11
Teaching artists and the future of education:Finding hope in unexpected places Rhode Island Foundation November 8, 2012 Nick Rabkin
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
22
A better mop? Or better than a mop?
Teaching Artists and the Future of Education
33
• Better grades • Proficiency in math• Higher standardized test scores• Less likely to be bored or drop out
• More friends of other races• Less TV • More likely to go to college, graduate, and get a job
Also, more likely to know something about the arts!
Arts education improves student outcomes
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
44
Correlation strongest for low-income students.
It’s the arts, stupid!
Very big deal
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
55
Up 184% from 1930 to 1980, down 25% from 1980 to 2008 with no sign that the decline is slowing.
Childhood arts education, 1930-2008
After nearly a century of growth, arts ed has declined for three decades.
Teaching Artists and the Future of Education
66
They’ve mitigated, but not reversed the decline.
Photo: Khanisha Foster with students, Project AIM/CCAP.
Significant numbers of Teaching Artists have entered schools since 1975.
Teaching artists
Jane Addams founded Hull-House in 1889
8
Benny Goodman at a Hull-House special event;
Louis Armstrong with his cornet teacher from the
Home for Colored Waifs on TV in 1963.
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
9
New pedagogy emerged at the settlements,
breaking with conservatory veneration of the
classical world and elite patronage, and included
rigorous and critical exploration of the real world.
.
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
1010
Viola Spolin
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
11
Art for arts’ sake—art for people’s sake: different pedagogies.
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
A Swiffer for education?
1313
Arts education is understood as affective and expressive, not academic and cognitive, a distraction from ‘real learning.’
Descarte’s error
A Nation at Risk, the template for school reform for three decades.
Teaching Artists and the Future of Education
1414
Structural economic changes provoked a sustained series of crises that choked most large school systems from the mid-1970s on. The crisis has taken different forms and continues today.
New York fiscal crisis, 1975.
Fiscal crisis
1515
From Proposition 13 (1978) to the Tea Parky
Tax rebellion
1616
• HS graduation rate flat over last 20 years
Has school reform worked?
1717
• HS graduation rate flat over last 20 years
• Dropout rate remains high
Has school reform worked?
1818
• HS graduation rate flat over last 20 years
• Dropout rate remains high• Achievement gap narrowed in 70s, but
has widened since
Has school reform worked?
1919
• HS graduation rate flat over last 20 years
• Dropout rate remains high• Achievement gap narrowed in 70s, but
has widened since
• US students have fallen farther behind students from more countries in more subjects
Has school reform worked?
2020
• HS graduation rate flat over last 20 years
• Dropout rate remains high• Achievement gap narrowed in 70s, but
has widened since
• US students have fallen farther behind students from more countries in more subjects
• Charters’ record is no better than conventional public schools
Has school reform worked?
Are TAs good teachers?
Aside from socio-economic background, good teaching is the most important predictor of student success in school.
22
What is good teaching?
• Student centered: Balances students’ interests, questions, and prior knowledge, with new challenges, choices and responsibilities
Zemelman, Daniels & Hyde (2005) Best Practice: Today’s Standards for Teaching and Learning in America’s SchoolsPerkins (2010) Making Learning Whole: How Seven Principles of Teaching Can Transform EducationSmith, Lee, and Newman (2001) Instruction and Achievement in Chicago Elementary Schools
23
What is good teaching?
• Student centered: Balances students’ interests, questions, and prior knowledge, with new challenges, choices and responsibilities
• Deeply cognitive: Learning is the consequence of thinking and making work about meaningful, rich, compelling problems, concepts, and ideas
Zemelman, Daniels & Hyde (2005) Best Practice: Today’s Standards for Teaching and Learning in America’s SchoolsPerkins (2010) Making Learning Whole: How Seven Principles of Teaching Can Transform EducationSmith, Lee, and Newman (2001) Instruction and Achievement in Chicago Elementary Schools
24
What is good teaching?
• Student centered: Balances students’ interests, questions, and prior knowledge, with new challenges, choices and responsibilities
• Deeply cognitive: Learning is the consequence of thinking and making work about meaningful, rich, compelling problems, concepts, and ideas
• Social: Collaborative activities are more powerful than individualist strategies
Zemelman, Daniels & Hyde (2005) Best Practice: Today’s Standards for Teaching and Learning in America’s SchoolsPerkins (2010) Making Learning Whole: How Seven Principles of Teaching Can Transform EducationSmith, Lee, and Newman (2001) Instruction and Achievement in Chicago Elementary Schools
25
Engagement is job one
For many, ‘A slow process of disengagement begins in 3rd grade…’ Photo by Joel Wanek
Photo by Joel Wanek
26
Voice
An aesthetic signature and a perspective on the world and life, a set of concerns, issues, and ideas that matter to students. Student work from Project AIM/CCAP, Joel Wanek, Teaching Artist
Courtesy Project AIM, photo by Joel Wanek
27
Building a community in the classroom
Insert Presentation Title and Any Confidentiality Information
28
Arts integration: The ‘elegant fit’: Moving the mind, connecting ideas, and building understanding.
Wheatstacks lesson credit: Luke Albrecht, 8th grade math, Crown Academy, Chicago
See: AIMPrint: New Relationships in the Arts and Leaning, Weiss and Lichtenstein.Renaissance in the Classroom, Burnaford, Aprill and Weiss.
Build demand for arts ed
Research must be complemented with real stories. TAs are a great source.
Make the field sustainable
Under-employment, low pay, and health insurance are serious problems for artists. Funders and employers need to take them seriously.
Arts education is vital to the future of the arts, too.
Teaching artists are experts on how to create more engaging and meaningful artistic experiences
Develop arts integration
Integrated and disciplinary instruction are more alike than different when grounded in good practice. Let’s get beyond the conflict and invest in serious development!
Arts ed in both schools and communities
Advocate for specialists and TAs
Good schools have both already. Make them models for collaboration, not competition.
Assessment – the next frontier
Bring the authentic assessment of the arts into classrooms.
Professional development
• Use the best arts pedagogy to train teaching artists AND teachers in all settings. Hands-on, project-based, problem oriented, learning by doing.