ContentsI. Introduction.........................................................3II. ExecutiveSummary..............................................4-5III. BrandDigitalMessaging:GoingSocial.................6-11IV. ConsumerBehavior..............................................12-18V. CreatingInfluence................................................19-24VI. Influencers&Revenue.........................................25-28VII. Influencers&Brands............................................29-32VIII. Influencers&Brands:Evolution...........................33IX. Conclusion............................................................34
comScore, December 2012
Foundedoveradecadeago,TechnoratiMediahasgrownintooneofthelargestsocialmediaadnetworksbringingtopbrandsandvaluable influencerstogetheratscale.Withanadvertisingreachofapproximately130millionUSuniqueusers/month,wesitinthemiddleofanincrediblesocialmedianexusandhavelongbelievedthatourdata,relationshipsanduniqueperspectiveareimportantelementsforustoshare.
Withthisinmind,wepresenttoyouour2013DigitalInfluenceReport,whichreplacesourhistoricalStateoftheBlogosphereandexpandstheconceptofallthingssocial.Wehopeyou’llbenefitfromthevaluableinsightsculledfromsurveysthatincludedover6,000influencers,1,200consumersand150topbrandmarketers.
1
1
I. Introduction
3
II. Executive SummarySixtypercentofbrandmarketerspredictanaverageincreaseof40percentinsocialspendfor2013.Currently,thebulkofbrands’over-alldigitalspendgoestodisplayadvertising,searchandvideo,withspendingonsocial,includinginfluenceroutreach,makinguponly10percentoftheirtotaldigitalspend.Withintheirsocialbudget,morethanhalfgoestoFacebook,followedbyYouTubeandTwitter,withtheremaining11percentoftheirsocialspendgoingtoblogsandinfluencers.
Thoughblogsandinfluencersdon’tgetalargeportionofbrands’digi-talspend,theyrankhighwithcon-sumersfortrust,popularityandinfluence.Whenmakingoverallpurchasedecisions,forconsumers,blogstrailonlybehindretailandbrandsites.Withregardtooverall
sourcesforinformationonthein-ternet,blogsrankamongthetopfive“mosttrustworthy”sources.Asanexample,accordingtoconsum-
ers,blogsaremoreinfluen-tialinshapingopinionthanTwitter,andwhenitcomestoaffectingpurchasedeci-sions,moreimportantthanFacebook.
Inshort,wherebrandsarespendingisnotfullyalignedwithhowandwherecon-sumersareseeingvalueandbeinginfluenced.Thishasmuchtodowithanessentialhurdlefacedbymostcontent
creators:alackofmetricsandthefragmentationthatleadstotheircomplexityasapurchasablemedi-um.
Thisreportalsodetailshowdiffer-entsocialplatformsstackupagainst
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE
4
eachother.You’llseethat influencersrankedpageviewsaboveallothermetricswhenfo-cusingontheirownkeymetrics,whileGoogleAnalyticsistheleaderamongtrackingtools.Brandshaddifferenttopmetricsforidentifyingandselectinginfluencers,withcom-Score/Nielsenrankingfirst,closelyfollowedbynumberofTwitterfol-lowers,Facebookfriends,andtheinfluencer’spotentialtodrawlikes.Itisimportanttonotehere,howev-er,thatduetotheirnichesize,in-
fluencersarenotwellrepresentedincomScore/Nielsen,furtherun-derscoringthedisconnectbetweeninfluencerdesirabilityandanabilitytoeffectivelyfindthematscale.
Accordingtobrandmarketers,whenmetricsfromtheirearnedmediagoalsareranked,Facebooklikes,traffictotheirwebsite,Face-bookfans,andTwitterfollowersarethemaincontenders–areversalfrominfluencers,wheremonitor-ingtraffic/pageviewsrankedNo.1,followedbyFacebooklikes.
FROM PREVIOUS PAGE
II. Executive Summary (cont.)
5
III. Brand Digital Messaging: Going Social
OVERAll DIGItAl SPEnD
whERE BRAnDS ARE SOcIAl
Brands’digitalmessaginghasgonesocial.Morethan90percentofbrandssurveyedfortheTechnoratiMediaDigitalInfluenceReportstatedtheyhaveapresenceonFacebook.It’snearlyashighforTwitter(85%)andYouTube(73%).Google+wasn’taspopularwithbrands,withonly26percentofbrandmanagersreportingapresenceonthatservice.
6
III. Brand Digital Messaging (cont.)
DIGITAl bUDGET brEAkDOwN SOcIAl BUDGEt BREAkDOwn
Weseethatbrandsarespendingthelargestparts(nearly75percent)oftheirdigitalbudgetondisplayadvertising,searchandproducingvideo.Spendingonsocial,includ-inginfluenceroutreach,makesuponly10percentofbrands’digitalmarketingspend.
Ofthatsocialbudget,morethanhalfgoestoFacebook.YouTubeandTwittereachget13percent,whileaboutsixpercentisspentoninfluencersand5percentadvertisingonblogs.
7
III. Brand Digital Messaging (cont.)
DIGItAl SPEnDInG IncREASES
DIGITAl bUDGET OUTlOOkBrandmanagersreportanexpectedincreaseinbudgetsfordigitalmarket-ingintheupcomingyear.Mobilespendisexpectedtoincreasefor79percentofbrandssurveyed,whilesocialandvideotieat59percentofbrandsexpectedtospendinthosetwoar-eas.Oftheadditionalbud-get,mostoftheincreasesaregoingtodisplayad-vertising(73%)andsearch(52%).Socialandmobilemakeupthesecondtierofexpectedincreases,eachcategorygetting37percentofbudgetincreases.Only3percentofbrandssaytheyexpecttodecreasesocialspending.
8
III. Brand Digital Messaging (cont.)Morethanhalfofbrandssaytheyhaveearnedmediagoals,andthatthosegoalsfallinthecat-egoriesofFacebooklikes/fans,websitetraffic,Twitterfollowersandlandingpagevisits.Intermsofmeasuringtheircampaigns,brandsreportthatsuccessisdefinedasincreasedactivityandtrafficonFacebook,Twitterandontheirwebsites.Spendisnotnecessarilycommensuratewiththeareasinwhichtheconsum-erimpactisgreatest,however(e.g.spendingonFacebookadstrumpedspendingonblogs).
EARnED MEDIA GOAlS BREAkDOwn
9
III. Brand Digital Messaging (cont.)
hOw BRAnDS MEASURE EARnED MEDIA SUccESS
10
III. Brand Digital Messaging (cont.)
BRAnDS MEASURInG InFlUEncER AttRIBUtES Use neutral Don’t use
Sixty-fivepercentofbrandspartici-pateininfluencer-basedmarketingandwhenitcomestoselectingwhichinfluencerstoworkwith,brandsareusingmetricslikecom-ScoreandNielsenindices,TwitterandFacebookfollowing,andbasicblogstatistics.
11
IV. consumer BehaviorWhenitcomestocommunitysize,54percentofconsumersagreethatthesmallerthecommunitythegreatertheinfluence.
“The smaller the community, the greater the influence.”
0
12
IV. consumer Behavior (cont.)
OnlInE SERVIcES MOSt USED
Thesurveyfindingsalsoindicatethatmanyofthoseconsumersareturningtoblogswhenlookingtomakeapurchase.Blogswerefoundtobethethird-mostinfluentialdigitalresource(31%)whenmakingoverallpurchases,onlybehindretailsites(56%)andbrandsites(34%).Infact,blogswerefoundtobethefifth-mosttrustworthysourceoverallforinformationontheinternet.YouTube,FacebookandGoogle+arethemostpopularsocialpropertiesforconsumers.
13
IV. consumer Behavior (cont.)
OnlInE SERVIcES MOSt tRUStED
14
IV. consumer Behavior (cont.)
OnlInE SERVIcES ShARED FROM thE MOSt
15
IV. consumer Behavior (cont.)
OnlInE SERVIcES MOSt lIkEly tO InFlUEncE A PURchASE
16
IV. consumer Behavior (cont.)
whAt cOnSUMERS thInk ABOUt hOw OFtEn BRAnDS POSt
Withthebiginvestmentsbrandsaremakingonthesocialplatforms,consumerssaidkeepingupwithacompany’sactivitiesandlearningaboutproductsandserviceswerethetopreasonsforfollowingbrandsonFacebook,Twitter,YouTube,PinterestandInstagram.
17
IV. consumer Behavior (cont.)
why cOnSUMERS FOllOw BRAnDS
18
V. creating Influence
hOw MAny BlOGS
Influencersaremostactiveonblogs,as86percentsaytheyhavethemand88percentofthosesaytheyblogforthemselves.Bloggingistheprimarypublishingtool,andaboutathirdofinfluencerssaytheyhavebeenbloggingforfiveormoreyears.Mostbloggers(52%)operatetwotofiveblogs,while43percentrunjustone.Only5percentofbloggersoperatesixormoreblogs.
19
V. creating Influence (cont.)
hOw InFlUEncERS POSt
whAt InFlUEncERS POSt
Theprimarymethodforbloggersistext(86%),butphotosandmicroblogging(likeTwitter)comeinat38percentand31percent,respectively.Only10percentofbloggersusevideoastheirprimarymeth-od,andlessthanthat(4%)prefersaudio.
20
Whenitcametotypeofcontentpublishedthemost,editorialswereaclearleaderamonginfluencers,eithertheirownorig-inalcontent(74%)orlinkstoothers’arti-cles(38%),makingupthemajorityofbloggingcontent.
V. creating Influence (cont.)
Influencing the influencers’ content
Bloggersalsosaythatotherbloggersareveryinfluential(18%)whenitcomestochoosingtheirowncontenttopublish.
Primary publishing platforms
21
V. creating Influence (cont.)
whERE InFlUEncERS ARE SOcIAl
FacebookandTwitterarethemostpopularsocialplatformsforbloggers,whicharethesameplatformsthatgeneratethemajorityofblogreferralsandshares.FacebookandTwit-terarealsothetopplatformsfromwhichbloggersaregeneratingrevenue.
22
V. creating Influence (cont.)
hOw SOcIAl wORkS FOR InFlUEncERS
23
V. creating Influence (cont.)
SOcIAl MEtRIcS FOllOwED By InFlUEncERS
Whenitcomestomeasuringtheirownsuccess,blog/websitepageviewsrankhighest(52%)amonginfluencers.Socialfollowing(Facebooklikes,Twitterfollowers)anduserinteractions(comments)alsoratehighamonginfluencers.Whenitcomestosizinguptheirpeers,Face-booklikesandTwitterfollowershavetheattentionofinfluencers.
24
VI. Influencers & Revenue
Annual Revenue
Nearlytwo-thirdsofinfluencerssaytheymakemoneyfromblogging,butmorethan80per-centsayit’slessthan$10,000peryear.Only11percentofbloggersreportmakingmorethan$30,000peryear.
25
hOw InFlUEncERS EARn REVEnUE
*Banner ads per page
VI. Influencers & Revenue (cont.)
Mostbloggers’reportedincomewasaresultofadvertising(61%banner,51%text).Affiliateprograms(41%),sponsoredcontent(24%),sponsoredproductreviews(19%)alsoweretopearningmethods.
26
VI. Influencers & Revenue (cont.)whAt InFlUEncERS ARE PAID FOR
Nearlyhalfofinfluencersreporthavingbeenpaidforasponsoredpostorarticle,whileecom-merce,affiliatelinks,banners,textads,brand-sponsoredcontentandproductreviewsarealllistedamongdesiredrevenuemethodsbyinfluencers.Interstitials(full-pageadsthatappearafterauserclicksonalink,butbeforetheusergetstothecontent)androadblocksareamongrevenueopportunitiesinwhichinfluencersaretheleastwillingtoparticipate.
27
VI. Influencers & Revenue (cont.)
wIllInGnESS tO RUn ADVERtISInG tActIcS
AccEPtABlE REVEnUE MEthODS On BlOGS
28
VII. Influencers & Brands
whERE InFlUEncERS FOllOw BRAnDS
ManyinfluencersarefollowingbrandsonFacebook(47%)andTwitter(38%)becausetheywanttokeepupwithbrandactivitiesandtolearnaboutproductsandservices.Fewerinflu-encersarefollowingbrandsonYouTube(17%),Pinterest(11%)andInstagram(7%),butthereasonsfordoingsoare,byandlarge,thesame.
InFlUEncERS’ thOUGhtS On BRAnD POSt FREqUEncy
29
VII. Influencers & Brands (cont.)why InFlUEncERS FOllOw BRAnDS
30
VII. Influencers & Brands (cont.)
Basis for working with brands Source for branding opportunities
BRAnDInG REqUEStS PER wEEkAcrossallinfluencertypes,mostinfluencers(70%)onaveragereceivejustunder10opportunitiestoworkwithbrandsaweek.Oneofthetopreasonsinfluencerswouldworkwithabrandisbecausetheyhaveaccesstoanaudiencethebrandwouldwanttoreach(61%).Othertopfactorsincludeinflu-encers’affinitytothebrand(68%),thecampaigntype(61%)andthecategoryoftheproductbeingpitched(60%).InfluencerssaythatmostoftheirbrandingopportunitiescomefromthePRagenciesthathavereachedouttothem(37%).
31
VII. Influencers & Brands (cont.)
PREFEREncE OF BRAnDInG InItIAtIVES
Influencersmostpreferreceivingafirstlookorreviewopportunitiesfornewproducts,featuresorreleaseswhenpresentedwithbrandingopportunitiesaswellasbeingpaidtocreatecustomcontent.Alsohighonthescaleareprizesandsamplestogiveawaytotheiraudience.
32
VIII. Influencers & Brands: Evolution
what influencers say brand sources lackInfluencers’ top branding pain points
Influencersreportthatunsuccessfulbrandingopportunitiesaremostoftencausedbyirrele-vantpitchesandexpectationsontheirtime.Influencersalsoreportthatthoseopportunitiessometimesdon’trepresentarelevancytotheirblogoraudience.
33
IX. conclusionAccordingtobrandmarketers, socialspendin2013willincreasesubstantially.Despitethisincrease,however,spendingonsocialmakesuponlyone-tenthofbrands’to-taldigitalbudget.Ontheflipside,blogsstillareoneofthemostinflu-entialmediums,rankinghighwithconsumersfortrust,popularityandinfluence.Thedisconnectbetweenbrandmarketersandinfluencersisaresultofachallengetheybothface–alackofuniformmetricstoeffectivelymeasurethesuccessofinfluencermarketingcampaigns.Atpresent,brandsprimarilylooktocomScore/Nielsenrankingforidentifyingandselectinginfluenc-ersfirst,yetinfluencersarenotwellrepresentedintheseindices.
Furthermore,whengaugingthesuccessofcampaigns,whereinflu-encersaremonitoringtraffic/pageviews,brandmarketersaremeasur-ingFacebooklikes.
Lookingatsocialplatforms,Face-bookandTwitterarethemostpop-ularsocialplatformsforbloggers,whicharetheplatformsthatgen-eratethemajorityofblogreferralsandshares,aswellasthosefromwhichbloggersaregeneratingrev-enue.Forconsumers,YouTube,FacebookandGoogle+arethemostpopularplatforms.Asforbrands,90percenthaveapresenceonFace-book,closelyfollowedbyTwitterandYouTube,butGoogle+wasnotaspopularaplatform.
Forquestionsonthisreportortoshareideas,contact:
Shani higginsCEO,[email protected]@shiggles
TojointheTechnoratiMediaAdNetwork:http://technoratimedia.com/publishers
34