This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis mniSvne-lovani gadawyvetilebebi. am da sxva saqmeTa moZebna SesaZle-belia saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos veb-gverdze:http://www.supremecourt.ge/default.aspx?sec_id=133&lang=1
s i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i s
z o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z o
n a w i l e b in a w i l e b in a w i l e b in a w i l e b in a w i l e b i
s i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i ss i s x l i s s a m a r T l i s
p r o c e s ip r o c e s ip r o c e s ip r o c e s ip r o c e s i
modgenili saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilob-riv, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlilebaSemdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakma-risi da utyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivruleWvs miRma dasturdeba, rom msjavrdebulma b. t-m namdvi-lad Caidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis bralad Se-racxuli qmedeba, rasac arc mxareebi xdian sadavod.
3. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris mier sa-CivarSi miTiTebul pozicias imis Sesaxeb, rom saapelaciosasamarTlos gadawyvetileba ewinaaRmdegeba saqarTve-los uzenaesi sasamarTlos didi palatis 2014 wlis 25 Te-bervlis ganaCens da aRniSnavs, rom uzenaesi sasamarTlosxsenebul gadawyvetilebaSi miTiTebulia ganaCenTa er-Tobliobis dros sasjelis gansazRvris sakiTxze proku-roris poziciis ararsebobis pirobebSi sauaresod Sebru-nebis dauSveblobis Taobaze da ara _ konkretuli mux-lisTvis sanqciis saxis/zomis gansazRvris Sesaxeb.
4. amasTan, sakasacio palata saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-emuxlis Sesabamisad, mxedvelobaSi iRebs b. t-s mier Cade-nili qmedebis xasiaTsa da simZimes, qmedebaSi gamovlenilmarTlsawinaaRmdego nebas, movaleobaTa darRvevis xasi-aTs da miaCnia, rom samarTliani iqneba misTvis ganaCenTaerTobliobiT sasjelis gansazRvra STanTqmis wesis gamo-yenebiT.
modgenili saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilob-riv, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlilebaSemdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakma-risi da utyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivruleWvs miRma dasturdeba, rom msjavrdebulma t. m-ma nam-dvilad Caidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis braladSeracxuli qmedeba. misi braleuloba dadasturebuliamowmeebis _ l. C-s, k. T-s, d. x-s, l. k-s, p. S-s, a. a-s, n. i-sa dav. Z-s CvenebebiT, eqspertebis _ m. W-s, n. l-sa da s. c-s Cve-nebebiTa da maT mier gacemuli eqspertizebis daskvnebiT,msjavrdebul t. m-s piradi Cxrekis oqmiTa da saqmeSi ar-sebuli sxva urTierTSeTanxmebuli mtkicebulebebiT.
3. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris mier sa-CivarSi miTiTebul argumentebs dakavebisa da bralis war-dgenis vadebis darRvevis Taobaze, vinaidan saqmis masa-lebis Seswavlisa da mxareTa poziciebis mosmenis Sede-
11
gad aRniSnuli garemoebebi ar dadasturda.4. amasTan, sakasacio palata saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e
muxlis Sesabamisad, mxedvelobaSi iRebs t. m-s pirovne-bas, mis warsul cxovrebas, amoRebuli narkotikuli saSu-alebis odenobas da miaCnia, rom samarTliani iqneba mis-Tvis daniSnuli sasjelis Semsubuqeba.
m. j-s interesebis damcvelma, advokatma z. q-m. man moiT-xova ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setana da msjavrdebulisaTvisiseTi sasjelis daniSvna, romelic ar iqneba dakavSirebu-li Tavisuflebis aRkveTasTan.
liza warmodgenili saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida imdaskvnamde, rom sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes,xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. palatas miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi da ut-yuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivrul eWvs miRmadasturdeba, rom msjavrdebulma m. j-m namdvilad Caidi-na gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis bralad Seracxuliqmedeba, rasac arc mxareebi xdian sadavod.
3. amasTan, sakasacio palata saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-emuxlis Sesabamisad, mxedvelobaSi iRebs m. j-s mier Cade-nili qmedebis xasiaTsa da simZimes, qmedebaSi gamovlenilmarTlsawinaaRmdego nebas da miaCnia, rom samarTliani iq-neba misTvis daniSnuli sasjelis Semsubuqeba. kerZod:
4. msjavrdebul m. j-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 344-e muxlis1-li nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis CadenisTvissasjelis saxiT unda ganesazRvros jarima, rac misi pa-timrobaSi yofnis vadis gaTvaliswinebiT, unda CaeTvalosmoxdilad.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. msjavrdebuli c. a-e saapelacio saCivriT iTxovdamis mimarT gamotanili gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqme-basa da gamarTlebas im motiviT, rom saqmeze Sekrebilimtkicebulebebi ar iyo damajerebeli da utyuari, rac sa-bolood ver uzrunvelyofda gonivrul eWvs miRma arse-bul mtkicebulebaTa standarts.
3. saapelacio palatis sxdomaze apelantis, msjavrde-bul c. a-s Sesavali, daskvniTi da saboloo sityvis mixed-viT ar ikveTeba aSkarad da mkafiod is garemoeba, rom mansrulad aRiara gamamtyunebeli ganaCeniT dadgenili faq-tobrivi garemoebebi da ganaCeni gaxada sadavod mxolodsasjelis nawilSi, miuxedavad imisa, rom man daazusta sa-apelacio saCivris moTxovna da moiTxova jarimis Semci-reba, amasTan, is ganmartavda, rom mas araferi dauSave-bia, an ar gaukeTebia iseTi ram, rom ase mkacrad daisajos.
4. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul c. a-shqonda ara mxolod mis mimarT sasjelis saxiT daniSnulijarimis 100 laramde Semcirebis moTxovna, aramed asevealternativis saxiT iTxovda mis mimarT gamamarTlebeliganaCenis gamotanas.
5. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palata msjav-rdebul c. a-s sakasacio saCivris moTxovnis safuZvelzesaqmes amowmebs kanonierebis mxriv sruli moculobiT.
6. sakasacio palata Tvlis, rom saqmeze Sekrebili mtki-cebulebebiT msjavrdebul c. a-s braleuloba saqarTve-
21
los ssk-is 120-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis Ca-denaSi dadasturebulia gonivrul eWvs miRma arsebulistandartiT da misi moTxovna gamarTlebis Taobaze arisusafuZvlo da kanonSeusabamo.
7. 1-li instanciis sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmis saxiTdakiTxul dazaralebul e. s-s mier micemuli Tanmimdev-ruli CvenebiT dadasturebulia, rom 2014 wlis 24 Teber-vals, dRis meore naxevarSi, masa da c. a-s Soris moxda kon-fliqti. maT miwis nakveTTan dakavSirebiT didi xania aqvTojaxuri uTanxmoeba. c. a-m Tavisi Robis SigniTa mxridanucenzuro sityvebiT dauwyo sityvieri Seuracxyofis mi-yeneba da aseve misi mimarTulebiT qvebisa da xis naWrebissrola. mas sxeulze moxvda ramdenime qva, xolo erT-er-Ti xis naWeri moxvda marjvena xelis mtevanSi da SeniSna,rom xelis mtevanze SerWobili hqonda xis naWris natexi,romlis damoukideblad amoReba ver moaxerxa. is wavidabaTumis respublikur saavadmyofoSi, sadac eqimma amou-Ro xis naWeri da daumuSava Wriloba. xelis tkivilis gamois didxans ver axerxebda fizikur muSaobas.
8. dazaralebul e. s-s aRniSnuli Cvenebis faqtobrivigaremoebebi srulad Tanxvdenilia gamoZiebis etapze sa-gamoZiebo eqsperimentis Catarebis dros mis mier mice-mul CvenebasTan. oqmis mixedviT, e. s-m miuTiTa is adgili,sadac moxda masa da c. a-s Soris fizikuri Seuracxyofa,saidanac e. s-s esrola qvebi da xis naWrebi.
9. msjavrdebul c. a-a da e. s-s Soris momxdar konfliqtsadasturebs mowme T. m-e. misi CvenebiT, e. s-e muSaobda mi-waze, ra drosac masa da c. a-s Soris daiwyo konfliqti. mansTxova orives, molaparakebiT moegvarebinaT maT SoriswarmoSobili dava, magram mainc gaagrZeles konfliqti.
10. sakasacio palatas aradamajereblad miaCnia msjav-rdebul c. a-s ganmarteba, rom mas ar usvria e. s-s mimar-TulebiT qvebi da xis naWrebi, mas xelSi, albaT, SeerWoxis pwkari, roca miwas asufTavebda. am ganmartebis mixed-viT, e. s-s dazianeba unda hqonoda mxolod xelis mtevnisim nawilSi, sadac SerWobili hqonda xis naWris natexi, ma-Sin, rodesac gansxvavebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebi dad-ginda mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli eqimis _ S. b-s CvenebiTa dasasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis daskvniT, romelTaTanaxmadac, e. s-s aReniSneboda daJeJili Wriloba ara mxo-lod xelis mtevnis nawilSi, aramed sxeulis sxva nawileb-
22
Sic hqonda mravlobiTi sisxlnaJRenTebi, rac imaze miu-TiTebs, rom e. s-s mimarTulebiT c. a-e isroda qvebsa daxis naWrebs.
11. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma eqimma S. b-m daadastura,rom respublikur saavadmyofoSi misi morigeobis dros sa-medicino daxmareba aRmouCina qalbatons _ e. s-s, romel-sac marjvena xelis mtevnis areSi hqonda daJeJili Jri-loba. mas zustad ar axsovs saqmis garemoebebi, magram yve-laferi detalurad miuTiTa avadmyofobis istoriaSi.
wavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma saCivris safuZvlianobada miaCnia, rom misi moTxovna ar unda dakmayofildes Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom i. q-as mier sxvagvariseqsualuri kontaqtis gaukuRmarTebuli formiT, Zala-dobiTa da Zaladobis muqariT Cadena im piris mimarT, ro-melsac ar Sesrulebia ToTxmeti weli, danaSauli, rac gaT-valiswinebulia saqarTvelos ssk-is 138-e muxlis me-4 na-wilis `g~ qvepunqtiT da Zarcva, e.i. sxvisi moZravi nivTisaSkara daufleba marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis miz-niT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli ssk-is 178-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT, dasturdeba gonivrul eWvs miRma arsebuli,sakmarisi, utyuari da SeTanxmebuli mtkicebulebebis er-TobliobiT. saqmeSi ar arsebobs sxva iseTi mtkicebule-bebi, romlebiTac gabaTildeboda, anda eWvqveS dadgebo-da i. q-as mimarT ganaCeniT Seracxuli braldeba. aRniSnu-lidan gamomdinare, palata ver gaiziarebs msjavrdebuli. q-asa da misi advokatis ganmartebas msjavrdebulis uda-naSaulobis Taobaze.
3. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom gansaxilvel Sem-TxvevaSi sadavo ar aris SemTxvevis adgilze braldebuli. q-as yofnis faqti, rasac ar uaryofs arc braldebuli.
28
dacvis mxare sadavod xdis da, Sesabamisad, saproceso ko-deqsis moTxovnaTa dacviT unda dadgindes is faqtebi,Tu ra moxda SemTxvevis adgilze, ra viTarebaSi miiRo a. m-am sxeulze arsebuli dazianebebi; miayena Tu ara mas esdazianebebi i. q-am da Tu miayena _ ra mizniT; daamyara Tuara dazaralebulTan sqesobrivi kavSiri da Tu daamyara _ra formiT.
4. dazaralebul a. m-as mier mowmis statusiT micemuliCvenebiT dasturdeba, rom igi bebiasgan brundeboda so-felSi (saxlSi). gzaSi oTxTvaliT wamoewia i. q-a, romel-mac SesTavaza soflisken wayvana, razec daTanxmda, daj-da oTxTvalaze da erTad wavidnen. i. q-am gzas gadauxvia,pirze xeli aafara da buCqebSi Seiyvana. saxeSi xeli gaar-tya, ZaliT gaxada tansacmeli da Zaladobis muqariT uka-na tanidan sasqeso organos meSveobiT daamyara sqesobri-vi kavSiri. am dros gaigones meTevzeebis xma, ris gamoc i.q-am uTxra, swrafad Caecva. man maisuris Cacma ver moas-wro, iqve darCa qamaric. cota manZilis gavlis Semdeg, k-is teritoriaze isev Camoiyvana oTxTvalidan, SeaTriabuCqebSi, saxeSi xeli gaartya, ZaliT Caxada Sarvali, Sem-deg _ trusi da ukana tanidan daamyara masTan sqesobrivikavSiri. aseve ZaladobiT pirSi Seuyo sasqeso organo daZaliT aalokina ukanali. i. q-a emuqreboda mas mokvliT,Tu ise ar gaakeTebda yvelafers, rogorc etyoda. SeeSin-da da daujera. i. q-am sqesobrivi aqti daasrula misi sxeu-lis gareT da sasqeso organodan gadmosuli siTxe Sarval-ze daesxa. sqesobrivi kontaqtis dros igi grZnobda tki-vils. am periodis ganmavlobaSi ramdenjerme daureka de-idam, magram i. q-am aTqmevina _ gzaSi var da movdivaro.Semdeg xelidan gamoglija telefoni, gaTiSa, baraTebiamoyara, telefoni jibeSi Caido, panRuri amoartya da uT-xra, rom sanam gzaze ar gavidoda, wasuli ar daenaxa. ro-desac saxlSi mivida, bebias mouyva yvelaferi, ris Semde-gac darekes policiaSi. TviTon aCvena policielebs is ad-gili, sadac moxda SemTxveva da mouyva yvelafers, racmoxda. eqspertebTanac waiyvanes. amoicno maisuri da qa-mari, romelic SemTxvevis adgilze darCa. policias Tavi-si nebiT Caabara is tansacmeli, romelic im dRes ecva _lurji feris jinsis Sarvali da nacrisferi jempri.
5. 2013 wlis 17 oqtombris sagamoZiebo eqsperimentisoqmiT dasturdeba, rom dazaralebulma a. m-am miuTiTa is
29
adgilebi, sadac i. q-am masze ganaxorciela Zaladoba, da-amyara sqesobrivi kavSiri da waarTva telefoni. oqmis sis-wores adastureben mowme a. m-a, kanonieri warmomadgene-li j. W-a, fsiqologi a. C-a, prokurori q. y-i, eqspertebi _T. b-a da e. g-a.
a. m-as Sarvalze aRmoCnda sperma, romelic datovebu-lia A/II/ jgufis sisxlis mqone, Tavisi jgufobrivi Tvi-sebriobis gamomyofi piris, maT Soris SesaZlebelia i. q-asmier.
amave eqspertizis daskvniTa da masze darTuli fotoc-xriliT dasturdeba, rom eqspertizaze gamosakvlevadwardgenili iyo sami fuTa da a. m-sa da i. q-as sisxlisa danerwyvis nimuSebi. aRniSnuli fuTebi eqspertizaze war-dgenil iqna daluqul mdgomareobaSi. fuTa #2 daluqu-li iyo saqarTvelos Sss samegrelo-zemo svaneTis samxa-reo mTavari sammarTvelos zugdidis raionuli sammarTve-los paketebisaTvis #36/1 beWdis anabeWdis etiketiT.etiketze aris ori gaurkveveli xelmowera. igi dakruliaqaRaldze, romelzec aris xelnaweri: `2013 wlis 15 oqtom-
30
bers mowme a. m-as mier warmodgenili tansacmeli: 1. nac-risferi zeda, 2. TeTri perangi, 3. Savi feris qveda sacva-li, 4. lurji feris jinsis Sarvali. xels aweren: 1. mowme a.m-a, 2. warmodgenili j. W-a da piri, romelmac ganaxorcie-la daluqva _ i. s-a. aseve daluqul mdgomareobaSi iqnawardgenili fuTa #3. luqze ikiTxeba: `2013 wlis 16 oq-tombers mowme i. q-as mier warmodgenili Ria lurji ferisjinsis Sarvali, maisuri da qveda sacvali~. masze Sesru-lebulia xelmowerebi: 1. mowme i. q-as, 2. warmomadgenlisv. q-as da 3. i. s-as mier. aRniSnuli fuTebi dasuraTebuliada erTvis eqspertizis daskvnas. eqspertma n. g-ma daadas-tura mis mier gacemuli eqspertizis daskvnis siswore.
8. 2013 wlis 12 noembris qimiuri eqspertizis daskvniTdasturdeba, rom i. q-as maisuris zedapirze aRmoCenilimonacisfro Salis boWkos mikronawilakebi da a. m-as pu-loveris qsovilis SemadgenlobaSi Semavali monacisfroSalis boWkoebi xasiaTdebian erTnairi gvarobrivi niSne-biT, bunebiT, feriT, feris tonalobiT da boWkos struq-turiT. daskvnis kvleviT nawilSi miTiTebulia, rom eq-spertizaze wardgenili iqna daluquli fuTebi _ i. q-asada a. m-as wardgenili tansacmeli. eqspertma e. k-ma daa-dastura mis mier gacemuli eqspertizis daskvnis siswo-re.
9. saqmeSi arsebuli l. samxaraulis saxelobis sasamar-Tlo eqspertizis erovnuli biuros genetikuri eqsper-tizis daskvniT dasturdeba, rom a. m-as jinsis Sarvalze,kerZod, ukana zedapiris zeda mesamedSi, sawelurTan, Suanakeris mimdebared markirebul amonaWrebTan arsebulispermis laqebis genetikuri profili da i. q-as sisxlis ge-netikuri profili identuria. eqspertebma _ i. e-em da i.m-am daadastures maT mier gacemuli eqspertizis daskvnissiswore.
10. mowme j. W-as CvenebiT dasturdeba, rom misi SviliS-vili _ a. m-a saxlSi dabrunda namtiralevi, SewiTlebulisaxiT da dawvrilebiT mouyva, Tu i. q-am mdinare e-is na-pirze Zalis gamoyenebiT, rogor Seiyvana buCqebSi, scema,gaaupatiura da waarTva telefoni. mis SviliSvils saxlSimisvlisas mobiluri telefoni Tan aRar hqonda. aRniSnu-li Seatyobina policias. analogiuri garemoebebi daadas-tures CvenebebSi mowmeebma _ r. W-am da T. m-am.
11. mowme a. C-as CvenebiT dasturdeba, rom mas, rogorc
31
fsiqologs a. m-asTan ramdenjerme hqonda Sexvedra. a-imasTan saubarSi momxdar faqts aRwerda detalurad dayovelTvis ambobda erTsa da imaves. man ganmarta, rom a. m-as, misi asakidan gamomdinare, gacnobierebulic ar aqvs,Tu ra moxda, amitom pasuxobs ase martivad kameris winCvenebis micemisas. ararsebul faqtebze, Tan yovelTviserTsa da imaves, ase martivad ar laparakoben. SeuZlebe-lia, 11 wlis bavSvma aseTi ambavi moigonos.
12. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli gamomZieblis _ i. s-as Cve-nebiT dasturdeba, rom man dakiTxa a. m-a da i. q-a. maT neba-yoflobiT warudgines tansacmeli, romelic ecvaT Sem-Txvevis dRes. warmodgenili tansacmeli daluqa man dagagzavna eqspertizaze, Tumca calke oqmi ar Seudgenia.
13. i. q-am Tavi ar cno damnaSaved wardgenil braldeba-Si da ganmarta, rom a. m-sTan sqesobrivi kavSiri ar daumya-rebia, arc ucemia da arc telefoni waurTmevia misakuT-rebis mizniT.
14. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom dazaralebul a. m-as Cvenebis utyuaroba mis mimarT i. q-as mier ZaladobiTada Zaladobis muqariT, gaukuRmarTebuli formiT sqesob-rivi kontaqtis damyarebis Taobaze dasturdeba: misi mo-nawileobiT Catarebuli sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmiT,romelSic Tanmimdevrulad aRwers, Tu ra viTarebaSi da-amyara masTan iZulebiT sqesobrivi kavSiri i. q-am; sasa-marTlo-samedicino eqspertizis daskvniT, romlis Tanax-madac, saxeze a. m-as aReniSneboda dazianebebi sisxlnaJ-RenTebis saxiT; biologiuri eqspertizis daskvniT, rom-lis Tanaxmadac, a. m-as Sarvalze aRmoCnda sperma; geneti-kuri eqspertizis daskvniT, riTac dasturdeba, rom a. m-as jinsis Sarvalze aRmoCenili spermis laqebis geneti-kuri profili da i. q-as sisxlis genetikuri profili iden-turia; mowmeebis _ j. W-as, r. W-sa da T. m-as CvenebebiT,romelTac miuTiTes, rom a. m-as saxeze etyoboda siwiTleda Calurjebebi, mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli fsiqologis _ a.C-as CvenebiT, romelmac ganmarta, rom SeuZlebelia 11wlis bavSvma aseTi ambavi moigonos da yovelTvis erTnai-ri sizustiT aRweros momxdari.
15. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatorebis miTiTe-bas imis Sesaxeb, rom dazaralebul a. m-as tansacmeli sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeze damagrebul iqna saproceso ka-nonis arsebiTi darRveviT da, Sesabamisad, vinaidan aR-
32
niSnuls eyrdnoba qimiuri, biologiuri da genetikuri eq-spertizis daskvnebi, ar unda iqnes gaziarebuli. is gare-moeba, rom wardgenili nivTieri mtkicebulebis _ tansac-mlis daTvalierebis Taobaze ar Sedga calke oqmi, warmo-adgens saproceso kodeqsis darRvevas, Tumca, mocemulSemTxvevaSi ar aris arsebiTi xasiaTis, kerZod: palata aR-niSnavs, rom dazaralebul a. m-as 2013 wlis 15 oqtombrisdakiTxvis oqmiT dasturdeba, rom man gamomZiebels neba-yoflobiT warudgina tansacmeli da sacvlebi, romelicSemTxvevis dros ecva. is faqti, rom aRniSnuli tansacme-li aRiwera, dailuqa da aseTi saxiT gadaigzavna eqsper-tizaze, dasturdeba 2013 wlis 19 noembris biologiurieqspertizis, 2013 wlis 12 noembris qimiuri eqspertizisada l. samxaraulis saxelobis sasamarTlo eqspertiziserovnuli biuros genetikuri eqspertizis daskvnebiT,romlebSic miTiTebulia, rom waredginaT 2013 wlis 15 oq-tombers mowme a. m-as mier wardgenili tansacmeli: 1. nac-risferi zeda, 2. TeTri perangi, 3. Savi feris qveda sacva-li, 4. lurji feris jinsis Sarvali. xels aweren: 1. mowme a.m-a, 2. warmomadgenili j. W-a da piri, romelmac ganaxorci-ela daluqva _ i. s-a. aRniSnuli teqsti dawerilia xeliTqaRaldze, romelzec gakeTebulia luqi da miTiTebuliaxelmowerebi. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom dazarale-bulis tansacmeli, romelzec aRmoCnda braldebul i. q-as sperma, ar aris mopovebuli sisxlis samarTlis sapro-ceso kodeqsis moTxovnaTa arsebiTi darRveviT, rogorcamas kasatori miuTiTebs. is faqtebi, rom dazaralebulmaSemTxvevis dResve, dakiTxvis dros, nebayoflobiT warad-gina tansacmeli, romelic dailuqa gamomZieblis mier, ra-sac xelmoweriT adastureben dazaralebuli, misi kano-nieri warmomadgeneli da gamomZiebeli da daluquli sa-xiT gadaigzavna saeqsperto kvlevisaTvis, rasac adastu-reben CvenebebSic, gamoricxavs eWvs nivTieri mtkicebu-lebis SesaZlo gamocvlis, misi niSan-Tvisebebis arsebiTiSecvlis an masze darCenili kvalis arsebiTi gaqrobis Se-saxeb. am mocemulobaSi palatas obieqturad SeuZlebladmiaCnia i. q-as spermis ganzrax an SemTxveviT a. m-as tansac-melze mogvianebiT moxvedra. amasTan, Tavad braldebul-mac ver axsna, Tu saidan moxvda misi sperma a. m-as Sarval-ze. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom kasatoris mi-TiTeba aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebis sisxlis samarTlis
g. SavliaSvili (Tavmjdomare),m. oSxareli,p. silagaZe
monawileobiT ganixila msjavrdebul a. T-sa da misi in-teresebis damcvelis, advokat l. x-s sakasacio saCivariquTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 1 oqtombrisganaCenze.
aRwerilobiTi nawili:1. braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebiT a. T-s, _ nasamar-
5. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra senakis raionu-li prokuroris moadgile k. a-m. man iTxova senakis raio-nuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 10 ivlisis ganaCenis gauqme-ba a. T-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 139-e muxlis 1-li nawiliTudanaSaulod cnobis nawilSi da zemoaRniSnuli muxliTmisi damnaSaved cnoba.
6. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT aseve gaasaCivres msjav-rdebulma a. T-m da misma advokatma g. q-m. apelantebma iT-xoves a. T-saTvis daniSnuli sasjelis Semcireba da piro-biTad CaTvla.
8. kasatorebi _ msjavrdebuli a. T-a da misi advokatil. x-a aRniSnaven, rom videokadrebis gadaReba ar momxda-ra farulad da es gakeTda orive mxaris TanxmobiT; saqme-ze dakiTxuli arc erTi mowme ar miuTiTebs a. T-s mxridanT. k-s iZulebaze, daemyarebina masTan sqesobrivi kavSiri,amitom saqarTvelos ssk-is 139-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT qme-debis kvalifikacia ukanonoa; garda amisa, a. T-saTvis da-niSnuli sasjeli Seusabamoa mis pirovnebasa da Cadeniliqmedebis xasiaTTan.
mis masalebi da mivida im daskvnamde, rom sakasacio saCi-vari unda dakmayofildes nawilobriv da gasaCivrebul ga-naCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba kerZod:.
2. gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebis Sefasebis Sedegad sa-kasacio palata mivida daskvnamde, rom a. T-a unda gamar-Tldes saqarTvelos ssk-is 139-e muxliT wardgenil bral-debaSi mtkicebulebaTa arasakmarisobis gamo, Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
3. dazaralebulma T. k-ma aCvena, rom a. T-a Tavs ar ane-bebda, dReSi ramdenjerme ukavSirdeboda mobiluri te-lefonis saSualebiT da aiZulebda masTan urTierTobas,maT Soris _ sqesobrivs. winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi emuqre-boda maTi sqesobrivi kavSiris amsaxveli foto da video-masalis socialur qselSi gavrcelebiT, rac sabolood Se-asrula kidec.
4. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom dazaralebulis ze-moaRniSnuli Cveneba ar Seesabameba da ar gamomdinareobssaqmeSi arsebuli sxva mtkicebulebebis analizidan, vina-
38
idan mowme m. T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom T. k-sa da a. T-s hqondaT sasiyvarulo urTierToba. TbilisSi or-samjerSexvdnen erTmaneTs, Tbilisidan rom Camodioda, samtre-diaSic xvdeboda. hqondaT satelefono saubrebi; roca a.T-a rekavda T-s telefonze, ekranze a-s suraTi Cndebo-da. T. k-sa da g.j-s urTierTobis Sesaxeb gaigo dekembrisbolos. g. j-s dedam uTxra, rom mis megobars _ T. k-s niS-navdnen. manamde icoda, rom T. k-i a. T-s unda moeyvana co-lad.
5. mowme a. T-m aCvena, rom 2012 wlidan mis Zmas a. T-sa daT. k-s hqondaT axlo urTierToba, uyvardaT erTmaneTi damis Zmas undoda colad moeyvana T-i. analogiuri faqtob-rivi garemoebebi daadastures mowmeebma _ b. x-m da f. T-m.
6. aRniSnul mowmeTa Cvenebebi met sandoobas matebenmsjavrdebul a. T-s mier sasamarTloSi micemul Cvenebas,romliTac man ganmarta, rom T. k-Tan hqonda nebayoflo-biTi sasiyvarulo urTierToba da undodaT ojaxis Seq-mna, xolo fotosuraTebi gaavrcela im mizniT, rom T-sqorwili CaeSala.
7. palata ar eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos das-kvnas imis Taobaze, rom T. k-s Cveneba dadasturebuliamowmeebis _ m. j-s, s. k-sa da g. j-s CvenebebiT, radgan mow-meebis _ m. j-sa da s. k-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom a. T-aSetyobinebebs ugzavnidaT mobilur telefonze moTxov-niT, ar gaeTxovebinaT T., rom maTi Svili ar iyo patiosanida samSobiaro saxl `senamedSi~ ekiTxaT, Tu ramdeni abor-ti hqonda gakeTebuli. mowme s. k-s CvenebiT dasturdebaaseve, rom a. T-a Sexvedrisas daemuqra Semdegi sityvebiT:`kidev mets vizam, jer sad xarTo~; xolo mowme g. j-m aCve-na, rom a. T-a misuli iyo masTan saxlSi da uTxra, T. ar arisSeni Rirsi, cudi yofaqcevis adamianiao. Semdeg telefo-niT miiRo Setyobineba parolisa da saitis miTiTebiT, rom-lis gaxsnis Semdeg naxa T. k-sa da ucxo mamakacis sqesob-rivi kavSiris amsaxveli fotoebi.
8. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom zemomiTiTebul mow-meTa CvenebebiT dasturdeba mxolod is faqti, rom a. T-sar surda T. k-s sxvaze gaTxoveba da yvelanairad cdilob-da am procesisTvis xelis SeSlas, maT Soris _ piradi sai-dumlos Semcveli informaciis gavrcelebis muqariTac,rac Seasrula kidec. Sesabamisad, mas msjavri daedo sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 157-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT gaTvaliswi-
39
nebuli danaSaulis CadenisTvis da arc xdis sadavod mis-Tvis wardgenil braldebas am nawilSi.
9. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs aseve saapelacio sasa-marTlos daskvnas imis Sesaxeb, rom a. T-s mier masa da T. k-s Soris sqesobrivi kavSiris amsaxveli kadrebis ukanonodmopoveba miuTiTebs a. T-s swored im ganzraxvaze, rom amkadrebis gavrcelebis muqariT iZulebuli gaexada T. k-imasTan seqsualuri urTierToba gaegrZelebina. sakasaciopalatis azriT, piradi cxovrebis amsaxveli kadrebis uka-nono mopoveba ar moicavs imis upirobo varauds, rom mismompovebels am kadrebis gavrcelebis muqariT intimuriurTierTobis gagrZelebis motivi amoZravebs.
10. amasTan, sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom a. T-s qme-deba SesaZloa, Seicavdes iZulebisTvis (saqarTvelos ssk-is 150-e muxli) damaxasiaTebel niSnebs im nawilSi, rom igiyvela xerxiTa da saSualebiT cdilobda, iZulebuli gae-xada T. k-i uari eTqva qorwinebaze, anu aiZulebda mas ua-ri eTqva im moqmedebis Sesrulebaze, romlis Sesruleba/Sesrulebisgan Tavis Sekaveba mis uflebas warmoadgens,Tumca, iqidan gamomdinare, rom braldebis Sesaxeb dad-genileba ar Seicavs a. T-s mier ganxorcielebul aRniSnu-li moqmedebis samarTlebriv aRweras _ sakasacio palatakanonismierad moklebulia SesaZleblobas, imsjelos mi-si qmedebis saqarTvelos ssk-is 139-e muxlidan ssk-is 150-e muxlze gadakvalificirebis Taobaze.
11. rac Seexeba kasatoris moTxovnas saqarTvelos ssk-is 157-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT daniSnuli sasjelis Semsu-buqebis Taobaze, sakasacio palata ar iziarebs da miaCnia,rom Cadenili qmedebis ganxorcielebis saxisa da formisgaTvaliswinebiT, misTvis gansazRvruli sasjeli samar-Tliania.
8. kasatorebi _ msjavrdebuli k. g-e da misi interese-bis damcveli, advokati m. j-a sakasacio saCivrebSi aRniS-naven, rom k. g-e maRaziaSi Sevida sigaretisa da puris sa-yidlad; maRaziis kari iyo Ria; k. g-s kari saxraxnisiT romgaeRo, aucileblad darCeboda dazianebebi rogorc sax-raxnisze, ise _ karsa da saketis enaze; amgvari dazianebe-bi ki, 2014 wlis 11 Tebervlis #—/tr trasologiuri eq-
42
spertizis daskvnis Tanaxmad, ar aRiniSneboda; garda ami-sa, arc saxraxnisze iyo k. g-s TiTebis anabeWdebi.
9. kasatorTa azriT, k. g-s ganzraxva iyo maRaziaSi siga-retis sayidlad Sesvla da ara _ saxraxnisis gamoyenebiTSeRweva da sxvisi nivTis faruli daufleba marTlsawina-aRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT; saxezea gauTvaliswinebe-li SemTxveva, romlis uneblie monawile sxvac SeiZlebo-da gamxdariyo.
10. saCivris avtorebi aseve aRniSnaven, rom orive in-stanciis sasamarTloebis ganaCenebi ar efuZneba eWvis ga-momricxav, erTmaneTTan SeTanxmebul utyuar mtkicebu-lebaTa erTobliobas; sasamarTloebma moaxdines adamia-nis uflebaTa da ZiriTad TavisuflebaTa dacvis evropu-li konvenciis me-6 muxlisa da saqarTvelos konstituci-is me-40 muxlis moTxovnebis ignorireba.
11. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, msjavrdebuli k.g-e da advokati m. j-a iTxoven Tbilisis saapelacio sasa-marTlos 2015 wlis 28 ianvris ganaCenis gauqmebas da k. g-sgamarTlebas.
iswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma saCivrebis safuZvlia-noba da miaCnia, rom kasatorebis moTxovna ar unda dakma-yofildes, vinaidan sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs sa-apelacio sasamarTlos argumentebs k. g-s mier sacavSi uka-nono SeRweviT qurdobis mcdelobis Cadenis Taobaze. Se-sabamisad, masac miaCnia, rom kanonis moTxovnaTa srulidacviT, srulyofilad da obieqturad gamokvleul, ut-yuar, urTierTSejerebul da sakmaris mtkicebulebaTaerTobliobiT dasturdeba k. g-sTvis bralad Seracxuliqmedebis Cadena, kerZod:
2. dazaralebul l. k-as CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014wlis 10 Tebervals misi kuTvnili marketi Cveulebisamebrdaiketa 23:00 saaTze da ayvanil iqna signalizaciaze, risSemdegac TanamSromeli qalbatonebi Tavisi avtomanqaniT
43
miacila sacxovreblamde. gzaSi gaaxsenda, rom sabuTebidarCa marketSi, amitom manqanaSi myof TanamSromel l. g-sTan erTad dabrunda xizaniSvilis quCaze mdebare mar-ketTan. marketis SesasvlelTan dainaxa biWi, romelicmTvrali egona, magram Semdeg, misi moZraobidan gamomdi-nare, gauCnda eWvi, rom kars awvalebda da iyo qurdi. ami-tom 10-15 wamSi, roca ucnobma kari gaaRo da SigniT Sevi-da, Tavadac Sehyva mas, SeboWa da ar misca gadaadgilebissaSualeba. dakavebuli eZiZgilaveboda, Tumca ver moaxer-xa Tavis gaTavisufleba. daaxloebiT erT wuTSi ki market-Si misi TanamSromeli l. g-e Semovida, romelmac aanTo Su-qi da misi TxovniT gamorTo signalizacia, romelic ucno-bi piris mier karis gaRebisTanave CairTo. l. g-m SeniSnabiWis xelSi saxraxnisi, gamoarTva da dado daxlze. daax-loebiT 2-3 wuTSi movidnen dacvis policiis TanamSrom-lebic da daakaves braldebuli. dazaralebulma ganmar-ta, rom wasvlisas kari namdvilad daketa da darwmunebu-lia, rom braldebulma igi saxraxnisiT gaaRo, vinaidan kar-ze SeniSna iseTi nakawrebi, romelic mas manamde ar hqon-da.
3. analogiuri faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadasturamowme l. g-mac. mowmem ganmarta, rom SemTxvevamde karidazianebuli ar yofila.
5. analogiuri faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadastures sa-patrulo policiis inspeqtorebma _ g. l-m da l. C-m.
6. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatoris miTiTebas,imis Sesaxeb, TiTqos mas Ria egona marketi, ver dainaxa,rom maRaziaSi Suqi ar enTo da iq purisa da sigaretis sa-yidlad Sevida, vinaidan:
7. SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmidan da gada-Rebuli fotomasalidan naTlad Cans, rom maRaziis Sesas-
44
vleli kari damzadebulia aluminisgan da aris erTfrTi-ani minebiani, masze ar aris sareklamo plakatebi. sarek-lamo plakatebi mikrulia mxolod karis marjvena da mar-cxena mxares arsebul minis vitrinebze _ anu moqmedi alu-minis kari warmoadgens Cveulebriv minian, gamWvirvale Se-sasvlels. Sesabamisad, sakasacio palatas SeuZleblad mi-aCnia k. g-s ver SeemCnia, rom maRaziaSi ar enTo sinaTle,miT umetes, dazaralebul l. k-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, romigi (k. g-e) ramdenime wami idga karTan da garkveul moZra-obebs akeTebda, rac miuTiTebs imaze, rom mas uneblied,gauazreblad ar SeuRia kari; amasTan, dakavebisa da pira-di Cxrekis oqmiT irkveva, rom k. g-sgan Cxrekis Sedegadfuli ar amouRiaT, rac aseve abaTilebs mis versias, TiT-qos maRaziaSi purisa da sigaretis sayidlad Sedioda.
8. kasatoris pozicias imis Sesaxeb, rom radgan traso-logiuri espertizis daskvnis Tanaxmad, karis saketis gu-laze ar aRmoCnda dazianebis kvali, es gamoricxavs mismier qurdobis Cadenis faqts _ palata aseve ar iziarebsda miuTiTebs, rom trasologiuri eqspertiza Catardamxolod karis saketis gulaze maSin, rodesac meqanikuridazianebis kvali aRmoCnda karis CarCoze.
9. Sesabamisad, palata aRniSnavs, rom saketis gulazedazianebis aRmouCenloba arc pirdapir da arc sxva dad-genil garemoebebTan erTad ar miuTiTebs k. g-s udanaSau-lobaze. saketis gulaze dazianebebis aRmoCenis SemTxve-vaSi trasologiuri eqspertizis daskvna iqneboda bral-debis damatebiT kidev erTi mtkicebuleba, xolo misi aR-mouCenloba gavlenas ar axdens mtkicebulebaTa sakmari-sobaze. Sesabamisad, k. g-s braldebis sisxlis samarTlissaqmeze, braldebis mxaris mier mopovebuli mtkicebule-baTa erToblioba qmnis gamamtyunebeli ganaCenisaTvis sa-Wiro gonivrul eWvs miRma standarts.
5. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrdebul-ma i. g-ma da misma advokatebma _ z. r-ma da k. c-m. maT moiT-xoves ganaCenis gauqmeba da i. g-s gamarTleba.
6. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2014 wlis 3 oqtombris ganaCeniTsaapelacio saCivari ar dakmayofilda da TeTriwyaros ra-ionuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 4 aprilis ganaCeni darCaucvlelad.
7. kasatori _ msjavrdebul i. g-s interesebis damcve-li, advokati z. r-i sakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnavs, rom ga-naCeni aris ukanono, dausabuTebeli, usamarTlo da igiunda gauqmdes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
8. mowme e. a-s i. g-i ar amoucnia; arc mas da arc mowme z.m-s ar axsovT, Tu ra niSniT amoicnes amosacnobi piri, ami-tom maTi Cvenebebi mxolod varauds efuZneba da ar iZle-va zust informacias, ris gamoc isini sasamarTlos mxed-velobaSi ar unda mieRo; arc mowme l. a-s CvenebiT dadgin-da raime, igi mxolod dayaCaRebis moments aRwerda; mowmem. g-ma, romelmac Seadgina dakavebis oqmi, ganacxada, romdakavebuls hqonda saubris gansxvavebuli manera da sva-nuri kilo, xolo mowme l. a-s CvenebiT, borotmoqmedebisaubrobdnen gamarTuli qarTuliT da kuTxuri kilo arhqoniaT.
9. aRsaniSnavia isic, rom srolis adgilis daTvaliere-
47
ba moxda RamiT, amitom masra ver ipoves, Tumca ganmeore-biT, dRis sinaTleze SemTxvevis adgili aRar dauTvalie-rebiaT; Tu namdvilad arsebobda gasrolili masra, maSinCndeba kiTxva _ ratom ar Caatares ganmeorebiT SemTxve-vis adgilis daTvaliereba.
10. dazaralebulebis CvenebiT, i. g-ma n. a-s sakinZeSimokida xeli, sxeuli gaukawra da sisxli wamouvida; aseTSemTxvevaSi i. g-s frCxilebSi n. a-s genetikuri profilisSemcveli nivTiereba unda darCeniliyo, eqspertizis das-kvniT mixedviT ki i. g-s genetikuri kodi ar aRmoCnda, anun. a-Tan i. g-i ar yofila; aRniSnuli dasturdeba eqsper-tebis _ v. o-sa da i. m-s CvenebebiTac.
11. dazaralebul n. a-s da kinolog r. w-s ganmartebe-biT, sunis nimuSi aiRes daaxloebiT dilis 7 saaTze; maRa-ziaSi uamravi policieli trialebda, amitom braldebu-lis sunis nimuSi adgilze veRar darCeboda; garda amisa,daudgenelia, Tu konkretulad romelma kinologma _ r.w-ma Tu n. b-ma aiRo sunis nimuSi; n. w-s CvenebiT, i. g-s su-nis nimuSi policiis SenobaSi auRes; mowme b. i-s CvenebiT,Tu SemTxvevis adgilze 10-15 kaci iqneboda, maSin sunisnimuSi daziandeboda; misive TqmiT, SemTxvevis adgilzeaRebuli da odorologiur eqspertizaze wardgenili sa-mi sunis nimuSi i. g-s sunis nimuSis msgavsi iyo.
12. mowmeebis _ i. x-sa da i. f-s CvenebebiT, amosacnobipiri maT saerTod ar hgavdaT, xolo amocnoba 2-3 saaTisganmavlobaSi grZeldeboda, e.i. gamodis, rom i. g-i ZaliTamoacnobines dazaralebulebs; garda amisa, i. g-s simaR-le aris 1 metri da 69 santimetri, xolo i. x-sa da i. f-s _ 1metri da 87 santimetri, anu maT Soris sxvaoba 18 santi-metria; gamomZiebel m. d-s ganmartebiT, amosacnobi pire-bi erTmaneTisagan gansxvavdebodnen; amocnobis oqmSi araris dafiqsirebuli amosacnobad wardgenili pirebis da-badebis TariRebi, gamomZiebels arasworad aqvs miTiTe-buli i. f-sa da i. x-s, romelTac i. g-s msgavsad (gadmoweu-li qveda tuCi da `Colka~ Sublze) gansxvavebuli niSani arhqondaT, simaRle; aqedan gamomdinare, amocnobis oqmi sa-samarTlos dauSvebel mtkicebulebad unda ecno.
13. msjavrdebul i. g-s CvenebiT, dakavebisas, rodesacis miwaze daagdes, erT-erTma policielma, romlis amoc-noba SeuZlia, Sarvlis marjvena jibeSi Caudo ori tyvia,amitom Cxrekis oqmze xeli ar moawera; amis Semdeg gadaiy-
48
vanes policiis ganyofilebaSi, sadac policielebma, ro-melTa amocnobac aseve SeuZlia, miayenes fizikuri da sit-yvieri Seuracxyofa; amocnobis Catarebis Semdeg mas mai-suris jibeSi raRac Caudes da kvlav Cautares piradi Cxre-ka, ra drosac amoiRes maT mierve Cadebuli ori xelTaT-mani da saTvale; Cxrekis oqmi ar SeudgeniaT; i. g-s aranai-ri danaSauli ar Caudenia da maRaziasTan skamze martoijda.
14. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, vinaidangamamtyunebeli ganaCeni emyareba urTierTsawinaaRmde-go Cvenebebsa da eWvebs da ara _ urTierTSejerebul mtki-cebulebaTa erTobliobas, advokati z. r-i iTxovs Tbili-sis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 3 oqtombris gana-Cenis gauqmebas da i. g-s mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenisdadgenas.
ma sakasacio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da mivida daskvnam-de, rom msjavrdebul i. g-sa da misi interesebis damcve-lis, advokat z. r-s sakasacio saCivrebi ar unda dakmayo-fildes, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvli-leba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos argumentebs i. g-s mier jgufuri yaCaRobis Ca-denisa da sabrZolo masalis marTlsawinaaRmdego SeZena-tarebis Cadenis Taobaze da miaCnia, rom kanonis moTxov-naTa sruli dacviT, srulyofilad da obieqturad gamok-vleul, utyuar, urTierTSejerebul da sakmaris mtkice-bulebaTa erTobliobiT dasturdeba i. g-sTvis bralad Se-racxuli qmedebebis Cadena, kerZod:
3. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma, dazaralebulma l. a-m de-talurad uCvena sasamarTlos, Tu 2013 wlis 10 seqtembersrogor daayaCaRes maRaziaSi is da dedamisi n. a-a msjav-rdebulma da misma Tanmxlebma pirma, aseve ra moqmedebe-bi ganaxorcieles Tavdamsxmelebma. mowmem detalurad
49
aRwera i. g-s garegnoba da Cacmuloba, rac policielebsacganucxada Tavdasxmis Semdeg. i. g-i amoicno Catarebuliamocnobis dros; rogorc ki oTaxSi Seiyvanes, maSinveTvalSi moxvda i. g-i. masTan erTad kidev 2 Tu 3 piri idga,yvelani iyvnen daaxloebiT erTi simaRlisa. marTalia, i.g-i myisierad amoicno, magram SeeSinda da maSinve darwmu-nebiT ar Tqva. sasamarTloze Cvenebis micemis dros l. a-mganacxada, rom mas darwmunebiT SeuZlia Tqvas, rom bral-debulis skamze myofi i. g-i aris is piri, romelic saRamosmas da dedamiss yaCaRurad Tavs daesxa da gastaca fula-di Tanxa.
6. garda zemomiTiTebuli mtkicebulebebisa, i. g-sTvisbralad Seracxuli qmedebebi dasturdeba aseve mowmee-bis _ T. T-s, n. b-s, m. g-s, l. m-s, r. k-s, m. d-s, m. g-s, n. d-s, a.S-s CvenebebiT, braldebulis dakavebisa da piradi Cxre-kis oqmiT, amocnobis oqmebiT, balistikuri eqspertizis#— da odorologiuri eqspertizis #— daskvnebiTa da ase-ve, sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamokvleuli sxva mtkicebule-bebis erTobliobiT.
7. palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris sakasacio saCivar-Si moyvanil argumentebs da miaCnia, rom saapelacio pala-tam amomwuravi pasuxi gasca kasatoris mier miTiTebulyvela garemoebas, kerZod:
8. usafuZvloa dacvis mxaris apelireba im garemoeba-ze, rom SemTxvevis adgilze uamravi policielis misvlisgamo, braldebulis sunis nimuSebi veRar darCeboda ad-gilze, vinaidan saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis dros mowmis sa-xiT dakiTxulma eqspertma b. i-m ganmarta, rom adgilzexalxmravlobis mizeziT sunis kvali SeiZleba daziandes,magram mcirediT mainc darCeba, sul ar gaqreba, suni 24saaTic rCeba, 48 saaTic da a. S. gaaCnia Senobas, zedapirs,razec Seexeba piri. manve daadastura 2013 wlis 12 seq-tembris odorologiuri eqspertizis #— daskvnis siswo-re, romliTac dadgenilia, rom 2013 wlis 10 seqtembers q.TeTriwyaroSi, didgoris quCis #-Si mdebare maRaziaSi,l. a-sa da n. a-ze ganxorcielebuli yaCaRuri TavdasxmisfaqtTan dakavSirebiT, SemTxvevis adgilidan, kerZod: ma-RaziaSi, salaro aparatis daxlis win, xis iatakis zedapi-ridan, maRaziaSi Sesasvleli karis win, metlaxis iatakiszedapiridan, tyeSi aRmoCenili naWris qudidan da bral-debul i. g-sgan amoRebuli sunis kvalis nimuSebi vargisiapiris Semdgomi identifikaciisaTvis. 2013 wlis 10 seqtem-bers q. TeTriwyaroSi, didgoris quCis #-Si mdebare maRa-ziaSi l. a-sa da n. a-ze ganxorcielebuli yaCaRuri Tavdas-xmis faqtTan dakavSirebiT, SemTxvevis adgilidan, ker-Zod: maRaziaSi, salaro aparatis daxlis win, xis iatakiszedapiridan da maRaziaSi Sesasvleli karis win, metlaxisiatakis zedapiridan amoRebuli sunis kvalis nimuSebiidenturia braldebul i. g-sgan aRebuli sunis kvalis ni-muSisa.
51
9. usafuZvloa aseve dacvis mxaris mosazreba, rom saq-meSi arsebuli amocnobis oqmebi sasamarTlos dauSvebelmtkicebulebad unda ecno, vinaidan sakasacio palatas mi-aCnia, rom gamoZiebis procesSi i. g-s amocnobisas sapro-ceso kanonmdeblobis moTxovnebi arsebiTad ar darRve-ula.
10. sakasacio palata aseve ar iziarebs dacvis mxarispretenzias, rom i. g-s Catarebuli piradi Cxrekisas poli-ciis TanamSromlebma jibeSi Caudes ori tyvia, ori xel-TaTmani da saTvale, vinaidan aRniSnulis damadasture-beli mtkicebuleba dacvis mxares ar warmoudgenia, xoloe. a-sa da z. m-s Tanmimdevrul da urTierTSeTavsebad Cve-nebebSi eWvis Setanis safuZveli palatas ar gasCenia.
11. dacvis mxaris im argumentTan dakavSirebiT ki, Turatom ar daaTvaliera braldebis mxarem SemTxvevis ad-gili ganmeorebiT, palata miuTiTebs, rom sisxlis samar-Tlis saproceso kodeqsis Sesabamisad, mtkicebulebebismopoveba mxareTa prerogativaa. isini TavianTi Sexedule-bisamebr moipoveben da waradgenen mtkicebulebebs. Se-sabamisad, dacvis mxare uflebamosili iyo, saWiroebis Sem-TxvevaSi Tavad moepovebina is mtkicebulebebi, romel-Tac saWirod miiCnevda Tavisi poziciis dasadastureblad.
12. rac Seexeba msjavrdebul i. g-sTvis saqarTvelosssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtis (yaCaRoba,Cadenili sacavSi ukanono SeRweviT) bralad Seracxvas, pa-lata aRniSnavs, rom braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebidanar ikveTeba, Tu ratom Seeracxa i. g-s aRniSnuli makvali-ficirebeli garemoeba; metic, arc gasaCivrebul ganaCen-Si ar aris msjeloba imis Sesaxeb, Tu konkretulad raSigamoixata msjavrdebulis mier aRniSnuli qmedebis Cade-na. rac Seexeba im faqts, rom Tavdasxma moxda maRaziaSi,palata aRniSnuls ver ganixilavs sadgomSi/sacavSi uka-nono SeRwevad, vinaidan, rogorc saqmis masalebidan ir-kveva, yaCaRoba moxda daaxloebiT 19.20 saaTze, maSin, ro-desac maRazia Ria iyo da samuSao saaTebi ar iyo damTav-rebuli; Sesabamisad, i. g-s ar miumarTavs aranairi ukano-no xerxisTvis maRaziaSi Sesasvlelad da arc hqonda amissaWiroeba, vinaidan mas, iseve rogorc nebismier sxva pirs,iq Sesvlis sruliad kanonieri ufleba hqonda.
13. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, gasaCivrebuli ga-naCenidan unda amoiricxos miTiTeba i. g-s mier yaCaRobis
52
sacavSi ukanono SeRweviT Cadenis Taobaze da braldebisam nawilSi msjavrdebuli unda gamarTldes.
14. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom braldebis moculo-bis Semcirebis gamo, msjavrdebul i. g-s unda Seumsubuq-des Tavisuflebis aRkveTis saxiT daniSnuli sasjeli.
4. 2013 wlis 4 ivnisis fotosuraTiT amocnobis oqmebiTdadgenilia, rom m. k-em amoicno T. C-e da m. g-e.
5. mowme l. z-is CvenebiT, romelic aris T. C-is naTesavidadgenilia, rom 2013 wlis 2 ivniss, dilis saaTebSi, mas-Tan ojaxSi mivida T. C-e. mogvianebiT es ukanaskneli te-lefoniT esaubreboda viRac pirs, ra drosac l. z-ma gai-gona T. C-is saubari, rom RamiT viRac pirTan konfliqtimouxda.
m. k-is sisxli miekuTvneba A /II/ jgufs da Rh (D+) rezusdadebiT faqtors;
m. k-is or maisurze, Sarvalze, trussa da pirsaxoczeaRmoCnda adamianis sisxli, romelic miekuTvneba A /II/jgufs da Rh (D+) rezus dadebiT faqtors;
a/manqanidan amoRebul: or anawmendze aRmoCnda ada-mianis sisxli, romelic miekuTvneba A /II/ jgufs da Rh(D+) rezus dadebiT faqtors;
xelketsa da xelketidan aRebul anawmendze aRmoCndaadamianis sisxli, romelic miekuTvneba A /II/ jgufs da Rh(D+) rezus dadebiT faqtors;
baliSispirze aRmoCnda adamianis sisxli, romelic mi-ekuTvneba A /II/ jgufs da Rh (D+) rezus dadebiT faqtors;
m. k-is sisxli da m. k-is or maisurze, Sarvalze, trusze,pirsaxocze, a/manqanidan amoRebul or anawmendze, bali-Sispirze, xelketsa da xelketidan arsebul anawmendzearsebuli sisxli miekuTvneba A /II/ jgufs da Rh (D+) re-zus dadebiT faqtors.
11. mowme o. a-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom cxovrobsxelvaCauris municipalitetis sofel s-Si. sacxovrebelsaxlSi yofnisas gaigona xma _ moqalaqe iTxovda daxmare-bas. es piri aRmoCnda m. k-e, romelic iyo daWrili. mas da-exmara avtomanqanis mobrunebaSi da gaCerdnen iqve mcxov-reb l. T-is saxlTan. l. T-em dareka saswrafo samedicinodaxmarebis samsaxurSi, imavdroulad ki m. k-is avtomanqa-niT gaemarTnen q. baTumSi, saavadmyofoSi. gzaSi Semox-vdaT saswrafo daxmarebis avtomanqana, romelSic gadaiy-vanes daWrili. o. a-is Cvenebis Tanaxmad, man avtomanqani-dan aiRo fuli _ xuTlariani kupiura da erTlariani rki-nis moneta da iyida sawvavi, romelic Caasxa m. k-is avto-manqanaSi.
12. mowme l. T-em mis mier micemul CvenebaSi daadastu-ra mowme o. a-is mier miTiTebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebi.
13. msjavrdebulebma _ T. C-em da m. g-em sasamarTlo
59
sxdomaze wardgenil braldebaSi Tavi damnaSaved ar cnesda ganmartes, rom maT taqsis mZRolis, dazaralebul m. k-is dayaCaRebis ganzraxva ar hqoniaT. isini apirebdnen me-gobarTan misvlas, romelsac unda mieca fuli taqsis mZRo-lisaTvis gadasacemad. gzaSi mZRoli gabrazda, Tu fuliar gqondaT, ratom wamomiyvaneTo, daiwyo gineba, gaaCeramanqana, saidanac gadmoxta, isinic gadmoxtnen da gaiqcnen.T. C-em aseve ganmarta, rom m. k-e maT daedevna da mas Tavi-sa da zurgis areSi ramdenjerme daartya xelketi, ra dro-sac T. C-em m. k-es fexis areSi daartya dana, ris Semdegacisini gaiqcnen.
14. sakasacio palata yuradRebas amaxvilebs dazarale-bul m. k-is Cvenebis damajereblobaze da miaCnia, rom mas-Si eWvis Setanis safuZveli ar arsebobs, vinaidan mis mierganmartebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebi aseve dasturde-ba: sagamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmiT, avtomanqanis daTva-lierebis oqmiT, trasologiuri da sasamarTlo-samedici-no eqspertizis daskvnebiT, amocnobis oqmebiT da saqme-Si arsebuli sxva mtkicebulebebiT. SemTxvevis adgilzeyofnas da im garemoebas, rom T. C-e da m. g-e mgzavrobdnenm. k-is taqsiT, TviTonac ar uaryofen, Tumca uaryofendayaCaRebis ganzraxvis arsebobas. amasTan, gamokvleulmtkicebulebebs Soris arsebiTi xasiaTis winaaRmdegobe-bi ar fiqsirdeba, rac eWvqveS daayenebda maT sandoobas.
15. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom zemoaRniSnuli er-TmaneTTan SeTanxmebuli, aSkara da damajerebeli mtki-cebulebebis analizis safuZvelze, gonivrul eWvs miRma,utyuarad aris dadasturebuli braldebulebis _ T. C-isada m. g-is mier dazaralebulze jgufurad Tavxasxmis faq-ti sxvisi moZravi nivTis dauflebis mizniT, Cadenili si-cocxlisa da janmrTelobisaTvis saSiSi Zaladobis gamo-yenebis muqariT. mtkicebulebaTa analiziT naTelia da sa-davo ar aris, rom T. C-em da m. g-em daiqiraves m. k-is taqsi,romliTac gadaadgildebodnen s-Si `b-is~ mimdebare te-ritoriisaken. dazaralebul m. k-is CvenebiT, sagamoZieboeqsperimentis oqmiT, amocnobis oqmebiT, avtomanqanisdaTvalierebis oqmiT, romelTa sarwmunoobaSi eWvis Se-tanis safuZveli ar arsebobs, utyuarad dgindeba, rom da-zaralebuls gaaCerebines manqana, T. C-em uknidan miadodana da mimarTa _ `fuli an sulio~, aseve m. g-mac uTxra,rom Cqara mieca fuli. dazaralebulma moaxerxa avtoman-
60
qanidan gadmosvla, avtomanqanis karis gverdidan amoiRojoxi da Tavdamsxmelebis mogeriebis mizniT zurgSi Zli-erad daartya erT-erT maTgans. palata aRniSnavs, rom sa-xezea danaSaulis _ yaCaRobis Semadgenlobis yvela niSa-ni, Tavdasxma dazaralebulze, sicocxlisa da janmrTe-lobisaTvis saSiSi realuri muqara, romlebic mimarTuliiyo dazaralebulis kuTvnili moZravi nivTis dauflebi-saken. aseve calsaxaa, rom m. k-ze TavdasxmaSi erTobli-vad, jgufurad monawileobdnen T. C-e da m. g-e. amdenad,sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom quTaisis saapelacio sasa-marTlos 2014 wlis 27 oqtombris ganaCeni T. C-isa da m. g-is msjavrdebis Taobaze ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis`b~ qvepunqtiT gaTvaliswinebul danaSaulSi kanonieriada am nawilSi unda darCes ucvlelad.
16. rac Seexeba T. C-is msjavrdebas ganzrax mkvlelo-bis mcdelobaSi, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom gamokvle-uli mtkicebulebebiT _ dazaralebulis CvenebiT, saga-moZiebo eqsperimentis oqmiT, avtomanqanis daTvaliere-bis oqmiT, trasologiuri da sasamarTlo-samedicino eq-spertizis daskvnebiT, amocnobis oqmiT utyuarad das-turdeba, rom T. C-em ganzrax mokvlis mizniT dazarale-bul m. k-es miayena sicocxlisaTvis saxifaTo, mZime xaris-xis dazianebebi. aRsaniSnavia, rom, zogadad, danis dar-tymas dazaralebulisaTvis ar uaryofs msjavrdebuli T.C-ec, Tumca miuTiTebs, rom imyofeboda aucilebeli mo-geriebis mdgomareobaSi.
17. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatorebis miTiTe-bas, rom T. C-e imyofeboda aucilebeli mogeriebis mdgo-mareobaSi, kerZod:
saqarTvelos ssk-is 28-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Tanaxmad,marTlsawinaaRmdegod ar moqmedebs is, vinc am kodeqsiTgaTvaliswinebul qmedebas Caidens aucilebeli mogerie-bis mdgomareobaSi, e.i. vinc marTlsawinaaRmdego xelyo-fisas daazianebs xelmyofs Tavisi an sxvisi samarTlebri-vi sikeTis dasacavad.
palata aRniSnavs, rom aucilebeli mogeriebis mdgoma-reobas axasiaTebs ramdenime niSani, kerZod, samarTleb-rivi sikeTis xelyofa, romelic unda iyos imwuTieri darealuri. am SemTxvevaSi arsebuli mocemuloba, im piro-bebSi, rodesac dazaralebuli m. k-e qvis TavSi dartymisSedegad daeca da am dros mas (waqceul kacs) samjer daar-
61
tya dana T. C-em, ver miiCneva samarTlebrivi sikeTis xel-yofad, miT umetes _ realurad da imwuTierad, rac T. C-esmiscemda aucilebeli mogeriebis _ danis dartymis ufle-bas m. k-isaTvis. amdenad, kasatorebis apelireba am gare-moebaze usafuZvloa da ar arsebobs ganzrax mkvlelobismcdelobis nawilSi quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2014wlis 27 oqtombris gasaCivrebuli ganaCenis Secvlis an ga-uqmebis safuZveli.
18. amdenad, sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatorebismTiTebas T. C-isa da m. g-is udanaSaulobis Sesaxeb da miaC-nia, rom quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2014 wlis 27 oqtombris ganaCeni ma-Ti msjavrdebis Taobaze unda darCes ucvlelad.
g. SavliaSvili (Tavmjdomare)m. oSxareli,p. silagaZe
monawileobiT ganixila msjavrdebul g. l-sa da misi in-teresebis damcvelis, advokat m. C-s sakasacio saCivariTbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 18 noembrisganaCenze.
9. kasatorebi _ msjavrdebuli g. l-e da advokati m. C-isakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnaven, rom msjavrdebuls arhqonda avtomanqanis dauflebisa da misakuTrebis mizanida ganzraxva; igi avtomanqanaSi mxolod imitom Cajda, romsurda dazaralebulebisaTvis xelebi gaexsna da gaeTavi-suflebina; g. l-m ar icis manqanis marTva, amitom mas verdaeufleboda.
10. sayuradReboa isic, rom dakavebis dros g. l-e po-licielTa mxridan ganxorcielebuli fizikuri zewolisgamo dainvalidda; g. l-e ar aris nasamarTlevi; hyavs mci-rewlovani Svili da moxuci mSoblebi; dazaralebulebsmis mimarT aranairi pretenzia ar gaaCniaT; aRiarebs rea-lurad Cadenil danaSauls; ar gaaCnia pasuxismgeblobisdamamZimebeli garemoebebi.
wavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma saCivris safuZvlianobada miaCnia, rom kasatorebis moTxovna ar unda dakmayo-fildes da gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvle-lad Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. pirvel yovlisa, sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom sa-qarTvelos sssk-is 306-e muxlis me-4 nawilis Tanaxmad, sa-kasacio saCivari ganixileba saCivris farglebSi, Sesaba-misad, sakasacio palata ar Seafasebs gasaCivrebuli gana-
3. rac Seexeba g. l-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `g~ da me-3 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtebiT (yaCaRo-ba satransporto saSualebis winaaRmdeg da didi odeno-biT nivTis dauflebis mizniT) msjavrdebas, sakasacio pa-lata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlos argumen-tebs g. l-s mier misTvis bralad Seracxuli danaSaulisCadenis Taobaze da miaCnia, rom aRniSnuli gonivrul eWvsmiRma standartiTaa dadasturebuli kanonis moTxovna-Ta sruli dacviT, srulyofilad da obieqturad gamok-vleuli, utyuari, urTierTSejerebuli da sakmarisi mtki-cebulebebis erTobliobiT, kerZod:
4. dazaralebulebis _ g. d-sa da e. S-s CvenebebiT dadge-nilia, rom g. l-m da gamoZiebiT daudgenelma pirma g. d-se.w. `skoCiT~ Seukres xelebi, mokvlis muqariT gadaiyvanesmanqanidan da Casves sabargulSi, sadac is imyofeboda po-liciis TanamSromelTa mier mis gaTavisuflebamde, xolodazaralebul e. S-s ki xelebi Seukres da muqariT aiZules,xma ar amoeRo da ise mjdariyo avtomanqanis ukana savar-Zelze, ris Semdegac Tavdamsxmelebma daZres avtomanqanada daaxloebiT 2 wuTis ganmavlobaSi gadaadgildebodnensaavtomobilo gzis gverdis avliT, ris Semdegac manqanagaCerda da Tavdamsxmelebi gadavidnen avtomanqanidan,Tumca maleve g. l-e dabrunda da dajda avtomanqanis wina,marjvena savarZelze. amave dros adgilze aseve gamoCndnenpolicielebic, romlebmac daakaves l-e.
5. palata miuTiTebs, rom dazaralebulebis mier aRwe-ril faqtobriv garemoebebs arc msjavrdebuli xdis sa-davod, Tumca apelirebs imaze, rom mas ar hqonia manqanisgatacebisa da, Sesabamisad, didi odenobiT nivTis dauf-lebis mizani.
6. aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiT palata miuTiTebs, romyaCaRoba formalur danaSaulTa kategorias miekuTvnebada damTavrebulia Tavdasxmis momentidan _ anu im momen-tidan, rodesac g. l-e sxva pirTan erTad sicocxlisa dajanmrTelobisaTvis saSiSi Zaladobis muqariT daeufla
66
satransporto saSualebas da Tavisi Sexedulebisamebr ga-moiyena igi.
5. nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: mobiluri kompaniebidanamoRebuli detaluri nusxa sam CD diskad; ss `T-s~ saqmi-anobis amsaxveli eleqtronuli informacia xuT DVD dis-kad Senaxul unda iqnes sisxlis samarTlis saqmis Senax-vis vadiT; i. b-s saxelze gacemuli saqarTvelos moqala-qis pasporti # saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRe-bis Semdeg unda daubrundes i. b-s an misi ndobiT aRWur-vil pirs.
6. ganaCeniT msjavrdebul i. b-s mier Cadenili danaSau-li gamoixata SemdegSi:
TloSi sarCelis ganxilvamde, a. w-i da misi siZe T. f-e im-yofebodnen b-i, ra drosac a. w-s mobiluri telefonis meS-veobiT daukavSirda i. b-e, Sexvda maT sastumros foieSida uTxra, rom i. C-a da d. t-n erTad apirebda Sps `s-s~ Se-Zenas, romelsac `k-n~ SeZenili hqonda Sps `s-s~ 70% wili.manve a. w-s mosTxova uari eTqva sarCelze, winaaRmdeg Sem-TxvevaSi daemuqra misi da misi ojaxis wevrebis mimarT Za-ladobis gamoyenebiT, biznesisa da qonebis dazianeba-ga-nadgurebiT.
12. a. w-i winaaRmdegi iyo, daeTmo misTvis sasamarTlosgadawyvetilebis safuZvelze miniWebuli Sps `s-s~ 100%wili, ris gamoc i. b-e kvlav ganagrZobda fizikuri ganad-gurebis muqariT sarCelze uaris Tqmis moTxovnas. 2011wlis martis meore naxevarSi i. b-e ramdenjerme Sexvda a.w-s mis ofisSi, mdebare q. T-i, z-s quCaze. aRniSnuli Sex-vedris drosac i. b-e kvlav ganagrZobda Zaladobis da qo-nebis dazianeba-ganadgurebis muqariT eiZulebina a. w-i,uari eTqva saapelacio sasamarTloSi sarCelze da Sps `s-s~ 70% wili kvlav daregistrirebuliyo Sps `s-s~ saxelze,romelic SeiZina i. b-s, i. C-a da d. t-s kompaniam _ `p-m~.
13. zemoaRniSnuli muqarebi a. w-a aRiqva misTvis da mi-si axlo naTesavebisaTvis realur safrTxed da mosalod-neli Zaladobis Tavidan aridebis mizniT daTanxmda i. b-ssaapelacio sasamarTloSi sarCelis ukan gamoTxovaze.
14. mas Semdeg, rac i. b-m a.w-n miiRo Tanxmoba sarCelisgamoTxovasTan dakavSirebiT, romlis safuZvelzec aR-dgeboda sasamarTloSi davis dawyebamde arsebuli mdgo-mareoba da Sps `s-e~ dafiqsirdeboda Sps `s-s~ 70%-iani wi-li, xolo T. f-s saxelze _ 30%-iani wili, man Tavisi, i. C-ada d. t-s saxeliT, garda garantirebuli 70% wilisa, dama-tebiT moiTxova T. f-s saxelze registrirebuli 30% wi-lidan 15%-is Sps `s-s~ sasargeblod daTmoba, winaaRmdegSemTxvevaSi kvlav daemuqra misi da misi ojaxis wevrebismimarT Zaladobis gamoyenebiTa da qonebis dazianeba-ga-nadgurebiT. a. w-a muqara kvlav aRiqva ra realur saf-rTxed, mosalodneli angariSsworebisa da Zaladobis Ta-vidan aridebis mizniT, daTanxmda T. f-s saxelze dafiq-sirebuli 30% wilidan 15% wilis Sps `s-s~ sasargebloddaTmobas. aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiT, 2011 wlis 24 marts,vidre a. w-i uars ityoda sarCelze, T. f-a da i. b-s Sorisgaformda garigeba Sps `s-s~ 15% wilis nasyidobis Sesaxeb,
70
romelSic miTiTebul iqna, rom xelSekruleba ZalaSi Se-vidoda mas Semdeg, rac a. w-i uars ityoda sarCelze daT.f-s daubrundeboda 30% wili sawarmoSi.
21. nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: mobiluri kompaniebidanamoRebuli detaluri nusxa sam CD diskad; ss `T-s~ saqmi-anobis amsaxveli eleqtronuli informacia xuT DVD dis-kad Senaxul unda iqnes sisxlis samarTlis saqmis Senax-vis vadiT; i. b-s saxelze gacemuli saqarTvelos moqala-qis pasporti # saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRe-bis Semdeg unda daubrundes i. b-s an misi ndobiT aRWur-vil pirs.
22. gamarTlebul i. b-s ganemarta, rom ufleba aqvs, au-nazRaurdes miyenebuli ziani.
sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas, yovelmxriv da obieqturadSeamowma saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebani, Seafasa TiTo-euli maTgani saqmesTan maTi relevanturobis, dasaSvebo-bisa da utyuarobis TvalsazrisiT da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom saxelmwifo bralmdeblis, prokuror m. j-s saka-sacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoeba-Ta gamo:
2. i. b-m Tavi ar cno damnaSaved wardgenil braldebaSida aCvena, rom 2011 wlis Tebervlis bolos an martis da-sawyisSi daukavSirda misi megobari i. C-i, romelmac uT-xra, rom Tambaqos warmoebis aqciebis SesaZenad i. C-n awar-moebda molaparakebebs da aRniSnulis Sesaxeb ecnobebi-na a. w-s. igi Sexvda a. w-s b-i, sastumro `k-s~ foieSi da in-formaciis saxiT miawoda, rom i. C-s ukve dasrulebulihqonda molaparakebebi i. g-a da i. C-n da Sps `s-s~ 70%-ismflobeli xdeboda. misi varaudiT, a. w-i informirebuliiyo amis Sesaxeb, ris gamoc Cavida b-i. Sexvedrisas masa daa. w-s Soris aranair daZabulobasa da konfliqts adgiliar hqonia. man ubralod informacia miawoda momxdaris Se-saxeb.
72
3. misi CvenebiT, igi dainiSna aRniSnuli sawarmos di-reqtorad da informacias awvdida sawarmoSi arsebulimdgomareobis Sesaxeb i. C-s. a. w-i Tanaxma iyo, rom 70% wi-lis mflobeli yofiliyo i. C-i, xolo 30%-is _ TviTon, ro-melic ganaxorcielebda sadistribucio saqmianobas, ub-ralod, ver SeTanxmda i. C-n marTvis sakiTxze, kerZod: a.w-s surda, rom isini darCeniliyvnen marTvis sakiTxSi.problemebi gaCnda maSin, rodesac i. C-a gaarkvia, rom sa-warmosTan ukve aRar iyo kavSirSi samarko niSnebi, dis-tribucia. a. w-a da i. C-s Soris SeTanxmeba ver iqna miRweu-li, ris Semdegac Seiqmna axali kompania, romelic dRemdeaxorcielebs distribucias. am ukanasknels a. w-s kompani-isgan SeZenili avtomobilebi ijariT hqonda aRebuli, ra-Sic Tanxas uxdidnen. Semdgom mocemul sawarmos statusiSeecvala da gaxda saaqcio sazogadoeba. igi amis Semdeggaxda saaqcio sazogadoebis sameTvalyureo sabWos Tav-mjdomare.
4. misive CvenebiT, mas araviTari molaparakeba an sau-bari ar hqonia d. t-n Tambaqos warmoebasTan dakavSire-biT. misTvis ucnobia, Tu ratom an rogor moxda 15%-isgadaformeba, man mxolod am faqtis Semdeg ganviTarebu-li movlenebi icis i. C-n, rac gamoiwvia valebma, distribu-ciam, samarko niSnebma da sxva. erTaderTi, rac man i. C-sdavalebiT moagvara, iyo distribuciis sakiTxi. distri-buciasTan dadebuli xelSekrulebis gauqmebis SemdegwarmoiSva samarTlebrivi dava. davis sagani iyo is Tanxa,romelic waRebuli hqondaT qarxnidan wina distribuci-ebs da qarxanaSi ar iyo es Tanxa Semosuli. mocemuli davadasrulda morigebiT.
5. dazaralebul a. w-s CvenebiT, 2004 wlidan igi arisSps ̀ s-s~ 100%-iani wilis mflobeli. 2007 wlis ianvris Tve-Si man Sps `s-s~ 100%-iani wili nasyidobis xelSekrulebissafuZvelze gadasca b. p-s kompania `k-s~. nasyidobis sag-nis Rirebuleba ganisazRvra daaxloebiT 8 700 000 aSS do-lariT. vinaidan a. w-s b. p-n hqonda kargi urTierToba, Se-Tanxmdnen, rom Tanxas gadauxdida ori wlis ganmavloba-Si. b. p-i gardaicvala ise, rom Tanxa ar gadauxdia. garkve-uli periodis Semdeg kompania, romelic 2007 wlis ianvrisTveSi wilis gasxvisebis xelSekrulebiT mihyida kompania`k-s~, aRmoCnda i. C-s faqtobriv mflobelobaSi ise, rom`k-s~ nakisri valdebuleba mis mimarT ar Seusrulebia. amis
6. 2011 wlis martis dasawyisSi ojaxTan erTad imyofe-boda b-i, sadac i. b-e telefoniT daukavSirda da uTxra,rom masTan undoda Sexvedra. satelefono saubridan ram-denime dReSi i. b-e Sexvda mas sastumro `k-s~ foieSi i. C-ada d. t-s davalebiT, ra drosac ganucxada, rom apireb-dnen Sps `s-s~ SeZenas, romelsac `k-n~ SeZenili hqonda Sps`s-s~ 70%-iani wili, Tumca a. w-s gaukvirda, rogor apireb-dnen aRniSnuli warmoebis SeZenas, radgan TviTon iyo100%-iani wilis mflobeli. aseve uTxra, rom 2011 wlis 11Tebervlis gadawyvetilebaze maT mier Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTloSi Setanil sarCels daTanxmebuliyo dauari eTqva Tavis sarCelze. winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi i. b-edaemuqra Svilisa da siZis daWeriT da sicocxlis xelyo-fiT.
7. saqarTveloSi Camosvlis Semdeg i. b-e kvlav daukav-Sirda isev imave muqariTa da daSinebiT. saqarTveloSi isi-ni erTmaneTs xvdebodnen T-i, z-s quCa #-Si mdebare ofis-Si. yoveli Sexvedra damuqrebiT da daSinebiT mimdinare-obda.
8. i. b-e Sps `s-s~ 70% wilis garda, aseve misgan iTxovdaT. f-s saxelze gaformebuli 30% wilidan 15% wilis daT-mobas. maTi saerTo moTxovna iyo, rom mieRoT Sps `s-s~ 85%wili, rac imas niSnavda, rom garda Sps `s-s~ kuTvnili 70%wilisa, T. f-s kuTvnili 30%-dan unda daeTmo 15%. wina-aRmdeg SemTxvevaSi daemuqra, rom finansur policias Se-uSvebda masTan, aseve daemuqra siZisa da Svilis daWeriTda sicocxlis xelyofiT.
9. a. w-s ganmartebiT, i. b-m telefoniT daakavSira i. C-n,romelmac uTxra, rom misi interesi iyo, aseve telefo-niT esaubra d. t-s, romelsac aseve uari uTxra wilis daT-mobaze. Semdeg erT-erTi Sexvedris dros i. b-m gadascaTavisi telefoni da alaparaka i. m-n, romelmac uTxra, ra-sac geubneba, yvelaferi gaakeTeo. `cota, iseTi toniT da
74
maSin ukve yvelaferi gasagebi iyo CemTvis.~ a. w-a pirveliinstanciis sasamarTloSi saqmis ganxilvisas aseve ganac-xada, rom `m-s SemeSinda me, Torem amaTi ki ar SemSinebia~.i. m-s igi piradad icnobda, asjer maincaa Sexvedrili daamitom darwmunda, rom telefonze swored igi elapara-keboda, Tumca ise swrafad moaxdines zemoqmedeba, rom i.m-n situaciis garkveva ver moaswro. a. w-a muqara realu-rad aRiqva, ris gamoc iZulebuli gaxda, daTanxmeboda i.b-s moTxovnas. marTalia, gamoZiebaSi micemul pirvel Cve-nebaSi sicocxlis xelyofis muqara ar aqvs miTiTebuli,radgan is pasuxobda gamomZieblis kiTxvebs. amasTan, `si-cocxlis xelyofis ~ muqara mas naxsenebi aqvs Tavis Sem-dgom CvenebebSi, roca gamomZiebelma kiTxva dausva.
10. mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas T. f-m aCvena, rom 2011 wlismartSi imyofeboda b-i a. w-n erTad. b-i yofnis dros a. w-stelefonze daukavSirda i. b-e da uTxra, rom masTan un-doda Sexvedra. satelefono saubris Semdeg i. b-e SexvdamaT b-i sastumro `k-s~ foieSi da dasxdnen sasaubrod, radrosac i. b-m uTxra a. w-s, rom misuli iyo i. C-a da d. t-sdavalebiT, romelTac Sps `s-s~ SeZenis survili hqondaTda aRniSnulis gamo a. w-s saapelacio sasamarTloSi uariunda eTqva sarCelsa da Sps `s-s~ 100%-ian wilze, razedaca. w-a uari ganucxada, ris Semdegac i. b-m uTxra, nu gavar-TulebT situacias da daiwyo muqara Svilze, biznesze. b-i maT mouxdaT konfliqti da i. b-e xelis kvriT gamoagdes.Semdeg a. w-s i. b-e xvdeboda T-i. erT-erTi Sexvedris drostelefoniT daakavSira d. t-a da i. m-n. i. m-a uTxra, rasacgeubnebian, is gaakeTeo. mowmis CvenebiT, marto i. b-e, er-Ti kaci, maT ver moereoda, magram iyvnen misi `amfsonebi~,vinc exmarebodnen da amitomac CaTvales muqarad. T. f-sganmartebiT, `mogklav da tyvias dagaxli~, aseTi saxis mu-qara ar yofila, magram i. b-e eubneboda: `nu gavarTulebTsituacias, gamoitaneT sarCeli, finansuri policia CvensxelSia, Svili gyavs~. aseve iyo sicocxlis xelyofis muqa-ra. T. f-s ganmartebiT, i. b-e marto rom misuliyo da ardaesaxelebina C-i, t-i da m-i, wils ar gadauformebda. mi-sive ganmartebiT, mas sicocxlis xelyofis muqarasTan da-kavSirebiT, gamomZieblisTvis ar uTqvams, rogori konteq-stiTac iyo kiTxva dasmuli, im mimarTebiT gasca pasuxi.
11. mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas b. x-m pirveli instanciissasamarTloSi daadastura is garemoeba, rom 2011 wlis ga-
75
zafxulze imyofeboda b-i. masTan erTad imyofebodnen a.w-i da misi siZe _ T. f-e meuRleebTan erTad da cxovrob-dnen sastumro `k-i~. 2011 wlis martSi a. w-a da T. f-n er-Tad imyofeboda sastumros foieSi, ra drosac mivida i. b-e, romelmac saubari daiwyo a. w-n, xolo TviTon datovasastumro. sastumroSi dabrunebisas ki a. w-n Seityo, romi. b-e gamogzavnili iyo i. C-a da d. t-s mier da iTxovdnenmisgan Tambaqos qarxnis daTmobas. winaaRmdeg SemTxveva-Si Svilisa da siZis `aorTqlebiT~ emuqrebodnen.
12. mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas z. b-a ganacxada, rom a. w-naqvs samsaxurebrivi urTierToba, romelic gadadis erTma-neTis ndobaSi. 2007 wels a. w-a Sps `s-s~ 100%-iani wili mih-yida kompania ̀ k-s~. xelSekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli Tan-xa _ 8.760.000 aSS dolari unda gadaxdiliyo ori wlis gan-mavlobaSi. sabolood Sps `s-s~ 100%-iani wili gadavida i.C-s xelSi ise, rom a. w-s Tanxa aravis gadauxdia, rac mis-Tvis cnobilia a. w-n. a. w-i i. C-n moiTxovda misi kuTvniliqonebis dabrunebas, ris Sedegadac man miaRwia imas, romSps `s-a~ daTmo Sps `s-s~ 30%-iani wili a. w-s sasargeblod,rac samewarmeo reestrSi registrirebul iqna misi siZis _T. f-s saxelze. garkveuli periodis Semdeg a. w-i agrZe-lebda wilis dabrunebasTan dakavSirebiT moTxovnas. vi-naidan es sakiTxi gaWianurda, pirvandeli mdgomareobisaRdgenis moTxovniT sarCeliT mimarTa Tbilisis saqala-qo sasamarTlos. aRniSnuli moTxovna daakmayofila Tbi-lisis saqalaqo sasamarTlom da gadawyvetileba dauyov-nebliv mieqca aRsasruleblad.
13. 2011 wlis martSi a. w-i ojaxTan erTad imyofebodab-i. b-n dabrunebis Semdeg a. w-n Seityo, rom i. b-e b-i iyoCasuli masTan da i. C-a da d. t-s saxeliT iTxovda misganSps `s-s~ 100%-ian wilze uaris Tqmas, razedac a. w-a uariganucxada, ris gamoc, rogorc misTvis cnobilia, iyo a. w-ada misi ojaxis, aseve misi biznesis mimarT `awiokebis~ mu-qara. a. w-i aRniSnuli muqaris gamo iZulebuli gaxda, da-Tanxmeboda maT moTxovnas.
14. 2011 wlis maisis meore naxevarSi z. b-i stumrad im-yofeboda a. w-n, ra drosac a. w-a sTxova masTan darCena,radgan i. b-e apirebda misvlas. rodesac i. b-e mivida, a. w-nkategoriuli toniT iTxovda sarCelis gamotanas. a. w-a ua-ri uTxra da karisken miuTiTa, amaze i. b-m uTxra maT: `na-xavT Tqven, Tu ar gaitrupoT~. mowmis ganmartebiT, i. b-e
76
emuqreboda yvelas, vinc samsaxurebrivad dakavSirebu-li iyo a. w-n, visac Sexeba hqonda sigaretis warmoebasa dadistribuciasTan, maT Soris _ masac.
15. mowme o. f-m ganacxada, rom iyo Sps `p-s~-s direqto-ri, romelic Sps `s-s~ uwevda sadistribucio momsaxure-bas. 2011 wlis maisis dasawyisSi mas daukavSirda T. f-e dauTxra, rom misuliyo Sps `s-i~ i. b-n da xeli moewera SeTan-xmebis aqtze Sps `p-d~-sa da Sps `s-s~ Soris distribucias-Tan dakavSirebuli xelSekrulebis Sewyvetaze. mis kiT-xvaze, Tu ra xdeboda, T. f-m uTxra, rom `biznesi wagvar-Tveso~. amis Semdeg Sexvda Tambaqos qarxnis ofisSi i. b-s,romelmac daaxvedra dabeWdili saxiT gamzadebuli do-kumenti _ SeTanxmeba `xelSekrulebis Sewyvetis Taoba-ze~’. SeTanxmebis Tanaxmad, Sps `p-d~ da Sps `s-a~ Tanxmde-bodnen xelSekrulebis upirobo Sewyvetaze, maT Soris _pirgasamtexlos moTxovnaze uaris Tqmazec. amis SemdegdaukavSirda i. b-e da sTxova Sexvedra sakuTar binaSi. Sex-vedrisas man ikiTxa, Tu rogor moxda biznesSi partnio-rebis Canacvleba, radgan icoda, rom Sps `s-s~ 100%-ianiwilis mflobeli iyo a. w-i, razedac i. b-m ganumarta, rom a.w-s biznesi waarTves, ris Semdegac SesTavaza TanamSrom-loba, razedac TviTon daTanxmda. mowmis CvenebiT, i. b-migi gaaTavisufla samsaxuridan. igi masze aris nawyeni, xo-lo a. w-n aqvs kargi, megobruli urTierToba.
16. mowme n. T-a ganacxada, rom 2008 wlidan muSaobs a. w-s mdivan-TanaSemwed. 2011 wlis martSi a. w-a gaafrTxila i.b-s mosvlis Taobaze. cota xanSi mivida mamakaci, romelicgaecno rogorc i. b-e da Seiyvana a. w-n kabinetSi. mas Sem-deg a. w-n i. b-e ramdenjerme, sxvadasxva dResac iyo misu-li. man daadastura is garemoeba, rom a. w-s kabinetidan i.b-s stumrobis dros yovelTvis ismoda xmamaRali saubarida im periodSi a. w-i yovelTvis iyo aRelvebuli.
17. mowme z. T-m ganacxada, rom muSaobda a. w-n dacvisTanamSromlad. stumris mosvlis Taobaze saqmis kursSiayenebda n. T-i. igi xvdeboda mosul stumars da acilebdan. T-s oTaxamde, xolo mas stumari Sehyavda a. w-n. 2011 wlismartSi a. w-s ofisSi xSirad modioda i. b-e. man daadasturais garemoeba, rom i. b-s stumrobis dros a. w-i xSirad iyoaRelvebuli.
18. mowme i. C-a ganacxada, rom Sps `s-i~ flobda 70% wilsSps `s-i~, danarCeni 30% wilis mflobeli iyo a. w-s siZe _ T.
77
f-e. rogorc misTvis cnobilia, kompania `k-s~ Tanxis gada-ricxvis operacia ar ganuxorcielebia. a. w-a Tbilisis sa-qalaqo sasamarTlos mimarTa sarCeliT Sps `s-i~ 100% wi-lis dabrunebis moTxovniT. aRniSnuli sarCeli dakmayo-filda da Sps `s-s~ 100% wilis mflobelad Tbilisis saqa-laqo sasamarTlom aRiara a. w-i. mocemuli gadawyvetile-ba gasaCivrda saapelacio wesiT. amis Semdeg i. C-s SesTava-za Sps `s-s~ SeZena, romelic flobda 70% wils Sps `s-i~.manve uTxra i. C-s, rom aRniSnulze mimdinareobda davaTbilisis saapelacio sasamarTloSi. marTalia, pirvel in-stanciaSi sarCeli dakmayofilda da a. w-i gaxda Sps `s-s~100%-iani wilis mflobeli, magram apelaciis wesiT SeiZ-leboda sawarmos 70% wilis ukan dabruneba, romelsac ma-namde flobda Sps `s-i~, razedac igi daTanxmda. gaformdasammxrivi SeTanxmeba i. C-s, masa da i. g-s Soris, romlisTanaxmadac, i.C-a i. C-n SeiZina 70% wili Sps `s-i~ da sanac-vlod unda gadaexada 2 500.000 aSS dolari, saidanac1.250.000 aSS dolari ekuTvnoda i. g-s. misTvis ucnobia, i.g-m miiRo Tu ara aRniSnuli odenobis Tanxa. Tavad ki xel-SekrulebiT gaTvaliswinebuli Tanxa ar miuRia.
19. mowme a. a-m ganacxada, rom 2011 wlis ivnisidan arisss `T-s~ (igive Sps `s-a~) direqtori, xolo i. b-e _ sameT-valyureo sabWos Tavmjdomare. xsenebuli kompaniis dam-fuZneblebi arian Sps ,`s-i~ 85% wiliT da a. w-i _ 15% wi-liT. igi kurirebs warmoebis process, xolo kompaniisstrategiul marTvas aTanxmebs i. C-n. 2011 wlis zafxulSiSewyda xelSekruleba Sps `p-7~-sa da Sps `p-d~-s Soris, ro-melic axorcielebda ss `T-s~ distribucias, romlis dam-fuZnebeli da mflobeli iyo a. w-i. amis Semdeg dafuZndaSps `g-a~, romelmac daiwyo aRniSnuli kompaniis nawarmisdistribucia.
20. mowme d. t-a ganacxada, rom i. b-s icnobs da megob-robs masTan. a. w-s arasdros Sexvedria. biznesTan saer-Tod aranairi Sexeba ar hqonia da saerTod misTvis ucno-bia, Tu sad mdebareobs Tambaqos qarxana saqarTveloSi.
21. mowme T. S-m ganacxada, rom 2011 wels dainiSna Sps`s-i~ finansur direqtorad. misTvis cnobilia a. w-a da T.f-n sawarmos xelmZRvanelobis mxridan gamarTuli mola-parakebebis Sesaxeb, romelic exeboda sawarmosa da T. f-skuTvnil sadistribucio kompaniebs Soris gaformebulixelSekrulebis gauqmebas, aseve _ sawarmos kuTvnili sa-
78
marko niSnebis gasxvisebas. molaparakebebi agreTve exe-boda a. w-a da T. f-s mxridan, misi ganmartebiT, dausabu-Tebuli valis moTxovnas Sps `s-s~ mimarT. misTvis cnobi-lia, rom T. f-s kompanias gadaxdili hqonda daaxloebiTxuTi milion samoci aTasi lari, xolo danarCen TanxazeSedga morigebis aqti.
22. mowme i. C-a ganacxada, rom 2011 wlis martSi, lon-donSi yofnisas, daukavSirda i. C-i da SesTavaza `s-s~ 70%wilis SeZena, razedac upasuxa, rom mas sWirdeboda dro,raTa enaxa, iuridiulad ra mdgomareoba iyo warmoebaSi,aseve dainteresda, Tu vin iyo i. C-s partniori. misTviscnobili gaxda, rom arsebobda rigi procesualuri dar-Rvevebi, magram SeTanxmebas miaRwia i. C-a da i. g-n. proble-mebis warmoSoba daiwyo iqidan, rom i. C-a rac mihyida mas,praqtikulad araferi ar aRmoCnda adgilze. man konkre-tul SemTxvevaSi warmoeba iyida Tavisi distribuciiT dadistribucia adgilze ar iyo. distribucia ukve a. w-s or-ganizacias hqonda da ara _ mas. samarko niSnebi, romelicZiriTadi kapitalia, am organizaciis aRar iyo. igi gada-formebuli iyo simbolur fasad raRac organizaciaze, ro-melsac flobda a. w-s organizaciis erT-erTi wevri. ro-desac man moiTxova, rom es yvelaferi unda dabrunebu-liyo, a. w-n miiRo uari. man advokatebis daxmarebiT sarCe-li Seitana 2011 wlis martis bolos. erT-erTi sarCeliTiTxovdnen 30%-is `s-s~ dabrunebas, vinaidan es gasxvisebamoxda arasworad. distribuciaze verafers ver miaRwies.misive CvenebiT, distribuciis manqanebis daqiraveba xde-boda im kompaniisgan, romelsac a. w-i flobda. Tanxas ux-didnen, sanam moaxerxes sadistribucio manqanebis yidva.aseve moiTxovda im ukanonod miTvisebuli 30%-is dabru-nebas, rac mas ekuTvnoda, Tumca didi kamaTiTa da saub-rebiT, iuristebisa da auditorebis CareviT sabolood Se-Tanxmdnen, rom a. w-i uars ityoda TerTmeti milioni la-ris moTxovnaze, sawarmos daubrundeboda samarko niSne-bi, gauqmdeboda distribuciis Sesaxeb kabaluri xelSek-ruleba da a. w-n iyidda 15%-ian wils. sanacvlod igi a. w-sar mosTxovda distribuciis davalianebas, daaxloebiT _3.400.000 an 3.500.000 laris odenobiT, damatebiT gadaux-dida erT milion aSS dolars da distribuciis manqanebidarCeboda a. w-s.
23. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saqmeSi braldebis
79
mxaris mier warmodgenili zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebisasamarTlos ar aZlevs calsaxad da erTmniSvnelovnadim daskvnis gakeTebis saSualebas, rom i. b-m Caidina gamo-Zalva, e.i. sxvisi qonebrivi uflebis gadacemis moTxovna,rasac Tan erTvis dazaralebulisa da misi axlo naTesavismimarT Zaladobis gamoyenebis, maTi nivTis ganadgurebisda dazianebis muqara, Cadenili didi odenobiT qonebismiRebis mizniT, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 181-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis `g~ qvepunqtiT.
24. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom gamoZalvis Semad-genlobis sakanonmdeblo konstruqciidan gamomdinare,gamoZalvis sagans warmoadgens rogorc qoneba, ise qone-baze ufleba (xelwerili, xelSekruleba an sxva dokumen-ti), romlis Tanaxmadac, gansazRvruli qonebrivi uflebaan qonebiT sargebloba damnaSaveze gadadis. gamoZalvisobieqturi Semadgenloba gamoixateba damnaSavis mier qo-nebis mesakuTris an qonebis mflobelis mimarT moTxov-naSi, gadasces mas nivTi an masze ufleba, aseve qonebiTsargeblobis ufleba.
25. danaSaulis konstruqciidan gamomdinare, SesaZle-belia, qonebis ukanono moTxovna gulisxmobdes mis gada-cemas damnaSavisaTvis sasurveli sxva pirisaTvis. amasTan,am moTxovnas Tan erTvis dazaralebulis an misi axlo na-Tesavis mimarT muqara. muqara SeiZleba gamoxatuli iyosrogorc zepiri, ise werilobiTi formiT, telefoniTa dasxva.
26. braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebis mixedviT, i. b-s bra-li daedo imaSi, rac 1-li instanciis sasamarTlom damtki-cebulad cno, rom a. w-a da misi ojaxis wevrebis mimarTZaladobis gamoyenebis muqariT, gamoZalviT daeufla di-di odenobiT _ 110 000-lariani sawesdebo kapitalis mqo-ne Sps `s-s~ 85%-ian wils, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebulisaqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 181-e muxlisme-2 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT.
27. mocemul SemTxvevaSi saqmis masalebiT utyuaraddadgenilia is garemoeba, rom, marTalia, Tbilisis saqa-laqo sasamarTlos 2011 wlis 11 Tebervlis gadawyvetile-biT a. w-s moTxovna dakmayofilda da Sps `s-s~ 100% wilismflobeli gaxda a. w-i, magram im periodSi, rodesac bral-deba edaveba i. b-s a. w-s qonebis gamoZalvas, a. w-s saxelze
80
ar iricxeboda sakuTrebis uflebiT Sps `s-s~ 85 %-iani wi-li. winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi, 2011 wlis 22 marts ver gafor-mdeboda yidva-gayidvis xelSekruleba, romlis Tanaxmad,i. C-s kompania `p-a~ gaxda Sps `s-s~ mesakuTre, xolo imavewlis 24 marts aseve ver gaformdeboda 15%-iani wilis nas-yidobis xelSekruleba T. f-n, maSin, rodesac a. w-a sar-Celze uari Tqva amave wlis 31 marts.
28. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom mocemulSemTxvevaSi saxeze ar gvaqvs gamoZalvis sagani da, Sesaba-misad, a. w-s sakuTrebis uflebas ver miadgeboda ziani,vinaidan kanonmdeblobiT dadgenili wesiT sajaro rees-trSi a. w-i sadavo qonebaze mesakuTred ar yofila aRric-xuli.
29. braldebis mxare da 1-li instanciis sasamarTlosganaCeni calsaxad dadasturebulad miiCnevs im garemoe-bas, rom i. b-e aris mxolod is subieqti, romelmac gamos-Zala Tambaqos warmoebis 85%-iani wili a. w-s. saqmis masa-lebiT ar dasturdeba is garemoeba, rom i. b-e daeufladidi odenobiT _ 110 000-lariani sawesdebo kapitalis mqo-ne Sps `s-s~ 85% wils. i. b-s saxelze arasdros yofila da-registrirebuli sakuTrebis uflebiT Sps `s-s~ Tambaqos85%-iani wili, rasac arc mxareebi xdian sadavod, xolobraldebis mxare mas ar edaveba imas, rom man dazarale-buls es wili gamosZala sxvis sasargeblod.
30. amdenad, mocemul SemTxvevaSi saxeze ar gvyavs ga-moZalvis is subieqti, romelmac braldebis Sesaxeb dad-genilebis Tanaxmad, gamoZalviT miiRo sxvisi nivTi an qo-nebrivi ufleba.
31. sasamarTlo procesze mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli, da-zaralebul a. w-a da mowme T. f-s mier micemuli Cvenebe-biT, i. b-e moqmedebda i. C-a da d. t-s davalebiT, xolo masSemdeg, rac is ar daeTanxma i. b-s moTxovnas sarCelis ga-motanaze, man is daalaparaka i. m-s, ris Semdegac a. w-i iZu-lebuli gaxda, uari eTqva sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebiTmisTvis mikuTvnebul Tambaqos warmoebis 100%-ian wil-ze. sakasacio palatis xdomaze braldebis mxarem mTlia-nad dauWira mxari maT Cvenebebs da aRniSna, rom i. b-e sZa-lavda 85%-ian wils a. w-s i. C-a da d. t-s saxeliT da dava-lebiT, rasac miaRwia mxolod mas Semdeg, rac a. w-i daala-paraka i. m-s, romelmac uTxra, rom daejerebina i. b-s damoqceuliyo ise, rogorc is etyoda.
81
32. sakasacio palata sayuradRebod miiCnevs im gare-moebas, rom braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebis mixedviT, i.b-s mier Cadenili danaSaulebrivi qmedebis aRwerisas mi-TiTebulia mxolod i. C-a da d. t-s Sesaxeb, rom i. b-e moq-medebda maTi saxeliTa da davalebiT da sTxovda a. w-s,uari eTqva sarCelze, maSin, rodesac i. b-s brali ar war-dgenia jgufurad Cadenil gamoZalvaSi.
33. amasTan sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom a. w-a da T. f-s Cvenebebi ar aris sando da damajereblobas moklebuliaim garemoebasTan dakavSirebiT, rom i. b-m is asaubra i. m-ntelefoniT. am saubriT ki is darwmunda, rom i. b-s mxri-dan momdinare muqara iyo realuri, ris gamoc man uari TqvasarCelze.
34. sakasacio palata aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiT ganmar-tavs, rom, marTalia, braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebis mi-xedviT, braldebis mxare dadgenilad ar miiCnevs im faq-tobriv garemoebas, rom i. b-m is asaubra i. m-n telefoniT,am saubriT ki is darwmunda, rom i. b-s mxridan momdinaremuqara iyo realuri, ris gamoc man mxolod amis SemdegTqva uari sarCelze, magram sakasacio palata a. w-a da T. f-s Cvenebebis sandoobis dadgenis mizniT msjelobs am ga-remoebasTan mimarTebiTac.
35. saqmis masalebSi ar arsebobs a. w-a da i. m-s Sorissaubris faqtis damadasturebeli, sakmaris da utyuarmtkicebulebaTa erToblioba. gamarTlebuli i. b-e kate-goriulad uaryofs im garemoebas, rom man daalaparaka a.w-i i. m-n, Tavad i. m-i ki mowmis saxiT ar aris dakiTxuli.saqmeSi warmodgenili, i. b-s mobilur telefonze Semava-li da gamavali zarebis informaciiT, i. b-s telefonidanar ganxorcielebula zari i. m-n, aseve arc i. m-s telefo-nidan ganxorcielebula zari i. b-n. am garemoebas adastu-reben mxolod a. w-i da misi siZe _ T. f-e. rac Seexeba z. b-sCvenebas, rom man am saubris Sesaxeb icis gadmocemiT a. w-n, aris iribi Cveneba da mas samarTlebrivi Sefaseba vermiecema sakonstitucio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 22 ianvrisgadawyvetilebis gaTvaliswinebiT, xolo sxva pirdapirimtkicebuleba, rac erTmniSvnelovnad daadasturebs a. w-a da T. f-s Cvenebebs am epizodSi, saqmeSi ar arsebobs. aR-niSnuli ki miuTiTebs a. w-a da T. f-s Cvenebebis arasar-wmunoobaze.
36. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom alogikuri da wina-
82
aRmdegobrivia Tavad braldebis mxaris pozicia a. w-a da i.m-s Soris Semdgar saubarTan dakavSirebiT.
37. rogorc aRvniSneT, braldebis mxare braldebis Se-saxeb dadgenilebaSi dadgenilad ar miiCnevs a. w-a da T. f-s CvenebebSi miTiTebul faqtobriv garemoebebs im nawil-Si, rom a. w-a da i. m-s Soris Sedga saubari, ramac a. w-s gan-martebiT, is iZulebuli gaxada, daTanxmeboda i. b-s moT-xovnas. sasamarTlos sxdomaze ki saxelmwifo bralmdebe-li i. b-s mier Cadenili qmedebis Sefasebisas a. w-isa da mow-me T. f-s Cvenebebs am nawilSic sarwmunod miiCnevs da aR-niSnavs, rom i. b-m sakuTari telefoniT asaubra a. w-i i. m-sTan, romelmac uTxra, rom yvelaferi daejerebina i. b-sTvis da sarCeli ukan gamoexmo.
38. sakasacio palata ganmartavs: garda imisa, rom yove-live zemoaRniSnuli palatas ar aZlevs SesaZleblobas,damajereblad miiRos a. w-sa da T. f-s Cvenebebis sandoo-ba am garemoebasTan mimarTebiT, amasTan, sayuradReboa,rom arc braldebis mxarem miiCnia maTi Cvenebebi sakmarismtkicebulebebad am faqtis dasadastureblad. winaaR-mdeg SemTxvevaSi braldebis mxare dadgenilad miiCnevdaam garemoebas braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebaSi, Tumca,miuxedavad amisa, saxelmwifo bralmdebeli braldebis mxa-ris mtkicebulebebis Sefasebisas apelirebda am faqtob-rivi garemoebis Taobazec, riTac braldebis mxare gascdabraldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebaSi miTiTebuli faqtobri-vi garemoebebis farglebs.
39. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom braldebis mxarem ase-ve ver warmoadgina sakmaris, Tanmimdevrul da damajere-bel mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba im faqtis dasadastu-reblad, rom i. b-e a. w-s mimarT axorcielebda misi da misiojaxis wevrebis sicocxlis xelyofis muqaras, ris gamoca. w-a ukan gamoixmo sarCeli, kerZod:
40. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba braldebis mxa-ris mosazrebas imis Sesaxeb, rom samoqalaqo dava Tbili-sis saqalaqo sasamarTlom gadawyvita a. w-s sasargeblodda igi Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlodan Tavisi nebiTsarCels ukan ar gamoixmobda. sakasacio palata mTlianadiziarebs saapelacio sasamarTlos motivacias da miaCnia,rom mxolod aRniSnuli garemoeba ar aris sakmarisi safuZ-veli i. b-s braleulobis dasadgenad gamoZalvaSi. palataganmartavs, rom sarCelis gamoxmoba, aseve mxareTa mori-
83
geba gaTvaliswinebulia samoqalaqo saproceso kanonmdeb-lobiT. mxareebs aqvT ufleba, awarmoon xelaxali mola-parakeba erTmaneTTan da me-3 pirebTan, Seafason saqmisgaremoebebi da sarCeli gamoiTxovon an daamTavron davamorigebiT. Tavad i. C-sa da i. b-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia,rom maTi mxridan a. w-sTan, i. C-sa da i. g-sTan mimdinareob-da molaparakebebi Tambaqos warmoebis SeZenasTan dakav-SirebiT, ris Sedegadac sabolood SeTanxmdnen, rom a. w-iuars ityoda TerTmeti milioni laris moTxovnaze, sawar-mos daubrundeboda samarko niSnebi, gauqmdeboda dis-tribuciis Sesaxeb kabaluri xelSekruleba da a. w-sganiyidda 15%-ian wils. sanacvlod, igi a. w-s ar mosTxovdadistribuciis davalianebas, daaxloebiT _ 3.400.000 an3.500.000 laris odenobiT, damatebiT gadauxdida erT mi-lion aSS dolars da distribuciis manqanebi darCeboda a.w-s.
41. braldebis mxarem im faqtis dasadastureblad, romi. b-e a. w-s mimarT axorcielebda misi da misi ojaxis wevre-bis sicocxlis xelyofis muqaras, ZiriTadad warmoadginaori mtkicebuleba _ a. w-sa da misi siZis _ T. f-s Cvenebebi.
42. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom a. w-isa da T. f-s ara-Tanmimdevruli da winaaRmdegobrivi Cvenebebi maT sar-wmunoobas eWvqveS ayenebs da damajereblad ver adastu-rebs i. b-s braleulobas.
43. sakasacio palata sayuradRebod miiCnevs im gare-moebas, rom gamoZiebis pirvel etapze, mowmis saxiT da-kiTxvisas, rac gamokvleuli iqna 1-eli instanciis sasa-marTlo sxdomaze, a. w-i ar uTiTebs imis Sesaxeb, rom i. b-smxridan mis mimarT adgili hqonda sicocxlis xelyofismuqaras misi da misi ojaxis wevrebis mimarT, mxolod uTi-Tebs im garemoebaze, rom i. b-e eubneboda finansuri po-licia Sevidoda masTan biznesSi da problemebs Seuqmnid-nen. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom aRniSnuli, gamo-Zalvis sakanonmdeblo definiciidan gamomdinare, arqmnis gamoZalvis Semadgenlobis niSnebs, kerZod, gamoZal-vis dros moTxovnas unda erTvodes dazaralebulis an mi-si axlo naTesavis mimarT Zaladobis gamoyenebis, raSicmoiazreba fizikuri an fsiqikuri Zaladoba, an maTi niv-Tis ganadgurebis muqara an dazianebis anda maTTvis saxe-lis gamtexi cnobis gaxmaurebis an sxva iseTi cnobis gav-rcelebis muqara, romelmac SeiZleba arsebiTad daazia-
84
nos maTi uflebebi, rasac aRniSnul gansaxilvel SemTxve-vaSi adgili ar hqonda.
44. gamoZiebis pirvel etapze, analogiurs uCvenebs T.f-e, xolo Semdeg CvenebebSi da sasamarTloSic Cvenebismicemis dros rogorc a. w-a, aseve T. f-m aCvenes, rom maTmimarT adgili hqonda sicocxlis xelyofis muqaras.
45. sasamarTlo procesze, dacvis mxaris SekiTxvaze, a.w-ma ganmarta, rom gamomZiebels misTvis kiTxva ar daus-vams da amitom ar uCvena, rom mis mimarT xorcieldebodasicocxlis xelyofis muqara. sayuradReboa, rom misiveganmartebiT, rasac aseve adasturebs misi siZe _ T. f-e,mas ar SeSinebia i. b-s, piriqiT T. f-s CvenebiT, is b-i Sex-vedris Semdeg xelis kvriT gaagdes, mxolod maSin, rode-sac a. w-i SeaSines sicocxlis xelyofis muqariT misi damisi ojaxis wevrebis mimarT da rodesac saqme mis ojaxsSeexo, ra drosac is `cota sustia~, is ojaxis wevrebis si-cocxles ver daayenebda eWvqveS. marTalia, mas misi siZe,T. f-e urCevda, araferi gadaexadaT da qveyana daetove-binaT. magram mas miaCnda, rom maT unda `Cahyoloda~, rad-gan isini didxans mainc ver gaZlebdnen da dRes Tu xvalSeZlebda maT winaaRmdeg brZolis dawyebas da qonebisukan dabrunebas, ris gamoc man uari Tqva sarCelze.
46. sakasacio palata Zaladobis muqaris faqtis dadas-turebas safuZvlad ver daudebs a. w-sa da T. f-s winaaR-mdegobriv da araTanmimdevrul Cvenebebs.
47. amasTan, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom maTi Cvene-bebis arasandoobaze metyvelebs is garemoebac, rom Tu i.b-e a. w-s emuqreboda misi da misi ojaxis wevrebis sicoc-xlis xelyofiT da is amis gamo gaxda iZulebuli, uari eT-qva sarCelze, bunebrivia saqmis warmoebis pirvel etapzemicemul CvenebebSi rogorc a. w-i, aseve misi siZe, T. f-eamis Taobaze aucileblad miuTiTebdnen da ar daaviwyde-bodaT im SemTxvevaSic ki, gamomZiebels romc ar daesvakiTxva, riTac arsebiTi ganxilvis dros micemul Cveneba-Si isini xsnian maT Cvenebebs Soris arsebul am winaaRmde-gobas. amdenad, aseve yovelgvar damajereblobas mokle-bulia maTi zemoaRniSnuli gancxadeba.
48. sasamarTlo aseve sayuradRebod miiCnevs im gare-moebas, rasac aseve mxareebi ar xdian sadavod, rom a. w-sda i. b-s Sexvedrebi xdeboda a. w-s kabinetSi. a. w-ma winas-war icoda i. b-s masTan vizitis Taobaze. T. f-s CvenebiT, a.
85
w-s kabineti aRWurvili iyo videokamerebiT, rac sauke-Teso saSualeba iqneboda maTi saubris Casawerad, Tumca,ratomRac a. w-ma es saSualeba ar gamoiyena, raTa Semdegutyuarad daedasturebina mis mimarT Cadenili danaSau-lebrivi faqti, roca, misive CvenebiT, is apirebda moma-valSi maT winaaRmdeg brZolas da qonebis ukan dabrune-bas. man ara marto ar gamoiyena es teqnikuri saSualeba,aramed aseve ar mimarTa Sesabamis samarTaldamcav orga-noebs mis mimarT ukanono moqmedebis ganxorcielebis Ta-obaze.
49. yovelive aRniSnuli sasamarTlos uqmnis STabeWdi-lebas, rom a. w-i da T. f-e ar arian gulaxdilebi, xolomaTi Cvenebebi, araTanmimdevruli da winaaRmdegobriviSinaarsis gamo, ver miiCneva im urTierTSeTavsebad, dama-jerebel da aSkara mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobad, rac da-edeba safuZvlad gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT i. b-smimarT gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamotanas.
50. amasTan, sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba saxel-mwifo bralmdeblis ganmartebas da mosazrebas sakonsti-tucio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 22 ianvris gadawyvetile-basTan dakavSirebiT, rom sasamarTlos aqvs SesaZleblo-ba, gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamotanis dros gamoiyenosiribi Cveneba mtkicebulebis saxiT.
52. Sesabamisad, sakasacio palata moklebulia SesaZ-
86
leblobas, samarTlebrivi Sefaseba misces o. f-s, b. x-a daz. b-s Cvenebebs im faqtebTan dakavSirebiT, rac maTTvisgaxda cnobili Tambaqos biznesTan dakavSirebiT.
53. rac Seexeba mowme z. b-s Cvenebas, rom is iyo a. w-is dai. b-is erT-erTi Sexvedris uSualo monawile, ra drosac i.b-m a. w-s uTxra, rom `naxavT Tqven, Tu ar gaitrupoTo~,amasTan dakavSirebiT palata ganmartavs, rom Tavad z. b-sCvenebiT, is Seeswro a. w-s da i. b-s Soris saubars maisismeore naxevarSi. aRsaniSnavia, rom braldebis Sesaxeb dad-genilebiT i. b-s edavebian mxolod 2011 wlis martSi Cade-nil gamoZalvaze, rac dasrulda 2011 wlis 31 marts, ro-desac a. w-ma uari Tqva sarCelze. Sesabamisad, maisis epi-zodSi Tu ra moxda a. w-sa da i. b-s Soris, amas braldebismxare i. b-s ar edaveba da, Sesabamisad, am dros maTi saub-ris Sesaxeb mowme z. b-s Cvenebas sasamarTlo ver miscemssamarTlebriv Sefasebas martSi ganviTarebul movleneb-Tan dakavSirebiT a. w-sa da i. b-s Soris.
54. saqmeze dakiTxuli mowmeebis _ n. T-a da z. T-s Cve-nebebTan mimarTebiT sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapela-cio palatis mosazrebas da ganmartavs, rom isini adastu-reben mxolod i. b-s stumrobas a. w-Tan, rasac arc TavadgamarTlebuli i. b-e uaryofs, xolo is faqti, rom i. b-sstumrobisas a. w-is kabinetidan ismoda a. w-is xmamaRalisaubari da is iyo saxeze awiTlebuli da ganerviulebuli,erTmniSvnelovnad ar adasturebs i. b-s mier raime saxisdanaSaulebrivi qmedebis Cadenis faqts.
55. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom garda zemoaRniS-nuli samarTlebrivi Seusabamobebisa saqmeze dadgenil dabraldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebaSi miTiTebul faqtobrivgaremoebebs Soris, saqmeze gamokvleuli da miTiTebulimtkicebulebebis safuZvelze, i. b-s mier danaSaulis Ca-denis faqti ar SeiZleba miCneul iqnes dadasturebuladda safuZvlad daedos mis mimarT gamamtyunebel ganaCens.
10. aseve ar aris sadavo da calsaxad dadgenilia is ga-remoeba, rom msjavrdebuli l. m-i sargeblobda im mobi-luri telefoniT, romliTac ganxorcielda zari 112-Si.Tavad l. m-i ar uaryofs im garemoebas, rom is sargeblobsaRniSnuli mobiluri telefoniT da 2013 wlis 12 seqtem-bersac sargeblobda am telefoniT.
11. mowme m. i-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom is aris Sss-svake-saburTalos raionuli sammarTvelos policiis me-2ganyofilebis gamomZiebeli. mocemul saqmesTan dakavSi-rebiT man Caatara sagamoZiebo moqmedebebi, kerZod, bral-debulis dakiTxva, aseve n. k-a da braldebulis geris da-kiTxvebi. n. k-s dakiTxvisas wardgenil iqna braldebulismobiluri telefoni, romelic m. i-m daaTvaliera. dakave-
93
bis dRes gamoiZaxa saswrafo daxmareba, radgan n. k-e gax-da cudad, Tumca es iyo mis dakiTxvamde Tu dakiTxvis Sem-deg, ver ixsenebs, iseve rogorc im faqts, Tu ra medika-mentebi iqna gamoyenebuli.
12. Tavad mowme n. k-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom aRniS-nuli mobiluri telefoniT sargeblobda misi meuRle l.m-i. miTiTebul dResac telefoni hqonda meuRles, ro-melmac Semdeg mas gadasca Sesanaxad. mas mobiluri tele-foni hqonda CanTaSi.
13. gamomZiebel m. i-s mier 2013 wlis 12 seqtembers Sed-genili daTvalierebis oqmis Tanaxmad, daTvalierda `no-kias~ firmis mobiluri telefoni. sagamoZiebo moqmede-bis dawyebamde pirs, visTanac tardeba daTvaliereba _ amSemTxvevaSi n. k-s _ waredgina dadgenileba daTvaliere-bis Sesaxeb, ganemarta ufleba, gamoeTqva SeniSvna, dama-teba an Sesworeba, rac aisaxeba oqmSi. amasTan, n. k-m ganac-xada Tanxmoba nebayoflobiT waredgina amosaRebi nivTi.telefons aqvs ori imei kodi:, masSi moTavsebulia simba-raTi warweriT _ `warmoadgens magTikomis sakuTrebas~.
14. sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs msjavrdebul l. m-s Cvenebas im nawilSi, rom, marTalia, 2013 wlis 12 seqtem-bers is sargeblobda aRniSnuli mobiluri telefoniT,magram mas am mobiluri telefonidan ar daurekia 112-Si.
15. msjavrdebul l. m-s CvenebiT, is sargeblobs da 2013wlis 12 seqtembersac sargeblobda mobiluri telefoniT,romlis nomeria. 2013 wlis 12 seqtembers, 09:20 saaTze, Ca-vida maRaziaSi erTjeradi yavisa da funTuSebis sayid-lad, Tan waiRo nagvis parki. me-5 korpusTan idga misTvisucnobi axalgazrda biWi, romelmac darekva sTxova. man uT-xra, rom telefonze angariSi ar hqonda, razec ucnobmaupasuxa, rom saswrafo unda gamoeZaxebina. man miawoda mo-biluri, TviTon mivida nagvis gadasayrelad, dabrunda,gamoarTva mobiluri, Sevida maRaziaSi da avida saxlSi. da-axloebiT 1-2 wuTSi daurekes sapatrulodan da hkiTxes,saswrafo man gamoiZaxa Tu ara. man upasuxa, rom ucnobsdaarekvina. telefonSi ikiTxes, Sejaxeba xom ar iyo mom-xdari, razec man upasuxa, rom msgavsi ar unaxavs. daaxlo-ebiT 2 saaTSi kvlav daurekes da uTxres, rom `sapatriar-qos~ televiziasTan axlobeli qali iyo cudad da miekiT-xa. man gaTiSa telefoni da daapira misvla, Tan meuRlessTxova gadaereka da gaerkvia, razec uTxres, rom SeeSa-
94
laT. Semdeg isev Sevida zari da uTxres, rom gasaRebi Ca-egdoT. daaxloebiT 1430 saaTze gamovida meuRlesTan er-Tad saxlidan, sadac Sexvdnen misTvis ucnobi pirebi, rom-lebic miesalmnen. man uTxra, rom eSlebodaT, radgan aricnobda, magram pasuxad miiRo, rom isini icnobdnen, risSemdegac gaigo xma _ `ar gainZreT, policiaa~. daaxloebiTiyo 6-7 policiis TanamSromeli, misTvis ar ganumartavTuflebebi, an mizezi, Tu ratom mihyavdaT. sTxoves tele-foni, man uTxra, rom meuRles hqonda, Semdeg meuRlesuTxra, rom mieca maTTvis mobiluri telefoni, meuRlemSeayovna telefonis micema, ris gamoc 2-3 adamiani arTmev-da mas CanTas. erT-erTi maTgani, rogorc Semdeg gaigo, iyoufrosi d. d-i. is da misi meuRle Casxes avtomanqanebSi dawaiyvanes policiis ganyofilebaSi, sadac esmoda meuRlistirili da yvirili. Semdeg meuRlis Tavisuflebis sanac-vlod aRiara danaSauli, radgan is xangrZlivad hyavdaTganyofilebaSi. miuxedavad amisa, misi meuRle ar gauSvi-aT. is dakiTxa n. m-m, xolo gamomZiebeli m. i-e beWdavdaCvenebas. daaxloebiT saaT-naxevris Semdeg mouwera xeliCvenebebze, daades xelborkili da gadaiyvanes vake-sabur-Talos raionis policiis sammarTveloSi. misi gayvanisasmeuRle gaxda cudad da saswrafo gamoiZaxes. Semdeg miiy-vanes modulis SenobaSi. SemdgomSi n. m-s sTxova axali Cve-nebis micema. am droisaTvis ukve hyavda advokati, Tumca2013 wlis 19 seqtembers n. m-m hkiTxa, advokatma ZaliTdaawerina Cveneba Tu nebayoflobiT misca. man aseve uT-xra, rom SeeZlo im piris amocnoba, vinc telefoni gamo-arTva. aRniSnuli aseve uTxra 20 seqtembers m. i-sac.
16. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom braldebis mxaris mi-er warmodgenili mtkicebulebebis erTobliobaSi urTi-erTSejerebisa da analizis Sedegad damajereblad das-turdeba is garemoeba, rom l. m-a Caidina terorizmis Se-saxeb cru Setyobineba _ man dareka 112-Si, gagzavnili in-formacia ar Seesabameboda sinamdviles, riTac Seaferxa`r-s~ muSaoba.
17. Tavad msjavrdebul l. m-sa da misi meuRlis Cvene-bebiT calsaxad dadgenilia, rom mobiluri telefoni, sa-idanac ganxorcielda zari 112-Si, ekuTvnis l. m-s da dro-is im SualedSi, ra drosac moxda es faqti, is sargeblob-da am mobiluri telefoniT.
18. saqmeze warmodgenili fonoskopiuri eqspertize-
95
bis daskvnebiTa da sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmis saxiT da-kiTxuli eqspertebis _ e. k-a da a. m-s CvenebebiT calsaxaddasturdeba is garemoeba, rom aRniSnuli mobiluri te-lefonidan dareka ara ucnobma pirma, aramed Tavad msjav-rdebulma l. m-m.
20. 2013 wlis 21 oqtombris nivTieri mtkicebulebisgaxsnisa da daTvalierebis oqmis Tanaxmad, n. m-m gaxsnapaketebi da masSi moTavsebuli CD diskebidan dakopire-bul iqna l. m-s xmis nimuSi da 112-is Canaweri, ris Semde-gac diskebi kvlav dailuqa.
21. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli e. k-s mier sasamarTlo sxdo-maze micemuli Cvenebis Tanaxmad, igi aris saqarTvelosSss saeqsperto kriminalistikuri mTavari sammarTvelosfonoskopiuri da video-teqnikuri eqspertizis ganyofi-lebis mTavari eqsperti. daniSnuli iyo fonoskopiuri eq-spertiza. man sasjelaRsrulebis me-8 dawesebulebaSibraldebulisagan aiRo xmis nimuSi. gamokvlevis Sedegaddadginda, rom arsebuli Canaweri teqnikuri Tvalsazri-siT aris Tavsebadi, anu sadavo fonogramasTan etalonu-ri fonograma aris identuri, xolo lingvisturi anali-zis Catareba SeuZlebelia, radgan masala arasakmarisi iyo.lingvisturi da teqnikuri analizi erTmaneTs avsebs, mag-ram marto teqnikuri TvalsazrisiTac xdeba identuro-bis dadgena. teqnikuri TvalsazrisiT daskvna aris 100%-iani.
22. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli a. m-s mier sasamarTlo sxdo-maze micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom is aris sasamar-Tlo eqspertizis erovnuli biuros eqsperti. man daadas-tura mis mier 2013 wlis 21 noembers gacemuli fonoskopi-uri eqspertizis daskvna, romlis Tanaxmadac, eqsperti-zaze wardgenili sadavo fonograma nawilobriv vargisiapirovnebis identifikaciisaTvis, xolo wardgenili l. m-sxmis nimuSi vargisia xmis mixedviT pirovnebis identifi-kaciisaTvis. sadavo fonogramaze ar aRiniSneba raime sa-xis montaJis kvali. Catarebuli kompleqsuri gamokvle-vis Sedegebidan gamomdinare dadginda, rom sadavo fo-
96
nogramaze dafiqsirebuli diqtoris xma da etalonur fo-nogramaze dafiqsirebuli l. m-s xmis nimuSi savaraudodekuTvnis erTsa da imave pirovnebas. eqspertma ganmarta,rom Catarebul analizebze dayrdnobiT ar aris SesaZle-beli, rom es xma ekuTvnodes sxva pirs. mowmem daskvnaSiaRniSnul terminze `savaraudo~ sasamarTlos misca gan-marteba da ganacxada, rom `savaraudo~ niSnavs imas, rommocemuli monacemebiT yvela TanadamTxveva arsebobs, mag-ram radgan mcire niuansebiT srulad ver moxda gamokvle-va, miuTiTes sityva `savaraudo~. manve daamata da ganac-xada, rom is, rogorc saqarTveloSi yvelaze didi gamoc-dilebis mqone eqsperti am sferoSi, gamoricxavs, rom ar-sebuli mocemulobidan gamomdinare, ar aris SesaZlebe-li, rom es xma ekuTvnodes sxva pirs. eqspertizaze gamo-sakvlevad warmodgenil sadavo fonogramaSi miTiTebulixma da l. m-s xmis nimuSi ekuTvnis erTsa da imave pirs. sxvapiris SemTxvevaSi daskvnaSi daiwereboda kategoriulad,rom xmebi ar ekuTvnis erTsa da imave pirovnebas, manvedaadastura, rom xmebze arsebuli mniSvnelovani, Zneladkontrolirebadi TanadamTxvevidan gamomdinare, gamo-ricxavs, rom xma ekuTvnodes sxva pirs, vinaidan arsebu-li damTxvevebi ar SeiZleba iyos ori sxvadasxva piris Sem-TxvevaSi, miT ufro, rom gansxvavebebi ver iqna aRmoCeni-li da dafiqsirebuli.
23. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba dacvis mxaris mo-sazrebas imis Sesaxeb, rom sasamarTlom ar unda gaizia-ros levan samxaraulis saxelobis sasamarTlo eqsperti-zis erovnuli biuros fonoskopiuri eqspertizis daskvnada mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli eqspert a. m-s Cveneba, radganmaT saproceso kanonis moTxovnaTa darRveviT gadaecaTdadgenileba eqspertizis Catarebis Sesaxeb da mis safuZ-velze Catarebuli Tavad fonoskopiuri eqspertizis das-kvna. aRniSnuliT darRveul iqna maTi dacvis ufleba.
26. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom, marTalia, mxare-ebis mier mtkicebulebiTi mniSvnelobis informaciis gac-vlis Semdeg mxareebis mier axali damatebiTi mtkicebu-lebis safuZvlis warmoSobis SemTxvevaSi am saprocesodokumentis, mocemul SemTxvevaSi eqspertizis daniSvnisSesaxeb dadgenilebis, mxarisaTvis gadacemis sakiTxs saq-mis arsebiTi ganxilvis sxdomamde saproceso kanonmdeb-loba ar awesrigebs, magram palatas miaCnia, rom mocemulSemTxvevaSi dacvis mxaris ufleba ar darRveula, dacvismxares mieca SesaZlebloba da uzrunvelyofili iyo misidacvis uflebisTvis im saproceso garantiiT, rom gascno-boda rogorc dadgenilebas, xolo Semdeg, saqmis arsebi-Ti ganxilvis dros, mis safuZvelze miRebul fonoskopi-uri eqspertis daskvnas da gamoeTqva Tavisi mosazreba ammtkicebulebis dasaSvebobis sakiTxTan dakavSirebiT.
27. aRniSnul sakiTxTan mimarTebiT igive pozicia aqvsadamianis uflebaTa evropul sasamarTlos saqmeze m-i ru-seTis winaaRmdeg (Mirilashvili v. Russia). am gadawyvetilebiT
98
evropulma sasamarTlom daadgina, rom im SemTxvevaSi, Tudacvis uflebis SezRudvas aqvs legitimuri mizani, Sem-dgom ganxilul unda iqnes is sakiTxi, iyo Tu ara am ufle-bis SezRudva dabalansebuli sxva saproceso garantiebiT,rac mocemul SemTxvevaSi dabalansebul iqna.
28. igive mosazreba aqvs evropul sasamarTlos saqmezeC-o ukrainis winaaRmdeg (Chopenko v. ukraine). evropuli sa-samarTlo mxedvelobaSi iRebs im SesaZleblobas, Tu ram-denad obieqturad moxda Semdgom etapze saproceso xar-vezis gamosworeba. rogorc aRvniSneT, dacvis mxares missasargeblod braldebis mxarem gadasca dadgenileba daeqspertizis daskvna, rogorc ki amis SesaZlebloba mieca.aRniSnuli ver CaiTvleba im absolutur darRvevad, racsasamarTlos ar miscems SesaZleblobas, mtkicebulebe-bad gamoiyenos aRniSnuli fonoskopiuri eqspertizisdaskvna da mowme a. m-s Cveneba.
29. gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT l. m-s msjavri daedo aseveimaSi, rom misi moqmedebiT telekompania `r-s~ srulfaso-van funqcionirebas xeli SeeSala da miayena mniSvnelova-ni materialuri ziani _ 10000 laris odenobiT. sakasaciopalatas dadgenilad miaCnia, rom l. m-s moqmedebiT te-lekompania `r-s~ srulfasovan funqcionirebas SeeSalaxeli, magram ver daeTanxmeba braldebis mxaresa da saape-lacio sasamarTlos da mTlianad iziarebs dacvis mxarismosazrebas im garemoebasTan dakavSirebiT, rom sakmarisida damajerebeli mtkicebulebebiT ar aris dadasture-buli mniSvnelovani zianis odenoba, rac sakasacio pala-tas miscemda SesaZleblobas, jerovnad Seefasebina mniS-vnelovani ziani, kerZod:
30. sasamarTlo am garemoebis dadgenisas daeyrdno mxo-lod mowme z. k-s Cvenebas, romelic warmoadgens dazara-lebuli telekompaniis interesebs. misi CvenebiT, ganxor-cielebulma cru Setyobinebam telekompanias miayena10000 laris ziani. mas es informacia miawoda reklamebisxelmZRvanelma da endo mxolod mis informacias. xar-jTaRricxvis Taobaze raime dokumenti werilobiT maT arwarudgeniaT. aseve saqmis masalebSi ar moipoveba aranai-ri saxis dokumenti, romelic daadasturebda, rom tele-kompaniam Tanxobrivad ganicada 10000 laris ziani. saape-lacio sasamarTlom pirdapir gaiziara mowmis Cveneba dayovelgvari mtkicebulebis gareSe dadgenilad miiCnia,
99
rom marTlac 10000 laris Rirebulebis ziani miadga te-lekompanias. rogorc aRvniSneT, am muxlis miznebisaTvismniSvnelovani ziani SefasebiTia. swored amitom mniSvne-lovania dazaralebul mxares warmoedgina Sesabamisi do-kumenti, romelze dayrdnobiTac dadgindeboda miyene-buli zianis odenoba da sasamarTlo imsjelebda, Tu ram-denad iyo es ziani mniSvnelovani telekompania `r-s~.
31. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatas miaC-nia, rom l. m-s msjavrdebidan unda amoericxos makvali-ficirebeli garemoeba mniSvnelovani ziani da, Sesabami-sad, misi moqmedeba unda dakvalificirdes saqarTvelosssk-is 331-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT (2006 wlis 28 aprilis re-daqcia).
32. rac Seexeba sasjels, sakasacio palata sasjelis da-niSvnis dros iTvaliswinebs msjavrdebul l. m-s pirovne-bas, mis mier Cadenili danaSaulis motivs, mizans, qmede-baSi gamovlenil marTlsawinaaRmdego nebas, qmedebis gan-xorcielebis saxes, xerxs, pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubu-qebel garemoebebs, kerZod: igi pirveladaa samarTalSi,xasiaTdeba dadebiTad, miRebuli aqvs monawileoba saqar-Tvelos teritoriuli mTlianobisaTvis warmoebul brZo-lebSi samaCablosa da afxazeTSi, aqvs mZime materialurimdgomareoba, ar aqvs sacxovrebeli saxli, damamZimebeligaremoeba ar gaaCnia da miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul l. m-ssaqarTvelos ssk-is 331-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT (2006 wlis28 aprilis redaqcia) sasjelis zomad unda ganesazRvros1 wliTa da 21 dRiT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa.
ma sakasacio saCivris kanoniereba, safuZvlianoba da mivi-da im daskvnamde, rom prokuroris sakasacio saCivari arunda dakmayofildes, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi undaSevides cvlileba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saapelacio sasamar-Tlom yovelmxriv da obieqturad Seamowma mxareTa mierSekrebili da warmodgenili mtkicebulebebi, gaaanalizada Seajera isini erTmaneTTan, Tumca ganaCenSi Camoyali-bebul sasamarTlo daskvnebs ar misca swori samarTleb-rivi Sefaseba.
3. saapelacio palatis sxdomaze mowmis saxiT dakiT-xul, msjavrdebul o. b-s CvenebiT, 2012 wlis 1 oqtombersbiZasTan _ a. k-n erTad manqaniT imyofeboda quCaSi, radrosac uTxres, rom saarCevno ubanze iyo kamaTi. vinai-dan misi biZis meuRle am ubanze iyo damkvirvebeli, ga-dawyvites, rom misuliyvnen da gaerkviaT, ra xdeboda. ...-e saarCevno ubanze misvlisTanave maT dauwyes gineba, Turatom mividnen iq. mas ainteresebda gaego, bicolas xomaraferi emuqreboda. rodesac darwmunda, rom mniSvnelo-vani araferi xdeboda, gamotrialda ukan. am dros viRacpirovneba maTi manqanisken garboda da Jurnalistebi mis-devdnen. iZaxdnen, ratom axorcielebT zewolas, rom xal-xi movides da biuletenebi Cayarono. es Jurnalisti iyo q.w-a. ucnobi pirovneba Cajda biZamisis manqanaSi. SemdegJurnalistebi movidnen da maT iRebdnen videokameriT.biZamisma ramdenjerme uTxra, rom ar gadaeRoT, TavadacJurnalistebs orjer gaumeora, rom ar gadaeRoT. aRniS-nul incidents Tan axlda sityvieri Seuracxyofa. q. w-mmimarTa maSindeli policiis ufross _ m. b-s, rom iq sis-xlis samarTlis danaSauli iyo momxdari da gamoZiebiTimuqreboda. msjavrdebulis CvenebiT, am yvelaferma mas-
103
ze imoqmeda. ver mixvda, raze iyo saubari. es rom gaigo,dainteresda, operators gamostaca kamera da gaiqca. sax-lSi misvlis dros naxa kamera, radgan ainteresebda, Cawe-rili iyo Tu ara maTi gineba. masalis naxvis Semdeg, meoredRes, kamera daabruna xeluxlebeli. mas ar surda kame-ris misakuTreba. es iqidan Cans, rom roca saxlSi mividada naxa kameraSi arsebuli masala, daureka mZRols _ g. b-sda sTxova q. w-s nomeri, raTa kamera daebrunebina. g-m uT-xra, rom isini TbilisSi iyvnen wasulebi da ver moaxerxeb-da dabrunebas. msjavrdebulis CvenebiT, man mis deidaS-vils gamoarTva q. w-s nomeri da TviTon gadaureka masacda g-sac, Tan uTxra, rom araferi hqonda waSlili da sur-da videokameris dabruneba. meore dRes daureka q. w-s dabodiSi mouxada. mcirewlovan bavSvs sTxova, rom mietanakamera q. w-s saxlSi. bavSvma q. w-s gadasca kamera. msjav-rdebulma ganacxada, rom man danaSauli Caidina, magramara _ Zarcva. kameris gayidva rom sdomoda, albaT, veravinSeuSlida xels.
4. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT da-kiTxuli a. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2012 wlis pirve-li oqtombrisTvis operatorad muSaobda sainformaciosaagento `i-i~. 2012 wlis 1 oqtombers, daaxloebiT 5:00 sa-aTze, ...-e saarCevno ubanze gavidnen. maT Tan axlda aseveJurnalisti q. w-a. Caweres g. m-i, romelic `qarTuli ocne-bis~ wevrebma daiWires, radgan gasayalbebeli biuletene-bi eWira. saarCevno ubanze SenobaSi yofnis dros xmauriSemoesmaT da ezos gareT gavidnen. k-Si mcxovreb `TaTarqals~, saxelad n-s (romlis gvari ar axsovs) iRebdnen, radrosac `i-s~ meore operatoris _ g. x-s kuTvnili kameragaitaces. mowmis CvenebiT, sainformacio saagento `i-is~kuTvnili kamera gaitaca o. b-ma da gaiqca. es pirovnebamaSin dainaxa, roca Tavis kameraSi naxa gadaRebuli masa-lebi. Semdeg uTxres, rom kameris gamtacebeli piri iyo o.b-i. meore dRes q. w-as da g. x-s viRac bavSvma miutana kame-ra. yvela masala xelSeuxebeli iyo da arc kamera iyo da-zianebuli. mowmem aseve ganmarta, rom q. w-s gadmocemiT,o. b-ma videokamera gaitaca im mizniT, rom ainteresebda,misi gineba iyo Tu ara Cawerili. mowmis CvenebiT, mas uSu-alod kameris warTmevis momenti ar daunaxavs. mogviane-biT mis kameraSi naxa kameris warTmevis momenti. kameriswarTmevamde o. b-s g. x-Tvis xeli ar gaurtyams da arc da-
104
muqrebia. uceb gamostaca kamera da gaiqca. mowmis ganmar-tebiT, o. b-s kameris misakuTrebis mizani rom hqonoda,survilis SemTxvevaSi igi SeZlebda kameris 1000 dolaradgayidvas, Tumca man es ar gaakeTa.
5. mowme g. b-s saapelacio sasamarTloSi micemuli Cve-nebiT dadgenilia, rom 2012 wlis pirveli oqtombrisTvissainformacio saagentoSi `i-i~ muSaobda mZRolad. 2012wlis 1 oqtombers, 4-5 saaTis SualedSi, ofisSi informa-cia Sevida, rom k-is ...-e saarCevno ubanze raRac igegmebo-da, ris gamoc iq wavida. rodesac saarCevno ubanze mivida,`qarTuli ocnebis~ aqtivistebs dakavebuli hyavdaT pi-rovneba, gvarad m-i, romelsac biuletenebi amouRes we-lis aredan. is pirovneba acxadebda, rom ar icoda, iq ris-Tvis iyo da ra undoda. intervius `i-s~ Jurnalistebi wer-dnen. uceb atyda xmauri. ̀ eTnikurad TaTari qali n-a~, rom-lis gvari ar icis, Sexla-SemoxlaSi iyo CarTuli, `qarTu-li ocnebis~ aqtivistebs eCxubeboda. am dros SemovidaTeTri feris avtomanqana, romelSic o. b-i ijda. orive ope-ratori qalbaton n-s uRebda da erT-erTma operatorma,g. x-a, manqanis mimarTulebiT daiwyo gadaReba; albaT, ga-daReba ar esiamovnaT da o. b-sa da biZamisis mxridan Seu-racxmyofeli sityvebi gaisma, dadeT kamera, nu gviReb-To. o. b-i Jurnalists aginebda, nu miRebTo. am yvelafrisSemdeg isev am qalbatonze gadavida yuradReba. am drosmTeli policia, maSindeli policiis ufrosi b-i da kon-stituciuri usafrTxoebis departamentis maSindeli sam-marTvelos ufrosi g. g-i movidnen. aseve iq imyofeboda l.b-c, romelmac is gamoZiebisas dakiTxa. policielebis aT-kaciani jgufi idga, am jgufSi Sevida o. b-i da gaiqca. o-smisces saSualeba, Camjdariyo manqanaSi da wasuliyo. mow-mis CvenebiT, o. b-i maSin dainaxa, roca ukve manqanaSi jde-boda. o-i wavida da waiRo kamera. meore dRes o-m pirve-lad mas daureka da sTxova q. w-n dakavSireba, raTa daeb-runebina kamera. man aseve uTxra, rom kamera waiRo im miz-niT, raTa enaxa, xom ar iyo gadaRebuli misi Seuracxmyo-feli sityvebi. mowme g. b-s ganmartebiT, man o. b-i daakav-Sira q. w-s, romelmac Caibara videokamera. kameris Rire-buleba iyo 3500-4000 dolaramde da o. b-s rom moendome-bina, SeZlebda mis gayidvas.
de muSaobda sainformacio saagento `i-s~ k-s biuros Jur-nalistad. 2012 wlis 1 oqtombers, daaxloebiT 5:00 saaT-ze, sainformacio saagento `i-s~ meSveobiT Tbilisidan mi-iRes informacia, rom k-s #-e saarCevno ubanze xdebodagayalbeba. ori ekipaJi wavida informaciis gadasamowmeb-lad da gadasaRebad. rodesac saarCevno ubnis Sesasvlel-Tan mividnen, daxvdaT kavTisxevSi mcxovrebi pirovneba(saxeli da gvari zustad ar axsovs), romelsac ekava TxuT-metamde gayalbebuli biuleteni, sadac 5 nomeri iyo Se-moxazuli. maT daiwyes sinqronebis Cawera. misi operato-ri iyo a. m-e, meore operatori ki _ g. x-i. gadaRebis pro-cesSi saarCevno ubnis gareT moxda sityvieri Selaparake-ba, ris gamoc gareT gavidnen. m. a-i sityvier Seuracxyo-fas ayenebda maT meore operators _ g. x-s. m. a-n erTadimyofebodnen g. C-i, a. b-i da o. b-i. m. a-s hkiTxa, Tu ratomayenebda igi maT Seuracxyofas, razec man pasuxi ar gascada gadavida sityvier Seuracxyofaze. mikrofonis warTme-va scada da Semdeg gaiqca. mowmis ganmartebiT, erT-erTmoqalaqes werdnen. win iRebda operatori a. m-e, ukan gan-viTarebul procesebs ki _ meore operatori g. x-i, romel-sac am dros o. b-m kamera gastaca. mowmis CvenebiT, saar-Cevno ubanze gadaRebis mimdinareobisas maT ayenebdnensityvier Seuracxyofas da uSlidnen xels Jurnalisturisaqmianobis SesrulebaSi. o. b-m kamera waiRo saarCevnoubanze arsebuli situaciis gayalbebis damalvis mizniT.kameras fizikurad ver gayidda, radgan is iblokeba eqvssaaTSi erTxel da gasaxsnelad kodis codnaa saWiro. mow-mis CvenebiT, o. b-m kameris gatacebiT mas, rogorc Jurna-lists, 5-6 saaTiT xeli SeuSala muSaobaSi, radgan ver ga-daagzavnes siuJetis sruli versia. q. w-s ganmartebiT, ka-mera warmoadgenda sainformacio saagento `i-s~ sakuTre-bas da misi Rirebulebaa daaxloebiT 4000 lari. kameriswaRebis Semdeg es pirovnebebi, romlebic sityvier Seu-racxyofas ayenebdnen `i-s~ Jurnalists da operatorebs,Casxdnen manqanaSi da wavidnen. o. b-sgan interviu ar au-RiaT, iRebdnen mxolod ganviTarebul procesebs, rac iqxdeboda. kadrebSi moxvedrili iyo o. b-c. kamera sad wai-Res, misTvis ucnobia, magram meore dRes daaxloebiT 15wlis biWma mas saxlSi miutana kamera sruliad uvnebeli,masalac iyo xeluxlebeli. o. b-i daukavSirda erTxel _kameris dabrunebis Semdeg da bodiSi moixada Cadenili
106
saqcielisTvis.7. mowme q. w-m daadastura is garemoeba, rom 2012 wlis 3
oqtombers, 13 saaTsa da 20 wuTze, `i-s~ eTerSi gavida misida a. m-s siuJeti, rom k-s #-e saarCevno ubanze `i-s~ gadam-Rebma jgufma winaswar Semoxazuli saarCevno biuletene-bi daafiqsira. es biuletenebi erT-erT moqalaqes _ g. m-svinme b. z-m gadasca da saarCevno yuTSi Cayra daavala. amfaqtis dafiqsirebis gamo `i-s~ warmomadgenlebs ucnobmapirebma fizikuri da sityvieri Seuracxyofa miayenes daoperator g. x-s kamera waarTves. xsenebuli sateleviziosiuJetis Sinaarsis mixedviT, videokameris g. x-s warTme-vis mizezad dasaxelda yalbi biuletenebis m-sTvis Camor-Tmevis faqti, rac nacionaluri moZraobis mxardamWerTainteresebSi ar Sedioda. mowmem aseve daadastura, rom 1oqtombers momxdari incidentis Semdeg, g. x-sTan erTadwavida TbilisSi `i-s~ xelmZRvanelobasTan, ra drosac saq-mis kursSi Caayena xelmZRvaneloba qalaq k-s ...-e saarCev-no ubanze momxdari incidentis Sesaxeb.
8. saapelacio palatis sxdomaze mowmis saxiT daikiTxag. x-i, romelmac aCvena, rom 2012 wlis 1 oqtombers muSa-obda `i-s~ tele-operatorad. 2012 wlis 1 oqtombers m. b-mdareka da moiTxova misuliyvnen k-s ...-e saarCevno ubanze.miTiTebul saarCevno ubanze mivida Jurnalist q. w-sa damZRol g. b-sTan erTad, sadac daxvdaT areuloba da qaosi.mis garda iq imyofeboda aseve meore operatori a. m-e. ro-desac ubanze mivida, daiwyo situaciis aRbeWdva firze,ra drosac ramdenime biWma, maT Soris o. b-mac, miayena Se-uracxyofa, daiwyes gineba, yvirodnen, kamera gawieT, nuiRebTo. miuxedavad amisa, igi mainc ganagrZobda gadaRe-bas. Semdeg Jurnalistma ikiTxa, ra xdeboda, cdilobdagaerkvia situacia. am dros qali gamovida da daiwyes misigadaReba, ra drosac o. b-ma gamostaca kamera da gaiqca.mas gaekida Tavadac, meore operatoric, Jurnalistic, da-axloebiT oci adamiani, magram ver daewivnen, radgan gam-tacebeli manqanaSi Cajda da gaiqca. kameris gatacebisprocess iRebda a. m-e. im dros ar icoda, vin iyo gamtace-beli, mogvianebiT gaigo misi vinaoba. Semdeg dareka `i-i~-sdireqtorTan da uTxra, rom kamera waarTves. meore dReski ucnobma bavSvma moitana kamera.
9. mowmis CvenebiT, rodesac o. b-ma kamera waarTva, fi-zikurad saerTod ar Sexebia. mowmem aRniSna, rom kameris
107
gatacebis mizezi gaxda yalbi biuletenebis gadaRebisfaqti. o. b-s Tavidanve SeeZlo kameris gataceba, vidreigi gafrTxilebas da Semdeg ginebas dauwyebda. o. b-ma ka-mera mas Semdeg waarTva, rac misi gadaReba ar Sewyvita.
10. garda zemoaRniSnulisa, o. b-s mier videokamerismarTlsawinaaRmdego dauflebisa da Semdeg am videoka-merisa da `dvd~ diskis ukan dabrunebis faqti dadastu-rebulia aseve mxareTa mier udavod cnobili Semdegi mtki-cebulebebiT _ mowmeebis: i. m-s, x. y-s, n. o-s, g. g-s, T. m-s, a.k-s, d. b-s, l. n-s, g. m-s, d. W-s, m. a-s, n. e-s, z. w-s, g. b-s, i. b-s, t. q-s, m. g-s, a. r-s, v. t-s, l. b-s, m.z b-s, g. m-s, l. x-sCvenebebiT, SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmiT, vi-deokamerisa da `dvd~ diskis daTvalierebis oqmiT, amo-Rebuli nivTieri mtkicebulebebiT.
11. zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebidan gamomdinare,sakasacio palata mTlianad eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamar-Tlos gamamtyunebeli ganaCeniT dadgenil faqtobriv ga-remoebebs, rom 2012 wlis 1 oqtombers qalaq k-i, Tavisuf-lebis quCaze, im dros, rodesac Jurnalistebi da opera-torebi cdilobdnen, arCevnebis dros ganviTarebuli mov-lenebis gadaRebas, kadrSi moxvda o. b-c, razec man da mis-ma Tanmxlebma pirebma sityvieri Seuracyofa miayenes Jur-nalistebs da eubnebodnen, aRar gadaeRoT maTTvis vide-okameriT. Tavad o. b-ma orjer uTxra operators, rom argadaeRo. mas Semdeg, rac operatorma gaagrZela misi gada-Reba, xolo Jurnalisti q. w-a samarTaldamcavebs eubne-boda, rom Cadenili iyo sisxlis samarTlis danaSauli,msjavrdebulma o. b-ma gadawyvita, operatorisTvis waer-Tmia kamera, raTa misi gadaReba SeCerebuliyo da amasTan,ainteresebda, xom ar iyo misi gineba dafiqsirebuli vide-okameraSi an sisxlis samarTlis sxva danaSaulis amsaxve-li kadrebi. man operator g. x-s waarTva kamera da gaiqca.xolo mas Semdeg, rac daaTvaliera videokameraSi aRbeW-dili masala, romelic misTvis saintereso ar aRmoCnda,daubruna igi Jurnalist q. w-s.
12. sakasacio palata mTlianad iziarebs saapelacio pa-latis msjelobas imasTan dakavSirebiT, rom o. b-s qmede-baSi ar aris Zarcvis SemadgenlobisaTvis damaxasiaTebe-li yvela niSani da miaCnia, rom prokuroris sakasacio sa-Civris moTxovna dausabuTebeli da ukanonoa, magram pa-lata ver daeTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos gasaCiv-
108
rebuli ganaCeniT o. b-s mier Cadenili qmedebis dakvali-ficirebas saqarTvelos ssk-is 154-e muxlis 1-li nawiliTda Tvlis, rom saqmeze Sekrebili mtkicebulebebis safuZ-velze dadgenili faqtobrivi garemoebebidan gamomdina-re, o. b-s qmedeba moicavs ssk-is 360-e muxlis 1-li nawi-liT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis _ TviTnebobis niSnebs.
14. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, marTalia, o. b-ma Sps `m-s~operator g. x-s aSkarad gastaca videokamera, magram saq-meze Sekrebili mtkicebulebebis gamokvleviT utyuaraddasturdeba, rom mas ar amoZravebda videokameris mar-TlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizani. TviT msjavrde-bul o. b-s, aseve Jurnalist q. w-s, operatorebis _ g. x-s, a.m-s, mowme g. b-s CvenebebiT dadasturebulia, rom isini as-rulebdnen TavianT profesiul movaleobas, iRebdnen si-uJets, ra drosac o. b-s Tanmxlebi piri _ m. a-i cdilobdaJurnalistisaTvis mikrofonis warTmevas. videokameriswarTmevas win uswrebda o. b-s gineba da SeZaxili `nu mi-RebT~, xolo mas Semdeg, rac operatorma kvlav gaagrZelaTavisi profesiuli saqmianoba -ganagrZo gadaReba, o. b-avideokamera waarTva operator g. x-s. mowmeebma detalu-rad aRweres, Tu ra garemoebebSi gaitaca o. b-a videokame-ra da Semdeg daabruna, rac gamoricxavs mis qmedebaSi vi-deokameris marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis miznis ar-sebobas.
15. amasTan, im garemoebebis mxedvelobaSi miRebiT, rommsjavrdebuli o. b-i aris Jurnalist q. w-s Tanaklaseli,iq myofi yvela piri mas kargad icnobda, iqve iyvnen poli-ciis TanamSromlebi, amasTan, saqmeze utyuarad dadgeni-li faqtobrivi garemoebebis erToblivi samarTlebrivianaliziT _ rom mas operatorisaTvis videokameris war-Tmevis momentSi amoZravebda mxolod is motivi, rom ope-rators Seewyvita misi gadaReba da mas enaxa, Tu ra iyoCawerili videokameraSi, Semdeg videokameris Semowmeba
109
da Tavisi nebiT dabruneba JurnalistisaTvis _ sakasaciopalatas miaCnia, rom yovelgvar damajereblobas aris mok-lebuli is faqti, rom mocemul SemTxvevaSi o. b-i moqme-debda marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, mis gan-zraxvaSi ar ikveTeba videokameris misakuTrebis mizani.am aucilebeli makvalificirebeli niSnis gareSe msjav-rdebulis qmedebaSi ar SeiZleba arsebobdes da arc arse-bobs Zarcvis Semadgenloba.
16. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom braldebismxaris mier warmodgenili mtkicebulebebiT utyuaradver mtkicdeba is faqti, rom o. b-i videokameris marTlsa-winaaRmdego dauflebis momentSi moqmedebda marTlsa-winaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, ris gamoc prokurorissakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes.
17. sakasacio palata Tvlis, rom gasaCivrebuli ganaCe-niT o. b-s qmedebis dakvalificireba saqarTvelos ssk-is154-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT arasworia. am muxlis dispozi-ciis Tanaxmad, sisxlis samarTlis wesiT akrZalul da das-jad qmedebas warmoadgens JurnalistisaTvis profesiulsaqmianobaSi xelis SeSla, ese igi misi iZuleba, gaavrce-los informacia an Tavis Seikavos misi gavrcelebisagan.
18. braldebis dadgenilebis mixedviT, o. b-s brali ede-ba mxolod imaSi, rom man 2012 wlis 1 oqtombers qalaq k-i,T-s quCaze, Sps `m-s~ operator g. x-s gastaca telekompa-niis kuTvnili, 4621 larad Rirebuli videokamera da mar-TlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT aSkarad daeuflamas.
19. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saapelacio palatagascda braldebis farglebs, rodesac imsjela o. b-s qme-debaSi ssk-is 154-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulisniSnebis arsebobaze da am muxliT daakvalificira misi qme-deba. braldeba ar edaveba o. b-s, rom man aRniSnuli moqme-debiT Jurnalists xeli SeuSala profesiul saqmianobaSida, Sesabamisad, sakasacio palata moklebulia SesaZleb-lobas am mimarTebiT imsjelos, iyo Tu ara o. b-s qmedeba-Si ssk-is 154-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli da-naSaulis niSnebic.
20. amasTan, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom rodesacmsjavrdebuli o. b-i daeufla g. x-s kuTvnil videokame-ras misi nebis sawinaaRmdegod, riTac dazaralebul mxa-res aRar mieca saSualeba, ganexorcielebina Tavisi pro-
25. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom mocemul SemTxveva-Si, rogorc aRvniSneT, o. b-s qmedebaSi aris TviTnebobisdanaSaulis niSnebi. gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebiT ut-yuarad aris dadgenili, rom im dros, rodesac operatoriaxorcielebda Tavis profesiul saqmianobas da uRebda o.b-s, es ukanaskneli amaze gabrazda, Seagina operators daramdenjerme mosTxova, Seewyvita misi gadaReba. aseve, amfaqts Tan erTvoda isic, rom o. b-i aginebda Jurnalis-tebs. am dros movidnen samarTaldamcavi organos warmo-madgenlebi. operatorma gaagrZela misi gadaReba, xoloJurnalisti q. w-a samarTaldamcavebs eubneboda, rom `ad-gili hqonda sisxlis samarTlis danaSauls~. msjavrdebul-ma o. b-ma gadawyvita, operatorisTvis waerTmia kamera, ra-Ta misi gadaReba SeCerebuliyo da amasTan, mas aintere-sebda, xom ar iyo misi gineba dafiqsirebuli videokamera-
111
Si, an sxva raime sisxlis samarTlis danaSaulis amsaxvelikadrebi. man operator g. x-s waarTva kamera da gaiqca kad-rebis sanaxavad, xolo mas Semdeg, rac daaTvaliera vide-okameraSi aRbeWdili masala, romelic misTvis saintere-so ar aRmoCnda, daukavSirda Jurnalistis mZRols da ga-igo, rom Jurnalisti da operatori ukve TbilisSi iyvnenwasulebi, Semdeg telefoniT daukavSirda Jurnalists dauTxra, rom dauzianeblad daubrunebda videokameras, racmeore dRes daubruna Jurnalist q. w-s.
26. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom im dros, rodesacoperatori asrulebda Tavis profesiul saqmianobas dauRebda o. b-s, man SecdomiT CaTvala, rom operators misigadaRebis ufleba ar hqonda Tanxmobis gareSe da mosTxo-va, Seewyvita misi gadaReba. xolo mas Semdeg, rac opera-torma mainc gaagrZela misi gadaReba, miuxedavad misimxridan ramdenjerme moTxovnisa, man gadawyvita, TviTonmoexdina mis mier SecdomiT dagulvebuli uflebis aR-dgena, realizeba da waarTva operators videokamera, ra-Ta misi gadaReba Sewyvetiliyo da amasTan, enaxa, misi sur-vilis sawinaaRmdegod, manamde ra gadaiRo operatorma,xom ar iyo videokameraSi dafiqsirebuli iseTi kadrebi,rac mas problemebs Seuqmnida. aRniSnuli moqmedebiT o.b-ma ugulebelyo kanoniT dadgenili wesi, rom pirs, ro-melsac marTlzomier mflobelobaSi aqvs nivTi da axor-cielebs Tavis profesiul saqmianobas, ufleba hqonda ne-bayoflobiT Seewyvita misi gadaReba, Tu amas TviTon CaT-vlida saWirod. aRniSnuli qmedebiT msjavrdebulma o. b-ma dazaralebul mxares miayena mniSvnelovani ziani, ker-Zod, arCevnebis dRes, 2012 wlis 1 oqtombers, dazarale-bul mxares aRar mieca saSualeba, ganexorcielebina Jur-nalistuli profesiuli saqmianoba, esargebla videokame-riT, gaegrZelebina saWiroebisamebr videokameris saSua-lebiT gadaReba, xolo Semdeg gadaRebuli masala siuJe-tis saxiT droulad gasuliyo eTerSi. aRniSnuli qmede-biT o. b-s qmedebaSi ikveTeba saqarTvelos ssk-is 360-e mux-lis 1-li nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis _ TviT-nebobis niSnebi.
27. amdenad, sasamarTlom yovelmxriv da obieqturadSeamowma saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebani, Seafasa TiTo-euli maTgani saqmesTan maTi relevanturobis, dasaSvebo-bisa da utyuarobis, aseve o. b-s damnaSaved cnobisTvis
112
sakmarisobis TvalsazrisiT da mivida im daskvnamde, romerTmaneTTan SeTanxmebul mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobagonivrul eWvs miRma adasturebs, rom o. b-ma Caidina TviT-neboba, ese igi Tavisad dagulvebuli uflebis dadgeniliwesis sawinaaRmdegod ganxorcieleba, ramac gamoiwviamniSvnelovani ziani.
28. sasjelis daniSvnis dros sasamarTlo iTvaliswinebso. b-s pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebel da damamZimebelgaremoebebs, danaSaulis Cadenis motivsa da mizans, qme-debaSi gamovlenil marTlsawinaaRmdego nebas, qmedebisganxorcielebis saxes, xerxsa da marTlsawinaaRmdego Se-degs, damnaSavis pirovnebas, mis ojaxur mdgomareobas. o.b-s pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebeli garemoebaa is, romaRiarebs Cadenil danaSauls, xolo damamZimebeli gare-moebebi ar gaaCnia.
29. garda amisa, sasjelis gansazRvrisas sasamarTlo iT-valiswinebs danaSaulebrivi qmedebis xasiaTs da miaCnia,rom o. b-s unda Seefardos sasjelis iseTi saxe da zoma,rac gaxdeba momavalSi misi sazogadoebaSi usafrTxo in-tegraciis safuZveli da iqneba damafiqrebeli msjavrde-bulisaTvis, raTa man ukeT gaacnobieros Cadenili qmede-bis xasiaTi, sazogadoebrivi saSiSroebisa da gasakicxao-bis xarisxi da bolos, sasjelma unda Seamciros msjavrde-bulis mier axali danaSaulis Cadenis riski, rac, Tavismxriv, xels Seuwyobs samarTlianobis aRdgenas.
30. palatis SefasebiT, sasjelis daniSvnis dros gaT-valiswinebul unda iqnes Cadenili danaSaulis xasiaTi, ra-Ta sasjeli iyos samarTliani. damnaSave piris resociali-zaciisaTvis, aseve sazogadoebrivi cxovrebis dacvis au-cileblobidan da samarTlianobis principidan gamomdi-nare, agreTve zogadi da kerZo prevenciis miznebisaTvispalatas mizanSewonilad miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul o. b-sdaeniSnos saqarTvelos ssk-is 360-e muxlis 1-li nawiliTgaTvaliswinebuli sasjeli jarimis saxiT, rac mas undaSeumcirdes saqarTvelos ssk-is 62-e muxlis me-5 nawilisSesabamisad, patimrobaSi yofnis vadis gaTvaliswinebiT.
31. amave dros palata yuradRebas miapyrobs im garemo-ebas, rom o. b-ma danaSaulebrivi qmedeba Caidina 2012 wlis1 oqtombers. `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012 wlis 28 dekembrissaqarTvelos kanonis 21-e muxlis Tanaxmad, am kanonis moq-medeba vrceldeba im pirze, romelmac danaSauli 2012 wlis
113
2 oqtombramde Caidina. amave kanonis me-20 muxlis Tanax-mad, `am kanonis moqmedeba ar vrceldeba sasjelis saxiTSefardebul jarimasa da qonebis CamorTmevaze. Sesabami-sad, o. b-s mimarT ver gavrceldeba `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012wlis 28 dekembris saqarTvelos kanonis moqmedeba, vinai-dan mas ZiriTadi sasjelis saxiT unda ganesazRvros ja-rima.
32. yovelive aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, palata miiC-nevs, rom Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 26noembris ganaCenSi o. b-s mimarT unda Sevides cvlileba.
1.3. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrde-bulma g. l-am da misma interesebis damcvelebma, advoka-tebma _ z. k-am da v. s-em, romlebmac iTxoves gasaCivrebu-li ganaCenis gauqmeba da gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gamo-tana.
wavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma saCivris safuZvlianobada miaCnia, rom saCivris moTxovna nawilobriv unda dakma-yofildes, xolo gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda gauqmdesSemdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata pirvel rigSi aRniSnavs, rom g. l-asmimarT saapelacio sasamarTlos mier gamotanili ganaCe-nis arsebiTi mxaris _ mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobis, da-naSaulis kvalifikaciis marTebulobisa da misi damnaSa-veoba/udanaSaulobis Sefasebamde yuradReba unda gamax-vildes im saproceso samarTlebriv sakiTxebze, romleb-sac dacvis mxare sadavod xdida pirveli da saapelacioinstanciis sasamarTloebSi da am etapzec warmoadgens sa-kasacio saCivris erT-erT ZiriTad safuZvels.
3. sakasacio palata yuradRebas amaxvilebs kasatorismiTiTebaze, rom pirveli instanciis sasamarTlom ukano-nod, sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis arsebiTi dar-RveviT uari uTxra dacvis mxares winasasamarTlo sxdo-maze dasaSvebad cnobili mtkicebulebebis gamokvlevaze_ mowmeTa dakiTxvaze, rac saapelacio sasamarTlomac ga-iziara. am mimarTebiT palatas miaCnia, rom sakiTxis gadaw-yvetisas zedmiwevniT unda Sefasdes im saproceso moqme-debisa da gadawyvetilebebis kanoniereba, romelic ukav-Sirdeba am sakiTxs da damoukideblad an sxva garemoebeb-
118
Tan mimarTebiT gavlenas axdens mis samarTlebriv Sefa-sebaze, kerZod:
5. palata ganmartavs, rom aRniSnuli ufleba warmoad-gens mxareTa Tanasworuflebianobisa da SejibrebiTi pro-cesis mniSvnelovan garantias. miuxedavad dacvis mxari-saTvis am uflebis mniSvnelobisa, unda aRiniSnos, rom igiar aris absoluturi xasiaTis da sasamarTlo yvela Sem-TxvevaSi, upirobod ar aris valdebuli, daakmayofilosdacvis mxaris es moTxovna. es damokidebulia im sisxlissamarTlis saproceso normebze, romlebic zemoaRniSnu-li principebis gaTvaliswinebiT, saxelmwifoSi awesrigebsmtkicebulebaTa dasaSvebobisa da gamokvlevis procedu-rebs.
6. saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeq-sis me-9 muxliT ganmtkicebulia mxareTa Tanasworobisada SejibrebiTobis principi, kerZod: am muxlis 1-li nawi-lis Tanaxmad, sisxlissamarTlebrivi devnis dawyebisTa-nave sisxlis samarTlis procesi xorcieldeba mxareTa Ta-nasworobisa da SejibrebiTobis safuZvelze, xolo me-2nawilis Tanaxmad, mxares ufleba aqvs, am kodeqsiT dad-genili wesiT daayenos Suamdgomloba, moipovos, sasamar-Tlos meSveobiT gamoiTxovos, waradginos da gamoikvli-os yvela Sesabamisi mtkicebuleba. aRniSnuli principebiaseve reglamentirebulia sssk-is 25-e muxlis 1-li nawil-Si _ sasamarTlo valdebulia, mxareebs TavianTi uflebe-bisa da kanonieri interesebis dasacavad Seuqmnas Tanaba-ri SesaZleblobebi ise, rom arc erT maTgans ar mianiWosupiratesoba. palata aRniSnavs, rom miTiTebuli normebiaris zogadi xasiaTis, romlebic ganamtkicebs Sejibrebi-Tobisa da Tanasworobis principebs, xolo konkretuli sa-
120
marTlebrivi sakiTxi unda gadawydes im specialuri nor-mebis Sesabamisad, romlebic aregulirebs sadavo samar-Tlebriv urTierTobas, kerZod:
7. saqarTvelos sssk-is 83-e muxli aregulirebs mxare-Ta mier mtkicebulebaTa erTmaneTisaTvis gadacemisa dasasamarTlosaTvis wardgenis wess. mocemul SemTxvevaSiaRniSnul muxlTan mimarTebiT unda Sefasdes dacvis mxa-ris mier mtkicebulebaTa braldebis mxarisaTvis gadace-misa da sasamarTlosaTvis wardgenis kanonierebis sakiT-xi.
8. aRniSnuli muxlis me-6 nawilis Tanaxmad, winasasa-marTlo sxdomis gamarTvamde ara ugvianes 5 dRisa mxare-ebma erTmaneTs da sasamarTlos unda miawodon im momen-tisaTvis maT xelT arsebuli sruli informacia, romlismtkicebulebad sasamarTloSi wardgenasac apireben. ama-ve muxlis me-4 nawilis Tanaxmad, `...mxareebis mier infor-maciis gacvlis Tobaze dgeba oqmi, romlis aslic egzavne-ba sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmesTan erTad~. mo-cemul SemTxvevaSi dadgenilia, rom dacvis mxarem misxelT arsebuli gamokiTxvis oqmebi gadasca mowinaaRmde-ge _ braldebis mxares, ris Taobazec Seadgina Sesabamisioqmebi da warudgina sasamarTlos, aseve sasamarTlos wa-rudgina oqmebi informaciis gacvlis Sesaxeb.
9. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom qvemdgomi instanciissasamarTloebma arasworad ganmartes sssk-is 83-e muxlisme-6 nawili da masSi moxseniebuli termini _ `sruli in-formacia~, romlis erTmaneTisTvis miwodebis valdebu-leba aqvT mxareebs. palata aRniSnavs, rom `srul infor-maciaSi~ moiazreba yvela is informacia (mtkicebuleba),romlebic mxareebs xelT aqvT da mis sasamarTloSi war-dgenas apireben. damatebiT mxareebisaTvis im movaleobisdakisreba, rom gamokiTxvis oqmebis meore mxarisaTvis ga-dacemasa da sasamarTlosTvis wardgenasTan erTad dae-kisroT aseve erTmaneTisa da sasamarTlosaTvis dasakiTxpirTa siis (nusxis) wardgena, ar gamomdinareobs saqarTve-los sssk-is 83-e muxlis an sxva normebis moTxovnebidan,ris gamoc qvemdgomi instanciis sasamarTloTa gadawyve-tileba am sakiTxze aramarTebulia.
15. amasTan, sakasacio palata yuradRebas amaxvilebsqvemdgomi instanciis sasamarTloebSi saqmis ganxilvisasganviTarebul mosazrebaze, rom mocemul SemTxvevaSidacvis mxaris mowmeTa dakiTxviT braldebis mxare aRmoC-ndeboda dacvis mxaresTan araTanabar mdgomareobaSi. pa-lata aRniSnavs, rom braldebis mxaris mier mowmeT dasa-kiTx pirTa nusxis Sedgena da sasamarTlosaTvis wardgenaim pirobebSi, rodesac saproceso kodeqsis arc erTi nor-ma aseT valdebulebas mxareTaTvis ar iTvaliswinebs, arSeiZleba Sefasdes SejibrebiTobisa da Tanasworobisprincipebis darRvevad, Tu aseTive, mowmed dasakiTx pir-
124
Ta nusxa ar Seadgina dacvis mxarem da ar gadasca sasamar-Tlos. palata miuTiTebs, rom SejibrebiTobisa da Tanas-worobis principebis aralegitimuri SezRudva saxeze iq-neboda im SemTxvevaSi, rodesac konkretuli saprocesokodeqsis normis moTxovnis safuZvelze mosamarTle ana-logiur mocemulobaSi braldebisa da dacvis mxareebis sa-sargeblod miiRebda gansxvavebul gadawyvetilebebs damaT ar miscemda konkretuli normiT garantirebuli uf-lebebiT sargeblobis Tanabar SesaZleblobas, rac moce-mul SemTxvevaSi ar momxdara.
16. sakasacio palata aseve aRniSnavs, rom sasamarTlosaqmes ganixilavs wardgenili braldebis farglebSi. sa-qarTvelos sssk-is me-17 muxlis me-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, pi-ris braldeba mxolod prokuroris uflebamosilebaa. ama-ve kodeqsis 169-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtis Ta-naxmad, braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenilebaSi unda aRiniSnos:braldebis formulireba _ inkriminirebuli qmedebis aR-wera, misi Cadenis adgilis, drois, xerxis, saSualebis, ia-raRis, agreTve am qmedebiT gamowveuli Sedegis miTiTe-biT. amdenad, wardgenili braldebis farglebSi moiazre-ba swored prokuroris mier braldebis Sesaxeb dadgeni-lebaSi Camoyalibebuli braldebis formulireba, romel-Sic mkafiod unda iyos Camoyalibebuli im marTlsawina-aRmdego da braleuli qmedebis aRwera (rogor gamoixa-ta), romelsac braldebis mxare edaveba braldebuls, mi-si Cadenis adgilis, drois, xerxis, saSualebis, iaraRis,agreTve am qmedebiT gamowveuli Sedegis miTiTebiT.
17. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, g. l-as braldebis Sesaxeb dad-genilebis Tanaxmad, misi danaSaulebrivi qmedeba imaSi ga-moixata, rom igi 2013 wlis 20 seqtembers q. f-Si, W-is quCa-ze, 21:30 wuTze gadaadgildeboda da atarebda mis miermarTlsawinaaRmdegod SeZenil `naganis~ sistemis cec-xlsasrol iaraRsa da 7 sabrZolo masalas. pirveli da saa-pelacio instanciis sasamarTloebma g. l-as msjavri das-des cecxlsasroli iaraRisa da sabrZolo masalis mar-TlsawinaaRmdego SeZenis, Senaxvisa da tarebisaTvis, ri-Tac sasamarTloebma mas faqtobrivad braldeba daumZi-mes cecxlsasroli iaraRisa da sabrZolo masalis mar-TlsawinaaRmdego SenaxviT, romelic braldebis mxaresmisTvis ar warudgenia (dadgenilebidan ar gamomdinare-obs). Sesabamisad, saapelacio sasamarTlom aseve unda im-
125
sjelos am mimarTebiT.18. sakasacio palata zemoaRniSnuli garemoebis gamo,
ar msjelobs kasatoris miTiTebaze _ braldebis mxarismtkicebulebebs Soris arsebul urTierTwinaaRmdegobeb-ze, dakavebisa da piradi Cxrekis oqmSi SesaZlo cru in-formaciis Setanaze, mtkicebulebaTa utyuarobasa dasakmarisobaze, vinaidan es da sxva sadavo sakiTxebi sabo-lood erTobliobaSi unda Sefasdes dacvis mxaris mtki-cebulebebis gamokvlevis _ mowmeTa dakiTxvis Semdeg,aseve maTi braldebis mxaris mtkicebulebebTan urTier-TSejerebis Sedegad.
19. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom dacvis mxarisaTvis mowmeTa da-kiTxvaze uaris TqmiT arsebiTad dairRva sisxlis samar-Tlis saproceso kodeqsis moTxovnebi, ris gamoc unda ga-uqmdes quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2014 wlis 3 oqtombris ganaCenimsjavrdebul g. l-as mimarT. amasTan, vinaidan sakasaciopalatas ar gaaCnia aRniSnuli darRvevis gamosworebisa dadacvis mxaris uflebebis aRdgenis _ mowmeTa dakiTxvissamarTlebrivi meqanizmi, es unda gamoasworos saapela-cio sasamarTlom, kerZod: saqme unda ganixilos da dakiT-xos dacvis mxaris mowmeebi, ris Semdegac unda Seafasos g.l-as damnaSaveoba/udanaSauloba da miiRos kanonis Sesa-bamisi gadawyvetileba.
9. kasatorebi _ msjavrdebul a. b-s interesebis dam-cveli advokatebi _ g. k-i da a. m-e sakasacio saCivarSi aR-niSnaven, rom Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTloSi saqmisganxilvis dros arsebiTad dairRva saqarTvelos sisxlis
128
samarTlis saproceso kodeqsi da msjavrdebulis qmede-bas mieca araswori kvalifikacia.
11. pirveli instanciis sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamokvle-uli mtkicebulebebiT, mowmeebisa da dazaralebulis Cve-nebebiT ar dadasturda, rom a. b-sa da a. k-s hqondaT kon-fliqti, rac SeiZleboda gamxdariyo mkvlelobis motivi;mowmeebis _ s. m-sa da q. z-s CvenebebiT, msroleli ar iyo a.b-e; gamoZiebam amoiRo, Tumca saqmeSi ar moaTavsa taSken-tis q. #...-is gare saTvalTvalo videokameris Canaweri dadacvis mxares araoficialurad gadaeca ramdenimewamiani`daCexili~ masala, rasac adasturebs 2013 wlis 11 dekem-bris cnoba da daTvalierebis oqmi, romelic braldebismxarem udavod miiCnia, xolo saapelacio sasamarTlom amas-Tan dakavSirebiT saerTod ar imsjela; saapelacio sasa-marTlom saerTod ar imsjela a. b-s iZulebaze, xsenebulidanaSaulis CadenaSi emxila Tavisive megobari da naTesa-vi T. d-e.
12. xazgasasmelia d. T-ze samarTaldamcavi organosmxridan ganxorcielebuli ukanono qmedebebi, romlebi-Tac mas aiZulebdnen, danaSaulis CadenaSi emxila T. d-e,romelic, oficialuri informaciiT, danaSaulis CadenismomentSi ar imyofeboda saqarTvelos teritoriaze; masSemdeg, rac miiRes sasurveli Cveneba, romlis mixedviT,d. T-e iribad amxelda a. b-s mkvlelobis mcdelobis Cade-naSi, braldebis mxarem yvelaferi gaakeTa, rom igi ar ga-mocxadebuliyo sasamarTlo procesze da ar eTqva simar-
129
Tle, rom a. b-e iyo udanaSaulo; saapelacio sasamarTlokanonis moTxovnaTa uxeSi darRveviT, calsaxad daeyrdnod. T-s mier gamoZiebisaTvis miwodebul falsificirebulinformacias, romelic, prokuraturis ZalisxmeviT, sasa-marTloSi ver gadamowmda; a. b-s braleuloba, d. T-s Cve-nebis garda, ar dasturdeba arc erTi sxva mtkicebule-biT, d. T-s Cveneba ki iribi mtkicebulebaa, romelic imSemTxvevaSi SeiZleba gaxdes dasaSvebi, Tuki is dadastur-deba sxva iseTi mtkicebulebiT, romelic ar aris iribi(sssk-is 76-e muxli); bunebaSi ar arsebobs iseTi mtkice-buleba, romelic daadasturebda a. b-s mier a. k-s daWras.
13. d. T-s mier gamoZiebaSi iZulebiT micemuli infor-macia ar SeiZleboda aRqmuliyo, rogorc mowmis Cveneba,radgan mowmis Cveneba _ es aris informacia, romelsac mow-me iZleva sasamarTloSi; d. T-s mier gamoZiebisaTvis miwo-debuli informaciis deponirebul Cvenebad CaTvla dasssk-is 243-e muxlis me-2 nawilis Tanaxmad, SemdgomSi mi-si sasamarTlo sxdomaze wakiTxva saproceso kanonis uxe-Si darRvevaa, Sesabamisad, dauSvebelia amgvari mtkice-bulebis safuZvelze gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamotana.
14. a. b-s CvenebiT, igi policiam daakava d. T-s colis-Zmis saxlSi; policiaSi mas aiZulebdnen, rom `xeli dae-do~ T. d-saTvis, romelic iyo misi megobari da naTluli,amitom Tavdapirvelad a. k-s daWra aiRo Tavis Tavze; aR-niSnuli Cveneba srulad dadasturda mowmed dakiTxulig. r-sa da n. k-s CvenebebiTa da i. m-s gamokiTxvis oqmiT,Tumca saapelacio sasamarTlom usamarTlod da usafuZ-vlod ar gaiziara es Cvenebebi im motiviT, rom isini cdi-loben, pasuxismgebloba aaridon megobars.
15. mowmeebi _ g. s-e, m. x-i, t. b-e, n. k-e, g. r-e, e., l. da v.c-ebi, g. w-i da T. C-e acxadebdnen, rom isini Seeswrnen s. m-s saubars, rodesac igi aRwerda a. k-s daWris detalebs daacxadebda, rom msroleli ar iyo a. b-e; braldebis mxaremaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebi da maTSi gadmocemuli faq-tobrivi garemoebebi ar gaxada sadavod, Tumca sasamar-Tlom isini usafuZvlod ar gaiziara.
16. mowme q. z-s CvenebiT, a. b-e misi gulisTvis ar daWri-da a. k-s, romelic, misi azriT, daWra Tavisma yofilma me-uRlem T. d-m, romelsac araoficialurad hqonda `bere-tas~ modelis iaraRi mayuCTan erTad; saapelacio sasamar-Tlo saerTod gverds uvlis am garemoebebs da a. b-s adana-
130
Saulebs SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebuli iaraRis ukano-no SeZenasa da tarebaSi, maSin, rodesac amis iribi mtkice-bulebac ki ar gaaCnia; eqspertizis daskvniT, amoRebuliaraRze ar aris a. b-s TiTis anabeWdebi, mis tansacmels araReniSneba metalizaciis kvali; aRsaniSnavia isic, rom re-zinis xelTaTmanebi napovnia da samZebro ZaRli `jina~ wa-vida a. b-sa da d. T-s moZraobis sapirispirod, anu im mxa-res, saiTac a. b-s saerTod ar gauvlia; dacvis mxaris mierwarmodgenil da sasamarTloSi udavod cnobil, taSken-tis quCaze s/s `saqarTvelos bankisa~ da `medi qlab jor-jias~ saTvalTvalo videokamerebiT 2013 wlis 5 noembersganxorcielebul CanawerebSi ar Cans a. b-e, riTic dastur-deba misi udanaSauloba.
17. odorologiuri eqspertizis #... daskvnis Tanaxmad,`SemTxvevis adgilze napovni TeTri feris samedicino xel-TaTmanebidan amoRebuli sunis kvalis nimuSebi araiden-turia braldebul a. b-s tansacmlidan da misgan aRebulisunis kvalis nimuSebis~; xelis kvlebi ar gamovlinda pis-toletze, mWidsa da xelTaTmanebze; a. b-s tansacmelzeraime saxis metalis kvali ar dafiqsirda; aRniSnul faq-tobriv garemoebebs saerTod ar axsenebs saapelacio sa-samarTlo da ar cdilobs, gaaqarwylos an raime logikurimsjeloba SemogvTavazos mocemul mtkicebulebebze; ub-ralod ignorirebas ukeTebs a. b-s aSkara gamamarTlebelfaqtobriv garemoebebs.
18. braldebis mxaris mier warmodgenili qimiuri eq-spertizis #... daskvnis Tanaxmad, ar aris dadgenili a. b-smarjvena xelis anawmendsa da qurTukis saxeloze ra rao-denobis stibiumisa da bariumis kvali iqna aRmoCenili, racimaze miuTiTebs, rom, gamoZiebas ar awyobda ra qimiurielementebis odenobis dafiqsireba, eqspertizis mier das-kvnaSi saerTod ar aisaxa aRniSnuli; daskvnaSi araferiaTqmuli a. b-s tansacmelsa da xelis anawmendze difenila-minis kvalis aRmoCenis Taobaze, rac kidev erTxel miuTi-Tebs im garemoebaze, rom a. b-s tansacmelsa da xelis anaw-mendze darCenili qimiuri Semadgenlobebi ar aris darCe-nili cecxlsasroli iaraRidan gasrolis Sedegad (a. b-m g.r-sTan gaisrola saaxalwlo SuSxuna).
19. eqspertizis daskvniT, romelic daadastura eqsper-tma z. o-m, NO2 aris maRali temperaturis wvis dros gamo-yofili gazisebri komponenti, romelic gamoiyofa TiT-
131
qmis nebismieri nivTierebis wvis dros (maT Soris _ SuSxu-nis, denTis da a.S.); miuxedavad amisa, saapelacio sasamar-Tlom faqtobrivad ugulebelyo mocemuli ganmarteba datendenciurad ar gaiziara dacvis mxaris mier warmodge-nili eqspertizis daskvna.
20. garda amisa, sasamarTlom ar gaiziara g. r-s mier war-modgenili sabavSvo baRis gare saTvalTvalo videokame-ris Canaweri (romliTac dgindeba, rom 2013 wlis 5 noem-bers a. b-e g. r-sTan sabavSvo baRSi mivida 20 saaTsa da 52wuTze) im motiviT, rom SenobaSi Semsvleli piris qurTu-kis feri ar emTxveva mowmeebis mier aRwerili a. b-s qur-Tukis fers; cnobili faqtia, rom gare saTvalTvalo kame-ra Ramis saaTebSi infrawiTeli sxivebis meSveobiT gansxva-vebul ferebSi aRiqvams materias; a. b-s SemTxvevis dRes,amoRebisa da daTvalierebis oqmis mixedviT, ecva tyavisada naWris komponentebisagan Sekerili qurTuki, amitomRamiT infrawiTel kameraSi tyavisa da materiis Semadgen-loba aRiqmeba sxvadasxva ferad.
21. braldebis mxaris mier wardgenil SemTxvevis adgi-lis daTvalierebis oqmze TandarTul suraTebSi naTladCans, Tu rogor kargad aris ganaTebuli SemTxvevis adgi-li, amitom gamoricxulia, s. m-s ver ecno Tavisi alali de-idaSvili a. b-e; miuxedavad amisa, saapelacio sasamarTlosmosamarTleebma irwmunes gareSe pirebis monaTxrobi, re-aluri, obieqturi garemoebebisa da faqtebis sawinaaRmde-god.
22. kasatorTa azriT, a. k-sa da sasuliero piris saub-ris faruli audioCanaweridan aSkarad ikveTeba danaSau-lis Camdeni piri da motivi; am Canaweris samarTlebriv Se-fasebas saapelacio sasamarTlo gverds uvlis; rac Seexe-ba T. d-s, man 2013 wlis 4 noembers gadakveTa saqarTvelossazRvari TurqeTis mimarTulebiT da oficialurad saqar-TveloSi ar dabrunebula, Tumca 2013 wlis 9 noembers da-akaves saqarTvelos teritoriaze TurqeTis sazRvris ga-dakveTis mcdelobisas da amJamad ixdis sasjels.
23. dazaralebul a. k-s ar daunaxavs, Tu vin esrola;misi azriT, msrolels surda misi daWra da ara _ mokvla;mokvla rom ndomeboda, msroleli daaxloebiT 2 metrSiimyofeboda da sakontrolo gasroliT a. k-s mokvla prob-lemas ar warmoadgenda, miT ufro, rom SemTxvevis adgi-lidan amoRebul iaraRSi iyo erTi gausroleli vazna; aR-
132
niSnulis gamo, a. k-s mimarT ganxorcielebuli qmedeba un-da dakvalificirebuliyo saqarTvelos ssk-is 117-e mux-lis 1-li nawiliT da ara _ ssk-is me-19,108-e muxliT.
24. saCivris avtorTa azriT, pirveli instanciis sasa-marTlom miiRo swori da obieqturi gadawyvetileba, xo-lo braldebis mxares saapelacio sasamarTloSi ar warud-genia axali mtkicebuleba, romliTac dadgindeboda a. b-sSemxebloba xsenebul saqmesTan, miuxedavad amisa, saape-lacio sasamarTlom daarRvia saproceso kanonis araerTimoTxovna, arasworad ganmarta kanonis muxlebi, miiRoukanono gadawyvetileba da revizia gaukeTa ganaCenis imnawilsac, romelsac arc erTi mxare sadavod ar xdida dadaamZima a. b-s samarTlebrivi mdgomareoba.
kasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma sa-Civris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom saCivris moTxovnaunda dakmayofildes da gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda Se-icvalos vinaidan, braldebis mxaris mier warmodgenilida sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebi ariZleva imis safuZvels, rom sakasacio palatam gonivruleWvs miRma dadgenilad miiCnios a. b-s mier ganzrax mkvle-lobis mcdelobisa da cecxlsasroli iaraRis ukanonodSeZena-tarebis faqti, kerZod:
2. mowme g. s-m aCvena, rom a. b-e misi Svilis naTliaa daicnobs daaxloebiT 1992-1993 wlebidan, is aseve misi mami-daSvilis _ a. k-s mamidaSvilia. a. k-e daavadebulia C hepa-titiTa da SidsiT, ris gamoc, samkurnalod infeqciur sa-avadmyofoSi uwevda kviraSi erTxel misvla da amitom mom-xdar faqtamde masTan xSirad rCeboda, Tumca xandaxansxva naTesavebTanac midioda. n. m-s icnobda a. k-sa da a. b-sagan, is a. k-s mamidaSvilia. a. b-e da n. m-i deidaSvilebi
133
arian. cixidan gamosvlis Semdeg a. k-e gaSorda meuRles,2-3 Tve baTumSi iyo, Semdeg _ monasterSi, Semdeg ki mkur-nalobis mizniT _ TbilisSi. a. k-s da a. b-s cixidan gamos-vlis Semdeg gaufuWdaT urTierToba, Tumca mizezi aricis. q. z-s icnobs a. k-sagan, igi aris misi mamidaSvili, ismeuRles aseve gaSorebulia; am sakiTxTan dakavSirebiTicis baTumSi gavrcelebuli Woris Sesaxeb, rom a. k-sa da q.z-s hqondaT intimuri urTierToba. aRniSnuli q. z-s me-uRlem T. d-m daijera da isini ganqorwindnen. mowmem ga-nacxada, rom xSirad unaxavs a. da q. erTad. 2013 wlis 5 no-embers daureka a. k-m da uTxra, rom samsaxuris Semdeg ga-evlo n. m-Tan, visTanac sufra iSleboda. sufris erT-erTwevrs _ s. m-s sigareti gauTavda da Cavida maRaziaSi sa-yidlad, mas a. k-e gahyva. daaxloebiT or wuTSi s-s meuR-lis telefonze gaisma zari, Seityves, rom a. k-e iyo cu-dad. sufris wevrebi Cavidnen ezoSi, a. k-e Zirs iwva da igi-neboda. fexebTan dainaxa sisxli da mixvda, rom is iyo daW-rili. s. yviroda, rom avtomanqana ver gavidoda ezodan,ra avtomanqanas gulisxmobda s., misTvis ucnobia. momxda-ris Semdeg s. m-i bevrjer naxa, is saavadmyofoSi midiodaxolme da momxdarTan dakavSirebiT saubrobdnen. s. m-mauTxra, rom srolis dros silueti dainaxa, romelmac av-tomanqanasTan miirbina da swored am manqanas gulisxmob-da SemTxvevis dros. mowmem daadastura, rom ezo korpu-sis mxares ganaTebulia, `arka~ ki _ Cabnelebuli. rogorcs. m-i ambobda, msroleli a. b-e rom yofiliyo, icnobda.
3. analogiuri faqtobrivi garemoebebi daadasturessufris sxva wevrebmac, mowmeebma _ n. m-ma, d. l-m da m. x-ma.
4. dazaralebulma a. k-m aCvena, rom a. b-e misi mamidaSvi-lia. q. z-e aris aseve misi mamidaSvili, xolo q. da a. ariandeidaSvilebi. mas a. b-sTan hqonda kargi urTierToba, Tum-ca bolo periodSi ukve aRar hqonda urTierToba. q. da a.erTmaneTTan, rogorc icis, bolo periodSi aRar kontaq-tobdnen. mas q-sTan daZmuri urTierToba aqvs. q. z-e qor-winebaSi iyo T. d-sTan, Tumca amJamad aris ganqorwinebu-li, mas aseve gacnobis dRidan kargi urTierToba aqvs T.d-sTan. misTvis ucnobia q. z-sa da T. d-s ganqorwinebismizezi. mowmem ganacxada, rom 2013 wlis 5 noembers imyo-feboda n. m-Tan sufraze. saRamos s. m-s gahyva maRaziaSi,ezoSi Casvlisas `arkaSi~ yofnisas esroles. im droisaT-vis ukve bneloda. pirveli tyviis moxvedra ver igrZno,
134
egona iyo SaSxana, Semdeg ki mixvda, rom viRaca cecxlsas-rol iaraRs esroda zurgis mxridan. man s-s miartya xeli,mobrunda, magram Suqi mienaTa da ver dainaxa veravin. s.yviroda, ucnobebs mimarTavda saswrafo daxmareba gamo-eZaxaT. mowmem daadastura, rom mas ar daunaxavs, vin es-roda, dainaxa adamiani, romelic garboda, Tumca sqesisidentificirebac ver SeZlo. mowmem ganmarta, rom ar sje-ra, rom a. b-e Caidenda misTvis bralad Seracxul qmede-bas.
5. mowme s. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom a. b-e misi dei-daSvilia, dazaralebuli a. k-e aseve misi naTesavia, iseverogorc _ a. b-s. misi ganmartebiT, a. k-e samkurnalo prog-ramaSi iyo CarTuli da yovel samSabaTs nemsis gasakeTeb-lad Camodioda TbilisSi da rCeboda an mis dasTan _ n. m-Tan, romelic cxovrobda vaJa-fSavelas —Si, an Tavis bi-ZaSvilTan _ g. s-sTan, romelic agreTve cxovrobda vaJa-fSavelas kvartalSi. mowmem aCvena, rom 2013 wlis 5 noem-bers n. m-Tan imyofeboda, sadac aseve iyo am ukanasknelismeuRle, da, a. k-e da g. s-e. daaxloebiT saRamos 9-is naxe-varze is da a. k-e Cavidnen maRaziaSi sigaretis sayidlad;`arkidan~ gasvlisas gaiges gasrolis xma, 2-3 metriT windainaxa naperwkali asfaltze, rac maSxala egona, TumcaaRniSnuls mohyva ramdenime gasrola, is raRac momentSimotrialda da dainaxa msrolelis xeli, Semdeg ki _ waqce-uli a. k-e. iqve 20-30 metrSi, xelmarcxniv, kalaTburTismoedanTan, dainaxa avtomanqana, romelic ukve daZruliiyo da silueti, romelic avtomanqanisken garboda. igiSvelas iTxovda. rogorc axsovs, meuRlesTan darekvac mo-axerxa. azrze rom movida, Zalian bevri policieli iyo,Semdeg policielebs eZebda da yviroda, rom ezos sxva ga-sasvleli ar aqvs, avtomanqana ki ezoSi iyo da moeZebnaT.`arkaSi~ aranairi ganaTeba ar iyo da bneloda. misi ganmar-tebiT, man srolis dros dainaxa iaraRiani xeli idayvi-dan. msrolels, rogorc axsovs, Savi tansacmeli ecva. mow-mem ganmarta, rom mis mier danaxuli silueti a. b-e romyofiliyo, aucileblad icnobda.
6. mowme q. z-s mier sasamarTlo sxdomaze micemuli Cve-nebiT dadgenilia, rom a. b-e aris misi deidaSvili, xolodazaralebuli a. k-e misi biZaSvilia. a. k-e da a. b-e arianbiZaSvil-mamidaSvilebi. ramdenime welia a. b-sTan aranai-ri urTierToba ar aqvs, xSirad Cxubobdnen. a. k-sTan Zali-
135
an kargi urTierToba aqvs. a. k-s da a. b-s daZabuli urTier-Toba hqondaT bavSvobidan, magram periodulad rigdebod-nen, Tumca es urTierToba ar iyo iseTi, rom erTmaneTisasikvdilod gaemetebinaT. T. d-sTan ganqorwinebulia,radgan baTumSi gavrcelda Wori, rom TiTqosda mas da a. k-s hqondaT intimuri urTierToba, ris gamoc T. d-m scemada uTxra, rom umjobesi iqneboda, Tu a. k-s arsad gadaey-reboda. mowmem ganacxada, rom T. d-s hqonda iaraRi e.w.`bereta~ mayuCiT, tyviebi ki iyo grZeli, makarovismagva-ri.
7. mowme T. d-s mier sasamarTlo sxdomaze micemuli Cve-nebiT dadgenilia, rom a. b-e misi megobari da naTliaa. 2013wlis 4 noembridan 9 noembramde imyofeboda stambulSi,saidanac aralegalurad gadmokveTa saqarTvelos sazRva-ri da gadmosvlisas daakaves. waiyvanes narkologiurSi,sadac xalxi laparakobda a. b-sa da a. k-s saqmeze. `kapeze-Si~ gamomZieblebma aseve uTxres momxdari ambavi, kerZodis, rom a. b-m esrola a. k-s. is imyofeboda qorwinebaSi q. z-sTan, qorwinebamde periodidan icnobs a. k-s. b-e da k-e na-Tesavebi arian. icis, rom kargi urTierToba ar hqondaT a.b-sTan arc a. k-s da arc q. z-s. a. da q. naTesavebi arian. asevemeuRlisgan icis, rom binZurad Woraobdnen, TiTqos a-sada q-s hqondaT intimuri urTierToba, Tumca mas ar dau-jerebia Wori, Sesabamisad, arc gaurkvevia. a. k-e Cveuleb-riv midioda masTan saxlSi da hqonda urTierToba, arculaparakiaT WorebTan dakavSirebiT. misTvis ucnobia,icoda Tu ara a. b-m Worebis Sesaxeb. mowmem daadastura,rom meuRlesTan WorebTan dakavSirebiT ar uCxubia. gan-qorwinebis mizezi iyo is, rom q. Tbiliseli iyo, is ki _baTumeli, q-s mSoblebi TbilisSi hyavda da ar SeeZlo ba-TumSi cxovreba. a. k-s mokvliT ar damuqrebia, amasTan,cecxlsasrol iaraRebTan arasdros hqonia Sexeba da arcarasdros hqonia. misi meuRle garkveulia Tu ara iaraReb-Si, ar icis.
8. mowme l. x-s mier sasamarTlo sxdomaze micemuli Cve-nebiT dadgenilia, rom is aris Sss saeqsperto dawesebu-lebis mTavari eqsperti. man daadastura mis mier 2013 wlis6 noembers gacemuli daskvna, romlis Tanaxmadac, iara-Ris lulidan aRebul anawmendze denTis SemadgenelierT-erTi komponentis funqcionaluri jgufis _ NO2-isarseboba dafiqsirda. eqspertizaze warmodgenili iara-
136
Ridan bolo gawmendis Semdeg nawarmoebia gasrola; manvedaadastura 2013 wlis 8 noembers gacemuli daskvna, rom-lis Tanaxmadac, eqspertizaze warmodgenil a. b-sa da d.T-s tansacmelze denTis Semadgeneli erT-erTi komponen-tis funqcionaluri jgufis _ NO2-is arseboba dafiqsir-da a. b-s qurTukis gulispirsa da orive saxeloze, tyviiskafsulaSi Semavali komponentebis _ stibiumisa da bari-umis arseboba dafiqsirda a. b-s qurTukis marjvena saxe-loze. samedicino xelTaTmanze dafiqsirda denTis Semad-geneli erT-erTi komponentis funqcionaluri jgufis _NO2-is da tyviis kafsulaSi Semavali komponentebis _ sti-biumisa da bariumis arseboba. tyviis kafsulaSi Semavalikomponentebis _ stibiumisa da bariumis arseboba dafiq-sirda a. b-s marjvena xelidan aRebul anawmendze. cilin-druli formis metalis sagnidan aRebul anawmendze da-fiqsirda denTis Semadgeneli erT-erTi komponentisfunqcionaluri jgufis _ NO2-is arseboba. gasrolis Sem-deg a. b-s qurTukze, samedicino xelTaTmanze da cilin-druli formis metalis sagnidan aRebul anawmendze da-fiqsirebuli NO2-is mixedviT denTis identifikacia Se-uZlebelia.
9. mowme l. x-m aseve ganmarta, rom NO2 aris denTis wvisproduqti _ gazi, romlic warmoiqmneba gasrolis Sede-gad. NO2 piris tansacmelze SeiZleba moxvdes gasrolisprocesSi, SesaZlebelia adamians daefinos tansacmelzean sxeulze. stibiumi da bariumi aris tyviis kafsulis Se-madgeneli komponentebi da gasrolis Sedegad analogiu-rad rCeba tansacmelsa da sxeulze. SesaZlebelia, NO2 yo-fiT cxovrebaSi dafiqsirdes, nebismieri nitro jgufisSemcvelma naerTma SeiZleba datovos analogiuri kvali.stibiumi da bariumi nakleb gavrcelebulia, amitom nak-lebi Sansia sayofacxovrebo an garemo pirobebidan maTiadamianis sxeulze an tansacmelze darCena. daskvnaSi mi-TiTebuli denTis wvis produqtis _ NO2-is arseboba datyviis kafsulis SemadgenlobaSi Semavali komponentebis_ stibiumisa da bariumis arseboba SesaZleblobas iZlevavivaraudoT, rom gasrola nawarmoebia.
10. mowme t. b-s Cvenebis Tanaxmad, a. b-s didi xania ic-nobs. 2013 wlis 5 noembers, Ramis pirvelidan oris naxev-ramde, T. C-m, a. b-s dedis m. a-s meuRlem, daureka da sTxo-va gagarinis quCaze mdebare policiaSi gaevlo, radgan a.
137
b-e hyavdaT dakavebuli, savaraudod, a. k-s daWris gamo.gamomZieblis oTaxSi dainaxa a. b-s deidaSvilebi, maTi me-uRleebi _ d. da m., aseve a. k-s da. maT uTxres momxdarisSesaxeb, kerZod is, rom s. m-s da a. k-s maRaziaSi Casvlisas,`arkaSi~ moxda gasrola da daiWra a.. aseve mividnen a. b-smeuRle i., megobari s. da advokati. daaxloebiT dilis 5saaTze policiis Senobidan gamovida s. m-i da danarCene-bi, man gverdiT gaiyvana s. m-i da hkiTxa, Tu ra SuaSi iyo a.b-e, razec s. m-ma uTxra, rom masac ukvirda, Tu ratom da-iWires a. b-e. manve uTxra, rom a. ar yofila, is mas suniTacicnobda. man dainaxa susti, saSualo tanis biWi, romelsackepi exura da garboda. meore dRes ojaxis wevrebi Sex-vdnen, ra drosac s. m-ma uTxra, rom mas policiaSi uTxres,TiTqos momxdari a. b-s gakeTebuli iyo, rasac Tavad a. b-cadasturebda da TviTon ratom ar adebda xels. mowmem gan-marta, rom a. k-s da a. b-s arasdros hqoniaT urTierTkon-fliqti.
11. dacvis mxaris mier warmodgenilma mowmeebma _ v. c-m, g. w-ma, l. c-m, e. c-m da T. C-m ganmartes, rom s. m-i gaogne-buli iyo, Tu ratom iRebda a. b-e Tavis Tavze momxdars.igi absoluturad gamoricxavda a. b-s SemTxvevis adgilzeyofnas. mowmeebma gamoricxes a. b-sa da a. k.s Soris raimeiseTi konfliqtis arseboba, rac braldebuls Caadenineb-da momxdars.
12. dacvis mxaris mier warmodgenil, mowme n. k-s Cvene-bis Tanaxmad, a. b-e aris misi mejvare da bavSvis naTlia.rogorc misTvis cnobilia, a. b-e dakavebulia a. k-s daWrisgamo. 2013 wlis 5 noembers mivida megobarTan sabavSvo baR-Si, sadac daxvdnen g. r-e da a. b-e, es ukanaskneli araadek-vaturad iqceoda, iyo cota `acancarebuli~. a-m uTxra,rom marixuana hqonda moweuli da `dabolili~ iyo. aRniS-nulis Semdeg isini iyvnen g. r-s ojaxSi, saidanac gadaw-yvites n. k-s saxlSi wasvla. gareT gasvlisas a. b-m sabavSvobaRidan wamoRebuli maSxala daanTo. saxlSi misvlidan da-axloebiT 15-20 wuTSi a. b-s telefonze daurekes, am uka-nasknelma wasvla gadawyvita, radgan megobrisaTvis Rvi-no unda mieca. n. k-m taqsi gamoiZaxa, ra drosac operatorsmimarTulebad saburTalo miuTiTa, rogorc es a. b-m uT-xra. aRniSnulis Semdeg n. k-saTvis cnobili gaxda, rom a. b-e daiWires a. k-s daWris gamo. mowmem daadastura, rom po-liciidan gamosulma s. m-ma Tqva, rom ra SuaSi iyo a. b-e, ar
138
icoda. s-m aseve ganmarta, rom a. b-e iq ar iyo, radgan romyofiliyo, is icnobda. mowmem ganmarta, rom is sabavSvobaRSi saRamos cxris naxevrisTvis mivida da aRelveba a. b-saTvis ar SeumCnevia.
13. a. b-s sabavSvo baRSi misvlisa da `bengaliuri~ SuS-xunebis danTebis faqti daadastura sasamarTlo sxdoma-ze mowme g. r-mac.
14. mowme j. C-s mier sasamarTlo sxdomaze micemuliCvenebis Tanaxmad, man megobar g. m-s TxovniT monawileo-ba miiRo eqsperimentSi, daiWira e.w. SuSxuna, romlis daw-vis Semdegac misi qurTukidan aiRes nimuSi da Caatareseqsperimenti, rasac videokameriT iRebdnen. mowmem daa-dastura, rom saadvokato biuroSi SemTxveviT moisminavinme T-s naTqvami, romelsac `—~ eZaxdnen, rom gamoZiebasra Cvenebac misca, is iyo araswori. moyva, rom is da a. b-e immomentSi erTad iyvnen da mas ar usvria. a-m ki sTxova xelimisTvis daedo, radgan vinme d-sTvis sTxovdnen xelis da-debas.
15. mowme z. o-s Cvenebis Tanaxmad, is aris damoukide-beli sasamarTlo eqspertizis centr Sps `veqtoris~ eq-sperti. man daadastura mis mier 2014 wlis 14 ianvars gace-muli daskvna, romlis Tanaxmadac, saaxalwlo SuSxunebie.w. `bengaliuri sanTlebi~ daumwvar mdgomareobaSi Sei-cavs iseT qimiur elementebs, rogoricaa stibiumi da ba-riumi. misi moxmarebis Sedegad garemoSi gamoiyofa aRniS-nuli qimiuri elementebi. rac Seexeba NO2-is aRmoCenas _azotisa da Jangbadis naerTi Zalian msubuqi elementebisnaerTia, igi speqtrometis fanjaraSi ver xvdeba da, Sesa-bamisad, kvlevis mocemuli meTodiT NO2-is aRmoCena Se-uZlebelia. mowmem ganmarta, radgan SuSxunis anTebis Sem-deg adgili aqvs egzoTermul reaqcias da temperaturisadiabatur matebas, sayovelTaod cnobilia, rom bariumisda gogirdis Warbi raodenobisas warmoiqmneba da gamoi-yofa atmosferoSi NO2-is kompleqsuri naerTi. mowmem da-adastura, rom SuSxunis wvis Sedegad NO2, rom wamoiqmne-ba, faqtia, magram moxvdeboda Tu ara is xelze, amasTandakavSirebiT eqsperimenti ar Cautarebia.
16. braldebulma a. b-m ar cno Tavi damnaSaved saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 19,108-e muxliTa da 236-e muxlis 1-li, me-2nawilebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulebis CadenaSi daganmarta, rom 2013 wlis 5 noembers daakaves da brali wau-
139
yenes a. k-s daWris gamo, rasTan dakavSirebiTac man miscaaraswori Cveneba, radganac imyofeboda marixuanas zemoq-medebis qveS. realurad ki 2013 wlis 5 noembers d. s-sTanerTad doliZis quCaze imyofeboda daaxloebiT 5 saaTam-de, sadac agreTve iyo misi megobari l. a-e. Semdeg buda-peStis quCaze mivida d. T-sTan, romlisTvisac unda miecaRvino. d. T-m megobars gamoarTva avtomanqana da qalaqSimoZraobdnen. man uTxra d. T-s, rom hqonda marixuana, ra-zec T-m upasuxa, rom ar eweoda. d. T-m Seuxvia taSkentisquCaze da avtomanqana `arkaSi~ Seayena. a. b-m mowia marixu-ana, xolo 1-2 wuTSi srolis xma gaigo. radgan iyo `kaifSi~da adrec hqonda policiasTan problemebi, d. T-s uTxra,rom gasclodnen iqaurobas. d. T-m avtomanqana daZra, mag-ram gasasvleli ar aRmoCnda, ris gamoc fexiT gadavidnenvaJa-fSavelaze, Cavidnen pekinis quCaze da daSordnen er-TmaneTs. is taqsiT wavida g. r-sTan sabavSvo baRSi, sadacnaxa SuSxuna mwvane yuTSi, romelic ezoSi daanTo. Semdegwavidnen n. k-sTan savaxSmod, ra drosac daureka d. T-m dasTxova budapeStis quCaze misvla. maT avtomanqana undawamoeyvanaT da aseve a. b-s Rvino unda mieca. is daukavSir-da ojaxis axlobel s. m-s, romelsac Rvino hqonda, daax-loebiT TerTmetis naxevari iqneboda. Semdeg karze iyokakuni da policiam daakava, maSin ifiqra, rom marixuanasmowevis gamo akavebdnen. policiaSi sTxovdnen eTqva, romT. d-m daWra a. k-e, rac absurdi iyo, ris gamoc Tqva, romman Tavad Caidina aRniSnuli qmedeba, rac aseve tyuilia.
17. sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamoqveynebuli, mowme d. T-sCvenebis Tanaxmad, 2013 wlis 4 noembers Camovida stum-rad TbilisSi colis ZmasTan _ g. b-sTan. 2013 wlis 5 noem-bers daukavSirda mobiluri telefonis saSualebiT me-gobar a. b-s da sTxova Sexvedra budapeStis quCaze, daax-loebiT 1930 saaTze a. b-e da is seirnobdnen budapeStisquCaze, ra drosac saubrobdnen sxvadasxva sakiTxze; sa-ubrisas aseve Seexnen a. b-s naTesavebis _ q. z-sa da a. k-surTierTobas. aRniSnulis Semdeg daureka megobar T. b-s,romelsac sTxova avtomanqana BMW-545. is a. b-sTan er-Tad moZraobda saburTalos teritoriaze, ra drosac a. b-m uTxra, rom viRac hyavda sanaxavi, rogorc SemdgomSi Se-ityo _ a. k-e. taSkentis quCidan Sevidnen da gaCerdnenvaJa-fSavelas gamziris #...-is ezoSi. daaxloebiT 20:40 sa-aTze avtomanqanasTan Caiara a. k-m Tanmxleb qalbatonTan
140
erTad, ra drosac avtomanqanidan swrafad gadavida a. b-eda gaagrZela moZraoba maTi mimarTulebiT. ramdenime wamSigaigona sami-oTxi gasrolis xma, gasrolis xmebi ar iyomkveTri da Seeqmna STabeWdileba, rom gasrola moxda xmisCamxSobis gamoyenebiT. gasrolidan ramdenime wamSi swra-fad mivida a. b-e, romelic iyo SeSinebuli da dabneuli. isiZaxda, rom mokla a. k-e, ris Semdegac man swrafad daZraavtomanqana da daapira ezodan gasvla, magram ara im gziT,saidanac Sevida, radganac `arkis~ qveS moxda gasrolisada daWris faqti. vinaidan gasasvleli versad ipova, gaaCe-ra avtomanqana, swrafad gadmovida da sirbiliT gadakve-Ta vaJa-fSavelas gamziri, Soriaxlos morboda aseve a. b-c. d. T-m al. yazbegis gamzirze gaaCera taqsi da mivida bu-dapeStis quCaze, colis Zmis binaSi, sadac maleve mividaa. b-e. mas momxdari ar Seutyobinebia samarTaldamcavi or-ganoebisTvis. daaxloebiT 2300 saaTze binaSi gamocxaddnenpoliciis muSakebi, romlebmac binaSive daakaves danaSau-lis Seutyobineblobis gamo. policiis muSakebma bralde-bulis saxiT daakaves agreTve a. b-c.
18. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom sasamarTlo sxdoma-ze gamokvleuli zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebidan er-TaderTi, romelic uSualod miuTiTebs a. b-s mier a. k-smkvlelobis mcdelobisa da iaraRis ukanono SeZena-tare-bis faqts, aris mowme d. T-s Cveneba, romelic gamoqveyndasasamarTlo sxdomaze mowmis gamoucxadeblobis gamo.
19. d. T-s Cvenebis gamoqveynebasaTan dakavSirebiT sa-kasacio palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris mosazrebas, romd. T-s mier gamoZiebaSi micemuli informaciis mowmis Cve-nebad aRqma da misi sasamarTlo sxdomaze wakiTxva sapro-ceso kanonis uxeSi darRvevaa da miuTiTebs, rom pirveliinstanciis sasamarTlos mier aRniSnuli Cvenebis mowmisCvenebad CaTvla da misi gamoqveyneba Seesabameba saqar-Tvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeqsis 332-e da243-e muxlis moTxovnebs.
20. amasTan, sakasacio palata iziarebs dacvis mxarisargumentacias imis Taobaze, rom mxolod d. T-s Cvenebaver daedeba safuZvlad gamamtyunebel ganaCens SemdeggaremoebaTa gamo:
21. pirvel yovlisa, sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom d.T-s Cveneba im nawilSi, rom a. b-m daWra a. k-e, Tavisi samar-Tlebrivi bunebiT aris mowmis iribi Cveneba (rac arc mxa-
141
reebs gauxdiaT sadavod), vinaidan efuZneba sxva piris _am SemTxvevaSi a. b-s mier gavrcelebul informacias, xo-lo am ukanasknelma ki uaryo mis mier aRniSnuli informa-ciis T-sTvis miwodeba.
22. saqarTvelos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos 2015wlis 22 ianvris gadawyvetilebis Tanaxmad, mowmis iribiCveneba ver akmayofilebs utyuarobis konstituciur-sa-marTlebriv standarts, ris gamoc sakasacio palatas, imisgaTvaliswinebiT, rom d. T-s iribi Cvenebis garda sxva arcerTi pirdapiri mtkicebuleba ar adasturebs a. b-s mier a.k-s daWris faqts, miaCnia, rom igi ver gaxdeba b-s msjav-rdebis safuZveli.
23. garda amisa, sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom saqar-Tvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kanonmdebloba da-fuZnebulia mxareTa Tanasworobisa da SejibrebiTobisprincipebze, rac vlindeba mxareTa mier mopovebul mtki-cebulebaTa gamokvlevis wesSic, rac gulisxmobs imas, rommxareebs Tanabari SesaZlebloba unda mieceT, waradginonda gamoikvlion mtkicebulebebi.
24. mxareTa Tanasworobisa da SejibrebiTobis princi-pi ganmtkicebulia aseve saerTaSoriso xelSekrulebebi-Ta da SeTanxmebebiT, kerZod: samoqalaqo da politikuriuflebebis Sesaxeb saerTaSoriso paqti da adamianis uf-lebaTa evropuli konvencia uzrunvelyofen, rom yovelpirs, visac bralad edeba sisxlis samarTlis danaSaulisCadena, ufleba aqvs `TviTon dakiTxos an daakiTxvinosmisi braldebis mowmeebi da gamoaZaxebinos da daakiTxvi-nos misi dacvis mowmeebi braldebis mowmeebis Tanabar pi-robebSi~.
25. mowmeTa jvaredini dakiTxvis ufleba unda iqnes ga-gebuli SejibrebiTobis procesis WrilSi, rac samarTlia-ni sasamarTlos koncefciaSi devs da igi gulisxmobs, rommosarCeles mieces mowmis gancxadebis an Cvenebis nebis-mier aspeqtSi Sedavebis SesaZlebloba dapirispirebis andakiTxvis dros. am konteqstSi mniSvnelovania aseve ze-pirobis principi, romelic gulisxmobs sasamarTlos uSu-alo kontaqts pirebTan, romlebic Cvenebas iZlevian pro-cesze, kerZod, braldebuli unda daupirispirdes mowmesmosamarTlis TandaswrebiT, romelic iRebs saboloo ga-dawyvetilebas saqmeze, raTa SesaZlebeli gaxdes mowmisqcevis manerasa da sandoobaze yuradRebiT dakvirveba.
142
26. zemoaRniSnuli principis mniSvneloba adamianis uf-lebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos araerT gadawyvetileba-Sia xazgasmuli. Tumca, amave dros adamianis uflebaTa ev-ropuli sasamarTlo adgens, rom am principidan gamonak-lisi dasaSvebia, magram aman ar unda Selaxos dacvis mxa-ris uflebebi. msjavrdeba, romelic efuZneba mxolod anmetwilad im dauswrebeli mowmis Cvenebas, visi gamokiT-xvis SesaZleblobac ar hqonda gansasjels arc gamoZiebismimdinareobisas da arc sasamarTlo procesze, rogorc we-si, CaiTvleba me-6 muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli samarTlia-nobis moTxovnasTan (`erTaderTobis an metwilobis wesi~)Seusabamod. Tumca es ar aris absoluturi wesi, romelicmouqnelobiT xasiaTdeba da ar iTvaliswinebs konkretu-li samarTlebrivi sistemis gansakuTrebulobas. Sesaba-misad, maSinac ki, rodesac dauswrebeli mowmis CvenebaaerTaderTi an metwili mtkicebuleba gansasjelis wina-aRmdeg, mtkicebulebad misi miReba avtomaturad ar iw-vevs 6.1 muxlis darRvevas. amavdroulad, im SemTxveveb-Si, rodesac msjavrdeba mxolod an metwilad efuZneba e.w.`dauswrebeli mowmis~ Cvenebas, sasamarTlom saqmiswarmo-eba unda ganixilos gansakuTrebuli yuradRebiT. aseTimtkicebulebis daSvebis safrTxidan gamomdinare, gansa-kuTrebiT mniSvnelovani faqtori iqneba misi dabalanse-ba da swored es moiTxovs sakmarisad gamawonasworebelfaqtorebs, maT Soris Zlier procedurul garantiebs. Ti-Toeul aseT saqmeSi mniSvnelovania gamawonasworebelifaqtorebis arseboba, maT Soris iseTi zomebisa, romle-bic SesaZlebels xdis am mtkicebulebis sarwmunoobis sa-marTlian da saTanado Sefasebas. msjavrdeba SeiZleba da-fuZnebuli iyos amgvar mtkicebulebaze (gamoqveynebulCvenebaze) mxolod im SemTxvevaSi, Tu is sakmarisad san-doa.
27. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare saqmeze, Al-Khawaja daTahery gaerTianebuli samefos winaaRmdeg, adamianis uf-lebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos didma palatam, imis gaT-valiswinebiT, rom meore ganmcxadebeli (batoni taheri)moklebuli iyo SesaZleblobas, Seemowmebina T-s Cvenebisnamdviloba da sandooba jvaredini dakiTxviT da vinai-dan T. erTaderTi mowme iyo, romelmac moisurva da SeZ-lo eTqva, Tu ra naxa, ganmcxadebels ar SeeZlo moewviasxva mowme, romelic daupirispirdeboda am Cvenebas, ris
28. gansaxilvel SemTxvevaSi, sakasacio palata miuTi-Tebs, rom d. T-s Cveneba arsebiTia saqarTvelos ssk 19,108-e muxliTa da 236-e muxlis 1-li da me-2 nawilebiT gaTva-liswinebul braldebasTan dakavSirebiT a. b-s msjavrde-bis sakiTxis gadasawyvetad da gasaCivrebuli ganaCenicmetwilad swored maszea dafuZnebuli, xolo dacvis mxa-res arc gamoZiebis etapze da arc saqmis arsebiTi ganxil-vis dros ar hqonia misi dakiTxvis/gamokiTxvis da Cvene-bebis gaprotestebis adekvaturi da jerovani SesaZleb-loba, maSin, roca dacvis mxaris mier dasmul SekiTxvebsSeeZlo ara mxolod mowmeTa sandoobis Sefasebaze moex-dina gavlena, aramed naTeli moefina iseTi garemoebebis-Tvis, romlebic relevanturi iqneboda wardgenil bral-debasTan dakavSirebiT sasamarTlos mier saboloo gadaw-yvetilebis misaRebad, miT umetes im pirobebSi, roca d.T-s Cveneba garkveul epizodebSi ewinaaRmdegeba sxvamtkicebulebebs. magaliTisTvis palata miuTiTebs, romT-s CvenebaSi aRniSulia, rom man gaaCera manqana taSken-tis quCaze da rodesac masTan a. b-e mivida da uTxra, romesrola k-s, daZra avtomanqana; maSin, rodesac s. m-ma Cve-nebaSi miuTiTa, rom silueti daZruli avtomanqaniskengarboda. aseve d. T-e CvenebaSi miuTiTebs, rom is martomivida g. b-sTan, xolo g. b-e imaves ar miuTiTebs CvenebaSi.palata yuradRebas amaxvilebs aseve 2013 wlis 7 noembrisqimiuri eqspertizis #-_ daskvnaze, romlis mixedviTac,eqspertizaze gamosakvlevad warmodgenil a. b-s tansac-melze raime saxis metalis (rkinis, spilenZis da tyviis)kvali ar aRmoCnda. aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT palatasmiaCnia, rom a. b-s xelSi unda sWeroda iaraRi, rac Tavismxriv unda SeemCnia T-s, xolo es ukanaskneli Tavis Cvene-baSi ar miuTiTebs aRniSnulis Taobaze.
29. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs saapelacio sasamar-Tlos motivacias imis Taobaze, rom garda d. T-s Cvenebi-sa, a. b-s braleuloba dadasturebulia sxva pirdapirimtkicebulebebis erTobliobiT, kerZod:
30. saapelacio sasamarTlo aRniSnavs: d. T-s Cvenebisis nawili, rom a. b-e 2013 wlis 5 noembers taSkentis q. #...-is mimdebare teritoriaze a. k-s sanaxavad iyo misuli, das-
144
turdeba mowmeebis: s. m-s, n. m-sa da g. s-s CvenebebiT, ro-melTa mixedviTac, a. k-e yovel samSabaTs nemsis gasake-Teblad Camodioda TbilisSi da rCeboda aRniSnul misa-marTze. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom xsenebuli mow-meebi mxolod im faqts adastureben, rom a. k-e samSabaTo-biT imyofeboda xolme aRniSnul teritoriaze, rac arcpirdapir da arc iribad ar adasturebs im faqts, rom a. b-e5 noembers iq k-s sanaxavad mivida.
31. saapelacio sasamarTlos miTiTeba, rom s. m-sa da a.k-s CvenebebSi aRniSnuli faqti, rom maT uknidan esrod-nen da d. T-s Cveneba, rom a. b-e a. k-s da masTan erTad myofqalabatons ukan gahyva, aseve mxolod varaudia, rom swo-red b-m esrola k-s.
32. dausabuTebelia agreTve gasaCivrebuli ganaCenisdaskvna, rom d. T-s CvenebaSi aRniSnuli garemoeba, romgasrolidan ramdenime wamSi avtomanqanasTan swrafad mi-vida a. b-e, aseve dasturdeba s. m-s CvenebiT, rom man dai-naxa daZruli avtomanqana da silueti, romelic misken gar-boda, radganac s. m-ma Tavis CvenebaSi aRniSna, rom man da-inaxa silueti, romelic manqanisken garboda, magram Caj-da Tu ara is manqanaSi, ar daunaxavs da, ubralod, iseTiSTabeWdileba darCa, rom silueti manqanisken garboda,rac sakasacio palatis azriT, ar SeiZleba iqnes imis ut-yuari mtkicebuleba, rom silueti manqanaSi Cajda da miTumetes, rom is silueti a. b-s iyo.
33. rac Seexeba a. b-s xelze aRmoCenil denTis kvals,sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom, marTalia, ar iziarebsdacvis mxaris versias a. b-s sabavSvo baRSi yofnisa da iq`bengaliuri SuSxunebis~ anTebis Taobaze, iseve rogorcar iziarebs dacvis mxaris miTiTebas, rom videomasalazenaTlad Cans a. b-s sabavSvo baRSi Sesvlis faqti, vinaidanpalatisTvis habitoskopiuri eqspertizis daskvnis gare-Se SeuZlebelia masalaze aRbeWdili piris amocnoba, miTumetes sruliad gaugebaria, Tu aseTi aSkaraa, rom swo-red b-a videoze aRbeWdili, ram SeuSala xeli dacvis mxa-res, warmoedgina habitoskopiuri eqspertizis daskvna,raTa metad gaemyarebina sakuTari pozicia, magram yurad-Rebas miaqcevs im garemoebas, rom eqspert o-s CvenebiTdadgenilia, rom `bengaliuri sanTlebis~ wvis Sedegadacgamoiyofa NO2, stibiumi da bariumi; Sesabamisad, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia: is faqti, rom b-s xelze aRmoCnda ze-
145
moaRniSnuli nivTierebebis kvali, utyuarad ar adastu-rebs misi mxridan k-s daWris faqts, vinaidan SesaZlebe-lia, b-s sxva iaraRidan gaesrola sxva viTarebaSi, an sxvaproduqtis wvis Sedegad darCenoda es kvali. metic, bral-debis mxaris mowmis, eqspert l. y-s ganmartebiT, imis gaT-valiswinebiT, rom a. b-s qurTukis gulispirsa da orivesaxeloze dafiqsirda denTis Semadgeneli erT-erTi kom-ponentis funqcionaluri jgufis NO2 _ is arseboba, xolotyviis kafsulaSi Semavali komponentebis _ stibiumisa dabariumis arseboba dafiqsirda misive qurTukis marjvenasaxelosa da marjvena xelidan aRebul anawmendze, Seg-viZlia vivaraudoT, rom pirma gaisrola. Sesabamisad, pa-lata verc aRniSnuli eqspertizis daskvnis safuZvelzemiiCnevs dadasturebulad b-s braleulobas sayovelTa-od aRiarebuli principis in dubio pro reo (yvela eWvis bral-debulis sasargeblod gadawyvetis) gaTvaliswinebiT, ro-melic aseve ganmtkicebulia saqarTvelos sisxlis samar-Tlis kodeqsis me-5 muxlis me-3 nawilSi, romlis mixedvi-Tac, mtkicebulebis Sefasebis dros warmoSobili eWvi, ro-melic ar dadasturdeba kanoniT dadgenili wesiT, undagadawydes braldebulis (msjavrdebulis) sasargeblod.
34. yovelive zemoaRniSnulisa da saqmeSi arsebuli Sem-degi mtkicebulebebis gaTvaliswinebiT _ 2013 wlis 7 no-embris odorologiuri eqspertizis #... daskvniT, romlismixedviTac, SemTxvevis adgilze napovni TeTri feris sa-medicino xelTaTmanebidan amoRebuli sunis kvalis nimu-Sebi vargisia pirovnebis identifikaciisTvis, Tumca ara-identuria braldebulebis: a. b-sa da d. T-s tansacmlidanda maTgan aRebuli sunis kvalis nimuSebisa; 2013 wlis 7noembris daqtiloskopiuri eqspertizis #... daskvniT,romlis mixedviTac, saqmeze warmodgenil erT cal pis-toletze, erT cal mWidsa da xelTaTmanis fragmentebzexelis kvlebi ar aRmoCnda, xolo SemTxvevis adgilidanamoRebuli kvlebi araidenturia a. b-sa da d. T-s xeli kva-lis nimuSebisa; 2013 wlis 11 noembris qimiuri eqsperti-zis #.... daskvniT, romlis mixedviTac, a. b-sa da a. k-s tan-sacmelze urTierTgadamavali boWkos mikronawilakebi araRmoCnda; a. b-s marjvena xelis frCxilebSi a. k-s tansac-mlis qsovilis SemadgenlobaSi Semavali boWkos mikrona-wilakebi ar aRmoCnda; faruli audioCaweris krebsebiT,romlis mixedviTac a. k-e eubneba sasuliero pirs, rom f-
146
ebma `Seusrules~, xolo mis kiTxvaze, Tu vin esrola daiyo Tu ara is `k-s~ (q. z-e) qmari, a. k-e pasuxobs, rom amsaqmeSi 40000 aSS dolari iyo gadaxdili da maT isroles,f-ebs da k-s qmarsac undoda amis gakeTeba, msrolelTandakavSirebiT ki pasuxobs, rom a. b-ze amboben `ZaRlebi~,risic mas ar sjera. k-m aseve uTxra mas, rom k-s qmari daWe-rilia; aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiT man sasuliero pirs ga-numarta, rom wina dReebSi T. d-e gadavida TurqeTSi, Sem-deg gadmoipara, aseT dros keTdeba saqme, aRniSnuliTalibi gaikeTa _ pasportis monacemebiT imyofeboda Tur-qeTSi _ sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saapelacio sasa-marTlos daskvna a. b-s braleulobis Sesaxeb (saqarTve-los ssk-is 19,108-e muxli, 236-e muxlis 1-li da me-2 nawi-lebi) agebulia eWvebsa da varaudebze, rac saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis sproceso kodeqsis me-13 muxlis me-2nawilis, 259-e muxlis me-3 nawilisa da 273-e muxlis 1-linawilis Sesabamisad, safuZvlad ver daedeba gamamtyune-bel ganaCens.
35. rac Seexeba a. b-s msjavrdebas saqarTvelos ssk-is273-e muxliT, palata iziarebs dacvis mxaris pozicias, romsaapelacio sasamarTlom ar daicva sauaresod SebrunebisdauSveblobis wesi, kerZod: Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamar-Tlos 2014 wlis 25 ivnisis ganaCeniT a. b-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 273-e muxliT ganesazRvra pirobiTi sasjeli, xolo sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 19,108-e muxliTa da 236-e muxlis 1-li dame-2 nawilebiT wardgenil braldebaSi gamarTlda. bralde-bis mxarem aRniSnuli ganaCeni gaasaCivra mxolod gamamar-Tlebel nawilSi, ris gamoc saapelacio sasamarTlo, saqar-Tvelos sssk-is 298-e muxlis me-4 nawilis moTxovnebidangamomdinare, ar iyo uflebamosili, am nawilSi gaeuarese-bina a. b-s samarTlebrivi mdgomareoba (miuxedavad imisa,rom mocemul konkretul SemTxvevaSi a. b-sTvis saqarTve-los ssk-is 273-e muxliT gansazRvruli sasjeli STanTqmu-lia) _ kerZod, ar unda Seecvala pirobiTi sasjeli sasje-laRsrulebis dawesebulebaSi mosaxdeli sasjeliT (e.w.`realuri~ sasjeliT), vinaidan braldebis mxares saapela-cio saCivari am moTxovniT ar Seutania.
genili Suamdgomloba da miaCnia, rom quTaisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2015wlis 3 aprilis ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba, saxel-mwifo bralmdeblis Suamdgomloba unda dakmayofildesda damtkicdes saproceso SeTanxmeba prokuror i. t-asada msjavrdebul v. s-as Soris Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
157
2. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze prokurorma i. t-am mxa-ri dauWira Tavis Suamdgomlobas dazustebuli pirobe-biT da iTxova msjavrdebul v. s-as damnaSaved cnoba sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 236-e muxlis 1-li, me-3 nawilebiT gaT-valiswinebul danaSaulTa CadenaSi.
3. sasamarTlo sxdomaze saproceso SeTanxmebis damtki-cebas mxari dauWires procesSi monawile msjavrdebulmav. s-am da misma interesebis damcvelma, advokatma a. g-ma.
4. sasamarTlom saqmis masalebis safuZvelze kanonismoTxovnaTa dacviT ganixila Suamdgomlobis dasabuTe-buloba da aRniSnavs, rom saqmeze warmodgenil mtkice-bulebaTa erTobliobiT _ msjavrdebulis aRiarebiTi Cve-nebiT, a/manqanis Cxrekis oqmiT, mowmeebis _ n. W-as, c. z-as,g. q-as, v. T-asa da sxvaTa CvenebebiT, saeqsperto krimina-listikuri eqspertizis daskvniTa da saqmis sxva masale-biT v. s-as mimarT bralad Seracxuli marTlsawinaaRmde-go qmedebebis Cadena dadasturebulia.
5. sakasacio palata darwmunda, rom saproceso SeTan-xmebis dadebisas msjavrdebul v. s-as mimarT ar ganxor-cielebula Zaladoba, daSineba, motyueba, muqara an raimeukanono dapireba; amasTan, mas ar SezRudvia ufleba, mie-Ro iuridiuli daxmareba. palatis sxdomaze gamokvleuliqna, rom msjavrdebuli srulad acnobierebs saprocesoSeTanxmebasTan dakavSirebul, kanoniT gaTvaliswinebulyvela moTxovnas, aRiarebs brals da eTanxmeba prokurorssasjelis zomaze. msjavrdebuli v. s-a aseve acnobierebs,rom sasamarTlo uflebamosilia, ar miiRos mxedvelobaSiSeTanxmebis safuZvelze prokuroris mier warmodgeniliSuamdgomloba.
6. msjavrdebulisaTvis aseve cnobilia saqarTvelossssk-is 212-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `i~ qvepunqtiT gansaz-Rvruli misi uflebebi; misTvis aseve cnobilia, rom sap-roceso SeTanxmeba mas ar aTavisuflebs samoqalaqo pasu-xismgeblobisagan.
7. sakasacio palata aseve aRniSnavs, rom moTxovnilisasjeli kanonieri da samarTliania, ris gamoc arsebobssssk-is 213-e muxlis me-3 da me-4 nawilebiT gansazRvru-li, Suamdgomlobebis dakmayofilebis samarTlebrivi dafaqtobrivi safuZvlebi.
8. amdenad, zugdidis raionuli prokuraturis staJi-or-prokuror i. t-as Suamdgomloba msjavrdebul v. s-as
158
mimarT saproceso SeTanxmebis damtkicebis Taobaze sa-fuZvliania da unda dakmayofildes.
5. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCeni sakasacio wesiT ga-asaCivres dazaralebulis uflebamonacvlem _ i. g-ma damisma warmomadgenelma _ g. s-am. maT iTxoves saapelaciosasamarTlos gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gauqmeba da T. k-as mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gamotana, aseve saa-pelacio sasamarTlos mier Suamdgomlobis dakmayofile-baze uaris Tqmis Sesaxeb miRebuli yvela araSemajamebe-li gadawyvetilebis gauqmeba, Semdegi samarTlebrivi sa-fuZvlebiT: Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlom dausabu-Teblad uaryo dacvis mxaris pozicia T. k-as udanaSaulo-
165
bis Sesaxeb da usafuZvlod gaiziara konfliqtSi monawi-le mxaris warmomadgenlebis _ d. C-as, l. C-as, z. t-isa da b.l-as Cvenebebi; ar aris dadgenili dasabuTebuli ganaCe-nis gamosatanad saWiro yvela faqtobrivi garemoeba; ga-moZiebis dros ar daukiTxavT an arasrulad dakiTxes ismowmeebi, romelTa Cvenebebsac arsebiTi mniSvnelobahqonda WeSmaritebis dadgenisaTvis; ar Catarebula anarasrulad Catarda eqspertizebi da sxva saproceso moq-medebebi; T. k-as damnaSaved cnobis Taobaze sasamarTlosdaskvna ar gamomdinareobs saqmeze Sekrebil mtkicebu-lebaTa erTobliobidan; sasamarTlom usafuZvlod ar ga-iziara saqmeze dacvis mxaris mier wardgenili eqsperti-zis daskvnebi, romlebic arsebiTad cvlidnen pirveli in-stanciis sasamarTlos mier saqmeze dadgenil faqtobrivgaremoebebs; sasamarTlo sxdomebi warimarTa dazarale-bulis uflebamonacvlisa da misi warmomadgenlis monawi-leobis gareSe, riTac uxeSad SeizRuda maTi uflebebi da-eyenebinaT Suamdgomlobebi mtkicebulebebis gamoTxovis,mowmeTa dakiTxvisa da sxva mniSvnelovan sakiTxebze; maTdausabuTeblad eTqvaT uari saapelacio sasamarTloSidayenebuli Suamdgomlobebis dakmayofilebaze; eqsper-tizis daniSvnis Taobaze dazaralebulis uflebamonac-vles ecnoba dagvianebiT, riTac arsebiTad dairRva sap-roceso kodeqsis moTxovnebi; sasamarTlom arasworad, uk-ritikod gaiziara z. t-isa da l. C-as urTierTsawinaaRmde-go Cvenebebi, romlebic iyvnen konfliqtis monawile pi-rebi da iyvnen dainteresebulni, maT ar dabralebodaTmomxdari mkvleloba, rac maTi Cvenebebis sarwmunoobisdabal xarisxze miuTiTebs; gamoZieba warimarTa arasru-lad da calmxrivad; braldebis mxarem sasamarTlo sxdo-maze iSuamdgomla mowmed dasakiTx pirTa siidan o. c-ismoxsnis Taobaze, romlis Cveneba arsebiTad ewinaaRmde-geboda braldebis mxaris mier dadgenil gayalbebul faq-tobriv garemoebebs da misi dakiTxva ar Sedioda proku-roris interesebSi; sasamarTlom saTanadod ar Seafasamowme m. g-as Cveneba sxva mtkicebulebebTan mimarTebiT;ar dakiTxula sasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis avto-ri, raTa pasuxi gascemoda kiTxvas, ra igulisxmeboda das-kvnaSi miTiTebuli cecxlsasroli Wrilobis miyenebis ara-axlo manZilSi; ar Catarebul eqspertiza imis dasadgenad,Tu ra manZilidan hqonda miyenebuli s. g-s cecxlnasroli
166
dazianeba marcxena barZayis midamoSi; sasamarTlo-same-dicino eqspertizis daskvniT l. C-as mimarT srolis man-Zilis gansazRvra, wardgenili dokumentebis Tanaxmad, Se-uZlebelia, xolo z. t-is mimarT gacemul daskvnaSi saer-Tod ar aris gacemuli pasuxi kiTxvaze, Tu ra manZilidanaqvs mas miyenebuli dazianeba. miuxedavad amisa, aravis mo-uTxovia ganmarteba am sakiTxebze eqspertebisagan da arcdamatebiTi eqspertiza daniSnula; s. g-i da T. k-a iyvnenmegobrebi, erTad isxdnen barSi, romelTa Sorisac arana-iri konfliqti ar momxdara. konfliqti moxda, erTi mxriv_ z. t-s, l. da d. C-ebs, xolo, meore mxriv _ s. g-s Soris. ampirobebSi, ratom unda gasCenoda T. k-as megobris _ s. g-ismokvlis ganzraxva, gaurkvevelia, miTumetes, braldebismxare ver miuTiTebs danaSaulis motivsa da mizanze.
bamisad, sakasacio palatam Seamowma saqme sruli moculo-biT, gaaanaliza warmodgenili saCivris safuZvlianoba damivida im daskvnamde, rom igi unda dakmayofildes, xologasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda gauqmdes Semdeg garemoeba-Ta gamo:
2. saqmis masalebiT irkveva, rom T. k-as braldebis saq-meSi warmodgenili ar aris utyuari mtkicebulebebi, rom-lebic, misi sandoobisa da Sesaxebobis TvalsazrisiT, sak-marisia daskvnisaTvis, rom T. k-am Caidina saqarTvelosssk-is 109-e muxlis 1-li nawilis `g~, 19,109-e muxlis me-3nawilis `a~ qvepunqtebiT, ssk-is 236-e muxlis 1-li, me-2nawilebiTa da ssk-is 239-e muxlis me-3 nawiliT gaTvalis-winebuli danaSaulebi, kerZod:
3. saapelacio wesiT saqmis ganxilvisas dakiTxuli da-zaralebulis uflebamonacvlis _ i. g-is CvenebiT dadge-nilia, rom 2010 wlis 15 marts imyofeboda saxlSi. vinai-dan Caqra Suqi, daureka Svils s. g-s, romelic iyo kafeSisaxlidan daaxloebiT 100-150 metrSi da uTxra, rom sax-lSi dabrunebuliyo. rogorc ki telefoni gaTiSa, gaigonagasrolis xma. man instinqturad Cairbina kibeebze, ra dro-sac kidev gaigo srolis xma. igi wavida im mimarTulebiT,saidanac srolis xma ismoda. iyo sruli sibnele, mxolodW-is quCaze enTo `lampionebi~. W-isa da g-is quCebis kveTa-ze Sexvda T. k-a. i. g-is ganmartebiT, icoda, rom misi Svili
167
da T. k-a erTad iyvnen. T. k-am mas uTxra _ `mgoni, s-s esro-la viRacamo~. isini erTad wavidnen im `arkis~ mimarTule-biT, sadac ukve bevri xalxi iyo Sekrebili. misive Cvene-biT dadgenilia, rom amasobaSi mas wamoewia misi meuRle.SemTxvevis adgilze misulma icno Tavisi Svili, romelicCasves mezoblis avtomanqanaSi da saavadmyofoSi waiyva-nes. am dros k-ac saavadmyofoSi iyo. i. g-is ganmartebiT,eqimi, romelic s-os operacias ukeTebda da tyvia romel-mac amoiRo, mivida masTan da uTxra, rom an liliputis nas-rolia an maRalze idga TviTon s. g-o, aseve imdenad axlomanZilidan aris nasrolio, rom tyvia ar gavida da qsovi-lebSi darCao. misi ganmartebiT, C-ebis biZam erTi wlis Sem-deg viTom maTi iaraRebi Caabara, ris Semdegac maT sapro-ceso SeTanxmeba gauformdaT, mkvleloba ki k-as dabral-da.
4. dazaralebul z. t-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2010wlis 14 marts, saRamos, g-isa da W-is quCebis kuTxeSi, isSemTxveviT Sexvda s. g-s, romelTanac megobrobda. Sexved-risas man Tavze xeli gadausva s. g-s, rac am ukanasknelmaiukadrisa da xeli hkra. iqve myofma pirebma s. g-i gaakaves.man CaTvala, rom s. g-i nasvami iyo da wavida saxlSi. meoredRes, daaxloebiT 12 saaTze, daureka s. g-s, moikiTxa dauTxra, rom mis saxlTan idga da Casuliyo. man upasuxa, romTavs moiwesrigebda da mogvianebiT TviTon daurekavda.saRamos, rodesac igi imyofeboda Tavis meobrebTan _ Zmebl. da d. C-ebTan, aseve b. l-asTan erTad am ukanasknelisavtomanqanaSi, daureka s. g-ma, romelmac uTxra, rom im-yofeboda g-is quCaze kafesTan da misuliyo. amis Semdegb. l-as avtomanqaniT mividnen g-is quCaze mdebare kafe-bar `...-Tan~, kafes SesasvlelTan gaaCeres manqana. b. l-aavtomanqanaSi darCa, TviTon, l. da d. C-ebi ki manqanidangadavidnen da Sexvdnen s. g-s, romelsac Tan axlda T. k-a.is da g-i Sevidnen iqve kafes gverdiT mdebare arkaSi, sa-dac Seyvnen d. da l. C-ebi. masa da s. g-s Soris saubari wari-marTa wina dRes momxdar incidentTan dakavSirebiT, ker-Zod, man s. g-s uTxra, rom Tavze xeli megobrulad gadaus-va, razec man upasuxa, rom ar esiamovna. amis Semdeg kvlavgaumeora zemoT naTqvami, razec s. g-ma pasuxad cecxlsas-roli iaraRi amoiRo da miuSvira mas. d. C-a, romelic gver-diT edga s. g-s, xelSi swvda am ukanasknels da iaraRi daa-wevina qveviT, Semdeg TviTon da l. C-ac daeWidnen xelze
168
da Seecadnen, ar miecaT misTvis srolis saSualeba, mag-ram s. g-ma mainc moaxerxa ramdenime gasrola, rasac `ar-kis~ Sesasvlelis mxridan, pirovnebisgan, romlis garCevasibnelis gamo ver moaxerxa, mohyva cecxlsasroli iara-Ridan eqvsze meti gasrola. aRniSnuli gasrolis SedegaddaiWrnen TviTon, Zmebi C-ebi da s. g-i. Tavdacvis mizniTman da l. C-am ganaxorcieles sapasuxo srolebi `arkis~ mi-marTulebiT, ris Semdegac b. l-as avtomanqaniT datovesSemTxvevis adgili. mividnen y-is quCaze, n. C-as sacxovre-bel saxlSi, sadac gadamales cecxlsasroli iaraRebi dawavidnen #... klinikur saavadmyofoSi. z. t-ma aseve gan-marta, rom aRniSnuli _ sasamarTloSi micemuli Cvenebaaris swori, xolo gamoZiebisaTvis micemuli Cveneba _mcdari. gamoZiebis dros mcdari Cveneba imitom misca, romiaraRi ar iyo amoRebuli.
5. dazaralebul l. C-as CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2010wlis 15 marts, saRamos, z. t-Tan, d. C-asa da b. l-asTan er-Tad, am ukanasknelis avtomanqaniT mividnen g-is #...-Tan,kafe-bar `...-Tan~. Sexvdnen s. g-s da T. k-as. jer s. g-i naxes,Semdeg wamierad _ T. k-ac. z. t-i da s. g-i Sevidnen kafe-baris gverdiT mdebare `arkaSi~, sadac Seyvnen TviTon dad. C-a. saubari gaimarTa z. t-sa da s. g-s Soris wina dRiskonfliqtTan dakavSirebiT. am dros s. g-ma amoiRo cec-xlsasroli iaraRi. man iaraRis danaxvaze g-s miaZaxa, romar esrola. d. C-a s. g-s majaSi swvda da iaraRiani xeli qve-viT daawevina. TviTon da z. t-ic daeWidnen iaraRian xel-ze s. g-s. samive daxril mdgomareobaSi imyofeboda, ra dro-sac aRniSnuli iaraRidan moxda ori gasrola `arkis~ mi-marTulebiT. l. C-as ganmartebiT, is sTxovda s. g-s, romiaraRisTvis xeli gaeSva da Semdeg isev daubrunebda. ama-sobaSi ̀ arkis~ Semosasvlelidan viRacam daiwyo srola, da-axloebiT eqvsze meti gasrola iyo, daaxloebiT mexuTegasrolis dros daiWra. msroleli maT daaxloebiT or met-rSi miuaxlovda. im mizniT, rom Tavi daecva da Tavdam-sxmeli SeeSinebina, Tannaqoni pistoletidan quCis mimar-TulebiT 4-5-jer gaisrola. srolebis Semdeg dainaxa, roms. g-i Zirs iwva iaraRiT xelSi. mokida xeli g-is iaraRs dawaiRo, raTa dazRveuli yofiliyo, rom s. g-s isev ar gaes-rola. z. t-Tan da d. C-asTan erTad, romlebic aseve daW-rilebi iyvnen, Casxdnen avtomanqanaSi da wavidnen y-is qu-Caze, sadac gadamales iaraRebi. Semdeg gzidan Seatyobi-
169
nes ojaxis wevrebs, rom daWrilebi iyvnen da wavidnen sa-avadmyofoSi. misive ganmartebiT, manqana, romliTac isi-ni mividnen, `arkidan~ daSorebuli iyo daaxloebiT orimetriT. man simarTle am CvenebaSi Tqva.
6. z. t-ma da l. C-am CvenebebSi aseve miuTiTes, rom, mar-Talia, ver dainaxes sibnelis gamo vin esrola maT, magramgamoZiebisa da saqmis masalebidan gamomdinare, savarau-dod, es pirovneba unda yofiliyo T. k-a.
7. saqmis saapelacio wesiT ganxilvisas dazaralebuld. C-as mier micemuli CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom T. k-as ic-nobs, misi skolelia, xolo z. t-i misi megobaria. man gan-marta, rom wina dRes momxdari konfliqtis Sesaxeb ara-feri icoda. misma Zmam _ l. C-am da megobarma _ z. t-ma mia-kiTxes saxlSi b. l-as avtomaqaniT. midiodnen megobrebissanaxavad, TurqeTSi ragbis matCze dasaswrebad wasvlissakiTxis gasarkvevad. gzaSi z-as daurekes mobilurze. sa-ubris dasrulebisTanave z-am uTxra b. l-as Sesuliyo iq-ve, g-is quCaze mdebare kafesTan, `g-ra~ unda enaxa. kafes-Tan rom mividnen, z. da l. gadavidnen avtomanqanidan, Sem-deg TviTonac gadavida mis sanaxavad. b. l-a avtomanqani-dan ar gadasula. misalmebis Semdeg Sevidnen gverdiTmdebare `arkaSi~. mokiTxvis Semdeg s-os da z-as Soris da-iwyo saubari wina dRes momxdari Selaparakebis Sesaxeb.man saubridan gaigo, rom s-os z-sagan agdebuli misalmebada Tavze xelis gadasma ar esiamovna, z-as ki _ misi misal-meba. am dros misma Zmam Tqva daemTavrebinaT saubari _`Sinaurebi varT da ra gvaqvs salaparakoo~, rasac yveladaeTanxma. man erTi-ori nabiji gadadga, z-am da s-om gaag-rZeles saubari. igi s-os agresiul saubarze Semotrial-da. s-o ambobda, Seni bavSvi xom ara var Sublze xels rommisvamo, Semdeg s. g-ma amoiRo iaraRi da SublTan axlosmiutana. man xeli mokida iaraRze da cdilobda maT sawina-aRmdego mxares yofiliyo mimarTuli. s-o iZaxda vixum-reo, mas miexmarnen z. da l-i. is da s-o daecnen da jajgur-Si ori gasrola moxda s-os iaraRidan `arkis~ Semosasvle-lis mimarTulebiT. am dros is da s-o dawolil mdgomare-obaSi iyvnen. am ori gasrolidan ramdenime wamSi arkis Se-mosasvlelidan misTvis ucnobma pirovnebam ganaxorcie-la mravaljeradi gasrolebi maTi mimarTulebiT da gaiq-ca. misive CvenebiT, igi srolis dawyebisTanave daiWra damiiwia `arkis~ marjvena mxares. amasobaSi l-i da z-a srola-
170
sroliT gaiqcnen `arkis~ gasasvlelisken da gavidnen qu-CaSi. quCaSi gavida TviTonac. Casxdnen b. l-as avtomanqa-naSi, romelic ukve daZruli Sua quCaze iyo da wavidnen.avtomanqanaSi man dakarga goneba da saavadmyofoSi rommivida, gaukeTes operacia. amis Semdeg gaigo s. g-is gar-dacvalebis Sesaxeb. misive CvenebiT, is pirovneba, rome-lic esrodaT, dainaxa. mas ar icnobs, Tumca amocnoba Se-uZlia. manve aCvena, rom T. k-as icnobs da igi iq ar yofila.im dRes saerTod ar unaxavs. man aseve daadastura, romSemTxvevis dros wvimda, lampionebi gamorTuli iyo da ar-kaSi bneloda. misive ganmartebiT, srolis dros is da s-oZirs, erTmaneTis gverdiT iwvnen, s-os xelebi hqonda gaS-lili `arkis~ Semosasvlelis mimarTulebiT, mas ki mis ia-raRsa da s-os xelze ekida xeli, s-os orive xeli iaraRzehqonda, xolo iaraRi asfaltze iyo. igi koncentrirebu-li iyo iaraRze da vin saiT idga, ar axsovs, ras akeTebdnenl-i da z-a ar daunaxavs, albaT, mas exmarebodnen. d. C-asCvenebiT, srolis dawyebamde z-as da l-s iaraRebi ar amo-uRiaT. iaraRebis amoRebis faqti ar daunaxavs, magram ro-desac maT isroles, is msroleli, ukve gaqceuli iyo. Ta-vidan l-as avtomanqana `arkis~ SesasvlelTan gaaCeres. man-ve aseve ganmarta, rom masze samarTaldamcavi organos mu-Sakebis mxridan mimdinareobda zewola, mas ayenebdnen fi-zikur Seuracxyofas, awamebdnen da eubnebodnen, rom xe-li daedo T. k-asTvis, xolo Tu amas ar gaakeTebda, daiRu-peboda da mTel cxovrebas cixeSi gaatarebda, Tumca amfaqtTan dakavSirebiT gancxadebiT policiisTvis an pro-kuraturisTvis ar miumarTavs, radgan ar surda gaexmau-rebina.
8. mowme b. l-as CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2010 wlis 15oqtombers, saRamos, Tavisi avtomanqaniT z. t-i, Zmebi _l. da d. C-ebi miiyvana g-is quCis #... saxlTan, sadac avto-maqanidan s. g-Tan Sesaxvedrad gadavidnen z. t-i da ZmebiC-ebi. TviTon avtomanqanidan ar gadasula da aRniSnulisaxlis `arkidan~ daaxloebiT 15-20 metris moSorebiT av-tomaqanaSi ijda. ramdenime wuTSi gaigona cecxlsasroliiaraRidan ori gasrolis xma, rasac maleve mohyva ramde-nime gasrola. aRniSnuliT SeSinebulma avtomanqana daZ-ra, ra drosac mivardnen z. t-i da Zmebi C-ebi, uTxres, romdaWrilebi iyvnen. Casxdnen avtomanqanaSi da z. t-is Txov-niT mividnen y-is quCaze, sadac t-ma da C-am datoves cec-
171
xlsasroli iaraRebi. b. l-am aseve ganmarta, rom iaraRebihqondaT mxolod z. t-s da l. C-as. misTvis l. C-sgan cnobi-li gaxda, rom SemTxvevis adgilidan man aseve wamoiRo s.g-is iaraRi. b. l-am daadastura aseve is garemoeba, rom 2010wlis oqtombris TveSi, rodesac sasjelaRsrulebiTi da-wesebulebidan axdendnen misi, t-is da l. C-as badragire-bas, gaigona, rom l. C-am uTxra z. t-s, rom `arkaSi~ maTimimarTulebiT k-am gaisrola, rasac daeTanxma z. t-ic. b.l-am damatebiT ganmarta, rom `arkis~ win idga raRac jipi,xolo jipis gverdiT, cota win, misi manqana. pirveli _ origasrolis Semdeg aanTo Suqebi, viRac movida am dros, man-qanaSi Caixeda da wavida. es piri, misi varaudiT, mowmissaxiTac daikiTxa. quCaSi Cavlili aravin daunaxavs.
9. mowmeebis _ g. l-isa da e. c-is CvenebebiT dadgenilia,rom s. g-i iyo maTi megobari. 2015 wlis 15 marts, saRamos, s.g-sa da T. k-asTan erTad imyofebodnen g-is quCaze mdeba-re kafe-bar `...-Si~. kafeSi yofnis dros s. g-s telefonzedaurekes, ris Semdegac igi wamodga, Tqva, nacnobebi mo-vidnen da unda gavideo da gavida. s. g-is gasvlidan daax-loebiT 10 wamSi T. k-ac wamodga, Tqva, Cemi nacnobebic ari-ano da isic gavida. s-os da T-es gasvlisTanave, baris ga-reT, quCaSi atyda yvirili da gineba. yvirilis Semdeg gai-gones srolis xmebi. uceb barSi Semovarda T-e, romelsacxelSi pistoleti eWira. is Sokur mdgomareobaSi iyo dayviroda `gamiWedao~, man `gaaCxakuna~ pistoleti da male-ve gavarda gareT, rasac mohyva 6-7 gasrola. male Sewydasrolebi. barSi myofi xalxi SeSinebuli da dabneuli iyo.maTi CvenebebiT, isini srolebis damTavrebisTanave wavid-nen.
10. mowme S. n-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2010 wlis 15marts, saRamos, is, z. g-e da e. g-i wavidnen g-is quCaze mde-bare kafe-bar `...-Si~. barSi misvlamde gaiares `arka~, rom-lis SesasvlelTan dainaxa 3-4 biWi. barSi maTi Sesvlidannaxevar wuTSi, Sesasvlelidan pirdapir mdgari magididanerTi biWi gareT gavida, magram uceb Semobrunda ukan, radrosac xelSi ekava pistoleti. mowmis ganmartebiT, igicnobs `makarovis~ sistemis iaraRs da pistoleti, rome-lic biWs ekava, iyo `makarovis~ sistemis. man is aSkarad da-inaxa, rodesac Semosulma biWma sanTlis Suqze miitana,gadatena da Tqva _ `zadni momcao~, anu ar gavardao. mas-Tan erTad myofma orma biWma uTxra _ `ras Svrebi biWoo~.
172
amis Semdeg im biWma iaraRi moiyvana sabrZolo mdgomareo-baSi da gavida gareT, rasac momentalurad mohyva inten-siuri srolebi. srolebi warmoebda ramdenime pistole-tidan.
11. mowmeebis _ z. g-is da e. g-is CvenebebiT dadgenilia,rom 2010 wlis 15 marts, saRamos, isini S. n-Tan erTad, Se-vidnen g-is quCaze mdebare kafe-bar `...-Si~. barSi misvlam-de gaiares `arka~, sadac ramdenime biWi idga. cota xanSiSemoesmaT yvirilisa da ginebis xma. maTive ganmartebiT,aRniSnul xmaurze gareT gavida amave barSi sxva pirebTanerTad myofi biWi. is uceb Semobrunda ukan, ra drosacxelSi ekava pistoleti. biWi daZabuli iyo da ambobda, romiaraRma umtyuna. amis Semdeg man iaraRi moiyvana sabrZo-lo mdgomareobaSi da gavida gareT, rasac mohyva intensi-uri srolebi. srolebi warmoebda ramdenime pistoleti-dan. maT SeeSindaT da gaiqcnen samzareulosaken. mowme z.g-em aseve ganmarta, rom is biWi rogorc ki gavida, gaismasrolis xma, albaT, quCaSi gaisrola, radgan ase ucbad `ar-kaSi~ Sesvlas ver moaswrebda. incidenti daaxloebiT 10-12 wuTi gagrZelda. e. g-is CvenebiT aseve dadgenilia, romrodesac kafe-barisken midiodnen `arkasTan~ trotuari-dan gadavidnen gzis saval nawilze, radgan trotuarzecudad iyo gaCerebuli avtomanqana.
12. mowme m. k-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobda g-is quCis #...-Si mdebare kafe-bar `...-Si~ direqtorad. 2010wlis 15 marts, saRamos, kafe-barSi erT-erT magidasTan,romelic iyo Sesasvlelidan 3 metrSi, isxdnen s. g-i da T.k-a, romlis saxeli mere gaigo. maT SeuerTdaT ori pirov-neba, romlebic manamde mas ar unaxavs. mowmis ganmarte-biT, samzareulodan rodesac gamodioda, gaigona srolisxmebi da dainaxa iq myofebi samzareulosken mirbodnen.am dros mas iq s. da T. k-a ar daunaxavs, xolo maTTan erTadmyofi ori biWi iq iyo da yvelaferi rom Cawynarda, meregavidnen gareT. mowmis CvenebiT, quCidan Semosulma sro-lis xmam gamoiwvia kafe-baris stumrebis SeSineba da Sewu-xeba. misive CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom man fotosuraTiTamocnobis dros amoicno T. k-a, romelic kafe-bar `...-Si~Tavidan axlda s. g-s.
13. mowme e. w-is CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom SemTxvevisdros is imyofeboda g-is q. #...-Si da uvlida moxucebulqalbatons. oTaxis gasaniaveblad gamoaRo fanjara, ra
173
drosac wina korpusis `arkis~ qvemodan gaigona yvirilisxma `gauSvi xeli~, rac ramdenjerme ganmeorda. aRniSnulsmohyva gineba da srolebi, rac xorcieldeboda sxvadas-xva iaraRidan. mowmis ganmartebiT, manqanis Suqze daina-xa, rom ori Tu sami biWi gamovarda. isini Casxdnen avto-manqanaSi da wavidnen, ori biWi ki fexiT garboda. e. w-isganmartebiT, aRniSnuli incidentis gamo SeSinebuli daSewuxebuli iyo, rogorc TviTon, ise mezoblebic.
5 tyviidan damatebiT warmodgenili 2 tyvia (obieqti#1, #2) gasrolilia `makarovis~ sistemis unomro pisto-letis lulidan, xolo qirurg a. a-isgan amoRebuli erTityvia, s. g-is gvamidan amoRebuli erTi tyvia da l. C-assxeulidan amoRebuli erTi tyvia (sami tyvia) gasroliliaerTi da imave `makarovis~ sistemis sxva pistoletis lu-lidan.
25. Ss saministros saeqsperto kriminalistikuri mTva-ri sammarTvelos 2010 wlis 14 aprilis balistikuri eq-spertizis #... daskvniT dadgenilia, rom ss # ... saqmezegamosakvlevad wardgenili ori cali tyvia (obieqti #1da #2) warmoadgens qarxnuli wesiT damzadebul, 1951wlis nimuSis 9mm kalibriani vaznis Semadgenel nawilebs(tyviebs), gankuTvnils `makarovis~ sistemis pistolete-bisaTvis (Ï Ï) da `steCkinis~ sistemis avtomaturi pisto-letebisaTvis da sxva. orive tyvia vargisia identifika-ciisaTvis, gasrolilia 9mm kalibriani ̀ makarovis~ an ̀ steC-kinis~ sistemis erTi da imave pistoletis lulidan da araris identuri l. C-as sxeulidan amoRebuli tyviis, s. g-is gvamidan amoRebuli tyviis da qirurg a. a-isagan amoRe-buli tyviis. warmodgenil or tyviasa da tyvia masroTe-kaSi arsebul s. g-is mkvlelobis faqtze amoRebul mas-rebze ver iqna aRmoCenili saTanado raodenoba indivi-dualuri kerZo niSnebisa, romelTa erTobliobioT cal-saxad dgindeba, Seadgenda Tu ara gasrolamde warmodge-
180
nili romelime masra da romelime tyvia erT mTels, risgamoc am ukanasknelis dadgena ver moxerxda.
26. rac Seexeba saqmeSi arsebul sxva mtkicebulebebs:2010 wlis 17 marts Catarebuli pirovnebis amosacnobadwardgenis oqmebs, qimiuri, biologiuri, fiziko-teqniku-ri da balistikuri eqspertizis daskvnebs, z. t-is, l. dad. C-isa da b. l-as mimarT arsebul Tbilisis saqalaqo sasa-marTlos 2010 wlis 3 dekembris ganaCens, T. k-as mimarTarsebul Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2008 wlis 30 de-kembris ganaCens da saqmeze arsebul sxva mtkicebulebebs,maTi analiziT ar dgindeba arsebiTi mniSvnelobis gare-moebebi, romlebic miuTiTebda T. k-as danaSaulebriv qme-debebze (s. g-is, z. t-isa da sxvaTa mimarT cecxlsasroliiaraRiT srolis faqtze) saqarTvelos ssk-is 109-e mux-lis 1-li nawilis `g~, 19,109-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qve-punqtebiT, ssk-is 236-e muxlis 1-li, me-2 nawilebiTa dassk-is 239-e muxlis me-3 nawiliT gaTvaliswinebul dana-SaulebTan mimarTebiT.
27. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saqmeze arsebuli dagamokvleuli zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebisa da saqmismasalebis erToblivi analiziT, utyuarad ver dastur-deba T. k-as mier saqarTvelos ssk-is 109-e muxlis 1-linawilis `g~, 19,109-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtebiT,ssk-is 236-e muxlis 1-li, me-2 nawilebiTa da ssk-is 239-emuxlis me-3 nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulebis Ca-dena:
28. saqmis masalebiT dadgenilia da sadavo ar aris, rom2010 wlis 15 marts erTi mxriv, z. t-i da, meore mxriv, s. g-i g-is quCaze kafe-bar `...-Tan~ Sexvdnen erTmaneTs, maTSoris wina dRes momxdari usiamovnebis gasarkvevad. ase-ve dadgenilia, rom z. t-i am Sexvedraze mivida ZmebTan _d. da l. C-ebTan erTad.
29. rac Seexeba T. k-as SemTxvevis adgilze yofnas, z. t-ma da l. C-am miuTiTes, rom kafe-barTan misulebs daxvdaTT. k-ac, Tumca Semdeg sad wavida da ras akeTebda, maT arician. d. C-am ganmarta, rom SemTxvevis adgilze T. k-a arunaxavs. mowmeebma _ g. l-ma da e. c-em miuTiTes, rom s. g-iskafe-baridan gasvlidan daaxloebiT 10 wamSi gavida T. k-ac. mowmeebma _ S. n-ma, z. g-em da e. g-ma miuTiTes, rom kafe-barSi Sesvlamde gaiares `arka~, sadac biWebi idgnen. maTikafe-barSi Sesvlidan cota xanSi gareT gavida amave barSi
181
sxva biWebTan erTad myofi biWi. sasamarTlos sarwmunodmiaCnia saqmis SedegebiT dauinteresebeli mowmeebis _ S.n-is, z. g-isa da e. g-is Cvenebebi, romlebic miuTiTeben,rom kafe-barSi maT Sesvlamde `arkasTan~ ukve idgnen bi-Webi da saubrobdnen, xolo maTi Sesvlis Semdeg kafe-ba-ridan gavida erTi piri (T. k-a). aRniSnuli imaze miuTiTebs,rom T. k-a gareT gavida s. g-is gasvlidan garkveuli droisSemdeg (am monakveTSi mowmeebma gaiares `arka~, Sevidnenda dasxdnen kafe-barSi) da Tavidanve ar Sexvedria z. t-sda mis megobrebs, rogorc amas isini miuTiTeben.
30. b. l-asTan mimarTebiT z. t-ma ganmarta, rom avto-manqana gaaCeres kafe-baris SesasvlelTan. b. l-a darCa av-tomanqanaSi. l. C-am ganmarta, rom manqana `arkidan~ daax-loebiT ori metris moSorebiT gaaCeres. d. C-am ki miuTi-Ta, rom Tavdapirvelad avtomanqana gaaCeres `arkis~ Se-sasvlelTan. b. l-a manqanidan ar gadasula. e. g-is ganmar-tebiT, rodesac kafe-barisken midiodnen, `arkasTan~ tro-tuaridan gadavidnen gzis saval nawilze, radgan cudadiyo gaCerebuli avtomanqana. m. g-am ganmarta, rom `arkaSi~Sesasvleli gza daketili hqonda avtomanqanas, manqanaSiraRac anaTebda _ telefoni an magnitofonis baneri. Can-da, rom skamze aravin ijda. `arkidan~ gamodioda Cxubisada ginebis xma. b. l-am ganmarta, rom avtomanqana gaCerebu-li hqonda `arkidan~ daaxloebiT 15-20 metris moSorebiT,saidanac ar gadasula da arkaSi mimdinare movlenebis Sem-swre ar aris. aRsaniSnavia, rom braldebis mxarem pirveliinstanciis sasamarTloSi moxsna neitraluri mowme o. c-e(gamoZiebis mimdinareobis dros, dakiTxvisas miuTiTeb-da, rom avtomanqana ketavda ezoSi Sesasvlels. srolisdamTavrebis Semdeg avtomanqanaSi swrafad Cajda oTxi pi-ri), romlis dakiTxviTac gaizrdeboda saqmeze faqtob-rivi garemoebebis sworad garkvevisa da WeSmaritebis dad-genis SesaZlebloba. am winaaRmdegobebis pirobebSi sasa-marTlos arasarwmunod miaCnia b. l-as Cveneba.
31. aRsaniSnavia, rom uSualod SemTxvevis adgilze myo-fi pirebi _ z. t-i, l. da d. C-ebi ver/ar miuTiTeben T. k-asmier raime danaSaulebrivi qmedebis ganxorcielebis Se-saxeb, Tu raSi gamoixata T. k-as roli savaraudod Cade-nil danaSaulebSi. piriqiT, l. C-am da z. t-ma miuTiTes,rom Sexvedris Semdeg T. k-a sad iyo da ras akeTebda, ardaunaxavT, xolo d. C-am ganmarta, rom T. k-a saerTod ar
182
unaxavT. amdenad, maTi Cvenebebis mixedviT, saerTod ga-urkvevelia, raSi gamoixata T. k-as danaSaulebrivi qmede-ba.
32. z. t-ma da l. C-am CvenebebSi miuTiTes, rom, marTa-lia, sibnelis gamo ver dainaxes, vin esrola maT, magramsaqmis masalebis mixedviT, es piri unda yofiliyo T. k-a.aRniSnulTan mimarTebiT sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, romam ganmartebas ver mieniWeba arsebiTi mniSvneloba, vinai-dan saqmis masalebis Sefaseba sasamarTlos kompetenci-aa, xolo maT uSualod ar daunaxavT piri, romelmac maTimimarTulebiT isrola. Sesabamisad, maTi Cvenebebi ar Se-iZleba miCneul iqnes mtkicebulebebad, romliTac SesaZ-lebelia utyuarad dadgindes piri, romelmac cecxlsas-roli iaraRidan maTi da s. g-is mimarTulebiT isrola.
33. z. t-i, l. da d. C-ebi, rogorc konfliqtis monawileerTi mxaris warmomadgenlebi, arian dainteresebuli pi-rebi, romlebic gamoZiebis mimdinareobisas rig garemoe-bebs sxvadasxva CvenebaSi gansxvavebulad aRwerdnen. aR-saniSnavia, rom z. t-ma da l. C-am sasamarTlo sxdomaze da-kiTxvisas miuTiTes, rom simarTles Seesabameba maT miersasamarTlo sxdomaze micemuli Cvenebebi. aseve maTi Cve-nebebi rig mniSvnelovan sakiTxebTan mimarTebiT ewinaaR-mdegeba saqmeze dakiTxuli sxva mowmeebis Cvenebebs. ampirobebSi SemTxvevis adgilze ganviTarebuli movlene-bis, danaSaulebrivi qmedebis ganxorcielebisa da iq ar-sebuli suraTis dadgena (aRdgena) gamoZiebisa da qvemdgo-mi instanciis sasamarTloebis mier mxolod maTi Cvenebe-bis safuZvelze kritikas ver uZlebs, xolo z. t-is, l. C-asa da d. C-as Cvenebebi ar akmayofilebs utyuarobis stan-darts. amdenad, warmodgenili mtkicebulebebis mixed-viT, SeuZlebelia utyuarad dadgindes, realurad ra mox-da SemTxvevis adgilze: iaraRi pirvelad marTla s. g-maamoiRo, Tu sxva iq myofma romelime pirma; `arkidan~ gamo-suli xmebi _ `xeli gauSvi~ da sxva, konkretulad konfliq-tis romeli mxaris warmomadgenlisgan modioda; savarau-doa aseve iq ganviTarebuli sxva movlenebic.
TiTebulia, rom mas savaraudod miaCnia, rom ... pistoletiTan hqonda 2010 wlis 15 marts g-vis quCaze #... saxlTan s.g-Tan Sexvedrisas. analogiuri mocemulobaa 2010 wlis 2noembris sagnis amosacnobad wardgenis oqmSi, rom l. C-amamoicno `makarovis~ sistemis unomro pistoleti, rome-lic unda iyos misi. l. C-am aseve wardgenili iaraRebidanamoicno s. g-is kuTvnili iaraRi, romelic aris `makaro-vis~ sistemis da wardgenili iaraRebidan unda iyos ... pis-toleti. am iaraRze arsebuli niSnebi aZlevs varaudis sa-Sualebas, rom aRniSnuli iaraRi aris s. g-is, Tumca iyoRame, TviTon iyo daWrili da iaraRi ar dauTvalierebia.amdenad, orive amocnobis oqmSi miTiTebulia, rom amom-cnobma pirebma _ z. t-ma da l. C-am savaraudod miuTiTeskonkretul cecxlsasrol iaraRebze, Sesabamisad, am ga-remoebis gamo amocnobebi ar aris kategoriuli da aRniS-nulis safuZvelze utyuarad imis dadgena, Tu konfliq-tis dros romeli iaraRi vis hqonda, SeuZlebelia.
35. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom saqmeze utyuaradar dgindeba s. g-s _ fexis areSi, z. t-s, l. da d. C-ebs cec-xlnasroli Wrilobebi ra manZilidan aqvT miyenebuli, ri-Tac SesaZlebeli gaxdeboda srolis manZilis gansazRvra.bundovania, ra igulisxmeba araaxlo manZilSi, rac eqsper-tizis daskvnaSia miTiTebuli s. g-isaTvis Tavis areSi mi-yenebuli Wrilobis srolis manZilTan mimarTebiT.
36. sakasacio palata yuradRebas amaxvilebs saapela-cio sasamarTlos msjelobaze, romlis Tanaxmadac, sasa-marTlom ar gaiziara dazaralebulis uflebamonacvlisi. g-is Cveneba T. k-as udanaSaulobis Taobaze da aRniS-navs, rom i. g-i ar aris faqtis TviTmxilveli, Semswre daman momxdari faqtis Taobaze icis mxolod sxva pirebisgadmocemiT. amdenad, mis Cvenebas, saqmis faqtobrivi ga-remoebebis dadgenis TvalsazrisiT, ver mieniWeba arse-biTi mniSvneloba, maT Soris verc T. k-as gamarTlebasTanmimarTebiT.
37. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sa-samarTlos msjelobas SemTxvevis adgilze aRmoCenilimasrebis mdebareobasTan mimarTebiT. sadavo ar aris dadadgenilia, rom SemTxvevis adgilze samarTaldamcave-bis misvlamde Sekrebili iyo xalxi, aseve maT misvlamdeda SemTxvevis adgilis dacvamde moxda `arkidan~ s. g-issaavadmyofoSi gadayvana, ris gamoc SemTxvevis adgilze
184
aRmoCenili masrebis mdebareoba utyuarad ver iqneba miC-neuli. miT ufro, SemTxvevis adgilis damatebiTi daTva-lierebisas aRmoCenili masrebis mdebareoba SeuZlebeliadadgindes utyuarad, vinaidan igi damatebiT daTvalier-da SemTxvevidan meore dRes. Sesabamisad, SemTxvevis ad-gilis daTvalierebis oqmebiT im faqtis dadgena, Tu kon-kretulad romeli adgilidan esroles s. g-s da visi iara-Ridan, SeuZlebelia.
38. marTalia, mowmed dakiTxuli, kafe-bar `...-Si~ myofipirebi adastureben, rom T. k-a iq Sevarda iaraRiT xelSida Tqva, rom iaraRma umtyuna (gaWeda), Semdeg gadatena,swrafad gavida gareT, rasac momentalurad mohyva inten-siuri srolebi ramdenime iaraRidan, magram mxolod am ga-remoebis meSveobiT, rodesac sxva pirdapiri mtkicebu-leba saqmeze warmodgenili ar yofila, SeuZlebelia dad-gindes, rom swored T. k-am isrola cecxlsasroli iaraRi-dan megobris _ s. g-is, aseve z. t-is, d. da l. C-ebis misamar-TiT. miTumetes, braldebis mxarem mis mier warmodgenilimtkicebulebebiT ver SeZlo daedasturebina raime iseTimotivis arseboba, romelic T. k-as gadaawyvetinebda misiuaxloesi megobris mokvlas.
39. saqmeze arsebuli Ss saministros saeqsperto kri-minalistikuri mTavari sammarTvelos 2010 wlis 25 oqtom-bris balistikuri eqspertizis #... daskvniT dadginda,rom s. g-is Tavidan da fexidan, aseve l. C-as sxeulidanamoRebuli sul sami tyvia gasrolilia erTi da imave `ma-karovis~ sistemis sxva pistoletidan, romelic saqmezeamoRebuli ar yofila. aRniSnuli daudgeneli iaraRi arisT. k-asi, Tu igi ekuTvnoda incidentSi monawile romelimepirs an sxva pirs, amis utyuarad dadgena saqmeSi arsebu-li mtkicebulebebis analizis safuZvelze SeuZlebelia.miT ufro, rom ar aris sarwmuno da damajerebeli z. t-is,l. da d. C-ebis, b. l-as Cvenebebi, romlebmac SemTxvevisSemdeg Tavisuflad gadamales cecxlsasroli iaraRebi daromelTa mier micemul Cvenebebsa da SemoTavazebul ver-siaze aris ZiriTadad agebuli T. k-as braldeba.
40. rac Seexeba saqmeze arsebul eqspertizis sxva das-kvnebs, maTi Sinaarsidan gamomdinare, imis dadgena, romT. k-am ganaxorciela srolebi cexlsasroli iaraRidan me-gobris _ s. g-is, z. t-is, d. da l. C-ebis misamarTiT, SeuZ-lebelia.
185
41. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom sisxlis sa-marTlis saqmeze ar aris warmodgenili arc erTi utyuari,pirdapiri xasiaTis mtkicebuleba, romelic palatas saSu-alebas miscemda, daedgina T. k-as mier cecxlsasroli iara-Ridan s. g-is, z. t-is, d. da l. C-ebis misamarTiT mravalje-radi gasrolis faqti. Sesabamisad, mtkicebulebebis ara-sakmarisobis gamo T. k-as mimarT ssk-is 109-e muxlis 1-linawilis `g~ da 19,109-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qvepunqte-biT msjavrdebis nawilSi unda gauqmdes Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2014wlis 13 oqtombris ganaCeni da Sewydes saqme. amasTan, vina-idan arc erTi pirdapiri mtkicebulebiT utyuarad ar das-turdeba is, Tu raSi gamoixata T. k-as mxridan xulignobisCadenis faqti da SemTxvevis adgilze ra moqmedebebi gana-xorciela man, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom gasaCivrebu-li ganaCeni unda gauqmdes aseve T. k-as ssk-is 239-e muxlisme-3 nawiliT msjavrdebis nawilSi da Sewydes saqme. rac Se-exeba T. k-as msjavrdebas ssk-is 236-e muxlis 1-li da me-2nawilebiT, vinaidan amoRebuli ar aris cecxlsasroli ia-raRi, misi vargisianoba (eWvqveS dadga gaWedvis gamo, rackafe-barSi myofma pirebma daadastures) ver dadginda iseverogorc mis mier cecxlsasroli iaraRidan gasroliT s. g-is mokvlisa da sxva dazaralebulebis sxeulis sxvadasxvaxarisxis dazianebis faqtebi, rac utyuarad miuTiTebda ia-raRis kuTvnilebas cecxlsasroli iaraRis kategoriisad-mi da mis vargisianobas, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom T. k-as msjavrdeba cecxlsasroli iaraRisa da sabrZolo masa-lis SeZena, Senaxvisa da tarebis nawilSi aseve arasworia daam nawilSic (ssk-is 236-e muxlis 1-li da me-2 nawilebi) misimsjavrdebis Taobaze gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda gauq-mdes da Sewydes saqme.
42. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom saqmeze arsebulinivTieri mtkicebulebebi Senaxul unda iqnes saqmis Se-naxvis vadiT, raTa ar moispos s. g-is mkvlelobis saqmezedanaSaulis Camdeni piris dadgenis SesaZlebloba.
43. T. k-as unda ganemartos, rom ufleba aqvs, saqar-Tvelos kanonmdeblobiT dadgenili wesiT moiTxovos zi-anis anazRaureba.
g. SavliaSvili (Tavmjdomare),m. oSxareli,p. silagaZe
monawileobiT ganixila msjavrdebulebis _ v. v-sa da a.m-s interesebis damcveli advokatebis _ k. j-sa da o. r-ssakasacio saCivrebi quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos2014 wlis 26 seqtembris ganaCenze.
4. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrdebul-Ta advokatebma _ k. j-m da b. b-m.
5. msjavrdebul v. v-s advokatma k. j-m saapelacio sa-CivriT iTxova xelvaCauris raionuli sasamarTlos 2014wlis 23 ivlisis ganaCenis gauqmeba da v. v-s gamarTleba,xolo advokatma b. b-m _ gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi cvlile-bis Setana, a. m-s udanaSaulod cnoba saqarTvelos ssk-is177-e muxlis me-3 nawiliT wardgenil braldebaSi, xolossk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~ da `b~ qvepunqtebiT _arasapatimro sasjelis gansazRvra.
6. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 26 seq-tembris ganaCeniT saapelacio saCivrebi ar dakmayofil-da da gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni darCa ucvlelad; amasTan,msjavrdebul a. m-s sasjelis moxda daewyo 2014 wlis 12martidan.
7. kasatori _ msjavrdebul v. v-s interesebis damcve-li, advokati k. j-a sakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnavs, rom sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeSi warmodgenili mtkicebulebebisgamokvlevis Sedegad ar dadgenila v. v-s mier saqarTve-los ssk-is 177-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis Ca-denis faqti, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni ki unda efuZnebo-des mxolod erTmaneTTan SeTanxmebul, aSkara da dama-jerebeli mtkicebulebebis erTobliobas; is faqti, romv. v-i icnobda a. m-s da daexmara mas nivTebis gadazidvaSi,ver gamodgeba mis mier qurdobis Cadenis dasturad. sa-qarTvelos sssk-is 269-e muxlis Tanaxmad, gamamtyunebelganaCens ar SeiZleba safuZvlad daedos varaudi.
8. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, advokati k. j-a iT-xovs quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 23 seq-tembris ganaCenis gauqmebas da v. v-s gamarTlebas.
9. msjavrdebul a. m-s interesebis damcveli, advokatio. r-e sakasacio saCivarSi miuTiTebs, rom saqmeSi ar moi-poveba arc erTi pirdapiri mtkicebuleba, rom a. m-a dana-Saulis Cadenis dros moqmedebda sxvasTan SeTanxmebiTan sxvasTan erTad, swored amitom misi qmedeba ar undadakvalificirebuliyo jgufurad Cadenil danaSaulad.Tavad msjavrdebulebi ganmartavdnen, rom v. v-ma arafe-ri icoda televizorebis qurdobaze.
190
10. aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, advokati o. r-e iT-xovs a. m-s udanaSaulod cnobas saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-emuxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiT gaTvaliswinebuli da-naSaulis CadenaSi, misi qmedebis dakvalificirebas ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `a~, `b~ qvepunqtebiT da sas-jelis minimumis gansazRvras, rac CaeTvleba pirobiT.
mis masalebi da mivida im daskvnamde, rom msjavrdebul v.v-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat k. j-s sakasacio saCi-vari unda dakmayofildes, xolo msjavrdebul a. m-s inte-resebis damcvelis, advokat o. r-s sakasacio saCivari un-da dakmayofildes nawilobriv da gasaCivrebul ganaCenSiunda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom gamamtyunebeli ga-naCeni unda eyrdnobodes urTierTSeTavsebad da damaje-rebel mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobas, rac gonivrul eWvsmiRma daadasturebs piris braleulobas. braldebis mxa-ris mier warmodgenili da sasamarTlo sxdomaze gamokvle-uli mtkicebulebebi ki ar iZleva imis safuZvels, rom sa-kasacio palatam dadgenilad miiCnios v. v-s mier a. m-sTanerTad winaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufurad, sadgomSi ukano-nod SeRweviT qurdobis Cadenis faqti, ramac mniSvnelo-vani ziani gamoiwvia, kerZod:
3. gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT v. v-s mier zemoaRniSnulidanaSaulis Cadenis damadasturebel mtkicebulebebadmiCneulia Semdegi faqtebi: v. v-i da a. m-a icnobdnen er-TmaneTs da hqondaT axlo urTierToba; v. v-i eswrebodasastumros mepatronis mier sastumros gadabarebis pro-cess da icoda, rom sastumroSi iyo televizorebi; v. v-madaureka z. b-s da sTxova manqaniT miekiTxa misTvis, xoloSemdeg imave manqaniT imgzavra a. m-sTn erTad, romelsac(m-s) Tan hqonda moparuli televizori; aseve is garemoe-ba, rom v. v-i sTavazobda m. n-s plazmuri televizoris Ses-yidvas, xolo z. b-s v-ma da m-m mihyides erT-erTi televi-zori.
4. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs saapelacio sasamar-Tlos daskvnas, rom zemoaRniSnuli garemoebebi adastu-rebs v. v-sTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedebis Cadenas da mi-aCnia, rom zemomiTiTebuli faqtebi adasturebs mxolod
191
imas, rom v. v-s Sexeba hqonda moparul televizorebTanda exmareboda m-s maT gasaRebaSi, rac SesaZloa, Seicav-des sxva danaSaulis niSnebs, Tumca, iqidan gamomdinare,rom v. v-s braldebis Sesaxeb dadgenileba ar Seicavs aR-niSnuli qmedebebis aRweras (televizoris gasaReba/gasa-Rebis mcdeloba), sakasacio palata kanonismierad mokle-bulia SesaZleblobas, imsjelos misi qmedebis gadakvali-ficirebis Taobaze
5. rac Seexeba im garemobas, rom v. v-i winaswari SeTan-xmebiT jgufurad, sadgomSi ukanonod SeRweviT daeuf-la aRniSnul televizorebs, palata miuTiTebs, rom bral-debis mxares am faqtis damadasturebeli arc erTi pirda-piri mtkicebuleba ar warmoudgenia. Sesabamisad, saape-lacio sasamarTlos aRniSnuli daskvna warmoadgens ze-moT miTiTebuli faqtobrivi garemoebebis analizis Sede-gad warmoqmnil varauds, rac saqarTvelos sisxlis samar-Tlis saproceso kodeqsis moTxovnebidan gamomdinare,ver daedeba safuZvlad gamamtyunebel ganaCens, vinaidan,saqarTvelos sssk-is me-13 muxlis me-2 nawilis, 259-e mux-lis me-3 nawilisa da 273-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Sesabami-sad, ganaCenSi Camoyalibebuli yvela daskvna dasabuTe-buli unda iyos. gamamtyunebel ganaCenSi unda aRiniSnosutyuari da sakmarisi mtkicebulebebi, romlebsac emya-reba sasamarTlos daskvna. saqarTvelos sssk-is 82-e mux-lis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, gamamtyunebeli ganaCeniT pi-ris damnaSaved cnobisaTvis saWiroa gonivrul eWvs miRmaarsebul, SeTanxmebul mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba.
6. yovelive aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio pa-latas miaCnia, rom v. v-i unda gamarTldes misTvis braladSeracxul qmedebaSi.
7. rac Seexeba msjavrdebul a. m-s, misi ganmartebiT, manmartom Caidina misTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedeba, xolov. v-s uTxra, rom aRniSnuli televizorebi iyo misi; Sesa-bamisad, gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni sadavod gaxada mxolodim nawilSi, rom Caidina qurdoba v. v-Tan erTad.
8. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom garda a. m-s aRiare-bisa, mis mier sadgomSi ukanono SeRweviT qurdobis Cade-nis faqti, ramac mniSvnelovni ziani gamoiwvia, gonivruleWvs miRma dadasturebulia saqmeSi arsebuli da sasamar-Tlo sxdomaze gamokvleuli sxva mtkicebulebebis erTob-liobiT. xolo rac Seexeba mis mier aRniSnuli qmedebis v.
192
v-Tan winaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufurad Cadenas, rogorcpalatam zemoT miuTiTa, am faqtma dadastureba ver hpo-va braldebis mxaris mier warmodgenili mtkicebulebebiT,Sesabamisad, a. m-c unda gamarTldes saqarTvelos ssk-is177-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiT wardgenil bral-debaSi, xolo saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis `a~ da `b~ qvepunqtebiT wardgenili braldebisaTvis,saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e muxlis Sesabamisad, misi pasuxis-mgeblobis Semamsubuqebeli garemoebebis _ aRiarebs dainaniebs Cadenil qmedebas _ mxedvelobaSi miRebiT, undaganesazRvros samarTliani sasjeli.
9. advokat o. r-s moTxovnasTan dakavSirebiT, a. m-sTvisdaniSnuli sasjelis pirobiTad CaTvlis Taobaze, palatamiuTiTebs, rom Cadenili qmedebis simZimidan da xasiaTi-dan gamomdinare, ar aris mizanSewonili misTvis daniSnu-li sasjelis pirobiTad CaTvla.
3. gasaCivrebuli ganaCenis mixedviT, k. m-s msjavri da-edo imaSi, rom man arasrulwlovnebis asakSi Caidina qur-dobis, ese igi sxvisi moZravi nivTis farulad, marTlsawi-naaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT dauflebis mcdeloba, wi-naswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier, rac gamoixata Semdeg-Si: 2013 wlis 24 ianvars, Ramis saaTebSi, q-i, c-s quCis #-ismimdebared ganTavsebul v. S-s swrafi Caricxvis aparati-dan srulwlovani g. j-e da arasrulwlovani k. m-e cdilob-dnen fuladi Tanxis farulad, marTlsawinaaRmdego misa-kuTrebis mizniT dauflebas.
4. msjavrdebuli k, m-e 1-li instanciis sasamarTlosxdomaze nawilobriv aRiarebda Cadenil danaSauls, ker-Zod, is uaryofda jgufurad danaSaulis Cadenas. saqmissaapelacio da sakasacio wesiT ganxilvisas man sruladcno Tavi damnaSaved Cadenil danaSaulSi.
5. k. m-s braldebis saqme gamoZiebidan sasamarTloSi Se-vida 2013 wlis 6 marts. k. m-e am dros iyo 17 wlisa da 9Tvis. winasasamarTlo sxdoma CainiSna 2013 wlis 11 marts,saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis sxdoma daiwyo 2013 wlis 22marts, igi 2013 wlis 2 ivniss gaxda srulwlovani, ese igi
197
saqmis sasamarTloSi Sesvlis momentidan 3 Tvis Semdeg,Catarda sul 11 sxdoma, xolo ganaCeni gamovida 2013 wlis9 seqtembers. 1-li instanciis sasamarTlom mas sasjeladdauniSna 4 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, rac Seumcirda 1/4-iT da sabolood daniSnuli sasjeli _ 3 weli CaeTvalapirobiT, 4 wlis gamosacdeli vadiT. sasamarTlom srul-wlovani msjavrdebulis mimarT, romelmac arasrulwlov-nebis dros Caidina danaSauli, ise gamoiyena pirobiTimsjavri, rom ar imsjela ssk-is 63-e muxlis me-5 nawilismoTxovnis sawinaaRmdegod saerTaSoriso standartebissruli dacvis Sesabamisad pirobiTi msjavris gamoyenebismizanSewonilobaze.
6. saapelacio sasamarTlom saxelmwifo bralmdeblissaapelacio saCivris moTxovnis safuZvelze ise gaauqmaaRniSnuli muxlis moTxovnis safuZvelze k. m-s mimarT re-alurad daniSnuli sasjelis pirobiTad CaTvla da sabo-loo sasjelad dauniSna realuri sasjeli _ 3 weli, romsaerTod ar imsjela, Tu ramdenad iyo daculi ssk-is 316-e muxlis moTxovnebi, kerZod: 1-li instanciis sasamar-Tlos sxdomaze, arasrulwlovan k. m-s process moeqcnenTu ara gansakuTrebuli yuradRebiT rogorc braldebismxare, aseve sasamarTlo; mxedvelobaSi iqna Tu ara miRe-buli misi asaki da resocializaciis gansakuTrebuli sa-zogadoebrivi interesi, aseve misi xelaxali aRzrdisaT-vis xelis Sewyobis aucileblobloba, raTa ganaCeniT swo-rad yofiliyo daculi misi WeSmariti interesi da ar mom-xdariyo pirovnebisa da misi Cadenili danaSaulis Seusa-bamo, araadekvaturi Sedegis dadgoma, rac mocemul Sem-TxvevaSi dadga k. m-s mimarT realuri sasjelis saxiT. saa-pelacio sasamarTlom gaauqma k. m-s mimarT gamoyenebulipirobiTi msjavri ara im safuZvliT, rom misi pirovnebisada mis mier Cadenili danaSaulis xasiaTidan gamomdinare,mizanSewonili ar iyo mis mimarT pirobiTi msjavris gamo-yeneba, aramed _ ssk-is 63-e muxlis me-5 nawilis danawesisSesabamisad, rom Tu msjavrdebuls ganaCenis gamotanismomentisaTvis ar Sesrulebia Tvrameti weli da man pir-velad Caidina danaSauli, sasamarTlo uflebamosilia da-adginos, rom daniSnuli sasjeli CaiTvalos pirobiT, Tumas Cadenili ara aqvs gansakuTrebiT mZime danaSauli.
7. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom saqarTvelos sssk-is 316-e muxlis moTxovnebidan gamomdinare, sasamarTlo
198
valdebulia, daicvas arasrulwlovnis uflebaTa saerTa-Soriso garantiebi. im SemTxvevaSi, Tu sisxlis samarTliskodeqsis konkretuli muxlis moTxovna ewinaaRmdegebaarasrulwlovnis dacvis saerTaSoriso samarTlis sayo-velTaod aRiarebul principebsa da normebs, riTac ir-Rveva arasrulwlovnis uflebebi da misi resocializaci-isaTvis gansakuTrebuli sazogadoebrivi interesi, swo-red saerTaSoriso principebisa da normebisaTvis upira-tesi Zalis miniWebiT, saerTaSoriso standartebis srulidacviT unda gadavwyvitoT arasrulwlovnis WeSmariti in-teresi, risi samarTlebrivi safuZvelic mocemulia saqar-Tvelos konstituciis me-6 muxlis me-2 punqtSi, kerZod:saqarTvelos kanonmdebloba Seesabameba saerTaSoriso sa-marTlis sayovelTaod aRiarebul principebsa da normebs.saqarTvelos saerTaSoriso xelSekrulebas an SeTanxme-bas, Tu igi ar ewinaaRmdegeba saqarTvelos konstituci-as, aqvs upiratesi iuridiuli Zala Sidasaxelmwifoebri-vi normatiuli aqtebis mimarT.
8. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul k. m-sgaaCnia samarTliani pretenzia imasTan dakavSirebiT, romwardgenili braldebis Taobaze saboloo gadawyvetilebagonivrul vadaSi ar iqna miRebuli. sisxlis samarTlis saq-mis mokle vadaSi ganxilvisa da gadawyvetis aucileblo-bis sakiTxi miT ufro TvalsaCinoa, rodesac braldebuliarasrulwlovania da sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 63-e mux-lis me-5 nawili arasrulwlovnis mimarT pirobiTi msjav-ris gamoyenebis samarTlebriv regulacias zRudavs gana-Cenis gamotanis momentSi misi srulwlovani asakis dad-gomiT.
25. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom swored zemoaRniS-nuli saerTaSoriso standartebis safuZvelze iqna miRe-buli arasrulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebis axali kodeq-si, romelic amoqmeddeba 2016 wlis 1 ianvridan. am kodeqsssruliad gansxvavebuli da axali midgoma aqvs aRniSnulsakiTxTan dakavSirebiT. kodeqsis 74-e muxlis Tanaxmad,Tu arasrulwlovanma, romelic ganzraxi danaSaulisaT-vis msjavrdebuli ar yofila, naklebad mZime an mZime da-naSauli Caidina, sasamarTlo uflebamosilia daadginos,rom daniSnuli sasjeli CaTvalos pirobiT msjavrad. am-denad, dRes moqmedi sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 63-e mux-lis me-5 nawilis redaqciisagan gansxvavebiT, arasruwlov-nis mimarT pirobiTi msjavris gamoyenebis dros mniSvne-loba eqneba arasrulwlovnebis dros danaSaulis Cadenisfaqts da ara imas, ganaCenis gamotanis momentisaTvis xomar Seusrulda mas Tvrameti weli. amasTan, kodeqsSi Sema-val debulebebs miecema ukuZala msjavrdebulis mdgo-mareobis sasargeblod.
26. sakasacio palata ganmartavs: vinaidan saqarTvelosssk-is 63-e muxlis me-5 nawilis debuleba, rom Tu msjav-rdebuls ganaCenis gamotanis momentisaTvis Seusrulda18 weli, sasamarTlo ar aris uflebamosili, daniSnuli sas-
205
jeli CauTvalos pirobiT, winaaRmdegobaSia zemomiTiTe-bul saerTaSoriso aqtebsa da konvenciebTan, saqarTve-los konstituciis Tanaxmad ki am dros upiratesi Zalaunda mivaniWoT saerTaSoriso aqtebiT aRiarebul normeb-sa da principebs, Sesabamisad, palata uflebamosilia, upi-ratesi Zala mianiWos saerTaSoriso standartebs da im-sjelos k. m-s mimarT pirobiTi msjavris gamoyenebis sa-kiTxze.
27. sasjelis daniSvnis dros sasamarTlo iTvaliswinebsk. m-s pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebel da damamZimebelgaremoebebs, danaSaulis Cadenis motivsa da mizans, qme-debaSi gamovlenil marTlsawinaaRmdego nebas, qmedebisganxorcielebis saxes, xerxsa da marTlsawinaaRmdego Se-degs, damnaSavis pirovnebas, mis ojaxur mdgomareobas. k.m-s pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebeli garemoebaa is, romaRiarebs Cadenil danaSauls, xolo damamZimebeli gare-moebebi ar gaaCnia.
28. garda amisa, sasjelis gansazRvrisas sasamarTlo iT-valiswinebs danaSaulebrivi qmedebis xasiaTs, rom Cade-nilia daumTavrebeli danaSauli _ qurdobis mcdeloba damiaCnia, rom k. m-s unda Seefardos sasjelis iseTi saxe dazoma, rac gaxdeba momavalSi misi sazogadoebaSi usafrTxointegraciis safuZveli da iqneba damafiqrebeli msjav-rdebulisaTvis, raTa man ukeT gaacnobieros Cadenili qme-debis xasiaTi, sazogadoebrivi saSiSroebisa da gasakicxa-obis xarisxi da bolos, sasjelma unda Seamciros msjav-rdebulis mier axali danaSaulis Cadenis riski, rac, Ta-vis mxriv, xels Seuwyobs samarTlianobis aRdgenas.
29. palatis SefasebiT, sasjelis daniSvnis dros gaT-valiswinebul unda iqnes Cadenili danaSaulis xasiaTi, ra-Ta sasjeli iyos samarTliani. damnaSave piris resociali-zaciisaTvis, aseve sazogadoebrivi cxovrebis dacvis au-cileblobidan da samarTlianobis principidan gamomdi-nare, agreTve zogadi da kerZo prevenciis miznebisaTvispalatas mizanSewonilad miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul k. m-smimarT gamoyenebul unda iqnes pirobiTi msjavri, kerZodmas unda daeniSnos saqarTvelos ssk-is 19,177-e muxlismesame nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiT 4 wliT Tavisuflebis aR-kveTa, rac ssk-is 88-e muxlis me-4 nawilis safuZvelze un-da Seumcirdes 1/4-iT da Seefardos 3 wliT TavisuflebisaRkveTa, rac ssk-is 63-e-64-e muxlebis safuZvelze unda
lata miiCnevs, rom quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sis-xlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2014 wlis 17 TebervlisganaCenSi k. m-s mimarT unda Sevides cvlileba.
5. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos SuamdgomlobiTmimarTa msjavrdebulma d. k-m, romelmac iTxova axlad ga-movlenil garemoebaTa gamo ganaCenis gadasinjva da ga-marTleba Semdegi samarTlebrivi safuZvlebiT: quTaisissaapelacio sasamarTloSi dacvis mxaris mier wardgenilil. s-is saxelobis sasamarTlo eqspertizis erovnuli biu-ros 2014 wlis 14 ivnisis grafikuli eqspertizis #... das-kvna, romliTac dasturdeba misi udanaSauloba, usafuZ-vlod ar iqna daSvebuli da gamokvleuli. aRniSnuli sa-kiTxi Sefasebis gareSe datoves uzenaesi sasamarTlos mo-samarTleebmac; saqarTvelos ssk-is 362-e muxliT sisxlis-samarTlebrivi pasuxismgebloba dawesebulia mxolodoficialuri dokumentis gayalbebisaTvis da ara _ zoga-dad nebismieri sabuTis gayalbebisaTvis; sasamarTloeb-
209
ma ar miaqcies yuradReba im garemoebas, rom kerZo pirebsSoris dadebuli xelSekruleba, Tu igi ar aris damowme-buli sanotaro wesiT, ar warmoadgens oficialur doku-ments; ukanonod daedo msjavri im danaSaulisaTvis, ro-melic kanoniT danaSaulad ar aris gamocxadebuli.
e) arsebobs adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTloskanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gadawyvetileba (ganCineba), ro-melmac daadgina adamianis uflebaTa da ZiriTad Tavisuf-lebaTa dacvis evropuli konvenciis an misi oqmebis dar-Rveva am saqmesTan dakavSirebiT, da gadasasinji ganaCeniam darRvevas efuZneba;
v) axali kanoni auqmebs an amsubuqebs sisxlissamar-Tlebriv pasuxismgeblobas im qmedebisaTvis, romlis Ca-denisTvisac pirs gadasasinji ganaCeniT msjavri daedo;
z) warmodgenilia axali faqti an mtkicebuleba, rome-lic gadasasinji ganaCenis gamotanis dros ar iyo cnobilida TavisTavad, Tu sxva dadgenil garemoebasTan erTadamtkicebs msjavrdebulis udanaSaulobas an mis mier imdanaSaulze ufro msubuqi an ufro mZime danaSaulis Ca-denas, romlisTvisac mas msjavri daedo, agreTve amtki-cebs gamarTlebulis braleulobas an danaSaulis im pirismier Cadenas, romlis mimarTac sisxlissamarTlebrividevna Sewyvetili iyo;
e) arsebobs adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTloskanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gadawyvetileba (ganCineba), ro-melmac daadgina adamianis uflebaTa da ZiriTad Tavisuf-lebaTa dacvis evropuli konvenciis an misi oqmebis dar-Rveva am saqmesTan dakavSirebiT, da gadasasinji ganaCeniam darRvevas efuZneba;
v) axali kanoni auqmebs an amsubuqebs sisxlissamar-Tlebriv pasuxismgeblobas im qmedebisaTvis, romlis Ca-denisTvisac pirs gadasasinji ganaCeniT msjavri daedo;
z) warmodgenilia axali faqti an mtkicebuleba, rome-lic gadasasinji ganaCenis gamotanis dros ar iyo cnobilida TavisTavad, Tu sxva dadgenil garemoebasTan erTadamtkicebs msjavrdebulis udanaSaulobas an mis mier imdanaSaulze ufro msubuqi an ufro mZime danaSaulis Ca-denas, romlisTvisac mas msjavri daedo, agreTve amtki-cebs gamarTlebulis braleulobas an danaSaulis im pirismier Cadenas, romlis mimarTac sisxlissamarTlebrividevna Sewyvetili iyo;
5. msjavrdebulma j. S-m da misma advokatma r. a-ma Suam-dgomlobiT mimarTes quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlosaxlad gamovlenil garemoebaTa gamo mis mimarT dadgeni-li ganaCenis gadasinjvisa da sasjelis Semcirebis an gana-Cenis xandazmulad miCnevis gamo sasjelis moxdisagansrulad ganTavisuflebis Sesaxeb.
6. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 29 ian-vris ganaCeniT msjavrdebul j. S-sa da advokat r. a-s Su-amdgomloba dakmayofilda nawilobriv: saqarTvelos uze-naesi sasamarTlos 1998 wlis 22 dekembris ganaCeni da 2014wlis 23 seqtembris ganCineba Seicvala: j. S-s qmedeba sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 961-e muxlidan (1960 wlis redaqcia) ga-dakvalificirda amJamad moqmedi redaqciis ssk-is 180-emuxlis me-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtze da ganesazRvra 7 wliTTavisuflebis aRkveTa, rac `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012 wlis28 dekembris saqarTvelos kanonis safuZvelze Seumcir-da erTi meoTxediT da sabolood miesaja 5 wliTa da 3 TviTTavisuflebis aRkveTa; masve sasjelis moxdaSi CaeTvalawinaswar patimrobaSi yofnis 5 Tve, 4 dRe da sasjelis mox-da daewyo 2014 wlis 28 ivnisidan. ganaCeni da ganCineba da-narCen nawilSi darCa ucvlelad.
7. msjavrdebuli j. S-e da advokati r. a-i sakasacio sa-CivrebSi aRniSnaven, rom sajaro reestris erovnuli saa-gentos 2014 wlis 12 seqtembris monacemebiT, s/s z-is ...qarxana likvidirebulia, amitom j. S-s mimarT unda gamo-yenebuliyo `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012 wlis 28 dekembris sa-qarTvelos kanonis me-11 muxlis me-3 nawili.
kasacio saCivrebi, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma sa-Civrebis safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul j.S-sa da misi advokatis _ r. a-s sakasacio saCivari ar undadakmayofildes, xolo prokuror n. k-s sakasacio saCivariunda dakmayofildes nawilobriv da gasaCivrebul gana-CenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom msjavrdebul j. S-sdanaSaulebrivi qmedeba saapelacio sasamarTlom sruli-ad kanonierad moiyvana SesabamisobaSi moqmed kanonmdeb-lobasTan; amasTan, palata iziarebs saxelmwifo bralmdeb-lis pozicias, rom j. S-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 180-e muxlisme-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT sasjelis saxiT unda ganesaz-Rvros 9 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, vinaidan sakasaciosasamarTlos mier ganmartebulia, rom axlad gamovlenilgaremoebaTa gamo ganaCenis gadasinjvisas sasamarTlo araris uflebamosili, imsjelos gadasasinji gadawyvetile-bis samarTlianobaze (#39ag-12 http://www.supremecourt.ge/files/upload-file/pdf/ganmarteba32.pdf). aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, j.S-sTvis sasjelis saxiT gansazRvruli 12 wliT Tavisuf-lebis aRkveTa unda moeqces saqarTvelos ssk-is 180-e mux-lis me-3 nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli sanqciis farglebSiise, rom ar Sefasdes gadasasinji ganaCenis samarTliano-ba, vinaidan mocemul SemTxevvaSi ar arsebobs aRniSnulissamarTlebrivi safuZveli.
3. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs saxelmwifo bralmdeb-lis pozicias, rom j. S-s mimarT saapelacio palatas saer-Tod ar unda emsjela `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012 wlis 28 de-kembris saqarTvelos kanonis gamoyenebis Taobaze. pala-ta miuTiTebs, rom quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlom ax-lad gamovlenil garemoebaTa gamo gadasinja rogorc sa-
226
qarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saq-meTa kolegiis 1998 wlis 22 dekembris ganaCeni, ise uzena-esi sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 23 seqtembris ganCineba, vinai-dan es ukanaskneli j. S-s mimarT warmoadgens bolo sap-roceso dokuments da, Sesabamisad, radgan aRniSnuli gan-CinebiT namsjelia `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ kanonis gamoyene-bis Taobaze, saapelacio sasamarTlos unda emsjela amni-istis gamoyenebis sakiTxzec.
4. rac Seexeba dacvis mxaris pozicias saqarTvelos uze-naesi sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa kolegiis1998 wlis 22 dekembris ganaCenis xandazmulobasTan da-kavSirebiT, palata am nawilSi srulad iziarebs saapela-cio sasamarTlos pozicias da miuTiTebs, rom ganaCenisaRsrulebis xandazmulobis vadebi mocemul SemTxvevaSiar aris darRveuli.
5. palata aseve ar iziarebs advokatis pozicias, rom j.S-s mimarT unda gavrceldes `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ 2012 wlis28 dekembris saqarTvelos kanonis me-11 muxlis moqmede-ba im motiviT, rom dazaralebuli iuridiuli piri _ z-is ...qarxana sajaro reestris erovnuli saagentos monaceme-biT likvidirebulia, vinaidan sakasacio palata mxedve-lobaSi iRebs im garemoebas, rom sabraldebo daskvniTada ganaCeniT j. S-s msjavri daedo saxelmwifo qonebis uka-nono mitacebisaTvis, Sesabamisad, sasamarTlo aRniSnulsaqmeSi dazaralebulad miiCnevs saxelmwifos da radganmis warmomadgenels (mocemul SemTxvevaSi _ prokurors)ar daufiqsirebia pozicia j. S-s gaTavisuflebis Sesaxeb,sakasacio palata kanonismierad moklebulia SesaZleblo-bas, gaavrcelos masze `amnistiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos ka-nonis me-11 muxlis moqmedeba.
aRniSnuli informaciis gamoTxovniT unda dadastur-des, rom saqmeebi mosamarTleebs Soris ar nawildeba Sem-TxveviTi principis gamoyenebiT; erT SemadgenlobaSi mo-samarTleebi _ g. C-a da m. x-i sxvadasxva dros monawileob-dnen i. f-s sisxlis samarTlis saqmis ganxilvaSi; es infor-macia aseve daadasturebda, rom mosamarTleebs erT sa-muSao dReze meti ar hqondaT Suamdgomlobis Sesaswav-lad.
zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, msjavrdebuli i. f-ida advokatebi _ k. C-a da S. x-e iTxoven Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 5 martis ganCinebis gauqmebas,Suamdgomlobis dasaSvebad cnobas da saqmis arsebiTadganxilvas, aseve _ Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos mTli-ani Semadgenlobis acilebas.
e) arsebobs adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTloskanonier ZalaSi Sesuli gadawyvetileba (ganCineba), ro-melmac daadgina adamianis uflebaTa da ZiriTad Tavisuf-lebaTa dacvis evropuli konvenciis an misi oqmebis dar-Rveva am saqmesTan dakavSirebiT da gadasasinji ganaCeniam darRvevas efuZneba;
v) axali kanoni auqmebs an amsubuqebs sisxlissamar-Tlebriv pasuxismgeblobas im qmedebisaTvis, romlis Ca-denisTvisac pirs gadasasinji ganaCeniT msjavri daedo;
z) warmodgenilia axali faqti an mtkicebuleba, rome-lic gadasasinji ganaCenis gamotanis dros ar iyo cnobilida TavisTavad, Tu sxva dadgenil garemoebasTan erTadamtkicebs msjavrdebulis udanaSaulobas an mis mier imdanaSaulze ufro msubuqi an ufro mZime danaSaulis Ca-denas, romlisTvisac mas msjavri daedo, agreTve amtki-cebs gamarTlebulis braleulobas an danaSaulis im pirismier Cadenas, romlis mimarTac sisxlissamarTlebrividevna Sewyvetili iyo.
sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom kasatoris mier miTi-Tebuli garemoebebi arc erT zemoT CamoTvlil safuZ-vels ar akmayofilebs. palata srulad iziarebs saapela-cio sasamarTlos motivebs SuamdgomlobasTan dakavSire-biT da miiCnevs, rom saapelacio sasamarTlom saqmeSi ar-sebuli masalebis erToblivi analizis safuZvelze sworisamarTlebrivi Sefaseba misca saqmis garemoebebs.
234
palata miuTiTebs, rom saCivris motivebidan gamomdi-nare, kasatorebi faqtobrivad iTxoven saqmis xelaxla ar-sebiTad ganxilvas, risi kanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli safuZ-velic mocemul SemTxvevaSi ar arsebobs.
rac Seexeba dacvis mxaris mier saCivarSi miTiTebulgaremoebebs saqmeTa ganawilebis wesTan dakavSirebiT, aR-niSnuli sakiTxi mocemul SemTxvevaSi ar warmoadgens sa-kasacio palatis msjelobis sagans da ar aris Semxebloba-Si i. f-s msjavrdebis sakiTxTan.
sakasacio palata ar iziarebs aseve dacvis mxaris miTi-Tebas imis Taobaze, rom mosamarTle g. C-a ar iyo ufleba-mosili ganexila misi Suamdgomloba da miuTiTebs, rom sa-qarTvelos sssk-is 59-e muxlis Sesabamisad, saqmis arse-biT ganxilvaSi monawileoba mosamarTles ar uzRudavsuflebas, monawileoba miiRos axlad gamovlenil garemo-ebaTa gamo saqmis ganxilvaSi.
amdenad, Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos ganCinebamsjavrdebul i. f-sa da advokat k. C-s Suamdgomlobis da-uSveblad cnobis Taobaze kanonieri da dasabuTebulia,romlis gauqmebis an Secvlis samarTlebrivi safuZveliar arsebobs, ris gamoc igi unda darCes ucvlelad.
Tvelos sssk-is 314-e muxlis moTxovnaTa farglebSi Sea-mowma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida das-kvnamde, rom msjavrdebul n. b-s sakasacio saCivari ar un-da dakmayofildes, xolo gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni undadarCes ucvlelad Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. saqmis masalebis mixedviT, n. b-s braldebis saqmeze
239
evrosasamarTlom daamtkica morigeba saqarTvelos sa-xelmwifosa da n. b-s Soris. saqarTvelos saxelmwifom kon-venciis me-6 muxlis darRvevad aRiara is garemoeba, romsaqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis dros ar iqna dakiTxuli bral-debis mowme, policiis TanamSromeli d. f-i, romelic uSu-alod monawileobda b-s dakavebasa da sacxovrebeli binisCxrekaSi, riTac braldebulsa da mis damcvels ar miecaTSesaZlebloba, daekiTxaT mowme.
3. saapelacio sasamarTloSi saqmis ganxilvis dros mow-mis saxiT daikiTxa d. f-i, romelmac aCvena, rom 2005 wlisivnisSi, miRebuli operatiuli informaciis safuZvelze,rom n. b-e eweoda narkotikuli saSualebis SeZena-Senax-vas, es ukanaskneli or Tanmxleb pirTan erTad dakavebuliqna q. T-i, rogorc axsovs, veris mimdebare teritoriaze.n. b-a da mis Tanmxleb pirebs adgilze CautardaT piradiCxreka, Tumca araferi kanonsawinaaRmdego ar aRmoaCndaT.amis Semdeg vakeSi Caatares n. b-s sacxovrebeli binis Cxre-ka. binaSi rom Sevidnen, TviTon n. b-m Cxrekis dawyebamdewarmoadgina TeTri abis natexebi, sul 5-dan 10 natexamdeiyo, romlebic oTaxidan gamoitana. amis Semdeg daiwyes bi-nis Cxreka, ra drosac saZinebel oTaxSi mdgari tumbosujridan amoRebul iqna 100 abze meti narkotikuli saSu-aleba `suboteqsi~. n. b-m aRiara, rom es narkotikebi iyomisi da moawera xeli Cxrekis oqms. gamomZiebelma adgil-ze daluqa narkotikebi. n. b-s dakavebasa da binis CxrekaSiaseve monawileobdnen gamomZiebeli g. g-e da operatiuliTanamSromeli l. g-a. rogorc icis, aRniSnuli sacxovre-beli bina iyo n. b-s meuRlis, sadac TviTon b-c cxovrob-da. Cxrekas eswreboda binis mepatrone qalbatoni _ n. b-smeuRle. mowmis ganmartebiT, n. b-s Sesaxeb miRebuli ope-ratiuli informaciis safuZvelze Seadgina pataki. n. b-smier warmodgenili abis natexebi gaxveuli iyo TeTri fe-ris qaRaldSi.
4. garda d. f-s Cvenebisa, n. b-s mier saqarTvelos ssk-is260-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtiT gaTvaliswinebu-li danaSaulis Cadenis faqti dadgenili da dadasture-bulia pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi saqmis ganxilvisdros gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebiT, kerZod:
5. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma g. g-m aCvena, rom iyo n. b-ssaqmis gamomZiebeli. b-s Sesaxeb operatiuli informaciamiiRo operatiulma samsaxurma. n. b-e daakaves q-s quCaze.
240
mas da mis Tanmxleb pirebs adgilze CautardaT piradiCxreka. amis Semdeg gaiCxrika n. b-s sacxovrebeli bina a-squCaze, sadac viRac qalebic imyofebodnen. Cxrekis oqmimisi Sedgenilia, romlis Sinaarssac adasturebs. n. b-m nar-kotikebi saidan warmoadgina, aRar axsovs. Cxrekis drosdamswreebis mowveva savaldebulo ar iyo. vinmes rom mo-eTxova Cxrekaze daswreba da ar daaswres, aseTi faqti armomxdara. n. b-s binis Cxrekisas aranairi pretenzia ar ga-mouTqvams. b-s damswreebi rom moeTxova, daaswrebdnen.nivTmtkiceba ramden konvertSi dailuqa, ar axsovs.
6. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma i. x-a daadastura, rom, ro-gorc damxmare gamomZiebelma, monawileoba miiRo n. b-s da-kavebasa da sacxovrebeli binis CxrekaSi, ra drosac amo-Rebul iqna narkotikuli saSualeba `suboteqsi~, romlisnawilic danawevrebuli abebis saxiT b-m nebayoflobiTwarmoadgina. amoRebuli narkotikebi moTavsebul iqna orpaketSi, erTSi moTavsda nebayoflobiT warmodgenilinivTiereba, meoreSi _ Cxrekis Sedegad amoRebuli. es oripaketi moTavsda erT konvertSi da rogorc axsovs, ase ga-daigzavna eqspertizaze. b-s da misi ojaxis wevr viRac go-gonas, romelic Cxrekas eswreboda, aranairi pretenzia arganucxadebiaT, maT xeli moaweres Cxrekis oqms.
13. saqmis masalebiT ar dasturdeba is faqtobrivi ga-remoeba, rom sacxovrebeli binis Cxrekisas n. b-e da misisacole m. s-i iTxovdnen damswreebis mowvevas Cxrekis Ca-tarebis dros. orive maTgani xels awers sacxovrebeli bi-nis Cxrekis oqms, riTac faqtobrivad adastureben aRniS-nuli sagamoZiebo moqmedebis Catarebis faqts, mimdina-reobasa da Sedegebs. oqmis mixedviT, arc n. b-s da arc m. s-s ar gamouTqvamT raime SeniSvna an pretenzia CxrekasTandakavSirebiT.