The Belgian Approach: the Family Units Geert Verbauwhede, acting Advisor Conference on Alternatives to Detention Interior 16.11.2011
The Belgian Approach: the Family Units Geert Verbauwhede, acting Advisor Conference on Alternatives to Detention Interior 16.11.2011.
Dec 16, 2015
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
The Belgian Approach: the Family Units
Geert Verbauwhede, acting Advisor
Conference on Alternatives to Detention
Interior
16.11.2011
16.11.2011
History before and since alternative
• Until 1998: no detention of families with children (exception: border cases)
• Until 15.05.2001: detention of one of the parents; rest of the family free problem: rest of the family did not present themselves at date of removal
• Until 01.10.2008: detention of families as a whole
• From 01.10.2008: no detention of families with children (exception: border cases)
• Since 01.10.2009: also border cases no longer detained
16.11.2011
Why this change?
• Pressure of NGO’s and parliament to seek for alternatives
• 2006-2007: report made by external study agency with presentation of different alternatives
• 2007: report presented to parliament
• March 2008: test with invitations to the Immigration Office – unsuccessful (only 10 % of invitees came)
16.11.2011
Creation of Family Identification and Return Unit (FITT) 1 October 2008
• Return officers (coaches) of Immigration Office
• Assist families in preparation of return, legal questions, logistical matters, …
• Cooperation with IOM
• Sponsored by EU Return Fund
• Cooperation with local authorities and NGO’s
• Also looking for staying alternatives if asked by families (depending on information given by families)
• Now: 4 coaches + 1 coordinator + 2 technical support + 1 logistical supervisor
16.11.2011
Family Units
• Alternative = individual houses or apartments for families (former police force houses)
• 15 family units in use – 7 in preparation
• Completely equipped en furnished
• One family per unit because of privacy – in bigger houses possibility to put 2 families
• Long term Plans : looking for bigger site and / or extra locations then of course necessity for extra coaches
16.11.2011
16.11.2011
16.11.2011
16.11.2011
Family units in detention Centre
• Recent ECHR decision: no detention of families unless specific infrastructure
• Decision of State Secretary for Migration and Asylum Policy: creation of specific family units in the detention centre at the airport separated from rest of detention centre; 5 prefab vacation houses with necessary infrastructure
• Who can be detained: specific border cases (INAD), families who did not respect rules in family units
• Timing: Spring 2012
16.11.2011
Legislative framework
• Royal Decree of 14 May 2009: rules for the family units, rights and obligations for families
• Planned: Royal Decree stipulating which categories of families with children can be detained in future
16.11.2011
Evaluation
• Relatively positive evaluation by NGO’s and by administration; international interest in system (Council of Europe, EU, other EU member states)
• BUT: concerns about large number of absconding (25 % - percentage of absconders within Dublin scheme is even 53 %)
• Exhaustive internal evaluation on different criteria, which can be used for future continuous evaluation
• Family units are no longer Project but are embedded return procedure
• Still necessity to develop cooperation with other State Agencies (e.g. reception centres)
16.11.2011
Assessment on arrival of families at the Border
• Since opening of family units for border cases: clear increase of families arriving at border + new nationalities (Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, Sri Lanka) and new departure airports (Moscow) from 23 families in 2009 over 66 in 2010 to already 103 until 27.10.2011
• Families stayed already a long time in third (transit) countries before arriving in Belgium
• Many recognized refugees + subsidiary protection at the border
• Looking for balance – avoid that family units become pull factor
16.11.2011
Statistics (up to 03.11.2011)
• 249 families with 452 minor children (80 irregular migrant families,
51 Dublin families, 118 border families)
• 240 families have left the family units
- 102 families departed to country of origin or third country (23 IOM, 25 Dublin cases, 5 bilateral cases, 14 “forced” removals, 34 refoulments at border, 1 voluntary departure without assistance)
- 60 families “escaped” (absconded)
- 78 families were freed (9 families temporarily or definitively regularized; 29 families recognised as refugee; 8 families subsidiary protection, 5 families pending asylum procedure; …)
- 1 family separated (child not related with “parent”)
• Average staying period: 23,7 days
• Top 5 nationalities: Iraq, Afghanistan, Brazil, Russian Federation,
Armenia
Related Documents
