The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

1/81

Z`i Vbr Nitwiih Trleiss bhj MustoeiZ`i Eovoa Vbr, [olaiht @ircihiutoes, Lpplsohf T`ihlcihlalfois, bhj t`i Bcihjciht Tbrbjlx

L.F. ^lsi

Muhi >;t` >429 cbrgs t`i ixtihjohf lk AFNZ cbrrobfi hbtolhwoji t`rluf` t`i abhjcbrgLnirfikiaa v. @ljfis Jieosolh. Basl oh t`i hiws `bs niih b cbmlr elhtrlvirsy lvir t`i

Elhkijirbti Kabf bhj t`i quistolh lk w`it`ir lr hlt t`i kabf os oh`irihtay rbeost bhj ok ot s`luaj ni nbhij ―  b jinbti troffij ny t`i trbfoe s`lltohf lk hohi nabeg Bciroebhs oh E`braistlh, UE nyb w`oti supricbeost bhj tirrlrost. Cue` lk t`i Elhkijirbti Kabf jinbti `bs eihtirij lh t`iquistolh lk ‐w`bt wbs t`i Eovoa Vbr ribaay bnlut

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

2/81

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

3/81

ribslh). Zl t`i Yholh, ‐t`i Yhotij Utbtis os‟, w`oai tl t`i Elhkijirbey, ‐t`i Yhotij Utbtis bri‟, okylu woaa.

Niebusi lk t`isi jokkiriht cberl-voiws, Aohelah sbw `ocsiak bs ihklreohf t`i Abw bhjup`lajohf t`i Elhstotutolh, w`oai Ulut`irhirs sbw Aohelah bs volabtohf t`i Elhstotutolh bhjocpijohf Utbti slviriofhty. Aohelah elhsojirij t`i Elhkijirbti Utbtis fuoaty lk tribslh, w`oai

Ulut`irhirs elhsojirij Aohelah fuoaty lk tyrbhhy. Aohelah elhsojirij sieissolh ocplssonai niebusi t`i Yholh wbs ‐ohjovosonai‟, w`oai Ulut`irhirs niaoivij t`i plwir tl sieiji wbshieissbry klr t`i Utbtis tl `laj tl e`ieg bhj nbabhei t`i plwir lk t`i Eihtrba Flvirhciht.> Aohelah splgi bnlut jikohohf t`i ohjovosonai Yholh, w`oai Ulut`irhirs jojh‟t niaoivi t`i Yholhixostij oh bhj lk otsiak= ot lhay ixostij ohslcue` bs Utbtis bfriij tl pbrtoeopbti oh ot, bhj `bj hlclri plwir lr slviriofhty t`bh Utbtis frbhtij tl ot vob pbrtoeopbtolh. Ivirylhi bfriij t`btuatocbtiay, baa slviriofhty ebci krlc t`i pilpai, nut t`iri wbs josbfriiciht lh w`l ‐t`i pilpai‟ wiri. V`oai Aohelah niaoivij ‐t`i pilpai‟ wiri t`i tltba suc lk t`i Bciroebh plpuabtolh bs icnljoij oh t`i Yholh lk Bciroeb, t`i Utbtis niaoivij ‐t`i pilpai‟ rikirrij tlibe` ohjovojuba, bhj sl ohjovojubas eluaj nribg krlc ‐t`i Yholh‟ lk ‐t`i pilpai‟ bhj ritbohslviriofhty.

V`l‟s rof`t

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

4/81

t`iy kof`tohf lvir sabviry balhi< Z`bt siics uhaogiay tl ci, t`luf` O jlh‟t ghlw= ot siics clriaogiay t`bt clst Ulut`irhirs wiri kof`tohf lvir t`i rof`ts lk Utbtis tl `bvi sabvis bhj tl sieijilvir sabviry, w`oe` os saof`tay jokkiriht krlc sbyohf Ulut`irhirs wiri kof`tohf jorietay lvirsabviry (t`luf` t`bt osh‟t tl sby t`bt sabviry wbsh‟t ‐t`i korst clvir‟ lk t`i Eovoa Vbr, ok yluwoaa). O ebh t`ohg lk t`rii plssonai bhj fihirba ribslhs t`bt cltovbtij Ulut`irhirs=

2.  Jikihj sabviry.>.  Jikihj t`i rof`ts lk Utbtis tl `bvi sabviry (sl t`bt t`iy eluaj lhi jby `bvi sabvis,

 prisirvi t`ior ielhlcois, lh proheopai, ite.).5.  Jikihj t`i rof`ts lk Utbtis.

@iri bri ribslhs O t`ohg Yholhosts wluaj ni kof`tohf=

2.  Ihj sabviry.>.  Jikihj t`i rof`t lk t`i Kijirba Flvirhciht tl lvirroji Utbtis t`bt pirpitubti ohmustoeis,

ivih ok t`lsi ohmustoeis kbaa wot`oh t`i rof`ts lk Utbtis.

5. 

Zl prisirvi t`i Yholh.

O jlunt t`bt iviry Ulut`irh wbs cltovbtij ny t`i sbci ribslh, bs O jlunt iviry Yholhostwbs uhoklrcay cltovbtij. Z`i plssonai ribslhs bri vbroij, bhj sl b quistolh aogi ‐w`bt wbs t`iEovoa Vbr bnlut

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

5/81

 prisirvi sabviry7 ok t`iy kluf`t niebusi t`i Hlrt` wbs ohvbjohf t`ic, t`iy kluf`t bfbohst b klreit`bt wluaj ihj sabviry7 ok Ulut`irhirs kluf`t tl prisirvi t`i rof`t lk Utbti sieissolh, t`iy kluf`ttl eut sabvis lkk krlc icbheopbtolh7 bhj sl lh. Nut jl hlti t`iri os b jokkirihei nitwiih sbyohf‐t`i Elhkijirbey kluf`t tl prisirvi t`i rof`ts lk Utbti‟s tl `bvi sabviry‟ bhj sbyohf ‐t`iElhkijirbey kluf`t tl prisirvi sabviry‟. Z`isi p`rbsis bri clstay ojihtoeba oh elhsiquihei, nut

t`i korst cibhs slcit`ohf jokkiriht. Z`i sielhj cibhs t`bt Ulut`irhirs wbhtij sabviry, w`oait`i korst cibhs Ulut`irhirs wbhtij tl jieoji ok t`iy wbhtij lr jojh‟t wbht sabviry. Z`i sielhj pbohts Ulut`irhirs bs hieissbroay oh supplrt lk sabviry, w`oai t`i korst cibhs Ulut`irhirs lhaycby `bvi supplrtij sabviry7 t`i sielhj ocpaois t`i Ulut` wluaj bawbys `bvi sabvis, w`oai t`ikorst ocpaois lhay t`bt t`i Ulut` cby bawbys `bvi sabvis. _is, t`i sielhj p`rbsi ebh ni usij bs`lrt`bhj klr t`i korst, nut t`i s`lrt`bhj virsolhs lk p`rbsis `bvi b tihjihey tl ebusi elhkusolhbhj tl pboht ohbeeurbti poeturis. O t`ohg t`bt `bs `bppihij oh rifbrj tl t`i Eovoa Vbr.

Bs b ealsohf t`luf`t, t`iri os b pbrt lk ci t`bt wos`is wi stlppij bsgohf t`i quistolh lk‐w`bt wbs t`i Eovoa Vbr bnlut

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

6/81

 nrlgi lkk krlc t`i Yholh, ot jojh‟t jl sl t`ohgohf lk otsiak bs ‐prisirvohf ivoa‟, bs wi oh lurcljirh bfi tihj tl t`ohg lk t`i Elhkijirbey bs jlohf (klr wi bawbys wi ribj `ostlry oh aof`t lklur ‐clrba selpi‟, bs wrottih bnlut oh ‑Ihjohf ^beosc– ny L.F. ^lsi).Z`os osh‟t tl sby t`iElhkijirbey wbsh‟t fuoaty lk frbvi btrleotois ―  suriay t`i Hbzos jojh‟t t`ohg lk t`icsiavis bs‐ivoa‟ bs t`iy pirpitubtij t`i @lalebust ―  nut ot os tl sby t`bt `lw Elhkijirbtis ixpiroiheij t`ior

occlrba betolhs os viry jokkiriht t`bh `lw wi ixpiroihei ribjohf bhj/lr t`ohgohf bnlut t`iorocclrba betolhs. Zl ixpaboh w`bt O cibh bhj tl bpprlbe` cy cboh ploht lk t`os wlrg, elhsojir b`yplt`itoeba=

‐Z`i Uielhj Eovoa Vbr‟. Ocbfohi t`bt tlclrrlw bnlrtolh wbs cbji oaaifba uhjir t`i 2: t` Bcihjciht niebusi ot

joserocohbtij bfbohst t`i uhnlrh ny elhsojirohf t`ic ‐hlt `ucbh‟ jispoti `bvohf `ucbh JHB.Ocbfohi t`bt, bs b risuat, Hlrt`irh Utbtis elhsojirij sieijohf oh lrjir tl prisirvi t`iriprljuetovi rof`ts lk wlcih ―  eotohf t`i 24t` Bcihjciht bhj t`i slviriofhty lk t`i Utbtis bs mustokoebtolh klr sieissolh ―  bhj ocbfohi t`bt Ulut`irhirs wbrhij t`bt t`iy wluaj ohvbjisieijohf, Hlrt`irh Utbtis tl ihj joserocohbtolh bhj tl sbvi ‐t`i Yholh‟.5 Hlw ocbfohi t`bt, tlstbrt, jispoti t`i Ulut`‟s t`ribts, t`rii Hlrt`irhir Utbtis sieijij, bhj t`bt wbrhohfs krlc t`i

Ulut` ohtihsokoij. Zwl clri Utbtis t`ih sieiji tl mloh t`i lt`ir t`rii, niaoivohf t`i Ulut` `bjhl rof`t tl nuaay lt`ir Utbtis. Ocbfohi t`ih t`bt t`i Ulut` ohvbjij lhi lk t`i Utbtis tl klrei ot nbeg ohtl ‐t`i Yholh‟, bhj ocbfohi t`bt t`os cltovbtij cbhy clri Hlrt`irhirs tl soji wot` ‐Z`i Hiw Elhkijirbey‟. Kof`tohf t`ih nrlgi lut, bhj pir`bps cbhy Hlrt`irhirs w`l wiri bfbohstbnlrtolh wluaj ihj up kof`tohf lh t`i soji lk t`lsi w`l kbvlrij bnlrtolh, klr t`lsi Hlrt`irhirskiat prissurij ny Ulut`irh bjvbheiciht. Z`isi prissurij Hlrt`irhirs basl niaoivij t`bt t`iywiri kof`tohf klr t`i rof`t lk pilpai tl `bvi b voiw lh bnlrtolh, rifbrjaiss `lw must lr uhmust otcof`t ni. Cbhy Hlrt`irhirs w`l mlohij t`i kof`tohf jojh‟t betubaay fit b, lr niaoivi oh, bnlrtolh, nut kluf`t bhylhi tl jikihj t`i rof`ts bhj slviriofhty lk wlcih.

Ocbfohi t`bt t`i Ulut`irhir stbtis eabocij t`bt t`i lhay ribslh Hlrt`irhirs sieijij wbs niebusi Hlrt`irhirs wiri noflts bhj wbhtij tl giip joserocohbtohf bhj curjirohf e`oajrih.Vluaj Ulut`irhirs ni rof`t bnlut Hlrt`irhirs< Oh t`ior iyis, yis, bhj ok t`i Ulut`irhirs wlh b‐Uielhj Eovoa Vbr‟ tl giip Hlrt`irhirs oh ‐t`i Yholh‟, `ostlry wluaj prlnbnay soji wot` t`iUlut`irhirs. Nut os t`bt `lw Hlrt`irhirs wluaj `bvi ixpiroiheij bhj elheiptubaozij t`iorbetolhs< Hlt bt baa= t`iy wluaj `bvi siih t`icsiavis bs prltietohf wlcih, pir`bps bsElhkijirbtis sbw t`icsiavis bs jikihjohf Utbtis. Vluaj t`isi Hlrt`irhirs ni bs wrlhf bnlutbnlrtolh bs Elhkijirbtis wiri bnlut sabviry< Tir`bps ―  t`bt wluaj jipihj lh ok bnlrtolh ribaayos curjir ―  nut t`i ploht os t`bt oh t`i iyis lk Ulut`irhirs, t`iy wluaj ni iquovbaiht. Nut t`luf`Ulut`irhirs wluaj hieissbroay `bvi tl uhjirstbhj t`i betolhs lk t`i Hlrt` ―  w`l usij ‐Utbti‟srof`ts‟ bs b mustokoebtolh klr t`ior betolhs ―  bs ‐occlrba‟ bhj ‐jiclhoe‟, Hlrt`irhirs wluajhieissbroay `bvi tl uhjirstbhj t`ior betolhs bs ‐hlnai‟ bhj ‐must‟. V`l wluaj ni rof`t< (V`ih otelcis tl t`i riba Eovoa Vbr, t`os os t`i quistolh O t`ohg wi `bvi kleusij kbr tll cue` lh= ot `bsrisuatij oh us kboaohf tl elhsojir `lw t`i pilpai ixpiroiheij bhj elheiptubaozij t`i Eovoa Vbr.Cy `lpi os ny rielhsojirohf t`i ayhe`poh ossui lk t`i Eovoa Vbr bs ‐bnlrtolh‟ ohstibj lk‐sabviry‟, wi cby nifoh tl icp`bsozi oh b cbhhir ny w`oe` wi ebh betubaay aibrh k rlc t`i`lrronai wbr.)

 Hlw ocbfohi t`bt b `uhjrij yibrs krlc hlw, stujihts lk `ostlry jinbti t`i ebusi ni`ohj‐Z`i Uielhj Eovoa Vbr‟, pir`bps bt b uhovirsoty t`bt‟s kluhjir lhei s`bcikuaay supplrtijbnlrtolh. @bak brfui ot wbs niebusi lk Utbti‟s rof`ts7 t`i rist, bnlrtolh= joserocohbtolh bhj e`oajsabuf`tir. Z`lsi ‐Alst Ebusirs‟ w`l eabocij ot wbs niebusi lk Utbti‟s rof`ts brfuij t`bt t`lsi

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

7/81

w`l kbvlrij bnlrtolh jojh‟t t`ohg lk ot bs b clrba ohmustoei (t`luf` ot wbs beelrjohf tl t`i wby`ostlry wiht), bhj stujihts w`l eabocij ‐Z`i Uielhj Eovoa Vbr‟ wbs niebusi lk bnlrtolht`luf`t t`lsi w`l eabocij lt`irwosi wiri jihyohf t`i uhmust `ostlry bfbohst t`i uhnlrh, bhjt`bt t`os wbs ivoa bhj lkkihsovi. V`l wluaj ni rof`t< Nlt`/hiot`ir. Z`lsi w`l eabocij Hlrt`irhirs sieijij oh lrjir tl prisirvi ‐wlcih‟s rof`ts‟ wluaj ni bgoh tl t`lsi w`l eabocij

Ulut`irhir‟s sieijij oh lrjir tl prisirvi ‐prlpirty rof`ts‟ bhj/lr ‐Utbti‟s rof`ts‟. Vluaj t`os nib kbor elcpbroslh< _is bhj hl. Ok t`lsi w`l wiri lkkihjij ny t`i Hlrt` jicbhjij baa kabfs bhjstbtuis t`bt t`i Hlrt` usij jurohf ‐Z`i Uielhj Eovoa Vbr‟ ni nbhhij krlc punaoe spbeis, balhfwot` baa ciclrobas `lhlrohf t`lsi w`l supplrtij bnlrtolh, wluaj t`iy ni aogi t`lsi tljby w`ljicbhj t`i nbhhohf lk t`i Elhkijirbti kabf< _is/hl.

Ikklrts tl uhjirstbhj `ostlry rbriay uhjirstbhj `ostlry.(Jl hlti t`bt O ribaozi t`os os b elhtrlvirsoba ixbcpai bhj t`bt ot woaa upsit cbhy, nut

ribaozi t`bt O eluajh‟t `bvi cbji t`i ploht O bc tryohf tl cbg i wot`lut usohf sue` bh ixbcpai= ot`bj tl ni bh ossui oh w`oe` slci brfuij pbssolhbtiay klr, lt`irs bfbohst, bhj w`oe` clst kiatuhsuri bnlut, nut t`bt ivirylhi kiat slcit`ohf bnlut, bhj bnlrtolh siicij aogi b pirkiet cbte`.Bnlrtolh os elhtrlvirsoba bhj t`i stbgis bri `of`, bs wbs t`i ebsi wot` sabviry. Ohjiij, O bc Bhto-

Bnlrtolh, niebusi O uhklrtuhbtiay sii hl wby tl eluhtir t`i brfuciht t`bt bnlrtolh osjoserocohbtolh, bhj uhklrtuhbtiay t`bt os prlnbnay w`bt clst bssucij krlc ribjohf cy`yplt`itoeba niklri O jorietay sboj t`os, siiohf bs wi ixost oh bh bfi w`ih ‐bssucptovi`ircihiutoes‟ bhj ‐eyhoeba `ircihiutoes‟ bri elcclh (bs woaa ni joseussij). Nut cy voiw lhbnlrtolh jlish‟t e`bhfi lr ohkauihei t`i vbaojoty lk t`i `yplt`itoeba lr ploht O bc cbgohf, bs otwluajh‟t ni t`i ebsi t`bt ok O wbs ivoa, ot wluaj ni kbasi w`ih O sboj ‐> + > 3 :‟. Ok cy`yplt`itoeba os ohvbaoj, ot osh‟t ohvbaoj niebusi O bc Bhto-Bnlrtolh, nut niebusi cy alfoe osohbeeurbti, w`oe` wluaj ni b kbor brfuciht klr slcilhi tl cbgi. Taibsi basl giip oh cohj t`bt`bj O niih wrotohf t`os pbpir yibrs niklri t`i Eovoa Vbr bhj cbji ‐sabviry‟ t`i ossui O usij klrcy `yplt`itoeba, t`i ixbcpai wluaj basl `bvi niih elhtrlvirsoba bhj lkkihsovi. Abstay, giip ohcohj t`bt ok > + > 3 : wbs lkkihsovi bhj elhtrlvirsoba, ot wluaj stoaa ni trui.)

Bs O `lpi os eaibr, t`i joe`ltlcy lk ‐Utbti‟s rof`ts virsus bnlrtolh‟ wluaj ni tllsocpaostoe ―  t`i twl naur tlfit`ir ohjovosonay ―  bhj sue` os t`i ebsi w`ih ot elcis tl t`i EovoaVbr. Aogiwosi, O basl `lpi t`os `yplt`itoeba cbgis eaibr t`bt t`i wby pilpai kiat bnlut clrbaohmustoeis aogi sabviry oh t`i pbst bri jokkiriht krlc `lw wi bri kiia  bnlut t`ic tljby lhei`ostlry `bs elhkorcij t`lsi clrba ohmustoeis bri oh kbet clrba ohmustoeis. Zljby, wi baa aovi oh t`icojst lk bnlrtolh, bhj fl bnlut lur jboay aovis. Vi cby josbfrii wot` ot, wi cby ivih t`ohg ot oscurjir, nut jl wi rifuabray nlcn bnlrtolh eaohoes lr ivih t`ohg bnlut ot< Trlnbnay hlt ―  wiclstay must aovi lur aovis. Klr w`bt iasi ebh wi jl< Beelrjohf tl t`i Kijirba Flvirhciht, otosh‟t oaaifba lr bh ohmustoei, sl lh w`bt frluhjs lt`ir t`bh sunmietovoty eluaj wi stlp ot< Bhj ok  wi troij, wi wluaj ni brristij, bhj lur ikklrts wluaj jl aottai. Bhj sl wi aovi, bhj b `uhjrijyibrs krlc hlw, pir`bps wi woaa ni t`luf`t lk bs ‐pbrtoeopbtohf oh b frbvi clrba ohmustoei‟, aogiUlut`irhirs oh t`i toci lk sabviry. Bhj pir`bps wi bri, nut t`bt osh‟t `lw wi ixpiroihei lr t`ohgbnlut t`i aovis wi bri aovohf. Bs b scbaa pireihtbfi lk Ulut`irhirs `bj sabvis, b scbaa pireihtbfi lk pilpai fit bnlrtolhs= t`luf` plaotoeobhs tbag bnlut ot elhstbhtay bhj t`luf`eluhtaiss spiie`is eluaj ni kluhj oh w`oe` plaotoeobhs prbosi ‐wlcih‟s rof`ts‟ bhj ‐jikihjbnlrtolh‟ (pbpirs `ostlrobhs eluaj abtir kohj tl prlvi t`bt ‐Z`i Uielhj Eovoa Vbr‟ bs bnlutbnlrtolh), clst lk us must aovi lur aovis hlt t`ohgohf bnlut ot uhaiss bsgij. Vi wlrg7 wisleobaozi7 wi fl bnlut lur jbys. Vi `bvi tl ―  wi `bvi aovis tl aovi bhj kbcoaois tl prlvoji klr ―  w`bt iasi ebh wi jl< Bs alhf bs ot os supplrtij ny t`i Uuprici Elurt, wi ebh pitotolh, wi ebh

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

8/81

`lst cbre`is, wi ebh put tlfit`ir plaotoeba frlups ―  bs cbhy joj bfbohst sabviry ―  nut ebh wistlp ot< Lhay ohslcue` bs lur betolhs stocuabti flvirhciht betolh, nut uatocbtiay, t`i kohbajieosolh os lut lk lur elhtrla. Z`i ebsi wbs hl jokkiriht nbeg niklri bhj jurohf t`i Eovoa Vbr, slait us ni salw niklri wi mujfi Elhkijirbtis. Tir`bps t`iy betij wrlhfay, nut ok t`iri ivir wbs b‐Uielhj Eovoa Vbr‟, t`iy woaa `bvi betij hl jokkiriht t`bh wi bet bt t`os viry clciht.

Yh-clhstrlus clhstirs.Jiclhoe sbohts.Jl wi Bciroebhs ixpiroihei t`i ossui lk bnlrtolh wot` t`i icltolhba kiiaohf t`bt wi

ixpiroihei w`ih wi elhsojir sabviry< Hl ―  niebusi wi aovi wot` bnlrtolh ―  bhj ivih t`lsi w`lbri bfbohst bnlrtolh jlh‟t tihj tl ribaay kiia t`ior josjboh klr ot= ot‟s clri cihtba t`bh icltolhba(t`luf` t`bt osh‟t tl sby hl lhi kiias lvir bnlrtolh). V`ih elhsojirohf t`i Eovoa Vbr bhjElhkijirbey, wi cust ribaozi t`os uhelcklrtbnai trut` bnlut lursiavis. Ok wi jlh‟t, wi‟aa aibrhkrlc `ostlry hlt `lw tl e`bhfi ot, nut tl wbte` `iapaissay bs ot ripibts oh wbys wi jlh‟t ixpiet  lr kiia .

O[

Zl icpbt`itoebaay uhjirstbhj t`i Eovoa Vbr, oh baa Eovoa Vbr jleucihts, spiie`is,aittirs, ite. krlc bhj bnlut ot, ripabei t`i wlrj ‐sabviry‟ wot` ‐bnlrtolh‟, prieosiay niebusi t`iviry suffistolh lk t`os wluaj ohkurobti slci, hlt lt`irs, bhj aibvi clst wot` b kiiaohf lkuheirtbohty. Krlc ‑Z`i Jieabrbtolh lk Ebusis lk Uieijohf Utbtis–, tbgi klr ixbcpai t`isi aohiskrlc Filrfob‟s jieabrbtolh lk sieissolh, bs ebh ni kluhj lh Eovoa Vbr.lrf= 

‐Z`i pilpai lk Filrfob `bvohf josslavij t`ior plaotoeba elhhietolh wot` t`i Flvirhciht lk t`i Yhotij Utbtis lk Bciroeb, prisi httl t`ior elhkijirbtis bhj t`i wlraj t`i ebusis w`oe` `bvi aij tl t`i sipbrbtolh. Klr t`i abst tih yibrs wi `bvi `bj hucirlus bhjsirolus ebusis lk elcpaboht bfbohst lur hlh-Wbnlrtolh- pirklrcohfS elhkijirbti Utbtis wot` rikirihei tl t`i sunmiet lk Wwlcih‟srof`tsS. Z`iy `bvi ihjibvlrij tl wibgih lur sieuroty, tl josturn lur jlcistoe pibei bhj trbhquoaoty, bhj pirsostihtay rikusij tlelcpay wot` t`ior ixpriss elhstotutolhba lnaofbtolhs tl us oh rikirihei tl t`bt prlpirty, bhj ny t`i usi lk t`ior plwir oh t`iKijirba Flvirhciht `bvi strovih tl jiprovi us lk bh iquba ihmlyciht lk t`i elcclh Zirrotlrois lk t`i ^ipunaoe. Z`os `lstoai

 plaoey lk lur elhkijirbtis `bs niih pursuij wot` iviry eoreucstbhei lk bffrbvbtolh w`oe` eluaj brlusi t`i pbssolhs bhj ixeotit`i `btrij lk lur pilpai, bhj `bs pabeij t`i twl sietolhs lk t`i Yholh klr cbhy yibrs pbst oh t`i elhjotolh lk vortuba eovoa wbr.Lur pilpai, stoaa bttbe`ij tl t`i Yholh krlc `bnot bhj hbtolhba trbjotolhs, bhj bvirsi tl e`bhfi, `lpij t`bt toci, ribslh, bhjbrfuciht wluaj nrohf, ok hlt rijriss, bt aibst ixicptolh krlc kurt`ir ohsuats, ohmurois, bhj jbhfirs. ^ieiht ivihts `bvi kuaayjossopbtij baa sue` `lpis bhj jiclhstrbtij t`i hieissoty lk sipbrbtolh.‟ 

‐W…S B nroik `ostlry lk t`i rosi, prlfriss, bhj plaoey lk bhto-WbnlrtolhostsS bhj t`i plaotoeba lrfbhozbtolh ohtl w`lsi `bhjs t`ibjcohostrbtolh lk t`i Kijirba Flvirhciht `bs niih elccottij woaa kuaay mustoky t`i prlhluheij virjoet lk t`i pilpai lk Filrfob.Z`i pbrty lk Aohelah, ebaaij t`i ^ipunaoebh pbrty, uhjir ots prisiht hbci bhj lrfbhozbtolh, os lk rieiht lrofoh. Ot os bjcottij tl nibh bhto-WbnlrtolhS pbrty. V`oai ot bttrbets tl otsiak ny ots eriij t`i sebttirij bjvlebtis lk ixpaljij plaotoeba `irisois, lkelhjichij t`ilrois oh plaotoeba ielhlcy, t`i bjvlebtis lk elccireoba ristroetolhs, lk prltietolh, lk spieoba provoaifis, lk wbstibhj elrruptolh oh t`i bjcohostrbtolh lk Flvirhciht, bhto-WbnlrtolhS os ots cossolh bhj ots purplsi. Ny bhto-WbnlrtolhS ot os cbji b

 plwir oh t`i stbti. Z`i quistolh lk WbnlrtolhS wbs t`i fribt jokkoeuaty oh t`i wby lk t`i klrcbtolh lk t`i Elhstotutolh.‟ 

Ny ripabeohf t`i wlrj ‐sabviry‟ wot` ‐bnlrtolh‟ oh t`i jieabrbtolh, t`i wby wi bri

icltolhbaay strueg ny t`i jleuciht os jokkiriht, bhj t`os icltolh os pir`bps ealsir tl w`bt t`lsijurohf t`i toci lk t`i Eovoa Vbr betubaay kiat. Bhj ot os oh t`i clji lk t`os icltolh t`bt wi hiijtl uhjirstbhj t`i Eovoa Vbr.

Zl lkkir bhlt`ir ixbcpai= elhsojir Mikkirslh Jbvos, t`i Trisojiht lk t`i Elhkijirbey. Okwi ripabei ‐sabviry‟ wot` ‐bnlrtolh‟ bs t`i ossui w`oe` Jbvos niaoivij oh, wi ebh `iap riclvit`i icltolhba nbrroir t`bt cby giip us krlc uhjirstbhjohf `oc, bhj t`i aiss wi uhjirstbhjJbvos, t`i aiss iquoppij wi bri tl bvloj ripibtohf `os costbgis. Jl hlti `iri t`bt elcpbroslhosh‟t iqubaozbtolh= tl elcpbri bnlrtolh bhj sabviry osh‟t tl sby t`iy bri clrbaay iquovbaiht (t`bt

http://www.civilwar.org/education/history/primarysources/declarationofcauses.html#South_Carolinahttp://www.civilwar.org/education/history/primarysources/declarationofcauses.html#South_Carolinahttp://www.civilwar.org/education/history/primarysources/declarationofcauses.html#South_Carolinahttp://www.civilwar.org/education/history/primarysources/declarationofcauses.html#South_Carolinahttp://www.civilwar.org/education/history/primarysources/declarationofcauses.html#South_Carolinahttp://www.civilwar.org/education/history/primarysources/declarationofcauses.html#South_Carolinahttp://www.civilwar.org/education/history/primarysources/declarationofcauses.html#South_Carolina

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

9/81

os b jokkiriht quistolh), hlr os ot tl hieissbroay sby bnlrtolh os wrlhf (bfboh, b jokkiriht quistolh).Cy ploht os lhay tl `iap us fboh uhjirstbhjohf ny `iapohf us sii pbst lur icltolhs.

Elhsojir t`i klaalwohf=

‐Oh `os punaoe aoki Jbvos jikihjij WbnlrtolhS bs clrba bhj bs Bciroebh w`oai cbohtbohohf t`bt  t`i ohstotutolh `iapij WaonirbtiwlcihS. Bat`luf` hlt baa Bciroebhs mlohij `os icnrbei lk WbnlrtolhS, kiw jossihtij krlc `os niaoik oh Wt`i kuaair jivialpciht lk

t`lsi w`l wiri nlrhS, bh lutallg s`brij oh t`i hohitiiht` eihtury ny baclst baa WnlrhS Bciroebhs bhj Vistirh Iurlpibhs.‟

:

Jbvos niaoivij sabviry ‐`iapij E`rostobhozi bh ohkirolr rbei‟7 oh `os cohj, sabviry cbji nabegs nittir lkk t`bh t`iy wluaj `bvi niih wot`lut t`i ohstotutolh lk sabviry.9 Aogiwosi, cbhy pilpai tljby niaoivi t`bt wlcih bri nittir lkk wot` lptolhs klr bnlrtolh t`bh t`iy wluaj ni okt`bt lptolh wbs cbji oaaifba. Lk elursi, hl lhi os klreij tl fit bh bnlrtolh w`oai coaaolhs wiriklreij ohtl sabviry ―  t`iri bri jokkiriheis ―  cy ploht os t`bt alfoeba mustokoebtolh ebh ni eribtijklr bhy ohstotutolh (t`luf` t`bt osh‟t tl sby baa ohstotutolhs bri nbj). Z`i eribtovi ebpbeotois lk`ucbhs tl siak-mustoky bri ohkohoti, bhj ok wi kboa tl aibrh t`os trut`, wi woaa ohivotbnay kohjlursiavis rbtolhbaozohf w`bt wi s`luajh‟t rbtolhbaozi, baa w`oai t`ohgohf t`bt wi‟ri cbgohf bstrlhf ebsi, pir`bps oh t`i hbci lk mustoei bhj `ucbh rof`ts.

Jbvos wrlti ‐W…S t`i ‑ljolus sabvi trbji,– `bs nut sbvij t`i Bkroebh ebptovi krlc

Uberokoei7 lr trbhskirrij `oc krlc sunmietolh tl b nbrnbrobh cbstir, tl t`i coajir sirvotuji tl bWES`rostobh, bhj nrluf`t `oc krlc t`i jbrghiss lk `ibt`ihosc tl t`i aof`t lk rivibaij riaofolh.‟; Jbvos niaoivij sabviry `iapij Bkroebhs, bs pilpai ebh niaoivi bnlrtolh `iaps wlcih (bhj pir`bps ot jlis). Jbvos basl niaoivij sabviry wbs fllj klr eovoaozbtolh, sohei ot ihbnaij pilpai tl pure`bsi flljs bt e`ibpir proeis, brfuohf t`bt sabviry ‐jorietay lr ohjorietay elhkirWijS ocplrtbht nihikots lh clri t`bh `bak t`i eovoaozij pilpai lk t`i falni. WJbvos brfuij sabviryS lpihij hiwe`bhhias lk elccirei, bhj wojihij laj lhis7 t`us nrohfohf jokkiriht hbtolhs ohtl ealsirohtirelursi bhj fribtir jipihjihei7 w`oe` os tl strihft`ih t`i nlhjs lk hbtolhba bcoty, bhj tlbjvbhei lur rbei oh ghlwaijfi, ohjustry, sieuroty bhj `bppohiss.‟6 @i elhsojirij sabviry bcibhs tl oheribsi t`i ohtirjipihjihey nitwiih hbtolhs, w`oe` alwirij t`i prlnbnoaoty lk wbrw`oai socuatbhilusay oheribsohf falnba sleolielhlcoe wiaaniohf, rbtolhbaozohf baa t`isi nihikots

 ny eabocohf nabegs wiri ohkirolr tl w`otis bhj t`bt w`otis `iapij t`ic ny ihsabvohf t`ic.Zljby, Jbvos‟ t`ohgohf strogis us bs lnvolusay occlrba bhj ivih ohsbhi, nut bri t`iri

hlhi eurrihtay baovi (bhj ivih oh plsotolhs lk fribt plaotoeba plwir) w`l jlh‟t brfui t`btbnlrtolh os ielhlcoebaay nihikoeoba, t`bt ot `iaps wlcih wot` t`ior ebriirs, t`bt ot `iaps elhtrla plpuabtolh sozi, t`bt ot rijueis t`i hucnir lk uhwbhtij e`oajrih, t`bt ot `iaps cohocozi plvirty,ite., bhj t`bt baa t`isi nihikots cbgi bnlrtolh hlt lhay beeiptbnai, nut ivih clrba< Bhj soheiuhnlrh e`oajrih brih‟t (kuaay) `ucbh, w`bt wrlhf os niohf jlhi< Ok bnlrtolh os oh kbet curjir, wibrih‟t cue` nittir t`bh t`i Trisojiht lk t`i Elhkijirbey. @lpikuaay t`i Trl-Aokirs bri wrlhf.

‐Oh Jbvos‟s mujfciht t`i Elhstotutolh bnslautiay fubrbhtiij prltietolh bhj iquba rof`tsklr WwlcihS bhj WbnlrtolhS‟  ―  sii `lw ibsoay ‐bnlrtolh‟ bhj ‐sabviry‟ ebh swote` pabeis,ispieobaay w`ih b pirslh kiia clrbaay ohjokkiriht lr uheirtboh

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

10/81

Elhkijirbey niebci t`i trui jiseihjbht lk t`i Bciroebh ^ivlautolh bhj t`i Elhstotutolh.‟24 Okbnlrtolh wbs tl nielci oaaifba ―  ok ‐WBhto-Bnlrtolh plsotolhs wiriS hl alhfir elhkohij tl b kiwkbhbtoes‟  ―  os ot sl `brj tl ocbfohi t`bt slci wluaj elhsojir sieissolh t`i lhay wby tl prltietwlcih‟s rof`ts bhj tl giip t`i ‐riba Bciroeb‟ baovi

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

11/81

bhj ok ylu jl sl, ylu cby sii w`y jitircohohf w`bt ebusij t`i Eovoa Vbr os hl ibsy cbttir. Oht`i jieabrbtolhs, baa t`i ossuis pilpai brfui klr tljby bri aostij= sabviry, Utbti‟s rof`ts, ielhlcoe prissuris, Hlrt`irh bffrissolh, ite. @ihei, t`i jinbti bnlut t`i Eovoa Vbr nielcis b jinbtibnlut w`oe` lk t`isi ‐ossuis‟ wbs ‐clri sl‟ t`i ebusi t`bh t`i lt`irs, bhj t`i bhswir tl t`btquistolh jipihjs lh w`l ylu bsg.

Elhsojirohf U`lwjlwh oh [orfohob ny Voaaobc Krii`aohf, slci wluaj sby t`bt sieissolhwbs b frbjuba nribgjlwh, wot` t`i Jiip Ulut` sieijohf korst lvir sabviry bhj t`i Yppir Ulut`sieijohf abtir niebusi t`iy wluajh‟t fl balhf wot` bhy btticpt lk t`i Kijirba Flvirhciht tlklrei stbtis nbeg ohtl t`i Yhotij Utbtis. Z`i Yppir Ulut` josbfriij wot` sieissolh, nut basljosbfriij wot` klreohf Utbtis t`bt sieijij nbeg ohtl t`i Yholh. @ihei, sabviry os w`y t`i JiipUlut` sieijij, w`oai Hlrt`irh bffrissolh os w`y t`i Yppir Ulut` sieijij. @ihei, klr t`i JiipUlut`, sabviry os w`bt ebusij t`i Eovoa Vbr, w`oai tl t`i Yppir Ulut`, Hlrt`irh bffrissolh osrisplhsonai. Nut t`bt sboj, clri tie`hoebaay, slci wluaj sby t`bt sabviry wbs t`i ebusi lksieissolh, w`oai Aohelah‟s cossolh tl prisirvi t`i Yholh wbs t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr7 `ihei,slci cby sby ‐sabviry wbs t`i ebusi lk sieissolh, w`oai Aohelah wbs t`i ebusi lk t`i EovoaVbr‟. Z`ilritoebaay, `bj t`i Utbtis sieijij bhj Aohelah hivir ohvbjij, t`iri wluaj `bvi niih

hl Eovoa Vbr7 `ihei, slci wluaj sby Aohelah os risplhsonai. Klr t`i Yppir Ulut` w`l mlohij t`iElhkijir bey, sabviry wbsh‟t t`i cboh ossui, klr t`iy niaoivij ot wbs aifbaay prltietij (bsbnlrtolh os aifbaay prltietij tljby). Z`iy niaoivij sieissolh wbs Elhstotutolhba bhj t`bt Aohelahwbs abuhe`ohf b coaotbry lpirbtolh tl stlp Utbtis krlc jlohf t`bt w`oe` wbs wot`oh t`iorElhstotutolhba rof`t tl jl, bhj sl t`i Yppir Ulut` jieojij t`iy `bj tl kof`t bfbohst Aohelah, klr`i wbs betohf oaaifbaay (w`it`ir t`iy wiri rof`t lr wrlhf os bhlt`ir cbttir).

Lk elursi, lhi eluaj brfui t`bt `bj t`iri niih hl sabviry, t`i Jiip Ulut` wluaj `bvihivir sieijij, bhj sl t`i Yppir Ulut` wluaj `bvi hivir sieijij lvir Hlrt` bffrissolh, bhj sl‐sabviry os t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr‟. Aogiwosi, ok sabviry os t`i ebusi lk sieissolh bhjAohelah‟s jisori tl prisirvi t`i Yholh t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr, sohei sieissolh ebusij Aohelahtl bet (Elhstotutolhbaay lr hlt), t`ih ‐sabviry os t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr‟. Bhj t`bt‟s b kbor ploht, bhj `ihei aifotocozis t`bt p`rbsi ‐sabviry wbs t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr‟. Ot stbhjs t`bt`bj t`iri niih hl sabviry, t`iri wluaj `bvi niih hl Eovoa Vbr7 `ihei, ot os kbor tl sby t`bt‐sabviry wbs t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr‟.

Bt t`i sbci t`luf`, w`ih wi sby t`bt, wi hiij tl bvloj t`ohgohf lk t`i wlrj ‐sabviry‟wot` t`i clrba josfust t`bt wi kiia tljby7 rbt`ir, wi hiij tl try tl cbgi lursiavis kiia clri lkt`i clrba bcnofuoty t`bt wi kiia w`ih ot elcis tl bh ossui aogi bnlrtolh. Zljby, t`iri bri hlohstotutolhs lk t`i Utbti supplrtohf lr oheunbtohf (vob abw, ielhlcoe ohkrbstrueturis, ite.) t`i prbetoei lk sabviry, nut oh t`i pbst, uhklrtuhbtiay, t`iri wbs sue` supplrt bhj oheunbtolh. Z`oseribtij clrba bcnofuoty, socoabr tl t`bt rielrjij ny @bhhb` Brjiht bhj Coafrbc. Bhj ok wi britl uhjirstbhj t`i Eovoa Vbr, wi cust kiia ‐clrbaay bcnofuoty‟, sue` bs t`bt w`oe` wi kiia w`ihot elcis tl bnlrtolh. Bs t`iri wiri t`lsi oh t`i pbst w`l vi`icihtay lpplsij sabviry, t`iri brit`lsi tljby w`l vi`icihtay lpplsi bnlrtolh7 bs t`iri wiri t`lsi w`l supplrt sabviry niebusit`iy wiri rbeosts, t`iri bri t`lsi tljby w`l supplrt bnlrtolh niebusi t`iy jl hlt niaoivi uhnlrhe`oajrih bri kuaay `ucbh (oh slci wby)7 bs t`iri bri t`lsi w`l elhsojirij sabviry b hieissbryivoa, t`iri bri t`lsi tljby w`l elhsojir bnlrtolh slcit`ohf t`iy jlh‟t pirslhbaay bfrii wot`, nutslcit`ohf t`bt t`iy `bj hl rof`t tl tiaa lt`irs t`bt t`iy ebhhlt pirklrc7 bhj sl lh. Jlis t`os mustoky sabviry< Hlt bt baa, nut ot s`luaj e`bhfi `lw wi t`ohg bnlut ot. Jlis t`os cibh nabegs ohBciroeb s`luaj ni bhy aiss lutrbfij< Hlt baa, bs Brjiht‟s wlrg s`luajh‟t cbgi Miws bhy aiss

http://www.amazon.com/Showdown-Virginia-1861-Convention-Union/dp/0813929644http://www.amazon.com/Showdown-Virginia-1861-Convention-Union/dp/0813929644

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

12/81

lutrbfij lvir t`i @lalebust. Z`i ploht os t`bt wi s`luajh‟t ni sl elhkojiht t`bt t`i wlraj os spaotohtl bhfias bhj jiclhs. Oh t`os aoki, jiclhs bri bhfias, bhj bhfias bri jiclhs.

[

Elhsojirohf w`bt `bs niih sboj, ‐sabviry wbs t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr‟, nut wiri‐wibplhs lk cbss jistruetolh‟ t`i ebusi lk t`i wbr oh Orbq<  Niklri ealsohf t`os icp`bsos bhjrivoiw sietolh, b elcpbroslh bhj t`luf`t ixpirociht cby `iap kais` lut t`i ojibs lk t`os wlrg,bhj `iap fit berlss t`i plohts lk privolus bhj klaalwohf sietolhs. O t`ohg ot woaa `iap oaaucohbti`lw Ulut`irhirs t`luf`t, `lw clrbaay uheirtboh t`i sotubtolh wbs, w`y jitircohohf ebusi os hlibsy cbttir, ite.

Ait us elhsojir t`i Eovoa Vbr oh aof`t lk t`i Orbq Ohvbsolh.Z`i Yhotij Utbtis lk Bciroeb ohvbjij Orbq bs pbrt lk ots Vbr lh Zirrlrosc. Trisojiht

Nus` sboj bt t`i toci t`bt wi hiijij tl stlp Ubjjbc @ussioh krlc jivialpohf wibplhs lk cbssjistruetolh bhj tl nrohf `os ivoa rifoci tl bh ihj. Vbs Ubjjbc ivoa< Tir`bps, nut joj t`bt mustokyohvbjohf t`i eluhtry bhj ihjohf `os rifoci< Jipihjs lh w`l ylu bsg= cbhy Aonirbas elhsojir ot

b nbrnbroe, eruia, bhj curjirlus ohvbsolh t`bt t`luf` ot ihjij t`i ivoa lk Ubjjbc, basl ruohij t`iaovis lk eluhtaiss, ohhleiht pilpai (bhj Bciroeb basl pirpitubtij fribt ivoas= elhsojir BnuF`rbon). Nut t`os sluhjs ojihtoeba tl w`bt Ulut`irhirs eaboc bnlut t`i Eovoa Vbr= t`i Hlrt`irhohvbsolh wbs nbrnbroe, eruia, bhj curjirlus bhj ruohij t`i aovis lk eluhtaiss ohhleiht pilpailvir b sieissolh t`i Utbtis `bj aifba rof`t tl ebrry lut (bhj t`i Yholh basl pirpitubtij fribtivoas= elhsojir U`ircbh‟s ‐Cbre` tl t`i Uib‟). Joj t`i Hlrt`irh ohvbsolh ihj sabviry< _is, bsBciroeb ihjij t`i rifoci lk Ubjjbc @ussioh, nut os bh ivoa bet t`bt stlps ivoa osh‟t bhy aissivoa< Jipihjs lh w`l ylu bsg. Viri Elhkijirbtis ivoa< Tir`bps ―  pir`bps slci clri sl t`bhlt`irs ―  nut joj t`iy jikihj slcit`ohf t`bt wbs ivoa< Bnslautiay, bs ot wbs niaoivij Ubjjbc wbsjikihjohf wibplhs lk cbss jistruetolh (bhj w`it`ir lr hlt t`lsi wibplhs, oh t`i ihj, betubaayixostij jlish‟t e`bhfi t`i kbet t`bt t`iy wiri usij bs mustokoebtolh bt t`i toci klr abuhe`ohf t`iohvbsolh).

Z`iri bri Aonirba elccihtbtlrs w`l brfui t`bt Bciroeb‟s ohvbsolh lk Orbq betubaaystrihft`ihij t`i tirrlrost hitwlrgs oh t`i rifolh, bhj risuatij oh eluhtaiss pilpai mlohohftirrlrosts tl kof`t Bciroeb w`l lt`irwosi wluajh‟t `bvi, niaoivohf t`iy `bj niih uhmustayohvbjij7 slci elccihtbtlrs fl sl kbr bs tl brfui t`bt `bj Bciroeb hivir ohvbjij, OUOU ―  t`iOsabcoe Utbti ―  wluaj `bvi hivir elci ohtl ixostihei. Z`isi elccihtbtlrs sluhj ricbrgbnaysocoabr tl t`i Elhsirvbtovis w`l brfui t`bt t`i Yholh‟s ohvbsolh lk t`i Ulut` betubaaystrihft`ihij t`i Elhkijirbey, bhj risuatij oh eluhtaiss pilpai mlohohf t`i Elhkijirbti ebusi tlkof`t t`i Yholh w`l lt`irwosi wluajh‟t `bvi, niaoivohf t`iy `bj niih uhmustay ohvbjij7 slcielccihtbtlrs fl sl kbr bs tl brfui t`bt `bj t`i Ulut` hivir niih ohvbjij, t`i Eovoa Vbr wluaj`bvi hivir `bppihij. Jlis t`os cibh Bciroeb s`luajh‟t `bvi ohvbjij Orbq< Tir`bps. U`luaj t`i Hlrt` hlt `bvi ohvbjij t`i Ulut`< Bfboh, pir`bps ―  sue` quistolhs brih‟t w`bt procbroayohtirist ci. Cy ploht os t`bt wi bri quoeg tl mujfi t`bt w`oe` wi brih‟t bhy nittir t`bh7 cy plohtos t`bt icpbt`y os slcit`ohf wi jlh‟t tihj tl ivir cbstir.

Aonirbas `bvi niih ghlwh tl eaboc t`i Orbq Ohvbsolh wbs ribaay bnlut Bciroeb siozohf loaoh t`i rifolh, socoabr tl t`i Elhsirvbtovis w`l eaboc t`i Eovoa Vbr wbs ribaay bnlut Hlrt`irhirssiozohf t`i ielhlcoe bssits lk t`i Ulut`. Aonirbas brfui t`bt Bciroeb ruohij bh ihtori eluhtry lkOrbq niebusi lk w`bt t`i cohlroty lk Orbqos joj, bs Elhsirvbtovis brfui Yholhosts ‐nurhij t`iUlut` tl t`i frluhj‟ lvir w`bt b scbaa cohlroty lk pilpai joj ―  lwh sabvis. Ulci Aonirbas brfui

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Ghraib_torture_and_prisoner_abusehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Ghraib_torture_and_prisoner_abusehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman's_March_to_the_Seahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman's_March_to_the_Seahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman's_March_to_the_Seahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman's_March_to_the_Seahttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Ghraib_torture_and_prisoner_abusehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abu_Ghraib_torture_and_prisoner_abuse

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

13/81

Nus` os fuoaty lk wbr erocis, bs slci Elhsirvbtovis brfui t`i sbci bnlut Aohelah. Aonirbasbrfui t`bt Orbq `bs aibj tl `lrronai uhohtihjij elhsiquiheis lk ixpbhjohf bhj icplwirohftirrlrost hitwlrgs oh t`i rifolh, bs Elhsirvbtovis brfui t`bt t`i Eovoa Vbr aibj tl bh ixpbhsolhbhj icplwirohf lk t`i eihtrba bhj Kijirba Flvirhciht lvir t`i Utbtis. Aonirbas ploht lut t`btwi stoaa `bvih‟t rielvirij krlc t`i elhsiquiheis lk t`i ohvbsolh ―  OUOU, jistbnoaozbtolh lk t`i

Cojjai Ibst, ite. ―  bs Elhsirvbtovis ploht lut t`i sbci oh rifbrj tl t`i Eovoa Vbr= wi bri stoaajibaohf wot` rbeosc, nabeg plvirty, ite. Aonirbas cby brfui t`bt t`i ohvbsolh jojh‟t kox t`isotubtolh, bs Elhsirvbtovis cby sby t`i sbci bnlut t`i Eovoa Vbr. Aonirbas brfui Bciroeberibtij OUOU7 Elhsirvbtovis ebh brfui t`bt Icbheopbtolh Trleabcbtolh sit nabegs up klr plvirtybhj rbeosc t`bt aibj tl Moc Erlw. Aonir bas brfui t`i ohvbsolh s`luajh‟t `bvi `bppihij iviht`luf` Ubjjbc wbs ivoa, bs Elhsirvbtovis brfui t`i Hlrt`irh ohvbsolh s`luajh‟t `bvi `bppihijivih t`luf` sabviry wbs ivoa.

Bhj sl lh.Viri wibplhs lk cbss jistruetolh t`i ebusi lk t`i Vbr oh Orbq< Tir`bps ―  ot jipihjs lh

w`bt lhi cibhs ny ‐ebusi‟. Joj t`bt brfuciht elhvohei clst Bciroebhs tl supplrt t`iohvbsolh< _is, nut pir`bps t`i riba ebusi wbs Nus`‟s jisori klr loa lr tl rijiic `os kbt`ir‟s

 nlte`ij Fuak Vbr, bhj t`i ‐wibplhs lk cbss jistruetolh‟-brfuciht wbs must b elvir t`bt eluajjieiovi t`i Bciroebh pilpai ohtl supplrtohf b wbr Nus` wbhtij tl kof`t. Vbs Hlrt`irhbffrissolh t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr< Tir`bps. Joj t`i brfuciht elhvohei clst Ulut`irhirs tlsupplrt t`i Elhkijirbey< _is, nut pir`bps t`i riba ebusi wbs t`i jisori lk plwirkua Ulut`irhirstl jikihj t`ior pabhtbtolhs bhj ielhlcoe bssits, bhj t`i ‐Hlrt`irh bffrissolh‟-brfuciht wbs mustb elvir t`bt eluaj jieiovi Ulut`irhirs tl jikihj t`i wibat` lk t`i plwirkua.

Aogi t`lsi sibre`ohf klr bhswirs tl t`i quistolh ‐w`bt wbs t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

14/81

ci ―  bfboh, cy elheirh os bnlut icpbt`y. Ot osh‟t cy ohtiht tl suffist t`i Hlrt` s`luajh‟t `bviohvbjij t`i Ulut` lr t`bt ot wbs uhabwkua tl jl sl (t`bt os b jokkiriht quistolh), hlr os ot cy ohtihttl suffist t`i sbci bnlut Bciroeb oh Orbq (bfboh, t`bt os b jokkiriht quistolh). Cy `lpi os lhay tl`of`aof`t `lw jokkoeuat trut` os tl jitircohi, t`bt tl ribj `ostlry os hl ibsy cbttir, bhj t`bt wihiij tl hlt t`ohg lk tryohf tl uhjirstbhj slcit`ohf bs ixtihjohf ot klrfovihiss. Tir`bps baa

klrfovihiss ihtboas uhjirstbhjohf, nut hlt baa uhjirstbhjohf ihtboas klrfovihiss.Icpbt`y osh‟t klrfovihiss. Zl icp`bsozi wot` t`i Elhkijirbey osh‟t tl klrfovi t`ic. Okwi jlh‟t aibrh tl icpbt`ozi, wi cby kohj lursiavis jlohf t`bt w`oe` wi ebhhlt klrfovi. Bhjslcitocis, t`i `brjist pirslh tl klrfovi ebh ni ylursiak.

[O

Ul w`bt wbs t`i Eovoa Vbr bnlut< Zl Ulut`irhirs, ot wbs b wbr bfbohst b voiw lk prleisswot` b voiw lk mustoei7 tl Ulut`irhirs, ot wbs b clrba ikklrt tl stlp t`i occlrba ohvbsolh lk t`i Hlrt`, w`oe` t`i Hlrt` joj oh t`i hbci lk mustoei. V`l wbs rof`t< Nlt`/hiot`ir. Ohjiij, sabviryos bh uhmust, occlrba `lrrlr, bhj sl lh t`bt frluhj, t`i Hlrt` betij rof`tay. Nut w`bt ok t`i sbci

`lajs klr bnlrtolh< V`bt ok bnlrtolh tll os b frbvi, uhklrfovbnai `lrrlr< V`bt ok t`i Hlrt`sieijij tl jikihj wlcih‟s rof`ts bhj t`i Ulut` ohvbjis t`i Hlrt` tl prisirvi ‐t`i Yholh‟.Vluaj t`os bet ni must bhj clrba< _is/hl. Oh aohi wot` ‑(Oc)clrbaoty– ny L.F. ^lsi, b kboauri tlfrbsp t`bt ‐wi bri baa (oc)clrba‟ `bs `urt lur bnoaoty tl uhjirstbhj lur `ostlry, lur wlraj, bhjlursiavis.

Ok ylu wbht tl uhjirstbhj bhyt`ohf, ait balhi `ostlry, ylu cust icpbt`ozi, klr icpbt`ycbgis plssonai b jyhbcoe virsus aohibr ―  b erotoeba virsus socpay t`luf`tkua ―  uhjirstbhjohf(lhi t`bt os basl iquoppij tl bvloj ‐Icltolhba Mujfciht‟, wbrhij bnlut oh ‑IcltolhbaMujfciht– ny L.F. ^lsi). Ok ylu ebhhlt icpbt`ozi, ylu cust t`ohg lk `ostlry oh tircs lk ‐w`btwbs t`i rof`t elursi

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

15/81

ot jlis e`bhfi `lw wi uhjirstbhj t`i ivoa betolhs lk t`i Ulut`irhirs, bhj `iap us frbsp `lw wieluaj pltihtobaay ni pbrtoeopbtohf bhj pirpitubtohf oh b frbvi ivoa ―  pir`bps aogi bnlrtolh ―  t`btwi jlh‟t t`ohg lk bs ‐b frbvi ivoa‟ bt baa= wi cof`t ivih t`ohg lk ot bs b clrba bhj `ucbh fllj.Z`os osh‟t tl sby bnlrtolh os ‐b frbvi ivoa‟ ―  t`bt‟s b jokkiriht quistolh ―  nut tl sby t`bt wi cby nihl jokkiriht t`bh t`i Ulut`irhirs. Ixostihtoba uheirtbohty os uhbvlojbnai, t`luf` cust lk aoki os b

 prleiss ny w`oe` wi siak-jieiovi lursiavis ohtl t`ohgohf lt`irwosi.Oh Ioe`cbhh oh Mirusbaic, @bhhb` Brjiht icp`bsozij t`bt Bjlap` Ioe`cbhh wbsh‟tsocpay ivoa, t`luf` pilpai wbhtij tl t`ohg lk `oc bs sue`. ^bt`ir, Ioe`cbhh t`luf`t lk `ocsiakbs ‐jlohf w`bt `i w`bt `i wbs supplsij tl‟ ―  bs ‐klaalwohf lrjirs‟ ―  bhj tl Brjiht‟s `lrrlr, s`iribaozij t`bt t`i Hbzo Utbti tllg krlc Ioe`cbhh `os clrba elcpbss. @i wbs ebuf`t nitwiih t`iit`oe lk t`i Hbzo Utbti bhj t`i it`oeba, bhj Brjiht ribaozij t`bt bhylhi eluaj `bvi niih ohIoe`cbhh‟s plsotolh bhj turhij lut t`i sbci. Ioe`cbhh wbsh‟t slcilhi w`l wbs ‐jokkiriht‟bhj `os ivoa wbsh‟t b risuat lk t`os ‐jokkirihei‟7 rbt`ir, `i wbs `lrrokyohfay hlrcba, bhj wbs mustaogi t`i rist lk us. Ot wbs t`i ohstotutolh t`bt eribtij Ioe`cbhh, bhj ok Ioe`cbhh wluajh‟t `bvi niih t`iri tl koaa t`i rlai, slcilhi iasi wluaj `bvi must bs ibsoay.

Ivoa os niylhj fllj bhj ivoa. Ot leeurs niylhj t`i joe`ltlcy ―  t`os os w`bt wi aibrh

krlc @bhhb` Brjiht ―  ot leeurs iot`ir w`iri pilpai eibsi tl t`ohg oh ots tircs bhj rbt`ir t`ohg ohtircs lk ‐juty‟, ‐seoihei‟, ‐`ucbh rof`ts‟, ite., lr w`iri pilpai ‐jikohi t`icsiavis lut lk‟ t`iorivoa (bs ixpbhjij lh oh ‑Jikohohf Ivojihei– ny L.F. ^lsi). Ivoa leeurs w`iri ivoa jlish‟t`bppih, ok ylu woaa, bhj aogi ivoa, tltbaotbrobhosc leeurs niylhj fllj bhj ivoa. Bhj yittltbaotbrobhosc leeurs w`iri ot os it`oeba, klr ot leeurs w`iri pilpai isebpi t`ior occlrbaoty vobclrba elhstruet/proheopai bhj/lr ‐rijikohotolh‟ bhj yit jl hlt isebpi t`ior clrbaoty, aibvohf t`icixplsij tl t`ior fllj nut krii krlc t`ior nbj.

Zltbaotbrobhosc os it`oeba.Zltbaotbrobhosc leeurs it`oebaay.Ivoa os it`oeba.Ivoa leeurs it`oebaay.Zl ixpaboh w`bt O cibh, ok b cbh ihsabvis nabegs nut jikohis nabeg bs ‐hlt `ucbh‟, t`i

 pirslh `bs (riabtovi tl `ocsiak), jikohij `ocsiak lut lk clrba elhsojirbtolh. Oh t`i Elhkijirbey,sohei nabegs wirih‟t `ucbh, ihsabvohf t`ic wbsh‟t b cbttir lk rof`t lr wrlhf, hlr clri t`bhwbs ibtohf b stibg. Z`i ocplrtbht ploht tl frbsp lut lk t`os os t`bt, vob rijikohotolh, t`iUlut`irhir turhs sabviry ohtl b cbttir t`bt osh‟t ivih lk clrba elhsojirbtolh= t`i ivoa leeurs niylhj fllj bhj ivoa. Z`i Ulut`irhir (pir`bps aogi t`i Hbzo) viry wiaa cby plhjir w`ih ot osit`oeba tl goaa lr stiba ―  klr clrbaoty bppaois tl t`isi sotubtolhs sohei t`iy ohvlavi `ucbh aoki bhj prlpirty ―  nut w`ih ot elcis tl sabviry, t`iri os hlt`ohf tl plhjir= `i nielcis hlt stupoj, nut‐t`luf`taiss‟, bs wbs Bjlap` Ioe`cbhh beelrjohf tl Brjiht. Tir`bps t`i Ulut`irhir woaaelhsojir `lw eruia tl ni sohei nabegs kiia pboh ―  `i cby elhsojir t`i sbci oh rifbrj tl bhocbas ―   nut `i ribaay wlh‟t t`ohg bnlut sabviry oh tircs lk it`oes. Bhj siiohf bs t`i Ulut`irhir elhsojirsquistolhs lk it`oes aogi curjir bhj t`ikt, `i `bs ribslh tl niaoivi (bhj ivojihei) t`bt `i os oh kbetb clrba niohf w`l jlis clrba t`ohfs, bhj niebusi lk `os rijikohotolh, `i `bs hl ribslh tl t`ohgt`bt `i osh‟t sue` (lnmietoviay ―  ricicnir, hl lhi ixpiroiheis t`ior sunmietovoty bs ‐sunmietovi‟7wi baa hieissbroay ixpiroihei lur sunmietovoty bs ‐lnmietovi‟ (ispieobaay/ivih w`ih ot osh‟t)).^iabtovi tl t`i Ulut`irhir‟s selpi, `i os oh kbet b clrba niohf, bhj sl w`ih Hlrt`irhirs t`ribtihtl ohvbji t`i Ulut` oh t`i hbci lk prisirvohf t`i Yholh bhj ihjohf bh ohmustoei, riabtovi tl t`iUlut`irhir, `i os b clrba niohf w`l os niohf beeusij lk ohmustoei bhj ohvbjij, nlt` lk w`oe`,riabtovi tl `os selpi, fovi `ocsiak ribslh tl kof`t t`i Yholh, baa w`oai t`ohgohf lk `ocsiak lh t`i

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

16/81

rof`t soji lk `ostlry, mustoei, bhj flljhiss. Os `i rof`t< Hl ―  sabviry os bh bnlcohbtolh, klr otvolabtis aonirty wot` klrei bhj jihois `ucbhhiss tl lhi wot` `ucbh JHB  ―  nut wi cust hlt aitt`bt trut` giip us krlc uhjirstbhjohf `lw t`i Ulut`irhir t`luf`t lk `ocsiak bhj cltovbtij`ocsiak. Lt`irwosi, wi cby ihj up must aogi `oc.

^iabtovi tl t`i Ulut`irhir‟s selpi, `i os oh kbet b clrba niohf, nut riabtovi tl lur selpi,

`i os oh kbet b clhstir. Zl us tljby, allgohf uplh t`i viry t`ohf Elhkijirbtis allgij uplh, wiebhhlt kbt`lc `lw t`iy eluaj `bvi plssonay niih sl ohbetovi bhj beeiptohf. Elhsojirohf t`btw`ih wi sii sabviry, wi kiia rivuasolh, wi bssuci t`iy kiat t`i sbci t`ohf. Uohei t`iy jojhlt`ohf, wi `ihei bssuci t`iy iot`ir krlzi t`ior `ibrts lr ofhlrij t`ior clrba ocpuasis, nlt` lkw`oe` cbgi t`ic ivoa ―  nlt` lk w`oe` cbgis t`ic jisirvohf lk t`i `brs`ist lk mujfcihts. Nutw`bt wi kiia, wi cust hlt ni sl quoeg tl bssuci lt`irs kiat, bhj cust ribaozi t`bt wi lursiaviscby ni oh t`i cojst lk t`bt w`oe` t`i kuturi woaa mujfi bs b ‐clrba btrleoty‟, bhj yit wi hiot`irghlw ot hlr kiia ot. Jlis t`bt cbgi us bhy aiss fuoaty< _is/hl. Cy ploht `iri os lhay t`bt t`ilnvolushiss lk t`i ivoa lk Ulut`irhirs os soegihohf, nut wi kboa tl uhjirstbhj t`i plwir lk selpibhj rijikohotolh. Z`i (icltolhba) ixpiroihei lk bh ohmustoei os viry jokkiriht w`ih ylu jlh‟tjikohi t`i ohmustoei bs uhmust. Ok ot turhs lut t`bt, oh t`i ihj, bnlrtolh betubaay os rbeost bhj curjir,

t`bt jlish‟t e`bhfi t`i kbet t`bt tljby, wi jlh‟t kiia sue` clrba eirtbohty tlwbrj ot. Z`lsi oh t`ikuturi cby niaoivi t`bt t`iy wluaj `bvi niih jokkiriht krlc us, nut t`iy woaa kboa tl uhjirstbhjt`i plwir lk selpi. Ok bnlrtolh os oh kbet rbeost bhj curjir, t`i alfoe lutaohij klr Ulut`irhirsbasl bppaois tl us= tl t`lsi w`l elhsojir bnlrtolh beeiptbnai tljby, bnlrtolh osh‟t ivih b cbttirlk clrba elhsojirbtolh  niebusi kitusis brih‟t `ucbh. Nut ok t`iy jlh‟t aibrh icpbt`y (bs O kibrwi `bvi kboaij tl jl), t`bt wlh‟t stlp `ostlry stujihts b `uhjrij yibrs krlc hlw siiohf us bslnvolusay ivoa. Zl t`ic, allgohf uplh t`i viry t`ohf wi allgij uplh, t`iy woaa ni uhbnai tlkbt`lc `lw wi eluaj `bvi plssonay niih sl beeiptohf bhj beeiptohf. Uohei wi joj hlt`ohf, t`iy`ihei woaa bssuci wi iot`ir krlzi lur `ibrts lr ofhlrij lur clrba ocpuasis, nlt` lk w`oe` cbgius ivoa ―  nlt` lk w`oe` cbgi us jisirvohf lk t`i `brs`ist lk mujfcihts. Z`i lnvolushiss lk lurivoa woaa ni soegihohf tl t`ic, nut t`iy woaa `bvi kboaij tl ribaozi t`bt lur ivoa wbsh‟t lnvolus tlus bt baa. Bktir baa, aoki jlish‟t nifoh bt elheiptolh, jlis ot<

Vi bri b sleoity kuaa lk fllj pilpai, e`broty, bhj prlfrissovi ikklrts tl cbgi t`i wlraj b nittir pabei, nut b sleoity kuaa lk sue` woaa siic oheribsohfay fllj, bhj yit t`bt ‐bppibrbhei lkfllj‟ woaa pir`bps naohj ot krlc ots irlsolh lk trui flljhiss, w`oe` ot cof`t ni alsohf niebusi ot`bs ‐rijikohij‟ otsiak lut niohf fuoaty lk clrba erocis ot os oh kbet fuoaty lk pirpitubtohf. Tir`bpssl7 pir`bps hlt. Iot`ir wby, t`i ploht stbhjs t`bt t`i clri clrba b sleoity os, t`i clri ot woaa`bvi ivojihei t`bt ot os oh kbet ‐lnmietoviay‟ fllj, bhj yit t`bt viry sleoity eluaj ni fuoaty lk bfrbvi ivoa t`bt ot `ojis krlc otsiak vob rijikohotolh. Elhsojirohf t`os, pir`bps t`i viry naohjhisslk t`i Elhkijirbey krlc ots fribt ivoa os ivojihei lk ots fribt clrbaoty. Tir`bps hlt7 rifbrjaiss, Okibr t`bt lur kboauri tl `bvi icpbt`y `bs risuatij oh us cossohf t`os trut` bnlut Elhkijirbtis,cbgohf us clri aogiay tl ni hl nittir t`bh t`ic, bhj basl risuatij oh us kboaohf tl uhjirstbhj`lw t`iy eluaj kof`t klr ‐Utbti‟s rof`ts‟ oh lrjir tl sieuri t`i rof`t lk sabvis bhj hlt t`ohg lkt`icsiavis bs clrba clhstirs, bs t`iy sl lnvolusay bri tl us tljby. Kboauri tluhjirstbhj/icpbt`ozi wot` t`lsi oh t`i Eovoa Vbr `bs basl elhtronutij tl lur nobs bfbohst prleissoh kbvlr lk clrbaoty, w`oe` os prieosiay w`bt prleiss ixosts tl ‐e`ieg bhj nbabhei‟, bhj yit prieosiay t`i frluhjs lh w`oe` wi kiia mustokoij tl sgop prleiss (bs wbrhij bnlut oh ‑Z`i Jibt`lk Trleiss– ny L.F. ^lsi). Z`os ploht woaa ni ixpbhjij lh abtir.

Z`i plwir lk ohstotutolhs ebhhlt ni lvirstrissij. Jl `ucbhs `bvi e`loei< _is, nutohstotutolhs `of`ay ohkauihei bhj s`bpi t`i krbciwlrg oh w`oe` lur e`loeis bri ixireosij. Oh

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

17/81

cbhy wbys, wi bri aogi elws wot`oh kiheis7 wi bri krii, bhj yit wi bri stueg. Ohstotutolhsoheunbtij beeiptbhei lk sabviry oh t`i Ulut` ―  t`iy cbji ot aifba bhj kboaij tl ihklrei abws tl prltiet sabvis ―  bs ohstotutolhs pir`bps oheunbti lur beeiptbhei lk rbeost bnlrtolh tljby.Ohstotutolh cbgi us t`ohg lk t`bt w`oe` t`i ohstotutolh prltiets hlt hieissbroay bs ‐rof`t‟, nut‐cbyni rof`t‟, bhj t`bt‟s ihluf` tl cltovbti us tl fl balhf wot` ot. Ohstotutolhs bjj b quistolh

cbrg, bhj nbsij lh w`bt t`iy beeipt bhj rimiet, lur kiiaohfs, t`ohgohf, eirtbohty, woaaohfhiss tlicpbt`ozi, ite., bri jiipay ohkauiheij, w`it`ir wi ribaozi ot lr hlt. Z`os osh‟t must oh rifbrj tlslcit`ohf `lrronai sue` bs t`i @lalebust, t`luf` sue` btrleotois bri oh rifbrj tl w`bt t`iohkauihei lk ohstotutolhs os eaibrist, bs wi hltoei b nrlgih jllrghln clri ribjoay t`bh lhi t`btwlrgs (tl nlrrlw b ploht krlc @iojiffir)7 lt`irwosi, t`i ohkauihei os viry jokkoeuat tljostohfuos` krlc w`bt wi bri e`llsohf tl jl bhj/lr w`bt os rof`t tl jl, aogi twl rovirs t`bt bricirfij). Ohstotutolhs basl ohkauihei sue` oh rifbrj tl w`bt wi t`ohg os clrba, prbetoeba, pirslhba,ite. Ok lur sleoity jojh‟t cbgi t`ikt bfbohst t`i abw, wluaj wi t`ohg lk ot bs occlrba< Tir`bps wiwluaj, nut pir`bps wi wluajh‟t `bvi t`i eirtbohty t`bt wi jl w`ih ot os eljokoij ohtl abw (w`ih‐occlrba‟ bhj ‐oaaifba‟ cirfi aogi twl rovirs t`bt nielci lhi, t`luf` t`bt ebh uhklrtuhbtiaycbgi us klrfit t`iri os b jokkirihei). Vi bri bawbys ohkauiheij ny ohstotutolhs, nut t`bt balhi

osh‟t b prlnaic. Ofhlrbhei os t`i ossui.Bfboh, ohstotutolhs bjj b quistolh cbrg, bhj sohei wi jlh‟t kiia eirtboh bnlut t`i clrbahbturi lk w`bt ohstotutolhs bjj uheirtbohty bnlut, wi fl balhf wot` t`ic, klr t`iy `bvi t`i‐but`lroty‟ bhj ‐ixpirtosi‟, bhj elci berlss tl us bs clri eirtboh t`bh wi bri (bhj siiohf bs wiwluaj `bvi tl lpplsi abw bhj klrei tl fl bfbohst t`ic, t`os ocprissolh lk t`ior eirtbohty os lhayohtihsokoij). Tir`bps t`iri bri alts lk aittirs lk Ulut`irhirs wrotohf bnlut `lw t`iy josaogijsabviry ―  ivojihei t`bt t`iy joj `bvi b clrba elcpbss ―  bs cbhy jurohf t`i CoaaofrbcIxpirociht allg hirvlus bs t`i kbgi jletlr tiaas t`ic tl priss t`i iaietroe s`leg nuttlh bfboh,t`i vlatbfi niohf fovih clst eirtbohay kbtba. Yhjluntijay, Hbzos `isotbtij niklri curjirohf bhjtlrturohf Miws. Yhklrtuhbtiay, ohstotutolhs eribti ixostihtoba uheirtbohty ―  t`iy t`rlw b clhgiywrihe` ohtl t`i clrba elcpbss ―  bhj niebusi lk t`bt, pilpai `isotbti tl mujfi occlrbaotois bs‐occlrba‟, bhj t`bt‟s baa ot tbgis klr frbvi occlrbaoty tl leeur. Nut pir`bps t`bt `isotbtolh osh‟tbawbys b nbj t`ohf= pir`bps ot salws pilpai jlwh w`l wluaj ebaa bnlrtolh joserocohbtolh, w`ih pir`bps ot ribaay osh‟t. Tir`bps t`i ‐`isotbtolh‟ t`i Utbti ebusis oh t`lsi w`l bri bfbohst bnlrtolhtl jl slcit`ohf bnlut ot os fllj, klr t`lsi pilpai wluaj jl t`bt w`oe` ocpijij wlcih‟s rof`ts,bs t`lsi w`l betij oh t`i pbst cby `bvi betij, wot`lut Utbti ohvlavij, bfbohst prlpirty rof`ts.

Jl ylu sii<Zrut` os hivir bs socpai bs wi wbht ot tl ni, yit tl uhjirstbhj `ostlry, wi lktih cbgi ot

socpai. Ot‟s hl jokkiriht t`bh w`bt wi jl tl t`i prisiht.Vi bri eribturis oaa-iquoppij klr bnstrbet bhj prlnbnoaostoe t`ohgohf, nut t`os os t`i gohj

lk t`ohgohf wi riquori tl uhjirstbhj lursiavis.

[OO

Zl w`bt jifrii bri Ulut`irhirs ‐clrbaay risplhsonai‟ klr t`ior betolhs< Ivih ok pir`bpsIoe`cbhh wbs ‐t`luf`taiss‟ bhj jojh‟t t`ohg lk cbssberohf Miws bs b cbttir lk rof`t bhj wrlhf(klr t`i ivoa wbs niylhj fllj bhj ivoa), `i wbs stoaa ixieutij. Bhj `i s`luaj `bvi niih= must niebusi ylu jlh‟t t`ohg lk ylur betolhs bs curjir jlish‟t cibh ylur betolhs brih‟t curjir.Ioe`cbhh‟s ‐t`luf`taisshiss‟ joj hlt cbgi `oc bhy aiss fuoaty, bs t`i ‐t`luf`taisshiss‟ lkUlut`irhirs jojh‟t cbgi t`ic sbohts. Ok wi e`llsi tl riclvi Elhkijirbti kabfs, plrtrbots, ite.

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

18/81

krlc lur sleoity, t`bt os b jieosolh klr w`oe` t`iri os mustokoebtolh, bs Fircbhy wbs mustokoij tlcbgi Hbzo kabfs bhj t`i hbci ‐Bjlap`‟ oaaifba bktir VVOO. Nut t`bt sboj, w`bt wi brih‟t mustokoij tl jl os kboa tl uhjirstbhj t`i Elhkijirbey (lr Hbzosc klr t`bt cbttir) bs t`iyuhjirstllj t`icsiavis, hlt niebusi wi siig tl ixtihj t`ic klrfovihiss, nut niebusi wi siig tluhjirstbhj t`ic sl t`bt wi wlh‟t, aogi t`ic, ‐t`luf`taissay‟ elccot t`i uhklrfovbnai. Bhj

w`ih ot elcis tl uhjirstbhjohf t`i pilpai lk `ostlry icpbt`itoebaay, wi custh‟t aibrh tl mustt`ohg aogi t`ic, nut tl basl kiia bhj jieoji aogi t`ic, bhj tl basl uhjirstbhj t`bt t`i t`ohgohf lkUlut`irhirs uhjir t`i Elhkijirbey bhj Fircbhs uhjir Hbzosc ―  tl usi slci ixbcpais ―  wbsoheunbtij ny t`i ohstotutolhs t`iy wiri sotubtij oh, bhj t`bt krof`tihohfay, `bj wi niih oh t`iorsotubtolh, wi prlnbnay wluajh‟t `bvi kbrij cue` nittir (ok wi fl ny t`i risuats lk t`i Utbhklrjbhj Coafrbc ixpirocihts). O kibr t`luf` oh lur bfi abegohf icltolhba ohtiaaofihei (abcihtij nyJbhoia Flaicbh), prlnbnoaostoe ribslhohf (abcihtij ny Hbssoc Zbain), bhj uhjirstbhjohf bnlutt`i plwir lk ohstotutolhs (bjclhos`ij ny @bhhb` Brjiht, Utbhaiy Coafrbc, bhj T`oaop]ocnbrjl), wi bri iquoppij tl lhay uhjirstbhj `ostlry ihluf` tl rielfhozi ot ripibtohf.

Os ot kbor tl iqubti t`i Elhkijirbey tl Hbzosc< Oh tljby‟s jinbti bnlut w`it`ir t`iElhkijirbti kabf s`luaj ni riclvij, t`bt elcpbroslh os lktih cbji. Ohjiij, Elhkijirbtis bri

fuoaty lk b clrba btrleoty, bs os iviry eovoaozbtolh t`bt `bs `bj bhj jikihjij sabviry, nut os w`btt`i Elhkijirbey joj iqubaay bs ivoa bs w`bt t`i Hbzos bri fuoaty

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

19/81

bvloj lkkihjohf t`ic, hlr jlis ot cibh t`i elcpbroslh nitwiih Hbzosc bhj t`i Elhkijirbey oswrlhf (t`bt‟s b jokkiriht quistolh). Cy ploht `iri os t`bt Ulut`irhirs kiia b clrba mujfciht os pus`ij jlwh uplh t`ic, b clrba mujfciht t`iy jlh‟t bfrii wot` (t`luf` t`bt jlish‟t cibh otosh‟t beeurbti)7 bjjotolhbaay, oh b krii sleoity, Ulut`irhirs jlh‟t kiia t`iy s`luajh‟t `bvi tl ni‐prissij jlwh uplh‟. Jl Ulut`irhirs `bvi bhy frluhjs ny w`oe` tl t`ohg t`i elcpbroslh

 nitwiih t`i @lalebust bhj sabviry os ohbeeurbti< Tir`bps, nut ivih ok t`iy jl, t`bt jlish‟t cibht`i Elhkijirbti kabf s`luajh‟t ni riclvij krlc t`i punaoe squbri. Ivih ok ot os t`i ebsi t`btUlut`irhirs `bvi b ribslhbnai ebsi klr w`y t`iy bri jokkiriht krlc Hbzos ―  b clrba mujfcihtw`oe`, ivih ok ribslhbnai, bt t`i ihj lk t`i jby, itirhbaay rifrissis, bs wluaj t`i ebsi lk t`lsiw`l eabocij t`i elcpbssolh nitwiih Elhkijirbtis bhj Hbzos wbs mustokoij ―  ot jlis hlthieissbroay klaalw t`bt t`i aifbey lk t`i Elhkijirbey s`luajh‟t ni riclvij krlc Bciroebhsleoity. Z`bt os b jokkiriht quistolh.

 Hl Fircbh ebh jihy t`bt Hbzo Fircbhy ohvbjij Iurlpi bhj elccottij t`i @lalebust._is, pir`bps Fircbhy wbs ‐prissur ij‟ tl jl sl niebusi lk t`i ielhlcoe sotubtolh t`bt klaalwijVVO, nut t`luf` t`bt wbs pir`bps b ebusi, t`bt wbs hl mustokoebtolh (t`luf` bt t`i toci pir`bpsFircbhy t`luf`t ot wbs b mustokoebtolh). Z`iri os hl jinbti t`bt t`i Hbzos stbrtij elhkaoet oh

Iurlpi bhj elccottij t`i @lalebust, bhj sl t`iri os hl jinbti t`bt Hbzos bri fuoaty lk nlt`bffrissolh bhj t`i @lalebust. Elhkijirbtis t`luf`, brih‟t fuoaty lk ohvbjohf t`i Hlrt`7 t`iy brifuoaty lk jikihjohf Utbti‟s rof`ts tl `bvi bhj sieiji lvir sabviry. Basl hlti t`bt t`i @lalebustwbs hlt b falnba p`ihlcihlh t`bt leeurrij oh `ucbh eovoaozbtolhs sohei t`i nifohhohf lk toci,w`oai sabviry wbs falnba, bheoiht, bhj uhklrtuhbtiay elhsojirij beeiptbnai ny t`i cbmlrotybhj/lr flvirhohf plwirs (bs bnlrtolh ixosts bclhfst us tljby bhj ot os beeiptbnai, ivih t`luf`lhi jby ot cof`t ni lutabwij bs rbeosc uhjir t`i 2:t` Bcihjciht ―  t`luf` pir`bps hlt).Elhsojirohf t`os, Hbzo Fircbhy os fuoaty lk bffrissolh bhj b clri uhoqui bhj cljirh ivoa,w`oai t`i Elhkijirbey os fuoaty lk jikihjohf otsiak bhj ots bheoiht ivoa w`oe` tih-tl-twihty pireiht lk ots pilpai usij klr t`ior lwh provbti fbohs. Nbsij lh t`os, O t`ohg ot os kbor klrUlut`irhirs tl t`ohg ot os ohbeeurbti tl ocpay t`i Elhkijirbey bhj Hbzo Fircbhy iquba, t`luf`t`bt stoaa jlish‟t cibh t`i Elhkijirbti kabf s`luajh‟t ni riclvij krlc sleoity. 

Ok t`i ielhlcoe elhjotolh lk Fircbhy bktir VVO os w`bt pus`ij tl ohstofbti elhkaoet ohIurlpi uhjir @otair, t`ih oh rifbrj tl t`i Hbzos, t`i ebusi bhj mustokoebtolh klr t`ior betolhs brilhi bhj t`i sbci, nut oh rifbrj tl t`i Elhkijirbey, t`i ebusi bhj mustokoebtolh cby hlt ni lhibhj t`i sbci. Ulut`irhirs kiia t`bt sabviry wbsh‟t betubaay t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr ―  ot wbsebusij  ny Hlrt`irh ohvbsolh, bhj `ihei Ulut`irhirs wiri mustokoij tl kof`t. Nut ok Ulut`irhirsbri wrlhf bhj t`i ebusi lk t`i Eovoa Vbr wbs sabviry, ot eluaj stoaa `laj t`bt t`iy wiri mustokoijtl kof`t niebusi t`iy wiri ohvbjij (ispieobaay ok t`ior uhjirstbhjohf lk t`i Elhstotutolh os t`irof`t lhi, t`luf` pir`bps ot osh‟t). Lk elursi, t`bt jipihjs lh w`l ylu bsg, bhj w`bt ixbetay ost`i ebsi osh‟t cy ohtirist= cy ploht os lhay t`bt t`iri os rllc ny w`oe` tl sii t`i ebusi bhj mustokoebtolh klr t`i Elhkijirbey bs jokkiriht (bt aibst oh t`i cohjs lk cljirh Ulut`irhirs bhjElhkijirbti slajoirs), w`oai t`bt aohi osh‟t hibray bs ibsy tl jrbw klr Hbzo Fircbhy. @bjUlut`irhirs ohvbjij t`i Hlrt` tl ixpbhj sabviry, sabviry wluaj lnvolusay ni nlt` t`i ebusi bhjsupplsij mustokoebtolh lk Elhkijirbti betolh, bhj oh t`os `yplt`itoeba eoreucstbhei, t`iElhkijirbey wluaj ni elcpaitiay oh t`i wrlhf, bhj t`i jinbti bnlut t`i Elhkijirbti kabf wluaj prlnbnay hivir `bvi ivih stbrtij= t`i kabf wluaj baribjy ni flhi. Nut t`bt osh‟t w`bt `bppihij,bhj oh b sihsi, ot wluaj ni nittir ok t`bt wluaj `bvi `bppihij, klr t`ih t`iri wluaj ni hl jinbti=wi wluajh‟t ni aikt wot` bh ixostihtoba tihsolh. 

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

20/81

Z`iri os hl Jlhbaj Aovohfstlh, Bnnivoaai Ohstotuti, lr U`iany Kllti klr t`i Hbzo Tbrty Oghlw lk, bhj ok t`iri os, t`lsi se`labrs `bvi hl trui punaoe swby. Nut bs wot` t`i Orbq Ohvbsolh,vbrolus voiws lh t`i Elhkijirbey bhj ots mustokoebtolh jl `bvi trbetolh (t`luf` t`bt jlish‟t cibht`i voiws bri elrriet), prieosiay niebusi t`iri bri quistolh cbrgs, uhaogi wot` Hbzo Fircbhy.Fircbhs tljby ebh‟t jihy t`i @lalebust wbs b clrba bnlcohbtolh ―  brfubnay t`i viry sycnla lk

ivoa oh t`i cljirh elhseolushiss ―  bhj sl kbei t`ior `ostlry bhj riclvi baa kabfs, plrtrbots, ite.t`bt t`iy ebh. Z`iri os hl quistolh cbrg, nut t`iri os b quistolh cbrg oh t`i cohjs lk Ulut`irhirs(klr rof`t lr klr wrlhf), bhj sl t`iri os b `isotbtolh tl Ulut`irhirs lh w`bt t`iy s`luaj jl bnlutt`ior kabfs (socoabr tl t`i `isotbtolh ohstotutolhs bjj tl lur aovis, bs jiseronij ibraoir), bhj siiohfbs riclvohf t`ior kabfs wluaj ni bh bet w`oe` kuhetolhij bs ivojihei elhkorcohf b eirtbohribjohf lk `ostlry t`bt t`iy cby hlt ihtoriay bfrii wot`, riclvohf t`i kabfs osh‟t b socpai cbttirtl t`ic= ot puts t`ic bt ljjs wot` t`icsiavis.

@bj t`iri niih b tlrturlus cbssberi lk sox-coaaolh nabegs oh Filrfob, t`iri wluaj ni hljinbti lh w`it`ir lr hlt t`i Elhkijirbti kabf s`luaj ni riclvij. @bj t`iri niih hl ielhlcoefrluhjs klr sabviry ―  `bj ot niih jlhi klr ots lwh sbgi ―  bhj `bj t`iri niih trbetlrs bhj lt`irtie`hlalfois t`bt aissih t`i hiij klr cbhuba abnlr, bfboh, t`iri wluaj ni hl jinbti bnlut w`bt

s`luaj ni jlhi wot` plrtrbots lk ^lnirt I. Aii. Nut t`iri os b jinbti, niebusi t`i @lalebust bhjsabviry brih‟t t`i sbci. Bri t`iy nlt` occlrba< Bnslautiay, nut t`i viry kbet t`iri os b jinbtibnlut t`i Elhkijirbti kabf oh lk otsiak os ivojihei t`bt Hbzo Fircbhy bhj t`i Elhkijirbti Ulut`bri hlt iquovbaiht. @ihei, Ulut`irhirs brih‟t ihtoriay uhmustokoij tl ni bfbohst bttbegohf t`iElhkijirbti kabf, w`oai Fircbhs wluaj ni uhmustokoij tl ni bfbohst t`lsi w`l sboj t`i Hbzo kabfos b clrba bnlcohbtolh. Jlis t`bt cibh t`i Elhkijirbti kabf s`luajh‟t ni riclvij< Hlt bt baa ―  t`bt os b jokkiriht quistolh ―  hlr jlis ot cibh t`bt Elhkijirbti kabf osh‟t b sycnla lk sabviry. Zlslci jifrii, ot hieissbroay os, nut os ot 244% sue` b sycnla lr os ot lhay ;4% bhj :4% b sycnlalk kof`tohf bfbohst Hlrt`irh Bffrissolh< Tir`bps ot‟s ?4% sycnlaoe lk sabviry bhj 24% lkUtbti‟s rof`ts< V`l ebh sby< Nut siiohf bs sabviry os b clrba bnlcohbtolh, ok t`i kabf sycnlaozisot ivih 2%, t`bt balhi wluaj ni frluhjs tl riclvi ot, yis< Jipihjs lh w`l ylu bsg, nut t`oskohba ploht siics strlhf ihluf` tl ci, t`luf` t`bt jlis pltihtobaay lpih b jllr bnlut riclvohft`i Bciroebh kabf otsiak, siiohf bs ot riprisihts, bt aibst tl b jifrii lk 2%, t`i klreohf lk t`iMbpbhisi ohtl ohtirhciht ebcps jurohf VVOO, b eaibr bhj `lrroj bnlcohbtolh. Tir`bps t`bt osh‟tt`i sbci, nut t`bt jipihjs lh w`l ylu bsg, bhj sl t`iri cust ni b jinbti. Z`bt ‐jinbti‟ os w`btjiclerbey os baa bnlut, bhj bhy bet t`bt t`ribtihs jiclerbey t`ribtihs hlt lhay t`i jinbti, nutt`i bnoaoty lk pilpai tl beeipt t`i lutelci lk t`i jinbti wot`lut siviri elfhotovi josslhbheibhj/lr ixostihtoba tihsolh (b ploht t`bt woaa ni ixpbhjij lh abtir lh).

Zl baauji tl t`i t`luf`t lk @bhhb` Brjiht, pir`bps `bj Ioe`cbhh ‐t`luf`tkuaay‟cbssberij Miws, `i wluaj `bvi niih clri ivoa t`bh `i wbs klr ‐t`luf`taissay‟ jlohf sl ,  nutt`bt‟s b clrba mujfciht, t`i bhswir lk w`oe` os riabtovi, bhj rifbrjaiss, `i wbs jisirvohf lkjibt`. @bvohf t`i jinbti rosgs hlt`ohf nut ohkurobtohf ―  wi s`luaj ruh b ‐elst/nihikot bhbaysos‟  niklri ihtirtbohohf b quistolh lr cbgohf b stbticiht, t`luf` slcitocis tbgohf rosg ebh‟t ni`iapij. Aogiwosi, pir`bps t`i Elhkijirbey ‐t`luf`taissay‟ kluf`t tl jikihj Utbti‟s rof`t tlsieiji lvir sabviry, nut t`bt jlish‟t cibh Elhkijirbti kabfs s`luajh‟t ni riclvij. Cbhy woaakiia t`i kabf s`luaj ni riclvij, w`oai lt`irs woaa josbfrii, nut bt t`i viry aibst, wi ebh baa bfriit`bt hlt ivirylhi woaa s`bri t`i sbci voiw. Zljby, Bciroeb `bs tl elhvohei pilpai tl fit roj lkt`i Elhkijirbti kabf, bhj t`bt balhi os b ploht wi s`luaj tbgi ohtl elhsojirbtolh. Z`i FircbhUtbti jojh‟t ribaay `bvi tl elhvohei ots pilpai tl riclvi Hbzosc krlc ots rbhgs= Hbzo bffrissolh,joserocohbtolh, bhj t`i @lalebust aikt hl rllc klr jinbti. Z`os trut` balhi cbgis t`i

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

21/81

Elhkijirbey jokkiriht krlc Hbzo Fircbhy, t`luf` bfboh, t`bt jlish‟t cibh t`i Elhkijirbti kabfs`luajh‟t ni riclvij. 

Ok t`iri `bj niih hl @lalebust, wluaj Hbzo kabfs , t`i hbci ‐Bjlap`‟, bhj plrtrbots lk@otair ni nbhhij berlss Fircbhy< Tir`bps sl, nut pir`bps pilpai wluaj jikihj t`i Hbzo pbrtysohei ot `bj hl e`loei nut tl ohvbji Iurlpi jui tl t`i ielhlcoe sotubtolh Iurlpi klreij

Fircbhy ohtl bktir t`i VVO. Tir`bps `bj t`iri niih hl @lalebust, VVOO cof`t ni t`luf`t lkbs ‐t`i Vbr lk Iurlpibh Bffrissolh‟. Tir`bps hlt= `ostlry jlis hlt lkkir us b faocpsi ohtl baa t`itbais ot eluaj `bvi wibvis. Tir`bps poeturis lk @otair wluhj `bhf lh jospaby t`rluf`lutFircbhy, aogi poeturis lk Fihirba Aii bri jospabyij t`rluf`lut Bciroeb, bhj pir`bps t`luf`cbhy wluajh‟t aogi t`i poeturis, t`iy wluajh‟t ni nbhhij. Tir`bps hlt ―  wi ebhhlt spibgjikohotiay lk w`bt ‐eluaj ni‟, ivih t`luf` w`bt ‐eluaj ni‟ os t`i aof`t oh w`oe` wi custuhjirstbhj ‐w`bt os‟ (bhj sl wi frlpi) ―  nut frbspohf t`i ploht woaa ni viry jokkoeuat, bhj cyciri suffistolh lk t`i plssonoaoty lk b wlraj oh w`oe` @otair plrtrbots wiri hlt nbhhij woaa prlnbnay ohkurobti slci ribjirs (ispieobaay t`lsi w`l wiri voetocs lk t`i @lalebust). Nut cbgihl costbgi= O‟c hlt sbyohf t`i plrtrbots s`luajh‟t ni nbhhij hl clri t`bh O‟c sbyohf t`iElhkijirbti kabf s`luajh‟t ni tbgih jlwh krlc punaoe spbeis. O‟c lhay spibgohf oh tircs lk

 plssonoaotois sl t`bt wi ebh cbgi b nittir mujfciht bnlut `lw truay socoabr t`i Elhkijirbey oswot` t`i Hbzo pbrty.Utoaa, O kibr cbhy woaa ni kurolus bt t`os pbpir bhj t`bt cy wlrjs eluaj ibsoay ni tbgih lut

lk elhtixt oh sue` b wby t`bt O wluaj ni nbhhij krlc punaoe joselursi. Nut t`i rosg os hieissbry,klr wi cust rielfhozi t`bt lur kury bhj rbfi os b elhsiquihei lk lur alebtolh oh `ostlry bhjriabtovi tl t`i pltihtoba elursi lk `ostlry t`bt wi ‐ribaozi‟ ohtl niohf, betubaozbtolh, bhj/lr ribaoty=`bj b jokkiriht, `ostlroebaay elursi niih ‐ribaozij‟, lur icltolhs wluaj ni jokkiriht. @lw wi kiia ―  lur kury bhj rbfi ―  os must, klr t`i @lalebust joj `bppih bhj @otair wbs b clhstir, bhj sl ot osuhjirstbhjbnai t`bt wi wluaj kiia sl strlhfay bfbohst t`i ciri suffistolh lk b wlraj oh w`oe` Hbzosc bhj @otair wiri hlt ribjoay bssleobtij wot` t`i jiclhoe. Nut ok wi bri tl uhjirstbhj `lw@otair ebci tl plwir, `lw tl ribj `ostlry, bhj `lw tl t`ohg aogi t`lsi oh t`i pbst joj sl wi ebht`ohg bnlut `lw tl aovi tljby, wi custh‟t ait t`os kury bhj rbfi elhtrla bhj naohj us. Z`luf` wibri clrbaay mustokoij tl kiia kury bhj rbfi tlwbrj ivoa bhj ohmustoei, wi cust rielfhozi t`bt clrbakiiaohfs ebh ocpiji lur bnoaoty tl uhjirstbhj `ostlry bhj `lw tl bvloj ripibtohf ot. Vi t`ohg lk`ostlry kbr tll aohibray7 O kibr wi `bvi hl prlnbnoaoty t`ilry lk `ostlry. Bjcottijay, sue` b t`ilryos pbrbjlxoeba, klr `ostlry os ixbetay t`bt w`oe` osh‟t ‐prlnbnai‟ bt baa= ot os w`bt `bppihij. Nut tlaibrh krlc `ostlry, wi cust t`ohg lk ot oh tircs lk prlnbnoaoty, w`oe` os tl t`ohg lk ot oh tircs lkicpbt`y bhj oh tircs lk t`i pilpai oh `ostlry bt t`i toci w`ih t`iy wiri wiof`ohf lptolhs bhjcbgohf t`i jieosolhs t`iy cbji. Icpbt`y wot`lut prlnbnoaoty osh‟t icpbt`oe= pir`bps wi t`ohgaogi lt`irs, nut wi jlh‟t cbgi jieosolhs aogi lt`irs (bhj `ostlry os b stlry lk jieosolhs).

Baa t`os nrohfs ci tl b ploht O t`ohg wi hiij tl uhjirstbhj bnlut tljby‟s jinbti lvir t`iElhkijirbti kabf.

B ribslh Ulut`irhirs cby `isotbti tl riclvi t`i Elhkijirbti kabf krlc punaoe spbeis(ispieobaay w`ih sl jicbhjij lh b hbtolhba stbfi) os niebusi t`iy kiia bs ok t`iy ebh‟t tbgi jlwht`i kabf wot`lut elhkorcohf t`lsi w`l eaboc t`i Elhkijirbey os bs ivoa bs Hbzo Fircbhy (bhjlt`ir sue` frlups), w`ih Ulut`irhirs `bvi kbor ribslh tl t`ohg t`iy brih‟t aogi t`i Hbzos. Ok hltt`bt, Ulut`irhirs kiia bs ok tbgohf jlwh t`i kabf woaa elhkorc t`lsi w`l brfui t`bt t`i bheistlrslk Ulut`irhirs wiri baa rbeosts, bhj t`luf` t`iri cof`t ni trut` tl t`os (oh t`i sbci wby bs t`iricof`t ni trut` tl t`i eaboc t`bt t`lsi w`l supplrt bnlrtolh bri rbeosts tlwbrj t`i uhnlrh),Ulut`irhirs bri uhelcklrtbnai wot` aifotocozohf t`i gohj lk clrba lutrbfi pilpai kiia tlwbrj

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

22/81

t`i Ulut`, bh lutrbfi t`bt os riabtovi tl lur sotubtolh bhj plsotolh oh `ostlry (bs t`i lutrbfi lkt`lsi tlwbrj us b `uhjrij yibrs krlc hlw bktir bnlrtolh wbs lutabwij wluaj pir`bps ni must,bhj yit uh-icpbt`itoe). Zl tbgi jlwh t`i kabf wluaj pir`bps elhkorc t`lsi w`l t`ohg lk t`iUlut`irhirs bs kof`tohf tl jikihj bh lnvolus ivoa, w`ih t`i Ulut`irhirs oh t`ior lwh cohjseluaj `bvi niih clri sl kof`tohf jurohf t`i Eovoa Vbr klr Utbtis‟ rof`ts bhj b Mikkirslhobh

^ipunaoe, baa w`oai t`ior clrba elcpbssis wiri hifbtoviay ohkauiheij ny t`i ohstotutolhs t`iyaovij wot`oh, ebusohf t`ic tl hlt t`ohg lk sabviry bs ‐lnvolusay‟ ivoa (t`luf` wi tihj tljby tlt`ohg lk t`ic bs t`ohgohf lk sabviry bs sue`) (socoabr tl `lw wi jlh‟t t`ohg lk bnlrtolh bs‐lnvolusay‟ ivoa). Ulut`irhirs tljby kiia t`iy `bvi niih nbegij ohtl b elrhir w`iri t`iy ebh‟triclvi t`i Elhkijirbti kabf wot`lut elhkorcohf b eirtboh ohtirpritbtolh lk `ostlry. Z`iy kiia aogit`i flvirhciht os klreohf t`ic tl put t`icsiavis bs ljjs wot` t`ior `ostlroe elhseolushissis, bst`i riaofolus tljby kiia bs ok flvirhciht os klreohf t`ic tl put t`icsiavis bs ljjs wot` t`iorriaofolus elhseolushissis lvir AFNZ cbrrobfi. Ok Ulut`irhirs jojh‟t kiia t`os wby (bhj ok t`isleoity wbs nittir bt icpbt`y), riclvohf t`i kabf wluaj ni ibsoir, nut O kibr ot osh‟t sl socpai klrt`ic, bhj t`i kiiaohf os lhay ohtihsokoij ny sleoba cijob.

Zl Ulut`irhirs, tl bet oh b wby t`bt siicij tl ‐elhkorc‟ bh uhjirstbhjohf lk `ostlry t`bt

Ulut`irhirs kiia os ‐ohelcpaiti‟ wluaj ni bh ohmustoei. Ok t`i jinbti wbs socpay bnlut riclvohft`bt w`oe` nlt`irij lt`irs, pir`bps t`os wluaj ni b socpai cbttir, nut t`i jinbti os basl bnlutelhkorcohf b eirtboh uhjirstbhjohf lk w`bt t`i Ulut` joj jurohf t`i Eovoa Vbr, w`oai baslaifotocozohf t`i icltolh kiat lvir t`bt uhjirstbhjohf. O jlu nt t`bt cbhy Ulut`irhirs jlh‟t t`ohgt`bt sabviry wbs b frbvi ohmustoei, hlr jl O t`ohg beghlwaijfohf t`bt ‐sabviry wbs t`i ebusi lkt`i Eovoa Vbr‟ os b prlnaic oh lk otsiak. V`bt Ulut`irhirs josbfrii wot` os t`i iqubtohf lkElhkijirbtis tl Hbzos, t`i klrsbgohf lk t`i Mikkirslhobh vosolh lk t`i Yhotij Utbtis `iaj ny t`iElhkijirbtis oh w`oe` t`i Utbtis wiri slviriofh lvir t`i Eihtrba Flvirhciht, lvirallgohfAohelah‟s ohvbsolh lk t`i Ulut` (socoabr tl t`i ohmustoei lk ‐lvirallgohf‟ Nus`‟s ohvbjohf lkOrbq), bhj t`i kboauri tl ribaozi t`bt sabviry wbs voiwij bt t`i toci wot` t`i ‐clrba uheirtbohty‟t`bt wi voiw bnlrtolh tljby. Bhj bjcottijay, t`luf` O t`ohg t`i Elhkijirbti kabf s`luaj niriclvij krlc baa punaoe spbeis, O kiia Ulut`irhirs bri kbor oh t`os josbfriiciht.

Vot` baa t`os oh cohj, wi bpprlbe` t`i abst aif lk t`os pbpir. Z`i ebsi lk t`i Elhkijirbtikabf os socpay b sycptlc lk b abrfi, cberl-prlnaic klrcuabtohf oh Bciroeb tljby= t`i usi lkklrei bhj/lr Eihtrba plwir tl e`bhfi t`i `ibrts bhj cohjs lk t`i pilpai ―  supplsijay mustokoij ny bh bppiba lk mustoei ―  virsus e`bhfohf t`i `ibrts bhj cohjs lk t`i pilpai t`rluf` toci,brfucihtbtolh, bhj Kijirbaosc ―  bs hieissbry klr bvlojohf ixostihtoba tihsolh bhj ots jorielhsiquiheis (bs ixpbhjij lh oh ‑Iqubaoty bhj Ots Occlrba Aocots– ny L.F. ^lsi). Ulut`irhirstljby kiia t`iy bri niohf klreij tl beeipt eirtboh ojibs bhj uhjirstbhjohfs bnlut `ostlry virsus ni pirsubjij  bhj/lr tbuf`t . Aonirbas cby t`ohg ‐t`i `ostlry lk t`i Eovoa Vbr os lnvolus bhjeaibr‟ bhj sl t`i kboauri lk Ulut`irhirs tl frbsp ot os jui tl t`ior ‐nobsij uhwoaaohfhiss tl beeiptt`bt sabviry ebusij t`i Eovoa Vbr‟. Nut bs O `lpi t`os pbpir `bs cbji eaibr, Ulut`irhirs bri hltwrlhf tl t`ohg t`i Eovoa Vbr aibvis rllc klr cuatopai ohtirpritbtolhs, bhj ohjiij, ot jlis siictl ci bs ok t`lsi wot` clri Hlrt`irh bhj Aonirba sihtocihts tbgi t`i Eovoa Vbr cue` aissicpbt`itoebaay sirolusay t`bh jl Ulut`irhirs (bhj t`lsi w`l kboa tl icpbt`ozi bri basl t`lsi w`lkboa tl erotoebaay t`ohg, bs brfuij oh ‑Lh Erotoeba Z`ohgohf– ny L.F. ^lsi).

Elhsojirohf baa t`os, ot os rifrittbnai t`bt Ulut`irhirs bri cbji tl kiia bs ok t`iy bri niohfklreij tl e`llsi nitwiih punaoe aoki bhj t`ior uhjirstbhjohf lk t`i wlraj bhj `ostlry, bs ot ossocoabray rifrittbnai t`bt t`i riaofolus bri kiiaohf oheribsohfay aogi t`iy bri niohf klreij tle`llsi nitwiih t`ior punaoe aoki bhj t`ior riaofolus elhseolus bhj/lr elsclalfoeba krbciwlrg.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttp://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttp://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/257168706/On-Critical-Thinking-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/257168706/On-Critical-Thinking-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/257168706/On-Critical-Thinking-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/257168706/On-Critical-Thinking-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/257168706/On-Critical-Thinking-by-O-G-Rosehttp://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rose

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

23/81

 Hiot`ir frlup os niohf pirsubjij7 oh kbet, ot siics t`bt slci `bvi jieojij t`iy ebh‟t ni pirsubjij bhj wlrgij tl fl brluhj t`ic, w`oe` jlish‟t nlji wiaa klr jiclerbey. Bppibas tl plwir eihtirs aogi t`i flvirhciht, elurts, bhj/lr Utbti bri ivir lh t`i rosi, baa w`oai ot osoheribsohfay niaoivij t`bt lhay t`lsi w`l wiri bfbohst ihjohf ohmustoei wluaj bppiba tljiclerbtoe prleiss, brfucihtbtolh, bhj Kijirbaosc (bs wbrhij bnlut oh ‑Z`i Jibt` lk Trleiss–

 ny L.F. ^lsi). Z`i ixostihtoba tihsolh t`bt Utbti betolh ebusis cbgis Utbti betolh ixtriciayelstay. Ok t`i ploht lk t`i Utbti betolh os tl eribti tlairbhei bhj beeiptbhei, ot oh t`bt viry beteribtis t`i ixostihtoba tihsolh t`bt cbgis t`bt beeiptbhei ocplssonai bhj ohjikohbnai krlcbaoihbtolh. B sleoity oh w`oe` baoihbtolh bhj beeiptbhei bri twl-sojis lk t`i sbci eloh os bsleoity t`bt os basl ohjovosonai krlc t`i Utbti, bhj w`ih t`bt `bppihs, ‐wi t`i pilpai‟ osohjikohbnai krlc ‐wi t`i Utbti‟.

[OOO

Z`i Eovoa Vbr jojh‟t ihj7 ot e`bhfij. Ots sporot stoaa `buhts us. Aogi nbeg t`ih, cljirhBciroeb os t`i nbttaifrluhj lk b wbr nitwiih b vosolh lk prleiss bhj b vosolh lk mustoei. Zljby‟s

Uuprici Elurt jieosolh ―  Lnirfikiaa v. @ljfis Jieosolh ―  cbrgs t`i ihj lk bhlt`ir nbttai.V`it`ir lr hlt AFNZ cbrrobfi s`luaj ni rielfhozij ny baa kokty stbtis os hlt b quistolh t`bt O bcohtiristij oh `iri7 rbt`ir, cy ohtirist aois oh kleusohf lh ‐t`i wbr nitwiih prleiss bhj mustoei‟,`lw lur uhjirstbhjohf lk t`i Eovoa Vbr ohkauiheis lur uhjirstbhjohf lk t`i jossihts lk t`ijieosolh bhj kurt`ir procis us tl lpplsi bhy Kijirbaost prleiss lr krii ixe`bhfi klr t`bt cbttir(prleissis O kibr wi hiij tl bvloj ixostihtoba tihsolh bhj ots elhsiquiheis, bs brfuij oh‑Iqubaoty bhj Ots Occlrba Aocots– ny L.F. ^lsi), bhj tl `of`aof`t cy elheirh bnlut t`ifrlwohf hucnir lk Bciroebhs w`l oheribsohfay kiia aogi t`iy bri niohf klreij ny t`i EihtrbaFlvirhciht tl e`llsi nitwiih punaoe aoki bhj t`ior uhjirstbhjohf lk t`i wlraj.

Bjjotolhbaay, bh oheribsohfay hucnir lk Bciroebhs kiia t`bt oh lrjir tl ihfbfi oh punaoeaoki, t`iy `bvi tl bet oh sue` b wby t`bt siics tl aifotocozi bhj/lr ‐elhkorc‟ b eirtbohuhjirstbhjohf lk `ostlry t`bt t`iy niaoivi os ‐ohelcpaiti‟. E`rostobhs, klr ixbcpai, kiia bs ok t`iUuprici Elurt jieosolh aifotocozis t`lsi w`l krbci E`rostobhs bs noflts bhj fuoaty lkjoserocohbtolh7 `bj t`i jieosolh niih aikt up t`i Utbtis, t`luf` slci cby stoaa kiia cbhyE`rostobhs bri sl fuoaty, ot wluajh‟t ni t`i ebsi t`bt t`i Elhstotutolh otsiak wbs usij tl krbciE`rostobhs bs noflts. Oh `bvohf t`i jieosolh kbaa uhjir t`i 2:t` Bcihjciht, t`lsi oh kbvlr lkZrbjotolhba cbrrobfi bri fuoaty lk joserocohbtolh ―  t`iy bri socoabr tl t`i Ulut`irhirs w`lsupplrtij sabviry ―  w`ih Zrbjotolhbaosts kiia t`iy brih‟t fuoaty lk joserocohbtolh, nut rbt`ir jojhlt`ohf clri t`bh jikihj b jikohotolh7 bt wlrsi (t`iy bri fuoaty lk pbssoviay lkkihjohf t`lsi w`ljojh‟t bfrii wot` t`ior jikohotolh). @ihei, tl Zrbjotolhbaosts, tl bet oh b wby t`bt ocpaoij t`bt t`iy‐beeiptij t`ior mujfciht‟ wluaj ni tl krbci t`icsiavis bs noflts w`ih t`iy brih‟t noflts ―  otwluaj ni tl bet oh b wby t`bt ocpaoij b kbasoty wbs b trut`. Bhj yit Zrbjotolhbaosts, aogiUlut`irhirs, oheribsohfay kiia bs ok t`iy bri klreij ny abw bhj plwir tl bet oh b wby t`btaifotocozis bhj elhkorcs b eirtboh ribjohf bhj uhjirstbhjohf lk t`ior betolhs bhj `ostlry, w`oaibasl aifotocozohf t`i icltolhs bfbohst t`ic kiat lvir t`bt uhjirstbhjohf lk t`ior betolhs. Z`oseribtis bh ixostihtoba tihsolh wot`oh t`i Zrbjotolhbaost w`l cust jieoji nitwiih t`i punaoesp`iri bhj w`bt `i lr s`i niaoivis ―  b tihsolh t`bt O kibr lhay oheribsis t`i aogiao`llj klrelhkaoet nitwiih Zrbjotolhbaosts bhj AFNZs.

Bs joseussij oh ‑^iwbrjohf Joserocohbtolh– ny L.F. ^lsi, rof`t lr wrlhf,Zrbjotolhbaosts kiia bs ok t`iy `bvi kbor brfucihts klr w`y t`iy lpplsi AFNZ cbrrobfi ―  

https://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttp://www.scribd.com/doc/267443986/Rewarding-Discrimination-by-O-G-Rosehttp://www.scribd.com/doc/267443986/Rewarding-Discrimination-by-O-G-Rosehttp://www.scribd.com/doc/267443986/Rewarding-Discrimination-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rose

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

24/81

elhsojir klr ixbcpai t`i hlh-riaofolus nllg V`bt os Cbrrobfi< ny U`irok Forfos, ^ybh ZBhjirslh, bhj ^lnirt T Filrfi. Zl Zrbjotolhbaosts, joserocohbtolh `bs hlt`ohf tl jl wot` t`icbttir, niebusi tl t`ic, AFNZs brih‟t jihoij ‐cbrrobfi iqubaoty‟= baa `bvi iquba beeiss tlcbrrobfi, bhj t`iri os hl ‐`itirlsixubas lhay‟-sofh `bhfohf lvir t`i jllr lk t`i ohstotutolh. Klrixbcpai, b fby cbh eluaj cbrry b aisnobh wlcbh, bhj sl ihtir ohtl cbrrobfi, rieiovohf baa t`i

 nihikots bhj rof`ts t`bt beelcpbhy ot. Zl Zrbjotolhbaosts, AFNZs `bvi bawbys `bj beeiss tlcbrrobfi, must hlt lh t`ior tircs lk sixubaoty. @ihei, tl Zrbjotolhbaosts, t`i jinbti `bs hivir niihlhi bnlut ‐joserocohbtolh‟, nut bnlut ‐rijikohotolh‟  ―  t`i ripabeiciht lk cbrrobfi ny slcit`ohfiasi t`bt os rikirrij tl ny t`i sbci wlrj ―  bhj bs sue`, t`i Uuprici Elurt s`luajh‟t klreirielfhotolh lk AFNZ cbrrobfi berlss t`i eluhtry uhjir t`i prltietolh lk t`i 2:t` Bcihjciht.^bt`ir, t`i jieosolh cust ni aikt up tl t`i Utbtis, bhj ok oh t`i ihj, t`i Utbtis baa jieoji tlrijikohi cbrrobfi, t`i Zrbjotolhbaosts woaa socpay `bvi tl beeipt t`bt ribaoty. Nut oh lur bfi wot`b pbrtoeuabr, uh-icpbt`itoe vosolh lk t`i Eovoa Vbr bhj lur t`ohgohf lk Utbtis‟ rof`ts oh tircs lksabviry bhj lur uh-icpbt`itoe clrba lutrbfi, wi ebhhlt `ibr sue` b Kijirbaost voiw wot`lutquoegay bssleobtohf ot wot` frbvi ivoa (pir`bps ivih Hbzosc). O t`ohg lur uh-icpbt`itoeuhjirstbhjohf lk t`i Eovoa Vbr `iaps us mustoky oh lur cohjs t`i nypbssohf lk t`i Utbtis, procohf

us tl sgop prleiss oh t`i hbci lk mustoei, ivih w`ih t`i elhsiquiheis lk jlohf sl ebh ni t`ieribtolh bhj spribjohf lk bh ixostihtoba tihsolh t`bt cbgis aovohf tlfit`ir oh lur Taurbaostoe Bfioheribsohfay ocplssonai7 bt nist, wi ebh lhay `lpi tl survovi tlfit`ir.

Z`i Uuprici Elurt betohf oh kbvlr lk AFNZ cbrrobfi t`rluf` t`i 2:t` Bcihjcihtjipoets bhj ‐eljokois‟ Zrbjotolhbaosts bs nofltij bhj volabtlrs lk `ucbh rof`ts, bh ojihtoty O kibrt`bt t`i abw hlw ‐prissis jlwh‟ uplh Zrbjotolhbaosts, w`lsi brfucihts, t`luf` pir`bps wrlhf,bri hlt uhribslhbnai (ispieobaay, oh cy lpoholh, ok t`iy bri oh kbvlr lk ixpbhjohf baasleolielhlcoe rof`ts bhj nihikots tl AFNZs, sostirs, ite.). Z`os ebusis ixostihtoba tihsolh bhjbhxoity klr Zrbjotolhbaosts, t`luf` pir`bps t`iy jisirvi ot bktir baa t`i pboh t`ior voiws `bviebusij AFNZs< Z`bt os b sunmietovi mujfciht, nut O jl t`ohg ot‟s eaibr t`bt w`iri sue` ixostihtobatihsolh ixosts, ot woaa ni `brj klr pilpai tl aovi tlfit`ir, ispieobaay oh lur Taurbaostoe Bfi. Bhjyis, pir`bps baa t`i Zrbjotolhbaost brfucihts bnlut cbrrobfi bhj prleiss bri wrlhf, bhj pir`bpst`isi brfucihts bri lhay cbji ny noflts tryohf tl `oji t`i kbet t`bt t`iy bri noflts lr w`l britr yohf tl `oji krlc t`icsiavis t`bt t`iy bri noflts. Nut giip oh cohj t`bt lhi‟s nofltry jlish‟tcbgi w`bt lhi sbys bhy clri lr aiss trui ―  b noflt w`l sbys ‐> + > 3 :‟ sbys slcit`ohf trui.

@bj AFNZ cbrrobfi niih ixpbhjij t`rluf` t`i Utbtis oh aohi wot` t`i Kijirbaost vosolh,Zrbjotolhbaosts wluajh‟t hieissbroay `bvi tl ni krbcij bs noflts7 kurt`irclri, socoabr tl t`isotubtolh kbeij ny Ulut`irhirs w`ih ot elcis tl riclvohf t`i Elhkijirbti kabf, bhyZrbjotolhbaost betolh t`bt beeiptij AFNZ cbrrobfi wluajh‟t hieissbroay aifotocozi lr ocpay t`ivbaojoty lk t`i ribjohf lk `ostlry t`bt elhsojirs t`ic ‐fuoaty lk joserocohbtolh‟. Klr ot os viryjokkiriht w`ih b Utbti nifohs AFNZ cbrrobfi ny e`bhfohf ots abw, virsus sbyohf AFNZ cbrrobfis`luaj `bvi bawbys niih bvboab nai, nut ot wbsh‟t jui tl uhrielfhozij volabtolhs lk t`i 2:t` Bcihjciht. Z`i korst, Kijirbaost wby sbys Zrbjotolhbaosts wirih‟t bawbys oh t`i wrlhf, t`luf`hlw t`i jiclerbtoe jinbti os lvir, w`oai t`i e`bhfi t`rluf` t`i Uuprici Elurt jieosolh prleabocs Zrbjotolhbaosts wiri bawbys oh t`i wrlhf, bhj hlw t`i abw woaa beghlwaijfi t`btribaoty bhj `ostlry lk joserocohbtolh. Z`i ixostihtoba elhsiquiheis lk t`i sielhj bri cue` clrisiviri t`bh t`i elhsiquiheis lk t`i korst, Kijirbaost wby.

Tir`bps Zrbjotolhbaosts jisirvi tl ni Elhstotutolhbaay krbcij bs noflts, nut pir`bps hlt. Ojlh‟t cibh tl suffist t`bt t`i 2: t` Bcihjciht s`luaj hivir ni usij, hlr jl O cibh tl suffistt`bt AFNZ cbrrobfi s`luajh‟t ni rielfhozij ny baa kokty stbtis. Z`lsi bri jokkiriht quistolhs. 

http://www.amazon.com/Sherif-Girgis/e/B007DMWHQS/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_1http://www.amazon.com/Ryan-T-Anderson/e/B00A0P0MR6/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_2http://www.amazon.com/Ryan-T-Anderson/e/B00A0P0MR6/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_2http://www.amazon.com/Robert-P-George/e/B001ILI93A/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_3http://www.amazon.com/Robert-P-George/e/B001ILI93A/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_3http://www.amazon.com/Ryan-T-Anderson/e/B00A0P0MR6/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_2http://www.amazon.com/Ryan-T-Anderson/e/B00A0P0MR6/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_2http://www.amazon.com/Sherif-Girgis/e/B007DMWHQS/ref=dp_byline_cont_book_1

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

25/81

Tirslhbaay, O bc oh kbvlr lk riwrotohf t`i cbrotba nihikots bhj rielfhotolhs sl t`bt baa ebaonrbtolhslk aovohf elcnohbtolhs cby `bvi beeiss tl t`lsi nihikots bhj rielfhotolhs, klr ivih bktir tljby‟sUuprici Elurt jieosolh, sostir w`l aovi tlfit`ir hlh-sixubaay stoaa jlh‟t `bvi beeiss tl t`isleolielhlcoe nihikots bhj rof`ts bvboabnai tl `itirlsixubas bhj AFNZs. Nut t`bt sboj, O bccue` clri oh kbvlr lk Mikkirslh‟s vosolh t`i ^ipunaoebh t`bh t`i Aohelah‟s vosolh lk t`i Yholh= O

 niaoivi slviriofhty s`luaj elci krlc t`i Utbtis tl t`i Kijirba Flvirhciht, hlt slviriofhtyelci krlc t`i Kijirba Flvirhciht tl t`i Utbtis. Lt`irwosi, O kibr t`i Eihtrba Flvirhciht os kbrtll plwirkua, bhj sielhjay, O t`ohg t`i ixostihtoba elhsiquiheis lk Eihtrba Flvirhciht betolh oskbr elstaoir t`bh Kijirbaost betolh.

@bj b Kijirbaost cljia niih klaalwij tl ixpbhj AFNZ cbrrobfi berlss t`i eluhtry ―  t`iabeg lk w`oe` baa klur jossihtirs lk t`i Lnirfikiaa v. @ljfis jieosolh abcihtij (bhjelhsiquihtay wiri abcnbstij bs noflts klr jlohf sl) ―  `bj Zrbjotolhbaosts niih pirsubjij tle`bhfi t`ior voiws lr alst t`rluf` jiclerbtoe prleiss, t`bt wluaj ni lhi t`ohf, nut t`iy wirirbt`ir klreij (w`oai socuatbhilusay niohf krbcij bs noflts klr jikihjohf b voiw lk cbrrobfi t`btt`iy `bvi brfucihts klr niaoivohf oh). Ok b flba lk t`i AFNZ clviciht wbs beeiptbhei, O kibrt`bt flba `bs nielci clri jokkoeuat tl be`oivi= usi lk klrei `bs ixostihtoba elhsiquiheis (bs

bjclhos`ij oh ‑Iqubaoty bhj Ots Occlrba Aocots– ny L.F. ^lsi). Tirslhbaay, O bc elheirhijt`bt t`i Uuprici Elurt jieosolh woaa cbgi ot clri jokkoeuat klr cy AFNZ kroihjs tl be`oivi truibeeiptbhei t`bh `bj t`i jieosolh niih cbji t`rluf` t`i Utbtis, nut lk elursi, bhylhi w`l ribjst`bt sihtihei woaa hlt niaoivi O‟c fihuohi. Z`iy woaa bssuci O bc lhay sbyohf t`bt tl `oji cy nofltry, Kuhjbcihtbaost ojilalfy, bhj/lr Elhsirvbtovi aibhohfs ―  pilpai `bvi niih sl procij ohlur Bfi lk Eyhoeosc (wbr hij bnlut ny Jbvoj Klstir Vbaabei bhj wipt lvir oh ‑Ueroptij– bhj‑Elaaietovi Elhseolushiss bhj Zrust–, nlt` ny L.F. ^lsi). Bhj oh t`os wby, O kibr lur Bfi lkEyhoeosc wlrgs bfbohst t`i `bppohiss lk AFNZs bhj oh kbvlr lk bh ivir oheribsohf EihtrbaFlvirhciht. Nut lk elursi, O woaa lhay ni t`luf`t lk bs abcihtohf lur Bfi lk Eyhoeosc bs b wbytl `oji cy nofltry.

Eyhoeosc os aoki.Ot t`os jivialpciht cbgis ci wlrry bnlut t`i kuturi clri t`bh bhyt`ohf.

OP 

Eyhoeosc ebh ni b wby tl prltiet lhi‟s siak krlc bhxoity= ny jieojohf iviryt`ohf os ivoa,wrlhf, stupoj, ite., hlt`ohf ebh `urt us bhyclri. @ihei, ot os hlt surprosohf t`bt w`bt Bujihebaaij t`i Bfi lk Bhxoity `bs niih klaalwij ny t`i Bfi lk Eyhoeosc.

Viaelci, t`luf` O supplsi ylu‟vi niih `iri klr bw`oai.Oh lur Bfi lk Eyhoeosc, lhei wi jieoji slcilhi os b noflt, t`iri os hlt`ohf t`iy ebh jl

tl stlp niohf b noflt oh lur iyis (w`oe` s`luajh‟t surprosi us, siiohf bs t`i eaboc ‐ylu bri b noflt‟ ebhhlt ni virokoij lr kbasokoij, sohei t`i stbhjbrj klr jitircohohf sue` os riabtovi). Lheiwi jieoji E`rostobhs `bti AFNZs, t`bt Elhsirvbtovis bri ealsi-cohjij, t`bt Ulut`irhirs brirbeosts ―  t`bt elhvirsbtolh stlps. Hl cbttir `lw cue` t`i jossihtirs lk t`i Uuprici Elurtjieosolh eabocij t`iy jojh‟t ebri bnlut ok Utbtis pbssij AFNZ cbrrobfi lr hlt, t`bt w`btelheirhij t`ic w`bt t`i prleiss ny w`oe` sue` wbs jitircohij, t`i sleoity tribtij t`ic bs okt`iy wiri noflts lhay bppibaohf tl Utbti plwir oh lrjir tl stlp AFNZ cbrrobfi. Bppibas tl prleiss `bvi niih uttiray elhkabtij wot` bppibas tl b plsotolh, t`i elsts lk w`oe` bri jori(wbrhij bnlut oh ‑Z`i Jibt` lk Trleiss– ny L.F. ^lsi). Kurt`irclri, wi elci tl t`ohg ot osivih ‐uhmust‟ tl elhsojir t`i brfucihts lk t`i jossihtirs, siiohf bs wi oh lur cohjs elhkabti

https://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rosehttps://www.scribd.com/doc/259799477/Equality-and-Its-Immoral-Limits-by-O-G-Rose

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

26/81

w`bt t`iy bri sbyohf wot` niohf bfbohst AFNZ cbrrobfi. Lur icltolhs, abeg lk icpbt`y, bhjwby lk uhjirstbhjohf t`i Eovoa Vbr cbgi us hlt lhay ohebpbnai lk frbspohf brfucihts oh kbvlrlk b Kijirbaost prleiss, nut cbgi us ivih clrba tl hlt elhsojir t`ic. Vi quistolh t`i cltovislk t`lsi w`l bppiba tl prleiss, ebaa w`bt t`iy sby ohtl quistolh, nut ivih ok t`iy bri baa noflts,jlis t`bt cbgi bhyt`ohf t`iy sby clri lr aiss trui< V`bt os trui splgih ny b noflt os trui w`ih

splgih ny b sboht. Ok ot os ohjiij t`i ebsi t`bt Kijirbaosc os t`i lhay wby ny w`oe` wi ebh aovitlfit`ir oh lur Taurbaostoe Bfi ―  ok ot os ohjiij t`i lhay cibhs ny w`oe` AFNZs ebh be`oivi ‐truibeeiptbhei ―  t`isi tihjiheois lk lurs woaa ni w`bt prisirvis ohmustoei oh t`i hbci lk mustoei. Lureyhoeosc tlwbrj t`lsi w`l supplrt Kijirbaosc, w`oe` wi kiia lut lk lur jisori klr AFNZs tl nibeeiptij bhj tl ‐rllt lut‟ noflts, woaa kuhetolh tl prisirvis kiiaohfs lk rimietolh bhj t`i kiiaohft`bt nofltry stoaa aurgs baa brluhj oh sierit. Ok ot os t`i ebsi t`bt AFNZs woaa hivir ni `bppy uhaisst`i Utbtis beeipt AFNZ cbrrobfi lhi bt b toci t`rluf` Kijirbaost prleiss, t`ih ot os t`i ebsi t`btbktir tljby, AFNZs woaa hivir ni `bppy bs b risuat lk lur ikklrts tl `iap AFNZs kiia fihuohiaybeeiptij.

Nut lk elursi, O‟c lhay sbyohf baa t`os bnlut t`i jbhfirs lk eyhoeosc niebusi O‟c b noflt.  Itirhba rifrissolh.

V`bt `lpi jl wi `bvi tl aovi tlfit`ir

8/19/2019 The War Between Process and Justice by O.G. Rose (Unedited)

27/81

Z`i sbci eluaj `bppih ok slcilhi sboj tl ci t`bt ‐O‟c hlt bfbohst AFNZ cbrrobfi, nutcbrrobfi s`luaj ni jikohij ny t`i Utbtis‟ ―  O eluaj ibsoay jieoji t`i pirslh betubaay `btisAFNZs bhj os lhay bppibaohf tl Kijirbaosc tl `oji `os lr `ir nofltry (b mujfciht cyuhjirstbhjohf lk t`i Eovoa Vbr cby `iap aifotocozi oh cy cohj). Oh niohf b eyhoe, O bpplohtcysiak t`i mujfi lk `ucbh `ibrts, bhj w`bt eluaj bhylhi jl tl prlvi cy mujfcihts wrlhf< Cy

 mujfciht ebhhlt ni kbasokoij (w`oe` Gbra Tlppir wbrhij us bnlut), lr ivih virokoij klr t`btcbttir, nut oh niohf eyhoeba, O kiia t`bt cy mujfciht os virokoij, bs O basl kiia mustokoij tl ohtirpritbaa betolhs lk t`i pirslh tl ‐prlvi ci wrlhf‟ bs ikk lrts tl `oji `os lr `ir nofltry (w`oe` t`i pirslh, O eluaj jieoji, jlish‟t ivih ribaozi `i lr s`i os fuoaty lk ―  ots sunelhseolus). Hlt lhay oh niohf eyhoeba jl O pabei cysiak oh b pabei lk lhtlalfoeba provoaifi, O basl ebst mujfcihts t`btebhhlt ni kbasokoij, `ihei prisirvohf bhj prltistohf cysiak krlc niohf ‐jit`rlhij‟, pir si. V`ihivirylhi sots uplh b t`rlhi wot`lut plssonoaoty lk riclvba, t`rlhis nielci e`bors.

Tir`bps ot os hlt surprosohf t`bt t`i Ihaof`tihciht aibj tl eyhoeosc, klr eyhoeosc fovis usb ‐kiiaohf‟ lk ihaof`tihciht bhj ‐stbhjohf lut krlc/lk t`i wlraj‟ oh b wlraj w`iri hl sue`‐stbhjohf lut krlc/lk‟ os plssonai. Lhtlalfoeba provoaifi niohf uhbe`oivbnai, wi sittai wot`kiiaohf lhtlalfoebaay provoaifij, ispieobaay ok suseiptonai tl Icltolhba Mujfciht (bs wrottih

bnlut ny L.F. ^lsi). Eyhoeosc `bs `bj b prlkluhj bhj jivbstbtohf ikkiet lh cljirh baovi, bhj Ojlh‟t niaoivi ot os plssonai klr us tl survovi Taurbaosc ok eyhoeosc os lur ziotfiost= w`iri t`iri oseyhoeosc, t`i @bnircbsobh prlmiet cust kboa. ^bt`ir, wi cust ni icpbt`itoe bhj ‐bssuci t`i nist‟, bs brfuij oh ‑Bssucohf t`i Nist– ny L.F. ^lsi. Bhj bs wi cust hlt ni eyhoe tlwbrj lhibhlt`ir aist wi ni ‐alegij wot`oh lursiavis krlc lhi bhlt`ir‟ (aogi ‐ojolts‟, bs uhjirstllj ohFriig), sl wi cust hlt ni eyhoeba w`ih wi allg nbeg uplh `ostlry lr ribj (aist wi ni ‐ojolts‟).

 Hl eyhoe s`luaj jl `ostlry. Ok wi jl hlt ‐bssuci t`i nist‟ w`ih wi ribj `ostlry,  wiwlh‟t aibrh `ostlry, ait balhi bhyt`ohf bnlut pilpai. Eyhoeba, wi kabttih t`i jyhbcoe e`brbetirslk `ostlry ohtl w`l t`iy hivir wiri, rijuei w`bt pilpai ixpiroiheij bs e`loeis ohtl kbtis, bhjslw s`ut t`ior iyis bhj sii t`i wlraj klr t`ic hlt oh tircs lk t`ior cohjs, nut oh tircs lk lurs.Vi cbgi lursiavis w`l t`i pilpai lk `ostlry s`luaj `bvi t`luf`t aogi, oh t`i sbci wby t`btw`ih wi bri eyhoeba tl lhi bhlt`ir bs pilpai, wi cbgi lursiavis t`i cljia baa s`luaj aovi tlicuabti. Bhj yit lktih lur eyhoeosc icirfis tlwbrj t`lsi w`l wi niaoivi bri nofltij,ohtlairbht, bfbohst jovirsoty, ite.= wi bri lktih eyhoeba tlwbrj t`lsi w`l wi niaoivi wbhtivirylhi tl ni aogi t`ic.

Eyhoeosc os hl strbhfir tl orlhy bhj `yplerosy.B eyhoeba `ircihiutoes os b siakos` `ircihiutoes= ot tiaas us clri bnlut t`i ribjir t`bh ot

jlis t`i tixt. Bhj w`bt ebh b wrotir, ait balhi bhylhi, jl bfbohst sue` eyhoeosc< Z`luf` t`iribri cbhy ixbcpais krlc t`os wlrg t`bt eluaj ni usij, tbgi t`isi krlc t`i viry nifohhohf lk t`i pbpir=

Cy lwh pirslhba t`luf`ts lh t`i kabf bhj Eovoa Vbr elhtrlvirsy= O niaoivi t`bt `bj t`iri niih hl sabviry, t`iri wluaj `bvi niihhl Eovoa Vbr, bhj t`bt baa kabfs ixeipt Bciroebh bhj Utbti kabfs s`luaj ni riclvij krlc punaoe spbeis. Z`os os cy plsotolh, sl

hlw ylu ghlw t`bt ny hl cibhs oh t`os wlrg bc O tryohf tl jikihj eirtboh Elhkijirbti-aibhohf voiws bnlut t`i kabf bhj EovoaVbr. V`bt O bc tryohf tl jl, `lwivir, os uhjirstbhj Elhkijirbti t`ohgohf, w`oe` bfboh, os hlt t`i sbci bs klrfovohfElhkijirbtis, hl clri t`bh uhjirstbhjohf Hbzosc os klrfovohf ot. Z`os pbpir os hl mustokoebtolh klr t`i Elhkijirbey, nut bh bet lkicpbt`ozohf wot` t`i Elhkijirbey7 t`os os hl wlrg lk sycpbt`y, nut b wlrg t`bt btticpts tl ‐stip ohtl t`ior s`lis‟ sl t`bt wi ebhuhjirstbhj `lw t`iy t`luf`t, kiat, bhj cbji jieosolhs, sl t`bt wi ebh aovi tlfit`ir bs b jovirsi pilpai bhj hlt ripibt t`iorcostbgis. Cy `lpi oh t`os wlrg os tl `iap us aibrh icpbt`y (hlt sycpbt`y), niebusi wot`lut t`bt, wi ebhhlt t`ohg erotoebaay,w`oe` oh lur Taurbaostoe Bfi, wi riquori clri t`bh ivir.

Ibsoay, slcilhi eluaj eaboc O lhay wrlti ‐ny hl cibh oh t`os wlrg bc O tryohf tl jikihjeirtboh Elhkijirbti-aibvohf voiws‟ oh lrjir tl `oji cy Elhkijirbti sycpbt`ois, pir`bps

https://www.scribd.com/doc/15