7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
1/72
THE COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
Massachusetts Emergency Management Agency
400WORCESTER RD.,FRAMINGHAM,MA01702-5399 508-820-2000FAX508-820-1404
Department of Conservation and Recreation251 CAUSEWAY STREET,SUITE 600-700,BOSTON,MA02114-2104 617-626-1250FAX 617-626-1449
Kurt N. Schwartz
DIRECTOR
Deval L. Patrick
GOVERNOR
Edward M. Lambert, Jr.
COMMISSIONER
Grant Sub-Application Package for theHazard Mitigation Grant Program (HMGP)
(FEMA-1994-DR-MA & FEMA-4028-DR-MA)This package has been developed to assist prospective Sub-Applicants in the preparation of Hazard
Mitigation Grant Program (HMGP) Sub-Applications. The package outlines the specific information
required for the State and Federal government to review proposed mitigation activities. While utilization of
forms contained within this package is strongly encouraged, the Sub-Applicant may submit the requested
information in any format it elects. By providing all of the information requested, the review process at the
State and Federal levels may be significantly expedited.
The Commonwealth has established Monday, April 2, 2012 as the HMGP Sub-Application deadline. AllSub-Applications must be received by (3:00pm) 04/02/2012 to be considered for possible funding. Sub-
Applications should be submitted to:
Kathryn Fatherley, Hazard Mitigation Assistant
MA Emergency Management Agency400 Worcester Road
Framingham, MA 01702
C iti h ld di t ll S b A li ti th i i b d d t t t id
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
2/72
Communities should coordinate all Sub Applications among their various boards or departments to avoid
TABLEOFCONTENTS
Sub-Application Information ...3
Sub-Application Completion Checklist .............................................................................................................. 5
A. Project location .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... .......... ...... 8B. Description of Existing Conditions .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ....... 8
C. Scope of Work (Project Description) .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... .. 10
D. Project Photographs .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ....... 14
E. Project Maps ............................................................................................................................................... 14
F. Project Drawings .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... .. 14
G. Alternatives ......... ........... .......... .......... ........... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... 16
H. Work Schedule ............................................................................................................................................ 18
I. Maintenance Schedule and Associated Cost .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... . 18
J. Project Cost Information .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... 18K. Estimated Project Cost Share .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... ... 21
L. Other Funding Agencies .......... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... . 22
M. Mitigation Plan Status & Information .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... 22
N. Public Notice/Official Newspaper Information .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ....... 23
O. Required Benefit-Cost Analysis (BCA) Information ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ......... 23
P. Environmental/Historic Preservation Information .......... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... ... 24
Q. Waterway/Waterbody/Wetlands Information .......... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... 25
R. Floodplain Location .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ....... 26
S. National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) ......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ..... 26T. General Conditions ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... ........ 28
U. Funding Certification .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ..... 28
V. Maintenance Agreement .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... 29
W. Property Acquisition/Relocation/Elevation Worksheet.............. .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... .. 30
X. Property Acquisition/Relocation/Elevation Certification .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... .......... .... 40
Y. Contact Information .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... .......... ........... .......... ........... .......... ....... 41
Appendix AMitigation Grant program resources .......................................................................................... 42
Appendix BHMGP Project review criteria ................................................................................................... 44
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
3/72
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
4/72
This page is intentionally left blank.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
5/72
SUB-APPLICATION COMPLETION CHECKLISTThis checklist will assist local communities and consultants in developing a complete Hazard Mitigation Grant
Program (HMGP) Sub-Application. Project and plan Sub-Applications submitted for funding under disasters
declared after June 1, 2009, shall use Hazard Mitigation Assistance (HMA) Unified Guidance:
http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=4225
Below section to be completed by Sub-grantee:
Sub-Applicant Town of Willliamstown, Massachusettts____________________
Project Title ___Spruces Mobile Home Park Acquisition & Mitigation
Community Name
Williamstown
Funding:
HMGP DR #
FEMA-1994-DR-MA
FEMA-4028-DR-MA
Below section to be completed by State:
State Reviewer_____________________________Phone_________________Email____________________________
Below section to be completed by FEMA:
Date received in Region: Date Received at FEMA ______________________
FEMA Reviewer_____________________________Phone_________________Email___________________________
*Note: For Property Acquisition Sub-Applications (Use Section 1 and 2 only)For Planning Sub-Applications (Use Section 3 only)
Section 1: Project Sub-Application
Project Sub-Application TaskReferenced information
locationState
ReviewFEMAReview
Sub-Applicant Information Page 3
Point of Contact (POC) Page 3
Project Location Page 8
Description of Existing Conditions Page 89
Scope of Work (SOW) Summary (Project Description) Page 11-13
http://www.fema.gov/library/viewrecord.do?id=4225http://www.fema.gov/library/viewrecord.do?id=4225http://www.fema.gov/library/viewrecord.do?id=4225http://www.fema.gov/library/viewrecord.do?id=4225http://www.fema.gov/library/viewrecord.do?id=42257/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
6/72
Section 1 Project Sub-Application (contd)
Project Sub-Application Task Referenced informationlocation
StateReview FEMAReview
Environmental / Historic Preservation Information Page 24
Waterway/Waterbody/Wetlands Information Page 25
Floodplain Location Page 26 Appendix F
National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) Page 27
General Conditions (Signature Required) Page 28
Funding Certification (Signature Required) Page 28
Maintenance Agreement (Signature Required) Page 29
Section 2: Property Acquisition/Elevation Projects
Property Acquisition/Relocation/Elevation Worksheet Page 30 - 39
Photographs Pg. 3236 & Appendix C
Substantial Damage Letter
Elevation Certificate
Voluntary Transaction Letter
Model Deed
Tax Assessor Card
Property Acquisition/Relocation/Elevation Certification Page 40
Section 3: Hazard Mitigation Plan (New Plans or Plan Updates)Sub-Applicant Information
Project Location
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
7/72
This page is intentionally left blank.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
8/72
A. PROJECT LOCATION
Attach a brief description of the project location. Include the name of the municipality and county,
intersecting streets, and easily identified landmarks such as waterbodies and structures. Include
the street address of the property, if applicable. For Planning Projects, provide a description of
the jurisdictions (communities) involved in the planning proposal.
The Spruces Mobile Home Park is located at 60 Main Street on the eastern end of
Williamstown, Massachusetts adjacent to the North Adams City Line. The park is bounded
to the south by Main Street (Mass Rt. 2), to the north by the Hoosic River, to the east by
Paull Brook.
Please provide project Latitude and Longitude in decimal degrees (including six or moredecimal places) in the spaces below or on additional sheets. For projects with multiple
structures or sites, provide lat/long for each structure or site. For projects that cover larger
geographic areas provide a lat/long for the key project element.
Latitude 42.704452 Longitude -73.179517
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
9/72
level of most mobile homes, and while not a major threat to life and property will sometimes
necessitate evacuation of the park.
The much more dangerous type of flooding event occurs when, in addition to the nuisance
flooding, the floodwall adjacent to the Hoosic River is overtopped. This allows high velocity,
considerably deeper water to enter the park. Tropical Storm Irene resulted in this type of
flooding, and caused widespread property damage. A full mandatory evacuation of the park
was also conducted.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
10/72
C. SCOPE OF WORK (PROJECT DESCRIPTION)3
A detailed scope of work (SOW) is a description all work required to implement the proposed activity
and the associated cost and timeframes. Provide a complete and detailed description of the proposed
project including the following:
Describe the source of the hazards and risk to life, safety and improved property that you aretrying to solve
Physical area to be affected by the proposed project
For flood related projects please describe/discuss any potential upstream/downstream impacts ofproposed improvements
Survey, Design & Engineering, Permitting, Bidding & Advertising, Construction, SitePreparation, Erosion Control, Utility Relocation/Re-connection, Direct Administrative Cost and
Project Close-out
Construction methods, including excavation or earth moving activities, if applicable
If project is implemented, explain how it will reduce future damages
How is the project an improvement over the existing conditions? (Maintenance & repair is notconsidered an improvement under this grant program)
Describe how the project is consistent with the goals, strategies and recommended actionsoutlined in your FEMA-approved Multi-Hazard Mitigation Plan
Describe how proposed project would address the existing conditions previously identified
Indicate the level of protection to be provided (frequency or intensity of event to be mitigated;e.g. 100-year flood, 100 mph wind event, etc.)
Explain level of public involvement in the decision to select the proposed project
The pros and cons of the proposed project including: the social, political, administrative,technical, economic, legal and environmental ramifications of project.
Explain why the proposed project was selected over the other alternatives (see section D.)
Note: If the project is intended to protect a critical facility from flooding, the project should be designed to provide
protection from a 500-year event. Critical facilities include generating plants, other utility lines, nursing homes, housingfor the elderly, fire and police stations, hospitals, and other facilities that provide public health and safety services.
For a Hazard Mitigation Plan, the Scope of Work must, but is not limited to the following:
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
11/72
Scope of Work SummaryProvide description of the proposed project and work to be accomplished
Proposed Project: Spruces Mobile Home Park: Acquisition and Mitigation
Level of Protection: All events of any intensity.
Describe the source of the hazards and risk to life, safety and improved property that you are
trying to solve:
The Spruces is a 225-unit Manufactured Housing Community (MHC) adjacent to the Hoosic River in
Williamstown MA. Seven storms have exceeded moderate flood stage since recordkeeping began in
1940. Four of the seven storms exceeded major flood stage. Most recently TS-Irene (DR-4028-MA)
displaced 160 of the 180-day mobile homeowners, a 3-unit apartment building, and the park
recreation center. Underground utilities in one third of the park are compromised beyond repair. The
remaining 65 of 225 units are not sufficient for the park to remain economically viable.
Physical area to be affected by the proposed project:
The Spruces MHC is located on 115-acre assessors parcel 112-19 at 60 Main Street inWilliamstown MA 01267. Latitude 42.704452 Longitude -73.179517
For flood related projects please describe/discuss any potential upstream/downstream impacts of
proposed improvements:
There are no identified negative potential upstream/downstream impacts of the proposed
improvements. Project is intended to remove all structures and manmade improvements from the
parcel and return it to its natural state. Only permitted re-uses will be allowed e.g. agriculture andrecreation. Flood storage capacity will be minimally increased.
Survey, Design & Engineering, Permitting, Bidding & Advertising, Construction, Site
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
12/72
All residents will be relocated to decent, safe, and sanitary dwellings. No structures will be permitted
on the site.
Describe how the project is consistent with the goals, strategies and recommended actions
outlined in your FEMA-approved Multi-Hazard Mitigation Plan:
The Multi-Hazard Mitigation Plan identifies flooding at The Spruces as the #1 threat in
Williamstown. The MHMP identifies only education and storm warning information as locally
feasible strategies to minimize loss of life and property. This project exceeds the Plan goals by
eliminating the threat.
Describe how proposed project would address the existing conditions previously identified:
All residents will be relocated to decent, safe, and sanitary dwellings. All existing structures will be
removed and no new structures will be permitted on the site in accordance with the FEMA Model
Deed Restriction.
Indicate the level of protection to be provided (frequency or intensity of event to be mitigated;
e.g. 100-year flood, 100 mph wind event, etc.):
All events of any intensity.
Explain level of public involvement in the decision to select the proposed project:
The displaced and returning residents of The Spruces continue to experience high stress levels due to
the uncertain future of the park. We have thus far avoided public discussion of this proposed project
so as not to increase stress among the residents pending identification of a potentially feasible
solution.
The pros and cons of the proposed project including: the social, political, administrative,
h i l i l l d i l ifi i f j
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
13/72
It is expected that considerable community discussion will ensue among those who already
appreciate the need for a resolution at the park and the broader community.
Explain why the proposed project was selected over the other alternatives (see section D.):
Proposed project eliminates all threats by relocating park residents at a lower initial cost and minimal
maintenance costs. Alternatives 1 (elevation) and 2 (flood berm) limit protection against flooding to
the design flood standard, and provide no protection against other threats. Flood proofing by
elevating mobile homes is impractical due to the senior population of the park and the limited space
available for the required HP ramps. Flood proofing by constructed berm is unlikely to be permitted.
Both alternatives have significant maintenance burdens.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
14/72
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
D. PROJECT PHOTOGRAPHSPhotograph the project site. Digital photos are strongly encouraged. Also include photos of any
structure or unique features likely to be impacted by the project. Note the position, direction, and date
that the photo was taken on a drawing or sketch of the project site. The Sub-Applicant should also
provide aerial photography of the project area.
SEE APPENDIX C
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
E. PROJECT MAPSProvide a site location map(s) that clearly identifies the proposed project. A United States Geological
Survey (USGS) topographic quadrangle map or a detailed local road map is ideal for use as a location
map. Provide the site location, including a north arrow, title, and legend from the original map on an 8-
1/2 x 11 sheets. Additionally, Provide wetlands map or waterways (if applicable and available), roads,
and other surrounding area should be noted. If applicable, identify adjacent community boundaries.
Assessors maps are strongly encouraged for Acquisition/Relocation/Elevation projects only.
SEE APPENDIX D
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
F. PROJECT DRAWINGSA drawing detailing the proposed project must be included in the Sub-Application. The drawing should
b l h t h th l ti f i ti t t d t t d di
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
15/72
Any structure/land feature likely to be impacted by the proposed project
Cross-Section2. Proposed Conditions (proposed structures are generally a solid line)
Location and dimensions of proposed structures
Limits of proposed fill (est. quantity) or excavation (est. quantity)
Project limits
Limits of encroachment into wetlands or waterbodies
Limits and dimensions of shoreline stabilization (est. quantity)
Major clearing of vegetation (est. area)
Any structure or land feature modified by the proposed project
Drainage area(s) (attach drainage calculations if available) Cross-Section
SEE APPENDIX D
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
16/72
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
G. ALTERNATIVESAttach an evaluation of two (2) feasible alternatives to the proposed project. Try to avoid the No
Action alternative. A description of the alternative projects may include but are not limited to:
A description of the work to be accomplished
The level of protection
The pros and cons of that alternative
A description of why this alternative was not selected
Estimated project costs
A detailed scope, budget, and work schedule is required for the proposed project only. (Not
alternatives)
Alternative #1: Floodproof All Existing Structures Level of Protection: Level of Protection: 100 Year Storm
This alternative would raise all existing structures to an elevation at least one foot above the base flood elevation.
Assume removal of all remaining mobile homes from their existing supports, construct new flood proof supportsystems at avg 6 feet high, reset mobile homes on new support structures, construct handicap accessible rampsto each mobile home, install flood/freeze proof water and sewer connections.
Assume $40,000/ea x 225 $ 9,000,000.00
Replace entire Park electrical distribution system, all above ground, overhead drops, meters on mobile homes
$ 500,000.00
Jack apartment house, extend foundation, reset @ reconnect.
$ 50,000.00Tear down rec hall (expect unsuitable construction to allow jacking), rebuild with flood proof foundation, finishedfloor.
1 foot above base flood elevation. Assume $150/SF demo & rebuild x 9000sf $ 1,350,000.00
Total $10 900 000 00
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
17/72
Alternative #2: Flood Protection System Level of protection: 100 Year Storm
This alternative would construct a levee around the entire inhabitable portion of the park to an elevation sufficientto protect against the 100 year flood. The large diameter storm drain line which drains the Luce Road area and
the Park would need to be fitted with a means to prevent high river water from flooding the park through thedrainage outlet. A pumping system would also be required to eject storm water.
5000lf levee @ $3000/lf $15,000,000.00
Flood gate on drain, pump system $500,000.00
TOTAL $15,500,000.00
ProsProvides protection for homes and personal property in the event of a major floodingevent.
ConsProhibitively expensive.The levee spanning a large portion of the floodway would undoubtedly increase water depth and velocity on otherarea. If fact, the project may not be permitable due to offsite impacts.Required footprint width of the levee may seriously reduce the number of usable mobile home lots.Highly reliant on mechanical systems (flood gates, pumps) to prevent flooding.In the event the levee failed during a flood event, the area inside the enclosure would equalize with the flood waterelevation at an extremely rapid rate, increasing chance of severe property damage and loss of life.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
18/72
H. WORK SCHEDULE
Please provide a detailed work schedule and timeframe for the proposed project (attach a separate
schedule or add additional lines as necessary below).
Make sure work schedule allows for grant administration [contact execution, close-out, etc], final design
and permitting, bidding and advertising, and unanticipated delays. Also consider construction season
FEMA award/performance period may occur during non-construction season. Be conservative and
request more time than you think you needyou will not be penalized for completing the project sooner
than the requested performance period. FEMA allows up to a three year performance period fromthe date of grant award.
TaskMonths from Award
Start CompleteRelocate Residents of Park 1 12
Design & Engineering 1 8
Permitting 9 10
Bidding & Advertising 10 12
Erosion Control 13 36
Site Preparation 13 14
Construction & Demolition 13 30
Utility Relocation 30 36
Administration & Close Out 1 36
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
19/72
J. PROJECT COST INFORMATIONA detailed line item budget/cost estimate including narrative that describes all anticipated cost associated
with the Scope of work for the proposed project. Sub-Applicants are encouraged to be conservative
when developing project cost estimates - grant award notification and ultimate project
implementation/construction may be more than one-year after initial Sub-Application submission.
The proposed project cost estimate should be as detailed as possible, including but not limited to all work
required to implement the proposed mitigation activity:
Pre-Award Costs (studies, analyses, assessments, engineering, etc. used to prepare theapplicationsee Section F.2 Pre-Award Costs in the HMA Unified Guidance for details.)
Survey
Design & Engineering Permitting
Right-of-Way (temporary and permanent easements, construction access & drainage rights,etc.)
Bidding & Advertising
Construction
On-site Construction Management (construction inspection, material testing & certification,item and quantity confirmation, etc.)
Site Preparation Erosion & Sedimentation Control
Utility Relocation/Re-connection
Project costs should be as detailed as possible and include specific line item name, quantities, rates, units
of measurement (SF, CY, LF, etc.), unit costs, etc. Sub-Applicants should provide the source of the
estimate (e.g. documented local cost, bids from qualified professionals, published national or local cost
estimating guides). Lump Sums should be avoided when possible.
If in-kind contributions of labor or materials devoted to the project are being claimed as part of the
grant match requirements, provide documentation of the basis for the valuation of the contributions.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
20/72
Pre-Irene value of Spruces Mobile Home Park $6,428,000.00
Relocation cost for remaining residents (65 x $22,500) $1,462,500.00
Displaced 180 day owner/occupant rental assistance (65 x $5,250) $ 341,250.00
Total Project Value $8,231,750.00
FEMA share (75%) $6,173,812.50
Local Share (Morgan Management as loss from park value) (25%) $2,057,937.50
Expenses
Uniform Relocation Act compensation for 65 mobile home owners $1,462,500.00
Displaced 180 day owner/occupant rental assistance (65 x $5,250) $ 341,250.00
SURVEY Not Applicable
DESIGN - ENGINEERING $ 25,000.00
PERMITTING $ 5,000.00
BIDDING & ADVERTISING $ 10,000.00
UTILITY RELOCATION & RETIREMENT
Disconnect/Cap water services(2) in Main St $ 5,000.00
Re-lay Town sewer mains (2) through park eliminating all taps $ 50,000.00
Cut off Power, Phone & CATV at Main St pole(s)To be completed by wire
utilities at no cost
Cut off/Cap gas in Main StTo be completed by
Berkshire Gas at no cost
Remove all above ground panels/poles/wires in Park +-75 units @ $200/ea $ 15,000.00
All remaining underground pipes/conduits and wires within Park area shall be abandoned inplace
CONSTRUCTIONDemolition of remaining structures
65 mobile homes @ AVG $3500 ea
+ Apt House & Rec Hall + 13000sf @ $10/sf $ 357 500 00
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
21/72
K. ESTIMATED PROJECT COST SHARE
Provide the cost and funding cost share information (round figures to the nearest dollar). The maximum
FEMA share for a HMGP project is 75%.
Funding Sources Funding Amount % of Total Costs
Federal $6,173,812 Maximum 75%
Non Federal (local share) $2,057,938 Minimum 25%
Total Project Cost $8,231,750 100%
For private homeowner elevation/utility retrofit and acquisitions projects, where the non-federal share is
being provided by the homeowner(s), please include documentation from the homeowner(s) committingto the non-federal share and any ongoing or necessary maintenance.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
22/72
L. OTHER FUNDING AGENCIESHas this project been submitted to any other Federal agency as a possible source of funding?
Yes No Unknown
Has funding been approved for this project from any other Federal or State agency?
Yes No
IfYes, from either of the above, provide the following information:
Agency Name
Address
Contact Name
Phone Number
Amount $
M. MITIGATION PLAN STATUS & INFORMATIONPlease indicate the status of the Multi-Hazard Mitigation Plan
(plan must meet requirements of 44 CFR Part 201):
No Plan [A FEMA-approved hazard mitigation planconsistent with 44 CFR Part 201
is a pre-requisite for all FEMA mitigation grant programs.]
FEMA Approved ( d L ll d t d) l i di t FEMA l d t
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
23/72
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
N. PUBLIC NOTICE/OFFICIAL NEWSPAPER INFORMATIONFEMA is required to publish a Public Notice for any project that has the potential to affect a wetland orfloodplain.
Provide the following about your communitys official newspaper(s):
Name THE ADVOCATE & THE NORTH ADAMS TRANSCRIPT
Address 85 Main Street, Suite 2North Adams, MA 01247
Telephone # (413) 663-3741
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
O. REQUIRED BENEFIT-COST ANALYSIS (BCA) INFORMATION
SEE APPENDIX E
Sub-Applicants are required to submit one (1) electronic copy of the completed BCA (exported zip
file) and one (1) printed hardcopy of the BCA report from the FEMA Benefit-Cost Analysis
Software Version 4.5 as part of the official HMGP Sub-Application.
Benefit-cost analysis (BCA) is a standardized, systematic way to count the benefits of a mitigationproject and to compare these benefits to the costs of mitigation. A complete benefit-cost analysis counts
all of the significant direct benefits of a mitigation project A benefit cost analysis always involves
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
24/72
Benefits of a proposed mitigation project can be sorted into four main categories:
Avoided Physical Damages Buildings Contents Infrastructure Landscaping Site Contamination Vehicles Equipment
Avoided Loss-of-Function Costs Displacement costs for temporary quarters Loss of rental income Loss of business income Lost wages Disruption time for residents Loss of public services Economic impact of loss of utility services Economic impact of road/bridge closures
Avoided Casualties DeathsInjuriesIllnesses
Avoided Emergency Management Costs Emergency operations center costsEvacuation or rescue costsSecurity costsTemporary protective measure costs
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
25/72
Does your project involve the disturbance of ground?
Yes No Unknown
If yes please describe the past use and dimensions of the area to be disturbed: _Past use of the area is
occupancy by mobile homes, disturbed area is approximately 32 acres.
Are State and/or Federally listed threatened or endangered species or their critical habitat present in the
area affected by the project?
Yes No Unknown
If yes, please describe: __The area of the Spruces Property in close proximity to the Hoosic River and
Paull Brook is designated by Massachusetts as an estimated habitat area of rare or endangered species.
Does your proposed project meet or exceed any Massachusetts Environmental Policy Act (MEPA)
thresholds for preparation of an Environmental Notification Form (ENF), or mandatory Environmental
Impact Report (EIR)? www.env.state.ma.us/mepa/regs/11-03.aspx
Yes No Unknown
Please describe: ___Property currently under conservation will be swapped for the land that currently
contains the Spruces once remediation has been completed. This land will remain permanently conserved
floodplain land.
http://www.env.state.ma.us/mepa/regs/11-03.aspxhttp://www.env.state.ma.us/mepa/regs/11-03.aspxhttp://www.env.state.ma.us/mepa/regs/11-03.aspx7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
26/72
3. Is the project in an area regulated by the Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act(http://www.mass.gov/dep/service/regulations/310cmr10a.pdf), including the Rivers ProtectionAct (http://www.mass.gov/dep/water/laws/rpa01.htm)?
Yes No
4. Is the project located in (or adjacent to) an Area of Critical Environmental Concern (ACEC)?A list and map of ACECs is available at:
http://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/listACEC.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/statewideMap.pdf
Yes No
5. Is there a Flood Insurance Study (FIS) available for your community?
Yes
No
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
R. FLOODPLAIN LOCATIONFIRMETTE ATTACHED AS APPENDIX FFlood mitigation and drainage improvement project Sub-Applications must include a Firmette or copy of
the flood insurance rate map (FIRM). The project location and community panel number must be
clearly identified. Firmettes can be created on-line from FEMAs map service center at:http://msc.fema.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/femawelcomeview?storeid=10001&catalogid=10001&langid=-1
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
http://www.mass.gov/dep/service/regulations/310cmr10a.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dep/service/regulations/310cmr10a.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dep/service/regulations/310cmr10a.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dep/water/laws/rpa01.htmhttp://www.mass.gov/dep/water/laws/rpa01.htmhttp://www.mass.gov/dep/water/laws/rpa01.htmhttp://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/listACEC.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/listACEC.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/statewideMap.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/statewideMap.pdfhttp://msc.fema.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/FemaWelcomeView?storeId=10001&catalogId=10001&langId=-1http://msc.fema.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/FemaWelcomeView?storeId=10001&catalogId=10001&langId=-1http://msc.fema.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/FemaWelcomeView?storeId=10001&catalogId=10001&langId=-1http://msc.fema.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/FemaWelcomeView?storeId=10001&catalogId=10001&langId=-1http://msc.fema.gov/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/FemaWelcomeView?storeId=10001&catalogId=10001&langId=-1http://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/statewideMap.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dcr/stewardship/acec/listACEC.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/dep/water/laws/rpa01.htmhttp://www.mass.gov/dep/service/regulations/310cmr10a.pdf7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
27/72
4. Based on the FIRM, indicate the flood zone(s) of the project site(s) (e.g., A10, C, AE, V): _A8___
100-Year (base) flood elevation at the site is 613 608 Ft. [NGVD 29 (MSL)]
Source of 100-year (base) flood elevation: Spruces Flood Study, 2005, Vincent Guntlow &
Associates (This information can be provided as best available data from sources such as:
MA DCR, local engineering records, etc.)
Coastal Barrier Resource Area Otherwise Protected Area (OPA)
5. Floodplain Consultation (Coordination/consultation with the local floodplain administrator is stronglyencouraged if the proposed project is located in, or near mapped special flood hazard areas).
Local Floodplain Administrator:
Name: __Michael Card_______________________ Phone: __413-458-9344__
Local Floodplain Administrator consulted? Date: __3/16/2012_____Yes No
Provide Floodplain Administrator Comments:
Acquisition of this property would significantly reduce the flood danger to residents inWilliamstown. The placement of mobile homes in a regulatory floodway is an extremelydangerous situation. Moving these residents out of harms way will be greatly beneficial to all
stakeholders involved.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
28/72
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
29/72
$ 6,428,000
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
30/72
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
31/72
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
W. PROPERTY ACQUISITION/RELOCATION/ELEVATION WORKSHEET
(Prepare separate worksheets for each individual property)
Property Owner Spruces MHC, LLC Public X PrivateTax Map, Lot or Parcel Number 112-19
Rental Property Yes
No
Tenants Name __See Attached______ (If more than one tenant provide separate sheet w/ complete list)
If tenant occupied provide estimated relocation assistance costs $ Include three or more photographs showing the front, side and rear views of the structure as well as
illustrating the surrounding properties. Digital photos are strongly encouraged.
If the structure has been certified Substantially Damaged please check this box and attach a copy ofcertification from your local flood plain administrator or local building inspector. For this property provide
property owners name, street address and complete section 3 of this worksheet.
1. Site InformationAddress (or Physical Legal Location): 60 Main Street, Williamstown, MA 01267
Structure located in 100-year floodplain:Yes
No Base Flood Elevation for Property: 613 ft Lowest Finished Floor of Structure: 610 ft (indicate elevation datum__NGD 1929_)
2. Structural Information
Year of Construction - 1953 Total Square Footage of Principal Structure 2870 (sf)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
32/72
Estimated Cost for Site Restoration $ Additional Fees/Surveys/Relocation Assistance $ Other (describe) $
b. Relocation Total Cost $ NOT APPLICABLE : STRUCTURE TO BE DEMOLISHED
Fair Market Value of Existing Land $ Architectural, Engineering, Surveying, etc. $ Relocation Costs $ Estimated Cost for Site Restoration $ Estimated Cost for Appraisal $ Other (describe) $
c. Elevation Total Cost $ NOT APPLICABLE : STRUCTURE TO BE DEMOLISHED
Elevation of Structure $ Utility Relocation/Reconnection $ Architectural, Engineering, Surveying, etc. $ Incidental sitework/restoration $ Displacement $ Other (describe) $
TENANT INFORMATIONApt 3: VACANT (1BR)
Apt5: RICHARD HASKINS (3BR)
Apt6: KENNETH BLISS (1BR)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
33/72
Photo 1: Northeasterly face of apartment building.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
34/72
Photo 3: Southerly face of apartment building.
W. PROPERTY ACQUISITION/RELOCATION/ELEVATION WORKSHEET
(Prepare separate worksheets for each individual property)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
35/72
Structure located in 100-year floodplain:
Yes
No Base Flood Elevation for Property: 613 ft Lowest Finished Floor of Structure: 608 ft (indicate elevation datum_NGD 1929
2. Structural Information
Year of Construction - 1954 Total Square Footage of Principal Structure 6120 (sf) Building Type:
1-Story w/o basement 1-Story w/ basement 2-Story w/o basement 2-Story w/ basement Split Level w/o basement Split Level w/ basement Mobile Home X Other : Office & Meeting Hall
Foundation Type: Basement (Walkout Y/N) CrawlspaceX Slab-on-grade
3. Structure Cost Information
a. Acquisition Total Cost $ NOT APPLICABLE : INCLUDED IN TOTAL COST OF PARK
Fair Market Value (FMV) $ $44,800 Estimated Cost for Demolition $ Estimated Cost for Appraisal $ Estimated Closing Costs $ Estimated Cost for Site Restoration $
Additional Fees/S r e s/Relocation Assistance $
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
36/72
Recreation Building northwestern corner.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
37/72
Recreation Building southwest corner and south face.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
38/72
W. PROPERTY ACQUISITION/RELOCATION/ELEVATION WORKSHEET AG
(Prepare separate worksheets for each individual property)
Property Owner Spruces MHC, LLC Public XPrivateTax Map, Lot or Parcel Number 112-19
Rental Property Yes
No
Tenants Name _SEE ATTACHED____ (If more than one tenant provide separate sheet w/ complete list)If tenant occupied provide estimated relocation assistance costs $
Include three or more photographs showing the front, side and rear views of the structure aswell as illustrating the surrounding properties. Digital photos are strongly encouraged.
If the structure has been certified Substantially Damaged please check this box and attach acopy of certification from your local flood plain administrator or local building inspector. For
this property provide property owners name, street address and complete section 3 of thisworksheet.
2. Site InformationAddress (or Physical Legal Location): 60 Main Street, Williamstown, MA 01267
Structure located in 100-year floodplain:Yes No
Base Flood Elevation for Property: 610 613 ftLowest Finished Floor of Structure: Varies
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
39/72
Fair Market Value (FMV) $ Estimated Cost for Demolition $ Estimated Cost for Appraisal $ Estimated Closing Costs $ Estimated Cost for Site Restoration $ Additional Fees/Surveys/Relocation Assistance $ Other (describe) $
b. Relocation Total Cost $ NOT APPLICABLE : STRUCTURE TO BE DEMOLISHED
Fair Market Value of Existing Land $ Architectural, Engineering, Surveying, etc. $ Relocation Costs $ Estimated Cost for Site Restoration $ Estimated Cost for Appraisal $ Other (describe) $
c. Elevation Total Cost $ NOT APPLICABLE : STRUCTURE TO BE DEMOLISHED
Elevation of Structure $ Utility Relocation/Reconnection $ Architectural, Engineering, Surveying, etc. $ Incidental sitework/restoration $ Displacement $ Other (describe) $
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
40/72
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
41/72
This Section Not Required for Planning Applications
X. PROPERTY ACQUISITION/RELOCATION/ELEVATION CERTIFICATION
Participation in this Sub-Application is voluntary and prospective homeowners may withdraw theirparticipation at any time prior to contract initiation.
Check One:
The Sub-Applicant will contribute the local matching share in its entirety.
X The individual homeowner/property owner(s) will provide the local match in its entirety. Pleaseinclude documentation from the homeowner(s) committing to the non-federal share and any ongoingor necessary maintenance.
The Sub-Applicant has asked homeowners to voluntarily donate up to 25% of proceeds of theirproperty towards the Sub-Applicants matching share. In doing so, the homeowner is essentiallyagreeing to accept a minimum of 75% of the fair market value for the purchase of their real property.Participation in property acquisition and relocation projects by property owners is voluntary.Documentation of voluntary interest for property acquisition must be submitted as part of the sub-
application; sample notices of voluntary interest are available at:www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/vol_notice2.shtm
For structures that remain in the SFHA after the implementation of the mitigation project, floodinsurance must be maintained for the life of the structure to an amount at least equal to the project cost orto the maximum limit of coverage made available with respect to the particular property, whichever isless. Insurance coverage on the property must be maintained during the life of the property regardless of
transfer of ownership of such property.
The sub-grantee (or property owner) must legally record, with the county or appropriate jurisdictionsland records a notice that includes the name of the current property owner (including book/page
http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/vol_notice2.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/vol_notice2.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/vol_notice2.shtm7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
42/72
Y. CONTACT INFORMATION
For additional information concerningHMGP project eligibility and/or Sub-Application process
contact:
Scott MacLeod, Mitigation Grants Coordinator Richard Zingarelli, State Hazard Mitigation OfficerMA Emergency Management Agency MA Department of Conservation and Recreation400 Worcester Road Flood Hazard Management ProgramFramingham, MA 01702 251 Causeway St., Ste. 800, Boston, MA 02114-2104(508) 820-1445 (617) [email protected] [email protected]
For additional information concerning theNationwide Rivers Inventory classification contact:
Jamie Fosburgh, National Park ServiceRivers, Trails and Conservation Assistance15 State StreetBoston, MA 02109(617) [email protected]
Questions related to theArea of Critical Environmental Concern (ACEC) designation can be directedto:
Elizabeth Sorenson, DirectorACEC Program
Massachusetts Department of Conservation and RecreationDivision of Resource Conservation251 Causeway St., Ste. 700, Boston, MA 02114-2104(617) 626 1394
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
43/72
APPENDIX AMITIGATION GRANT PROGRAM RESOURCES
HAZARD MITIGATION GRANT PROGRAMS:PDM Info: http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/pdm/index.shtm
FMA Info: http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/fma/index.shtm
SRL Info: http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/srl/index.shtm
RFC Info: http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/rfc/index.shtm
Unified HMA Guidance: http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=4225
Grant Applicant Resources: http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/hma/grant_resources.shtm e-Grants:
E-Grants website: https://portal.fema.gov/famsVuWeb/home
e-Grants Course website:http://training.fema.gov/EMIWeb/IS/is30.asp
E-Grants Helpdesk: (866)476-0544 [email protected]
To obtain e-grants access contact:
Sherry Leung, Asst. Hazard Mitigation Coordinatoror
Scott MacLeod, Mitigation Grants Coordinator
Phone: 508-820-1436e-mail:[email protected]
Phone: 508-820-1445e-mail:[email protected]
OTHER RESOURCES:Benefit-Cost Analysis Software Download and related Toolkit:http://www.bcahelpline.com/
Benefit-Cost Analysis Helpline: (866)222-3580 [email protected]
Engineering Helpline: (866)[email protected]
E /Hi i H l li (866)222 3580 hh l li @dh
http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/pdm/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/pdm/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/fma/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/fma/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/srl/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/srl/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/rfc/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/rfc/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=4225http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=4225http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/hma/grant_resources.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/hma/grant_resources.shtmhttps://portal.fema.gov/famsVuWeb/homehttps://portal.fema.gov/famsVuWeb/homehttp://training.fema.gov/EMIWeb/IS/is30.asphttp://training.fema.gov/EMIWeb/IS/is30.asphttp://training.fema.gov/EMIWeb/IS/is30.aspmailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.bcahelpline.com/http://www.bcahelpline.com/http://www.bcahelpline.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.bcahelpline.com/mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]://training.fema.gov/EMIWeb/IS/is30.asphttps://portal.fema.gov/famsVuWeb/homehttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/hma/grant_resources.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=4225http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/rfc/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/srl/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/fma/index.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/pdm/index.shtm7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
44/72
Hazard Mitigation Resources inCoastal Environments:
Coastal Zone ManagementStormSmart Coasts: http://www.mass.gov/czm/stormsmart/index.htm
Massachusetts River & Stream Crossing Standards:
http://www.nae.usace.army.mil/reg/Stream/MA_RiverStreamCrossingStandards.pdf
Procedures for Developing Scopes of Work for a Draining/Stormwater Management Project:
http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1846
Procedures for Developing Scopes of Work for the Elevation of Floodprone Structures:
http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1844
Procedures for Developing Scopes of Work for Wind Retrofit Projects:
http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1876
Procedures for Developing Scopes of Work for Protective Measures Retrofit Projects for Utility, Water, and
Sanitary Systems and Infrastructure:
http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1881
PROPERTY ACQUISITION HANDBOOK FOR LOCAL COMMUNITIES:http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/acqhandbook.shtm
Engineering Case Studies by Project Type:
FEMA has developed sample engineering case studies to provide the types of information and data needed to ensurecompleteness of the sections of project applications affecting engineering feasibility for several common mitigationmeasures. The Engineering Case Studies below are available from the FEMA Information Resources Library:
Minor Structural Flood Control Projects (http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1863)
Elevation (http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1862)
Acquisition (http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1861)
http://www.mass.gov/czm/stormsmart/index.htmhttp://www.mass.gov/czm/stormsmart/index.htmhttp://www.nae.usace.army.mil/reg/Stream/MA_RiverStreamCrossingStandards.pdfhttp://www.nae.usace.army.mil/reg/Stream/MA_RiverStreamCrossingStandards.pdfhttp://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1846http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1846http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1844http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1844http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1876http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1876http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1881http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1881http://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/acqhandbook.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/acqhandbook.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/government/grant/resources/acqhandbook.shtmhttp://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1881http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1876http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1844http://www.fema.gov/library/viewRecord.do?id=1846http://www.nae.usace.army.mil/reg/Stream/MA_RiverStreamCrossingStandards.pdfhttp://www.mass.gov/czm/stormsmart/index.htm7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
45/72
Appendix BHMGP Project review criteria
HMGP Project Evaluation Criteria
The proposals will be evaluated and prioritized by the State Hazard Mitigation Interagency Committeeand the State Hazard Mitigation Team according to the following criteria.
1. The project application clearly describes the hazard/problem the proposed mitigation project isintended to address.
2. Hazard Mitigation measure that, if not taken, will have a detrimental impact on the applicant, such
as potential loss of life, loss of essential services, damage to critical facilities/infrastructure, and/oreconomic hardship.
3. The proposed project clearly describes the solution to the hazard/problem. This includes a detailedscope of work, budget, and alternative analysis. The proposed project appears to be the mostpractical, effective, and environmentally sound alternative.
4. Application describes how the proposed project will provide long-term hazard mitigation benefits.
The level of protection that will exist after the project is implemented is clearly defined.
5. The project application clearly demonstrates that the project is cost-effective-anticipated benefitsof the mitigation activity exceed the project costs. A well-defined Benefit-Cost Analysis (BCA) isprovided with relevant supporting documentation.
6. The application demonstrates the capability of the applicant to implement and complete the projectin a timely manner. This includes all environmental permitting, state and local, which are required.
7. The application demonstrates the commitment of the applicant to get the project accomplished.This includes providing documentation of the availability of the non-federal cost match,description of relevant public/private partnerships.
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
46/72
Appendix C:
Project Photographs & Location Map
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
47/72
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
!?
9
8
4
2 22
21
20
19
18
16
12
10
572 70
3
81
78
73
89
71
90
81
85
77
88
1
88
95
92
93
86
84
91 91
7776
77
82
86
87
75
93
75
85
94
7979
82
90
75
74
96
87
92
95
94
87
89
82
7371
88
83
72
96
74
79
7171
87
89
140
73
78
80
7879
81
75 73
85
88
72
68
73
69
80
72
79
84
80
75
83
68
80
91
80
86
93
96
130
74
142
68
82
89
125
138 132
90
71 69
82
92
83
80
74
100
77
95
71
79
136
85
94
76
76
83
74
77
134
7675
70
7778
72
76
78
127
110
83 84
81
74
112
78
76
116
91
114
104
73
10286
108
70
81
106
85
118
RiversideDrive
Higgin D i Higgi C t
EmeraldLane
Nutm
egLane B
achandAvenue
Lan
gloisAvenue
The Spruces Mobile Home Park
-Photo Locations-
Hoosic
Riv
er
nue
Green points with numbersrepresent the following photographs
of the Spruces Mobile Home Park.Aerial Orthophoto April 2009, MassGIS.
1 inch = 200 feet
r
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
48/72
Spruces Mobile Home Park : Tropical Storm Irene Flooding & Damage
1) Spruces Mobile Home Park at height of flood, water depth on Recreation Building (center, left) is approximately 4 feet deep.
(8/28/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
49/72
2) Corner of Champagne and Riverside Avenues in The Spruces, Hoosic River is behind the blue mobile home; photo taken shortly
after overtopping of floodwall. (8/28/11)
3) Local Fire Department volunteers evacuating residents who did not heed pre storm evacuation order. (8/28/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
50/72
5) Higgins Drive in The Spruces, as seen from Main Street, near height of flooding. Water is approximately 5 feet in depth. (8/28/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
51/72
7) Flooding damaged most utility connections to mobile homes such as this electric junction box at 54 Bachand Ave. (8/29/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
52/72
9) High water line, 72 Emerald Lane. (8/29/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
53/72
11) This floating debris caused damage to mobile homes. This former fence slat broke through skirting and further damaged the
under carriage of 55 Langlois Avenue. (8/29/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
54/72
13) More examples of scouring action on soil, such as near this landscaped wall on Higgins Court. Similar soil excavations via water
occurred under many mobile homes, this was especially destabilizing to mobile homes not placed upon concrete slab foundations.
Scouring action caused tipping and destabilizing of pier systems of many units. (8/29/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
55/72
15) 64 Langlois Avenue with shifted and sunk piers. (8/29/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
56/72
17) The park experienced significant damage to home infrastructure such as this outdoor central air conditioning unit at 57 Langlois
Avenue. This unit was completely submerged. (8/29/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
57/72
19) Siltation covers Riverside Drive. (8/29/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
58/72
21) Floodwall and Hoosac Water Quality District sewer easement where floodwaters entered the property (8/30/11)
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
59/72
Appendix D:
Project Maps & Drawings
Site Location Map
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
60/72
Nort
hA
dams
Willia
mstown
Project Location:Spruces Mobile Home Park
Site Location Map
RailroadWetland & Waterway Location Map
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
61/72
H
oosicR
iver
Railroad
Parcels
Property Lines
Land of Spruces MHP
WetlandsDeep Marsh
Shallow Marsh
Shurb Swamp
Wooded Swamp
Water
Floodplain
100 yr Floodplain
500 yr Floodplain
FloodWay
Wetland & Waterway Location Map
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
62/72
The Spruces
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
63/72
Hoosic R
iver
p
Mobile Home Park
-Proposed Conditions-
PaullB
rook
Boundary Lines
Town Line
Property Lines
Other Property Lines
Land of Spruces MHP
Natural Features
Waterway
Deep Marsh
Shallow Marsh
Shurb Swamp
Wooded Swamp
Vegetation
1 inch = 200 feetCreated: 3/28/2012Cartography: Andrew Groff, PlannerData Sources: FEMA, MassGIS, Cartographic Associates, Williamstown DIS, Williamstown DPW
The proposal will remove all existing structureswithin the subject property.
All associated infrastructure, including sanitary sewer,natural gas, electricty will be retired.
Only minor clearing of vegetation will take place.Roadways will be reclaimed and removed.
Only structure to remain will be floodwall andassociated sewer main along the Hoosic River bank.
Flood Zones
100 yr Floodplain
500 yr Floodplain
FloodWay
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
64/72
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
65/72
Appendix E:
Benefit Cost Analysis
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 1 of 5The Spruces MHC
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
66/72
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 1 of 5
Total Benefits: Total Costs: BCR:
Project Number: Disaster #: Program: Agency:
State: Point of Contact: Analyst:
2012-01 DR 4028 HMGP Town of Williamstown
Massachusetts
The Spruces MHC
$8,339,549 $6,202,351 1.34
Peter FohlinPeter Fohlin
Comments:
Structure Summary For:
Spruces Mobile Home Park, 60 Main Street, Williamstown, Massachusetts, 01267, Berkshire
$8,339,549 $6,202,351Benefits: Costs:
Structure Type: Historic Building: Contact:Other No
1.34BCR:
Project Summary:
Point of Contact:
Address:
Peter Fohlin
31 North Street, Williamstown, Massachusetts, 01267
Project Number: Disaster #:
Program:
Analyst:
2012-01 DR 4028
HMGP Town of Williamstown
Peter Fohlin
413.458.3500Phone Number:
Email: [email protected]
Agency:
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 2 of 5The Spruces MHC
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
67/72
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 2 of 5
Total Benefits: Total Costs: BCR:
Project Number: Disaster #: Program: Agency:
State: Point of Contact: Analyst:
2012-01 DR 4028 HMGP Town of Williamstown
Massachusetts
The Spruces MHC
$8,339,549 $6,202,351 1.34
Peter FohlinPeter Fohlin
Structure and Mitigation Details For:
Benefits: Costs: BCR:
Spruces Mobile Home Park, 60 Main Street, Williamstown, Massachusetts, 01267,Berkshire
$8,339,549 $6,202,351 1.34
Project Useful Life: 100Latitude: Longitude:
Hazard: Damage-Frequency Assessment - Flood
Mitigation Option: Acquisition
Mitigation Information
Basis of Damages:
Number of Damage Events:
Expected Damages
2
2Number of Events with Know Recurrence
Intervals:
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 3 of 5The Spruces MHC
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
68/72
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 3 of 5
Total Benefits: Total Costs: BCR:
Project Number: Disaster #: Program: Agency:
State: Point of Contact: Analyst:
2012-01 DR 4028 HMGP Town of Williamstown
Massachusetts
The Spruces MHC
$8,339,549 $6,202,351 1.34
Peter FohlinPeter Fohlin
Damages After MitigationDamages Before Mitigation
Expected Damages Before and After Mitigation
Analysis Year:
Year Built:
Analysis Duration:
User Input Analysis Duration:
Utilities ($/day):
Buildings ($/day):
Roads/Bridges ($/day):
2012
1954
59
Damage Year: RI: 14.00
Are Damages In Current Dollars? Yes
Buildings (Days): Utilities (Days):
FEMA Grants Paid ($) $3,597,195Lost Property Value ($) $4,585,000
Total $8,182,195
Total Inflated
Damage Year: RI: 14.00Are Damages In Current Dollars? Yes
Buildings (Days): Utilities (Days): Roads (Days):
Lost Property Value ($) $0FEMA Grants Paid ($) $0
Total $0
RI: 14.00Are Damages In Current Dollars? Yes
Buildings (Days): Utilities (Days): Roads(Days):
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 4 of 5The Spruces MHC
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
69/72
y j g
Total Benefits: Total Costs: BCR:
Project Number: Disaster #: Program: Agency:
State: Point of Contact: Analyst:
2012-01 DR 4028 HMGP Town of Williamstown
Massachusetts
p
$8,339,549 $6,202,351 1.34
Peter FohlinPeter Fohlin
Cost Estimate
Project Useful Life (years):
Detailed Scope of Work:
Detailed Estimate for Entire Project:
Mitigation Project Cost:
Annual Project Maintenance Cost:
Final Mitigation Project Cost:
100
Yes
Yes$6,173,812
$6,202,351
$2,000
100
$28,539
Yes
Years of Maintenance:
Present Worth of Annual Maintenance Costs:
Estimate Reflects Current Prices:
Cost Basis Year:
Construction Start Year:
Construction End Year: Project Escalation:
Construction Type:
Summary Of Benefits
Expected Annual Damages BeforeMitigation
Expected Annual Damages AfterMitigation
Expected Avoided Damages AfterMitigation (Benefits)
Annual:
Present Value: $8,339,549
$584,442 Annual:
Present Value:
$0
$0
Annual:
Present Value:
$584,442
$8,339,549
Mitigation Benefits: $8,339,549 Mitigation Costs: $6,202,351
Benefits Minus Costs: Benefit-Cost Ratio:$2,137,198 1.34
31 May 2012 Project: Pg 5 of 5The Spruces MHC
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
70/72
y j g
Total Benefits: Total Costs: BCR:
Project Number: Disaster #: Program: Agency:
State: Point of Contact: Analyst:
2012-01 DR 4028 HMGP Town of Williamstown
Massachusetts
p
$8,339,549 $6,202,351 1.34
Peter FohlinPeter Fohlin
Justification/Attachments
Mitigation Project Cost Documented in attached DetailedScope and Cost Estimate.
Detailed Scope and Cost Estimate.pdf
Project useful life Project Useful Life Summary Table -Acquisition/Relocation - All Structures -100 years standard value
Unknown Frequency - Damagesafter Mitigation
Property to become Town owned andsubject to permanent deed restriction.
Year Built Williamstown, The First 250 Years,Williamstown House of Local History,page 437.
Spruces_YearBuilt.pdf
Expected damages beforemitigation
Historical USGS and US Army Corps ofEngineers data document 6 catastrophicflood events in 84 years.Town of Williamstown Board ofAssessors pre-Irene less post-Ireneassessed value @ 7% discount rate.FEMA Grants Paid through 03-19-12.
Spruces FEMA Briefing 03-19-12.pdf;Spruces FEMA Briefing 01-27-12.pdf;FEMA Spruces Grants Paid as of 03-19-12.pdf;Spruces MHC Assessed Value Post-Irene.pdf;Spruces MHC Assessed Value Pre-Irene.pdf;HoosicFloodHistory.pdf
Analysis Year Current calendar year
Annual Project Maintenance Cost $2,000 Annual maintenance mowing by
Town of deed restricted parcel, postacquisition.
Field Description Attachments
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
71/72
Appendix F:
FEMA Firmette
7/29/2019 Williamstown Hazard Mitigation Grant Application
72/72
Project Location