DIESEL AND ELECTRIC POWERED PUMP IRRIGATION
A Comparative Cost Analysis
Alkhter liddin Ahmed
US Agency for International Development
May 1981 Dacca Bangladesh
DIESEL AND ELECTRIC POWERED PUMP IRRIGATION
A Comparative Cost Analysis
Contents PAge
Introduction 1
Methodology 1
Summary of Findings 4
ANNEX A - Deep Tubewell 8
ANNEX B - Low Lift Pump 15
ANNEX C - Shallow Tubewell 21
Akhter Uddin Ahmed
Agricultural Economist
US Agency for International Development
May 1981Dacca Bangladesh
DIESEL AND ELECTRIC POWERED PUMP IRRIGATION
A Comparative Cost Analysis
Introduction
It is expected that power irrigation pump operators will be important users of electricity when made available to rural areas in the future Currently most irrigation pumps operating in rural Banglashydesh are diesel powered
Converioq IrFe t- elc-cri oer irrigation and expansion of el ctric poer ieneration an distribution require heavy investments
An assessment of the coriparamptive coss o1 diesel and electric powered
irrigation is essential to determine the soundness of these investments
Methodology of Analysis
The mctlod of economic analysis used here is a comparison of costs associat-oi with diesel and electric powei-fd irrigation systems currently operating in Bangladesh The aialysis ex-amines the costs of deeD tubeshywell (Annex A) low lifts pump (Annex B) and shallow tubewell (Annex C) irrigaticn systems
The analysis is limited exclusively to the cost side of the equation Whether diesel powered or electric powered a particular pump system is assumed to cover the same acreage and cropsl A comparison of cost effectiveness of the tw power sources therefore only takes into account the cost considerations The impact of electric versus diesel powered irrigation on pump comnvnid area and cropping patterns is left for 3 separate analysis
The analysis is conducted from two cost comparison stand points (1) newly installed diesel powered and electric powered iirigation pumps and (2) diesel powered pumps and electric powered pumps converted from diesel after a certain time period Based on the age of the majority
1 One b-nefit of pump electrification might result from the greater reliability and much lower breakdown frequency of an electric pump which may contribute to additional pumping hours Thus it is reasonshyable to assume that using electric powered irrigation pumps more area will be irrigated and agriculture output will increase On the other hand the benefit of a diesel punp is its independence of a fixed location Moreover stocks of diesel fuel can be stored up not the case for electric supply where users have no control if supply of electricity is disrupted it may be disasterous for crop production However t se assumptions heed field verification for proper analysis
number of pumps currently in operation it is assumed that on thu
average 5 y old dLep tubewelli a- low lift pumps and 2 ycar old
shallow tubcwampus are convrtcd into eic-ctric powered pumps
The analysis takes into account three cost categorics which
vary widely among pumping systems These cateories are-
Investmen Costr (Tables A- I B-] _)I All capital costs of
diesel and eclcctric powered deep tuhewells low lift pumps ad shallow
tubewells are identified TradC and transncrt cost and overhead cost
are added to total capital cost to duterninc investment cost of each
pump type Salvarc vluos of different equipmcnt arc also considered
Investmont ccst - and salvagc values arc discount ( over the life span
of pumps and the salvage values aro deductcd from investment cost to
detcrmindn the pre-sent value of cost strea- of investment costs
Power Costs (Tables A-2 B-2 C-2) Diesel and electric power
costs are calculated based on the assumptions used in the analysis
Fuel and lubricants arc priced cif Chittagong plus trade and transshy
port cost Tesc prices prevailcd in May 1981 As the world market
price of fuel escalates frequently the reader is cautioned that the
power cost of diesel pumps should also be adjusted accordingly Because
of the complexitics in calculating the real cost of electricity to
society electricity rate recommended by the Rural Electrification
Board for irrigation has been used A sensitivity cnalysis is also
done to show the- impact cn costs using alternative power rates (Table 4)
Power cost is discounted over th life span of the pumps to determine
the prcsent value of power cost stream
Opcratin and Maintcna ncc Costs (able A-2 B-2 C-2) Salary or
opportunity costs of labor for operation and protection of pumps lubrishy
cant costs and costs of repair and maintenance are calculated and disshy
counted over the life span of pumps to determine the present value of
operation and maintenance cost stream
Discount Rates Because some ol the above costs particularly
investment costs take place at different times depending on the life
of equipment it was necessary to olbtain present values of cost expendishy
tures for the purpose of comparison between electric and diesel powered
irrigationi pumps Cst streams are cxpresscd in present values applying of 10 percent is assumeddiscounted measurcs A real discount rate
with all monetary values put into real tcrms by deflating and thereby rate of return not aeliminating the clement of inflation As a real
nominal rate bolster(d by inflation 10 percent discount rate is
believed to be appropriatoI
1 Bangladesh Power Devclopment Board Tarrif Study Vol I Coopers amp
Lybrand Associates Limited November 1979 Chapter 8 pp 9-11
Tht followirn mnthmnticl fo-muii is used to find tht present valuc of cost st P
= C CC)+ + C t _ t
wherc
Total investmcnt cost incurred in year 0Co
=Cost incurrtd ii vcr tCt
= Salv ic v-1Lu_ in year tAt
n = Life of lU11) tubuwcl]
r = Interest (di scount) rate
Socinl Costs vs Privte Costs Finally tho reader should note
cccwci0C si from ofthat this 111 -carri d out the point of view
costs incurred yvsocity not by the rivaN individual Bucause duties -nd L -s W pvovn(hni vrv vjciv among different
componcnts of uh cus r usrp rent or purchasc irrigation
pumps PE MOAKamp r mnjr rc ca ptu i difficult is surround
determination of piOW tat C( Uc tl actual costs arc shared
between the public (ovarnmavet) ind privt (farmors) sectors of the
econuJoy i s also nLt N t connurn of tiLF salxsls
Data for th ana]ysis hav boo provi dod by the planners and engineers of the Bang]adesh Aricullu ini Development Corporation
(BAI)C) and the Rura Electrification Board (REB) They are to be
thanked for their collaboration
3
SuMin0 - J i__
f - -- types vi ] E trii C puphover diesel
in ri is fro deep
in u__ivJ 1d i swthat there nrc signishy
p f ampW SAtnrv ii t t u ] n] -z 1 0 - 1 A u n y b- d S h J ull s - I K]] ] p n A_Y t I II
iiibsol I thi 1 just thL r vt v]i o M luA ubewelIs fo]ul- 5y i a p anld Olup t uLwlPli 110in I heca-usu cost Of dCC LAir i 1 n t 7 nn jit- tia11 10 ibu r ]ow lift pump
and Lh-1 w I ubV( t Y-s ewivvtIv
Talle 1 Con]maatrivc Savin from Elcctrjfiqd over Diesel Powered rri risr Pumps 1
Present Vaiue of
C- 1t St-re=n_ Cost SavingsType -Pum [cteict1-i c Amount Percent
Dcep T 1bveI 47 C (0( 364201 105868 23
Luw I if I u1 ]9 S2684 32284 28
Shal Tubwe 7163B 4565 26073 35
1 Refr te Tabjc3 -3 B-3 and C-3
y
to - 1 lLx _ [ (_2-t aibl 2 w thE CompnSition of COM- Slln t17 Oftvu di-1 I(wl~Tc1 -uMj by type of CuSt F I mt in aibsIlutt n T y in iii investment costs
in t11h O r wp itu i] f l wd bv Kw lift pur an~d shallow tuhIt ] i I K A (f nv Fr in w ro -Alow tubowel Is rank hir~eSt ampKOWA IV I ft pU Mid dUL P tuK ItI and in case of operaiLto ow t arL iow andixt W pumps followed s tubewcl ls doep tubeumrl
able 2 Composition of Savings Ire Elct rificd nver PiisOl Powered Irrigtation Pumpsl
yj3e of S vings S2
Type of I= Investment IIower Operation Total
Deep lubo-1 48 29 237 1001Z
Low lift _ziv 35A 35 30Z 1007
Shallow Thkw il 11 60 29 100
1 Refer Tables A- B-4 and C-4
2 Includ- lubricant operators salary repair and maintenance costs
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
DIESEL AND ELECTRIC POWERED PUMP IRRIGATION
A Comparative Cost Analysis
Contents PAge
Introduction 1
Methodology 1
Summary of Findings 4
ANNEX A - Deep Tubewell 8
ANNEX B - Low Lift Pump 15
ANNEX C - Shallow Tubewell 21
Akhter Uddin Ahmed
Agricultural Economist
US Agency for International Development
May 1981Dacca Bangladesh
DIESEL AND ELECTRIC POWERED PUMP IRRIGATION
A Comparative Cost Analysis
Introduction
It is expected that power irrigation pump operators will be important users of electricity when made available to rural areas in the future Currently most irrigation pumps operating in rural Banglashydesh are diesel powered
Converioq IrFe t- elc-cri oer irrigation and expansion of el ctric poer ieneration an distribution require heavy investments
An assessment of the coriparamptive coss o1 diesel and electric powered
irrigation is essential to determine the soundness of these investments
Methodology of Analysis
The mctlod of economic analysis used here is a comparison of costs associat-oi with diesel and electric powei-fd irrigation systems currently operating in Bangladesh The aialysis ex-amines the costs of deeD tubeshywell (Annex A) low lifts pump (Annex B) and shallow tubewell (Annex C) irrigaticn systems
The analysis is limited exclusively to the cost side of the equation Whether diesel powered or electric powered a particular pump system is assumed to cover the same acreage and cropsl A comparison of cost effectiveness of the tw power sources therefore only takes into account the cost considerations The impact of electric versus diesel powered irrigation on pump comnvnid area and cropping patterns is left for 3 separate analysis
The analysis is conducted from two cost comparison stand points (1) newly installed diesel powered and electric powered iirigation pumps and (2) diesel powered pumps and electric powered pumps converted from diesel after a certain time period Based on the age of the majority
1 One b-nefit of pump electrification might result from the greater reliability and much lower breakdown frequency of an electric pump which may contribute to additional pumping hours Thus it is reasonshyable to assume that using electric powered irrigation pumps more area will be irrigated and agriculture output will increase On the other hand the benefit of a diesel punp is its independence of a fixed location Moreover stocks of diesel fuel can be stored up not the case for electric supply where users have no control if supply of electricity is disrupted it may be disasterous for crop production However t se assumptions heed field verification for proper analysis
number of pumps currently in operation it is assumed that on thu
average 5 y old dLep tubewelli a- low lift pumps and 2 ycar old
shallow tubcwampus are convrtcd into eic-ctric powered pumps
The analysis takes into account three cost categorics which
vary widely among pumping systems These cateories are-
Investmen Costr (Tables A- I B-] _)I All capital costs of
diesel and eclcctric powered deep tuhewells low lift pumps ad shallow
tubewells are identified TradC and transncrt cost and overhead cost
are added to total capital cost to duterninc investment cost of each
pump type Salvarc vluos of different equipmcnt arc also considered
Investmont ccst - and salvagc values arc discount ( over the life span
of pumps and the salvage values aro deductcd from investment cost to
detcrmindn the pre-sent value of cost strea- of investment costs
Power Costs (Tables A-2 B-2 C-2) Diesel and electric power
costs are calculated based on the assumptions used in the analysis
Fuel and lubricants arc priced cif Chittagong plus trade and transshy
port cost Tesc prices prevailcd in May 1981 As the world market
price of fuel escalates frequently the reader is cautioned that the
power cost of diesel pumps should also be adjusted accordingly Because
of the complexitics in calculating the real cost of electricity to
society electricity rate recommended by the Rural Electrification
Board for irrigation has been used A sensitivity cnalysis is also
done to show the- impact cn costs using alternative power rates (Table 4)
Power cost is discounted over th life span of the pumps to determine
the prcsent value of power cost stream
Opcratin and Maintcna ncc Costs (able A-2 B-2 C-2) Salary or
opportunity costs of labor for operation and protection of pumps lubrishy
cant costs and costs of repair and maintenance are calculated and disshy
counted over the life span of pumps to determine the present value of
operation and maintenance cost stream
Discount Rates Because some ol the above costs particularly
investment costs take place at different times depending on the life
of equipment it was necessary to olbtain present values of cost expendishy
tures for the purpose of comparison between electric and diesel powered
irrigationi pumps Cst streams are cxpresscd in present values applying of 10 percent is assumeddiscounted measurcs A real discount rate
with all monetary values put into real tcrms by deflating and thereby rate of return not aeliminating the clement of inflation As a real
nominal rate bolster(d by inflation 10 percent discount rate is
believed to be appropriatoI
1 Bangladesh Power Devclopment Board Tarrif Study Vol I Coopers amp
Lybrand Associates Limited November 1979 Chapter 8 pp 9-11
Tht followirn mnthmnticl fo-muii is used to find tht present valuc of cost st P
= C CC)+ + C t _ t
wherc
Total investmcnt cost incurred in year 0Co
=Cost incurrtd ii vcr tCt
= Salv ic v-1Lu_ in year tAt
n = Life of lU11) tubuwcl]
r = Interest (di scount) rate
Socinl Costs vs Privte Costs Finally tho reader should note
cccwci0C si from ofthat this 111 -carri d out the point of view
costs incurred yvsocity not by the rivaN individual Bucause duties -nd L -s W pvovn(hni vrv vjciv among different
componcnts of uh cus r usrp rent or purchasc irrigation
pumps PE MOAKamp r mnjr rc ca ptu i difficult is surround
determination of piOW tat C( Uc tl actual costs arc shared
between the public (ovarnmavet) ind privt (farmors) sectors of the
econuJoy i s also nLt N t connurn of tiLF salxsls
Data for th ana]ysis hav boo provi dod by the planners and engineers of the Bang]adesh Aricullu ini Development Corporation
(BAI)C) and the Rura Electrification Board (REB) They are to be
thanked for their collaboration
3
SuMin0 - J i__
f - -- types vi ] E trii C puphover diesel
in ri is fro deep
in u__ivJ 1d i swthat there nrc signishy
p f ampW SAtnrv ii t t u ] n] -z 1 0 - 1 A u n y b- d S h J ull s - I K]] ] p n A_Y t I II
iiibsol I thi 1 just thL r vt v]i o M luA ubewelIs fo]ul- 5y i a p anld Olup t uLwlPli 110in I heca-usu cost Of dCC LAir i 1 n t 7 nn jit- tia11 10 ibu r ]ow lift pump
and Lh-1 w I ubV( t Y-s ewivvtIv
Talle 1 Con]maatrivc Savin from Elcctrjfiqd over Diesel Powered rri risr Pumps 1
Present Vaiue of
C- 1t St-re=n_ Cost SavingsType -Pum [cteict1-i c Amount Percent
Dcep T 1bveI 47 C (0( 364201 105868 23
Luw I if I u1 ]9 S2684 32284 28
Shal Tubwe 7163B 4565 26073 35
1 Refr te Tabjc3 -3 B-3 and C-3
y
to - 1 lLx _ [ (_2-t aibl 2 w thE CompnSition of COM- Slln t17 Oftvu di-1 I(wl~Tc1 -uMj by type of CuSt F I mt in aibsIlutt n T y in iii investment costs
in t11h O r wp itu i] f l wd bv Kw lift pur an~d shallow tuhIt ] i I K A (f nv Fr in w ro -Alow tubowel Is rank hir~eSt ampKOWA IV I ft pU Mid dUL P tuK ItI and in case of operaiLto ow t arL iow andixt W pumps followed s tubewcl ls doep tubeumrl
able 2 Composition of Savings Ire Elct rificd nver PiisOl Powered Irrigtation Pumpsl
yj3e of S vings S2
Type of I= Investment IIower Operation Total
Deep lubo-1 48 29 237 1001Z
Low lift _ziv 35A 35 30Z 1007
Shallow Thkw il 11 60 29 100
1 Refer Tables A- B-4 and C-4
2 Includ- lubricant operators salary repair and maintenance costs
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
DIESEL AND ELECTRIC POWERED PUMP IRRIGATION
A Comparative Cost Analysis
Introduction
It is expected that power irrigation pump operators will be important users of electricity when made available to rural areas in the future Currently most irrigation pumps operating in rural Banglashydesh are diesel powered
Converioq IrFe t- elc-cri oer irrigation and expansion of el ctric poer ieneration an distribution require heavy investments
An assessment of the coriparamptive coss o1 diesel and electric powered
irrigation is essential to determine the soundness of these investments
Methodology of Analysis
The mctlod of economic analysis used here is a comparison of costs associat-oi with diesel and electric powei-fd irrigation systems currently operating in Bangladesh The aialysis ex-amines the costs of deeD tubeshywell (Annex A) low lifts pump (Annex B) and shallow tubewell (Annex C) irrigaticn systems
The analysis is limited exclusively to the cost side of the equation Whether diesel powered or electric powered a particular pump system is assumed to cover the same acreage and cropsl A comparison of cost effectiveness of the tw power sources therefore only takes into account the cost considerations The impact of electric versus diesel powered irrigation on pump comnvnid area and cropping patterns is left for 3 separate analysis
The analysis is conducted from two cost comparison stand points (1) newly installed diesel powered and electric powered iirigation pumps and (2) diesel powered pumps and electric powered pumps converted from diesel after a certain time period Based on the age of the majority
1 One b-nefit of pump electrification might result from the greater reliability and much lower breakdown frequency of an electric pump which may contribute to additional pumping hours Thus it is reasonshyable to assume that using electric powered irrigation pumps more area will be irrigated and agriculture output will increase On the other hand the benefit of a diesel punp is its independence of a fixed location Moreover stocks of diesel fuel can be stored up not the case for electric supply where users have no control if supply of electricity is disrupted it may be disasterous for crop production However t se assumptions heed field verification for proper analysis
number of pumps currently in operation it is assumed that on thu
average 5 y old dLep tubewelli a- low lift pumps and 2 ycar old
shallow tubcwampus are convrtcd into eic-ctric powered pumps
The analysis takes into account three cost categorics which
vary widely among pumping systems These cateories are-
Investmen Costr (Tables A- I B-] _)I All capital costs of
diesel and eclcctric powered deep tuhewells low lift pumps ad shallow
tubewells are identified TradC and transncrt cost and overhead cost
are added to total capital cost to duterninc investment cost of each
pump type Salvarc vluos of different equipmcnt arc also considered
Investmont ccst - and salvagc values arc discount ( over the life span
of pumps and the salvage values aro deductcd from investment cost to
detcrmindn the pre-sent value of cost strea- of investment costs
Power Costs (Tables A-2 B-2 C-2) Diesel and electric power
costs are calculated based on the assumptions used in the analysis
Fuel and lubricants arc priced cif Chittagong plus trade and transshy
port cost Tesc prices prevailcd in May 1981 As the world market
price of fuel escalates frequently the reader is cautioned that the
power cost of diesel pumps should also be adjusted accordingly Because
of the complexitics in calculating the real cost of electricity to
society electricity rate recommended by the Rural Electrification
Board for irrigation has been used A sensitivity cnalysis is also
done to show the- impact cn costs using alternative power rates (Table 4)
Power cost is discounted over th life span of the pumps to determine
the prcsent value of power cost stream
Opcratin and Maintcna ncc Costs (able A-2 B-2 C-2) Salary or
opportunity costs of labor for operation and protection of pumps lubrishy
cant costs and costs of repair and maintenance are calculated and disshy
counted over the life span of pumps to determine the present value of
operation and maintenance cost stream
Discount Rates Because some ol the above costs particularly
investment costs take place at different times depending on the life
of equipment it was necessary to olbtain present values of cost expendishy
tures for the purpose of comparison between electric and diesel powered
irrigationi pumps Cst streams are cxpresscd in present values applying of 10 percent is assumeddiscounted measurcs A real discount rate
with all monetary values put into real tcrms by deflating and thereby rate of return not aeliminating the clement of inflation As a real
nominal rate bolster(d by inflation 10 percent discount rate is
believed to be appropriatoI
1 Bangladesh Power Devclopment Board Tarrif Study Vol I Coopers amp
Lybrand Associates Limited November 1979 Chapter 8 pp 9-11
Tht followirn mnthmnticl fo-muii is used to find tht present valuc of cost st P
= C CC)+ + C t _ t
wherc
Total investmcnt cost incurred in year 0Co
=Cost incurrtd ii vcr tCt
= Salv ic v-1Lu_ in year tAt
n = Life of lU11) tubuwcl]
r = Interest (di scount) rate
Socinl Costs vs Privte Costs Finally tho reader should note
cccwci0C si from ofthat this 111 -carri d out the point of view
costs incurred yvsocity not by the rivaN individual Bucause duties -nd L -s W pvovn(hni vrv vjciv among different
componcnts of uh cus r usrp rent or purchasc irrigation
pumps PE MOAKamp r mnjr rc ca ptu i difficult is surround
determination of piOW tat C( Uc tl actual costs arc shared
between the public (ovarnmavet) ind privt (farmors) sectors of the
econuJoy i s also nLt N t connurn of tiLF salxsls
Data for th ana]ysis hav boo provi dod by the planners and engineers of the Bang]adesh Aricullu ini Development Corporation
(BAI)C) and the Rura Electrification Board (REB) They are to be
thanked for their collaboration
3
SuMin0 - J i__
f - -- types vi ] E trii C puphover diesel
in ri is fro deep
in u__ivJ 1d i swthat there nrc signishy
p f ampW SAtnrv ii t t u ] n] -z 1 0 - 1 A u n y b- d S h J ull s - I K]] ] p n A_Y t I II
iiibsol I thi 1 just thL r vt v]i o M luA ubewelIs fo]ul- 5y i a p anld Olup t uLwlPli 110in I heca-usu cost Of dCC LAir i 1 n t 7 nn jit- tia11 10 ibu r ]ow lift pump
and Lh-1 w I ubV( t Y-s ewivvtIv
Talle 1 Con]maatrivc Savin from Elcctrjfiqd over Diesel Powered rri risr Pumps 1
Present Vaiue of
C- 1t St-re=n_ Cost SavingsType -Pum [cteict1-i c Amount Percent
Dcep T 1bveI 47 C (0( 364201 105868 23
Luw I if I u1 ]9 S2684 32284 28
Shal Tubwe 7163B 4565 26073 35
1 Refr te Tabjc3 -3 B-3 and C-3
y
to - 1 lLx _ [ (_2-t aibl 2 w thE CompnSition of COM- Slln t17 Oftvu di-1 I(wl~Tc1 -uMj by type of CuSt F I mt in aibsIlutt n T y in iii investment costs
in t11h O r wp itu i] f l wd bv Kw lift pur an~d shallow tuhIt ] i I K A (f nv Fr in w ro -Alow tubowel Is rank hir~eSt ampKOWA IV I ft pU Mid dUL P tuK ItI and in case of operaiLto ow t arL iow andixt W pumps followed s tubewcl ls doep tubeumrl
able 2 Composition of Savings Ire Elct rificd nver PiisOl Powered Irrigtation Pumpsl
yj3e of S vings S2
Type of I= Investment IIower Operation Total
Deep lubo-1 48 29 237 1001Z
Low lift _ziv 35A 35 30Z 1007
Shallow Thkw il 11 60 29 100
1 Refer Tables A- B-4 and C-4
2 Includ- lubricant operators salary repair and maintenance costs
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
number of pumps currently in operation it is assumed that on thu
average 5 y old dLep tubewelli a- low lift pumps and 2 ycar old
shallow tubcwampus are convrtcd into eic-ctric powered pumps
The analysis takes into account three cost categorics which
vary widely among pumping systems These cateories are-
Investmen Costr (Tables A- I B-] _)I All capital costs of
diesel and eclcctric powered deep tuhewells low lift pumps ad shallow
tubewells are identified TradC and transncrt cost and overhead cost
are added to total capital cost to duterninc investment cost of each
pump type Salvarc vluos of different equipmcnt arc also considered
Investmont ccst - and salvagc values arc discount ( over the life span
of pumps and the salvage values aro deductcd from investment cost to
detcrmindn the pre-sent value of cost strea- of investment costs
Power Costs (Tables A-2 B-2 C-2) Diesel and electric power
costs are calculated based on the assumptions used in the analysis
Fuel and lubricants arc priced cif Chittagong plus trade and transshy
port cost Tesc prices prevailcd in May 1981 As the world market
price of fuel escalates frequently the reader is cautioned that the
power cost of diesel pumps should also be adjusted accordingly Because
of the complexitics in calculating the real cost of electricity to
society electricity rate recommended by the Rural Electrification
Board for irrigation has been used A sensitivity cnalysis is also
done to show the- impact cn costs using alternative power rates (Table 4)
Power cost is discounted over th life span of the pumps to determine
the prcsent value of power cost stream
Opcratin and Maintcna ncc Costs (able A-2 B-2 C-2) Salary or
opportunity costs of labor for operation and protection of pumps lubrishy
cant costs and costs of repair and maintenance are calculated and disshy
counted over the life span of pumps to determine the present value of
operation and maintenance cost stream
Discount Rates Because some ol the above costs particularly
investment costs take place at different times depending on the life
of equipment it was necessary to olbtain present values of cost expendishy
tures for the purpose of comparison between electric and diesel powered
irrigationi pumps Cst streams are cxpresscd in present values applying of 10 percent is assumeddiscounted measurcs A real discount rate
with all monetary values put into real tcrms by deflating and thereby rate of return not aeliminating the clement of inflation As a real
nominal rate bolster(d by inflation 10 percent discount rate is
believed to be appropriatoI
1 Bangladesh Power Devclopment Board Tarrif Study Vol I Coopers amp
Lybrand Associates Limited November 1979 Chapter 8 pp 9-11
Tht followirn mnthmnticl fo-muii is used to find tht present valuc of cost st P
= C CC)+ + C t _ t
wherc
Total investmcnt cost incurred in year 0Co
=Cost incurrtd ii vcr tCt
= Salv ic v-1Lu_ in year tAt
n = Life of lU11) tubuwcl]
r = Interest (di scount) rate
Socinl Costs vs Privte Costs Finally tho reader should note
cccwci0C si from ofthat this 111 -carri d out the point of view
costs incurred yvsocity not by the rivaN individual Bucause duties -nd L -s W pvovn(hni vrv vjciv among different
componcnts of uh cus r usrp rent or purchasc irrigation
pumps PE MOAKamp r mnjr rc ca ptu i difficult is surround
determination of piOW tat C( Uc tl actual costs arc shared
between the public (ovarnmavet) ind privt (farmors) sectors of the
econuJoy i s also nLt N t connurn of tiLF salxsls
Data for th ana]ysis hav boo provi dod by the planners and engineers of the Bang]adesh Aricullu ini Development Corporation
(BAI)C) and the Rura Electrification Board (REB) They are to be
thanked for their collaboration
3
SuMin0 - J i__
f - -- types vi ] E trii C puphover diesel
in ri is fro deep
in u__ivJ 1d i swthat there nrc signishy
p f ampW SAtnrv ii t t u ] n] -z 1 0 - 1 A u n y b- d S h J ull s - I K]] ] p n A_Y t I II
iiibsol I thi 1 just thL r vt v]i o M luA ubewelIs fo]ul- 5y i a p anld Olup t uLwlPli 110in I heca-usu cost Of dCC LAir i 1 n t 7 nn jit- tia11 10 ibu r ]ow lift pump
and Lh-1 w I ubV( t Y-s ewivvtIv
Talle 1 Con]maatrivc Savin from Elcctrjfiqd over Diesel Powered rri risr Pumps 1
Present Vaiue of
C- 1t St-re=n_ Cost SavingsType -Pum [cteict1-i c Amount Percent
Dcep T 1bveI 47 C (0( 364201 105868 23
Luw I if I u1 ]9 S2684 32284 28
Shal Tubwe 7163B 4565 26073 35
1 Refr te Tabjc3 -3 B-3 and C-3
y
to - 1 lLx _ [ (_2-t aibl 2 w thE CompnSition of COM- Slln t17 Oftvu di-1 I(wl~Tc1 -uMj by type of CuSt F I mt in aibsIlutt n T y in iii investment costs
in t11h O r wp itu i] f l wd bv Kw lift pur an~d shallow tuhIt ] i I K A (f nv Fr in w ro -Alow tubowel Is rank hir~eSt ampKOWA IV I ft pU Mid dUL P tuK ItI and in case of operaiLto ow t arL iow andixt W pumps followed s tubewcl ls doep tubeumrl
able 2 Composition of Savings Ire Elct rificd nver PiisOl Powered Irrigtation Pumpsl
yj3e of S vings S2
Type of I= Investment IIower Operation Total
Deep lubo-1 48 29 237 1001Z
Low lift _ziv 35A 35 30Z 1007
Shallow Thkw il 11 60 29 100
1 Refer Tables A- B-4 and C-4
2 Includ- lubricant operators salary repair and maintenance costs
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
Tht followirn mnthmnticl fo-muii is used to find tht present valuc of cost st P
= C CC)+ + C t _ t
wherc
Total investmcnt cost incurred in year 0Co
=Cost incurrtd ii vcr tCt
= Salv ic v-1Lu_ in year tAt
n = Life of lU11) tubuwcl]
r = Interest (di scount) rate
Socinl Costs vs Privte Costs Finally tho reader should note
cccwci0C si from ofthat this 111 -carri d out the point of view
costs incurred yvsocity not by the rivaN individual Bucause duties -nd L -s W pvovn(hni vrv vjciv among different
componcnts of uh cus r usrp rent or purchasc irrigation
pumps PE MOAKamp r mnjr rc ca ptu i difficult is surround
determination of piOW tat C( Uc tl actual costs arc shared
between the public (ovarnmavet) ind privt (farmors) sectors of the
econuJoy i s also nLt N t connurn of tiLF salxsls
Data for th ana]ysis hav boo provi dod by the planners and engineers of the Bang]adesh Aricullu ini Development Corporation
(BAI)C) and the Rura Electrification Board (REB) They are to be
thanked for their collaboration
3
SuMin0 - J i__
f - -- types vi ] E trii C puphover diesel
in ri is fro deep
in u__ivJ 1d i swthat there nrc signishy
p f ampW SAtnrv ii t t u ] n] -z 1 0 - 1 A u n y b- d S h J ull s - I K]] ] p n A_Y t I II
iiibsol I thi 1 just thL r vt v]i o M luA ubewelIs fo]ul- 5y i a p anld Olup t uLwlPli 110in I heca-usu cost Of dCC LAir i 1 n t 7 nn jit- tia11 10 ibu r ]ow lift pump
and Lh-1 w I ubV( t Y-s ewivvtIv
Talle 1 Con]maatrivc Savin from Elcctrjfiqd over Diesel Powered rri risr Pumps 1
Present Vaiue of
C- 1t St-re=n_ Cost SavingsType -Pum [cteict1-i c Amount Percent
Dcep T 1bveI 47 C (0( 364201 105868 23
Luw I if I u1 ]9 S2684 32284 28
Shal Tubwe 7163B 4565 26073 35
1 Refr te Tabjc3 -3 B-3 and C-3
y
to - 1 lLx _ [ (_2-t aibl 2 w thE CompnSition of COM- Slln t17 Oftvu di-1 I(wl~Tc1 -uMj by type of CuSt F I mt in aibsIlutt n T y in iii investment costs
in t11h O r wp itu i] f l wd bv Kw lift pur an~d shallow tuhIt ] i I K A (f nv Fr in w ro -Alow tubowel Is rank hir~eSt ampKOWA IV I ft pU Mid dUL P tuK ItI and in case of operaiLto ow t arL iow andixt W pumps followed s tubewcl ls doep tubeumrl
able 2 Composition of Savings Ire Elct rificd nver PiisOl Powered Irrigtation Pumpsl
yj3e of S vings S2
Type of I= Investment IIower Operation Total
Deep lubo-1 48 29 237 1001Z
Low lift _ziv 35A 35 30Z 1007
Shallow Thkw il 11 60 29 100
1 Refer Tables A- B-4 and C-4
2 Includ- lubricant operators salary repair and maintenance costs
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
SuMin0 - J i__
f - -- types vi ] E trii C puphover diesel
in ri is fro deep
in u__ivJ 1d i swthat there nrc signishy
p f ampW SAtnrv ii t t u ] n] -z 1 0 - 1 A u n y b- d S h J ull s - I K]] ] p n A_Y t I II
iiibsol I thi 1 just thL r vt v]i o M luA ubewelIs fo]ul- 5y i a p anld Olup t uLwlPli 110in I heca-usu cost Of dCC LAir i 1 n t 7 nn jit- tia11 10 ibu r ]ow lift pump
and Lh-1 w I ubV( t Y-s ewivvtIv
Talle 1 Con]maatrivc Savin from Elcctrjfiqd over Diesel Powered rri risr Pumps 1
Present Vaiue of
C- 1t St-re=n_ Cost SavingsType -Pum [cteict1-i c Amount Percent
Dcep T 1bveI 47 C (0( 364201 105868 23
Luw I if I u1 ]9 S2684 32284 28
Shal Tubwe 7163B 4565 26073 35
1 Refr te Tabjc3 -3 B-3 and C-3
y
to - 1 lLx _ [ (_2-t aibl 2 w thE CompnSition of COM- Slln t17 Oftvu di-1 I(wl~Tc1 -uMj by type of CuSt F I mt in aibsIlutt n T y in iii investment costs
in t11h O r wp itu i] f l wd bv Kw lift pur an~d shallow tuhIt ] i I K A (f nv Fr in w ro -Alow tubowel Is rank hir~eSt ampKOWA IV I ft pU Mid dUL P tuK ItI and in case of operaiLto ow t arL iow andixt W pumps followed s tubewcl ls doep tubeumrl
able 2 Composition of Savings Ire Elct rificd nver PiisOl Powered Irrigtation Pumpsl
yj3e of S vings S2
Type of I= Investment IIower Operation Total
Deep lubo-1 48 29 237 1001Z
Low lift _ziv 35A 35 30Z 1007
Shallow Thkw il 11 60 29 100
1 Refer Tables A- B-4 and C-4
2 Includ- lubricant operators salary repair and maintenance costs
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
to - 1 lLx _ [ (_2-t aibl 2 w thE CompnSition of COM- Slln t17 Oftvu di-1 I(wl~Tc1 -uMj by type of CuSt F I mt in aibsIlutt n T y in iii investment costs
in t11h O r wp itu i] f l wd bv Kw lift pur an~d shallow tuhIt ] i I K A (f nv Fr in w ro -Alow tubowel Is rank hir~eSt ampKOWA IV I ft pU Mid dUL P tuK ItI and in case of operaiLto ow t arL iow andixt W pumps followed s tubewcl ls doep tubeumrl
able 2 Composition of Savings Ire Elct rificd nver PiisOl Powered Irrigtation Pumpsl
yj3e of S vings S2
Type of I= Investment IIower Operation Total
Deep lubo-1 48 29 237 1001Z
Low lift _ziv 35A 35 30Z 1007
Shallow Thkw il 11 60 29 100
1 Refer Tables A- B-4 and C-4
2 Includ- lubricant operators salary repair and maintenance costs
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
fl 01 (Utt- V( ANOTTOO tI tvii 0 N mnt rv terms dlo-k il Ira in u L 1 K J o ruwu2r A lift
p vm in OF 3ut t-- L1 o tubow IK rr- KJ Lt HOWC( S du p tubvcL IsK nN lv -a ft unp
Tabl Y Cot Saings from Pump onversion from Diesel to Electric--
(Amount ii TOa)
Present Value of
Type of Pumps 1~i( ]C L t ~i Amount 1e- cent
Deep Tuewe]] 70069 407999 62075 33
Low Lift Pump 114968 102984 11984 0
Shallow Tubewall 74636 54792 19846 27Y
I Refer to Tables A-5 B-1 and C-5
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
anlyis Tak C70 perKW electf~~ ra na en usampd Thi rato proposed bv th~e ura Ete trJ f -at ion ca~ard (RE or rri- gation bn4j the exist4ng rat chag d Because thiayisa
-ele Icity incurred bt~he nati$oIV Howev beaue inBan 1ades is -ted hydrD electrc ~natural-ga an d e
ifino imfotsjol~ to find the rea unit cos of el(campticitN to sciety Therefore the following sensitijvity-shy
analvii done showtile impact on sayings frb~nm electric powered Jrrlgatin Fh g alterna t ive poveYr~ rats I shouild be~noted that elect rJic1line conncion to irrigati~onpumnps or hoo-u cost is
Vassu Cd to e n1tepwrrts
~ ~ i~iltAlternative Power~Rates r
V~mount(A in Taka)
V 4
(Tk KMI Amount Amun V o t
050~~V143 159 3 4363 38 302
0 6 V 4 51 26VVlt 3796 V 3 2614 38V
0 88 2 3 8 6033 2 V- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 3VVVV V223 97
00 8722 jV 19V 26)h -
4110
09 6857 100R4e993gtDep 1 ue
31 28
12 1 J2640 130V -6 006
14 (-4 6 2
29 )
15-- 20g o9e0Dise 2192 lb11 15Lo253 13m4K 1984Sh2Twu 7 9___576__ 8__________~gt 1 176
3 3) ~ 3 1569
(-1)V ( -78 (2 1 1
5)(641401
(-) (13A 2 _ 9 4 4
29shy
___
21Vlt
3
Tk67V cV~ ecrct uo 4 v Vc nlss
V 4 5V~ 3-~368 ~- 8 0254 4
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
lAssupt il Use -- t AnaJ4 s
1Dep Tulewl eptlv 3
2bL esrpa $ n o i feren cmonets ad be1Iwa rill ~~ ~ PYovid ed by th BAD Cen gin are s
i~~aoo~ l l l p o ced i mrpr c x-fa t r
a headbead 0t required when a vert al moa t is us 6d
~condition ~ tc oosa rated 25 HP (18 7 K ) a fid C1isaqC
P- itl~e3 30~5I
6 a1aa 20 for pup enginemotore ue
7 lnk this~analysis 3A-e of~ a de~ep tubewell1 iscond i k Nsy~ Economic life of 4a deep tubewell is considered tbe of
~20 years by the Planning Divisio4BAD
~Ai~8 Avc-age pumping hours per year-borcamp a us seas~on) 1000 hours
FeL According- to BADC enineesubricant oil consumptionr 1al4o of diesel is required 4for~ a 30 HP engine to run I hour 1lricant
0125 gal3onHPl0Q hours sectrunning
10 Fuallubricarit oilcost uladlu i r prce c f dh4ttgn plusta~ad rnpr ot On thi baipi of- Highr SpeedDiese1 (1SOD sTkl894Imp~ria C3n prijceof 1ub oil~(HighViscocityl
401G Ths ap1iln prvi
-N6tieeg cosmtin 219KI pe~perating huPooe 17Beetrct ae fT070KHi se ntean~alysis Compardashy
tiv-6otsare also shown in Tbl 4at alternin e ou Propose
12 -Ti esaayoopotntcoofne man for six months 1Tk400month-
~for Operation and protection f the qipment
44r231 According to BADO 4engineers abouit 4 o0~fdeep7 tibewlls are~8 year oW I~boiiu 40Z _-z L ~ _ud - esL202ampar~ I year old In the analy sist is assumed tha~t on the avrerage 5 yeair1d~diese3 powered deep-
gt amp tubewcllsiwill be coverte to~elc r poerddeep tubewells
Due to la cofmintenance the output o(f diese] eiigine-44ecreases aa fate rate tha noma Thereo engineers recomnn over-s zed engine
KH 046xHP~Xas i 5efficienyo oo otorofficiency
and the~full rated ourput ao t iemotor -E requ d a i the o u head ad discha~rge as n1the -case f diese d eun
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
i in I i QV -7 1
4~
-t P
ppb~ we1 rig20C6 2~
N ON
100~~~~ oft8 10 Tortaiiia fL 7g1OOv ~~
A7
cpp180fo 4gsbaIdpjtuppr I a Q2 1-O Tk~ 35 ft
ubn 15 3 6
(lif ~gt2 ~ 20 ar f
b 2 cua up (ie yors) 50 00 0
-ya ~ -
-lt -h eI vetial ebti~ao 20t 135000
-~sare 2 Quf 20- ycr~ 9kasj~ A4W~~0
~vTrade A50i and transpartP3 5~A- a A -7r3-e- h shy
-a--- Tta inetmn - coq 204-~-~ R7SOO
KR~~~erto~ ~ AR aay -7~su~iosue
~ a~ 47~ vyedA 7-~ - 0 580 0~- - - - OFA - - - -
-7
- -
-A-S7lip kV~amp~ 525
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
iii U121~ 0~I
vplusmnuof p tori in c2-0t-10ilc
110
ngie in20t -ir
P I
6
0
3e00
26000
Annual operation nd mant~enanccamp coc
1000 pc~uplusmnonsbf High ~S c
s2
iesel_2 ~
2
8940 1
CLbic-t 9 (7jX CI-osof lub oil d- 688 A
IRpoundF j and
12
iiiaintcnancc 240 500
URoer Lt4lch assumptions useci ii- the naiy~is
11 ~ ~4~ IU
4~ ~lowjmum
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
a-a ~ a pr
~~C~llt i t~0wia
-~ ~ a~ acl 2~h~1 37Lr~Ph -( 2 w a~ 9$a) 1j5a shy
i7 7- 7 7
6aT~t iL0T1 T pi I n 7 t1~12aY a-a ri on t D C t T 14
-a-~a C ms c Cos iaaa-a 1a It M ac s
2-( ) 2 05 a- 25 2-a0 5-0o08 ~ 0 0 204-00 )shy
17-20 a4ll~ 100 a201a 7a 4ashy
-sAs( u m n c 10 discount rata-tepoetvlu of cost t a o dieea
aaaa--~pcortd~Q t-ubewcll-~ 4
~a-25028 j 2(~2502aa---a- 17000 64000
a-gt21iC7 20~ 218 aamp528~~a4)
-n a[252050 + (2528) -a(7 605 (1002) - 6 2IS 2508) 01-191
a [(1)7000(03) ( + 640O00(0192
a---A-a-ssumi~ng 10 discount ratheponvIuc of c emfoan-lcrc ast
- 183 1 2905300 O0
-a- -a- ~ -(J1-+r) t (1+r) 16 a t-)a
a-- -- a-a- 80jt=17290
~2j 8) [(-a-a~7000a)0239) + (29000) (0-149)] ai
2 0480) + (a18530) ( 1 6C5) +a (5 330) (0 a+ (18530) 0 6 9 a) a
ia-a 6 r -E1a p a- -a-r2 shy
a- ~ ~ 4
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
Ur r rW
AA
~Cos tei Dii~ I ~tQo C Eb
C
a
a
Amqutf6 1 lo nC
slt1
P~ r
n
ampI
f TobItd
ampC01
0C
-iC
~ 2~-S u ~ 5
~CC CC
B 3C~
7CCC0 0 69
130 52 0 C~CCCC~CC4CCC2
30 0
3D0
24
73 5
47
KI
23-4gt
N
jC FCCCAJC7O0(a CV~cu C
CC -s
73 Zo2 L~ in g~CC~CpC
kl I ofC
823 in e tm C n o
CC C~ lnv~steuJ co~ LoacuaincurO inKVQC~wgtC CC AC C0
CCCCo tCt incurredCCin eiC L
At-C SCCClCCCC
C ~~ ~ ~ ~ l a IjCCCiCC c a~C C C
~~~~ LiCC CCCC -C Ca oac
r C Di~C sc u C- t c
2C~C- InCC4CCCCCCCCC es li C C CClf a t r s- sal
yea 0i
ymCcp
L~
n a it
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
~ ~~ Cl~ t 11r~tl WI
k- j
1 1 c l x
- 4shy
7 ) Itcnmain Ir r3 0amp1 ot (Ah~~l 3 0
PI01 c11C L U7
54 va) v~ FA Im3353
ECC iC C tu11o 1 (Yzj t 20
0 AIS050~JLJi 05L~K4 ~ ~ I~~ -52l
1 ~~ Al 1 A i12 ~1 1shy 511 1i
1 -~gtIsect~ 37 5 0l 37 5200)
A 35A 01 1 530 5 3 0
~~I-74 Ashy 12- 01
c~ Q p u m~Cnhntar
f~~u2Lora u zosus~ed init a-yltE
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
C 5~2 59+ 5 +
V4
jzA) Ofj
-I
34) 0 ~$i L
UP25ON 05028)(3790)
Q3jXU2~ 09185 30
V
Cost~ snvintsovrdcclwre
CD Q= 4706940799
(50)~ (0 504t 8530)~
A 6921)(7000)
eptb
6070or 1 peront
~
(02310
~ ~ 34
9
4
~
~ ~lt ~
s
I
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
Iq~lo th Pr~ WnIQshy
conIt mo I
~2 G
32(11o g - -r I
C QQ211D 790 + 1350 05I (19(i
(70010)Q (029)+
ampVV
o pipoe s4powered deep tubewc I 4~shydiesel
iC4~4l141 C 470060 4071999 6 2 07 or( 13 percentW4~l44 41 1 44 1lt41l~rl4111 lT~ 4
-~ 1I-~lt111444
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
--
---------------------------------
AN N X B L0Q1 IFTPU1
Assu oins ucg~i-r han]- if
whil locaJ1lly produced items are Priced exfzicory
2Pe14 obgrvatAion~shw th- o il u
- 3 Salvage ivalue 111OZ Of lowifI - pump siet
-4s Life of~a low lift pump issconsidere to beo Sya
~~~ 5--Average pu~iling hours per year(bor and all- season)~ 700 bur1 -6p -ulihr cn t oil4 co s mt o 2 agtui f
-5 7 2 sujubricant oil cost~ Same as assumption 10LiniDeep Tubewe4
enrgycosumtio 2KWH
- ~1-55 9 The salary ~ po rrunity icost 4 of one ma ~ 2r i - m nhs shy
-Tk401 t foroperationltand protecti of pump
G lecri 13 per oprating hour
5 eng aD1pt ako m)tnne h output of5$ diese4 2- 5 5ine) derese
ratfate ia noml-e ngnesrcmen oe-ie
074 - umnK 44Px 5-V Z efiinyo t
mtradthe fl ae output of todirdlodl~co~ ppfrateulthnd orand isc-hare asein tecae ommdeel drien6
js-amp~ - 15es4e4-A
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
IRk
Foee 1 i f t umps I
Ei 2 cu)IIeZ pum ye r ) -0 04 0 0
bTrol~ey i cing~cuplig (Life 10o years) ~000 )
C Accessories (Tipesbndsfoot valveetc ) F000809
qjn (ifea 10 y ar99s
f Total capitai cost 44Z 35000 2~5000
Tra1dc and transport4 14]~750 i 1-250
43 To tal1investmpent~cos t gt 4 3750 K 27250
44 444444 gt4~~b 4 L44~4 4444 ~lt Ree to the ag-Ulp iD use in the analysis444414444-
5 of ccpi cost~4 c+ 441
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
VV
1 7
4 -K
441)
41-~I Total invEstiiujj
~4~V~10 salvage - ~ ~
4~0sal1vae
L 43
9
value 1
value
g~~galeos
24411 0 M
44j_gt1L377
of the 144444
of mt
woo
T
pumfp set in cludingi 4
1 ~ 1
A 1
1I
rpun 10th yearudng
dinsl7 108yar96
4
44 4gt
94t4
104
1 444
1
0
1
4
4
II
1
7 5
115gt 144
4000-y4~
6~l 4684444414
-~11~ j4
41~142 414gt1 o Opuaerat a r and maronenaceon-~ 4W~ 14444 44-11240084 4 2400
Ree to 43he gassumtos 4194444444414l4444 1411l
uised in 1
the analysis ~44l11 4 1444 444A
Zb i 4 H141444444
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
I-4
c c Qj
Tab e 1) r t-C 4op t le e al l r o c
L o- L i f PUmp S ~i1 QpjD ipound a p 1 me a sure
_04_Costivv -Year teh amp Itcn~ t emst
4~~~p~-QO ~ 50 37 750v ~27 2504~4 3 7
(3 3 50) -0) (5 500)
a Salvage value o f pump set engincampmotor4- ~ r-~YA
4 ----- Assumn~ J0u4 discun t~ Fu ofcstsram for a4-
- -~~diesel pbered low~ lift pmp~--amp44--44- 4 44~-4444 ~44Z
12-78 3500444-44444 r-4gt 4 ~~-444444 - ~
t 10B 44 4~~O-v ( 1-r)4- --
CDlt [347750 + (12788)(6J144)1-I(350)(0 386)~ 444
~4CD + 1149--6-
an44444444g4 dicont rate 44luthe4preen of cos sta fo ectr 444-4- 4if pump4444-shy
a- ic44 ow444444powere4 -
~ 4C 11 9 8 1044 44444444444~A44444444444i-444 ~~- ~4B4 Af4 4 4 44 44 4shy5500 4 ~ ~ 4~444 4444-4 ~~I4444~~44444936 4 44-44-4~ 4444444
44 4272504-4 4~--4 lt4 -- 444 - -
Costrsaingpwovd~ e ~~--~-~-owlit - zgtjpowre pump4
4444 444or-4 444 44 ~ CE 4 44444-28 pe c n - 4-~lt-44C 44-444gt4444---lt4 ---444 7lt44-44444-444- -~44~444 444444- - A
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
-on- ir a1T~ieTetkf
Cos 1 t4 sl7ectr
CsrStr~ans ~
m u
Cost Savings
tPerceI)t ot -
-11-~~iw 27 599 ~ 17 818 9 7F1 3 5 Z30
1ormlliforcalculattng present vatlueo netetc
For power and OampM costAt 7 ~i~ 4 j
4
SA
--- Cb Investment t cost
Salvgi vau in yea
~~CtCot incl -red iplusmn-i1~
t4~
f t f-tv
t tt
21
-r t
1n c2h1ucdues
-Discount rate(1 0 4~ t
I u ic a n operators salary repair and
4
main enance costS
4 ~4 AS N
-4
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
Wmr 1- 1n1~ 1rsicW o er in~ the -Year~~5th
44-11 4444of I 4 e I w 1 c pu p 7 5 60 si~vI 1i of~enin -5th c--4o 1200vau ir
Cotfamo nt e are t 10~1200
4n a44d mait O tS4~~na 4 B-2)4 4
p we e4 lift I44 444a 4 ow p (Y aa 1-5) 278B 4w b I rc low1i~f pu p ( ar-G 09 3 8
aunp ena1 QprampMf~a~ Cost(ccTbh
~~44Cost 4 4 srcxidiSt0 rnvii eagt~ g ntct N
Totalcnnc 4ItemY4
444 0 37 71570k 4 7750443 94
0 -C 4 4J 4044 (12 0)
6gt- 1004936 96 7-10 37 42 7)71
(9149 00 444 000)4
4j1-54~ 4444 6394
4ag gin4gt44 value4)o ~ enY 4Imse
Assmin 104 dicon rat the4l presen ue4 ofcstsram r 4ve lo t i 444gt tq 4 i 4 44 4 4 44
45 440 -412 78tcn 19369 i1bbo 9000118+4C_________________ 3775
4i+ r) (1+r) 1014
(1790Toa~4gt Yea (12788 l 564) (9368)Oamp[3754- (3Capit +ltei 4 (9000(44 440gt1- 4i
-[(2 0 + 621 44386 44]
4444 4 4 1 2 9 4 4~4 1 ~ 44 4 V4 1 ~7n4 4 75
cost444~ g dise powered lo lf4 PMsnv ove
4 C 4 96 102 4e98 1198 or 10 44444444~~ce t
~41A 44~y - 4~ 4 ~ i~ ~ ~9 O ~ 3 0 4 y - -7i4
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
hNNEY- C SULLOW T TIUJBT1 I lt
-~- ~ ~ wiic locn~1by Produced3 i~m aepic -atr
codtjis clcti moo nu ne _ T 3-KI and -dieselv
3 g va for pupcnginenIotor-lt
- ~-4Ufev f a-shni1lowtubw11l is considec1 to be of 3~5 years
5 Average pum~pingj hours per~Year (bco an~d ius)- --700 hoursshy
6i Tu 1Ilub r c ant oil gtconsurapt ionv --------- o desl erhor bibricant_ 0C 125 galrI0 us runni -
The salary or~3inh coto n a crsx otopocibgtti
TV20ot fo prtcto of th equ--i~ pmentan AportAo 2
u to lak ma-f nen n e th c4Kpt o d e e nin~ er
ataao aeta oml Thr-r engieer reombdo 8edletri r ompio 4f- PHproprt
p mpfo eqa head~jaandr~pocuitdicharg as iornth cas ofntdisldie2 nt J
ThOO~on~bf6~o~rat~n Mad po~ecionofgt~h~eequj~wet4-
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
Di cTn) c C t Ij L t T-on t C c t c 1 f n E oc
LIP Ila
wil -nplee
D 234CL)SfUMo Ct (life 10i v eu s
C Pi -10onin dil ~ip 10r~r4
dit4 5 PlcrcmtrwtAt-ro
1
40
4a0
37000~
)0
(life 15 y2ars
~~~
ISinkin amp co
f ATotl apita] costgt +
~-zade and~ ransportJjjgt-y~
Sh CQyerhead
iZ Total invstn cost4 -
w
V~V4shy
0
20
985 910~
7004~~
22-885~
1500
900
700
21)310
--- tA-
55
er to~-5
(a 1+
asu p in vie Agt-In
of
t n lss
Y4 -4
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
To t2 a~ I cot285 213
1 S1 v4 C4 aIl- p ma d n i ii 0tli r 3 L--hl--- 4t ( - c)f 4im4 d i iIIY1 0 6vagvAocC10y-~ sa fpmpade pinc 721 0I~~ n1L
10 gSa 11 ue1A~ 174 il yc2 I 2v V-~ of 15t 014 8500~ 10 -4~alvago4 valublt~ n30hyp~ 4gtl 0t 0 f
~~U~~~T)- in gn 1th yo 1 - 4QiQQ
14 ons444 Sp(4e e 6 345Iii- 4i
+ greasing4 fo dies-I greasin ony f oshy
21 24P shy
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
IApub Oc C F~ ont(r 1I
~ A
110 500 6~ 57 3 1i 073i 4 00 3~ 511 7 51 1 ~A
~
4
a a a ev-11u c- fpop ci ebgine to
AMsmng1 diC)rL rtN pcse vleo-ost streami
~~ 6571i z 17073 657gtI0gt__0_ =(1288PXJrt +r 1- (]+r)
2E~85+(673 6 4 4+ 7073 )( 350) (673) (K1 111)
~~1) 74 638 47
Assmii10 discaunt~ rratc Llc present value~of costp s treatm ~powered shQ1low~tuibewe-i-l 4
f or
f cr~
diesel
6300 +) 5
(1050) (0 386)
electric
4
4shy
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
21 I0Z
I I 11 - III~ 7 7 4r 4
7 7 7 Ta lc 7 f( il 7 U o 3 O
7~
C77o e 1 47 1 C IL~4 2- 7 7 A m o i I e
~I7~ ~ ~ Cost Sa7 7
v els 1 nn77 iurl ~ 2e0t2TE8647gt 4 2 7
0amp7 19 773 iZ~ 168 737 57 5 4 Y 7
7777777777747 -- a 777673 47S 5657 26744 077777 3 5 Z 10077
uht n for n a u f iv7777777377774s t c s 7cl 7rs
7 7 7 37 7777477 777777 7 7k 4C 7 7~C + 777~77 t 7 7 3~ 4 377 4
7~47777773774 L + r~
777~~747 ~Fo po e i7773444A~77777777~77OEMn7 d 77777
~ ~gt1777777777 777k 777gt 77777777777 147lt7 7 7777777~ 47 n77
77Cgt7777t~2~
V~~~J 9a~797~ 2~6~~7737~ 7 4077777 74
gt77O47 77777 cost ur e in 0tme7nt7 in 77
7t7 C Cos incurred771777 i7ye
it~47~ 47 47 ~~Savg777 7 7 4 ill777 4CJ7777~ uLe 7855 t ~ 377777c u l77 7 7777~~~~~ ~~ Of7774777777777777777777777
r77777777777 77477747777777 a 0zDI scoun q4J
7 gt Y2~ 7777777 7j
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
I I 6
~~~~~ X~ ~ We
CC)CCt -St
nv i c c tslpoc dCC lw uC~o 22 8
80 C r5 of en in ii 0
C( SI~ f n -o- in CltC313 c r5 00
Qf~CXf80 0C2sC~CGZCIC o T1t r n 1 th v-r10 CVCClc
altI 0e~~ 1 o uu nCt) 2nd 3 C 0
M lt l ~ ~ CC C C eC p IC t aC~o )np i lt- ~ 0
6C0sa Cu c o u- in l C yar40
CiC1C4C 5y~~~1u~~a 3- 15)~o 3jjlt~C
CCCC ~ ~~ ~ ~ C~CCaCCCCCs~~ ~ C s SCCC4r
CJ~ ) CC~iCCC CCCIC C C C~CgtyCC CC~ ~ ApCI~C~I~~
r C~ laO M a
0 CCI C
c aCCCgtj C t 1 o~CCCCCCIgtCCCCCIYCC C IC CCC C1CCCC C C 2C2885Cf
1 -2 C6C 131 13 14CCC
CC~CCC200) gt200)CC~CCd1KCfpipCil1t~~ (5~C~
3C C CC 0 3511 8 5C11
C~CCC1fC 2C~C I5 7 2457CC7 4ICCCCCCC
C C1~i~C(400)~C CC ~C I CCCC CC
1
W)C ~ ~ ~ 0 3511 4
C C os51p1pjl
12-15~CC CCCC C C1CCIC 044 ~ jU ~ ~ CCJCC~ 7~e1~mn
14044
~ C ~C 3 00)CCCC~(3400)L
CCCCCCC CC Cj6 C~ C Clt~ C p u ~ h 2 l ~) A y ~ j 4~C iC ACCC
plusmn
gi e C C Q 4
ge flt 6n 4C~~CCCaCSa Iva CCC~-va oCC~ ump 2
C C~~~~~~~~~~~CC ~ ~ ~C4C C C j
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt
~~~~ U
_______ 0 340
CV t2852~Zv 4 (6573) (1 75) (8 511( 75I+ (3-512) (3 65) (7511) (0 350) ~11) (1 3U i1) (5200) (0lt8 ~ 4o6 ~ ~ 0 O3
~ Cost Snviings c-ve ~di cs e 1)w e e s h low tubewe1Ja I I~
C CV- 74 63F 5792~ 19 8 6 or 27 percent Dr ~
3 4 -333 -34-4
-133--3-T I4~ 13 3 lt-33lt4Y334~ --3 amp3U 3333~3 gt13~3~333 3j~ $334gt3AA43lt 33- ~3JO~
A33333-31lt43 ~ ~Llt