Page 1 of 25
,
Pre-print Gender, Poverty and Old-Age Livelihoods in Urban South India in an Era of Globalisation. Oxford Development Studies 40 (3), pp. 324-340, 2012 ISSN 1360-0818.
Gender, Poverty and Old Age Livelihoods in Urban South India in
an Era of Globalisation
Penny Vera-Sanso1
Abstract:
This article examines how older women’s work in the informal economy contributes
to family, national and global economies. It is argued here that protecting and
promoting older women’s livelihoods will not only serve the interests of older
women, but will also have much wider social and economic significance. Drawing on
fieldwork undertaken over the last two decades in urban South India, the article
demonstrates that amongst the poorest families, rather than being dependent on
spouse or family, older women are often self-supporting, support husbands and
subsidise the incomes of younger relatives. Older women’s work not only helps to
reduce family poverty, it is critical to the distribution of agricultural produce in urban
areas and supports India’s global competitiveness. The article identifies how state and
market responses to liberalisation and globalisation are threatening older women’s
livelihoods while failing to provide adequate safety nets for older women or their
families.
Key words: old age, livelihoods, globalisation, inter-generational relations, poverty,
gender, informal economy
The orthodox approach to development and poverty alleviation, ie integration into the
global market, foreign direct investment and the reduction of state provision, relies on
the assumption of a ‘trickle down’ effect that will expand employment and raise
living standards for all. It is claimed that this will enable families to invest in their
1 Birkbeck, University of London, [email protected]. The 2007-10 research project on which
this article is mainly based was undertaken in conjunction with V. Suresh, Marlia Hussain, Henry Joe
and Arul George from the Centre for Law, Policy and Human Rights, Chennai. I am grateful to a
number of generous funders including the University of London for their funding of the 1989-1992
research (Central Research Fund and University Postgraduate Studentship) and the ESRC, EPSRC,
BBSRC, MRC and AHRC for funding the 2007-10 research through the New Dynamics of Ageing
Programme. I would like to thank the anonymous reviewer for very helpful comments and suggestions.
Page 2 of 25
,
futures through education, by building assets and purchasing ‘risk-averting’ pensions
and insurance. Whilst it is clear that certain sectors of society are doing well under
economic globalisation, for others the global market is compounding pre-existing
disadvantage. This compounding is evident when we consider the gender dimensions
of the generation and distribution of wealth, and is particularly so when we investigate
how gender and age combine to determine the living standards of older women – we
find that disadvantage accumulates over a lifetime.2 National and multinational
agencies have put few resources into addressing old age poverty (Gorman and Heslop,
2002; Barrientos, Gorman and Heslop, 2003; Lloyd-Sherlock, 2010). Instead policy
makers have relied on two assumptions: first, that older women are supported by their
spouses or adult children and second, that older women’s economic engagement is of
little consequence to the economy and the development process (Gorman and Heslop,
2002). This article takes issue with both these assumptions. Drawing on two decades
of research in the low-income settlements of urban South India, the article reveals that
older women provide significant sources of financial support to their husbands and
married children. It also demonstrates that older women’s work plays an essential
role in the distribution of agricultural produce and directly supports the economy’s
engagement in global markets. This article not only demonstrates that the routine
assumption of female dependence in old age is erroneous but also identifies the kinds
of policies and effects of globalisation that are undermining older women’s
livelihoods while failing to provide alternative means of support.
The first section of the article introduces arguments to explain why the poor are
forced to work late into old age, and why women are at greater risk of deeper
impoverishment in old age than men. The second section sets out the reasoning
behind gendered work trajectories in urban South India in order to explain gendered
differentials in work patterns and access to spousal and family support. The third
2 The category older here refers to people aged 60 and above which is consistent with the Government
of India’s recent lowering of the age threshold for the means-tested social old age pension. While older
people may not know their exact date of birth, which is common to all contexts without a longstanding
formalised system for registering births, it is generally accepted that functional age and the social
construction of age are not determined by chronology but by economic positioning. In such
circumstances exactitude regarding chronological age is less telling than perceptions of a person’s age,
especially the perceptions of labour hirers, family members and state policy implementers (Vera-Sanso,
2006).
Page 3 of 25
,
section sets out older women’s contribution to and experience of the national and
global economy.
The era of globalisation: exacerbating pre-existing pressures on older women
Inequalities in later life derive from the accumulation of advantage and disadvantage
over the life course (Dannefer, 2003). The Cumulative Advantage/Disadvantage
(CAD) approach shifts analytical attention away from dualist approaches that posit
declining physical and mental capacities as the source of old age disadvantage,
focusing instead on issues of inequality both within and between age cohorts. The
CAD framework ‘thus brings into focus questions concerning the extent to which
observed age differences and age-related variability result from systemic processes’
(Dannefer, 2003: S327). Of central importance to the possibilities available in later
life are social and economic class and socio-demographic characteristics; critical to
improving such possibilities is public policy (Estes and Mahakian, 2001; see also
Schroeder-Butterfill and Marianti, 2006). In other words, the circumstances of older
women are the outcome of: a) their social and class position, b) institutionalised
discrimination that women experience throughout their life and c) age discrimination.
The divergent possibilities of later life for men and women within the same social
class are determined by lower levels of education and training for women, gendered
productive and reproductive roles, lower pay, fewer enforceable rights in property and
other assets and lower (if any) independent pensions, coupled with women’s greater
longevity and morbidity in old age. In the South Asian context, where large portions
of the population find it difficult to meet their daily nutritional requirements and
public provision of social pensions and health care fall significantly short of need, the
poor are forced to live a hand-to-mouth existence, irrespective of age and gender. In
these circumstances, and due to the age differentials between spouses and the low
levels of widow remarriage, men are more likely than women to end their lives having
had the financial support and care of a spouse.3 Women, by contrast, face a long old
age reliant on themselves, younger relatives (who are struggling to support their own
marital families) and inadequate state provision to meet subsistence and care needs.4
This reality is very different from the commonly held assumption that in developing
3 See also Rahman (1999) on Bangladesh, and Durr-y-Nayab (2010) on Pakistan.
4 See also Panda (1998) on Orissa, India.
Page 4 of 25
,
countries it is inevitably and overwhelmingly women who depend on spousal and
family support in old age.
The erroneousness of the assumption of spousal or familial support for older women
arises from a failure to examine family relations as one of the primary mechanisms
through which economic systems extract paid and unpaid labour. Deeply unequal
systems put pressure on the poorest and socially weakest to labour the most and
accept the lowest returns. Economic systems combine with social and political
systems to value labour and attribute needs and rights by socio-demographic
categorisation: class, race, caste, ethnicity, migration status, gender, age, marital
status, physical ability, and so on. This categorisation defines not only wage levels
but also access to family resources and state provision and, indeed, the capacity of a
person to control the incomes they earn (Vera-Sanso, 2008). What this means in
practice is that in countries without adequate safety nets, the poorest families must
find the means to ensure that everyone contributes to the household economy.5 In
South India, for example, the means used by poorer families to cap dependency and
increase contributions are the formation of nuclear households soon after marriage
and the postponing of support, in favour of more urgent expenses, for those whose
capacity to secure employment or earn a living is on the wane (Vera-Sanso, 2004).6
Global market integration has amplified these pressures on the poorest and socially
weakest as the downward pressure on wages increases, property values boom and
state policies and resources are switched from an emphasis on the direct support of
local social and economic development through public services and the stimulation of
domestic production, including public-sector driven industrialisation, towards
privatisation and the encouragement of foreign direct investment. Simulation and
field studies have demonstrated that trade liberalisation has led to a reduction of
regular work, an increase in casual work and downward pressure on informal sector
wages (Sinha and Adam, 2007; Kaur et al, 2007; Singh and Sapra, 2007). In an
5 See Vera-Sanso (2010) on social pension policy design and implementation outcomes that exclude
the poor. 6 The only people who are likely to be quickly absorbed into another household are those who have a
sudden and irreversible breakdown in their living arrangements, such as young widows or young
deserted women, widowed or deserted men and orphaned or deserted children. The terms on which
they are incorporated into another’s household varies. By no means will all be incorporated as full,
long-term members of the family, as this would provide the family and incomer with much stronger
claims on each other’s resources. Instead, while young women will be given physical protection, men
will have access to a woman’s domestic labour and children a safe environment, most will be expected
to cover their expenses or to take on unpaid work, often to release someone else into the work force.
See also Shah (1996) whose use of census and other data demonstrates that the joint family household
was never the dominant form in India.
Formatted: Highlight
Formatted: Normal, Line spacing: single
Page 5 of 25
,
economy such as India’s where an estimated 86% of workers are engaged in informal
activities and the informal sector in 2004-5 (NCEUS, 2008:3) and where 42% of the
population lives on incomes below the international poverty line of $1.25 per day in
2005 PPP (Chen and Ravallion, 2008) it is clear that, far from bringing prosperity,
trade liberalisation has led to the deepening immiseration of the growing number of
informal sector workers (NCEUS 2009). Evidence from the 2001 Census showing a
substantial increase in the female work participation rate demonstrates that a large
number of women entered the workforce as marginal workers to compensate for the
sharp fall in the numbers of main workers, especially male workers since India began
to liberalise under the Structural Adjustment Programme of 1991 (Government of
India, undated).7 Liberalisation has increased the need for older women from the
poorest sections of society to support themselves and their families, drawing many
more women into contributing to the national product and, indirectly, to the global
economy.8
Gender Differentials in Spousal and Family Support
This article draws on two decades of research undertaken in urban Tamil Nadu, the
south-eastern state of India. The research was undertaken in Chennai, formerly
Madras, between 1989 and 1992 and between 2007 and 2010. In the 1989-92 study a
stratified sample of 200 households was selected for qualitative research from a
purposive sample of 450 households surveyed in two slums.9 In the 2007-10 mixed
methods study of 800 households, a survey was undertaken drawing on a systematic
sample of five low-income settlements, including the two from the 1989-92 study.
From the 800 households, 175 participated in in-depth qualitative research. In
addition, a street market in central Chennai was observed between 2007 and 2011.
Chennai is the capital of the state of Tamil Nadu; in 2001 it had over 7 million
residents of whom 7.8% were aged 60 and over (CMDA, 2008). In recent years the
city has developed an international profile for information technology (IT) and Back
Office Processing sectors (BOP) as well as medical tourism, and has a diverse
industrial base catering to national and international markets.
i) Gendered work trajectories and spousal support
The field research, undertaken over the past two decades with people living in
Chennai’s slums, shows an unanticipated degree of continuity in the patterning of
7 See also Durr-y-Nayab (2010) on older women in Pakistan entering the work force to compensate for
male unemployment. Census of India data on work participation rates for 2011 are not yet available. 8 See NSSO 52
nd Round Report (1998:14) which found that older women in India were more self-
supporting than they had been in the prior, 1986-7, NSS survey of older people. 9 For the definition of ‘slum’ in the 2001 Census see Chandramouli (2003) and for the recent
redefinition see Government of India (2010).
Page 6 of 25
,
work force participation across the gendered life course. In all the low-income
settings studied, at the start of the marriage husbands are the sole earners. Married
women only take up paid work to cover the gap between family expenses and their
husband’s income.10
By their late twenties a few widowed and deserted women are
beginning to take up paid work.11
Thereafter the number of women entering paid
work rises as their husband’s contribution to the family budget declines. By the time
men reach their late 40s, their contribution to the household budget is increasingly
irregular due to age-discrimination in the labour market, injury and ill-health.12
Qualitative data gathered between 1989 and 1992 revealed that women living in
Chennai’s slums were generally married before the age of twenty, did not start
working until they were in their late twenties or later and only did so to support their
family because of debts, their husband’s inability or unwillingness to fully support the
family or because of widowhood or desertion (Vera-Sanso 1995). The 2007-10 800
household survey in five of Chennai’s slums and the interview data from a subsample
of 175 of these 800 households reveals that women are continuing to enter the work
force to support or substitute for their husband’s role as family provider. While the
reasons propelling women into the work force have remained the inadequacy or lack
of male incomes, the reasons for that inadequacy have changed since the early 1990s.
In Chennai the population structure and labour market is changing and this is evident
in the settlements studied. The survey of 800 households reveals a preponderance of
young men in the age band 20-39, which corresponds to Chennai’s overall population
structure. This youth bulge is a factor contributing to age discrimination against men
in some sections of the labour market that begins when they reach their early forties.
In addition to age discrimination, older men are facing a reorganisation of labour
markets that marginalises middle-aged and older workers; some skilled crafts are
being displaced by digital technologies and some sections of the job market are being
10
See also Kapadia (2010). 11
In surveys deserted women prefer to identify themselves as widows. 12
As is well-documented, there is a high dependence on alcohol consumption in the slums that
impinges on men’s contributions to the household budget. What is not well-documented, but is
repeatedly reported by slum dwellers, is that the pain and injuries of heavy manual work in unsafe
working conditions force men to seek cheap pain relief that will enable them to continue working and,
further, to come off alcohol men must either find ‘less painful work’ or turn to the more expensive,
over-the-counter pain relievers.
Page 7 of 25
,
organised using more formal recruitment practices.13
Added to this increasing
marginalisation of middle-aged and older men is a dramatic drop in the number of
men aged 40-44 (highlighted in Table 1); thereafter the number of men in the
population is outstripped by the number of women to the extent that in the sixty and
above age band, there are 1.6 women to every man.14
Table 2 plots the reported work
participation rate for women and men by age. From this we can see that almost all
men are reported as working by the age of 29 and that there is a long and substantial
tail of older men reported working, with the result that while 78% of all males aged
fifteen or more are reported as working, 30% of all men aged over seventy are
reported as continuing to work. Table 3 plots age and reported work participation
against marital status. It demonstrates that approximately one-third of men reported
as working are single and two-thirds are married. It shows that 90% of men aged 20-
24 are single, that by 35-39 most men are married and at age 60-64 90% of men are
married. Tables 2 and 3 reveal results that run counter to the usual expectations
regarding gender, age and dependency. Table 2 reveals that young men aged 20-24
have a lower reported work force participation rate than older men aged 60-64. Table
3 indicates that young men’s work participation is closely linked to their transition
into marriage, which in Chennai’s slums mainly happens between the ages of 25 and
34. Survey data corroborate qualitative data: the pressure on older married men to
generate income is greater than that on younger unmarried men, especially when we
bear in mind that a number of the younger working men surveyed are apprentices
(mechanics, carpenters and painters) whose work is ‘more learning than earning’.
Table 1: Age distribution of females and males in the settlements studied in 2007-
10
AGES Count
% of
Females Count
% of
Males 0-4 101 5.60% 117 7.00% 5-9 141 7.90% 142 8.50% 10-14 143 8.00% 164 9.80% 15-19 140 7.80% 138 8.20% 20-24 188 10.50% 191 11.40%
13
While recruitment agencies formalise the recruitment process, and require workers to fund a mobile
phone, the conditions of work remain informal. 14
This dramatic drop in male slum-dweller numbers from age 40-44 is also reported by the National
Family Health Survey III (IIPS, 2008), a survey of 940 households across the slums of Chennai.
Page 8 of 25
,
25-29 173 9.60% 175 10.40% 30-34 146 8.10% 137 8.20% 35-39 126 7.00% 153 9.10% 40-44 111 6.20% 100 6.00% 45-49 110 6.10% 81 4.80% 50-54 89 5.00% 59 3.50% 55-59 70 3.90% 61 3.60% 60-64 90 5.00% 46 2.70% 65-69 66 3.70% 47 2.80% 70-74 55 3.10% 36 2.10% 75-79 20 1.10% 21 1.30% 80-84 15 0.80% 5 0.30% 85-89 7 0.40% 5 0.30% 90-94 1 0.10% 1 0.10% >=95 1 0.10% 1 0.10%
Total 1,793 100.00% 1,680 100.00%
Table 2: Age and work participation of women and men in the settlements
studied in 2007-10
Age bands Female
Population
Female
Workers
% of
Female
Workers
% of
Females in
Age Band
Working
Male
Population
Male
Workers
% of
Male
Workers
% of
Males in
Age Band
Working
Count Count Count Count
0-4 101 0 0.0% 0%
117 0 0.0% 0%
5-9 141 0 0.0% 0%
142 0 0.0% 0%
10-14 143 2 0.6% 0.6%
164 5 0.5% 0.50%
15-19 140 22 6.2% 16%
138 46 4.7% 33%
20-24 188 33 9.3% 16%
191 138 14.1% 72%
25-29 173 41 11.5% 24%
175 158 16.1% 90%
30-34 146 41 11.5% 28%
137 128 13.0% 93%
35-39 126 42 11.8% 33%
153 147 15.0% 96%
40-44 111 40 11.3% 36%
100 95 9.8% 95%
45-49 110 41 11.5% 37%
81 78 8.0% 96%
50-54 89 32 9.0% 36%
59 55 5.6% 93%
55-59 70 20 5.6% 29%
61 54 5.5% 89%
60-64 90 18 5.1% 20%
46 32 3.3% 76%
65-69 66 13 3.7% 20%
47 23 2.3% 49%
70-74 55 6 1.7% 11%
36 14 1.4% 39%
75-79 20 3 0.8% 15%
21 5 0.5% 24%
80-84 15 1 0.3% 7%
5 1 0.1% 20%
85-89 7 0 0.0% 0%
5 1 0.1% 20%
90-94 1 0 0.0% 0%
1 0 0.0% 0%
>=95 1 0 0.0% 0% 1 0 0.0% 0%
Page 9 of 25
,
Table 3: Age and marital status of working women and men in the settlements
studied in 2007-10
Working Females Working Males
Single Married Widowed Single Married Widowed
Count 73 167 114 272 694 13
% % % % % %
10-14 2 2
15-19 30 17 0.1
20-24 38 2 0.8 45 2
25-29 15 15 4 25 13 8
30-34 6 19 4 7 15 8
35-39 6 18 7 2 20 15
40-44 13 17 0.7 13 8
45-49 3 13 17 0.4 11 8
50-54 8 17 0.4 8 8
55-59 4 12 8 8
60-64 7 6 0.7 4 8
65-69 2 8 0.4 3 23
70-74 5 2 8
75-79 3 0.7 3
80-84 0.8 0.1 0.8
85-89 0.1
90-94
>=95
Turning to the data on the female population in the slums studied, Table 1
demonstrates that while there is also a youth bulge in the population pyramid for
women, the drop in numbers across the age bands is less precipitous than for men,
despite starting at the same age, ie 25-29, which is also the age at which women’s
reported work force participation begins to climb (see Table 2). Unmarried women
are reported as working earlier than unmarried men and some women seem to be
working until their late twenties, which is late for marriage in these settlements. This
appears to corroborate activist views that families have begun to delay their
daughter’s marriages as young unmarried women are now better placed to earn
incomes in Chennai’s export-orientated economy. More than half of women aged over
40 reported as working are widows (see Table 3). However, it is not widowhood per
se that is the determining factor in women’s work, for only a third of all women
reported as workers are widowed (see Table 3, counts). Rather, for women work is
associated with greater age; 62% of women reported as working are aged 40 and over,
Page 10 of 25
,
the peak being 45-49, where the percentage of women reported as working reaches
37% (see Table 2). A larger percentage of women aged 65-69 (20%) is reported as
working than of women aged 20-24 (16%). If we take Government of India
standards for working age (15-59 years), it is apparent that in the slums, for men and
women, work is more closely aligned with ‘post-retirement age’ than with ‘early
working life’ and that the association of women with later life working is stronger
than it is for men.
The number and proportion of women reported as working is much less than that of
men. Yet to dismiss women as having a limited role in supporting themselves, their
husbands or their families would be to misunderstand women’s, particularly older
women’s, role as an economic safety net in domestic economies. This is visible from
an analysis of work trajectories across the life-course. While the total number of men
reported as working in the five slums outnumbered women by nearly three times, 63%
of the reported male workforce in the settlements studied was under forty and only
37% of men reported as working are aged forty or more. By contrast, 49% of
reported women workers were over forty (see Table 2). Breaking this down further,
Table 2 demonstrates that between the ages of 25 and 29 men reported as working
outnumbered women reported as working by a ratio of 4:1, but in the age band 40-44
men’s dominance fell to 2.3:1 and then to 1.8: 1 in the age band 65-69. What we are
seeing are work trajectories in which husbands start out as the main family providers,
over time many married women are forced into work to supplement or substitute for
insufficient, possibly falling, male incomes and/or contributions to the household,
such that by age 39, a third of women are reported as working. The proportion then
continues to rise as women move from supplementing to substituting for and then
replacing a spouse’s contribution to the household.
Qualitative data gathered from in-depth semi-structured interviews with members
from 175 of the 800 households studied provides a more nuanced account of age,
gender and workforce participation than is possible from the survey data set out
above. It demonstrates that ‘worker’ status is as much about gender-age identity as it
is about whether a person works. As provider status is so closely aligned with
masculinity and, bearing in mind the dominance of casual labour and the paucity of
pensions in the informal economy, it is only when men have completely given up
Page 11 of 25
,
work, including the search for work, that they are no longer classed as ‘workers’ by
themselves and their families. Older women are much less likely to be classed as
workers; frequently they are classed as ‘helpers’ in someone else’s micro business,
even if that business was originally theirs or they are the primary or only worker.15
The fact that ‘worker’ is a socially-situated identity, causing older men to be over-
defined as workers and older women to be under-defined, both by themselves and by
their families, means that reported ratios of men and women working in later life are
extremely likely to overestimate gendered differentials in old age work participation
by underestimating the rates of decline in men’s work and of increase in women’s
work over the life course. Even so the overall trend revealed by the survey, of
declining male work and increasing female work over the life course, remains valid.
Overall, the pattern in Chennai’s low-income households is one in which young men
try to secure regular, or frequent, work in order to establish themselves as adults and
to improve their marriage prospects.16
Women, on the other hand, may work to help
their birth family when young but withdraw from the workforce prior to marriage,
only taking up work after marriage because of a shortage of male incomes, either
through men’s declining access to work, reduced contributions to the household,
widowhood or filial support which is insufficient, if any. Hence men’s economic
contribution to the marital family is high at the beginning of marriage and then
declines over the life course, whereas women’s starts with no paid work and no
‘helper’ role, and then, if they start working, rises over the life course, generally
continuing into late old age.
As was also the case in the 1989/92 study, in the 2007-10 study many older women
were engaged in small-scale vending businesses, such as selling agricultural produce,
cooked food and clothing, while older men were more likely to be on casual day and
15
See also Rahman (2010) on Bangladesh, where over 70% of men aged over 55 are self-employed
while 35% of women working aged over 55 years are classed as engaged in unpaid family
employment. Between 1997 and 2006 this was the only growing employment status in Bangladesh. 16
The dominant marriage system in Chennai is arranged marriage. In Chennai’s low-income
settlements the arranged marriage market places a premium on demonstrable capacity and willingness
to conform to conventional gender roles. This requires young men to be ‘settled’ in work and young
women ‘at home’ when marriage alliances are being sought; thereby influencing labour force
participation rates in early adulthood for both men and women.
Page 12 of 25
,
piece rates.17
This was the result of a gendered division of work whereby men would
only take on, and only be taken on for, ‘masculine’ work, such as masculine roles in
construction (plumber, plasterer and so on) and cycle rickshaw work. Men would
only participate in more capitalised vending, including as a casual labourer, whereas
petty trading by women was considered gender-appropriate. The disadvantage older
men have here, as compared to older women, is that concepts of gender-appropriate
work can combine with age discrimination to lock older men out of income earning
in a way that does not happen to women. Bearing in mind that women in South India
are generally five to ten years younger than their husbands, what we are seeing here is
a clear trend of women taking up work in their thirties and forties, once their
husband’s work opportunities begin to decline, and continuing to work deep into old
age, often helping to make younger women’s businesses viable. This means that
rather than all, or even most, wives being supported by husbands in old age, a
significant number of wives living in Chennai’s slums are supporting older men either
fully or in part.18
Men and women marry with the expectation that men will support their wife and
family while women will take on the onerous and time-consuming work attached to
running a home and bringing up children in a context of poor or no state provision for
water, drainage, health, childcare, education and so on. However, under the
conditions of poverty, low and irregular incomes, injury, chronic ill-health and age
discrimination men become increasingly less able to secure sufficient levels of
income, forcing women to extend their efforts to manage the home and family on
declining resources and rising debts and, finally, to take on paid work.19
Taking a
life-course perspective demonstrates that relations between husbands and wives are
much more interdependent than is suggested by accounts that posit older women as
dependent on the incomes of their spouses. If a life-course perspective is tied to one
that investigates how gendered identities are reproduced over time, we can see that
17
See Rahman (2010) on Bangladesh for the reverse situation; self-employment is much more the
preserve of older men and women are more likely to be employed on casual or piece rate. 18
See also Chant (2007:150) on Gambia where ‘elderly’ women vegetable sellers described themselves
as ‘slaves’ to their men. As in India, it appears that in Gambia the efforts of working older women in
supporting themselves and their husbands are disregarded by younger men who consider older people
‘the best off ‘because we care for them all the time’’ (ibid:181). 19
Age discrimination in relation to wages is widespread in South Asia (Arunatilake, 2010; Rahman
2010; Ghosh et al, 2010; Vera-Sanso, 2004)
Page 13 of 25
,
men and women’s gender identities not only constrain their opportunities for work
over the life course but that they result in the over-stating of men’s role as workers
and providers and women’s status as non-working dependents. From a CAD
perspective, we can see that the advantages and disadvantages of class, caste and
gender play out in such a way that while all those living in slums are disadvantaged as
compared to other classes and castes, women are in a more disadvantaged position in
relation to their work opportunities, pay and work-status than men. Ironically,
women’s inferior work and social status enables them to work longer than men but, as
will be seen below, in circumstances of severe poverty this may make them less able
to rely on others’ support in old age.
ii) Age, work and family support
The assumption that women are, or should be inevitably and adequately supported by
their families in old age is misplaced.20
The economic pressure amongst the poor for
everyone to contribute to family incomes ensures that older women work as much as
they can to support themselves and, frequently, to assist the families of their married
children. This assistance starts in early middle age, when working parents have newly
married children living with them and cover all housing and establishment costs (rent,
tax, electricity, repairs) and may substantially provide for the young family’s food and
other expenses, prior to becoming nuclear households (Vera-Sanso 2004; see also
Caldwell et al, 1988). Comparing the 1989-92 and the 2007-10 studies reveals that the
impact of Chennai’s property boom on the lower end of the housing market, including
that in squatter settlements, has sharpened pressures on low-income families, slowing
young families’ move out of the parental home and forcing many to return to it. The
result is substantially higher levels of over-occupation of parents’ very small homes,
which are now commonly occupied by between one and three married children’s
nuclear households; these are complex households in which each family, including
that of the parent(s), maintains ostensibly independent economies. In practice,
however, older parents and especially older mothers, are not able to resist pressure for
the transfer of resources and labour to ease the frequent difficulties that their
children’s families confront.
20
See Kreager and Schroeder-Butterfill (2008) for an analysis of varying cultural formats for
intergenerational relations and exchanges and how these are shaped by class position.
Page 14 of 25
,
When married children live elsewhere, parents continue to help them with food,
money, loans, the lending of items for pawning and with labour. For those living in a
low-income settlement and having to rely on public sector safety nets, the delivery of
the basic inputs necessary to sustain life (drinking water, sewers, storm water
drainage) and social protection (the Public Distribution System of subsidised food
rations), is inadequate and unpredictable and accessing them requires significant
inputs of time and effort. In these circumstances, someone needs to be at home to
take on domestic and caring work and many older women do this work for family
members, irrespective of whether they are living in the household or not.
Alternatively, older women play a critical role in their daughter or daughter-in-law’s
capacity to earn an income as there are strong impediments to them hiring or working
with anyone other than a closely-related older woman.21
In these two-person petty
vending businesses, older women are considered simply to be ‘helping out’.
However, the centrality of older women’s role is demonstrated by the swiftness with
which such businesses collapse when the younger woman no longer has access to the
older woman’s labour, due to significant ill-health, extreme frailty or death.22
Under circumstances of significant privation and the now low rates of child labour
(see Table 2) many men and women have to rely on their parents, particularly their
mothers, for help.23
This means that once women start working after marriage, their
families expect them to carry on working until they are no longer able to do so.
Determining exactly when aged women need economic support, how much they need
and who will provide it is a heavily contested issue (Vera-Sanso 2006) and a number
of different patterns of support exist, some of which serve more to acknowledge the
relationship than sustain the parent. Parents may receive small sums of money on a
weekly or monthly basis as a token of care; they may visit a son or daughter for a
meal or a son may bring food to his mother to cook and share with him if he works
closer to her home than his. In some instances mothers visit their working daughter’s
houses on a daily basis to take care of grandchildren and do vital domestic work and
receive food in exchange.
21
Impediments include a strict taboo on women employing unrelated men to work for them, men’s
unwillingness to work for family women and young women’s reluctance to work in contexts where
they are not closely supervised/chaperoned (Vera-Sanso 1995; Lessinger 1990) 22
As long as vendors have someone who can fetch goods from the wholesaler/retailer, vending is more
forgiving of frailty than other occupations open to older people, as pavement vendors sit all day. 23
See also Barrientos, Gorman and Heslop (2003).
Page 15 of 25
,
These varied and variable arrangements are the inevitable outcome of insecure
livelihoods in the informal economy, inadequate access to basic infrastructural
provision, age discrimination, morbidity and mortality, all of which impinge on the
possibility of older people depending on their children for support in old age. Two
further demographic factors and one sociological factor impinge on older people’s
support. The continuing legacy of early marriages alongside increasing longevity
means that families can now, and will increasingly, comprise up to five generations
(assuming 20 years between each) of which one is an infant, one has children to
support, the next is facing age discrimination in the labour market and two, being in
their sixties and eighties, are classed as ‘old’. In these circumstances reliance on
family support for older people is not feasible amongst those living on very low
incomes and older people, particularly older women, will need to make significant
contributions to the household economy wherever social pensions are not available,
inaccessible or do not cover needs.
From a sociological perspective, we know that the distribution of resources within
social entities across radically different scales (state to family) is shaped by shifting
conceptualisations of needs and rights (Fraser, 1989; Whitehead, 1981). Underlying
the low level of support for older women are two views: first, that older people,
especially older women, have limited needs that are easily met with small quantities
of food or money and, second, that children have a right to health care, education and
to a childhood free of child labour (Vera-Sanso 2004). If an older woman has been
supporting someone, usually her husband, once that person is gone she is judged by
her family to have an income larger than she needs. This is why older working
women are deemed not to need support and may be pressed for what their married
children view as excess income. The reasons for the continual deferral of support for
women in later life and for downward transfers of resources lie in the downward
pressure on work and wages, the rising cost of living, especially in relation to food
and housing, and in the inadequacy of state provision of basic infrastructure, including
education and health, in slums, , which frequently forces residents to resort to non-
state providers (Balagopal, 2009).
Formatted: Highlight
Page 16 of 25
,
It is clear that, contrary to the assumption that women in later life are supported by
their families, older women in poorer communities may well be self-supporting, and
are likely to provide housing, money and collateral to their adult married children, to
take on domestic duties and childcare or ‘help out’ in vending businesses in order to
allow their daughters and daughters-in-law to juggle work and domestic
responsibilities.24
Older Women’s Contribution to the National and International Economy in
Chennai: the case of domestic work and street vending
Having seen that older women are not uniformly dependent on either husbands or
families in later life and that women play an important direct and indirect role in the
livelihoods of their married children, we need to ask whether older women’s work
force participation is of significance to the national and international economy. Older
women’s roles are shaped by shifts in the wider economy, including the expansion of
new industries and young people’s move out of the lower-paid, less prestigious, more
arduous forms of work or more taxing work locations. Younger women and men and
children are moving out of a range of jobs that are being taken on by older women,
most notably domestic work and street vending. By taking on the lower status and
less well paid but necessary work that younger people have vacated, older women are
contributing to the national economy in the way that studies of the informal sector
pointed to thirty years ago, that is by holding down wage costs in the formal sector
(Lomnitz, 1977) and by expanding the available workforce.
In recent years, Tamil Nadu has become closely tied into the global economy through
a wide range of sectors, including its IT and BOP sectors; older women working as
domestic workers to employees in these sectors are indirectly contributing to the
global economy by providing the essential domestic labour needed to reproduce the
labour power of young, unmarried employees who migrate to the city to live in shared
accommodation. Similarly, the ‘gender dividend’ that is expected from the rising
work force participation of women in expanding export production, services and retail
is facilitated by older women taking on the domestic and caring work of wives and
24
For examples of this elsewhere, see Schroeder-Butterfill (2004) on Indonesia, Paradza (2009) on
Zimbabwe, Nyanzi (2009) on Uganda, Judd (2009) on China and Bastia (2009) on Bolivia.
Page 17 of 25
,
mothers. In this way, older domestic workers are critical to the expansion of an
educated labour force in Chennai and to keeping wage rates down, both of which
contribute significantly to India’s competitiveness in the global market.
As with domestic workers, , street vendors contribute to the global economy in a
number of ways. Primarily their overheads are small so they can sell very cheaply.
Their distribution throughout the city facilitates the employment of women by making
low-cost prepared food, agricultural produce and other goods easily accessible to
them on their way to and from work. The opportunity to buy locally in small
quantities on a daily basis benefits the Indian economy by enabling women to
participate in India’s standard six day working week, and by providing the means for
people on daily wages to source food on a daily basis. The poorest older women
tend to trade in the riskier end of street vending, by selling the more perishable items
that require lower capital investment such as green leafy vegetables and tomatoes that
provide the cheapest fresh food available for people to buy. Older women’s street
vending sustains India’s competitiveness in the global market by holding down wage
costs and by increasing married women’s labour force participation. Further, in a
context where over 65% of Tamil Nadu’s population depend on agriculture for a
living (Government of Tamil Nadu 2003:5) and most fruit, vegetables, spices and so
on that reach the final consumer are brought by market traders, street vendors and
hawkers from the wholesale market to local residential and commercial areas, older
women play an important role in linking the agricultural and urban economy. They
also support small businesses: by drawing people to the street market they increase
the footfall essential for the survival of small businesses without a brand identity.
Despite the importance to the economy of street vending in general, and older
women’s street vending in particular, vending is threatened by a number of recent
developments in urban and economic planning. Big national and international capital
is beginning to move in on street vending, pursuing predatory pricing strategies that
are forcing street vendors out of self-employment and down the social scale to casual
and piece rate work such as washing clothes. In the longer term this is likely to have
a highly pernicious effect on street vendors. In an effort to attract FDI by turning
Chennai into a world city the Corporation of Chennai and the World Bank, in
association with rising middle-class activism, is attempting to limit street vendor
Formatted: Highlight
Formatted: Font: Not Bold, Highlight
Formatted: Highlight
Page 18 of 25
,
numbers through licensing and clearing street markets (Srivathsan, 2012; Arabindoo,
2010: Harriss, 2006) .25
Such efforts draw on an idealised image of ‘the western city’
as an ordered city of free flowing traffic in which streets are stripped of people and
activity, becoming corridors for the unimpeded movement of people and things to and
from large residential, retail and commercial complexes; a city in which public space
is only occupied by those engaged in high end consumption.26
Beautification and
anti-congestion schemes implemented by the Corporation of Chennai have resulted in
the relocation or restriction of longstanding street markets.27
This 'cleansing' of the
city of the urban poor has been challenged in the Supreme Court and a regulatory
framework is being negotiated with the National Alliance for Street Vendors of India
that will protect street traders’ livelihood rights. It is notable, however, that vending
as a trade particularly suited to the needs of older people (as it enables them to tailor
their practices to their needs, capital and capacities) is not recognised. Rather vending
is seen as a livelihood that should be restricted to current vendors; it is not seen as a
trade into which older people might move.
While older women’s urban livelihoods play an important role in local and global
economies by increasing Chennai’s competitiveness in the global market by
facilitating the expansion of the labour force and keeping wage rates down, the under-
recognition and under-valuation of that role threatens older women’s contribution as
well as their capacity to support themselves, their husbands and families. The current
trend is to squeeze older women out of the trade most suited to, and most profitable
in, older age, that of vending, forcing older women back into domestic work.
Extrapolating from evidence gathered on the impact of the 2008-9 sub-prime crisis on
the slum settlements studied, it is clear that those engaged in self-employment,
including vendors, were more able to weather the financial storm by putting in more
25 In this article ‘global city’ refers to the aspiration to become a global city, it does not refer to global
cities as defined by Sassen (2001), also classed as Alpha ++ world cities by the Globalisaton and
World Cities Research Network. According to the latter, Chennai did not rank as a world city in 2000
but became a minor world city in 2004, rising from gamma to gamma+ world city in 2008. 26
See Sassen (2001) on the informal economy underbelly of the global cities of New York, London
and Tokyo. 27
This restructuring of the urban landscape is the outcome of a rising middle class identity ‘linked to a
politics of “spatial purification” (Sibley, 1995), which centres on middle class claims over public
spaces and a corresponding movement to cleanse such spaces of the poor and working classes’
(Fernandez 2004: 2416) which is occurring in all of India’s leading cities (see Chatterjee 2004 on
Kolkata, formerly Calcutta; Rajagopal 2001, Fernandez 2004, Anand 2006, Anjaria 2006, on Mumbai,
formerly Bombay).
Formatted: Highlight
Formatted: Highlight
Page 19 of 25
,
hours of work than were those whose quantum of work was determined by hirers and
employers (Olsen et al, 2010).
Conclusion
This article examines how older women’s work in the informal economy contributes
to family, national and global economies. It reveals that the expectation that women
will be supported by their spouse or family in old age is erroneous. A close
examination of work patterns across the life course in five slums that takes into
account wider issues such as the impact of economic policy on labour markets, age
discrimination and gendered roles and constraints, uncovers the increasingly large
role in spousal and family support played by women as they age. By setting survey
data against qualitative data, the article exposes the way in which gender biases
highlight men’s work and disguise women’s work. It demonstrates that older men are
still defined as workers when in fact their time is increasingly spent looking for work
without success, while older women may spend long hours running family businesses
as unpaid and unrecognised workers but are seen as merely helping out or passing
time. .
The article reveals that older people support younger relatives in diverse ways, from
subsidising living costs to taking on reproductive and caring work, in order to help
younger relatives get by in the city. By pointing to the linkages of older women’s
work to the agricultural economy and to new and old industries through their enabling
of younger women’s work participation and their undertaking of young migrants’
domestic work, the article shows that older slum women’s paid and unpaid work is
not marginal to the national and global economy but an important buttress to a range
of policies and strategies, including economic liberalisation itself. Older women’s
work helps to ease the punitive costs of economic liberalisation on those at the bottom
of the social scale by supporting their families and providing cheap goods and
services. The latter benefits capital and India itself by facilitating the maintenance of
a low-cost work force.
The article demonstrates the dynamic nature of the factors that are meshing together
to produce the current situation in which the urban poor and older slum women find
themselves. Economic liberalisation and integration into the global economy has
Page 20 of 25
,
deepened the already significant deprivation of a huge population of impoverished
people. Casualisation of regular work, pressures on informal sector wages, the
opening up of new contexts for younger people to work, globalisation’s impact on
food and property markets and marketisation of services are combining with
demographic legacies and shifts to undermine the capacity of families in slum
settlements to sustain themselves. These are new factors that are deepening the
difficulties that families who live on severely depressed incomes under conditions of
high morbidity and mortality have always had to face in sustaining themselves and
supporting people too old to support themselves. At the moment economic spaces
have widened for older women to work, some of which, such as street vending,
provide good and flexible opportunities for their livelihoods. However, pressure from
big national and international capital as well as from urban planners and street
vendors’ associations may squeeze older women out of vending, pushing them further
down the social scale. Until older women’s work is recognised for its part in reducing
poverty and buttressing the economy and until they are recognised as workers with
rights equal to those of younger people, older women’s livelihoods will remain
insecure and their wellbeing, as well as that of their spouses and families, will not
improve.
Bibliography
Anand N. (2006) Disconnecting Experience: making world-class roads in Mumbai',
Breslauer Symposium: The Right to the City and the Politics of Space, UC Berkeley,
April 14 2006.
Anjaria J. (2006) Street Hawkers and Public Space in Mumbai, Economic and
Political Weekly May 27.
Arabindoo P. (2010) ‘City of sand’: stately re-imagination of Marina Beach in
Chennai, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 35:2 pp379-401
Arunatilake N (2010) The labour market institutions, ageing and elderly welfare in Sri
Lanka in Alam M and A Barrientos (eds) Demographics, Employment and Old Age
Security: Emerging Trends and Challenges in South Asia, Macmillan, Delhi.
Balagopal, G (2009) Access to health care among poor elderly women in India: how
far do policies respond to women’s realities? Gender and Development, Vol 17, 3,
p481-491.
Formatted: Font: Italic
Page 21 of 25
,
Barrientos, A. Mark Gorman and Amanda Heslop (2003) ‘Old Age Poverty in
Developing Countries: Contributions and Dependence in Later Life’
World Development Vol. 31, 3, p555–570.
Bastia, T (2009) Women’s migration and the crisis of care: grandmothers caring for
grandchildren in urban Bolivia, Gender & Development, Vol 17, 3, p389-402.
Caldwell, J., P. Reddy and P. Caldwell (1988). The Causes of Demographic Change:
Experimental Research in South India. Madison and London: University of Wisconsin
Press.
Chandramouli, C. (2003) Slums in Chennai: a profile’ in Bunch MJ, VM Suresh and
TV Kumaran (eds) Proceedings of the Third International Conference on
Environment and Health, Chennai, India 15-17 December 2003, Chennai: University
of Madras and York University, pp82-88. Chant, S. (2007) Gender, Generation and Poverty: Exploring the ‘Feminisation of
Poverty’ in Africa, Asia and Latin America, Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.
Chatterjee P. (2004) The Politics of the Governed: Reflections on Popular Politics in
Most of the World, New Delhi: Permanent Black.
Chen, S and M Ravallion (2008) The developing world is poorer than we thought, but
no less successful in the fight against poverty, World Bank Policy Research Working
Paper Services, http://ssm.com/abstract=1259575
(CMDA) Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority (2008) Second Master Plan
For Chennai Metropolitan Area, 2026, Vol 1, Chennai: CMDA.
Dannefer, D. (2003) Cumulative Advantage/Disadvantage and the Life Course:
Cross-Fertilizing Age and Social Science, Journal of Gerontology, 58 S327-S337.
Durr-e-Nayab (2010) ‘Demographic transition in Pakistan: implications for old age
employment and economic security’ in Alam M and A Barrientos (eds)
Demographics, Employment and Old Age Security: Emerging Trends and Challenges
in South Asia, Macmillan, Delhi.
Estes, C. and J. Mahakian (2001) The Political Economy of Productive Aging in N.
Morrow-Howell, J. Hinterlong and M Sherraden (eds). Productive Ageing: Concepts
and Challenges, Balitmore: John Hopkins University Press 197-213.
Fernandez L (2004) The Politics of Forgetting: Class Identities, State Power and the
Restructuring of Urban Space in India, Urban Studies 41 no.12:2415-2430.
Fraser N (1989) Unruly Practices: Power, Discourse and Gender in Contemporary
Social Theory, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press
Ghosh N, BN Goldar and A Mitra (2010) Population ageing and its implications on
the labour market: the South Asian experience in Alam M and A Barrientos (eds)
Formatted: Font: Italic
Page 22 of 25
,
Demographics, Employment and Old Age Security: Emerging Trends and Challenges
in South Asia, Delhi: Macmillan.
Gorman, M. and A Heslop, (2002), Poverty, policy, reciprocity and older people in
the South, Journal of International Development, 14: 1143–1151.
Government of India (undated) ‘Work Participation Rate, (2001 Census)’, Ministry of
Home Affairs, Government of India.
http://censusindia.gov.in/Data_Products/Library/Post_Enumeration_link/eci6_page3.h
tml accessed 12 Nov 2011.
Government of India (2010) Report of the Committee on Slum Statistics/Census, New
Delhi: Ministry of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation.
Government of Tamil Nadu (2003) Tamil Nadu Human Development Report, Delhi:
Social Science Press.
Harriss J (2006) Middle-Class activism and the politics of the informal working class:
a perspective on class relations and civil society in Indian cities, Critical Asian
Studies, 38:4 pp 445-465.
Harriss-White B (1991) Child nutrition and poverty in South India: noon meals in
Tamil Nadu, New Delhi: Concept Publishing Company.
(IIPS) International Institute for Population Sciences (2008) National Family Health
Survey III, 2005-6: Tamil Nadu, Mumbai: IIPS http://www.nfhsindia.org/NFHS-
3%20Data/TamilNadu_report.pdf
Islam R (2010) The role of human resource in sustaining economic growth in South
Asia in Alam M and A Barrientos (eds) Demographics, Employment and Old Age
Security: Emerging Trends and Challenges in South Asia, Delhi: Macmillan.
Judd, E (2009) Starting again in rural west China: stories of rural women across
generations, Gender & Development, Vol 17, 3, p441-452.
Kapadia, K (2010) Liberalisation and transformations in India’s informal economy: Female breadwinners in working-class households in Chennai, in Harriss-White, B. and J. Heyer (eds) The Comparative Political Economy of Development: Africa and South Asia Abingdon: Routledge. Kaur R, PK Ghosh and R M Sudarshan (2007) Trade liberalization and informality in
the rice processing industry, in B Harriss-White and A Sinha (eds) Trade
Liberalization and India’s Informal Economy, New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Kreager P and Elisabeth Schroeder-Butterfill (2008) Indonesia against the trend?
Ageing and inter-generational wealth flows in two Indonesian communities,
Demographic Research, vol 9, article 52, p1781-1810, http://www.demographic-
research.org/Volumes/Vol19/52/
Formatted: Font: Italic
Page 23 of 25
,
Lessinger, J (1990) Work and modesty: the dilemma of women market traders in
Madras, in Dube, L and Palriwala, L (eds), Structure and Strategies: Women, Work and
the Family, New Delhi: Sage.
Lloyd-Sherlock, P (2010) Ageing and International Development, The Sage
Handbook of Social Gerontology, London: Sage.
Lomnitz, L. A. (1977) Networks and Marginality. Life in a Mexican Shanty Town,
New York: Academic Press.
(NCEUS) National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganized Sector (2008) The
Challenge of Employment in India; An Informal Economy Perspective, Report of the
National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganized Sector, Government of
India, Volumes 1 & 2, New Delhi: Academic Foundation www.nceus.gov.in
(NCEUS) National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganized Sector (2009)
Report on Conditions of Work and Promotion of Livelihoods in the Unorganised
Sector New Delhi: Academic Foundation
(NCPCR) National Commission for the Protection of Child Rights (undated) Inputs
by Vidya Sagar on Indian Children
http://www.ncpcr.gov.in/Reports/Inputs_by_Vidya_Sagar_on_Indian_Children.pdf
(NSSO) National Sample Survey Organisation (1998) The Aged in India: A Socio-
Economic Profile, 52nd
Round, 1995-1996, Ministry of Planning and Programme
Implementation, Government of India.
Nyanzi, S (2009) Widowed mama-grannies buffering HIV/AIDS-affected households
in a city slum of Kampala, Uganda, Gender & Development, Vol 17, 3, p467 – 479.
Olsen W, B Harriss-White, P Vera-Sanso and V Suresh (2010) The experience of
slum dwellers in Chennai under the economic and environmental insults of 2008-9,
International Conference, ‘The Hidden Contribution of Older People: Rethinking
Age, Poverty, Opportunity and Livelihoods; Mainstreaming Elderly in Policy,
Planning and Practice’, March 19th
-20th
, International Institute of Technology,
Madras, India.
Panda, P.K. 1998. The Elderly in Rural Orissa: Alone in Distress, Economic and
Political Weekly 20 June: 1545-1549.
Paradza, G (2009) Intergenerational struggles over urban housing: the impact on
livelihoods of the elderly in Zimbabwe, Gender and Development, 17, 3 p417-426.
Rahman, O. 1999. Family Matters: The Impact of Kin on the Mortality of the Elderly
in Rural Bangladesh, Population Studies 53, no. 2: 227-235.
Rahman RI (2010) Labour market response to demographic changes in Bangladesh: a
focus on ageing of the labour force, in Alam M and A Barrientos (eds) Demographics,
Employment and Old Age Security: Emerging Trends and Challenges in South Asia,
Delhi: Macmillan.
Page 24 of 25
,
Rajagopal A (2001) The violence of commodity aesthetics: hawkers, demolition raids,
and a new regime of consumption, Social Text 19(3) pp 91-113.
(RTBI) Rural Technology and Business Incubator (2010) Evaluation of National
Rural Guarantee Act, Chennai: Indian Institute of Technology, Madras.
Sassen S. (2001) The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo, Princeton: Princeton
University Press.
Sassen S (2010) Strategic gendering: one factor in the constituting of novel political
economies, in Chant, S (ed) The International Handbook of Gender and Poverty:
Concepts, Research, Policy, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar pp29-34.
Schroeder-Butterfill, E (2004) Inter-generational family support provided
by older people in Indonesia, Ageing & Society 24, 497–530.
Schroeder-Butterfill, E and Ruly Marianti (2006) A framework for understanding
old-age vulnerabilities, Ageing & Society 26, 9–35.
Shah AM (1996) Is the Joint Household Disintegrating? Economic and Political
Weekly, Mar. 2, pp. 537-542
Sibley D. (1995) Geographies of Exclusion: Society and Difference in the West. New
York: Routledge.
Singh N and M K Sapra (2007) Liberalization in trade and finance: India’s garment
sector, in B Harriss-White and A Sinha (eds) Trade Liberalization and India’s
Informal Economy, New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Sinha A. and C Adam (2007) Modelling the informal economy in India: An analysis
of trade reforms, in B Harriss-White and A Sinha (eds) Trade Liberalization and
India’s Informal Economy, New Delhi: Oxford University Press.
Srivathsan A (2012) Urban jungle: street vendors get a raw deal, The Hindu, May
14http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/article3415940.ece,
Vera-Sanso P. (1995) Community, Seclusion and Female Labour Force Participation
in Madras, India, Third World Planning Review 17, no. 2:155-168
Vera-Sanso P. (2004) ”They Don’t Need It, And I Can’t Give It”: Filial Support In
South India, in: P. Kreager, & E. Schroeder-Butterfill (eds). Ageing Without Children:
European and Asian Perspectives. New York, Oxford: Berghahn Books.
Vera-Sanso P. (2006) Experiences in old age: a south Indian example of how
functional age is socially structured, Oxford Development Studies, 34:3 pp 457-72.
Vera-Sanso P. (2008) Whose Money is it?: On Misconceiving Female Autonomy and
Economic Empowerment in Low-income Households IDS Bulletin, 39:6, pp 51–59,
Formatted: Font: Italic
Page 25 of 25
,
Vera-Sanso P. (2010) Gender and Ageing in India: Conceptual and Policy Issues, in
Sylvia Chant (ed) Elgar International Handbook on Gender and Poverty, pp220-225.
Whitehead, A (1981) ‘I’m hungry mum: The politics of domestic budgeting’, in
Young K, Carol Wolkowitz and Roslyn McCullagh . (eds.) Of Marriage and the
Market, London: CSE Books.
Formatted: Indent: Left: 0 cm, Firstline: 0 cm, Line spacing: single
Formatted: Font: Italic