Top Banner
Un-publication: Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve) Colin Harrison, School of Education / Learning Sciences Research Institute, University of Nottingham
48

Un-publication: Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Apr 15, 2017

Download

Education

Colin Harrison
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Un-publication: Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)Colin Harrison, School of Education / Learning Sciences Research Institute, University of Nottingham

Page 2: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 3: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 4: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 5: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 6: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 7: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 8: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

Page 9: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 10: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 11: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!DEStech publishes

23 journals, so one is

bound to be in

education!

Page 12: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!DEStech publishes

23 journals, so one is

bound to be in

education!

Page 13: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!DEStech publishes

23 journals, so one is

bound to be in

education!

Page 14: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 15: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 16: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 17: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 18: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 19: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 20: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 21: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 22: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 23: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 24: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 25: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 26: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 27: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 28: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 29: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 30: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 31: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Are our students now finding (and citing as authoritative) otherwise unpublishable research from rogue ‘peer-reviewed’ journals?

Page 32: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 33: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 34: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 35: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Good news!

N=790 publishers

N=658 other stand-alone journals

Page 36: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Another opportunity!

scrip.org

Page 37: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Another opportunity!- especially for

Chinese authors….

Page 38: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 39: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 40: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

STOP PRESS!!

MORE good news!

Page 41: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 42: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 43: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

(plus another 17….)

Page 44: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 45: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 46: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)
Page 47: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Un-publication: the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)Colin Harrison, University of Nottingham/LSRI

Points to consider: -Are online ‘predatory publishers’ any more predatory than regular publishers?-Are ‘Scholarly’ Open-Access Publications (SOAPs) valuable?

- For the desperate- yes- And for crackpots- yes- For the naïve – potentially less reliable than Wikipedia- SOAPs do greatly extend the possibilities for publishing

online for academics in non-OECD nations-Take-home message: CAVEAT LECTOR

Page 48: Un-publication:  Fake journals and the dark side of open-access publication  (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)

Un-publication: the dark side of open-access publication (for the desperate, for crackpots and for the naïve)Colin Harrison, University of Nottingham/LSRI