Transcript
1
Motivation
2
Discussion Questions
What is the best way to motivate a salesforce?
How can you systematically design a motivation system?
3
Three Major Determinants of Motivation
Environmental conditionsThe firm’s management policies
compensation supervision task characteristics
Personal characteristics of the salesperson
4
Motivation Session Objectives
understand the components of motivation through the expectancy-value model
relate management tools to components of the expectancy-value model, to use in influencing motivational levels
consider how management style and the use of various “tools” influence motivation
5
Motivation Session Outline
Locus of Control and MotivationExpectancy-Value Model of
motivation what is it? Who cares? (implications of the model)
Glengarry Glen Ross & the impact of the sales manager on motivation
The impact of role stress
6
Locus of Control and Motivation
Locus: External vs. internal attributions Stable vs. unstable attributions
Examples: External Stable: External Unstable: Internal Stable: Internal Unstable:
7
The Expectancy-Value model
Why are people motivated to initiate a task to choose a certain effort level to persist in a task
Expectancy Principle: salespeople choose a level of effort based on the expected payoffs of alternative effort levels
Most popular model of motivation (at least among sales force researchers)
8
Expectancy-Value Model in Notation
Mj=Ej x Vj where:
Mj=motivational drive to achieve level j of performance (e.g. sales, number of new accounts etc.)
Ej =beliefs about the effort to performance linkage: perceived chances of achieving level j of performance given effort
Vj = overall subjective utility (valence or value) of achieving level j of performance
9
Examples:
Ej Vj Mj Level of Performance
80% 60 48 If j=$200,000 in sales
40% 100 40 If j=$300,000 in sales
10% 80 8 If j=$400,000 in sales
10
Valence/Value: Vj
Valence is a composite of the utility you derive from the suboutcomes (consequences) that accompany achieving level j of performance
These might include: more pay, promotion, liking & respect, lack of leisure
time, personal growth security, sense of accomplishment, recognition, hurting
personal life
Outcomes can have negative utility/valenceObviously the list could be longer & vary across
individuals
11
Vj= (Iij x Vi)
Vj = expected overall utility to an individual of achieving performance level j
Iij = beliefs about the performance to suboutcomes linkages: the individuals subjective probability that achieving performance level j would create suboutcome I (instrumentalities)
Example: 30% chance that selling $300K (performance level j) would get one a promotion (suboutcome I)
Vi = the utility an individual derives from suboutcome I (e.g., a promotion) Note: this can be negative
12
That’s nice, but who cares?
Nobody thinks like this (it’s too complicated)
But model holds up well in field testing (good “as if” model)
Explains up to 40% of variance in performance
13
Expectancy-Value Model Advantages
Model is a handy way to structure a messy question
Forces you to project o each individual’s underlying beliefs (expectancies) and needs/wants (values)
Different people can exhibit the same level of motivation for very different reasons
Nice vocabulary to talk about motivation
14
Implications for How to Motivate
No reward is motivating if it is out of reach (low expectancy)
Raising the goal (performance level j) often depresses motivation Introduces negative outcomes Depresses expectancies
Can motivate by trying to induce sales people to: raise expectancy (I.e. through training, encouragement) consider a negative suboutcome unlikely consider a positive suboutcome likely Add a new positive suboutcome Change their ideas about whether suboutcomes are desirable or
undesirable (vi: doomed strategy for the most part)
15
Glengarry Glen Ross
what is the impact of management style on the components of the expectancy value model?
What motivational “tools” are used? How do these tools impact motivation in the
short-term? Over the long term? How do these tools impact extrinsic motivations?
Intrinsic motivation?
16
Motivators
Positive Motivators
Commission Recognition Acceptance Respect Trust Achievement Pride
Negative Motivators Fear Intimidation Revenge Obligation Social Comparison
(one-up)
17
Sales Manager Objectives & Tools
Objectives: Increase magnitude and accuracy of expectancies Increase accuracy of instrumentalities Understand and work with valences
Key: reduce role stress arising from role ambiguity & role conflict
Tools: training: expectancies evaluations, reviews: expectancies, instrumentalities communication, participation: instrumentalities selection: hire SP whose Vi’s match company suboutcomes
18
How to Motivate
Define each employee’s motivating factors and provide an environment that incorporates those factors
Praise performance Address poor performance Set goals & clearly communicate expectations Share your vision and include your team in creating it
19
Measuring Components of the Model
May be done informally for small sales forces, but beware of biases (e.g. we believe what we want to believe; we think everyone else is like we are)
periodic surveys can be conducted to quantify each component of the model expectancies: to what extent do you believe that if you do
x, y will happen instrumentalities: to what extent do you believe that if y
happens, you’ll receive z valences for suboutcomes: how important is ..
Quantified information is valuable at both the aggregate level and the individual level
20
Role Stress
“A primary influence on how salespeople perform is their perceptions of the demands placed upon them”
“A role is a prescription: it tells you the activities and behavior that are expected of
anyone in a position
Role partners communicate expectations pressure salespeople to meet them
A role partner is anyone with a vested interest in how a salesperson does the job, such as: the boss, the customers, other executives, other salespeople and
support people, people who are significant in the sales rep’s personal life
21
Role Stress (continued)
Role stress is like a disease; most reps suffer complications of role stress
Why? Sales is at the boundary of the firm; salespeople are
boundary spanners, which means lots of role partners Salespeople often have to be creative; find solutions;
reconcile needs A sales reps performance affects performance of lots of other
people Sales reps personify the cruel voice of the marketplace
(scapegoat- kill the messenger) Time and resource constraints necessitate tradeoffs between
role partners’ expectations
22
Role Stress (continued)
Day after day, salespeople grapple with the messages their role partners send them and the pressures role partners put on them.
Two things create role stress (create problems that eventually will make the salesperson miserable): Perceived Role Conflict Perceived Role Ambiguity
23
Perceived Role Conflict:
you feel that the demands of your role partners are incompatible. To make one happy, you have to upset another (perceived).
Upshot: misery & poor motivation
24
Perceived Role Ambiguity:
You feel you don’t have the information to cope with your job demands don’t know how to do a task don’t know what role partners expect don’t know how your performance is being evaluated don’t have clear objectives SUM: unsure how you’re doing and what to do next
25
How to reduce Role Stress
Communicate! Give feedback! Even bad news is better than news Salespeople must have accurate expectancies &
instrumentalities Training and encouragement: increase
expectancies for desired levels of performance- people who believe they can, often do
Accept that some role stress is normal (even desirable)
but be especially alert for dysfunctional levels of role stress in inexperienced people
26
Sales Manager Atmosphere Creation
Traditional Approach Authoritative “management” Emphasis on rewards the manager gives out:
pay promotion recognition of achievement
Leading to: Motivation to work harder: intensity, persistence
27
Non-traditional atmosphere
Participate leadership Emphasis on intrinsic rewards & motivation people work because selling satisfies them with:
challenges pride in serving customers pride in skills
“Warm Culture” informal sense of shared values identify with company long-term employment
28
Motivating
A motivator is one who can understand an overall goal and inspire others to make a personal commitment to this goal
5 ways to provide a motivating environment Participation: involvement in decisions that affect the
team Environment: climate for success, creativity Recognition: giving credit, praise, rewards Knowledge: having it, communicating it Style: use appropriate style for each situation:
coaching, supporting, delegating, directing
top related