Top Banner
 Environmental Business Council of New England Energy Environment Economy EBC Dam Management Program Up and Over, Around and Through: Dam Management’s Role in Fish Passage & Stream Restoration
261

4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

Mar 01, 2016

Download

Documents

ebcne

Dam Management Program - Fish Passage
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 1/261

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

EBC Dam Management Program 

Up and Over, Around and Through:

Dam Management’s Role in FishPassage & Stream Restoration

Page 2: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 2/261

Chad Cox, P.E.

Chair, EBC Dam Management Committee

Civil Engineer / Principal

GZA GeoEnvironmental, Inc.

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Welcome

Page 3: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 3/261

Chad Sumner

Program Chair & Moderator

Principal

SumCo Eco-Contracting

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Introduction

Page 4: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 4/261

Beth Lambert

 Aquatic Habitat Restoration

Program Manager

Division of Ecological Restoration

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Technical, Social, and Other

Challenges that May PreventDam Removal

Page 5: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 5/261

Technical, Social, and Other Factors

That Prevent Dam Removal

(or, why some restoration projects

come to a screeching halt)

Page 6: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 6/261

DER’s Aquatic Habitat Restoration Group 

Page 7: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 7/261

Page 8: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 8/261

Outline

• DER prefers damremoval for river

restoration

• But that isn’t alwayspossible.

• Top 4 reasons why

high priority damsaren’t removed 

Page 9: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 9/261

 

Ecological Reasons for

Dam Removal

Dams• Damage ecosystem

processes that build habitat

• Cause lower DO; highertemp

• Block movement of fish and

wildlife

• Drown floodplains

• Removing the dam

eliminates these problems

immediately

Page 10: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 10/261

Dams do more than block fish

• Low dissolved oxygen

• Drowned floodplain•  Aquatic invasive plants Warm water spillover

Fish and wildlife can’tmigrate upstream

This sediment should be

heading downstream to

build up salt marshes

Non-native species

Page 11: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 11/261

Societal Reasons for Dam Removal

Page 12: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 12/261

3000 dams and 20,000 culverts(Only) 40 Dams Have Been Removed in MA

3000 dams in MA

43 are flood control dams 44 licensed hydropower dams

164 water supply dams

Worcester County has highest density in USA

Page 13: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 13/261

Reason #4: Dam has an Active UseDrinking water supply

Pumping Station Dam,

Greenfield, 2011

Page 14: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 14/261

Kendall Company

No. 1 Dam, Colrain

Reason #4: Dam has an Active UseIndustrial water supply

Page 15: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 15/261Mill Street Dam, Green River, Greenfield

Reason #3: Upstream Infrastructure

Page 16: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 16/261

Dam / Bridge

Utility line

Over-steepened,

eroding banks

More Mill Street Dam infrastructure challenges

(Utility line issues are common to many projects)

Page 17: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 17/261

Ipswich Mills Dam, Ipswich

Reason #3: Upstream Infrastructure

Page 18: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 18/261

Contaminated Sediment

Baker Chocolate Dam

T&H Dam

Map by Neponset River Watershed Association

Reason #2: Expense of Managing

Contaminated Sediment

Page 19: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 19/261

Baker Dam, Neponset River, Milton/Boston

Page 20: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 20/261

Tileston & Hollingsworth Dam, Neponset River

Page 21: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 21/261

Expense of Managing Contaminated Sediment

Columbia Mill Dam, Housatonic River, Lee

Reason #2: Expense of Managing

Contaminated Sediment

Th #1 f i d

Page 22: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 22/261

Watertown Dam, Charles River

The #1 reason for not removing a dam:

Public Sentiment, Attachment, and Fear

Th #1 f t i d

Page 23: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 23/261

Public SentimentThe #1 reason for not removing a dam:

Public Sentiment, Attachment, and Fear

Fyfeshire Dam, Bolton

Page 24: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 24/261

Solutions

4. Dam has an active use money

3. Upstream infrastructure money

2. Contaminated sediment money1. Public sentiment / fear local advocacy

Page 25: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 25/261

Page 26: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 26/261

 

“…I caught my first wild

brook trout in the spot

where the dam oncestood. I believe you can

say the project was a

success…”

- Jameson Bastarache

Beth Lambert

Aquatic Habitat

Restoration Program

Manager

617-626-1526

[email protected]

Page 27: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 27/261

Nils Wiberg, P.E., CFM

 Associate

Fuss & O’Neill  

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Up & Over: Rock Ramps – 

Kenyon Mills Dam Rock Ramp

Fishway

Page 28: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 28/261

Presentation to theEnvironmental Business Council

of New EnglandApril 28, 2015

Design and Construction ofKenyon Mill Dam Nature-Like

Rock Ramp Fishway

Page 29: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 29/261

Presentation Overview

• Project Background• Site Constraints

• Fish Passage Design Alternatives

 – Full Dam Removal vs. Rock Ramp

• Construction Phase

• Test Flows and Completion

Page 30: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 30/261

Pawcatuck River Fish Passage Restoration Projects

Lower Shannock FallsDam Removal (2010) 

Horseshoe Falls DamFish Ladder (2012) 

Kenyon Mill Dam Nature-Like Rock Ramp (2013)

Potter Hill Dam Fish Ladder 

White Rock DamRemoval (2015)

Bradford Dam FishLadder (2016)

Page 31: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 31/261

Historic Kenyon Mill Dam

Page 32: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 32/261

Kenyon Mill Dam - 1939

Page 33: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 33/261

Existing Spillway (2009)

Page 34: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 34/261

Dam Deficiencies

 – Partial Breach at End of Spillway on

River-Left

 – Spillway Section in Need of Repair

 – No Low-level Discharge Outlet

 – POOR Condition Structure –  Would

Need Major Repair or Reconstruction

if Fish Ladder or Bypass ChannelSelected

Page 35: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 35/261

Source: August 2007

Malone and MacBroom Feasibility Study

2007 Feasibility Study Alternatives Evaluation

Page 36: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 36/261

Dam

PumpHouse

Fire Suppression System Pump Intake Structure

Page 37: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 37/261

Fire Suppression System Pump Intake Structure

Page 38: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 38/261

Fish Passage Design Alternatives

• Rock Ramp Construction

 – Replaces Dam Spillway with a Rock Ramp (approx. 160-feet long)

 –   Minimal Water Level Change or Effect on Upstream WetlandResources

 –  Continued Use of River by Kenyon Industries’ Fire SuppressionSystem

 – Portage Path Planned for Recreational Boaters

• Full Dam Removal

 –  Spillway Removed, Potential Modifications to River Channel toOptimize Fish Passage

 – Water Level Lowered to Pre-Dam Levels, Some Effect onUpstream Wetland Resources

 –  River No Longer Used for Kenyon Industries’ Fire SuppressionSystem –  WOULD REQUIRE 200k GAL. REPLACEMENT WATERSTORAGE TANK/INFRASTRUCTURE (> $500K)

i l d

Page 39: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 39/261

Extensive Upstream Wetland Resources

Kenyon Dam

Worden Pond

Great Swamp

Alt ti E l ti C it i

Page 40: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 40/261

Alternatives Evaluation Criteria

• Kenyon Industries Fire Suppression System and Local Fire Water

Supply

• Potential Effects on Wetland Resource Alterations,

Rare/Endangered Species and Habitat, Historic Resources

• Potential Effects on Shallow Groundwater Wells

• Potential Sediment Migration (transitional)

• Potential Bridge and River Channel Scour/Instability

• Potential Effects on Recreational Users (boaters, hunters)

• Potential Flood Impacts/Benefits

• Construction Costs / Post-Construction Maintenance Costs

Page 41: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 41/261

Base Flow Water Surface Elevation Modeling

E i ti W t S f P fil

Page 42: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 42/261

Existing Water Surface Profile

Amtrak Overpass

Kenyon Dam

Route 2 Bridge

Biscuit City Rd

Bridge

Worden Pond Outlet

Page 43: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 43/261

Rock Ramp Water Surface Profile

Amtrak Overpass

Kenyon Dam

Route 2 Bridge

Biscuit City Rd

Bridge

Worden Pond Outlet

F ll D R l W t S f P fil

Page 44: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 44/261

Full Dam Removal Water Surface Profile

Amtrak Overpass

Kenyon Dam

Route 2 Bridge

Biscuit City Rd

Bridge

Worden Pond Outlet

P t ti l Sh ll G d t W ll I t

Page 45: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 45/261

Potential Shallow Groundwater Well Impacts

Alt ti E l ti

Page 46: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 46/261

• Rock Ramp vs. Dam Removal

 – Dam Removal is Best Option from Fish PassageStandpoint; Rock Ramp is Less than Optimal

 –  Alternatively, Dam Removal results in:

•  Lowered Upriver Water Surface Profile (Well Impacts)

•  Reduced Upriver Riverbank Widths

• Increased Potential Effects on Wetland Hydrology (Dependent onSoil Properties and Magnitude of Profile Change)

• Increased Potential Effects on Rare Species

• Increased Potential of Sediment Mobility and Riverbank Scour

 –  Dam Removal potentially Cost Prohibitive

 –  Other Considerations (Easements, etc.)

Alternatives Evaluation

Selected Design Approach Rock Ramp

Page 47: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 47/261

Selected Design Approach - Rock Ramp

• Eliminating River as Supply for Kenyon’s Fire

Suppression System deemed Cost Prohibitive; RockRamp Alternative Selected

• Rock Ramp Design Highlights

 ‒ Overall Layout (4% Avg. Longitudinal Slope)

 –  Primary Grade Control Weir

 –  Downgradient Fish Passage Weirs

 –  Riverbank Stabilization

 –   Minimal WSE Change, Wetland Impacts, and Sediment Migration

 –   Minimum WSE of El. 85.42 must be maintained upstream ofRamp during 7Q10 Conditions; Two Dry Hydrants Installed

R k R G li d P fil

Page 48: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 48/261

Rock Ramp Generalized Profile

Grade Control Structure With6’ Wide Low-Level Notch

Inv. El.=84.48

Raised Arched WeirsSpaced Every 20’ (Typ.) 

Rock Ramp –  El. 84.48 To El. 80.32 (-3%-5% Longitudinal Slope)

Tailout –  El. 80.32 To El. 77.5(20% Longitudinal Slope)

Geotextile or Bentonite WaterproofingSheet/Membrane

TailwaterElevation

S l t d Alt ti R k R

Page 49: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 49/261

Selected Alternative - Rock Ramp

S l t d Alt ti R k R

Page 50: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 50/261

Selected Alternative - Rock Ramp

Selected Alternative Rock Ramp

Page 51: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 51/261

Selected Alternative - Rock Ramp

Construction Phase Temporary Bypass Channel

Page 52: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 52/261

Construction Phase –  Temporary Bypass Channel 

Construction Phase Temporary Bypass Channel

Page 53: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 53/261

Construction Phase –  Temporary Bypass Channel 

Construction Phase Temporary Bypass Channel

Page 54: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 54/261

Construction Phase –  Temporary Bypass Channel 

Construction Phase Weir Construction

Page 55: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 55/261

Construction Phase –  Weir Construction 

Construction Phase Weir Construction

Page 56: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 56/261

Construction Phase –  Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Weir Construction

Page 57: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 57/261

Construction Phase –  Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Weir Construction

Page 58: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 58/261

Construction Phase –  Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Weir Construction

Page 59: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 59/261

Construction Phase –  Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Weir Construction

Page 60: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 60/261

Construction Phase –  Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Weir Construction

Page 61: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 61/261

Construction Phase –  Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Test Flows

Page 62: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 62/261

Construction Phase    Test Flows 

Construction Phase – Test Flows

Page 63: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 63/261

Construction Phase   Test Flows 

Construction Phase – Test Flows

Page 64: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 64/261

Construction Phase   Test Flows 

Construction Phase – Weir Construction

Page 65: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 65/261

Construction Phase    Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Weir Construction

Page 66: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 66/261

Construction Phase    Weir Construction 

Construction Phase – Site Restoration

Page 67: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 67/261

Construction Phase    Site Restoration 

Construction Phase – Site Restoration

Page 68: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 68/261

Construction Phase    Site Restoration 

Completed Kenyon Mill Rock Ramp

Page 69: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 69/261

Completed Kenyon Mill Rock Ramp 

Completed Kenyon Mill Rock Ramp

Page 70: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 70/261

Completed Kenyon Mill Rock Ramp 

Completed Kenyon Mill Rock Ramp 

Page 71: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 71/261

Co p e ed e yo oc a p

U & O D il L dd & E l

Page 72: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 72/261

Chad Cox, P.E.

Civil Engineer / Principal

GZA GeoEnvironmental, Inc.

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Up & Over: Denil Ladders & Eel

Ramps – Upper Mystic Lake

Dam

EBC Fish Passage Forum 2015

Page 73: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 73/261

Moving Fish and Eels overUpper Mystic Lake Dam

Fish Ladders and Eel Ramps

Chad W. Cox, P.E.

Civil Engineer / Principal

GZA GeoEnvironmental, Inc.Norwood, MA

Presentation Outline

Page 74: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 74/261

1. Dam and Site Setting

2. Fisheries Issues

3. Pre-Project Fisheries Management

4. Fish Passage Alternatives

5. Design

6. Construction

7. Completed Structures

8. O&M

9. System Performance

1. Dam & Site Setting

Page 75: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 75/261

Upper Mystic Lake Dam

1. Dam & Site Setting

Page 76: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 76/261

Upper Mystic Lake Dam

1. Dam & Site Setting

Page 77: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 77/261

Upper Mystic Lake Dam

2. Species of Concern

Page 78: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 78/261

American eel Anguilla rostrata 

Duane Raver/USFWS

American Shad Alosa sapidissima 

Alewife Alosa pseudoharengus 

Blueback Herring Alosa aestivalis 

Cornell University Cornell University

NOAA

3. Pre-Project Fisheries Management

Page 79: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 79/261

BUCKET BRIGADE!

4. Fish Passage Alternatives

Page 80: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 80/261

• Fish Ladder• Denil

• Alaska steeppass

• Pool and Weir

• Fish Elevator

• Nature-Like Bypass Channel• Eel Ramp

• Temporary

• Permanent

Upstream Passage

Downstream Passage

• Chute

• Weir and Plunge Pool

4a. Upstream Passage Alternatives

Page 81: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 81/261

DENIL FISH LADDER

Diagram of a denil fishway.

Source: The Connecticut River Watershed Council, Inc.

4a. Upstream Passage Alternatives

Page 82: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 82/261

ALASK STEEPPASS

FISH LADDER

4a. Upstream Passage Alternatives

Page 83: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 83/261

POOL AND WEIR FISH LADDER

Diagram of a pool-and-weir fishway.

Source: The Connecticut River Watershed Council, Inc.

4a. Upstream Passage Alternatives

Page 84: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 84/261

Fish Elevator Nature-Like Bypass Channel

Northeast Utilities

4a. Upstream Passage Alternatives

Page 85: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 85/261

PERMANENT EEL LADDER

4a. Upstream Passage Alternatives

Page 86: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 86/261

TEMPORARY EEL LADDER

4a. Upstream Passage Alternatives

Page 87: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 87/261

TEMPORARY EEL LADDER

4b. Downstream Passage Alternatives

Page 88: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 88/261

CHUTE

WEIR ANDPLUNGE POOL

5. Design

Page 89: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 89/261

6. Construction

Page 90: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 90/261

6. Construction

Page 91: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 91/261

6. Construction

Page 92: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 92/261

6. Construction

Page 93: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 93/261

7a. Completed Fish Ladder

Page 94: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 94/261

7a. Completed Fish Ladder

Page 95: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 95/261

7b. Completed Eel Ramp

Page 96: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 96/261

7b. Completed Eel Ramp

Page 97: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 97/261

7b. Completed Eel Ramp

Page 98: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 98/261

7c. Completed Downstream Passage

Page 99: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 99/261

7c. Completed Downstream Passage

Page 100: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 100/261

7c. Completed Downstream Passage

Page 101: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 101/261

8. Operation and Maintenance

Page 102: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 102/261

9. System Performance

Page 103: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 103/261

Source: Mystic River Watershed Association

9. System Performance

Page 104: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 104/261

Source: Mystic River Watershed Association

Page 105: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 105/261

9. System Performance

Page 106: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 106/261

M i Fi h d E l

EBC Fish Passage Forum 2015

Page 107: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 107/261

Moving Fish and Eels over

Upper Mystic Lake DamFish Ladders and Eel Ramps

Chad W. Cox, P.E.

Civil Engineer / Principal

GZA GeoEnvironmental, Inc.

Norwood, MA

Up & Over: Denil Ladders & Eel

Page 108: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 108/261

Chris Haker, P.E.

Principal Engineer

Tighe & Bond

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Up & Over: Denil Ladders & Eel

Ramps – Stony Brook Fish

Passage

EBC Dam Management Program Series

Page 109: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 109/261

Tighe&Bond

Stony Brook Fish Passage

Improvements Lower Mill Pond Dam

Rehabilitation

 April 28, 2015

Christopher D. Haker, P.E. 

Principal Engineer

Lay of the Land

Page 110: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 110/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 111: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 111/261

Tighe&Bond

Background

Page 112: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 112/261

Tighe&Bond

■ Stony Brook watershed provides 386 acres of

herring spawning habitat

■ Five fresh water ponds, salt marsh, wetlands

■ Over 900 acres of protected open space

Lay of the Land

Page 113: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 113/261

Tighe&Bond

Site Background

Page 114: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 114/261

Tighe&Bond

■ Historic herring run in Brewster, MA

■ Known as the “Disney World” of herring runs 

■ Historic grist mill and museum – Stony Brook-Factory Village Historic District

 – National and State Registers of Historic Places

Stony Brook Improvements

Page 115: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 115/261

Tighe&Bond

■ Replace culvert at Route 6A crossing

■ Repair dam and improve herring run channel

■ General brook cleanup

Lay of the Land

Page 116: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 116/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 117: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 117/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 118: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 118/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 119: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 119/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 120: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 120/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 121: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 121/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 122: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 122/261

Tighe&Bond

Lay of the Land

Page 123: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 123/261

Tighe&Bond

Dam Deficiencies

Page 124: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 124/261

Tighe&Bond

■ Upstream stone masonry wall and outlet gate

deteriorated and leaking

■ Insufficient freeboard during spillway design flood

Dam Deficiencies

Page 125: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 125/261

Tighe&Bond

■ Seepage at left (west) abutment■ Trees and brush on dam and abutments

Fish Passage Issues

Page 126: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 126/261

Tighe&Bond

■ Some weirs required modification to meetrecommended flow depth, velocity, and slope criteria

Fish Passage Issues

Page 127: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 127/261

Tighe&Bond

■ Fish orifice acted as confined opening (herringprefer swimming through notch with free surface)

Dam Rehabilitation

Page 128: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 128/261

Tighe&Bond

Dam Rehabilitation

Page 129: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 129/261

Tighe&Bond

Dam Rehabilitation

Page 130: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 130/261

Tighe&Bond

Dam Rehabilitation

Page 131: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 131/261

Tighe&Bond

Dam Rehabilitation

Page 132: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 132/261

Tighe&Bond

Dam Rehabilitation

Page 133: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 133/261

Tighe&Bond

Fish Passage Improvements

Page 134: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 134/261

Tighe&Bond

Fish Passage Improvements

Page 135: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 135/261

Tighe&Bond

Fish Passage Improvements

Page 136: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 136/261

Tighe&Bond

Fish Passage Improvements

Page 137: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 137/261

Tighe&Bond

Fish Passage Improvements

Page 138: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 138/261

Tighe&Bond

Results

Page 139: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 139/261

Tighe&Bond

■ The 2013 and 2014 runs were largest in 20+ years■ Estimated herring counts since 2007:

 – 2007: 22,300

 – 2008: 25,300

 – 2009: 11,100

Culvert replaced – 2010: 48,100

 – 2011: 37,100

 – 2012: 41,000

Dam and fish ladder

improvements – 2013: 153,300

 – 2014: 271,400

Results

Page 140: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 140/261

Tighe&Bond

Results

Page 141: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 141/261

Tighe&Bond

Results

Page 142: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 142/261

Tighe&Bond

■ The restoration of the Stony Brook watershedreceived the President’s U.S. Coastal America

Partnership Award in 2012

Results

Page 143: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 143/261

Tighe&Bond

http://youtu.be/4h2V-VAPc-o 

Acknowledgements

Page 144: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 144/261

Tighe&Bond

Many thanks to:

Town of Brewster

Chris Miller, Director, Natural Resources Department

Charles Sumner, Town Administrator

Dana Condit, Alewife Committee/Dam Caretaker

Association to Preserve Cape Cod

Jo Ann Muramoto, Mass Bays Program Regional

Coordinator, Cape Cod

Division of Marine Fisheries

Brad Chase, Senior Marine Fisheries Biologist

Page 145: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 145/261

Tighe&Bond

Questions?

Around: Fish Bypass Channels – 

Page 146: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 146/261

Bjorn Lake, Ph.D., P.E.

Engineering Team Leader

Kleinschmidt

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

yp

Howland Dam Bypass Channel

Around: Fish Bypass Channels – 

Page 147: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 147/261

George P. Aponte Clark

Deputy Director

Penobscot River Restoration Trust

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

yp

Howland Dam Bypass Channel

Page 148: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 148/261

EBC – DAM MANAGEMENT PROGRAM

PLIMOUTH PLANTATIONAPRIL 28, 2015

George Aponte Clarke

Deputy Director

Penobscot River Restoration Trust

Bjorn A. Lake, PhD, PE

Engineering Team Leader

Dept. of Ecological Services

PENOBSCOT RIVER RESTORATION PROJECT 

Page 149: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 149/261

Restoring Sea-runFisheries and

Rebalancing

Hydropower on the

Page 150: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 150/261

• Penobscot Basin is the second

Page 151: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 151/261

• Penobscot Basin is the second

largest river system in New

England

• One of the largest freshwater

sources to the Gulf of Maine

• Historic fish community hasbeen severely altered

• Penobscot River supports the

largest run of Atlantic salmon in

the U.S.

Over 100 dams located in the

Penobscot Basin

1000s of road crossingsMap Courtesy of Tara Trinko Lake, NOAA

Dams, water pollution and over fishing have virtually

eliminated sea-run fish above Bangor in the Penobscot River

“After  this the Great Works dam was built, and in 1834 or 1835 the Veazie

Dam. The latter dam was closed in the winter. When the fish came in the

spring they found an impassable barrier across their way; they gathered in

ltit d b l th d d t i i t t it A t

Page 152: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 152/261

American shad 3-5 million Near 1000 1.5 million

Species Historic Current Potential

River herring 14-20 million Below 1,000 ~ 15 million

Atlantic salmon 75 – 100,000 1,300 (10 yr. avg.) 10,000-12,000

multitudes below the dam and strove in vain to surmount it. . . . A great many

shad and alewives lingered about the dam and died there, until the air was

loaded with the stench.” Maine Commissioner of Fisheries, Charles Atkins, 1869

Page 153: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 153/261

Page 154: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 154/261

 Atlantic salmon fishing at the Bangor

Salmon Pool in June of 1926.

Bangor Salmon

Pool in April of1912.

Delivery of the presidential

salmon to President Hoover .

Page 155: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 155/261

Page 156: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 156/261

Page 157: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 157/261

Lower

Page 158: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 158/261

Lower

Penobscot RiverDams

Factors contr ibu t ing to

the reduction in DFS

num bers inc lud e the

cumulative impact of

mult ip le dams, a

signi f icant known yet

unaddressed impact.

(Laser ‘09 and NRC ’04)

Partners in the Penobscot River Restoration Project

Penobscot River

Page 159: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 159/261

Restoration Trust

Page 160: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 160/261

Removed Two Dams

closest to sea – Veazie & Great Works

Page 161: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 161/261

Bypass Howland Dam

for inland habitat access

Improved Fish passage

at four other dams

Increased Energyto maintain power generation. 

Enhanced Habit Access

1,000 miles of historic habitat

Help Restore

11 species of native sea-run fish

associated traditions, culture, and

economic opportunities

  enobscot River Restoration roject

Before and After Habitat Access

Page 162: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 162/261

Existing Access for

Sea-Run Fish

Significantly Improved

Access for Sea-Run Fish to

Nearly 1,000 Miles

Restored use of upriver

spawning habitat for

salmon, shad, alewife,

blueback herring, and eels

Mattawa mkeag River 

East Branch Penobscot River 

Piscataquis River 

Pleasan t River 

Bangor 

Orono Old Town

West Enfield

Howland

Penobscot River 

Bucksport

M att awamkeag Riv er 

East Branch Penobscot R iver 

Piscataquis River 

P leasant R iver 

Bangor 

OronoOld Town

West Enfield

Howland

Penobscot River 

Bucksport

M att awamkeag Riv er 

East Branch Penobscot River 

Piscataquis River 

P leasant R iver 

Bangor Orono

Old Town

West Enfield

Howland

Penobscot River Bucksport

Diminished use of

upstream spawning

habitat by salmon

and eels

Underused state

of the artupstream fish

 passage

Little or no

commercial,

recreational,

or tribal

sustenance

fisheries

Little if any passage of

shad, alewife, blueback

herring, striped bass,

sturgeon, smelt, and

tomcod, impaired passage of eels

Restored use of

upriver spawning

habitat for salmon,

shad, alewife,

 blueback herring,

and eels

State of the art

 passage for salmon,

alewife, shad,

 blueback herring,

and eels

Restored

commercial,

recreational,

and tribal

sustenance

fisheries

Full restoration of

historical habitat and

access for salmon, shad,

alewife, blueback herring,

eel, striped bass, sturgeon,

smelt, and tomcod

Page 163: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 163/261

Page 164: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 164/261

Page 165: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 165/261

Page 166: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 166/261

Page 167: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 167/261

Page 168: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 168/261

Page 169: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 169/261

Photo by R.W. Estella

Page 170: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 170/261

Page 171: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 171/261

Page 172: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 172/261

ATLANTIC SALMON  255RIVER HERRING  187,429

AMERICAN SHAD  805

STRIPED BASS  18SEA LAMPREY  641

Page 173: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 173/261

Page 174: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 174/261

Page 175: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 175/261

 

Page 176: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 176/261

Howland Dam… 

Page 178: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 178/261

IN-LINE BYPASS CHANNEL ALTERNATIVE

STREAMSIDEPARK

INLINE

BYPASS

CHANNEL

Retain brick building if

desired

POND ELEV.

TO REMAIN AS IS

HOWEVER FLASH-

BOARDS MAY BE

REMOVED

DAM

EXTENSION

REMOVE EXISTING

FISH LADDER

AND HYDRO

FACILITY

Page 179: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 179/261

UPLAND BYPASS CHANNEL ALTERNATIVE

UPLAND

BYPASS

CHANNEL

STREAMSIDE

PARK

Retain brick building if

desired

Example of a bypass

channel in Austria

POND ELEV.

TO REMAIN AS IS

HOWEVER FLASH-

BOARDS MAY BE

REMOVED

REMOVE EXISTING

FISH LADDER

AND HYDRO

FACILITY

Nature-like Fish Bypass

Page 180: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 180/261

PROJECT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 

Page 181: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 181/261

Provide safe, timely, and effective upstream and downstream passageof all species that historically had access at the site

Maintain or enhance in-stream habitat value

Reconnect the Penobscot River and its watershed to the Gulf of Maine

Restore the fishery and cultural heritage of the Penobscot Nation

Provide appropriate opportunities for recreation, public access, andriver-related economic development

Address environmental and permitting considerations by avoiding orminimizing impacts

Achieve the objectives at a reasonable cost

Avoid unnecessary work

Manage permitting challenges

Address difficult construction

Minimize O&M demands

DESIGN TEAM 

Page 182: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 182/261

•Project Management•Powerhouse Modifications•Bridge

•Soils Management•Geotechnical

•Hydraulics•Channel Design

•Soils Management•Construction Oversight

SITE HISTORY 

Page 183: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 183/261

1952 1997

EXISTING CONDITIONS 

Page 184: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 184/261

UPSTREAM FISH PASSAGE 

Page 185: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 185/261

Page 186: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 186/261

FISH PASSAGE DESIGN CRITERIA 

Page 187: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 187/261

Operational Range

250 to 10,600 cfs

April 15th to

December 1st

  Velocity should be 6

fps or less

Minimum depth of

1.5 feet Six diadromous

species

DESIGN PROCESS & OBJECTIVES 

Page 188: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 188/261

1. Balancing fish passage effectiveness withchannel stability and impoundment levels

2. Minimize operation and maintenance3. Minimize construction cost

Design Team Agency Staff

UPSTREAM ATTRACTION FLOW 

Page 189: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 189/261

BYPASS CHANNEL DESIGN 

Page 190: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 190/261

BYPASS CHANNEL DESIGN 

Page 191: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 191/261

250 cfs

1,000 cfs

4,000 cfs

8,000 cfs

FLOW SPLIT 

Page 192: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 192/261

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 9,000 10,000 11,000

   F   l  o  w    S  p   l   i   t   P  e  r  c  e

  n   t  a  g  e

   P

  e  r  c  e  n   t   E  x  c  e  e   d  a  n  c  e   i  n   P   i  s  c  a   t  a  q  u   i  s   R   i  v  e  r

Flow in the Piscataquis River (cfs)

Channel

Spillway

Peak Salmon Immigration

DOWNSTREAM PASSAGE 

Page 193: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 193/261

CHANNEL CONSTRUCTION 

Page 194: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 194/261

www.penobscotriver.org

Page 195: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 195/261

  www.facebook.com/PenobscotRiver

Through: Dam Removal & River

Restoration – Whittenton Dam

Page 196: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 196/261

Nick Nelson

Fluvial Geomorphologist

Inter-Fluve, Inc.

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Removal

Whittenton Dam Removal

Page 197: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 197/261

Environmental Business Council Dam Management ProgramPlymouth, MA

April 28, 2015

Nick Nelson, Inter-Fluve

Page 198: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 198/261

 

Site Background

Page 199: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 199/261

Mill River Dams

Page 200: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 200/261

Taunton River:

Wild & Scenic

Mill River

Morey’sBridge Dam

Mill River Restoration

MA Di i i f E l i l R t ti

Page 201: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 201/261

• MA Division of Ecological Restoration

• The Nature Conservancy

• American Rivers

• NOAA

• USFWS

• Save the Bay

• Southeast Regional Planning and EconomicDevelopment District

• MA Audubon

• Dam owners – MA Department of Mental Health,Jefferson Development Partners, Reed & Barton

Goals

Page 202: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 202/261

• Remove owner liability associated withdilapidated dams

• Improve fish passage

• Improve water quality• Restore hydrologic and sedimentologic flow

conditions

Morey’s Bridge Dam – Replaced in 2013with Eel Ramp and Fish Ladder

Page 203: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 203/261

Page 204: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 204/261

 

Whittenton – Removed in 2013

Page 205: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 205/261

2010

Page 206: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 206/261

 

2013

West Britannia Dam – In Designs forRemoval

Page 207: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 207/261

Page 208: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 208/261

 

1896

West Britannia Dam

Page 209: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 209/261

West Britannia Designs

Page 210: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 210/261

Hopewell Mills Dam – Removed in 2012

Page 211: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 211/261

Hopewell Mills/State Hospital

Page 212: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 212/261

 

Hopewell Mills/State Hospital

Page 213: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 213/261

 

Page 214: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 214/261

Hopewell Mills Dam Looking Upstream June, 2012

Page 215: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 215/261

Hopewell Mills Dam Looking Upstream May, 2013

Page 216: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 216/261

 

Hopewell Mills Dam Looking West June, 2012

Page 217: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 217/261

 

Hopewell Mills Dam Looking West High Flows, June, 2013

Whittenton Dam

Page 218: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 218/261

 

Page 219: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 219/261

 

2005

Page 220: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 220/261

 

2005

Page 221: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 221/261

 

2005

Page 222: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 222/261

2005

Page 223: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 223/261

 

2005

Page 224: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 224/261

 

2005

Page 225: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 225/261

 

2005

Page 226: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 226/261

 

2005

Page 227: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 227/261

2013

Components of Whittenton Dam Removal

Page 228: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 228/261

• Sediment Management• Endangered Species

• Historical Buildings

• Crazy landowners• Channel Construction

• Plantings

Sediment Management

Page 229: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 229/261

Hopewell Mills – Sediment Removal and Disposal

Whittenton Impoundment:

Low Flows

Page 230: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 230/261

FullImpoundment

Edge

Page 231: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 231/261

Stumps

Longitudinal Profile

Page 232: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 232/261

Whittenton DamMorey’s Bridge 

Endangered Mussels - Relocated

Page 233: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 233/261

Page 234: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 234/261

Historical Buildings/Resources

Page 235: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 235/261

 

Landowners

Page 236: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 236/261

Landowners

Page 237: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 237/261

Dam Demolition/Channel Construction

Page 238: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 238/261

2010

Page 239: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 239/261

 

Page 240: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 240/261

 

Page 241: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 241/261

Page 242: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 242/261

Page 243: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 243/261

Page 244: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 244/261

Channel and Bank Construction

Page 245: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 245/261

Page 246: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 246/261

 

Page 247: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 247/261

Page 248: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 248/261

Page 249: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 249/261

Page 250: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 250/261

2013

Page 251: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 251/261

2013

 

Page 252: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 252/261

2013

Page 253: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 253/261

2014

Page 254: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 254/261

2012

Page 255: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 255/261

2014

 

Page 256: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 256/261

2013

 

Page 257: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 257/261

2013

Th k Y

Page 258: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 258/261

Thank You

Nick Nelson

Inter-Fluve, Inc.617-714-5537

[email protected]

www.interfluve.com

Networking Break

Page 259: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 259/261

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Panel Discussion

Moderator: Chad Sumner, SumCo Eco-Contracting

Speakers

Page 260: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 260/261

Environmental Business Council of New England

Energy Environment Economy

Speakers• Beth Lambert, MA Div. of Ecological Restoration

• Nils Wiberg, Fuss & O’Neill  

• Chad Cox, GZA GeoEnvironmental, Inc.

• Chris Haker , Tighe & Bond

• Bjorn Lake, Kleinschmidt

• George P. Aponte Clarke, Penobscot River Restoration Trust

• Nick Nelson, Inter-Fluve, Inc.

EBC Dam Management Program 

Up and Over Around and Through:

Page 261: 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

7/18/2019 4-28-15 Dam Management Program - Fish Passage

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/4-28-15-dam-management-program-fish-passage 261/261

Up and Over, Around and Through:Dam Management’s Role in Fish

Passage & Stream Restoration

Thank you for attending.