WorldSID debut for UN / WP 29 WorldSID Tri Chair Committee On behalf of the WorldSID Task Group of the ISO/TC22/SC12/WG5 133 rd session of UN / WP 29 Geneva,

WorldSID debut

for

UN / WP 29

WorldSID debut

for

UN / WP 29WorldSID Tri Chair Committee

On behalf of the WorldSID Task Group of the ISO/TC22/SC12/WG5

133rd session of UN / WP 29Geneva, June 22, 2004

WorldSID Tri Chair CommitteeOn behalf of the WorldSID Task Group of the ISO/TC22/SC12/WG5

133rd session of UN / WP 29Geneva, June 22, 2004

WorldSID Tri Chair Committee WorldSID debut 133rd WP 29 Session, Geneva, June, 22, 2004


2

OutlineOutlineOutlineOutline Background Scope Organization Worldwide Participation Timeline Design Worldwide Evaluation Production Release Documentation Other Activities Next Steps

Background Scope Organization Worldwide Participation Timeline Design Worldwide Evaluation Production Release Documentation Other Activities Next Steps



3

BackgroundBackgroundBackgroundBackground Need for improved side impact dummy

biofidelity

Need for harmonization No biomechanical reason for having different

dummies in different markets – no corresponding safety benefit

Need for improved side impact dummy biofidelity

Need for harmonization No biomechanical reason for having different

dummies in different markets – no corresponding safety benefit

Dummy TypeISO Rating

(1-10)

SID 2.3

Eurosid-1 4.2

Biosid 5.9



4

Worldwide program to design, develop, fabricate and test a harmonized mid-sized male side impact dummy

ISO TR 9790 Biofidelity classification: “good” to “excellent”

Design documentation to be in public domain

Worldwide program to design, develop, fabricate and test a harmonized mid-sized male side impact dummy

ISO TR 9790 Biofidelity classification: “good” to “excellent”

Design documentation to be in public domain

ScopeScopeScopeScope



5

WorldSID Organization Structure

ISO/TC22/SC12/WG5

TASK GROUPTri-Chairpersonship

(Asia/Pacific, Europe & Americas)

SPECIFICATIONS DESIGN

4 Technical Representatives per Region 1 Governmental Representative per Country

Advisory StatusParticipating Dummy Manufacturers

Participating Instrumentation Manufacturers

Asia/Pacific Europe AmericasAdvisory Group Advisory Group Advisory Group

(Unlimited Membership) (Unlimited Membership) (Unlimited Membership)

Country No. 1 Country No. 2 Country No. nAdvisory Group Advisory Group Advisory Group

(Unlimited Membership) (Unlimited Membership) (Unlimited Membership)



6

AAMA ACEA Alliance Autoliv AUDI BASt BMW Group CEESAR DaimlerChrysler DOTRS – Australia

AAMA ACEA Alliance Autoliv AUDI BASt BMW Group CEESAR DaimlerChrysler DOTRS – Australia

Worldwide participationWorldwide participationWorldwide participationWorldwide participation Fiat Ford GM Honda INRETS ISO JAMA JARI JMLIT LAB

Fiat Ford GM Honda INRETS ISO JAMA JARI JMLIT LAB

Lear MIRA NHTSA Nissan OSRP PDB PSA Porsche Renault SIBER*

Lear MIRA NHTSA Nissan OSRP PDB PSA Porsche Renault SIBER*

* EC Sponsored* EC Sponsored

TNO TRC Toyota Transport Canada TRL TRW Volvo VW

TNO TRC Toyota Transport Canada TRL TRW Volvo VW



7

TimelineTimelineTimelineTimeline

1998 2000 2001 2002 2003 20041999

Set up program anddevelop specificationsSet up program anddevelop specifications

Prototype development and evaluationsPrototype development and evaluations

Pre-production development and evaluations

Prototype Rev. 1development and evaluationsPrototype Rev. 1development and evaluations

ReleaseFinalize ProductionDocuments



8

DesignDesignDesignDesign Developed by hundreds of engineers, scientists and

technicians

Over 45 organizations from around the world

Governmental agencies, research institutes, industry

Design Team working under the direction of the Task Group

Dynamic Research Inc. (Project Management) Denton ATD DTS FTSS R.A. Denton, Inc.

Developed by hundreds of engineers, scientists and technicians

Over 45 organizations from around the world


Design Team working under the direction of the Task Group

Dynamic Research Inc. (Project Management) Denton ATD DTS FTSS R.A. Denton, Inc.



9

DesignDesignDesignDesign Available Instrumentation Available Instrumentation

Head 14 channels

Neck 9 channels

Shoulder 7 channels

Thorax 19 channels

Abdomen 8 channels

Lumbar Spine 9 channels

Pelvis 24 channels

Leg 25 channels per leg

Full Arm (optional) 20 channels per arm



10

DesignDesignDesignDesign



11

11 pre-production dummies were evaluated

Organizations from around the world


11 pre-production dummies were evaluated

Organizations from around the world


Worldwide EvaluationWorldwide EvaluationWorldwide EvaluationWorldwide Evaluation



12

Biofidelity testing ISO TR 9790 tests IHRA proposed tests

Sled and pendulum tests Durability Sensitivity (impact location, offset, impact angle) Repeatability Reproducibility

Certification and component testing Repeatability and reproducibility Developed certification corridors

Biofidelity testing ISO TR 9790 tests IHRA proposed tests

Sled and pendulum tests Durability Sensitivity (impact location, offset, impact angle) Repeatability Reproducibility

Certification and component testing Repeatability and reproducibility Developed certification corridors

Worldwide Evaluation Worldwide Evaluation Worldwide Evaluation Worldwide Evaluation



13

Full scale crash tests (25 +) In-vehicle performance Durability, handling, repeatability Comparison of WorldSID and other side impact dummy

responses including ES-2, ES-2re

Full scale crash tests (25 +) In-vehicle performance Durability, handling, repeatability Comparison of WorldSID and other side impact dummy

responses including ES-2, ES-2re




14

Test procedures

ECE-R-95EURO-NCAP barrierEURO-NCAP poleFMVSS 201 pole FMVSS 214

Test procedures

ECE-R-95EURO-NCAP barrierEURO-NCAP poleFMVSS 201 pole FMVSS 214


SINCAP IHRA proposed IIHS barrier IHRA proposed AEMDB barrier IHRA proposed oblique poleVehicle- to-vehicle tests

SINCAP IHRA proposed IIHS barrier IHRA proposed AEMDB barrier IHRA proposed oblique poleVehicle- to-vehicle tests

More than 1000 component, sled and crash tests

More than 1000 component, sled and crash tests



15

WorldSID WorldSID

unacceptable marginal fair good excellent

0 2,6 4,4 6,5 8,6 10

unacceptable marginal fair good excellent

0 2,6 4,4 6,5 8,6 10

DOT-SID 2,3DOT-SID 2,3

Worldwide EvaluationWorldwide EvaluationWorldwide EvaluationWorldwide Evaluation Highest ISO TR 9790 Biofidelity Rating for WorldSID Highest ISO TR 9790 Biofidelity Rating for WorldSID

7,67,6

ES-2 4,7ES-2 4,7

ES-2 re 4,2ES-2 re 4,2



16

WorldSID kinematics in 201 pole test Shoulder shrugs and flexes

WorldSID kinematics in 201 pole test Shoulder shrugs and flexes




17

World Evaluation World Evaluation World Evaluation World Evaluation US SINCAP test

Crabbed barrier 62 km/h

US SINCAP test Crabbed barrier 62 km/h



18

Predicts abdominal injury risk Predicts abdominal injury risk


ES-2ES-2 ES-2reES-2re WorldSIDWorldSID

Risk of InjuryRisk of Injury

Abdomen Rib 1 Displacement


Abdominal Load SumAbdomen Rib 1 Displacement


Abdominal Load Sum



19

Two repeat ECE-R-95 tests Two repeat ECE-R-95 tests


Middle thoracic rib Middle thoracic rib deflectiondeflection

Upper thoracic rib Upper thoracic rib accelerationacceleration

Thoracic spine accleration at T1Thoracic spine accleration at T1

Thoracic spine accleration at T12Thoracic spine accleration at T12



20


Superior biofidelity Superior injury assessment capability Good repeatability Good reproducibility Excellent handling Good durability

Superior biofidelity Superior injury assessment capability Good repeatability Good reproducibility Excellent handling Good durability



21

Worldwide evaluation completed in February 2004

Production design sign off occurred on February 12th, 2004

Production release on March 9th, 2004

Worldwide evaluation completed in February 2004

Production design sign off occurred on February 12th, 2004

Production release on March 9th, 2004

Production ReleaseProduction ReleaseProduction ReleaseProduction Release

Production Dummy available(approx. 12 weeks lead time)

Production Dummy available(approx. 12 weeks lead time)



22

ISO 15830 documentation to support GTR

Working draft approved by ISO/TC22/SC12/WG5 May 2004

Currently for review and balloting by ISO/TC22/SC12 Committee Draft

Late 2004: review and balloting by ISO/TC22Start process for ISO DIS 15830

ISO 15830 documentation to support GTR

Working draft approved by ISO/TC22/SC12/WG5 May 2004

Currently for review and balloting by ISO/TC22/SC12 Committee Draft

Late 2004: review and balloting by ISO/TC22Start process for ISO DIS 15830

DocumentationDocumentationDocumentationDocumentation

ISO 15830 available in 2005ISO 15830 available in 2005



23

Injury risk curves ISO/TC22/SC12/WG6 is developing injury risk

curves for the WorldSID

Injury risk curves ISO/TC22/SC12/WG6 is developing injury risk

curves for the WorldSID

Other ActivitiesOther ActivitiesOther ActivitiesOther Activities

Draft presented at ISO/WG 6 Meeting in May 2004

Draft presented at ISO/WG 6 Meeting in May 2004

Seating procedure ISO/TC22/SC10 is developing a seating procedure

for the WorldSID

Seating procedure ISO/TC22/SC10 is developing a seating procedure

for the WorldSID

Draft is included in ISO/CD 15830 Draft is included in ISO/CD 15830



24

Evaluation of WorldSID by the NHTSA beginning in August 2004

WorldSID Task Group to manage comments and revisions

Continue updates to GRSP

WorldSID Task Group to work with safety regulators to seek agreement for WorldSID to be the globally harmonized side impact dummy by 2007

Evaluation of WorldSID by the NHTSA beginning in August 2004

WorldSID Task Group to manage comments and revisions

Continue updates to GRSP

WorldSID Task Group to work with safety regulators to seek agreement for WorldSID to be the globally harmonized side impact dummy by 2007

Next StepsNext StepsNext StepsNext Steps

Thank you!Thank you!

www.worldsid.orgwww.worldsid.org

Thank you!Thank you!

www.worldsid.orgwww.worldsid.org

WorldSID debut for UN / WP 29 WorldSID Tri Chair Committee On behalf of the WorldSID Task Group of the ISO/TC22/SC12/WG5 133 rd session of UN / WP 29 Geneva,

Documents

worldsid task group

rd session

designdesign slide

arm slide

impact dummy iso tr

impact dummy biofidelity

channels leg

channels neck