A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution Lynne Kerger, The Chicago Tribune Ron Pocs, The Blackstone Group Engaging Consumers in New Product Development
Mar 31, 2015
A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Lynne Kerger, The Chicago TribuneRon Pocs, The Blackstone Group
Engaging Consumers
in New Product Development
2
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Three Things We All Know about Newspapers
3
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Three Things We All Know about Newspapers
4
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Three Things We All Know about Newspapers
5
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
How Did This Happen?
• Our future is in the hands of a sight, sound, motion generation
• News is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week
• Depth of coverage is out of sync with fast-paced 21st century life
• Things that used to drive 18-34s to the paper are now done online
• Multitasking is a way of life
The world changed …
6
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
2002 Reach Among 18-34’s
(% of mkt.)
50%
10%
6%
Source: Gallup Poll of Media Usage, Chicago Market 2002
Chicago Tribune Needed an EdgeChicago Tribune Needed an Edge
7
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Preliminary Work Informed Us
Focus Groups20 Adults in their 20’s
Tribune Proprietary Research Studies
Local Newspaper StudySingle Copy Newspaper Buyer Study
P R I Z MP R I Z M
Tribune Young Readers Panel
10 adults 17 – 23
Leisure Time Study
1 x 1 Interviews with External
Industry Experts3 out of market
newspaper peers
Industry Analysis
Internal Information Resources External Resources Primary Research
THE GALLUP
ORGANIZATION
THE GALLUP
ORGANIZATION
Editorial Readership Priorities, 2001
8
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
What We Learned
• Young readers are interested in local and relevant news
• You can have attitude but you must choose your spots
• Humor is essential
• Too much celebrity coverage is too much
• Brand credibility still means something
9
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
What We Made
10
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
What We Needed To DoShort-term
• Reach 18-34 year-olds, mainly in the city, who are commuters
• Quickly build trial and brand awareness
• Develop a daily reading habit
Long-term
• Grow circulation and readership among young readers
• Increase market share against competing publications
• Migrate readers to other Tribune media
• Generate healthy profits and margins
11
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
What We Launched
12
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
• Who was reading this thing?
• Was it working for them?
• Did we have the right content mix?
• Most importantly, were the covers attracting our targets?
What We Still Needed to Learn
13
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Conduct a study among consumers of a product that does not yet exist
Routinely survey a target audience (Gen Y) that is difficult to reach• Mobile• Tech savvy• Notorious for low newspaper readership• Generate initial and sustained interest
Construct a daily interviewing and reporting process• Cover and content specific• Frequent topline reporting• Iterative process• Track results over time
The Research Challenge
14
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Quantitative Panel
• Online ?
• On Site / Central Location Intercept ?
• Other ?
Methodology
Recruitment Options
• Use existing online panel(s) ?
• In-paper ads ?
• Postcard ?
• Online ?
15
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Postcard
16
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
In-Paper Ad
17
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Intro survey (populate potential panel members, comments)
Panel Construction
Panel survey (screening, demographics, panel invite)
Weekly survey• Morning launch (9-10am)• Midnight close• Reshuffle sample each week
Qualifications• Current RedEye reader• Mix of demographics (age, gender, income, etc.)• Mix of geography (city/non-city, distribution area)• Security (industry) screen
18
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
1st half: Base survey• Readership behavior
Questionnaire
2nd half: Targeted area (specific focus over 1-3 week periods)• General appeal• Specific content, design elements• Reader attitudes• Shopping behaviors and cross-media habits
Length: Less than 10 minutes
Form:• Mostly closed ends• “Comments” at end• Visual
19
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Questionnaire
20
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Fieldwork
A. WeeklyQuestionnaire
Provided
C. SampleCleaned /
Randomized
1. Cover .jpgReceived /Inserted
B. QuestionnaireProgrammed /
Tested
2. SurveyRe-tested
then Launched
3. InitialResults
Checked
4. ResultsMonitored
5. CloseSurvey
6. DataPulled /ToplineCreated
WEEKLY
DAILY
D. WeeklyReport
Generated
21
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Daily topline• Download from secure site• Basic graphical report
Reporting
Summary report• Compiled weekly
Verbatims• Presented in raw form
22
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Reporting
23
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Did today's cover entice you to pick up RedEye? (n=186)
No38%
Yes62%
What was it about the cover that enticed you to pick up RedEye? (n=116)
57%
25%
70%
10%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Pic/graphic Boldness ofHeadline
Topic of Cover Story Other
What was it about today's RedEye that caused you to pick it up? (n=70)
41%
3%
23% 0.21
40%
16% 19%27%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Handed
to m
e
Class
ified
Met
rom
ix
Oth
er E
nt.
News
Red H
ot
Sports
Oth
er
Reporting
24
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Initial Sweepstakes
Incentives
$ Gift card• Mailed via USPS• 3 options• $10 per occasion
• After first full survey• After every 4 additional surveys
25
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Non-Responders (Non-Readers)• Out after X weeks
Ongoing Panel Management
Feedback Loop• Establish one• Monitor it daily
Housekeeping• Removal from panel• Change of address (mail, e-mail)
Repopulate as needed
26
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Panel Members: 900
Panel Results
Response rates: High (63-72%)
Longevity: 5 months
Bottom line: Actionable results …• provided on a timely basis• used to improve the product• ultimately resulting in increased circulation
27
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Consider multiple options (be creative)
Offer popular incentives (relevant)
Monitor costs (10,500+ at less than $10 per complete)
(Try to) keep it simple
Avoid overload (take a break)
Pre-test (and adapt)
Build in controls (process checks)
Key Process Learnings
28
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Cover Elements Analysis
• Working with Tedesco Analytics, Inc. analyzed panel findings• Panel readership and satisfaction scores varied from issue to issue• Wanted to make best use of panel learnings to inform future efforts
• Complexity science uncovered patterns of most successful covers
• Each element of every cover was put into the model
• Appended readership/satisfaction scores for each issue
• Determined which elements were linked with highest readership/satisfaction
29
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Subject preferences of younger audience will not turn off 35+ readers
What We Learned
30
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Covers featuring males that have an outdoor feel outperform others
What We Learned
31
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Stories with a local connection and covers that give people a lot of reasons to open the paper work best
What We Learned
32
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Photos that suggest action and are not staged resonate most
What We Learned
33
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
TV/movie take-offs are best used sparingly
What We Learned
34
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Engaging Consumers in New Product Development: A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Fieldwork recently completed
Smaller scale, more focused
Previous learnings put into action
RedEye Panel – Wave II
A Case Study in Panel Design and Execution
Lynne Kerger, The Chicago TribuneRon Pocs, The Blackstone Group
Engaging Consumers
in New Product Development