2
Death Penalty
Facts and Figures
76 countries - for all crimes
15 countries - for all but exceptional crimes (e.g. wartime crimes)
20 countries can be considered abolitionist in practice (they retain the DP in law, but have not carried out executions for the past 10 years)
111 countries have abolished DP in law or practice
84 other countries retain and use the DP
Over half of the countries in the world have now abolished the death penalty in law or practice.
3
Death Penalty
Facts and Figures2 Trends
Progress towards worldwide abolition:more than 3 countries a year on average have abolished the DP for all crimes in the past decade
Moves to reintroduce the death penalty:once abolished, the DP is seldom reintroduced (since 1985, only 4 abolitionist countries reintroduced DP vs. abolitions in over 40 countries)
6
Death Penalty
Executions 2001
at least 5,265 sentences to death in 69 countries
at least 3,048 executions in 31 countries
TRUE FIGURES ARE HIGHER!
7
Death Penalty
Executions 2001 - Countries
90 percent of all known executionstook place in
China (at least 2,468 executions - true figure much higher)
Iran (at least 139 executions)
Saudi Arabia (at least 79 executions)
USA (66 executions)
8
Death Penalty
Executions in the USA
71 executions in the year 2002,
bringing to 820 the total number executed since the use of the DP was resumed in 1977
over 3,700 prisoners were under sentence of death as of 1 January 2002
38 of the 50 US states provide for the death penalty in law
9
Death Penalty
Executions of Juvenile Offenders
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
American Convention on Human Rights
Convention on the Rights of the Child
prohibit anyone under 18 years old at the time of crime being sentenced to death.
International Human Rights Treaties, such as
10
Death Penalty
Executions of Juvenile Offenders
More than 100 countries whose laws still provide for the DP for at least some offences have laws specifically excluding the execution of juvenile offenders.
BUT:
Since 1990, 7 countries are known to have executed juvenile offenders: Congo, Iran, Nigeria, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, USA and Yemen (Pakistan and Yemen have now abolished executions of juvenile offenders in law)
The USA carried out the greatest number of known executions of child offenders (17 since 1990).
11
Death Penalty
Executions of Juvenile Offenders
»I don’t think we should be proud of the fact that the United States is the world leader in the execution of child offenders.«
(U.S. Senator Russ Feingold, November 11, 1999)
»I don’t think we should be proud of the fact that the United States is the world leader in the execution of child offenders.«
(U.S. Senator Russ Feingold, November 11, 1999)
12
Death Penalty
Mental Retardation / Illness
Not to impose it on those under the age of 18 at the time of the crime.
Not to impose it on a person suffering from any form of mental disorder (mentally ill and/or mentally retarded).
In April 2000, the UN Commission on Human Rights urged all states that maintain the DP:
13
Death Penalty
Mental Retardation / Illness
Japan
Kyrgyztan
USA (35 executions of people with mental retardation 1976-2001)
U.N. Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions has received reports of the executions of people with mental retardation in only 3 countries:
14
Death Penalty
USA: Racial Discrimination
»... a pattern of evidence indicating racial disparities in the charging, sentencing, and imposition of the death penalty ...«
»... i.e. those who murdered whites were found more likely to be sentenced to death than those who murdered blacks.«
(U.S. General Accounting Office, Death Penalty Sentencing, 1990)
»... a pattern of evidence indicating racial disparities in the charging, sentencing, and imposition of the death penalty ...«
»... i.e. those who murdered whites were found more likely to be sentenced to death than those who murdered blacks.«
(U.S. General Accounting Office, Death Penalty Sentencing, 1990)
15
Death Penalty
USA: Racial Discrimination
Since 1977, over 80% of the death row defendants have been executed for killing whites (nationally only 50% of murder victims are white).
Several studies concluded: In the US, holding all other factors constant, the single most reliable predictor of whether someone will be sentenced to death is the race of the victims.
16
Death Penalty
USA: Racial DiscriminationRace of the defendants
A study on the city of Philadelphia (1998): the odds of receiving a death sentence in Philadelphia are nearly 4 times higher if the defendant is black
Differential treatment of Afro-Americans at every turn: from initial decisions to plea bargaining to jury sentencing
All-white juries are still commonplace. Prosecutors may, in most states, remove potential black jurors - without giving any reasons.
98% of chief District Attorneys (=responsible of overseeing the decision on whether to seek a death sentence) are white.
17
Death Penalty
Socio-Economic Discrimination
»Race, ethnic origin and economic status appear to be key determinants of who will, and who will not, receive the death sentence« in the United States.
(UN Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary and Abritary Executions, 1997)
»Race, ethnic origin and economic status appear to be key determinants of who will, and who will not, receive the death sentence« in the United States.
(UN Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary and Abritary Executions, 1997)
USA:
95% of death row inmates cannot afford a lawyer
poor people are subjected to convictions and death sentences that equally or more culpable but more affluent people would not have received
18
Death Penalty
Executions of Innocent
since 1990, 350 people have been wrongfully convicted of capital crimes
of these, 23 were executed
between 1973 and 2002, 99 people in 24 US states have been released from death rows after evidence of their wrongful convictions emerged
inadequate defense
police and prosecutorial misconduct
false testimony / mistaken eyewitness testimony
racial prejudice
suppression of evidence / misinterpretation of evidence
community pressure
Factors leading to wrongful convictions
Situation in the USA:
19
Death Penalty
Cost
A New York study estimated the cost of an execution at 3 times than of life imprisonment.
In Florida, each execution costs the state $3.2 million, compared to $600,000 for life imprisonment.
USA: Capital punishment is a far more expensive system than one whose maximum penalty is life in prison:
20
Death Penalty
Why is it so expensive?
under a DP system, trials have 2 separate phases (conviction and sentencing) - they are typically preceded by special motions and extra jury selection questioning
more investigative costs are generally incurred in capital cases
The greatest costs of the DP are incurred prior to and at trial (not in post-conviction proceedings):
21
Death Penalty
Deterrance
»Research has failed to provide scientific proof that executions have a greater deterrent effect than life imprisonment and such proof is unlikely to be forthcoming.«
(Roger Hood, The Death Penalty: A World-Wide Perspective,1996)
»Research has failed to provide scientific proof that executions have a greater deterrent effect than life imprisonment and such proof is unlikely to be forthcoming.«
(Roger Hood, The Death Penalty: A World-Wide Perspective,1996)
People who murder are rarely rational at the time they commit the crime: influence of drugs/alcohol
in the grip of fear or rage
suffering from mental illness/retardation
22
Death Penalty
Deterrance
Studies have consistently failed to find convincing evidence that the death penalty deters crime.
On the contrary: DP has a brutalization effect.
23
Death Penalty
Brutalization
Study on Texas: high number of executions, high murder rate
Study on California: after the 1st execution in 1992 (after 25 years) - increases in homicides in the year following the execution
American-wide study: higher crime rates in countries with DP
Studies found incidence that DP has a brutalization effect.
New Times survey (Sept. 2000): homicide rate in states with DP has been 48% to 101% higher than in states without the DP
Falling of homicide rates in abolitionist countries (e.g. Canada)
25
Death Penalty
It’s up to you!
Contact:amnesty international ÖsterreichArbeitsgruppe für verfolgte GewerkschafterInnenMoeringgasse 10/1A-1150 WienSpeaker: Sabine VoglerTel.: +43 664 171 92 99e-mail: [email protected]://www.amnesty.at/gruppe/gew/