Kristin Schwitzer, Beacon Research Andy Rieger, UnitedHealth Group 5/7/09 Seniors Go Online to Co-Create a Tool to Track Healthcare Information
Dec 28, 2015
Kristin Schwitzer, Beacon Research
Andy Rieger, UnitedHealth Group
5/7/09
Seniors Go Online to Co-Create a Tool to Track Healthcare Information
Agenda
• What is a PHR?• Going-in business issues• Research objective• Study design• Outcomes/impact
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
What is a PHR?
Personal health record…
A computerized tool typically initiated by an individual that stores and manages one’s personal health and medical information, and is viewable by anyone who has been granted access.
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
What is a PHR? (cont.)
PHRs most commonly contain information on:
•allergies and adverse drug reactions
•medications (including dose and how often taken)
•illnesses and hospitalizations
•surgeries and other procedures
•vaccinations
•laboratory test results
•family history
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Going-in business situation
• UnitedHealth Group and AARP wanted to introduce a PHR targeting the needs of Seniors
• Little was known about the ways that America’s aging population goes about keeping track of their personal health records
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Key questions
Would UHG’s existing online PHR, designed for the general population, also work for Seniors?
What changes, if any, would be needed to optimize the tool and drive greater utilization and improved health outcomes?
Would the tool improve the ability of adult children to provide care for their elderly parents?
How could the tool improve the health of the chronically ill?
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Research objectives
1. Explore how today’s Senior population is handling management of their personal health records
2. Get reactions to UHG’s existing online PHR, and collect input on the “ideal” PHR tool design
3. Check assumptions that Caregivers and the Chronically Ill are market segments with a greater need for a PHR
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Key Issues
1. Current behavior:
The various assorted “jobs” The biggest pain points Tricks and tools
2. The “ideal” tool
Form and access Content and features
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Key Issues (cont.)
3. Personal health records:
Awareness and perceptions Reactions to the existing UHG tool Suggestions to make more targeted to 65+ year olds PHR set-up and maintenance – who’s responsible? Granting access to others Privacy concerns
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Sample
Four respondent segments were included:
– Healthy Seniors
– Chronically-ill Seniors
– Adult children caregivers
– Healthcare providers
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
A portion of the test PHR(as shown to the online respondents)
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Methodology
A 3-phase hybrid qualitative research design:
2-hour in-person focus groups 3-day online bulletin boards 5-day online immersive research one-on-ones
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Is online really a good way to reach Seniors?
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Absolutely! -- a majority of U.S. Seniors are now online
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Source: Pew Internet and American Life Project January 2009
Percentage of Americans Online by Age
Internet usage by our respondents
• Roughly 2/3 of our in-person Seniors use the Internet
• Popular sites: healthcare, news, banking, games, shopping
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
OLBBs
2 weeks in between each phase to debrief/evolve planned Guide and optimize learning
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
In-personfocus groups
Let’s take a closer look at each of the 3 phases,from both the researcher and client perspectives
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
In-person focus groups
1. Current behavior: Memory-based data collection Lots of storytelling about “jobs” and related frustrations Bullseye exercise on biggest pain points “Tricks and tools” shared verbally
2. The “ideal” tool Collaborative brainstorming
3. Personal health records: Top of mind associations Surface-level reactions to UHG PHR
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
In-person focus groups
Very cathartic for both the Seniors and Caregivers
Ate up a LOT of time on Current Behavior as participants had to take turns talking –
resulted in proportionally less learning on other key issues
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
In-person focus groups
• Team all together at project kickoff
– Dedicated time focused on voice of the consumer
– Seeing their emotions and non-verbal cues re: various “jobs”
– Constant backroom discussion and simultaneous learning– Evolving the Guide to maximize real-time learning
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
In-person focus groups (cont.)
• Videostreaming for 2nd market, with remote debriefing
– Efficient use of team members’ time
– Constant discussion via Instant Messaging
– Able to synthesize observations with those from 1st group
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Online bulletin boards
1. Current behavior: Memory-based data collection Faster, more streamlined issue exploration
2. The “ideal” tool Collaborative brainstorming, with time for reflection and additions Included 65+ content/feature suggestions
3. Personal health records: Top of mind associations Enhanced stimuli Much deeper exploration on PHR,
plus emerging themes of privacy and maintenance
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Online bulletin boards
Able to hear from ALL respondents on all questions
Data collected was 100% text-based, with a mix of unbiased individual feedback and group discussion
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Online bulletin boards
• Able to check in on data collection at our convenience
• Questions could be fine tuned and areas of interest explored more deeply than during in-person focus groups
• Text-based medium allowed for more in-depth analysis of responses
• Respondents not limited in terms of geographic region
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Online immersive research
Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
Open-ended blog/ photodiary
All aboutme
PHR expectations
Your ideal PHR
Reactions to sample PHR
Security/privacy cues
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Online immersive research
1. Current behavior: Experiential via 5-day blog
2. The “ideal” tool Drawings and rich descriptions
3. Personal health records: Top of mind associations Reactions to enhanced stimuli Much deeper exploration
on current and ideal content and features
Security cues
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Online immersive research
Longitudinal one-on-ones yielded rich individual insights
And lots of visual data (80 photos, 60 websites), in addition to text
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Online immersive research
• Able to check in on data collection at our convenience
• In-depth look at individual situations helped to uncover true jobs
• Rich media provided a broader perspective than just verbal/text
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Outcomes and impact
From video footage, transcripts, websites and images…
• Sample PHR was well received overall -- what’s working/ not working
• Still, a redesign of the general-population version was recommended
85 suggestions to maximize appeal to this target audience
• All want security cues and reassurance messages added
• All Seniors would grant access to their adult children
• Some want an offline version also
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Outcomes and impact
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Outcomes and impact
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Outcomes and impact
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group
Final assessment on hybrid design
• 3 methods triangulated into deeper insights than one alone
• 2-weeks in between phases helped maximize learning
• Approach can be adapted to all respondent types/ research needs
• And… Seniors can make outstanding online participants!
Beacon Research and UnitedHealth Group