Recommendations to Improve Pedestrian & Bicycle Safety in the Azusa Unified School District October 2017
RecommendationstoImprovePedestrian&BicycleSafetyintheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict
October2017
1
RecommendationstoImprovePedestrian&BicycleSafetyintheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrictByMihaelaTomuta,TonyDang,CaliforniaWalks;JillCooper,AnaLopez,AmandaReynosa,UCBerkeleySafeTransportationResearch&EducationCenter(SafeTREC)
IntroductionAttheinvitationofHealthyAzusa,theUniversityofCaliforniaatBerkeley’sSafeTransportationResearchandEducationCenter(SafeTREC)andCaliforniaWalks(CalWalks)facilitatedacommunity-drivenpedestrianandbicyclesafetyaction-planningworkshopfortheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistricttoimprovepedestriansafety,bicyclesafety,walkability,andbikeabilityacrosstheschooldistrictanditsvariousjurisdictionsincludingthecitiesofCovinaandAzusaandunincorporatedLosAngelesCounty.Priortotheworkshop,CalWalksstaffconductedanin-personsitevisitonWednesday,July19,2017,toadapttheCommunityPedestrianandBicycleSafetyTrainingprogramcurriculumtomeetthelocalcommunities’needsandtoprovidecontext-sensitiveexamplestrategiesforthecommunity’sexistingconditions.CalWalksfacilitatedtheworkshoponWednesday,August30,2017from7:30amto1:00pm,whichconsistedof:1)studentdrop-offobservations2)anoverviewofmultidisciplinaryapproachestoimprovepedestrianandbicyclesafety;3)threewalkabilityandbikeabilityassessmentsalongthreekeyroutes;and4)smallgroupaction-planningdiscussionstofacilitatethedevelopmentofcommunity-prioritizedrecommendationstoinformtheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrictaboutactivetransportationandSafeRoutestoSchoolsefforts.Thisreportsummarizestheworkshopproceedings,aswellasideasidentifiedduringtheprocessandrecommendationsforpedestrianandbicyclesafetyprojects,policies,andprograms.
BackgroundCommunityPedestrianandBicycleSafetyTrainingProgramTheCommunityPedestrianandBicycleSafetyTraining(CPBST)programisajointprojectofUCBerkeleySafeTRECandCalWalks.FundingforthisprogramisprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafety(OTS)throughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration(NHTSA).ThepurposeoftheCPBSTprogramistotrainlocalneighborhoodresidentsandsafetyadvocatesonhowtoimprovepedestrianandbicyclesafetyandtostrengthentheircollaborationwithlocalofficialsandagencystafftomakecommunitiessaferandmorepleasanttowalkandbike.Foreachtraining,theprogramconvenesamulti-sector,multi-disciplinarylocalplanningcommitteetotailorandrefinethetraining’scurriculumandfocustomeetthecommunity’sneeds.Additionally,CalWalksstaffconductpre-trainingsitevisitstocollecton-the-groundobservationsofexistingwalkingandbikingconditionstoinformthetraining’sscopeandfocus.
2
Thehalf-daytrainingisdesignedtoprovideparticipantswithbothpedestrianandbicyclesafetybestpracticesandarangeofprovenstrategies(the6E’s:Empowerment&Equity,Evaluation,Engineering,Enforcement,Education,andEncouragement)toaddressandimprovepedestrianandbicyclesafetyconditionsandconcerns.Participantsarethenguidedonawalkabilityandbikeabilityassessmentofnearbystreetsbeforesettingpedestrianandbicyclesafetyprioritiesandactionablenextstepsfortheircommunity.ForasummaryofoutcomesfrompastCPBSTworkshops,pleasevisit:www.californiawalks.org/projects/cpbstandhttps://safetrec.berkeley.edu/programs/cpbst
SelectedPedestrian&BicycleSafetyConditionsintheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrictHighSpeeds&WideStreetsThepostedspeedlimitsalongArrowHighway,AzusaAvenue,andLarkEllenAvenueneartheworkshoplocationare45,40,and40milesperhour(MPH)respectively;however,CalWalksstaffobserveddriverstravelingatmuchhigherspeedsduringthesitevisitandworkshop.Driversalsoappeartoexceedthe25mphspeedlimitonresidentialstreetsintheschoolzonesforGladstoneHighSchool,EllingtonElementary,andValleydaleElementarySchools.ArrowHighway,AzusaAvenue,LarkEllenAvenuemeasurefrom58feettoover80feetincurb-to-curbwidthwithtwotravellanesineachdirection,astrippedcenterleftturnlaneordedicatedleftturnlane,parallelparkinginvariouslocationsalongonesideofthestreet,sidewalks,andamixofunmarkedandmarkedcrossings.Intermittently,frontageroadsarefoundalongbothsidesofArrowHighwayandalongthewestsideofLarkEllenAvenueneartheGladstoneHighSchool.Researchhasdemonstratedthatwidestreetsandwidetravellanesareassociatedwithhighervehiclespeeds1,whichaffectthesafetyofpeoplewalkingandbicycling.
WidevehiclelanesonLarkEllenAvenue.
1SeeKayFitzpatrick,PaulCarlson,MarcusBrewer,andMarkWooldridge,“DesignFactorsThatAffectDriverSpeedonSuburbanArterials":TransportationResearchRecord1751(2000):18–25.
3
LackofBicycleFacilitiesNobicyclelanesexistintheGladstoneHighSchoolarea,butCalWalksstaffobservedbicyclistsridingalongArrowHighwayandLarkEllenAvenueinthetravellane,onthesidewalk,andonfrontageroads.NotonlydidtheareasurroundingGladstoneHighSchoollackbicycleinfrastructurebuttheareaalsolackssafeandcomfortableconnectionstoexistingoff-streetbicycletrailsinneighboringcommunities.Duringtheworkshop,CountyrepresentativesconfirmedplanstoaddbicyclefacilitiesinthenearfuturealongtheBigDaltonWashthatrunsthroughCovinaandconnectstonearbybicycleroutesandoff-streettrails.
AbicyclistrideseastalongArrowHighwaytowardsAzusaAvenue.
InadequateEnhancementsforMarkedPedestrianCrossingsandUnmarkedCrossingsDuringthesitevisit,CalWalkstaffobservedmarkedandunmarkedcrosswalksnearGladstoneHighSchool,ValleydaleElementary,andEllingtonElementary.High-visibilitymarkedcrosswalksexistobservedonLarkEllenAvenueandTudorStreet;onAspanAvenuenearEllingtonElementarySchool;andonEnidAvenuenearValleydaleElementarySchool.AllcrossingsalongEnidAvenuenearGladstoneHighSchoolareunmarked(AlcrossStreet,BygroveStreet,GragmontStreet,DevanahStreet,NubiaStreet,andGroverdaleStreet).
4
AnunmarkedcrossingalongEnidAvenueinfrontofGladstoneHighSchool.
AstandardmarkedcrosswalkatEnidAvenueandArrowHighwayisdifficulttoseebypedestriansandvehicles.
PedestrianandDriverBehaviorsatMarkedandUnmarkedCrossingsCalWalkstaffobserveddriversblockingthelengthofEnidAvenueinfrontofGladstoneHighSchoolduringmorningschoolarrivalhours,whilestudentscrossedthestreetoutsideoftheunmarkedcrossing,inthemiddleoftheintersection,orbetweencars.ThelackofanymarkedcrosswalksandpedestriancrossingsignagealongEnidAvenueencouragesunsafedriverandpedestrianbehaviors.AllcrossingsatArrowHighwayandEnidAvenuearestandardmarkedcrosswalksandtheintersectionhasatraditionaldesign.Duringschooldismissal,largegroupsofstudentsgatheronthesidewalkattheintersectionandwaittocross.Oncethepedestriancrossingsignalphasebegins,studentscontinuecrossingbeyondtheallottedpedestriansignaltiming,indicatingthatthecrossingphasetimingmaynotbesufficient.Additionally,drivers,turnrightorleftontoArrowHighwaythroughbreaksingroupsofstudentscrossingthestreet,therebynotrespectingthepedestriansignalortheright-of-wayofthestudentscrossing.
GladstoneHighSchoolstudentscrossinbetweenvehiclesonEnidAvenue,
anunmarkedcrossingisjustoutsideoftheframeofthephoto.
5
MissingSidewalks&SidewalksinDisrepairDuetothelocationofGladstoneHighSchool,atthejunctionofthreejurisdictions—Covina,Azusa,andunincorporatedLosAngelesCounty—sidewalksvaryinwidthandconditionwhentheyexist.TheeastsideofEnidAvenuefromArrowHighwaytoNubiaStreethassidewalksbufferedbyalandscaping/plantingstrip,buttheyaretoonarrowfortwoadultstowalkcomfortablyside-by-side.ThewestsideofEnidAvenue,inunincorporatedLosAngelesCounty,doesnothavesidewalksatall,andovergrownvegetation,shrubs,andfencingextendoutintothestreet,oftenforcingstudentstowalkdirectlyintheroadway.ShadeisonlyavailablefromNubiaStreettoGragmontStreetontheeastsideofEnidAvenue,wherethelandscapebuffercontainsshadetrees;therestoftheeastsideofEnidAvenueisunshadedalthoughthereisalandscapebuffer.AtGragmontStreetandEnidAvenuethesidewalkisupheavedfromexpandingtreeroots.
AnunmarkedcrossingwithadrainagechannelinthecrossingzoneonEnidAvenueandBygroveStreet.
AnupliftedsidewalksegmentonEnidAvenue
infrontofGladstoneHighSchool.
6
LackofPedestrian-ScaleLightingCalWalksstaffobservedalackofpedestrian-scalelighting,especiallynearthecommercialcenteratAzusaAvenueandArrowHighwayandnearValleydaleElementary,EllingtonElementary,andGladstoneHighSchool.Pedestrian-scalelightingisalsomissingneartransitstopsandsheltersalongArrowHighway.
Lackofpedestrian-scalelightingatbusshelters
andtransitstopsalongArrowHighway.
Pedestrian&BicycleCollisionHistoryBetween2011-2015,2therewere87pedestriancollisionsintheCityofAzusa,includingfour(4)fatalitiesandten(10)severeinjuries,withcollisionsconcentratedonFoothillBoulevardandAzusaAvenue.56.2%ofthesepedestriancollisionscanbeattributedtoadriverviolation,while16.1%ofpedestriancollisionscanbeattributedtoapedestrianviolation.Overthe10-yearperiodbetween2006-2015,pedestriancollisionsappeartobeonanupwardtrajectory,exceptduringthemostrecentrecordedyear,wherecollisionsdecreased.Between2011-2015,therewere136bicyclecollisionsintheCityofAzusa,includingone(1)fatalityandten(10)severeinjuries,withcollisionsconcentratedonFoothillBoulevard,AzusaAvenue,andSanGabrielAvenue.Forbicyclecollisions,16%areattributedtoaright-of-wayviolationeitherbyabicyclistordriverand15.3%areattributedtoimproperturningeitherbyabicyclistordriver,and15.3%areattributedtobicyclistsridingonthewrongsideoftheroad.Overthe10-yearperiodbetween2006-2015,bicyclecollisionsappeartobeonadownwardtrajectory.UCBerkeleySafeTRECalsoconductedadditionalcollisionanalysisofschoolsofinterestintheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict.Between2011-2015,therewereten(10)pedestrianandbicyclecollisionsaroundGladstoneHighSchool,includingtwo(2)pedestrianfatalities.Between2011-2015,therewereten(10)pedestrianandbicyclecollisionsnearEllingtonElementarySchool,includingone(1)pedestrianfatality.Between2011-2015,therewere19pedestrianandbicyclecollisionsaroundCenterMiddleSchool,includingone(1)fatalityandtwo(2)severinjuries.Between2011-2015,therewere17 2Pleasenote2014and2015dataisprovisional.
7
pedestrianandbicyclecollisionsnearValleydaleElementarySchool,includingone(1)fatalityandthree(3)severeinjuries.Ofthesecollisions,nineteen(19)involvedschool-agedchildren.AfulldiscussionofthepedestrianandbicyclistcollisiondatapreparedbyUCBerkeleySafeTRECcanbefoundAppendixA.
August30,2017WorkshopHealthyAzusarequestedaworkshopto1)provideCity/Countystaff,communityorganizations,andresidentswithatoolkitforpromotingpedestrianandbicyclesafetytoinformfutureactivetransportationprojectsandsaferoutestoschoolintheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict;2)strengthenworkingrelationshipsbetweentheschooldistrictstaffandboardmembers,BikeSanGabrielValley,theYMCA,locallawenforcementagenciesandotherstakeholderstoensurethebestoutcomesfortheresidentsofAzusa,CovinaandunincorporatedLosAngelesCounty;and3)developconsensusregardingpedestrianandbicyclesafetypriorityandactionablenextsteps.
AzusaMayorJosephRochawelcomingworkshopparticipants.
Theworkshopwashostedfrom7:30amto1:00pm,withlunchandsimultaneousEnglishtoSpanishinterpretationprovidedbytheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistricttomaximizecommunityparticipation.Forty-three(43)individualsattendedtheworkshop,includingAzusaMayorJoeRocha,CovinaMayorJorgeMarquez,representativesfromtheCityofAzusa,LosAngelesCountyBoardSupervisorHildaSolis’office,AzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict,LosAngelesCountySheriff’sDepartment,HealthyAzusa,theValleydaleandEllingtonElementarySchoolPrincipals,GladstoneHighSchoolstaff,BikeSanGabrielValley,andnumerousresidentsandparents.TheworkshopalsoincludedanoptionalobservationofschoolarrivalconditionsatGladstoneHighSchool.
8
ReflectionsfromWalkability&BikeabilityAssessmentWorkshopparticipantsconductedwalkabilityandbikeabilityassessmentsalong3routes:
● Route1travelednorthfromGladstoneHighSchooltowardsArrowHighway,westtowardsLarkEllenAvenue,northtowardsWoodcroftStreet,easttowardsEnidAvenue,northtowardsNewburghStreet,andsouthtowardsGladstoneHighSchool.Route1focusedonArrowHighwayandtheareaaroundValleydaleElementarySchool.
● Route2travelednorthfromGladstoneHighSchooltowardsArrowHighway,eastononesideofArrowHighwaytowardsAzusaAvenue,westontheothersideofArrowHighway,andsouthonEnidAvenuetowardsGladstoneHighSchool.Route2focusedonArrowHighwaybetweenEnidAvenueandAzusaAvenue,acommondestinationforstudentsontheirwayhomefromschool.
● Route3traveledsouthfromGladstoneHighSchooltowardsTudorStreet,westalongTudorStreetacrossLarkEllenAvenuetoAspanAvenue,northalongAspanAvenuetoGroverdale,eastonGroverdaletoLarkEllenAvenue,southonLarkEllenAvenuetoTudorAvenue,eastalongTudorAvenuetoEnidAvenue,andnorthonEnidAvenuetoGladstoneHighSchool.Route3focusedonTudorStreet,crossingsonLarkEllenAvenue,andtheareaaroundEllingtonElementary.
Participantswereaskedto1)observeinfrastructureconditionsandthebehaviorofallroadusers;2)applystrategieslearnedfromthe6E’spresentationthatcouldhelpovercomeinfrastructureconcernsandunsafedriver,pedestrian,andbicyclistbehavior;and3)identifypositivecommunityassetsandstrategieswhichcanbebuiltupon.Followingthewalkabilityandbikeabilityassessment,theparticipantssharedthefollowingreflections:
• LackofSidewalksandPoorSidewalkConditions:SidewalksarecontinuousalonglargerthoroughfareslikeArrowHighway,AzusaAvenue,andLarkEllenAvenueintheworkshoparea,butsmallresidentialstreetslikeEnidAvenue,WoodcroftStreet,andTudorStreetaremissingsidewalksleadinguptotheschools.ResidentsnotedthattherearenosidewalksonthewestsideofEnidAvenueacrossfromGladstoneHighSchool,andthesidewalksontheeastsideofEnidAvenuearetoonarrowfortwoadultstowalkside-by-sideorpasscomfortably.Theyalsonotedthatduringschooldismissal,studentswalkinlargegroupsandspilloverintothestreetalongtheeastsideofEnidAvenue.ThelackofcontinuoussidewalksisamajordeterrentforValleydaleandEllingtonElementaryparentstoallowtheirstudentstowalkorbiketoschool.
Overgrownvegetationblocksthewalkingpath
alongtheCountyportionofEnidAvenue.
9
Althoughthereareshadetreesandsidewalklandscapebuffersalongthemainthoroughfares,thecommunitynotedtherearelargesegmentsofsidewalksthatofferednoshadeduetosmalltreeswithlittlefoliageandlandscapeareaswithmissingtrees.Insomeareas,overgrownvegetationfromnearbyhomesnarrowedthewalkingpathandleftdebris.ParticipantsnotedsidewalksalongArrowAvenueonRoute2aresufficientlywide,bufferedfromvehicletraffic,shaded,andclean.
AnemptylandscapebufferonEnidAvenueadjacenttoGladstoneHighSchoolcreatesasunnywalkingpath.
TreewellsinfrontofEllington
ElementarySchoolhavebeenpavedover.
● SchoolZoneSignage:ParticipantsonRoute1and2notedtherearenoSchoolZonesignsalongArrowHighwayontheCovinasideanditisdifficultforfastmovingvehicletraffictoidentifytheGladstoneHighSchoolmarquee.GladstonePrincipalChrisSilvassharedduringtheworkshopthatheexpectsanew,morevisiblemarqueetobeinstalledbytheDistrictwithinayear–whichshouldhelpmaketheschoolmorevisibletopassingvehicles.
● LackofBicycleFacilities:Participantsnotedalackofbicycleinfrastructuresuchasbicyclelanesandbicycleroutesignagethroughouttheworkshoparea.Despitethis,severalbicyclistswereobservedduringtheassessmentridingonArrowHighway.Participantsexpressedconcernaboutridingintheroadwayduetothehighspeedofvehicletraffic.
● LackofMarked&EnhancedMarkedCrossings:ThestandardmarkedcrossingsalongArrowHighwayandAzusaAvenuearefaded,withstandardmarkingsandrequirepedestrianstocross5lanesofvehicletrafficwithfewpedestriancrossingenhancements.ParticipantsnotedalackofcurrentADAcurbrampsalongArrowHighway.ParticipantswhowalkedRoute1towardValleydaleElementaryexpressedconcernoverthelackofmarkedcrossingsatEnidAvenueandWoodcroftStreet.
● BusShelteratEnidAvenueandArrowHighway:ThebusshelteronthenortheastcornerofArrowHighwayatEnidAvenueislocatedtooclosetothecornernearestGladstoneHigh
10
School.Participantsnotedthereisoftennotenoughspacetowait.Further,thebenchnexttothebusshelterdoesnotprovidesufficientshadeandisnotwell-litatnight.
● PedestrianandVehicleConflictsatEnidAvenueandArrowHighway:TheintersectionofEnidAvenueandArrowHighwayexperiencespedestrian-vehicleconflicts,especiallyduringGladstoneHighSchoolarrivalanddismissaltimes.ParticipantsexpressedconcernforstudentsusingthewesterncrosswalkonArrowHighwayduetovehiclesturningleftontoArrowHighway.Asstudentscrossinlargegroups,vehiclesattempttoturnleftinbetweengroupsofstudents.Similarly,asstudentscrossintheeasterncrosswalkonArrowHighway,right-turningvehiclesattempttoturninbetweengroupsofstudents.
CommunityResidentRecommendations Followingthewalkabilityandbikeabilityassessment,CalWalksfacilitatedsmall-groupactionplanningdiscussions.Workshopparticipantsdiscussedtwosetsofquestions:thefirstfocusedonidentifyingandprioritizingnon-infrastructurecommunity-ledprogramsthatcanbesustainedwithlittleornofunding.ThesecondfocusedonprioritizinginfrastructureimprovementsinAzusaandidentifyingpriorityprojectsforAzusaandLosAngelesCounty.
Participantsengagedinsmallgroupactionplanningdiscussions.
Workshopparticipantsprovidedthefollowingrecommendationsforoverallpedestrianandbicyclistsafetyimprovements:Non-InfrastructurePriorities&Recommendations
● ExpandandSupportExistingSafeRoutestoSchoolEfforts:ParticipantswouldliketosupportSafeRoutestoSchool(SRTS)effortsbyhighlightingcommunitymemberswhoarealreadyengagedinSRTSworkandbuildingcapacityforfutureprojects.TheywouldliketoapplyforanSRTSeducationandencouragementgrantthroughtheActiveTransportationProgram(ATP)toexpandandbuildprogramsacrosstheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict.
11
HealthyAzusa,Districtstaff,andparentshavealreadyconductedSafeRoutestoSchoolassessmentsforelementaryschoolsintheDistrict,andtheywouldliketoexpandtheexistingWalktoSchoolDaywalkingschoolbusprogramtoabi-annualprogrampotentiallyduringBiketoSchoolDayinMaytocomplementthecurrentannualeventduringWalktoSchoolDayinOctober.LosAngelesCountyPublicWorksrepresentativessharedSafeRoutestoSchoolmapsfornearbyelementaryschoolswithpreferredwalkingroutesduringtheworkshop,andworkshopparticipantshopedtousethesemapstosupportcurrentwalkingschoolbusefforts.TheprogramcanalsobesupportbyallowingstudentvolunteerhourstobeusedduringSRTSevents.ParticipantsalsodiscussedtheneedtodevelopSRTSprogramsthatarerelevantandengagingtoolderjuniorhighandhighschoolstudents.AfundedSRTSprogramwouldsupporttheformationofanSRTSTaskForceandschoolchampionsthatcandevelopsustainableSRTSprogramswithlittleornofunding.ParticipantswouldliketoaddactivetransportationeducationmessagingthroughoutthecommunitybytakingadvantageoftheSouthernCaliforniaAssociationofGovernment’s(SCAG)GoHumancampaign,whichprovideslawnsignswithsafetyeducationmessagestoschooldistrictsandcities.Theywouldalsoliketoprioritizeaddingpedestriansafetymessagesonsidewalkswherestudentsarelikelytowalk.AdditionalSRTSeducationeffortswillfocusonteachingsafewalkingandbikingskillsatayoungageandprovidinghelmetsafetyprogramstothecommunity.
InfrastructurePriorities&Recommendations
Awell-wornwalkingpathontheeastsideofEnidAvenueleadingtoValleydaleElementary.
• SidewalkInstallation:Participantshighlightedtheneedtoinstallsidewalksintheworkshoparea,especiallynearschoolsandplaceswherestudentsarelikelytowalk.PrioritylocationsidentifiedbyparticipantsincludethewestsideofEnidAvenuefromArrowHighwaytoTudorStreetandtheeastsideofEnidAvenuefromArrowHighwayleadingtoValleydaleElementarySchool.Residentsalsoexpressedtheneedtoaddressovergrownvegetationalongexistingsidewalksandwalkingpaths.LosAngelesCountyPublicWorksstaffrecommendedresidentsusetheCounty’sSeeClickFixonlineandmobilereportingsystem.
12
● SchoolZoneSignage:ParticipantscalledfortheinstallationofaschoolzonesignontheCityofCovinasegmentofArrowHighwaytosignaltodriverstoexpectstudentsinthearea.
• CrossingEnhancements:Throughouttheworkshopareaandparticularlyatintersectionsnearschools,participantsnotedcrossingchallengesduetofadedstandardtransversecrosswalks,lackofbulb-outs/curbextensions,lackofADAcompliantramps,andothertrafficcalmingmeasures.Participantsrecommendtheinstallationofhigh-visibilitycrosswalksnearschoolsandacrossArrowHighway,bulb-outsatEnidAvenueandArrowHighway.ParentsofValleydaleElementarySchoolstudentswerealsointerestedintheinstallationofaRectangularRapidFlashBeacon(RRFB)attheintersectionofEnidAvenueandWoodcroftStreet.Lastly,manyworkshopparticipantsidentifiedtheinstallationofadedicatedleft-turnsignalfordriversonArrowHighwayandEnidAvenueastheirtopprioritytoimprovesafety.LosAngelesCountyPublicWorksstaffsharedwithparticipantsthattheCountyisalreadyplanningonmakingtherequestedimprovementandprovidedaprojecttimelinewithanexpectedcompletionofnolaterthanDecember2018.
Ahigh-visibilitycrosswalkatAspanAvenueandTudorStreetacrossfromEllingtonElementary.
● AdditionalStreet&Pedestrian-ScaleLighting:Participantsrecommendedimprovingexistinglightingconditionsbyinstallingadditionalstreetlightingandpedestrian-scalelighting,especiallynearschools.Currently,therearelongstretchesofbothlargearterialsandresidentialstreetswithlimitedlighting.Parentssharedthatafter-schoolprogramsextendintotheeveningandthattheywanttheirchildrentofeelsaferwithlightingwhensuchprogramsreleasedstudents.ParentsofValleydaleElementarySchoolalsorecommendedaddingpedestrian-scalelightingtotheintersectionofWoodcroftStreetandEnidAvenuetoimprovesafetyforstudentsandparentswalkingtoschool.
CaliforniaWalks/SafeTRECRecommendationsCaliforniaWalksandSafeTRECalsosubmitthefollowingrecommendationsforconsiderationbytheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict,CityofCovina,CityofAzusa,andLosAngelesCounty:
● CityofAzusa,CityofCovina,andLosAngelesCounty○ TrafficCalmingMeasuresalongArrowHighway&LarkEllenAvenue:Participants
consistentlyidentifiedArrowHighwayandLarkEllenAvenueastwochallengingstreetsforresidentstocrossandusewhileonfootoronbike.WerecommendtheCountyandCitiesofAzusaandCovinacollaboratetoengageresidentstoidentifylong-termtrafficcalmingmeasures,suchasimplementingaroaddiet,installingbulb-outs,enhancedcrossings,transit-prioritylanes,andphysically-separatedbicycleinfrastructure,forconsiderationonArrowHighwayandLarkEllenAvenue.Becauseofconcernsaroundspeed,itwouldbehelpfulforthecountytogatherspeeddataalongArrowHighway,AzusaAvenue,andLarkEllenAvenue.Thesetypesofimprovementscandecreasevehiclespeedsandimprovesafetyforpedestrians,bicyclists,anddrivers.We
13
recommendthattheCountyengagethecommunityintheFall2017/Winter2018inordertoprepareanapplicationtothestate’sActiveTransportationPrograminSpring2018.
○ ApplyforInfrastructureFundsforGladstoneHighSchool:SidewalksareneededonthewestsideofEnidAvenueinunincorporatedLosAngelesCountyandmarkedcrossingsareneededalongEnidAvenueacrossfromGladstoneHighSchoolintheCountyandCityofCovina.CalWalksandSafeTRECrecommendcontinuedcollaborationbetweentheSchoolDistrict,CityofCovina,andLACountytoapplyforinfrastructurefundingforpedestriansafetyimprovementsalongEnidAvenue.Additionally,werecommendthatthestreetowner(s)installaraisedcrossingwithhigh-visibilitycrosswalkmarkingsonthesouthernlegoftheEnidAvenueandDevanahStreetintersection.
ExampleofraisedcrosswalkleadingtoaschoolinEureka,CA.
PhotoCredit:HumboldtPartnershipforActiveLiving
○ CrossingEnhancementsatEnidAvenueandArrowHighway:SignaltimingduringschoolarrivalanddismissalhoursshouldbeobservedandretimedacrossArrowHighwayatEnidAvenuetoallowawalkingpaceofnomorethan2.8”persecondneartheschoolstohelpstudentsandparentscrosssafely.WerecommendthatCity/Countystaffcollaboratetodoadistrict-wideanalysisofpedestriansignaltimingatintersectionsnearschools.WealsorecommendtheCity/Countyconsiderenablingaleadingpedestrianinterval(LPI)whentheleft-turnsignalisinstalledbytheCountyinDecember2018.Othercrossingsafetyenhancementssuchasbulboutsshouldbeconsideredtoshortenthecrossingdistanceandtimeforpedestrians.PedestrianrefugeislandsonArrowHighwaywouldalsoallowpedestrianstostopatthehalfwaypointandfinishcrossingthestreetonthenextpedestrianwalksignal.Pedestrianrefugeislandsprovideasafeplacetostopforseniors,students,parentswithsmallchildren,andotherswithlimitedmobility.
14
● AzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict○ ImproveGladstoneHighSchoolPick-UpandDrop-OffZone:CalWalksandPlanning
Committeemembersconductedobservationsofstudentarrivalhourspriortotheworkshop.Intheschooldrop-offzone,driversfailedtomoveforwardintheschoolarrivalanddepartureparkinglotbutconcentratedintheareaneartheMainOfficegate,creatingavehiclebackupontoEnidAvenue.Driversinthedrop-offzonealsodouble-parked,resultinginstudentshavingtowalkbetweenvehiclestogettothesidewalk.CalWalksandSafeTRECrecommendrestripingthedrop-offzonetocreatetwodedicateddrop-offlanesandinstallingsignageinstructingdriverstopullforwardandwatchforpassingstudents.Additionally,werecommendthattheSchoolDistrictcollaboratewithHealthyAzusatolaunchastudentsafetypatrolprogramthatcanhelpassistwithmanagingthedrop-offzonearea.
○ EstablishaDistrictSafeRoutestoSchoolTaskForce:TheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrict,althoughbasedinAzusa,servesstudentsintheCityofAzusa,CityofCovina,CityofGlendora,andunincorporatedLACounty.CalWalksandSafeTRECrecommendtheDistrictestablishaSRTSTaskForcetoengagealljurisdictionsandinmorefrequentcommunicationwithoneanotherandwithresidents,parents,andotherSRTSchampions.
○ DevelopCommunityBicyclePlan:Althoughtherearesomebicyclefacilitiesineachofthejurisdictions,moreandimprovedbicyclingfacilitiesandwayfindingareneededtoensuresafetyforstudentsandcommunitymembersalongArrowHighway,LarkEllenAvenue,andAzusaAvenue.Wayfindingisneededtodirectcycliststoexistingandpreferredbikeroutes.CalWalksandSafeTRECrecommendtheDistrictandCityofAzusacollaborateandpursuefundingforthedevelopmentofabicycleplantoidentifybicycleinfrastructureneedsanddevelopabikewayplanningguide.
AcknowledgmentsWewouldliketothankHealthyAzusaandMaria-InezPerezforinvitingusintotheircommunityandtheAzusaUnifiedSchoolDistrictandGladstoneHighSchoolforhostingtheCommunityPedestrianandBicycleSafetyTraining.Wewouldliketoacknowledgethemanycommunitymembersandagenciespresentattheworkshopandtheirdedicationtopedestrianandbicyclesafety.Theircollectiveparticipationmeaningfullyinformedandstrengthenedtheworkshop’soutcomes.FundingforthisprogramwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
AppendixA
PedestrianandBicycleCollisionDataAnalysis
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Azusa,CA–8/30/17PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisionalatthistime.FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
PEDESTRIANSNumberofCollisionsInvolvingPedestrians,2006-15
Thebluelineshowsthenumberofpedestriancollisionswhereafatalityand/orinjuryoccurred.Therewere189peopleinjuredorkilledin174pedestriancollisionsoverthelast10years.Thegreenlineshowsthethree-yearmovingaverageofthenumberofpedestriancollisionswhereafatalityand/orinjuryoccurred.Themovingaverageisusefulfortrackingtrendchangeovertime,especiallywhenthenumberofcollisionsissubjecttovariability.Datapointsarethemidpointofthethreeyearsofdataspecified.
Thefollowinganalysesarebasedonthemostcurrentfiveyears,2011to2015,ofdataforAzusa,CA.Therewere94peoplekilledorinjuredin87pedestriancollisions.TopViolationTypesforCollisionsInvolvingPedestrians
TypeofViolation CollisionsN(%)
Drivermustyieldpedestrianrightofwayinacrosswalk 34(39.1%)Pedestrianyield,uponroadwayoutsidecrosswalk 14(16.1%)Sidewalk,failuretoyieldtopedestrianon. 7(8.0Unsafespeedforprevailingconditions(useforallprimafacielimits) 5(5.7%)Unsafeturnwith/withoutsignaling. 3(3.4%)Otherviolation* 24(27.6%)Total 87(100.0%)
*Note:Eachviolationtypeaccountedfortwoorfewercollisions.PedestrianActionsinCollisionsInvolvingPedestrians
PedestrianAction CollisionsN(%)
CrossinginCrosswalkatIntersection 41(47.1%)CrossingNotinCrosswalk 24(27.6%)NotinRoad 9(10.3%)InRoad,IncludingShoulder 7(8.0%)NotStated 4(4.6%)CrossinginCrosswalkNotatIntersection 2(2.3%)Total 87(100.0%)
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Azusa,CA–8/30/17PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisionalatthistime.FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
PedestrianVictimDemographics Theageofpedestrianvictimsrangedconsiderablyacrossallagegroups,withyouthage19oryoungeraccountingfor40.4percentofallvictims.Themajorityofvictimsweremale.
VictimInjurySeverity,2011-15Mostcollisionsresultedinminorinjuries.
19 (20.2%)
19 (20.2%)
9 (9.6%)
14 (14.9%)
19 (20.2%)
14 (14.9%)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
14oryounger 15to19 20to24 25to44 45to64 65orolder
Numbe
rofV
ictim
s(n)
VictimAge
Fatal 4 (4.3%) SevereInjury
10(10.6%)
OtherVisibleInjury40(42.6%)
ComplaintofPain
40(42.6%)
Male 45 (47.9%)
Female 39
(41.5%)
NotStated10 (10.6%)
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Azusa,CA–8/30/17PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisionalatthistime.FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
BICYCLISTSNumberofCollisionsInvolvingBicyclists,2006-2015
Thebluelineshowsthenumberofbicyclecollisionswhereafatalityand/orinjuryoccurred.Therewere260peoplekilledorinjuredin251bicyclecollisionsoverthelast10years.Thegreenlineshowsthethree-yearmovingaverageofthenumberofbicyclecollisionswhereafatalityand/orinjuryoccurred.Themovingaverageisusefulfortrackingtrendchangeovertime,especiallywhenthenumberofcollisionsissubjecttovariability.
Thefollowinganalysesarebasedonthemostcurrentfiveyears,2011to2015,ofdataforAzusa,CA.Therewere136peoplekilledorinjuredin131bicyclecollisions.TopViolationTypesforCollisionsInvolvingBicycles
TypeofViolation CollisionsN(%)
AutomobileRightofWay 21(16.0%)WrongSideofRoad 20(15.3%)ImproperTurning 17(13.0%)TrafficSignalsandSigns 14(10.7%)UnsafeSpeed 7(5.3%)PedestrianRightofWay 7(5.3%)Unknownornotstated 25(19.1%)OtherViolation* 20(15.3%)Total 131(100.0%)
*Eachviolationtypewasreportedfiveorfewertimes.
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Azusa,CA–8/30/17PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisionalatthistime.FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
BicyclingVictimsDemographicsTheageofbicyclingcollisionvictimsvariedacrossallagegroups,withyouthage19oryoungeraccountingforoverone-thirdofvictims.Victimswereprimarilymale.
VictimInjurySeverity,2011-15Mostcollisionsresultedinminorinjuries.
19 (14.0%)
32 (23.5%)
14 (10.3%)
31 (22.8%)
31 (22.8%)
7 (5.1%)
2 (1.5%)
0
20
40
60
80
14oryounger 15to19 20to24 25to44 45to64 65orolder Unknown
Num
bero
fVictim
s(n)
VictimAge
Fatal 1 (0.7%) SevereInjury
10(7.3%)
OtherVisibleInjury83(61.0%)
ComplaintofPain42(30.9%)
Male 109 (80.1%)
Female 18 (13.2%)
NotStated9(6.7%)
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Azusa,CA–8/30/17PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisionalatthistime.FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
PedestrianCollisionLocations,2011-15Note:Only81of87collisionsaregeo-coded.
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Azusa,CA–8/30/17PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisionalatthistime.FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
BicyclistCollisionLocations,2011-15Note:Only103of131collisionsaregeo-coded.
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Covina,CA–August30,
2017
PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisional
atthistime.
FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
PEDESTRIANS
NumberofCollisionsInvolvingPedestrians,2006-15
Thebluelineshowsthenumberof
pedestriancollisionswhereafatalityand/or
injuryoccurred.Therewere131people
injuredorkilledin118pedestriancollisions
overthelast10years.
Thegreenlineshowsthethree-yearmoving
averageofthenumberofpedestrian
collisionswhereafatalityand/orinjury
occurred.Themovingaverageisusefulfor
trackingtrendchangeovertime,especially
whenthenumberofcollisionsissubjectto
variability.Datapointsarethemidpointof
thethreeyearsofdataspecified.
Thefollowinganalysesarebasedonthemostcurrentfiveyears,2011to2015,ofdataforCovina,CA.There
were64peoplekilledorinjuredin56pedestriancollisions.
TopViolationTypesforCollisionsInvolvingPedestrians
TypeofViolation CollisionsN(%)
Drivermustyieldpedestrianrightofwayinacrosswalk 27(48.21%)
Pedestrianyield,uponroadwayoutsidecrosswalk 8(14.29%)
Other 7(12.50%)
RedorStop,vehiclesstopatlimitlineorX-walk. 3(5.36%)
Jaywalking,betweensignalcontrolledintersections. 2(3.57%)
Unsafeturnwith/withoutsignaling. 2(3.57%)
‘Walk’pedestrianfailuretoyieldright-of-waytovehiclesalreadyin
crosswalk. 2(3.57%)
OtherViolation 12(8.95%)
Total 56(100.02%)
PedestrianActionsinCollisionsInvolvingPedestrians
PedestrianAction CollisionsN(%)
CrossinginCrosswalkatIntersection 34(60.71%)
CrossingNotinCrosswalk 16(28.57%)
NotinRoad 3(5.36%)
InRoad,IncludingShoulder 2(3.57%)
CrossinginCrosswalkNotatIntersection 1(1.79%)
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Covina,CA–August30,
2017
PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisional
atthistime.
FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
Total 56(100.0%)
PedestrianVictimDemographics
Theageofpedestrianvictimsrangedconsiderablyacrossallagegroups,butadults45to64accountedfor26.6%
percentofallvictims.Victimswereprimarilymale.
VictimInjurySeverity,2011-15
Mostcollisionsresultedinminorinjuries.
10… 12… 7… 10… 17 (26.6%) 8 (12.5%) 0
5
10
15
20
14oryounger 15to19 20to24 25to44 45to64 65orolder
NumberofVictims(n)
VictimAge
Killed 1… Severe
Injury5(7.81%)
OtherVisibleInjury28(43.75%)
ComplaintofPain
30(46.88%) Male 34 (53.13%)
Female 26 (40.63%)
NotStated4 (6.25%)
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Covina,CA–August30,
2017
PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisional
atthistime.
FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
BICYCLISTS
NumberofCollisionsInvolvingBicyclists,2006-2015 Thebluelineshowsthenumberofbicycle
collisionswhereafatalityand/orinjury
occurred.Therewere113peopleinjuredin
113bicyclecollisionsoverthelast10years.
Thegreenlineshowsthethree-yearmoving
averageofthenumberofbicyclecollisions
whereafatalityand/orinjuryoccurred.The
movingaverageisusefulfortrackingtrend
changeovertime,especiallywhenthe
numberofcollisionsissubjecttovariability.
Thefollowinganalysesarebasedonthe
mostcurrentfiveyears,2011to2015,of
dataforCovina,CA.Therewere47people
injuredin47bicyclecollisions.
TopViolationTypesforCollisionsInvolvingBicycles
TypeofViolation CollisionsN(%)
WrongSideofRoad 26(55.32%)
TrafficSignalsandSigns 5(10.64%)
ImproperTurning 4(8.51%)
OtherHazardousViolation 3(6.38%)
AutomobileRightofWay 3(6.38%)
OtherViolation 5(10.64%)
Unknown 1(2.13%)
Total 47(100.1%)
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Covina,CA–August30,
2017
PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisional
atthistime.
FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
BicyclingVictimsDemographics
Theageofbicyclingcollisionvictimsvariedacrossallagegroups,withyouthage14oryoungeraccountingfor
25.53percentofvictims.Themajorityofvictimsweremale.
VictimInjurySeverity,2011-15
Mostcollisionsresultedinminorinjuries.
12(25.53%)
9(19.15%)
8(17.02%) 9 (19.15%) 7
(14.89%) 2 (4.26%)
0
5
10
15
14oryounger 15to19 20to24 25to44 45to64 65orolder
NumberofVictims(n)
VictimAge
SevereInjury2(4.26%)
OtherVisibleInjury15(31.91%)ComplaintofPain
30(63.83%) Male 42 (89.36%)
Female 4
(8.51%)
NotStated1(2.13%)
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Covina,CA–August30,
2017
PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisional
atthistime.
FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
PedestrianCollisionLocations,2011-15Note:Only48of56collisionsaregeo-coded.
CommunityPedestrianandBicyclistSafetyWorkshop–Covina,CA–August30,
2017
PedestrianandBicycleCollisionAnalyses,2006-15*
*DataSource:CaliforniaStatewideIntegratedTrafficRecordsSystem(SWITRS).Collisiondatafor2014and2015areprovisional
atthistime.
FundingforthisprojectwasprovidedbyagrantfromtheCaliforniaOfficeofTrafficSafetythroughtheNationalHighwayTrafficSafetyAdministration.
BicyclistCollisionLocations,2011-15Note:Only39of47collisionsaregeo-coded.