This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Mark Watson / Industrial Support ATM Performance Advisor 17/12/2015
Reviewed By - Reviewers internal to the project.
Name & Company Position & Title Date
Alfredo Gomez / SJU Head of Release Management and Validation
17/12/2015
Approved for submission to the SJU By - Representatives of the company involved in the project.
Name & Company Position & Title Date
Gianni Inzerillo / Industrial Support SESAR IS Director 17/12/2015
Document History
Edition Date Status Author Justification
01.00.00 18/04/2014 First Edition Mark Watson
Taking into account SJU comments, and renamed SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary
02.00.00 23/09/2014 Second Edition Mark Watson
The first edition of this report was intended for OFA Coordinators, Work Package Leaders and Contribution Managers. Edition 2 is intended for general publication.
03.00.00 28/01/2015 Third Edition Mark Watson
Edition 3 integrates the outcomes of R5SE1, and includes analysis of the V&V Roadmap.
04.00.00 30/11/2015 Fourth Edition Mark Watson
Edition 4 integrates Release 4 outcomes plus Ad-hoc assessments. Maturity of SESAR Solutions added to the Report.
04.01.00 17/12/2015 Fourth Edition Mark Watson After feedback from SJU
The SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary summarizes the progress of Operational Focus Areas (OFAs) and the current baseline maturity of SESAR Solutions and Operational Improvement (OI) steps per Concept Storyboard Step within the SESAR programme.
1.2 Intended readership
The intended readers are the SESAR members, more specifically Project Managers (PjM), Work Package Leaders (WPL) and the OFA Coordinators.
1.3 Acronyms and Terminology
Term Definition
ATM Air Traffic Management
CI Configurable Items
DMT Definition Maturity Target
E-ATMS European Air Traffic Management System
MAT Maturity Assessment Tool
OFA Operational Focus Area
OI Operational Improvement
PCP Pilot Common Project
PIRM Programme Information Reference Model
PMP Programme Management Plan
SESAR Single European Sky ATM Research Programme
SJU SESAR Joint Undertaking (Agency of the European Commission)
SJU Work Programme The programme which addresses all activities of the SESAR Joint Undertaking Agency.
SESAR Programme The programme which defines the Research and Development activities and Projects for the SJU.
This document is the "SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary". The maturity is captured through Release Systems Engineering Reviews and ad-hoc assessments based on latest information available to the OFA Coordinators or the SJU.
Since this status was captured, for some OI steps, it may happen that maturity has changed compared to the results which are reflected in the “SESAR Maturity Report”. In this case, these new assessments results will feed next versions of the “SESAR Maturity Report”.
The “SESAR Maturity Report” is to be understood as reflecting the current and known status of the overall "SESAR maturity". It will more accurately reflect SESAR maturity over time, once new results are achieved within the Programme and assessments made available. SESAR maturity will be reviewed periodically by SJU after main Systems Engineering Reviews (on a basis of twice a year). Following the same process, new versions of this SESAR Maturity Report will be issued, in order to update the current "SESAR maturity ",
The “SESAR Maturity Report” provides a shared and common reference for SESAR Solutions and OI steps maturity (SESAR maturity baseline) and provides a controlled way to make this reference change.
The SESAR maturity baseline reported makes use of assessments that have been made available through Release Systems Engineering Reviews or have been provided by OFA Coordinators, as well as assumptions based on the information declared in the Validation and Verification Roadmap. SESAR Members are invited to review the SESAR maturity baseline and in case of variance, to provide evidence of the maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps.
1.5 SESAR Maturity Report Contents
The “SESAR Maturity Report” is constituted by five documents:
“SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary” (this document), summarizing the progress of OFAs and the maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps;
Step 1 MAT report, providing a consolidated view of the Step 1 assessments (PDF);
Step 2 MAT report, providing a consolidated view of the Step 2 assessments (PDF);
Step 3 MAT report, providing a consolidated view of the Step 3 assessments (PDF);
“MAT Report Principles and Layout” presenting: the principles applied to determine the SESAR Solutions & OI Step Maturity and the resulting progress of OFAs; the layout of the MAT report; and user guidelines to help reading the MAT reports.
The results are issued from a Maturity Assessment Tool (MAT) that implements the SESAR maturity criteria
1 and has been developed to provide a consolidated view for each SESAR Solution and related
OI step(s), based on individual assessments performed by experts. MAT allows to determine SESAR Solution / OI step maturity at V1->V2, V2->V3 and V3->V4 transition
2 phases (European Operational
Concept Validation Methodology) and to compute progress of OFAs.
In this document:
Section 2 provides an overview of the maturity assessment process;
Section 3 summarizes the maturity status per SESAR Solution;
Section 4 summarizes the overall progress per OFA;
1 The SESAR Maturity Criteria guidance has been published (03/10/2012). A short guidance note and the criteria
themselves can be found in the Extranet Programme Library under Validation & Verification 2 In this Report, the transition criteria V1->V2 V2->V3, V3->V4 are referred as V1, V2 and V3
Section 5 summarizes the maturity status per OI step;
Appendix A summarizes the maturity of OI steps that contribute to the PCP;
Appendix B provides definitions of the OI steps;
Appendix C provides definitions of the SESAR Solutions;
Appendix D provides definitions of the Operational Focus Areas
1.6 Assumptions
The principles to assess SESAR Solution / OI step maturity are described in the document “MAT Report Principles and Layout”. However, for SESAR Solutions / OI steps declared to be in a particular validation phase (e.g. V3) and for which there were no assessments available from the previous validation phases, then it was assumed that previous validation phases were satisfactorily achieved (e.g. V1 and V2).
The assessment of SESAR Solutions / OI steps is based on SESAR Programme Management Plan (Edition 03.00.02). SESAR PMP provides a high level description of the process to assess and determine the degree of maturity of the SESAR concept definition.
Maturity assessment takes place along the Programme lifecycle on a yearly basis, as part of three Release management process:
Extended Release Strategy definition, to identify and plan the future activities needed for the SESAR Solutions / OI steps to achieve end of V3;
Release Systems Engineering Review 1, to confirm the V2 maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps using the results of the exercises preceding the proposed V3 exercises candidates;
Release Systems Engineering Review 3, to confirm the V3 maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps using the Release exercise results.
Maturity Assessment should also be undertaken by projects working on a given OFA along their development process.
3
2.2 Report Generation
The MAT report is generated using the following inputs (Figure 1):
The latest maturity assessments available to the SJU, providing an indication of the maturity of a SESAR Solution / OI step, and the completeness of an OFA, specifically:
o Release Systems Engineering Reviews;
o SESAR Solution / OI step assessments by OFA Coordinators;
o Setting up SESAR Solution / OI step(s) maturity assessment baseline, consolidating information provided in the V&V Roadmap, OFA Description Forms, and systems engineering data (OI step requirements/validation objectives), Extended Release Strategy.
The latest applicable integrated roadmap (DS14), providing the organization of the OFA and OI step.
Programme Information Reference Model (PIRM6.1) Configurable Items (CI) and Reports:
o Definition Maturity Target (DMT) Report4, providing a summary of the validation
exercises (past, present and future) that contributes to the validation of OI steps;
o CI#046 Validation Result, providing the B.05 performance assessment5.
o CI#064 and CI#065, providing the baseline reference for SESAR Solutions.
More detailed information on the report generation is provided in the document “MAT Report Principles and Layout”.
3 Progress in the maturity of an OI step is assessed at Release Systems Engineering Reviews, so there may be
an 18 month period (SE#1 to SE#3) where progress from V2 to V3 is not reported. .SESAR Members are invited to provide new ad-hoc assessments and visibility on the achieved maturity anytime between SE#1 and SE#3. 4 DMT Report generated 26 November 2015
The evolution of the delivery of SESAR Solutions by the SESAR1 Programme is summarized in the following chart. The Release 5 SESAR Solutions are expected to be delivered at the end of the SESAR1 programme.
Figure 2: SESAR Solution Delivery
6 Appendix B provides definitions of the OI steps, Appendix C provides definitions of the SESAR Solution and
Table 1 provides a summary of the maturity of SESAR Solutions that have already achieved or expected to achieve V3 maturity in the scope of SESAR1. SESAR Solutions highlighted in blue indicate that one or more contributing OI steps are covered by the Pilot Common Project.
SESAR Solution Package column denotes the Release that the SESAR Solution was delivered (green) or if validation is required or planned (amber);
Operational Improvement Step column identifies the OIs that contribute to the SESAR Solution.
Solution Coverage7 indicates if the SESAR Solution contains part of the OI step, or the full
OI step;
V1, V2 and V3 columns indicate if the validation phase is completed (green) or ongoing (amber);
OFA Solution Solution Title SESAR
Solution Package
OIs Solution Coverage
V1 V2 V3
OFA01.01.01 #55 Precision approaches using GBAS CAT II/III based on GPS L1
Table 2 provides a summary of the maturity of the OI steps that contribute to SESAR Solutions that will be addressed in SESAR2020. SESAR Solutions highlighted in blue indicate that one or more contributing OI steps are covered by the Pilot Common Project.
Solution Solution Title OIs V1 V2 V3
PJ.01-01 Extended Arrival Management with overlapping AMAN operations and interaction with DCB and CTA
TS-0109 1
TS-0305-B 1
PJ.01-02 Use of Arrival and Departure Management Information for Traffic Optimisation within the TMA
PJ.17-01 SWIM TI Purple Profile for Air/Ground Advisory Information Sharing
IS-0901-B
PJ.17-02 SWIM TI Federated Identity Management IS-0901-B
PJ.17-03 SWIM TI Green profile for G/G Civil Military Information Sharing
IS-0901-C
PJ.17-07 SWIM TI Purple Profile for Air/Ground Safety-Critical Information Sharing
IS-0901-C
PJ.17-08 SWIM TI Common runtime registry IS-0901-B
PJ.18-01 Mission Trajectories
AOM-0304-A 1 1 2
AOM-0304-B
AUO-0215 1 1 2
AUO-0216 1
PJ.18-02 Integration of trajectory management processes in planning and execution
AUO-0205-A 1 1 2
AUO-0205-B 1 1
AUO-0217 1
AUO-0218 1
AUO-0219 1
AUO-0220 1
AUO-0221 1
AUO-0222 1
AUO-0223 1 1 2
AUO-0224 1 1
AUO-0225 1 1
AUO-0226 1 1
AUO-0227 1 1
AUO-0228 1 1
AUO-0303-B 1 1
AUO-0305
CM-0105-A 1 1
CM-0105-B 1
CM-0201-B
PJ.18-04 Management and sharing of data used in trajectory (AIM, METEO)
IS-0206 1 1
MET-0201 1 1
PJ.18-06 Performance Based Trajectory Prediction
IS-0301 1 2 2
IS-0302 1 2 2
IS-0303-A 1 1 2
IS-0305
Table 2: SESAR2020 Solutions Maturity
3.4 Enabling Capabilities
Future editions of the Maturity Report will include an assessment of the maturity of Technological Solutions based on Technology Readiness Level criteria (TRL). Technology that enables future SESAR Solutions, verified as feasible, safe and to provide Performance Improvements is considered to be a “Technological Solution”.
Four Technological Solutions have been initially proposed for Release 5:
Automated Assistance to Controller for Surface Movement Planning and Routing
AO-0205 S1 1 2 1.5
Airport Safety Nets AO-0104-A S1 1 2 1.5
Flexible Airspace Management and Free Route
Airspace Management and Advanced Flexible Use of Airspace
AOM-0202-A S1 1 2 1.5
AOM-0206-A S1 1 2 1.5
CM-0102-A S1 1 2 3
Free Route
AOM-0500 S1 1 1 1.5
AOM-0501 S1 1 1 1.5
AOM-0502 S2 1 1
Network Collaborative Management
Enhanced Short Term ATFCM Measures
DCB-0308 S1 1 2 1.5
Collaborative NOP DCB-0103-A S1 1 2 1.5
Calculated Take-off Time to Target Times for ATFCM purposes
DCB-0208 S1 1 1 1.5
Automated support for Traffic Complexity Assessment
AUO-0203-A S1 1 1 1.5
CM-0103-A S1 1 1 1.5
Initial System Wide Information Management
Common Infrastructure Components, SWIM Technical infrastructure and Profiles, Aeronautical information exchange, Cooperative network information exchange
IS-0901-A S1 1 1 1.5
Meteorological information exchange MET-0101 S1 1 2 1.5
Flight information exchange CM-0201-A S1 1 1 1.5
Initial Trajectory Information Sharing (i4D) - Extended Projected Profile (EPP)