Looking to unleash data explosion momentum Smartphone growth sets off data explosion The number of smartphone subscribers is forecast to grow from 7.18mn in 2010 to 20mn in 2011 and to 31.8mn in 2012. The telecom services market has seen a phenomenal increase in mobile data traffic driven by the surge in smartphone users and the introduction of unlimited data service. Korea’s mobile data jumped 15.3x in the past 14 months and is projected to expand 8.7x over the next two years. Three carriers taking different paths in dealing with data growth In June, the Korea Communications Commission (KCC) will announce guidelines for the allotment of 1.8GHz and 2.1GHz spectrums. Telcos’ networks have four strategies to deal with the data explosion 1) additional spectrum acquisition, 2) LTE network rollout, 3) alternative networks such as WiFi and femtocell, and 4) existing network upgrade through HSPA+, cell splitting and cloud service. SK Telecom (SKT) is upgrading its 3G network (HSPA+, cell splitting) and is also preparing to launch LTE. KT plans to enlist the help of WiFi/WiBro networks and cloud services. KT lags behind peers in its LTE rollout plan. LGU+ aims to roll out a nationwide LTE network by July 2012 and build a nationwide WiFi network by drawing on its pool of household WiFi access points. Profitability to remain healthy despite capex increase Growing mobile traffic brings with it concerns over increased capex requirement for infrastructure improvement and over additional frequency band acquisition costs. However, we expect telcos’ profitability to remain firm. Traffic growth will boost carriers’ revenue significantly and per-bit data transmission cost will be minimized through the use of alternative networks. Also, tariff plans are likely to be restructured in the direction of scrapping or revamping the unlimited data plans and bringing usage-based pricing into the market. We do not expect the infrastructure investment and frequency acquisition costs to eat into profitability. OVERWEIGHT, SKT and KT our top picks Korean telcos have been underperforming the market year-to-date, while overseas peers have seen substantial gains in share price. We maintain OVERWEIGHT on the telecom services sector due to its compelling valuations, attractive dividend prospects, and profitability improvement from increased smartphone exposure. Our top picks are SKT and KT. Explosive mobile data traffic growth is reshaping the competitive landscape of the telecom services industry around network and voice call quality as well as service (competitive content) quality, as opposed to the previous marketing focus of handset subsidies. We find SKT best positioned to benefit from the mobile data explosion thanks to its edge in subscriber base, frequency band, financial capacity, and content (T-map, mobile music portal service Melon, etc). We also like KT for its competitive fixed-line network and deep pockets. Sector Report / Telecom Services Telecom Services May 20, 201 1 Overweight (Maintain) Company Rating TP (won) SK Telecom BUY (-) 222,000 (-) KT BUY (-) 54,000 (-) LG Uplus Hold (-) 7,900 (-) Contents I. Oversold, OVERWEIGHT.......................................... 1 II. Mobile data explosion ................................................. 5 1. Unprecedented growth of smartphones and tablet PCs 2. Wireless data traffic up tenfold in two years III. Data traffic strategies differ by carrier ............. 7 1. Additional frequency allocation and network neutrality issue 2. Taking different paths on network issue IV. Is data explosion a threat?.................................. 11 1. Opportunity: ARPC hike, usage-based pricing and network neutrality exception 2. Threats: Added capex burden, frequency acquisition costs, and wVoIP V. Profitability to remain at a healthy level ....16 VI. The strong get stronger as competition surrounds network capacity..............................19 Company.........................................................................................21
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Looking to unleash data explosion momentum
Smartphone growth sets off data explosion The number of smartphone subscribers is forecast to grow from 7.18mn in
2010 to 20mn in 2011 and to 31.8mn in 2012. The telecom services
market has seen a phenomenal increase in mobile data traffic driven by
the surge in smartphone users and the introduction of unlimited data
service. Korea’s mobile data jumped 15.3x in the past 14 months and is
projected to expand 8.7x over the next two years.
Three carriers taking different paths in dealing with data growth In June, the Korea Communications Commission (KCC) will announce
guidelines for the allotment of 1.8GHz and 2.1GHz spectrums. Telcos’
networks have four strategies to deal with the data explosion 1) additional
spectrum acquisition, 2) LTE network rollout, 3) alternative networks such
as WiFi and femtocell, and 4) existing network upgrade through HSPA+,
cell splitting and cloud service. SK Telecom (SKT) is upgrading its 3G
network (HSPA+, cell splitting) and is also preparing to launch LTE. KT
plans to enlist the help of WiFi/WiBro networks and cloud services. KT lags
behind peers in its LTE rollout plan. LGU+ aims to roll out a nationwide
LTE network by July 2012 and build a nationwide WiFi network by drawing
on its pool of household WiFi access points.
Profitability to remain healthy despite capex increase Growing mobile traffic brings with it concerns over increased capex
requirement for infrastructure improvement and over additional frequency
band acquisition costs. However, we expect telcos’ profitability to remain
firm. Traffic growth will boost carriers’ revenue significantly and per-bit data
transmission cost will be minimized through the use of alternative networks.
Also, tariff plans are likely to be restructured in the direction of scrapping or
revamping the unlimited data plans and bringing usage-based pricing into
the market. We do not expect the infrastructure investment and frequency
acquisition costs to eat into profitability.
OVERWEIGHT, SKT and KT our top picks Korean telcos have been underperforming the market year-to-date, while
overseas peers have seen substantial gains in share price. We maintain
OVERWEIGHT on the telecom services sector due to its compelling
valuations, attractive dividend prospects, and profitability improvement
from increased smartphone exposure. Our top picks are SKT and KT.
Explosive mobile data traffic growth is reshaping the competitive
landscape of the telecom services industry around network and voice call
quality as well as service (competitive content) quality, as opposed to the
previous marketing focus of handset subsidies. We find SKT best
positioned to benefit from the mobile data explosion thanks to its edge in
subscriber base, frequency band, financial capacity, and content (T-map,
mobile music portal service Melon, etc). We also like KT for its competitive
fixed-line network and deep pockets.
Sector Report / Telecom Services
Telecom Services
May 20, 2011
Overweight (Maintain)
Company Rating TP (won)
� SK Telecom BUY (-) 222,000 (-)
� KT BUY (-) 54,000 (-)
� LG Uplus Hold (-) 7,900 (-)
Contents
I. Oversold, OVERWEIGHT ..........................................1
II. Mobile data explosion .................................................5
1. Unprecedented growth of smartphones and
tablet PCs
2. Wireless data traffic up tenfold in two years
III. Data traffic strategies differ by carrier .............7
1. Additional frequency allocation and network
neutrality issue
2. Taking different paths on network issue
IV. Is data explosion a threat? ..................................11
1. Opportunity: ARPC hike, usage-based
pricing and network neutrality exception
2. Threats: Added capex burden, frequency
acquisition costs, and wVoIP
V. Profitability to remain at a healthy level ....16
VI. The strong get stronger as competition surrounds network capacity..............................19
Note: Adopted iPhone in October 2009. Started unlimited data service in July 2010. Source: Korea Communication Commission, Korea Information Society Development Institute
Mobile traffic will continue to rise, driven by the increasing penetration of smart
devices and upgraded content services such as broadcasting and streaming video.
Exponential mobile data demand growth will continue for the foreseeable future.
Mobile industry watchers forecast domestic mobile data traffic to increase 8.7-fold
Source: Korea Information Society Development Institute
Mobile data traffic
increased 15.3x over 14
months from December
2009 to February 2011
Mobile traffic demand to
grow 8.7x over the next
two years
Telecom Services
7
III. Data traffic strategies differ by carrier
1. Additional frequency allocation and network neutrality issue
1) Government to allocate more spectrum to decongest network
The policy of the KCC to deal with growing mobile traffic is based on frequency band redistribution, reassessment of the network neutrality principle, and revamping the current unlimited data service. The KCC plans to put up for auction 20MHz of spectrum in the 2.1GHz and 1.8GHz band each, in June 2011. Later, the redistribution of 108MHz in the 700MHz band should be on the table as well. If the government permits it, the 700MHz frequency band should be used for telecommunications from 2013 when analog broadcasting is no longer available. However, broadcasters argue that the 700MHz spectrum must be used for 3D broadcasting while digital broadcasting is aired through 470-698MHz. The total bandwidth that can be redistributed from the three frequency bands - 2.1GHz, 1.8GHz and 700MHz - amounts to 148MHz. Telecom service researchers believe Korea’s mobile carriers will need at least 240MHz of additional spectrum by 2015 and 390MHz by 2020. Frequency bands to be allocated in major overseas mobile service markets in the next five to ten years amount to roughly 2-3x the frequency bands currently used by carriers. Increased frequency bands equal more traffic capacity.
Frequency band redistribution plans
Band Bandwidth Redistribution period
2.1GHz 20MHz 11.6 - 20MHz of spectrum immediately available. Golden band globally used for 3G and offer advantages in smartphone lineup and global roaming.
1.8GHz 20MHz 11.6 - 20MHz of spectrum to be available when KT’s 2G is terminated in July. - Some European companies are deploying LTE on 1.8GHz band. - However, domestic carriers may risk handset lineup disadvantage compared to 2.1GHz and 700MHz.
700MHz 108MHz ? - Available from 2013 after the switch to digital TV broadcasting is completed. Prime LTE band.
Total 148MHz - Notably short of minimum 240MHz needed by 2015. A pressing need for policies to secure additional frequency bands.
Source: KISDI policy open forum, Professor Kang, Choon-gu of Korea University
2) Revisiting network neutrality issue
Voice over IP over wireless (wVoIP) network and instant messaging services that allow users to bypass paying mobile networks are seeing rapid growth. Google Voice and Skype are the leading wVoIP services offered overseas. Domestic mobile users using flat-rate tariff plans of over W55,000 a month are allowed to use wVoIP services. The market has seen an increase in demand for free or low-cost mobile messenger services - such as KakaoTalk, MeToday, Twitter, Facebook, and Cyworld - as alternatives for voice calls and SNS. However, mobile instant messaging volume growth has come to crowd the mobile network, resulting in the deterioration of voice call quality. Telcos are increasing network capex to deal with rising traffic, but the free wVoIP and messaging services put mobile operators in a tough spot as they have an adverse effect on revenue. Usage-based pricing for mobile data traffic is gaining support in major mobile markets including the US, UK, Japan, France, Spain, Italy, and Norway. Usage-based pricing supporters argue that the mobile network should be an exception to network neutrality (unlimited access). The Korean government is expected to bring this issue to the public in 2H11.
Additional frequency bands to be auctioned
out
Mobile carriers need an additional 240-390MHz
by 2015
Telcos and Internet portals at odds over
wVoIP and SNS
Government to weigh ‘usage-based pricing’ for mobile networks
from 2H11
Telecom Services
8
2. Taking different paths on network issue
The three mobile carriers are taking differing approaches in dealing with the data
explosion. Their network strategies are 1) additional spectrum acquisition, 2) LTE
network rollout, 3) alternative networks such as WiFi and femtocell, and 4) existing
network upgrade through HSPA+, cell splitting and cloud service.
1) High-stakes competition over frequency bands
Mobile operators are bent on securing additional frequency bandwidth. The 20MHz
spectrum on the 2.1GHz and 1.8GHz band set to be redistributed is the most
coveted spectrum. Competition will also be intense for the golden low-frequency
700MHz band although the band will not be freed up by analog broadcasters until
end-2012 and the redistribution of the band has not been fixed yet.
If the government decides to auction off 2.1GHz, 1.8GHz, and 700MHz bands at
the same time, mobile carriers will have some flexibility in their network strategy.
Considering LGU+’s weak financial capacity, we do not believe mobile carriers will
end up bleeding too much over frequencies.
Frequency band assigned by company (as of 2010)
800MHz 900 1800 2100 2300
SK Telecom 2G(50) 3G(40) WiBro(27)
KT 2G(40) 3G(40) WiBro(27)
LG Uplus 2G(20)
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
Spectrums for possible use by mobile operators after reallocation (July 2011) and the forecast of future
spectrum allocation
700MHz 800 900 1800 2100 2300
SK Telecom 3G or LTE (108) 2G(20) LTE(10) 3G or LTE (20) 3G(40) 3G(20) 3G(20) WiBro(27)
KTPossible spectrum
reallocation LTE(20) LTE(20)
To be
reallocated3G(40)
To be
reallocatedWiBro(27)
LG UplusAvailable for use
after 2013LTE(20) 2G(20)
KT to terminate 2G
service
Note: 1. Figures in parenthesis indicates channel bandwidth. 2. As of April 2011. Source: Korea Investment & Securities
2) Next-generation networks: LTE
The long-term evolution (LTE) is a core part of telcos’ traffic growth strategy. LTE,
also called a 3.9G system, provides a maximum downlink speed of 40Mbps vs.
14.4Mbps of the current 3G (HSUPA) network and 100Mbps of the 4G LTE
advanced. About 17 carriers around the world have already launched LTE service
and the number is expected to rise to 64 by end-2012.
Over the long term, mobile carriers will have to move up to 4G. However, the LTE
commercialization decision hinges on the issues of 1) 3G investment payback
period, 2) voice revenue decline, and 3) slower data revenue growth vs. explosive
traffic growth. For now, domestic carriers’ traffic growth strategies are primarily
based on 3G upgrades and alternative networks.
Telcos to compete
for the golden
2.1GHz, 1.8GHz
Looking to LTE to cope
with rising data demand
Telecom Services
9
KT plans to make best use of alternative networks such as WiFi and WiBro. Its
planned migration to LTE lags behind competitors’ timelines. In the meantime, KT
plans to fall back on the High Speed Packet Access+ (HSPA+) services. SKT
intends to channel data traffic over to alternative networks such as WiFi and
femtocell, while moving up its scheduled migration of 3G network to HSPA+ and
LTE. SKT plans to complete its nationwide LTE network by 2013. SKT is expected
to maintain a dual network strategy of using LTE for data and 3G for voice for a
while. LGU+ does not have a 3G network but upgraded its CDMA network to EV-
DO Rev.B in April 2011. The third-ranked carrier plans to kick off LTE service for
the capital region in July 2011 and complete a nationwide network by July 2012.
Mobile technology evolution process: SKT, KT (HSPA+); LGU+ (EV-DO r.B); eventually migrating towards 4G
Note: 1. (Upload/download rates). 2. LTE (long-term evolution): The long-term evolution of mobile technology that offers upgrade path from 3G networks. Source: Korea Investment & Securities
Note: CDMA technology evolution was closed after the development of CDMA EVDO REV.A/B. There are only few mobile operators that selected WiMAX as the key technology, so we only consider evolution towards LTE in the table.
Note: Average of postpaid subscribers. Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
2. Threats: Added capex burden, frequency acquisition costs, and wVoIP
The surge in data traffic entails the risks of: 1) capex increase; 2) cost burden to
secure more frequencies; 3) tariff-cut pressure; and 4) proliferation of wVoIP and
SNS.
1) Added capex burden
Exploding data demand is heightening concerns over the heavier burden of capex
laid on mobile carriers. The combined capex of Korea’s four telcos is expected to
expand 18.6% to W7.595trn in 2011 from W6.405trn in 2010. However, we believe
the extent of the capex increase will be manageable by telcos. Pre-investments
are concentrated in 2011, indicating capex will slightly decline in 2012 compared to
2011. The ratio of capex to sales in 2011 and 2012 will remain within the range of
15-17%. This is because capex will not be limited to establishing the next-
generation LTE network, but will be dispersed to areas such as the upgrade of
previous 2G and 3G networks (HSPA+, CDMA Rev.B) and investments in
alternative networks such as WiFi and femtocells to offload data traffic.
LGU+, the most eager to invest in LTE, is expected to spend W1.2trn in building a
nationwide network from 2011 to June 2012. LTE equipment prices have declined
to a mere two thirds of previous 3G equipment prices. Telcos are also working on
improving existing networks, as investments in LTE to boost the capacity of
existing networks by only two to threefold. Infrastructure investment for HSPA+ and
CDMA Rev.B involve minimal capex. SKT is enthusiastically investing in HSPA+,
as capex on HSPA+ stands at a mere one third of that on LTE. LGU+ also
completed building a CDMA Rev.B network (replaced software) in April by
investing W5bn. As for WiFi and femtocells, these alternative networks require
minimal capex.
Capex to increase, but
at a manageable pace
Building LTE networks,
upgrading existing
networks, and investing
in alternative networks
require less capex than
did previous 3G
networks
Telecom Services
13
Capex outlook for four telcos
16.1
14.8
17.0
15.9
5,500
6,000
6,500
7,000
7,500
8,000
2009 2010 2011F 2012F
13
14
15
16
17
18Combined capex of f our telcos (LHS)
Combined capex-to-sales of f our telcos (RHS)
(W bn) (%)
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
Capex-to-sales ratio (W bn, %)
2,009 2,010 2011F 2012F
Capex
SK Telecom 1,769 1,865 2,300 2,250
KT 2,959 3,057 3,250 3,200
LG Uplus 1,248 1,148 1,700 1,500
SK Broadband 540 334 345 345
Total 6,516 6,405 7,595 7,295
Capex-to-sales
SK Telecom 14.6 15.0 17.4 16.2
KT 15.6 15.1 15.8 15.5
LG Uplus 16.5 13.5 19.8 16.8
SK Broadband 28.5 15.8 15.1 14.2
Total 16.1 14.8 17.0 15.9
Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
2) Cost burden to secure additional frequencies
Along with capacity expansion through infrastructure investments, acquisition of
additional frequency bands is a prerequisite for accommodating the surging data
traffic. Adding the cost for obtaining frequency bands, the overall cost to deal with
the explosion in data traffic could be a burden on wireless carriers.
The bidding costs could increase if the Korean government simultaneously puts up
for auction each 20MHz of the 2.1GHz and 1.8GHz band and then 108MHz of the
700MHz band additionally. The costs fluctuates depending on the frequency
bandwidth, whether it is a high or low frequency (value of frequency below 1GHz is
higher due to greater efficiency), usage period, and competitive landscape.
The 20MHz spectrum in the 2.1GHz band will be offered until 2016. As for other
bandwidths, the government has yet to determine whether to reassign the bands
and under what conditions. In 2010, SKT was allocated 20MHz of the 2.1GHz
band at a price of W230bn (W106.4bn in 2010 + 1.6% of revenue for the next 6.5
years) until 2016.
The need to secure
more frequencies raises
concerns over bidding
costs
Telecom Services
14
The preference of bandwidth is in the order of 2.1GHz, 700MHz, and 1.8GHz
taking into consideration the purpose of usage and available period. Applying the
revenue calculation criteria used when reallocating frequency in 2010 and
assuming a usage period of five, eight, and nine years for 20MHz of the 2.1GHz
frequency band, 108MHz of the 700MHz frequency band, and 20MHz of the
1.8GHz frequency band, respectively, the acquisition price comes down to
W175.4bn, W2.3272trn, and W315.7bn, respectively. The combined amount is
estimated at W2.8183trn. In addition to financing costs, three telcos will annually
incur amortization expenses on intangible assets (frequency allocation cost/usage
period) totaling W361.1bn. On average, amortization expenses of W128.1bn will
be added to each wireless carrier annually. Compared to the expenses from
infrastructure investments, this amount appears nominal.
Spectrum allocation fees per service (W bn)
SKT KT LGT
License fee (W bn)
CDMA 80 in 1994 110 110
200 from 1994 to 2002 +0.5% of sales +0.5% of sales
+0.75% of sales
WCDMA (2001) 650 in 2002 650 in 2002 220
650 from 2007 to 2011 650 from 2007 to 2011 Returned in 2006
WCDMA or LTE 106.4 in 2010 251.4 in 2011 251.4 in 2011
(Allocated in 2010 ) +1.6% of sales from 2010 to 2016 +1.6% of sales from 2011 to 2021 +1.6% of sales from 2011 to 2021
WiBro 117 117 -
License period (start date-end date)
CDMA (allocated in 1994, 1996) 34,639 96~11 96~11
WCDMA (allocated in 2001) 01~16 01~16 01~06
WCDMA or LTE (allocated in 2010) 10~16 11~21 11~21
WiBro 05~12 05~12 -
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
Spectrum acquisition cost estimates (W bn)
Band Bandwidth Service period Service life 20MHz spectrum acq. cost Spectrum Annual depreciation cost
(MHz) for using 1 year (A) acq. cost (acq. cost/service life)
700MHz 108 8 2013~2021 53.9 2,327.2 290.9
1800MHz 20 9 2012~2021 35.1 315.7 35.1
2100MHz 20 5 2012~2016 35.1 175.4 35.1
Total 148 2,818.3 361.1
Note: 1. We assume the service life of 700MHz and 1800MHz is until 2021, which is the closing period of LTE. 2. 700MHz is high priced due to the efficiency of low spectrum.
3. Spectrum acquisition cost = A *bandwidth* service life.
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
Spectrum acquisition cost and depreciation cost of three domestic mobile
operators (W bn)
SKT KT LGU+ Total
Spectrum acq. cost
2009 2,340 1,342 0 3,682
2010 2,340 1,342 0 3,682
Depreciation cost
2009 129 115 0 245
2010 129 115 0 245
Note: CDMA pays for spectrum license fees. Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
Total costs to acquire
148MHz bandwidth
estimated at W2.3272trn,
smaller in scale
compared to
infrastructure
investments
Telecom Services
15
3) Rate-cut pressure
The Korean government recently shifted the direction of its telecom services policy
from promoting the industry to benefiting consumers. The government plans to
induce telcos to lower rates by slashing marketing expenses. Soaring data
demand from the usage of smartphones is burdening consumers with hefty mobile
phone bills, leaving the government no choice but to press telcos to cut rates.
If mobile rates are lowered while capex is increased to handle rising wireless data
demand, telcos will see marginal revenue growth and stagnant profit growth. After
the government’s scheduled announcement of a rate-cut plan in May 2011,
another round of rate cuts could follow as the general and presidential elections
are slated for June and December 2012, respectively.
4) Replacement of voice calls and text messages by wVoIP and SNS
The emergence of the social network service (SNS)―i.e., me2day, KakaoTalk,
Twitter, and Facebook―and the proliferation of wVoIP,―i.e., Google Voice, Viber,
and Skype― threaten to supplant mobile carriers’ voice call and text message
services.
The evolution of technologies is raising concerns that the ‘dumb pipe’ (simply
transmitting voice and data) fate could befall mobile operators, impairing their
ability to create value from their telecom networks, as it did in the case of fixed-line
operators. In Korea, only mobile phone users that pay more than W55,000 per
month are allowed access to wVoIP services.
If the wireless network is excluded from the network neutrality policy―a policy that
is opposed by telcos as it opens networks to all users and guarantees the same
speed and quality to all Internet websites― telecom service providers will be able
to charge users for using their networks by the amount of usage, which will
compensate for the eroded revenue to some extent.
Rate-cut pressure
lingers
Concerns over the
possible erosion of
telcos’ revenue by SNS
and wVoIP services
Charging users of
mobile networks by the
amount of usage would
be positive for revenue
Telecom Services
16
V. Profitability to remain at a healthy level
The surge in mobile data traffic due to the growing number of smartphone
subscribers is boosting revenue as well as costs. The key here is how the
increasing traffic will impact the profitability of telcos. Optimists argue the revenue
growth of smartphones will outpace cost growth. On the other hand, pessimists
predict revenue growth will be slower than data traffic growth while capex on
networks and management costs will swell in line with soaring data demand.
We believe telcos will be able to maintain profitability at a moderate level based on
the following: 1) exploding data traffic will sharply boost revenue; 2) alternative
networks will reduce per-bit transmission costs; 3) value-added services (i.e.,
content) will be reinforced; and 4) tariff plans are likely to be restructured in the
direction of abolishing unlimited data plans and introducing usage-based pricing
plans.
Market concerns about data traffic growth
0
5
10
15
20
25
Y Y+1 Y+2 Y+3 Y+4 Y+5 Y+6
Capex growth Sales growth
OP growth
(%)
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
KIS data traffic growth estimates
2
4
6
8
10
12
Y Y+1 Y+2 Y+3 Y+4 Y+5 Y+6
Capex growth Sales growth
OP growth
(%)
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
Optimists and
pessimists clash over
the impact of heavier
traffic on profitability
Profitability to remain at
a healthy level
Telecom Services
17
1) Establishment of next-generation networks such as LTE and usage of WiBro
and ethernet backhaul will curtail the per-bit cost of data transmission. LTE
equipment prices are on the decline, and alternative data paths such as WiFi and
femtocell will be effective in dispersing data traffic.
2) Instead of turning into ‘dumb pipes’, mobile telecom operators will maintain their
role as ‘smart pipes’ by creating added value via competitive content, as they hold
sway over services offered in handsets and control mobile tariffs. The case will be
different from that of fixed-line operators whose networks became ‘dumb pipes’ as
they failed to link their telecommunication services to the terminals.
3) In the incipient phase of the smartphone business, the current flat-rate pricing
system is more beneficial to telcos because the growth rate of data usage is high
but the absolute volume of data usage is low. Mobile carriers will be able to offset
the adverse effects of free riders such as SNS by providing handset subsidies
related to rate plans and offering a certain amount of free voice calls and text
messages through flat-rate plans. Under the current flat-rate pricing system, only
subscribers who exceed their allotted minutes of voice calls are allowed to use
SNS and VoIP services such as Skype and Facebook. Moreover, VoIP is still
inferior to mobile phone calls in terms of call quality and user interface.
4) In the long term, a shift to a usage-based pricing system, under which
subscribers have to pay for the amount of data used, will give a boost to revenue
growth, considering that mobile data usage volume is expected to surge. The
usage-based pricing plan will heighten the correlation between voice call usage
volume and revenue. We expect mobile carriers to adopt the usage-based pricing
system starting with LTE services.
5) Telcos will discontinue or revamp their unlimited data plans. While AT&T of the
US and TeliaSonera of Sweden scrapped their unlimited data plans in June and
July 2010, respectively, Korean counterparts introduced the plan in August 2010 as
a strategy to win the race. The abolishment of such a plan will hinder the small
number of heavy data users from generating excessive traffic and lift the cap on
mobile tariffs, ultimately increasing data revenue.
6) If the Korean government excludes mobile telecom networks from the network
neutrality debate, users will have to pay for the data that they use. This will
diminish the negative effects from free riders offering wVoIP and free texting
services.
7) The Korean government will not be able to force telcos to radically cut rates, as
it needs to encourage the telcos to build telecom networks, invest in R&D, and
offer new services.
8) The smartphone business will contribute to improving profitability as surging
data usage will boost ARPU and decrease the churn rate. This has already been
proven in the US where smartphones were introduced earlier than in Korea.
Note: 1. Average of mobile operators. 2. 1Q11 EBITDA decreased due to greater loss from T-Mobile and subscriber growth. Source: Company data, Korea Investment & Securities
Telecom Services
19
VI. The strong get stronger as competition
surrounds network capacity
Explosive mobile data traffic is reshaping the competitive landscape of the telecom
services industry around network and voice call quality as well as service
(competitive content) quality, as opposed to the previous marketing focus of
handset subsidy. Determinants of the competitiveness of network and service
Media TU media, IPTV Sky life, IPTV TU media, IPTV
Source: Korea Investment & Securities
SK Telecom (017670).......................................................................................................................................................................22
LG Uplus (032640) ..............................................................................................................................................................................28
Company
Telecom Services
22
SK Telecom (017670) BUY (Maintain), TP: W222,000 (Maintain)
Armed with high growth potential and solid profitability
Maintain BUY with a target price of W222,000: We reiterate BUY and our target
price of W222,000. We derived our price by applying a target PER of 7.5x to the
12-month-forward EPS (K-IFRS consolidated basis). The target PER is 20%
discounted to the past two-year average PER of 9.4x. We maintain BUY on the
following. 1) The valuation is attractive. The stock currently trades at a 12-month-
forward PER of 5.6x (K-IFRS consolidated basis), which is a low level. Even based
on the past K-GAAP standard, the PER stands at a mere 7.0x. 2) The proliferation
of smartphones and expansion of corporate (B2B) business have stepped up the
mobile operator's growth potential. We expect top-line growth to reach 6% for the
first time in four years, while the bottom line should also pick up. 3) The improving
bottom line should lead to greater shareholders’ return. We expect the total
dividend yield (dividend + stock buyback) to exceed 7% in 2011.
Top-line growth to reach 6% for the first time in four years: In 2011, SKT
should enjoy recovery in both the top and bottom lines for the first time in four
years. The growing popularity of smartphones and expansion of corporate (B2B)
business should recuperate the carrier’s growth potential. Top-line growth should
reach 6% in 2011, doubling the CAGR of 3.3% during 2008-2010. The number of
smartphone subscribers should expand from 3.91mn in 2010 to 10mn in 2011.
Moreover, B2B sales should surge from W900bn in 2010 to W1.2trn in 2011 as the
business explores new areas such as mobile offices, mobile payments, distribution
(i.e., online shopping mall ‘11st’), education, and ubiquitous healthcare services.
Bottom line to improve from 2011: Profitability deteriorated in 2010 as the carrier
introduced a rate system that charges for calls on a second-by-second basis, but
should pick up in 2011 buttressed by the earnings contribution by smartphones
and lower marketing expenses. The EBITDA margin should rise from 28.6% in
2010 to 30.3% in 2011 and to 31.0% in 2012. SKT’s bottom line will improve on the
growing number of smartphone subscribers, while its subsidiaries such as SK
Broadband should see faster recovery in profitability. In 1Q11, SKT reported net
profit growth of 35.7% YoY on a standalone basis and 56.5% YoY on a
consolidated basis. Meanwhile, the carrier is enjoying explosive growth in its
platform business including T Store (application market) and 11st (online shopping
mall). The platform business is inherently favorable to a dominant mobile carrier.
Larger capex and rate-cut pressure: Risk factors include increased capex and
rate-cut pressure. SKT revised up its capex guidance for 2011 from W2trn to
W2.3trn to reflect surging mobile data demand. While investment in next-
generation networks is inevitable down the road, the Korean government is
pressuring telcos to cut rates. If rates are lowered dramatically, profitability will be
hurt despite rising data demand.
May 18, 2011 / W165,000 / Mkt cap: USD12,256.7mn, KRW13,323.0bn
Yr to Sales OP EBT NP EPS % chg. EBITDA P/E EV/EBITDA PBR ROE
Dec (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (won) (YoY) (W bn) (x) (x) (x) (%)
Strong competitiveness in fixed-line/mobile integrated networks
Maintain BUY with a target price of W54,000: We reiterate BUY and our target price of W54,000. We derived our price by applying a target PER of 9.6x to the 12-month-forward EPS (K-IFRS consolidated basis). The target PER is 13% discounted to the past five-year average PER. We maintain BUY on the following grounds: 1) The valuation is attractive. The stock currently trades at a 12-month-forward PER of 6.0x, EV/EBITDA of 3.3x, and PBR of 0.7x. 2) The growing number of smartphone subscribers is expected to spur top- and bottom-line growth. ARPU should turn to positive growth in 2Q11. Bottom line to stagnate in 1Q11 before recovering in 2Q11: In 1Q11, K-IFRS-based operating revenue (consolidated basis) gained 6.1% YoY as merchandise sales ballooned 45.8% YoY thanks to greater sales of high-end smartphones. Net profit jumped 84.7% YoY due to a decrease in depreciation costs and reflection of gains from the sale of stocks. However, barring the effect from the changes in accounting methods, profitability stagnated in 1Q11 due to reduced revenue from fixed-line services and the introduction of a per-second voice call billing system. K-IFRS-based adjusted EBITDA (standalone basis; and excluding earnings from real estate) dropped 4.4% YoY. We expect profitability to improve from 2Q11 thanks to: 1) higher ARPU from the increase in smartphone subscribers; and 2) lower marketing costs. The smartphone and IPTV businesses should drive the carrier’s top- and bottom-line growth. The number of smartphone subscribers totaled 3.84mn (2.42mn iPhone subscribers) in March 2011, a whopping 40.1% growth from December 2010. We expect the number to further expand to 6.5mn at end-2011 and 10.2mn at end-2012. We also expect the IPTV business to turn to the black in early 2012, as the release of bundled services with its subsidiary, KT Skylife, is spurring new subscriptions. The number of IPTV subscribers surged from 1.17mn in 2009 to 2.09mn in 2010 and should further rise to 3mn by 2011. Earnings contribution of real estate business to gain traction: The real estate business should begin to contribute to KT’s top- and bottom-line growth. Property development, including pre-sale, rental, and sale activities, generates high profitability due to low labor costs and cheap land purchase costs. As for the company’s land holdings, the total book value reaches W1.4trn (buildings total W3.2trn), officially assessed land price amounts to W5.4trn, and the market price is valued at W7trn. Of its land holdings, about 30% is deemed developable. The evolution of technologies should help the company reduce the number of telephone central office buildings from the current 400 to 50 by 2018; thus, KT is aggressive in property development. Fixed-line networks crucial for maintaining fixed-line/mobile integrated networks, but efficiency is waning: Along with WiFi and WiBro, fixed-line networks serve as the foundation for maintaining fixed-line/mobile integrated networks. However, their efficiency is waning, as the declining number of fixed-line telephone subscribers are dragging down telephony revenue. The pressure to lower rates is also a risk factor.
May 18, 2011 / W38,200 / Mkt cap: USD9,175.7mn, KRW9,974.0bn
Yr to Sales OP EBT NP EPS % chg. EBITDA P/E EV/EBITDA PBR ROE
Dec (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (W bn) (won) (YoY) (W bn) (x) (x) (x) (%)
M ay-09 Sep-09 Jan-10 M ay-10 Sep-10 Jan-11 M ay-11
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
M ay-09 Sep-09 Jan-10 M ay-10 Sep-10 Jan-11
LG Uplus(032640)
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
14,000
M ay-09 Sep-09 Jan-10 M ay-10 Sep-10 Jan-11
■ Guide to Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. stock ratings based on absolute 12-month forward share price performance
� BUY: Expected to give a return of +15% or more
� Hold: Expected to give a return between -15% and +15%
� Underweight: Expected to give a return of -15% or less
■ Guide to Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. sector ratings for the next 12 months
� Overweight: Recommend increasing the sector’s weighting in the portfolio compared to its respective weighting in the Kospi (Kosdaq) based on market
capitalization.
� Neutral: Recommend maintaining the sector’s weighting in the portfolio in line with its respective weighting in the Kospi (Kosdaq) based on market capitalization.
� Underweight: Recommend reducing the sector’s weighting in the portfolio compared to its respective weighting in the Kospi (Kosdaq) based on market
capitalization.
■ Analyst Certification
I/We, as the research analyst/analysts who prepared this report, do hereby certify that the views expressed in this research report accurately reflect my/our personal
views about the subject securities and issuers discussed in this report. I/We do hereby also certify that no part of my/our compensation was, is, or will be directly or
indirectly related to the specific recommendations or views contained in this research report.
■ Important Disclosures
As of the end of the month immediately preceding the date of publication of the research report or the public appearance (or the end of the second most recent
month if the publication date is less than 10 calendar days after the end of the most recent month), Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates does
not own 1% or more of any class of common equity securities of the companies mentioned in this report.
There is no actual, material conflict of interest of the research analyst or Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates known at the time of publication
of the research report or at the time of the public appearance.
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates has not managed or co-managed a public offering of securities for the companies mentioned in this report
in the past 12 months;
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates has not received compensation for investment banking services from the companies mentioned in this
report in the past 12 months; Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates does not expect to receive or intends to seek compensation for investment
banking services from the companies mentioned in this report in the next 3 months.
Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd., or its affiliates was not making a market in securities of the companies mentioned in this report at the time that the research
report was published.
Prepared by: Jong In Yang
This report was written by Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. to help its clients invest in securities. This material is copyrighted and may not be copied,
redistributed, forwarded or altered in any way without the consent of Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. This report has been prepared by Korea Investment &
Securities Co., Ltd. and is provided for information purposes only. Under no circumstances is it to be used or considered as an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer to
buy. We make no representation as to its accuracy or completeness and it should not be relied upon as such. The company accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct
or consequential loss arising from any use of this report or its contents. The final investment decision is based on the client’s judgment, and this report cannot be used
as evidence in any legal dispute related to investment decisions.
HEAD OFFICE
WON-JAE RHEE, Executive Managing Director ([email protected] +822 3276 5660)
This report has been prepared by Korea Investment & Securities Co., Ltd. and is provided for information purposes only. Under no circumstances is it to be used or
considered as an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer to buy. While all reasonable care has been taken to ensure that the information contained herein is not untrue
or misleading at the time of publication, we make no representation as to its accuracy or completeness and it should not be relied upon as such. This report is provided
solely for the information of professional investors who are expected to make their own investment decisions without undue reliance on this report and the company
accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from any use of this report or its contents. This report is not intended for the use of private
investors.
2011. All rights reserved. No part of this report may be reproduced or distributed in any manner without permission of Korea Investment & Securities Co.,Ltd.