8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
1/22
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
2/22
St. Thomas Aquinas was an Italian Catholic priestin the Dominican Order, and an immenselyinfluential philosopher and theologian in thescholastic tradition, known as Doctor Angelicus,Doctor Universalis and Doctor Communis. He was
the foremost classical proponent of naturaltheology, and the father of the Thomistic school ofphilosophy and theology. His influence on Westernthought is considerable, and much of modernphilosophy was conceived as a reaction against,
or as an agreement with, his ideas, particularly inthe areas of ethics, natural law and political
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
3/22
Aquinas is held in the Catholic Church to be themodel teacher for those studying for thepriesthood. The works for which he is best-knownare the Summa Theologica and the SummaContra Gentiles, One of the 33 Doctors of the
Church, he is considered by many Catholics to bethe Catholic Church's greatest theologian andphilosopher. Consequently, many institutions oflearning have been named after him.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
4/22
Aquinas was born c. 1225 in the kingdom of Sicily.At the age of five, Aquinas began his earlyeducation at Monte Cassino. After his elementaryeducation, he went on to study at the Universityof Naples, where he studied for six years before
leaving when he was 16. Aquinas had come underthe influence of the Dominicans, who wished toenlist the ablest young scholars of the age. TheDominicans and the Franciscans represented a
revolutionary challenge to the well-establishedclerical s stems of Medieval Euro e.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
5/22
His superiors saw his great aptitude for theologicalstudy. In late 1244, they sent him to the Dominicanschool in Cologne, where Albertus Magnus waslecturing on philosophy and theology. In 1245, Aquinasaccompanied Albertus to the University of Paris herethey remained for three years. During this time,Aquinas threw himself into the controversy betweenthe university and the Friar-Preachers about the libertyof teaching.
Aquinas then graduated as a bachelor of theology. In1248, he returned to Cologne, where he was appointedsecond lecturer and magister studentium. This yearmarks the beginning of his literary activity and publiclife.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
6/22
The philosophy of Aquinas has exerted enormousinfluence on subsequent Christian theology, especiallythat of the Roman Catholic Church, extending toWestern philosophy in general, where he stands as avehicle and modifier of Aristotelianism, which he fused
with the thought of Augustine. Philosophically, hismost important and enduring work is the SummaTheologica,in which he expounds his systematictheology of the quinquae viae.
Aquinas believed that truth is known through reasonnatural revelation and faith su ernatural revelation .
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
7/22
Aquinas believed "that for the knowledge of anytruth whatsoever man needs Divine help, that theintellect may be moved by God to its act."However, he believed that human beings have thenatural capacity to know many things without
special divine revelation, even though suchrevelation occurs from time to time, "especially inregard to [topics of] faith. Aquinas was also anAristotelian and an empiricist. He substantially
influenced these two streams of Western thought.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
8/22
Resurgence of Christianity during the 12th
and 13th centuries the theological supplement to the teleological
concept of the nature of the law gainedascendancy
St. Thomas Aquinas - thought of the law as aninstitution ordained by God
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
9/22
The ultimate source of laws was substituted bythe power of God who governs all things by therational arrangement and distribution of his divineprovidence.
The Church was considered as the authoritativeinterpreter and final arbiter.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
10/22
The doctrines of right and justice were blendedwith the basic principles of Christianity asinterpreted by the Church.
THOMISTIC PHILOSOPHY OF LAW
-Primacy of a higher law over positive law
St. Thomas Aquinas believed in the rationalcapacity of men to know the absolute good.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
11/22
Reason influenced by sensation is not sufficient tobring men to a correct understanding of what is rightand just.
Right reason (sophia) is the governing idea to bring
man to his well being that is in real harmony with hissocial relations.
Summa Theologica-St. Thomas Aquinas introduced a combination of right
reason and justice and equity, infusing it with profoundobservation that the first rinci le of an conce t is its
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
12/22
Law (jus) - is an ordinance of right reason for thecommon good and happiness, laid down by himwho has the care and welfare of the wholecommunity, and made public by those in authorityto those who are subject to it.
Law (lex) - a rule and measure of acts, wherebyman is induced to act or is restrained from acting.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
13/22
Two Aspects:
- As an ethical (moral)
virtue- As a juristic (secular)
norm
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
14/22
As an ethical or moral virtue- Justice is considered to be inherent inevery person
As a juristic or secular norm-- habit whereby man renders to each onehis due by a constant and perpetual will
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
15/22
Puts an emphasis on the fundamental ideaof consideration for others and the basicprinciple of equality of men in their relationwith one another.
Justice in its secular sense cannot beseparated from ethical or moral justice.- What is ones due depends on the norms
of ethical or moral justice
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
16/22
Best application of juristic or secularjustice:
3.It must come from one in and with
authority4.It must come from one with a particulardisposition or propensity for justice5.It must conform to right judgment
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
17/22
The public welfare or the commonhappiness is the first concern of the peoplesince anything concerns a person to whomthe end or purpose belongs.
The law is ordained for the sake oflawness or the common good andhappiness
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
18/22
The task belongs either to the people orto someone who is the vicegerent of thepeople
The compulsive force or authority todetermine the form and content of thelegal precepts inheres and emanates fromthe people
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
19/22
There is need to emphasize that changes dooccur in the subsequent applications of thelaw and that these changes may be byexpansion or contraction in accordance withthe civilization of time and place.
The reason why there are changes in thesubsequent applications of the first principleis that human decisions vary in the choice of
means to realize the ends that are implicit inthe first principles.
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
20/22
Change may be through:
ExtensionContractionSuper imposition of somethingdifferent
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
21/22
Basis: assumption that it is for thewelfare of the community
Ex. Concept of ownershipGeneral freedom and libertyFreedom of expression
8/14/2019 St. Thomas (Group 6) - Legal Philosophy
22/22