This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
s i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l is i s x l i s s a m a r T a l i
z o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z oz o g a d i d a k e r Z o
n a w i l e b in a w i l e b in a w i l e b in a w i l e b in a w i l e b i
krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis mniSvne-lovani gadawyvetilebebi. am da sxva saqmeTa moZebna SesaZle-belia saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos veb-gverdze:http://www.supremecourt.ge/default.aspx?sec_id=133&lang=1
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rom sa-kasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, xolo gasaCiv-rebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg garemoe-baTa gamo:
samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palatam Seiswavla msjavrdebul S. k-s saq-
mis masalebi, Seamowma Tbilisis vake-saburTalos raionu-li prokuraturis prokuror daviT kapanaZis, msjavrde-bul S. k-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat e. m-s sakasa-cio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom isini ar un-da dakmayofildes, Tumca ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvli-leba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio pala-tis motivebs, rom sasamarTlo sxdomaze mxareTa Sejib-rebiTobisa da Tanasworobis principis safuZvelze gamok-vleuli mtkicebulebebis Sefasebis Sedegad gonivruleWvs miRma standartiT ver dadasturda S. k-s braleulo-ba saqarTvelos ssk-is 179 muxlis me-4 nawilis `b~ qvepun-qtiT wardgenil braldebaSi.
3. braldebis mxare apelirebs mowmeebis _ l. s-sa da g.g-s Cvenebebze da aRniSnavs, rom maTi Cvenebebi sxva mtki-cebulebebTan erToblivad, adasturebs S. k-s mier yaCa-Robis Cadenis faqts, rac marTebulad ar gaiziara saape-lacio palatam da miuTiTa: marTalia, mowmeebma _ l. s-mda g. g-m sasamarTlo sxdomaze daadastures yaCaRuri Tav-dasxmis faqti, magram ganmartes, rom ar SeuZliaT Tav-damsxmelis amocnoba, radgan ar daunaxavT misi saxe, vina-idan igi TavdasxmisTanave, ramdenime wamSi gaiqca. l. s-maseve ganmarta, rom ar daunaxavs sagani, romelic Tavdam-sxmelma mas miabjina. amdenad, faqtis TviTmxilvelma pi-rebma sasamarTlos ver misces utyuari da damajerebeliCvenebebi danaSaulis Camdeni piris Sesaxeb da ver daa-
13
dastures faqti, rom Tavdamsxmeli namdvilad S. k-e iyo.4. prokuroris kidev erT argumentTan dakavSirebiT,
rom sasamarTlom saTanadod ar Seafasa odorologiurida biologiuri eqspertizis daskvnebi da eqspertTa Cve-nebebi, romelTa Tanaxmad, dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 8seqtembers ... q. #...-is ... sadarbazos asasvleli kibis sa-fexurebidan aRebuli sunis kvali S. k-sgan aRebuli suniskvalis nimuSis identuria, xolo SemTxvevis adgilidanamoRebuli sigaretis namwvze arsebuli biologiuri masa-lis genetikuri profili da S. k-s genetikuri profiliidenturia, saapelacio palatam aseve sworad ganmarta: aR-niSnuli eqspertizis daskvnebiTa da eqspertTa Cvenebe-biT marTlac dasturdeba SemTxvevis adgilis siaxlovesS. k-s yofnis faqti, rac aseve dasturdeba saqmis masaleb-Si moTavsebuli gare sameTvalyureo kamerebis Canawere-biTa da taqsis mZRol z. k-s CvenebiT, romelmac amoicnoS. k-e da daadastura, rom 2015 wlis 8 seqtembers, daaxlo-ebiT 20:00 saaTidan, 21:00 saaTamde drois SualedSi, ... q.#...-is mimdebare teritoriaze gaaCera S. k-m da mosTxova... quCaze wayvana. Sesabamisad, saxezea mtkicebulebaTa er-Toblioba, romliTac marTlac dasturdeba, rom S.k-e im-yofeboda SemTxvevis adgilis mimdebare quCebze, magrames mtkicebulebebi ver akmayofilebs yaCaRobis CadenaSigamamtyunebeli ganaCenis gamotanisaTvis mtkicebuleba-Ta sakmarisobisa da gonivrul eWvs miRma dawesebul ma-Ral samarTlebriv standarts. konkretuli piris yofnasazogadoebrivi mimosvlis adgilze _ quCaSi, TavisTavadar niSnavs faqtis utyuarad dadasturebas, rom imave ad-gilas momxdari danaSauli aRniSnuli piris Cadenilia, Tu-ki gamovlenili ar aris sxva mtkicebulebac. rogorc aRi-niSna, TviTmxilvelma mowmeebma ver SeZles danaSaulisCamdeni piris danaxva da amocnoba, xolo sxva pirdapirimtkicebuleba, romelic daadasturebda, rom yaCaRobauSualod S. k-s Cadenilia, saqmis masalebSi ar moipoveba.
5. saqarTvelos konstituciis me-40 muxlis Tanaxmad,gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni unda emyarebodes mxolod ut-yuar mtkicebulebebs. yovelgvari eWvi, romelic ver das-turdeba kanoniT dadgenili wesiT, unda gadawydes bral-debulis sasargeblod.
8. zemoaRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, yaCaRobis epizod-Si S. k-s mimarT wardgenili braldeba ar emyareba eWvisgamomricxav, urTierTSeTanxmebul da sakmaris mtkice-bulebaTa erTobliobas. mocemul SemTxvevaSi braldebismxaris mier warmodgenili mtkicebulebebi aris arasar-wmuno, aradamajerebeli, urTierTSeuTanxmebeli da maTSoris arsebobs, winaaRmdegobebi, ris gamoc, arsebuli eW-vi unda gadawydes braldebulis sasikeTod.
9. rac Seexeba S. k-Tvis Seracxuli braldebis kidev erT,Zarcvis epizods, sakasacio palata am SemTxvevaSic izia-rebs saapelacio palatis motivebs, rom gamokveTilia go-nivrul eWvs miRma arsebul SeTanxmebul mtkicebuleba-Ta erToblioba, romliTac utyuarad dasturdeba, rom S.k-m Caidina saqarTvelos ssk-is 178-e muxlis me-4 nawilis`g~ qvepunqtiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSauli, Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
10. mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli, dazaralebul q. i-s Cvene-biT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs fsiqotropul afTiaqSi far-macevtad. 2015 wlis 30 oqtombers, daaxloebiT 00:30 sa-aTze, afTiaqis fanjris gisosTan mivida daaxloebiT 24-25 wlis mamakaci, romelic iyo maRali, Savgvremani, hqon-da wveri. mas ecva tyavis Savi qurTuki da jinsis Sarvali.am pirma mosTxova ori abi saZile preparati `...~, Tan aCvena100 (as) lariani kupiura da uTxra, rom xurdac Tan wamoe-Ro. rodesac mivida JaluzTan, xelSi eWira xurda _ 70 la-ri da ori abi `...~, ra drosac axalgazrda mamakacma mou-lodnelad xeli Seyo JaluzSi, gamostaca fuli, prepara-
15
ti da gaiqca. q. i-m daiwyo yvirili, gaqceul pirs daedev-nen quCaSi myofi biWebi. daaxloebiT 10 wuTSi masTan mivi-da piri, romelmac uTxra, rom gzis meore mxridan daina-xa, rom piri, romelmac fuli gastaca, iyo S. k-e da aseveuTxra, rom ar daereka policiaSi da Tavad daubrunebdaTanxas. q. i-m aseve ganmarta, rom monawileobda piris amoc-nobaSi da is darwmunebulia, rom piri, romelic amoicno,namdvilad is aris, vinc gaZarcva. mas gaqcevisas didxansuyurebda da daamaxsovrda.
11. mowme n. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom is aris Tbili-sis policiis departamentis vake-saburTalos sammarTve-los policiis me-... ganyofilebis ubnis inspeqtor-gamom-Ziebeli. anonimuri pirisagan miiRo informacia afTiaqSimomxdari Zarcvis faqtze, rac miawoda xelmZRvanels.
12. mowme g. v-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs vake-saburTalos me-... ganyofilebaSi, sadac 2015 wlis 30 oq-tombers Sevida Setyobineba ... quCaze q. i-s gaZarcvis faq-tTan dakavSirebiT. gamomZiebelma n. m-m miiRo operatiu-li informacia danaSaulis SesaZlo Camden pirze. g. v-e damisi TanamSromeli m-i gavidnen ... quCaze #...-Si. iq misvli-sas SeniSnes S. k-e, romelic daakaves. braldebulis Cxre-kis Sedegad qurTukis Siga jibidan amoiRes ori abi saZi-le preparati `...~, maT Soris 1 gaxsnili; Sarvlis jibidanamoiRes fuli _ 25 lari, kerZod: erTi oclariani da erTixuTlariani kupiura. Cxrekis dros S. k-s winaaRmdegobaar gauwevia.
13. 2015 wlis 30 oqtombris braldebulis piradi Cxre-kis oqmis Tanaxmad, TbilisSi, ... q. #...-is mimdebare teri-toriaze, S. k-sgan amoiRes fuladi Tanxa da 1 abi `...~.
14. piris amocnobis oqmis mixedviT, amomcnobma pirmaq. i-m amoicno S. k-e, romelmac gastaca fuli da ori abi ̀ ...~.amomcnobma ganmarta, rom amosacnobi piri amoicno simaR-liT, asakiT, saxis nakvTebiT _ mogrZo gauparsavi pirisa-xiT, mokled SeWrili TmiT, moyavisfro TvalebiT, moz-rdili, odnav kexiani cxviriT, saSualo zomis tuCebiT.
arasando da bundovani.16. sakasacio palata iziarebs saapelacio instanciis
sasamarTlos Sefasebas dazaralebul q. i-s mier pirveliinstanciis sasamarTloSi micemul CvenebasTan dakavSire-biT, rom mis sisworeSi eWvis Setanis safuZveli ar arse-bobs, vinaidan q. i-m damajereblad ganmarta, rom rode-sac man JaluzTan miitana 70 lari xurda da ori abi medika-menti `...~, pirma Seyo JaluzSi xeli, gamostaca fuli dapreparati da gaiqca. igi gaqceuls kargad daakvirda dadaamaxsovrda. amasTan, man araerTxel ganmarta, rom amoc-nobis dros darwmunebuli iyo, rom mis mier amocnobilipiri swored is iyo, vinc gaZarcva da amosacnobi piri dar-wmunebiT amoicno.
17. garda amisa, dazaralebul q. i-s Cveneba, romelmacdetalurad da damajereblad ganmarta SemTxvevis drosganviTarebuli movlenebi, srulad Seesabameba saqmeSiwarmodgenil sxva mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobas, kerZod:piris amocnobis oqms, romlis Tanaxmadac, q. i-m amoicno S.k-e; mowme g. v-s Cvenebas, romelmac ganmarta, rom n. m-TanerTad daakava S. k-e, romelsac Cxrekis Sedegad qurTukisSiga jibidan amouRes saZile preparati ̀ ...~ da 25 lari; 2015wlis 30 oqtombris braldebulis dakavebis oqms, romlisTanaxmad, TbilisSi, ... q. #...-is mimdebare teritoriaze, S.k-sgan amoiRes fuli da 1 abi `...~.
18. aseve usafuZvloa dacvis mxaris argumentacia pi-ris amocnobis oqmis gauziareblobasTan dakavSirebiT imsafuZvliT, rom amocnobis oqmSi ar yofila gamokveTilida naCvenebi, Tu konkretulad romeli maxasiaTebelihqonda amosacnob pirs iseTi, rac ar hqondaT sxva pirebsda gamoarCevda maTgan. saapelacio palatam sworad miu-TiTa, rom sagamoZiebo moqmedebis _ amocnobis Catarebisdros srulad iyo daculi saproceso kanonmdeblobismoTxovnebi; amocnoba Catarda saqarTvelos sssk-is 131-emuxlis moTxovnaTa sruli dacviT, amocnobamde amomcno-bi _ q. i-i daikiTxa amosacnobi obieqtis individualuriniSan-Tvisebebis Taobaze da amocnobisas amomcnobma gan-marta, Tu ra niSan-TvisebebiT amoicno amosacnobi obieq-ti _ S. k-e. amocnobisas aseve daculi iyo saqarTvelos sssk-is 131-e muxlis me-3 nawilis moTxovna da amomcnobs amo-sacnobi piri waredgina imave sqesis or pirTan erTad, rom-
17
lebic garegnobiT da tansacmliT erTmaneTisa da amosac-nobi pirisagan mkveTrad ar gansxvavdebodnen. rac Seexe-ba advokatis ganmartebas, rom amocnobis oqmSi ar yofilaaRniSnuli, Tu ra hqonda S. k-s iseTi, rac sxva amosacnobipirisagan ganasxvavebda, usafuZvloa, vinaidan aseT daT-qmas da moTxovnas saproceso kanonmdebloba ar iTvalis-winebs.
19. amdenad, saapelacio palatam sworad Seafasa mow-mis saxiT dakiTxuli, dazaralebul q. i-s Cveneba da miiC-nia, rom misi Cvenebis realurobis saeWvod miCnevis safuZ-veli ar arsebobs, vinaidan igi srulad aris Tanxvdenilisaqmeze Sekrebil sxva utyuar da relevantur mtkicebu-lebebTan da naTlad warmoaCens danaSaulis Cadenis mo-mentSi ganviTarebuli movlenebis realur suraTs. pala-tam aseve miuTiTa: is garemoeba, rom mowmem amocnobazemyofi gamomZiebeli miamsgavsa msjavrdebulis advokats(Tumca, aRniSnuli kategoriuli mtkicebiT ar ganucxade-bia), ar warmoadgens misi Cvenebisa da amocnobis oqmis ga-uziareblobis safuZvels.
e. a-s yofaqcevaze kontroli gamosacdeli vadis peri-odSi daevala probaciis biuros msjavrdebulis sacxov-rebeli adgilis mixedviT.
v. i-s (1000 lari), e. a-s (1000 lari), b. b-s (1000 lari), r. m-s (1000 lari) mimarT aRkveTis RonisZiebis _ giraos saxiTgadaxdili Tanxa unda daubrundes maT Semtan pirebs.
2. aRniSnuli ganaCeniT v. i-s, b. b-s, r. m-sa da e. a-s msjav-ri daedoT samsaxurebriv gulgrilobaSi, ese igi moxelismier Tavisi samsaxurebrivi movaleobis arajerovnad Ses-rulebaSi misdami daudevari damokidebulebis gamo, ra-mac saxelmwifos kanonieri interesebis arsebiTi darRve-va gamoiwvia, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelossisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 342-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT.
maT mimarT bralad Seracxuli qmedebebi gamoixataSemdegSi:
miuxedavad kanonis msgavsi moTxovnisa, ... municipali-tetis sakrebulos fizikuri da kerZo samarTlis iuridi-uli pirebis mflobelobaSi (sargeblobaSi) arsebul miwisnakveTebze sakuTrebis uflebis aRiarebis komisiis Tav-jdomarem _ v. i-m komisiis sxva wevrebTan: n. b-sTan, r. m-Tan, b. b-sa da e. a-Tan erTad, a. W-s gancxadebis ganxilvi-sas arajerovnad Seasrula samsaxurebrivi movaleoba mis-dami daudevari damokidebulebis gamo, saTanadod ar ga-moikvlia gancxadebaze TandarTuli dokumentebi, ar ga-iTvaliswina is garemoeba, rom a. W-s mier TviTneburad da-kavebul miwis nakveTze ar iyo ganTavsebuli sacxovrebe-li saxli (aSenebuli an dangreuli) an arasacxovrebeli da-niSnulebis Senoba (aSenebuli) da komisiis wevrebTn er-Tad miiRo gadawyvetileba gancxadebis dakmayofilebisSesaxeb.
daniSnulebis miwis nakveTi, romelzedac ganTavsebuliasacxovrebeli saxli (aSenebuli an dangreuli) an arasac-xovrebeli daniSnulebis Senoba (aSenebuli).
miuxedavad kanonis msgavsi moTxovnisa, …..municipali-tetis sakrebulos fizikuri da kerZo samarTlis iuridi-uli pirebis mflobelobaSi (sargeblobaSi) arsebul miwisnakveTebze sakuTrebis uflebis aRiarebis komisiis Tav-jdomarem _ v. i-m komisiis sxva wevrebTan: n. b-Tan, r. m-Tan, b. b-sa da e. a-Tan erTad, m. d-s gancxadebis ganxilvi-sas arajerovnad Seasrula samsaxurebrivi movaleoba mis-dami daudevari damokidebulebis gamo, saTanadod ar ga-moikvlia gancxadebaze TandarTuli dokumentebi, ar ga-iTvaliswina is garemoeba, rom m. d-s mier TviTneburad da-kavebul miwis nakveTze ar iyo ganTavsebuli sacxovrebe-li saxli (aSenebuli an dangreuli) an arasacxovrebeli da-niSnulebis Senoba (aSenebuli) da komisiis wevrebTn er-Tad miiRo gadawyvetileba gancxadebis dakmayofilebisSesaxeb.
saqarTvelos kanonis `fizikuri da kerZo samarTlisiuridiuli pirebis mflobelobaSi (sargeblobaSi) arsebulmiwis nakveTebze sakuTrebis uflebis aRiarebis Sesaxeb~me-2 muxlis `g~ qvepunqtis Tanaxmad, TviTneburad daka-vebul miwas warmoadgens dasaxelebuli kanonis amoqme-debamde fizikuri piris mier TviTneburad dakavebuli sa-xelmwifo sakuTrebis sasoflo an arasasoflo-sameurneodaniSnulebis miwis nakveTi, romelzedac ganTavsebuliasacxovrebeli saxli (aSenebuli an dangreuli) an arasac-xovrebeli daniSnulebis Senoba (aSenebuli).
26
miuxedavad kanonis msgavsi moTxovnisa,…..municipali-tetis sakrebulos fizikuri da kerZo samarTlis iuridi-uli pirebis mflobelobaSi (sargeblobaSi) arsebul miwisnakveTebze sakuTrebis uflebis aRiarebis komisiis Tav-jdomarem _ v. i-m komisiis sxva wevrebTan: n. b-Tan, r. m-Tan, b. b-sa da e. a-Tan erTad, v. m-s gancxadebis ganxilvi-sas arajerovnad Seasrula samsaxurebrivi movaleoba mis-dami daudevari damokidebulebis gamo, saTanadod ar ga-moikvlia gancxadebaze TandarTuli dokumentebi, ar ga-iTvaliswina is garemoeba, rom v. m-s mier TviTneburad da-kavebul miwis nakveTze ar iyo ganTavsebuli sacxovrebe-li saxli (aSenebuli an dangreuli) an arasacxovrebeli da-niSnulebis Senoba (aSenebuli) da komisiis wevrebTn er-Tad miiRo gadawyvetileba gancxadebis dakmayofilebisSesaxeb.
nakveTebze sakuTrebis uflebis aRiarebis komisiis Tav-jdomarem _ v. i-m komisiis sxva wevrebTan: n. b-Tan, r. m-Tan, b. b-sa da e-e a-Tan erTad, o. x-s gancxadebis ganxilvi-sas arajerovnad Seasrula samsaxurebrivi movaleoba mis-dami daudevari damokidebulebis gamo, saTanadod ar ga-moikvlia gancxadebaze TandarTuli dokumentebi, ar ga-iTvaliswina is garemoeba, rom o. x-s mier TviTneburad da-kavebul miwis nakveTze ar iyo ganTavsebuli sacxovrebe-li saxli (aSenebuli an dangreuli) an arasacxovrebeli da-niSnulebis Senoba (aSenebuli) da komisiis wevrebTn er-Tad miiRo gadawyvetileba gancxadebis dakmayofilebisSesaxeb.
2014 wlis 27 ivniss zemoaRniSnuli gadawyvetilebis sa-fuZvelze v. i-s mier gaica sakuTrebis uflebis mowmoba,ris Semdgomac o. x-m sajaro reestrSi daikanona 2200 m2
5. gasaCivrebuli ganaCenis faqtobrivi da samar-Tlebrivi dasabuTeba:
e. a-s, v. i-s, b. b-sa da r. m-Tvis Seracxuli braldebebidadasturebulia saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebiT,romlebic dacvis mxares sadavod ar gauxdia da mxareTaSeTanxmebis safuZvelze, gamokvlevis gareSe iqna miRe-buli, romlebic saqarTvelos sssk-is 73-e muxlis `d~ qve-punqtis Sesabamisad, mieniWa preiudiciuli mniSvneloba.
29
kerZod: mowmeebis _ s. d-s, e. a-s, o. x-s, n. s-s, v. m-s, n. j-s,T. x-s, g. k-s, g. a-s, v.a-s, a. W-s, m. d-s, g. s-s, e. a-s, z. m-s, m. a-s, a. a-s, z. c-s, k. g-s, b. b-s, n. b-s, r. m-s, v. i-s dakiTxvisoqmebiT, ... municipalitetis sakrebulodan da sajaro re-estridan amoRebuli dokumentaciiT, eqspertizis das-kvnebiT, daTvalierebis oqmebiTa da saqmeSi arsebul sxva,erTmaneTTan SeTanxmebul mtkicebulebaTa erToblio-biT.
saapelacio palatam ar gaiziara braldebis mxaris saa-pelacio saCivris moTxovna v. i-s, e. a-s, b. b-sa da r. m-ssaqarTvelos ssk-is 342-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT gaTvalis-winebuli danaSaulis CadenaSi Svid epizodSi cal-calkedamnaSaved cnobis Taobaze, vinaidan samsaxurebriv gul-grilobas umetes SemTxvevaSi sistematuri xasiaTi aqvsda igi vlindeba mTel rig konkretul moqmedebaTa Seus-ruleblobasa an arajerovnad SesrulebaSi, rac ar qmnisdanaSaulis araerTgzisobas, aramed mas gangrZobadi xa-siaTi aqvs.
modgenili saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rom saka-sacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilobriv da gasa-Civrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg gare-moebaTa gamo:
bas xeliT miayenebda Tu sxva sagniT da aseve is garemoeba,Tu ra simZimis iqneboda dazianeba, saqarTvelos ssk-is3531-e muxlis me-2 nawiliT kvalifikaciisaTvis mniSvne-lovani garemoeba ar aris. prokurori im garemoebis sai-lustraciod, rom g. q-am xelyo policielis janmrTelo-ba mis samsaxurebriv saqmianobasTan dakavSirebiT, uTi-Tebs g. q-as warsulSi araerT nasamarTlobasa da gacemulSemakavebel orderebze. aRniSnulis gamo, g. q-as uaryo-fiTi damokidebuleba hqonda policiis TanamSromlebismimarT.
3. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrdebul-ma p. s-m da misma interesebis damcvelma, advokatma m. n-m.apelantebma iTxoves zugdidis raionuli sasamarTlos2017 wlis 30 ianvris ganaCenis gauqmeba da p. s-s mimarTgamamarTlebeli ganaCenis gamotana, vinaidan ganaCeni arisukanono da dausabuTebelia; p. s-s bralad Seracxuli qme-deba ar Caudenia; saqmeSi ar arsebobs misi braldebis da-madasturebeli mtkicebulebebi.
modgenili saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rom saka-sacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilobriv, xolo ga-saCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
51
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos motivacias p. s-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis `a~ da me-4 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtebiT msjav-rdebis nawilSi da miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi dautyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivrul eWvs miR-ma dasturdeba, rom p. s-m namdvilad Caidina gasaCivrebu-li ganaCeniT misTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedeba, rasac sa-davod arc kasatori xdis sakasacio saCivarSi.
3. amasTan, sakasacio palata nawilobriv iziarebs kasa-toris pozicias misTvis Sefardebuli sasjelis Semsubu-qebis Sesaxeb da imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom mas ar gaaCniapasuxismgeblobis damamZimebeli garemoebebi, xasiaTde-ba dadebiTad da amasTan, aqvs mZime ekonomikuri da oja-xuri garemoebebi (hyavs avadmyofi deda da meuRle, rom-lebic mis kmayofaze imyofebodnen), samarTliani iqnebap. s-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 59-e muxlis me-5 nawilis safuZ-velze ganaCenTa erTobliobiT, wina ganaCeniT daniSnulisasjelis mouxdeli nawilis nawilobriv damateba bologanaCeniT daniSnul sajelze da, Sesabamisad, saboloosasjelis Semsubuqeba.
sasamarTlo valdebuli iyo, saqarTvelos ssk-is 67-emuxlis me-5 nawilisa da 59-e muxlis danawesis safuZvel-ze S. d-s sasjeli Seefardebina ganaCenTa erTobliobiT,vinaidan dadgenilia, rom man axali danaSauli Caidina ga-mosacdeli vadis periodSi.
apelantma aseve aRniSna, rom msjavrdebulisaTvis gan-sazRvruli sasjeli ver uzrunvelyofda sasjelis miz-nebs, radgan sasamarTlom sasjelis Sefardebisas ar ga-iTvaliswina misi qonebrivi mdgomareoba, kerZod is faq-ti, rom S. d-s ar hqonda gadaxdili misTvis Sefardebuligiraos Tanxa _ 1000 lari, radgan ar gaaCnda amis materia-luri SesaZlebloba.
6. palata ver gaiziarebs kasatoris moTxovnas adamianisuflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlosTvis sakonsultaciodaskvnis Taobaze mimarTvis Sesaxeb, vinaidan sakiTxi arexeba konvenciiTa da misi damatebiTi oqmebiT gaTvaliswi-nebuli uflebebis ganmartebasa da gamoyenebas, ra drosacSesaZlebelia, mizanSewonilad mieCnia aRniSnuli moTxov-na. amasTan, palata miuTiTebs, rom `saqarTvelos sisxlissamarTlis saproceso kodeqsSi cvlilebis Setanis Sesaxeb~saqarTvelos 2015 wlis 29 maisis kanonis Sesabamisad, sa-qarTvelos sssk-is 3041-e muxli (romliTac gaTvaliswine-bulia adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlosTvis sa-konsultacio daskvnis Taobaze mimarTvis ufleba) amoq-meddeba adamianis uflebaTa da ZiriTad TavisuflebaTadacvis konvenciis me-16 oqmis saqarTvelos mimarT amoqme-debisTanave. dReis mdgomareobiT, xsenebuli oqmi ar arisamoqmedebuli, ris gamoc, palata kanonismieradac mokle-bulia SesaZleblobas, isargeblos saqarTvelos sssk-is3041-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli procedurebiT.
7. sakasacio palata ar dgas aseve sakonstitucio sasa-marTlosadmi mimarTvis saWiroebis winaSe, vinaidan ar mi-iCnevs, rom mis mier gamosayenebeli kanoni ewinaaRmdgebasaqarTvelos konstitucias. amasTan, ganumartavs kasa-tors, rom Tavad msjavrdebuli ar aris SezRuduli, mi-marTos sakonstitucio sasamarTlos im normaTa konsti-tuciurobis Semowmebis Sesaxeb, romlebic, misi mosazre-biT, arRvevs konstituciiT garantirebul mis uflebebs.
8. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasaciopalatas miaCnia, rom gasaCivrebuli ganCineba kanonieriada unda darCes ucvlelad.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida daskvnam-de, rom msjavrdebul v. S-is sakasacio saCivari unda dak-mayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. palatas miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi da ut-yuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivrul eWvs miRmadasturdeba msjavrdebul v. S-is mier qurdobisa (ori epi-zodi) da kompiuterul sistemaSi unebarTvod SeRwevisfaqti, rasac arc mxareebi xdian sadavod.
76
3. amasTan, sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba saapelaciosasamarTlos v. S-is qmedebis saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e mux-lis me-4 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT _ qurdoba Cadenili imismier, vinc orjer an metjer iyo nasamarTlevi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebisaTvis (oriepizodi) _ dakvalificirebis nawilSi Semdeg garemoeba-Ta gamo:
ganaCeniT i. k., _ cnobil iqna udanaSaulod da gamarTldasaqarTvelos ssk-is 111-19-108-e muxliT wardgenil bral-debaSi; i. k-is mimarT SerCeuli aRkveTis RonisZieba gauq-mda. i. k-s ganemarta, rom ufleba aqvs, aunazRaurdes mi-yenebuli ziani.
kasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma sa-Civris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom sakasacio saCivrismoTxovna unda dakmayofildes da i. k-is mimarT dadgeni-li gamamarTlebeli ganaCeni unda gauqmdes Semdeg gare-moebaTa gamo:
2. sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas dazarale-bulma z. k-ma ganacxada, rom 2015 wlis 30 aprils imyofe-boda k-is raionis sofel q. g-Si da dilidan exmareboda
81
Tanasoflel b. m-s xexilis gasxvlaSi. mas saxlidan Tan wa-Rebuli hqonda ori dana. muSaobisas daniT daiziana xeli,ris gamoc xexilis gasxvlas Tavi daaneba da b. m-is saxlSidaiwyo aryis daleva. daaxloebiT 17:00 saaTze maTTan mi-vida Tavisi Svili i. k., romelmac agreTve miiRo alkoho-luri sasmeli. Sebindebisas, vinaidan gawvimda, i-Tan er-Tad wavida Tavisi sacxovrebeli saxlis mimarTulebiT, radrosac gaaxsenda, rom danebi darCa b. m-Tan da Svils sTxo-va dabrunebuliyo maT wamosaRebad, TviTon ki Sevida sax-lSi. oTaxSi Sesvlisas sibneleSi fexiT wamoedo karis Car-Cos, ris gamoc Tavi ver Seikava da mkerdiT daeca Sesas-vlelTan mdgar magidaze, romelzec ewyo naxevrad daw-nuli kalaTebi, basri piris mqone nergis wnelebiT. am drosxelSi eWira sasxlavi makrateli. fexze adgomis Semdegkvlav daeca zurgiT. orive SemTxvevaSi sxeulze miiRomravlobiTi dazianebebi, mosdioda sisxli, magram dasax-mareblad aravisTvis miumarTavs. mogvianebiT saswrafo-samedicino daxmarebis brigadam igi saavadmyofoSi gada-iyvana. z. k-is CvenebiT, misTvis i. k-s dazianebebi ar miu-yenebia. Tavdapirvelad z. k-ma ganacxada, rom misi SvilisaxlSi ar mobrunebula da ar icoda, danebi wamoiRo Tuara; SemdgomSi ki manve ganmarta, rom saavadmyofoSi way-vanis dros dainaxa, rom misi Svili karSi Semodioda da,mgoni, waiqca kidevac.
3. mowme z. m-ma gamoZiebis dros micemuli Cveneba uar-yo, rom TiTqos, i. k-sagan Seityo misi mamis _ z. k-is daWrisSesaxeb. mowmem ganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 1 maiss, RamiT, k-is raionis sofel q. g-Si mdebare z. k-is saxlTan mivida,sadac imyofebodnen policiis muSakebi da saswrafo-sa-medicino daxmarebis brigada. z. k. mas ar unaxavs da misidaWris Sesaxeb i. k-sac araferi ganucxadebia.
4. mowme e. k-ma ganmarta, rom cxovrobs T-Si ZmasTan _ i.k-Tan erTad, xolo maTi mama z. k. marto cxovrobs k-is ra-ionis sofel q. g-Si. 2016 wlis 30 aprils igi T-Si, Tavissacxovrebel saxlSi imyofeboda, xolo i. k. diliT gavidasaxlidan da rogorc Semdeg Seityo, wavida sofelSi. gvi-an saRamos z. k-is mezoblad mcxovrebma naTesavma n. k-matelefoniT Seatyobina, rom mamamisi iyo cudad, kerZod,xmas ar scemda da iyo sisxliani. sagangebo situaciebis sam-saxuris nomerze 112-ze darekviT, z. k-saTvis daxmarebis
82
aRmosaCenad man gamoiZaxa saswrafo samedicino daxmare-bis brigada, TviTon ki avtomanqaniT gaemgzavra soflismimarTulebiT da mivida qalaq k-is saavadmyofoSi, sadacnaxa z. k., romelmac mas ganucxada, rom sxeulze daziane-bebi miiRo wnelebze dacemis Sedegad.
5. mowme n. k-is mier sasamarTloSi micemuli CvenebiTdadgenilia, rom igi aris z. k-is Zmiscoli da cxovrobenerT saxlSi, romelsac gaaCnia sxvadasxva Sesasvleli. 2015wlis 30 aprils imyofeboda saxlSi, ra drosac Ramis saa-TebSi (zusti dro ar icis) z. k-is oTaxidan moesma dacemisxma. igi Sevida z. k-is oTaxSi da naxa, rom igi iwva sawolSi.man SesasvlelTan sisxlis kvali SeniSna, z. k-s hkiTxa, xomaraferi sWirdeboda da saswrafo samedicino daxmarebisgamoZaxeba SesTavaza, magram uari miiRo. z. k-ma uTxra, romwnelze daeca, magram Tavs kargad grZnobda da daxmare-bas ar saWiroebda. n. k-ma daureka z. k-is Svils, e. k-s, ro-melsac Seatyobina, Tu ra mdgomareobaSi imyofeboda ma-mamisi, Semdeg dauZaxa mezoblad mcxovreb l. g-s, radganTviTonac esaWiroeboda daxmareba. mogvianebiT, saswra-fo-samedicino daxmarebis brigadisa da policiis Tanam-Sromlebis gamocxadebis Semdeg, man dainaxa, rom z. k-issacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi Sevida i. k., romelic imyofe-boda z.a m-Tan erTad. ar daunaxavs, magram saubrebis mos-menis Sedegad mixvda, rom policiis TanamSromlebma i. k-sCautares Cxreka. n. k-ma agreTve ganmarta, rom z. k-Tan Cxu-bis an sxva konfliqtis Sesaxeb ar smenia da gaigona mxo-lod dacemis, kerZod, misi ganmartebiT _ `bragunis~ xma.
6. sasamarTloSi dakiTxvisas mowme l. g-ma daadastura,rom 2015 wlis 1 maiss, RamiT, n. k-is TxovniT z. k-is saxlSimivida, ra drosac oTaxSi, sadac z. k. iwva, Sesasvlel kar-Tan, iatakze, SeniSna sisxlis wveTebis kvali. mis kiTxva-ze, Tu ra daemarTa, z. k-ma upasuxa, rom araferi. ramdeni-me xnis Semdeg iq mividnen policiisa da saswrafo-samedi-cino daxmarebis brigadis TanamSromlebi, maT Soris _ ub-nis eqimi e. S., romelmac z. k-s gauwia pirveladi daxmareba.l. g-is CvenebiT, mas z. da i. k-bs Soris konfliqtis an Cxu-bis Sesaxeb araferi smenia da mxolod qalaq k-is saavad-myofoSi Seityo, rom z. k-is janmrTelobis dazianebis faq-tze dakavebuli iyo misi Svili i. k..
9. k-is samedicino centr `...~ qirurg z. p-is CvenebiTdadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 1 maiss igi, rogorc morige qi-rurgi, imyofeboda aRniSnul samedicino dawesebuleba-Si da asrulebda samsaxurebriv movaleobas, ra drosac01:25 saaTze saswrafo-samedicino daxmarebis samsaxurisbrigadam saavdmyofoSi miiyvana z. k., romelsac gulmker-dis wina, ukana zedapirze da kisris areSi aReniSnebodaneknTa rkalis doneze muclis RruSi Semavali ori Wri-loba. pacients Cautarda gadaudebeli operacia. mowmisganmartebiT, man ar icis, SeeZlo Tu ara z. k-s aRniSnulidazianebebi mieRo dacemis Sedegad.
10. Sinagan saqmeTa saministros k-is raionuli sammar-Tvelos ubnis inspeqtor-gamomZieblis S. q-sa da m. b-is mi-er sasamarTloSi micemuli CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom2015 wlis 1 maiss isini erTad asrulebdnen samsaxurebriv
84
movaleobas ra drosac, miiRes Setyobineba k-is raionissofel q. g-Si mcxovreb z. k-is daWris Sesaxeb. SemTxvevisadgilze misvlisas naxes, rom z. k-is sacxovrebeli saxlisiataki iyo sisxliT mosvrili, xolo igi iwva sawolze. S. q.da m. b. icavdnen SemTxvevis adgils, am dros maTTan mivi-da i. k., romelsac Sarvalsa da qurTukze aReniSneboda sis-xlis kvali. vinaidan hqondaT informacia i. k-is mier dana-Saulis SesaZlo Cadenis Sesaxeb, daakaves da Cautares pi-radi Cxreka, ris Sedegad, i. k-sgan amoiRes ori dana, rom-lebzec SeiniSneboda sisxlis msgavsi kvali.
11. sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas Sinagan saq-meTa saministros k-is raionuli sammarTvelos ubnis in-speqtor-gamomZiebelma g. m-ma daadastura danaSaulis Se-saZlo Camdeni piris Sesaxeb mis mier informaciis miRebisfaqti da ganmarta, rom 2015 wlis 1 maiss, Ramis saaTebSi,miiRo operatiuli informacia, rom k-is raionis sofel q.g-Si mcxovreb z. k-s janmrTelobis dazianeba miayena Ta-visma Svilma i. k-ma, romelic imyofeba sofel g-Si. miRe-buli informaciis Taobaze dauyovnebliv patakiT mimar-Ta policiis xelmZRvanelobas. meore dRes gamomZiebelg. x-sagan Seityo, rom mis mier miRebuli informacia da-dasturda.
12. sasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertis _ p. j-is Cvene-bebiTa da mis mier gacemuli #... eqspertis daskvnebiTdadgenilia Semdegi garemoebebi: z. k-s 2015 wlis 1 maisismiRebul travmasTan dakavSirebiT daudginda diagnozi:ori nakveTi Wriloba muclis areSi, Semavali muclis Rru-Si, RviZlis, ganivi kolinjis serozuli garsis, didi ba-deqonisa da diafragmis dazianebiT; erTi nakveTi Wrilo-ba kisris midamoSi da sami nakveTi Wriloba gulmkerdismarcxena naxevarSi, wina da ukana zedapirebze; mravlobi-Ti eqskoraciebi da Wrilobebi sxeulis sxvadasxva mida-moSi. dazianebebi nakveTi Wrilobebis saxiT miyenebuliaqvs raime mWreli sagnis moqmedebiT, eqskoraciebi _ mkvri-vi da blagvi sagnis moqmedebiT. muclis midamoSi arsebu-li Wrilobebi, vinaidan Semavalni arian muclis RruSi, ga-nekuTvneba sicocxlisaTvis saxifaTo mZime xarisxis da-zianebebs, xolo sxva dazianebebi, erTad aRebuli, miekuT-vneba janmrTelobis dazianebis msubuq xarisxs, janmrTe-lobis xanmokle moSliT;
19. biologiuri (genetikuri, serologiuri) eqsperti-zis #... daskvnis Tanaxmad, i. k-sgan amoRebul movercxlis-fro metalis danis pirsa da tarze, i. k-is kuTvnil jinsisSarvalze, TeTr Jaketze, botasis tipis marjvena fexsac-melze, SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebul obieqtebsa da z.k-is tansacmelze aRmoCnda adamianis sisxli, romelic ge-netikuri profilis mixedviT, z. k-is sisxlis identuria.i. k-is orive xelidan aRebul anawmendebsa da frCxilebzesisxli ar aRmoCnda.
20. nivTierebaTa, masalaTa, nakeTobaTa da mcenareTaeqspertizis #... daskvniT dadgenilia, rom i. k-is JaketzeaRmoCnda SemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebuli naqsovi Jile-tisa da maisuris qsovilebis analogiuri boWkoebi, xoloi. k-is danarCen tansacmelsa da frCxilebis gadanaWrebzeSemTxvevis adgilidan amoRebuli nivTebisa da z. k-is tan-sacmlis qsovilebis Semadgeneli boWkoebi ar aRmoCnda.
21. aRniSnuli eqspertizebis maT mier Catarebis faq-ti, eqspertizebis daskvnebis warmomavloba da avTentu-roba dadasturebulia eqspertebis _ q. g-is, T. S-is, n. n-is, n. k-isa da T. m-is mier sasamarTloSi micemuli Cvenebe-biT.
22. usafuZvloa dacvis mxaris pozicia, rom saqmeSi armoipoveba pirdapiri saxis mtkicebulebebi, romlebic mi-uTiTebda i. k-is mier danaSaulis Cadenaze. kasatoris mi-TiTebiT, dazaralebuls ar ganuxadebia, rom mas sxeulzearsebuli dazianebebi Svilma miayena da arc i. k-s ganumar-tavs, rom mama man daWra.
87
23. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom ojaxuri danaSau-li, misi bunebidan gamomdinare, mowmeTa simravliT ar ga-moirCeva. danaSaulis msxverpli SesaZloa, misi ojaxis wev-risaTvis sisxlissamarTlebrivi pasuxismgeblobis Tavi-dan aridebas cdilobdes, ris gamoc misi Cvenebis utyua-roba, saqmeSi arsebuli yvela faqtobrivi garemoebisa damtkicebulebis detaluri analiziT unda Sefasdes.
24. dazaralebulma z. k-ma Tavis sxeulze arsebuli da-zianebebi oTaxSi Sesvlisas sibneleSi waqceviTa da basripiris mqone nergis wnelebze dacemiT axsna. sakasacio pa-lata ver daeTanxmeba dazaralebulis ganmartebas, vinai-dan SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmiTa da mowme-Ta CvenebebiT (romlebsac daWril z. k-Tan pirveladi Se-xeba hqondaT) wnelebis SemTxvevis adgilze arsebobis faq-ti ar dasturdeba. k-is saswrafo-samedicino daxmarebissamsaxuris eqimis _ e. S-is Cvenebis Tanaxmad, SemTxvevisadgilas raime mWreli, basri sagani an/da wnelebi ar dau-naxavs. e. S-is ganmartebiT, dazaralebulma mas uTxra, romwnelebze daeca da rodesac Wriloba daumuSava, eWvi See-para mis warmoSobaSi. eqspertma p. j-em ganmarta, rom z. k-s nakveTi Wrilobebi hqonda, romelic SeiZleba iyos mWre-li sagniT, maT Soris, daniT miyenebuli. palata agreTveyuradRebas amaxvilebs dazianebebis simravleze, maT lo-kalizaciasa da zomebze, romelic agreTve saeWvos xdisdazaralebulis wnelebiT dazianebis faqts, kerZod, sa-medicino eqspertizis daskvnis Tanaxmad, z. k-s aReniSne-boda: ori nakveTi Wriloba mucelSi, sami, gulmkerdis are-Si, erTi, kisris midamoSi da mravlobiTi eqskoriaciebi daWrilobebi _ sxeulis sxvadasxva midamoSi, sxvadasxva, maTSoris 5X0.5, 4X1, 3.5X1 zomebiT. aRsaniSnavia, rom msgavsidazianebebis miuxedavad, z. k-s ar surda saswrafo daxma-rebis brigadis gamoZaxeba.
25. safuZvels moklebulia z. k-is ganmarteba imis Tao-baze, rom wnelebze orjer dacemis Semdeg, maleve masTanklienti mivida, romelmac dasaxelebuli wnelebi SeiZina.dazaralebulis miTiTebiT, klienti mas T. m-d gaecno. pir-veli instanciis sasamarTlo sxdomaze daikiTxa dazara-lebulis Tanasofleli a. m., romelmac ganmarta, rom er-TaderTi kaci iyo sofelSi saxelad da gvarad _ T. m.. saxe-li _ a. mas mxolod sabuTebSi aqvs miTiTebuli. SemTxvevis
88
dRes dazaralebuli ar unaxavs da arc raime uyidia mis-gan.
26. amdenad, saqmeSi warmodgenili zepiri da werilo-biTi mtkicebulebebi saeWvos xdis da ewinaaRmdegeba da-zaralebulis Cvenebas mis sxeulze mravlobiTi daziane-bis warmoSobis Sesaxeb, ris gamoc igi ver CaiTvleba ut-yuarad. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom z. k-is Cveneba mi-marTulia ojaxis wevris, Svilis sisxlissamarTlebrivi pa-suxismgeblobis Tavidan aridebisaken.
27. i. k-is mier braladSeracxuli qmedebis Cadenaze ag-reTve miuTiTebs: i. k-is dakavebis oqmi, mowmeebis _ m. b-sada S. q-is Cvenebebi, romelTa Tanaxmadac, i. k-s mamis, z. k-is sacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi Sesvlisas tansacmelze aRe-niSneboda mowiTalo laqebi; igi daakves da piradad gaC-xrikes, ra drosac amouRes ori dana, romlebzec agreTvemowiTalo laqebi aRiniSneboda. SemdgomSi, biologiuri(genetikuri, serologiuri) eqspertizis #... daskvnis Ta-naxmad dadasturda, rom i. k-sgan amoRebuli erTi danispirsa da tarze da mis kuTvnil jinsis Sarvalze, TeTriferis Jaketsa da botasis tipis marjvena fexsacmelze aR-moCenili sisxli, genetikuri profilis mixedviT, z. k-issisxlis identuria. nivTierebaTa, masalaTa, nakeTobaTada mcenareTa eqspertizis #... daskvniT ki dadasturebu-lia i. k-sa da z. k-is tansacmelze urTierTidenturi qso-vilis boWkoebis arsebobis faqti.
28. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom safuZvels mokle-bulia dacvis mxaris versia, romlis Tanaxmadac, i. k-is tan-sacmelze z. k-is sisxlis kvalis arseboba SemTxvevis ad-gilze misi waqcevis Sedegia. dazaralebulma mowmed da-kiTxvis dros Tavdapirvelad ganacxada, rom misi SvilisaxlSi ar mobrunebula da ar icoda, danebi wamoiRo Tuara; SemdgomSi ki ganmarta, rom saavadmyofoSi wayvanisdros dainaxa karSi Semomavali i. k-i, romelic, mgoni, wa-iqca kidevac. amdenad, dazaralebuls braldebulis Sem-Txvevis adgilze waqcevis faqti utyuarad ar daudastu-rebia da gasaTvaliswinebelia is garemoebac, rom polici-am braldebuli misi adgilze misvlis dros ezoSi (da arasacxovrebel saxlSi) daakava da piradad gaCxrika, ra dro-sac sisxlis laqebi ara mxolod mis tansacmelze aRiniS-neboda, aramed misgan amoRebul danebzec. dakavebisa da
89
piradi Cxrekis oqms xels awers Tavad braldebuli da masSiSeniSvna an/da Sesworeba ar Seutania. amdenad, i. k-is tan-sacmelze, fexsacmelsa da misgan amoRebul danaze sis-xlis kvali arsebobda SemTxvevis adgilze saswrafo-sa-medicino daxmarebisa da policiis misvlamde, rac ewina-aRmdegeba dazaralebulis versias, rom SemTxvevis drosmisi Svili saxlSi ar imyofeboda.
31. amdenad, saqmeSi warmodgenili zemoaRniSnuli ma-salebi erToblivad gonivrul eWvs miRma mtkicebulebi-Ti standartiT adasturebs i. k-is mier danaSaulis Cade-nas, vinaidan:• dazaralebul z. k-is Cveneba ar aris utyuari da misi
sxeulis wnelebiT dazianebis versia ar Seesabameba saq-meSi warmodgenil masalebs. wnelebi SemTxvevis adgi-lidan ar amoRebula, xolo maTi klientisaTvis miyid-vis faqti a. m-is Cvenebidan da z. k-is sxeulze arsebuldazianebaTa simravlidan, maTi zomebidan da lokali-zaciidan gamomdinare, arasando da aradamajerebelia;
blagvi sagnis moqmedebiT;• i. k-s tansacmelsa (ramdenime adgilas, kerZod, Sarval-
sa da Jaketze) da fexsacmelze, agreTve misgan amoRe-bul danaze aRmoCnda dazaralebulis sisxli. i. k. mamissacxovrebeli saxlis ezoSi daakaves, ra drosac mistansacmelze mowiTalo laqebi aRiniSneboda da saqme-Si arsebuli arc erTi mtkicebulebiT utyuarad ar das-turdeba, rom sisxli braldebuls SemTxvevis adgil-ze waqcevis Sedegad moecxo;
• eqspertizis daskvniT agreTve dadasturebulia i. k-sa da z. k-is tansacmelze identuri qsovilebis boWko-ebis aRmoCenis faqti.32. Sesabamisad, palatas miaCnia, rom prokuroris saka-
sacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes da i. k. cnobil undaiqnes damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is 111-19-108-e muxliTwardgenil braldebaSi.
33. rac Seexeba sasjelis zomas, sakasacio palata mxed-velobaSi iRebs saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeq-sis 39-e muxlisa da amave kodeqsis 53-e muxlis Sinaarss,individualurad afasebs msjavrdebulis pirovnebas dasasjelis daniSvnis zogadsavaldebulo garemoebebs. saq-mis masalaTa Tanaxmad, i. k. xasiaTdeba dadebiTad. amas-Tan, gasaTvaliswinebelia, rom z. k-s drouli samedicinodaxmarebis Sedegad SeunarCunda sicocxle.
34. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom bralad Seracxuliqmedebis sasjelis zomis minimumi sakmarisi iqneba i. k-isgamosworebisa da resocializaciis uzrunvelsayofad.
ma msjavrdebul p. o-s interesebis damcvelis, advokat q.v-s sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom igiar unda dakmayofildes, xolo ganaCeni unda darCes uc-vlelad, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. braldebulma p. o-m sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT da-kiTxvisas ganmarta, rom 2017 wlis 12 Tebervals g. c-sTanerTad `.....~ Sexvda megobrebs _ k. da v. g-ebs, g. g-s, l. l-sda i. C-s. Semdeg g. c-s gahyva saxlSi. isini gzad, metrosvagonSi Sexvdnen gardacvlil d. d-s, romelic g. c-s gamo-elaparaka misTvis gaugebar megrul enaze. mowmem aRniS-na, rom miuxedavad g. c-s sacxovrebeli adgilisa (g. c-acxovrobda ..... `.....~), isini amovidnen `.....~ ..... da gza fexiTganagrZes. mas c-sa da gardacvlilis saubari ar esmoda,radgan moSorebiT midioda. mxolod gaigo is, Tu rogorsTxova c-m gardacvlils telefoni dasarekad. aRniSnu-lis Semdeg mas mounda moSardva, ris gamoc moZebna bneliadgili da mSenebare obieqtze Sevida. mowmis ganmarte-biT, sibnelis gamo waiqca da nikapi daiziana. ukan dabru-nebuls Cxubis xma Semoesma. miaxloebisas SeamCnia, rom c-a da d-a Cxubobdnen, ris gamoc gasaSveleblad SuaSi Cad-ga. Cxubi daaxloebiT 5 wams gagrZelda. moCxubrebi erTma-neTs ar aginebdnen, magram mimarTavdnen uwmawuri sityve-biT. maT erTmaneTi eWiraT da axlos idgnen, Tumca igi verxedavda, urtyamdnen Tu ara erTmaneTs. mas arc is dauna-
96
xavs, eWira Tu ara c-s raime xelSi. mowmem ganmarta, romman gaaSvela Tu ara moCxubrebi, d-a c-s moSorda da gaiq-ca. gzad mas c-m sportuli zedatani misca da uTxra, gaq-ceuliyvnen. asec moiqcnen. daaxloebiT 200 metrSi taqsigaaCeres. p-m taqsSi moisxa zemoaRniSnuli sportuli ze-datani, romelic, misi azriT, c-s ekuTvnoda. mowme p. o-mdaadastura is faqti, rom c-s xelze hqonda dazianeba,ris gamoc SeekiTxa am ukanasknels, Tu ra mouvida, razecg. c-m upasuxa, rom SesaSineblad daWra d-a, xeli moqneu-li daniT daiziana, xolo fexi _ `armaturiT~. amis Semdegis da c-a `.....~ Sexvdnen megobrebs, romlebsac man gadascamisi saxlis gasaRebi, xolo Tavad wavida `.....~ g. g-sa da misSeyvarebulTan Sesaxvedrad. mowmem ganmarta, rom tani-samosze sisxlis laqa mxolod maSin SeniSna, rodesac sax-lSi dabrunda, sisxliani Sarvali gamoicvala da karadaSiSeinaxa, raTa Semdeg gaerecxa. dakavebisas policielebmamas aCvenes `.....~ benzingasamarT sadgurze ganTavsebulikamerebidan amoRebuli fotosuraTebi, saidanac icodnen,rom mas SemTxvevis dros ecva Ria feris jinsis Sarvali,ris gamoc amoiRes sisxliani jinsis Sarvali da Caacves.aRniSnulis Semdeg policilelebma igi gaiyvanes calkeoTaxSi da urtyamdnen. urtyamdnen aseve g. c-sac. p. o-sganmartebiT, masze axdendnen zewolas sasurveli Cvene-bis misaRebad, ra drosac iyenebdnen eleqtroSoks. igi iT-xovda advokats, romelic ar miuyvanes. p-m sakuTari aRi-arebiTi Cveneba axsna im garemoebiT, rom g. c-sTan Sedare-biT mas, arasrulwlovnebidan gamomdinare, ufro msubu-qad dasjidnen, xolo masze ganxorcielebuli ZaladobisSesaxeb ar ganacxada misi gagrZelebiT gamowveuli SiSiT.mowmem daadastura is faqti, rom mis dakiTxvas eswrebo-da rogorc kanonieri warmomadgeneli, ise misi interese-bis damcveli advokati.
3. braldebulma aseve ganmarta, rom mas gardacvlilipiri egona g. c-s megobari, vinaidan misi telefoniT sura-Tebs iRebdnen. misive CvenebiT, d. d-a iyo maRali da Cas-kvnili, saxeze aSkarad etyoboda, rom c-ze didi iyo. imfaqts, rom mis tansacmelze aRmoCnda sisxli, xsnis im ga-remoebiT, rom gardacvlil d. d-s sisxliani zedatani mo-ixvia. man uaryo `kastetis~ qonis faqti.
4. braldebulma g. c-m sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT da-
97
kiTxvisas ganmarta, rom 2017 wlis 12 Tebervals, saRamos,p. o-sTan erTad `.....~ Sexvda c. j-s, Zmeb g-ebs, g. g-s, l. l-sda i. C-s. daaxloebiT 20:00 _ 21:00 saaTisaTvis man p. o-ssTxova saxlSi gayola. gzad metros vagonSi gaicno d. d-a,radgan warmoSobiT erTi kuTxidan aRmoCndnen. d-m uT-xra, rom `.....~ cxovrobda. mowmis ganmartebiT, mas surdaufro axlos gaecno d-a, ris gamoc amovidnen `.....~ metroSida gza fexiT ganagrZes. man gardacvlils SesTavaza, eme-gobraT. gzaSi d-s telefoniT ramdenime suraTic gadai-Res. fexiT daaxloebiT 45 wuTi iares. igi gardacvlilTanerTad midioda xelgadaxveuli, xolo p. o-e _ maTgan mo-SorebiT. gzad man d-s sTxova telefoni mieca, raTa l. l-Tan daereka. Tavidan gardacvlilis telefoniT undodasaubari, magram angariSze sakmarisi Tanxa ar hqonda da mxo-lod zari gauSva, ris Semdeg l-m TviTon gadaureka miskuTvnil telefonze. amasobaSi, o-m mosaSardad gadaux-via gzidan, sadac bneloda. igi d-sTan erTad gahyva o-s,romelic maTgan ramdenime metris moSorebiT midioda. manuTxra d-s, rom problemebi hqonda, ris gamoc sWirdebo-da misi telefonis dalombardeba, razec d-a gabrazda, Se-uracxyofa miayena da xelic hkra, rac fizikur dapirispi-rebaSi gadaizarda. mowmem daadastura is faqti, rom isinierTmaneTs muStebs urtyamdnen. gardacvlili masze Zli-eri iyo da radgan ver moeria, SesaSineblad fexSi daar-tya dana, Tumca zustad ar axsovs, sul ramdeni Wrilobamiayena. dana, romliTac d-a daWra, iyo patara, moyavis-fro, vercxlisferi piriT, romelsac adrec atarebda. da-nas hqonda Rilaki da masze daWeriT ixsneboda. mowmis gan-martebiT, Cxubis dros is da d-a marto iyvnen. o-e maTgandaaxloebiT 10-15 metris moSorebiT imyofeboda. igi yvi-roda, magram aravis gaugia, radgan axlomaxlo aravin cxov-robda. amis Semdeg igi o-sTan erTad SemTxvevis adgili-dan gzaze gamovida da samSobiarosTan taqsi gaaCeres. `.....~taqsiT imgzavres. gardacvlils misTvis raime dazianebaar miuyenebia. fexze, kerZod, muxlis qvemoT, koWTan hqon-da dazianeba, romelic betonis iatakze dacemisas miiRo,sadac `armaturebi~ eyara.
TviTon, d. d-sTan erTad. gamoZiebisas man misca Cveneba,rom TiTqos d-a telefonis warTmevis mizniT gaicno daTiTqos, xeli danis gaSlis dros gaeWra, radgan masze xor-cieldeboda zewola. Tavdapirvelad p. o-m aRiara danaSa-uli, radgan o-e misi axlo megobaria da mis adgilas Tava-dac ase moiqceoda.
6. g. c-m ganmarta, rom SemTxvevis adgilidan daaxloe-biT 5-6 metrSi man p. o-s gadasca gardacvlilis sportuliqurTuki, romelic Cxubis dros SerCa xelSi, radgan iyoSeSinebuli da ver moifiqra SemTxvevis adgilze datove-ba. man ar icoda, rom gardacvlili arasrulwlovani iyo,radgan ar hgavda 15 wlisas. d-Tvis arc asaki ukiTxavs daarc is, skolaSi swavlobda Tu ara.
7. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma dazaralebulis ufleba-monacvle o. d-m, romelic gardacvlili d. d-s mamaa, gan-marta, rom 2017 wlis 12 Tebervals, saRamos, mis vaJs Sinmisvla Seagvianda. daaxloebiT saRamos 20:40 saaTze gada-urekes, ra drosac d-m upasuxa, rom gzaSi iyo da Sin maledabrundeboda. daaxloebiT 21:40 saaTze isev daurekes dapoliciisgan Seityo momxdaris Sesaxeb. man gamoricxa qu-CaSi d-s vinmesTan spontanuri damegobreba, radgan misivaJi ar iyo kontaqturi, ZiriTad dros kompiuterTan ata-rebda, ar uyvarda suraTebis gadaReba, arc CxubSi Caebme-boda, radgan fizikuri monacemebi ar uwyobda amisTvisxels.
8. manve ganmarta, rom maT ojaxs araferi akavSirebs af-xazeTTan da daadastura, rom gardacvlilma ar icodamegruli ena. mis gardacvlil vaJs telefoniT mxolodsms-ebis gagzavna SeeZlo, Sesabamisad, SemTxvevis drosmas mobilur telefonze dasarekad sakmarisi Tanxa ar eq-neboda.
9. igive daadastura sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT dakiT-xvisas gardacvlilis dedam e. q-m da damatebiT ganmarta,rom d-s hqonda `aifon 5s-is~ firmis mobiluri telefoni,romelic Rirda daaxloebiT 800-900 lari. misi Svili iyoZalian bavSvuri, rogorc fizikurad, ise xasiaTiT.
10. mowme n. d-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2017 wlis 12Tebervals, saRamos cxridan aT saaTamde, uyurebda te-levizors, ra drosac moesma xmauri. saxlis meore sar-Tulze arsebuli saZinebeli oTaxis fanjrebidan gaixeda
99
da daaxloebiT 15-20 metris moSorebiT dainaxa sami ada-mianis landi, romelTa simaRliT mixvda, rom iyvnen bav-Svebi da ZiZgilaobdnen. erTi iyo SedarebiT maRali, ro-melic SuaSi idga, mas haerSi aweuli telefoni eWira, ro-melic anaTebda. mowmem ramdenjerme gaimeora CvenebaSi,rom daiZaxa _ `Tavi daanebeT, SeeSviT~, rasac maTi mxri-dan reagireba ar mohyolia, xolo rodesac fanjaras xu-ravda, moesma xma _ `miSveleT~ (ix. sasamarTlo sxdomisoqmi 08.06.17 _ 15:28:14). manve saxlis ukana aivnidan daina-xa, rom erTi biWi quCisken nasvamiviT midioda. naxevarigzis gavlis Semdeg ukan dabrunda da manqanasTan Caikeca.ezoSi Casvlisas bavSvi gardacvlili daxvda, romelic da-axloebiT 15-17 wlis iqneboda.
11. mowme m. b-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2017 wlis 12Tebervals, saRamos cxridan aT saaTamde, misi mSoblebissaxlidan ramdenime metrSi momxdari Cxubis faqti da gan-marta, rom sasadilo oTaxSi vaxSmobisas Semoesma Cxubis-magvari xma. fanjridan dainaxa zurgiT mdgari, muq ferebSiCacmuli adamiani, romelsac kapiuSoni efara. imis gamo,rom saxlis kedeli efareboda, sxva veraferi gaarCia. amdros gaigo dedamisis (n. d-s) xma _ `Tavi daanebeT~, xoloSemdeg _ `miSveleT~. amis Semdeg igi avida meore sarTul-ze da saZineblis fanjridan, romelic gadahyurebs mSene-bare korpuss, dainaxa ori piri, romlebic ... quCidan mir-bodnen ... quCisken. sibnelis gamo ver gaarCia maTi silue-tebi. ezoSi Casuls biWi gardacvlili daxvda, romelicwlovanebis Sesabamisad gamoiyureboda da ver ityodi, romiyo TxuTmet-Cvidmet welze didi.
12. mowme g. b-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2017 wlis 12Tebervals, daaxloebiT 21:00-22:00 saaTis periodSi, misisacxovrebeli korpusis gverdze mdebare mSenebare obi-eqtidan Semoesma biWebis SekamaTebisa da xmamaRali saub-ris xma. gadaixeda fanjridan da dainaxa erTnairi aRnago-bis sami mozardi biWi, erT-erTi maTgani iTxovda daxmare-bas. am dros misma meuRlem, n. d-m fanjridan daiyvira, romTavi daenebebinaT misTvis, TviTon ki ezoSi Cavida. mSene-bare obieqtTan aRaravin iyo, xolo mozardi, romelic dax-marebas iTxovda, iqve, miwaze, daeca. SemTxvevis adgilzemosulma saswrafo daxmarebis brigadam daafiqsira biWisgardacvaleba.
100
13. mowme n. n-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom man d.d-smkvlelobis saqmeze Caatara ramdenime sagamoZiebo moq-medeba, maT Soris _ p. o-s binis Cxreka, ra drosac amoiResp. o-s mobiluri telefoni, Savi feris ori qurTuki, ro-melTagan erTi iyo dazianebuli da hqonda sisxlis laqe-bi. rogorc mogvianebiT gairkva, es qurTuki ekuTvnodagardacvlils. aseve amoiRes dana, sisxlis laqebiT. binisCxrekisas man naxa `kasteti~, romelic ido kompiuterismagidis Taroze. imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom im momentis-Tvis gamoZiebisTvis cnobili iyo, rom d-a gardaicvala da-niT miyenebuli WrilobebiT, `kasteti~ gamoZiebisTvismniSvnelovan nivTad ar miiCnies. saqmesTan misi kavSirimxolod p. o-s dakiTxvis Semdeg gaxda cnobili.
14. pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi analogiuri Cve-neba misca mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma saqmis gamomZiebelmai. c-m, romelmac damatebiT ganmarta: mas Semdeg, rac p. o-s gamokiTxvisas gairkva, rom am ukanasknelma d. d-s `kas-tetiT~ miayena dazianebebi, daukavSirda dedamiss binisCxrekasTan dakavSirebiT, razec miiRo Tanxmoba, TumcabinaSi `kasteti~ ar aRmoCnda.
15. mowme v. g-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2017 wlis 12Tebervals, saRamos, igi mivida ... Tavis ZmasTan _ k. g-Tan,g. g-sTan, p. o-sTan, g. c-sTan, c. j-sa da i. C-Tan erTad. amadgilas isini xSirad ikribebodnen. g. c-a da p. o-e malevewavidnen, raTa vinme `SeeyenebiaT~, misive ganmartebiT,vinmesTvis telefoni waerTmiaT. rodesac ukan dabrun-dnen, g. c-s xeli da fexi hqonda gaWrili. mowmis ganmarte-biT, maTive naambobidan viRac biWisTvis telefonis war-Tmevas cdilobdnen, rac ver SeZles da SekamaTebisas mii-Res dazianebebi. telefonis warTmevisas aRniSnul pirs,c-m daniT, xolo p. o-m `kastetiT~ miayenes dazianebebi dagaiqcnen. mowmis CvenebiT dgindeba, rom man p. o-Tan sax-lSi, savarZelze, naxa vercxlisferi `kasteti~.
16. mowme c. j-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2017 wlis 12Tebervals g. g-sTan erTad mivida `.....~, sadac Sexvdnen i.C-s da k. g-s. isini erTad mividnen metro ..... `.....~, sadacnaxes g. c-a da p. o-e. o-s etyoboda Cxubis kvali. igi See-kiTxa p. o-s, raSi iyo saqme, razec man upasuxa, rom biWssTxova telefoni da mouvidaT SekamaTeba. g. c-s xeli hqon-da Sexveuli da Sarvalzec etyoboda sisxlis kvali. masac
101
hkiTxa, Tu ra moxda, razec c-m upasuxa, rom Cxubi mouvi-daT biWTan da danis gaSlisas gaeWra xeli. metroSi mgzav-robisas man SeniSna, rom p. o-s ecva Ria feris jinsis Sar-vali da e.w `plaSovkis~ mosacmeli. welze hqonda Semoxve-uli Jaketi, romelic jinsis Sarvals ar ufaravda. man da-inaxa, rom p. o-s Ria feris jinsis Sarvali sisxliT hqondadasvrili da emCneoda Savi laqa. mowmem ganmarta, rom gar-dacvlil d. d-s, romelic aRmoCnda misi ubneli, icnobda.d. d-s garegnoba asakis Sesabamisi hqonda, 16 welze metiSexeduleba ar hqonia.
17. pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi kanonis srulidacviT gamoqveynda mowme i. C-s Cveneba, romlis mixed-viT, 2017 wlis 13 Tebervals, daaxloebiT 23:00 saaTze, met-ros ..... `.....~ g. -sTan, c. j-Tan, m. k-sTan, k. da v. g-Tan erTadSexvda p. o-s da g. c-s. man c-s tansacmelze SeniSna sisxliskvali, razec c-m hkiTxa, ra xdeboda da c-m upasuxa, romigi da o-e metros ..... `.....~ gahyvnen ucxo biWs, raTa waer-TmiaT mobiluri telefoni. `.....~, sportuli kompleqsismimdebared arsebul mSenebare korpusTan, Cabnelebuladgilas, gadawyvites amis ganxorcieleba da mas Semdeg,rac am biWma gauwiaT winaaRmdegoba, g. c-m ramdenjermedaartya dana sxeulis sxvadasxva areSi. imis gamo, rom mo-saxleobam atexa yvirili, man da p. o-m sirbiliT datovesiqauroba. g. c-a nanobda, rom tyuilad daWra biWi, mobilu-ri ki mainc ver waarTva. c-s marjvena xeli hqonda gaWri-li, Semoxveuli hqonda binti da etyoboda sisxldenis kva-li. g. c-s monaTxrobi daadastura p. o-m, romelsac welzehqonda Semoxveuli muqi feris Jaketi, razec ganmarta,rom Cxubis dros waarTva biWs, romelic mobiluris war-Tmevis dros daiWra.
22. biologiurti eqspertizis daskvniT dadgeniliaSemdegi: p. o-s Sarvalze arsebuli mowiTalo-moyavisfrolaqebi warmoadgens adamianis sisxls, romlis genetikuriprofili (ob #10) ekuTvnis d. d-s (ob #51). p. o-s binisCxrekisas amoRebul qurTukze arsebuli muqi moyavisfrolaqebi (ob #13) Seicavs adamianis sisxls, romlis geneti-kuri profili Sereulia, ZiriTadi nawilisa da d. d-s ge-netikuri profili identuria. amave obieqtis profilSivlindeba aseve p. o-sa da g. c-s genetikuri Tanamonawile-oba; p. o-s binis Cxrekisas amoRebuli dasakeci danis pir-ze arsebuli mowiTalo-moyavisfro laqebi warmoadgensadamianis sisxls, romlis genetikuri profili ekuTvnisd. d-s. danis tarze arsebuli biomasalis genetikuri pro-fili Sereulia da vlindeba d. d-s da g. c-s genetikuriTanamonawileoba.
23. sakasacio palata miuTiTebs, rom srulad iziarebssaapelacio palatis motivebs da dadgenilad miaCnia, romp. o-m Caidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis msjavradSeracxuli danaSaulebi, rasac adasturebs Semdegi mtki-cebulebebi:
24. sakasacio palata pirvel rigSi aRniSnavs, rom saa-pelacio palatam marTebulad ar gaiziara p. o-s Cveneba,rom igi ar aris mkvlelobis Tanaamsrulebeli, mas gardac-
104
vlil d. d-Tvis dazianebebi ar miuyenebia da is moCxub-rebs mxolod aSvelebda.
25. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul p. o-sCveneba miznad isaxavs sisxlissamarTlebrivi pasuxismgeb-lobisgan Tavis aridebas, amasTan, igi aradamajerebeliada ewinaaRmdegeba rogorc saqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiT-xul braldebul g. c-s, aseve sxva mowmeTa Cvenebebsa dasaqmeSi arsebul sxva mtkicebulebebs, romelTa utyua-robis saeWvod miCnevis safuZveli, maTi Tanmimdevrulo-bisa da urTierTSeTanxmebulobis gamo, sakasacio pala-tas ar gaaCnia, kerZod:
26. dacvis mxaris versiiT, p. o-e g. c-sa da dazarale-buls Soris Cxubis dawyebamde gasuli iyo bunebrivi moT-xovnilebis dasakmayofileblad da rodesac igi maTTanbrundeboda, moesma Cxubis xma. rodesac maTTan mivida,isini ukve Cxubobdnen. igi mivida maT gasaSveleblad daCadga SuaSi. gaSvelebisas daiZaxa sityvebi _ `ar ginda~,rac dasturdeba TviTmxilveli mowmeebis _ m. b-sa da n. d-s CvenebebiT. dacvis mxaris aRniSnuli versia safuZvelsmoklebulia, ar aris sarwmuno, radgan igi ewinaaRmdegebasaqmeze Sekrebil mtkicebulebebs, kerZod: mowme n. d-sTavis CvenebaSi arsad uTqvams, rom Cxubis adgilidan gai-gona sityvebi _ `ar ginda~. mowmem xazgasmiT aRniSna, romsaxlis meore sarTulze arsebuli saZinebeli oTaxis fan-jridan gaixeda da daaxloebiT 15-20 metris moSorebiTdainaxa sami adamianis landi, romelTa simaRliT mixvda,rom iyvnen bavSvebi da ZiZgilaobdnen. erTi iyo Sedare-biT maRali, romelic SuaSi idga, mas haerSi aweuli tele-foni eWira, romelic anaTebda. mowmem ramdenjerme gai-meora CvenebaSi, rom daiZaxa _ `Tavi daanebeT, SeeSviT~,rasac maTi mxridan reagireba ar mohyva, xolo rodesacfanjaras xuravda, moesma xma _ `miSveleT~. mowme m. b-m kiganmarta, rom gaigo dedamisis, n. d-s xma _ `Tavi daane-beT~, xolo Semdeg `miSveleT~, ris Semdegac avida meoresarTulze da saZineblis fanjridan, romelic gadahyu-rebs mSenebare korpuss, dainaxa ori piri, romlebic …..qu-Cidan mirbodnen ... quCisken. analogiuri Cveneba misca ki-dev erTma TviTmxilvelma mowmem g. b-m, romelmac ganmar-ta, rom fanjridan gaxedvisas dainaxa erTnairi aRnago-bis sami mozardi biWi, romelTagan erT-erTi iTxovda dax-
105
marebas. am dros misma meuRlem _ n. d-m fanjridan daiyvi-ra, biWisTvis Tavi daenebebinaT, TviTon ki ezoSi Cavida.garda amisa, amoRebuli videoCanawerebiT dasturdeba,rom g. c-a, p. o-e da d. d-a gadaadgildebodnen erTad da p.o-e maTgan gancalkevebiT ar gasula.
27. garda amisa, saapelacio palatam aseve marTebuladaRniSna, rom msjavrdebul p. o-sa da mowme g. c-s CvenebebsSorisac arsebobs arsebiTi winaaRmdegobebi, kerZod:
28. pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi msjavrdebulmap. o-m rogorc pirdapiri, ise jvaredini dakiTxvisas aRwe-ra mis mier d. d-sa da g. c-s gaSvelebis epizodi da ganmar-ta, rom rodesac mSenebare obieqtis avtofarexSi buneb-rivi moTxovnileba daikmayofila da ukan brundeboda, ga-igona kamaTis xma da amosvlisas dainaxa, rom d. d-a da g. c-a erTmaneTs eCxubebodnen. is Cadga maT Soris da SeecadamaT gaSvelebas, Tan daiZaxa `gaCerdiT~. d. d-m ukan gadad-ga nabiji da gaiqca. p. o-s arc pirdapiri da arc jvaredinidakiTxvisas ar uTqvams, rom man daiZaxa `Tavi daanebe~.amdenad, misi Cvenebis es nawili ar Seesabameba mowmeebis_ n. d-sa da m. b-s Cvenebebs.
29. mowme g. c-s mier micemuli Cvenebis mixedviT ki sa-erTod gamoiricxa is faqti, rom p. o-e aSvelebda g. c-sa dadazaralebuls. misi Cvenebis Tanaxmad, rodesac p. o-e mSe-nebare obieqtis avtosadgomidan amovida, d. d-a ukve gar-boda. amdenad, Tu p. o-s avtosadgomidan amosvlis momen-tSi d. d-a ukve garboda, maSin msjavrdebuli moCxubrebsver gaaSvelebda.
30. p. o-m aseve icrua, rom TiTqosda, d. d-a da g. c-aerTmaneTs megrulad esaubrebodnen, vinaidan saqmezewarmodgenili mtkicebulebebiT, dazaralebul d. d-smSoblebis _ o. d-sa da e. q-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia, romman ar icoda megruli ena. p. o-m aseve icrua, rom TiTqos-da, gardacvlilis Jaketi g. c-si egona, radgan dadgeni-lia, rom dazaralebulis Jaketi feriT radikalurad gan-sxvavdeba g. c-s Jaketisagan (Savi da mwvane) da igi p. o-mwelze moixvia Sarvalze arsebuli sisxlis kvalis dasafa-rad.
31. Sesabamisad, m. b-sa da n. d-s CvenebebiT araTu das-turdeba msjavrdebul p. o-s udanaSauloba, aramed piri-qiT, dasturdeba, rom SemTxvevis adgilze imyofeboda sa-
106
mi axalgazrda, romelTagan ori maTgani eZiZgilavebodadazaralebuls da cdilobdnen misTvis telefonis war-Tmevas. maTi Cvenebebis siswores adasturebs aseve mowmeg. b-s Cveneba. yvela TviTmxilveli mowme adasturebs er-Tsa da imave faqts, rom CxubSi monawileobda sami piri,romelTagan ori erTad gaiqca SemTxvevis adgilidan, xo-lo mesame adgilze gardaicvala. amdenad, dacvis mxarisargumenti, rom p. o-e aSvelebda moCxubrebs da sityvebi`ar ginda~ ekuTvnoda ara dazaralebuls, aramed _ msjav-rdebul p. o-s, am mowmeebis Cvenebebidan ar gamomdinare-obs.
32. aRsaniSnavia is faqtic, rom Tavad g. c-a ar uaryofs,rom man daWra dazaralebuli d. d-a, Tumca ganmarta, rommisi mokvlis ganzraxva ar hqonia da dana daartya fexSiSesaSineblad.
33. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom damamZimebel ga-remoebebSi Cadenili ganzrax mkvleloba warmoadgens Se-degian deliqts, romelic damTavrebulad iTvleba dam-naSavis mier gamiznuli marTlsawinaaRmdego Sedegis rea-lurad dadgomis SemTxvevaSi. am danaSaulis CadenisaT-vis aucilebelia, rom danaSaulis subieqti moqmedebdesganzraxviT _ Caidinos mkvleloba, rac unda efuZnebodesSesabamis mizans, motivs, qmedebaSi gamovlenil marTlsa-winaaRmdego nebas, qmedebis ganxorcielebis saxesa daxerxs. aseTi kategoriis saqmeebze gansakuTrebiT mniSvne-lovania, dadgindes danaSaulis Cadenis motivi, Tu raamoZravebda damnaSaves, ra garemoebam miiyvana igi dana-Saulis Cadenamde, romeli faqtori iyo gadamwyveti. amas-Tan, unda dadgindes faqtobrivad ganxorcielebul qme-debasa da damdgar Sedegs Soris mizezobrivi kavSiri, ro-melTa gareSec qmedebis ganzrax mkvlelobad dakvalifi-cireba samarTlebriv safuZvels moklebuli iqneba.
34. mocemul saqmeze gamokvleuli mtkicebulebebidangamomdinare dadgenilia, rom p. o-e da g. c-a moqmedebdenSeTanxmebulad rogorc danaSaulis Cadenamde, ise misi Ca-denisa da Cadenis Semdeg, kerZod: mowme v. g-s CvenebiTdadgenilia, rom p. o-sa da g. c-s ganzraxuli hqondaT sa-kuTrebis winaaRmdeg mimarTuli danaSaulis Cadena (sur-daT vinmesTvis telefonis warTmeva) saqmis masalebiT,maT Soris videoCanawerebiT, aseve dadgenilia, rom g. c-a
107
da p. o-e metroSi aedevnen dazaralebul d. d-s da misigacnobidan mkvlelobamde isini masTan erTad uwyvetadgadaadgildebodnen. metrodan amosvlis Semdeg, dazara-lebulis dayaCaRebis mizniT, igi Seiyvanes mofarebul ad-gilas, mSenebare korpusis teritoriaze, ra drosac manwinaaRmdegoba gauwia Tavdamsxmelebs. yaCaRobis Cadenisgaadvilebisa da misi winaaRmdegobis daZlevis mizniT, g.c-m danis, xolo p. o-m `kastetis~ gamoyenebiT d. d-s miaye-nes mravlobiTi dazianebebi da ganzrax mokles igi, risSemdegadac erTad gaiqcnen SemTxvevis adgilidan. marTa-lia, dazaralebul d. d-s daniT sasikvdilo Wrilobebi mi-ayena uSualod g. c-m, magram SemTxvevis TviTmxilvelimowmeebis CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom dazaralebuls er-Tdroulad ori piri daesxa Tavs, romlebic erToblivadcdilobdnen misTvis telefonis warTmevas. am qmedebiTTavdamsxmelebma d. d-s faqtobrivad mouspes Tavis dac-visa da gadaadgilebis saSualeba da amavdroulad g. c-mdaniT, xolo p. o-m `kastetiT~ miayenes mas dazianebebi,rasac pirdapiri mizezobrivi kavSirSi aqvs damdgar Se-degTan _ d. d-s sikvdilTan.
35. garda SemTxvevis TviTmxilveli mowmeebis Cvenebe-bisa, p. o-s mimarT bralad Seracxuli qmedebebi dadastu-rebulia Semdegi mtkicebulebebiT:• mowmeebis _ v. g-s, i. C-sa da g. g-s CvenebebiT, romelTa
Tanaxmad, p. o-m da g. c-m maT uambo ucxo pirisaTvistelefonis warTmevis mcdelobisa da misi daWris Sesa-xeb. maTive CvenebebiT irkveva, rom g. c-s tansacmelisisxliani hqonda, xolo p. o-s welze Semoxveuli hqon-da daWrilis sisxliani Jaketi;
saxiT, rac maTi odenobis, xasiaTis, lokalizaciisa daxarisxis gaTvaliswinebiT, utyuarad adasturebs imfaqts, rom dazaralebuls dazianebebi miayena araer-Tma pirma;
• 2017 wlis 10 martis biologiuri eqspertizis daskvniT,romlis mixedviT: p. o-s Sarvalze arsebuli mowiTalo-moyavisfro laqebi warmoadgens adamianis sisxls, rom-lis genetikuri profili ekuTvnis dazaralebul d. d-s; p. o-s binis Cxrekisas amoRebul qurTukze arsebulimuqi moyavisfro laqebi Seicavs adamianis sisxls, rom-lis genetikuri profili Sereulia, ZiriTadi nawilisada d. d-s genetikuri profili identuria. amave obieq-tis profilSi vlindeba aseve p. o-sa da g. c-s genetiku-ri Tanamonawileoba; p. o-s binis Cxrekisas amoRebulidasakeci danis pirze arsebuli mowiTalo-moyavisfrolaqebi warmoadgens adamianis sisxls, romlis geneti-kuri profili ekuTvnis d. d-s. danis tarze arsebulibiomasalis genetikuri profili Sereulia da vlinde-ba d. d-sa da g. c-s genetikuri Tanamonawileoba.
36. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelacio palatis mo-tivebs da ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris pozicias, rom mowme-ebze _ g. g-ze, k. g-sa da m. k-ze policiis TanamSromlebmamoaxdines fizikuri da fsiqologiuri zewola da rom sa-samarTlom usafuZvlod ar gaiziara maTi Cvenebebi. saka-sacio palata aRniSnavs, rom maTi Cvenebebi aSkarad wina-aRmdegobrivia, ar Seesabameba saqmis faqtobriv garemoe-bebs da mimarTulia msjavrdebulis mdgomareobis Semsu-buqebisaken, kerZod:
37. mowmeebi, erTi mxriv, adastureben, rom Cvenebebismicemisas maTze axdendnen fizikur da fsiqologiur ze-wolas, xolo, meore mxriv, ver uaryofen maT dakiTxvebSikanonieri warmomadgenlebis monawileobas. mowme m. k-m ga-nacxada, rom dakiTxvisas masze axdendnen fsiqologiurzewolas, maSin, rodesac TviTonve daadastura, rom misdakiTxvas eswreboda misi kanonieri warmomadgeneli, racrealobas moklebulia, xolo k. g-m Cvenebis micemisas Ta-vidan saerTod uaryo, rom misTvis cnobili iyo momxdarifaqtis Sesaxeb, Tumca Semdeg daadastura. manve ganacxa-da, rom esmoda c. j-s kivili, romelsac scemdnen polici-
109
is ganyofilebaSi. p. o-s gancxadebiT, man dainaxa polici-is ganyofilebaSi, rogor daeca kibeze nacemi v. g-i, TumcaaRniSnuli faqtebi saerTod ar uxsenebiaT Tavad c. j-sada v. g-s. amasTan, mowmeebma ver axsnes maTze ganxorcie-lebuli zemoqmedebis SemTxvevaSi ratom awerdnen Cvene-bebs xels maTi kanonieri warmomadgenlebi.
38. mowme k. g-m ganmarta, rom Cveneba misca misi kanoni-eri warmomadgenlis gareSe, magram mere miuTiTa, rom Cve-nebas ise moawera xeli, rom piradad ar waukiTxavs, wai-kiTxa mxolod misma kanonierma warmomadgenelma. misiveTqmiT, p. o-s saxlSi p. o-e da g. g-e gaiyvanes calke oTaxSi,saidanac maTi yvirili esmoda, Tavad p. o-e ki acxadebs,rom igi calke gaiyvanes oTaxSi da urtyamdnen, xolo g. c-m ki ganmarta, rom igi p. o-sTan erTad gaiyvanes calke oTax-Si. k. g-m aseve ganacxada, rom sagamoZiebo organoSi Cvene-bis micemisas iyo arafxizel mdgomareobaSi, Tumca p. o-mganmarta, rom im saRamos, mis megobrebs alkoholi ar miu-RiaT.
39. mowme g. c-s TqmiT mis mimarT arasaTanado mopyro-bis faqts eswreboda misi advokati, Tumca policilebissimravlis gamo marto damcveli verafers gaxdeboda, racmoklebulia yovelgavar damajereblobas. niSandobliviasasamarTloSi misi gancxadeba, rom misi megobris, p. o-sgadasarCenad yvelafers gaakeTebda
40. p. o-e erT SemTxvevaSi uCvenebs, rom gamoZiebaSi mas-ze fizikur zewolas axdendnen da imitom misca aRiarebi-Ti Cveneba, xolo Semdeg ganmarta: imitom aRiara danaSau-li, rom icoda mas, rogorc arasrulwlovans, ufro msu-buqad dasjidnen, vidre srulwlovan g. c-s da ara imitom,rom masze raime saxis zewola ganxorcielda.
2 ix. adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos gadawyvetilebasaqmeze: „el-masri yofili iugoslaviis respublika makedoniiswinaaRmdeg~, (El-Masri v The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia)[didi palata], #39630/09, § 151, 13.12.2012).
112
re mocemuli braldebis epizodebs sadavod ar xdis da,Sesabamisad, sakasacio palata damatebiT aRar msjelobsam sakiTxze.
4. kasatori _ ozurgeTis raionuli prokuraturis pro-kurori mamuka nadiraZe iTxovs gasaCivrebul ganaCenSicvlilebis Setanas da msjavrdebulisaTvis ufro mkacrisasjelis daniSvnas Tavisuflebis aRkveTis saxiT im mo-tiviT, rom s. m. nasamarTlevia ganzraxi mZime danaSaulis-Tvis (qurdoba binaSi ukanono SeRweviT) da miuxedavad mismimarT gamoCenili lmobierebisa, rac gamoixata misTvispirobiTi sasjelis gansazRvraSi, man arasrulwlovani Svi-lebis TandaswrebiT iZalada meuRlesa da mamaze. amde-nad, sazogadoebisTvis sasargeblo Sromis gansazRvra araris samarTliani, ar Seesabameba s. m-is pirovnebasa da mismier Cadenili qmedebis xasiaTs, ar iqneba damafiqrebelida ver uzrunvelyofs mis resocializacias.
samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palatam Seiswavla saqmis masalebi da miaC-
nia, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi da utyuari mtkicebu-lebebi, maT Soris _ braldebul s. m-is aRiarebiTi Cvene-ba, dazaralebulebis: l. q-sa da m. m-is Cvenebebi, mowmee-bis: q. m-sa da k. m-is Cvenebebi, SemTxvevis adgilis daTva-
aqvs srulad da ixdis arasapatimro sasjels _ eweva sazo-gadoebisTvis sasargeblo Sromas. penitenciuri dawese-bulebidan gaTavisuflebis Semdeg s. m-is raime antisoci-alur an danaSaulebriv qcevaze an/da sazogadoebisTvissasargeblo SromisTvis Tavis aridebis Sesaxeb informa-cia sasamarTloSi ar yofila warmodgenili, ris gamoc, sa-kasacio palatis mosazrebiT, arasapatimro sasjelis Sec-vla sapatimro sasjeliT da misi kvlav penitenciur dawe-sebulebaSi moTavseba xels SeuSlis misi resocializaci-is process, rac aseve sasjelis mizans warmoadgens.
7. rac Seexeba prokuroris mier saCivarSi miTiTebulim garemoebas, rom s. m-em danaSauli Caidina arasrulwlo-vani Svilebis TandaswrebiT, ra Tqma unda, palata izia-rebs braldebis mxaris suliskveTebas, rom arasrulwlo-vani bavSvebis TandaswrebiT s. m-Tvis Seracxuli qmede-bis (ojaxuri Zaladobis) Cadena mometebulad gasakicxia,magram imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom aRniSnuli warmoadgensmuxlis makvalificirebel garemoebas, sasjelis gansaz-Rvrisas sakasacio palata mas mxedvelobaSi ar miiRebs,vinaidan saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e muxlis me-4 nawilis Se-sabamisad, Tu am kodeqsis kerZo nawilis muxli an muxlisnawili danaSaulis Semadgenlobis niSnad iTvaliswinebsSemamsubuqebel an damamZimebel garemoebas, igive gare-moeba sasjelis daniSvnis dros mxedvelobaSi ar miiReba.
cvlilebis Setanas da s. m-Tvis saqarTvelos ssk-is 1261-emuxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ da `g~ qvepunqtebiT msjavrdebisnawilSi ufro mkacri sasjelis daniSvnas TavisuflebisaRkveTis saxiT, im motiviT, rom s. m. nasamarTlevia gan-zraxi danaSaulisTvis (qurdoba, ramac mniSvnelovani zi-ani gamoiwvia, Cadenili binaSi ukanono SeRweviT) da miu-xedavad mis mimarT gamoCenili lmobierebisa, rac gamoi-xata misTvis am danaSaulTan dakavSirebiT pirobiTi sas-jelis gansazRvriT, man arasrulwlovani Svilebis Tandas-wrebiT iZalada meuRlesa da mamaze. amdenad, aseT piro-bebSi aRniSnuli danaSaulisTvis msjavrdebulis mimarTsasjelis saxed sazogadoebisTvis sasargeblo Sromis gan-sazRvra ar aris samarTliani, ar Seesabameba s. m-is pirov-nebasa da mis mier Cadenili qmedebis xasiaTs, ar iqnebadamafiqrebeli da ver uzrunvelyofs mis resocializa-cias.
8. sakasacio palatam Seiswavla saqmis masalebi da miiC-nia, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi da utyuari mtkicebu-lebebi, maT Soris _ braldebul s. m-is aRiarebiTi Cvene-ba, dazaralebulebis: l. q-sa da m. m-is Cvenebebi, mowmee-bis: q. m-isa da k. m-is Cvenebebi, SemTxvevis adgilis daTva-lierebis oqmi, samedicino eqspertizis daskvna, romle-biTac gonivrul eWvs miRma dasturdeba, rom msjavrde-bulma s. m-em namdvilad Caidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniTmisTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedeba, rasac arc mxareebixdian sadavod.
9. mocemul SemTxvevaSi braldebis mxarem ganaCeni gaa-saCivra mxolod sasjelis nawilSi da iTxova s. m-Tvis pe-nitenciur dawesebulebaSi mosaxdeli sasjelis gansaz-Rvra, rac mimaCnia mizanSewonilad da prokuroris sakasa-cio saCivari unda dakmayofildes saqmeSi arsebul Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
10. zemoxsenebuli SemTxveva ar yofila msjavrdebu-lis mier ojaxis wevris mimarT Zaladobis pirveli faqti,rasac adasturebs 2015 wlis 5 agvistos ozurgeTis raio-nuli sasamarTlos mosamarTlis gadawyvetileba Semaka-vebeli orderis #... damtkicebis Sesaxeb moZalade-s. m-ismimarT. sasamarTlo sxdomaze Zaladobis msxverplma l. q-m mxari dauWira orderis damtkicebas da daadastura s. m-is mxridan mis mimarT ojaxuri Zaladobis faqtebi da s. m-
123
c daeTanxma Semakavebeli orderis damtkicebas. moZala-des daevala, moSoreboda msxverplis sacxovrebel saxls.aseve aekrZala l. q-sTan, mis samsaxursa da im adgilebTanmiaxloeba, sadac msxverpli imyofeboda. Semakavebeli or-deri gaica erTi Tvis vadiT. aRniSnuli cxadyofs, rommsjavrdebuli adrec Zaladobda ojaxis wevrze, meuRle-ze.
11. saqmeSi arsebobs msjavrdebulis mezoblis, mowmek. m-is dakiTxvis oqmi, sadac igi aRniSnavs, rom s. m. xSiradsvams da mTvrali Tavisi ojaxis wevrebis mimarT xdeba ag-resiuli. xSirad gaugonia misi ojaxidan msjavrdebulisyvirilisa da ginebis xma. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, Cans,rom s. m. sistematurad avlens agresias ojaxis wevrebismimarT da safrTxes warmoadgens maTTvis.
12. s. m-is pasuxismgeblobis erT-erT mTavar damamZime-bel garemoebas warmoadgens is, rom ojaxSi Zaladoba aryofila misi mxridan ganzraxi danaSaulis Cadenis pirve-li faqti, rac aRniSnulia prokuroris sakasacio saCivar-Si. ozurgeTis raionuli sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 2 noem-bris ganaCeniT damtkicda ozurgeTis raionuli prokura-turis prokurorsa da s. m-es Soris dadebuli saprocesoSeTanxmeba. s. m. cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos sis-xlis samarTlis kodeqsis 177-e muxlis meore nawilis `a~da imave muxlis mesame nawilis `g~ qvepunqtebiT gaTva-liswinebuli danaSaulis CadenaSi (qurdoba, ramac mniS-vnelovani ziani gamoiwvia, Cadenili binaSi ukanono SeR-weviT). aRniSnuli danaSaulebrivi qmedebis Cadenis gamo,sasamarTlom msjavrdebuls sasjelis saxed da zomad ga-nusazRvra 4 (oTxi) wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, rac sa-qarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 63-e, 64-e muxle-bis safuZvelze CaeTvala pirobiT msjavrad da gamosac-del vadad daudginda 4 (oTxi) weli. s. m-em ojaxuri Zala-doba Caidina gamosacdeli vadis msvlelobis periodSi. aR-niSnuls ki didi mniSvneloba gaaCnia bralis cnebis upira-tesobaze agebuli sisxlis samarTlisTvis, romlis mixed-viT, mosamarTle subieqturad da personalurad kicxavsdanaSaulebrivi qmedebis amsrulebels mis mier CadenilimarTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebis gamo. amasTan, sasjelsa dadanaSauls Soris proporciulobis gansazRvrisas, gardaCadenili danaSaulebrivi qmedebis makvalificirebeli da
124
Semamsubuqebeli garemoebebisa, xelmZRvanelobs asevedamnaSavis pirovnuli maxasiaTeblebiT. xolo sisxlis sa-marTlisTvis pirovnebis daxasiaTebis dros, pirvel rig-Si, gasaTvaliswinebelia misi kriminaluri warsuli, arisTu ara piri nasamarTlevi. nasamarTlobisa da miT umetes,pirobiT daniSnuli gamosacdeli vadis msvlelobisas gan-zraxi danaSaulis Cadena warmoadens iseT samarTlebrivmdgomareobas, romelic erTob amcirebs damnaSavis mimarTmsubuqi sasjelis gamoyenebis Sanss. mocemul SemTxveva-Si pirobiTma msjavrma ver uzrunvelyo sasjelis im miz-nebis miRweva, romelic gulisxmobs axali danaSaulis Ta-vidan acilebas da damnaSavis resocializacias. msjavrde-bul s. m-is mier ganxorcielebuli qmedebidan da misi pi-rovnebidan gamomdinare, misTvis sasjelis saxed sazoga-doebisTvis sasargeblo Sromis gansazRvra ver SeZlebsagreTve samarTlianobis aRdgenis miznis miRwevas.
13. garda aRniSnulisa, aucileblad mimaCnia msjavrde-bulis mier Cadenili qmedebis garemoebebis zedmiwevniTgaanalizeba. s. m. ojaxSi Zaladobas sCadis misi ojaxis oriwevris mimarT, Tanac arasrulwlovani Svilebis Tandas-wrebiT. saqmis masalebisa da mis mimarT Seracxuli bra-lis mixedviT, s. m-is mier Cadenili danaSauli faqtobri-vad moicavs ori epizodis kumulacias. saxeldobr, pir-vel SemTxvevaSi rogorc braldebulis, dazaralebule-bisa da mowmis CvenebebiT irkveva, jer sakuTari qaliSvi-lis TandaswrebiT fizikurad iZalada meuRleze _ l. q-ze, kerZod, Sublis areSi esrola Wiqa da saxeSi daartyamTeli ZaliT moqneuli xeli. Semdgom Zalis gamoyenebiTgaaRo mSoblebis saZinebeli oTaxis kari, romelic Signi-dan iyo Caketili TokiT, Sevarda oTaxSi, sadac eZinaTmsjavrdebulis mamas-m. m-es, dedas _ q. m-es da msjavrde-bulis arasrulwlovan Svils _ g. m-es. is yviroda da sit-yvierad emuqreboda sicocxlis mospobiT mamasa da saku-Tar meuRles _ l. q-as, romelic cdilobda daewynarebinamsjavrdebuli. amis Semdeg ki man mamas _ m. m-s, romeliccdilobda sawolidan wamodgomas, sxeulze, kerZod, fe-xebis areSi muStebiT miayena ramdenime dartyma. amgvariqmedebis Cadenam arasrulwlovanTa TandaswrebiT SesaZ-loa, savalalo zemoqmedeba iqonios maT fsiqikasa da Sem-dgom ganviTarebaze, vinaidan ojaxSi Zaladoba negatiur
125
gavlenas axdens bavSvze, ungrevs mas stabilurobisa dausafrTxoebis gancdas. rogorc sisxlis samarTlis saqme-Si arsebuli dabadebis mowmobebis aslebidan irkveva,msjavrdebulis Svilebi iyvnen 3 da 4 wlisani, rodesacSeeswrnen s. m-is mier ojaxis ori wevris mimarT CadenilZaladobas. s. m-em ar gaiTvaliswina, mis qmedebas ra uar-yofiTi gavlenis moxdena SeeZlo Tavis Svilebze. miT ume-tes, rom aRniSnul asakSi bavSvis fsiqika adreuli Camoya-libebis stadiazea da gamoirCeva gansakuTrebuli mgrZno-belobiT. is jer Tavisi qaliSvilis winaSe fizikurad Za-ladobs meuRleze, xolo Semdgom _ ukve sakuTar mamazeorive arasrulwlovani Svilis TandaswrebiT, rac calsa-xad warmoadgens Cadenili qmedebis maxasiaTebel iseT ga-remoebas, romelic mis saSiSroebas mniSvnelovnad zrdis.
14. rac Seexeba saqmeSi arsebul sasjelis Semamsubuqe-bel garemoebebs-s. m-is mier gamoZiebasTan TanamSromlo-basa da mis mier bralis aRiarebas, aseve sanotaro aqts,romliTac damowmebulia dazaralebulebis _ l. q-sa da m.m-is gancxadeba, romliTac isini afiqsireben, rom ar gaaC-niaT pretenziebi s. m-is mimarT da iTxoven masze kanoniTgaTvaliswinebuli maqsimaluri SeRavaTebis gavrcelebas,miTiTebuli garemoebebi SeiZleboda, gamxdariyo mxolodCadenili danaSaulisaTvis saqarTvelos ssk-is 1261-e mux-lis meore nawilis sanqciiT gaTvaliswinebuli sasjelissaxis _ Tavisuflebis aRkveTis farglebSi msjavrdebu-lisTvis SeRavaTis gawevis da ara mis mimarT ufro msubu-qi saxis sasjelis-sazogadoebisTvis sasargeblo Sromisgamoyenebis safuZveli.
15. mocemul sisxlis samarTlis saqmeSi arsebuli sas-jelis damamZimebeli da Semamsubuqebeli garemoebebis Se-darebiT davaskveni, rom s. m-Tvis sasjelis saxed da zomadsazogadoebisTvis sasargeblo Sromis Sefardeba aris zed-metad lmobieri sasjeli, ver akmayofilebs saqarTvelossssk-is 259-e muxlis me-4 nawilis moTxovnebs, romlis mi-xedviT, sasamarTlos ganaCeni samarTliania, Tu daniSnu-li sasjeli Seesabameba msjavrdebulis pirovnebas da mismier Cadenili danaSaulis simZimes, aseve ver uzrunvel-yofs saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis zogadi na-wilis 39-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT gansazRvruli sasje-lis miznebis ganxorcielebas. samarTlianobis aRdgena
126
praqtikaSi daiyvaneba samarTliani sasjelis daniSvnaze das. m-is danaSaulebrivi qmedebis damamZimebeli garemoebe-bidan gamomdinare, daniSnuli sasjeli, sazogadoebisTvissasargeblo Sroma, ver SeZlebs miaRwios samarTlianobisaRdgenis mizans. rac Seexeba axali danaSaulis Tavidan aci-lebasa da damnaSavis resocializacias, rogorc ukve aR-vniSne, msjavrdebulma ganzraxi danaSauli, janmrTelo-bis winaaRmdeg mimarTuli qmedeba _ ojaxSi Zaladoba (1261-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ da `g~ qvepunqtebi) Caidina gamo-sacdeli vadis msvlelobis dros da aseTi msubuqi sasje-lis gamoyeneba ver gamoricxavs mis mier axali danaSaulisCadenis risks da ver iqneba damafiqrebeli msjavrdebu-lisTvis, gaacnobieros Tavisi qmedebis xasiaTi, marTlwi-naaRmdegoba da danaSaulebrivi qmedebis simZime.
16. sasjelis proporciulobis, anu Tanazomierebisprincipi samarTlebrivi saxelmwifos ideidan momdinare-obs. daniSnulma sasjelma sazogadoebas samarTlianobisgancda unda gauCinos. amasTanve, sasjeli unda efuZne-bodes samarTlianobis ara abstraqtul ideas, aramed dam-naSavis racionalur, mizanSewonil dasjas, mis mier Cade-nili marTlsawinaaRmdego da braleuli qmedebis gamo, racxels uwyobs danaSaulTan efeqtian brZolas. amgvarad,sasjelis individualizaciis procesSi gadamwyveti mniS-vneloba eniWeba sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis normiT gaT-valiswinebuli sanqciis sworad SerCevas. am Tvalsazri-siT, sasjelis individualizaciisTvis maqsimalur SesaZ-leblobas iZleva SefardebiT gansazRvruli da alterna-tiuli sasjelebi. maTi meSveobiT sasamarTlos SeuZlia,gaiTvaliswinos danaSaulis saSiSroeba, damnaSavis pirov-neba da saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebu-li sxva garemoebebi. saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis ko-deqsis 1261-e muxlis me-2 nawili iTvaliswinebs sasjelisor saxes: sazogadoebisTvis sasargeblo Sromas an Tavi-suflebis aRkveTas. sazogadoebisTvis sasargeblo Sro-ma, rogorc sisxlis samarTlis sasjeli, warmoadgensmsjavrdebulis usasyidlo Sromas, romlis saxesac gan-sazRvravs probaciis biuro. Tavisi SinaarsiT igi gulis-xmobs sazogadoebisTvis sargeblis motanas. Sesabamisad,rodesac pirs Sefardebuli aqvs sazogadoebisTvis sasar-geblo Sroma, misi mxridan unda arsebobdes molodini, rom
127
igi aRar Caidens danaSauls. saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e mux-lis mesame nawilis mixedviT, sasamarTlo sasjelis daniS-vnisas iTvaliswinebs damnaSavis warsul cxovrebas, xolos. m-is warsuli ar iZleva safuZvels varaudisaTvis, romigi aRar Caidens saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeq-siT gaTvaliswinebul danaSauls da Tavisuflebis aRkve-Tis gareSe SesaZlebeli iqneba misi gamosworeba. ganxilulsaqmeSi arsebuli garemoebebi, kerZod: warsulSi Semaka-vebeli orderis arseboba, nasamarTloba, pirobiTi msjav-ris dros ojaxSi Zaladobis Cadena, arasrulwlovanTaTandaswrebiT, ojaxis ori wevris mimarT sasjelis indi-vidualizaciisTvis arsebiTia da am SemTxvevaSi gamoiric-xeba msubuqi sanqciis saxis, sazogadoebisTvis sasargeb-lo Sromis gamoyenebis safuZveli da misi daniSvna ver iq-neba samarTliani. sxvanairad, kanonmdebeli sasjelis sa-xed 1261-e muxlis nawiliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTas aRargansazRvravda da dasjerdeboda mxolod msubuq sanqci-as. sasjelis individualizaciisTvis alternativis dato-veba imas niSnavs, rom yoveli konkretuli SemTxveva undaSefasdes individualuri Taviseburebebidan gamomdina-re. vadiani Tavisuflebis aRkveTa ki ufro efeqtian ze-gavlenas moaxdenda msjavrdebulze, vinaidan igi gulis-xmobs damnaSavis sazogadoebisgan izolacias misi Tavi-suflebis aRkveTis dawesebulebaSi moTavsebiT da SesaZ-lebels gaxdida sasjelis miznebis miRwevas, rac ver uz-runvelyo s. m-is SemTxvevaSi kanoniT gaTvaliswinebulmaSeRavaTebis gamoyenebam. sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 53-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Sesabamisad, sasjelis ufromkacri saxe SeiZleba dainiSnos mxolod maSin, rodesacnaklebad mkacri saxis sasjeli ver uzrunvelyofs sasje-lis miznis ganxorcielebas.
17. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, maqvs raCemi kolega mosamarTleebisgan gansxvavebuli azri, mi-maCnia, rom msjavrdebul s. m-es, mis mier Cadenili danaSa-ulebrivi qmedebis gamo, sasjelis saxed unda gansazRvro-da Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, saqarTvelos ssk-is 1261-e mux-lis me-2 nawilis sanqciiT gaTvaliswinebul farglebSi.
manve Caidina Zarcva, ese igi sxvisi moZravi nivTis aSkaradaufleba marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebis mizniT, ra-mac mniSvnelovani ziani gamoiwvia, Cadenili ZaladobiT,romelic saSiSi ar aris sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaT-vis.
mis mier Cadenili danaSaulebrivi qmedebebi gamoixa-ta SemdegSi:
2016 wlis 19 Tebervals, saRamos saaTebSi, v. S. imyofe-boda T-Si, metros sadgur `d-is~ mimdebare teritoriaze,15 wlis r. m-sa da 11 wlis o. b-Tan erTad. am dros v. S-maSeamCnia, rom metros mxridan S-is xidis mimarTulebiT fe-xiT marto moZraobda s. z.. v. S-ma r. m-sa da o. b-es SesTava-za, gahyolodnen gogos, raTa misTvis waerTmiaT fuli. r.m. da o. b. dasTanxmdnen da yvela erTad gahyva s. z-s. ro-desac isini miuaxlovdnen restoran — v. S-ma, r. m-ma da o.b-em s. z. Zaladobis gamoyenebiT Caiyvanes b-is sanapiros-ken mdebare tye-parkSi da waaqcies. v. S-ma da r. m-ma gadaw-yvites s. z-is gaupatiureba da sxvagvari seqsualuri kon-taqtis damyareba gaukuRmarTebuli formiT, Tumca da-zaralebuli uwevda winaaRmdegobas. miuxedavad amisa, v.S-ma s. z-s Semoaxia tansacmeli, ra drosac r. m-s gogonadaWerili hyavda, ar aZlevda moZraobis saSualebas da mis-Tvis xeli pirze hqonda afarebuli, raTa ar eyvira. v. S-mada r. m-ma cemisa da Zaladobis gamoyenebiT s. z-s gaxadesqveda sacvali da v. S-ma Zaladobis gamoyenebiT daamyaramasTan sqesobrivi kavSiri. Zaladobrivi sqesobrivi aqtismomentSi r. m-s gakavebuli hyavda s. z. da pirze xelis afa-rebiT ar aZlevda yvirilis saSualebas. amis Semdeg v. S-maZaladobis gamoyenebiT, r. m-is daxmarebiT, s. z. gadmoab-runa mucliT miwisken. miwaze waqceul s. z-s v. S-ma mos-Txova misTvis gadaeca fuli, razec dazaralebulma uariganucxada. v. S-ma Zaladobis gamoyenebiT, romelic saSiSiar aris sicocxlisa da janmrTelobisaTvis, s. z-s qurTu-kis jibidan aSkarad, marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebismizniT, amoacala 175 lari da sakredito baraTebi. Semdegman winaaRmdegobisa da Txovnis miuxedavad, gaukuRmar-Tebuli formiT, ukana tanidan daamyara masTan sqesobri-vi kavSiri, ris Semdegac v. S-s Caenacvla r. m., romelmacaseve gaukuRmarTebuli formiT daamyara s. z-Tan sqesob-rivi kavSiri, rasac Tan axlda Zaladoba da cema, ris Sem-
130
degac v. S-ma, r. m-ma da o. b-em datoves SemTxvevis adgili.3. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-
advokati msjavrdebulis gamarTlebis safuZvlad mi-uTiTebs im garemoebaze, rom saqmeSi ar arsebobs utyuarmtkicebulebaTa iseTi erToblioba, romelic sakmarisi iq-neboda v. S-is msjavrdebisTvis. sasamarTlom usafuZvlodgaiziara dazaralebulis mier sasamarTloSi micemuli Cve-neba, romelic iyo radikalurad gansxvavebuli da urTi-erTgamomricxavi mis mier gamoZiebaSi micemuli Cvenebis-gan, sadac is ambobda, rom v. S-s ar daumyarebia seqsualu-ri kontaqti arc saSodan da arc gaukuRmarTebuli for-miT, man mxolod fuli waarTva. aseve, ar unda iqnes gazia-rebuli mowmeebis _ r. m-sa da o. b-is Cvenebebi, vinaidanisini urTierTwinaaRmdegobrivia da Seicavs mxolod damxolod urTierTgamomricxav garemoebebs. saqmeSi arse-buli eqspertizis daskvnebis Tanaxmad ki, naTlad gamo-ikveTa is faqti, rom v. S-s raime saxis kavSiri aRniSnuldanaSaulTan ar hqonia.
samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palatam sakasacio saCivrebisa da saqmis ma-
salebis Seswavlis Sedegad daaskvna, rom kasatoris moT-xovna ar unda dakmayofildes, xolo gasaCivrebul gana-CenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
3. saqarTvelos parlamentis 2017 wlis 5 aprilis dad-genilebiT ratificirebul iqna evropis sabWos konvencia`qalTa mimarT Zaladobisa da ojaxSi Zaladobis preven-ciisa da aRkveTis Sesaxeb~ (e.w. ̀ stambolis konvencia~), ro-melic miznad isaxavs qalebis dacvas yvela formis Zala-dobisagan. dasaxelebuli konvenciis 36-e muxliT dadge-nilia yoveli qalis seqsualuri Zaladobis, maT Soris _gaupatiurebisagan dacvis valdebuleba. niSandoblivia,rom sakasacio palatam araerTxel gausva xazi seqsualu-ri Zaladobis gansakuTrebulad mZime xasiaTsa da mis da-mangrevel gavlenas msxverplze da, Sesabamisad, saxel-mwifos valdebulebas seqsualuri Zaladobisgan adamia-nis dacvis Taobaze, xolo ukve Cadenili danaSaulis Sem-TxvevaSi damnaSavis gamovlenisa da misTvis adekvaturisasjelis Sefardebis, danaSaulis msxverplis mimarT ki _saTanado moraluri/fsiqologiuri mxardaWeris aRmoCe-nis aucileblobas (magaliTisTvis ix. saqme #466ap-16).
4. palatam araerTxel imsjela aseve dazaralebulisCvenebis mniSvnelovnobaze am kategoriis danaSaulTa gan-xilvisas da miuTiTa, rom gansakuTrebuli yuradReba un-da mieqces dazaralebulis Cvenebis Tanmimdevrulobasada Sesabamisobas sxva mtkicebulebebsa da saqmeze dadge-nil sxva faqtobriv garemoebebTan (ix. saqmeebi #253ap-15, #466ap-16).
5. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom mxareTa sruli Tana-saworobisa da SejibrebiTobis pirobebSi gamokvleulimtkicebulebebiT gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiTaa da-dasturebuli v. S-is mier misTvis bralad Seracxuli qme-debebis Cadena, kerZod:
6. dazaralebulma s. z-ma ganmarta, rom 2016 wlis 20 Te-bervals, Rame, daaxloebiT 23:30-24:00 saaTze, samsaxuri-dan saxlSi fexiT brundeboda. d-is xidis bolos, benzin-gasamarT sadgurTan, miuaxlovda axalgazrda mamakaci dagamoelaparaka gacnobis mizniT, rasac s. z-ma ar miaqciayuradReba da ganagrZo gza. parkSi gzis gadakveTisas, v. S.miuaxlovda da ukanalze miartya xeli, ramac gaaRizianas. z. da mamakacs miayena sityvieri Seuracxyofa. am dros
132
dainaxa, rom S-s mohyveboda ori, misi azriT, arasrulwlo-vani. samive Semoexvia da CaaTries g-is ukana mxares, tye-parkSi. igi daRmarTze waaqcies, ra drosac mravali Wri-loba miiRo. S. daawva zemodan, auwia qvedabolo, sacvaligauxia da cdilobda seqsualuri aqtis ganxorcielebas,raSic exmareboda ori mozardi _ r. m. da o. b.. S-ma amoiRosasqeso organo Sarvlidan, romelic hqonda eregirebulida amyarebda masTan sqesobriv kavSirs, kerZod: sasqesoorganoTi awveboda sasqeso organoze da akeTebda biZgebs,ris gamoc did tkivils ganicdida, vinaidan iyo qaliSvi-li. am dros is ori piri xelebs uWerda, raTa naklebi emoZ-rava da naklebi winaaRmdegoba gaewia S-sTvis, romelicmaTTvis meTauriviT iyo, radgan swored S. aZlevdaT brZa-nebebs. r. m. da S. urtyamdnen da ayenebdnen sityvier Seu-racxyofas, ra drosac miiRo dazianebebi. amis Semdeg S-madaiwyo masturbacia da Tan eubneboda, rom sxvebi xels araxlebden, Tan xelebs ufaTurebda. Semdeg dazaralebu-li gadaabrunes mucelze, ra drosac ukana tanSi viRacamTiTi Seuyo. dazaralebulma daazusta, rom, SesaZloa, Ti-Ti ar iyo da sxva rame iyo. manve ganmarta, rom zustad aricis, konkretulad romelma, SesaZloa, S-ma SesaZloa, m-ma. Semdeg m-ma TmaSi mohkida xeli da xian-totian adgilassaxiT aTria da masTan oraluri sqesobrivi aqti daamyara.Semdeg m-ma masTan analuri sqesobrivi kavSiric daamyara,ra drosac daRvara sperma, romelic dazaralebulma ig-rZno sxeulze. amis Semdeg moZaladeebma datoves SemTxve-vis adgili, xolo dazaralebulma mimarTa policias.
7. r. m-ma ganmarta, rom icnobs da megobruli urTier-Toba aqvs v. S-Tan. 2016 wlis 20 Tebervals r. m. imyofebo-da Tavis deidaSvil o. b-sTan erTad. isini v-ze Sexvdnen v.S-s da wavidnen d-Si, sadac ludis barTan dainaxes gogo-na, romelsac daedevna S., xidTan daewia da gacnoba SesTa-vaza, razec gogom uari ganucxada da mosTxova Tavi dae-nebebina. v. S-ma da man gogona daiWires TmiT da xididanqvemoT CaaTries, kaba gauxies da winaaRmdegobis miuxe-davad, jer S-a, xolo Semdeg TviTon daamyares masTan sqe-sobrivi kavSiri. m-is ganmartebiT, S-ma rogorc `winidan~,ise `uknidan~ daamyara dazaralebulTan sqesobrivi kav-Siri.
8. mowme o. b-is CvenebiT irkveva, rom igi da misi dei-
133
daSvili r. m. d-is metrosTan Sexvdnen v. S-s. am dros d-ismetrosTan gamoiara gogonam. S-ma m-s uTxra, rom wasuliy-vnen da fuli waerTmiaT. samive gahyva gogonas da wavid-nen tyisken, sadac S-ma igi CaaTria tyeSi da daiwyo `cudiraRaceebis~ keTeba. Tan S-ma gogos muSti daartya. jer S-ma `gaakeTa cudi saqme~, ra drosac m. gogos fexebs uWer-da.
9. 2016 wlis 25 Tebrvlis amocnobis oqmiT dasturde-ba, rom s. z-ma amosacnobad warmodgenili sami axalgaz-rda mamakacidan amoicno piri, romelic cdilobda masTansqesobrivi kavSiris damyarebas da waarTva daaxloebiT165-175 lari. amocnobili piri aris v. S..
11. sasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis #... daskvnisTanaxmad, romlis sisworec daadastures eqspertebma _e. C-ma, T. q-em da d. g-m, s. z-s sxeulze aReniSneba daziane-bebi mravlobiTi sisxlnaJRenTebis, nakawrebisa da naWde-vebis saxiT. nakawrebi ganviTarebuli unda iyos raime max-vili sagnis wvetis, lesili kidis an mkveTrad gamoxatulikidis mqone mkvrivi-blagvi sagnis/sagnebis moqmedebiT dayvela dazianeba, cal-calke da erTad aRebuli, miekuT-vneba sxeulis dazianebaTa msubuq xarisxs, janmrTelo-bis mouSlelad. xandazmulobiT arsebuli dazianebebisganviTareba ar ewinaaRmdegeba saqmis garemoebebSi miTi-Tebul TariRs. amave daskvnis mixedviT, s. z-is saqalwu-le apkis mTlianoba darRveuli ar aris.
12. sasamarTlo-samedicino eqspertizis #... daskvnisTanaxmad, romlis sisworec daadastures eqspertebma _e. C-ma, T. q-em da d. g-am, s. z. aris orsulad da orsulobisvada (30.03.16-is mdgomareobiT) Seesabameba Svid kviras. s.z. SesaZloa, daorsulebuliyo saSoSi sasqeso asos Seyva-nisa da saqalwule apkis mTlinobis darRvevis gareSe, imSemTxvevaSi, Tu eakulati daiRvreboda saSos SesavalTan.T. q-em da d. g-am aseve ganmartes, rom xSiria SemTxvevebi,roca ukana tanidan xdeba sqesobrivi kavSiri da ar rCeba
134
kvali nawiburisa Tu dazianebis saxiT.13. C-s saxelobis klinikis mean-ginekologiis departa-
mentis xelmZRvanelma n. k-am daadastura, rom 30 martismdgomareobiT s. z. iyo Svidi kviris orsuli. mowmis gan-martebiT, orsulobis zusti TariRis gansazRvra ar arismartivi da TariRi zedmiwevniT zusti ver iqneba.
14. biologiuri eqspertizis #... daskvniTa da eqspertv. o-as CvenebiT, s. z-is tansacmelze aRmoCenili laqebi,romlebicSeicavs spermas, ekuTvnis r. m-s.
15. palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris pozicias, rom da-zaralebulis mier sasamarTloSi micemuli Cveneba iyo ra-dikalurad gansxvavebuli da urTierTgamomricxavi mismier gamoZiebaSi micemuli informaciisgan, sadac is yve-la CvenebaSi ambobda, rom v. S. cdilobda masTan sqesobri-vi kavSiris damyarebs, Tumca ar daumyarebia arc `wesie-ri~ da arc gaukuRmarTebuli formiT, vinaidan s. z-ma da-majereblad ganmarta sasamarTlo sxdomaze dakiTxvisas,rom vinaidan iyo qaliSvili da ar hqonda sqesobrivi kav-Siris gamocdileba, mis aRqmaSi sqesobrivi kavSiri aqtisdamTavrebasa da spermis daRvrasTan asocirdeboda, risgamoc gamoZiebaSi miuTiTa, rom v. S. cdilobda, Tumca ardaumyarebia masTan sqesobrivi kavSiri. sakasacio palatis-Tvis logikuri da damajerebelia s. z-is ganmarteba da mas-Si eWvis Setanis safuZveli palatas ar gasCenia.
16. s. z-is Cvenebis siswores adasturebs is faqtic, romigi SemTxvevis Semdeg daorsulda. orsulobis TariRi,imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom ver iqneba zedmiwevniT zusti,Seesabameba danaSaulebrivi qmedebis Cadenis dros. sagu-lisxmoa isic, rom eqspertebma daadastures piris daor-sulebis SesaZlebloba im viTarebaSi, rasac aRwers s. z..
17. palata ar iziarebs aseve dacvis mxaris pozicias mow-meebis _ r. m-sa da o. b-is CvenebebTan dakavSirebiT, rom,TiTqosda, isini urTierTwinaaRmdegobrivia da Seicavsmxolod da mxolod uriTerTgamomricxav garemoebebs, vi-naidan arsebiTi xasiaTis winaaRmdegobebi TviTmxilveliarasrulwlovani mowmeebis _ r. m-sa da o. b-is CvenebebsSoris, miT umetes maTi _ gansakuTrebiT o. b-is (11 wlis) _asakis gaTvaliswinebiT, konkretulad v. S-is mier s. z-isgaupatiurebis da seqsualuri xasiaTis ZalmomreobiTimoqmedebis faqtTan dakavSirebiT, ar gamovlenila.
135
18. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba aseve dacvis mxa-res, rom saqmeSi arsebuli eqspertizis daskvnebiT gamoi-ricxa v. S-is raime saxis kavSiri aRniSnul danaSaulTan,vinaidan, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom v. S-is mier s. z-TanCadenili sqesobrivi Zaladobis dasrulebis Semdeg, mas-Tan sqesobrivi Zaladoba gaagrZela r. m-ma da am dros sru-liad SesaZlebelia, rom v. S-is genetikuri masala gadae-fara r. m-is genetikur masalas, risi SesaZleblobac daa-dastura eqspertma.
19. dacvis mxare aseve apelirebs dazaralebulis Cve-nebaze, romlis mixedviT, v. S-ma gadaatriala ukan, zur-gze. rodesac amoabrunes, igrZno, rom mis analur xvrel-Si romeliRacam Seyo TiTi, Tumca ar gamoricxavs, rom esar yofiliyo TiTi, ra drosac igrZno Zlieri tkivili davinaidan dazaralebuli ver asaxelebs, rom konkretuladS. iyo is piri, romelmac Seuyo TiTi, es aris varaudi, ro-melic unda gadawydes msjavrdebulis sasargeblod da v.S. udanaSaulod unda iqnes cnobili seqsualuri xasiaTisZalmomreobiTi moqmedebis braldebaSi. sakasacio pala-ta ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris aRniSnul mosazrebas Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
r. m-is ganmartebiT, v. S-ma s. z-Tan orjer daamyara sqe-sobrivi kavSiri, erTxel _ bunebrivi gziT, xolo meored_ gaukuRmarTebuli formiT ukana tanidan. S. rom adga,Semdeg uTxra, rom xeliT gaagrZeleo. S-s kavSiri orjerhqonda, erTxel _ `winidan~ erTxel _ `uknidan~.
piris amocnobis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom 2016 wlis 25Tebervals T-Si, gr. r-is gamziris #...-si, d-is sammarTve-los _ ganyofilebis administraciul SenobaSi, o. b-es ga-momZiebelma amosacnobad warudgina sami piri, romelTa-gan amoicno erTi _ saxelad `g.~ (v. S-s am saxeliT icnobda),romelmac gogonas auwia kaba da Semoaxia trusi, daawvinamucelze da sajdomis mxridan `gaukeTa cudi saqme~.
20. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris mosaz-rebas, rom dazaralebulis Cvenebis gaziarebis SemTxve-vaSic ki gamokveTilia danaSaulis mcdeloba da miuTiTebs,rom gaupatiureba damTavrebulad CaiTvleba, rodesacdamnaSave sxvadasxva xerxis gamoyenebiT daiwyebs sqesob-rivi kavSiris damyarebas da ara aqvs mniSvneloba, miiyvansTu ara bolomde sqesobriv aqts. qmedebis dasrulebulad
136
miCnevisTvis ara aqvs mniSvneloba, sasqeso asos Seyvanadasruldeba saSos SesavalTan Tu TviT saSoSi, vinaidanam droidan ukve xelyofilia adamianis sqesobrivi Tavi-sufleba.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rommsjavrdebul d. v-is interesebis damcvelis, advokat T.t-is sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, xolo ga-
141
saCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
2. palata aRniSnavs, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi dautyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivrul eWvsmiRma dasturdeba, rom msjavrdebulma d. v-ma namdviladCaidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis bralad Serac-xuli qmedebebi, kerZod:
3. dazaralebulma d. j-am sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiTdakiTxvisas ganacxada, rom d. v-i aris misi colisdis _ q.a-is yofili meuRle, romelTanac da aseve v. b-sTanac bav-Svobidan hqonda megobruli urTierToba. 2015 wlis 7 seq-tembers mas Sexvda d. v-i da sTxova, saxlSi gahyoloda,radgan saqme hqonda. d. v-is saxlSi misvlisas isini q. a-TandakavSirebiT Selaparakdnen, ris Semdeg d. v-ma da v. b-emigi Zirs daagdes, plastmasis xundebiT Seukres xel-fe-xi, webovani lenti aakres saxeze, yurebSi bamba Caudes,Tvalebi auxvies, raTa mas ar enaxa viRac piri, romelicsaxlSi unda misuliyo, da am mdgomareobaSi misaReb oTax-Si, divanze dasves daaxloebiT 3 saaTis ganmavlobaSi. d.j-am aseve ganacxada, rom misi dabmis dros d. v-s xelSieWira samxedro formis sqeli dana.
4. dazaralebulma m. a-ma sasamarTloze aCvena, rom 2015wlis 7 seqtembers meuRlis telefonidan miiRo Setyobi-neba, rom Sexvedroda n-is quCaze mdebare Zvel afTiaq-Tan. iq Casvlisas mas Sexvda d. v-i, romelmac moatyua, romd. j-a iyo mTvrali, gaxda cudad da mis mosavlelad undawaeyvana. m. a-i d. v-ma manqaniT miiyvana Tavis saxlSi, sadacmiepara uknidan, pirze xeli aafara, xolo v. b-em xel-fexiSeukra plastmasis xundebiT, pirSi Caudes naWeri da ga-daakres webovani lenti. d. v-ma da v. b-em m-s daanaxvesoTaxSi dabmuli meuRle, Semdeg Seiyvanes saZinebelSi,ris Semdegac v. b-e gavida oTaxidan, xolo d. v-ma igi gaa-SiSvla da dauwyo fotosuraTebis gadaReba sxvadasxva po-zaSi, Tan emuqreboda, rom yvelafers gaimeorebda d. j-asTandaswrebiT da fotoebs gauvrcelebda. suraTebis ga-daReba rom daamTavra, d. v-ma m. a-i sawolze daayena mux-lebiT da Zalis gamoyenebiT daamyara masTan seqsualurikontaqti ukana tanidan. vinaidan mas hqonda buasilis niS-nebi, igrZno tkivili da rogorc SeeZlo, uwevda winaaR-mdegobas. momxdaris Semdeg d. v-ma Caacva tansacmeli da
142
isini erTad gavidnen manqaniT, Semdeg ukan dabrundnen,manqanaSi Caisves d. j-a, romelic v. b-sTan erTad ezoSiijda da wavidnen a-is saxlSi. d. v-s Tavisi saxlis misaRebda saZinebel oTaxebSi hqonda momrgvalebulTaviani da-na, msxvili, muqi yavisferi tariT. saxlSi misvlisas m. a-mayvelaferi uambo mamas, darekes sapatrulo policiaSi,Tumca d. v-i iq aRar iyo. m. a-is ganmartebiT, rogorc mas d.v-ma ganucxada, yvelaferi imitom gaakeTa, rom m-sa da mismeuRles adanaSaulebda q. a-Tan dacilebaSi.
5. mowme q. a-ma dakiTxvisas ganacxada, rom d. j-as te-lefonidan miRebuli Setyobinebis Semdeg m. wavida meuR-lesTan Sesaxvedrad. m. da d. v-is quCaSi saubari dainaxamezobelma da uTxra q-s, swored amitom man daureka d. dadis ambavi hkiTxa. amis mere saxlSi maleve mividnen d. j-a,m. a-i da d. v-i. m. oTaxSi Seiketa, tiroda da iTxovda mamis_ n. a-is saswrafod misvlas. mamis misvlis Semdeg m-ma moh-yva momxdaris Sesaxeb da gamoiZaxes patruli, xolo d. isewavida saxlidan, ver gaiges. q. a-is gancxadebiT, is da Ta-visi meuRle xSirad Cxubobdnen, d. fsiqologiurad da fi-zikurad (maT Soris _ seqsualuradac) Zaladobda masze,ris gamoc dascildnen. m-a da d-s hqondaT CveulebriviurTierToba, Tumca erTmaneTi ar uyvardaT.
6. mowme n. a-is CvenebiT, 2015 wlis 7 seqtembers, darek-vis Semdeg, is saswrafod dabrunda saxlSi, Sevida m-isoTaxSi, romelmac mouTxro momxdaris Sesaxeb. saubrisasmoesma q-is da d-is Cxubis xma da gamovida maT gasaCereb-lad, ra drosac d. v-ma uTxra, rom yvelaferi zRapari iyoda m-isaTvis ar daejerebina. Semdeg gaxda cudad da gamo-iZaxes saswrafo daxmareba. samedicino daxmareba dasWir-da d. j-sac. aRniSnuli Cveneba daadastura n. a-is meuR-lem v. c-m, romelmac aseve aCvena, rom, ise rom `gaupatiu-reba~ aravis uxsenebia, d. v-ma n. a-s uTxra, rom gaupatiu-rebaSi sdebdnen brals da amiT bavSvs ufuWebdnen moma-vals.
7. braldebulma v. b-em sasamarTlo sxdomaze ganacxa-da, rom Zaladoba ar CaudeniaT. d. v-ma uTxra d. j-s, romviRacas hqonda misi vali, movalis SesaSineblad da valisdasabruneblad d-s gakoWavda, xolo fulis dabrunebisSemdeg erTad wavidodnen sadme dasasveneblad. d-as d-saTvis uari ar uTqvams da nebiT gauwoda xelebi. gakoWi-
143
li d. j-a karisken zurgiT dasves, ris Semdegac d. v-i ga-reT gavida da daaxloebiT naxevar saaTSi dabrunda d-asmeuRlesTan _ m. a-Tan erTad. d. v. b-e gaagzavna ludis mo-satanad, saxlSi dabrunebulma ki dainaxa, rom d. da m. di-vanze isxdnen da saubrobdnen, Semdeg isini gavidnen, xo-lo d-ma daubara, rom d-sTvis aexsna webovani lenti damas dalodebodnen. m-isa da d-is dabrunebis Semdeg m-setyoboda nerviuloba. amis Semdeg samive Cajda manqanaSida wavida, xolo TviTon dabrunda saxlSi. daaxloebiT sa-aT-naxevarSi d. v-isagan gaigo, rom m. mas brals sdebda ga-upatiurebaSi, ris Semdegac wavida sofelSi.
8. braldebulma d. v-ma sasamarTlo sxdomaze aCvena,rom meuRlesTan _ q. a-Tan urTierTobaSi cudad ereodam. a-i, razec Tavis saxlSi esaubra d. j-as. am saubris Sem-deg d-s auxsna, rom valis dabrunebis mizniT mas gakoWav-da, gakoWils dasvamda meore oTaxSi da aCvenebda mova-les, razec d. dasTanxmda. igi gakoWes yovelgvari Zala-dobis gareSe. amis Semdeg saxlSi motyuebiT miiyvana m. a-i, dauwyo saubari q-Tan urTierTobaze, Semdeg aiRo tum-boze dadebuli e.w. `skoCi~, Seukra xel-fexi da aukra pi-ri. am dros m-i winaaRmdegobas ar uwevda. m-s gadauRo 3-4suraTi, makratliT gauxsna xel-fexi da gaagrZeles sau-bari. Semdeg TviTon da m-i manqaniT gavidnen, xolo v. b-esdaubara, rom is da d. j-a ezoSi dalodebodnen. `...-Si~ bav-SvisTvis iogurtis yidvis Semdeg TviTon, d. j-a da m. a-imanqaniT wavidnen m-is saxlSi, xolo v. b-e _ Tavis saxlSi.a-Tan misvlis Semdeg m-ma mamas uTxra, rom d. v-ma da v. b-emmasze iZalades, gaaSiSvles da fotoebi gadauRes. n. a-mad-s urCia, rom saxlSi wasuliyo da saRamos daelaparake-boda. d. v-ma ganmarta, rom d. j-as xel-fexi Seukra mot-yuebiT, raTa misi telefonis saSualebiT m-i advilad ga-moeyvana saxlidan. am dros d-as winaaRmdegoba ar gauwe-via. m-s fotoebis gamoqveynebiT imitom daemuqra, rom fiq-robda, daexmareboda meuRlesTan SerigebaSi. rac Seexe-ba sanadiro danas, aseTi saxlSi saerTod ara aqvs. saRamosnaxa mSoblebi da wavida sofelSi, sadac daakaves 8 seq-tembers, RamiT.
9. nivTieri mtkicebulebis gaxsnisa da daTvalierebis2015 wlis 9 seqtembris oqmis mixedviT, d. v-isagan amoRe-buli TeTri feris `SAMSUNG-is~ firmis telefonis kom-
144
piuterze SeerTebisas gaxsnes specialuri saqaRalde, ro-melzec gadatanili iyo, savaraudod, waSlili fotosu-raTebi; maTi daTvalierebisas aRmoCnda m. a-isaTvis SiS-vel mdgomareobaSi gadaRebuli 4 fotosuraTi da xelfex-Sekrul d. j-as erTi suraTi, romelsac Tavze Camofare-buli aqvs Savi qsovili, xolo Tvalebze akruli aqvs webo-vani lenti. aRniSnuli fotosuraTebi telefonis mexsie-rebidan amoiRes, aRadgines da gadaitanes diskze.
12. eqspertizebis daskvnis siswore sasamarTlo sxdo-maze daadastures eqspertebma _ T. q-em da q. b-ma.
13. zemoCamoTvlili mtkicebulebebiTa da nivTiere-baTa, masalaTa, nakeTobaTa da mcenareTa eqspertizis #-da odorologiuri eqspertizis #- daskvnebiT, d. j-as mi-er nebayoflobiT warmodgenili BLACKBERRY-is firmis mo-bilur telefonSi dafiqsirebuli zarebiTa da Setyobi-nebebiT, aseve _ d. j-asa da m. a-is mier warmodgenili tan-sacmliT utyuarad dasturdeba d. v-isa da v. b-is mier sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 143-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `g~ da me-3 na-wilis `a~, `g~, `e~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSa-ulis Cadena.
14. garda amisa, palata aRniSnavs, rom qmedebis aRniS-nuli muxliT kvalifikaciisaTvis mniSvneloba ara aqvs da-
145
zaralebulTa mxridan winaaRmdegobis gawevis xarisxs,mTavaria, rom gadaadgilebis ufleba SeizRuda maTive ne-bis sawinaaRmdegod. gasaTvaliswinebelia, rom orive da-zaralebuli CvenebebSi miuTiTebs, rom d. v-s Tan hqondadidi sanadiro dana, romlis gamoyenebis safuZvliani Si-Si gauCndaT; amasTan, dazaralebulebi danas aRweren um-niSvnelo gansxvavebiT, rac eWvis gaCenis safuZvels ar iZ-leva.
15. usafuZvloa dacvis argumenti imasTan dakavSire-biT, rom dazaralebulebs hqondaT saSualeba, vinmesTviseTxovaT daxmareba, radgan, rogorc m. a-ma ganacxada, d. v-is saxlidan gasvlisas iq darCa gakoWili d. j-a da misTvisrom araferi daeSavebinaT, swored amitom ar iTxova dax-mareba; rac Seexeba d. j-as, man sasamarTloze ganmarta,rom gaTavisuflebis Semdeg is imdenad iyo SeSinebuli,rom daeloda d. v-is dabrunebas, radgan ar icoda, borot-moqmedebi kidev ras moimoqmedebdnen.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida daskvnam-de, rom msjavrdebul S. b-is sakasacio saCivari unda dak-mayofildes nawilobriv da gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi undaSevides cvlileba Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. palatas miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi da ut-yuari mtkicebulebebi, maT Soris _ dazaralebul m. n-sada mowmeebis _ n. T-is, g. a-is, z. q-is, c. b-is, a. a-is, m. p-sa dag. g-is Cvenebebi, dakavebisa da daTvalirebis oqmebi, rom-lebiTac gonivrul eWvs miRma dasturdeba msjavrdebulS. b-is mier qurdobis Cadenis faqti, ris gamoc palata ariziarebs kasatoris pozicias misi gamarTlebis Sesaxeb.
3. amasTan, sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba saapelaciosasamarTlos S. b-is qmedebis saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e mux-lis me-4 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT _ qurdoba, Cadenili imismier, vinc orjer an metjer iyo nasamarTlevi sxvisi moZ-ravi nivTis marTlsawinaaRmdego misakuTrebisaTvis _ dak-valificirebis nawilSi Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
4. sasjelis gansazRvrisas palata mxedvelobaSi iRebsim garemoebas, rom S. b. midrekilia sakuTrebis winaaRmdegmimarTuli danaSaulis Cadenisken, pasuxismgeblobis Se-mamsubuqebeli garemoebebi ki ar gaaCnia.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da daaskvna, rommsjavrdebul l. b-a da misi interesebis damcvelis, advo-kat s. f-s sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, xo-lo gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvlelad, Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
158
2. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom warmodgenilia sak-marisi da utyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac goniv-rul eWvs miRma dasturdeba, rom msjavrdebulma l. b-anamdvilad Caidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis bra-lad Seracxuli qmedebebi, rasac arc Tavad dacvis mxarexdis sadavod.
3. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs dacvis mxaris pozici-as, rom l. b-s Sefardebuli sasjeli aris zedmetad mkac-ri da ar Seesabameba `bavSvTa uflebebis konvenciis~ me-3da me-40 muxlebis moTxovnebs, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
4. `bavSvTa uflebebis konvenciis~ 37-e muxlis (b) pun-qtis mixedviT, bavSvisaTvis Tavisuflebis aRkveTa da mi-si dapatimreba SeiZleba ganxorcieldes mxolod kanonisTanaxmad da mxolod ukiduresi zomis saxiT, rac SeiZle-ba Sesaferisi, naklebi periodiT. `gaeros standartuliminimaluri wesebi arasrulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebisganxorcielebis Sesaxeb~ (`pekinis wesebi~) 17.1 _ `b~, `g~ we-sebis Tanaxmad, arasrulwlovnis piradi TavisuflebisSezRudva SeiZleba gamoyenebul iqnes mxolod dawvrile-biT ganxilvis Sedegad da unda Semoifarglos SesaZlo mi-nimumiT. piradi Tavisuflebis SezRudva ar gamoiyeneba,Tu arasrulwlovans ar asamarTleben seriozuli qmede-bis _ sxva piris mimarT Zaladobis an sxva seriozuli sa-marTaldarRvevebis araerTjeradi CadenisaTvis da Tu ararsebobs sxva Sesabamisi zemoqmedebis RonisZieba.
5. gansaxilvel saqmeSi l. b-s brali Seracxuli aqvs gan-sakuTrebiT mZime danaSaulisaTvis, xolo warsulSi igiorjeraa nasamarTlevi mZime danaSaulebis CadenisaTvis.sakasacio palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs arasrulwlovanTamarTlmsajulebis kodeqsis 76-e muxlis danawess, romlisTanaxmad, mosamarTle uflebamosilia, arasrulwlovansSeufardos kanoniT gaTvaliswinebul zRvarze naklebi ansxva, ufro msubuqi sasjeli, Tu mis mimarT warsulSi ga-mamtyunebeli ganaCeni ar yofila gamotanili, magram gan-martavs, rom uflebamosili ar aris, l. b-s mimarT gamoi-yenos miTiTebuli SeRavaTi, radgan igi warsulSi orje-raa nasamarTlevi mZime danaSaulebis CadenisaTvis. gardaamisa, sakasacio palata aseve iTvaliswinebs im garemoeba-sac, rom saqarTvelos ssk-is 178-e muxlis me-4 nawilis san-qcia sasjelis saxed da zomad adgens mxolod Tavisuf-
159
lebis aRkveTas da ar gaaCnia arc erTi sxva alternatiu-li sasjeli.
6. yovelive zemoaRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT da agreT-ve l. b-s pasuxismgeblobis Semamsubuqebeli garemoebe-bis (aRiara da moinania Cadenili danaSauli), danaSaulisCadenis motivisa da miznis, qmedebaSi gamovlenili mar-TlsawinaaRmdego nebis, qmedebis ganxorcielebis saxis,xerxisa da marTlsawinaaRmdego Sedegis (igi warsulSi or-jeraa nasamarTlevi sakuTrebis winaaRmdeg mimarTuli da-naSaulebisaTvis da miuxedavad amisa, kvlav Caidina ana-logiuri xasiaTis danaSauli _ ori epizodi), damnaSavispirovnebis, misi warsuli cxovrebis, aRzrdis, ganviTare-bisa da ojaxuri pirobebis mxedvelobaSi miRebiT, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom l. b-s Tavisuflebis aRkveTissaxiT Sefardebuli sasjeli (saqarTvelos ssk-is 178-emuxlis me-4 nawilis sanqciiT gaTvaliswinebuli sasjelisminimumi) gamoyenebulia rogorc ukiduresi zoma da, am-denad, igi aris kanonieri, samarTliani da srulad Seesa-bameba arasrulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebis kodeqsiT, sa-qarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsiTa da saerTaSori-so samarTliT dadgenil normebsa da principebs.
7. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2017wlis 3 maisis ganaCeni l. b-s mimarT aris kanonieri da ararsebobs misi Secvlis safuZveli.