Top Banner
Locke The Dissolution of Government
22

The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Feb 20, 2019

Download

Documents

truongphuc
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Locke

The Dissolution of Government

Page 2: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditional Government

Locke says that the power of government isLimitedDividedConditional

What does it mean if a government is conditional?

Page 3: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditional Government

Locke says that the power of government isLimitedDividedConditional

What does it mean if a government is conditional?

That people have a right to replace it if it fails.

Page 4: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditional Government

Locke says that the power of government isLimitedDividedConditional

What does it mean if a government is conditional?

That people have a right to replace it if it fails.

What is it to replace it?

Page 5: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditional Government

Locke says that the power of government isLimitedDividedConditional

What does it mean if a government is conditional?

That people have a right to replace it if it fails.

What is it to replace it?

Revolution. Probably violent.

Page 6: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Revolution

Under what conditions does Locke say that we are allowed to dissolve government?

Actually, Locke turns this question on it's head...

Page 7: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

Under what conditions does Locke say that we are allowed to dissolve government?

Actually, Locke turns this question on it's head...

According to Locke, revolutions are justified against authorities that people never consented to. The are instigated when the legislative changes. When this happens, the people have no obligation to obey and may chose revolution.

According to Locke, governments are the first aggressors in the revolution.

Page 8: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government.

Dissolution of government is the general case of government failing.

Page 9: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government.

Dissolution of government is the general case of government failing.

A government dissolves when the legislative is altered, i.e., teh proceedure for producing laws that guide conduct in the society ceases to be the one that people consented to.

Page 10: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

"First, when a single person, or prince, sets up his own abitrary will in place of the laws, which are the will of the society, declared by the legislative, the the legislative is changed." (214)

Page 11: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

"Secondly, when the prince hinders the legislativefrom assemlbing in its due time, or from acting freely, pursuant to those ends for which it was constituted, the legislative is dissolved." (215)

Page 12: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

"Thirdly, when, by the arbitrary power of the prince, the electors, or ways of election, are altered, without the consent, and contrary to the common interest of the people, there also the legislative is altered." (216)

"Fourthly, the delivery also of the people into the subjection of a foreign power, either by the prince, or by the legislative, is certainly a change of legislative."

Page 13: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

For Locke, any change in the substance of the law making process without the consent of the people changes the government, and thereby makes it illegitimate. An illegitimate government is one against which people are allowed to rebel.

Page 14: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Furthermore....

"...the state of mankind is not so miserable that they are not capable of using this remedy till it be too late to look for any."

Page 15: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Furthermore....

"...the state of mankind is not so miserable that they are not capable of suing this remedy till it be too late to look for any."

What does this mean?

Page 16: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Furthermore....

"...the state of mankind is not so miserable that they are not capable of suing this remedy till it be too late to look for any."

What does this mean?

That the legislative does not need to change before rejection of government is justified, i.e., revolution can occur before the legislative is altered.

Page 17: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Furthermore....

If the legislative acts contrary to their trust, the legislative is dissolved.

What is the "trust" that is being talked about here?

Page 18: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Furthermore....

If the legislative acts contrary to their trust, the legislative is dissolved.

What is the "trust" that is being talked about here?

It's the trust of creating a society preferable to the state of nature, securing our property, and delivering known, settled law, thrid-party judges, and an executive to enforce the law.

Page 19: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Conditions for Dissolution

Locke also mentions governments that fail to perform their tasks of securing us a life better than in the state of nature:"Whensoever therefore the legislative shall transgress this fundamental rule of society; and either by ambition, fear, folly or corruption, endeavour to grasp themselves, or put into the hands of any other, an absolute power over the lives, liberties, and estates of the people; by this breach of trust they forfeit the power the people had put into their hands for quite contrary ends, and it devolves to the people, who have a right to resume their original liberty, and, by the establishment of a new legislative" (222)

Page 20: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

Who Judges the Call for Revolution

Who determines when a Government has justified a revolution by the people?

The people judge.

Page 21: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

The big problem for Locke

The big problem for Locke's view of revolution is this:

"This hypothesis lays ferment for frequent rebellion."

First, no government is perfect: all government will occasionally transgress, delivering law against the common good or changing itself procedures of legislation without consent.

Second: "the people being ignorant and always discontented, [this lays] the foundation of government in the unsteady opinion and uncertain humour or the people, [and] is to expose it to certain ruin."

Page 22: The Dissolution of Government - University of Arizonalenhart/trad104/slides2/locke.pdf · For Locke, revolution is but one form of dissolution of government. Dissolution of government

The big problem for Locke

Locke has two responses: First, people aren't nearly so apt to engage in the difficult and dangerous process of revolution as this suggests. People are slow to change their ways.Second, people don't rebel at the slightest breach, but only when failures and corruptions are systemic, when "a long train of abuses, prevarications, and artifices, all tending the same way, make the design visible to the people."