Page 1
WorkforcePlanninginaRapidlyChangingHealthcareSystem
ErinFraher,PhDMPPDirector,CarolinaCenterforHealthWorkforceResearch,
CecilG.ShepsCenterforHealthServicesResearch,AssistantProfessor,DepartmentsofFamilyMedicineandSurgery,
UniversityofNorthCarolinaatChapelHill
SouthCarolinaHealthCareWorkforceForumFebruary13,2017
Page 2
Disclaimer/NoConflictofInterest
• MyworkissupportedbytheNa4onalCenterforHealthWorkforceAnalysis(NCHWA),HealthResourcesandServicesAdministra4on(HRSA)undercoopera4veagreement#U81HP26495,TheRobertWoodJohnsonFounda4onandThePhysiciansFounda4on.
• Theinforma4on,conclusionsandopinionsexpressedinthispresenta4onaremineandnoendorsementbythefundersorTheUniversityofNorthCarolinaisintendedorshouldbeinferred.
• Ideclarenoconflictofinterest.
Page 3
ThispresentaKoninoneslide
• Currentsystemisnotsustainable—costpressureswilldrivechange
• Increasedemphasisonpopula4onhealthrequiresexpandeddefini4onofhealthworkforce
• Nursingworkforceiscri4caltotransforma4on.NeedtoshiYdialoguefromnumberstoretooling
• Di[oforphysicians—bigissueismaldistribu4onbyspecialtyandgeography
• Workforceplanningforrapidlychanginghealthcaresystemrequiresbe[erconnec4onsbetweeneduca4onandprac4ceandamoreflexibleworkforce
Page 4
ForcesDrivingChange
Page 5
Whydowecareaboutthehealthworkforce?
• Workforceisexpensive:of$2.6trillionspentonhealthcare,56%a[ributedtowages*
• Expensiveandinefficienttolurchfromoversupplytoshortage
*DunnL.GeWngaHandleonHospitalCosts.HospitalsandHealthNetworks.2015
Page 6
Needstrategicworkforceplanningto“smooth”thecycle
time
supp
ly
Typical intervention point
Ideal intervention point
Supply of health professionals
Page 7
LetOneThousandFlowersBloom:Experimentstoreformhealthsystem
• Withorwithouthealthreform,costpressuresaredrivingchange
• Newmodelsofcareaimtolowercosts,enhancequality,improvepopula4onhealthandlowerproviderburnout– Pa4entCenteredMedicalHomes
– AccountableCareOrganiza4ons– ClinicallyIntegratedNetworks
Page 8
WhatarethekeycharacterisKcsofnewmodelsofcare?
ProvidepaKentswithmorecomprehensive,accessible,coordinatedandhighqualitycareatlowercosts
• Emphasisonprimary,preven4veand“upstream”care
• Careisintegratedbetween:– Primarycare,subspecial4es,homehealthagenciesandnursinghomes
– Healthcaresystemandcommunity-basedsocialservices
• EHRsusedtomonitorpa4entandpopula4onhealth—increaseduseofdataforriskstra4fica4onandhotspofng
• Interven4onsfocusedatbothpa4ent-andpopula4on-level• Movetowardrisk-basedandvalue-basedpaymentmodels(maybe?)
Page 9
Differenthealthsystemmeansdifferentworkers
“Atransformedhealthcaresystemwillrequireatransformedworkforce.
ThepeoplewhowillsupporthealthsystemtransformaIonforcommuniIesand
populaIonswillrequiredifferentknowledgeandskills…inprevenIon,carecoordinaIon,careprocessre-engineering,disseminaIonofbestpracIces,team-basedcare,conInuousqualityimprovement,andtheuseofdatatosupporta
transformedsystem.”
Source:CentersforMedicareandMedicaidServices,HealthCareInnovaKonChallengeGrant,FundingOpportunityNumber:CMS-1C1-12-001,CFDA:93.610,November2011.hcp://www.innovaKons.cms.gov/Files/x/Health-Care-InnovaKon-Challenge-Funding-Opportunity-Announcement.pdf
Page 10
AHealthWorkforceoraWorkforceforHealth?
Page 11
Whoisthrowingbodiesintotheriver?
“IamstandingbytheshoreofaswiYlyflowingriverandhearthecryofadrowningman.Ijumpintothecoldwaters.Ifightagainstthestrongcurrentandforcemywaytothestrugglingman…Ilayhimoutonthebankandrevivehimwithar4ficialrespira4on.Justwhenhebeginstobreathe,Ihearanothercryforhelp…Ifightagainstthestrongcurrent,andswimforcefullytothestrugglingwoman…IliYheroutontothebankbesidethemanandworktoreviveherwithar4ficialrespira4on.Justwhenshebeginstobreathe,Ihearanothercryforhelp….Nearexhaus9on,itoccurstomethatI'msobusyjumpingin,pullingthemtoshore,applyingar9ficialrespira9onthatIhaveno9metoseewhoisupstreampushingthemallin....”(AdaptedfromastorytoldbyIrvingZolaascitedinMcKinlay,JohnB."Acaseforrefocusingupstream:Thepoli4caleconomyofillness."InConradandKern,2ndedi4on,1986,TheSociologyofHealthandIllness:CriIcalPerspecIves.pp.484-498.)
Page 12
ThisistheaimofAccountableHealthCommuniKesModelannouncedbyCMS“Werecognizethatkeepingpeoplehealthyisaboutmorethanhappensinsideadoctor’soffice…wearetesIngwhetherscreeningpaIentsforhealth-relatedsocialneedsandconnecIngthemtolocalresourceslikehousingandtransportaIontothedoctorwillulImatelyimprovetheirhealthandreducecoststotaxpayers…”SecretaryBurwell,h[p://www.hhs.gov/about/news/2016/01/05/first-ever-cms-innova4on-center-pilot-project-test-improving-pa4ents-health.html
Page 13
AccountableHealthCommuniKesGoalsandAims
“ThefoundaIonofthemodelisuniversal,comprehensivescreeningforhealth-relatedsocial
needs—includinghousingneeds,foodinsecurity,uIlityneeds,interpersonalsafetyandtransportaIon
difficulIes—inallMedicareandMedicaidbeneficiarieswhoobtainhealthcareatparIcipaIngsites”
Alley,DE,AsomughaCN,ConwayPH,SanghaviDM.(2016).AccountableHealthCommuni4es—AssessingSocialNeedsthroughMedicareandMedicaid.NewEnglandJournalofMedicine.371;1:8-11.
Page 14
SuchanapproachrequiresbroaderdefiniKonofthehealthworkforce
PopulaKonhealthrequiresusto:
• Expandworkforceplanningeffortstoincludeworkersincommunityandhome-basedsefngs
• Embracetheroleofsocialworkers,pa4entnavigators,communityhealthworkers,homehealthworkers,communityparamedics,die4ciansandothercommunity-basedworkers
• Planforworkforceneedsofpa4entsandcommuni4es,notforneedsofprofessions
• Determinehowtointegratethepublichealthworkforceintohealthworkforceplanning
Page 15
Wheredoesthepublichealthworkforcefitin?
• “PublicHealth3.0”(Oct2016)callsfor“neweraofenhancedandbroadenedpublichealthprac4cethatgoesbeyondtradi4onalpublichealthdepartmentfunc4ons”
• Howwillpublichealthmaintaintradi4onalstrengthsandconfrontchallengesofagingpopula4onwithchronicdisease?
• “Health-in-all-policies”arereshapinginterfacebetweenpublichealthandcommunitypartners
• PublicHealth3.0callsfora“ChiefHealthStrategist”todevelopcommunitypartnerships
• Thosepartnersincludehospitalsandphysicianprac4ces
Source:OfficeoftheAssistantSecretaryforHealth,USDepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.ACalltoAcKontoCreatea21stCenturyPublicHealthInfrastructure.Washington,DC.October2016.hcps://www.healthypeople.gov/sites/default/files/Public-Health-3.0-White-Paper.pdf
Page 16
IntegraKngpublichealthandhealthworkforceplanning
• RecentsurveybyNa4onalAssocia4onofCountyandCityHealthOfficials(NACCHO)foundthat58%oflocalhealthdepartmentswerecollabora4ngwithhospitalsoncommunityhealthneedsassessments
• ButareCHNAsbeingusedforworkforceplanning?• Surveyiden4fiedskillgapsininforma4cs
• Publichealthworkforceofthefuturewillincreasinglyneedtouse“bigdata”forsurveillance,assessmentandevalua4on(andworkforceplanning!)
Source:NACCHO.2016NaKonalProfileofLocalHealthDepartments.WashingtonDC.hcp://nacchoprofilestudy.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Main-Report-Final.pdf.
Page 17
Boundaryspanningrolesgrowingquickly
PanelManagers HealthCoaches
Assumeresponsibilityforpa4entsbetweenvisits.UseEHRsandpa4entregistriestoiden4fyandcontactpa4entswithunmet
careneeds.OYenmedicalassistantsbutcanbenursesor
otherstaff
Improvepa4entknowledgeaboutdiseaseormedica4onandpromotehealthybehaviors.Maybemedicalassistants,nurses,
healtheducators,socialworkers,communityhealthworkers,pharmacistsorotherstaff
“Boundaryspanning”rolesreflectshiYfromvisit-basedtopopula4on-basedstrategies
Twoexamples:
Page 18
Othernewrolesareemerginginevolvingsystem
• Pa4entnavigators• Casemanagers• Carecoordinators• Communityhealthworkers• Caretransi4onspecialists• Livingskillsspecialists• Pa4entfamilyac4vator• Peerandfamilymentors• Peercounselors
Ø Allplayroleinpa4enttransi4onsbetweenhome,community,ambulatoryandacutecarehealthsefngs
Ø Evidenceshowsimprovedcaretransi4onsreduceunnecessaryhospitaladmissions,lowercostsandimprovepa4entsa4sfac4on
EmergingRoles ImplicaKons
Page 19
It’scomplicated
• Newrolesmaybefilledbyexis4ngstaffornewhires
• Someroleshavesimilarfunc4onsbutdifferent4tles—caremanagersandcasemanagers
• Otherroleshavedifferentfunc4onsbutsamename—paKentnavigators
• Dependingonsefngandpa4entpopula4on,rolesareoYenfilledbydifferenttypesofproviders—medicalassistants,socialworkers,nurses,etc.
Page 20
Socialworkersplayincreasinglyimportantboundaryspanningroles
SocialworkersservingthreefuncKonsonintegratedbehavioralhealth/physicalhealthteams:
• Behavioralhealthspecialists:provideinterven4onsforpa4entswithmentalhealth,substanceabuseandotherbehavioralhealthdisorders
• CareManagers:coordinatecareofpa4entswithchroniccondi4ons,monitorcareplans,assesstreatmentprogressandconsultwithprimarycarephysicians
• Referralrole:connectpa4entstocommunityresourcesincludinghousing,transporta4on,food,etc.
Fraser M, Lombardi B, Wu S, Zerden L, Richman E, Fraher E. Social Work in Integrated Primary Care: A Systematic Review. Program on Health Workforce Research and Policy, Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research. September 2016. http://www.shepscenter.unc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/PolicyBrief_Fraser_y3_final.pdf
Page 21
Andnewhealthcareteamsareemerging:CommunityAginginPlace—AdvancingBecerLivingforElders(CAPABLE)Teams
• AnOccupa4onalTherapist,aRegisteredNurse,andahandymanformteamallowingseniorstoageinhomes
• Provideassis4vedevicesandmakehomemodifica4onstoenablepar4cipantstonavigatetheirhomesmoreeasilyandsafely
• AYercomple4ngfive-monthprogram,75percentofpar4cipants(n=281adultsage65+)hadimprovedtheirperformanceofADLs
• SymptomsofdepressionandabilitytoperforminstrumentalADLssuchasshoppingandmanagingmedica4onsalsoimproved
• Healthsystemsaretes4ngCAPABLEonalargerscale
h[p://nursing.jhu.edu/faculty_research/research/projects/capable/
Source: Szanton SL, Leff B, Wolff JL, Robers K, Gitlin LN. (2016). Home-Based Care Program Reduces Disability And Promotes Aging In Place. Health Affairs; Sep 1;35(9):1558-63.
Page 22
Wheredoesnursingfitin?Willwefaceanursingshortage?
Page 23
Shortage?Noshortage?Dowereallyknow?
• Na4onalnursingmodelsmixed:somesuggestshortage,othersexcesssupply
• Evenrecently,graduatesinstatespredictedtobeinshortagewerenotgefngtheirfirst,orevensecond,employmentchoice
• HRSAprojectsSouthCarolinawillbasicallybeinbalancein2025(600nursesshortonbasesupplyof54,000)
• Doesthisprojec4on“feelright”?
Page 24
NumberofnewNCLEXtakersincreasingrapidly
Between2001-2011:• Numberofbachelor’s
preparedRNcandidatestakingtheNCLEX-RNexammorethandoubled
• AssociatedegreecandidatestakingtheNCLEX-RNexamexperienceda99%growth
Figure19:GrowthinNCLEX-RNFirst-TimeTestTakers,byBachelor’sandNon-Bachelor’sDegreeStatus,2001to2011
DataSources:HRSAcompila4onofdatafromtheNa4onalCouncilofStateBoardsofNursing,NurseLicensureandNCLEXExamina4onSta4s4csPublica4ons,2002-2012,andfromtheNa4onalCouncilofStateBoardofNursing,“NumberofCandidatesTakingtheNCLEXExamina4onandPercentPassing,byTypeofCandidate,”h[ps://www.ncsbn.org/Table_of_Pass_Rates_2011.pdf
Source:Na4onalCenterforHealthWorkforceAnalysis,HRSA,h[p://bhpr.hrsa.gov/healthworkforce/supplydemand/nursing/nursingworkforce/nursingworkforcefullreport.pdf,pgs37-38,accessed11/5/15.
Page 25
Butontheground,we’rehearingaboutnursingshortages.Why?
Coulditbethatourmodelsarenotaccurate(GASP!)?
• Wemodeloverallsupplyandnotsupply/demandinspecificprac4ceareaslikeICU,ER,L&DandOR– Arethereshortagesforspecialtynurses?
• Re4rementassump4onshaveLARGEeffectonmodels.Maybeourmodelsdon’thaveit“right”?
– Arebabyboomersnowbeginningtore4reinlargernumbers?
Page 26
Maybewe’renotmodelingdemandcorrectly?
• Demandmaybeupduetoabe[ereconomy,increasedinsurancecoverageandagingpopula4on
• Demandhasincreasedinoutpa4entsefngsandinpa4entnursing-whichhasalwaysbeenpopular-isnowcompe4ngwithothersefngs
Page 27
Maybethereisamismatchbetweenwhateducatorsproduceandemployerswant?
• Hospitalswantexperiencednursesandarenothiringnewgradsbecausetheyarenotgradua4ngwiththeclinicalexper4sethathospitalswant
• Healthsystemsareseekingnursesfornewrolesinpa4entengagement,carecoordina4on,informa4csandotherfunc4onsinnewmodelsofcare(moreonthatlater….)
Page 28
AcriKonseemstobeontherise,FTEonthedecline
• A[ri4onofnewnursesseemstobeincreasing.Why?
• BSNsarenotstayingtheworkforce—theywanttobecomeadvancedprac4cenursesandareleavingtheworkforcetogobackschool
• Millennialsdon’twanttoworkasmanyhoursandarenottakingonextrashiYs
Page 29
Otherreasonswhyourmodelsmaynotbecorrect
• Hiringinterna4onallytrainednurseshasbecomemoredifficult
• Paymentmodelsarechanging—maybevalue-basedpaymentmodelsemploymorenurses?
• Other?
Page 30
Butlet’sshilthedialogue
Focusingonwhetherwehaveanursingshortagedistractsusfromamoreimportantques4on:
Willwehavetherightmixofnursesinthe
rightloca9ons,special9esandprac9ceseCngs
withtheskillsandcompetenciesneededtomeet
thedemandsofatransformedhealthcaresystem?
Page 31
Thefuturenursingworkforce:Newrolesinatransformed
healthsystem
Page 32
WhythenursingworkforceiscriKcaltohealthsystemtransformaKon
• Withnearly3millionnursesinac4veprac4ce,nursingisbyfarthelargestlicensedhealthprofession(aboutfourImesasmanynursesasphysicians)
• Nursingcarelinkedtoqualityandsa4sfac4onmeasuresthatwillincreasinglybe4edtovalue-basedpayments
• Nursesprovidewhole-personcareacrosshealthandcommunity-basedsefngs
• Nursesaretheul4mate“flexible”workforcetakingonnewrolesintransformedhealthsystem
Page 33
WorkforceisshilingfromacutetocommunityseWngs
• Changesinpaymentpolicyandhealthsystemorganiza4on:– ShiYfromfee-for-servicetowardrisk-andvalue-basedmodels– Finesthatpenalizehospitalsforreadmissions
• WillincreasinglyshiYhealthcare—andthehealthcareworkforce—fromexpensiveinpa4entsefngstoambulatory,communityandhome-basedsefngs
• Butwegenerallyeducatenursesininpa4entsefngs
• Currentworkforcenotadequatelypreparedtoworkinambulatorysefngsandpa4ents’homes
Page 34
WhiletheoverallpercentofSouthCarolinanursesemployedinhospitalshasn’tchanged
Source: SC Office for Healthcare Workforce, RNs active in the South Carolina workforce based on self-reported employment information provided during the biennial license renewal period, years 2004 – 2014.
Page 35
ThepercentworkinginpaKenthasdecreased,andpercentin“hospital-wide”roleshasincreased
Source: SC Office for Healthcare Workforce, RNs active in the South Carolina workforce based on self-reported employment information provided during the biennial license renewal period, years 2004 – 2014.
Page 36
Nursingworkforce:Newroles,newrules
Cita4on:FraherE,SpetzJ,NaylorM.NursinginaTransformedHealthCareSystem:NewRoles,NewRules.LDI/INQRIResearchBrief.June2015.h[p://ldi.upenn.edu/uploads/media_items/inqri-ldi-brief-nursing.original.pdf.
“Whatwillittaketoop9mizecontribu9onsofnurses?• Redesignthenursingcurriculumtoeducatenurseswithnewcompetencies;• RetrainexisIngnurseswithnewskillsandknowledge;• RevamplicensingexaminaIonandrequirementstoreflectthenewcurriculum;and• Restructurethestateregulatorysystemtoallowflexibledeploymentofthenurseworkforce.”
h[p://www.shepscenter.unc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/inqri-ldi-brief-nursing.original.pdf-QuotedfromJanetWeiner,MPH.PennLDIVoicesBlog.“Re:Nurses”.
June25,2015.hep://ldi.upenn.edu/voices/2015/06/25/re-nurses
Page 37
RegisteredNursesareunderuKlizedinprimarycare
1. CulturechangeneededtoelevateprimarycareinRNeduca4on
2. Prac4cesshouldredesigncaredeliverymodelstobe[eru4lizeRNskills
3. Educatorsneedtoputmoreemphasisonprimarycarecontent
4. Lifelonglearningopportuni4esneededtosupportRNsinprimarycare
5. Be[eralignmentneededbetweenRNeduca4onandprac4ce
6. Moreinterprofessionaleduca4onandteamworkneededincurricula
h[p://macyfounda4on.org/docs/macy_pubs/201609_Nursing_Conference_Exectuive_
Summary_Final.pdf
Page 38
PhysicianWorkforceIssues&GraduateMedicalEducaKon
Page 39
ExpertsdisagreeaboutwhethertheUnitedStateswillfaceashortage
• AAMCprojectsshor�allsofbetween12,500and31,000primarycarephysiciansand46,100and90,400totalphysiciansby20251
• Federalgovernment(HRSA)forecastsshortageof6,400primarycarephysiciansin20202withincreaseduseofNPsandPAs
• WereleasedmodelinJuly2014thatsuggestsoverallsupplywillbeadequate,morepressingissueismaldistribu4onbyspecialtyandgeography
1 AAMC, https://www.aamc.org/download/426242/data/ihsreportdownload.pdf?cm_mmc=AAMC-_-ScientificAffairs-_-PDF-_-ihsreport 2 HRSA, http://bhpr.hrsa.gov/healthworkforce/supplydemand/usworkforce/primarycare/projectingprimarycare.pdf
h[ps://www2.shepscenter.unc.edu/workforce
Page 40
This project is funded by a grant from The Physicians Foundation.
OurmodelhighlightsthatweareanaKonof“haves”and“have-nots”
Shortage/Surplus for All Visits, All Settings, 2014 Aurora,IL
NewOrleans,LA
Washington,DC
Boston,MA
NewYork,NY
SanFrancisco,CA
Slidell,LA
Rochester,MN
Boulder,CO
HunIngton,WV
Bangor,ME
MelrosePark,IL
Page 41
This project is funded by a grant from The Physicians Foundation.
AndthatexpectedgrowthinNPsandPAswilloffsetphysicianshortages
NP/PA Increase by 3%
Baseline
NP/PA Increase by 6%
Page 42
42
* Counts include master’s and post-master’s NP and NP/CNS graduates, and Baccalaureate-to-DNP graduates. Source: American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) and National Organization of Nurse Practitioner Faculties (NONPF) Annual Surveys
Gra
duat
es
GrowthinNursePracKKonerGraduates*2001-2015
Growth from 2014 to 2015 : 20.3%
Page 43
This project is funded by a grant from The Physicians Foundation.
ForSC,ourmodelforecastsstableoverallsupplybutdecliningsupplyinprimarycare
PrimaryCareAllspecial9es
13.1 13.5 6.0 4.9
PhysicianSupply,FTEper10,000PopulaKon,SouthCarolina,2013-2030
h[ps://www2.shepscenter.unc.edu/workforce
Page 44
This project is funded by a grant from The Physicians Foundation.
SouthCarolinalikelytofaceexcessdemandforhealthcarevisits
= supply of visits physicians can provide utilization of visits needed by population
h[ps://www2.shepscenter.unc.edu/workforce
RelaKveCapacityofPhysicianSupplytoMeetDemandforVisits,SouthCarolina,2013-2030
Page 45
This project is funded by a grant from The Physicians Foundation.
WhatifweactuallyusedworkforcedatatodeterminewheretoinvestinGME?Weusedmodeltodeterminehowtotargetproposed3,000PGY1slotstomeetan4cipatedshortagesn FindingssuggestexpandingGMEinstateswith:
q Poorhealthoutcomesandhighhealthcareu4liza4on(Arkansas,MississippiandAlabama)
q Large,growingpopula4ons(TexasandCalifornia)q Agingpopula4ons(Florida)q Lowresident/popula4onnumbers(Idaho,Wyoming,Montana,
AlaskaandNevada)n 5states(Connec4cut,Delaware,NewHampshire,RhodeIslandand
Vermont)andtheDistrictofColombiareceivenoGMEslotsbecausetheyarealreadywellsupplied
Page 46
SouthCarolinawouldreceive64newPGY1posiKons
Specialty Cardiology 6 Dermatology 2 Emergency Medicine 3 Family Medicine 6 Gastroenterology 3 General Pediatrics 3 Gynecology/Obstetrics 2 Infectious disease 4 Internal Medicine 9 Nephrology 2
Modelproposes64newPGY1posiKonsinSouthCarolina
Specialty Oncology 5 Other Physician Specialty 2
Pediatric Non-Surgical Specialties
3
Plastic Surgery 2 Psychiatry 2 Pulmonology 2 Surgery 4
Thoracic Surgery 2
Urology 2 New PGY1 Slots 64
# PGY1 Slots # PGY1 Slots
Page 47
Werecentlycompletedstudyoftenstates’effortstoreformMedicaidGMEWhystudystates?
• FederalGMEreformeffortshavestalled
• Statesare“policylaboratories”forGMEinnova4on
• Manystatesinves4nginGMEwithMedicaiddollars:
– In2015,43statesandDCmadeMedicaidGMEpayments
– TotalMedicaidGMEpaymentsincreased10%from$3.87billionin2012to$4.26billionin2015
h[p://www.shepscenter.unc.edu/programs-projects/workforce/projects/carolina-health-workforce-research-center/
Page 48
StudyisKmely
• Withchangeoffederaladministra4on,policywindowmaybeopeningforincreasedstateinvolvementinGME
• Poten4alforMedicaidblockgrantsorpercapitaallotmentscouldacceleratestate-levelGMEreform
• Statesfacingbudgetconstraintsandpressuretoiden4fyreturnoninvestmentforpublicfundsspentonGME
• Thisstudysoughtto:– Inves4gatehowstatesarereformingMedicaidandstate-fundedGMEfinancing
– Iden4fyinnova4onsandchallenges
Page 49
Whatwefound
• Highlevelofinterest,limitedreformofMedicaidGME
• MoststatesseekingnewGMEappropria4ons,notredistribu4ngexis4ngfunds
• Oversightbodiesplaycri4calroleineduca4nglegislatureandnaviga4ngcompe4ngGMEinterests
• Weheardloudcallforincreasedaccountability/transparency
• Cri4calneedforbe[erdataandmetricstomeasureworkforceoutcomesofresidencytraining
h[p://www.shepscenter.unc.edu/programs-projects/workforce/projects/carolina-health-workforce-research-center/
Page 50
Workforceplanningthefuture:Howdowegettherefromhere?
It’snotjustaboutretoolingtheworkforce.Weneedtoretoolthesystemthatsupportstheworkforce:educa4on,prac4ceandregula4onneedstobemoreresponsivetochangesinfront-linehealthcaredelivery
Page 51
WeneedtobecerconnecteducaKontopracKce
“RevoluIonarychangesinthenatureandformofhealthcaredeliveryarereverberaIngbackwardinto…
educaIonasleadersofthenewpracIceorganizaIonsdemandthattheeducaIonalmissionberesponsivetotheirneedsforpracIIonerswhocanworkwithteamsinmoreflexibleand
changingorganizaIons…”
• Buteduca4onsystemislaggingbecauseitremainslargelyinsulatedfromcaredeliveryreform
• Needcloserlinkagesbetweenhealthcaredeliveryandeduca4onsystems
Source:RickecsT,FraherE.ReconfiguringhealthworkforcepolicysothateducaKon,training,andactualdeliveryofcarearecloselyconnected.HealthAff(Millwood).2013Nov;32(11):1874-80.
Page 52
OnpracKceside:redesignhumanresourceinfrastructuretosupportnewroles
• Needtominimizeroleconfusionbyclearlydefiningandtrainingfornewfunc4ons
• Jobdescrip4onshavetoberewri[enorcreated
• Workflowshavetoberedesigned
• Lackofstandardizedtrainingandfundstosupporttrainingisbigobstacle
• Exis4ngstaffwon’tdelegateorsharerolesifdon’ttrustotherstaffmembersarecompetent
• Timespenttrainingisnotspentonbillableservices
Page 53
Howdoweredesignstructurestosupportnewroles?EducaKon
• Retrainandupgradeskillsofthe18millionhealthcareworkersalreadyinthesystem–theyaretheoneswhowilltransformcare
• Trainingmustbeconvenient–4ming,loca4on,andfinancialincen4vesmustbetakenintoconsidera4on
• Needtopreparefacultytoteachnewrolesandfunc4ons
• Clinicalrota4onsneedtoinclude“purposefulexposure”tohigh-performingteamsinambulatorysefngs
• Needtoredesigneduca4onsystemsoworkforcecanflexiblygainnewskillsandcompetenciesthroughoutcareer
Source:FraherE,SpetzJ,NaylorM.NursinginaTransformedHealthCareSystem:NewRoles,NewRules.LDI/INQRIResearchBrief.June2015;Laddenetal.TheEmergingPrimaryCareWorkforce.PreliminaryObserva4onsfromthePrimaryCareTeam:LearningfromEffec4veAmbulatoryPrac4cesProject”.AcademicMedicine;1013,88(12):1830-1835.
Page 54
Goal:flexibleworkforcethatcanadapttorapidlychanginghealthcaresystem
Bothnewentrantstotheworkforce
Andour“seasonedworkers”
Page 55
“The workforce innova4ons needed to implement ACA programs require an adaptable regulatory system capable of evolving with the health care environment. The health profession regula4on system in place today
does not have the flexibility to support change
Howdoweredesignstructurestosupportnewroles?RegulaKon
Tocreateamoredynamicregulatorysystem,weneedto:• developevidencetosupportregulatorychanges,especiallyfornewroles• evaluatenew/expandedrolestounderstandifinterven4onsimprovehealth,
lowercostsandenhancesa4sfac4on• removeregulatorybarrierstoletworkforceu4lizeskillstomaxbenefit
ofpa4ents
Source:DowerC,MooreJ,LangelierM.Itis4metorestructurehealthprofessionsscope-of-prac4ceregula4onstoremovebarrierstocare.HealthAff(Millwood).2013Nov;32(11);FraherE,SpetzJ,NaylorM.NursinginaTransformedHealthCareSystem:NewRoles,NewRules.LDI/INQRIResearchBrief.June2015.
Page 56
HealthWorkforcePlanningtheTradiKonalWay
Page 57
WeneedtobelikeWayneGretsky
….but how do we know where the
puck is going to be?
“Iskatetowherethepuckisgoingtobe,nottowhereithasbeen.”−WayneGretsky
Page 58
Contactinfo
ProgramonHealthWorkforceResearchandPolicyhcp://www.healthworkforce.unc.edu
[email protected]
(919)966-5012