8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
1/27
GE PBL \EGPL@ _PMPL_ @G_PZGOP OA\ZP
CAZ PBL EAZPBLZE @G_PZGOP AC PLRM_
QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ
)
OAE_LZSMPGAE CAZOL, @MHHM_ _MCMZG OH\J, )
BA\_PAE _MCMZG OH\J, Oarly DEAYHPAE, tbl )OMKVCGZL M__AOGMPGAE, me` tbl PME^MEGM )
B\EPGEI AVLZMPAZ_ M__AOGMPGAE, ) OAKVHMGEP CAZ
) @LOHMZMPAZW ME@
Vhmgetgccs, ) GEN\EOPGSL ZLHGLC
) ME@ @MKMIL_
v. )
) Omsl Ea. =
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
2/27
:
tbrlmtles tbgs suoolsscuh oaeslrvmtgae strmtliy me` tbl jlelcgts gt pravg`ls ta rmeil stmtl
iavlreklets, haomh plaphl, tbl wgh`hgcl, me` tbl Vhmgetgccs blrl.
:. Pbl jlelcgts geohu`l bmjgtmt prlslrvmtgae, wgh`hgcl kmemilklet, me` metg-
pamobgei. Buetgei mrlms mrl cmr hmrilr tbme atblr pratlotl` mrlms ge Mcrgome rmeil stmtls. Car
lxmkphl ge Pmezmegm, buetgei mrlms mrl cgvl tgkls hmrilr tbme tbl emtgaemh pmrds4 ge ^gkjmjwl
tbly mrl mhkast tbrll tgkls hmrilr tbme tbl emtgaemh pmrds. @lhtm‗s lkjmria sllds ta rl`uol
buetgei me` tblrljy, ta raj wgh`hgcl bmjgtmt ac gts loaeakgo vmhul, leoaurmil bmjgtmt oaevlrsgae
ta mirgouhturl, irmzgei, me` ge`ustry, me` ue`lrout rmeil stmtls‗ trgl`-me`-trul oaeslrvmtgae
strmtliy.
?.
Paurgst buetgei rlvleul gs tbl jmodjael ac metg-pamobgei ge Mcrgom. Buetgei clls
kmdl up tbl hgae‗s sbmrl ac aplrmtgei ju`ilt rlvleul car emtgaemh me` haomh wgh`hgcl mutbargtgls,
wbgob `l`gomtl tbl hmrilst sbmrl ac tblgr ju`ilts ta rmeilrs me` lqugpklet. Buetgei rlvleul mhsa
ue`lrwrgtls tbl metg-pamobgei uegts kmgetmgel` jy ge`gvg`umh smcmrg aplrmtars me` tbl oakkuegty
imkl soauts pravg`gei m``gtgaemh jaats ae tbl iraue`. Mhh tbrll hlvlhs ac metg-pamobgei (wgh`hgcl
`lpmrtklets, aplrmtars, me` oakkuegty soauts) mrl sustmgel` jy tbl uslr-pmy oaeslrvmtgae
systlk. Gc tblrl mrl clwlr uslrs, ms @lhtm‗s lkjmria levgsgaes, tblrl mrl clwlr jaats ae tbl
iraue` me` rl`uol` slourgty car lhlpbmet, rbgea, me` atblr mt-rgsd wgh`hgcl.
0. Paurgst smcmrg buetgei mhsa ilelrmtls cue`s car rlkatl vghhmils wblrl pbata
taurgsts `a eat trmvlh me` haomh plaphl mrl kast mcclotl` jy orap-rmg`gei lhlpbmet me` hgvlstaod-
lmtgei hgae. Buetgei rlvleul geoletgvgzls tbasl plaphl ta pratlot tblgr wgh`hgcl ms me msslt ‟ eat
ta dghh gt ms m eugsmeol, `meilr, ar jhmod-kmrdlt oakka`gty. Ms m rlsg`let ac _meduya vghhmil ge
Jatswmem smg` rlolethy ta tbl Elw Ward Pgkls> ‘Jlcarl, wble tblrl wms buetgei, wl wmetl` ta
pratlot tbasl megkmhs jlomusl wl delw wl lmrel` sakltbgei aut ac tblk … Eaw wl `ae‗t
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
3/27
?
jlelcgt mt mhh crak tbl megkmhs. Pbl lhlpbmets me` juccmhals hlmvl mctlr `lstraygei aur phawgei
cglh`s `urgei tbl `my. Pble, mt egibt, tbl hgaes oakl geta aur drmmhs.‛:
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
4/27
0
oaetrmjme`. Mklrgom‗s jusgelss, praclssgaemh, me` ogvgh hlm`lrs ‟ kmey ac wbak mrl crlqulet
chglrs ‟ sbauh` eat jl hukpl` wgtb trmccgodlrs (uehmwcuh trm`l). Pbl stgikm wghh ue`lrstme`mjhy
mcclot tblgr wghhgeielss ta buet ge Mcrgom. Jlomusl gt `gssum`ls hmwcuh buetlrs, @lhtm‗s lkjmria
nlapmr`gzls tbl jlelcgts ac taurgst buetgei me` gts oletrmhgty ge tbl oaeslrvmtgae prairmks ac
Mcrgome rmeil stmtls. Me` warsl, tbl lkjmria `lprgvls Jgi Cgvl splogls ac lssletgmh oaeslrvmtgae
cue`gei me` suppart.
9. Jlomusl ac tbl rgsds pasl` jy @lhtm‗s lkjmria, Vhmgetgccs jrgei tbgs sugt. Eat aehy
gs @lhtm‗s lkjmria ueoaesogaemjhl ‟ gt gs ghhlimh. @lhtm gs cmghgei ta cuhcghh gts ajhgimtgaes ms m
oakkae omrrglr, me` tbgs cmghurl genurls me` wghh oaetgeul ta genurl Vhmgetgccs uetgh tbl uehmwcuh
lkjmria gs hgctl`.
2. Vhmgetgccs msd tbl Oaurt ta `lohmrl tbmt @lhtm bms vgahmtl` gts cl`lrmh oakkae hmw
`utgls ms m oakkae omrrglr. @lhtm omeeat `gsorgkgemtl mimgest pmssleilrs ar omria. Prapbgls ac
tbl Jgi Cgvl mrl eat `meilraus iaa`s. @lhtm‗s grrlspaesgjhl lkjmria mpplmrs ta jl jmsl` ae
kgs-gecarkmtgae me` m kgsue`lrstme`gei ac tbl hlimh stmtus ac tblsl iaa`s, me` katgvmtl` jy m
`lsgrl ta phmomtl m eagsy me` ghh-m`vgsl` iraup ac Cmoljaad pastlrs, mt tbl lxplesl ac
oaeslrvmtgae prairmks, wgh`hgcl, me` hgvlhgbaa`s ac haomh plaphls, me` tbl getlrlsts ac Vhmgetgccs.
7. Pbl sugt mhsa msds tbgs Oaurt ta `lohmrl tbmt @lhtm bms tartgaushy getlrclrl` wgtb tbl
motumh me` prasplotgvl jusgelss rlhmtgaes ac Vhmgetgccs me` ta mwmr` `mkmils tblrlcar. @lhtm‗s
lkjmria `ltlrs \._. buetlrs crak iagei ta Mcrgom me` leimigei ge oakklrol tbmt loaeakgomhhy
sustmges rmeil stmtls, oakkuegtgls, smcmrg aplrmtars me` tbl rlhmtl` slrvgol ge`ustrgls, bmjgtmt, me`
wgh`hgcl. Pbl uehmwcuh lkjmria `lstrays jusgelss prasplots me` spmrds omeolhhmtgaes, rajjgei
oakkuegtgls ac geoakl ae wbgob tbly `lple`. Pbl lkjmria outs tbl cue`gei mvmghmjhl car smcmrg
aplrmtar metg-pamobgei uegts me` oakkuegty imkl soauts, wbgob tbrlmtles ta georlmsl pamobgei
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
5/27
<
me` rl`uol tbl wgh`hgcl jmsl. Me` tbl lkjmria `gkgegsbls wgh`hgcl mutbargty aplrmtgei rlvleul
tbmt wauh` atblrwgsl jl usl` car metg-pamobgei me` wgh`hgcl kmemilklet.
=6. @lhtm‗s uehmwcuh lkjmria jur`les hgolesl`, rliuhmtl` buetlrs jy `gsorgkgemtgei
mimgest tblk me` omusgei `lhmy me` irlmtlr lxplesl. Car lxmkphl, \._. buetlr Oarly Deawhtae
hlimhhy bmrvlstl` m jhmod rbgea ge Emkgjgm ge m buet suppartl` jy tbl Mcrgome Zbgea _plogmhgst
Iraup me` _ustmgemjhl \sl me` Hgvlhgbaa`s _plogmhgst Iraup ac tbl warh`‗s hmrilst oaeslrvmtgae
arimegzmtgae, G\OE, me` lxphgogthy mutbargzl` jy rlsahutgae ac tbl =26+ Vmrtgls ta tbl
Oaevletgae ae Getlremtgaemh Prm`l ge Le`meilrl` _plogls ac Ygh` Cmuem me` Charm (‘OGPL_‛).
Kr. Deawhtae wms tble uemjhl ta sbgp bgs rbgea jmod ta tbl \._. ae @lhtm me` bm` ta usl m
`gcclrlet omrrglr. Mhh ac tblsl genurgls mrl omusl` jy me uehmwcuh lkjmria tbmt bms ea hmwcuh
nustgcgomtgae.
==. Vhmgetgccs slld ta bah` @lhtm mooauetmjhl car gts cmghurl ta mjg`l jy \._. hmw me` gts
mjnlot `gskgssmh ac getlremtgaemh hmw. Pbl uehmwcuh lkjmria vgahmtls cl`lrmh oakkae hmw me`
tbl rliuhmtgaes me` tbl oae`gtgaes ac @lhtm‗s aplrmtgei olrtgcgomtl. Pbl lkjmria gs mhsa oaetrmry
ta quatms slt me` Zlsahutgaes lemotl` jy tbl OGPL_ Vmrtgls. OGPL_ rliuhmtls getlremtgaemh trm`l
ac lhlpbmet, rbgea, hgae, me` hlapmr` (jut eat Ompl juccmha, wbgob mrl eat hgstl`) jlomusl tbl
Vmrtgls rloaiegzl` lxphgogthy tbmt hmwcuh, rliuhmtl` trm`l ome jlelcgt tblsl splogls me` tbl plaphl
wba hgvl elxt ta tblk. Getlremtgaemh trm`l ge Jgi Cgvl trapbgls gs le`arsl` jy OGPL_, wgtb quatm
Zlsahutgaes lemotl` jy tbl Vmrtgls car hlapmr`, rbgea, me` lhlpbmet. @lhtm‗s lkjmria ae tbgs
jlelcgogmh trm`l `grlothy oaechgots wgtb jatb OGPL_ me`, car lhlpbmet, jhmod rbgea, me` hlapmr`,
wgtb \._. gkphlkletgei hmws me` rliuhmtgaes, ue`lr wbgob gkpart plrkgts mrl gssul` aehy mctlr
tbl \._. Cgsb me` Ygh`hgcl _lrvgol (‘CY_‛) cge`s tbmt tbl gkpart ‘lebmeols‛ tbl survgvmh ac tbl
tbmt splogls.
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
6/27
3
=:. Jlomusl @lhtm‗s lkjmria gs uehmwcuh me` mimgest pujhgo pahgoy ms lvg`leol` ge
\._. hmw me` OGPL_ Zlsahutgaes, Vhmgetgccs msd tbgs Oaurt ta gkkl`gmtlhy lenage @lhtm crak
lecarogei gt, ta rlqugrl @lhtm ta oakphy wgtb \._. me` getlremtgaemh hmw, me` ta oakplesmtl
Vhmgetgccs‗ hassls ta tbl lxtlet tbly mrl klmsurmjhl tbrauib kaely `mkmils.
VMZPGL_
=?. Vhmgetgcc Oaeslrvmtgae Carol gs m eae-pracgt =
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
7/27
9
=0. @mhhms _mcmrg Ohuj gs m eae-pracgt oaeslrvmtgae, l`uomtgae, me` buetlr m`vaomoy
arimegzmtgae jmsl` ge @mhhms, Plxms. Gts kgssgae gs ta oaeslrvl wgh`hgcl me` wgh`lrelss hme`s4 ta
l`uomtl yautb me` tbl pujhgo4 me` ta prakatl me` pratlot tbl getlrlsts ac buetlrs warh`wg`l.
@_O gs m klkjlrsbgp arimegzmtgae rlprlsletgei tbausme`s ac ge`gvg`umh buetlrs me` slrvgol
jusgelssls geohu`gei buetgei aplrmtars, wba suppart tbl uslr-pmy, sustmgemjhl usl-jmsl`
prairmks. @_O‗s prgkmry saurols ac geoakl mrl crak klkjlrsbgp clls me` gts meeumh
oaevletgae, mt wbgob gt rlets jaatb spmol ta Mcrgome buetgei aplrmtars me` bah`s muotgaes ac
Mcrgome buets. Gts klkjlrs buet lhlpbmet, rbgea, hgae, hlapmr`, me` juccmha, mkaei atblr splogls.
Gts haia gs tbl Mcrgome lhlpbmet. @_O bms oaetrgjutl` tles ac kghhgaes ac `ahhmrs ta oaeslrvmtgae
gegtgmtgvls me` bmjgtmt pratlotgae ge suppart ac gts kgssgae. @_O mpplmrs ae gts awe jlbmhc me` ms
m rlprlsletmtgvl ae jlbmhc ac gts klkjlrs. @_O me` gts klkjlrs mrl mt rgsd ac hasgei bue`rl`s ac
kghhgaes ac `ahhmrs `ul ta tbl lkjmria.
=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
8/27
2
=3. Vhmgetgcc Kr. Oarly Deawhtae gs m buetlr-oaeslrvmtgaegst `akgoghl` ge Plxms, m
hgcl klkjlr ac @_O, me` m suppartgei klkjlr ac Oaeslrvmtgae Carol. Bl bms buetl` mhh tbl Jgi
Cgvl me`, ge Kmy :6=< buetl` m jhmod rbgea ge Emkgjgm. Pa pmrtgogpmtl ge tbgs buet, Kr.
Deawhtae oaetrgjutl` $?
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
9/27
7
me` sbmrl ge tbl jlelcgts ac sustmgemjhl usl ms wlhh ms pbata-taurgsk, jut wgtb tbl vmst kmnargty ac
rlvleuls (76%) ilelrmtl` crak buetgei me` hlmsl ac buetgei oaeolssgaes, me` lsplogmhhy crak
tbl buetgei ac tbl Jgi Cgvl. Gkpravlklet pranlots me` hgkgtl` omsb `gstrgjutgaes cue`l` jy tbmt
rlvleul blhp mhhlvgmtl bukme-wgh`hgcl oaechgots ge vghhmils succlrgei crak lhlpbmet orap-rmg`gei,
hgae hgvlstaod-rmg`gei, me` atblr wgh`hgcl-omusl` m̀kmil. @ul ta gts loaeakgo, pahgtgomh, ouhturmh,
me` bgstargomh gkpartmeol, Vhmgetgcc OMKVCGZL Mssaogmtgae me` tbl Iavlreklet ac ^gkjmjwl
mrl lvmhumtgei up`mtls ta tbl prairmk ta georlmsl jlelcgt-sbmrgei me` geoakl ilelrmtgae
appartuegtgls. Vhmgetgcc OMKVCGZL Mssaogmtgae gs m rligstlrl` prgvmtl vahuetmry arimegzmtgae
carkl` ge =77= ta hlm` me` oaar`gemtl OMKVCGZL. Gt mpplmrs ae gts awe jlbmhc me` bms m `grlot
stmdl ge tbl suoolss ac ^gkjmjwl‗s buetgei ge`ustry. Pbl Jgi < mrl tbl hmrilst saurol ac
OMKVCGZL‗s rlvleul. Ge prgar ylmrs up ta 96% ac OMKVCGZL geoakl bms oakl crak lhlpbmet
taurgst buetgei. ^gkjmjwl bms tbl sloae` hmrilst lhlpbmet papuhmtgae ge tbl warh`, ac
mppraxgkmtlhy 2=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
10/27
=6
bmjgtmt, wgtb avlr cgvl tgkls tbl mkauet ac pratlotl` bmjgtmt ge buetgei mrlms tbme ge gts emtgaemh
pmrds. PMBAM sllds ta `lcle` Pmezmegm‗s buetgei ge`ustry me` ltbgo, me` mpplmrs ae gts awe
jlbmhc me` ms m rlprlsletmtgvl ae jlbmhc ac gts klkjlrs.
=7. @lcle`met @lhtm Mgr Hgels, Geo. gs m @lhmwmrl oarparmtgae `agei jusgelss ge tbl
Eartblre @gstrgot ac Plxms. Gt gs me getlremtgaemh mgrhgel blm`qumrtlrl` me` `akgoghl` ge Mthmetm.
Gt ohmgks ta kmgetmge me ‘ge`ustry-hlm`gei ihajmh eltward‛ wgtb chgibts ‘ta ??0 `lstgemtgaes ge 30
oauetrgls ae 3 oaetgelets‛ me` m ‘kmgehgel chllt ac karl tbme 966 mgrormct.‛ Yble gts ‘warh`wg`l
mhhgmeol pmrtelrs‛ (oa`lsbmrl) mrl geohu`l`, @lhtm ohmgks ta acclr avlr = Oarparmtgae
_lrvgol Oakpmey, :== L. 9tb _trllt, _ugtl 3:6, Mustge, Plxms 9296=-?:=2.
N\ZG_@GOPGAE ME@ SLE\L
:6. Vhmgetgccs rlsg`l ar mrl `akgoghl` ge tbl cahhawgei haomtgaes> Kltmgrgl, Haugsgmem4
@mhhms, Plxms4 Baustae, Plxms4 Bmrmrl, ^gkjmjwl4 me` @mr ls _mhmmk, Pmezmegm.
:=.
@lcle`met @lhtm gs m @lhmwmrl oarparmtgae blm`qumrtlrl`/`akgoghl` ge Mthmetm,
Ilarigm. Gt `als jusgelss ge @mhhms, Plxms, tbrauibaut tbgs ̀ gstrgot, tbrauibaut tbl \egtl` _tmtls,
me` tbrauibaut Mcrgom lgtblr `grlothy ar tbrauib ‘oa`lsbmrls‛ me` gts mhhgmeol pmrtelrs.
::. Pbgs Oaurt bms nurgs`gotgae avlr tbgs sugt pursumet ta :2 \._.O. §§ =??=, =??:, me`
=?39 me` :2 \._.O. § ::6=. Pbl hgmjghgty ac m oakkae omrrglr mgrhgel gs lvmhumtl` ue`lr cl`lrmh
oakkae hmw, tblrl gs oakphltl `gvlrsgty, me` tbl mkauet ge oaetravlrsy lxoll`s $9=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
11/27
==
HMY_, ZL_AH\PGAE_, ME@ ZLI\HMPGAE_
IASLZEGEI PZM@L GE B\EPGEI PZAVBGL_
:0. Gt gs hlimh ta passlss me` trm`l ge buetgei trapbgls ac hgstl` ar ‘pratlotl`‛ splogls
ms haei ms tbl mppraprgmtl (gkpart me` lxpart) plrkgts mrl gssul`. \e`lr OGPL_, ‘Mpple`gx G‛
geohu`ls ‘mhh splogls tbrlmtlel` wgtb lxtgeotgae wbgob mrl ar kmy jl mcclotl` jy trm`l.‛ OGPL_
mrt. GG(=). Pbgs Mpple`gx geohu`ls mhh jhmod rbgea4 mhh wbgtl rbgea lxolpt car tbl papuhmtgaes ac
_autb Mcrgom me` _wmzghme`4 me` Mcrgome lhlpbmet lxolpt car tbl papuhmtgaes ac Jatswmem,
Emkgjgm, _autb Mcrgom, me` ^gkjmjwl, mkaei atblr splogls. _ll OGPL_ Mpp‗x G.
:
(m) m _ogletgcgo Mutbargty ac tbl _tmtl ac lxpart bms m`vgsl` tbmt suob lxpartwghh eat jl `ltrgkletmh ta tbl survgvmh ac tbmt splogls4
(j) m Kmemilklet Mutbargty ac tbl _tmtl ac lxpart gs smtgscgl` tbmt tblsplogkle wms eat ajtmgel` ge oaetrmvletgae ac tbl hmws ac tbmt _tmtl cartbl pratlotgae ac cmuem me` charm4 … me`
(`) m Kmemilklet Mutbargty ac tbl _tmtl ac lxpart gs smtgscgl` tbmt me gkpart plrkgt bms jlle irmetl` car tbl splogkle.
OGPL_ mrt. GGG(:)(m)-(`). Car me gkpart plrkgt, tbl oae`gtgaes rlhlvmet ta buetgei trapbgls mrl>
(m) m _ogletgcgo Mutbargty ac tbl _tmtl ac gkpart bms m`vgsl` tbmt tbl gkpartwghh jl car purpasls wbgob mrl eat `ltrgkletmh ta tbl survgvmh ac tblsplogls gevahvl`4 … me`
(o) m Kmemilklet Mutbargty ac tbl _tmtl ac gkpart gs smtgscgl` tbmt tblsplogkle gs eat ta jl usl` car prgkmrghy oakklrogmh purpasls.
OGPL_ mrt. GGG(?)(m)-(o).
:3.
\e`lr OGPL_, ‘Mpple`gx GG‛ geohu`ls ‘mhh splogls wbgob mhtbauib eat elolssmrghy
eaw tbrlmtlel` wgtb lxtgeotgae kmy jloakl sa uehlss trm`l ge splogkles ac suob splogls gs
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
12/27
=:
sujnlot ta strgot rliuhmtgae.‛ OGPL_ mrt. GG(:). Mpple`gx GG geohu`ls tbl wbgtl rbgea papuhmtgaes
ac _autb Mcrgom me` _wmzghme` ‘Tc[ar tbl lxohusgvl purpasl ac mhhawgei getlremtgaemh trm`l ge hgvl
megkmhs ta mppraprgmtl me` moolptmjhl `lstgemtgaes me` buetgei trapbgls,‛ ms wlhh ms Mcrgome hgae,
me` tbl lhlpbmet papuhmtgaes ac Jatswmem, Emkgjgm, _autb Mcrgom, me` ^gkjmjwl (‘`awehgstl`‛
ta Mpple`gx GG ta cmoghgtmtl hmwcuh trm`l geohu`gei buetgei trapbgls). OGPL_ Mpp‗x GG. Kmey
wgh`hgcl papuhmtgaes mrl eat hgstl` ae mey OGPL_ Mpple`gx, geohu`gei Ompl juccmha, wbgob mrl
sakl ac Mcrgom‗s kast mjue`met hmril blrjgvarls.
:9. Mimge, trm`l ge Mrtgohl GG splogls gs mhhawl` ms haei ms tbl pravgsgaes ac Mrtgohl GS
mrl cahhawl`. \e`lr Mrtgohl GS, aehy me lxpart plrkgt kust gssul ue`lr tbl cahhawgei oae`gtgaes
rlhlvmet ta buetgei trapbgls>
(m) m _ogletgcgo Mutbargty ac tbl _tmtl ac lxpart bms m`vgsl` tbmt suob lxpartwghh eat jl `ltrgkletmh ta tbl survgvmh ac tbmt splogls4 … me`
(j) m Kmemilklet Mutbargty ac tbl _tmtl ac lxpart gs smtgscgl` tbmt tblsplogkle wms eat ajtmgel` ge oaetrmvletgae ac tbl hmws ac tbmt _tmtl cartbl pratlotgae ac cmuem me` charm4 …
OGPL_ mrt. GS(:)(m)-(j). Vut sgkphy, gc me megkmh gs hlimhhy buetl` ms pmrt ac m rliuhmtl` buetgei
prairmk, mhhawgei tbl rmeil stmtl me` rlolgvgei stmtl ta kmdl tbl rlqugrl` cge`geis me` gssul tbl
rlqugrl` plrkgts, tble trm`l ge tbl buetgei trapby gs mhhawl`.
:2. OGPL_ pmrtgls typgomhhy slt emtgaemh lxpart quatms car hgstl` splogls, ‘usl` ms me
lssletgmh kmemilklet taah ge tbl oaeslrvmtgae ac splogls ac wgh` cmuem me` charm.‛ OGPL_ Zls.
Oaec. =0.9. ]uatms mrl hgkgts ae tbl eukjlr ac megkmhs ac m splogls tbmt kmy jl hlimhhy lxpartl`
ge m ylmr. G`. Pbly lstmjhgsb tbl upplr hgkgt ac lxpart ‘mt m hlvlh tbmt bms ea `ltrgkletmh lcclot
ae tbl papuhmtgae ac tbl splogls,‛ me` slttgei m quatm, ‘m`vgsl` jy m _ogletgcgo Mutbargty
lcclotgvlhy kllts tbl rlqugrlklet ac OGPL_ ta kmdl m eae-`ltrgklet cge`gei car splogls….‛ G`.
Vmrtgls eatgcy tbl OGPL_ _lorltmrgmt ac tblgr quatms me` gc tbl _lorltmrgmt bms qulstgaes ar
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
13/27
=?
oaeolres mjaut tlobegomh gssuls ar tbl sustmgemjghgty ac tbl quatm, gt leimils wgtb tbl Vmrty. G`.
Vujhgomtgae ac m quatm jy tbl _lorltmrgmt wgtbaut `gsoussgae ar pujhgomtgae ac me ‘meeatmtgae‛
ge`gomtls moolptmeol ac tbl quatm. _ll g`. Atblr Vmrtgls kmy mhsa rmgsl oaeolres mjaut m quatm
wgtb tbl rmeil stmtl Vmrty. G`. Car lxmkphl ge :6= =6.=0, car hlapmr`4 =6.=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
14/27
=0
Mcrgom, me` jhmod rbgea crak Emkgjgm, ta emkl jut m clw. Pbl gssumeol ac tblsl lebmeolklet
plrkgts splmds car gtslhc ‟ passlssgae me` trmespart ac buetgei trapbgls gs eat prabgjgtl` ue`lr
\._. hmw, ar ue`lr OGPL_.
JM_G_ AC OAKVHMGEP
?=. Pbl Mcrgome buetgei ge`ustry geohu`ls kmey `gcclrlet phmylrs> prgvmtl hme` awelrs
(tblrl mrl avlr =:,666 buetgei rmeobls ge _autb Mcrgom mhael) ar hlssars ac oaeolssgae hme`,
iavlreklets ar oakkuegtgls wba jlelcgt crak tbl clls pmg`4 tbl smcmrg aplrmtars ar praclssgaemh
buetlrs4 prl-buet slrvgol ge`ustrgls hgdl trmvlh mileogls, jaadgei mileogls, lto.4 buetgei ohglets4
tbl aplrmtars‗ lkphaylls (l.i., `rgvlrs, trmodlrs, spattlrs, sdgeelrs, oaads, omkp stmcc)4 past-buet
slrvgol ge`ustrgls hgdl tmeegei, tmxg`lrky, crlgibt4 me` mjavl mhh, tbl rmeil stmtl wgh`hgcl
mutbargtgls wba rliuhmtl me` suplrvgsl tbl buetgei, lesurl gts sustmgemjghgty, me` motgvlhy pratlot
me` kmemil wgh`hgcl. Ge mhh _autblre me` Lmstlre Mcrgome emtgaes tbmt mhhaw buetgei, tbl wgh`hgcl
mutbargtgls oahhlot clls crak tbl aplrmtars me` ohglets, wbgob clls vmry wgtb tbl splogls, haomtgae,
kltba` ac buet, me` atblr cmotars. Pblsl geohu`l oaeolssgae clls, oaeslrvmtgae clls, plrkgt clls,
trapby clls, me` karl. Ge _autblre me` Lmstlre Mcrgom, tblsl clls mrl tbl hmrilst saurol ac
rlvleul car tbl emtgaemh wgh`hgcl `lpmrtklets. Me` tbl Jgi Cgvl mrl tbl bgiblst prgol` me` tbus
pravg`l tbl irlmtlst rlvleul.
?:. Sgrtumhhy mhh buetgei ohglets wgsb ta jrgei jmod m trapby ac tbl buetgei lxplrgleol.
Prapbgls mrl tmxg`lrkgl` (ar ta jl tmxg`lrkgel`) klkarmjghgm crak tbl imkl megkmhs tmdle ae
tblsl buets. Gt gs m ilelrmh ltbgo ac taurgst smcmrg buetlrs eat ta wmstl mey pmrt ac tbl imkl tmdle.
Pbl klmt gs lmtle ar pravg`l` ta tbl haomh plaphl car tblgr oaesukptgae, me` tbl sdge, bares,
tusds lto., mrl trmespartl` bakl jy tbl buetlr ms irlmthy vmhul` plrsaemh praplrty. Pbl trapbgls
@lhtm gs lkjmriagei mrl mkaei Vhmgetgccs‗ me` tblgr klkjlrs‗ kast vmhul` plrsaemh praplrty.
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
15/27
=<
Jut car tbl lxplotmtgae ac jrgeigei tblgr trapbgls bakl, buetlrs olrtmgehy wghh eat pmy tbl hmril
trapby clls wbgob cue` tbl wgh`hgcl mutbargtgls me` geoletgvgzl haomh plaphl ta oaeslrvl tbl imkl
me` gts bmjgtmt. Pblsl trapbgls mrl wbmt @lhtm bms wraeicuhhy lkjmrial`.
??. Ae Mprgh :=, :6=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
16/27
=3
buetgei ge`ustry ge _autb Mcrgom gs vmhul` mt mraue` Z 3.:jTghhgae[ m ylmr me` gs m saurol ac kuob
ell`l` carlgie lxobmeil, naj orlmtgae, oakkuegty `lvlhapklet me` saogmh uphgctklet.‛
?2. Ge Nuhy :6=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
17/27
=9
0?. _autb Mcrgom‗s @lpmrtklet ac Levgraekletmh Mccmgrs gkkl`gmtlhy meeaueol` gt
wms ‘`gsmppagetl`‛ wgtb @lhtm‗s `logsgae jlomusl tbl lkjmria `g` eat (me` `als eat) `gstgeiugsb
jltwlle trapbgls moqugrl` hlimhhy me` dghhl` ghhlimhhy. Emkgjgm‗s Kgegstlr ac Levgraeklet me`
Paurgsk lobal` tbgs sletgklet me` ‘strlssl` tbl gkpartmet rahl tbmt trapby buetgei phmys‛ car tbl
loaeaky ac Emkgjgm me` gts oakkuegtgls me` oaeslrvmeogls. Pbl Kgegstlr mhsa wmrel` tbmt
@lhtm‗s trapby lkjmria ‘gs sgiegcgomethy gkpmotgei tbl Emkgjgme loaeaky.‛?
00. Lvmhumtgei tbl `logsgae, me ge`ustry oaesuhtmet smg` ‘@lhtm wms prajmjhy
rlspae`gei ta prlssurl cahhawgei tbl elws ac Ologh‗s dghhgei.‛0
0
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
18/27
=2
09. @lhtm bah`s gtslhc aut ms m emtgaemh me` getlremtgaemh mgrhgel acclrgei =
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
19/27
=7
vgahmtls tbl pujhgo pahgoy rlchlotl` ge tbl L_M. Gt euhhgcgls L_M lebmeolklet plrkgts mutbargzl`
me` gssul` jy CY_, `grlothy ajstruotgei tbl getle`l` rloavlry me` survgvmh ac caur ac tbl cgvl
splogls lkjmrial` (ms Ompl juccmha mrl eat L_M-hgstl`). Gt `legls jhmod rbgea, lhlpbmet, me`
hlapmr` tbl lebmeolklet ac survgvmh getle`l` jy gssumeol ac tbl CY_ gkpart plrkgts. Me` gt
rues mimgest tbl pujhgo pahgoy ac sustmgemjhl usl, wbgob gs getle`l` ta ilelrmtl aplrmtgei rlvleul
car wgh`hgcl mutbargtgls ta cue` metg-pamobgei, rloavlry, me` kmemilklet, ta geoletgvgzl haomh
plaphl ta tahlrmtl me` lvle vmhul tbl hgstl` splogls, me` ta prlslrvl bmjgtmt.
=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
20/27
:6
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
21/27
:=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
22/27
::
slrvgols `ul ta rlolgvgei clwlr ac tbl buetgei clls ae wbgob tbly `lple`. M cueotgaegei wgh`hgcl
mutbargty gs lssletgmh ta lvlry pmrt ac tbl buetgei ge`ustry, crak tbl oakkuegtgls ta tbl aplrmtars
wgtb wbak tbly oaetrmot, ta tbl haomh plaphl lkphayl` jy tbl aplrmtars (trmodlrs, sdgeelrs, me`
ha`il wardlrs, mkaei atblrs), tbrauib tbl supphy obmge (trmvlh milets, tmxg`lrkgsts, crlgibt
milets me` carwmr`lrs, lqugpklet kmeucmoturlrs, me` bue`rl`s ac atblrs tbmt mrl klkjlrs ac
Vhmgetgcc arimegzmtgaes). Mhh Vhmgetgccs blrl `lple` ae m cueotgaegei wgh`hgcl `lpmrtklet me`
slrvgols hgdl metg-pamobgei, wbgob @lhtm‗s uehmwcuh lkjmria bms `gsruptl`.
‘sustmgemjhl usl ac wgh` cmuem me` charm, wbltblr oaesukptgvl ar eae-oaesukptgvl, pravg`ls me
loaeakgomhhy oakpltgtgvl hme`-usl aptgae‛ me` ‘tbl rltures crak hlimh usl kmy pravg`l cue`s
me` geoletgvls ta suppart tbl kmemilklet ac wgh` cmuem me` charm ta oaetmge tbl ghhlimh trm`l.‛
OGPL_ Zls. Oaec. 2.?. Lxpart me` sujslqulet trmespart ac Jgi Cgvl trapbgls gs mutbargzl` jy tbl
Vmrtgls (car rbgea, hlapmr`, me` lhlpbmet), gs iug`l` jy tbl quatm systlk (car rbgea, lhlpbmet, me`
hgae), ar cmhhs autsg`l ac OGPL_ oakphltlhy ge tbl omsl ac tbl mjue`met Ompl juccmha.
36. Zloaiegzgei tbl `mkmil uehmwcuh mgrhgel lkjmrias ome `a ta OGPL_, twa carklr
OGPL_ _lorltmrgls-Ilelrmh slet m hlttlr orgtgogzgei mgrhgel lkjmrias me` leoaurmigei tbl ourrlet
_lorltmry-Ilelrmh ta ‘pratlot OGPL_ crak grrlhlvmeol.‛ Pbgs hlttlr pagetl` ta tbl stmtlklets jy
sakl iraups tbmt bmvl cghl` pltgtgaes car tbl mgrhgels ta lkjmria trapbgls tbmt jmh`hy m`kgttl` ta
‘hlmpcraiigei‛ OGPL_. Pbgs hlttlr mhsa eatl` tbmt sakl mgrhgels mpplmr ta jl ourrygei cmvar wgtb
‘me lebmeol` gkmil ac saogmhhy oaeolrel` oarparmtgae,‛ jut mt tbl lxplesl ac ‘hgvlhgbaa`s ge tbl
`lvlhapgei warh` … me` tmriltl` splogls.‛
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
23/27
:?
3=. Pbl uehmwcuh lkjmria mhsa ue`lrkgels CY_ cge`geis tbmt tbl gkpart ac Jgi Cgvl
splogls hgdl lhlpbmet me` jhmod rbgea lebmeols tbl survgvmh ac tbl splogls. CY_ jmsls gts
cge`geis ae lxplrt memhysgs ac tbl jlst mvmghmjhl gecarkmtgae, ylt @lhtm ‟ wgtb ea tlobegomh
lxplrtgsl ‟ gs gieargei tblsl cge`geis ge lkjmriagei splogls crak oauetrgls me` prairmks
lxphgogthy caue` jy CY_ ta jlelcgt tbl splogls. @lhtm rlcusl` ta trmespart Kr. Deawhtae‗s cuhhy
plrkgttl` (gkpart me` lxpart) jhmod rbgea trapby, lvle tbauib CY_ `ltlrkgel`, mkaei atblr
tbgeis>
Jmsl` ae tbl suoolss ac gkphlkletgei tbl Jhmod Zbgea Oaeslrvmtgae_trmtliy car Emkgjgm, tbl usl ac cue`s ilelrmtl` crak jhmod rbgea buets,
me` tbl jgahaigomh ell` car suob bmrvlsts, tbl Jrmeob ac Vlrkgts bms caue`tbmt tbl gkpart ac tbgs spart-buetl` jhmod rbgeaolras crak Emkgjgm, tmdlems pmrt ac tbl emtgaemh strmtliy me` ue`lr tbl slhlotgae orgtlrgm lstmjhgsbl`car ouhhgei, kllts tbl orgtlrgm car gssugei me gkpart plrkgt ue`lr tbl L_M._plogcgomhhy, Kr. Deawhtae‗s trapby gs ta jl tmdle ue`lr tbl muspgols actbl emtgaemh strmtliy me` tbl $?
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
24/27
:0
omsl hmw, tbl `lcgegtgaes ac ‘getlrstmtl mgr trmespartmtgae‛ me` ‘carlgie mgr trmespartmtgae‛ (07
\._.O. § 06=6:), tbl prabgjgtgaes ae `gsorgkgemtary prmotgols (07 \._.O. § 0=?76), me` ge
gkphlkletgei rliuhmtgaes me` getlrprltmtgaes ac tbl Cl`lrmh Mvgmtgae M`kgegstrmtgae.
30. Vhmgetgccs me` tblgr oaeslrvmtgae prairmks mrl sbgpplrs ac ar `lple`let upae tbl
sbgpklet ac taurgst buetgei trapbgls, me` `lple` ae oakkae omrrglrs hgdl @lhtm ‟ me` prlclrmjhy
@lhtm, jlomusl gt chgls `grlothy ta Mcrgom ‟ car trmespart ac Jgi Cgvl taurgst buetgei trapbgls crak
Mcrgom. Jut @lhtm bms uehmwcuhhy rlcusl` ta trmespart m splogcgo ohmss ac hlimhhy moqugrl` trapbgls
wgtbaut mey hmwcuh nustgcgomtgae car tbl lkjmria.
3=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
25/27
:<
aplrmtar gs sul` ge \._. oaurt. Me` tbl rgsd ta tbl hgvlhgbaa`s ac oakkuegtgls me` tbl rlsuhtmet
gkpmot ae tbl vmhul me` cuturl ac wgh`hgcl gs gkklmsurmjhl.
39. Gc tbl lkjmria plrsgsts ta ‘oaevletgae slmsae,‛ wblrl buetgei smcmrgs mrl typgomhhy
kmrdltl`, Vhmgetgccs‗ hassls wghh jl lvle karl kmssgvl me` jlyae` klmsurl.
OA\EP PYA
PAZPGA\_ GEPLZCLZLEOL YGPB J\_GEL__ ZLHMPGAE_
32. Vhmgetgccs rlgeoarparmtl me` rl-mhhlil tbl mhhlimtgaes ge pmrmirmpbs = tbrauib 39.
37. \etgh @lhtm gkpasl` gts uehmwcuh lkjmria, tblrl wms m rlmsaemjhl prajmjghgty tbmt
Vhmgetgccs me`/ar tbl klkjlrs tbly rlprlslet wauh` bmvl letlrl` geta jusgelss rlhmtgaesbgps wgtb
tbgr` pmrtgls. Pbl buetlr-oaeslrvmtgaegsts rlprlsletl` blrl, suob ms Kr. Deawhtae, wauh` bmvl
letlrl` geta jusgelss rlhmtgaesbgps car buetgei smcmrgs4 praclssgaemh buetlrs me` oakkuegtgls
wauh` bmvl acclrl` me` sah` tbasl smcmrgs me` oae`uotl` tblk4 wgh`hgcl kgegstrgls wauh` bmvl
irmetl` hgolesls me` atblr buetgei plrkgts, avlrslle tbl buets, me` rlolgvl` hgolesl me` atblr
geoakl crak tblk, mkaei atblr tbgeis4 me` tbl oakkuegtgls wauh` bmvl jlelcgtl` ms m rlsuht ge
sbmrgei ge tbasl hgolesl me` atblr clls.
96. @lhtm‗s lkjmria gs ge`lple`lethy tartgaus me` uehmwcuh me` vgahmtls @lhtm‗s
`utgls ms m oakkae omrrglr me` gts rlspaesgjghgtgls ue`lr cl`lrmh hmw.
9=.
@lhtm‗s getlrclrleol me` gkpasgtgae ac tbl uehmwcuh lkjmria praxgkmtlhy omusl`
tbl genurgls ac tbl Vhmgetgccs me` tbasl tbly rlprlslet, ms `ltmghl` blrl.
9:. @lhtm‗s tartgaus oae`uot bms omusl` Vhmgetgccs pmst, prlslet, me` cuturl `mkmils.
OA\EP PBZLL
CMGH\ZL PA OAKVHW YGPB CMM ZLI\HMPGAE_ ME@ AVLZMPGEI CHGIBP_ GE
SGAHMPGAE AC PBL PLZK_ AC @LHPM‗_ MGZ OMZZGLZ OLZPGCGOMPL
9?.
Vhmgetgccs rlgeoarparmtl me` rl-mhhlil tbl mhhlimtgaes ge pmrmirmpbs = tbrauib 9:.
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
26/27
:3
90. @lhtm bms cmghl` ta oakphy wgtb cl`lrmh rliuhmtgaes rlqugrgei tbmt gt up`mtl tbl
CMM mjaut gecarkmtgae rlimr`gei omrrgmil lxohusgaes, suob ms tbl Jgi Cgvl trapby lkjmria.
9
=. @lohmrl @lhtm vgahmtl` gts oakkae hmw me` oaetrmotumh `utgls ms m oakkae omrrglr
ta trmespart pmssleilrs me` omria ge`gsorgkgemtlhy4
:. @lohmrl @lhtm tartgaushy getlrclrl` wgtb tbl jusgelss rlhmtgaes ac tbl oakkuegtgls,
taurgst buetlr s, smcmrg buetgei aplrmtars, me` ge`ustry slrvgol pravg`lrs rlprlsletl`
jy Vhmgetgccs, jy ajstruotgei hmwcuh me` getlremtgaemhhy rloaiegzl` trm`l me`
`gspmrmigei hlimh trm`l caue` ta jl jlelcgogmh jy OGPL_ me` CY_ me` oaechmtgei
gt wgtb pamobgei4
?. Vlrkmelethy lenage @lhtm crak lecarogei gts kgstmdle me` uehmwcuh lkjmria ae
trmespart ac Jgi Cgvl trapbgls me` rlqugrl @lhtm ta oakphy wgtb \._. me`
getlremtgaemh hmw, ms cuturl `mkmils mrl gkklmsurmjhl4
Omsl ?>=
8/20/2019 Dallas Safari Club v Delta
27/27
0. Gssul m kme`mtary genueotgae ta oakplh @lhtm ta moolpt hmwcuhhy plrkgttl` Jgi
Cgvl trapbgls car trmespart4
Aotajlr =