Numerical simulation of ceiling collapse in full-scale gymnasium specimen using ASI-Gauss technique 11th World Congress on Computational Mechanics (WCCM XI)
5th European Conference on Computational Mechanics (ECCM V) 6th European Conference on Computational Fluid Dynamics (ECFD VI)
E. Oñate, J. Oliver and A. Huerta (Eds)
NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF CEILING COLLAPSE IN FULL-SCALE GYMNASIUM SPECIMEN USING ASI–GAUSS TECHNIQUE
H. Tagawa1, T. Yamamoto2, T. Yamashita1, T. Sasaki1 and D. Isobe3 1 Hyogo Earthquake Engineering Research Center
National Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention (NIED) 1501-21 Nishikameya, Mitsuda, Shijimi-cho, Miki, Hyogo 673-0515, Japan
e-mail: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], www.bosai.go.jp/hyogo/
2 Graduate School, University of Tsukuba
1-1-1 Tennodai, Tsukuba-shi, Ibaraki 305-8573, Japan e-mail: [email protected], www.kz.tsukuba.ac.jp
3 Division of Engineering Mechanics and Energy, University of Tsukuba
1-1-1 Tennodai, Tsukuba-shi, Ibaraki 305-8573, Japan e-mail: [email protected], www.kz.tsukuba.ac.jp/~isobe/
Key Words: Ceiling Collapse, Gymnasium, ASI–Gauss Technique, Finite Element Method
Abstract. Many ceiling collapse accidents were observed during the 2011 Great East Japan earthquake and have been observed during other earthquakes in Japan. A numerical seismic simulation of the collapse of the ceiling in a full-scale gymnasium specimen, which was tested at the E-Defense shaking table facility in 2014 [1], was conducted. The numerical model represented steel structural frames and a suspended ceiling. All of the members were modeled using linear Timoshenko beam elements. The adaptively shifted integration–Gauss technique, which shifts the numerical integration point adaptively to an appropriate position, was applied to a nonlinear finite element analysis of this structurally discontinuous problem. The preliminary simulation results showed that ceiling collapse progressed owing to detachment of the clips that connected the ceiling joists to the ceiling joist receivers and eventually resulted in the ceiling falling down.
1 INTRODUCTION
A large-space building, such as a school gymnasium, which is typically used as a shelter during major earthquakes, must maintain its ability to function after an earthquake disaster and withstand aftershocks. After the main shock of the 2011 Great East Japan earthquake, a series of aftershocks occurred, and it was reported that, in addition to the human casualties suffered, many school gymnasiums failed to function as shelters because of the structural damage that they suffered, including column–base damage, brace buckling, and damage caused by falling nonstructural elements such as ceiling components and lighting equipment. To address these problems, design guidelines for suspended ceilings have been issued by
1398
seduwh
shsuofwaTi[3
2
2.
m boofgirgirturbo
illmocomoonthinuon
2.2
att
verurinhicTo
hakiuspef thas cimo]. T
M
1 GA an
oth f thrderdernb
oltsTh
lustode
onnode
ne mis r
umbn th
2 SA
tach
ral ng ph a
o exingende cconoshThe
MOD
Gypic
nd tthe
he cers, ers buc, an
he trateled
necteledmemreaberhe f
Sustyphed
inspre
are xam
g taded collnduenk
e m
DE
mncturthe e Xconbeare
klend tnum
ted d utiond umbson
r offirst
Fig
spepicad to
stituevionotminablece
apsucteko b
mode
ELI
nasre otop
X annstreame fes. Tthemerin
usinns usinber n, nf elet flo
gur
endal co th
utiooust nene e t
eilinse oed. beaelin
ING
siumof tp ond Yruct
ms, framThe
e roricaFig
ng lwe
ng pbe
nodemoor
re 1
ded conhe
ons eaecethetestng aof tTh
am ng m
G O
m Sthe of tY dtionand
mede b
oof pal gurline
ere pin mo
des ment
r w
1: G
Cenfigcei
H
s. Tarthssa
e cot wat tthe
he seleme
OF
Spespe
the diren od rod ieampurmore 2ear moco
odewe
ts were
Gym
eiligurailin
H. Ta
Theshquarilyolla
wasthe ce
simuemeetho
A G
ecimecimslo
ectiof aoofintoms,rlinode2. A
Tiode
onneledere wase fix
mna
ng atio
ng j
agaw
se guakey dapss c
E-eilinulaentod a
GY
menmeopeionan ef puo th ex
ns al oAll imoeledect
d wpla
s 17xed
asiu
on jois
wa,
guies aeriv
se mondDeng atios anand
YM
n en ied rns. Telemurlihe
xcepare of t
ofoshd ution
withace7,9d, an
um
of st w
T. Y
idelandvedmeducefenin tn wnd
d pr
MNA
s shrooThemens co
pt tconthe f thhenkusinns ih oned a00,nd
m sp
a swit
Yam
lined exd frcha
ctednse the
wasthe
reli
ASI
howof ise pientaare
olumthonne
gyhe mko ng in fnly at th, anthe
peci
sush s
mam
es axpe
romanisd osh
e gys bae adimin
IUM
wn s 9itchary e stmnsse i
ecteymmembearig
fututwhe nd te gr
ime
penscre
moto
areerim
m thsm onaki
ymnaseddapnar
M
in .09h oor
teels bin ted tnasmbamgid ure
wo eendtherou
en
ndeews
o, T
bamenhe a
ofa
ing nasd o
ptivry s
SP
Fig9 mf thm
l mby the to tsiumers
m elco
simelemd a tot
und
ed cs, t
T. Y
2
asedntaactuf aful tab
siumon nvelysim
PEC
gurm abhe r
middmem
we brthe m s, inlemonnmulmenandtal mo
F
ceithe
Yama
2
d ol d
ual su
ll-sble m snony sh
mula
CIM
re 1bovroodle-
mbereldiacegirspenclu
mentnectlatints
d cenu
otio
Figu
lingce
ashi
on idata
behuspscal
facspecnlinhifteatio
ME
1. Tve tof is-schrs winged frderecimudits. tionionsto
enteumbon a
ure
g ieilin
ita,
nvea obhavendle cilicim
neared
on r
EN W
Thethe s 3/hoowith. Tframrs wmening In ns, s. Tacc
er pber acc
2:
s ilng
T. S
estibtaiviordedschity menr finint
resu
WI
e plgr
/10ol gh w
Themeswithn, thethiw
Thecurpoinof
cele
Mo
llusjoi
Sasa
igainer ofd cehooin 2
n, oniteegrults
ITH
an roun0 (=gymwide brs, ah bince pis p
where Aratents no
erat
ode
straists
aki
tioned ff coeili
ol g201
obsee elratis ar
H A
of nd.
= 3.mnade-fracare boltcludplasprelrea
ASI–ely
ofodestion
el o
atedar
and
ns fromollainggym14 ervlemon
re p
A S
the Th.6/1asiuflances cons.dinsterlims b–Grep
f alls wn w
of g
d inre a
d D.
of m sapse, amna[1]
ved men
(Apres
US
e firhe 12)um nge
arenne
g ir bo
minaboltaus
presl of
was was
gym
n Fatta
Iso
ceiscaed
a thasiu. Ain
nt aASI)sent
SPE
rst spe. Thinor
e recte
its oardary tedss tsenf th13inp
mna
Figuache
obe
ilinale cei
hreeum
A nuthe
anal)–Gted
END
floecimhe
n Jach
roued t
sud osim
d cotechnt phe m3,73put
asiu
ure ed
ng dmo
iline-d
m spume shlysi
Gaud in
DE
oor mespe
apahannund to t
speon tmuonnhni
plasme36. at
um
3. to
damodegs. imepec
merichakis u
uss thi
ED
is 3n hecimn. nel
stethe
endthe
ulatinecquetic
embAlthe
spe
Plthe
magls o
enscimcal
kingutilitecis p
CE
30.has meTh seeelco
ded ceion
ctioe rebe
bersll oese
ecim
laste c
ge oof
sionmen
simg taizin
chnpap
EIL
0 m6
en ihe c
ctio balum
ceeilinn, ans equhavs. Tf thnod
men
ter ceili
obscei
nal w
muableng iquer.
LIN
m ×spas tycoluonsars mns
eilinng,
all owi
uirevioThehe ndes
n
boaing
servilin
(3with
latie teline
ue [
NG
× 18ansypiums. T
ws w
ng, we
of till
es thr. F
e tonods.
ardg jo
vedgs,
3D)h aionest,ear[2],
8.6 incalns,
Thewithwith
iserethebe
hatForotaldes
d isoist
d
a n
r
n l
h h
t r l
t
1399
rechadeanmo
sp4(nuele1,cli
4
ad
ceiangetacnd codeTh
pecia),
umeem147ip h
ANTh
dapt
verers
chmceileledhe simean
ericment
7 mheig
NAhe Ative
rs ws. Inmenlingd ususpen. nd tcal t as
mm ght
ALYASIely
witn pnt og jo
usinpenA
the mo
ssemalo
t wa
YSI–Gto
th cprevof thoist
ng bndepicnu
odembongas 2
Fi
IS Gau
an
clipviouhe t rebeamed ccturumeel oblagg th25
(aigur
MEuss n ap
H
ps, us cei
eceim eceilre oeric
of age. he smm
a) Gre 3
ETtec
ppro
H. Ta
anear
iliniveelemlingof tcal a pa
Thslopm.
Glo3: T
THOchnopr
agaw
nd trthq
ng jrs fmeg wthe mo
art ohe hpe i
obaTyp
ODniquriat
wa,
thequaoisfallnt t
was su
odeof thanin t
al pica
Fi
D ue [te p
T. Y
ceaket cllingthamospeel othe
nginthe
al c
igu
[2]posi
Yam
eilins, mlipsg dat caodeendof t ceng Y-
con
ure
, [3itio
mam
ng mas an
dowan eledded the eilinbol
-dir
nfig
4: M
3], won,
moto
joiany nd
wn. simd acceien
ng ilt wrect
ura
Mo
whwa
o, T
ist cehanTh
mulaccuilin
ntireis swertion
atio
ode
hichas e
T. Y
3
receilinnge
hereate
uratng ie sushore sn. T
on o
el of
h wemp
Yama
3
ceivng ers,eforfra
telyin tusp
ownspaThe
of s
f su
was ploy
ashi
vercol, rere, actuy, athe penn inacede ha
susp
usp
useyed
ita,
rs allapsulin
ureacco
gyded
n Fid 1ang
pen
pend
ed d in
T. S
arepse ltinthe. ordymnd cigu,00
ging
(nde
ded
to n a
Sasa
atac
g ine m
dingnasieili
ure 400 mg bo
(b) d c
d ce
shino
aki
tacccidn th
mod
g toiuming4(cmmolts
Deceili
eilin
ift tonli
and
cheddenthe
del,
o drm spg is c), am as w
etaiing
ng
the inea
d D.
d tts hplathe
rawpecsh
alonapar
were
l g (p
nuar f
Iso
o thavastee c
wingcimhowng rt ie 1,
pers
umefini
obe
the ve ber bclip
gs omen wn i
wiin t,50
spec
ericite
habee
boas a
of n is in Fith the
00 m
ctiv
cal ele
angen crd,
and
theshoFigtheX-
mm
ve)
inteme
gingcauceha
e deow
guree de-dir
m lo
egrent
g busedilin
ange
esigwn in
e 4etairec
ong,
ratiana
boltd bng jers
gn on F
4(b)ils otion, an
ion aly
t wby tjoiswe
of tFigu). Tof tn and t
poysis
withthests,ere
theure
Thetheandthe
oint of
h
d
t f
1400
H. Tagawa, T. Yamamoto, T. Yamashita, T. Sasaki and D. Isobe
4
the structure. The locations of the numerical integration and stress evaluation points used in the ASI–Gauss technique are illustrated in Figure 5. Two consecutive elements forming a member are considered to be a subset, and the numerical integration points of an elastically deformed member are placed such that the stress evaluation points are coincident with the Gaussian integration points of the member. Therefore, stresses and strains are evaluated at the Gaussian integration points of elastically deformed members, and the accuracy of the bending deformation is guaranteed even using one-point integration.
The updated Lagrangian method was used to consider geometric nonlinearity in the incremental analysis. The conjugate gradient (CG) method was used to solve the linear equations. The Newmark– method was used for implicit time integration. The time step of the analysis was 1.0 × 10-3 s. The numerical simulation of the ceiling collapse was considered a structurally discontinuous problem. The detachments of the ceiling joists and ceiling joist receivers were considered by setting the sectional forces of the clips and hangers to be zero once the axial forces acting on these members exceeded the maximum strength. The contact of members with the ground was also considered.
Figure 5 Location of numerical integration and stress evaluation points considered with the
ASI–Gauss technique
5 PRELIMINARY SIMULATION RESULTS A nonlinear time history simulation was conducted for the model of the full-scale
gymnasium specimen with its suspended ceiling. The ground motion acceleration K-NET Sendai, which was observed during the 2011 Great East Japan earthquake and is shown in Figure 6, was scaled by 0.5 and input at all nodes on the first floor. The maximum strength of all of the clips was set to be 0.4 kN [4], and that of all the hangers was set to be 2.8 kN [5], to model the detachment of these elements.
The simulation results are shown in Figure 7. The ceiling joists and plaster boards on the right side of the suspended ceiling started to fall down approximately 72.5 s after the commencement of the simulation, as shown in Figure 7(a). The ceiling collapse commenced at 72.95 s, as shown in Figure 7(b). The clips became detached from the ceiling joist receivers, and the ceiling joists and plaster boards fell down at 74.2 s, as shown in Figure 7(c). Finally, the suspended ceiling had fallen completely at 75.2 s, as shown in Figure 7(d). The ceiling joists and plaster boards were all piled on the first floor. These results show that the numerical simulation of the ceiling collapse could be successfully conducted using the ASI–Gauss technique.
1401
6
coth
IMTh
orree 3
TccebA
(a)
(c)
MPhe nespoD sTheconconelembraA s
) Th
) Pr
PRnumondshae bennecnnecmencessusp
hre
rogr
ROVmerds bakineamctectiontss, anpen
esho
res
VEMricabettng tms d tons. Tnd nde
old
sio
MEal mter tabare
to ts. IThe
rooed c
H
Fi
d of
on o
ENmod
to tle te tothe In se of pceil
H. Ta
igur
f ce
of c
TSdel thetesto be
giaddiss
purling
agaw
re 6
ilin
ceili
S INsho
e gyt. Te cirdeditiueslinsg is
wa,
6: G
ng c
ing
N FownymnThe onners on,s ws. s us
T. Y
Gro
coll
g co
FUTn innasiss
necwi
, bwill
sua
Yam
oun
lap
olla
TURn Fsiumsuesctedith racbe
ally
mam
nd m
pse
apseFig
REigum ss tod tobo
ces e ad
y su
moto
mot
(72
e (7gur
E SIure speco beo tholts.
widdr
urro
o, T
tion
2.5
74.2re 7
IM2 icime adhe c. Cith ress
oun
T. Y
5
n ac
s)
2 s)7: S
MULs b
menddrcolu
Currtu
sed
nde
Yama
5
cce
(b
) imu
LAein
n anressumrent
urnbd by
d b
ashi
eler
b) P
(dula
ATIOng ind bsed
mns tly,bucy u
by o
ita,
ratio
Prog
d) Catio
ONmpbett
d in wi
, thckleusin
out
T. S
on
gre
Comn r
NSprovter fut
ith hesees ang t
ter
Sasa
(K
essi
mplesu
vedsimturebole caretrus
wa
aki
-NE
on
leteults
d anmule silts,
conne cuss e
alls
and
ET
of
e fa
nd clateimu annecurreelem
. In
d D.
Se
cei
llin
calies thulatnd tctioentme
n th
Iso
end
ilin
ng-d
ibrahe btionthe ons tly ents
he g
obe
dai)
ng c
dow
atebehns aroarmo
s to
gym
coll
wn
d shavare
oof re modeo m
mn
laps
(75
o thvior
as pur
modeled
mod
asiu
se(7
5.2
hatr obfolrlindeld udel
um
72.
s)
t thebserllowns aed
usinthe
m sp
.95
e mrvews.are as
ng e be
pec
s)
moded i to rig
beaeam
ime
del n
begidamms,
en,
d
m
1402
7
whutisimcofalsu
RE[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
lwsIgpss
CA
hicilizmuonnllin
uspe
EF] T
EK
] YaE
] Ksp
] SsI
] TTSJ
latewalshoIn tgympartshasim
CONnu
h wzingulatinectng dend
FERT. SE-DKinY. anaEngK. strupp.2S. MstylInstT. STesSumJap
erallls,
ouldthe mnatial
akinmula
NCumewasg liionted dow
ded
RENSasDefnki-To
alysginM.
uctu253Mole otituSugsts mmpans
l joas
d becu
asiul cong tatio
CLUerics teine
n shthe
wn.ce
NCsakfens-Bri ansis eer. Lyure38-otoyof cute giyon
marise)
oists she courreumollatab
ons
UScal estear
howe c. Tilin
CESi, Kse
rancnd
ofringynns, I
-25yuiceilof
yamStr
ies
s arhowonsent
m spapsble .
(a
IOsimd aTim
wedeilihe
ng w
S K. KShch AD. f fg, Vn anInte63,, YlingTec
ma, Yrucof
H
re swn sidemo
pecie otes
a) E
NSmulat thmo
d thingiss
wit
KajakeAnnIso
framVolnd ern, 20
Y. Sg, 8chnY. turTec
H. Ta
set in eredodeimeof tst. M
ElevF
S latiohe E
oshehat tg josueth th
jiwe Tnuaobemel.36D.
nati007Sato8th noloNu
ral Echn
agaw
onFigd inel, ten, theMo
vatFig
on E-Denktheistss tohe
waraTabal Me, Aed 6, p. Isona
7. o anIntogy
ukuElenica
wa,
n thgurn futhethe ce
ode
tiongure
of Defko e ces too bout
a, Able MeeAda
strpp.2sobeal J
nd terny, T
ui, Temeal P
T. Y
he pe 8utur ceese eilinling
n (Xe 8:
thefenbea
eilino thbe ater
A. AEx
etinaptiruct232e, FJou
T. natiTokT. KentsPap
Yam
peri8. Tre s
eilinme
ng g o
X-Z: La
e conse am ng he caddwa
Aoixperng, ivelture
23-2Finurna
Koion
kyoKass anpers
mam
imeThesimng emjoi
of t
Z) ater
ollashael
colceildresalls,
i, HrimOsly ses, 233nite al o
oshnal , Ja
shiwnd Fs of
moto
etere co
mulajoi
mberiststhes
ral
apsakinemllaplingssed, ar
H. Tmensakashif
In39,
eleof N
hikaCo
apawazFulf A
o, T
rs sontaatiosts rs hs anse
joi
e ong
mentpse g jod inre a
Tagnts a, Jftednte199emNum
awaonfean, Mzakll-snnu
T. Y
6
so tactons
anhavnd me
ists
of thtabts proistn f
add
gawon
Jund in
erna93.
mentme
a: CerenMa
ki, Ascalual
Yama
6
thatof
. nd cve s
ceiemb
to
he ble and
rogrt hafutures
wa, W
ne 2ntegatio t co
eric
ChancearchA. Yle Pl M
ashi
t thf th
ceilspliilinbers
be
ceifac
d thressangure sed
T. Wide21-2graona
odecal M
arae onh 7-YabPart
Meet
ita,
he che s
lingces
ng js w
in
ilincilithe sedgerssim
d.
Are-a22, atioal
e foMe
cten U-8, buutialting
T. S
ceilsusp
g jos thjois
with
con
ng ity iAS
d ows anmul
rai, area
20on t
Jou
or ietho
eristUrb
20uchl Mg, A
Sasa
lingpen
oisthat st rh sp
nta
n ain 2SI–winnd lati
T. a S014techurn
impods
ticsban 11.
hi anModeAIJ,
aki
g cande
t remareceplic
(bact w
a fu201–Gang tult
ions
KaSusp. (inhniqnal
pacts in
s ofEa
. nd el o, B-
and
an ed c
eceiay beivces
b) Ewit
ull-s14, aussto ttims, i
anapenn Jque
of
t con En
f marth
T. of C-1,
d D.
be ceil
ivebec
verss m
Elevth c
scawas tethe
mateincl
ai, Mnsioapae fo
of N
ollangi
metahqu
KoConpp
Iso
in ling
ers coms, a
may
vatceil
ale as sech de
ely lud
M. on aneor fNu
apsinee
al juak
obaynve. 22
obe
cong w
areme sas o
be
ionling
gymsucchniqetacres
ding
TaCe
ese)finiume
se perin
joinke E
yasenti27-
ntawith
e cosepobse re
n (Yg
mncesquechmsultg th
akaoeilin) ite eric
prong,
nt pEng
shi:iona-23
act wh th
ontiparaerv
equ
Y-Z
nasissfue. Amented he c
okang
elecal
ble Vo
partgine
: Stal T0, 2
withe
inuatedveduire
Z)
umullyA pnt o
in con
a, YSy
emeM
emsol.6
ts ieer
taticTyp200
th tout
uoud and ined i
m spy copreof c
thentac
Y. Iyste
ent Meth
s of69,
in Jring
c Lpe C09.
the ter
s. Ind
n thin f
pecondlim
clipe cct o
Iwaems
colhod
f frNo
Japg, T
LoaCei(in
ouwa
In tcau
he 3futu
imeductminaps theiliof t
ashis, A
llapds
ramo.
paneTok
dinilinn
uteralls
theuse3Dure
en,tedaryhatingthe
ita,AIJ
psein
med12,
esekyo
ng ng,
r
d y t g
J
d
1403