This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
1
s i s xli s s a m arT alis i s xli s s a m arT alis i s xli s s a m arT alis i s xli s s a m arT alis i s xli s s a m arT ali
zogadi d a k er Zozogadi d a k er Zozogadi d a k er Zozogadi d a k er Zozogadi d a k er Zo
n a w il e b in a w il e b in a w il e b in a w il e b in a w il e b i
krebulSi gamoqveynebulia erTgvarovani sasamarTlo praqti-kis Camoyalibebisa da samarTlis ganviTarebisaTvis mniSvne-lovani gadawyvetilebebi. am da sxva saqmeTa moZebna SesaZle-belia saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos veb-gverdze:http://www.supremecourt.ge/default.aspx?sec_id=133&lang=1
5. kasatori _ msjavrdebuli f. c. sakasacio saCivarSiaRniSnavs, rom ganaCeni efuZneba mxolod varaudebsa damowmeTa urTierTgamomricxav Cvenebebs; b. g-m mas sityvi-eri Seuracxyofa miayena, ris gamoc mouqnia joxi, rome-lic, savaraudod, mas ar moxvedria, radgan xma ar amouRiada Cumad gaecala; kasatori aseve miuTiTebs, rom misTvisSefardebuli sasjeli aris usamarTlo, Cadenili qmede-bis simZimisa da misi pirovnebis gaTvaliswinebiT.
modgenili saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayofildes nawilob-riv da gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata srulad iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos motivacias f. c-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 125-e mux-lis 1-li nawiliT msjavrdebis nawilSi da miaCnia, rom war-modgenilia sakmarisi da utyuari mtkicebulebebi, rom-lebiTac gonivrul eWvs miRma dasturdeba, rom f. c-ma nam-dvilad Caidina gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT misTvis braladSeracxuli qmedebebi.
3. palata yuradRebas miaqcevs im garemoebaze, rom da-zaralebul b. g-Tvis joxis moqnevas arc Tavad msjavrde-buli uaryofs, xolo is faqti, rom moqneuli joxi moxvdab. g-es, dasturdeba Tavad b. g-sa da mowmeebis _ S. b-is, m. C-is, z. m-sa da n. a-is CvenebebiT, romelTa sisworeSic eWvisSetanis safuZveli palatas ar gaaCnia, vinaidan isini Tan-
16
mimdevruli da Tanxvedrilia rogorc erTmaneTTan, ise _saqmeSi arsebul sxva mtkicebulebebTan.
4. amasTan, sakasacio palata iziarebs kasatoris pozi-cias misTvis daniSnuli sasjelis simkacris Sesaxeb da mi-aCnia, rom Cadenili qmedebis simZimis, f. c-is asakis _ 67wlisaa, materialuri mdgomareobis _ pensioneria da ase-ve, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom f. c-s pasuxismgeblobis da-mamZimebeli garemoebebi ar gaaCnia, samarTliani iqnebamisTvis jarimis minimaluri odenobis gansazRvra.
g. SavliaSvili (Tavmjdomare),n. gvenetaZe,p. silagaZe
zepiri mosmenis gareSe ganixila marneulis raionuliprokuraturis prokuror g. j-s, msjavrdebul r. g-s ad-vokat g. t-s, msjavrdebul r. o-s advokatebis _ o. s-sa dad. n-s, msjavrdebul s. d-sa da misi advokatis _ l. b-s,msjavrdebulebis _ m. S-sa da n. i-s advokat o. s-s, msjav-rdebul j. a-sa da misi advokatis _ m. u-s, msjavrdebul g.k-s advokatebis _ m. f-sa da i. W-s, msjavrdebul T. g-s,msjavrdebulebis _ n. o-s, a. g-sa da T. g-s advokat g. n-s,msjavrdebul r. m-sa da misi advokatis _ o. g-s, msjavrde-bul a. x-s advokatebis _ n. c-sa da d. m-s sakasacio saCivre-bi Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis 5 ivnisis ganaCenze.
3. Tbilisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis 5 ivnisis ganaCeni sakasa-cio wesiT gaasaCivres: msjavrdebul r. g-s advokatma _ g.t-ma, msjavrdebulma j. a-ma da misma advokatma _ m. u-ma,msjavrdebulebis _ m. S-sa da n. i-s advokatma _ o. s-ma,msjavrdebul r. o-s advokatebma _ o. s-ma da d. n-ma, msjav-rdebul g. k-s advokatebma _ m. f-m da i. W-m, msjavrdebula. x-s advokatebma _ n. c-m, d. m-ma, msjavrdebulma s. d-mada misma advokatma _ l. b-m, msjavrdebulma r. m-ma da mis-ma advokatma _ o. g-m, msjavrdebulma T. g-ma, msjavrdebu-lebis _ n. o-s, a. g-sa da T. g-s advokatma _ g. n-ma da moiT-xoves gasaCivrebuli ganaCenis gauqmeba da msjavrdebu-lebis mimarT gamamarTlebeli ganaCenis dadgena. xolo ad-vokatma _ g. n-ma moiTxova msjavrdebul n. o-s mimarT al-ternativis saxiT saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeq-sis 2231-e muxlis pirveli nawilis gadakvalificireba ama-ve kodqsis 376-e muxlze.
4. aRniSnuli ganaCeni aseve gaasaCivra marneulis raio-nuli prokuraturis prokurorma _ g. j-ma, moiTxova misigauqmeba da msjavrdebulebis: m. S-s, k. g-s, s. d-s damnaSa-ved cnoba saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 2231-e muxliT da maTTvis Sesabamisi sasjelebis gansazRvra,xolo danarCeni msjavrdebulebis mimarT ufro mkacrisasjelebis gansazRvra.
ma sakasacio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da mivida im das-kvnamde, rom msjavrdebul r. g-s damcvelis, advokat g.t-s, msjavrdebul j. a-sa da misi damcvelis, advokat m. u-s, msjavrdebulebis _ n. i-sa da m. S-s damcvelis, advokato. s-s, msjavrdebul r. o-sa da misi damcveli advokatebis_ d. n-sa da o. s-s, msjavrdebul g. k-s damcveli advokate-bis _ m. f-sa da i. W-s, msjavrdebulebis _ n. o-s, a. g-sa da T.g-s damcvelis, advokat g. n-s, msjavrdebul a. x-s damcve-li advokatebis _ n. c-sa da d. m-s, msjavrdebul s. d-sa damisi damcvelis, advokat l. b-s, msjavrdebul r. m-sa damisi damcvelis, advokat o. g-s, agreTve, marneulis raio-nuli prokuraturis prokuror g. j-s sakasacio saCivrebiar unda dakmayofildes, xolo gasaCivrebul ganaCenSimsjavrdebulebis _ s. d-s, r. g-sa da r. o-s mimarT undaSevides cvlilebebi Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata kasatorTa moTxovnas msjavrdebu-lebis udanaSaulod cnobisa da maTi gamarTlebis Taoba-ze ar eTanxmeba, radgan warmodgenil saqmis masalebSi sa-amisod ar moipoveba kanonieri da dasabuTebuli safuZve-li. amasTan, pirveli instanciisa da saapelacio sasamar-Tloebis mier maT mimarT gamotanil gamamtyunebel gana-CenebSi Camoyalibebuli daskvnebi inkriminirebul qmede-bebSi maTi braleulobis Taobaze, savsebiT akmayofilebsgonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT gaTvaliswinebul kri-teriumebs, rasac adasturebs saqmeSi arsebuli, kanonie-ri gziT mopovebuli, utyuari da sakmarisi mtkicebule-
8. aRniSnuli ganaCenis obieqturobaze aSkarad miuTi-Tebs is garemoeba, rom am ganaCeniT s. d-s bralad Seerac-xa mxolod danaSaulis Seutyobinebloba, qmedeba, gaTva-liswinebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is 376-e muxliT, da ar dak-mayofilda prokuroris saapelacio saCivari, romliTacigi iTxovda mis mimarT ganaCenis sauaresod Sebrunebas,kerZod, misi qmedebis gadakvalificirebas saqarTvelosssk-is 2231-e muxlis pirvel nawilze da, Sesabamisad, mis-Tvis bevrad ufro mkacri sasjelis daniSvnas.
9. saapelacio sasamarTlos xsenebuli ganaCeniT s. d-Tvis saqarTvelos ssk-is 260-e muxlis pirveli nawilis sa-fuZvelze Seracxul brals _ woniT 18,96 grami narkoti-kuli saSualebis _ `gamomSrali marixuanis~ marTlsawina-aRmdego SeZenisa da Senaxvis Taobaze, am nawilSi msjav-rdebulis braleulobas dacvis mxarec ar xdis sadavod,romelic efuZneba ara mxolod s. d-s mier bralis aRiare-bas, aramed, agreTve, kanonieri gziT mopovebul sxva sar-wmuno mtkicebulebebsac, saxeldobr: misi binis Cxrekisoqmsa da am CxrekiT mopovebul nivTmtkicebas, qimiurieqspertizis daskvnas, eqspertTa Cvenebebs, mowmeTa Cve-nebebsa da amave saqmeze msjavrdebul sxva pirTan misi sa-telefono saubris Canawersa da krebsebs. mocemuli ga-remoebebis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasacio palata mivida imdaskvnamde, rom msjavrdebulebis _ s. d-s, r. m-sa da maTidamcvelebis _ advokat l. b-sa da advokat o. g-s sakasaciosaCivrebis moTxovnebi ar unda dakmayofildes.
10. msjavrdebul m. S-s damcveli, advokati o. s-i Tavi-si sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs ra mis srul gamarTlebas,saCivarSi warmodgenili argumentebis absoluturad udi-desi nawilis safuZvelze, ratomRac mTeli mondomebiTcdilobs misi dacvis qveS myofi piris gamarTlebas iseTbraldebaSi, romelic mas jer kidev pirveli instanciissasamarTlom mouxsna da rac saapelacio sasamarTlom Za-laSi datova.
11. rac Seexeba pirveli instanciisa da saapelacio sa-samarTloebis mier m. S-saTvis Seracxul brals saqarTve-
27
los ssk-is 376-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli qmedebis _ da-naSaulis Seutyobineblobis Cadenis Taobaze, unda aRi-niSnos, rom am nawilSi brali mis mimarT dadasturebuliam. S-s mier mocemul saqmeze msjavrdebul im sxva pireb-Tan gamarTuli satelefono saubrebis CanawerebiTa da Se-sabamisi krebsebiT, romlebic imxilebian qurduli samya-ros wevrobaSi, agreTve, mowme f. y-s CvenebiT.
12. aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebi sruliad sakmarisi dasarwmunoa saimisod, rom sasamarTlos m. S-i braleuladecno danaSaulis SeutyobineblobaSi, radgan am mtkice-bulebebidan gamomdinare, sruliad cxadi da ueWvelia isfaqti, rom misTvis cnobili iyo, rogor mzaddeboda daxorcieldeboda sxva pirebis mier qurduli samyaros xel-Semwyobi sxvadasxva qmedeba, agreTve, fsiqologiuri ze-moqmedebis gziT dazaralebulisgan Tanxebis gamoZalva.
13. aseT pirobebSi msjavrdebul m. S-s damcvelis miersakasacio saCivarSi warmodgenili mxolod erTi winada-deba imis Taobaze, rom policias masze ufro adre hqondainformacia xsenebuli qurduli samyaros warmomadgenel-Ta saqmianobaze, ver gaxdeba am nawilSi gamamtyunebeliganaCenis gadasinjvisa da m. S-s gamarTlebis safuZveli,vinaidan, jer erTi, m. S-saTvis araferi iyo cnobili imisTaobaze, policiam ra icoda da ra ar icoda; garda amisa,moqalaqe ar gaTavisufldeba pasuxismgeblobisagan dana-Saulis SeutyobineblobisaTvis mxolod imis gamo, rom isimedovnebda _ policia SeiZleba mis dauxmarebladac yo-filiyo informirebuli danaSaulis Sesaxeb; mesamec, ne-bismieri adamiani, maT Soris damnaSavis axlo naTesavic,valdebulia acnobos policias danaSaulis Taobaze im mo-mentSi, rodesac mzaddeba mZime an gansakuTrebiT mZimedanaSaulis Cadena an rodesac ukve mimdinareobs misi Ca-dena. ganxiluli garemoebebidan gamomdinare, sakasaciopalata Tvlis, rom msjavrdebul m. S-s damcvelis, advo-kat o. s-s sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes.
14. kasatori _ advokati g. t-i msjavrdebul r. g-s inte-resebis dasacavad Tavis saCivarSi aRniSnavs, rom mas sru-liad usafuZvlod Seeracxa saqarTvelos ssk-is 2231-e mux-lis pirveli nawiliTa da imave kodeqsis 260-e muxlis pir-veli nawiliT gaTvaliswinebul danaSaulTa Cadena. kasa-toris ganmartebiT, misi dacvis qveS myofi piris msjavrde-ba efuZneba im garemoebas, rom TiTqos r. g-i Tavis saxlSi
28
inaxavda e.w. ̀ obSiakis~ (aralegaluri qurduli salaros) si-as im pirebisa, romlebisganac grovdeboda Tanxebi am sala-roSi qurduli samyaros dasaxmareblad, es maSin, rodesacaRniSnuli sia ar gamokvleula saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvisdros, xolo kaligrafiuli eqspertizis daskvnis mixedviT,am siaSi arsebuli Canawerebi ar ekuTvnis r. g-s.
15. garda zemoaRniSnulisa, advokati g. t-i saqarTve-los ssk-is 260-e muxlis pirveli nawilis safuZvelze r. g-s msjavrdebasTan dakavSirebiT sakasacio saCivarSi ag-reTve aRniSnavs, rom mas arasdros araviTari Sexeba arhqonia narkotikul saSualebasTan. Cxreka, romlis Sede-gadac 21,59 grami narkotikuli saSualeba _ `gamomSralimarixuana~ iqna amoRebuli, Catarda r. g-s mamis _ i. g-s kuT-vnil sacxovrebel saxlSi, xolo narkotikuli saSualebaipoves aRniSnuli sacxovrebeli saxlis lojiaSi mdgar ma-gidaze, televizoris win _ yvelas dasanax adgilze. amri-gad, narkotikuli saSualeba ar yofila napovni r. g-s sa-Zinebel oTaxSi, aseve _ arc mis tansacmelSi. amasTan, i. g-i Cxrekis drosac da Semdegac, sasamarTloSi saqmis gan-xilvisas, kategoriulad acxadebda, rom mis saxlSi napov-ni narkotikuli saSualeba ar ekuTvnoda arc mis Svils _r. g-s da arc TviTon mas, aramed is iyo Cxrekisas policiismier `Cadebuli~. garda amisa, kasatoris ganmartebiT, i. g-s sacxovrebel saxlTan policiis TanamSromlebis gamoc-xadebidan, vidre maT kars gauRebdnen da Cxreka daiwye-boda, mTeli 25 wuTi hqonda r. g-s narkotikuli saSuale-bis, rogorc samxilis, Tavidan mosaSoreblad, Tuki is masnamdvilad eqneboda, magram sinamdvileSi ar hqonda.
16. saqarTvelos ssk-is 2231-e muxlis pirveli nawilissafuZvelze r. g-s msjavrdebasTan dakavSirebiT, misi uar-yofis mizniT, kasatoris mier saCivarSi warmodgenil po-zicias sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs Semdeg garemoe-baTa gamo: TviT dacvis mxarec ver uaryofs im udavo faqts,rom e.w. `obSiakis~ sia r. g-Tan iqna aRmoCenili, romelsacis Sin inaxavda. sasamarTlo sworad miuTiTebs, rom es faq-ti mowmobs mis danaSaulebriv kavSirurTierTobaze qur-dul samyarosTan da am ukanasknelis sasargeblod moqme-debaze.
17. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba ra saapelacio sasamar-Tlos daskvnebs r. g-s braleulobaze, miaCnia: mocemulSemTxvevaSi arsebiTi mniSvneloba ara aqvs im garemoebas,
29
rom xsenebul siaSi arsebuli Canawerebis kaligrafiuladr. g-sadmi kuTvnileba ar dasturdeba, aramed mniSvnelo-vania Semdegi _ igi `obSiakis~ siis TavisTan SenaxviT qur-dul samyaros daxmarebas uwevda mis Sesavsebad TanxebisSegrovebis organizebaSi da moqmedebda mis sasargeblod.magram saqme isaa, rom r. g-s mier aRniSnuli danaSauleb-rivi saqmianoba anu qurduli samyaros wevroba mxolodxsenebuli garemoebiT rodi dasturdeba, aramed, amasTanerTad, saqmeSi arsebobs kanonieri gziT mopovebuli sxvamtkicebulebebic, kerZod, misi im satelefono saubrebisCanawerebi da Sesabamisi krebsebis Sinaarsi, romlebsac isawarmoebda imave saqmeze aseve qurduli samyaros wevro-bisaTvis msjavrdebul pirebTan Tu kanonier qurdebTan,aseve mowmeTa CvenebebiT, rac saapelacio sasamarTlosganaCenSi damajereblad aris dadasturebuli Sesabamissaqmis masalebze miTiTebiT.
18. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs aseve kasator g. t-smosazrebebs r. g-s udanaSaulobaze saqarTvelos ssk-is260-e muxlis pirveli nawilis safuZvelze misTvis Serac-xuli bralis nawilSi, radgan aseTi pozicia aSkarad ewina-aRmdegeba saqmeSi arsebuli sarwmuno mtkicebulebebiserTobliobas, romliTac, Tanaxmad saapelacio sasamar-Tlos marTebuli daskvnisa, gonivrul eWvs miRma dastur-deba r. g-s mier aRniSnuli danaSaulis Cadena _ narkoti-kuli saSualebis ukanono SeZena da Senaxva.
19. rogorc gasaCivrebul ganaCenSia aRniSnuli, narko-tikuli saSualeba _ `marixuana~ Cxrekisas aRmoaCines aratelevizoris win, yvelas dasanax adgilze, aramed _ tele-vizoris qveS da is amoRebul iqna imis Sedegad, rom tele-vizori aiRes da gverdze gadadges. ase rom, aRniSnuli nar-kotikuli saSualeba ar yofila dadebuli televizoris win,yvelas dasanax adgilze da aseT adgilze mas policia ver`Cadebda~ da verc televizoris qveS moaTavsebda misi ga-daadgilebis gareSe, rac SeumCneveli ver darCeboda.
20. sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs kasatoris im argu-ments, rom r. g-s mTeli 25 wuTi hqonda saimisod, raTa Ta-vidan moeSorebina samxili _ narkotikuli saSualeba, Tu-ki aseTi ram mas namdvilad hqonda. saqme isaa, rom es arismxolod dacvis mxaris gancxadeba, xolo saqmeSi ar arse-bobs imis damadasturebeli raime mtkicebuleba, Tu ram-deni wuTi gavida policiis TanamSromlebis gamocxadebi-
30
dan maT mier Cxrekis dawyebamde da saerTod, ra SesaZ-leblobebi arsebobda samxilis Tavidan mosaSoreblad.
21. sakasacio palata dacvis mxaris verc im argumentsgaiziarebs, romlis Tanaxmad, r. g-s arasdros hqonia Sexe-ba narkotikul saSualebebTan, radgan saapelacio sasamar-Tlos ganaCenSi moxmobilia kanonieri gziT mopovebulimtkicebulebebi, kerZod, r. g-s satelefono saubrebis Ca-nawerebi da Sesabamisi krebsebi, romelTa Sinaarsi aaSka-ravebs, rom msjavrdebulisaTvis narkotikuli saSuale-bebi ucxo ar iyo. aq mxedvelobaSia sxva pirebTan, kerZod,amave saqmeze saqarTvelos ssk-is 260-e muxlis pirvelinawilis safuZvelze msjavrdebul r. o-Tan misi satele-fono saubrebis Sinaarsi, agreTve r. o-s mier msjavrde-bulebTan _ s. d-sa da g. k-Tan ganxorcielebuli satele-fono saubrebis Sinaarsi, romlebSic r. g-i ixsenieba nar-kotikul saSualebebTan mimarTebiT.
22. r. g-s mier aRniSnuli danaSaulis Cadena gasaCivre-bul ganaCenSi dadasturebulia agreTve mowmeTa Tanmim-devruli CvenebebiTa da qimiuri eqspertizis daskvniT,amitom misi damcvelis sakasacio saCivris moTxovna verdakmayofildeba usafuZvlobis gamo.
23. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCeni gaasaCivra msjav-rdebulebis _ a. g-sa da T. g-s interesebis damcvelma, ad-vokatma g. n-ma. pirveli, rasac uwinaresad aRniSnavs kasa-tori Tavis saCivarSi, isaa, rom sasamarTloebis mier gamo-tanili ganaCenebi atarebs zogadi, koleqtiuri braldebisxasiaTs, romlebic dadasturebulad miiCneven, rom saqmegvaqvs danaSaulebriv jgufTan da ar cdiloben imis gamok-veTas, am jgufSi maT mier moazrebul TiToeul wevrs kon-kretulad raSi miuZRvis brali da raSi gamoixateba calkeaRebuli misi danaSaulebrivi qmedeba. kasatoris mier ga-saCivrebuli ganaCenisaTvis wayenebuli es pretenzia veriqneba gaziarebuli, radgan ganaCenSi saapelacio sasamar-Tlos gancalkevebulad aqvs warmodgenili TiToeuli maT-ganis brali; amasTan erTad, gaanalizebulia saqmeSi arse-buli mtkicebulebebi cal-calke, rogorc a. g-s, ise T. g-smimarT, sadac araviTar jgufur danaSaulsa da koleqti-ur bralze ar aris saubari, miuxedavad imisa, rom aRniSnu-li ganaCeniT msjavrdebuli yvela piri sxvadasxva drosfaqtobrivad erTmaneTTan iyvnen dakavSirebulni danaSa-ulis Cadenisas, rac qurdul samyaros Tvisebrivad axasia-
31
Tebs da mis bunebriv Taviseburebas warmoadgens.24. rogorc a. g-s, ise T. g-s konkretulad brali edebaT
imaSi, rom maT 2013 wlis agvistoSi q. marneulSi, indme-warme a. S-s ukanonod gamoarTves fuladi Tanxa _ 1000 la-ris odenobiT qurduli samyarosaTvis sargeblis miRebismizniT, amave dros, imave mizniT, mas dauweses yovelTvi-uri gadasaxdeli Tanxa imave odenobiT, rasac Tan sdevdamaTi mxridan saqmis qurduli garCeva da qurduli wesebisSesabamisad mogvareba. garda amisa, aRniSnul periodSi T.g-i erTveba aseve qurduli samyaros sxva wevrebis mierbiznesmen f. y-s mimarT ganxorcielebul analogiur qme-debebSi, romelsac is sTavazobs saqmis mogvarebas qur-duli tradiciebis Sesabamisad, xolo am daxmarebisaTvismisgan gasamrjeloc miiRo 1400 laris odenobiT.
25. zemoaRniSnul qmedebebSi a. g-sa da T. g-s monawileo-bis dasadastureblad saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenSiwarmodgenilia mravali sarwmuno mtkicebuleba, romlebickanonieri gziTaa mopovebuli, mxedvelobaSia msjavrdebu-lebis _ a. g-sa da T. g-s mier erTmaneTTan, aseve qurdulisamyaros sxva wevrebTan gamarTuli satelefono saubre-bi, romelTa Sinaarsi naTlad cxadyofs, rom isini arianqurduli samyaros aqtiuri wevrebi, moqmedeben qurdulisamyaros wesebis Sesabamisad da qurduli samyaros mizne-bisaTvis sargeblis misaRebad. maT braleulobas adastu-rebs aseve mowmeebis _ f. y-sa da a. S-s Cvenebebi, romlebSicmkafiod ikveTeba a. g-sa da T. g-s mxriv moqmedebis iseTistili da xerxebi, rac swored qurduli samyarosTvisaa da-maxasiaTebeli da gamomdinareobs im wesebidan, rac am sam-yaroSi dominirebs kriminaluri avtoritetebis rogorcerTmaneTTan, ise sxva pirebTan urTierTobebSi.
26. ganxilul garemoebaTa gamo sakasacio palata vergaiziarebs kasatoris pozicias imis Taobaze, rom sasamar-Tlos mier dadasturebulad miCnevis SemTxvevaSi a. g-sada T. g-s qmedebebi unda dakvalificirebuliyo ara qur-duli samyaros wevrobad, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebulisaqarTvelos ssk-is 2231-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT, ara-med rogorc gamoZalva, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 181-e muxliT. aRniSnulTan dakavSire-biT sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom kasatoris aseTi po-zicia arasworia, radgan im SemTxvevaSi, rodesac pirisa-gan Tanxis an raime sxva materialuri sikeTis gamoZalva
32
xorcieldeba qurduli samyaros wevris mier qurdul sam-yaroSi moqmedi wesebis gamoyenebiT (saqmis qurduli gar-Ceva da sxv.), amasTan, gamoZalva xorcieldeba qurdulisamyarosaTvis sargeblis misaRebad, amgvari qmedeba ga-moZalvad (saqarTvelos ssk-is 181-e muxli) ver dakvali-ficirdeba, radgan Tavisi SinaarsiTa da niSnebiT is scde-ba gamoZalvis farglebs da gadaizrdeba sxva danaSaulSi,rogoricaa qurduli samyaros wevroba. saqme isaa, rom mxo-lod gamoZalva, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is181-e muxlis pirveli nawilis dispoziciiT, ar moicavsqurduli samyaros wevrobis niSnebs maSin, rodesac es uka-naskneli moicavs gamoZalvis Semadgenlobis niSnebsac.
27. yovelive zemoaRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom kasatoris, advokat g. n-s moT-xovna msjavrdebulebis _ a. g-sa da T. g-s gamarTlebis Ta-obaze ar unda dakmayofildes, rogorc dasabuTebul dakanonier safuZvels moklebuli.
28. saapelacio sasamarTlos xsenebuli ganaCenis Tao-baze kasatorma, advokatma g. n-ma saCivriT mimarTa sakasa-cio palatas misi dacvis qveS myofi piris _ n. o-s msjav-rdebasTan dakavSirebiT, romliTac is iTxovs mis gamar-Tlebas. saCivris avtori sakasacio moTxovnis safuZvladmiuTiTebs Semdeg ZiriTad argumentebze: saqmeSi faqtob-rivad ar arsebobs n. o-s braleulobis damadasturebeliraime mtkicebuleba; is garemoeba, rom n. o-i swored imdros imyofeboda Tavisi Zmis _ r. o-s sacxovrebel sax-lSi, rodesac iq, sasamarTlos daskvniT, qurduli samya-ros wevrebi _ g. k-i, r. g-i Tu sxva pirebi Seikribnen, arniSnavs n. o-s qurduli samyaros wevrobas, radgan is xSi-rad imyofeboda Tavisi Zmis saxlSi, romelic misgan 100metrSi cxovrobs, amgvari damTxveva ar SeiZleba misi dam-naSaved cnobis safuZveli gaxdes; telefoni, romelicamoRebul iqna n. o-s saxlidan da romlis nomridanac xor-cieldeboda saubrebi qurduli samyaros wevrebTan, ekuT-vnis ara mas, aramed mis Zmas _ r. o-s, romelsac masTan yof-nisas SemTxveviT darCa aRniSnuli telefoni, xolo is no-meri, romlidanac am telefoniT aris ganxorcielebulisaubrebi, aravis saxelze ar aris registrirebuli.
29. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs kasatoris mosazrebeb-sa da argumentebs msjavrdebul n. o-s udanaSaulobis Tao-baze, radgan saqmeSi moipoveba misi braleulobis mamtki-
33
cebeli faqtebi da Sesabamisi mtkicebulebebic. mis kavSirsqurdul samyarosTan aSkaras xdis qurduli samyaros wev-rebTan misive satelefono saubrebis Sinaarsi, kerZod,mxedvelobaSia misi saubrebi msjavrdebulebTan _ g. k-sada r. g-Tan, romlebzec miTiTebulia saapelacio sasamar-Tlos ganaCenSi. udavod dadgenili faqtia isic, rom tele-foni, romlis nomridan nawarmoebia saubrebi qurduli sam-yaros wevrebs Soris, n. o-sganaa amoRebuli da is inaxavda,xolo nomeri, romlidanac am telefoniT xorcieldebodazarebi, ar aris registrirebuli r. o-s saxelze da arc sxvamtkicebuleba arsebobs, rom igi r. o-s ekuTvnoda. amitomkasatoris apelireba imis Taobaze, rom aRniSnuli tele-foni ekuTvnoda ara n. o-s, aramed mis Zmas _ r. o-s, ver iqne-ba miCneuli misi bralis gamabaTilebel safuZvlian argu-mentad. rac Seexeba dacvis mxaris arguments, romlis mi-xedviT, n. o-i Tavisi Zmis _ r. o-s saxlSi SemTxveviT moxvdaim dros, rodesac iq qurduli samyaros wevrobaSi msjav-rdebuli pirebi Seikribnen, misi safuZvlianoba nakleb sa-varaudoa im urTierTobebidan gamomdinare, rac n. o-s ga-aCnda qurduli samyaros sxva, zemoxsenebul wevrebTan, aqganxiluli garemoebebis gaTvaliswinebiT, razec zemoT uk-ve iyo saubari. yovelive aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, kasa-tor g. n-s saCivris moTxovna msjavrdebul n. o-s gamarTle-bis Taobaze ar unda dakmayofildes.
30. msjavrdebuli j. a-i da misi interesebis damcveli,advokati m. u-i, iTxoven ra mis gamarTlebas, amis safuZ-vlad TavianT sakasacio saCivrebSi uTiTeben sxvadasxvagaremoebaze, kerZod, maTi azriT, mowmeTa Cvenebebi, rom-lebic braldebis mxaresa da sasamarTlos gamoyenebuliaqvT msjavrdebulis bralis dasadastureblad, ar SeiZ-leba miviCnioT utyuar mtkicebulebebad da SeiZleba pi-ris braleulobaze mxolod varaudis gamosaTqmelad iyosgamosadegi, radgan isini ar adastureben, rom j. a-ma maTsaqme gaurCia qurdulad an raime Tanxa gamosZala, anda ismoqmedebda qurduli samyaros dasaxmareblad, xolo ga-mamtyunebeli ganaCeni ki ar SeiZleba agebuli iyos dausa-buTebel varaudebze.
31. kasatorebi TavianT saCivrebSi aseve miuTiTebenSemdegze: jerovani mtkicebulebebiT ar aris dadgenilida dadasturebuli, rom j. a-i raime formiT aRiarebdaqurdul samyaros, anda qurdulma samyarom is miiRo Ta-
34
vis wevrad da aRiara. aseTi daskvnisaTvis safuZveli vergaxdeba j. a-s nacnoboba sasamarTlos mier kriminalur av-toritetad miCneul vinme `g-sTan~. ganaCenSi ki aris miTi-Tebuli, rom j. a-i aris qurduli mentalitetis mqone dawarmoadgens kriminalur avtoritets, romelic garCeve-biT, danaSaulisken waqezebiT, daSinebiTa da dumilis pi-robebiT moqalaqisagan iRebda sargebels, rac dadastu-rebulia mtkicebulebebiTo, magram sinamdvileSi aseTimtkicebulebebi saqmeSi ar arsebobs, arc erT mowmes armiucia sasamarTloSi j. a-s sawinaaRmdego Cveneba.
32. sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba xsenebuli kasatore-bis mier maT saCivrebSi warmodgenil argumentebs, rad-gan saqmeSi arsebuli masalebi sruliad sawinaaRmdegozemetyvelebs. maTi analizis safuZvelze saapelacio sasa-marTlos gamotanili aqvs marTebuli daskvnebi j. a-s bra-leulobaze im samarTlebrivi kvalifikaciis Sesabamisad,romliTac mas sabolood msjavri daedo. palatas mxedve-lobaSi aqvs uwinaresad saqmeSi mtkicebulebebis saxiTwarmodgenili j. a-s satelefono saubrebi qurduli sam-yaros sxva wevrebTan, magaliTad, m. S-Tan da sxvebTan, xo-lo mTeli am saubrebis Sinaarsi pirdapir miuTiTebs ima-ze, rom is kriminalur avtoritets warmoadgens, sargeb-lobs gavleniT qurdul samyaroSi, monawileobs saqmisgarCevaSi, ara mxolod aRiarebs qurdul samyaros, ara-med eweva aqtiur saqmianobas misi miznebisa da interese-bis sasargeblod.
33. aRniSnuli garemoebebi calsaxad ikveTeba ara mar-to TviT j. a-s saubrebSi, aramed qurduli samyaros sxvawevrebis mier erTmaneTTan, aseve sxva pirebTan gamarTulsatelefono saubrebSi. magaliTisaTvis SeiZleba miTiTe-bul iqnes qurduli samyaros wevris _ T. g-s saubari t. o-sa da r. i-Tan, agreTve misi saubari k. g-sa da v. t-Tan. amsaubrebis Sinaarsic gvarwmunebs, rom j. a-s mWidro kavSi-rurTieroba gaaCnia qurdul samyarosTan, ufro sworad_ misi aqtiuri wevria.
34. garda aRniSnulisa, j. a-s kavSiri qurdul samyaros-Tan da misi pirdapiri Tu arapirdapiri monawileoba qur-duli samyaros interesebis sasargeblod moqalaqeebis-gan ukanonod Tanxebis miRebaSi dasturdeba saqmeze mow-mis saxiT dakiTxuli moqalaqeebis _ f. y-sa da r. i-s Cvene-bebiT. magaliTad, f. y-i Tavis CvenebaSi saubrobs imis Ta-
35
obaze, Tu rogor moiTxovda misgan solidur Tanxas kri-minaluri avtoriteti, vinme `r.~ misTvis kanonier qurdadcnobili `g-s~ saxeliT, ra drosac xsenebul pirs Tan ax-lda j. a-i, xolo ramdenime dRis Semdeg j. a-ma daurekamas da uTxra masTan saxlSi misuliyo, sadac mas daxvda`r.~, romelsac j. a-s TandaswrebiT gadasca 10 000 aSS do-lari. daaxloebiT analogiur viTarebas aRwers j. a-s mo-nawileobiT mowme r. i-c, romlisganac aseve igive `r.~ cdi-lobda ukanonod Tanxebis miRebas.
35. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenSi warmodgenilimtkicebulebebi j. a-s braleulobis Taobaze eWvis qveSver iqneba dayenebuli maTi mopovebis kanonierebis, saq-mesTan Semxeblobis, aseve verc maTi utyuarobisa da sak-marisobis TvalsazrisiT. amrigad, saapelacio sasamar-Tlos sruli da udavo safuZveli gaaCnda j. a-s damnaSa-ved cnobisaTvis wardgenili braldebis mixedviT, ris ga-moc msjavrdebulisa da misi damcvelis, advokat m. u-ssakasacio saCivrebis moTxovna ar unda dakmayofildes.
36. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenis Taobaze saqar-Tvelos uzenaes sasamarTlos sakasacio saCivriT mimarTamsjavrdebul n. i-s interesebis damcvelma, advokatma o.s-ma, romelic iTxovs mis gamarTlebas. kasatori apeli-rebs Semdeg garemoebebze: n. i-i ar monawileobda qurdulSekrebebSi da arc r. o-s saxlSi ar yofila maSin, rodesaciq Seikribnen sasamarTlos mier qurduli samyaros wevre-bad aRiarebuli pirebi, aseve, mas ar miuRia monawileobaqurdul garCevebSi, e.w. `obSiakSi~ Sesatanad Tanxebis Seg-rovebaSi da arc biznesmenebisgan Tanxebis gamoZalvaSi.
37. garda aRniSnulisa, kasatori o. s-i Tavis saCivarSiimazec miuTiTebs, rom n. i-s araviTari qmedeba ar ganu-xorcielebia qurduli samyaros interesebis sasargeblodda arc raime kavSiri hqonia im pirebTan, romlebic sasa-marTlos mier miCneuli arian qurduli samyaros wevre-bad (g. k-i, n. o-i, r. o-i) an kanonier qurdebad (n. j-i, vinme`p.~), xolo n. i-s satelefono saubrebi, romlebic saape-lacio sasamarTlos gamamtyunebel ganaCenSi mtkicebu-lebebad aqvs moxmobili, swored imas adasturebs, rom n.i-i ar aris qurduli samyaros wevri.
38. sakasacio palata safuZvlianad ar miiCnevs kasato-ris mier warmodgenil argumentebs msjavrdebul n. i-sudanaSaulobis Taobaze. saqme isaa, rom mas sasamarTlo
36
msjavrs ar sdebs imaSi, rom is monawileobda qurdul Sek-rebebSi, r. o-s saxlSi gamarTul SexvedraSi, anda qurdulgarCevebSi an e.w. `obSiakisaTvis~ Tanxebis Segrovebasa Tubiznesmenebisgan Tanxebis gamoZalvaSi, ris gamoc am mi-marTebiT kasatoris Zalisxmeva da mis mier moZiebuli ar-gumentebi ararsebuli braldebis gasabaTileblad ramde-nadme gaugebaria.
39. gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT n. i-s bralad Seeracxa 2013wlis agvisto-seqtembris TveebSi mis mier Cadenili moq-medebebi qurduli samyaros interesebis sasargeblod damisi miznebisaTvis, rasac igi axorcielebda vinme `r. o-s~uSualo monawiloebiT kanonier qurdTan _ n. j-Tan kav-SirSi, rac dadasturebis SemTxvevaSi, sruliad sakmarisisafuZvelia piris qurduli samyaros wevrad miCnevisaT-vis. aRniSnuli garemoebis dasadastureblad saqmeSi war-modgenilia kanonieri gziT mopovebuli mtkicebulebebiqurduli samyaros sxva wevrebTan n. i-s satelefono sa-ubrebis saxiT, romelTa Sinaarsi aSkaras xdis, rom rea-lurad saqme gvaqvs ara Cveulebrivi nacnobobidan gamom-dinare, anda uwyinar megobrul an naTesaur urierTobeb-Tan, aramed erToblivi danaSaulebrivi miznebiTa da in-teresebiT ganpirobebul kavSirurTierTobebTan, rom-lebSic aqtiurad monawileobs n. i-i.
40. gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT qurduli samyaros wevro-bisaTvis msjavrdebuli a. x-i satelefono saubarSi n. i-Tan ganixilavs m-Si momxdar konfliqts da gamoTqvams say-vedursa da ukmayofilebas imis gamo, rom es konfliqtiqurduli garCevis gziT mis gareSe gadawyvita r. g-ma (ima-ve ganaCeniT is miCneulia qurduli samyaros wevrad), vi-naidan, aRniSnuli saubris mixedviT, a. x-i sakuTar TavsmiiCnevs m-s raionSi mTavar figurad da msgavsi sakiTxebimis daukiTxavad ar unda wydebodes. n. i-i am saubarSi cdi-lobs, a. x-i gaarkvios Seqmnil viTarebaSi, eubneba `r. Cve-ni Zma ariso~, rac pirdapiri miniSnebaa imaze, rom r. g-iqurduli samyaros wevri da sando Tanamzraxvelia, xolomis amgvar mosazrebas a. x-c eTanxmeba. aqedan naTlad ik-veTeba, rom n. i-i qurdul samyarosTan friad daaxloe-bul da mis wevrTa Soris miRebul pirs warmoadgens, wina-aRmdeg SemTxvevaSi, qurduli samyaros wevris mxridanmasTan aseTi gulaxdili saubari gamoricxuli iqneboda.
41. saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebiT ikveTeba is ga-
37
remoeba, rom n. i-i qurduli samyaros warmomadgenlebismxolod pasiuri mxardamWeri ki ar aris, aramed aqtiura-dac moqmedebs maTi xelSewyobis mizniT. magaliTad, manTavisi telefoniT daakavSira da Tavisi nomridan asaubraqurduli samyaros wevri _ r. g-i Tavis Tanamzraxvel kri-minalur avtoritetTan _ vinme `p-sTan~, razedac aSkaradmetyvelebs aRniSnuli saubris mTeli Sinaarsi.
42. im versias, rom n. i-i qurduli samyaros aqtiuri wev-ria, kidev ufro ganamtkicebs sxva mtkicebulebac, es arismisi saubari imave `p-sTan~. am saubarSi n. i-i gvevlinebarogorc m-s raionSi qurduli samyaros saqmeebsa da missaqmianobaSi Rrmad Caxeduli adamiani, rogorc aqtiurimonawile am saqmianobisa, romelic iTxovs sxvebisgan Ta-nadgomasa da mxardaWeras qurdul saqmianobaSi.
43. sakasacio palatas, miaCnia, rom aRniSnuli pirdapi-ri mtkicebulebebiT gonivrul eWvs miRma dadasturebu-lia gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT n. i-saTvis Seracxuli bra-li, ris gamoc msjavrdebulis damcvelis, kasator o. s-ssaCivris moTxovna misi gamarTlebis Taobaze ar unda dak-mayofildes.
44. saqarTvelos uzenaesi sasamarTlos sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeTa palatam ganixila aseve gasaCivrebuli gana-CeniT msjavrdebul a. x-s damcvelebis, advokatebis _ n.c-sa da d. m-s sakasacio saCivari, romliTac kasatorebiiTxoven mis gamarTlebas da aRniSnaven uwinaresad im ga-remoebas, rom saapelacio sasamarTlos gamamtyunebeliganaCeni emyareba ara pirdapir da utyuar mtkicebule-bebs, aramed _ mxolod araarsebiT, irib mtkicebulebebs.
45. kasatorebis ganmartebiT, rac Seexeba mtkicebule-bebad warmodgenil, a. x-s mier ganxorcielebul satele-fono saubrebsa da maT Sinaarss, unda aRiniSnos, rom amCanawerebis identuroba da auTenturoba ar aris dadge-nili eqspertizis daskvniT. amasTan, aRsaniSnavia isic, romxsenebul saubrebSi a. x-i arafers ambobs iseTs, rac qur-dul samyarosTan mis kavSirze mianiSnebs; sasamarTloeb-ma konteqstidan amoglejili calkeuli frazebis gamo-yenebiT mis nalaparakevs misces Taviseburi, damaxinje-buli interpretacia. garda aRniSnulisa, kasatorebi miu-TiTeben agreTve, rom a. x-saTvis sasamarTloebis mier bra-lad Seracxul qmedebebSi ar moipoveba is niSnebi, rasaciTvaliswinebs qurduli samyaros wevris sakanonmdeblo
38
cneba da gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni am mxrivac ukanono da da-usabuTebelia.
46. yovelive aRniSnulTan erTad, kasatorebi yurad-Rebas amaxvileben im garemoebazec, rom maTi azriT, a. x-ssruliad usafuZvlod aqvs Seracxuli bralad e.w. qurdu-li `obSiakis~ floba, es maSin, rodesac misi sacxovrebelisaxlis Cxrekisas misgan ar yofila amoRebuli `obSiakis~Tanxa. arc imis mtkicebuleba arsebobs, rom is `obSiakis~Tanxebis SegrovebaSi an ganawilebaSi monawileobda, andais sCadioda raime sxva iseT qmedebebs, rasac iTvaliswi-nebs saqarTvelos ssk-is 2231-e muxlis pirveli nawilis Si-naarsis ganmsazRvreli norma, romelic warmodgenilia or-ganizebuli danaSaulisa da reketis Sesaxeb saqarTveloskanonis me-3 muxlSi.
47. sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba msjavrdebul a. x-sinteresebis damcveli kasatorebis mier maT saCivarSi gan-xilul argumentebs misi udanaSaulobis Sesaxeb, vinaidanisini ar gamomdinareobs saqmeSi arsebuli masalebiT da-dasturebuli realuri faqtobrivi garemoebebidan da arc_ Sesabamisi sisxlissamarTlebrivi normebis swori ganmar-tebidan. erT-erT ZiriTad arguments, romliTac kasato-rebi apelireben, warmoadgens is, rom gasaCivrebuli gana-Ceni a. x-s msjavrdebis nawilSi efuZneba mxolod irib mtki-cebulebebs da saqmeSi faqtobrivad ar arsebobs pirdapi-ri mtkicebuleba, romelic mis brals daadasturebda, ra-sac sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba. sinamdvileSi saq-meSi warmodgenilia araerTi pirdapiri mtkicebuleba _ a.x-s mier qurduli samyaros sxva wevrebTan ganxorciele-buli satelefono saubrebis Canawerebisa da maTi Sesaba-misi krebsebis saxiT. marTalia, am mtkicebulebebs aRniS-nuli kasatorebi dauSveblad da arajerovnad miiCneven,magram aseT pozicias, rogorc zemoT, dasawyisSive ukveaRiniSna, ar gaaCnia realuri safuZveli da xsenebuli mtki-cebulebebi sruli iuridiuli Zalis mqonea.
48. aRniSnul mtkicebulebebSi dafiqsirebuli im saub-rebis Sinaarsi, romlebic msjavrdebul a. x-s ekuTvnis,swored rom pirdapir miuTiTebs mis uSualo kavSirze qur-duli samyaros sxva wevrebTan da maTTan aqtiur Tanamoq-medebazec qurduli samyaros miznebis gansaxorcieleb-lad. amitom sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs kasatorebismsjelobas imis Taobaze, rom a. x-s satelefono saubrebSi
39
iseTi araferi ikveTeba, rac qurdul samyarosTan mis kav-Sirs daadasturebda an misi, rogorc qurduli samyaroswevris, saqmianobasa da moqmedebebze miuTiTebda. saape-lacio sasamarTlos ganaCenSi gaanalizebulia am saubre-bis Sinaarsidan gamomdinare faqtobrivi garemoebebi dadasabuTebulia maTi sruli Sesabamisoba qurduli samya-ros wevrobis, rogorc qmedebis, normatiul SinaarsTan.am SemTxvevaSi sasamarTlos namdvilad ar mouxdenia mxo-lod calkeuli frazebis damaxinjebulad interpretire-ba a. x-s saubrebis mTliani konteqstidan maTi amoglejisgziT, aramed ganaCenSi gadmocemulia saubrebis mTlianiSinaarsi, xolo amis Semdeg miTiTebulia mis iseT momen-tebze, romlebSic mkafiod, udavod ikveTeba misTvis bra-lad Seracxuli qmedebebis realurad arseboba da ara mxo-lod varaudebi maT SesaZlo arsebobaze.
49. TavianTi poziciis gansamtkiceblad kasatorebicdiloben moiSvelion sisxlissamarTlebrivi normis _`organizebuli danaSaulisa da reketis Sesaxeb~ saqarTve-los kanonis me-3 muxlis pirveli punqtis Sinaarsi, rome-lic Seicavs zogadad qurduli samyaros da ara _ qurdu-li samyaros wevrobis, rogorc qmedebis, ganmsazRvrelkriteriumebs. saqme isaa, rom imave muxlis me-2 punqti ad-gens piris qurduli samyaros wevrad cnobisaTvis saWiroda, amasTan, sakmaris kriteriumebs; kerZod, es norma gan-martavs, rom qurduli samyaros wevri _ es aris nebismie-ri piri, romelic aRiarebs qurdul samyaros da aqtiuradmoqmedebs qurduli samyaros miznebis gansaxorcieleb-lad. am normis swori gagebis anu rogorc teleologiuri,ise sistemuri ganmartebis mixedviT, piris qmedeba qur-duli samyaros wevrobad rom Sefasdes, saamisod sruli-ad sakmarisia saxeze iyos xsenebuli kanonis me-3 muxlismeore punqtSi miTiTebuli niSnebi da ar aris aucilebeliim garemoebebis arsebobac, rac imave muxlis pirvel pun-qtSia mocemuli. aRniSnulis gamo, sakasacio palata verdaeTanxmeba kasatorebis im pozicias, romlis mixedviTaca. x-s is qmedebebi, rac saapelacio sasamarTlos dadastu-rebulad miaCnia, ar Seicavs qurduli samyaros wevrobiskanoniT gansazRvrul Semadgenlobas, xolo mis braleu-lobaze saapelacio sasamarTlos daskvnebSi eWvis Sesata-nad ar arsebobs kanonieri safuZveli.
50. rac Seexeba kasatorebis miTiTebas imaze, rom ara-
40
viTari mtkicebulebebiT ar dasturdeba a. x-saTvis Serac-xuli brali mis mier e.w. qurduli `obSiakis~ flobis, ase-ve `obSiakis~ Tanxebis Segrovebasa da ganawilebaSi, undaaRiniSnos aseTi msjelobis usafuZvloba da aramiznob-rioba, radgan arc pirveli instanciis sasamarTlos da arcsaapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCeniT a. x-s msgavsi konkre-tuli qmedebebis Cadena ar Seracxvia da amisaTvis arcmsjavri dasdebia. zemoaRniSnuli garemoebebidan gamom-dinare, sakasacio palata mivida im daskvnamde, rom msjav-rdebul a. x-s damcveli advokatebis _ n. c-sa da d. m-s sa-kasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes.
51. r. o-s mimarT saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCeniT Se-racxuli brali sakasacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrdebul-ma da misma interesebis damcvelma advokatebma _ d. n-mada o. s-ma, romlebic iTxoven mis gamarTlebas Semdegi mo-tivebiT: saqmeSi ar arsebobs kanonieri da utyuari mtki-cebulebebis erToblioba, romlis safuZvelzec SesaZle-beli iqneboda r. o-s msjavrdeba misTvis wardgenili bral-debis mixedviT; gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni ZiriTadad efuZ-neba satelefono saubrebis Canawerebsa da maT krebsebs,aseve mowme policielebis Cvenebebs, romlebic ver iqne-ba miCneuli kanonier da sando mtkicebulebebad; sxva mow-meebi, romlebic sasamarTloSi mocemul saqmeze daikiT-xnen, uaryofen maTgan raimes gamoZalvaSi r. o-s monawi-leobas da aRniSnaven, rom saerTod ar icnoben mas; r. o-sbinis Cxreka Catarebulia ukanonod, ris gamoc am CxrekiTmopovebuli mtkicebulebebi dauSveblad unda yofili-yo cnobili; saqmeSi ar arsebobs sxva sarwmuno mtkicebu-lebebi, romlebiTac dadasturdeboda r. o-s mier iseTimarTlsawinaaRmdego qmedebebis Cadena, rogoricaa: qur-duli garCevebi, e.w. `obSiakisaTvis~ Tanxebis Segroveba,gamoZalva, gavlenebis gadanawileba qurdul samyaroSi ansxvagvari qmedebebiT qurduli samyaros miznebis ganxor-cielebisaTvis xelSewyoba.
52. r. o-sa da misi damcveli advokatebis poziciasmsjavrdebulis udanaSaulobis Taobaze sakasacio pala-ta ver gaiziarebs, radgan mas ar moepoveba kanonieri dadasabuTebuli safuZveli saqmeSi arsebuli masalebis sa-xiT. pirvel rigSi, ar aris gasaziarebeli kasatorebis mo-sazrebebi imis Taobaze, rom r. o-s mier qurduli samya-ros sxva wevrebTan ganxorcielebuli satelefono saub-
41
rebis Canawerebi da maT safuZvelze Sedgenili krebsebi,romlebiTac is aSkarad imxileba misTvis bralad Serac-xuli qmedebebis CadenaSi, TiTqos ukanono da dauSvebelmtkicebulebebs warmoadgens. aseTi ramis mtkiceba romyovlad usafuZvloa, amis Taobaze zemoT ukve iyo deta-luri da myari argumentebiT gajerebuli msjeloba, risgamoc es sakiTxi aq ganmeorebiT aRar iqneba ganxiluli.
53. sakasacio palatas usafuZvlod miaCnia aseve kasa-torebis msjeloba imis Taobaze, rom saqmeSi ar arsebobskanonieri da sarwmuno mtkicebulebebi r. o-s mier qur-duli samyaros wevrobis an qurdul samyarosTan raime kav-Siris dasadastureblad. sinamdvileSi saqmeSi warmodge-nilia da gasaCivrebul ganaCenSic saapelacio sasamar-Tlos mier gaanalizebulia r. o-s im vrceli satelefonosaubrebis Canawerebi da maTi Sesabamisi krebsebi, romle-bic mas hqonda amave ganaCeniT qurduli samyaros wevre-bad cnobil pirebTan _ a. x-Tan da r. g-Tan, agreTve qur-dul samyaroSi kanonier qurdad aRiarebul n. j-Tan (met-saxeli `S.~). am saubrebis Sinaarsi pirdapir miuTiTebs r.o-s mWidro kavSirze da ara mxolod kavSirze, aramed misTanamoqmedebaze qurduli samyaros sxva wevrebTan er-Tad qurduli samyaros miznebis gansaxorcieleblad.
54. igive SeiZleba iTqvas n. j-Tan misi saubrebis Taoba-zec, rac adasturebs r. o-s srul damokidebulebas qur-dul samyaroze, aseve mis gavlenian warmomadgenlebze, igiTviTonac cdilobs moipovos gavlena qurduli samyarossxva wevrebze, gadawyvitos m-s raionSi qurduli samyarossaqmianobasTan dakavSirebuli sakiTxebi. magaliTad, msjav-rdebul a. x-Tan misi satelefono saubris SinaarsiT dgin-deba r. o-s aqtiuri monawileoba qurdul samyaroSi axaliwevris (g. k-s) miRebis, misTvis gzis gakvalvisa da kanonierqurdebTan misi dakavSirebis saqmeSi. is monawileobs asevearalegaluri qurduli salaros, e.w. `obSiakisaTvis~ Tan-xebis Segrovebasa da am Tanxebis ganawilebasTan dakavSi-rebuli sakiTxebis ganxilvasa da gadawyvetaSi.
55. garda amisa, r. o-s kuTvnili mobiluri telefoniTada aseve misi kuTvnili nomridan ukavSirdebian kanonierqurd n. j-s qurduli samyaros sxva wevrebic da aramartoTviTon r. o-i. amasTan, es ukanaskneli qurdul samyaroSiaRiarebuli qcevisa da moqmedebis wesebze, usityvod ma-Ti dacvis aucileblobaze moZRvravs qurduli samyaros
42
sxva wevrebs _ r. g-sa da g. k-s. aRniSnuli mtkicebulebe-biT dgindeba agreTve is garemoeba, rom r. o-s bina iyo qur-duli Sekrebebis adgili m-s raionSi moqmedi qurduli sam-yaros wevrebisaTvis maT saqmeebTan dakavSirebul sakiT-xebze msjelobisa da am sakiTxebis gadawyvetisaTvis, ag-reTve, kanonier qurd n. j-Tan satelefono saubrebis gan-saxorcieleblad da masTan urTierTobisaTvis. aRniSnu-li garemoebebi calsaxad da sruliad udavod adasturebs,rom msjavrdebul r. o-s namdvilad aqvs Cadenili qurdu-li samyaros wevroba, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqar-Tvelos ssk-is 2231-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT.
56. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs: rac Seexeba kasatore-bis miTiTebas imaze, rom ar moipoveba mtkicebulebebi,romlebiTac dadasturdeboda r. o-s uSualo monawileo-ba qurdul garCevebSi, konkretuli pirebisgan TanxebisgamoZalvaSi, e.w. `obSiakisaTvis~ uSualod mis mier Tanxe-bis SegrovebaSi, qurdul samyaroSi gavlenebis gadanawi-lebaSi da a.S., unda iTqvas Semdegi: arc pirveli instanci-is sasamarTlo da arc saapelacio sasamarTlo ar edavebi-an r. o-s misi kasatorebis mier saCivarSi miTiTebuli amkonkretuli qmedebebis Cadenas, aramed mas msjavri dae-do e.w. `obSiakTan~ dakavSirebuli sakiTxebis garCevisaT-vis qurduli samyaros sxva wevrebTan, rac udavod emsa-xureboda qurduli samyaros miznebis ganxorcielebas.
57. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom ar arsebobs safuZ-veli agreTve msjavrdebul r. o-sa da misi damcvelebismier gamoTqmuli pretenziebis gasaziareblad gasaCivre-buli ganaCeniT misTvis saqarTvelos ssk-is 260-e muxlispirveli nawiliT Seraxul bralTan dakavSirebiT. TavianTsaCivrebSi kasatorebi miuTiTeben, rom aRniSnuli bralisdasadastureblad saqmeSi arsebobs mxolod kanonis dar-RveviT mopovebuli mtkicebuleba _ r. o-s binis Cxrekisoqmi, romelsac xels ar awers misi ojaxis wevri (meuRle);Cxrekis oqmSi ar aris aRniSnuli, konkretulad ra adgil-ze iqna napovni narkotikuli saSualeba `marixuana~, raSiiyo is gaxveuli; Tarjimani, romelic eswreboda Cxrekas,saTanadod ver flobs azerbaijanul enas; Cxrekisas amo-Rebuli nivTiereba ar daluqula wesebis dacviT. maTi das-kvniT, aRniSnuli garemoebebis gamo, Cxrekis oqmic da amo-Rebuli nivTmtkicebac dauSvebel mtkicebulebebad un-da yofiliyo cnobili. maTive azriT, dauSvebel mtkice-
43
bulebad unda ecnoT mowme k. s-s Cveneba, romelSic is mi-uTiTebs, rom dakiTxvis dros r. o-ma Tavis CvenebaSi aRi-ara _ narkotikuli saSualeba, romelic misi binidan iqnaamoRebuli, TiTqos mas ekuTvnoda, maSin, rodesac TviTr. o-s es Cveneba dauSvebel mtkicebulebad aris cnobili.
59. is garemoeba, rom Cxrekis oqms xeli ar moawera Cxre-kis damswre e. x-m (r. o-s meuRlem), aRniSnuli mtkicebu-lebis dauSveblad cnobis safuZveli ver gaxdeba, radgansaproceso kanoni amas ar iTvaliswinebs. rac Seexeba Tar-jimnis kvalifikaciis sakiTxs, sasamarTlom gamoarkvia,rom Tarjimani n. g-i mravali welia profesiul saqmiano-bas eweva da misi kvalifikacia eWvqveS ar damdgara. aqveunda aRiniSnos isic, rom Cxrekasa Tu sxva sagamoZiebo moq-medebebSi monawile an maTi mwarmoebeli oficialuri pi-rebis SemdgomSi saqmeze mowmed dakiTxva ar ewinaaRmde-geba moqmed saproceso kanonmdeblobas.
bi gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT imave qmedebisaTvis msjavrde-bul r. g-Tan (2013 wlis 21 agvisto) da msjavrdebul g. k-Tan. am saubrebis Sinaarsidan sruliad aSkaraa r. o-s aqtiu-ri kavSiri narkotikuli saSualebebis ukanono brunvasTan,isic, rom am saqmeSi aseve aqtiurad iyo CarTuli msjavrde-buli r. g-c. ganxiluli garemoebebidan gamomdinare, r. o-sa da misi advokatebis mier gasaCivrebuli ganaCenis mimarTwayenebuli pretenziebi saqarTvelos ssk-is 260-e muxlispirveli nawilis safuZvelze mis msjavrdebasTan dakavSi-rebiT ver iqneba gaziarebuli, xolo maTi sakasacio saCiv-rebis moTxovna ar unda dakmayofildes.
61. sakasacio palatam ganixila aseve mocemul saqmezemsjavrdebul g. k-s damcvelebis, advokatebis _ m. f-sa dai. W-s sakasacio saCivari, romliTac kasatorebi iTxovenmis gamarTlebas Semdegi ZiriTadi mosazrebebiTa da ar-gumentebiT da romlebsac isini mimarTaven TavianTi po-ziciis dasabuTebisaTvis: g. k-s ar Seugrovebia Tanxebi e.w.`obSiakisaTvis~ da aravisgan mouTxovia raime sargeblismiReba TavisTvis an sxvisTvis, saamisod mas aravin dau-SantaJebia da aravin dauSinebia; amasTan, sasamarTloSi mo-cemul saqmeze mowmed dakiTxulma policielebma ganac-xades, rom maT ar ician adamiani, romlis mimarTac SesaZ-loa g. k-ma ganaxorciela romelime zemoaRniSnuli qmede-ba; usafuZvlo da arasworia braldebis mxaris gancxadebaimis Taobaze, rom g. k-i flobda e.w. `obSiaks~, afarToebdamas, qurduli samyarosaTvis sargeblis misaRebad esaub-reboda kanonier qurds _ n. j-s da rom mas danaSaulebri-vi kavSiri hqonda sasamarTlos mier qurduli samyaroswevrad miCneul a. x-Tan.
62. amasTan erTad, g. k-s advokatebi saCivarSi iSvelie-ben sxva argumentebsac, kerZod, maTi azriT, ar arsebobsimis damadasturebeli mtkicebuleba, rom k-ma Caidina`organizebuli danaSaulisa da reketis Sesaxeb~ saqarTve-los kanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli Tundac erTi romelimeqmedeba, ver dgindeba agreTve g. k-s satelefono saubrisfaqti sasamarTlos mier kanonier qurdad CaTvlil pir-Tan _ n. j-Tan, xolo am ukanasknelis saxeli mtkicebule-bad motanil saubris CanawerSi ar ixsenieba, aseve verdgindeba ra nomriT sargebloda n. j-i masTan saubrisas;telefonis nomeri, romelic amoRebul iqna a. k-s binidan,marTalia, dafiqsirebulia g. k-s saxelze, magram arafriT
45
ar dasturdeba, rom mxolod es ukanaskneli sargeblobdaam nomriT da ara sxva pirebic, xolo sasamarTlos mierqurduli samyaros wevrebad miCneul a. x-sa da r. o-s So-ris e.w. `obSiakis~ Sesaxeb gamarTul saubarSi moxseniebu-li `g.~ rom mainc da mainc g. k-ia da ara sxva vinme, arafriTar dasturdeba.
64. sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba msjavrdebul g. k-sinteresebis damcveli advokatebis mier misi gamarTle-bis mizniT warmodgenil argumentebsa da mosazrebebs Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo: arc saapelacio sasamarTlo da arcpirveli instanciis sasamarTlo ar miiCneven da arc gana-CenebSi daudgeniaT, rom g. k-i flobda e.w. `obSiaks~ daTanxebs agrovebda mis Sesavsebad, anda rom is vinmesganmoiTxovda Tanxebs da eweoda gamoZalvas, adamianTa da-SantaJebas, daSinebas da a.S., ris gamoc am mimarTebiT ka-satorebis mtkicebulebebi da msjelobebi miznobriobasmoklebulia, radgan sasamarTlos g. k-saTvis msjavri ardaudvia msgavsi qmedebebisaTvis.
65. is garemoeba, rom g. k-s namdvilad aqvs Cadenili sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 2231-e muxlis pirveli nawiliTa da `or-ganizebuli danaSaulisa da reketis Sesaxeb~ saqarTveloskanonis me-3 muxlis meore nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli qme-deba _ qurduli samyaros wevroba, dadasturebulia saqme-Si arsebuli, kanonieri gziT mopovebuli, pirdapiri da ut-yuari mtkicebulebebiT. mxedvelobaSia operatiul-sam-Zebro RonisZiebebis Sedegad mopovebuli Canawerebi damaT safuZvelze Sedgenili krebsebi im satelefono saub-rebisa, romlebsac g. k-i axorcielebda gasaCivrebuli ga-naCeniT amave saqmeze msjavrdebul qurduli samyaros sxvawevrebTan, kerZod, r. da n. o-ebTan, agreTve kanonier qur-dTan _ n. j-Tan da sxva pirebTan. am saubrebidan aSkarad daudavod gamomdinareobs, rom g. k-i qurduli samyaros aq-
46
tiuri wevria da cdilobs gaxdes qurduli tradiciebis mim-devarTa ojaxis srulfasovani da sruluflebiani warmo-madgeneli, gamoxatavs upirobo mxardaWerasa da Tanadgo-misaTvis mzadyofnas qurduli samyaros wevrTa saqmiano-bisadmi, interesdeba e.w. `obSiakSi~ Tanxebis Segrovebis sa-kiTxiT da cdilobs aqtiurad imoqmedos am mimarTebiT,qurduli samyaros sxva wevrebisgan iRebs miTiTebebs, iTa-visebs im wesebs, romliTac moqmedebs qurduli samyaro.yovelive aRniSnuli sarwmunod adasturebs, rom g. k-i Zal-ze aqtiurad moqmedebda qurduli samyaros miznebis gan-saxorieleblad, miuxedavad imisa, rom igi jer kidev axal-bedad iTvleboda qurduli samyaros sxva, masze bevrad uf-ro gamocdil wevrTa Soris.
66. g. k-s qurduli samyaros wevroba da aqtiuri moqme-deba am samyaros miznebisaTvis dasturdeba agreTve saq-meSi arsebuli sxva mtkicebulebiTac, kerZod, gasaCivre-buli ganaCeniT qurduli samyaros wevrobisaTvis msjav-rdebul pirTa Soris gamarTuli satelefono saubrebisCanawerebiTa da krebsebiT, mxedvelobaSia a. x-sa da r. o-s, r. o-sa da r. g-s, s. d-sa da r. g-s, r. o-sa da n. j-s SorisgamarTuli vrceli satelefono saubrebi, ra drosac mim-dinareobs msjeloba g. k-sa da mis momaval saqmianobazequrduli samyaros mxardasaWerad da mis sasargeblod. gar-da amisa, ganaCeniT dadgenilia da Sesabamisi mtkicebule-bebiT dadasturebuli g. k-s monawileoba qurduli samya-ros wevrTa SekrebaSi, romelic gaimarTa r. o-s saxlSi, sa-dac ganixiles e.w. `obSiakis~ sakiTxi da aseve Sedga maTisatelefono saubrebi n. j-Tan.
67. g. k-s advokatebi imeoreben im argumentebsa da mo-sazrebebs, rasac gamoTqvamdnen qurduli samyaros wev-robisaTvis am ganaCeniT msjavrdebul sxva pirTa damcve-lebic da romelTa safuZvelzec isini amtkiceben Tavi-anT saCivrebSi zemoaRniSnuli satelefono saubrebis Ca-nawerebisa da krebsebis ukanonobas, ris gamoc maT miiCne-ven dauSvebel mtkicebulebebad. aseTi pretenziebis Ta-obaze zemoT ukve araerTxel iyo aRniSnuli da Sesabamisipasuxicaa gacemuli, ris gamoc isini aq xelaxla aRar iqne-ba ganxiluli.
68. ganxiluli garemoebebis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom ar arsebobs kanonieri da dasa-buTebuli safuZveli msjavrdebul g. k-s damcvelTa sa-
47
Civris dakmayofilebisaTvis, ris gamoc gasaCivrebuli ga-naCeni misi msjavrdebis nawilSi unda darCes ucvlelad.
70. prokurori m. S-Tan dakavSirebiT aRniSnavs, rom igiaqtiurad CaerTo msjavrdebul k. g-s mier organizebulim SexvedraSi, sadac, erTi mxriv, miwveulni iyvnen qur-duli samyaros wevri j. a-i da kriminaluri avtoriteti`r.~, xolo, meore mxriv, biznesmeni f. y-i. maT f. y-s gamos-Zales fuladi Tanxa, amasTan, m. S-ma, qurduli garCevisgziT, f. y-s 10 000 aSS dolari mosTxova. garda amisa, kasa-toris azriT, m. S-sa da v. t-s, T. g-s, a. g-sa da qurdulisamyaros sxva wevrebs Soris ganxorcielebuli satelefo-no saubrebis Sinaarsi udavod adasturebs m. S-s mier ise-Ti moqmedebebis Cadenas, rac iZleva saqarTvelos ssk-is2231-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli qmede-bis _ qurduli samyaros wevrobis Semadgenlobas.
71. prokurori Tavis saCivarSi msjelobs aseve msjav-rdebul s. d-s mier Cadenil qmedebaTa Sesaxeb da aRniS-navs, rom saqmeSi arsebobs sakmarisi mtkicebulebebi, rom-lebiTac dasturdeba s. d-s aqtiuri monawileobis faqte-bi e.w. `obSiakis~ Tanxebis SegrovebaSi, agreTve m-s raion-Si qurduli tradiciebis damkvidrebaSi, kerZod, kasato-ri uTiTebs qurduli samyaros wevrebTan s. d-s satele-fono saubrebis Canawerebsa da krebsebze.
72. rac Seexeba k. g-s msjavrdebas, prokurori arc amnawilSi eTanxmeba gasaCivrebul ganaCens, vinaidan mas mi-aCnia, rom k. g-s namdvilad aqvs Cadenili qurduli samya-ros wevroba, danaSauli, gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelosssk-is 2231-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT. kasatori saamisodmiuTiTebs Semdeg garemoebebze: swored k. g-ma uzrunvel-yo f. y-s Sexvedra qurduli samyaros warmomadgenlebTan_ `r-sa~ da j. a-Tan, sadac mas Tanxa gamosZales, amasTan, k.
48
g-i eswreboda a. S-sa da r. i-s saqmis qurdul garCevas; misiazriT, sayuradReboa aseve qurduli samyaros wevrebTank. g-s satelefono saubrebis Sinaarsic, riTac dasturde-ba misi braleuloba.
73. garda zemoaRniSnulisa, prokurori sakasacio saCiv-riT iTxovs agreTve msjavrdebulebis _ j. a-s, v. t-s, T. g-s,a. g-s, r. g-s, g. k-s, r. o-s, n. o-s, n. i-s, r. m-sa da a. x-s mimarTsaapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenis sauaresod Sebrunebasada sasamarTlos mier maTTvis gansazRvruli sasjelebisgamkacrebas, rasac kasatori asabuTebs imiT, rom saqmis ma-salebiT dasturdeba iseTi garemoebebis arseboba, rac mi-uTiTebs aRniSnuli msjavrdebulebis pirovnebisa da maTmier Cadenili qmedebebis mometebul saSiSroebaze da risgamoc isini bevrad ufro mkacr sasjels imsaxureben.
74. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs prokuror g. j-s sa-Civris motivebs, romlebic mas jer kidev amave saqmezepirveli instanciis sasamarTlos mier gamotanil ganaCen-Tan dakavSirebiT Tavis saapelacio saCivarSi hqonda ga-moTqmuli, radgan miaCnia, rom aRniSnul motivebsa da mo-sazrebebze saapelacio sasamarTlom damajerebeli, amas-Tan, dasabuTebuli pasuxi gasca saqmidan moxmobil ro-gorc konkretul mtkicebulebebze, ise faqtobriv gare-moebebze miTiTebiTa da maTi logikuri analizis gziT. aR-niSnulis gamo, ar arsebobs imis aucilebloba da saWiroe-ba, rom amjerad, kidev erTxel, vrclad da detaluradiqnes ganxiluli kasatoris moTxovnisa da im motivebissafuZvlianobisa, Tu dasabuTebulobis sakiTxi, romle-bic man Tavis saCivarSi wamoWra da romelTa gaTvaliswi-nebiT is iTxovs zemoT dasaxelebul msjavrdebulTa mi-marT saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenis Secvlasa da maT-Tvis sauaresod Sebrunebas maT mier Cadenili qmedebiskvalifikaciis nawilSi.
75. SeiZleba pirdapir iTqvas, rom kidev ufro usafuZ-vlo da saerTod dausabuTebelia kasatoris moTxovnamsjavrdebulebisaTvis sasamarTlos mier daniSnuli sas-jelebis gamkacrebis Taobaze, radgan prokurori aravi-Tar argumentze ar uTiTebs, Tu ratom miaCnia aRniSnulisasjelebi usamarTlod, igi zogadad miuTiTebs mxolodim qmedebebze, romlebic msjavrdebulebs aqvT Cadeni-li, Tumca, arc erTi argumenti ar aqvs moxmobili imis da-sasabuTeblad _ daniSnuli sasjelebi ratom unda iqnes
1. marneulis raionuli prokuraturis prokuror g. j-s, msjavrdebul r. g-s advokat g. t-s, msjavrdebul r. o-sadvokatebis _ o. s-sa da d. n-s, msjavrdebul s. d-sa damisi advokatis _ l. b-s, msjavrdebulebis _ m. S-sa da n. i-sadvokat o. s-s, msjavrdebul j. a-sa da misi advokatis _ m.u-s, msjavrdebul g. k-s advokatebis _ m. f-sa da i. W-s,msjavrdebul T. g-s, msjavrdebulebis _ n. o-s, a. g-sa da T.g-s advokat g. n-s, msjavrdebul r. m-sa da misi advokatis_ o. g-s, msjavrdebul a. x-s advokatebis _ n. c-sa da d. m-ssakasacio saCivrebi ar dakmayofildes.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes, xologasaCivrebul ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba Semdeg ga-remoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs kasatoris miTiTe-bas, rom mas aranairi danaSauli ar Caudenia, radgan es ardasturdeba saqmis masalebis Seswavlisa da gaanalizebisSedegad. palata aRniSnavs, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisida utyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivrul eWvsmiRma dasturdeba msjavrdebul l. y-s mier gasaCivrebu-li ganaCeniT bralad Seracxuli qmedebis Cadena, kerZod:mowmeebis _ m. w-s, l. s-s CvenebebiT, narkologiuri eqsper-tizis daskvniT, romlis siswore daadastura sasamarTlosxdomaze mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma eqspertma x. j-m.
3. rac Seexeba sasjels, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rommsjavrdebul l. y-s mimarT sasjelis saxiT daniSnuli va-diani Tavisuflebis aRkveTa unda Seicvalos da mas sas-jelis saxiT unda ganesazRvros jarima Semdeg garemoe-baTa gamo:
10. sakasacio palata kidev erTxel aRniSnavs, rom Tbi-lisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqme-Ta palatam 2016 wlis 21 ivlisis ganaCeniT sworad gamoi-yena arasrulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebis kodeqsi da verdaeTanxmeba braldebis mxaris pozicias arasrulwlovan-Ta marTlmsajulebis kodeqsis 73-e muxlis pirveli nawi-lis daTqmaze, rom arasrulwlovans vadiani Tavisufle-bis aRkveTa SeiZleba daeniSnos, Tu mis mimarT warsulSigamotanilia gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni. palata verc amavekodeqsis 74-e muxlTan mimarTebiT gaiziarebs braldebismxaris mosazrebas, rom am muxlis dispoziciidan gamom-dinare (Tu arasrulwlovanma, romelic ganzraxi danaSau-lisaTvis msjavrdebuli ar yofila, naklebad mZime an mZimedanaSauli Caidina, sasamarTlo uflebamosilia daadgi-nos, rom daniSnuli sasjeli pirobiT msjavrad CaeTva-los), sakmarisia am muxlis gamoyenebisTvis arsebobdesmsjavrdebulis mimarT erTxel mainc gamotanili gamam-tyunebeli ganaCeni da ara _ warsulSi nasamarTloba. ze-moT aRniSnuli sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 79-e muxlisme-6 nawilis moTxovnidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatasmiaCnia, rom arasrulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebis kodeq-sis 73-e-74-e muxlebis miznebisTvisac, Tu arasrulwlo-
89
vani nasamarTlobis armqonea (mas moxsnili an gaqarwyle-buli aqvs nasamarTloba), mis mimarT warsulSi gamotani-li gamamtyunebeli ganaCeni ar unda iqnes mxedvelobaSimiRebuli da aseve, es garemoeba ar unda iqnes gaTvalis-winebuli pirobiTi msjavris gamoyenebis dros.
4. sakasacio palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs v. e-is mier Ca-denili danaSaulebrivi qmedebis aRiarebasa da monanie-bas, aseve im garemoebas, rom man iTanamSromla gamoZie-basTan da Tavad warudgina danaSaulis iaraRi; aRniSnu-lisa da aseve, imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom v. e-s pasuxis-mgeblobis damamZimebeli garemoebebi ar gaaCnia da amas-Tanave, ar arsebobs saqarTvelos ssk-is 63-e muxlis gamo-yenebis damabrkolebeli garemoebebi, mis mimarT unda gav-rceldes am muxliT dadgenili SeRavaTi.
5. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasaciopalatas miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul v. e-is moTxovna mis-Tvis daniSnuli sasjelis pirobiT CaTvlis Taobaze safuZ-vliania da unda dakmayofildes.
8. m. f-sgan, u. k-sgan, g. m-sa da l. j-sgan amoRebuli damaTze gapirovnebuli ... modelis #.., #..., #... da #... samsa-xurebriv-saStato cecxlsasroli iaraRebi da vaznebi(daluquli l. samxaraulis saxelobis sasamarTlo eqsper-tizis erovnuli biuros paketSi), romlebic inaxeba dasav-leT saqarTvelos saolqo prokuraturis administraci-ul SenobaSi, saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebisSemdeg unda daubrundes saqarTvelos Ss saministros ime-reTis, raWa-leCxumisa da qvemo svaneTis samxareo mTavarsammarTvelos Semdgomi gankargvis mizniT;
11. daaxloebiT 16 saaTze zemoaRniSnul maRaziasTanmyofma l. j-m SeniSna saavtomobilo gzaze `subaru fo-resteris~ markis ... saxelmwifo nomris mqone avtomanqa-niT moZravi m. b-e. l. j-i ubnis inspeqtor-gamoZiebel g. m-sTan, m. f-sa da u. k-sTan erTad fexiT daedevna m. b-s. av-tomanqanas uSualod ukan misdevdnen l. j-i da m. f-e, xo-lo policiis sxva ori TanamSromeli gaemarTa iqve arse-buli sacxovrebeli korpusebis mimarTulebiT, raTa av-tomanqanisaTvis gadaeRobaT gasasvleli gza. garkveulimanZilis gavlis Semdeg m. b-e aRmoCnda samanqano gzis Cix-Si, amitom man moabruna avtomanqana da imave gziT dabrun-da ukan. am dros l. j-m m. b-s mosTxova avtomanqanis SeCe-reba. m. b-e ar daemorCila l. j-s moTxovnas da imave mimar-TulebiT maRali siCqariT ganagrZo moZraoba.
12. l. j-m `policiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis 31-eda 34-e muxlebis moTxovnaTa sawinaaRmdegod, arapropor-ciuli iZulebis RonisZiebis gamoyenebiT, iaraRis gamo-yenebisaTvis savaldebulo pirobebis ararsebobisas, sit-yvieri gafrTxilebisa da gamafrTxilebeli gasrolis ga-nuxorcieleblad, gadaameta samsaxurebriv uflebamosi-lebas, tabeluri ... modelis #... iaraRidan gasroliT gan-zrax daaziana m. o-s avtomobili da gaufrTxileblobiTsicocxle mouspo m. b-s.
14. dasavleT saqarTvelos saolqo prokuraturis uf-rosi prokurori _ daviT leperti sakasacio saCivriT iT-xovs quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2015 wlis 21 dekembris ganaCenSi cvli-lebis Setanas im mimarTebiT, rom l. j-i cnobil iqnes dam-naSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliTa da 33-e muxlisme-3 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT da daeniSnos kanoniT gaTva-liswinebuli sasjeli.
15. kasatoris mosazrebiT, sisxlis samarTlis saqmeSiarsebul mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobiT utyuaradaa da-dasturebuli is garemoeba, rom m. b-s sikvdili uSualodl. j-s mier missave saxelze gapirovnebuli iaraRidan gan-xorcielebulma gasrolam gamoiwvia, rac sasamarTlos sav-
102
sebiT kanonierad gaiziara; sasamarTlom aseve marTebu-lad gaiziara braldebis mxaris mosazreba l. j-s mier sam-saxurebrivi uflebamosilebis gadametebasa da iaraRisukanonod gamoyenebasTan dakavSirebiT; sisxlis samar-Tlis saqmeSi arsebul mtkicebulebaTa erTobliobiT sa-fuZvlianadaa uaryofili dacvis mxaris versia gamaf-rTxilebeli gasrolis dros l. j-s mier betonis zedapir-ze fexis wamokvrisa da waborZikebis Taobaze.
16. amasTan, braldebis mxare ar eTanxmeba saapelaciosasamarTlos mier l. j-s qmedebis gadakvalificirebas sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxlidan 116-e muxlze da Tvlis,rom m. b-s sikvdilis mimarT l. j-i moqmedebda arapirda-piri _ eventuluri ganzraxviT.
17. l. j-i cecxlsasroli iaraRis amoRebis, sabrZolomdgomareobaSi moyvanisa da gasrolis dros srulad iTva-liswinebda marTlsawinaaRmdego Sedegis dadgomis SesaZ-leblobas, rac dadasturebulia rogorc saqmis faqtob-rivi garemoebebiT _ gasrola moxda mWidrod dasaxlebulubanSi, dRisiT, SuadRis saaTebSi, mravalbiniani korpu-sebis win mdebare ezoSi, aseve Tavad l. j-s CvenebiT, rom-lis Tanaxmad, igi iyo korpusebis axlos, amitom raimes da-zianebisa da tyviis saxlebSi Sevardnis Tavidan asacileb-lad, gadavida betonis gzaze, sadac moaxdina gasrola anumas srulad gaTvaliswinebuli hqonda marTlsawinaaRmde-go Sedegis dadgomis SesaZlebloba. l. j-i policieli iyo,kargad icnobda `policiis Sesaxeb~ kanonis moTxovnebs,mis ufleba-movaleobebs da gavlili hqonda iaraRis ga-moyenebasTan dakavSirebuli specialuri kursi. m. b-e swra-fi svliT gadaadgildeboda `subaru-foresteris~ markis,ukan daburuli saqare minis mqone avtomanqaniT da misgandaSorebuli iyo ramdenime aTeuli metriT, aseT viTare-baSi moZravi avtomanqanis mimarT uknidan gasrolis gan-xorcielebis dros l. j-i uSvebda imis SesaZleblobas,rom gasrolili tyvia SeiZleba moxvedroda m. b-s.
18. is faqti, rom moZravi avtomanqana sakmao manZiliTiyo daSorebuli braldebulidan da kidev ufro Sorde-boda, mianiSnebs ara qmedebis daudevrobiT, aramed ara-pirdapiri ganxraxviT Cadenaze, vinaidan rac ufro daSo-rebuli iyo avtomanqana l. j-sagan, daburuli hqonda uka-na saqare mina da swrafad midioda, ufro metad izrdebo-da srolis SemTxvevaSi aramarto manqanis dazianebis, ara-
103
med mis saWesTan mjdom pirze gasrolili tyviis moxved-ris riski, rac Segnebuli hqonda l. j-s. marTalia mas arsurda m. b-s mokvla, magram aseT viTarebaSi igi uSvebdaimis SesaZleblobas, rom gasrolili tyvia moxvedroda m.b-s, rac moxda kidevac, aRniSnuli ki warmoadgens ara da-udevrobas, aramed eventualur ganzraxvas. yvela ganzra-xi danaSaulis Cadenisas, pirs amoZravebs garkveuli mo-tivi, sababi, Tundac umniSvnelo, magram kanonmdeblobiTupirobod dasadgeni. mocemul SemTxvevaSi mkvlelobismotivTan dakavSirebiT l. j-s rogorc policiels, ganyo-filebis ufrosis z. j-sagan miRebuli hqonda davalebayvela Rone exmara m. b-s policiis ganyofilebaSi warmo-sadgenad. amasTan, braldebuli iyo operatiuli jgufisufrosi. Sesabamisad yoveli gauxsneli danaSauli da mima-luli savaraudo damnaSave, uaryofiTad aisaxeboda missamsaxurebriv avtoritetze. aseve uaryofiTad imoqme-debda mis samsaxurebriv mdgomareobaze uSualo ufro-sis z. j-sagan miRebuli davalebis dadgenil droSi Seus-rulebloba da imave dRiT m. b-s policiis ganyofilebaSiwarudgenloba. am fonze l. j-i ganawyenda ra maszed, romm. b-e ar daemorCila mis kategoriul moTxovnas avtoman-qanis SeCerebis Taobaze. piriqiT, is rogorc policieliugulebelyo m. b-m da moZravi avtomanqanis pirdapir wavi-da l. j-saken, ra drosac am ukanasknels gverdulze ga-daxdomac ki dasWirda. l. j-m sasurvel Sedegs ver miaR-wia da rogorc policielma ver moaxerxa danaSaulis Se-saZlo Camdeni piris SeCereba, rac isev uaryofiTad aisa-xeboda mis samsaxurebriv mdgomareobaze. amitom man av-tomanqanis Cavlis Semdgom uknidan moaxdina m. b-s mimarTmizanmimarTuli gasrola. aseT viTarebaSi l. j-i Segnebu-lad uSvebda (gacnobierebuli hqonda) imis SesaZleblo-bas, rom tyvia SeiZleba moxvedroda daburuli minis mqo-ne, swrafad moZrav manqanaSi mjdom m. b-s, rac moxda ki-dec. aRniSnuli ki Seicavs saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e mux-liT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis niSnebs. arapirdapiriganzraxvis uarsayofad arc is argumenti gamodgeba, rom`Tundac m. b-s araapirdapiri ganzraxviT mokvlis motivisarsebobis pirobebSi es ukanaskneli ar dajerdeboda mxo-lod erT gasrolas~. aRniSnulis sawinaaRmdegod unda iT-qvas, rom l. j-m meore gasrola imitom ki ar ganaxorcie-la, rom mas arapirdapiri ganzraxva ar hqonda, aramed mxo-
104
lod imitom, rom gasrolisTanave m. b-s marTvis qveS myo-fi avtomobili boZs Seejaxa da svla Sewyvita. sasamarTloarapirdapiri ganzraxvis uarsayofad aseve aRniSnavs, roml. j-s m. b-s mimarTulebiT srolisaTvis gacilebiT kargipirobebi hqonda maSin, rodesac idga avtomobilis piris-pir, Tumca mas es ar gaukeTebia. metic iaraRic ki ar amou-Ria saqamridan, aRniSnulis sawinaaRmdegod unda iTqvas,rom aRniSnuli araTu aqarwylebs, aramed ufro amyarebsbraldebis mosazrebas eventualur ganzraxvasTan dakav-SirebiT. swored is garemoeba, rom m. b-s marTvis qveS myo-fi avtomanqanis mimarT, ara mis win dgomis, aramed Cavli-sa da uknidan gasrolis ganxorcieleba mianiSnebs l. j-sara Tavdacvis mizniT, aramed piriqiT m. b-s SesaZlo mok-vlis mizniT moqmedebas, rac Seicavs saqarTvelos ssk-is108-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis niSnebs.
19. msjavrdebuli l. j-i da misi interesebis damcveli,advokati i. g-e sakasacio saCivriT iTxoven quTaisis saa-pelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis2015 wlis 21 dekembris ganaCenis gauqmebasa da l. j-s ga-marTlebas im safuZvliT, rom ganaCeni aris ukanono dadausabuTebeli, kerZod:
20. sasamarTlom daadgina, rom l. j-m gaufrTxileblo-biT mouspo sicocxle m. b-s, aseT viTarebaSi ki yovelgvarlogikas moklebulia, manve ganzrax rogor dauziana av-tomanqana m. o-s. sasamarTlom ar gaiTvaliswina is mniS-vnelovani garemoeba, rom dazaralebul m. o-s kanonieriinteresi ar Selaxula da verc Seilaxeboda, radgan kano-nieri interesi es aris interesi im samarTlebrivi urTi-erTobisadmi (xelSekrulebis Sesruleba, administraci-uli aqtis gamocema), romlisgan gamomdinare Sedegebi Se-saZloa pozitiurad an negatiurad aisaxos piris ufleb-riv mdgomareobaze. mocemul SemTxvevaSi SesaZlebeliasaubari iyos mxolod qonebriv zianze, rac aris samoqala-qo samarTalwarmoebis wesiT gansjadi, radgan l. j-s da-zaralebulad cnobili m. o-s avtomanqanis dazianeba damisi kanonieri interesis Selaxva ganzraxuli ar hqonia,xolo saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 333-e mux-liT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSauli ganzraxi bralis gare-Se ar arsebobs. aseve mniSvnelovania sasamarTlom gaiTva-liwinos dazaralebul m. o-s Cveneba, romelic adastu-rebs, rom misi kanonieri interesi ar Selaxula da bral-
105
debul l. j-s mimarT raime pretenzia ar gaaCnia.21. usafuZvloa gasaCivrebuli ganaCenis dasabuTeba
msjavrdebulis mier `policiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos ka-nonis 31-e da 34-e muxlis moTxovnebis darRvevis Sesaxeb,radgan l. j-m m. b-e jer sityvierad gaafrTxila, Semdegwin gadaudga mas da manqanis gaCereba mosTxova, magram nac-vlad imisa, rom m. b-s policielis kanonieri moTxovna Se-esrulebina, man l. j-i sasikvdilod gaimeta da didi siC-qariT cdilobda masze dajaxebas. Semdeg avtomanqaniT ma-Rali siCqariT moZravi m. b-s SesaCereblad l. j-m haerSigaakeTa gasrola, rac dadasturda sasamarTlo proceszedakiTxuli TviT l. j-sa da m. f-s CvenebebiT. saqmeSi arse-bobs iaraRidan gasrolis adgilis amsaxveli suraTi, ro-melzec naTlad Cans, rom ... sadarbazosa da gzis savalinawilis gadakveTasTan aris Wis Tavi da saniaRvre pataraarxi, sadac betonis safari dazianebulia, amoyrili, ra-sac wamohkra fexi l. j-m. marTalia, sasamarTlom ganzraxdanaSaulis CadenaSi ar cno igi damnaSaved, magram dadas-turebulad miiCnia mis mier m. b-sTvis sicocxlis gauf-rTxileblobiT mospobis faqti. sasamarTlos sworad romSeefasebina saqmis garemoebebi, mividoda im daskvnamde,rom l. j-s arc uflebamosilebisTvis gadaumetebia da arcgaufrTxilebeli danaSauli _ sicocxlis gaufrTxileb-lobiT mospoba Caudenia, radgan adgili hqonda ubedurSemTxvevas, romelic mohyva l. j-s mier gamafrTxilebelgasrolas, kerZod, gamafrTxilebeli gasrolis ganxorci-elebisas l. j-m fexi wamohkra dazianebul betonis safarsda waborZikda, ra drosac haerSi nasrolma tyviam Seicva-la mimarTuleba da moxvda m. b-s.
22. l. j-i am sistemis erT-erTi wevri iyo, romelic 2008wlidan keTilsindisierad anxorcielebda masze dakisre-bul movaleobas da swored aseTi movaleobis Sesrulebi-sas gasaCivrebuli ganaCeniT samsaxurebrivi uflebamosi-lebis gadametebaze iqna msjavrdebuli, rac arasworia dayovelgvar safuZvels aris moklebuli, aseve l. j-i asru-lebda misi zemdgomis ..... saqalaqo sammarTvelos polici-is ..... ganyofilebis ufrosis z. j-s davalebas, romelicmisTvis savaldebulo iyo, daeZebna b-e da mieyvana poli-ciis ganyofilebaSi sagamoZiebo moqmedebebis CatarebismizniT. policiaSi miyvanas, kanonmdebloba aseT terminsar icnobs, pirovneba an unda moiwviao policiis ganyofi-
106
lebaSi (policiis Sesaxeb kanonis 21-e muxli), romelsacegzavneba Sesabamisi uwyeba aseTis Sesaxeb, an unda miiyva-no iZulebiT, rac niSnavs imas, rom pirs misi nebis sawina-aRmdegod xanmokle vadiT SeuzRudo Tavisufleba, daa-kavo, Tanaxmad ssk-is 170-e muxlisa, rac sasamarTlos mi-er ar iqna kanoniT dadgenili wesiT Seswavlili da ar mie-ca swori samarTlebrivi Sefaseba.
23. l. j-i iyo im organos TanamSromeli, romelic gamo-Ziebis Catarebaze uflebamosili organo iyo, is asruleb-da operatiul funqcias, romelsac gauwia winaaRmdegobaSps ̀ .....~ ..... gaqurdvaSi amocnobilma b-m, ar daemorCila po-licielis kanonier moTxovnas, gauwia winaaRmdegoba dasafrTxe Seuqmna l. j-s sicocxles, sadac policiels Tun-dac davalebis gareSe ufleba hqonda daekavebina igi. da-kavebis gadawyvetileba miiRo, radgan SesaZlo iyo is mi-malvoda gamoZiebas, iyo samjer nasamarTlevi mZime dana-SaulisaTvis, Sesabamisi mtkicebulebebi devs sisxlis sa-marTlis saqmeSi. aseve ar hqonda iuridiuli misamarTi,ubralod sacxovrebeli, sadac SesaZlebeli iyo misi da-Zebna, riTac l. j-s qmedebaSi daculia ssk-is 171-e muxlismoTxovnebi. aqedan gamomdinare, kasatorebs miaCniaT, romb-e iyo is pirovneba, romelic policiis kanonier moTxov-nas ar daemorCila, gauwia mas winaaRmdegoba, xolo l. j-iiyo is policieli, romelsac b-s kanonieri dakavebis uf-leba hqonda. aqedan gamomdinare, sasamarTlom arasworiSefaseba misca l. j-s qmedebas.
24. l. j-m mosTxova sityvierad b-s, rom Seewyvita moZ-raoba da damorCileboda policias da gadaudga manqanaswin, nacvlad imisa, rom b-e damorCileboda policieliskanonier moTxovnas, man l. j-i sasikvdilod gaimeta dadidi siswrafiT undoda manqanis dajaxeba, magram l. mix-vda mis ganzraxvas, rodesac manqanas gazi moumata da swra-fi siCqariT misken wamovida, gverdiT wamierad gadaxta,amiT Tavi daaRwia sikvdils, rodesac l. j-i haerSi gamaf-rTxilebeli gasrolisaTvis moemzada, b-e misgan daaxlo-ebiT 75-80 metri manZiliT iyo mocilebuli, (rac dastur-deba saTvalTvalo gare xedvis kameriT, rac gamoarkviapirveli instanciis sasamarTlom procesze da eqspertisdakiTxviT, romelmac miuTiTa, rom tyvia b-s xvdeba ukveTavdaRmarTSi manqanis daSvebis dros, boZs rodesac gac-da maSin. saapelacio sasamarTlom ganaCeniT daadastura,
107
rom iaraRidan gasrolis dros b-e l. j-dan sakmao manZi-liT iyo mocilebuli. ras niSnavs sakmao manZili da gauge-baria ra unda gaeTvaliswinebina j-s, is, rom Tundac sak-mao manZiliT 75 m mocilebuli didi siswrafiT moZravi b-s haerSi gamafrTxilebeli gasroliT mouspobda sicoc-xles. sasamarTlo am dros msjelobs damdgari Sedegidangamomdinare da ara imwuTieri gadawyvetilebis kanonie-rebaze da marTlzomierebaze _ am nawilSi ganaCeni dausa-buTebelia. sasamarTlo iziarebs samedicino da balisti-kuri eqspertizis daskvnebs, magram ar miuTiTebs tyviisSemavali da gamavali Wrilobis lokalizacias, aseve dad-genilia saqmeze l. j-s dgomis adgili, sadac amoRebuliatviis masra. amitom sityvier gafTrxilebas b-s haerSi sro-lis Sesaxeb ver miscemda da verc imas dauSvebda, rom ha-erSi nasroli tyvia b-s moxvdeboda, uneburad, rodesachaerSi zemoT ixedeboda da xelsayrel pirobebs eZebda,rom mosaxleobisaTvis usafrTxo yofiliyo misi haerSi ga-mafrTxilebeli gasrola, srolis dros fexi wamokra,tyviam mimarTuleba Seicvala da moxvda b-s, rasac adas-turebs mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli m. f-e da l. j-s fexsac-mlis meqanikuri dazianeba, romelic vizualurad Tval-naTliv SeimCneva marjvena fexsacmelze. amave dros mniS-vnelovania erTi garemoeba, maRazia `.....~ saTvalTvalo ga-rexedvis kamerebis daTvalierebis Sedegad, sasamarTlomgamoarkvia da daaTvaliera, maRaziidan Cans manqana, ro-melsac b-e marTavda TavdaRmarTSi daSvebisas xvdebatyvia, amave dros swrafi nabijiT, gzaze sadac manqana moZ-raobda gadadis, gzas kveTavs ojaxi, l. f-e, meuRle fex-mZime coli da patara bavSvi, romelic xelSi uWiravs ma-mas, j-i amas yvelafers xedavs, aseve xedavs safrTxes man-qanis didi siswrafiT moZraobis gamo, amave dros b-e, ro-melic ar daemorCila policies, cdilobs mimalvas da da-narCeni ori policieli, romlebsac sxva mimarTulebiThqondaT gza Caketili funqcias kargavs, Tu b-e gaiqca,swored es faqtebi miiCnia j-m gamafrTxilebeli gasro-lis aucilebel pirobad. es unda momxdariyo dauyovneb-liv radgan j-m CaTvala, rom SesaZlebelia sxva mZime Se-degi gamoewvia dayovnebas. sasamarTlo gamamtyunebeli ga-naCenis dadgenis dros ar saubrobs realur safrTxeze,romelsac j-i xedavs, aramed saubrobs damdgari SedegismixedviT, radgan sirbiliT mimavalma f-m gadaaswro man-
108
qanas, risi gaTvaliswinebac winaswar j-s ar SeeZlo, rad-gan es yvelaferi xdeba wamis measedSi, intervali aris 9wami.
25. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze prokurorebma _ naTiakikvaZem da daTo cirekiZem vrclad mimoixiles saqmis ma-salebi, maT mxari dauWires dasavleT saqarTvelos saol-qo prokuraturis ufrosi prokuroris _ daviT lepertismier warmodgenili sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas da iSu-amdgomles misi dakmayofileba.
26. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze msjavrdebul l. j-s in-teresebis damcvelma, advokatma i. g-m vrclad mimoixilasaqmis masalebi, mxari dauWira warmodgenili sakasacio sa-Civris moTxovnas da iSuamdgomla misi dakmayofileba, ra-sac daeTanxma msjavrdebuli l. j-i.
samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palata saqmis masalebis Seswavlis, sakasa-
cio saCivrebis moTxovnebis gacnobis, saqmeSi arsebulimtkicebulebebis yovelmxriv, srulad da obieqturad Se-mowmebis Sedegad mivida im daskvnamde, rom sakasacio sa-Civrebi ar unda dakmayofildes, xolo quTaisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2015wlis 21 dekembris ganaCeni unda darCes ucvlelad Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlosmosazrebas, rom msjavrdebul l. j-sa da misi interese-bis damcveli advokatis sakasacio saCivris moTxovna l.j-s gamarTlebis Taobaze aris usafuZvlo da ar gamomdi-nareobs saqmis masalebidan. sakasacio palata aseve vergaiziarebs saxelmwifo bralmdeblis moTxovnas l. j-s sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT (ganzrax mkvleloba) dam-naSaved cnobis Sesaxeb, vinaidan saqmeSi warmodgenil er-TmaneTTan SeTanxmebul, utyuar mtkicebulebaTa erTob-liobiT dadasturebulia, rom l. j-m iaraRis gamoyenebiTgadaameta samsaxurebriv uflebamosilebas da manve gauf-rTxileblobiT mouspo sicocxle m. b-s, kerZod:
werebSi asaxuli piri iyo m. b-e. videoCanawerebis daTva-lierebis dasrulebis Semdgom, rasac l. j-c eswreboda,maT ganyofilebis ufrosma _ z. j-m daavala m. b-s moZebnada policiis ganyofilebaSi wardgena. amis Semdeg is da mi-si TanamSromlebi _ m. f-e, g. m-e da l. j-i imyofebodnenSemTxvevis adgilze videosaTvalTvalo kameris Canawe-rebis amosaRebad da iqve maRaziis win skamze isxdnen. ram-denime wuTSi Semouxvia vercxlisferi `subaru-foreste-ris~ markis avtomanqanam, romelsac m. b-e marTavda, svlasumata da korpusebSi Seimala. maT gadawyvites or jgufadgayofiliyvnen da m. b-s dadevnebodnen. m. f-e da l. j-imanqanis mimarTulebiT wavidnen, xolo TviTon da g. m-e _sacxovrebeli korpusebis mimarTulebiT. uecrad Semoes-ma gasrolis da 5-6 wamSi Sejaxebis xmac, magram uSualodgasrolis momenti ar daunaxavs. man SeniSna, rom m. f-e dal. j-i garbodnen avtomanqanisken. Sejaxebis adgilze mi-sulma dainaxa, rom manqanaSi marjvena mxares, saWesTan ij-da m. b-e, romelic dasisxlianebuli iyo. daWrili gadmo-iyvanes manqanidan, Casves l. j-s avtomanqanaSi da saekle-sio saavadmyofoSi waiyvanes.
4. saqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma mowme g. m-m analo-giuri Cveneba misca da igive faqtobrivi garemoebebi daa-dastura Tavis CvenebaSi.
5. mowme m. f-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom m. b-s SemCne-visTanave man, g. m-m, u. k-m da l. j-m gadawyvites dasdevne-bodnen da ganawildnen or jgufad. kerZod, u. k-e da g. m-esacxovrebeli binebis mimarTulebiT gaemarTnen, xoloTviTon da l. j-i moZrav avtomanqanas daedevnen sirbi-liT. ramdenime wuTSi dainaxa, rom m. b-e cdilobda avto-manqanis mobrunebas. l. j-m mas ramdenjerme mosTxova man-qanis gaCereba da mouwoda damorCileboda policiis moT-xovnas, Tumca man ar Sewyvita moZraoba da wamovida l. mi-marTulebiT, ra drosac es ukanaskneli marjvena mxaresgadaxta da waiforxila. rodesac l. j-i Semobrunda, masxelSi iaraRi eWira luliT cisken mimarTuli, igi misdev-da avtomanqanas da m. b-s mouwodebda SeCerebuliyo. esukanaskneli ar daemorCila mis miTxovnas da manqanam da-iwyo maRali siCqariT moZraoba. am dros dainaxa, rom l-mSeanela svla, maRla aixeda da waborZikda, ra drosac mox-da gasrola. male gaigona binis miSenebis konstruqciazeavtomanqanis Sejaxebis xma. l. j-m momxdaris Sesaxeb te-
110
lefoniT acnoba ganyofilebis ufross, ris Semdegac m. b-e gadmoiyvanes manqanidan da igi l-m Tavisi avtomanqaniTwaiyvana saavadmyofoSi. mowme m. f-s ganmartebiT, l. j-smier gamafrTxilebeli gasrolis ganxorcielebis momen-tSi arc masze da misi TvalTaxedvis areSi arc sxva vinme-ze Sejaxebis safrTxe ar arsebobda.
6. mowme z. j-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis iv-nisidan muSaobs saqarTvelos Sss ..... saqalaqo sammarTve-los policiis ... ganyofilebis ufrosis Tanamdebobaze.2014 wlis 3 oqtombers, diliT Seityo, rom gaiqurda ... mde-bare sasursaTo maRazia. aRniSnul faqtze daiwyo gamoZi-eba da daTvalierda maRaziaSi arsebuli saTvalTvalo ka-merebis videoCanawerebi, ra drosac policiis muSakebma,maT Soris l. j-m, amoicnes videoCanawerSi asaxuli sava-raudod danaSaulis Camdeni piri _ m. b-e. amis gamo man da-avala policielebs, rom moeZebnaT es ukanaskneli da wa-redginaT ganyofilebaSi. ramdenime xnis Semdeg daukav-Sirda l. j-i, romelmac ganucxada, rom m. b-e ar daemorCi-la mis kanonier moTxovnas da mohyva avtoavariaSi. Sem-Txvevis adgilze gasulma naxa, rom avtomanqana Sejaxebu-li iyo sacxovrebeli korpusis betonis boZs, xolo daSa-vebuli m. b-e l. j-s gadayvanili hyavda saavadmyofoSi.mogvianebiT l. j-i gamocxadda ganyofilebaSi da dawerapataki, sadac miuTiTa, rom m. b-e ar daemorCila mis kano-nier moTxovnas, ris gamoc ganaxorciela gamafrTxilebe-li gasrola. mowme z. j-s ganmartebiT, mas l. j-sTvis m. b-sdakaveba ar dauvalebia, vinaidan dakavebis sakiTxi gadaw-ydeboda mxolod m. b-s policiaSi wardgenisa da Sesabami-si sagamoZiebo moqmedebebis Catarebis Semdgom.
7. mowme m. a-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom qalaq quTais-Si, ..., #...-Si aqvs sasursaTo maRazia _ Sps `...~, sadac muSa-obs oTxi adamiani _ l. k-e, J. k-i, n. v-e da misi Svili _ d. a-e. maRaziaSi da mis gareT damontaJebulia saTvalTvalovideokamerebi. 2014 wlis 3 oqtombers, diliT, aRmoaCi-nes, rom misi maRazia iyo gaqurduli, ris Taobazec mimar-Ta samarTaldamcav organos. policiis TanamSromlebmamasTan erTad daaTvalieres saTvalTvalo kameris Cana-werebi, romelzec asaxuli iyo erTi ucxo piri, romelicmaRaziidan eufleboda nivTebs. mogvianebiT videoCana-weris amosaRebad marketSi mivida policiis oTxi Tanam-Sromeli da rodesac videoCanaweris gadaweris procesi
111
mimdinareobda, isini maRaziis win gavidnen da iqve xis skam-ze dasxdnen. uecrad gaigona avtomobilis motoris Zlie-ri xma, dainteresda ra xdeboda da mivida maRaziis kar-Tan, ra drosac Semoesma daZaxeba _ SeCerdio da iaraRi-dan gasrolis xma. am dros maRaziis win swrafad Caiara av-tomanqanam da sacxovrebeli korpusis betonis boZs See-jaxa.
9. igive garemoebebi daadastura Tavis CvenebaSi mowmeJ. k-m, romelmac damatebiT miuTiTa, rom policiis Tanam-Sromlebi maRaziidan gavidnen da iqve arsebul skamze das-xdnen. am dros maRaziis win gaiara vercxlisferma avto-manqanam, romelsac policiis muSakebi daedevnen, xoloTviTon marketis win SeCerda. maleve gaigona iaraRidangasrolis xma, magram vin da ra viTarebaSi isrola, ar dau-naxavs. gasrolis Semdeg avtomanqanam, romelsac ukan po-liciis muSakebi mohyvebodnen, marketis win Caiara da sac-xovrebeli korpusis betonis boZs Seejaxa.
10. mowme n. s-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom cxovrobs qa-laq quTaisSi, ... mdebare sacxovrebeli korpusis pirvelsarTulze. misi saxlidan daaxloebiT 30 metrSi mdebare-obs sasursaTo maRazia. 2014 wlis 3 oqtombers, SuadRi-sas, aivanze gavida antenis SesakeTeblad, ra drosac gai-gona gasrolis xma, magram gasrolis momenti ar daunaxavs.maleve gaigona meore xmac. gareT gamosulma dainaxa, romsacxovrebeli korpusis betonis boZs Sejaxebuli iyo av-tomanqana, romelSic axalgazrda biWi ijda da Wrilobi-dan sisxli mosdioda.
11. mowme l. W-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis 3oqtombers, saxlSi dabrunebulma mezoblebisgan Seityo,
112
rom maT ezoSi m. b-e ar damorCilebia policias, ris gamocmisTvis usvriaT da Sejaxebia boZs. adgilze misvlisas na-xa, rom avtomanqana Sejaxebuli iyo binis win betonis boZsda dazianebuli iyo. aseve man fanjridan dainaxa, rom po-liciis muSakma ezoSi Zebnis Semdgom ipova tyviis gula.
12. mowme m. o-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis 3oqtombers imyofeboda saxlSi, ra drosac ezodan moesmaswrafad moZravi avtomanqanis xma da fanjridan SeniSnaZalian didi siCqariT moZravi vercxlisferi avtomanqana.uceb gaigona gasrolis xma da dainaxa, rom avtomanqanismimarTulebiT mirboda ori Tu sami policiis TanamSro-meli. maTgan erTi manqanas misdevda odnav win waxrili,sadRac 45 gradusiT daSvebuli xeliT, romelSic iaraRieWira. man raimes gafiqrebac ver moaswro, rom Sejaxebisxma gaigona. mowmis ganmartebiT, avtomanqana am pirebis-gan imdenad Sors iyo, gasrolili tyvia mZRols Tu mox-vdeboda, ver warmoedgina.
13. mowme l. f-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis 3oqtombers, meuRlesTan _ e. W-sTan da mcirewlovan Svil-Tan erTad imyofeboda mis mezoblad mcxovreb m. kuTvnilmarketSi. iqidan gamosvlis Semdeg gadaWres marketis winarsebuli gza da wavidnen binis win mdebare avtofarexe-bis mimarTulebiT, ra drosac Semoesma iaraRidan gasro-lis xma. amave dros Semobrunda da dainaxa, rom gzaze di-di siswrafiT Camoiara `subarus~ markis avtomanqanam, ro-melic Seejaxa binis win arsebuli betonis boZs. mowme l.f-s ganmartebiT, xsenebuli avtomanqana mas da misi oja-xis wevrebs safrTxes ar uqmnida, radgan manqanis gamov-lis momentisaTvis isini sakmaod iyvnen moSorebuli gzas.im momentSi ezoSi sxva vinme ar SeuniSnavs.
14. saqmeze dazaralebulad cnobili m. o-s CvenebiTdadgenilia, rom sakuTrebaSi hyavda `subarus~ markis av-tomanqana, romelic SeiZina 4500 aSS dolarad. aRniSnuliavtomanqana masze iyo gaformebuli, magram misi Svilebicsargeblobdnen. 2014 wlis 3 oqtombers, diliT, manqana aT-xova Tavis Svils _ g. o-s, romelmac, Tavis mxriv, aTxovaTavis megobar m. b-s. saRamo xans policiis TanamSromlis-gan Seityo, rom misi kuTvnili avtomanqaniT momxdari iyoavtosagzao SemTxveva. adgilze misulma naxa, rom avto-manqana Sejaxebuli iyo betonis boZs. rogorc iqve myofipirebisgan Seityo, m. b-e ar daemorCila policiis muSaks,
31. balistikuri da samedicino eqspertizis #... das-kvniT dadgenilia, rom #... iaraRidan nawarmoebi unda iyosgasrola (gasrolebi) bolo gawmendis Semdeg. gamosakvle-vi tyvia gasrolilia #... pistoletidan. gamosakvlev tyvi-aze asxletisTvis damaxasiaTebeli kvlebi ar aRiniSneba.gamosakvlev saqare minaze kvleviT nawilSi miTiTebullokalur monakveTze arsebuli dazianeba cecxlnasroliwarmoSobisaa da ganviTarebulia spilenZis Semcveli, sa-varaudod Zaladakarguli tyviis moqmedebis Sedegad. av-tomanqana ̀ subaru-foresteris~, sax. # ̀ ...~ faqtiur mdgo-mareobaSi raime cecxlnasroli dazianeba ar aRiniSneba.srola nawarmoebia avtomanqanis ukana saqare minis mar-jvena zeda kuTxis midamoSi grZivi RerZis mimarT verti-kalur sibrtyeSi mcire 20-50 kuTxiT odnav zemodan qve-moT da horizontalur sibrtyeSi TiTqmis amave kuTxiTmarjvnidan marcxniv mimarTulebiT (amave saviziro xaz-ze imyofeboda m. b-s Tavi); gamosakvlevad wardgenili #...iaraRi gamarTulia da misgan sasxletis gamowevis gareSegasrola ar xorcieldeba.
32. balistikuri da samedicino eqspertizis Sedegebis
120
siswore sasamarTlo sxdomaze daadastures mowmis saxiTdakiTxulma eqspertebma _ a. a-m, g. c-m da n. m-m.
33. nivTierebaTa, masalaTa, nakeTobaTa da mcenareTaeqspertizis #... daskvniT dadgenilia, rom u. k-s, g. m-s, m.f-sa da l. j-s marjvena da marcxena xelis anawmendebzedenTis wvis produqtebis mikronawilakebi ar aRiniSne-boda; eqspertizaze wardgenil l. j-s tansacmlidan, mai-surze aRiniSneboda denTis wvis produqtebis mikronawi-lakebi.
34. nivTierebaTa, masalaTa, nakeTobaTa da mcenareTaeqspertizis Sedegebis siswore sasamarTlo sxdomaze da-adastures mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma eqspertebma _ l. m-mda d. C-m.
35. q. quTaisSi, ... #...-Si ganTavsebuli sasursaTo maRa-ziis (Sps `...~) saTvalTvalo kamerebze arsebuli videoCa-naweris daTvalierebis oqmiT dgindeba, rom videofirzeasaxulia 2014 wlis 3 oqtombris 03:00 saaTidan 04:00 saa-Tamde drois erTsaaTiani monakveTi, ra drosac kadrSiCndeba pirovneba, romelic midis daxlTan, iRebs celo-fans da iwyebs daxlidan celofanSi sigaretebis Calage-bas. monawile pirebis _ i. b-sa da n. q-s ganmartebiT, pirov-neba, romelic kadrSi Cans, aris m. z. Ze b-e, dabadebuli19.. wlis ... ivliss, registraciis mixedviT mcxovrebi q. qu-TaisSi, ... quCis #...-Si.
38. saapelacio sasamarTlos mier dadgenili faqtob-rivi garemoeba, rom l. j-s mier cecxlsasroli iaraRis gas-roliT dadga m. b-s sasikvdilo Sedegi, sakasacio saCivre-biT mxareebs sadavod ar gauxdiaT.
39. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saqmis masalebiT das-turdeba msjavrdebul l. j-s mier samsaxurebrivi ufle-bamosilebis gadametebis faqti. sakasacio palata eTan-xmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos msjelobas imasTan dakav-SirebiT, rom im viTarebis analizi, romelSic moqmedebdal. j-i da mis mier ganxorcielebuli qmedebis xasiaTi, ra-sac m. b-s sicocxlis mospoba mohyva, aSkarad miuTiTebsl. j-s mier `policiis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanoniT dad-genil moTxovnaTa darRvevaze samsaxurebrivi uflebamo-silebis gadametebis saxiT, rasac axlda mis mier cec-xlsasroli iaraRis aramarTlzomieri gamoyeneba. `poli-ciis Sesaxeb~ saqarTvelos kanonis moTxovnebidan gamom-dinare, romliTac detalurad aris gansazRvruli, Tu raviTarebaSia uflebamosili policiis muSaki ukiduresi Ro-nisZiebis saxiT gamoiyenos cecxlsasroli iaraRi, l. j-iSeqmnil viTarebaSi ar iyo uflebamosili moexdina araTudamazianebeli, aramed gamafrTxilebeli gasrolac ki, vi-naidan, saqmis masalebiT ar dasturdeba, rom srolis mo-mentSi arsebobda m. b-s mxridan l. j-s da an sxva piris si-cocxlis an/da janmrTelobis xelyofis realuri saf-rTxe.
40. sakasacio palata aseve ver gaiziarebs dacvis mxa-ris sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas, rom l. j-s saqarTve-los ssk-is 116-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT gaTvaliswinebulidanaSauli _ sicocxlis gaufrTxileblobiT mospoba ar
122
Caudenia, aramed adgili hqonda ubedur SemTxvevas, ro-melic mohyva mis mier gamafrTxilebel gasrolas. kasato-ri saCivarSi miuTiTebs, rom gamafrTxilebeli gasrolisganxorcielebisas l. j-m fexi wamohkra dazianebul beto-nis safars da waborZikda, ris Sedegadac haerSi nasrolmatyviam Seicvala mimarTuleba da moxvda m. b-s, xolo saka-sacio palatis sxdomaze ki axali versia warmoadgina, rom-lis mixedviT, rodesac is miwis safaridan gadadioda be-tonis safarian gzaze, romelic Tavis mxriv aris SemaRle-buli, am dros waiforxila, muxli TiTqmis daado betonissafars, ra drosac moxda gasrola. sakasacio palatas mi-aCnia, rom dacvis mxaris arcerTi poziciis safuZvliano-ba ar dasturdeba saqmis masalebiT. saxeldobr, 1-li in-stanciis sasamarTloSi saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvisas Tavadmsjavrdebulma da mowme m. f-m konkretulad ver miuTi-Tes is sagani da adgili, rasac TiTqosda fexi wamokra l.j-m, xolo mis mier sakasacio sasamarTloSi wamodgeniliaxali versiis damadasturebeli mtkicebuleba saqmeSi ararsebobs. SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebis oqmiTa damasze TandarTuli fotoilustraciiT dadgenilia, romgasrolis adgilas betonis gzas gaaCnia swori zedapiri damasze ar SeiniSneba raime iseTi obieqti an dazianeba, ra-zec SesaZloa fexi wamoekra l. j-s. sasamarTlo proceszemowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas gamomZieblebma _ g. C-m da v. x-maCvenes, rom maT daaTvalieres SemTxvevis adgili, ra dro-sac SemTxvevis adgilze arsebul betonis zedapirze rai-me saxis dazianeba an defeqti _ ormoebis an CaRrmavebissaxiT, romelzec SeiZleba msjavrdebuls fexi wamoekra,ver aRmoaCines. amasTan, trasologiuri eqspertizis das-kvniT dadgenilia, rom fexsacmelze, romelic SemTxve-vis dRes ecva l. j-s, eqspluataciuri cveTis garda sxvameqanikuri dazianeba ar aRiniSneboda.
41. aRniSnul daskvnasTan dakavSirebiT sasamarTloprocesze mowmis saxiT dakiTxvisas eqspert T. S-s Cvene-biT dadgenilia, rom l. j-s fexsacmelze, romelic mas ec-va SemTxvevis dRes, SeiniSneba mxolod eqspluataciuricveTis niSnebi. amasTan, masze raime saxis dazianeba, dama-xasiaTebeli meqanikuri zemoqmedebisaTvis, ar aRiniSne-ba. amdenad, l. j-s mier gasrolis dros fexis wamokvrisSemTxvevaSi fexsacmelze aucilebad unda darCeniliyoSesabamisi dazianebis kvali, rasac, mocemul SemTxvevaSi,
123
adgili ar hqonia. sakiTxi imis Taobaze, rom l. j-s gasro-lis dros cecxlsasroli iaraRi luliT mimarTuli hqon-da ara vertikalurad haerSi, aramed horizontalurad imavtomanqanisaken, romelsac marTavda m. b-e da swored amdros man moaxdina ara gamafrTxilebeli, aramed mizanmi-marTuli gasrola avtomanqanis gasaCereblad, rasac moh-yva ara mxolod avtomanqanis dazianeba, aramed aseve av-tomanqanis saWesTan mjdomi m. b-s sicocxlis mospobac,udavod dasturdeba agreTve balistikuri da samedicinoeqspertizebis daskvnebiT da Sesabamisi eqspertebis Cve-nebebiT.
48. amrigad, amgvar pirobebSi, faqtobrivad gamoric-xulia imis SesaZlebloba, rom msjavrdebul l. j-s miermomxdariyo aRniSnuli cecxlsasaroli iaraRis SemTxve-viTi gasrola misi nebisgan damoukideblad.
49. msjavrdebulma l. j-m ganmarta, rom gamafrTxile-beli gasrolis ganxorcielebas apirebda myarad dgomisda ara moZraobis momentSi. am ukanasknelisa da mowme m. f-s Cvenebebis mixedviT, gasrola moxda l. j-s moZraobisprocesSi. aseT viTarebaSi, gamafrTxilebeli gasrolissurvilis SemTxvevaSic ki, l. j-s myari poziciis dafiqsi-rebamde, sabrZolo mdgomareobaSi moyvanili `...~ modeliscecxlsasroli iaraRis sasxletze TiTi ar unda hqonodadadebuli, rac sinamdvileSi ase ar iyo. aRniSnuli gare-moeba ki pirdapir miuTiuTebs l. j-s survilze _ moexdi-na ara gamafrTxilebeli, aramed gamiznuli gasrola moZ-ravi avtomanqanis mimarTulebiT, mis SesaCereblad.
50. garda amisa, sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelaciosasamarTlos msjelobas imis Taobaze, rom SeuZlebeliawaborZikebis Sedegad tyvia TiTqmis horizontalurad,
125
mxolod mciredi daxriT (rogorc es balistikuri da sa-medicino eqspertizis daskvnebiT aris dadgenili) wasu-liyo avtomanqanis da ara miwis zedapiris mimarTulebiT.sadao ar aris, rom m. b-s marTvis qveS myofi avtomanqanadidi siswrafiT moZraobda da gasrolis ganxorcielebismomentSi l. j-sgan sakmao manZiliT iyo daSorebuli, racmniSvnelovnad zrdida gasrolili tyviis miznidan gadax-risa da, Sesabamisad, avtomanqanaSi myofi adamianisaTvismisi moxvedris risks.
51. aseve sworia gasaCivrebul ganaCenSi ganviTarebu-li msjeloba imis Taobaze, rom kasatoris pozicia, rom-lis mixedviT, SesaZloa m. b-s moxvda raime myari sagnidanasxletili tyvia, rac ar gamoikvlia da ar Seafasa 1-liinstanciis sasamarTlom, ver CaiTvleba iseT garemoebad,ramac SeiZleba eWvqveS daayenos l. j-s braleuloba, rad-gan aseT SemTxvevaSic ki iarsebebda misi mxridan sul co-ta safrTxis gaTvaliswinebis SesaZlebloba da valdebu-lebac.
52. sakasacio palata aseve ar iziarebs prokuroris sa-kasacio saCivris moTxovnas l. j-s saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT msjavrdebis Sesaxeb da mTlianad eTanxmeba saa-pelacio sasamarTlos mosazrebas imis Taobaze, rom saq-meSi warmodgenili da sasamarTlos mier gamokvleulimtkicebulebebi ar iZleva sakmaris safuZvels, raTa sar-wmunod iqnes miCneuli l. j-s mier saqarTvelos ssk-is 108-e muxliT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulis _ ganzrax mkvle-lobis Cadena.
53. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom qmedebis ganzraxmkvlelobad dakvalificirebisaTvis aucilebelia dadgin-des subieqtis ganzraxva, kerZod, misi mizanmimarTuliqmedeba dazaralebulis sicocxlis mospobisaken anda,ukidures SemTxvevaSi, damnaSavis mier dazaralebulissikvdilis, rogorc Sedegis Segnebul daSvebas an am uka-nasknelis dadgomisadmi gulgril damokidebulebas, ra-sac, mocemul SemTxvevaSi, adgili ar hqonia. rogorc Ta-vad l. j-s Cvenebis, aseve misi Tanamewyvilis _ m. f-sa daSemTxvevis adgilze myofi sxva mowmeebis Cvenebebis Sina-arsi adasturebs, l. j-s mier Cadenilia ara ganzrax mkvle-loba, aramed m. b-s sicocxlis mospoba gaufrTxileblo-biT, xolo saqmeSi ar moipoveba sxva mtkicebuleba, rom-liTac sarwmunod dadasturdeboda, rom l. j-s surda m.
126
b-s mokvla anda igi Segnebulad uSvebda mis sikvdils angulgrilad ekideboda aseT Sedegs.
54. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlospozicias, rom saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebis erTob-livi analiziT dasturdeba l. j-s qmedebaSi gaufrTxi-lebeli danaSaulis niSnebis arseboba, magram sakasacio pa-lata ver daeTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos msjelo-bas imis Taobaze, rom l. j-m gaufrTxileblobiTi danaSa-uli Caidina daudevrobis formiT, vinaidan man ar gaiTva-liswina, mis mier gasrolis ganxorcielebis SemTxvevaSi,m. b-saTvis tyviis moxvedris realuri SesaZlebloba, risigaTvaliswinebis movaleoba mas ekisreboda samarTlebri-vad da SeeZlo kidec gaeTvaliswinebina misi saqmianobisxasiaTidan da gamocdilebidan, aseve cecxlsasroli ia-raRis Tundac gamafrTxilebeli gasrolisaTvis gamosa-yeneblad araxelsayreli pirobebidan gamomdinare. saape-lacio sasamarTlos aseTi poziciis sawinaaRmdegod saka-sacio palatas miaCnia, rom aRweril viTarebaSi l. j-s mi-zani iyo ara m. b-s janmrTelobis dazianeba an sicocxlisxelyofa, aramed avtomanqanis SeCereba, ris gamoc gais-rola man avtomanqanis mimarTulebiT, ra drosac mas gac-nobierebuli hqonda windaxedulobis normiT akrZaluliqmedeba, iTvaliswinebda marTlsawinaaRmdego Sedegisdadgomis SesaZleblobas, kerZod, garda avtomanqanis ga-Cerebisa, SesaZlebeli iyo avtomanqanis saWesTan mjdomiadamianis, am SemTxvevaSi, m. b-s janmrTelobis dazianebaan misi sicocxlis mospobac. Tumca, l. j-i imaze dayrdno-biT, rom avtomanqana didi siswrafiT moZraobda da ukvemisgan Sor manZilze imyofeboda, imedovnebda, rom moZ-ravi avtomanqanis mimarTulebiT gasrolis SemTxvevaSi ardadgeboda sxva mZime Sedegi, garda avtomanqanis dazia-nebisa, xolo adamianis janmrTelobis dazianeba an sicoc-xlis xelyofa Tavidan iqneboda acilebuli. sinamdvile-Si rogorc aRmoCnda, igi usafuZvlod imedovnebda, romamjerad aseTi Sedegi Tavidan iqneboda acilebuli. gar-da amisa, sakasacio palata Tvlis, rom im viTarebaSi, ro-desac subieqti axorcielebs mizanmimarTul gasrolasmoZravi avtomanqanisaken, SeuZlebelia imavdroulad ariTvaliswinebdes gasrolili tyviis miznidan gadaxrisa daam avtomanqanaSi myofi adamianis janmrTelobis daziane-bis an sicocxlis mospobis SesaZleblobas, gansakuTre-
127
biT maSin, rodesac es subieqti aris policieli, mraval-wliani samsaxurebrivi da profesiuli saqmianobis, agreT-ve cecxlsasrol iaraRTan urTierTobisa da sxvadasxvarTul situaciebSi misi gamoyenebis gamocdilebiT.
55. aRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatas miaC-nia, braldebis mxaris pozicia imis Taobaze, rom saqmeSiwarmodgenilia utyuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac da-dasturebulia l. j-s mier arapirdapiri ganzraxviT m. b-smkvlelobis Cadena, safuZvels moklebulia, radgan saa-misod saqmeSi ar moipoveba sakmarisi mtkicebulebiTi ba-za, romlis safuZvelze SesaZlebeli iqneboda mxaris xse-nebuli poziciis dadasturebulad miCneva.
56. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palatas miaCnia, rom rogorc 1-li instanciis, asevesaapelacio sasamarTloebis mier srulad iqna gamokvle-uli saqmeSi arsebuli, kanonis moTxovnaTa dacviT mopo-vebuli mtkicebulebebi, sworad iqna dadgenili faqtob-rivi garemoebebi, Tumca am ukanasknelT ar mieca zustisamarTlebrivi Sefaseba l. j-s mier Cadenili qmedebisbralis formis TvalsazrisiT. kerZod, mxedvelobaSia isgaremoeba, rom aRniSnuli qmedeba l. j-s mier CadeniliagaufrTxilebeli bralis iseTi formiT, rogoricaa Tvi-Timedovneba da ara daudevrobiT, rogorc es CaTvala sa-apelacio sasamarTlom. magram, miuxedavad amisa, aRniS-nuli ar warmoadgens l. j-s qmedebis samarTlebriv Sefa-sebaSi daSvebul iseT arsebiT xarvezs, rac SeiZleba gam-xdariyo gamamtyunebeli ganaCenis Secvlis safuZveli.
58. rac Seexeba saapelacio sasamarTlos mier l. j-saT-vis daniSnul sasjels, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom aR-niSnuli sasjeli savsebiT Seesabameba rogorc CadenilqmedebasTan dakavSirebul garemoebebs, aseve misi Camde-
128
nis pirovnebas: l. j-s mier Cadenilia ori danaSauli damisi qmedebebiT gamowveulia mZime Sedegi. amasTan erTad,sakasacio palata iTvaliswinebs im garemoebasac, rom l.j-s warsuli xasiaTdeba dadebiTad, qmedebis Cadenis Sem-deg is Seecada piradad aRmoeCina daxmareba dazarale-bul m. b-saTvis da miiRo zomebi saimisod, rom is drou-lad yofiliyo gadayvanili samedicino dawesebulebaSi.amave dros mxedvelobaSia misaRebi is garemoebac, rom mismier qmedeba Cadenilia gaufrTxilebeli bralis ufro mZi-me formiT, ris gamoc, sasamarTlos mier misTvis daniSnu-li sasjelis Semsubuqeba ver CaiTvleba mizanSewoniladda dasabuTebulad. Tumca msjavrdebul l. j-s sasargeb-lod arsebuli zemoxsenebuli garemoebebis gaTvaliswi-nebiT, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom aseT pirobebSi, sa-samarTlos mier misTvis daniSnuli sasjelis gamkacrebaver iqneba miCneuli aucilebel da saWiro zomad misi ga-mosworebisa da resocializaciisaTvis. yovelive aRniS-nulidan gamomdinare, sakasacio palata mivida im daskvnam-de, rom saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCeniT msjavrdebull. j-saTvis gansazRvruli saboloo sasjeli _ 7 wliT Ta-visuflebis aRkveTa aris samarTliani da unda darCes uc-vlelad.
4. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivres msjavrdebul-ma da misma advokatebma _ t. k-em da m. l-em. maT iTxovesquTaisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2015 wlis 16 noembris ga-naCenSi cvlilebis Setana da l. m-is damnaSaved cnoba sa-qarTvelos ssk-is 117-e muxliT.
5. quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa palatis 2016 wlis 9 martis ganaCeniT ar dakmayo-filda msjavrdebulisa da misi advokatebis saapelaciosaCivari da gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni darCa ucvlelad.
6. kasatorebi _ msjavrdebuli l. m. da misi interesebisdamcveli, advokati t. k. sakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnaven,rom quTaisis saapelacio sasamarTlos 2016 wlis 9 martisganaCeni ukanono da dausabuTebelia, amitom unda gauq-mdes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo: saqmeSi ar arsebobs erTiutyuari mtkicebulebac ki, romelic daadasturebda l.m-is mier mkvlelobis mcdelobis Cadenas; sasamarTlomaraobieqturad da arakvalificiurad Seafasa gamokvle-uli mtkicebulebebi da gamoitana dausabuTebeli ganaCe-ni; aRsaniSnavia isic, rom am saqmis gamoZieba Catarda ze-reled da calmxrivad; braldebis mxaris mowmeTa (poli-cielebis) Cvenebebi identuria; aSkaraa, rom yvela es Cve-neba dawerilia erTi da imave piris mier da yvela polici-elma ukve gamzadebul Cvenebebs saTiTaod moawera xeli,amitom es Cvenebebi ar aris sando.
7. garda amisa, l. m. aris memarcxene (cacia); mas ar SeuZ-lia aranairi nivTis gamoyeneba marjvena xeliT; Sesabami-sad, policielebi cruoben, rodesac amboben, rom mas mar-
131
jvena xeliT eWira dana; l. m-s T. r-is mkvlelobis ganzrax-va rom hqonoda, is danas aucileblad marcxena xeliT da-iWerda; mowme policielebi rom cruoben, es kargad Canseqspertizis daskvnebiT, romlebSic aRwerilia l. m-is da-zianebebi. igi intensiurad rom ar iqnevda danas da T. r-esrom ar klavda, iqidanac irkveva, rom Cxubi Tavidan bo-lomde gagrZelda daaxloebiT 5-10 wuTs; am xnis ganmav-lobaSi l. m-s SeeZlo daaxloebiT 200-jer mainc moeqniadana, anu mkvlelobis ganzraxva rom hqonoda, mas sisru-leSi aucileblad moiyvanda.
8. kasatorebi aseve aRniSnaven, rom yvela arapolicie-li mowme calsaxad miuTiTebs, rom l. m. da T. r. `Cxubob-dnen xeldaxel~, erTmaneTs xeliT ayenebdnen dazianebebsda arc erTi maTganis xelSi dana ar daunaxavT; arc erTimowme ar ambobs, rom l. m-ma piradad T. r-is mimarT raimesaxis protesti gamoxata da mokvliT daemuqra; dazara-lebulisaTvis miyenebuli Wrilobebidan arc erTi ar arissicocxlisaTvis saxifaTo; maT Soris araferi momxdaraiseTi, rac l. m-s SurisZiebis grZnobas gauCenda. aseT Sem-TxvevaSi sasamarTlom qmedeba unda daakvalificiros mi-Rebuli Sedegis mixedviT.
9. zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, msjavrdebuli l. m.da advokati t. k. iTxoven quTaisis saapelacio sasamar-Tlos 2016 wlis 9 martis ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setanas dal. m-is damnaSaved cnobas saqarTvelos ssk-is 117-e mux-liT.
6. mowmeebis: T. C-is, a. q-as, g. S-isa da g. x-as CvenebebiT,l. m-s xelSi eWira dana da urtyamda T. r-es, rasac arcTavad msjavrdebuli da misi advokati uaryofen. l. m-masaboloo sityvaSi ganmarta, rom igi T. r-es SemTxveviTSexvda; maT Soris moxda Selaparakeba, rac gadaizardaCxubSi, miiRo dazianebebi, gamwarda da dana gamoiyena mxo-lod T. r-is mosagerieblad, xolo rodesac mixvda, rom
133
danas iqnevda, TviTonve gadaagdo. mas T. r-is mkvlelobisganzraxva ar hqonia. dazaralebulis CvenebiT, igi l. m-sSexvda Sinagan saqmeTa xonis raionuli sammarTvelos win,sadac isini Selaparakdnen da l. m-ma daniani muSti mou-lodnelad daartya mas marjvena TvalSi. dartyma imde-nad Zlieri iyo, rom igi waiqca; man ver dainaxa, pirvelidartymis dros Tavdamsxmels dana eWira xelSi Tu saxrax-nisi; dana dainaxa policielebis misvlis Semdeg avtoman-qanis farebis minaTebisas, rodesac isini waqceulebi iy-vnen da l. m-s zeviT aweul marjvena xelSi eWira dana.
8. sakacio palata aRniSnavs, rom mocemul SemTxvevaSisadavoa Cadenili qmedebis kvalifikacia: anu l. m-is mierCadenili marTlsawinaaRmdego qmedeba warmoadgens gan-zrax mkvlelobis mcdelobas, Tu janmrTelobis ganzraxmZime dazianebas.
9. migvaCnia, rom zemoaRniSnuli ori samarTlebrivi mo-cemulobis gamijvnis dros, qmedebis kvalifikaciisas Sec-domis gamosaricxad sasamarTloebma zedmiwevniT deta-lurad unda Seiswavlon da gaaanalizon saqmeSi arsebuliyvela garemoeba, radgan gamosakveTia danaSaulis subieq-turi Semadgenlobis _ ganzraxvis elementi, romlis (anuganzraxvis) mimarTulebac ganasxvavebs ganzrax mkvlelo-bis mcdelobas janmrTelobis mZime dazianebisgan. gan-zraxvis dasadgenad ki Seswavlil unda iqnes: danaSaulisCadenis xerxi da saSualeba, dazianebaTa raodenoba, xasi-aTi da maTi lokalizacia, rogor viTarebaSi iqna isini mi-yenebuli, damnaSavisa da msxverplis urTierTdamokide-buleba saerTod da dazianebis miyenebis momentSi da sxv.
• rogorc dazaralebuli z. r. CvenebaSi miuTiTebs, po-liciis SenobaSi l. m-Tan pirveli Sexvedridan daaxloe-biT sami saaTis Semdeg, iqve, k-is quCaze, Sexvda l. m-s. da-zaralebulis Cvenebis Sinaarsidan ar ikveTeba l. m-is mxri-dan masTan winaswar dagegmilad Sexvedris mcdeloba (ma-galiTad is, rom l. m-ma z. r. dainaxa da amitom mivida mas-
134
Tan, rom igi dazaralebuls elodeboda SemTxvevis adgil-ze). sasamarTlo sxdomaze l. m-ma ganmarta, rom igi sru-liad SemTxveviT Sexvda dazaralebuls. sawinaaRmdegosdasadastureblad ki braldebis mxares sasamarTloSi ra-ime mtkicebuleba ar warudgenia. aRniSnulidan gamomdi-nare, maTi SemTxveviTi Sexvedris faqti sakasacio sasa-marTlosTvis dadgenilad miCneul samarTlebriv moce-mulobas warmoadgens.
• mowmeebis _ T. C-is, g. S-is, a. q-as, g. x-as, g. f-as sasa-marTloSi micemuli Cvenebebidan irkveva, rom l. m-sa daT. r-s Soris Cxubi grZeldeboda daaxloebiT 2-dan 5 wu-Tamde, xolo mowme r. T-s CvenebiT _ 5 wuTze met xans;dazaralebulma pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi dakiT-xvisas ganacxada, rom igi l. m-s winaaRmdegobas uwevda er-Ti xeliT, radgan, savaraudod, dacemisas miiRo marjvenamxris Zvlis motexiloba da faqtobrivad cali xeli para-lizebuli hqonda (ix. pirveli instanciis sxdomis oqmi).
13. Sesabamisad, sakasacio palatisaTvis ar aris sarwmu-no, rom mkvlelobis ganzraxviT Sepyrobil l. m-s waqceu-li da ukve janmrTelobis mZime dazianebamiyenebuli T.r-Tvis danis gamoyenebiT mxolod janmrTelobis msubu-qi ori dazianebis miyenebaRa moexerxebina.
14. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom zemomiTiTebulifaqtobrivi garemoebebis erToblioba gamoricxavs l. m-is mier T. r-is mkvlelobis mcdelobis ganzraxvas da mka-fiod miuTiTebs misTvis mxolod janmrTelobis mZime da-
136
zianebis miyenebis mizanze, kerZod: saqmis masalebiT ardadginda, rom l. m. dazaralebuls gangeb Sexvda ganzrax-vis (mkvlelobis) sisruleSi mosayvanad; aseve ar dadgin-da, rom pirveli fizikuri dapirispirebisas l. m-ma T. r-esdana mWreli piriT Caartya marjvena Tvalbudis areSi; l.m-Tvis ar arsebobda gansakuTrebuli motivi ganzraxmkvlelobis Casadenad _ dazaralebulis qcevaSi arsebob-da umniSvnelo sababi (mxedvelobaSi gvaqvs SemTxvevamdedaaxloebiT sami saaTiT adre policiis Senobidan T. r-ismier l. m-is gayvanis faqti, ra drosac maT erTmaneTisaT-vis sityvieri da fizikuri Seuracxyofa ar miuyenebiaT _iyo mxolod xmamaRali saubari), romelic normalur ada-mianur urTierTobaSi ver warmoSobda SurisZiebis grZno-bas. amasTan, sasamarTlos miaCnia, rom sanam policielebil. m-s ganaiaraRebdnen, mas hqonda sakmarisi dro da saSu-aleba mkvlelobis ganzraxvis sisruleSi mosayvanad.
15. sakasacio palata ganmartavs, rom mocemul SemTxve-vaSi, erTi SexedviT, TiTqos saqme gvaqvs SurisZiebasTan,magram sinamdvileSi saxezea umniSvnelo sababiT ganpiro-bebuli janmrTelobis mZime dazianebis motivi, rac samar-Tlebrivad unda Sefasdes rogorc xulignuri qvenagrZno-biT Cadenili qmedeba. msgavs SemTxvevebSi, dazaralebu-lisadmi samagieros mizRvisken damnaSavis swrafva arefuZneba raime angariSgasawev, seriozul safuZvels (ma-galiTad, dazaralebulis mxridan Seuracxyofas, andadamnaSavis an misi axloblis mimarT marTlsawinaaRmdegoZaladobasa Tu sxva ukanono qmedebas da a.S.), ris gamocmisi qmedebis subieqturi Sinaarsi, motivaciis Tvalsaz-risiT, Sesabamisad fasdeba xulignur qvenagrZnobad.
16. swored amgvari viTareba dgindeba saqmeSi arsebu-li utyuari mtkicebulebebis erTobliobidan gamomdina-re, pirvel rigSi ki TviT dazaralebulis CvenebiT, rome-lic gadmoscems maTi SemTxveviTi Sexvedrisas l. m-Tanmisi saubris Sinaarss, vidre es ukanaskneli mis winaaR-mdeg aqtiur moqmedebaze gadavidoda. msjavrdebulis mi-er am Sexvedrisas dazaralebulis mimarT gamoTqmuli pre-tenzia da dazaralebulis mier gacemuli pasuxis Sinaar-si, romelic sasamarTlos mier, rogorc faqtobrivi gare-moeba, sworad aris dadgenili utyuar mtkicebulebad miC-neuli dazaralebulis CvenebiT (l. m-is mier T. r-is mi-marT gamoTqmuli pretenzia: ratom ar SeuSves is polici-
137
aSi da ratom ar Seaxvedres is misi ubnis inspeqtors; T. r-is mier misTvis gacemuli pasuxi: xom uTxra mas, rom ar iyois pirovneba samsaxurSi, wasuliyo, Sars nu eZebda da po-liciaSi fxizeli misuliyo...) verafriT ver SefasdebaiseT, arsebiTi mniSvnelobis mqone faqtorad, rasac SeiZ-leba eyrdnobodes SurisZieba, rogorc motivi, romelsacbevrad ufro mniSvnelovani safuZveli sWirdeba. amitommcdari poziciaa, rom dazaralebulis nebismieri qceva anraime gamonaTqvami, ris gamoc, SesaZloa, damnaSave ganew-yos mis winaaRmdeg da mas dazaralebulis mimarT Camou-yalibdes samagieros mizRvis gancda da swrafva, samar-Tlebrivad yovelTvis Sefasdes rogorc SurisZiebis sa-fuZveli, xolo am niadagze aRmocenebuli damnaSavis Si-naganad mamoZravebeli, fsiqologiuri muxti ki, rogorcSurisZiebis motivi.
17. adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlo mtkice-bis standartad ganixilavs ra `gonivrul eWvs miRma stan-darts~, ganmartavs, rom aseTi mtkiceba SeiZleba gamom-dinareobdes sakmarisad Zlieri, naTeli da urTierTda-kavSirebuli daskvnebidan, romlebic udavo, sakmarisadmtkice da zust xasiaTs atarebs da ar SeiZleba efuZne-bodes mxolod Teoriul hipoTezas. iseTi danaSaulis Ca-denisaTvis, rogoricaa ganzraxi mkvleloba, aucilebelia,rom danaSaulis subieqti moqmedebdes ganzraxviT, Cai-dinos mkvleloba, rac unda efuZnebodes Sesabamis mizans,motivs, qmedebaSi gamovlenil marTlsawinaaRmdego nebas,qmedebis ganxorcielebis saxesa da xerxs. sasamarTlo ase-ve ganmartavs, rom qmedebis danaSaulad kvalifikaciisaT-vis savaldebuloa danaSaulis Semadgenlobis yvela niS-nis dasadastureblad pirdapiri mtkicebulebebis arse-boba; mocemul SemTxvevaSi saqmeze mopovebuli da gamok-vleuli mtkicebulebebis erTobliobiT ar dasturdebal. m-is mier mkvlelobis mcdelobis Cadenis faqti.
2. g. z-i, _ dabadebuli 19.. wels, _ cnobil iqna damnaSa-ved saqarTvelos ssk-is 137-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT da mie-saja 7 wliT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa, rac ssk-is 88-e mux-lis me-4 nawilis Tanaxmad, Seumcirda 1/4-iT da sabolo-od mas sasjelis zomad ganesazRvra 5 wliTa da 3 TviT Ta-visuflebis aRkveTa. g. z-s sasjelis moxda daewyo 2015wlis 3 ivlisidan.
3. saqmeze arsebuli nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: g. z-skuTvnili mobiluri telefoni, T. m-s kuTvnili mobiluritelefoni, T. m-sa da g. z-s kuTvnili tansacmeli unda da-ubrundes maT kanonier mflobelebs; nacxis nimuSi, sis-xlis, nerwyvisa da Tmis nimuSebi saqmeze saboloo gadaw-yvetilebis miRebis Semdeg unda ganadgurdes.
4. ganaCeniT msjavrdebul g. z-s mier Cadenili danaSa-
140
uli gamoixata SemdegSi: 2015 wlis 2 ivliss qalaq ..., ... sta-dionTan arsebul fiWvnarSi, e.w. `...~ ... mimdebare terito-riaze, g. z-m ZaladobiTa da Zaladobis muqariT daamyarasqesobrivi kavSiri T. m-Tan.
6. g. z-i cnobil iqna damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is 137-e muxlis 1-li nawiliT da miesaja 7 wliT TavisuflebisaRkveTa. arasrulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebis kodeqsis73-e muxlis me-3 nawilis Sesabamisad, daniSnuli sasjeliSeumcirda 1/4-iT da sabolood g. z-s sasjelis zomad ga-nesazRvra 5 wliTa da 3 TviT Tavisuflebis aRkveTa. massasjelis moxda daewyo 2015 wlis 3 ivlisidan.
7. saqmeze arsebuli nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: g. z-skuTvnili mobiluri telefoni, T. m-s kuTvnili mobiluritelefoni, T. m-sa da g. z-s kuTvnili tansacmeli unda da-ubrundes maT kanonier mflobelebs; nacxis nimuSi, sis-xlis, nerwyvisa da Tmis nimuSebi saqmeze saboloo gadaw-yvetilebis miRebis Semdeg unda ganadgurdes.
8. Telavis raionuli prokuraturis prokurori qeTe-van vaSakiZe sakasacio saCivriT iTxovs Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2016wlis 28 aprilis ganaCenSi cvlilebis Setanas im mimarTe-biT, rom g. z-i cnobil iqnes damnaSaved saqarTvelos ssk-is 137-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `d~ qvepunqtiT da ganesaz-Rvros kanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli sasjeli.
9. kasatoris mosazrebiT, gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni dau-sabuTebelia; saqmis arsebiTi ganxilvis dros gamokvleu-li mtkicebulebebiT gonivrul eWvs miRma dasturdeba,rom g. z-m Caidina T. m-s gaupatiureba; sasamarTlom ar ga-iziara mxolod is faqti, rom g. z-m icoda T. m-s asaki.
10. winaswari SecnobiT arasrulwlovnebis damadastu-rebeli yvela garemoeba mocemul saqmeSi gamomdinareobsmtkicebulebebidan da mtkicebulebaTa erToblivi ana-lizidan. arcerTi mtkicebuleba, rac daadasturebda, romg. z-saTvis ar iyo cnobili T. m-s arasrulwlovaneba, sasa-marTloSi warmodgenili ar yofila.
141
11. sasamarTlo kvalifikaciis Secvlisas daeyrdnomxolod braldebulis Cvenebas, romelmac aCvena, rom aricoda T. m-s asaki. ganaCeniT ki gonivrul eWvs miRma stan-dartiT dadasturda, rom g. z-m gaaupatiura T. m-i, xoloCvenebis micemisas igi cruobda.
12. msjavrdebul g. z-s interesebis damcveli advoka-tebi _ d. a-i da f-n s-i sakasacio saCivriT iTxoven Tbili-sis saapelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTapalatis 2016 wlis 28 aprilis ganaCenis gauqmebasa da g. z-s udanaSaulod cnobas misi braleulobis damadasture-beli utyuari mtkicebulebebis saqmeSi ararsebobis dasaqmis ganxilvisas daSvebuli saproceso kanonis moTxov-nebis arsebiTi darRvevebis gamo.
13. kasatorebi saCivarSi miuTiTeben, rom Telavis rai-onulma sasamarTlom saqme ganixila sisxlis samarTlissaproceso kodeqsis normebiT da ar ixelmZRvanela aras-rulwlovanTa marTlmsajulebis kodeqsis debulebebiT,romelic ZalaSi iyo 2016 wlis 1 ianvridan da amoqmeddaganaCenis dadgomamde 1 TviTa da 12 dRiT adre, rac war-moadgens darRvevas.
15. sasamarTlom wardgenili braldeba gadaakvalifi-cira mZime kategoriis danaSaulze da ar ganixila ganri-debis ganxilvis SesaZlebloba.
16. sasamarTlom miiCnia, rom g. z-s hqonda Savtarianidana da emuqreboda T. m-s, riTac dgindeba Zaladobis faq-ti. kasatorebis mosazrebiT, aRniSnuli argumentaciis sa-winaaRmdegod moqmedebs g. z-s binis Cxrekisa da dakave-bis oqmi.
17. ganaCens safuZvlad daedo is garemoeba, rom g. z-ssxeulze gaaCnda nakawrebi, xolo T. m-s awyvetili hqondasaqamre da gaaCnda sisxlnaJRenTebi mkerdsa da yelTan,rac Zaladobaze miuTiTebs. kasatorebis mosazrebiT, g.z-i iyo TavisuflebaSi dakavebamde da misi da aseve misimegobris CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom g. z-m iWidava mego-barTan da es nakawrebi am dros iyo SeZenili.
18. sasamarTlom ganaCenSi miuTiTa, rom Zaladoba ga-
142
moixata g. z-s mier T. m-s tyeSi ZaliT SeyvanaSi, rac, kasa-torebis mosazrebiT, ar Seesabameba saqmeSi arsebul mtki-cebulebebs. dazaralebuli T. m-i bevr SemTxvevaSi tyui-liT malavs simarTles, igi Tavis CvenebebSi gamoricxavssakuTar braleulobas da Zaladobaze miuTiTebs Tavis ga-samarTleblad.
19. sasamarTlom ar gaiTvaliswina satelefono kontaq-ti dazaralebulsa da kanonTan konfliqtSi myof pirs So-ris sqesobrivi kontaqtis Semdegac. ganaCenSi saerTod araris msjeloba imis Taobaze, rom T. m-ma sqesobrivi kon-taqtis damalvis mizniT saswrafod garecxa tansacmelida trusi, ramac ganapiroba is, rom arcerTi saxis biolo-giuri kavSiri g. z-s da T. m-s Soris ar dadasturda.
20. saqmeSi arsebuli Cvenebebi ewinaaRmdegeba saapela-cio sasamarTlos im dasabuTebas, rom g. z-s mxridan adgi-li hqonda T. m-e Zaladobas.
21. kasatorebis mosazrebiT, g. z-s mxridan Tundac ne-bayoflobiTi sqesobrivi kontaqti dazaralebul T. m-Tanar dgindeba arcerTi mtkicebulebiT, Sesabamisad saape-lacio sasamarTlom arasworad daadgina, rom rom g. z-sfizikuri kontaqti hqonda T. m-Tan; g. z-s aRiareba neba-yoflobiTi kontaqtis Sesaxeb gamowveuli iyo misi daSi-nebiTa da saproceso SeTanxmebis surviliT. is faqti, romswored g. z-s mxridan moxda T. m-s saqalwule apkis dar-Rveva ar dgindeba da saeWvoa, vinaidan T. m-s mobiluritelefonis daTvalierebis Sedegad amoRebuli Setyobi-nebebiT dgindeba, rom mas sasiyvarulo mimowerebi hqon-da paralelurad sxva pirebTan. mimowerebs Soris gansxva-veba zogan aris wamebi da amdenad advilad SesaZlebeliaT. m-s sxvam daurRvia saqalwule apkis mTlianoba. aRniS-nul arguments amyarebs biologiuri eqspertizis das-kvnebi, ar aRmoCnda urTierTgardamavali boWkoebi, g. z-sspermis kvali, ar arsebobs mowme, romelic maTi kavSirisTviTmxilvelia, ar arsebobs biologiuri masala, rac kav-SirSi iqneba g. z-Tan. amgvarad ar arsebobs mxareTa Sorissqesobrivi kontaqtis mtkicebuleba kanonTan konfliq-tSi myofi arasrulwlovnis Cvenebis garda, romelic mi-Rebul iqna kanonis arsebiTi darRveviT da aseT mtkice-bulebebs Zala ar gaaCnia.
xila saqmis masalebi, mxari dauWira warmodgenili sakasa-cio saCivris moTxovnas da iSuamdgomla misi dakmayofi-leba.
23. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze kanonTan konfliqtSimyofi msjavrdebulis _ g. z-s interesebis damcvelma ad-vokatebma _ d. a-m da f. s-m vrclad mimoixiles saqmis masa-lebi da iSuamdgomles maT mier warmodgenili sakasaciosaCivris moTxovnis dakmayofileba, rasac mxari dauWiresmsjavrdebulma g. z-m da misma kanonierma warmomadgenel-ma _ x. z-m.
24. sakasacio palatis sxdomaze dazaralebul T. m-s in-teresebis damcvelma, advokatma g. f-m mxari dauWira Te-lavis raionuli prokuraturis prokuror qeTevan vaSaki-Zis mier warmodgenili sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas daiSuamdgomla misi dakmayofileba, rasac daeTanxmnen da-zaralebuli T. m-i da misi kanonieri warmomadgeneli a. m-i.
ma sakasacio saCivrebis safuZvlianoba da mivida im das-kvnamde, rom Telavis raionuli prokuraturis prokurorqeTevan vaSakiZisa da msjavrdebul g. z-s interesebis dam-cveli advokatebis _ d. a-sa da f. s-s sakasacio saCivrebiar unda dakmayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata kasatorTa moTxovnas msjavrdebulg. z-s udanaSaulod cnobisa da misi gamarTlebis Taobazear eTanxmeba, radgan warmodgenil saqmis masalebSi saami-sod ar moipoveba kanonieri da dasabuTebuli safuZveli.amasTan, 1-li instanciisa da saapelacio sasamarTloebismier mis mimarT gamotanil gamamtyunebel ganaCenebSi Ca-moyalibebuli daskvnebi inkriminirebul qmedebebSi misibraleulobis Taobaze savsebiT akmayofilebs gonivruleWvs miRma standartiT gaTvaliswinebul kriteriumebs,rasac adasturebs saqmeSi arsebuli, kanonieri gziT mo-povebuli, utyuari da sakmarisi mtkicebulebebis erTob-lioba.
3. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom msjavrdebul g. z-shqonda sqesobrivi kavSiri dazaralebul T. m-Tan, rasacadasturebs 1-li instanciis sasamarTloSi saqmis arsebi-Ti ganxilvisas rogorc dazaralebul T. m-s, aseve TviTmsjavrdebul g. z-s mier micemuli Cvenebebi. aRsaniSnavia
144
Semdegi garemoebac: is faqti, rom arasrulwlovan daza-ralebulsa da aseve arasrulwlovan msjavrdebuls Sorisnamdvilad moxda sqesobrivi kavSiri, dacvis mxares ar ga-uxdia sadavod arc saapelacio saCivriT.
4. aRniSnuli mtkicebulebebi warmoadgenen pirdapirCvenebebs, romelTa sarwmunooba dasturdeba sisxlis sa-marTlis saproceso kanonis moTxovnaTa dacviT saqmezemopovebuli sxva mtkicebulebebiTac, kerZod, mxedvelo-baSia saqmeze Catarebuli sasamarTlo-samedicino eqser-tizis safuZvelze gacemuli daskvna, eqspert e. C-s Cve-neba, dazaralebulis dedis, mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli T. m-s Cveneba da mowme o. s-s Cveneba. samedicino eqspertizis#... daskvniTa da eqspert e. C-s Cvenebis Tanaxmad, T. m-ssaqalwule apkis mTlianoba darRveulia _ ar aris mTeli,ganviTarebulia raime mkvrivi blagvi sagnis (SesaZlebe-lia mamakacis eregirebuli sasqeso asos) moqmedebiT. misidarRvevis xandazmuloba ar ewinaaRmdegeba saqmis gare-moebaSi miTiTebul TariRs _ 02.07.2015 w.
5. mowme T. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 2ivliss, rodesac is samxaxurSi imyofeboda, misma Svilma _T. m-m mobiluri telefoniT gaugzavna Setyobineba, rom13.00 saaTidan naxevari saaTiT gadioda saxlidan amxanag-Tan Sesaxvedrad. daaxloebiT 15.00 saaTze daureka T-s dahkiTxa sad imyofeboda im momentisaTvis, T. im droisTvisukve saxlSi iyo. rodesac T-s esaubra telefonze, masaRelvebuli xma hqonda da hkiTxa saxlSi hqondaT Tu ara`safenebi~, radgan hqonda sisxldena, razedac upasuxa,rom ar hqondaT, Tan aseve gaukvirda, radgan mas sami dRisukan daumTavrda menstruaciuli cikli. TviTon saxlSisaRamos cxris naxevridan cxra saaTamde dabrunda, T. dax-vda quCaSi, moefera mas, ra drosac SeamCnia, rom yelzehqonda ori didi Savi laqa, lurji sisxlCaqceva. T. da Tvi-Ton saxlSi roca Sediodnen, man dainaxa, rom T. uknidaniyo sisxliani da Zalian SeSinebuli. mowmis CvenebiT, T.cudad gaxda, guli misdioda, ris gamoc gamoiZaxa samedi-cino saswrafo daxmareba da is gadaiyvanes saavadmyofo-Si, sadac mas gaukeTda operacia. aRniSnulis gamo saavad-myofoSi policiis TanamSromlebis gamocxadebis SemdegmisTvis cnobili gaxda, rom im periodSi, rodesac T. sax-lidan gavida, igi Sexvda msjavrdebul g. z-s, romelTa So-ris moxda sqesobrivi urTierToba, T-s gancxadebis mixed-
145
viT, msjavrdebulis mxridan mis mimarT Zaladobis gamo-yenebiT.
6. msjavrdebul g. z-s megobris _ mowme o. s-s CvenebiTdadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 2 ivliss, daaxloebiT ori saa-Tisaken g. z-i mivida masTan da uTxra, rom Sexvda T-s damaT Soris iyo intimuri urTierToba T. m-s nebiT.
7. sakasacio palata iziarebs da eTanxmeba saapelaciosasamarTlos daskvnas, rom 2015 wlis 2 ivliss qalaq ..., ...stadionTan arsebul fiWvnarSi, e.w. `...~ ... mimdebare teri-toriaze, g. z-m ZaladobiTa da Zaladobis muqariT daamya-ra sqesobrivi kavSiri T. m-Tan, ras aseve dasturdeba saq-meSi arsebuli sarwmuno mtkicebulebebiT.
8. arasrulwlovani mowmis saxiT dakiTxuli dazarale-bul T. m-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 2 ivlissmas dilis 10 saaTze g-m miwera da moikiTxa. Semdeg 12 saa-TisTvis miwera, rom masTan Sexvedra surda, igi daTanxmdaSexvedraze da SeTanxmdnen, rom ... stadionze, ... Sexvde-bodnen erTmaneTs. Sexvedris adgili misi saxlidan 5-10wuTis savalze iyo. misi iq misvlidan daaxloebiT or wuT-Si g-c mivida, hkiTxa rom iyo Tu ara is T., dasxdnen ... kibe-ze da saubrobdnen. Semdeg g-m mas uTxra, rom iq xalxi moZ-raobda, ver ilaparakebdnen da sadme mofarebul adgilasgasuliyvnen. isic daTanxmda da Sevidnen stadionze, e.w.`...~. dazaralebulis CvenebiT, g-m mas uTxra, rom moswon-da da `cota raRacnairad uyurebda~, ris gamoc Tavi uxer-xulad igrZno da iqidan gamovida, TviTon Cqari nabijiTmidioda, isev kibeebisken fiqrobda wasvlas, radgan ga-reT xalxic moZraobda da aRar SeeSindeboda. g-m mas ma-jaSi waavlo xeli da tyeSi SeaTria, igi yviroda, magram imdros iq aravin moZraobda. maT gaiares didi manZili, rommiixed-moixeda garSemo iyo bardebi, man dainaxa, rom g-sjibeSi edo Savtariani dana. gaCerdnen, g-m mas ubiZga, romdamjdariyo, winaaRmdegobas uwevda, magram g-m mxrebzedaado xeli da ZaliT dasva. man aseve aCvena, rom dana iyoSavi, dasakeci, daaxloebiT 5-6 sm, riTac g. mas aSinebda. immomentSi Zalian SeSinebuli iyo. rodesac g-m ZaliT dasvaZirs, im dros amoiRo dana, dana gaxsnili iyo. g-m daiCoqa,erTi xeliT Sarvals ixsnida, meore xelSi dana eWira daTviTon rac Zali da Rone hqonda fexebs uWerda, rom argaexsna. mas Savi jinsi, ketebi da muqi lurji maisuri ecva.mis maisurs alublebi axatia, jinsi Savi feris iyo. g-s jinsi
146
ecva, romelic muxlebze iyo odnav yavisferi da mokleSavi maisuri, aseve exata yavisfrad raRac. fexze Savi kla-sikuri fexsacmeli ecva. misi CvenebiT, roca g-m TviTongaixsna Sarvali da qamari, Semdeg ukve cdilobda rom mis-Tvisac Sarvali gaexsna. igi cdilobda, rom g-sTvis amissaSualeba ar mieca, magram mainc gauxsna. erT fexze gaxa-da kedi da Sarvali, rodesac sacvals xdida, igi winaaR-mdegobas uwevda, magram amaod. g. mas maRlidan daawva, misSarvals hqonda sami Rili, g-m jer xeli gaaSvebina, radganim momentSi rac SeeZlo Cqmetda da fxaWnida g-s. misi gan-martebiT, mis Sarvals sanam Caicmevda diliT aranairi da-zianeba ar hqonia. amis Semdeg ki saqamreebi hqonda agle-jili, TviTon saerTod ar xmarobs qamars. misi CvenebiT,saqamre jajguris dros awyda. mas aseve ecva Savi biushal-teri, wvrili, TeTri koplebiT. ecva wiTeli trusi, ro-melsac hqonda Savi sartyeli da TeTri koplebi. g-s nac-risferi trusi ecva, SavSi gawyobili. g-m Sarvali gaixada,Semdeg maRlidan daawva, maisuri auwia mkerdamde, cdi-lobda g-s gaeSva xeli, zurgze xelebs urtyamda, tiroda.g-m uTxra, rom tirils aranairi azri ar hqonda. Semdeg mandainaxa rom mis marcxena fexTan ido g-s dana da cdilob-da mis aRebas, g-m SeamCnia, rom iRebda, yelTan axlos miu-tana da uTxra, Tu rames gaakeTeb aqve gamogasalmeb si-cocxles, ar dagindobo. g-s mxridan sqesobrivi aqtisdros igi grZnobda saSinel tkivils, umatebda tirils dakioda, es daaxloebiT xuTi wuTi gagrZelda. mas am drostelefoni Sarvlis jibeSi edo da ar hqonda SesaZleblo-ba, rom sadme daereka. g. rom morCa masTan sqesobrivi kav-Siris damyarebas, man Tavis Sarvals daxeda da is mTlia-nad sisxliani iyo, aseve dasvrili iyo misi trusic. Semdegadga, dasustebuli iyo, Caicva, balaxze SeamCnia sisxli.misive Cvenebis Tanaxmad, amis Semdeg g-m dana amoiRo dauTxra, rom Tu vinmesTan rames ityoda misi povna ar gau-Wirdeboda. sqesobrivi aqtis dros g. zemodan ewva da Tvi-Ton saxe zecisken hqonda, g-s Sarvali muxlebamde hqon-da gaxdili. mas calfexze hqonda mxolod gaxdili. amisgarda mas dazianeba hqonda miRebuli xelebze, sadac hqon-da nafxaWnebi da yelze orive mxares hqonda silurjeebi,mkerdTan hqonda gakawruli. is g-s zurgze fxaWnida daCqmetda. jer g. wavida, saiT ar icis, Semdeg TviTon sax-lSi dabrunda. mis saxlSi aravin ar imyofeboda. misi Sar-
ladobis faqti dadasturebulia agreTve saqmeSi arsebu-li sxva mtkicebulebebiTac: 2015 wlis 3 ivlisis sagamoZi-ebo eqsperimentis oqmis SinaarsiT, romelSic SetaniliaCvenebis adgilze Semowmebisas dazaralebul T. m-s miergamoZiebisaTvis micemuli Cveneba, romelSic is adastu-rebs SemTxvevis adgilze mis mimarT g. z-s mier fizikuriZaladobiTa da danis gamoyenebis muqariT masTan iZule-biTi sqesobrivi kavSiris faqts, ra drosac is detaluradmiuTiTebs rodis, ra adgilze da ra viTarebaSi moxda yo-velive zemoaRniSnuli.
10. samedicino eqspertizis #…..daskvniTa da eqsperte. C-s CvenebiT dadgenilia agreTve, rom T. m-s sxeulzeaReniSneboda dazianebebi sisxlnaJRenTebisa da erTi na-kawris saxiT. nakawri ganviTarebuli unda iyos raime max-vili sagnis wvetis, lesili kidis an mkveTrad gamoxatulikidis mqone mkvrivi-blagvi sagnis Semxebi zemoqmedebisSedegad. sisxlnaJRenTebi ganviTarebulia raime mkvrivi-blagvi sagnis moqmedebiT da yvela dazianeba cal-calkeda erTad aRebuli miekuTvnebian sxeulis dazianebaTamsubuq xarisxs, janmrTelobis mouSlelad. xandazmulo-biT, arsebuli dazianebebis ganviTareba ar ewinaaRmdege-ba saqmis garemoebaSi miTiTebul TariRs. T. m-s sxeulzearsebuli dazianebebi naCxvleti Wrilobebis saxiT ir-gvliv sisxlnaJRenTebiT da saSos kedelze arsebuli 1kv.nakeris saxiT, warmoadgenen samedicino manipulaciiskvals.
11. kanonTan konfliqtSi myofi g. z-s mier arasrul-wlovan dazaralebul T. m-s mimarT ganxorcilebuli fi-zikuri Zaladobis faqti dadasturebulia trasologiu-ri eqspertizis #... daskvniT, romlis mixedviT, eqsper-tizaze wardgenil T. m-s jinsis Sarvlis zedapirze arse-buli dazianebebi salteebis amoglejisa da nakeris ganar-Rvevis saxiT warmoqmnilia fizikuri Zalis zemoqmedebisSedegad.
12. arasrulwlovan dazaralebul T. m-s Cveneba im na-wilSi, rom is uwevda aqtiur winaaRmdegobas g. z-s masTanZaladobrivi sqesobrivi kavSiris damyarebisas, aseve da-dasturebulia samedicino eqspertis #... daskvniTa da amdaskvnis gamcemi eqspertis _ g. k-s CvenebiT, romlis Ta-
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida daskvnam-de, rom msjavrdebul l. m-s sakasacio saCivari unda dak-mayofildes Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. palatas miaCnia, rom warmodgenilia sakmarisi da ut-yuari mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTac gonivrul eWvs miRmadasturdeba msjavrdebul l. m-s mier qurdobis Cadenisfaqti, rasac arc kasatori xdis sadavod, kerZod:
3. garda Tavad l. m-s aRiarebiTi Cvenebisa, msjavrde-bulis mier danaSaulis Cadena dadasturebulia saqmeSiarsebuli utyuari mtkicebulebebis erTobliobiT: mow-meebis _ S. j-s, v. n-s, d. g-s, l. l-s, i. c-s, T. c-s, g. m-sa da n.f-s CvenebebiT, SemTxvevis adgilis daTvalierebisa da sa-gamoZiebo eqsperimentis oqmebiT.
4. zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebebis Sefasebis Sedegadsakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom l. m-ma Caidina qurdoba sa-cavSi ukanono SeRweviT. amasTan, palata ar eTanxmeba saa-pelacio sasamarTlos l. m-s qmedebis saqarTvelos ssk-is177-e muxlis me-4 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT dakvalificire-bis nawilSi Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
6. sakasacio palata, pirvel rigSi, eTanxmeba saapela-cio palatas, rom man marTebulad ar gaiziara mowme m. T-smier sasamarTlo sxdomaze micemuli urTierTsawinaaR-mdego Cveneba. braldebis mxaris mosazrebiT, saapelaciosasamarTlos unda gaeziarebina mowme m. T-s Cvenebis mxo-lod is nawili, romelSic igi uTiTebs, Tu rogor CaidineserToblivad danaSauli _ man, S. k-m, r. g-m da g. g-m, im sa-fuZvliT, rom dacvis mxarem _ braldebulebma dakiTxvisdros masze ganaxorcieles fsiqologiuri zewola, ris ga-moc mowme iZulebuli gaxda, Cveneba Seecvala. sakasaciopalata miuTiTebs, rom braldebis mxaris argumenti ar Se-esabameba realobas. dacvis mxaris mier kiTxvebis dasmisprocesSi m-m ikiTxa, SeiZleboda Tu ara Cvenebis Secvlada mas Semdeg, rac mosamarTlem ganumarta is samarTleb-rivi Sedegebi (saqarTvelos ssk-is 3711-e muxliT mosalod-neli pasuxismgeblobis Sesaxeb), romelic SesaZloa, moh-yoloda mis mier arsebiTad urTierTsawinaaRmdego Cve-nebis micemas, miuxedavad amisa, yovelgvari zewolis ga-reSe, arsebiTad Secvala Cveneba, kerZod: m. T-m Tavdapir-velad daadastura oTxive maTgans Soris winaswari SeTan-xmebis arseboba, Tumca Semdeg uaryo aRniSnuli da gan-marta, rom ar icis, Tu vin Seitana saTamaSo aparati sas-tumros oTaxSi. rodesac gaiRviZa, aparati daxvda iq. aR-niSnuli ki m. T-s Cvenebas ukargavs sandoobasa da damaje-reblobas, ver akmayofilebs utyuarobis standarts, risgamoc sakasacio palata, mas aseve ar iziarebs.
7. saxelmwifo bralmdebeli S. k-s, r. g-sa da g. g-s mierwinaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier qurdobis Cadenas, gar-da mowme m. T-s Cvenebisa, aseve dadasturebulad miiCnevssastumros saTvalTvalo kameris videoCanaweris, daza-ralebul g. T-sa da mowme k. T-s Cvenebebis safuZvelze,romelTa Tanaxmad, misi mosazrebiT, utyuarad dastur-deba, rom 2015 wlis 29 aprils S. k-i, r. g-e, g. g-e da m. T-iimyofebodnen sastumro `...~ da winaswari SeTanxmebiTa darolebis ganawilebiT jer farulad daeuflnen `iqsboq-sis~ aparats, ris Semdegac S. k-m da m. T-m is 110 larad gaas-xvises maTTvis ucnob pirze, xolo aRebuli Tanxa S. k-m, m.
170
T-m, g. g-m da r. g-m erToblivad daxarjes.8. saqarTvelos ssk-is 27-e muxlis me-2 nawilis Tanax-
mad, danaSauli winaswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mieraa Ca-denili, Tu mis ganxorcielebaSi monawileni winaswar Se-kavSirdnen danaSaulis erToblivad Casadenad.
9. sakasacio palatis mier ganmartebulia (618ap-15, mo-samarTleebi: g. SavliaSvili, n. gvenetaZe, p. silagaZe), romwinaswar SekavSirebaSi ar igulisxmeba danaSaulebriv qme-debamde drois xangrZlivi monakveTis arseboba; mTavaria,rom SeTanxmeba moxdes danaSaulis obieqturi Semadgen-lobis ganxorcielebis dawyebis momentamde. amasTan, au-cilebelia saqmeSi arsebobdes Sesabamisi mtkicebulebe-bi, romlebic miuTiTebs aseTi SeTanxmebis arsebobaze,rac SesaZlebelia, jgufis wevrebs Soris rogorc sityvi-er _ werilobiT, ise araverbalur komunikaciaSic _ Jes-tebsa da mimikebSi _ gamoixatos.
10. mocemul SemTxvevaSi dazaralebul g. T-sa da mowmek. T-s CvenebebiT dadgenilia, rom isini ar arian momxdarifaqtis TviTmxilvelebi da saTamaSo aparatis qurdobisepizodTan dakavSirebiT gadmoscemen im informacias, racixiles sastumros kameris videoCanawerSi, kerZod: kadrSiCans, Tu rogor iRebs r. g-e sastumros holidan `iqsboqsis~aparats da Seaqvs oTaxSi. garda amisa, maTi varaudiT, saTa-maSo aparati sastumrodan gaitana m. T-m, radgan mas Seno-bidan gasvlisas, g. T-s ganmartebiT, xelSi eWira CanTa, xo-lo k. T-s (uSualod Seeswro m. T-s mier sastumros datove-bis moments) ganmartebiT _ tansacmeli (maisuri), romel-Sic, maTi azriT, m. T-s damaluli eqneboda saTamaSo apara-ti, Tumca danamdvilebiT ar ician. amdenad, maTi Cvenebe-biT ar dasturdeba arc aRniSnul pirebs Soris winaswariSekavSirebis faqti da arc is, rom saTamaSo aparati sastum-rodan gaitana swored m. T-m da igi warmoadgens mxolodbraldebis mxaris varauds; rac Seexeba gamokvleul vide-oCanawers, masze ar Cans S. k-s, r. g-s, g. g-sa da m. T-s Sorisraime iseTi tipis komunikacia, an moqmedeba, rac palatassaSualebas miscemda, gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT er-wmuna maT Soris winaswari SeTanxmebis arseboba. mxolod isfaqti, rom 2015 wlis 29 aprils _ 09:12:04 saaTidan 09:18:22saaTis intervalSi _ videoCanawerze sxvadasxva dros Ca-nan _ S. k-i, r. g-e, g. g-e da m. T-i, ar miuTiTebs maT Sorisraime danaSaulebrivi kavSiris arsebobaze, razedac bral-
171
debis mxare usafuZvlod apelirebs. aseve, yovelgvar sa-fuZvels moklebulia braldebis mxaris argumenti imis Ta-obaze, rom maTi mxridan sxvisi nivTis dauflebis ganzrax-vis arsebobaze miuTiTebs is garemoebac, rom maTi wasvlisSemdeg, dalagebisas, sastumros nomerSi arsebuli tele-vizori aRmoCnda ukuRma dakidebuli, rac mianiSnebs maTmier televizoris dauflebis ganzraxvazec. sxva raime ut-yuari mtkicebuleba, romelic daadasturebda winaswari Se-TanxmebiT jgufis mier saTamaSo aparatis qurdobis faqts,braldebis mxares ar warmoudgenia.
11. garda aRniSnulisa, sakasacio palata aseve yurad-Rebas miapyrobs im garemoebaze, rom saqmis masalebiT araris dadgenili araTu is faqti, konkretulad romelmamaTganma gaitana sastumrodan `iqsboqsis~ aparati, aramedsaerTod gaurkvevelia, ra bedi ewia mas r. g-s mier oTaxSiSetanis Semdeg. mxolod dazaralebul g. T-sa da mowme k.T-s varaudi, rom sastumrodan gasvlisas m. T-s xelSi eWi-ra raRac nivTi da SesaZlebelia, swored is yofiliyo sa-TamaSo aparati, ar SeiZleba CaiTvalos utyuar mtkicebu-lebad da safuZvlad daedos gamamtyunebel ganaCens.
12. sayuradReboa aseve is garemoebac, rom, rogorc ze-moT ukve aRiniSna, dazaralebuli g. T-e da mowme k. T-e ararian mocemuli SemTxvevis TviTmxilvelebi da maTTvissaTamaSo aparatis dakargvis faqti cnobili gaxda winas-wari gamoZiebis mier r. g-s, S. k-sa da g. g-Tvis bralad Se-racxuli qmedebis Cadenis dRidan mxolod meoTxe-mexu-Te dRes. amdenad, mTeli am drois ganmavlobaSi rogorc g.T-s, aseve k. T-Tvis ucnobia saTamaSo aparatis bedi, sadiyo is _ sastumros romelime nomerSi, holSi Tu saerTod,daikarga. k. T-s CvenebiT, rom sastumrodan yoveli stum-ris gasvlis Semdeg piradad amowmebs, xolo damlagebelialagebs oTaxs, utyuarad ar dasturdeba is faqti, romaparati daikarga 2015 wlis 29 aprils, swored mas Semdeg,rac sastumros Senoba datoves S. k-m, r. g-m, g. g-m da m. T-m.amasTan, gamoZieba ar dainteresebula da ar gamouTxoviainformacia, am drois ganmavlobaSi isargebla Tu ara sxvadamsvenebelma sastumros im oTaxiT, romelSic ganTavse-buli iyvnen braldebulebi.
13. amdenad, sasamarTloSi warmodgenil mtkicebule-baTa gaanalizebisa da urTierTSejerebis safuZvelze, sa-kasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlos das-
172
kvnebs da miaCnia, rom zemoaRniSnuli garemoebebi saer-Tod gamoricxavs S. k-sa da g. g-s mxridan saTamaSo apara-tis qurdobis nawilSi marTlsawinaaRmdego da braleuliqmedebebis Cadenas da ar dasturdeba maT mier saqarTve-los sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 177-e muxlis me-2 nawi-lis `a~ da amave muxlis me-3 nawilis `a~ qvepunqtebiT gaT-valiswinebuli danaSaulebis Cadena. rac Seexeba S. k-TvissaqarTvelos ssk-is 185-e muxlis pirveli nawiliTa da ssk-is 2381-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT msjavrad Seracxul qme-debebs, sakasacio palata mas mTlianad dadasturebuladda safuZvlianad miiCnevs, saqmis faqtobrivi garemoebe-bidan da am garemoebaTa Taobaze saqmeSi arsebuli mtki-cebulebebidan gamomdinare. amasTan, sakasacio palata ariziarebs rogorc braldebis mxaris, aseve saapelacio sa-samarTlos samarTlebriv Sefasebas r. g-s mier CadenilqmedebasTan dakavSirebiT, Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2 ix. El Masri v The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia #39630/09,adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos 2012 wlis 13dekembris gadawyvetileba da Hassan v The UK #29750/09, adamianisuflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos 2014 wlis 16 seqtembrisgadawyvetileba.
nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: SemTxvevis adgilidan amo-Rebuli xelis kvlebi unda ganadgurdes, xolo mowme z. S-s mier warmodgenili muzeumis eqsponatebi unda daubrun-des muzeums.
4. ganaCeni saapelacio wesiT gaasaCivra Zveli Tbilisisraionuli prokuraturis prokurorma ana metrevelma, ro-melmac moiTxova msjavrdebul d. k-s damnaSaved cnobasaqarTvelos ssk-is 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ da me-4nawilis `b~ qvepunqtebiT gaTvaliswinebuli danaSaulisCadenaSi.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom Zveli Tbilisis raionuli prokuraturis proku-ror ana metrevelis sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayo-fildes, xolo gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvle-lad Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata ar iziarebs braldebis mxaris mierwarmodgenili sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas, msjavrde-bul d. k-s saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis kodeqsis 177-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ da me-4 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtebiTdamnaSaved cnobis Taobaze da eTanxmeba saapelacio sasa-marTlos msjelobas, rom saqmeSi arsebul, erTmaneTTanSeTanxmebul, eWvis gamomricxav da urTierTSejerebulmtkicebulebaTa erTobliobiT dasturdeba d. k-s mierqurdobis Cadenis faqti. amasTan, braldebis mxarem verwarmoadgina utyuar da sakmaris mtkicebulebaTa erTob-lioba, rac gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiT daadastu-rebda mis mier qurdobis Cadenas makvalificirebeli niS-nebiT _ sacavSi ukanono SeRweviTa da didi odenobiT, Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
3. saqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiTxul, dazaralebul n. o-sCvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs q. TbilisSi, ... #...-Simdebare ... muzeumis direqtoris Tanamdebobaze. muzeumiSedgeba ori Senobisagan, erTi maTgani aris centraluri,romlis me-3 sarTulze ganTavsebulia muzeumis eqspona-tebis (fondis) ZiriTadi nawili, xolo meore ki warmoad-gens calke Senobas, romelSic ganTavsebulia muzeumis sa-rezervo eqsponatebi (fondi). muzeumi ar funqcionirebs,orive Senoba aris meriis balansze da icavs dacvis samsa-xuri. muzeumis yvela gasaRebi inaxeba dacvis samsaxurSida mas gasaRebebTan aranairi Sexeba ar aqvs. erT-erT sa-cavSi Sesvlisas aRmoaCina, rom yuTebi, romlebSic inaxe-boda samuzeumo eqsponatebi, amotrialebuli da TiTqmisyvela maTgani gaxsnili iyo. rogorc Semdeg gairkva, muze-umidan daikarga araerTi Zvirfasi nivTi, romelTa saer-To Rirebulebam Seadgina `sadRac~ _ 20 000 aSS dolari,ris Sesaxebac ganacxada policiaSi. is TviTonac cdilob-
179
da dakarguli eqsponatebis aRmoCenas. amitom dadioda imadgilebSi, sadac iyideboda msgavsi nivTebi, ra drosac,e.w. `...~ gavlisas, aRmoaCina erT-erTi ... momZvrali deta-li, aseve sxva eqsponatebis nawilic. gamyidvelisagan Se-ityo, rom piri, romelmac mas es nivTebi Caabara, iyo d. k-a.n. o-m aseve ganmarta, rom is Tavis Tavs ar endo, daukav-Sirda TanamSromlebs, romlebmac daadastures, rom esnivTi maTi muzeumidan iyo waRebuli.
4. analogiuri Cveneba misca da igive faqtobrivi gare-moebebi daadastura saqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma ima-ve muzeumis TanamSromelma _ n. b-m da damatebiT ganmar-ta, rom is Tu ris safuZvelze Sefasda dakarguli nivTe-bis Rirebuleba (muzeumisaTvis miyenebuli zianis ode-noba), misTvis ucnobia, radgan aRniSnuli sakiTxi mis kom-petenciaSi ar Sedis.
5. mowme z. S-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom e.w. `...~ bazro-baze vaWrobs Zveli nivTebiT. 2015 wlis martis dasawyisSiSexvda piri (d. k-a), romelic idga magnitofonebis gamyid-velis daxlTan da eWira ….. qaRaldis saWreli dana. miskiTxvaze, xom ar yidda am nivTs, man Tanxmoba ganacxadada mihyida xsenebuli nivTi. z. S-m mas sTxova piradobismowmoba, magram man uTxra, rom iyo d. k-a da iq yvela ic-nobda. aRmoCnda, rom iqve maxloblad vaWrobda misi bav-Svis naTlia, romelmac daudastura, rom es piri marTlad. k-a iyo. z. S-s CvenebiT irkveva, rom im dRis Semdeg manaraerTxel SeiZina d. k-sagan sxvadasxva nivTi.
6. fotosuraTebis amocnobis oqmiT dadgenilia, rom z.S-m amoicno d. k-a.
7. mowme g. b-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom muSaobs q. Tbi-lisis meriis usafrTxoebis saqalaqo samsaxurSi dacvisTanamSromlad, romlis funqcias warmoadgens meriis ba-lansze arsebuli obieqtebis dacva. mas evaleboda q. Tbi-lisSi, ... #...-Si mdebare ... muzeumis usafrTxoebis dacva.man ganmarta, rom aRniSnuli muzeumi Sedgeba ori _ cen-traluri da damxmare Senobisagan da mas evaleboda orivemaTganis usafrTxoebis dacva. Senobebis gasaRebebi ina-xeboda mxolod dacvis samsaxurSi. orive Senobis karebiiketeba gasaRebiT da maTi gaReba xdeba maTTan dakavSi-rebis Semdeg. muzeumis SenobaSi Sesvlis ufleba ar aqvTgareSe pirebs, radgan muzeumi ar funqcionirebs. iq Ses-vlis ufleba aqvT mxolod muzeumis TanamSromlebs. isi-
180
ni morigeoben 3 dReSi erTxel da aqvT muSaobis 24-saaTi-ani grafiki. muzeumSi inaxeba yuTebSi dasawyobebuli sa-muzeumo eqsponatebi, romelTa gaxsnis, masSi moTavsebu-li nivTebis aRwerisa da inventarizaciis ufleba mas argaaCnda. man ganmarta, rom muzeumSi momxdari qurdobisfaqti Seityo TanamSromlebisgan.
8. analogiuri Cveneba misces da igive faqtobrivi gare-moebebi daadastures saqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiTxulmaimave muzeumis dacvis TanamSromlebma _ p. m-m da p. c-m.
9. saqmeze mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma _ i. a-m, g. f-m, m. g-mda a. b-m isaubres im sagamoZiebo moqmedebebze, romleb-Sic monawileobdnen, an romlebic Caatares uSualod maT.sasamarTlo sxdomaze daikiTxa aseve eqsperti x. W-e, ro-melmac daadastura mis mier gacemuli daqtiloskopiurieqspertizis daskvnis kanoniereba.
10. sakasacio palata mTlianad iziarebs saapelacio sa-samarTlos msjelobas, rom qmedebis sadgomSi an sacavSiukanono SeRweviT dakvalificirebisaTvis aucilebelia,damnaSaves ar hqondes sacavSi, an sadgomSi Sesvlis uf-leba. mocemul SemTxvevaSi swored im mowmeebis, kerZod_ p. m-s, g. b-s, n. o-sa da n. b-s CvenebebiT, romlebzec sa-xelmwifo braldeba apelirebs, dadgenilia is faqti, rom... muzeumis orive Senobas icavs dacvis samsaxuri, maTi ga-saRebebi inaxeba da maTi gamoyenebis ufleba aqvT sworedmxolod dacvis samsaxuris TanamSromlebs. Tu dacva argaaRebs kars, araTu gareSe piri, muzeumis TanamSromelicver SeZlebs muzeumSi Sesvlas. ufro metic, msjavrdebuld. k-s ganmartebiT, rasac aseve adastureben dacvis sxvaTanamSromlebi, mowmeebi _ g. b-i da p. m-i, isini muzeumiscentraluri Senobis me-3 sarTulze (saidanac daikarga sa-muzeumo eqsponatebi), samuzeumo eqsponatebidan daax-loebiT naxevari metris moSorebiT icvlidnen tansac-mels. amdenad, usafuZvloa kasatoris pozicia, rom dac-vis TanamSromlebs ar hqondaT ufleba, Sesuliyvnen mu-zeumis romelime oTaxSi da evalebodaT Senobis mxolodgaregani mTlianobis dacva.
11. sakasacio palata aseve iziarebs saapelacio sasa-marTlos mosazrebas d. k-Tvis saqarTvelos ssk-is 177-emuxlis me-4 nawilis `b~ qvepunqtiT wardgenili bralde-bis usafuZvlobis Taobaze da aRniSnavs, rom mocemul Sem-TxvevaSi, dakarguli nivTebis specifikidan gamomdinare,
181
vinaidan isini warmoadgenen eqskluziur da unikalur na-keTobebs, unda dadgeniliyo dakarguli nivTebis danaSa-ulis Cadenis dros arsebuli saxelmwifo, sacalo, sabaz-ro an sakomisio fasebi. aseve ar Catarebula sasaqonloeqspertiza, romliTac ganisazRvreboda qonebis Rirebu-leba. mocemul SemTxvevaSi muzeumisaTvis miyenebuli zi-ani ganisazRvra mxolod misi direqtoris _ n. o-s CvenebissafuZvelze, romelic uTiTebs nivTebis savaraudo da da-axloebiT Rirebulebas, xolo erT-erTi dakiTxvisas is za-ralis sxva odenobaze saubrobs, meore dakiTxvisas ki _sxvaze. sakasacio palata aseve ar iziarebs kasatoris mo-sazrebas, rom moparuli nivTebis Rirebulebis gansaz-Rvrisas sasamarTlos unda gaeTvaliswinebina msjavrde-bulis mier maTi gasxvisebis Rirebuleba, rac minimum, mniS-vnelovan zians aRemateba da aRniSnavs, rom miyenebulizianis odenoba unda dadgindes danaSaulis Cadenis drosnivTis sabazro Rirebulebidan gamomdinare da ara imismixedviT, ra fasSi moaxdina danaSaulis Camdenma pirma mi-si realizacia.
ma sakasacio saCivris safuZvlianoba da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom msjavrdebul m. k-s interesebis damcvelis, advo-kat k. k-s sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs msjavrdebul m. k-ada misi interesebis damcvelis, advokat k. k-s poziciasmsjavrdebulis gamarTlebis Taobaze, kerZod:
3. dazaralebul a. S-s mier micemuli CvenebiT, is muSa-obda mtvirTavad dilis rva saaTidan saRamos eqvs saaTam-de. samuSaos damTavrebis Semdeg wavida da `kurtka~ iyida.mere megobrebTan erTad sasmeli dalia da roca erTmaneTsdaSordnen, gaeSura samarSruto taqsisken. rkinigzis sad-guris mimdebare teritoriaze man gaicno m. k-e, ris Semde-gac gadawyvites, erTad daeliaT alkoholuri sasmeli. da-zaralebulma Tavis CvenebaSi garkveviT miuTiTa, rom Ta-vidan dalies quCaSi, jixurTan, xolo Semdeg _ raRac Seno-baSi, romelsac kibiT Casasvleli hqonda, magram ar axsovsmisi dasaxeleba. misive ganmartebiT, zogadad, yvelafer-ze saubrobdnen da konkretulad raze, ar axsovs. a. S-i m. k-
184
sTan Sexvedrisas ukve mTvrali iyo. man aRniSna, rom saub-robdnen rogorc qarTulad, ise rusulad, ufro sworad,m. k-e qarTulad esaubreboda, TviTon ki rusuladac saub-robda da qarTuladac. dazaralebulis Cvenebidan irkve-va, rom man m. k-s uTxra, rom is erovnebiT iyo iezidi davaraudobs, rom misi erovnebidan gamomdinare gaxda is ag-resiuli. Tumca, m. k-s ganmartebiT, maSinve ar gamouvleniaagresiuloba. is agresiuli gaxda mogvianebiT, ra drosac m.k-m moulodnelad saxis areSi xeli daartya, ris Sedegadacis waiqca da Tavi bordiurs daartya. rodesac Zlivs wamod-ga, sisxli wamouvida. k-s hkiTxa, Tu ratom daartya, amisSemdeg man fexic daartya marcxena mxares da dauwyo tya-vis qurTukis gaxda, is ki ekiTxeboda, Tu ras erCoda. m. k-mmas gaxada qurTuki da cdilobda gaqcevas. igi gasisxliane-buli iyo, yviroda da Svelas iTxovda, ra drosac SemTxve-vis adgilze mividnen policiis TanamSromlebi da daakavesm. k-e, Tavad ki goneba dakarga.
5. levan samxaraulis saxelobis sasamarTlo eqsperti-zis erovnuli biuros stacionaruli sasamarTlo _ fsiqi-atriuli eqspertizis #... daskvnis Tanaxmad, m. k-s mar-TlsawinaaRmdego qmedebis Cadenis periodSi ar SeeZlo,srulad gaecnobierebina Tavisi qmedebis faqtobrivi xa-siaTi da marTlwinaaRmdegoba da exelmZRvanela misTvis(SezRuduli Seracxadoba). m. k-e imgvari fsiqikuri avad-myofobiT, romelic xels uSlis sasjelis moxdas, daava-debuli ar aris. Tavisi fsiqikuri mdgomareobiT m. k-e Se-iZleba warsdges marTlmsajulebis winaSe da pasuxi agosbralad Seracxuli qmedebisaTvis.
6. mowmis saxiT dakiTxulma fsiqiatrma i. s-m uCvena,rom Seswavlil iqna sisxlis samarTlis saqme, gamosakvle-vi piri da gairkva, rom m. k-e marTlsawinaaRmdego qmede-
185
bis Cadenis periodSi daavadebuli iyo bipolaruli afeq-turi aSlilobiT, mimdinare epizodSi hipomaniiT. amJamadremisiis mdgomareobaa. mis mier micemuli Cvenebis mixed-viT, danaSaulebrivi qmedebis Cadenis dros energiul da`aweul~ xasiaTze iyo, gadaWarbebiT svamda sasmels da ad-vilad uaxlovdeboda ucxo pirebs. mis mier micemuli Cve-nebis mixedviT, igi iyo gawonasworebuli, araTanmimdev-ruli winadadebebi ar warmouTqvams, anu mas adekvaturiCvenebebi aqvs micemuli, winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi Cvene-bas ver miscemda. Tumca, eqspertma ganmarta, rom vinai-dan m. k-s aqvs fsiqikuri nakli, Sesabamisad, SeiZleba vergaerkves iuridiul sakiTxebSi. aseT SemTxvevaSi, saWiroamisi uflebebi daicvas advokatma. analogiuri Cveneba mis-ca pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi mowmis saxiT dakiT-xulma fsiqiatrma a. t-m.
7. amdenad, eqspertebi TavianT CvenebebSi arsad uTi-Teben, rom isini iziareben an ar iziareben m. k-s mier mice-mul Cvenebas. isini ganmartaven, rom Cveneba iyo dalage-buli da Tanmimdevruli, rac ar aZlevdaT saSualebas, em-sjelaT piris Seuracxadobaze. amasTan, m. k-s aReniSnebaiseTi fsiqikuri aSliloba, kerZod _ hipomaniakaluri epi-zodi, romelic grZeldeba ramdenime dRes an kviras, Sem-deg ki dgeba remisiis periodi, rasac adgili hqonda kon-kretul SemTxvevaSi.
8. mowme l. J-s CvenebiT 2014 wlis 31 dekembers, RamissaaTebSi, is asrulebda samsaxurebriv movaleobas Tavismewyvile v. m-sTan erTad. isini imyofebodnen ... quCisa da... kveTasTan, ra drosac moesmaT xmauri da mamakacis yvi-rilis xma, romelic daxmarebas iTxovda. man dainaxa, romori mamakaci erTmaneTSi ZiZgilaobda, erT-erTs m. k-s ec-va samxedro forma, romelmac saxis areSi xeli daartyadazaralebul a-e S-s da es ukanaskneli Zirs daeca. man ase-ve dainaxa, Tu rogor cdilobda m. k-e a-e S-sTvis tyavisqurTukis warTmevas, dazaralebuli ki Svelas iTxovda.aRniSnuli faqtis Semxedvare, is da v. m-e gaiqcnen Sem-Txvevis adgilisken, xolo m. k-e, romelmac qurTuki waar-Tva a. S-s, maTi mimarTulebiT gaiqca, ra drosac man da mis-ma TanamSromelma daakaves m. k-e. analogiuri Cveneba mis-ca pirveli instanciis sasamarTlo sxdomaze mowme v. m-m.
9. 2014 wlis 31 dekembris m. k-s dakavebisa da piradiCxrekis oqmis Tanaxmad, braldebul m. k-s piradi Cxrekis
10. yovelive zemoaRniSnulidan gamomdinare, sakasa-cio palata ver gaiziarebs msjavrdebul m. k-sa da misi in-teresebis damcvelis, advokat k. k-s pozicias msjavrde-bulis gamarTlebis Taobaze da miaCnia, rom kanonis moT-xovnaTa sruli dacviT, srulyofilad da obieqturad ga-mokvleul, utyuar, urTierTSejerebul da sakmaris mtki-cebulebaTa erTobliobiT gonivrul eWvs miRma dastur-deba m. k-saTvis bralad Seracxuli qmedebis Cadena, risgamoc gasaCivrebuli ganaCeni unda darCes ucvlelad.
3. saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis SemdegnivTieri mtkicebulebebi: kompaqtdiski unda daerTossaqmes misi Senaxvis vadiT, xolo sagiravno xelSekrule-ba, s. k-s piradobis mowmobis asli da oqros yelsabami un-da daubrundes maT kanonier mflobelebs.
4. ganaCeniT msjavrdebul s. k-s mier Cadenili danaSau-
188
li gamoixata SemdegSi: Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos2007 wlis 4 maisis ganaCeniT s. k-i cnobil iqna damnaSavedsaqarTvelos ssk-is 179-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `b~ da me-3nawilis `a~ qvepunqtebiT da miesaja 9 wliT TavisuflebisaRkveTa.
sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas, yovelmxriv da obieqturadSeamowma saqmeSi arsebuli mtkicebulebani, Seafasa TiTo-euli maTgani saqmesTan maTi relevanturobis, dasaSvebo-bisa da utyuarobis TvalsazrisiT da mivida im daskvnam-de, rom saxelmwifo bralmdeblis, prokuror kaxaber le-kiSvilis sakasacio saCivari ar unda dakmayofildes Sem-deg garemoebaTa gamo:
2. `e-s~ samxreT saqarTvelos filialis aRricxvisa daangariSsworebis ganyofilebis specialistis, mowme a. g-sCvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2014 wlis 26 agvistos gegmiuriSemowmebis mizniT ufros specialist g. m-sa da specialistd. a-Tan erTad unda Seemowmebina Sps `t-s~ kuTvnili de-nis transformatorebi da ... raionis sofel ... wyalsaqaCisdenis transformatorebi. maT `e…..s~ me-3 ubnis menejeri. n-es acnobes, rom ... wyalsaqaCze midiodnen Sesamowmeb-lad. d. a-m hkiTxa, obieqtze yuradRebas vin miaqcevda,razec i. n-m ganumarta, rom kavSiri hqonodaT n. T-Tan. miz-nobrivi instruqtaJi ar CatarebiaT. saWiro iyo ganwesisSedgena, magram ar Sedga, ucnobi iyo, vin iqneboda samuSa-os mwarmoebeli. obieqti warmoadgenda kerZo sakuTrebas,amitom mepatrones unda gamoeyo erTi piri, romelic iq-neboda eleqtromeurneobaze pasuxismgebeli da gamzade-buls daaxvedrebda jgufs, rom emuSavaT, dawerda Sesa-bamis ganwess, muSaobis dros ikisrebda pasuxismgeblobasobieqtis usafrTxoebaze. rodesac jgufi gadis da mepat-rone ar xvdeba, mas ar aqvs ufleba Sevides obieqtze daCaataros samuSaoebi, am dros gafrTxilebuli unda iyosSesabamisi uflebamosili piri da jgufma unda datovosteritoria. gegmiur SemowmebaSi ar Sedioda 10-kilovol-tiani gamTiSvelis gamorTva. Tu sahaero gamTiSveli gai-TiSeboda, moxdeboda damiweba da CarTuli iqneboda ma-Rali Zabva, usafrTxo iqneboda samuSaoebis Catareba, mag-
194
ram roca sahaero gamTiSveli gaTiSuli araa, arc damiwe-baa da gamorTulia maRali Zabva, usafrTxo araa samuSaoe-bis Catareba. sahaero gamTiSveli unda gaeTiSaT, magramar iyo mwyobrSi, misi gaTiSva obieqtis warmomadgenelsevaleboda, magram vinaidan iq ar iyo, amitom gamorTva sca-da s. m-m, Tumca uSedegod. g. m-i iyo ufrosi specialisti.vinaidan is da d. a-i arian dabali rangis specialistebi,samuSaoebis Catarebisas asrulebdnen mis davalebebs. amSemTxvevaSi samuSaos mwarmoeblad iTvleboda ufrosispecialisti g. m-i. g. m-s sityvieri davalebiT d. a-m dau-reka n. T-s da moiTxova fideris gaTiSva. fideris CarTvaSeiZleboda mxolod amave piris nebarTviT.
3. mowme i. n-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom 2015 wlis 26agvistos unda momxdariyo ... wyalsaqaCis gegmiuri Semow-meba. igi daukavSirda n. T-s da acnoba, rom unda momxdari-yo miTiTebul obieqtebze gegmiuri Semowmeba da Tu saWi-ro gaxdeboda, daxmareboda jgufs. mogvianebiT mas dau-kavSirda n. T-i da uTxra, rom 10 kv-is gamTiSveli ar muSa-obda da aRricxvisa da angariSsworebis jgufi usafrTxo-ebis mizniT iTxovda fideris gaTiSvas. saWiro iyo gankar-gulebis dawera, vinaidan gankargulebis nomris gadace-mis gareSe centraluri dispetCeri ... fiders ar gaTiSav-da. gankargulebaSi aucilebelia mieTiTos mizezi, ris ga-moc iTiSeba fideri, aseve samuSaos mwarmoebeli da bri-gadis wevrebi. vinaidan n. T-sagan icoda, rom molaparake-bas fideris CarTva-gamorTvaze awarmoebda d. a-i, amitomman saqmis mwarmoeblad miuTiTa igi, Tumca fideris Car-Tva-gamorTvaze SesaZlebeli iyo samuSaos mwarmoeblisdavalebiT jgufis romelime wevrs waremarTa molapara-kebebi. gankarguleba rodesac iwereba, saWiroa jgufiswevrebs Cautardes instruqtaJi, xeli unda moaweros jgu-fis yvela wevrma, Tumca am SemTxvevaSi, vinaidan jgufiiyo gasuli samuSao adgilze da gankarguleba i. n-m maTdauswreblad dawera, amitom jgufis wevrebisaTvis in-struqtaJi ar Cautarebia da, Sesabamisad, xelmowerebicar dafiqsirebula gankargulebaze.
4. ss `e-s~ ... momsaxurebis centris mesame ubnis osta-tis, mowme n. T-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom samsaxurebri-vi Sinaganawesis mixedviT, evaleboda SekeTebis da Semow-mebis dros fiderebis CarTva-gamorTvaze dispetCerTanmolaparakeba. 2014 wlis 26 agvistos mas daukavSirda d. a-
195
i da mosTxova fider `aralis~ gaTiSva da `SekeTebaSi Caye-neba~, raTa SeemowmebinaT sofel ... Sps `t-s~ aRricxviskvanZebi. n. T-i daukavSirda regionis dispeCers da moiT-xova fideris gamorTva. man ramdenime wuTSi acnoba, romfideri gamorTuli iyo da SesaZlebeli iyo samuSaos war-moeba. samuSaos dasrulebis Semdeg d. a-i kvlav daukav-Sirda da acnoba, rom SeeZlo fider `aralis~ CarTva. daax-loebiT erT saaTSi mas kvlav daukavSirda d. a-i da mos-Txova fider `dercelis~ gamorTva. igi kvlav daukavSir-da regionis dispetCers da moiTxova fider `dercelis~gamorTva da `SekeTebaSi Cayeneba~. rodesac acnobes, romfideri `derceli~ gamorTes, daukavSirda d. a-s, uTxra,rom fideri `derceli~ gamorTuli iyo da SeeZloT ewar-moebinaT samuSaoebi. is d.a-s gafrTxilebis gareSe dau-kavSirda regionis dispetCers da moiTxova fider `der-celis~ CarTva. mogvianebiT Seityo, rom gardaicvala g. m-i, romelic awarmoebda samuSaoebs. fideris CarTva-gamor-Tvaze molaparakebebis warmoeba SeeZlo samuSao jgufisnebismier wevrs, miuxedavad imisa, iqneboda Tu ara is saq-mis mwarmoebeli. momxdar faqtTan dakavSirebiT igigrZnobs Tavis danaSauls da aRniSnulTan dakavSirebiTixdis sasjels.
5. ss `e-s~ regionuli usafrTxoebis teqnikis ufrosiinspeqtoris, mowme r. x-s ganmartebiT, mis samsaxurSi Se-dis aRricxvisa da angariSsworebis jgufi, romelic ax-dens regionSi Semavali obieqtebis gegmiur Semowmebas aR-ricxvis kuTxiT. momsaxurebis centrebi afrTxileben obi-eqtis pasuxismgebel pirebs Semowmebis Sesaxeb, aRricxvissamsaxurSi samsaxuris ufrosi akompleqtebs jgufebs dauSvebs Sesamowmeblad obieqtebze. roca Sesamowmebeliobieqti aris kerZo, mis mepatrones afrTxileben winas-war, mas unda hyavdes eleqtromeurneobaze pasuxismge-beli piri, romelic valdebulia brigadis usafrTxo mu-Saobaze. man samuSao adgilze unda uzrunvelyos samuSaoobieqtis momzadeba, jgufis wevrebs Cautaros samuSaosmokle instruqtaJi, razec unda Sedges ganwesi an gankar-guleba, Semdeg jgufi gauSvas samuSaod. am SemTxvevaSisamuSaos mwarmoeblad da pasuxismgeblad iTvleba obieq-tze eleqtro meurneobaze pasuxismgebeli piri. im Sem-TxvevaSi, Tu jgufs ar daxvda obieqtis warmomadgeneli_ eleqtro meurneobaze pasuxismgebeli piri, jgufs ar
196
aqvs samuSaoebis warmoebis ufleba. miuxedavad amisa,jgufma daiwyo muSaoba. i. n-s mier gacemul iqna #... gan-karguleba im mizniT, rom aRniSnulis safuZvelze momxda-riyo fideris gamorTva. gankargulebaSi i. n-s mier samuSa-os mwarmoeblad dafiqsirebulia d. a-i, vinaidan fiderisCarTva-gamorTvaze molaparakebebs awarmoebda igi, Tum-ca gankargulebaze arc d. a-sa da arc jgufis sxva wevre-bis xelmowerebi dafiqsirebuli ar aris. miznobrivi in-struqtaJi jgufs ar Catarebia. fideris CarTva-gamorTva-ze molaparakebebis warmoebis ufleba hqonda jgufis sa-mive wevrs _ g. m-s, d. a-sa da a. g-s.
6. mowme eqspert u. x-s CvenebiT dadgenilia, rom pro-fesiiT aris inJiner-eqsperti. g. m-s gardacvalebis faq-tTan dakavSirebiT sasamarTlo eqspertizis erovnul bi-uros waredgina sisxlis samarTlis saqmis masalebi, rom-liTac dadginda, rom 2015 wlis 26 agvistos ss `e-s~ warmo-madgenlebi wavidnen ... gegmiuri samuSaoebis Sesamowmeb-lad, ra drosac jgufis erT-erTi wevri d. a-i daukavSir-da n. T-s da sTxova gamoerTo fideri `derceli~, raTa sa-muSaoebi usafrTxod CaetarebinaT, rac ganxorcielda dajgufi Sevida obieqtze samuSaod. n. T-m ise, rom aravindakavSirebia samuSaos dasrulebis Sesaxeb, TviTneburadCaarTvevina xazi, ris Sedegadac gardaicvala g. m-i. fide-ris CarTva-gamorTva xorcieldeboda ... . gankargulebisnomriT, romelic Seadgina i. n-m. ganwes-gankargulebisJurnalSi samuSaos mwarmoeblad miTiTebulia d. a-i, xo-lo samuSaoebis usafrTxod Catarebis mizniT miTiTebu-lia 10 kilovoltiani sahaero gamTiSvelis gaTiSva da da-miweba. obieqtze sahaero gamTiSveli gamosuli iyo mwyob-ridan, ris Sedegadac sahaero gamTiSvelis gamorTva vermoxerxda. samuSaos dawyebamde sityvieri SeTanxmebis Se-degad miiRes gadawyvetileba, rom gaTiSuliyo fideri`derceli~, rac ar iqna dafiqsirebuli ganwes-gankargu-lebis JurnalSi. mocemul SemTxvevaSi, vinaidan ar xer-xdeboda sahaero gamTiSvelis gamorTva, unda momxdari-yo damiweba an jgufi unda gamosuliyo da Semdgariyo axa-li ganwesi, romliTac ganwesis gamcemi gansazRvravda,moxdeboda damiweba Tu ara, vin iqneboda mwarmoebeli, visunda gamoerTo fideri, anu is pirebi, romlebic pasuxis-mgeblebi iqnebodnen samuSaos usafrTxod warmoebaze. Tumoxdeboda damiweba, gindac CarTuliyo maRali Zabva, mox-
197
deboda xazis avtomaturi gaTiSva, rac adamians icavs Zab-vaSi Cavardnisagan. rodesac jgufi Sedis obieqtze, masunda hqondes ganwes-gankarguleba. mis gareSe amgvari sa-muSaoebis Catareba kanondarRvevaa. ganwesi rom dgeba, isunda gaacnon masSi miTiTebul pirebs, gaafrTxilon usaf-rTxoebis normebis darRvevaze da gaacnon TavianTi uf-leba-movaleobebi, vin aris samuSaos mwarmoebeli, vin meT-valyure, vin brigadis wevri. amis Semdeg unda moxdes obi-eqtze gasvla da samuSaoebis dawyeba. Tu brigadis wevre-bis daswrebis gareSe Sedgeba ganwesi, es aucileblad un-da gaecnos brigadis wevrebs, arsebobs Sesabamisi grafaxelmowerebis, rom gaecnobian TavianT ufleba-movaleo-bebs, amas daeTanxmebian da imis mixedviT ixelmZRvanele-ben. eqspertma ganmarta, rom samuSaos aRricxvis Jurnal-Si samuSaos mwarmoeblad miTiTebulia d. a-i, Tumca gan-wes-gankargulebis JurnalSi arc saqmis mwarmoeblis daarc jgufis sxva wevrebis xelmowerebi ar aris dafiqsi-rebuli. imisaTvis, rom piri CaiTvalos saqmis mwarmoeb-lad, aucilebelia ganwesze xeli hqondes mowerili. gan-wes/gankargulebis Semdgens evaleba gaacnos ganwesi sa-muSaos mwarmoebels da brigadis wevrebs, moawerinos maTxeli. mocemul SemTxvevaSi ganwes/gankargulebis Jurnal-Si, vinc ar unda yofiliyo miTiTebuli, mas miiCnevda saq-mis mwarmoeblad. swored am dokumentiT ixelmZRvaneladaskvnis Sedgenisas. is garemoeba, rom jgufis wevrebis,maT Soris d. a-s xelmowera ar fiqsirdeba JurnalSi da aR-niSnulis gamo ramdenad unda dakisreboda d. a-s daskvna-Si gansazRvruli pasuxismgebloba, es unda Seefasebina ga-moZiebas sxva danarCen, mis mier dadgenil faqtobriv ga-remoebebTan erTad.
7. ganwesiTa da gankargulebiT Sesasrulebel samuSao-Ta aRricxvis Jurnalidan amonaweriT dadgenilia, rom ...wyalsaqaCis aRricxvisa da denis transformatorebis Se-samowmeblad samuSao warmoebda #... gankargulebis mixed-viT, romelic gacemulia i. n-s mier. JurnalSi samuSaosmwarmoeblad miTiTebulia d. a-i usafrTxoebis jgufis IVkategoriiT, xolo samuSaos usafrTxoebis uzrunvelyo-fis mizniT miTiTebulia samuSao adgilze 10kv-is saxazogamTiSvelis gamorTva da damiweba. brigadis wevrebi _ g-i,m-i, m-i. JurnalSi miznobrivi instruqtaJis mimRebi momu-Saveebis xelmowerebi dafiqsirebuli ar aris.
tis mier pirveli instanciis sasamarTloSi micemuli Cve-nebiT dadgenilia, rom eqsperts ar Seufasebia sakiTxi,icoda Tu ara d. a-m masze, rogorc samuSaos mwarmoebelzedakisrebuli valdebulebebis Sesaxeb. man d. a-i eqsper-tis daskvnaSi daafiqsira samuSaos mwarmoeblad imitom,rom igi samuSaos mwarmoeblad dafiqsirebuli iyo ganwe-siTa da gankargulebiT Sesasrulebel samuSaoTa aRric-xvis jurnalSi, xolo JurnalSi xelmoweris ararsebobisSefaseba mis kompetenciaSi ar Sedioda da aRniSnuli un-da Seefasebina sagamoZiebo organos.
13. mowme i. n-m ganmarta, rom JurnalSi d. a-i samuSaosmwarmoeblad daafiqsira n. T-s miTiTebiT mxolod imitom,rom d. a-m ganaxorciela satelefono zari fideris gamor-Tvis moTxovniT, xolo eleqtrogadamcemi xazis gasaTi-Sad savaldebulo iyo ganwesiTa da gankargulebiT Sesas-rulebel samuSaoTa aRricxvis JurnalSi SemTxvevis da-fiqsireba, raTa mas miniWeboda nomeri, romlis meSveobi-Tac `e-s~ regionaluri dispetCeri SesZlebda eleqtroe-nergiis gamorTvis Sesaxeb ganacxadis miRebas da mis dak-mayofilebas.
14. kasatoris mosazrebiT, d. a-i iyo samuSao jgufisufrosi, romelmac eleqtroobieqtis eqspluataciisdros daarRvia usafrTxoebis wesebi, xolo aRniSnulisdasadastureblad igi uTiTebs, rom d. a-m, mas Semdeg, racver moaxerxa aerogamomrTvelis gamorTva, moiTxova fi-deris gaTiSva.
15. sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs saxelmwifo bral-mdeblis aRniSnul arguments, vinaidan rogorc 1-li in-stanciis sasamarTloSi dakiTxulma mowme i. n-m ganmarta,molaparakebaSi fideris-CarTva gamorTvaze monawileob-da d. a-i, amitom man saqmis mwarmoeblad miuTiTa igi, Tum-ca fideris CarTva-gamorTvaze SesaZlebelia, samuSaosmwarmoeblis davalebiT jgufis romelime wevrs ewarmoe-bina molaparakebebi. mowme a. g-m ki ganmarta, rom g. m-i iyoufrosi specialisti. vinaidan is da d. a-i arian dabali ran-gis specialistebi, samuSaoebis Catarebisas asrulebdnenmis davalebebs. samuSaos mwarmoeblad iTvleboda ufro-si specialisti g. m-i da misi sityvieri davalebiT d. a-mdaureka n. T-s da moiTxova fideris gaTiSva. 1-li instan-ciis sasamarTloSi dakiTxulma mowme r. x-m aseve aCvena,rom fideris CarTva-gamorTvaze molaparakebebs warmar-
201
Tavda d. a-i, Tumca molaparakebebis warmoebis uflebahqonda jgufis samive wevrs _ g. m-s, d. a-sa da a. g-s. aRniS-nul mowmeTa CvenebebiT dadasturebulia, rom d. a-s mierfideris CarTva-gamorTvis moTxovna ar niSnavs imas, romis iyo jgufis ufrosi.
16. amdenad, sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom saqmeSi ar-sebuli mtkicebulebebiT utyuarad ver dadginda, romusafrTxoebis wesebis dacva, razec miuTiTebs kasatori,evaleboda swored d. a-s. d. a-s samuSaos mwarmoeblad mi-TiTeba ar momxdara aRniSnuli garemoebis momwesrigebe-li normatiuli aqtis moTxovnaTa dacviT. pirvel yovli-sa, ar momxdara d. a-s informireba misTvis raime valdebu-lebis dakisrebis Sesaxeb. Sesabamisad, mas ver daekisrebapasuxismgebloba am valdebulebaTa darRvevisaTvis. saq-meze gamokvleuli da miTiTebuli mtkicebulebebis sa-fuZvelze d. a-s mier danaSaulis Cadenis faqti ar SeiZ-leba miCneul iqnes dadasturebulad da safuZvlad dae-dos mis mimarT gamamtyunebel ganaCens.
3. samegrelo-zemo svaneTis saolqo prokuraturis war-moebaSi arsebul sisxlis samarTlis saqmeze braldebulik. l-a foTis saqalaqo sasamarTlos 2009 wlis 27 maisis ga-naCeniT cnobil iqna damnaSaved ssk-is 236-e muxlis pir-veli, meore da mesame nawilebiT gaTvaliswinebul dana-SaulTa CadenisaTvis da sasjelis saxed da zomad gane-sazRvra Tavisuflebis aRkveTa 8 wliTa da 6 TviT, xolo
204
damatebiTi sasjelis saxiT daekisra jarima _ 6000 lari.4. 2009 wlis dekemberSi msjavrdebul k. l-as meuRle m.
e-a, s-is saolqo prokuraturis administraciul SenobaSiSexvda r. a-as, ra drosac ganixiles k. l-asTan saprocesoSeTanxmebis gaformebis sakiTxi. r. a-a mas dahpirda, romgaerkveoda misi meuRlis braldebis sisxlis samarTlissaqmeSi da saproceso SeTnaxmebis gaformebis SesaZleb-lobis SemTxvevaSi daukavSirdeboda.
5. 2009 wlis 22 dekembers, m. e-a s-is saolqo prokura-turis administraciul SenobaSi kvlav Sexvda r. a-as, ro-melmac piradad mosTxova, rom k. l-asTan saproceso Se-Tanxmebis gaformebis sanacvlod saxelmwifo biujetisjarimis angariSze Caericxa 10 000 lari. garda aRniSnuli-sa, r. a-am piradi dainteresebiT, TiTqosda, qvelmoqme-debis mizniT, m. e-as mosTxova, rom k. l-as megobrebs, mismier gadacemul ararsebul `a-is g-is f-is~ sabanko anga-riSze CaericxaT 150 000 lari. realurad r. a-as mier gada-cemuli sabanko rekvizitebi warmoadgenda misi axloblis,s. g-as kuTvnil Sps `s-is~ sabanko angariSs.
6. marina e. i-i gaxda dasTanxmeboda SeTavazebul piro-bas. man meore dRes, k. l-as saxeliT, saxelmwifo xazinisjarimis angariSze Caricxa 10 000 lari, xolo misi meuR-lis megobris, g. w-is saxeliT 150 000 lari r. a-as mier mi-TiTebul Sps `s-is~ sabanko angariSze.
8. r. a-am, zemoaRniSnuli qmedebiT, gadaameta misi, ro-gorc saolqo prokuroris samsaxurebrivi uflebamosile-bis farglebs, ramac k. l-as da m. e-as uflebis da saxel-mwifos kanonieri interesis arsebiTi darRveva gamoiwvia.
9. 2009 wels saqarTvelos Sinagan saqmeTa saministross-is sammarTveloSi mimdinareobda gamoZieba sisxlis sa-marTlis saqmeze a. t-as, z. x-asa da d. k-is mimarT, danaSau-li gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is 19,196-e muxlisme-3 nawilis `g~ qvepnuqtiT, 27,197-e muxlis pirveli nawi-liT, me-200 muxlis me-2 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiTa da 27,362-
205
e muxlis pirveli nawiliT.10. a. t-as, z. x-as da d. k-s aRkveTis RonisZiebis saxiT
Sefardebuli hqondaT patimroba.11. r. a-as moTxovniT, pirobiTi msjavris gamoyenebiT
saproceso SeTanxmebis gaformebis sanacvlod, bralde-bulebs jarimis saxiT saxelmwifo biujetSi unda Caeric-xaT TiToeuls 30 000 lari, xolo 60 000 lari, SeniRbvismizniT, gareSe pirs damatebiT unda Caericxa Sps `s-is~ sa-banko angariSze. aRniSnuli firma warmoadgenda r. a-as ax-loblis, s. g-as sakuTrebas.
12. 2009 wlis 25 dekembers, r. a-as moTxovnis Sesabami-sad, braldebul a. t-as Svilma _ j. t-am braldebulebTansaproceso SeTanxmebis gaformebis sanacvlod, 60 000 la-ri mis megobars, m. w-as Caaricxina Sps `s-is~ sabanko anga-riSze, xolo 2009 wlis 29 dekembers braldebulebis war-momadgenlebis mier saxelmwifo biujetis jarimis anga-riSze Cairicxa saproceso SeTanxmebiT gaTvaliswinebu-li jarimis Tanxa, saerTo jamSi _ 90 000 lari.
13. 2009 wlis 29 dekembers, senakis raionuli sasamar-Tlos mier damtkicda saproceso SeTanxmeba, romlis Ta-naxmad, braldebulebs _ a. t-as, z. x-asa da d. k-s ZiriTadisasjelis saxiT daniSnuli Tavisuflebis aRkveTa CaeTva-laT pirobiT, xolo damatebiTi sasjelis saxiT daeniS-naT jarima TiToeuls 30 000 lari. rac Seexeba Sps `s-is~sabanko angariSze Caricxul 60 000 lars, romelic sapro-ceso SeTanxmebis oqmSi ar asaxula, mTlianad Sps `s-is~komerciuli miznebisaTvis gaixarja.
14. r. a-ia moqmedebda piradi dainteresebiT da sajarointeresis sawinaaRmdegod man aRniSnuli qmedebiT gada-ameta misi, rogorc prokuroris samsaxurebrivi ufleba-mosilebis farglebs, ramac a. t-as, z. x-asa da d. k-is uf-lebis da saxelmwifos kanonieri interesis arsebiTi dar-Rveva gamoiwvia.
15. Tbilisis saqalaqo sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlissaqmeTa kolegiis 2015 wlis 20 martis ganaCeniT r. a-ia cno-bil iqna udanaSaulod da gamarTlda saqarTvelos ssk-is333-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT (k. l-as epizodi) da ssk-is333-e muxlis pirveli nawiliT (a. t-as epizodi) wardgenilbraldebebSi.
• mowmeebis _ m. e-s, g. w-is, k. l-as, a. p-as, i. x-as, j. t-as,m. w-sa da a. t-as CvenebebiT utyuaradaa dadasturebuli,rom k. l-asa da a. t-as axloblebma Tanxebi gadaixades maT-Tvis saproceso SeTanxmebis gaformebis sanacvlod da ara-viTar qvelmoqmedebas adgili ar hqonia.
• saapelacio palatam usafuZvlod miiCnia, rom patri-arqis rezidenciisa da patriarqis dasasvenebeli odis asa-Seneblad ganxorcielda zemoxsenebuli Tanxebis mobili-zeba Sps `s-is~ angariSze, romelsac xsenebuli obieqte-bis aSeneba hqonda davalebuli, radgan utyuaradaa dad-genili, rom rodesac m. e-am Tanxa Caricxa, saerTod ar ico-da, rom sapatriarqo rezidencia Sendeboda. is faqti, rommSeneblobebis organizebaSi meufe p-sTan erTad aqtiurmonawileobas iRebda r. a-ia, ar Seesabameba sinamdviles.saqmeSi warmodgenilia sapatriarqos oficialuri gancxa-
207
deba, romelSic naTqvamia, rom mSeneblobis mimarTule-biT arc erTi realuri nabiji ar gadadgmula. Sesabamisad,radganac mxolod idea arsebobda da mSenebloba ar daw-yebula, mis organizebaSi veranair monawileobas ver mii-Rebda r. a-a; obieqtebi dRemde aSenebuli ar aris, xoloSps `s-is~ angariSze Caricxuli Tanxa _ 210 000 lari mTli-anad gaixarja firmis ekonomikuri miznebisaTvis da ara-nair sazogadoebriv saqmes ar moxmarebia.
• usafuZvloa saapelacio palatis msjeloba, rom saq-meSi ar arsebobs raime mtkicebuleba, romelic daadas-turebda, rom Sps `s-Si~ Tanxebis CaricxviT r. a-am miiRoraime piradi sargebeli, vinaidan aRniSnuli muxlis Semad-genloba, qmedebis kvalifikaciisaTvis ar iTvaliswinebsdanaSaulis subieqtis mier piradi sargeblobis miRebas;
• dausabuTebelia saapelacio palatis msjeloba m. e-as Cvenebis im nawilze, sadac mowme acxadebs, rom r. a-asmisTvis Tanxa ar gamouZalavs da rom kmayofilia masTanSexvedriT. braldebis mxarisTvis gaugebaria, Tu ratomamaxvilebs palata yuradRebas gamoZalvaze, rodesac r.a-as aRniSnuli kvalifikaciiT ar edavebian; aseve mcda-ria mosazreba, imis Sesaxeb, rom danaSaulis Cadenis Sem-TxvevaSi dazaralebulma Tavis cnobierebaSi unda aRiq-vas, ganicados da Seafasos, rom damnaSave piris mxridanmis winaaRmdeg ganxorcielebuli qmedebiT mas (dazara-lebuls) miadga materialuri Tu moraluri ziani, Seilaxamisi uflebebi da interesebi, winaaRmdeg SemTxvevaSi, dam-naSavis pasuxismgebloba gamoiricxeba.
• kasatorebi ar eTanxmebian agreTve saapelacio pala-tis msjelobas, rom saxelmwifo kanonieri interesis ar-sebiT darRvevad ar miiCnia saxelmwifo organos saqarTve-los prokuraturis prestiJisa da avtoritetis Selaxva;aseve, saxelmwifo mmarTvelobis dadgenili wesiT darRve-va, romlis Semadgenel nawils saproceso SeTanxmebis in-stitutic warmoadgens. saqmeze utyuarad aris dadastu-rebuli, rom r. a-as ukanono moTxovnis safuZvelze, sap-roceso SeTanxmebis gaformebis sanacvlod, didi odeno-bis Tanxebi kerZo firmis angariSze iricxeboda, es faqtiki araerTi pirisaTvis xdeboda cnobili da sazogadoebisnawils undoblobas uCenda samarTaldamcavi organoebissaqmianobis mimarT. aRniSnuliT dairRva saxelmwifo mmar-Tvelobis dadgenili wesi da Seilaxa saqarTvelos pro-
208
kuraturis prestiJi da avtoriteti. saxelmwifo mmarTve-lobis wesis darRvevam (saproceso SeTanxmebis gaforme-bis wesis ugulebelyofam) gamoiwvia isic, rom is Tanxa _210 000 lari, romelic saproceso SeTanxmebis safuZvel-ze sabolood saxelmwifo biujetis angariSze unda mox-vedriliyo da saxelmwifoebrivi miznebisaTvis unda ga-moyenebuliyo, gaixarja kerZo subieqtis sasargeblod.
kasacio saCivari, Seiswavla saqmis masalebi, Seamowma sa-Civris safuZvlianoba da miaCnia, rom sakasacio saCivariunda dakmayofildes da unda gauqmdes r. a-as mimarT dad-genili gamamarTlebeli ganaCeni Semdeg garemoebaTa ga-mo:
2. dazaralebul m. e-as Cvenebis mixedviT, rom mis me-uRlesTan _ k. l-asTan saproceso SeTanxmebis gaforme-bis mizniT orjer Sexvda r. a-as. pirveli Sexvedrisas, mansTxova a-s saproceso SeTanxmebis gaformeba meuRlesTan,razec am ukanasknelma upasuxa, rom gaerkveoda viTareba-Si da daukavSirdeboda. daaxloebiT erTi kviris Semdegmas daurekes da daibares a-asTan Sexvedraze. r. a-am uT-xra, rom SesaZlebeli iyo saproceso SeTanxmebis gafor-meba konkretuli Tanxis gaformebis sanacvlod. kerZod,saubari iyo 160 000 larze. ris Semdegac r. a-as moadgilemSemoitana ori furceli angariSebis nomrebiT. man da mis-ma axloblebma Seagroves zemoxsenebuli Tanxa da gada-ricxes miTiTebul angariSebze. qviTrebi ki r. a-as moad-giles _ m-s miutana moTxovnisamebr. amis Semdeg gafor-mda saproceso SeTanxmeba da misi meuRle gamouSves. pro-kuroris kiTxvaze dazaralebulma erTmniSvnelovnad gan-marta, rom 160 000 laris gadaxdis mizani saproceso Se-Tanxmebis miRweva iyo. g. w-is mier gadaxdil 150 000 lar-Tan dakavSirebiT mowmem ganmarta, rom Tanxis nawili, ker-Zod 15_20 aTasi lari iyo misi ojaxis, xolo danarCeni Tan-xa Seagroves misi ojaxis megobrebma.
3. mowme k. l-am ganmarta, rom 2009 wlis 9 Tebervalsdaakaves cecxlsasroli iaraRis ukanono SeZena-Senaxvi-sa da tarebis faqtze. miuxedavad bevri mcdelobisa, pro-kuraturasTan ver iqna miRweuli saproceso SeTanxmeba.Tumca, sabolood, rogorc meuRlisgan icis, 160 000 la-
209
ris sanacvlod moxda saproceso SeTanxmebis gaformeba.`r-im uTxra Cems cols imdeni fuli Tu gaqvs, rom viRacaferistebs urigeb, ager keTdeba a-aSi kargi saqmeebi dauTxari Seni qmris megobrebs, rom gadaricxon fulio~.prokuroris SekiTxvaze mowmem daadastura, rom megob-rebma Tanxa mis dasaxmareblad Seagroves; misma colma rommiitana qviTrebi da Tqva Tanxaa gadasaxdelio, oRond isgaTavisuflebuliyo da vin ikiTxavda ratom da risTviso.mowmem aseve ganmarta, rom marTalia megobrebi ar sTxo-ven Tanxas ukan, radgan Tavadac xSirad daxmarebia maT,magram rogorc adamiani, ra Tqma unda, davalebuladTvlis Tavs.
4. mowme g. w-ma ganmarta, rom k. l-as meuRlem _ m. e-amamcno, rom mas prokuraturaSi uTxres, rom k-as megobrebsunda CaericxaT garkveul angariSze fuli, rac maT usit-yvod Seasrules; fuli Seagroves da uSualod man Seitanam-as mier miTiTebul angariSze. prokuroris SekiTxvaze,Tu ratom Caricxes es fuli, mowmem ganmarta, rom radganprokuraturidan wamovida aseTi moTxovna, maTac Caric-xes. manve ganmarta, rom fuls ukan ar iTxovs da k-s dasax-mareblad mzadaa kidev gadaixados fuli.
5. mowme a. p-am ganmarta, rom k-as meuRlem m. e-am Seat-yobina maT, rom Tu a-is fondSi Tanxas gadaixdidnen, k-sgamouSvebdnen. saubari iyo 150 000 larze. prokuroriskiTxvaze, Tu ra iyo Tanxis Caricxvis mizani, qvelmoqme-debis mizniT xom ar gadauricxavT Tanxa, mowmem katego-riulad ganacxada, rom araviTar qvelmoqmedebas ar hqo-nia adgili da fuli k-s cixidan gamosayvanad gadaixades.
6. analogiuri Sinaarsis Cveneba misca sasamarTlos mow-me i. x-am da ganmarta, rom Tanxa k-s gamosayvanad Segrovda.
ciis TanamSromeli da uTxra, rom ibarebda s-is axali pro-kurori _ l. x-a. j. t-a prokuraturaSi wavida megobar m. w-sTan erTad. rodesac l. x-sTan mivida, am ukanasknelma uT-xra, rom rogorc icoda, wina prokurorTan SeTanxmebu-lan 150 000 laris sanacvlod saproceso garigebaze da romdRis bolomde unda gadaexadaT 60 000 lari. misca qviTa-ri, romelsac ewera `s-i~ da Tan gaafrTxila, rom Tanxa au-cileblad sxvisi saxeliT SeetanaT. Tanxis gadaxdis Sem-deg gadaxdis damadasturebeli qviTari ki isev masTan un-da mietanaT. aRniSnulis Semdeg j. t-a m. w-sTan erTad wa-vida q-Si. radgan ZiriTadi Tanxa j. t-as piradad hqonda,q-Si naTesavebs gamoarTva mizeruli Tanxa _ daaxloebiT300 lari da m. w-as saxeliT Seitana l. x-as mier gadacemulangariSze. Tanxis gadaxdis Semdgom, saRamos saaTebSi, ga-daxdis damadasturebeli qviTari l. x-as miutana proku-raturaSi. amis Semdgom mamamiss da sxva dakavebul pirebsgauformdaT saproceso SeTanxmeba jamSi 90 000 larze dagaTavisufldnen sasamarTlo darbazidan. mowmem katego-riulad ganacxada, rom Sps `s-is~ angariSze Tanxa Caric-xes mxolod im mizniT, rom misi avadmyofi mama gaTavisuf-lebuliyo da Tanxis gadaxdis dros aranair qvelmoqme-debas adgili ar hqonia. mowmem ganmarta: `ra qvelmoqme-deba, ris qvelmoqmedeba, dResac vixdi mag valebs. Cem-Tvis 60 000 60 milioniviT aris.~
8. mowme a. t-am ganmarta, rom rogorc Svilisgan _ j. t-sgan icis, sasamarTlomde erTi kviriT adre 60 000 Seitanamegobris saxeliT. manve ganmarta, rom vinaidan samni iy-vnen mogvianebiT am fulSi `gaswordnen~, Tumca umetesinawili misi iyo.
9. mowme m. w-am daadastura a. t-as naTqvami da ganmarta,rom manqanaSi elodeboda j-s, rodesac es ukanaskneliprokuraturaSi iyo Sesuli mosalaparakeblad. j-i rom ga-movida prokuraturidan, gamoitana angariSis nomeri, ro-melzec ewera `s-i~ da uTxra, rom saRamomde unda Seetana60 000, oRond gaafrTxiles, rom Tavisi saxeliT ara. amismere j-is saxlSi wavidnen, sadac man aiRo fuli, Tumcacota akldeboda, s-Si meti veRar iSova da naTesavs dau-reka q-Si da iq wavidnen. mere Seitanes saqarTvelos ban-kSi miTiTebul angariSze. prokuroris SekiTxvaze qvel-moqmedebis mizniT xom ar gadauricxavs Tanxa, mowmem gan-marta, rom pirvelad esmoda aRniSnulis Taobaze. mowmem
211
aseve ganmarta, rom rodesac isini bankSi Tanxas ricxav-dnen molare-operatoris kiTxvaze, Tu risi fuli iyo es,maT uTxres, rom saproceso SeTanxmebisTvis iyo gankuT-vnili, man ki ganucxada, rom es ar iyo saprocesos Tanxa damiTiTebuli angariSi kerZo kompanias ekuTvnoda. dacvismxaris kiTxvaze mowmem ganmarta, rom j-ma uTxa, rom dRisbolomde unda SeetanaT Tanxa Tu undoda, rom mamamisis-Tvis saproceso gaeformebinaT.
10. mowme l. x-as CvenebiT, rodesac s-is prokuroradgadaiyvanes e.w. `sigaretebis~ saqme warmarTuli iyo sasa-marTloSi. r. a-am daibara igi da uTxra, rom am saqmeze sap-roceso unda gaeformebina Semdegi pirobebiT _ pirobiTimsjavri da jarima 150 000 lari. aRniSnuli saubridan ram-denime dReSi daureka m-ma (a-as moadgilem) da uTxra, romsaprocesoze rom iyvnen SeTanxmebuli `sigaretebis~ saq-meze nawili biujetSi gaeSva da nawili angariSs gaugzav-nida da im angariSze Caricxuliyo (60 000 larze iyo sauba-ri). Semdeg daibara erT-erTi braldebulis ojaxis wevrida auxsna situacia; l. x-as ganmartebiT, rom gaigo bral-debulis Svilma rom uformebdnen saprocesos, sixaruliTdaTanxmda SeTavazebul pirobas. wavida da moitana qvi-Tari. mowmis ganmartebiT, jarimis odenoba TiToeulbraldebulze 30 000 iyo. qviTari rom miutanes, n. m-s Cau-tana z-Si da misca. n-ma uTxra, rom es 60 000 a-Si patriar-qis rezidenciis asaSeneblad iyo gamiznuli. garkveuliperiodis mere, r-Tanac hqonda am Temaze saubari da manacuTxra, rom sapatriarqosTvis iyo es fuli.
11. mowme n. m-is Cvenebis mixedviT, r. a-as moadgiledmuSaobda. l-s saqmeze axsovs is faqti, rom mdivani Sevidar-i geZaxiso, oTaxSi iyo k-as meuRle da f. S-a, romelicyvela moqalaqis miRebas eswreboda. r-im uTxra, rom sap-roceso formdeboda da saprocesos angariSis nomeri mie-ca; manve uTxra, rom m. e-as survili hqonda, monawileobamieRo patriarqis rezidenciis mSeneblobaSi da gadaecamisTvis Sps `s-is~ angariSic. Sps `s-is~ buRaltrisgan Se-ityo angariSis nomeri, Seitana r-sTan da gadasca bral-debulis meuRles. meore Tu mesame dRes miutana qviTre-bi, madloba gadauxada da wavida. amis mere gauformda l-as saproceso SeTanxmeba. e.w. `sigaretebis~ saqmezec r-imuTxra saproceso formdebao. ris merec daureka x-s dauTxra, rom saproceso gaeformebinaT 90 000 larze da Tan
212
daayola, rom 60 000 lari Sps `s-is~ angariSze gadaexdevi-nebina, radgan maT survili hqondaT daxmarebodnen sapat-riarqos. es naTqvami gadasca x-as da mere am ukanasknelmamiutana mas qviTrebi.
12. mowme s. g-am aCvena, rom aris Sps `s-is~ damfuZnebe-li da 60 procentiani wilis mflobeli. r. a-as icnobs, mag-ram arc naTesavia misi da arc megobari. vinaidan misi kom-pania axorcielebda samSeneblo samuSaoebs da saTanadoteqnikac hqonda, a-am hkiTxa SeZlebda Tu ara z-Si patri-arqis rezidenciis aSenebas, razec dadebiTi pasuxi gasca.amis Semdeg Sps `s-is~ angariSze ori piris mier Cairicxa210 000 lari. r-im uTxra mag fuls xeli ar axloo, savarau-dod, Seni asaSenebeli iqneba patriarqis rezidenciao.prokuroris kiTxvaze, Tu ratom ar aSenda rezidencia, s-a g-am aRniSna, rom aravis dauvalebia da imitom. mowmisganmartebiT, Sps `s-is~ TveSi samidan xuT milionamdebrunva hqonda. sameurneo xarjebisaTvis brunavda fulida xmardeboda firmis interesebs. sad gaixarja zemoxse-nebuli 210 aTasi lari, ar icis. dReis mdgomareobiT, val-debuleba aqvs, rac Cairicxa ukan unda daabrunos, radganar ganuxorcielebia aranairi samuSao.
13. mowme g. b-as CvenebiT, rogorc misTvis cnobilia,megobruli urTierToba hqondaT r-is da s-as. unaxavs a-amosuli `s-iSi~. misTvis ar aris cnobili Tu sapatriarqosrezidencia unda aeSenebina maT kompanias. sastumro `o-ss-Si~, romelic maTi aSenebulia, midioda xolme mSeneblo-bis periodSi r-i s-sTan. maT sastumroSi saaxalwlo suf-ra hqoniaT da dabadebis dReebic aRuniSnavT.
14. mowme g. J-is CvenebiT, sakuTrebaSi hqonda sigare-tis mwarmoebeli danadgarebi da biWebze (t-a, x-a, k-i) hqon-da miqiravebuli, sxva araferi akavSirdebda maTTan. W-ismeufe p-sTan hqonda axlo urTierToba. mas k-is axlob-lebma sTxoves, rom meufesTan misuliyo da eTxova am bi-WebisTvis daxmarebis aRmoCena. meufe Sehpirda, rom yve-lafers ecdeboda. amis Semdeg ar gasula didi dro da ga-formda saproceso SeTanxmeba. man am saqmeSi 60 000 lariTmiiRo monawileoba. rogorc icis, es fuli gadairicxa re-zidenciis mSeneblobisTvis. yovel SemTxvevaSi, man k-s esfuli am mizniT gadasca. Tumca _ vin, sad, rodis da rogorCaricxa ar icis, man ubralod fuli misca.
boda r-sTan. m. e-Tan Sexvedrasac eswreboda. r-ma m-as uT-xra, rom Seiswavlida misi meuRlis saqmes da acnobebda.Semdeg Sexvedraze r-im Tanxmoba rom uTxra, Zalian gau-xarda, daloca r-i da madlobebi uxada. r-im uTxra m-s,rom saproceso formdeboda da angariSis nomeri Seetana.m-am aseve Tqva Sexvedraze, rom Zalian eklesiurebi iy-vnen da icodnen, rom Sendeboda eklesia da daxmarebissurvili gamoTqva. r-is miTiTebiT, n-ma Seutana angariSisnomeri. mowmem ganmarta, rom m- e-sTvis gadaxdis qviTre-bis motana aravis dauvalebia. manve daadastura, rom m- e-sa da a-as yvela Sexvedras eswreboda.
16. mowme v. l-as CvenebiT, misTvis cnobilia k. l-sTansaproceso SeTanxmebis gaformebis Taobaze. icis isic, rommisi ojaxis wevrebi qvelmoqmedebaSi iRebdnen monawile-obas. gaTavisuflebis Semdeg igi SemTxveviT Sexvda l-as,romelic kmayofilebas gamoxatavda misi da misi megobre-bis gaweuli qvelmoqmedebis gamo. rac Seexeba t-as, mas t-as axloblebma sTxoves, rekomendacia gaewia maTTvis r-sTan, Tumca, mas arc ucdia amis gakeTeba, radganac icodar-is damokidebuleba aseT sakiTxebTan. erT-erTi trape-zis dros meufem hkiTxa a-s, Tu sad SeiZleboda reziden-ciisTvis Sewirulobis Caricxva, razec r-im upasuxa, romam sakiTxze mis moadgiles gasaubrebodnen. mowmem ganmar-ta, rom samegreloSi bevri mSenebloba mimdinareobda, ro-melsac r-d a-a xelmZRvanelobda; igi aqtiurad monawile-obda eklesiebis mSenebloba-reabilitaciis procesSi, ris-Tvisac jildoc daimsaxura patriarqisgan.
17. mowme e. g-as CvenebiT, mas kargad axsovs is faqti,rom patriarqma samegreloSi vizitisas r. a-as meufesTanerTad dauZaxa da rezidenciis mSeneblobis xelmZRvane-loba SesTavaza.
18. mowme i. k-ma ganacxada, rom muSaobs SemosavlebissamsaxurSi mTavar auditad da prokuroris Sesabamisi dad-genilebis safuZvelze, saqarTvelos mTavar prokuratu-raSi Seamowma Sps `s-is~ dokumentacia da gasca saTanadodaskvna. Sps `s-is~ angariSze Caricxuli 150 000 lari da 60000 lari gamotanili da gaxarjulia Sps `s-is~ samewarmeomiznebisaTvis.
19. mowme e. j-as CvenebiT 2003 wlidan 2014 wlis dekem-bris CaTvliT iyo Sps ̀ s-is~ mTavari buRalteri, xolo dam-fuZnebeli da direqtori iyo s. g-a. 2009 wlis dekemberSi
214
Sps `s-is~ angariSze Cairicxa 150 000 lari da 60 aTasi, jam-Si 210 aTasi lari. Camricxvelebi iyvnen w-i da w-a. firmisxelmZRvaneli gankargavs angariSebs, is akontrolebsbrunvas. firmis direqtori wyvets, sad, risTvis da ram-dens gaxarjavs sameurneo xarjebisaTvis. rogorc axsovs,zemoxsenebuli Tanxa maleve iqna aTvisebuli samSeneblosamuSaoebis warmoebis procesSi, anu firmisTvis gaixar-ja. Tanxebis gadaricxva xdeboda oficialurad bankiT daaranair Sav buRalterias adgili ar hqonia. Tanxebi xelzearc aravis gadaucia da arc miuRia. direqtors ar uTqvamsmisTvis, rom es Tanxebi ar unda aesaxa da arc etyoda amas,Zalian mowesrigebuli iyo. adasturebs, rom 210 aTasi la-ri asaxuli iyo baraTze. wi-s da wo-s mxridan am Tanxis ukangaTxovis moTxovna ar yofila. Tavidan ar icoda da Sem-deg gaigo, rom aRniSnuli Tanxebi rezidenciis mSeneblo-bas unda moxmareboda. televiziiT gaJRerda, rom patri-arqis rezidencia unda aSenebuliyo.
20. r. a-am ar cno Tavi damnaSaved misTvis wardgenilibraldebis arc erT epizodSi da ganmarta, rom 2009 wlismdgomareobiT, muSaobda saqarTvelos mTavari prokura-turis s- -is saolqo prokuroris Tanamdebobaze da misimuSaobis periodSi saproceso SeTanxmeba namdvilad ga-formda msjavrdebulebTan _ k. l-sa da a. t-sTan. igi samu-Sao oTaxSi marto aravis xvdeboda da mis Sexvedras moqa-laqeebTan yovelTvis eswreboda prokurori m. S-a. m. e-s,pirveli Sexvedrisas, romelsac aseve eswreboda m. S-a,dahpirda, rom gaerkveoda situaciaSi da daukavSirdebo-da. xolo meored, mas Semdeg rac xelmZRvanelobisgan da-debiTi pasuxi miiRo, auwya, rom formdeboda saprocesoSeTanxmeba. rogorc ki m. e-m sakiTxis dadebiTad gadaw-yvetis Sesaxeb gaigo, ise gauxarda, ar icoda madloba ro-gor gadaexada. rodesac dawynarda ganacxada, rom misTviscnobili iyo patriarqis davalebis Sesaxeb da surda, misojaxsac mieRo monawileoba a-Si patriarqis mosasvenebe-li odis mSeneblobaSi, ris gamoc dauZaxa m-s da daavala`s-is~ angariSis nomris Setana. prokuroris kiTxvaze, Tuvin gadawyvita Tanxis odenoba, mowmem ganmarta, rom ama-ze saubari ar hqoniaT da TviTon gadawyvites. mowmem gan-marta aseve, rom qviTrebis motana aravis uTxovia e-sTvisda rato miitana misTvis ucnobia. rac Seexeba t-s, igi maTsaerTod ar icnobs da kontaqti ar hqonia. m-sgan flobs
215
informacias, rom maT undodaT saproceso garigeba da masSemdeg, rac sakiTxi gadawyda dadebiTad, Tavadve gamoT-qves qvelmoqmedebis survili. prokuroris kiTxvaze, Turatom SeirCa konkretulad Sps `s-i~, mowmem ganmarta, romSps `s-i~ monawileobda mSeneblobSi da amitom gadawydaTanxebis akumulacia mis angariSze momxdariyo. manve daa-dastura, rom raime xelSekruleba Sps - `s-sTan~ aRniSnu-lis Taobaze ar iyo da Tu gadawyvetda sapatriarqo, merealbaT gaaformebda xelSekrulebasac. misi ganmartebiT,jer kidev seqtemberSi, roca patriarqi wabrZanda, manhkiTxa s. g-as, miiRebda Tu ara monawileobas mSenebloba-Si, razec dadebiTi pasuxi miiRo. `s-i~ muSaobda a-Si, axor-cielebda samSeneblo samuSaoebs da amitom SesTavaza maT.prokuroris kiTxvaze Tu ratom ar aSenda oda da ra moi-moqmeda mas Semdeg, a-m ganmarta, rom sapatriarqos undagaekeTebina proeqti da ar gaakeTa, xolo Tanxebze g-asuTxra, rom ar gaexarja.
21. saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kodeq-sis 259-e muxlis 1-li nawilis Tanaxmad sasamarTlos gana-Ceni unda iyos kanonieri, dasabuTebuli da samarTliani.amave muxlis me-3 nawilis Tanaxmad, ganaCenSi Camoyalibe-buli yvela daskvna da gadawyvetileba dasabuTebuli un-da iyos. sakasacio palata zemoaRniSnuli mtkicebulebe-bis Sefasebis Sedegad mivida daskvnamde, rom gasaCivre-buli ganaCeni dausabuTebelia, pirveli da saapelacio in-stanciis sasamarTloebma araswori samarTlebrivi Sefa-seba misces braldebis mxaris mier wardgenil da sasamar-Tlo sxdomaze gamokvleul utyuar da urTierTSejere-bul mtkicebulebebs, romlebic sakmarisia r. a-is braladSeracxuli qmedebebis gonivrul eWvs miRma standartiTdasadastureblad.
22. sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba gasaCivrebuli gana-Cenis daskvnas imis Sesaxeb, TiTqos braldebis orive epi-zodSi dazaralebulebma TavianTi surviliT gaswies qvel-moqmedeba _ vinaidan, mowmeebis _ ma. e-as, k. l-as, i. x-as, a.p-as, g. w-is, j. t-as, a. t-sa da m. w-as CvenebebiT erTmniS-vnelovnad gamoiricxeba saapelacio palatis aRniSnulimsjeloba. xsenebulma mowmeebma sasamarTlo sxdomaze ka-tegoriulad uaryves Tanxebis qvelmoqmedebis mizniT ga-Rebis faqti da mkafiod ganmartes, rom Tanxebi saproce-so SeTanxmebis gasaformeblad gadaixades.
veli ar gaaCnia dazaralebulTa Cvenebebis sisworeSi, vi-naidan isini Tanmimdevrul da saqmeSi arsebul sxva mtki-cebulebebTan Tanxvedril Cvenebebs iZlevian. metic, sa-kasacio palatas miaCna, rom m. e-a, romelic dRemde kmayo-filia imiT, rom misi meuRle gamouSves sasjelaRsrule-bis dawesebulebidan da amisTvis madlieria r. a. (rac mansasamarTlo sxdomaze daadastura), sruliad aralogiku-ria cdilobdes r. a-vis pasuxismgeblobis damZimebas, pi-riqiT palatas darCa gancda, rom man yvelanairad scadaSeerbilebina Cveneba r. a-s sasargeblod.
26. zemoaRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, sakasacio pala-ta aseve ar iziarebs r. a-sa da m. S-as Cvenebebs, sadac isiniaRniSnaven TiTqos, m. e-am rodesac gaigo, rom mis meuR-les saproceso SeTanxmebas ukeTebdnen, sixarulisganaRar icoda ra eqna da gamoTqva survili fuli Caericxaqvelmoqmedebis mizniT _ vinaidan, dazaralebulma uCve-na, rom mis pirvel Sexvedras r. a-Tan ar eswreboda aravin,arc meore Sexvedrisas daadastura man m. S-as oTaxSi yof-nis faqti. rac Seexeba r. a-as Cvenebas, igi aseve aradama-jerebelia, vinaidan yovelgvar logikasaa moklebuli pir-ma qvelmoqmedebis mizniT gadawyvitos im Tanxis gadaxda,romelic mas ar gaaCnia da unda iSovos. m. e-ac da j. t-sacdasWirdaT am Tanxebis moZieba axloblebsa da megobreb-Si, am ukanasknelis ganmartebiT ki igi dRemde valebs ix-dis. aseve palatisTvis yovlad gaugebria ratom dauma-lavdnen m. e. da j. t. TavianT axloblebs, rom qvelmoqme-debas eweodnen da ratom moatyuebdnen, rom aRniSnuliTanxebi saproceso SeTanxmebis gasaformeblad da Sesa-bamisad, maTi ojaxis wevrebis sapatimro dawesebulebi-dan gamosayvanad iyo saWiro. am sakiTxTan dakavSirebiTsakasacio palata aanalizebs aseve mowme v. l-as Cveneba-sac, sadac igi aRniSnavs, rom man naxa k. l., romelic kmayo-filebas gamoxatavda misi ojaxisa da megobrebis mier qvel-moqmedebis gawevis gamo. Tumca, palata ver gaiziarebs mow-me l-s am ganmartebas, da k. l-as damokidebulebas aRniS-nuli sakiTxis mimarT kmayofilebad ver ganixilavs, vina-idan man sasamarTlo procesze Cvenebis micemisas mkafi-od aRniSna, rom Tavs davalebulad grZnobs megobrebiswinaSe misTvis gaweuli daxmarebis gamo.
218
27. saapelacio palata usafuZvlod ayenebs eWvqveS imfaqts, rom Sps `...-~ angariSze Caricxuli 60 000 lari t-sojaxs ekuTvnoda. aRniSnulis argumentad palata iSve-liebs mxolod g. J-is Cvenebis im nawils, sadac mowme acxa-debs, rom 60 000 lari gaiRes man da k-ma da rogorc icoda,es Tanxa rezidenciis mSeneblobisaTvis unda Caricxuli-yo da saprocesosTvis ar iyo gankuTvnili. sakasacio pa-lata yuradRebas miaqcevs a. t-as Cvenebas, sadac igi uTi-Tebs, rom vinaidan samni iyvnen braldebulebi, isini am sa-moci aTasSic `gaswordnen~ Tumca didi nawili misi ojaxisiyo. amasTan, palata miuTiTebs, rom k-s 30 000 lari saku-Tari jarimac hqonda gadasaxdeli saproceso SeTanxme-bis pirobis Tanaxmad. Sesabamisad, J-is Cveneba ar gamoric-xavs da winaaRmdegobaSi ar modis t-as CvenebasTan. metic,SesaZloa k-ma J-is mier micemuli Tanxa saerTodac piradimiznebisTvis gamoiyena. mxolod J-is gancxadeba, rom igiendoba k-s, palatisTvis ar warmoadgens utyuar dadas-turebas imisa, Tu rogor moiqceoda k., miT umetes imisgaTvaliswinebiT, rom Tavad J. acxadebs, rom man 60 000misca k-s, magram vin, ra, rodis da rogor gadaixada ar icis.xolo rac Seexeba j. t-as Cvenebas, igi Tanmimdevrulia daTanxvedraSia a. t-sa da m. w-as CvenebebTan da saqmis sxvamasalebTan, romelTa utyuarobaSi eWvis Setanis safuZ-veli palatas ar gaaCnia.
28. rogorc saqmis masalebiT da sasamarTlo proceszegamokvleuli mtkicebulebebiT dgindeba, orive SemTxve-vaSi Sps `...~ angariSze Tanxebi Caricxulia gareSe pirebismier (amasTan dakavSirebiT dazaralebuli j. t. aRniSnavs,rom s-is prokurorma l. x-am igi gaafrTxila, rom fuliTavis saxeliT ar Seetana. xolo, mowme g. w-ma Tavis Cvene-baSi ganmarta, rom m. e-am maT uTxra, rom prokuraturaSimas (m. e-as) uTxres, rom k-s megobrebs unda CaericxaT an-gariSze fuli). aqedan gamomdinare, sakasacio palatisTvissruliad gaugebari da aralogikuri xdeba dacvis mxarisversia moqalaqeTa mxridan `nebayoflobiTi qvelmoqme-debis~ Sesaxeb, maTive saxeliT Tanxis arSetanis pirobiT.
29. amrigad, sakasacio palatas dadasturebulad miaC-nia, rom braldebis arc erT epizodSi, dazaralebulebs150000 da 60000 lari sakuTari iniciativiT saqvelmoqme-do miznebisTvis ar CauricxavT. maT es Tanxebi saprocesoSeTanxmebis gaformebis sanacvlod gadaixades ...- proku-
219
roris _ r. a-as moTxovniT.30. rac Seexeba im sakiTxs, r. a-as mier xdeboda Tu ara
Tanxebis mobilizeba saqvelmoqmedo miznebisTvis; amas-Tan dakavSirebiT sakasacio palata iziarebs braldebismxaris pozicias da miaCnia, rom araviTari saqvelmoqmdomiznebi r. a-as am Tanxebis mobilizebisas ar hqonia da romigi piradi dainteresebiT moqmedebda. kerZod:
• saqmeSi ar moipoveba arc erTi oficialuri dokumen-ti, romelic daadasturebda s-os regionSi sapatriarqosrezidenciis mSeneblobis sakiTxTan dakavSirebiT Sesru-lebuli an Sesasrulebeli samuSaos Sesaxeb raime faqts;araviTari oficialuri xelSekruleba Sps `...Tan~ msgavsimSeneblobis ganxorcielebis Sesaxeb ar arsebobda; asevear warmodgenila raime mtkicebuleba imis Sesaxeb, rom ammSeneblobebis organizebaSi sasuliero pirebTan erTadaqtiur monawileobas iRebda r. a.. metic, saqmeSi warmod-genilia saqarTvelos sapatriarqos oficialuri gancxa-deba, romelSic naTqvamia, rom rezidenciis mSeneblobismimarTulebiT arc erTi realuri nabiji ar gadadgmula.
• sakasacio palatisTvis aradamajerebelia is faqtic,rom ori adamianis garda aravis gauCnda sapatriarqosTvisTanxis, Tundac Zalzed mcire odenobiT, Sewirvis survi-li. im pirobebSi, rodesac (Tu dacvis mxaris versias gavi-ziarebT), am yvelafris xelmZRvaneloba daevala ...—pro-kuror r. a-as sasuliero pirTan erTad. amitom palata vergaiziarebs dacvis mxaris pozicias TiTqos, Sps `...~ xdebo-da sapatriarqosTvis rezidenciis asaSeneblad Tanxebisakumulireba da am ukanasknelma amitom miiRo aRniSnuliSemowirulobebi.
31. r. a-as marTlac rom hqonoda survili saqvelmoqme-do miznebisTvis Tanxebis akumulireba moexdina Sps `......~angariSze, aRniSnuli mainc ver gamoricxavda mis sisxlis-
220
samarTlebriv pasuxismgeblobas, vinaidan sakasacio pala-ta miuTiTebs, rom saqarTvelos ssk-is 333-e muxliT gaTva-liswinebuli danaSaulebrivi qmedebis kvalifikaciisTvismniSvneloba ar eniWeba im faqts, Tu ra mizniT (raoden ke-TilSobiluric ar unda iyos es mizani) moxdeba bralde-bulTa axloblebis mxridan Tanxebis gadaxda an raime sxvapirobis Sesruleba. saproceso SeTanxmebis gaformebisas,SeTanxmebis yvela piroba unda iyos asaxuli saproceso Se-Tanxmebis oqmsa da SuamdgomlobaSi. Txovna, moTxona an Se-Tavazeba imisa, rac ar aris asaxuli oqmsa da Suamdgomlo-baSi _ erTmniSvnelovnad warmoadgens kanonsawinaaRmde-go qmedebas. sakasacio palatas aseve miaCnia, rom saproce-so SeTanxmebis gaformebis sakiTxze molaparakebis warmo-ebisas sajaro moxeles (mocemul SemTxvevaSi prokurors)marTebs gansakuTrebuli sifrTxile da gulisxmiereba, rommolaparakebis procesSi ar dauSvas damatebiT raime iseTsakiTxze msjeloba, romelic scildeba saproceso SeTan-xmebis farglebs, raTa mxarem ar aRiqvas igi saproceso Se-Tanxmebis miRwevis damatebiT pirobad.
32. saproceso SeTanxmebis qarTuli modeli ar iTva-liswinebs im SemTxvevebs, rodesac xelisuflebis orga-noebs saproceso SeTanxmebisas SeuZliaT braldebulsSesTavazon Tanxis gadaxda saqvelmoqmedo miznebisTvis.saqarTvelos sisxlis samarTlis saproceso kanonmdeblo-biT, saproceso SeTanxmeba, romelic ideba braldebisa dadacvis mxares Soris, mtkicdeba sasamarTlos mier, saqmisarsebiTi ganxilvis gareSe ganaCenis dadgeniT. mosamar-Tle saproceso SeTanxmebis Sesaxeb gadawyvetilebasiRebs kanonis safuZvelze. sakasacio palata xazs usvamsim garemoebasac, rom dauSvebelia mxarisTvis winaswar ra-ime valdebulebis Sesrulebis moTxovna (magaliTad ja-rimis gadaxdevineba) manam sanam sasamarTlo kanoniT dad-genili wesiT ar imsjelebs mxareebs Soris miRweuli Se-Tanxmebis kanonierebsa da samarTlianobaze.
33. adamianis uflebaTa evropulma sasamarTlom ara-erT gadawyvetilebaSi ganmarta, rom saproceso SeTanxme-bis instituti Tavisi arsiT ar ewinaaRmdegeba adamianisuflebaTa evropuli konvenciis standartebs. amasTan sa-samarTlo xazs usvams im garemoebasac, rom saproceso Se-Tanxmeba ar unda iyos iZulebis Sedegi da sasamarTlianisasamarTlo ganxilvis uflebaze uaris Tqma ar unda ewi-
221
naaRmdegebods mniSvnelovan sajaro interess. evropu-li sasamarTlo am konteqstSi yuradRebas amaxvilebs sap-roceso SeTanxmebis jerovani da efeqturi sasamarTlokontrolis mniSvnelobaze.
34. adamianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlos zemo-aRniSnuli midgoma cxadyofs Tu raoden mniSvnelovania,saproceso SeTanxmebis oqmSi aisaxos mxareebs Soris miR-weuli yvela piroba, rom is sasamarTlo gadasinjvas daeq-vemdebaros sasamarTlos mier mxareebs Soris miRweuliSeTanxmebisa da molaparakebis kanonierebisa da samar-Tlianobis jerovnad Semowmebis mizniT.
41. dazaralebulebs: m. e-sa da j. t-as ganemartoT, k. l-sa da a. t-is gamamtyunebeli ganaCeniT damatebiTi sasje-lis saxiT dakisrebuli jarimis garda (k. l-as quTaisis sa-apelacio sasamarTlos 2009 wlis 25 dekembris ganaCeniTdaekisra jarima _ 10 000 lari, xolo a. t-as senakis raio-nuli sasamarTlos 2009 wlis 29 dekembris ganaCeniT dae-kisra jarima _ 30 000 lari) sxva _ Sps `...~ angariSze gadax-dili Tanxebis _ 150 000 larisa (k. l-as epizodi) da 60 000laris (a. t-as epizodi) kanonmdeblobiT dadgenili wesiTmoTxovnis uflebis Taobaze.
42. rac Seexeba sasjels, sakasacio palatas, misi asaki-sa da imis gaTvaliswinebiT, rom r. a-as ar gaaCnia pasuxis-mgeblobis damamZimebeli garemoebebi da pirveladaa sa-marTlaSi, mizanSewonilad ar miaCnia misTvis sasjelis sa-xiT Tavisuflebis aRkveTis Sefardeba da Tvlis, rom ja-rima srulad uzrunvelyofs sasjelis miznebis ganxor-cielebas.
9. saqmeze saboloo gadawyvetilebis miRebis Semdegsaqmeze arsebuli nivTieri mtkicebulebebi: operatiul-samZebro RonisZiebis amsaxveli faruli audio da video-Canaweri 6 DVD diskze, r. c-s mier warmodgenili audioCa-naweri erT diskze, j. S-s mier warmodgenili videoCanawe-ri erT diskze, garesaTvalTvalo kameris mier aRbeWdiliinformacia erT diskze Senaxul unda iqnes sisxlis sa-marTlis saqmesTan erTad saqmis Senaxvis vadiT; avtoman-qanis Cxrekis Sedegad amoRebuli fuladi Tanxa _ 27000lari, romelic inaxeba saqarTvelos erovnul bankSi undadaubrundes mesakuTres an mis mier saamisod uflebamo-
227
sil pirs; r. c-s mier warmodgenili fuladi Tanxa _ 3000lari, romelic inaxeba saqarTvelos erovnul bankSi undadaubrundes mesakuTres an mis mier saamisod uflebamo-sil pirs; a. c-s piradi Cxrekisas amoRebuli 10 lari undadaubrundes mesakuTres an mis mier saamisod uflebamo-sil pirs; avtomanqanidan amoRebuli mobiluri telefo-ni simbaraTiT da piradobis mowmoba unda daubrundes me-sakuTres an mis mier saamisod uflebamosil pirs; r. k-spiradi Cxrekisas amoRebuli metromanis baraTi da savi-zito baraTi unda daubrundes mesakuTres an mis mier sa-amisod uflebamosil pirs.
11. r. c-m r. k-e gaicno a. c-s meSveobiT, romlisganacgaigo, rom ... municipalitetis teritoriaze miwis nakve-Tebi iyo gasayidi da myidvels daexmareboda miwis nakve-Tebis yidvaSi SeRavaTiani pirobebiT. 2013 wlis ivlisSi r.c-e daukavSirda a. c-s da acnoba, rom investors surdamiwis nakveTis yidva da Tu daexmarebodnen, investoris-gan miiRebdnen fulad sargebels. a. c-m aRuTqva mas dax-mareba. igi daukavSirda r. k-s da moaxsena zemoaRniSnuli.r. k-m, miuxedavad imisa, rom mis uSualo uflebamosile-baSi ar Sedioda miwis sakiTxis gadawyveta, daudastura a.c-s, rom mas SeeZlo aRniSnuli sakiTxis mogvarebaSi dax-marebis gaweva da uTxra, rom gasayidi iyo 6000 kv.m miwisnakveTi da SeeZlo moegvarebina ise, rom SeRavaTiani pi-robebiT eyida. kerZod, Tu sabazro fasi iyo 120 aSS dola-ri, igi 1 kv.m miwis nakveTs gayidda 55 larad. r. k-m daxma-rebis sanacvlod moiTxova misTvis 20 laris gadaxda 1kv.m-ze, anu 6000 kv.m-ze _ 120.000 lari, Tumca mas TanxasTandakavSirebiT investorTan aranairi urTierToba ar undahqonoda. es sakiTxi unda moegvarebina a. c-s. r. k-e ram-denjerme Sexvda a. c-s, aseve r. c-s, ra drosac maT Sorissaubari gaimarTa gasayidi miwis Taobaze da aqedan gamom-
228
dinare, misTvis gadasacem Tanxaze. 2013 wlis 20 ivlissoperatiul-samZebro RonisZiebis farglebSi r. c-m a. c-sgadasca r. k-s mier moTxovnili Tanxis nawili _ 30.000 la-ri r. k-saTvis gadasacemad.
16. kasatori miiCnevs, rom saqmeze arsebuli mtkicebu-lebebiT utyuarad dasturdeba, rom r. k-s gaaCnia is uf-lebamosileba, rac daexmareboda mas zemoaRniSnuli da-naSaulis CadenaSi.
17. r. k-s mxridan saxeze gvaqvs qrTamis aReba, rogorc
230
misi samsaxureobrivi uflebamosilebis, aseve misi Tanam-debobrivi avtoritetis gamoyenebiT.
18. ar unda iqnes gaziarebuli sasamarTlos poziciaimasTan dakavSirebiT, rom r. k-s mxridan sxva Tanamdebo-bis pirebze aramarTlzomieri zegavlenis moxdena Sefa-sebul iqnes rogorc zegavleniT vaWroba. mniSvnelovaniais garemoeba, rom r. k-e sxva pirebze zemoqmedebas geg-mavs misi Tanamdebobidan gamomdinare, rogorc sakrebu-los Tavmjdomaris moadgile da es zemoqmedeba maTzeganpirobebulia swored misi maRali TanamdebobiT, racakuTvnebs am danaSauls qrTamis aRebis Semadgenlobas daara zegavleniT vaWrobas, ra drosac zegavleniT movaWreiyenebs ara mis Tanamdebobas aramed megobrul an naTesa-ur kavSirs.
19. msjavrdebuli a. c-e da misi interesebis damcveli,advokati v. t-a sakasacio saCivrebiT iTxoven Tbilisis sa-apelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa pala-tis 2016 wlis 28 ianvris ganaCenis gauqmebasa da a. c-s ga-marTlebas.
Si operatiuli muSakis CarTvis Sesaxeb dadgenilebaSi fiq-tiurad aris miTiTebuli s. j-s legendirebiT CarTvis mi-zan-amocanebi, vinaidan faruli miyuradebiT satelefonosaubrebSi 12 piri figurirebs da arcerTis vianoba ar yo-fila dadgenili gamoZiebis mier.
21. msjavrdebuli r. k-e da misi interesebis damcveli,advokati e. l-i sakasacio saCivriT iTxoven Tbilisis saa-pelacio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis2016 wlis 28 ianvris ganaCenis gauqmebasa da r. k-s gamar-Tlebas.
samotivacio nawili:1. sakasacio palata saqmis masalebis Seswavlis, sakasa-
cio saCivrebis moTxovnebis gacnobis, saqmeSi arsebulimtkicebulebebis yovelmxriv, srulad da obieqturad Se-mowmebis Sedegad mivida im daskvnamde, rom prokurorelizbar gozaliSvilis sakasacio saCivari unda dakmayo-fildes nawilobriv, msjavrdebul a. c-sa da misi intere-
232
sebis damcvelis, advokat v. t-s, msjavrdebul r. k-sa damisi interesebis damcvelis, advokat e. l-s sakasacio sa-Civrebi ar unda dakmayofildes, xolo Tbilisis saapela-cio sasamarTlos sisxlis samarTlis saqmeTa palatis 2016wlis 28 ianvris ganaCenSi unda Sevides cvlileba SemdeggaremoebaTa gamo:
2. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba saapelacio sasamarTlosmosazrebas, rom msjavrdebulebis _ r. k-sa da a. c-s saka-sacio saCivrebis moTxovna maTi gamarTlebis Taobaze arisusafuZvlo da ar gamomdinareobs saqmis masalebidan. sa-kasacio palata iziarebs agreTve saxelmwifo bralmdeb-lis pozicias imis Taobaze, rom msjavrdebulebis _ r. k-sada a. c-s qmedebebebs 1-li instanciisa da saapelacio sasa-marTloebis mier miecaT araswori samarTlebrivi kvali-fikacia.
3. dacvis mxaris _ msjavrdebulebis _ r. k-sa da a. c-s damaTi advokatebis pozicias imis Taobaze, rom gasaCivre-buli ganaCeni ukanono da dausabuTebelia im Tvalsazri-siT, rom maT ar CaudeniaT aranairi danaSauli, xolo si-namdvileSi adgili hqonda danaSaulis provokacias da, aqe-dan gamomdinare, maT ukanono da dausabuTebel msjavrde-bas, sakasacio palata ver gaiziarebs, radgan aseTi pozi-ciis dasadastureblad saqmeSi ar moipoveba saamisod sa-Wiro mtkicebulebaTa erToblioba.
4. saqmis masalebiT dadasturebulia, rom r. k-e 2012wlidan muSaobda ... municipalitetis sakrebulos Tav-mjdomaris moadgiled. amasTanave is aseve warmoadgenda... municipalitetis sakuTrebaSi arsebuli qonebis gankar-gvis auqcionis organizebis saauqciono komisiis Tavmjdo-maris moadgiles. saapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCeniT dad-genilad aris miCneuli, rom r. k-e, romlis samsaxurebrivisaqmianobis sferoSi Sedioda ..... municipalitetis sakuT-rebaSi arsebuli miwis nakveTis privatizebis sakiTxi, 2013wlis ivlisSi, Tavis nacnob a. c-sTan erTad, Sexvda r. c-s,romelmac ganucxada, rom misi nacnobi biznesmeni, vinme`g.~, dainteresebuli iyo ... municipalitetSi miwis nakve-Tis SeZeniT. r. k-m, a. c-sTan erTad, winaswari SeTanxme-biT, Tavisi samsaxurebrivi uflebamosilebis Sesrulebi-sas, ganizraxa gansakuTrebiT didi odenobiT Tanxis aRe-ba. am mizniT r. k-m r. c-s SesTavaza ..... municipalitetissakuTrebaSi arsebuli 6000 kv.m miwis nakveTi, romlis Se-
233
Zenis survilis arsebobis SemTxvevaSi, Tavisi Tanamdebob-rivi avtoritetis gamoyenebiT, xsenebuli investoris sa-sargeblod gadawydeboda aRniSnuli miwis nakveTis gas-xvisebis sakiTxi. saamisod man moiTxova misTvis Tanxis _120000 laris gadaxda, xolo am Tanxis misTvis gadacemaunda uzrunveleyo a. c-s anu am ukanasknels unda ekisraSuamavlis roli investoris mxriv aRniSnuli Tanxis gace-masa da r. k-s mier am Tanxis aRebaSi.
5. sakasacio palatas miaCnia, rom aRniSnuli faqtobri-vi garemoebebi dadasturebulia rogorc mowmeebis Cve-nebebiT, aseve operatiul-samZebro RonisZiebebiT mopo-vebuli mtkicebulebebiT. aRniSnuli operatiul-samZeb-ro RonisZiebebis ganxorcielebisas r. c-m a. c-s gadascar. k-s mier moTxovnili Tanxis nawili _ 30000 lari, rac amukanasknels unda mietana r. k-sTan.
6. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba dacvis mxaris po-zicias msjavrdebulTa udanaSaulobis Taobaze im safuZ-vliT, rom mowme r. c-e aris agent-provokatori, xolomsjavrdebulebis _ r. k-sa da a. c-s mimarT adgili hqondadanaSaulis provokacias. sakasacio palata aRniSnul po-zicias ar iziarebs Semdegi mosazrebebiT: saqmeSi aravi-Tari mtkicebuleba ar moipoveba imis dasadastureblad,rom mowme r. c-e moqmedebda rogorc agent-provokatori;operatiul-samZebro RonisZiebebis gamoyeneba samarTal-damcavi organoebis mxridan meqrTameobis saqmeebze, la-tenturi danaSaulis gamosavlenad operatiuli eqsperi-mentis saxiT, marTlzomieri qmedebaa da igi srulad gan-sxvavdeba provokaciisagan. danaSaulis gamosavlenad, aR-sakveTad da Tavidan asacileblad~ operatiul-samZebrosaqmianobis Sesaxeb~ kanonis Sesabamisad moqmedeba dam-naSaveTa mxilebis mizniT, kanonis mTavari amocanaa. r. c-e, romelsac danaSaulSi monawile pirebi (a. c-e da r. k-e)andoben danaSaulis Cadenis gadawyvetilebas, uxsnian fu-lis aRebis sqemas, aZleven rCeva-darigebas investorTan(moskovSi mcxovreb g-Tan) urTierTobisaTvis, erTad Ca-dian danaSauls-iReben da inawileben qrTamis saxiT SeTa-vazebul 30 000 lars, ver CaiTvleba danaSaulis provoka-torad. dacvis mxare apelirebs, rom mocemul SemTxveva-Si samarTaldamcavi organoebi r. c-s iyenebdnen rogorcfarul TanamSromels, romelsac ixsenieben agent-`...~. ada-mianis uflebaTa evropuli sasamarTlo Tavis erT-erT ga-
234
dawyvetilebaSi pirdapir miuTiTebs, rom faruli agentisgamoyeneba sagamoZiebo procesSi ar xelyofs evropulikonvenciis me-6 muxlis pirvel punqtSi dadgenil garan-tias. zogadad, faruli agentis mier piris waqezeba ar ga-moricxavs am ukanasknelis sisxlissamarTlebriv pasuxis-mgeblobas. danaSaulis provokacia ar aTavisuflebs pro-vocirebul pirs sisxlissamarTlebrivi pasuxismgeblo-bisgan materialur-samarTlebrivi TvalsazrisiT(Ramanauskas v. Lithuania, 74420/01, 2008 wlis 5 Tebervali).
7. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba dacvis mxaris mo-sazrebas imis Taobaze, rom r. c-e moqmedebda rogorc da-interesebuli piri, romelmac xelovnurad Seqmna TiTqos-da danaSaulis Cadenis viTareba, ris gamoc sasamarTlo-saTvis mis mier micemuli Cveneba, rac erT-erT safuZvladdaedo gamamtyunebel ganaCens, ar unda iqnes miRebulisarwmuno mtkicebulebad. sakasacio palata eTanxmeba sa-apelacio sasamarTlos msjelobas, romlis mixedviT, saq-meSi arsebuli mtkicebulebebiT utyuarad dadasture-bulia, rom r. c-e moqmedebda keTilsindisierad da misiTiToeuli nabiji ganpirobebuli iyo im motiviT, rom isSeeswro danaSaulis Cadenis faqts da sworad mis TaobazemimarTa samarTaldamcav organoebs.
8. dacvis mxaris warmomadgenlebs, cdiloben ra msjav-rdebulTa moqmedebebis gamarTlebas, TavianT sakasaciosaCivrebSi moaqvT calkeuli amonaridebi saqmeSi arsebu-li masalebidan mTliani konteqstidan amoRebuli calke-uli detalebis saxiT, romlebic TiTqos adastureben r.k-sa da a. c-s udanaSaulobas. magaliTad, r. k-s advokatiTavis sakasacio saCivarSi aRniSnavs: ... sakrebulodan ga-moTxovili sajaro informaciis mixedviT, ... pirvel zol-Si auqcioniT gasayidi miwis nakveTis erTi kvadratulimetris fasi iyo 54 lari. r. k-mac swored am fasad SesTava-za aRniSnul zolSi miwis nakveTis yidva investoris wamo-madgenels masTan molaparakebisas. dacvis mxare aseveuTiTebs farul CanawerebSi calkeuli saubrebis zogierTmomentze, sadac r. k-e eubneba a. c-s _ `investors qrTamsxom ar movTxov~; `xalxs xom daasaqmebs adgilobriv~; `qa-laqs xom gaalamazebs da damsveneblebs Camoiyvans~ da a.S.am SemTxvevaSi dacvis mxare mTlianad gverds uvlis saq-mis masalebSi dafiqsirebuli im saubrebis mTlian Sina-arss, romlebsac msjavrdebulebi awarmoebdnen rogorc
235
braldebis mowmeebTan _ r. c-sa da s. J-Tan, ise erTmaneT-Tan, xolo am saubrebis Sinaarsi utyuarad adasturebsmsjavrdebulTa danaSaulebriv ganzraxvebsa da maT Sesa-bamis qmedebebs.
9. garda aRniSnulisa, sakasacio palata yuradRebasamaxvilebs im garemoebazec, rom dacvis mxaris warmomad-geneli kasatorebi, msjavrdebulTa gamarTlebis mizniT,calkeul SemTxvevaSi mimarTaven saqmis faqtobrivi gare-moebebis aSkarad araswori rakursiT warmodgenas. maga-liTad, isini braldebis mowmeebTan warmoebul danaSau-lebriv molaparakebebSi msjavrdebulebis _ r. k-sa da a.c-s saubars imis Taobaze, rom investoris mier gadaxdiliTanxidan, kerZod, yoveli 100 laridan 20 lari rCeba maT,20 lari midis sxvebTan, xolo 60 lari warmoadgens saauq-cionod Sesatan Tanxas, ise ganmartaven, rom TiTqos aR-niSnuli saubari exeboda ara maTTvis gadasaxdel Tanxas,aramed auqcionze gasayidi miwis nakveTis _ 6000 kv.m. far-Tobis 20%-s, romelzec unda ganTavsebuliyo Senoba-na-gebobebi. sinamdvileSi saqme swored piriqiT iyo, radgansaubari exeboda Tanxis im wilebs, romelic msjavrdebu-lebs unda mieRoT rogorc Tavisi sargebeli investorismier gadaxdili mTliani Tanxidan. aRniSnuli kasatorebimiuTiTeben aseve imis Taobaze, rom rac Seexeba 30000 lars,romlis Taobazec farul CanawerebSia saubari da rome-lic amoRebul iqna operatiul-samZebro RonisZiebis Ca-tarebisas a. c-sgan, warmoadgenda investoris mier gamog-zavnil, auqcionis gamarTvasTan dakavSirebiT winaswar Se-satan Tanxas, rac sinamdviles ar Seesabameba. saqmeSi ar-sebuli sxva utyuari mtkicebulebebiT, romlebic mopo-vebulia operatiul-samZebro RonisZiebebiT, dadasture-bulia, rom aRniSnuli Tanxa msjavrdebulma a. c-m miiRo,rogorc r. k-sa da piradad misTvis gankuTvnili gasamrje-lo, miwis nakveTis SesaZenad gamarTul auqcionSi inves-torisaTvis saWiro daxmarebis gawevis sanacvlod. gardaaRniSnulisa, dacvis mxare aseve uTiTebs r. k-sa da a. c-sCvenebebze, romelTa mixedviT investoris warmomadgen-lebTan uSualo kontaqtisas maTi mxriv arc qrTamze daarc raime sxva Tanxaze saerTod saubaric ki ar yofila.garda amisa, isini miuTiTeben, rom farul CanawerebSi,romlebic sasamarTlom ZiriTad mtkicebulebebad gamoi-yena gamamtyunebeli ganaCenisaTvis, arsad araa dafiqsi-
236
rebuli r. k-s mier vinmesgan qrTamis an sxva raime materi-aluri sargeblis moTxovna. yovelive es, maTi ganmarte-biT, adasturebs imas, rom msjavrdebulebs araviTari da-naSaulebrivi ganzraxva ar amoZravebdaT. sinamdvileSi ka-nonieri gziT mopovebuli faruli CanawerebiT dastur-deba, rom r. k-e a. c-sa da r. c-sTan saubrisas acxadebs,rom misTvis gadasaxdel Tanxebsa da maT odenobaze Tvi-Ton investoris wamomadgenels ar daelaparakeboda, essakiTxi a. c-s unda moegvarebina.
10. msjavrdebul r. k-s advokati Tavis sakasacio saCi-varSi aRniSnavs, rom sasamarTlom mis winaaRmdeg bral-debis damadasturebel mtkicebulebad gamoiyena araav-Tenturi faruli audio-Canaweri, romlis Sesaxeb sasamar-TloSi dakiTxvisas eqspertma ganacxada, rom imis dadge-na, aRniSnuli Canaweri warmoadgens Tu ara montaJs, SeuZ-lebelia, radgan is araavTenturia. sakasacio palatas mi-aCnia, rom xsenebuli faruli audio-Canaweris Sinaarsisnamdviloba dasturdeba sxva faruli video-CanawerebiT,romelTa Sinaarsi sruliad udavod adasturebs im gare-moebas, rom msjavrdebulebi swored marTlsawinaaRmde-go miznebiTa da motivebiT axorcielebdnen TavianT da-naSaulebriv qmedebebs.
11. rac Seexeba msjavrdebul a. c-s advokatis _ v. t-ssakasacio saCivars, igi ZiriTadad eTmoba imis mtkicebas,rom msjavrdebulebis mimarT operatiul-samZebro Ronis-Ziebebi Catarda kanonis moTxovnaTa uxeSi darRvevebiT,ra drosac adgili hqonda faruli agentis _ r. c-s mierkanonis akrZaluli xerxebis gamoyenebas, kerZod, motyu-ebas, danaSaulebrivi viTarebis xelovnurad Seqmnas, ndo-bis borotad gamoyenebas, mtkicebulebaTa falsifikaci-as, masTan kontaqtSi myofi pirebis SecdomaSi Seyvanasada sxva msgavs qmedebebs msjavrdebulTa winaaRmdeg mtki-cebulebaTa falsifikaciis mizniT. manve SemdgomSi winas-war gamoZiebasa da sasamarTloSi misca aSkarad cru Cve-nebebi, rac mTlianobaSi gaxda r. k-sa da a. c-s ukanonomsjavrdebis erT-erTi ZiriTadi safuZveli. sakasacio pa-lata kasatoris amgvar pozicias ver daeTanxmeba, radgansaqmis masalebis SeswavliT dgindeba, rom msjavrdebul-Ta mimarT faruli Tu sxva sagamoZiebo moqmedebisas ka-nonmdeblobis arsebiT darRvevebs adgili ar hqonia. ase-ve, maTi braldebis saqmis rogorc 1-li instanciis, aseve
237
saapelacio sasamarTloSi ganxilvisas msjavrdebulTasaproceso uflebebis darRveva ar vlindeba. igive undaaRiniSnos msjavrdebul r. k-s advokatis mier sakasaciosaCivarSi ganviTarebul zogad msjelobebze maT mimarToperatiul-samZebro RonisZiebebisa da sagamoZiebo moq-medebebis ganxorcielebisas, agreTve sasamarTloebSi saq-mis ganxilvisas kanonierebis uxeSi darRvevebis Sesaxeb,radgan sakasacio sasamarTloSi aRniSnuli saqmis yovel-mxrivi, sruli da obieqturi SeswavliT kanonierebis rai-me arsebiTi darRvevebi ar dgindeba.
12. sakasacio palatam, Seiswavla ra braldebis mxariswarmomadgenlis, prokuror elizbar gozaliSvilis saka-sacio saCivris safuZvlebi da motivebi, miiCnia, rom aR-niSnuli saCivris moTxovna msjavrdebul r. k-s qmedebissaqarTvelos ssk-is 338-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `g~ da imavemuxlis me-3 nawilis `e~ qvepunqtze, xolo msjavrdebul a.c-s qmedebis aRniSnuli kodeqsis 25-e muxlze, agreTve338-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `g~ da imave muxlis me-3 nawilis`e~ qvepunqtze gadakvalificirebis Taobaze, unda dakma-yofildes nawilobriv Semdeg garemoebaTa gamo:
13. sakasacio palata ar eTanxmeba msjavrdebulebisqmedebebis im samarTlebriv Sefasebebs, rac mocemuliasaapelacio sasamarTlos ganaCenSi. saqmeSi arsebuli ut-yuari mtkicebulebebis erTobliobiT, romlebic mopove-bulia kanonieri gziT, dasturdeba, rom msjavrdebul r.k-s Cadenili aqvs ara zegavleniT vaWroba, aramed qrTamisaReba, ese igi moxelis mier pirdapir gansakuTrebiT didiodenobiT fulis moTxovna Tavis sasargeblod, raTa masTanamdebobrivi ufleba-movaleobebis Sesrulebisas sxvapiris sasargeblod ganexorcielebina qmedeba da gamoe-yenebina Tavisi Tanamdebobrivi avtoriteti analogiurimiznis misaRwevad, xolo msjavrdebul a. c-s Cadenili aqvsimave danaSaulSi Tanamonawileoba damxmaris saxiT.
14. sakasacio palata aRniSnavs, rom saapelacio sasa-marTlos mier saqmis faqtobrivi garemebebi sworad iqnadadgenili, Tumca maT miecaT araswori samarTlebrivi Se-faseba sisxlissamarTlebrivi kvalifikaciis Tvalsazri-siT. palata ganmartavs, rom im SemTxvevaSi, rodesac mo-xele Tavis samsaxurebriv uflebamosilebas iyenebs qrTa-mis mimcemis interesebis sasargeblod, adgili aqvs qrTa-mis aRebas, romelic damTavrebulia mis mier qrTamis moT-
16. amasTan, saapelacio sasamarTlos ganmartebiT, a. c-mCaidina daxmareba zegavleniT vaWrobaSi piris mier, rome-lic amtkicebs an adasturebs, rom mas SeuZlia aramar-Tlzomieri zegavlenis moxdena moxelis an masTan gaTanab-rebuli piris mier gadawyvetilebis miRebaze Tavisi an sxvapiris sasargeblod im pirisagan, romelic moqmedebs saku-Tari an sxva piris interesebisaTvis, pirdapir an arapirda-pir, fulis, fasiani qaRaldis, sxva qonebis, qonebrivi sar-geblis an sxva raime aramarTlzomieri upiratesobis moT-xovna an miReba, aseve aseTis Taobaze dapirebis an SeTava-zebis miReba, miuxedavad imisa, ganxorcielda Tu ara ase-Ti zegavlena an/da miRebul iqna Tu ara am zegavleniT sa-surveli Sedegi, danaSauli gaTvaliswinebuli saqarTve-los ssk-is 25-e muxliTa da 3391 muxlis me-2 nawiliT.
17. sakasacio palata ver daeTanxmeba saapelacio sasa-marTlos amgvar dasabuTebebs msjavrdebulTa qmedebeb-Si zegavleniT vaWrobis Semadgenlobis niSnebis arsebo-bis Taobaze, radgan is ar Seesabameba erTi mxriv qrTamisaRebisa da masSi Tanamonawileobis, xolo meore mxriv ze-
239
gavleniT vaWrobisa da masSi Tanamonawileobis arsis mar-Tebul gansazRvras. sakasacio palata ganmartavs: miuxe-davad imisa, rom aRniSnuli danaSaulebi TiTqos erTma-neTs hgavs, amave dros isini erTmaneTisagan mniSvnelov-nad gansxvavdebian. pirvel rigSi, aRsaniSnavia is garemo-eba, rom qrTamis aRebis subieqtia mxolod moxele, rome-lic qrTamis sanacvlod sxva piris kanonieri Tu ukanonointeresebis sasargeblod iyenebs Tavis samsaxurebriv uf-lebamosilebas. rac Seexeba zegavleniT vaWrobas, am da-naSaulis subieqti, rogorc wesi, ar aris moxele. Tumcaar aris gamoricxuli, rom es danaSauli Caidinos moxele-mac, magram ara Tavisi samsaxurebrivi uflebamosilebis,aramed sajaro samsaxurSi myof sxva moxeleebTan misi pi-radi urTierTobebis gamoyenebiT. nebismier SemTxvevaSi,Tuki moxele vinmes sasargeblod sxva moxeleze zegavle-nis mosaxdenad iyenebs Tavis samsaxurebriv uflebamosi-lebas da amis sanacvlod is Sesabamis sazRaurs an sxva sar-gebels moiTxovs anda mas aseTs pirdebian, adgili aqvsqrTamis aRebas da ara zegavleniT vaWrobas. garda aRniS-nulisa, qrTamis aRebisas moxele an masTan gaTanabrebu-li piri qrTamis sanacvlod uSualod TviTon axorcielebsSesabamis qmedebas qrTamis gamcemis sasargeblod, xolozegavleniT movaWres ar gaaCnia SesaZlebloba sxva pirisinteresebis sasargeblod TviTon miiRos gadawyvetile-ba. aseTi piri mxolod Tavisi piradi damokidebulebebisgamoyenebiT aRwevs im pirisaTvis sasurvel Sedegs, rom-lis sasargeblodac is moqmedebda.
18. sakasacio palata yuradRebas miaqcevs im garemoe-baze, rom saapelacio sasamarTlos daskvnebi msjavrde-bulebis _ r. k-sa da a. c-s mier Cadenili qmedebebis sis-xlissamarTlebrivi kvalifikaciis Taobaze, sruliad mok-lebulia Sesabamis aucilebel mtkicebulebiT bazas. uf-ro metic, saapelacio sasamarTlom msjavrdebul a. c-sqmedeba daakvalificira ra zegavleniT vaWrobaSi Tana-monawileobad damxmaris saxiT, mas ar daudgenia konkre-tulad raSi gamoixata misi aseTi qmedeba.
20. mosamarTlis brZanebis safuZvelze 2013 wlis 17 iv-liss ganxorcielebuli faruli video-audio Canaweris ga-mokvlevis Sedegad dadgenilia, rom r. c-e Sexvda a. c-s q.... da isini erTad gaemarTnen ..., r. k-sTan Sesaxvedrad. gza-Si isini saubrobdnen, rom Camosulia investori da elo-debian mis Camosvlas aWaraSi. a. c-m aRniSna, rom r. k-sTvishqonda naTqvami, rom investori agzavnida 60000 lars, ax-la unda uTxran, rom amjerad is agzavnis 30000 lars, xo-lo danarCens moitans, roca dainiSneba auqcioni da da-narCens _ rom gaimarjveben auqcionSi, mere miscemen. amisSemdeg isini msjelobdnen TavianTTvis ramdeni moeTxo-vaT, razedac a. c-e aRniSnavda, rom eTqvaT 50000 lari.amis Semdeg a. c-e da r. c-e Sexvdnen r. k-s mis samuSao kabi-netSi. maT daiwyes saubari investorTan dakavSirebiT. a.c-m uTxra r. k-s, rom xma auwios televizors, ris Semde-gac dabal xmaze gaagrZela saubari. man r. k-s aniSna 6 TiTida uTxra, rom amdens arao, aramed mas uCvena 3 TiTi, am-dens vakeTeb axlao. danarCeni mova gancxadebis dawerisSemdeg, xolo auqcionis dasrulebis Semdeg movidoda yve-la danarCeni. amaze r. k-m upasuxa, rom yvelaferi gaigo.amis Semdeg r. k-m furcelze daiwyo wera da Tqva: es xomaris 60000, razec a. pasuxobs, rom 60000 anu sul gamodis120000, saidanac 120-dan 60 modis, rogorc adre iTqva. iyosami mewile, TiToeuli debs 10000-s da 30000 lari wamovawinaswaro. r. k-m maT naxazze aCvena miwis nakveTi, aseve
241
auxsna r. c-s, Tu rogor unda daweros gancxadeba. r. k-mTqva, rom Tu g-s megobari brundeboda TbilisSi, isic gay-veboda. gancxadebis daweris Semdeg isini gamovidnen ka-binetidan.
21. garda amisa, sasamarTlo brZanebis safuZvelze 2013wlis 17 ivliss ganxorcielebuli faruli video-audio Ca-naweris gamokvleviT dadgenilia, rom r. c-e, romelic aR-Wurvili iyo faruli Camweri mowyobilobiT, Sexvda a. c-s,r. k-sa da s. J-s. isini wavidnen ..., miwis sanaxavad. a. c-m uT-xra s. J-s, rom miwis yidvis sakiTxi `keTdeboda~ maTi xaT-riT, Torem im droisaTvis yvelaferi gaCerebuli iyo. Tusxvebs aseT saqmeSi Casadebi eqnebodaT 5 da 3 milioni, masgaukeTebdnen 2 milionad. Tu sxvebs aZlevdnen mSeneblo-bisaTvis 2 wlian vadas, mas miscemdnen 3 wels. miwis nak-veTze gasvlis Semdeg maT SeuerTdaT r. k-e, romelmacauxsna investors sainvesticio pirobebi. amis Semdeg, r.k-e da r. c-e gancalkevdnen, ra drosac man auxsna r-s, rom1 kv.m. miwis sawyisi fasi iqneboda 54 lari, Tumca auditismier SeiZleba Sefasebuliyo 120 dolarad. r-m hkiTxa r-s,Tanxa rodis moetanaT, razec r. upasuxa, rom is midiodaTbilisSi da rom Camovidoda Tanxa daexvedrebinaT da me-re daewyoT saqmis keTeba.
22. sasamarTlos brZanebis safuZvelze 2013 wlis 19 iv-liss ganxorcielebuli faruli video-audio Canaweris ga-mokvleviT dadgenilia, rom r. c-e Sexvda a. c-s da maTisaubari warimarTa miwis nakveTTan dakavSirebiT. amis Sem-deg a. c-m uTxra r. c-s, rom r. k-e mas Seexvewa gaeSifraT s.J-i mogzavnili ar yofiliyo, arc Tavi daeRupaT da arc is.man aseve aRniSna, rom r. k-s yvelasTan hqonda sakiTxi Se-Tanxmebuli da milioni procentiT darwmunebuli iyo, romes saqme gakeTdeboda.
23. sasamarTlos brZanebis safuZvelze 2013 wlis 20 iv-liss ganxorcielebuli faruli video-audio Canaweris ga-mokvleviT dadgenilia, rom a. c-e Sexvda r. c-s da isinigaemarTnen ... s. J-Tan Sesaxvedrad. gzaSi a-m uTxra r-s,rom jobda sofelSi sadme saWmelad damjdariyvnen, rad-gan s-s rame sxva azrebi ar hqonoda, dajdebodnen da Sea-mowmebda, mere r. gavidoda da gamoarTmevda fuls, sxva-gan dadebda da kudi ar eyolebodaT. a-m mimarTa r-s, ramerom iyos man araferi ar icis, avtomatic rom miabjinonarafers ityvis. manve uTxra fuli s-Tvis mas gamoerTmia,
242
vinaidan TviTon ar undoda aRniSnulSi monawileobis mi-Reba. amis Semdeg, isini Sexvdnen s. J-s, ra drosac a. c-mmiwis nakveTis eskizi gadasca s. J-s da dabrunda avtoman-qanaSi, xolo r. c-e s-s Caujda avtomanqanaSi, sadac man r-s gadasca 30000 lari. r-i dabrunda a. c-s avtomanqanaSi damaT datoves Tanxis gadacemis adgili. gzaSi a. c-m uTxrar. c-s, Tanxa daedo avtomanqanis sabargulSi. amis Semdeg,r. c-m a-s miTiTebiT `imasTan wasaRebi~ 20000 lari dadoukana sabargulSi, xolo darCenili 10000 laridan aiRo Ta-vis wili _ 3000 lari, a. c-s wili ki _ 7000 lari, misive miTi-TebiT, dado savarZlis qveS. ramdenime xanSi a. c-s avto-manqana gaaCeres samarTaldamcavebma, ra drosac am avto-manqanidan Cxrekis Sedegad amoRebul iqna aRniSnuli Tan-xebi. yovelive aRniSnuli dadasturebulia avtomanqanisCxrekis oqmiT, aseve avtomanqanaSi gzaze msvlelobisasganxorcielebuli faruli video da audio CanaweriT.
24. zemoxsenebuli garemoebebis realoba dasturdebaagreTve braldebis mowmeebis _ r. c-sa da s. J-s pirdapiriCvenebebiT, romlebSic isini detalurad aRweren msjav-rdebulebTan Sexvdrebsa da am dros maTTan gamarTulisaubrebis Sinaarss, romelSic mkafiod da damajerebladaris warmodgenili is braleuli qmedebebi, romlebsacaxorcielebdnen msjavrdebulebi _ r. k-e da a. c-e Tavian-Ti danaSaulebrivi miznebis misaRwevad.
25. yvela zemomoxmobili mtkicebulebebi, romlebiTacmsjavrdebulebi _ r. k-e da a. c-e imxilebian SesabamisadgansakuTrebiT didi odenobiT qrTamis aRebaSi da am da-naSaulSi Tanamonawileobis CadenaSi daxmarebis saxiT, mo-povebulia moqmedi kanonmdeblobis dacviT, isini aseveimyofebian urTierTTanxvedraSi da ar arsebobs safuZ-veli maT utyuarobaSi eWvis Sesatanad.
26. zemoaRniSnulTan erTad, sakasacio palata ar eTan-xmeba braldebis mxaris sakasacio saCivris moTxovnas r.k-sa da a. c-s mier Cadenili qmedebebis saqarTvelos ssk-is 338-e muxlis me-2 nawilis `g~ qvepunqtiT dakvalifici-rebis Taobaze, rac iTvaliswinebs pasuxismgeblobas wi-naswari SeTanxmebiT jgufis mier qrTamis aRebisa da mas-Si TanamonawileobisaTvis. saqmis masalebiT ar dgindeba,rom, mocemul SemTxvevaSi, r. k-s garda qrTamis amRebi sxvapiric arsebobda moxelis saxiT. rac Seexeba imas, rom ga-Rebuli qrTamidan a. c-mac miiRo Tanxis garkveuli nawi-
243
li, es garemoeba jgufs ver Seqmnis, vinaidan is ar arismoxele, aramed warmoadgens aRniSnuli danaSaulis Tana-monawile kerZo pirs damxmaris saxiT. aRniSnuli garemoe-bis gamo braldebis mxaris sakasacio saCivari am nawilSiar unda dakmayofildes.
27. amrigad, sakasacio palata sabolood mivida im das-kvnamde, rom msjavrdebul r. k-s qmedeba unda dakvali-ficirdes saqarTvelosa ssk-is 338-e muxlis me-3 nawilis`e~ qvepunqtiT, rogorc qrTamis aReba damamZimebel ga-remoebaSi _ gansakuTrebiT didi odenobiT, xolo msjav-rdebul a. c-s qmedeba _ saqarTvelos ssk-is 25-e muxliTada 338-e muxlis me-3 nawilis `e~ qvepunqtiT, rogorc Ta-namonawileoba gansakuTrebiT didi odenobiT qrTamisaRebaSi damxmaris saxiT.
28. rac Seexeba msjavrdebulebis _ r. k-sa da a. c-s mi-marT sasjelis saxisa da zomis gansazRvras, mxedveloba-Si unda iqnes miRebuli saqarTvelos ssk-is 53-e muxlisme-3 nawiliT gaTvaliswinebuli, agreTve sisxlissamar-Tlebrivi pasuxismgeblobisa da sasjelis individuali-zaciis principidan gamomdinare moTxovnebi. am mimarTe-biT sakasacio palata maTTvis sasjelis daniSvnisas, erTimxriv, iTvaliswinebs im garemoebebs, romlebic warmoad-genen maT mier Cadenili qmedebis maxasiaTeblebs, xolomeore mxriv, garemoebebs, romlebic axasiaTeben maT pi-rovnebas. saxeldobr, palata mxedvelobaSi iRebs, rommsjavrdebulebs ar gaaCniaT damamZimebeli garemoebebi,xolo maTTvis pasuximgeblobisa da sasjelis Semamsubu-qeblad unda CaiTvalos Semdegi garemoebebi: isini pirve-lad arian samarTalSi, maTi warsuli arafriT ar aris Seb-Raluli, xasiaTdebian dadebiTad da maT qmedebas ar moh-yolia raime mZime Sedegi. aRniSnulis gaTvaliswinebiT, sa-kasacio palata SesaZleblad miiCnevs maT mier CadenilidanaSaulisaTvis kanoniT gaTvaliswinebuli sasjelis mi-nimaluri zomis daniSvnas msjavrdebul a. c-saTvis, xolominimalur zomasTan miaxloebuli sasjelis daniSvnasmsjavrdebul r. k-saTvis.