Page 1
Title slide
Volcanic eruptions: their impact on sea level and oceanic heat content
John A. Church1,2*, Neil J. White1,2 and Julie M. Arblaster3,4
1 CSIRO Marine Research, GPO Box 1538, Hobart Tasmania. 7001. Australia. 2 ACE CRC, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
3 National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, Colorado, USA4 Bureau of Meteorology Research Centre, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Mt Pinatubo eruption in the Philippines, June 15, 1991.
Gases and solids injected 20 km into the stratosphere.
Page 2
Reconstructed global average sea level for the period 1950 to 2000
Agung 1963
El Chichon 1982
Mt Pinatubo 1991
Page 3
Radiative forcing of climate
From Ramswamy et al., 2001, IPCC TAR
Page 4
Peaks of -5 W m-2 following major explosive volcanic eruptions
From Ramswamy et al., 2001, IPCC TAR
Page 5
Different stratospheric loading models
Page 6
PCM 20thC ensembles: 1890-1999
V volcanicS solarG ghgSu sulfatesOz ozoneSOz solar+ozoneVS volcanic+solarVSOz volcanic+solar+ozoneGS ghg+sulfatesGOz ghg+ozoneGSuOz ghg+sulfates+ozoneSGSuOz solar+ghg+sulfates+ozoneVSGSuOz volcanic+solar+ghg+sulfates+ozone (ALL)
4 members each with the following forcings:
DOE/NCAR Parallel Climate ModelAtmosphere CCM3 T42 18L ~ 2.8 degree
Land LSM
Ocean POP 32L ~2/3 degree
Sea-ice Dynamic and thermodynamic
Page 7
Observed concentrations and loadings used to force the model
Page 8
Simulated GMSL with/without volcanic forcing 1890-2000
Page 9
Differences in GMSL between simulations with/without volcanic
forcing1890-2000
Page 10
Volcanic forcing results in a rapid fall in GMSL of ~5 mm
Page 11
Differences in global ocean heat content between simulations with/without
volcanic forcing1890-2000
Page 12
Volcanic forcing results in a fall in global average heat content of ~3 x 1022 J
Page 13
Much of the heat content changes in the upper 200 m but some deeper signals
Page 14
Can we detect the signal in observations?
• In models can– Isolate forcing– Use ensembles to average variability
• Observations – many signals – natural variability– Inadequate observations
• Implies may be difficult to detect signal
Page 15
Differences in global ocean heat content between simulations
with/without volcanic forcing1960-2000
Page 16
Modelled and observed ocean heat content changes are correlated but the observed
signal is larger.
Page 17
Differences in GMSL between simulations with/without volcanic
forcing 1960-2000
Page 18
Modelled and observed GMSL changes are correlated but the observed signal is larger.
Page 19
What are the mechanisms involved?
• Examine Pinatubo response in the model– Best agreement with observations– Best observations
• Look at global ocean heat budgets
• Ensemble averages
Page 20
Surface ocean heat fluxes for the Pinatubo eruption (1991)
Page 21
Surface ocean heat fluxes for the Pinatubo eruption (1991)
Page 22
Surface ocean heat fluxes for the Pinatubo eruption (1991)
Page 23
Differences in GMSL between simulations with/without volcanic forcing for the Pinatubo eruption
Page 24
Differences in GMSL between simulations with/without volcanic forcing and Levitus’ steric heights for the Pinatubo eruption
Page 25
Differences in global ocean heat content between simulations with/without volcanic
forcing for the Pinatubo eruption
Page 26
Differences in global ocean heat content between simulations with/without volcanic forcing and Levitus’ heat content for the
Pinatubo eruption
Page 27
Conclusions• Large heat content variations
– order 3 x 1022 J in models, same order but smaller than previous controversial estimates of ocean heat content variability
• Sea level falls of order 5 mm (potentially larger) following volcanic eruptions
• Evaporation changes – same order as interannual variations in global land precipitation
• Small deceleration of heat-content increase and sea-level rise
• Post Pinatubo recovery in sea level occurs during modern satellite record
• Longer term impacts (deeper signals)• T/S signals in ocean and their impact
Page 28
Title slide
Mt Pinatubo eruption in the Philippines, June 15, 1991.
Gases and solids injected 20 km into the stratosphere.
Page 29
Reconstructed global average sea level for the period 1950 to 2000