Top Banner
Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin
50

Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Jan 04, 2016

Download

Documents

Gillian Barnett
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness

Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin

Page 2: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Introduction• Faces can be

discriminated from other objects, even when they are not consciously visible

• However, it is not

clear which type of subordinate information is processed (identity? Race? Gender? Expression? Just categorical?)

Morris, J.P., Pelphrey, K.A. & McCarthy, G. (2007). Processing without awareness in the right fusiform gyrus. Neuropsychologia

Page 3: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Methods: Gender and Race Adaptation (Webster, Kaping, Mizokami & Kuhamel, 2004)

Adaptor (male/female) Target (unclear gender)

Adaptation effect = (%adaptor and target were incongruent ) - (%adaptor and target were congruent)

Page 4: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

MethodsFemale male

Asian European

Page 5: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 6: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 7: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 8: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 9: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 10: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 11: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 12: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 13: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 14: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 15: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 16: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 17: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 18: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 19: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 20: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 21: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 22: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 23: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 24: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 25: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 26: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 27: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 28: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 29: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 30: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 31: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 32: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 33: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 34: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 35: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 36: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 37: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 38: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 39: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 40: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 41: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

CFS (invisible)

No CFS (visible)

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Dominant

Methods

Page 42: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Gender

Race

Non Dominant

Methods

1000 / 2500 / 4000 / 5000 ms

Page 43: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

300ms (ISI)

Dominant

300ms (ISI)

Methods

Page 44: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

300ms (ISI)

Dominant

300ms (ISI)

Methods

Page 45: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Predictions

• The occurrence of a bias when the adaptor is invisible would indicate that information about gender and race can be extracted from invisible faces.

• If the bias would occur only when the adaptors are visible, it would mean that such information is dependent on conscious awareness.

Page 46: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Results

Page 47: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

**

*

* **

Page 48: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

The Correlation between effect size and visibility

p = 0.12 p < 0.025

Page 49: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Summary

• The goal of the present study was to determine whether information about race and gender can be processed without awareness.

• We examined whether the presentation of adaptor faces can bias the classification of an ambiguous face’s gender or race when the adaptor is not consciously visible.

Page 50: Subordinate Categorization Requires Conscious Awareness Ido Amihai, Leon Deouell, and Shlomo Bentin.

Conclusions

• An adaptation effect occurred that correlates and increases with subjective visibility.

• Information about a faces gender and race depends on the amount of time that a face is subjectively visible for.