed water into the reactor R# at approximatel+ $$ml*min at T1
$#.:. The de1ioni8ed water was allowed to continue owin throuh the
reactor until the inlet (A1$#) and outlet (A1$5) conductivit+ values are
stable at low levels. !oth conductivit+ were recorded.J. =alve =N was closed and pump "# was switch o.M. =alve =## was opened pump "5 was switch on. The timer was started
simultaneousl+.
. "ump "5 ow controller was adjusted to ive a constant ow rate ofde1ioni8ed water into the reactor R# at approximatel+ $$ml*min at T1
$5.O. The salt solution was allowed to ow for # minute' then reset and
restart the timer. This will start the averae pulse input.N. =alve =## and pump "5 was switched on. =alve =N was opened and
pump "# was switched on.#$. ;a,e sure de1ioni8ed water into the reactor R# at approximatel+
$$ml*min at b+ adjustin the ow controller T1$#.
##. The inlet (A1$#) and outlet (A1$5) conductivit+ values were
recorded at interval -$ seconds.#5. (A1$#) and outlet (A1$5) conductivit+ values were recorded until
the+ are value almost constant and approachin low levels values.
.
O
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 9/21
Procedure:
#. The eneral start1up procedure were performed.5. =alve =N was opened and pump "# was switched on.-. "ump "# ow controller was adjusted to ive a constant ow rate of
de1ioni8ed water into the reactor R# at approximatel+ $$ml*min at T1
$#.:. The de1ioni8ed water was allowed to continue owin throuh the
reactor until the inlet (A1$#) and outlet (A1$5) conductivit+ values are
stable at low levels. !oth conductivit+ were recorded.J. =alve =N was closed and pump "# was switch o.M. =alve =## was opened pump "5 was switch on. The timer was started
simultaneousl+.
. The inlet (A1$#) and outlet (A1$5) conductivit+ values were recordedat interval -$ seconds.
O. (A1$#) and outlet (A1$5) conductivit+ values were recorded until the+
are value almost constant and approachin low levels values.
N
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 10/21
Result
"ulse input experiment
TimePutletcond. 9(t) t9(t) L5 S-
$.$$ $.$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$
$.$$ #.J$ $.-J$ $.$$$$ 5-.-:O5 1#O:.5-55
$.J$ #.$ $.O$$$ $.:$$$ :-.MN# 1-55.N:O
#.$$ #.:$ $.J$ $.J$ -M.NM 15J-.JJO#
#.J$ $.:$ $.:J$$ $.MJ$ #O.-O$ 1##.::5
5.$$ $.#$ $.#5J$ $.5J$$ :.--: 15J.JJ$5
5.J$ $.$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$
Summation 5.J5J$ 5.#$$$ #5M.JJO- 1N$-.-M-5$5
;ean residence time' tm E ∫0
∞
t ( E )dt
Second moment' =ariance' L5 E ∫
0
∞
(t −tm ) ᴧ 2 ( E )t dt
Third moment' S,ewness' s- E #* L-*5 ∫0
∞
(t −tm ) ᴧ 3 ( E )t dt
#$
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 11/21
$.$$ $.J$ #.$$ #.J$ 5.$$ 5.J$ -.$$$.$$
$.5$
$.:$
$.M$
$.O$
#.$$
#.5$
#.:$
#.M$
#.O$
outlet conductivit+ aainst time
time
outlet conductivit+
$.$$ $.J$ #.$$ #.J$ 5.$$ 5.J$ -.$$$
$.#$.5
$.-
$.:
$.J
$.M
$.
$.O
$.N
E&t' a#ainst time
Time
9(t)
##
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 12/21
T"e result (or step c"an#e experiment
Time Putlet 4(t) 9(t) tm L5 S-
$.$$ $.$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$ $.$$.J$ $.$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$ $.$#.$$ $.$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$$$$ $.$ $.$#.J$ $.J$$ $.5J$$ $.#5J$ $.$#O# $.$ $.$5.$$ #.J$$ $.J$$ $.J$$$ $.$NMM $.5 $.-5.J$ #.N$$ $.NJ$$ $.OJ$$ $.5$J- $.: #.$-.$$ 5.#$$ #.$J$$ #.$$$$ $.5ONN $. #.N-.J$ 5.-$$ #.#J$$ #.#$$$ $.-5$ #.$ -.-
:.$$ 5.:$$ #.5$$$ #.#J$ $.:J:# #.: J.#:.J$ 5.:$$ #.5$$$ #.5$$$ $.J5# #.O .-J.$$ 5.J$$ #.5J$$ #.55J$ $.JN#O 5.- #$.#J.J$ 5.J$$ #.5J$$ #.5J$$ $.MM:- 5.O #-.M.$$ 5.M$$ #.-$$$ #.5J$ $.-N# -.: #.N
Summation#$.-J$
$ N.$$$ -.NJ5N #:.M M$.M
$.$$ #.$$ 5.$$ -.$$ :.$$ J.$$ M.$$ .$$$.$$$
$.J$$
#.$$$
#.J$$
5.$$$
5.J$$
-.$$$
Putlet conductivit+ aainst Time
Time
Putlet conductivit+
#5
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 13/21
$.$$ #.$$ 5.$$ -.$$ :.$$ J.$$ M.$$$.$$$
$.#$$
$.5$$
$.-$$
$.:$$
$.J$$
$.M$$
$.$$
$.O$$
9(t) aainst time
Time
9(t)
ample calculation
or pulse input
∫0
∞
C (t ) dt =areaunder the graph
/rea E (t51t#)Bf(t)# f(t)5B*5
or time (#.$1#.J) minutes
E (t51t#)Bf(t)# f(t)5B*5
E (#.J C #.$) B #. #.:B*5
E $.J
or time (5.$1#.J) minutes
(#.J C #.$) B #.: $.:B*5
∫0
∞
E (t )dt =areaunder the graph
E 5.#J
#-
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 14/21
Residence time' tm E ∫0
∞
tE (t ) dt
E .ON$M min
;ean residence time' tm E ∫0
∞
tE (t )dt E M.JM5J min
S,ewness E 1O.#$#J
or step chane
∫0
∞
C (t ) dt =areaunder the graph
/rea E (t51t#)Bf(t)# f(t)5B*5
or time (#.J C 5.$) minutes
E (t51t#)Bf(t)# f(t)5B*5
E (#.J C 5.$) B $.J #.JB*5
E $.J$$$
or time (5.$1#.J) minutes
(#.J C #.$) B #.: $.:B*5
∫0
∞
E (t )dt =areaunder the graph
E 5.#J
Residence time' tm E ∫0
∞
tE (t ) dt
E .ON$M min
#:
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 15/21
;ean residence time' tm E ∫0
∞
tE (t )dt E M.JM5J min
S,ewness E 1O.#$#J
or step chane'
So based on result' area is #$.-J example of calculation at 5.$$ min
tmE (t x 9(t))*area
E (5.$$ x $.J )*#$.-J
E$.$NMM min
L5E ((t1 tm)59(t))*area
E ((51$.$NMM )5x $.J)* #$.-J
E $.5
S- E ((t1 tm)-9(t))*area
E ((51$.$NMM)-x $.J)* #$.-J
E $.-
#J
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 16/21
)iscussion
The objective of this experiment is to determine the eect of pulse
input and step chane in a tubular reactor and also to construct the
residence time distribution (RTD) function for tubular reactor at the end of
the experiment. !+ referrin to formula =R*A/E Kd4/*r/ ' the raph was 9(t)
C 4(t) * ∫0
∞
t ( E )dt in order to plot the 9(t) aainst time. Then' the 9 (t) was
plotted as a function of time. This is the residence time distribution (RTD)
function for the plu ow reactor.
Pn the other hand' we use the raphical method to determine 9(t) for
step input. !+ application of numerical method which is called trape8oidal
method' in 0ndin the area under the curve. or application of this method'
there man+ error ma+ occur while tr+in the to 0nd the dierentiation of
conductivit+. Fhen comparin the RTD function plot between experiment #
and 5' we can see the dierentiation based on raphs constructed above.
The most important parameters that characteri8e a curve raph are the
mean time which indicates when the wave of tracer passes the measurin
point and the variances which indicates how much tracer has spread out
durin the measurin time. /s we compare the pulse input and the step
chane' we can see that the pulse input iven hiher mean time but lower
variances. So we can conclude that the time' for a short interval (%impulse
#M
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 17/21
function&) or at a selected instant' a sudden chane from one feed to the
other is made for a continuous period (%step function&) and the concentration
chanes with time in each vessel is measure and pulse input poses input
process was faster than step chane.
This can be seen in result tabulated above and these formula was used
mean residence time' tm E ∫0
∞
t ( E )dt ' second moment' variance' L5 E
∫0
∞
( t −tm ) ᴧ 2 ( E )t dt . /s this experiment need to calculate the area under the
raph in order to et the result so the s,ewness of the raph need to be
calculated also. The s,ewness of the raph is about the s+mmetr+
distribution of the raph. So this formula was used' Third moment'
S,ewness' s- E #* L-*5 ∫0
∞
(t −tm ) ᴧ 3 ( E )t dt . or pulse input ' mean residence
time M.JM5J min' variance #5M.JJO- ' s,ewness of the raph 1O.$#$J . or
step chane ' mean residence time -.NJ5N min ' variance #:.M' s,ewness of
the raph M$.M. The result of this experiment miht not become ood result
due to errors had occurs durin conductin the experiment.
The advantaes of usin the Tubular plu ow reactor are it has hih
volumetric unit conversion' it can run for a lon period of time with
maintenance and the heat transfer can be optimi8ed b+ usin tube parallel
while the advantaes of usin this reactor are the temperatures are di7cult
to control' variabilit+ of products which mean the input product miht be the
same as the operatin cost.
!onclusion
#
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 18/21
rom the experiment' the eect of the pulse input and he step chane
in tubular ow reactor can be dierentiate. !esides' we also can construct
the residence time distribution (RTD) function for tubular ow reactor. The
dierences between these experiment is either for a short interval (%impulse
function&) or at a selected instant' a sudden chane from one feed to the
other is made for a continuous period (%step function&) and the concentration
chanes with time in each vessel was measured. rom the result' pulse input
poses input process was faster than step chane. or pulse input' mean
residence time M.JM5J min' variance #5M.JJO- ' s,ewness of the raph
1O.$#$J . or step chane' mean residence time -.NJ5N min' variance #:.M'
s,ewness of the raph M$.M. The raph for outlet conductivit+' 4 (t) aainst
time and distribution of exit time' 9(t) aainst time was plotted. The raph
plotted almost the same as stated in the theor+' 9(t) is depends on the value
4(t).
#O
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 19/21
Recommendation
n order to et the accurate result' the procedure should be followed
accuratel+. The pump and the valve should be opened simultaneousl+' for
example valve ## and pump 5 should be opened simultaneousl+. or time
ta,en b+ stopwatch' the time cannot be stopped inaccurate time because
the data miht not consistent. The experiment should be handle at the
stable or unsha,en place. ;a,e sure that there is no lea,ae in the
experiment.
Re(erences
1$ H. Scott Fogler, Element of Chemical Reaction, 4th edition, Pearson, United States of
America.
5. Steven 4. 4hapra' Ra+mond ". 4anale' Qumerical ;ethod for
enineers ;craw 6ill' sixth edition' /merica' Qew or,.-. https@**www.oole.com.m+*wsUrdEsslV2
#N
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 20/21
APPE*)I+
5$
7/23/2019 Tubular Plug Fow Reactor
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tubular-plug-fow-reactor 21/21
The tubular ow reactor used in the pilot plant.
The students are recordin the data of the experiments.
5#