SME Financing International SME Financing International Best PracticesBest Practices
2 SME Financing International Best Practices
Fundamental Considerations Fundamental Considerations
• Appreciation of the Importance of SMEs– Technology – Based– Traditional
• Cultural and Economic Factors of Society• Supportive Legal/Regulatory Framework• Access to borrowings• Equity:
– Government– Non-government foreign and domestic
3 SME Financing International Best Practices
Importance of SMEsImportance of SMEs
• To the Economy– Job creation– Innovation
• To Society– Management– Ownership
• To Individuals – Wealth Creation– Accomplishment
4 SME Financing International Best Practices
Cultural and Economics FactorsCultural and Economics Factors
• Entrepreneurship
• Support of family and friends
• Competitive advantages
• Education
• Government programs of support
• Relationship to large companies
5 SME Financing International Best Practices
Legal and Regulatory Environment Legal and Regulatory Environment
• Law allows formation of a new company
• Number of regulatory approvals
• Time & difficulty of required approvals
• Honesty & transparency of regulation
• Sickness & closure of companies
6 SME Financing International Best Practices
Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices
• Basic Principles:1. Simply the formation of company and investment funds by
eliminating barriers & regulations2. Require disclosure to parties3. Protect the interest of stakeholders with general laws
• Laws to Protect Stakeholders
For Example: 1. Workers protected by general labor laws.2. Investors protected by laws establishing rights and enforcement3. Customers and suppliers protected by contract laws4. Environment protected by law
7 SME Financing International Best Practices
Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices
• Access to Financing • Borrowing• Equity Financing • Venture Capital
• Current Sources of Borrowings • Banks• Informal Lenders
8 SME Financing International Best Practices
Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices
• Best Practices Government Support • To encourage bank lending to technology-based SMEs, form credit guarantee
companies• Loan guarantees to be made available to businesses that are not high tech• Each credit guaranty company operates independently
• Best Practices for Credit Support International best practice suggests desirability of
• Uniform and consistent practices• Common credit standards and regulations• Central re-guaranty program as incentive• Marketing and promotion• Need for training of guaranty personnel• Risk management and central data base • Lenders who are not banks
• Loan Related Facilities • To support a lending program, a Credit Rating System should be developed• A secondary market for the guaranteed portion of loans would be helpful• A micro credit program could serve small startup companies with very small loans
9 SME Financing International Best Practices
Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices Legal and Regulatory – Best Practices
Increasing Availability of Equity• Equity currently available from:
• Friends and family• Foreign investors• Government-funded venture capital funds (primarily for high tech
companies)• Almost no domestic private equity invested
Reasons for Equity Shortage
• Equity investors seek highest return consistent with the risk of the investment• SME investments are difficult to evaluate • SME investments take time to mature• They are often difficult to liquidate• In China, major institutional investors (pension funds and insurance
companies) are not allowed to invest in private SMEs
10 SME Financing International Best Practices
Equity International Best Practice Equity International Best Practice
• To encourage investment in SMEs, most countries have programs that either:
• Increase potential returns to investors or • Reduce risk of loss
• A pilot program could test the potential for attracting equity
11 SME Financing International Best Practices
Equity International Best Practice Equity International Best Practice
Importance of Training • In both credit guarantee companies and equity investment funds,
management training is needed, and is not available.• New materials and courses must be developed and offered to fulfill this
need. Recommendations (1)
• Current programs should be available to high-growth traditional businesses as well as technology-based companies
• Credit can be increased by a combination of training, consistency of operation through an association of guaranty companies, and establishment of a national credit re guaranty Company by the central government.
Recommendations (2)• Non-government sources of equity financing can be attracted by a pilot
program in which government would improve the profit opportunity or reduce risk of loss to private investors.
12 SME Financing International Best Practices
Equity International Best Practice Equity International Best Practice
Recommendations (3)• Laws and regulations should be modified to encourage financing:• The Company Law still inhibits financings • The Investment Funds Law is required if domestic funds are to be a attractive
as foreign funds• Laws and financial institutions should be changed to make it easier for an
investor to sell its investment as the company develops.Recommendations (4)Training programs are required in all aspects of SME Finance:
• Training of loan officers• Training of loan guarantee officials• Training of investment fund managers• Training of entrepreneurs
Recommendations (5)• Our recommendations will be described in more detail later in the Forum
13 SME Financing International Best Practices
Government Support for SME Equity Government Support for SME Equity Financing- International Best PracticeFinancing- International Best Practice
Objectives• To increase availability of equity for SMEs by attracting non-
governmental sources• To target investments in high-growth, high potential businesses• To create investment funds that will be profitable and self-sustaining,• To provide experience to investors and fund managers
Why is Government Support Needed ?• Investing is a truly global business, so an investment in China must
compete with all other investment possibilities• Investors seek the highest risk-adjusted rate of profit on their investment• SME investments are risky and take along time to mature• These investments are unmarketable
14 SME Financing International Best Practices
Government Support for SME Equity Government Support for SME Equity Financing- International Best PracticeFinancing- International Best Practice
Why is Government Support Needed ? • Investing is a truly global business, so an investment in China must compete with
all other investment possibilities• Investors seek the highest risk-adjusted rate of profit on their investment• SME investments are risky and take along time to mature• These investments are unmarketable
Aims of Government Support • Government programs change the risk-adjusted potential profit by:
• Increasing the profit to the investors, or• Reducing their risk of loss
What Can Government Do? • To provide additional venture capital Government can either:• Invest its own money in venture capital investments (directly or through funds) or • Support public-private partnership to encourage private investment
15 SME Financing International Best Practices
Government Support for SME Equity Government Support for SME Equity Financing- International Best PracticeFinancing- International Best Practice
Tools of Government Support • Government increases return or reduces risk• Direct participation in investment funds• Tax credits• Loans or loan guarantees to investment funds• Leveraged equity participation• Guarantees against loss
16 SME Financing International Best Practices
Public-Private Partnerships • The oldest, largest, and most successful support programs,
including U.S., Israel and Australia, are partnerships between:• Government• Private Investors• Private Funds Manager
Role of Each Partner • Government targets size or sector of investment, and agrees to
take low rate of return on its participation• Private investors invest with potential for increased rate of return
or reduced risk• Private managers invest professionally, with motivation of carried
interest in fund profits
Government Support for SME Equity Government Support for SME Equity Financing- International Best PracticeFinancing- International Best Practice
17 SME Financing International Best Practices
Structure of the SME Equity Program Structure of the SME Equity Program
State Guarantee of Loan
Investors Equity & Loan
SME EquityFund
Fund Manager
S SSSS
18 SME Financing International Best Practices
• Israel Yozma Funds:• Government put up 40%• Private investors put up 60%• Private Fund Managers• During first 5 years, Private Investors could purchase Govt. investment at
cost plus government – rate interest
• Australian Innovation Investment Funds:• Government invests 2/3 of Funds Capital• Private Investors invest 1/3• Private Fund Managers• Cash distributions to Govt. and private investors in proportion to
investment until all investment repaid with govt-rate interest• Therefore, govt takes only 10% of profit distributions
Some ExamplesSome Examples
19 SME Financing International Best Practices
• SBIC Program active since 1959• Government provides 2/3 of capital, private investors 1/3• Government seeks only a low return• Privately managed• Two programs:
• Debenture Financing• Equity (“Participating Security”)
• Over $5 billion invested by SBICs in 2000• Nearly half of all investments by organized venture capital
organizations in the U.S.
U.S. SBIC ProgramU.S. SBIC Program
20 SME Financing International Best Practices
• To test whether a government support program would attract non-government sources of equity, we recommend:
• Government to offer discount loans to five new investment funds:• Loans two times non-government investment • One times government investment
• Regulations based on the Australian and American programs• Investments must be direct into SMEs, either high-tech or traditional• Program administered by SETC• Government loans from the Development Funds proposed in new
legislation• Government to loan or guarantee loans
Recommended Pilot Program Recommended Pilot Program
21 SME Financing International Best Practices
Structure of the SME Equity Program Structure of the SME Equity Program
State DiscountLoan Investors
SME EquityFund
Fund Manager
S SSSS
22 SME Financing International Best Practices
SME Equity Program for Reduced Risk SME Equity Program for Reduced Risk
State Guarantee of
Loan
Investors Equity & Loan
SME EquityFund
Fund Manager
S SSSS
23 SME Financing International Best Practices
• Municipal and Provincial Governments• Large companies• Pension funds• Banks and insurance companies• Foreign investors• Wealthy individuals
Potential InvestorsPotential Investors