Top Banner
T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Cel ebration, Dec. 2009, Jeru salem 1 Tsevi Mazeh Dec 2009 School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University Tsvi Celebration
50

Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

Dec 30, 2015

Download

Documents

logan-espinoza

Transiting Extra-Solar Planets. Rossiter-Mclaughlin effect. super-earth planets. Tsvi Celebration. Tsevi Mazeh. School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University. Dec 2009. In the solar system:. Giant planets far away Circular orbits Planetary orbits aligned with the Solar spin. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

1

Tsevi Mazeh

Dec 2009

School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University

Tsvi Celebration

Page 2: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

2

•Giant planets far away

•Circular orbits

•Planetary orbits aligned with the Solar spin

In the solar system:

Page 3: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

3

Relative Inclination

Page 4: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

4

Core accretion paradigm

Page 5: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

5

Extra-solar planets:

Jupiter

Neptune

Earth

Page 6: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

6

Planets discovered by RV

Mass distribution

Page 7: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

7

Planets discovered by RVClose-in giant

planets•Giant planets far away

•Circular orbits

•Orbits aligned with Solar spin

Page 8: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

8

HD80606(Naef et al. 2001)e=0.93P=112 daysmsini=4MJup

•Giant planets far away

•Circular orbits

•Orbits aligned with Solar spin

Page 9: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

9

Transits

The inclination (i) must be very close to 90°P

R R

atransitp

Page 10: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

10

Page 11: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

11

Page 12: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

12

HD 209458Mazeh et al., 2000

daysP

MiSinM

orbit 524.3

68.0)(

JupPlanet

Page 13: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

13

HD 209458

Phase consistent with the radial velocities

Charbonneau, Brown, Latham & Mayor 2000

Henry, Marcy, Butler & Vogt 2000

Depth: ~1.5%

Duration: ~2.5 hours

Page 14: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

14

HD209458Brown, Charbonneau, Gilliland, Noyes & Burrows, 2001,

1.07.86

06.035.1

i

RR JupPlanet

3cm g 35.0

HST photometry

Page 15: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

15

A French CNES mission with European partners & Brazil

[+ S. Aigrain, T. Mazeh, A. Shporer] 27cm telescope with polar orbit Joint stellar seismology & exoplanets transits mission Launched on 12 / 27 / 2006

5 fields of 4 square degrees observed, including two for ~150 days at ~mid-term of the mission.

~30,000 dwarf stars observed between 11 < Vmag < 16 Photometric data is gathered in a « mask » of pixels

The CoRoT Satellite

Page 16: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

16

Aquila eye Monoceros eye

Page 17: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

17

First detected by alarm mode 153 transits,

all ~ seen when superimposed

Short period : P= 0.8536 days

>> transit depth : F/F = 0.035%=350 ppm compatible with Rpl = 1.8R

CoRoT-7b: first super –earth transiting planet

earthMM 5

d=150pc

Page 18: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

18

Charbonneau et al Dec. 17th, 2009

GJ1214b, 13pc

Page 19: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

19

Charbonneau et al Dec. 17th, 2009

GJ1214b, 13pc

Page 20: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

Snellen et al. Nature 459, 543-545 (2009)

Optical phase variation for CoRoT-1b centred on the planetary eclipse.Secondary eclipse and phase variation

~100 ppm

CoRoT-1b

Cold and dark side

Inefficient distribution of absorbed heat

Page 21: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

21

Afonso et al. 2009

~60 ppm

CoRoT-2b

Secondary eclipse

Page 22: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

22

Kepler

HAT-P-7:

Secondary eclipse and phase variation

Borucki et al. 2009

Page 23: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

23

Orbit of planet

Spin-orbit relative inclination

Stellar Spin-Planetary orbit relative inclination

Page 24: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

24

Orbit of planet

Transiting planets

Stellar Spin-Planetary orbit relative inclination

Page 25: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

25

Orbit of planet

Transiting planets

Stellar Spin-Planetary orbit relative inclination

Page 26: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

26

Orbit of planet

Spin-orbit relative inclination

Stellar Spin-Planetary orbit relative inclination

Page 27: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

27

Orbit of planet

Spin-orbit relative inclination

Stellar Spin-Planetary orbit relative inclination

Page 28: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

28

The Rossiter-McLaughlin effect

Gaudi & Winn 2007:

rotationplanet VR

rV *,

2

**

Page 29: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

29

Page 30: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

30

Ohta et al. 2005

The observer is at the y axis

The stellar rotational axis is at the y-z plane

Page 31: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

31

Ohta et al. 2005

Page 32: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

32

Fabrycky & Winn 2009

Submitted Dec. 2008

Page 33: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

33

CoRoT first planet

1.51

0.99 0.09

1.47 0.06

p Jup

p Jup

P d

M M

R R

Barge, Baglin, ….

Mazeh, …. Shporer …..

Page 34: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

34

CoRoT-1b

Page 35: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

35

Gillon et al. 2009

~30 ppm

Page 36: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

36

Page 37: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

37

CoRoT-1b The R-M effect

Page 38: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

38

Winn et al. 2009

HAT-P-7:

deg4.95.182

Page 39: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

39

Page 40: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

40

e=0

•Giant planets far away

•Circular orbits

•Orbits aligned with Solar spin

Page 41: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

41

Migration

Migration does NOT explain

Highly eccentric orbits

&

Spin-orbit MISalignment

Page 42: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

42

Migration does NOT explain

Highly eccentric orbits

&

Spin-orbit MISalignment

Planet-planet interactione.g., Juric & Tremaine 2008

Tidal circularization

Tidal alignment

Stars around the center of our galaxy

Oort cloud

Page 43: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

43

Page 44: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

44

Page 45: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

45

Mazeh, Zucker, Pont 2005:

See also Gaudi, Seager and Mallen-Ornelas 2005

Page 46: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

46

Page 47: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

47

1 PM

Page 48: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

48

2

2

* a

RL p

p

pp R

ME

2

1*

pE

TL

Evaporation:

Stellar radiation on the planet

Potential energy of the planet

Page 49: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

49

2

2

* a

RL p

p

pp R

ME

2

1*

pE

TL

TMa

R

p

p

122

3

pMTa

2

1

pMP 3/4

Page 50: Transiting Extra-Solar Planets

T. Mazeh: Tsvi Piran Celebration, Dec. 2009, Jerusalem

50

• Field: LRa01 anti-center direction - 135 days long

• The star: LRa01_E2_165– mV = 11.7

• The mask on CoRoT CCD:

• 3 colors

• Sampling: 32s

CoRoT-7 and the data taking