Using Visualization to Extend Students’ Number Sense and Problem Solving Skills in Grades 4-6 Mathematics (Part 1) LouAnn Lovin, Ph.D. Mathematics Education James Madison University
Dec 17, 2015
Using Visualization to ExtendStudents’ Number Sense and
Problem Solving Skills in Grades 4-6 Mathematics (Part 1)
LouAnn Lovin, Ph.D. Mathematics Education
James Madison University
Number Sense
What is number sense?
Turn to a neighbor and share your thoughts.
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 2
Number Sense“…good intuition about numbers and their
relationships.” It develops gradually as a result of exploring numbers, visualizing them in a variety of contexts, and relating them in ways that are not limited by traditional algorithms” (Howden, 1989).
“Two hallmarks of number sense are flexible strategy use and the ability to look at a computation problem and play with the numbers to solve with an efficient strategy” (Cameron, Hersch, Fosnot, 2004, p. 5).
Flexibility in thinking about numbers and their relationships.
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 3
Developing number sense through
problem solving and visualization.
A picture is worth a thousand words….
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 4
Do you see what I see?
Cat or mouse?
A face or an Eskimo?
An old man’s face or two lovers kissing?Not everyone sees what you may
see.
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 5
What do you see?
Everyone does not necessarily hear/see/interpret experiences the way
you do.www.couriermail.com.au/lifestyle/left-brain-v-right-brain-test/story-e6frer4f-1111114604318 Lovin NESA Spring 2012 6
Manipulatives…Hands-On… Concrete…Visual
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 7
T: Is four-eighths greater than or less than four- fourths?J: (thinking to himself) Now that’s a silly question. Four-eighths has to be more because eight is more than four. (He looks at the student, L, next to him
who has drawn the following picture.) Yup. That’s what I was thinking.
Ball, D. L. (1992). Magical hopes: Manipulatives and the reform of mathematics education (Adobe PDF). American Educator, 16(2), 14-18, 46-47. Lovin NESA Spring 2012 8
But because he knows he was supposed to show his answer in terms of fraction bars, J lines up two fraction bars and is surprised by the result:
Ball, D. L. (1992). Magical hopes: Manipulatives and the reform of mathematics education (Adobe PDF).
American Educator, 16(2), 14-18, 46-47.
J: (He wonders) Four fourths is more?T: Four fourths means the whole thing is shaded in.J: (Thinks) This is what I have in front of me. But it doesn’t quite make sense, because the pieces of one bar are much bigger than the pieces of the other one. So, what’s wrong with L’s drawing?
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 9
T: Which is more – three thirds or five fifths?J: (Moves two fraction bars in front of him and sees that both have all the pieces shaded.)
J: (Thinks) Five fifths is more, though, because there are more pieces.
Ball, D. L. (1992). Magical hopes: Manipulatives and the reform of mathematics education (Adobe PDF). American
Educator, 16(2), 14-18, 46-47.
This student is struggling to figure out what he should pay attention to about the fraction models: is it the number of pieces that are shaded? The size of the pieces that are shaded? How much of the bar is shaded? The length of the bar itself? He’s not “seeing” what the teacher wants him to “see.”
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 10
Base Ten Pieces and Number
10 20 30 40
4 3 2 1
Adult’s perspective: 31
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 11
What quantity does this “show”?
Is it 4?
Could it be 2/3? (set model for fractions)
?
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 12
Manipulatives are Thinker Toys,
Communicators
Hands-on AND minds-on
The math is not “in” the manipulative.
The math is constructed in the learner’s head and imposed on the manipulative/model.
What do you see? What do your students see?
.
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 13
The Doubting Teacher
Do they “see” what I “see”?How do I know?
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 14
Visualization strategies to make significant ideas explicit
Color Coding
Visual Cuing
Highlighting (talking about, pointing out) significant ideas in students’ work.
48 + 36 70 +14 84
48 + 36 = ?
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 15
Perimeter
Area All Over⅓
Teaching Number Sense through Problem Solving and
Visualization
Contextual (Word) ProblemsEmphasis on modeling the quantities and their
relationships (quantitative analysis)Helps students to get past the words by visualizing and
illustrating word problems with simple diagrams.Emphasizes that mathematics can make senseDevelops students’ reasoning and understandingGreat formative assessment tool
16Lovin NESA Spring 2012
What are the purposes of word problems? Why do we have students work on word problems?
and Visualization
A Student’s Guide to Problem SolvingRule 1
If at all possible, avoid reading the problem. Reading the problem only consumes time and causes confusion.
Rule 2 Extract the numbers from the problem in the order they appear. Watch for numbers written as words.
Rule 3 If there are three or more numbers, add them.
Rule 4 If there are only 2 numbers about the same size, subtract them.
Rule 5 If there are only two numbers and one is much smaller than the other, divide them if it comes out even -- otherwise multiply.
Rule 6 If the problem seems to require a formula, choose one with enough letters to use all the numbers.
Rule 7 If rules 1-6 don't work, make one last desperate attempt. Take the numbers and perform about two pages of random operations. Circle several answers just in case one happens to be right. You might get some partial credit for trying hard.
17Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Randomly combining numbers without
trying to make sense of the problem.
Solving Word Problems:A Common “Approach” for Learners
18Lovin NESA Spring 2012
19Lovin NESA Spring 2012
20Lovin NESA Spring 2012
This strategy is useful as a rough guide but limited because key words don't help students understand the problem situation (i.e. what is happening in the problem).
Key words can also be misleading because the same word may mean different things in different situations. Wendy has 3 cards. Her friend gives her 8 more cards.
How many cards does Wendy have now?There are 7 boys and 21 girls in a class. How many
more girls than boys are there?
Key Words
21Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Real problems do not have key words!
22Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Teaching Number Sense through Problem Solving and
Visualization
Contextual (Word) Problems and Visualization Emphasis on modeling the quantities and their
relationships (quantitative analysis)Helps students to get past the words by visualizing and
illustrating word problems with simple diagrams.Emphasizes that mathematics can make senseDevelops students’ reasoning and understandingGreat formative assessment toolAVOIDs the sole reliance on key words.
23Lovin NESA Spring 2012
The Dog Problem A big dog weighs five times as much as a little
dog. The little dog weighs 2/3 as much as a medium-sized dog. The medium-sized dog weighs 9 pounds more than the little dog. How much does the big dog weigh?
A big dog weighs five times as much as a little dog. The little dog weighs 2/3 as much as a medium-sized dog. The medium-sized dog weighs 9 pounds more than the little dog. How much does the big dog weigh?
Let x = weight of medium dog.
Then weight of little dog = 2/3 x
And weight of big dog = 5(2/3 x)
x = 9 + 2/3 x (med = 9 + little)1/3 x = 9x = 27 pounds
2/3 x = 18 pounds (little dog)5(2/3 x) = 5(18) = 90 pounds (big dog)
A big dog weighs five times as much as a little dog. The little dog weighs 2/3 as much as a medium-sized dog. The medium-sized dog weighs 9 pounds more than the little dog. How much does the big dog weigh?
weight of medium dog
weight of little dog
weight of big dog
9
99
18 18 18 18 18
99
5 x 18 = 90 pounds
A big dog weighs five times as much as a little dog. The little dog weighs 2/3 as much as a medium-sized dog. The medium-sized dog weighs 9 pounds more than the little dog. How much does the big dog weigh?
x = weight of medium dog
2/3 x = weight of little dog
5(2/3 x) = weight of big dog
9
99
18 18 18 18 18
99
x
2/3 x
5 (2/3 x)
So….how do you solve this problem from here?
The Cookie ProblemKevin ate half a bunch of cookies. Sara ate one-third of what was left. Then Natalie ate one-fourth of what was left. Then Katie ate one cookie. Two cookies were left. How many cookies were there to begin with?
28Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Different visual depictions of problem
solutions for the Cookie Problem:
Kevin
Sara
Natalie Katie
KevinSaraNatalieKatie2
Sol 1
Sol 2
Sol 3
29Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Mapping one visual depiction of solution for
the Cookie Problem to algebraic solution:
Kevin
Sara
Natalie KatieSol 1
30Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Sol 4
1
⅓(½x)
¼(⅔(½x))
2½x
x
+ ⅓(½x) + ¼(⅔(½x)) + 1 + 2 = x ½x
Visual and Graphic Depictions of Problems
Research suggests…..
It is not whether teachers use visual/graphic depictions, it is how they are using them that makes a difference in students’ understanding.
Students using their own graphic depictions and receiving feedback/guidance from the teacher (during class and on mathematical write ups)
Graphic depictions of multiple problems and multiple solutions.
Discussions about why particular representations might be more beneficial to help think through a given problem or communicate ideas.
(Gersten & Clarke, NCTM Research Brief)
31Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Supporting StudentsDiscuss the differences between pictures and diagrams.
Ask students toExplain how the diagram represents various components
of the problem.Emphasize the the importance of precision in the diagram
(labeling, proportionality)Discuss their diagrams with one another to highlight the
similarities and differences in various diagrams that may represent the same problem.
Discuss which diagrams are most appropriate for particular kinds of problems.
32Lovin NESA Spring 2012
little medium big
Visual and Graphic Depictions of Problems
Meilin saved $184. She saved $63 more than Betty. How much did Betty save?
Singapore Math, Primary Mathematics 5A
$184Meilin
$63?
Betty
33Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Singapore Math
184 – 63 = ?
Visual and Graphic Depictions of Problems
There are 3 times as many boys as girls on the bus. If there are 24 more boys than girls, how many children are there altogether?
Singapore Math, Primary Mathematics 5A
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 34
girls
boys
24
121212
12
4 x 12 = 48 children
x = # of girls3x = x + 242x = 24x = 12
Contextual (Word) ProblemsUse to introduce procedures and concepts (e.g.,
multiplication, division).Makes learning more concrete by presenting abstract
ideas in a familiar context. Emphasizes that mathematics can make sense.Great formative assessment tool.
35Lovin NESA Spring 2012
MultiplicationA typical approach is to use arrays or the area model to represent multiplication.
Why?
36Lovin NESA Spring 2012
3
4 3×4=12
Use Real Contexts – Grocery Store (Multiplication)
37Lovin NESA Spring 2012
MultiplicationContext – Grocery Store
How many plums does the grocer have on display?
plums38Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Multiplication - Context – Grocery Store
apples lemons
tomatoes
Groups of 5 or less subtly suggest skip counting (subitizing).
39Lovin NESA Spring 2012
How many muffins does the baker have?
40Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Other questionsHow many muffins did the baker have when all
the trays were filled?
How many muffins has the baker sold?
What relationships can you see between the different trays?
41Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Video:Students Using Baker’s Tray (4:30)
What are the strategies and big ideas they are using and/or developing
How does the context and visual support the students’ mathematical work?
How does the teacher highlight students’ significant ideas?
Video 1.1.3 from Landscape of Learning Multiplication mini-lessons (grades 3-5)
42Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Students’ Work
43Lovin NESA Spring 2012
JackieEdward
Counted by ones Skip counted by twos
Wendy Students’ Work
44Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Sam
Amanda
Decomposed larger amounts and doubled: 8 + 8 = 16;16 + 16 + 4 = 36
Used relationships between the trays.Saw the right hand tray has 20, so the middle tray has 4 less or 16.
Skip counted by 4. Used relationships between the trays. Saw the middle and last tray were the same as the first.
Area/Array ModelProgression
45
Context (muffin tray, sheet of stamps, fruit tray)
Area model using grid paperOpen arra
y
Lovin NESA Spring 2012
4 x 39How could you solve this? (Can you find a couple of ways?)
Video (5:02) (1.1.2) Multiplication mini-lessons
46Lovin NESA Spring 2012
Number Sense“…good intuition about numbers and their
relationships.” It develops gradually as a result of exploring numbers, visualizing them in a variety of contexts, and relating them in ways that are not limited by traditional algorithms” (Howden, 1989).
“Two hallmarks of number sense are flexible strategy use and the ability to look at a computation problem and play with the numbers to solve with an efficient strategy” (Cameron, Hersch, Fosnot, 2004, p. 5).
Flexibility in thinking about numbers and their relationships.
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 47
Lovin NESA Spring 2012 48
Take a minute and write down two things you are thinking about from this morning’s session.
Share with a neighbor.