Fundamentals and Best Practices for Handling
Multistate Taxation
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
1
Presented Thursday, April 16, 2015
2©2015 The Payroll Advisor
Housekeeping
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
3
Credit QuestionsToday’s
topicSpeaker
To earn RCH credit you must
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
4
Stay on the webinar, online for the full 60 minutes
Be watching using your unique URL
Certificates delivered by email, to registered email,
by May 15th
About the Speaker
Vicki M. Lambert, CPP, is President and Academic Director of Vicki M. Lambert, LLC, a firm specializing in payroll education and training. Known as “The Payroll Advisor,” Ms. Lambert is Founder and Director of www.thepayrolladvisor.com, a website that provides unique and expert services for anyone dealing with the complexities and technicalities of the payroll process.
As an adjunct faculty member at Brandman University, Ms. Lambert is the creator and instructor for the Practical Payroll Online payroll training program, which is approved by the APA for recertification credits.
5
What Is Our Focus For Today?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
6
Taxes that could be required including:
Income, SUI, SDI, and Local
Following the IRS Code—where the states stand
Determining State Withholding Liability
Reciprocal Agreements
Resident vs. Nonresident
Withholding Allowance Certificates
4 Factor Test for SUI
Our Example for Today
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
7
We have a HR manager who lives and works in Newark, New Jersey three days a week, works one day a week in New York City and one day a week in New Haven, Connecticut at each of the companies subdivisions…What taxes is she subject to? For what taxes are we an employer? What do we have to withhold, pay or provide?
Taxes
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
8
Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington & Wyoming have no state income tax or do not require withholding
All states and D.C. have SUI
5 states have SDI or TDI including California, Hawaii, New Jersey, New York and Rhode Island (also Puerto Rico)
And then there are local taxes
MT
WY
ID
WA
OR
NV
UT
CA
AZ
ND
SD
NE
CO
NM
TX
OK
KS
AR
LA
MO
IA
MN
WI
IL IN
KY
TN
MS AL GA
FL
SC
NC
VAWV
OH
MI
NY
PA
MD
DE
NJ
CTRI
MA
ME
VT
NH
AK
HI
Has local taxation
States with Local Tax Requirements
©2015 The Payroll Advisor9
Examples of Local Taxes
Employer or Payroll Expense Tax
License Fee
Earned Income taxes--Pennsylvania’s “Act 32”
Income Tax
County taxes
Payroll Tax
School District taxes
Occupational Privilege tax
Transportation taxes
10
©The Payroll Advisor, 2015
Following the IRS Code
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
11
Majority of the states have adopted a policy that states the withholding requirements are the same as the federal income tax withholding
CA, MS, NJ and NM have their own code
Other states follow a version of the IRC—But which version?
The states can follow the current version of the IRC—or only as of a certain date
States vs. IRC
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
12
Area to watch: same-sex marriage and health insurance
States that follow current code include: Alabama, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, DC,
Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, New York (with exceptions), North Dakota, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, and Utah
So if IRC changes, state changes automatically
States that Follow IRC as of a Certain Date
January 1, 2015: Arkansas, Idaho, Iowa and North Carolina
December 31, 2014: Georgia, Maine, Minnesota, Virginia, South Carolina and West Virginia
February 26, 2015: Nebraska
December 31, 2013: Hawaii, and Oregon
January 1, 2012: Arizona March 22, 2013: Ohio December 31, 2010:
Wisconsin
April 5, 2010: Nebraska Jan 1, 2005:
Massachusetts Jan 1, 1997: Pennsylvania
(may have sections with different dates)
Or they pick a specific time frame or date:
Vermont: Taxable year 2013
13
©The Payroll Advisor, 2015
Are You an Employer?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
14
First question that must be asked—What taxes are required?
Second question that must be asked—are you an employer for that tax? Are you required to withhold or pay?
Final question—where is the employee a resident?
For every tax—for every employee
It is their rules not your opinion and never what is logical
Determining State Withholding Liability—Are You an Employer?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
15
State laws vary somewhat in their definitions of “employer” subject to withholding requirements. Some follow federal definitions while others have their own. Some common definitions include:
Does business within the state
Pays wages for services to one or more persons whose services are rendered in the state
Maintains an office or other place of business within the state
Derives income from, or takes orders within the state
In Other Words…
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
16
Do you have a nexus within that state?
The word means: A link, a tie, a connection to something
Established by having a business presence in the state as discussed on previous slide
When it comes to withholding taxes a nexus means you have to withhold
Applies to both the resident state and the working state—where is the nexus?
To Determine Withholding
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
17
Ascertain the following to determine withholding:
1. In which state is the work performed
2. The state of residency for the employee
3. Reciprocal agreements in place, if any
4. Rules for residents or nonresidents for work state
Making the Determination on Taxation
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
18
State Working State Living
Rules for this state for
a nonresident working
here including
reciprocal agreements
Rules for when a resident
from this state works in
another state including
any reciprocal agreements
Based on all we have covered the employer then
determines the income tax withholding
Best and easiest way is to T-account it
What is the employer’s
nexus?
Definition of Resident
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
19
Usually set forth in the state’s income tax laws
Generally: someone who maintains a place of abode or live in the state for a certain period of time
Example: Withholding in NJ for SIT
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
20
Our example employee is a resident of New Jersey so:
As a New Jersey employer, you are required to withhold New Jersey income tax from wages paid to all New Jersey residents unless you are withholding another jurisdiction's income tax at a rate equal to or greater than New Jersey's rate.
This is considered a “special agreement”
Are You an Employer In NY for SIT or City Income Tax?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
21
If you are an employer as described in federal Publication 15, Circular E, Employer's Tax Guide, and you maintain an office or transact business within New York State, whether or not a paying agency is maintained within the state, you must withhold personal income tax.
Who you must withhold tax for:
New York State residents earning wages even when earned outside of the state
New York State nonresidents being paid wages for services performed within the state
New York City residents even when services are performed outside New York City
Note: Employees who claim they are not a resident of New York State, New York City, or Yonkers must certify they are not a resident and estimate the percentage of their wages and other compensation attributable to services in New York State or Yonkers.
Are You an Employer in CT for SIT?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
22
Are You an Employer In NJ for SUI/TDI?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
23
When an employee performs services for the same employer in New Jersey and in some other state(s), the question of whether that employee is covered by the New Jersey Unemployment Compensation Law is determined by the tests of Sections 19 (i) (2) (A) and (B). Similar tests exist in the unemployment compensation laws of other states to avoid conflict and overlapping of coverage.
The application of these tests will result in the reporting to one state of the employee’s total wages in all states. The tests are to be applied to the employee, not to the employer, in the following order: (A) localization of service; (B) base of operations; (C) place of direction and control; (D) residence of employee.
Are You an Employer In NY for TDI?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
24
An employer who has had in New York State employment one or more employees on each of at least 30 days in any calendar year shall be a "covered employer" subject to the Disability Benefits Law after the expiration of four weeks following the 30th day of such employment (WCL §202). These 30 days of employment need not be consecutive days but must be work days of employment in one calendar year.
Are There Any Local Taxes?
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
25
1. Newark Payroll Tax—you will allocate for the non-Newark wages
2. New York City—None for nonresidents
3. None for New Haven
Reciprocal Agreements
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
26
A number of states have entered into reciprocal agreements with other states to ensure that employees who work and reside in different states are not subject to multiple withholding or taxation
The agreements specify that employers should withhold income taxes on a nonresident employee’s wages only for the worker’s home state and that such employee’s wages are not subject to the income tax rules of the state where the wages were earned
Watch out for local taxes usually do not apply
There can be “special” agreements as well
Reciprocal Agreement Chart
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
27
State Reciprocal
Agreements With:
State Reciprocal Agreements
With:
Illinois Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan &
WisconsinNew Jersey Pennsylvania
Indiana Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio,
Pennsylvania & WisconsinNorth Dakota Minnesota & Montana
Iowa Illinois Ohio Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan,
Pennsylvania & West Virginia
Kentucky Illinois, Indiana, Michigan,
Ohio, Virginia, West Virginia &
Wisconsin
Pennsylvania Indiana, Maryland, New Jersey,
Ohio, Virginia & West Virginia
Maryland D.C., Pennsylvania, Virginia &
West VirginiaVirginia Kentucky, District of Columbia,
Maryland, West Virginia and
Pennsylvania
Michigan Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky,
Minnesota, Ohio, & WisconsinWest Virginia Kentucky, Maryland, Ohio,
Pennsylvania & Virginia
Minnesota Michigan & North Dakota Wisconsin Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky &
Michigan
Montana North Dakota District of
Columbia
Maryland and Virginia
For Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
28
WI has agreement with IL
Resident of IL works in WI but does not want WI tax taken out—completes Form W-220—NO WI tax is withheld
Employer may but IS NOT required to withhold for IL
Wisconsin
Illinois
Works
Resides
©2015 The Payroll Advisor29
©2015 The Payroll Advisor30
Wisconsin requires:
Illinois requires (Pub 130 page 6): When completing the W-2, enter only the
amount of wages paid in Illinois or paid to an Illinois resident employed in
Iowa, Kentucky, Michigan or Wisconsin in Box 16.
Resident vs. Nonresident
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
31
Resident: generally must have state income tax withheld from all payments not specifically exempted, including wages for services performed outside the state
Nonresident: compensation is subject to withholding only to the extent it is earned within the state
Sometimes states will allow residents to use credit for other state against tax liability
Example: Nebraska
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
32
Nonresidents whose wages are subject to federal withholding and who work in Nebraska are subject to the same withholding on their entire wages as that used for Nebraska residents.
Connecticut Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
33
Dec, 2009: Employers are not required to withhold Connecticut income tax from wages/compensation paid to nonresident employees for services performed in Connecticut provided said employees are assigned to a primary work location outside of Connecticut and work in Connecticut 14 or fewer days during a calendar year. --Still report
Maine Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
34
Compensation for personal services performed in Maine as an employee is Maine-source income subject to taxation if the nonresident taxpayer is present in the state performing personal services for more than 12 days during that tax year and directly earns or derives more than $3,000 in gross income during the year in Maine from all sources.
Maine Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
35
Performance of the following personal services for 24 days during a calendar year is not counted toward the 12-day threshold:
personal services performed in connection with presenting or receiving employment-related training or education;
personal services performed in connection with a site inspection, review, analysis of management or any other supervision of a facility, affiliate or subsidiary based in Maine by a representative from a company, not headquartered in Maine, that owns that facility or is the parent company of the affiliate or subsidiary;
personal services performed in connection with research and development at a facility based in Maine or in connection with the installation of new or upgraded equipment or systems at that facility; or
personal services performed as part of a project team working on the attraction or implementation of new investment in a facility based in Maine.
Employee Withholding Certificates—The States
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
36
Employers must verify if the state has an equivalent form to the IRS Form W-4
The States may: Not have their own form and use the Form W-4 Have their own form but allow Form W-4 to be used Require only the state form be used
Best Practice Recommendation: If they have a form it should be used
Examples
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
37
Arizona: Form A-4 is required
California: DE4 required if withholding is different from federal withholding
Idaho: No state form
Possible Other Forms on State Level
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
38
Special forms for employee to claim exempt from state income tax
Forms for nonresidents of the state
Reciprocal agreement forms
Example of Nonresident Form-CT
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
39
Completes the form if the employee is a nonresident who performs services partly within and partly outside of Connecticut for same employer
Must also complete Form CT-W4
Guidelines—Employees Working in 2 or More States
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
40
Still using the rules just discussed as to resident and nonresident etc.
Some states provide guidelines for computing the allocation of withholding liabilities when employees work in more than one state
There are three commonly approved formulas
Volume of business ratio
Time Basis
Mileage Basis
Volume of Business Ratio
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
41
Where an employee’s compensation depends directly on the volume of business transacted by that employee tax withholding attaches to that portion of the wages determined by ratio of volume of business transacted within the jurisdiction to the total volume of business transacted by the employee
Time Basis
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
42
Where an employee is paid on a daily, weekly or monthly basis, tax withholding attaches to that portion of the employee’s pay determined by the ratio of working hours within the taxing jurisdiction to the total working time
Example:
Human Resources Manager paid on salary
Mileage Basis
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
43
Where an employee is paid on a mileage basis, tax withholding attaches to that portion of the employee’s pay determined by the ratio of actual mileage within the taxing jurisdiction to the employee’s total mileage
Example:
Delivery driver just passing through
Form W-2 Reporting Resident of NJ
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
44
NY Example-Nonresident
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
45
CT Nonresident Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
46
The Form W-2 must show the correct amount of Connecticut wages paid during the calendar year and the correct amount of Connecticut income tax withheld from wages during the calendar year.
In box 16 enter total wages paid during the calendar year which are attributable to services performed in Connecticut by the employee.
Telecommuting
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
47
Do you withhold for the state where the work is sent (the employer state) or where the employee is performing the work?
Most states it is where the work is performed—such as Oklahoma’s recent decision
An employee who moved out of Oklahoma but still works for the same employer by telecommuting is not subject Oklahoma nonresident income tax because the salaries, wages and commissions are for work performed outside of Oklahoma and the employee derives no income from sources within the state of Oklahoma. Accordingly the employer does not withholding Oklahoma state income tax from the wages.
Telecommuting
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
48
Watch out for Delaware, Pennsylvania, Nebraska and most especially New York
“convenience of the employer” rules
If telecommutes out of the employer’s necessity then take tax where work is performed
Hard to prove in New York
Four Factor Test for SUI
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
49
The states have adopted uniform rules to help them determine which state has the right to claim coverage of employees who work in two or more states for an employer. Employers consider the following four factors in successive order:
Localization of services
Base of operations
The place of direction or control
Place of residence
Localization of Services
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
50
Services performed partly within and without the state will be covered by state law if the work performed outside the state is incidental to the work performed in the state.
Incidental means transitory or temporary or isolated instances or transactions
Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
51
Localization of Services: A payroll clerk normally works at the company’s headquarters in Georgia. Due to the acquisition of a firm in Alabama the payroll clerk is sent to that state for three months to change over the payroll system. Georgia retains jurisdiction even during the period the payroll clerk is working in Alabama.
Base of Operations
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
52
If a worker normally or regularly works in two or more states the employee’s services can’t be said to be localized in one state. The next best claim to jurisdiction is the state where the employee performs some services and in which the base of operations is located
Base of operations means the place where employees report for work or customarily return to
Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
53
Base of Operations: A New York based company employs a regional sales manager to cover the states of PA, NJ and MD. The sales manager works out of an office in PA and divides his time fairly evenly among the three states. His activities are directed and controlled from the New York office. Pennsylvania has jurisdiction since the sales manager’s services aren’t localized in any one state and the base of operations is in PA.
Place of Direction or Control
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
54
If the prior two tests aren’t applicable then the employer goes to the next best claim of jurisdiction which is the state in which the employee performs some services and which is the place of direction or control
The determinant is the place of immediate or potential control even if the control is exercised only rarely
Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
55
Place of direction or control: A salesperson covers the DC metropolitan area including parts of DC, VA and MD. The salesperson has no primary base of operations and is under standing orders to call in at least daily to the company headquartered in DC. DC has jurisdiction in this instance since services aren’t localized, no primary base of operations and the salesperson receives direction and control from the DC office
Place of Residence
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
56
If the prior three tests don’t establish jurisdiction the state of jurisdiction becomes the one in which the employee both performs some services and maintains a place of residence
Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
57
Place of Residency: An equipment manufacturer in Detroit has an employee who supervises equipment installations and handles complaints from customers in IN and OH. The employee has no particular place of operations but lives in Ohio. The state of jurisdiction is Ohio.
Reciprocal Coverage Agreements
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
58
Most states subscribe to the Interstate Reciprocal Coverage Arrangement
Permits employers to cover services in a single state by election of the employer
All services will be covered in any state either in which any part of the services are performed, the employee resides or where the employer maintains a place of business
States accept and pay contributions on each other’s behalf to assure that services provided by multistate employees are not covered under more than one state
Example
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
59
A construction engineer who works for a Texas firm on a job in New Mexico for four months and who then goes to CA for six months on a job might be covered under both New Mexico and California laws. Under the interstate reciprocal arrangement, the Texas firm could elect to cover all the services performed by the engineer under Texas law
Are There Any Questions?
©The Payroll Advisor, 2015
60
How Can Ascentis Help Me?
61
Process payroll
• Real time flexible processing
• 100% accuracy
• Reduce processing time by up to 30%
Employee portal
• Paycheck data
• Paystubs
• Tax forms
• Paycheck simulation tools
To earn RCH credit you must
©2015 The Payroll Advisor
62
Stay on the webinar, online for the full 60 minutes
Be watching using your unique URL
Certificates delivered by email, to registered email,
by May 15th
Download Slides? Watch again?63
On-Demand Webinars
Watch from anywhere, at anytime, at no cost to you!
64
Download Slides? Watch again?65
Sharing the Education66