2
ALLEGORY: a solution to various expressive problems BUNYAN - Political disengagement & a dissenter’s commentary
Bunyan faces the conceptual impossibility of conveying directly a spiritual transformation--a transformation by definition “beyond words”
Allegory embodies what is not body.
DRYDEN - Political engagement & an insider’s commentary
Dryden deals with the political inadvisability and the psychological ineffectiveness of direct statement.
Allegory is a weapon in a political battle.
Players: David = Charles II
Absalom = James Scott, Duke of Monmouth
Michal =Katherine of Braganza
Bathsheba = Duchess of
Portsmouth
Monmouth’s Mother = Lucy Walter(s)
http://www.npg.org.uk/2563.htm; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:James_Scott.jpg http://www.portcities.org.uk/london/server/show/conMediaFile.4728/King-Charles-II-(163085).html http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Louise_de_K%C3%A9rouail
More players
Achitophel = Anthony Ashley Cooper, 1st Earl of Shaftesbury
Corah = Titus OatesPharaoh = Louis XIVAgag = Sir Edmund
Godfrey
5
Review the players Absalom: James Scott, Duke of Monmouth and
Buccleugh (1649-1685), son of Charles II & Lucy Walters
Achitophel: Anthony Ashley Cooper, Earl of Shaftesbury (1621-1683)
David & Israel’s Monarch: Charles II (1630-1685)
Michal: Catherine of Braganza (1638-1705), Queen
Bathsheba: Duchess of Portsmouth (1649-1734), Charles II's mistress.
Pharaoh: Louis XIV of France
6
More players Israel: England Egypt: France Jerusalem & Sion: London
The Jews: the English “the chosen people”: Protestants Hebrew Priests: Church of England (Anglican) clergy Jewish Rabbins: Church of England priests Levites: The Presbyterian ministers displaced by the
Act of Uniformity. Aaron's Race, the Clergy
Solymaean Rout: London mob. Jebusites: Roman Catholics. Egyptians: French. Sanhedrin: Parliament.
7
And more players Saul: Oliver Cromwell Ishbosheth, Richard Cromwell (1626-1712)
Gath: Brussels, where Charles was in exile after period in France
Hebron: Scotland (where Charles was crowned on Jan. 1, 1651)
Ethnic Plot: Popish Plot
“his Progress”: Monmouth’s journey, beginning July 26, 1680
8
Background: The Exclusion Crisis
The problem of succession
Exclusion Bill: a bill to exclude James, Charles II’s brother, from succession.
See notes in our course booklet.
9
The political problem
Charles has no legitimate children.How do Dryden’s opening lines start to address the problem?
Charles’s sexual promiscuity: many heirs but not one heir
Look closely at lines 1-18.
From the end rhymes of the first 18 lines, what can you guess about the problem the poem presents?
begin, sin; kind, confin'd: deni'd bride; heart, impart command land.
wear; care: bore before. ascend, attend. none Absalom:
10
11
The poem’s strategy
To link Charles II to David To link Monmouth to Absalom, David’s much
loved but rebellious son To recall the Civil War and associate the
supporters of exclusion with it To persuade readers that Charles II’s
political opponents threaten the stability of the restoration. Those who aim to alter the succession aim to erode monarchy.
See lines 69-74.
12
Solution
Dryden relies on his allegory to build up the association between Charles and David and create a sense of sexual blessing.
The art of the subordinate clause: The first ten lines are one sentence, its temporal clauses focusing attention on the history of David.
In pious times Before When Ere When Then
13
Getting a little help from alliteration
man on many multiplied one to one cursedly
confined
The poem makes Charles’s extensive sexual activity a virtue rather than a state problem. The queen is “a soil ungrateful to the tiller’s care” (12).
14
Sexual energy underlies politics.
What does “Scatter'd his Maker's image through the land” mean?
Absalom’s conception seems to have been inspired by a “diviner lust/greater gust.”
Contrast: Achitophel’s cramped conceptions define him.
169 And all to leave, what with his toil he won 170 To that unfeather'd, two-legg'd thing, a
son: 171 Got, while his soul did huddled notions
try; 172 And born a shapeless lump, like anarchy.
15
Further scrutiny of Dryden’s link between sexual and political
activity Dryden fuses sexual and political
corruption.
169 And all to leave, what with his toil he won 170 To that unfeather'd, two-legg'd thing, a son: 171 Got, while his soul did huddled notions try; 172 And born a shapeless lump, like anarchy.
Note also the poem’s use of the term debauched: “debauch'd with ease”(47); “debauch'd with praise”
(312).
The OED for definition of debauch: “To turn or lead away, entice, seduce, from one
to whom service or allegiance is due”
16
But the problem of succession is not solved by prolific sexual activity: “No true succession”(l. 16)
The problem of succession
Highlighted in the opening lines
Obscured by the poem’s effort to make Charles’s extensive sexual activity a sign of blessing and generous energy.
17
Achitophel: satiric portrait (l. 150 ff.)
A portrait of excess and deformity
Achitophel is a Satan figure and a master rhetorician.
Achitophel is greatness deformed, an epic figure fallen to satiric status.
18
What is worth noticing here? Rhymes. Alliteration, Metaphors 150 Of these the false Achitophel was first: 151 A name to all succeeding ages curst. 152 For close designs, and crooked counsels fit; 153 Sagacious, bold and turbulent of wit: 154 Restless, unfixt in principles and place; 155 In pow'r unpleas'd, impatient of disgrace. 156 A fiery soul, which working out its way, 157 Fretted the pigmy-body to decay: 158 And o'er inform'd the tenement of clay. 159 A daring pilot in extremity; 160 Pleas'd with the danger, when the waves went high 161 He sought the storms; but for a calm unfit, 162 Would steer too nigh the sands, to boast his wit. 163 Great wits are sure to madness near alli'd; 164 And thin partitions do their bounds divide:
19
Achitophel as Satan: the temptations of Absalom
Auspicious Prince! (230)
Their [thy longing country’s] second Moses (234)
Thee, Saviour, thee, the nation's vows confess (240)
How long wilt thou the general joy detain; Starve, and defraud the people of thy reign? (244-5) Believe me, royal youth, thy fruit must be, Or gather'd ripe, or rot upon the tree (250-1).
Had thus Old David, from whose loins you spring, Not dar'd, when fortune call'd him, to be king (262-3).
What strength can he to your designs oppose, Naked of friends and round beset with foes? (279-80).
20
Temptation (cont.)
Unwarily was led from virtue’s ways; Made drunk with honour, and debauch'd with praise.
Half loath, and half consenting to the ill,(For loyal blood within him struggled still)He thus repli'd.--And what pretence have ITo take up arms for public liberty?My Father governs with unquestion'd right;The Faith's defender, and mankind's delight:Good, gracious, just, observant of the laws;And Heav'n by wonders has espous'd his cause.Whom has he wrong'd in all his peaceful reign?Who sues for justice to his throne in vain?(312 ff.)
21
The Popish Plot exacerbated the problem of succession. Dryden’s view of the plot:
108 From hence began that plot, the nation's curse, 109 Bad in itself, but represented worse. 110 Rais'd in extremes, and in extremes decri'd; 111 With oaths affirm'd, with dying vows deni'd. 112 Not weigh'd, or winnow'd by the multitude; 113 But swallow'd in the mass, unchew'd and crude.
Dryden’s treatment of the plot: fever in the body politic
136 For, as when raging fevers boil the blood, 137 The standing lake soon floats into a flood; 138 And ev'ry hostile humour, which before 139 Slept quiet in its channels, bubbles o'er: 140 So, several factions from this first ferment, 141 Work up to foam, and threat the government.