Top Banner
> 1 Cement-Lock ® Technology Healthy Communities, Clean River Alternative Technologies Workshop Michael C. Mensinger Gas Technology Institute Portland, Oregon June 3, 2006
23
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: PH CementLock Presentation

>

1

Cement-Lock®

Technology

Healthy Communities, Clean RiverAlternative Technologies Workshop

Michael C. MensingerGas Technology Institute

Portland, OregonJune 3, 2006

Page 2: PH CementLock Presentation

2

ECH

Presentation Outline

> Cement-Lock Technology> Status> Effectiveness and

Permanence> Reduction of toxicity,

mobility, or volume> Implementation> Costs> Summary

Page 3: PH CementLock Presentation

3

ECH

Cement-Lock Technology

Advanced thermo-chemical process for:> Decontaminating sediments,

sludges, and other materials,> Destroying organic or immobilizing

inorganic contaminants, and > Converting these wastes into

beneficial use product – blended cement

Page 4: PH CementLock Presentation

4

ECH

Cement-Lock Technology Applications

> Harbor & river sediments> MGP site soils> Brownfield soils and debris> Superfund site soils> Military base closure wastes & debris> Municipal solid wastes & sludges> Rubber tires> Petroleum sludges> Tank/tanker bottoms> Spent molecular sieves> Coal ash

Page 5: PH CementLock Presentation

5

ECH

Cement-Lock Technology

FUEL

AIR/O2

MODIFIERS

ECOMELT®

GENERATOR2400° - 2600°F

PULVERIZER/MIXER

SECONDARYCOMBUSTION

High QualityCONSTRUCTION-GRADE CEMENT

ADDITIVE

ECOMELT®

QUENCH

GASCLEAN

UPHEAT

RECOVERY

STEAM

SEDIMENT

CLEANFLUEGAS

Page 6: PH CementLock Presentation

6

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologyStatus > Bench-scale data with Newtown Creek (NY)

sediment – EPA Region 2, Brookhaven National Lab, USACE, and Black Lagoon (MI) sediment –MI-DEQ

> Pilot-scale (1-ton/day) data with Newtown Creek (NY) sediment and contaminated soil – EPA Region 2, BNL, USACE, Unitel Technologies

> Demo plant for dredged sediment from Stratus Petroleum (Newark Bay) currently undergoing testing in NJ – EPA Region 2, BNL, USACE, NJ-DOT/OMR, Gas Research Institute

Page 7: PH CementLock Presentation

7

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologyPilot-Scale Unit

Page 8: PH CementLock Presentation

8

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologyPilot-Scale Unit

Ecomelt® Production

Page 9: PH CementLock Presentation

9

ECH

Cement-Lock demo plantIMTT, Bayonne, NJ

Page 10: PH CementLock Presentation

10

ECH

Cement-Lock demo plantIMTT, Bayonne, NJ

Page 11: PH CementLock Presentation

11

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologyEffectiveness and Permanence

> Organic contaminants destruction

> Heavy metals (inorganics) immobilization

> Cement quality> Comparison of Cement-Lock

cement with Portland cement

Page 12: PH CementLock Presentation

12

ECH

Organic ContaminantsDestruction --- NY Estuarine Sediment --- -------- MI River Sediment -------- Contaminant

Untreated CementSediment Product

DRE*

Untreated CementSediment Product

DRE

----- mg/kg(dry) ----- --%-- ----- mg/kg(dry) ----- --%-- Oil & Grease -- -- -- 18,000 < D.L.** > 99.99 PAHs 370 0.22 99.93 51.2 < D.L. 99.99

------ μg/kg(dry) ----- ------ μg/kg(dry) ------

PCBs 8,585 < D.L. > 99.99 1,100 < D.L. > 99.99 ----- ng/kg(dry) ----- ----- ng/kg(dry) -----

2,3,7,8- TCDD/TCDF

262

< D.L.

> 99.99

--

--

--

Total TCDD/F 2,871 < D.L. > 99.99 -- -- -- Total PeCDD/F 4,363 < D.L. > 99.99 -- -- -- Total Hx/Hp/OCDD/F

34,252

< D.L.

> 99.99

--

--

--

* Destruction and removal efficiency ** Analytical method detection limit

Page 13: PH CementLock Presentation

13

ECH

Heavy MetalsImmobilization

----------------------------- TCLP* ----------------------------- ---------- Untreated Material ---------- ------- Cement Produced From ------- Metal

NY Estuarine Sediment

MI River

Sediment

Concrete

NY Estuarine Sediment

MI River

Sediment

Concrete

Regulatory Limit

-------------- mg/kg (dry) -------------- ------------------------------ mg/L ---------------------------- Arsenic 39 7.8 -- < 0.005** < 0.01 -- 5 Cadmium 27 9.5 -- < 0.001 < 0.002 -- 1 Chromium 298 138 500 0.15 < 0.072 0.097 5 Copper -- 180 -- -- < 0.01 -- -- Lead 542 218 -- < 0.002 < 0.01 -- 5 Mercury 2.9 0.55 -- < 0.0004 < 0.0004 -- 0.2 Selenium 6.2 -- -- < 0.003 -- -- 1 Silver 13 -- -- < 0.001 -- -- 5

* Toxicity Characteristic Leaching Procedure ** Analytical method detection limit

Page 14: PH CementLock Presentation

14

ECH

Pilot-Scale Air Emissions(NY Estuarine Sediment)

Flue Gas Composition* System OutletCO2, mol % 8.1 CO, ppm 25 HCl, ppm 14.2 NOx, ppm 67.7 SO2, ppm 44.1 Total Hydrocarbons, ppm 10.6 PCBs < 1.1 x10-6 lb/hr Pesticides < 2.8 x 10-7 Chlorobenzenes/Chlorophenols < 6.8 x 10-5 SVOCs BDL** Total 2,3,7,8-CDDs (TEF) < 4.0 x 10-12 Total 2,3,7,8-CDFs (TEF) < 8.1 x 10-12 Particulates, grains/dscf < 2.0 x 10-4 Particulate Phase Composition PCBs < 5.3 x 10-7 Total 2,3,7,8-CDDs (TEF) < 8.0x10-12 Total 2,3,7,8-CDFs (TEF) < 7.3x10-13

___________________________

* Adjusted to 7% oxygen ** Below detection limit, some phthalate compounds detected

Page 15: PH CementLock Presentation

15

ECH

Compressive Strength of Cementfrom Sediment and Debris

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

Estuarine Sediment River Sediment Concrete Debris

Com

pres

sive

Str

engt

h, p

si 3 Days 7 Days 28 Days28-day portland cement requirement: 4060 psi

Page 16: PH CementLock Presentation

16

ECH0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

PetroleumContaminated Soils

Soils Contaminatedwith 9,100 ppm of PCB

Equivalent

MSW

Com

pres

sive

Stre

ngth

, psi

3 Day 7 Day 28 Day

28-day portland cement requirement: 4060 psi

Compressive Strength of Cementfrom Contaminated Soils

Page 17: PH CementLock Presentation

17

ECH

Trace Elements in Cement-Lock Cement & Portland Cement

Element

Cement-Lock Cement

Portland Cement** ---------- Range ----------

-------------------------- mg/kg -------------------------- Mercury < 0.07* < 0.001 0.039 Selenium < 0.94 0.62 2.23 Cadmium 1.59 0.03 1.12 Lead 35.8 1 75 Silver 2.66 6.75 19.9 Arsenic 9.22 5 71 Barium -- 91 1402 Chromium 196 25 422 Nickel 133 15 129

* Below detection limit ** PCA, 1992

Page 18: PH CementLock Presentation

18

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologyImplementation

> Plants are modular and scaleable> A 500,000 yd3/year facility requires 5

Cement-Lock modules> Amount of Ecomelt produced from

sediment is ~250,000 ton/year> Cost estimate for a Cement-Lock plant

module is $20-$25 million

Page 19: PH CementLock Presentation

19

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologyImplementation> Permit requirements – similar to those for

waste processing plants> Air permit required> No process water discharge permit needed> Large-scale plant (>500,000 yd3/year) would

be engineered to process sediment directly into cement

> Flexible with respect to site preparation and utility requirements

> Access to transportation facilities> Access to electric and natural gas utilities

Page 20: PH CementLock Presentation

20

ECH

Demo Plant TestOperating ConditionsTest No. 1 2 3 5 6Test Date 12/10/03 7/16/04 7/22/04 10/27/04 3/11/05

Ecomelt Generator (rotary kiln)Operating Mode ---------------- Slagging ---------------- Non-Slagging

Temperature, °F 2425 2400 2455 2450 1835

Drop-out Box Temp., °F 1909 1855 2218 2400 1720

Gas Residence Time, sec. 3.5 3.5 3.3 3.2 N/A

Solids Residence Time, min. 80 80 80 80 80

Secondary Combustion ChamberSCC Burner --------------- Not Used --------------- Used

Temperature, °F 2309 2260 2280 2285 2115

Gas Residence Time, sec. 2.5 2.5 2.3 2.3 2.2

Flue Gas StackTemperature, °F 335 297 302 292 245

Beneficial Use Product --------------- Ecomelt --------------- EcoAggMat

Page 21: PH CementLock Presentation

21

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologyCost – Sediment Treatment> 500,000 yd3/yr sediment treatment

facility estimated cost = $82 million

> Estimated annual operatingcost = $46 million

($92/yd3)

> Potential Revenues: Sale of EcomeltPower Generation

> Estimated net operating cost = $35/yd3

> Co-processing other wastes improves economics

Page 22: PH CementLock Presentation

22

ECH

Cement-Lock TechnologySummary> Effectively remediates both organic and

inorganic contaminants in sediments– Improves the environment

> A beneficial use of sediments, soils, sludges, MSW, fly ash, etc.– Construction-grade cement

> Processing equipment commercially available– No development required

> Favorable economics– Tipping / processing fees– Sale of construction-grade cement)– Industrial wastes co-processing

Page 23: PH CementLock Presentation

>

23

Cement-Lock®

Technology

Thank you for your attention!