{rtr€ qf(, f+Art. qcfl d ftg edvisory support for lmplementation of
Gor"rnrn." tnitiative q'rd c-g u-Tundering a qlE.q t crql llfd-<Tst s
ftft* "ftft
d dao (ftllio:-zt'oz'2017 3lqflq< e:oo qd) o1 ordqr$ :-
tT le-ffiq
sqRerfr :-1- fi rrdq eqn.
qftrq,qrq-s qf<, lg6R, q-{rl
z- fi 5dw nsr<,€{ffi qfr'q,
sI;€ q{q, fuan, qe{r t
3- rt s'Aq qqR sr,E*s qAq -q-6- 3ridfu6 frfiq qclr*n-{'
ris€'G $ Wrs frqrrr, fr-6x, qsrTt
4- 4 olqtq c-flr<,
ol-fl gfuE,
<rq-s qfE, kan. qccrt
* {fr{q-{ {q'R fu€r.q$r€r qfl'ett5rft,qlq€ qfq, l+an, qe.crt
3IEIEI
g{€r
{{{g
sflq
s{trI
cftfttu
cfdB'E
cFdfttu
cfafitu
6-
7-
9-
8-
Deloitte Touch Tohmatsu lndia L'L'P
ERNST AND YOUNG LLP
Price Waterhouse Coopers Private Limited'
aft qi< q'"flq,
gfrfrB Beltron e-Proc.
f+ax, qc<rt
fr..T sfrfr o1A_d_6 t qrq d.ffi qercr6TRtji G ftF<rsrdrZgr-d qfrBfutii oI
reT.ro o-rd gv teo o1 6rffi mq"r a1 trfi r teo fr sqRrd !r<-st G ftfr-<rareitZs-{d
qRfrfU ol scRarR 3t-f,.I i qtTlftd t r ge' t66 t Beltron d e-proc. A cftfiB * {i<qnrs .i sqRar $1 $eo n trt ftfr<rcroT sm d cTE-f-d cfrfr.D scF€m ttcr-d alr
Authority letter qftft d vra rqo frtqr rrqr I fu-sq{ s{d ditt 6E<Ierq vE flfiO'3ifu-d fusI
rsrl 2- teo ol drffi ,pq o-rd gv 6=it frB"tr" d qftftMt o) earqrrqr fu
d-64@1 F.Esr qfrft ?,1 ,*-a-u- fr4i-t2o'''ot'E{ frdi ftfo<roor a qRftE wturd
e) t u-ffi a-6-u; u,l q'rffi **-',ruu fuqiq'-rs.oz.zoiz Q Fplo ol rr$ t €_m q'rffi {+c{
d qruqq t elff F.C-<rEror ; ffi "{ * t oen srrff a-6fi fu{rf,- 2o.o7.2o17 o1 fi oo qd
fltrlftoo1.r{roqrinRqio-zooz-zolzoiaoffiftfaEr$ffadqq:t669{rq-s-}.:\ure6\urer\deskrop\e13\eporpre'oer-21 07 2017 dOCX
ERNST AND Youllc L.L.P ftfrqi-qror Er{r sqdEil 6qd tI} self declaration .Iefl qTo s-lqrqrcr{I, ftd A qrqrasfi A fido t s-n-a --+tA fr-s 6l frfld ori ol f,a ftat
;,'";dqtfi ssi6-1e77, ffi zt'ot'zott t Frto a1 T { orn gsfi qfr qfr !E==tnt
6] ,fi ff q{ } 1 n-66 t srfi ftft<r<ror d crfu-fld cfrfrD ai snr eIffi d sfr scrf,eT
-"ff +,aa aa-o-"* d cftftff er*, u,t{ "*e o61 ff.r{rcrrSwn ftft'o eftfr am
*, Uorg"O ortqd 6-C 6r ffs fuqr rql I
g- t66 d corql'rqr 61 f{Ffi un1 d er5er< Qualitv and cost Based :"':'":iry d
ffio ffq fuqr iilrcr tr fcfu{r } "gt r'rio d 3Trf,b n qrK ilf,ffi ftfu{rcit E1
Appendixrl d rgur< Technical Evaluation tft detailed marking d ftt+qoft t'qlt d *{j *3qf,r{-1 qs rid-{ t r sm- A'#- a -g"o trt ftfr-<rsrdrcit 6r Ea score 51 ftmoft
fcfufl s'frft gm qlgr trqr fr gffi A=it s{ Quallty and cost Based selection d criteria
i "ft"d
,o (ou"l 3to t 3{86 score tl qd ilqsT{ effi em tr$q'ftfufl # ot
Fdq ftrqr rrsl I
+- tao ti e-proc. a cfrftfu Erqr qdm'rq ft sm fi-ii ftfr'fl<rflr 6r Financial
uia norRm ftfrsT n frqffto Format aefi €rtd crd d T{f, online glkl E3TI B I Beltron e-
,,""acFdftEda-f,ffis6d,ITtfifi'itFinancialbids4)downloado-t$s.FIhard
"opy nAa qB'fr ol sqded 6trqr arql I Beltron e-proc' d c.frfrB 6m q-a rft qorot 'rqt
fu e-proc. system A 3rTgR Financial bid Sheet generate gen B f fl rfi downtoa'd as qfrfr
5- Download fttn tr} Financial bid \ti Financial bid Sheet ol sffid\-6-{ ftfr{r
q.ftft d west aqr ftqrrqrr fu; of g* qr BfuEr qFlfr d is'.ft s+lrii gq frh-qra'rgii
; rrft"_ gFdEDst gRr E-KTSR 3iftrd frSr :Tzn I ontine generated Financiat bid \?i Financial
ito ,ni", i *g"o fr-dq ftfu-dr (eo me d fu q-s'cn categorv d Expert a1 +4r a ft\3ifu-d El) o1fufr ftruqR q-&,d t
MarksFirmS.No.84
Deloitte Touch Tohmatsu India L L P(i)88
ERNST AND YOUNC LLP90
Price Waterhouse CooPers Private Limited(iii)
Pri cewaterhouseCooPersPrivate Limited
ERNST AND YOUNCLLP
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu lndia
LLP
Name ofthe
BidderPlot No. DN 56 & 57,
Sector V, Salt Lake City,Kolkata - 700091
6th Floor, Wing A&B,Worldmark I ,
New Delhi I 10037Aerocity,Building 10, Gurgaon
DLF Cyber CitY ComPlex,Tower
B, DLF City Phase II, 7th Floor,
,122002
AddressoftheBidder
(:\oreB\u5er\der[top\e1]\"po'pre'ae'-21 07 2017 dOCX
Bq Bt
o1 gqdcr qr{Iql rrqT I
(ii)
Anindya [email protected]
Mr. HonnurMuralidhara,Mob: 98455967
48
Telephone: +91 174 6'19 2302,
Yo611g; +91 9811100081
Fax: +91 124 679 2012
Emai l-akj ain@del oitte.com
Bidder '
ContaclDetails
Total (excluding Service
Tax/or any other taxesapplicable)
Toul (excluding Service
Tax/or anY other taxes
applicable)
Total(excluding
ServiceTax/or
any othertaxes
applicable
Duration
- months(B)No of
positions
Categor
v
46000001296000036ProjectManager
6145273r 0800000
Business
Process
1080000036ICTExpert
1,15,00000r,98,00000
in Fi re
' Total -Amount
One Crore & Fifteen' Lakhs INR onlYOne Crore & Ninety Eight
Lakhs INR onlYThree Crores FourtY Five Lakhs
and Sixty Thousands INR onlY
TotalAmountin Word
,r{ t
6- fi:dt ftfq-{Kmtt d em qqffio fofi-q ftftqi ol ga-<rfl-o frqq"r fiqrrs]{ llfl
7- BIFI g-cffirflo fril{"ft d 3[S-dtf,{ q ge t fu iqd Price waterhouse Coopers Private
r-i*tt"a Jm ffiq Ffu<T t 3ifu-d fl ed dqifi 1'15'oooo0'oo (\'o 6ts q{6 drs so)
+^"tti*; ;' frft. qF.fr ari "fi;*ft t fttun {+<r ol tdBor-r'teg t *t,A- t
#;'q.", et (Lr) 3ifu-d *i *a ftBsr-<ral i Negotiations of 6rfu fii 6r ffqfuqr rrqrt {s'-E 28.07.2017 o} rt.so dd WkT t qroa'<t (L) 3{fu-d$ *frfu+<ror- Price Waterhouse Coopers Private
'imited
t Negotiations 6{i 6l fr'tq fuql
oiftrd E{Firm
Rs 3,45,600001 (Three Crores Forty Five Lakhs
and Sixty Thousands onlY)Deloitte Touch Tohmatsu India L.L'P
Rs. 1,98,000001 (One Crore
only)
& Ninety Eight takhs
2
Rs. l,l 5,00000/- (One Crore & Fifteen Lakhs only)Price Waterhouse CooPers Private
t.imited.3
.:\use,5\use,\desktop\s13\ep-p r"'oe'-2l- 07'2017'doCx
I 7s09454
l 363450000
I6145273 34s0000
3,45,60000
S. No.
1
ERNST AND YOUNG LLP
{qrl i5fil Negotiation n ftfu<r-<mr grn 3rr{i ftffEr sKrs 6r detailed cost breakup $ 3rct
iq<et oql fr*. rmrs a l"^""ir**s Er e-qfi-f,ror frqr qrilnr frfu{r qftfr a1T
ffi;;;; - ; -.tu'gG ffi '-ftf inn a" ffq ftrur z'* tu qo 3raa
]d- ""*,.*;
c{< t 3r;; qiq 6{ 3rifl 3r-j.ff 6ffi ol qtt
qaFIrE grffi 6 sp1 {'eo d ortrslfi qqr( ol 'r{ t
fi.is{ eqncflo qEIo
rise q(<, fr-sn,qe;[rl
\)-fu€T,
J4-"q*ttlutn<#eBq
"rsr; q{<, ft-dtq
qdll I
?'qe'ha..r-l+l+tz,al+
{t\rl g+ \0g
Ytmylr \f-*E ffi" ,aq etn sto* qau frts qfuq'
trqe'qf<, fu6i{. ttc-s r-s TfrCd=nl lrIR
ftl{FT-ie{rif,fu6frfrq sarro-nt
qPds
qrse cf(. REn,qt:{il
"ffimrqrwg qf<, ft-ar<, trc+t
Y 0 )
' a1qtao.- L00O qe+' frct6- !r7'o7'zoll
qfrfuE:- qrftq 3nas-rr6-sfiq, sIq€ qf{ d qqrq 3Tllf, efu'eZq]Tfr'q 3FR s{€l'' q.rs
"q. at*l"gu, qtq€ cfE d ftfr sarqozffis opq-s5-316fu5 ffiu
. ftITFF]I-_ltrItI G 3in +,"-foTlrllq$ffi efrql3r?Y-sfra7m-er-+<remft @Hrt -
qrw€ qf<. n-an, q-e-irZm qf< q-€r<, Beltron d E-Proc d qfufr'EZs'ffJfrErareii oi
qil{T'r, gi affiiwffi orqPi ifuot
DETAILED MARKING SCHEME FOR TECHNICAL EVALUATION
l42020
oJ
bj
ecn PrIId aoIehkwof rne oCCxE n ngpat ve Snoe-CIfo Tt1 tSem nnaM age
ntu Ioalll \ mo aLI ectSn 2be
veboadanProh ccacE
l010l0bjroJ
meo nts,erna e CS n SAssfen oCCxE erpUenMana gemfomento rncC
ol-Tl 5Iax ulImac1eCC LIShaceM Sk'l p
o Each Pro ect should be of val ue of Rs 1 Cr. and above
0l0510
t of Bihar in ProjectExperience of Assisting Governmen
bjfo oJ
nme ncaM all ts,f 5Oto aS LI eccc1acheks IarM p
vebod anCRs.fLI oeo ihS LIo decPro
Firm'sExperience(Marks =40): Last 3
years onlY(work orderof the period01" January,201 3 - 31"December2016)
Project Managera. Should be a full time employee
(necessary requirement)
b. B.Tech and MBA (in HRiFinance): 5 Marks;
c. Minimum 7 Years of exP: 5 Marks;
d. Should have worked with the Govt (Min 3
Projects): 5 Marks;
e. Proiect Managemenl experience in Systems- irt.grution and IT solutions implementation for at
i.u.i ptoj".t. of value more than INR I crore: 5
I
of the firm
Marks;
J
ERNSTANI)
YOUNGLLP
Max. PointsCriteria for Point allotmentS.N. li Ileading
Project Team(60 marks)
15 l520
'hicewaterhotls
e CoopersPrivate Limited
Deloite TouchTtrhmatsu lndia
LLP
14
CovernmentwithU
marks,l1
should be of value of Rs. I Cr.
Each project
l0 projects.
10ProjeclBihar,
thanothernits,ln
tofor
10Umaximum2
lvalbeEach
ScorcNo ofpositi
onsPosition
2{)
20
20t
Business Process ExPert
".--i.i*f, (in Computer Science/Electronics)/MCA : 5
Marks;b. Minimum 5 Years of exP: 5 Marks;
c. Should have worked with Covernment (min 3
oroiects): 5 Marks;
d. liroufa have experience of lTie-Cov initiatives for
govemment at least 3 Projects: 5 Marks;
202020
8E9084Total
I
ICT Expertu. Sf,orfa be a B.Tech (in Computer Sc or
Elecrronics)/MCA. (necessary requirement)
b. Should have CCNA/CCNP Certificate - 5 Marks
c. Minimunr 5 Years of exP: 5 Marks;
O. Si,orfa have experience in Systems lntegration and
lT solutions implementation for al least 3 pro;ects ol
value more than INR I crores: 5 Marks;
e. Should have experience of lT/e-Gov initiatives for
government at least 3 Projects: 5 Marks;
, Deloilts Touch
Mar. Points 'lrrhtrtatsu Indi:rt,LP
Pricewaterhouse Coopqn
iiivate lir:iired
ERNSTAND
YOTJNGt.t.Periteria:foi Point allotmentS.N.';''ll Hdnding
]l I 20 I ls
1tI
HI I
20
I