8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
1/26
TOPIC 4ISSUES ON THEAPPLICATION OF
ACCOUNTING STANDARDSFair Value AccountingPresente !or"
Dr# S$a%rul A%&ar A%&a
Presente '$"A(lina 'inti A%a&atNa(ura% 'inti )ista&a&Nurul S$a(*ani 'inti Rosli
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
2/26
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
3/26
Ans*erLans&an -.//01
• Accoring to )art% -23341 ,ns t%atin5est&ent securities6 !air 5alues areincre&entall$ associate *it% 'an7 s%are
8rices a!ter controlling !or in5est&entsecurities6 'oo7 5alues#
• )art% et al# -23391 also ,n e5ience t%atloans6 !air 5alues are also incre&entall$
in!or&ati5e relati5e to t%eir 'oo7 5alues ine:8laining 'an7 s%are 8rices#
• Fair 5alues o! loans re;ect in!or&ationregaring t%e e!ault an interest rate ris7 o!
t%ose loans#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
4/26
• T%e$ consier re
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
5/26
Ans*er " Georgiou ? @ac7-./221Use o! FV &easure&ent on t%e
asset
• In IAS 29 Accounting !or Pro8ert$ Plant an
E
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
6/26
Use o! FV on t%e asset• IAS 2= Re5enue Recognition o'ser5e t%at t%e a&ount o!
re5enue in an e:c%ange o! non&onetar$ assets is nor&all$eter&ine using t%e !air 5alue o! t%e assets e:c%ange *%ilstIAS .. Accounting !or )usiness Co&'inations also incluere!erence to !air 5alues#
•
FRS 2B Tangi'le Fi:e Assets *%ic% 8er&its a c%oice as to*%et%er tangi'le ,:e assets are state at cost or at a re5alue
a&ount# T%ese stanars containe t%e conce8t o! !air 5alue*%ic% uring t%e 233/s 8la$e an increasingl$ 8ro&inent role int%e stanars o! t%e IASC an se5eral national stanar setters#
• T%roug% IAS 4/ In5est&ent Pro8ert$ t%at a88lies FVA to non,nancial assets an IAS 42 Agriculture -'ot% issue in .///1
re
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
7/26
Use o! FV &easure&ent on t%elia'ilit$
• ,rst inclue t%e conce8t o! !air5alue in t%e 2300 ra!ts o! IAS 20Accounting !or Leases# In IAS 20 !air
5alue 8la$e a role in eter&iningt%e classi,cation o! a lease as eit%era ,nance lease or an o8erating lease
as *ell as in t%e eter&ination o!8ro,t or loss in sale an lease'ac7transactions#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
8/26
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
9/26
+uestion B
T%e use o! !air 5alue&easure&ents 8ro5ies
&ore rele5ant in!or&ation#Discuss#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
10/26
Ans*er)all -.//91
• Accoring to )all -.//91 %as state t%at t%eFV accounting rules aim to incorporate more-timely information about economic gains andlosses on securities, derivatives and other
transactions into the nancial statements,and to incorporate more timely information.• Fair 5alue incorporates more information into
the nancial statements#• Incor8orating &ore in!or&ation in t%e
,nancial state&ents '$ e,nition &a7es t%e&&ore in!or&ati5e *it% 8otential a5antagesto in5estors an ot%er t%ings e
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
11/26
Ans*erLans&an -.//01
• Accoring to Lans&an -.//01 t%e !air 5alues*oul mitigate the use of accounting motivated-transaction structures designed to exploitopportunities for earnings management #
•
Fair 5alue accounting !or all ,nancial instru&ents*oul reduce the complexity of nancialreporting arising !ro& t%e &i:e attri'ute&oel#
• T%e researc% ,nings suggest t%at disclosed andrecognized fair values are informative toinvestors 'ut t%at t%e le5el o! in !or&ati5eness isaecte '$ t%e a&ount o! &easure&ent erroran source o! t%e esti&ates &anage&ent ore:ternal a88raisers#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
12/26
Ans*erOncioiu et al# -./2.1
• Eac% o! t%e current values measures a current ratherthan an historical attribute of the asset and looks to themarket rather than the specic transaction for evidence'ut t%is leas in eac% case to a egree o! esti&ation
'ecause t%e current &easures are not 'ase on actualtransactions 'ut u8on transactions t%at &ig%t ta7e 8lacein &ar7ets t%at are !ar !ro& 8er!ect an in t%e e:tre&e&a$ not e5en e:ist#
• T%ese ecisions are assu&e to 'e 8ri&aril$ t%ose &ae
'$ an in5estor an t%e$ t%ere!ore relate primarily to the prediction of future cash ows# Ho*e5er 8reiction oesnot i&8l$ &erel$ !orecasting an t%e concerns o!
ste*ars%i8 are also assu&e to 'e inclue in t%eo'ecti5e#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
13/26
Ans*erOncioiu et al# -./2.1
Continue• Ho*e5er *%en t%e cost &easure use is t%e
%istorical cost it coul 'e argue t%at suc%&easures cannot 'e co&8are in anecono&icall$ &eaning!ul *a$ 'ecause t%e&easure is e8enent on t%e ti&e o! ac
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
14/26
Ans*erDeans -.//01
• T%e !air 5alue information to vary in relevancedepending on sector *%ic% 8riceto'oo7&easures are *iel$ use !or 5aluation 8ur8osesan t%ere!ore !air 5alue in!or&ation !or 'alance
s%eet ite&s to 'e &ore 5alue rele5ant in t%esesectors#
• T%e extent of usefulness of fair value informationto depend on the types of assets and liabilities#
• T%e FV !re
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
15/26
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
16/26
Ans*er+ua% -./2.1
• T%e !air 5alue &easure&ent an isclosuresu88osel$ provide appropriate information torationalize the decision making process
• T%e greater uality of accounting informationand best informative content of the nancialreporting for managers on various organizationallevels or other stakeholders associated with theorganization.
• Poon -.//41 re8orte t%at !air5alue accounting8ro5ies &ore suita'le an &eaning!ul
in!or&ation to ecision&a7er t%an t%e %istoricalcost accounting#
• T%e !air 5alue e8ens &ore on &an$ esti&ates suc%as !uture &onetar$ ;o*s an iscount rates in cases o!illi
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
17/26
• Pen&an -.//01 stresse on t%e a5antages o! t%efair value from perspective e of proponents arguingthat investors are much concerned with value
rather than cost so !air 5alue s%oul 'e re8orte#• T%e !air 5alue %as 'een issue consiering its
perceived features and the meaningful informationthey provide to help market partners makedi!erent decisions#
• T%e !air 5alue also consiere as more relevantcompared with historical costing provides betterindication to current risk an as a result ena'lein5estors ta7e correcti5e actions *it% res8ect to
cor8orate ecisions#• T%e !air 5alue is an ieal &oel re;ecting 8resent
&ar7et conitions 8ro5ie ti&el$ in!or&ation*%ic% increases trans8arenc$ an encourages
instant correcti5e action#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
18/26
Ans*er"Pen&an-.//01
Benefts o FVA
• In5estors are concerne *it% 5aluenot costs so re8ort !air 5alues#
• it% t%e 8assage o! ti&e %istorical8rices 'eco&e irrele5ant in assessingan entit$6s current ,nancial 8osition#Prices 8ro5ie u8toate in!or&ationa'out t%e 5alue o! assets#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
19/26
)ene,ts o! using FVA-con6t1
• Fair 5alue accounting re8orts assetsan lia'ilities in t%e *a$ t%at anecono&ist *oul loo7 at t%e& !air
5alues re;ect true econo&icsu'stance#
• Fair 5alue accounting re8ortsecono&ic inco&e
• Fair 5alue is a &ar7et'ase &easuret%at is not aecte '$ !actors s8eci,cto a 8articular entit$
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
20/26
Ans*erPen&an-.//01
FVA HCA
• t%e 'alance s%eet 'eco&es
t%e 8ri&ar$ 5e%icle
! or con5e$ing in!or&ation to
s%are%olers
• t%e inco&e state&ent is t%e
8ri&ar$ 5e%icle !or
con5e$ing in!or&ation a'out
5alue to s%are%olers
•t%e inco&e -8ro,t an loss1
state&ent re8orts econo&ic
inco&e6 'ecause it is si&8l$
t%e c%ange in 5alue o5er a
8erio
•current inco&e !orecasts
!uture inco&e on *%ic% a
5aluation can 'e &ae
•inco&e re8orts t%e
ste*ars%i8 o! &anage&ent in
aing 5alue !or s%are%olers#
•earnings &easure t%e
ste*ars%i8 o! &anage&ent in
ar'itraging in8ut an out8ut
&ar7ets t%at is in aing
5alue in &ar7ets#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
21/26
Pen&an-.//01 ##con6tFVA HCA
-une:8ecte1 earnings 'eing a
s%oc7 to 5alue re8orts on t%e ris7 o!t%e e
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
22/26
Source o inormation used in air value measurement:
Le5el 2 Valuation 'ase u8on
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
23/26
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
24/26
2) Value relevance o air value(eseciall! "evel 3 air values) is
greater or frms #ith strongcororate governance.
T%is is 'ecause ,r& *it% ine8enent'oars %ig%l$ ,nancial literate auitco&&ittees acti5e auit co&&ittees t%e8resence o! institutional in5estors auit '$auitors !ro& large oMce an no &aterialcontrol *ea7nesses are less li7el$ to engage
in ,nancial re8orting 'iases#>anagers &a$ &ani8ulate in8uts !or !air5alue !or t%eir o*n interest# Ho*e5er *it% agoo cor8orate go5ernance t%is can 'e
reuce an t%e in!or&ation 8ro5ie *ill 'e&ore rele5ance#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
25/26
3) Fair value hierarch! disclosuredisaggregating t!e inormation #ith
level inormation #ill increase value orelevance to the inormation
>atri: !or&at !or re8orting !air 5alues'ase on assetsJlia'ilit$ t$8e an le5el o!in8ut *ill 8ro5ie &ore rele5ancein!or&ation# T%is *ill e8ens on %o* in5estorsierentiall$ 5alue in8uts across t%e t%ree
le5els an *%et%er t%e ,r&s re8ortsuMcient !air 5alue assets an lia'ilit$t$8es#
8/9/2019 TOPIC 4 Fair Value
26/26
Conclusion• Fair 5alue is t%e 'est a5aila'le &et%oolog$
!or eter&ining an re8orting t%e 5alue o!,nancial instru&ents co&8are to %istoricalaccounting
• Ho*e5er i! it %a 'een i&8le&ente 8oorl$'ot% FVA an HCA can 8rouce &isleaingin!or&ation an lea to ris7 accu&ulation8ro'le&s an t%e 8otential !or &ar7etistortion-Green'erg et.al,./2K1
• T%us i&8ro5ing t%e