Disclaimer: These spreadsheets are intended to be used as a sample of the projects Contrarian Realty Partners
will pursue and complete. We are not seeking funding for this particular sample project.
List of Tables - Development StagesStage 1a: Rent & Sales Summary
Stage 1b: Pro Forma NOI
Stage 1c: Maximum Debt Calculation
Stage 1d: Development Costs
Stage 1e: Summary Analysis & Simple Ratios
Stage 2a: Analysis
Stage 2 Analysis--For-Sale Units Cash Flow
Stage 3a--Analysis, Cash Flows During Development Period, Including Initial Lease-Up Activities
Stage 3b: Development Cost Summary
Stage 3c: Analysis--Combined Annual Before- and After-Tax Cash Flows during Development and Operating
Period
Stage 5 Analysis - Investor Return
Stage 1a - Rental and Sales Revenue Summary
Industrial Unit Types No. of Units Rent/Ft2
Area/Unit
(ft2) Total Ft
2
Rent/Month/U
nit
Total
Annual
Rent
Free Standing Industrial 1 $0.68 90,000 90,000 $61,200 $734,400
0 $0.00 0 0 $0 $0
0 $0.00 0 0 $0 $0
0 $0.00 0 0 $0 $0
0 $0.00 0 0 $0 $0
Total Rental Revenue 1 0.68$ 90,000 90,000 $61,200 $734,400
Total Retail Rental Revenue (see below) 0 -$ 0 0 $0 $0
Other Rental Revenuea
$0
Other Miscellaneous Revenueb
$0
Total Rental Revenue 1 0.68$ 90,000 90,000 $61,200 $734,400
Retail Tenants No. of Units Rent/Ft2
Area/Unit
(ft2) Total Ft
2
Rent/Month/U
nit
Total
Annual
Rent
Retail Tenant #1
Retail Tenant #2
Total Rental Revenue 0 -$ 0 0 $0 $0
For Sale No. of Units Sales/Ft2
Area/Unit
(ft2) Total Ft
2Sales/Unit
Total
Annual
Sales
Project Units
Total Sales Revenue
aOther Rental Revenue includes additional revenue derived from leasing space at the property e.g. leases for parking, rooftop
telecommunication devices, storage space, and billboards.
bOther Miscellaneous Revenue includes additional revenue as a result of conducting daily business activities e.g. late fees and
penalties, forfeiture of deposits, and lost key fees. Revenue from tax increment financing would be included in this line item.
Stage 1b - Pro Forma NOI
Factor
Annual
Revenue/Co
st
Revenue
Gross Potential Revenuea
$734,400
Less: Vacancy 5.00% ($36,720)
Less: Bad Debt 0.00% $0
Effective Gross Revenue $697,680
Expensesb
Property Management 3.00% of Effective Gross Revenue $20,930
Controllable Costsc -$ per unit $0
Real Estate Taxes 1.20% of estimated bldg acq cost $64,800
Insurance $13,500 per unit $13,500
Utilities $500 per unit $6,000
Maintenance 2% per unit $14,688
Total Expenses $119,918
Net Operating Income $697,680
= link from another sheet
cControllable costs typically include salary, administrative, marketing, and maintenance expenses.
aGross Potential Revenue is provided by the prior Rental and Sales Revenue Summary (4-
3a-Stage 1a Rents & Sales). Vacancy is a customary charges against gross revenue.
bCustomary expense items have been shown. In the pro forma, per-unit expense items are
applied against 1 units. For expenses based on project cost, the total project cost is used to
estimate expenses.
Stage 1c - Maximum Debt Calculation
Pro Forma Net Operating Income (NOI) and Value
Pro Forma NOIa
$697,680
Capitalization Rate 6.00%
Value of Income Property Only (NOI / Cap Rate) $11,628,000
Loan Terms
Interest Rateb Const Loan 5.25%
Amortization (years) 25
Debt Based on Loan to Value (LTV)
Maximum Const Loan Percentage Adj for 70% LTCb 52.00%
Maximum Loan Based on LTC for Const Loan $6,046,560
Using Debt Coverage Ratio (DCR)
Monthly NOI $58,140
Maximum DCR 1.20
Maximum Monthly Payment (NOI/DCR/12) $48,450
Maximum Loan Based on DCR for Income Property $8,085,137
Maximum Loan (Lesser of LTC or DCR Result)
Maximum Loan for Development Propertyc
$6,046,560
Add: Loan for For-Sale Propertyd
$0
Total Initial Project Debt $6,046,560
= link from another sheet
aThe pro forma NOI figure is provided by the prior eponymous exhibit and does not include any
revenues from For Sale Units.
bInterest rate and loan-to-cost reflect market rate financing at the time of project analysis (06/13)
and represents 70% of total project cost not the 52% shown as "Max Const Loan %.
cTypically valuation of pure income properties the maximum debt calc ends by selecting the lesser
of two loan values, based on LTV or DCR. A modified LTC Const loan is shown line 23.
dLine item equal to 70 percent of the For Sale sales revenue to allow for a construction loan on
multiple unit sales from a lender. N/A to this proforma.
Gross f
Total
Usable
Free Standing
Industrial
For-Sale
Units
Number of Units 1 1 1 0
Square Footage (Input Gross) 90,000 90,000 90,000 0
Percentage of Total Square Footage 100% 100% 0%
Development Costsa
Building Acquisition $60.00 per gross ft2
5,400,000$ 5,400,000$ 0$
Carry Preferred Returnb
0.00% rate 12 months 0 0 0
Approval Fees $0.30 per gross ft2
27,000 27,000 0
Environmental Reports & Remediation $0.06 per gross ft2
5,000 5,000 0
Construction Hard Cost $25.00 per gross ft2 2,250,000 2,250,000 0
Lease Up Costs 5.00% 213,580 213,580 0
Soft Costs:
Architecture & Engineering 5.00% of hard cost 112,500 112,500 0
Legal & Other Fees $15,000 estimate 15,000 15,000 0
Appraisal & Title $9,000 estimate 9,000 9,000 0
Marketing $5,000 per total units 5,000 5,000 0
Taxes during Construction $129,600 estimate 129,600 129,600 0
Insurance during Construction $27,000 estimate 27,000 27,000 0
Total Soft Costs 298,100 298,100 0
Development Fee 5% hard, soft costs 409,684 409,684
Contingency 3.00% of hard cost 67,500 67,500 0
Total Development Cost before Interest and Operating Reserve 8,670,863$ 8,670,863$ 0$
Estimate of Construction Interestc
Construction Loan $6,046,560
Construction Interest 5.25%
Construction Period / Lease Up(months) 24
Average Draw 65.00%
Estimated Construction Loan Interest 412,678 412,678 0
Total Project Cost before Operating Reserve 9,083,541$ 9,083,541$ 0$
Estimate of Operating Reserved
Gross Potential Rent (monthly) $61,200
Lease-Up Period (months until stabilization) 6.0
Average Occupancy during Lease-Up 65%
Estimated Rent during Lease-Up -
Estimated Op. Expenses during Lease-Up 59,959
NOI during Lease-Up (59,959)
Construction Interest during Lease-Up 158,722
First-Year Operating Reserve Required 0 0 0Total Project Costs 9,083,541$ 9,083,541$ 0$
Less: Development Cost Subsidiese
(162,000) (162,000)
Total Project Costs after Subsidies 8,921,541$ 8,921,541$ 0$
= link from another sheet
eThe development of this project includes a Federal Tax Subsidy through section 179D of "The Emergency Economic Stabilization Act 2008". The present value of this
subsidy has been deducted from the total project cost as a means to simplify the analysis. Practically speaking the subsidy will require a qualification process through an
independent 3rd party "approved" certification specialist. The subsidy is available as of the time of project analysis 6/13. Due to the varying nature of subsidies, the subsidy
is prorated based on the applicable portion of the project, and not by square footage. The subsidy allowance is $1.80 PSF.
Stage 1d - Development Costs
cThis calculation is a preliminary estimate of interest during construction and reflects market rate construction financing.as of 6/13.
dOperating Reserve represents the amount that will be required to cover operating costs and debt service before the project reaches break-even occupancy. Operating
reserve will be taken from draws against the construction loan on an as needed basis. N/A to this proforma.
aThe following outline of development costs include customary expenses.
bCarry refers to preferred interest paid to the seller or investors that are part of the purchase contract. The interest rate is applied to the negotiated purchase price less any
upfront paid capital amounts. N/A to this proforma.
Net Operating Income (NOI) 697,680
Total Project Cost 9,083,541
Less: Development Subsidies (162,000)
Project Cost after Subsidies 8,921,541
Less: Development Cost of For-Sale Units 0
Total Adjusted Cost for Development Property 8,921,541
Overall Return, Overall Cap Rate (NOI/Total Adjusted Cost) 7.8%
Net Operating Income 697,680
Annual Debt Servicea
434,806
Cash Throw-Off (CTO or BTCF) 262,874
Total Adjusted Cost 8,921,541
Construction Loanb
6,046,560
Equity 2,874,981
Cash-on-Cash Return (CTO/Equity) 9.1%
Development Profit for Free Standing Industrial
Net Operating Income 697,680
Overall Cap Rate at Sale 6.0%
Capitalized Value (NOI/Cap Rate) 11,628,000
Less: Total Adjusted Cost (8,921,541)
Development Profit 2,706,459
= link from another sheet
b Construction Loan excludes financing of the For-Sale Units. Also, if applicable, the loan
amount is capped so as to not exceed the Total Project Cost after Subsidies.
a Annual Debt Service reflects the total construction loan principal amount of $6,046,560,
which excludes financing the For-Sale Units.
Stage 1e Summary Analysis & Simple Ratios
Stage 2a Analysis
Project Costs Total Industrial For Sale Units
Total Project Cost $9,083,541 9,083,541 -
Operating Reserves - - -
Total Project Cost before Operating Reserve 9,083,541 9,083,541 -
Total Project Cost after Subsidies 8,921,541 8,921,541 -
Total Proj Cost after Subsidies before Op Reserve 8,921,541 8,921,541 - 36,234
Building Cost 5,400,000 5,400,000 -
bop int prin eop
Financing Assumptions - - - 6,046,560
Equity 2,874,981 2,874,981 - 6,046,560 26,454 9,780 6,036,780
Construction Loan Principala
6,046,560 6,046,560 - 6,036,780 26,411 9,823 6,026,957
Interest Rate 5.25% 5.25% 6,026,957 26,368 9,866 6,017,091
Amortization 25 N/A 6,017,091 26,325 9,909 6,007,182
Annual Debt Service $434,806 $434,806 $0 6,007,182 26,281 9,952 5,997,229
5,997,229 26,238 9,996 5,987,233
Depreciation Assumptions 5,987,233 26,194 10,040 5,977,194
Building Basisb
3,521,541 3,521,541 $0 5,977,194 26,150 10,084 5,967,110
Life (in years) 27.5 5,967,110 26,106 10,128 5,956,982
Acceleration Factor 1.0 5,956,982 26,062 10,172 5,946,810
Straight Line (calculated) $128,056 $128,056 $0 5,946,810 26,017 10,217 5,936,594
5,936,594 25,973 10,261 5,926,332
Alternate Project Cost Assumptions for Vacancy Overridec
Total Proj Cost after Subsidies before Op Reserve 8,921,541 8,921,541 -
Equity 2,874,981 2,874,981
Building Basis 3,521,541 3,521,541 -
Straight Line $128,056 $128,056 $0
MORTGAGE CALCULATION FOR CONSTRUCTION LOAN* Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8
1 = I/O; 2 = AMORTIZE 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
Beginning Balance 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560
Ending Balance 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560 6,046,560
Amortization of Principal - - - - - - - -
Interest 317,444 317,444 317,444 317,444 317,444 317,444 317,444 317,444
DEPRECIATION CALCULATION FOR INDUSTRIAL DEV Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8
Beginning Balance 3,521,541 3,521,541 3,393,485 3,265,429 3,137,373 3,009,317 2,881,261 2,753,205
Less: Annual Depreciation - (128,056) (128,056) (128,056) (128,056) (128,056) (128,056) (128,056)
Ending Balance 3,521,541 3,393,485 3,265,429 3,137,373 3,009,317 2,881,261 2,753,205 2,625,149
Cumulative Depreciation Taken - 128,056 256,112 384,168 512,224 640,280 768,336 896,392
Cumulative Straight Line 128,056 256,112 384,168 512,224 640,280 768,336 896,392 1,024,448
Remaining Book Value 8,921,541 8,793,485 8,665,429 8,537,373 8,409,317 8,281,261 8,153,205 8,025,149
ANNUAL CASH FLOWS FOR INDUSTRIAL DEV Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8
override vacancy rates c
0.0% 0.0%
Gross Potential Revenue 2.00% inflation 734,400 734,400 749,088 764,070 779,351 794,938 810,837 827,054
Less: Vacancy 5.00% vacancy - - (37,454) (38,203) (38,968) (39,747) (40,542) (41,353)
Less: Vacancy During Lease Up (734,400) (385,560) - - - - - -
Effective Gross Revenue - 348,840 711,634 725,866 740,384 755,191 770,295 785,701
Total Operating Expenses:(NNN Lease) 2.00% inflation 119,918 122,317 124,763 127,258 129,804 132,400 135,048 137,749
Net Operating Income - 348,840 711,634 725,866 740,384 755,191 770,295 647,952
Annual Debt Service - - 317,444 317,444 317,444 317,444 317,444
Before-Tax Operating Cash Flow - 353,290 1,029,078 1,043,311 1,057,828 1,072,636 1,087,739
Taxes (see below) - (68,443) (82,501) (86,913) (91,414) (96,004) (100,686)
After-Tax Operating Cash Flow - 284,847 946,577 956,397 966,414 976,632 987,053
INCOME TAX CALCUATION FOR INDUSTRIAL DEV Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7
Net Operating Income - 348,840 711,634 725,866 740,384 755,191 770,295
Add: Replacement/Capital Reserve - - - - - - -
Deduct: Interest - - (317,444) (317,444) (317,444) (317,444) (317,444)
Deduct: Depreciation - (128,056) (128,056) (128,056) (128,056) (128,056) (128,056)
Taxable Income/(Loss) - 220,784 266,133 280,366 294,883 309,691 324,795
Passive Loss Offsetd
- - - - - - -
Taxable Income - 220,784 266,133 280,366 294,883 309,691 324,795
Passive Loss Carryforwardd
- - - - - - -
Annual Income Taxes 31.00% rate - 68,443 82,501 86,913 91,414 96,004 100,686
SALE CALCULATION OF INDUSTRIAL DEV (Incl. Tax) Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7
Cash Flow from Sale
Normalized NOI - 697,680 711,634 725,866 740,384 755,191 770,295
Sale Price (cap rate applied to following year NOI) 6.0% cap rate - 11,628,000 11,860,560 12,097,771 12,339,727 12,586,521 12,838,252
Less: Commission 2.50% rate - (290,700) (296,514) (302,444) (308,493) (314,663) (320,956)
Adjusted Sales Price - 11,337,300 11,564,046 11,795,327 12,031,233 12,271,858 12,517,295
Less: Remaining Mortgage Balance: (Yr 2=100% unamortized) (6,046,560) (6,046,560) (6,046,560) (6,046,560) (6,046,560) (6,046,560) (6,046,560)
Before-Tax Cash Flow from Sale (6,046,560) 5,290,740 5,517,486 5,748,767 5,984,673 6,225,298 6,470,735
Total Tax at Sale (recapture & capital gain, see below) (394,378) (460,404) (527,110) (594,510) (662,618) (731,447)
After-Tax Cash Flow from Sale 4,896,362 5,057,082 5,221,657 5,390,164 5,562,680 5,739,288
Tax Calculation from Sale
Adjusted Sales Price 11,337,300 11,564,046 11,795,327 12,031,233 12,271,858 12,517,295
Remaining Book Value (8,793,485) (8,665,429) (8,537,373) (8,409,317) (8,281,261) (8,153,205)
Total Taxable Gain 2,543,815 2,898,617 3,257,954 3,621,917 3,990,597 4,364,091
Passive Loss Carryforwardd
- - - - -
Total Net Taxable Gain 2,543,815 2,898,617 3,257,954 3,621,917 3,990,597 4,364,091
Total Depreciation Taken 128,056 256,112 384,168 512,224 640,280 768,336
Recapture Tax @ 25% 25.00% rate 32,014 64,028 96,042 128,056 160,070 192,084
Capital Gain 2,415,759 2,642,505 2,873,786 3,109,693 3,350,317 3,595,755
Deduct: Capital Reservese
- - - - -
Net Capital Gain 2,415,759 2,642,505 2,873,786 3,109,693 3,350,317 3,595,755
Tax on Capital Gain 15.00% rate 362,364 396,376 431,068 466,454 502,548 539,363
Total Tax at Sale 394,378 460,404 527,110 594,510 662,618 731,447
RETURN MEASURES Investment Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7
SALE END OF YEAR 2
Unleveraged IRR
Project Cost (excluding Interest) (8,508,863)$
For-Sale Revenuesf
-
Net Operating Income - 348,840 - - - - -
Adjusted Sales Price 11,337,300 - - - - -
Unleveraged Cash Flow (8,508,863)$ 0$ 11,686,140$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
Unleveraged IRR Ending Year 2 17.19%
Net Present Value @ 5.0%g
$2,090,810
Before-Tax IRR
Equity (2,874,981)$
Before-Tax Cash Flow from Industrial -
Before-Tax Operating Cash Flow:Adj for Int Only - 348,840 - - - - -
Before-Tax Cash Flow from Sale 5,290,740 - - - - -
Total Before-Tax Cash Flow (2,874,981)$ 0$ 5,639,580$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
Before-Tax IRR Ending Year 2 40.06%
Net Present Value @ 6.0% $2,144,225
After-Tax IRR
Equity (2,874,981)$
After-Tax Cash Flow from For Sale Unitsf
-
After-Tax Operating Cash Flow - 284,847 - - - - -
After-Tax Cash Flow:(Adj for Interest Only Loan) - 4,896,362 - - - - -
Total After-Tax Cash Flow (2,874,981)$ 0$ 5,181,209$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
After-Tax IRR Ending Year 2 34.24%
Net Present Value @ 2.0% $2,105,036
Simple Return Measures Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7
NOI/Adjusted Project Cost Excluding For-Sale Units 0.0% 3.9% 8.0% 8.1% 8.3% 8.5% 8.6%
Before-Tax Cash Flow / Equity 0.0% 12.3% 35.8% 36.3% 36.8% 37.3% 37.8%
Tax Shelter/Equity 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%
= link from another sheet
bCustomarily, the building basis is the difference between the total project cost and the land value. For this analysis, however, the building basis is the total project cost less the building acquisition cost.
aThe construction loan reflects an interest-only construction loan through the end of year 2. This proforma is adjusted and based on interest only payments at the 5.25% interest rate during the construction period. Years 3 to 7
should be disregarded in this proforma. For the develoopment phase and refinance for long term property hold please see the presentation section titled "Long Term Lease Investment".
fCash flows related to the sales and profit of For-Sale Units are not applicable to this development analysis.
dCurrent tax regulations treat real estate investments as a passive activity for non real estate investors. As a result, tax losses in real estate are considered passive income losses and can only be taken against other passive
income (with minor adjustments for small investors). In the event that an investor does not have any passive income, the passive losses are carried forward until they can be used against future passive income.
gNet Present Value equals the present value of future cash flows, less the initial investment. Note that Stage 2 analysis assumes all equity is invested at the beginning of the project. Also note that the unleveraged NPV represents
the development profit.
cTo incorporate vacancy rates during lease-up directly into this spreadsheet, enter the vacancy rates into cells E51 and F51. If these cells are left as zero, then the Total Project Costs and Equity are taken from lines 3 9. If they are
not zero, then Total Project Cost, Building Basis, and Equity are taken from lines 24 28.
eCapital reserves are not a part of this specific development analysis model.
Stage 2b Analysis
For-Sale Units Cash Flow
Revenue and Expense For Sale Units
Sales Revenue 0
Development Costs & Expensesa
0
Profit -
Tax Determination of For Sale Units
Profit 0
Tax Rate 35.0%
Tax Liability 0
Mortgage Calculation of For Sale Unitsb
Beginning Balance 0
Borrowings 0
Releases 0
Trial Ending Balance 0
Average Balance 0
Interest Owed 0
Interest Paid 0
Ending Balance 0
Cash Flow Determination for For Sale Units
Revenues 0
Less: For Sale Releases to Lender 0
Less: Interest Paidb
0
Before-Tax Cash Flow 0
Less: Taxes 0
After-Tax Cash Flow 0
aSpecific to this case and Stage 2 analysis, operational expenses pertaining to the marketing
and sales of the condominiums have been accounted for as a development cost.
bSpecific to this case and Stage 2 analysis, it is assumed that the condominiums are effectively
presold such that the construction loan is immediately repaid at the completion of the
construction. The interest owed is the amount of interest that accrued while the project was
being constructed. Note that this amount had previously been accounted for in determining the
total development costs and initial equity required. As a result, the interest owed amount is not
shown to affect the ultimate cash flows for the condominiums.
Stage 3a Analysis
Cash Flows during Development Period, Including Initial Lease-Up Activities
– Development – – Lease-Up – – First Stabilized Year –
Data Total Time Zero Year 1 Total Year 2 Total Quarter 1 Quarter 2 Quarter 3 Quarter 4 Quarter 5 Quarter 6 Quarter 7 Quarter 8 Quarter 9 Quarter 10 Quarter 11 Quarter 12 Year 3 Total
Development Costs
Building Acquisition $5,400,000 5,400,000 5,400,000 0 0 0
Building Carry Preferred Return - 0 $0 0 0 0
Approval Fees 27,000 27,000 $27,000 0 0 0
Environmental Reports & Remediation 5,000 5,000 5,000 - - 0
Construction Hard Cost 2,250,000 2,250,000 2,250,000 - 562,500 562,500 562,500 562,500 0
Lease Up Costs 213,580 213,580 - 213,580 - - - - - - 213,580 - - - - - 0
Soft Costs: 0 Architecture &
Engineering 112,500 112,500 112,500 - 112,500 0
Legal 15,000 15,000 15,000 - - 0
Appraisal & Title 9,000 9,000 9,000 - - 0
Marketing 5,000 5,000 - 5,000 1,250 1,250 1,250 1,250 0
Taxes during Construction 129,600 129,600 64,800 64,800 16,200 16,200 16,200 16,200 16,200 16,200 16,200 16,200 0
Insurance during Construction 27,000 27,000 13,500 13,500 3,375 3,375 3,375 3,375 3,375 3,375 3,375 3,375 0
Contingency 67,500 67,500 67,500 - 16,875 16,875 16,875 16,875 - - - - 0
Development Subsidies (162,000) (162,000) (162,000) - (40,500) (40,500) (40,500) (40,500)
Development Fee 409,684 409,684 409,684 102,421 102,421 102,421 102,421
$8,508,863 8,508,863 $5,456,000 $2,755,984 $296,880 $773,371 $660,871 $660,871 $660,871 $20,825 $20,825 $234,405 $20,825 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
For Sale Units Sales Schedule
Units Sold 0 0 0 0
Cumulative Units Sold 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Revenue per Unit 0 0 0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
For Sale Units Sales Revenue 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Expensesa 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
For Sale Units Net Revenues 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Operating Income/ (Loss) during Lease-Up
Initial Occupancy upon Opening 0%
Quarter to Stabilize 7.00
Units Leased per Quarter 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 1.0 0.0 0 0 0 0 0
Cumulative Number of Leased Units 0 1 0 0.0 0.0 1.0 1.0 1 1 1 1 1
Vacancy Due to Lease-Up (% of Gross Potential)b 100% 0% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0%
Stabilized Vacancy (% of Gross Potential) 5% 0% 5% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5%
Overall Vacancy Rate 100% 53% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5%
Gross Potential Revenuec 2% 183,600 734,400 734,400 183,600 183,600 183,600 183,600 187,272 187,272 187,272 187,272 749,088
Vacancy Lossd (385,560) (385,560) (183,600) (183,600) (9,180) (9,180) (9,364) (9,364) (9,364) (9,364) (37,454)
Bad Debtc
0.00% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Effective Gross Revenue 348,840 348,840 0 0 174,420 174,420 177,908 177,908 177,908 177,908 711,634
Operating Expensesc 2% (119,918) (119,918) (29,980) (29,980) (29,980) (29,980) (30,579) (30,579) (30,579) (30,579) (122,317)
Net Operating Income 348,840 348,840 ($29,980) ($29,980) $144,440 $144,440 $147,329 $147,329 $147,329 $147,329 $589,317
Net Cash Flow before Debt during First Three Years (8,279,941) (5,456,000) (2,755,984) (67,958) (773,371) (660,871) (660,871) (660,871) (50,805) (50,805) (89,964) 123,615 147,329 147,329 147,329 147,329 $589,317
Equity Contribution Account
Total Development Costse
8,921,541
Maximum Loan Balancee
6,046,560
Equity Required 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Equity Account Ending Balancef 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981 2,874,981
Construction Loan Account and Interest Calculation
Beginning Balance 2,581,019 5,532,186 2,581,019 3,388,266 4,093,608 4,808,207 5,532,186 5,655,600 5,780,635 6,015,039
Loan Draw & Releases
Construction Draw—Initial Requestg
5,633,882 2,581,019 2,755,984 296,880 773,371 660,871 660,871 660,871 20,825 20,825 234,405 20,825
Construction Releasesh
70% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Operating Deficit 59,959 0 0 59,959 0 0 0 0 29,980 29,980 0 0
Trial Balance 6,035,864 2,581,019 5,469,078 6,035,864 3,354,390 4,049,137 4,754,479 5,469,078 5,582,990 5,706,405 6,015,039 6,035,864
Additional Equity Required 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Construction Draw—Net Fundedg
5,753,801 2,581,019 2,755,984 416,798 773,371 660,871 660,871 660,871 80,784 80,784 234,405 20,825
Ending Balance before Interest 2,581,019 5,469,078 6,035,864 3,354,390 4,049,137 4,754,479 5,469,078 5,582,990 5,706,405 6,015,039 6,035,864
Average Loan Balance Before Interest 1,290,509 4,025,048 5,784,025 2,967,704 3,718,701 4,424,043 5,138,643 5,557,588 5,681,003 5,897,837 6,025,452
Total Construction Loan Interest 5.25% 496,841 0 195,183 301,658 33,876 44,471 53,729 63,108 72,610 74,230 75,871 78,947
Interest Accrued during Construction Period 195,183 0 195,183 0 33,876 44,471 53,729 63,108 0 0 0 0
Interest Accrued during Operating Period 301,658 0 0 301,658 0 0 0 0 72,610 74,230 75,871 78,947
Interest Paid from Operations (154,818) 0 0 (154,818) 0 0 0 0 0 0 (75,871) (78,947)
Interest Paid from For Sale Unit Salesh
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Trial Ending Balance 6,035,864 2,581,019 5,532,186 6,035,864 3,388,266 4,093,608 4,808,207 5,532,186 5,655,600 5,780,635 6,015,039 6,035,864
Additional Equity Required 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Interest Accrued—Neti
342,023 0 195,183 146,840 33,876 44,471 53,729 63,108 72,610 74,230 0 0
Ending Balance 6,035,864 2,581,019 5,532,186 6,035,864 3,388,266 4,093,608 4,808,207 5,532,186 5,655,600 5,780,635 6,015,039 6,035,864
Total Additional Equity Required 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Net Cash Flow after Debt 74,103 $0 0 74,103 $0 $0 $0 $0 ($29,980) ($29,980) $68,570 $65,493
= link from another sheet
aExpenses related to the selling of For Sale Units are n/a.
bThe vacancy calculation assumes that the units leased in the present quarter are economically realized in the middle of the quarter. Hence, the Vacancy for the quarter is an average of the vacancy from the prior quarter and present quarter.
cThe estimates for revenue and expenses are taken from the pro forma. Gross potential revenue and operating expenses are inflated 2 percent in the second year.
dVacancy Loss is a product of the Overall Vacancy Rate within the project.
fEquity is committed first, before draws from the construction loan. Construction draws cover any remaining shortfall in funding.
Total Development Cost, Excluding Construction Loan
Interest & Operating Reserves
gConstruction Draws are provided by the lender as construction progresses. The net construction draw amount is the amount borrowed after additional equity is contributed, if any. Also note that any operating deficits that need to be funded by the lender are
requested and included as part of the draw.
eThe Total Development Costs after Subsidies was previously provided in the Development Costs worksheet, and includes interest and operating reserves. The Maximum Loan Balance was previously provided by the Maximum Debt Calculation worksheet, and
is capped so as to not exceed the Development Costs.
Stage 3a Analysis
Cash Flows during Development Period, Including Initial Lease-Up Activities
– Development – – Lease-Up – – First Stabilized Year –
Data Total Time Zero Year 1 Total Year 2 Total Quarter 1 Quarter 2 Quarter 3 Quarter 4 Quarter 5 Quarter 6 Quarter 7 Quarter 8 Quarter 9 Quarter 10 Quarter 11 Quarter 12 Year 3 Total
iAccrued interest is added to the overall balance of the construction loan. In the event that the accrued interest, together with the carried balance of the construction loan, exceeds the maximum draw limit, then additional equity is required to maintain the
construction loan balance at the maximum draw limit. The net accrued interest amount is the amount accrued after additional equity is contributed, if any.
gConstruction Draws are provided by the lender as construction progresses. The net construction draw amount is the amount borrowed after additional equity is contributed, if any. Also note that any operating deficits that need to be funded by the lender are
requested and included as part of the draw.
hConstruction releases are n/a.
Stage 3b Analysis
Development Cost Summary
USES Total 0 1 2
Total Development Costs $8,508,863 $5,456,000 $2,755,984 $296,880
Construction Loan: Capitalized Interest $195,183 0 195,183 0
Total Capital Costs $8,704,046 $5,456,000 $2,951,167 $296,880
Cash Flow from Operations
Net Sales Revenue of For Sale Units 0 0 0 0
Net Operating Income From Lease 348,840 0 0 348,840
Less: Construction Loan Interest during Operations (301,658) 0 0 (301,658)
Less: Construction Loan Releases 0 0 0 0
Cash Flow from Operations after Interest 47,182 0 0 47,182
Construction Loan Balance to Be Refinanced 0 0
TOTAL USES $8,656,865 $5,456,000 $2,951,167 $249,698
SOURCES
Construction Loan Funding
Construction Loan: Net Draws 5,753,801 2,581,019 2,755,984 416,798
Construction Loan: Net Accrued Interest 342,023 - 195,183 146,840
Net Construction Loan Funding 6,095,824 2,581,019 2,951,167 563,638
Equity Sources 2,874,981 2,874,981 - -
Additional Equity Required - - - -
Permanent Mortgage Refinancing - -
Less: Positive Cash Flow after Interest—Distributed (74,103) - - (74,103)
Less: Cash Proceeds from Construction Loan Takeout - -
TOTAL SOURCES 8,896,701 5,456,000 2,951,167 489,534
Check
2,848,059 2,874,981 - (26,922)
2,608,223 2,874,981 - (266,758)
Capital Costs
Total Development Cost Excluding Interest 8,508,863$
Interest Accrued during Construction 195,183$
Total Capital Costs 8,704,046$
Depreciable Basis Annual Depreciation Estimate
Total Capital Costs 8,704,046$ 27.5 Life Years
Land Cost 5,400,000$ 1.0 Accel. Factor
Depreciable Basis (Capital Cost, minus Land) 3,304,046$ $120,147 Annual Deprec.
Operating Reserve
Operating Loss during Lease-Up 0$
Interest Accrued during Operating Period 301,658$
Interest Paid during Operating Period (154,818)$
Total Operating Reserve funded by Construction Loan 146,840$
Total Net Project Costs
Total Project Cost (Capital Costs plus Operating Reserve) 8,850,886$
Positive Cash Flow after Interest (74,103)
Interest Paid from For Sale Units Sold -
Total Project Cost after First-Year Operations (Year 2) 8,776,783$
Construction Loan Takeout at Stabilization
Permanent Mortgage Amount for Income Propertyb
6,035,864$
Construction Loan Ending Balance for Income Property 6,035,864$
YEAR
Equity for cap. Inv (equity sources+cash flow from ops—positive
cash flow after int)a
Equity for Capital Investment (Total Capital Costs—Loan Sources)
Cash Proceeds from Construction Loan Takeout -$
= link from another sheet
bSpecific to this underwriting, the Permanent Mortgage amount is assumed to be the lesser of the maximum loan amount for the income property
only (as calculated in Figure 4-3c) or the balance of the construction loan. However, under certain conditions, this assumption can be
conservative and cash proceeds can be generated at the time of refinancing.
aEquity for Capital Investment provides a helpful check for Stage 3. One must be careful not to double-count this equity since it comes not only
from new equity but also from positive operating cash flows during lease-up. Line 37 and Line 38 should be equal for each year.
Stage 3c Analysis
Combined Annual Before- and After-Tax Cash Flows during Development and Operating Period
– Development Period – – Investment Period –
Mortgage Calculation Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8
Beginning Balancea
6,035,864 6,035,864 5,950,755 5,861,069 5,766,560 5,666,967 5,562,018
Ending Balance 5,950,755 5,861,069 5,766,560 5,666,967 5,562,018 5,451,425
Amortization of Principal 85,109 89,686 94,510 99,593 104,949 110,593
Interest/Annual Payment 5.25% 399,963 314,854 310,277 305,454 300,371 295,014 289,370
DEPRECIATION CALCULATION
Beginning Balanceb
3,304,046 3,183,899 3,063,752 2,943,605 2,823,458 2,703,311 2,583,163
Less: Annual Depreciation 120,147 120,147 120,147 120,147 120,147 120,147 120,147
Ending Balance 3,183,899 3,063,752 2,943,605 2,823,458 2,703,311 2,583,163 2,463,016
Cumulative Depreciation Taken 120,147 240,294 360,441 480,589 600,736 720,883 841,030
Cumulative Straight Line 120,147 240,294 360,441 480,589 600,736 720,883 841,030
Recapture 120,147 240,294 360,441 480,589 600,736 720,883 841,030
Remaining Book Value 8,583,899 8,463,752 8,343,605 8,223,458 8,103,311 7,983,163 7,863,016
ANNUAL CASH FLOWS Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8
Gross Rent 2% 0 734,400 749,088 794,938 810,837 827,054 843,595 860,467
Vacancy Rate 5% 100.00% 52.50% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00% 5.00%
Vacancy ($) 0 (385,560) (37,454) (39,747) (40,542) (41,353) (42,180) (43,023)
Bad Debt 0.00% 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Effective Gross Revenue 0 348,840 711,634 755,191 770,295 785,701 801,415 817,443
Net Lease Expense Recovery 119,918 123,516 127,221 131,038 134,969 139,018 143,189
Operating Expenses 2.00% 0 (119,918) (122,317) (124,763) (127,258) (129,804) (132,400) (135,048)
Net Operating Income 0 348,840 712,833 757,649 774,075 790,866 808,033 825,585
- Construction Loan Interest During Operatingc
0 0
- Annual Debt Service (399,963) (399,963) (399,963) (399,963) (399,963) (399,963)
+ Operating Reserve Funded by Construction Loand
0 59,959
Before-Tax Cash Flow 408,799 312,870 357,686 374,112 390,903 408,070 425,622
Taxes (see below) 68,147 81,988 95,902 101,937 108,149 114,545 121,130
After-Tax Cash Flow 340,652 230,882 261,784 272,174 282,754 293,525 304,491
INCOME TAX CALCUATION FOR APARTMENTS & RETAIL Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7 Year 8
Net Operating Income - 348,840 712,833 757,649 774,075 790,866 808,033 825,585
Add: Replacement/ Capital Reserve 14,688 14,982 15,281 15,587 15,899 16,217 16,541
Deduct: Interest - - (314,854) (310,277) (305,454) (300,371) (295,014) (289,370)
Deduct: Depreciation - (120,147) (120,147) (120,147) (120,147) (120,147) (120,147) (120,147)
Taxable Income/(Loss) - 243,380 292,813 342,506 364,061 386,247 409,089 432,609
Passive Loss Offset - - - - - - - -
Taxable Income - 243,380 292,813 342,506 364,061 386,247 409,089 432,609
Passive Loss Carryforward - - - - - - - -
Annual Income Taxes 28.00% rate - 68,147 81,988 95,902 101,937 108,149 114,545 121,130
SALE CALCULATION OF APARTMENTS & RETAIL (Incl. Tax) Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7
Cash Flow from Sale
Sale Price (cap rate applied to next year NOI) 6.0% cap rate 11,628,000 12,627,486 12,901,245 13,181,108 13,467,224 13,759,745
Less: Commission 2.50% rate (290,700) (315,687) (322,531) (329,528) (336,681) (343,994)
Adjusted Sales Price 11,337,300 12,311,799 12,578,714 12,851,580 13,130,543 13,415,752
Less: Remaining Mortgage Balance (6,035,864) (5,950,755) (5,861,069) (5,766,560) (5,666,967) (5,562,018)
Before-Tax Cash Flow from Sale 5,301,436 6,361,043 6,717,645 7,085,020 7,463,576 7,853,734
Total Tax at Sale (recapture & capital gain, see below) (574,710) (775,690) (856,054) (937,546) (1,020,196) (1,104,031)
After-Tax Cash Flow from Sale 4,726,726 5,585,353 5,861,591 6,147,474 6,443,380 6,749,703
Tax Calculation at Sale
Adjusted Sales Price 11,337,300 12,311,799 12,578,714 12,851,580 13,130,543 13,415,752
Remaining Book Value (8,583,899) (8,463,752) (8,343,605) (8,223,458) (8,103,311) (7,983,163)
Total Taxable Gain 2,753,401 3,848,047 4,235,110 4,628,122 5,027,232 5,432,588
Passive Loss Carryforward - - - - - -
Total Net Taxable Gain 2,753,401 3,848,047 4,235,110 4,628,122 5,027,232 5,432,588
Total Depreciation Taken 120,147 240,294 360,441 480,589 600,736 720,883
Recapture Tax @ 25% 25.00% rate 30,037 60,074 90,110 120,147 150,184 180,221
Capital Gain 2,723,364 3,607,753 3,874,668 4,147,534 4,426,497 4,711,705
Deduct: Capital Reservese (29,670) (44,951) (60,538) (76,437) (92,654)
Net Capital Gain 2,723,364 3,578,083 3,829,717 4,086,996 4,350,060 4,619,052
Tax on Capital Gain 20.00% rate 544,673 715,617 765,943 817,399 870,012 923,810
Total Tax at Sale 574,710 775,690 856,054 937,546 1,020,196 1,104,031
RETURN MEASURES Year 0 Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7
SALE END OF YEAR 2
Unleveraged IRR
Project Cost (8,508,863)$
For-Sale Revenuesf
-
Net Operating Income - 348,840 - - - - -
Adjusted Sales Price 11,337,300 - - - - -
Unleveraged Cash Flow (8,508,863)$ 0$ 11,686,140$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
Unleveraged IRR Ending Year 2 17.19%
Net Present Value @ 6.0% g
$1,891,760
Before-Tax IRR
Initial & Additional Equity Required (2,874,981)$ 0$ 0$
Before-Tax Cash Flow from Condominiumsf
-
Before-Tax Operating Cash Flow - 408,799 - - - - -
Before-Tax Cash Flow from Refinancings -
Before-Tax Cash Flow from Sale 5,301,436 - - - - -
Total Before-Tax Cash Flow (2,874,981)$ 0$ 5,710,234$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
Before-Tax IRR Ending Year 2 40.93%
Net Present Value @ 8.0% $2,020,625
After-Tax IRR
Initial & Additional Equity Required (2,874,981)$ 0$ 0$
After-Tax Cash Flow from Condominiumsf
-
After-Tax Operating Cash Flow - 340,652 - - - - -
After-Tax Cash Flow from Refinancings -
After-Tax Cash Flow from Sale 4,726,726 - - - - -
Total After-Tax Cash Flow (2,874,981)$ 0$ 5,067,378$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
After-Tax IRR 32.76%
Net Present Value @ 10.0% $1,312,935
dThe operating reserve n/a
fCash flows related to the sales and profit of the For-Sale Units are n/a.
gNet Present Value equals the present value of future cash flows, less the initial investment. Note that the analysis assumes all equity is invested at the beginning of the project. Also note that
the unleveraged NPV represents the development profit.
aThe permanent mortgage balance was determined based on value and cash flow from the industrial building of the project. The permanent mortgage would replace the outstanding
construction loan upon stabilization of the project. Note that the construction loan is interest only, whereas the permanent mortgage is amortizing.
cConstruction Interest During Operating represents the amount of interest charged during the operating period that was paid from operating revenues.
bThe depreciable basis is the total project cost after subsidies and before Op Expenses, excluding building acquisition cost and operating losses during the lease-up period. The remaining book
value includes the building cost.
eSpecific to this model, yearly replacement reserves are n/a
Stage 5 Analysis
Investor Return
Initial & Additional Equitya
2,874,981$
Investor Equity Contributionb
95%
Cumulative Preferred Return 8%
Investor Proportionate Payback of Equityb
95%
Investor Share of Remaining Cash Flow 65%
– Development Period – – Operating Period –
Initial Investment Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6 Year 7
Before-Tax Cash Flow (2,874,981)$ 0$ 5,710,234$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
Preferred Returnb
Beginning Equity Account Balance 2,874,981 2,874,981 0 0 0 0 0
Preferred Return Earned 229,998 229,998 0 0 0 0 0
Preferred Return Paid Currently 0 229,998 0 0 0 0 0
Unpaid Return Accountb
Beginning Balance 0 229,998 0 0 0 0 0
Deferred Preferred Return 229,998 0 0 0 0 0 0
Deferred Preferred Return Paid 0 229,998 0 0 0 0 0
Ending Balance 229,998 0 0 0 0 0 0
Equity Account Balanceb
Beginning Equity Account Balance 2,874,981 2,874,981 0 0 0 0 0
Equity Payback 0 2,874,981 0 0 0 0 0
Ending Balance 2,874,981 0 0 0 0 0 0
Equity Payments Recapb
Preferred Return Paid Currently 0 229,998 0 0 0 0 0
Deferred Preferred Return Paid 0 229,998 0 0 0 0 0
Equity Payback 0 2,874,981 0 0 0 0 0
Total Payments on Equity 0 3,334,978 0 0 0 0 0
Remaining Cash Flow
Before-Tax Cash Flow 0 5,710,234 0 0 0 0 0
Total Payments on Equity 0 3,334,978 0 0 0 0 0
Remaining Cash Flow 0 2,375,257 0 0 0 0 0
Investor Share of Equity & Remaining Cash Flow (based on terms above)
Investor Share of Equity Payments 0 3,168,229 0 0 0 0 0
Investor Share of Remaining Cash Flow 0 1,543,917 0 0 0 0 0
Total Share to Investor 0 4,712,146 0 0 0 0 0
Developer Share of Equity & Remaining Cash Flow
Developer Share of Equity Payments 0 166,749 0 0 0 0 0
Developer Share of Remaining Cash Flow 0 831,340 0 0 0 0 0
Total Share to Investor 0 998,089 0 0 0 0 0
Investor Cash Flows
Before-Tax Cash Flow to Investor (2,731,232)$ 0$ 4,712,146$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
2 Year
Investor Before-Tax IRR 31.35%
Net Present Value, at 15.0% 831,827
Developer Cash Flows
Before-Tax Cash Flow to Developer (143,749)$ 0$ 998,089$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$ 0$
2 Year
Developer Before-Tax IRR 0.00%
Net Present Value, at 15.0% 610,949$
aIn this simplified investor return analysis, it is assumed that all equity, or committed capital by the investors, is invested in the initial year into an escrow account.
bIn this analysis, it is assumed that the investor and the developer have equal priority to the preferred return and that the payback of their respective equity is
proportional to their contributed amount. Hence, the preferred return and equity balance calculations are performed for both the investor and the developer and
later individually proportioned according to their proportionate share.