Top Banner
Transiting Extrasolar Planets Recent Progress, XO Survey, and the Future Christopher J. Burke
44

Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Mar 29, 2018

Download

Documents

tranthien
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Transiting Extrasolar PlanetsRecent Progress, XO Survey, and the Future

Christopher J. Burke

Page 2: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Solar SystemHas Predominately

Circular Orbits

Top ViewSide View

Page 3: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Planet Formation

NASA/JPL-Caltech/R. Hurt (SSC)

Page 4: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

ExceptionsNon-circularEccentricity

PlutoSedna

Nasa/Caltech Courtesy of Windows to the Universe, http://www.windows.ucar.edu

Page 5: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

~200 Extrasolar Planets

Page 6: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

● >7% stars have Jupiter mass planets within 5 AU● 1.2% stars have Hot Jupiter planets● Most planets have a>1 AU

Fischer & Valenti 2005

Metallicity Correlation

Page 7: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

● Multi-planet systems common (>30%)Wright et al. (2006)

● Low mass planets more common than high mass planets.

●5.5 Earth mass planet Beaulieu et al. (2006)

NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle (SSC)

Page 8: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

How do you detect planets?Radial Velocity Technique

Only Measure Planet Mass

Doppler Shifted Light

©Think Quest

Page 9: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

flux

time

Transit TechniqueExtrasolar Planet Detection

Δf = (Rp/R*)2 ~1%

Measure Radius!!

Page 10: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Charbonneau et al. 2006, Brown et al. 2001

Page 11: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter
Page 12: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Core Dominated

Inflated Radius

70 Mearth coreSato et al. (2005) & Fortney et al. (2005)

Difficult to explain

Charbonneau et al. 2006

Page 13: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

● Highly accurate radii● Stellar limb darkening

What do we learn fromTransiting Planets?

Dan Bruton

Page 14: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

HD 209458bKnutson et al. (2006)

Page 15: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

● Highly accurate planet radii● Stellar limb darkening● Characterize planet atmosphere

Transmission spectroscopyNa, H, C, O detection HD 209458Charbonneau et al. (2002), Vidal-Madjar (2003, 2004)

What do we learn fromTransiting Planets?

Page 16: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Compare SpectraOut of Transit

In Transit Vidal-Madjar (2003)

Page 17: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Vidal-Madjar (2003)

Page 18: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

● Highly accurate planet radii● Stellar limb darkening● Characterize planet atmosphere

Phased light curve – optical

What do we learn fromTransiting Planets?

Page 19: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Albedo <0.25 Rowe et al. (2006)will soon reach ~0.1 limits

Hot Jupiter planets are dark!

Reflected Light

Page 20: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

● Highly accurate planet radii● Stellar limb darkening● Characterize planet atmosphere

Secondary Eclipse – IRTest planet atmosphere models

What do we learn fromTransiting Planets?

Page 21: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter
Page 22: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

NASA/JPL-Caltech/R. Hurt (SSC)

Page 23: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Constrain atmosphere metallicity, clouds, redistribution of heat, perhaps CO & H2O

Disentagling these effects may be difficult

Burrows et al. (2006)

Page 24: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Motivated to find bright transiting planets

XO Transit SurveyPI Peter McCullough

Jeff ValentiKen Janes, Boston U

Jim Heasley, U of HawaiiChris Johns-Krull, Rice U

Extended Team Professionals & “Amateurs”

Ron Bissinger, CAMike Fleenor, TNCindy Foote, UTEnrique Garcia, SpainBruce Gary, AZ

Paul Howell, MEFranco Malia, Italy Gianluca Masi, ItalyTonny Vanmunster, Belgium

Page 25: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Haleakala, Maui

Page 26: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Baker Nunn Observatory 1957Built to track satellitesin particular Sputnik

www.ifa.hawaii.edu/users/steiger/post_cook.htm

Page 27: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Today houses XO

Page 28: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Every 10 min7.2o x 63o strip

10 cm aperture

Page 29: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Why have so few transits been found?● Only 1.2% stars have Hot Jupiter planets● The probability for a Hot Jupiter to transit ~10%● Most stars are too big (sub-giant or giant)

In magnitude limited survey only 10% of stars are dwarfs Gould & Morgan (2003)

● There are many objects that mimica transit signal

Page 30: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter
Page 31: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Transit ImpostersTransit surveys yield 10/1 false positives

● Dwarf star eclipsing a subgiant/giant● Grazing eclipsing binary● Triple star / blend diluted deep eclipse● Brown dwarfs

Page 32: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Transit Imposters

Page 33: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

96 MJup

Brown dwarf same radiusas planet!

Radial Velocity Followup Required!

Page 34: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

How does XO deal with imposters

Stellar spectral type estimate Photometric catalogs - Tycho, 2MASS, TASS

Transit duration, depth, and periodconsistent with a planet orbiting the estimated stellar spectral type

Page 35: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Closer stars Higher Proper Motion

1955 1993 2000

NASA/IPAC Infrared Science Archive

DSS1 DSS2 2MASS

Discriminate dwarfs from giants

Page 36: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

XO's Extended Team

Page 37: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter
Page 38: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Blending

Page 39: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Triple Stars

Page 40: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

XO has timeon the Hobby-EberlyTelescopefor precisionRV

ConfirmedXO-1bas a bona fideplanet

Page 41: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Future of Extrasolar Planets

HARPS now achieves 20 cm/sRV stability over several days

ESO La Silla 3.6m

Pont priv. comm. (2006)

Page 42: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Space Based Transit SearchesCOROT – Launched Dec. 26

27cm primary2.5 year duration

150 day continuous

Page 43: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

KEPLER – Nov. 20081.4m primary4 year duration fully continuous42 CCDs to fill 1.2o diameter FOV 100,000 stars V<15.0

Space Based Transit Searches

Page 44: Transiting Extrasolar Planets - HubbleSitehubblesite.org/about_us/public_talks/presentations/burke_2007_02... · Motivated to find bright transiting planets XO Transit Survey PI Peter

Precision Transit Timing

Sensitive to moons, rings, stellar spotsCan detect Earth mass planets in resonance

XO Future

XO-2b, XO-3b, XO-4b,...Expansion to 3+ mounts in 2007