SRMSCET
A RESEARCH project REPORT
ON
A COMPARETIVE ANALYSIS OF SBI AND ICICISession:2014-2015
Submitted for the partial fulfillment of the requirement for the
award of degree Of MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION
SUBMITTED TO:
Gautam BuddhTechnical University, LucknowSubmitted to:Dr.Ritesh
Agarwal
SUBMITTTED BY:SHAYRA KHATUNMBA IV SEM
Certificate
This is to certify that Ms.ShayraKhatun, a student of MBA IV
Semester has completed her Research Project Report titledA
comparative analysis of financial performance of SBI AND
ICICIassigned by MBA Department and under my supervision.
It is further certified that she has personally prepared this
report that is the result of her personal survey/observation. It is
of the standard expected to MBA student and hence recommended for
evaluation.
Signature of the Supervisor (Dr.RiteshAgarwal )
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSomeone has rightly said, No one can live in
isolation. It is true that everyindividual needs the help of others
in every work he does.No task is single mans effort. Any job in
this world however trivial ortough cannot be accomplished without
the assistance of others. Anassignment puts the knowledge and
experience of an individual to litmus test. There is always a sense
of gratitude that one likes it express towards thepersons who
helped to change an effort in a success. The opportunity toexpress
my indebtedness to people who have helped me to accomplish
thistask.First of all I would like to express my gratitude to Head
of Department and my faculty Ms. RichaMurti who guided me with her
knowledge and skill and helped me in successful completion of the
work.I thank my institute who has given me an opportunity to show
my skills. I also thank my nearer and dearer ones without whose
support this project would not been possible.I extent my sincere
gratitude towards my parents, who have always encouraged me and
gave suggestions. They always stand by me. Their support has always
motivated me.
DECLARATION
I Manpreet Kaurstudent of SRMSWCET Bareilly has completed my
Dissertation Report at Bareilly, my project title is A comparative
analysis of financial performance of SBI AND ICICI. All the work is
original and has been done during my research.
PREFACESomeone rightly said that practical experience is for
better and closer to the real world then mere theoretical exposure.
The research work constitutes the back bone of any management
education programme. A management student has to do research work
quite frequently during his entire span. This report is helpful to
enhance the knowledge in analyzing the financial performance of the
Banks. The report on the financial performance helped me to find
out the various techniques used to evaluate the financial results
of the banking financial statements. The report is a analysis of
its true financial results and it is helpful tool for the
understanding the evaluation techniques. The research work is
titled A comparative analysis of financial performance of Bank of
Baroda and HDFC Bank.
CHAPTER-1INTRODUCTION & SCOPE1.1:-Introduction:-
After preparation of the financial statements, one may be
interested in knowing the position of an enterprise from different
points of view. This can be done by analyzing the financial
statement with the help of different tools of analysis such as
ratio analysis, funds flow analysis, cash flow analysis,
comparative statement analysis, etc. Here I have done financial
analysis through ratios. In this process, a meaningful relationship
is established between two or more accounting figures for
comparison Financial ratios are widely used for modeling purposes
both by practitioners and researchers. The firm involves many
interested parties, like the owners, management, personnel,
customers, suppliers, competitors, regulatory agencies, and
academics, each having their views in applying financial statement
analysis in their evaluations. Practitioners use financial ratios,
for instance, to forecast the future success of companies, while
the researchers' main interest has been to develop models
exploiting these ratios. Many distinct areas of research involving
financial ratios can be discerned. Historically one can observe
several major themes in the financial analysis literature. There is
overlapping in the observable themes, and they do not necessarily
coincide with what theoretically might be the best founded areas.
Before understanding the meaning of analysis of financial
statements, it is necessary to understand the meaning of analysis
and financial statements. Analysis means establishing a meaningful
relationship between various items of the two financial statements
with each other in such a way that a conclusion is drawn. By
financial statements, we mean two statements- (1) profit & loss
a/c (2) balance sheet. These are prepared at the end of a given
period of time. They are indicators of profitability and financial
soundness of the business concern Financial statements are those
statements which provide information about profitability and
financial position of a business. It includes two statements, i.e.,
profit & loss a/c or income statement and balance sheet or
position statement. The income statement presents the summary of
the income earned and the expenses incurred during a financial
year. Position statement presents the financial position of the
business at the end of the year. .Thus, analysis of financial
statements means establishing meaningful relationship between
various items of the two financial statements, i.e., income
statement and position statement
Parties interested in analysis of financial statements:-Analysis
of financial statement has become very significant due to
widespread interest of various parties in the financial result of a
business unit. The various persons interested in the analysis of
financial statements are:- Short- term creditors:-They are
interested in knowing whether the amounts owing to them will be
paid as and when fall due for payment or not. Long term
creditors:-They are interested in knowing whether the principal
amount and interest thereon will be paid on time or not.
Shareholders:-They are interested in profitability, return and
capital appreciation. Management:-The management is interested in
the financial position and performance of the enterprise as a whole
and of its various divisions. Trade unions:-They are interested in
financial statements for negotiating the wages or salaries or bonus
agreement with management. Taxation authorities:-These authorities
are interested in financial statements for determining the tax
liability. Researchers :-They are interested in the financial
statements in undertaking research in business affairs and
practices. Employees:-They are interested as it enables them to
justify their demands for bonus and increase in remuneration. Thus
we see that different parties are interested in the results
reported in the financial statements. These results are reported by
analyzing financial statements through the use of ratio
analysis.1.2 Scope of the study:-This study contains a wide scope
in measuring financial analysis of two banks, of which one bank is
private bank and second bank is public bank.SBI is a public bank
and ICICI is a private bank. By this study I shall be able to
measure the financial performance of both the banks in terms of
their profitability. I shall be use different ratio analysis to
find out the financial performance and viability of the study.1.3
Objectives:-Analysis of financial statements is an attempt to
assess the efficiency and performance of an enterprise. For that
there are some objectives which are described as under. 1. To
analyze the deposit performance of SBI and ICICI bank:-This
objective is defined to understand the deposit performance of both
the banks and compare it. This objective in my research process
would be achieved by interpretation of secondary data. 2. To
analyze the lending function of SBI and ICICI:- This objective is
defined the lending function of both the banks and the differences
in loan procedures of both the banks.3. To analyze the
profitability segment of SBI and ICICI bank:- This objective is
defined the earning capacity of both the banks. It also helps in
knowing the capacity to pay the interest and dividend. It should be
calculated with the help of ratio analysis, by which comparison of
profitability and financial soundness can be made between one
industry and another. 4. To compare the total financial performance
of SBI and ICICI bank:- This objective is defined with the help of
different ratio analysis. This objective defines the overall
financial performance of both the banks. Ratio analysis discloses
the position of business with different viewpoint. It discloses the
position of business with liquidity viewpoint, solvency view point,
profitability viewpoint, etc. with the help of such a study, we can
draw conclusion regarding the financial health of business
enterprise.
CHAPTER-2LITERATURE REVIEW2.1:-State bank of India:-
State bank of India is a type of public bank with (BSE, NSE,
SBI) & (LSE: SBID). It was founded as bank of Calcutta in 1806
in Calcutta. The headquarter is situated in corporate centre, madam
came road, Mumbai 400021 India. The key people is MR. Pratip
Chaudheri who is a chairman of state bank of India.State Bank of
India (SBI) (LSE: SBID) is the largest bank in India. It is also,
measured by the number of branch offices and employees, the second
largest bank in the world. The bank traces its ancestry back
through the Imperial Bank of India to the founding in 1806 of the
Bank of Calcutta, making it the oldest commercial bank in the
Indian Subcontinent. The Government of India nationalized the
Imperial Bank of India in 1955, with the Reserve Bank of India
taking a 60% stake, and renamed it the State Bank of India. In
2008, the Government took over the stake held by the Reserve Bank
of India. SBI provides a range of banking products through its vast
network in India and overseas, including products aimed at NRIs.
With an asset base of $126 billion and its reach, it is a regional
banking behemoth. SBI has laid emphasis on reducing the huge
manpower through Golden handshake schemes and computerizing its
operations. The State Bank Group, with over 16000 branches, has the
largest branch network in India. It has a market share among Indian
commercial banks of about 20% in deposits and advances
International presence.
As of December 31, 2009, the bank had 157 overseas offices
spread over 32 countries. It has branches of the parent in Colombo,
Dhaka, Frankfurt, Hong Kong, Tehran, Johannesburg, London, Los
Angeles, and Male in the Maldives, Muscat, Dubai, New York, Osaka,
Sydney, and Tokyo. It has offshore banking units in the Bahamas,
Bahrain, and Singapore, and representative offices in Bhutan and
Cape Town. It also has an ADB in Boston, USA.SBI operates several
foreign subsidiaries or affiliates. In 1990, it established an
offshore bank: State Bank of India (Mauritius).In 1982, the bank
established a subsidiary, State Bank of India (California), which
now has ten branches nine branches in the state of California and
one in Washington, D.C. The 10th branch was opened in Fremont,
California on 28 March 2011. The other eight branches in California
are located in Los Angeles, Artesia, San Jose, Canoga Park, Fresno,
San Diego, Tustin and Bakersfield.The Canadian subsidiary, State
Bank of India (Canada) also dates to 1982. It has seven branches,
four in the Toronto area and three in British Columbia.In Nigeria,
SBI operates as INMB Bank. This bank began in 1981 as the
Indo-Nigerian Merchant Bank and received permission in 2002 to
commence retail banking. It now has five branches in Nigeria.In
Nepal, SBI owns 55% of Nepal SBI Bank, which has branches
throughout the country. In Moscow, SBI owns 60% of Commercial Bank
of India, with Canara Bank owning the rest. In Indonesia, it owns
76% of PT Bank Indo Monex.The State Bank of India already has a
branch in Shanghai and plans to open one in Tianjin In Kenya, State
Bank of India owns 76% of Giro Commercial Bank, which it acquired
for US$8 million in October 2005..The State Bank of India (with 74%
of the total capital) along with the largest global banking
groupBNP Paribas (with 26% of the remaining capital) headquartered
in Parisformed a joint venture which established India's most
reputed and trusted life insurance company named SBI Life Insurance
company Ltd. in March 2001.As of March 2011, it had assets of
US$370 billion with over 13,000 outlets including 150 overseas
branches and agents globally. The bank traces its ancestry to
British India, through the Imperial Bank of India, to the founding
in 1806 of the Bank of Calcutta, making it the oldest commercial
bank in the Indian Subcontinent. Bank of Madras merged into the
other two presidency banksBank of Calcutta and Bank of Bombayto
form the Imperial Bank of India, which in turn became the State
Bank of India. The Government of India nationalized the Imperial
Bank of India in 1955, with the Reserve Bank of India taking a 60%
stake, and renamed it the State Bank of India. In 2008, the
government took over the stake held by the Reserve Bank of India.
SBI is ranked #292 globally in Fortune Global 500 list in 2011. SBI
provides a range of banking products through its vast network of
branches in India and overseas, including products aimed at
non-resident Indians (NRIs). The State Bank Group, with over 16,000
branches, has the largest banking branch network in India. SBI has
14 local head offices situated at Chandigarh, Delhi, Luck now,
Patna, Kolkata, Guwahati (North East Circle), Bhubaneswar,
Hyderabad, Chennai, Trivandrum, Bangalore, Mumbai, Bhopal &
Ahmadabad and 57 Zonal Offices that are located at important cities
throughout the country. It also has around 130 branches
overseas.SBI is a regional banking behemoth and is one of the
largest financial institutions in the world. It has a market share
among Indian commercial banks of about 20% in deposits and loans.
The State Bank of India is the 29th most reputed company in the
world according to Forbes. Also, SBI is the only bank featured in
the coveted "top 10 brands of India" list in an annual survey
conducted by Brand Finance and The Economic Times in 2010.The State
Bank of India is the largest of the Big Four banks of India, along
with ICICI Bank, Punjab National Bank and HDFC Bankits main
competitors.The government of India is the largest shareholder in
SBI. The bank has 52 branches, agencies or offices in 32 countries.
It has branches of the parent in Colombo, Dhaka, Frankfurt, Hong
Kong, Johannesburg, London and environs, Los Angeles, Male in the
Maldives, Muscat, New York, Osaka, Sydney, and Tokyo. It has
offshore banking units in the Bahamas, Bahrain, and Singapore, and
representative offices in Bhutan and Cape Town. SBI operates
several foreign subsidiaries or affiliates. In 1990 it established
an offshore bank, State Bank of India (Mauritius). It has two
subsidiaries in North America, State Bank of India (California),
and State Bank of India (Canada). In 1982, the bank established its
California subsidiary, which now has seven branches. The Canadian
subsidiary was also established in 1982 and also has seven
branches, four in the greater Toronto area, and three in British
Columbia. In Nigeria, it operates as INMB Bank. This bank was
established in 1981 as the Indo-Nigerian Merchant Bank and received
permission in 2002 to commence retail banking. It now has five
branches in Nigeria. In Nepal SBI owns 50% of Nepal SBI Bank, which
has branches throughout the country. In Moscow SBI owns 60% of
Commercial Bank of India, with Canara Bank owning the rest. In
Indonesia it owns 76% of PT Bank Indo Monex. State Bank of India
already has a branch in Shanghai and plans to open one up in
Tianjin. Board of directors:-1. Pratip Chaudhuri (Chairman)2.
Hemant G. Contractor (Managing Director)3. Diwakar Gupta (Managing
Director)4. A Krishna Kumar (Managing Director)5. Dileep C Choksi
(Director)6. S. Venkatachalam (Director)7. D. Sundaram (Director)8.
Parthasarathy Iyengar (Director)9. G. D. Nadaf (Officer Employee
Director)10. Rashpal Malhotra (Director)11. D. K. Mittal
(Director)12. Subir V. Gokarn (Director)
2.2:- Industrial Credit & Investment Corporation of India
(ICICI):-ICICI was formed in 1955 at the initiative of the World
Bank, the government of India and Indian industry representatives.
The principal objective was to create a development financial
institution for providing medium-term and long-term project
financing to Indian businesses. Until the late 1980s, ICICI
primarily focused its activities on project finance, providing
long-term funds to a variety of industrial projects. With the
liberalization of the financial sector in India in the 1990s, ICICI
transformed its business from a development financial institution
offering only project finance to a diversified financial services
provider that, along with its subsidiaries and other group
companies, offered a wide variety of products and services. As
Indias economy became more market-oriented and integrated with the
world economy, ICICI capitalized on the new opportunities to
provide a wider range of financial products and services to a
broader spectrum of clients. ICICI Bank was incorporated in 1994 as
a part of the ICICI group. ICICI Banks initial equity capital was
contributed 75.0% by ICICI and 25.0% by SCICI Limited, a
diversified finance and shipping finance lender of which ICICI
owned 19.9% at December 1996. Pursuant to the merger of SCICI into
ICICI, ICICI Bank became a wholly-owned subsidiary of ICICI. ICICIs
holding in ICICI Bank reduced due to additional capital rising by
ICICI Bank and sale of shares by ICICI, pursuant to the requirement
stipulated by the Reserve Bank of India that ICICI dilute its
ownership of ICICI Bank. Effective March 10, 2001, ICICI Bank
acquired Bank of Madura, an old private sector bank, in an
all-stock merger. The issue of universal banking, which in the
Indian context means the conversion of long-term lending
institutions such as ICICI into commercial banks, had been
discussed at length over the past several years. Conversion into a
bank offered ICICI the ability to accept low-cost demand deposits
and offer a wider range of products and services, and greater
opportunities for earning non-fund based income in the form of
banking fees andcommissions. ICICI Bank also considered various
strategic alternatives in the context of the emerging competitive
scenario in the Indian banking industry. ICICI Bank identified a
large capital base and size and scale of operations as key success
factors in the Indian banking industry. In view of the benefits of
transformation into a bank and the Reserve Bank of Indias
pronouncements on universal banking, ICICI and ICICI Bank decided
to merge.ICICI Bank was originally promoted in 1994 by ICICI
Limited, an Indian financial institution, and was its wholly-owned
subsidiary. ICICI's shareholding in ICICI Bank was reduced to 46%
through a public offering of shares in India in fiscal 1998, an
equity offering in the form of ADRs listed on the NYSE in fiscal
2000, ICICI Bank's acquisition of Bank of Madura Limited in an
all-stock amalgamation in fiscal 2001, and secondary market sales
by ICICI to institutional investors in fiscal 2001 and fiscal 2002.
ICICI was formed in 1955 at the initiative of the World Bank, the
Government of India and representatives of Indian industry. The
principal objective was to create a development financial
institution for providing medium-term and long-term project
financing to Indian businesses. In the 1990s, ICICI transformed its
business from a development financial institution offering only
project finance to a diversified financial services group offering
a wide variety of products and services, both directly and through
a number of subsidiaries and affiliates like ICICI Bank. In 1999,
ICICI become the first Indian company and the first bank or
financial institution from non-Japan Asia to be listed on the NYSE.
After consideration of various corporate structuring alternatives
in the context of the emerging competitive scenario in the Indian
banking industry, and the move towards universal banking, the
managements of ICICI and ICICI Bank formed the view that the merger
of ICICI with ICICI Bank would be the optimal strategic alternative
for both entities, and would create the optimal legal structure for
the ICICI group's universal banking strategy. The merger would
enhance value for ICICI shareholders through the merged entity's
access to low-cost deposits, greater opportunities for earning
fee-based income and the ability to participate in the payments
system and provide transaction-banking services. The merger would
enhance value for ICICI Bank shareholders through a large capital
base and scale of operations, seamless access to ICICI's strong
corporate relationships built up over five decades, entry into new
business segments, higher market share in various business
segments, particularly fee-based services, and access to the vast
talent pool of ICICI and its subsidiaries. In October 2001, the
Boards of Directors of ICICI and ICICI Bank approved the merger of
ICICI and two of its wholly-owned retail finance subsidiaries,
ICICI Personal Financial Services Limited and ICICI Capital
Services Limited, with ICICI Bank. The merger was approved by
shareholders of ICICI and ICICI Bank in January 2002, by the High
Court of Gujarat at Ahmadabad in March 2002, and by the High Court
of Judicature at Mumbai and the Reserve Bank of India in April
2002. BOARD OF DIRECTORS:-1.N. Vaghul, Chairman
2. Sridar Iyengar
3. L. N. Mittal
4. Narendra Murkumbi
5. Anupam Puri
6. Arun Ramanathan
7. M. K. Sharma
8. P. M. Sinha
9. Marti G. Subrahmanyam
10. T. S. Vijayan
11. V. Prem Watsa
12. K. V. Kamath, Managing Director
CHAPTER-3RESEARCH DESIGN3.1-Introduction: - Research is defined
as human activity based on intellectual application in the
investigation of matter. The primary aim for applied research is
discovering, interpreting, and the development of methods and the
system for the advancement of human knowledge on a wide variety of
scientific matters of our world and the universe. The term
"research design" refers to how a researcher puts a research study
together to answer a question or a set of questions. Research
design works as a systematic plan outlining the study, the
researchers' methods of compilation, details on how the study will
arrive at its conclusions and the limitations of the research.
Research design is not limited to a particular type of research and
may incorporate both quantitative and qualitative analysis. When
defining research design to an audience, there are a few things one
will need to make clear, while avoiding the use of scientific terms
that may lose your audience.3.2: Types of research:-There are four
main types of researches. Such as: Qualitative, Quantitative,
Pragmatic (mixed) and Advocacy/participatory research.1)
Qualitative Research: - Qualitative research is the approach
usually associated with the social constructivist paradigm which
emphasizes the socially constructed nature of reality. It is about
recording, analyzing and attempting to uncover the deeper meaning
and significance of human behavior and experience, including
contradictory beliefs, behaviors and emotions. Researchers are
interested in gaining a rich and complex understanding of peoples
experience and not in obtaining information which can be
generalized to other larger groups.2) Quantitative Research: -
Quantitative research is generally associated with the
positivist/post positivist paradigm. It usually involves collecting
and converting data into numerical form so that statistical
calculations can be made and conclusions drawn.3) Pragmatic
Research (mixed research): -The pragmatic approach to science
involves using the method which appears best suited to the research
problem and not getting caught up in philosophical debates about
which is the best approach. Pragmatic researchers therefore grant
themselves the freedom to use any of the methods, techniques and
procedures typically associated with quantitative or qualitative
research. They recognize that every method has its limitations and
that the different approaches can be complementary. They may also
use different techniques at the same time or one after the other.
For example, they might start with face-to-face interviews with
several people or have a focus group and then use the findings to
construct a questionnaire to measure attitudes in a large scale
sample with the aim of carrying out statistical analysis. Depending
on which measures have been used, the data collected is analyzed in
the appropriate manner. However, it is sometimes possible to
transform qualitative data into quantitative data and vice versa
although transforming quantitative data into qualitative data is
not very common. 4) Advocacy/participatory research: - To some
degree, researchers adopting an advocacy/participatory approach
feel that the approaches to research described so far do not
respond to the needs or situation of people from marginalized or
vulnerable groups. As they aim to bring about positive change in
the lives of the research subjects, their approach is sometimes
described as emancipator. It is not a neutral stance. The
researchers are likely to have a political agenda and to try to
give the groups they are studying a voice. As they want their
research to directly or indirectly result in some kind of reform,
it is important that they involve the group being studied in the
research, preferably at all stages, so as to avoid further
marginalizing them. The researchers may adopt a less neutral
position than that which is usually required in scientific
research. This might involve interacting informally or even living
amongst the research participants (who are sometimes referred to as
co-researchers in recognition that the study is not simply about
them but also by them). The findings of the research might be
reported in more personal terms, often using the precise words of
the research participants. Whilst this type of research could by
criticized for not being objective, it should be noted that for
some groups of people or for certain situations, it is necessary as
otherwise the thoughts, feelings or behavior of the various members
of the group could not be accessed or fully understood3.3: Types of
data: - There are two types of data. Such as:1) Primary
Data:-Primary data are data that has not been previously published,
i.e. the data is derived from a new or original research study and
collected at the source, e.g., in marketing, it isinformation that
is obtained directly from first-hand sources by means of surveys,
observation or experimentation. Primary research entails the use of
immediate data in determining the survival of the market. The
popular ways to collect primary data consist of surveys, interviews
and focus groups, which shows that direct relationship between
potential customers and the companies. Primary data is more
accommodating as it shows latest information. Primary data are
accumulated by the researcher particularly to meet up the research
objective of the subsisting project.2) Secondary Data: - These are
sources containing data that have been collected and compiled for
another purpose. The secondary sources consist of readily available
compendia and already compiled statistical statements and reports
whose data may be used by researches for their studies.Secondary
sources consist of not only published records and reports, but also
unpublished records. The latter category includes various records
and registers maintained by firms and organizations, e.g.,
accounting and financial records, personnel records, register of
members, minutes of meetings, inventory records, etc. Features of
Secondary Sources: Though secondary sources are diverse and consist
of all sorts of materials, they have certain common
characteristics. First, they are readymade and readily available,
and do not require the trouble of constructing tools and
administering them. Others shape both the form and the content of
secondary sources. Finally, secondary sources are not limited in
time and space. That is, the researcher using them need not have
been present when and where they were gathered. But in this
research work I have used only Secondary data.3.4- Research Tool:
The data required for the study have been collected from annual
reports of respective banks, journals and reports on trends, and
websites of respective banks.3.5:Mode of data collection: In my
research report I have used only secondary data and for which I
took help of balance sheet of the respective banks
CHAPTER-4DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRATATION4.1: Introduction: -
Data analysis is a body of methods that help to describe facts,
detect patterns, develop explanations, and test hypotheses. It is
used in business, in administration, and in policy.The numerical
results provided by a data analysis are usually simple: It finds
the number that describes a typical value and it finds differences
among numbers. Data analysis finds averages, like the average
income or the average temperature, and it find differences like the
difference in income from group to group or the differences in
average temperature from year to year. Fundamentally, the numerical
answers provided by data analysis are that simple.4.2: Analysis of
data:-1) Capital deposit ratio: - The traditional function of bank
capital is to protect bank depositors against loss. Bank capital is
in effect, a first line of deposit guarantee; supervisory
authorities have come to apply the proportion of a bank capital to
its deposit as a measure to its capital position.The capital
deposit standard frequently is cited in a very precise and concrete
form, that is one to ten. There appears to be no scientific basis
for this particular ratio. It is simply a good round decimal, easy
to calculate at a glance.The circumstances that have decreased
capital deposit ratios are well known. Deposits have grown very
considerably, not so much as a result of an increase in earning
assets, as of a growth in cash holdingsCapital deposit ratios from
2007-2011:-Table 4.1:-capital deposit ratioSr.no.Banks
name20072008200920102011
1SBI12.3413.4714.2513.3911.98
2ICICI11.6913.9715.3319.4119.54
Figure-4.1 capital deposit ratioInterpretation:-It shows that in
2007 capital deposit ratio is higher in case of SBI than ICICI but
after that the capital deposit ratio is higher in case of ICICI as
compared to SBI. In 2011 capital deposit ratio of ICICI is much
higher than SBI .So in 2011 ICICI is much capable of protecting
their capital against bank depositors. 2)Loan deposit ratio:-The
loan to deposit ratio is used to calculate a lending institution's
ability to cover withdrawals made by its customers. A lending
institution that accepts deposits must have a certain measure of
liquidity to maintain its normal daily operations. Loans given to
its customers are mostly not considered liquid meaning that they
are investments over a longer period of time. Although a bank will
keep a certain level of mandatory reserves, they may also choose to
keep a percentage of their non-lending investing in short term
securities to ensure that any monies needed can be accessed in the
short term.The formula for the loan to deposit ratio is exactly as
its name implies, loans divided by deposits.Loan deposit
ratio=loan/depositLoans in the numerator of the formula are
investments or assets for a bank. Deposits in the denominator of
the formula can be considered the same as debt as the individual
depositors are essentially granting monies to the bank with a
return equal to the deposit rates and that can be called upon at
any time. In these respects, the loan to deposit ratio is similar
to a liquidity ratio and debt ratio.The loan to deposit ratio can
be used by investors and internally by the company to determine the
financial institutions short term viability. Although many
depositors may not be as concerned when a financial institution is
insured, the loan to deposit ratio may be used to ensure that any
money needed is immediately available. Banking insurance companies
may also find this ratio or some variation of it of use when
underwriting the policy to determine insurability.
Loan deposit ratios from 2007-2011:-Table 4.2:-Loan deposit
ratioSr. no.Bank name20072008200920102011
1SBI73.4477.5174.9775.9679.90
2ICICI83.8384.9991.4490.0487.81
Figure 4.2:-Loan deposit ratioInterpretation:-In comparison of
SBI and ICICI the loan deposit ratio of ICICI is high in comparison
of SBI. It means that ICICI insured that to investor when they
required money it is available to him. So lending function of ICICI
is better than ICICI. But in last three years the loan deposit
ratio of SBI increases whereas the loan deposit ratio of ICICI
decreases.3) Cash deposit ratio:- The amount of money a bank should
have available as a percentage of the total amount of money its
customers have paid into the bank. This amount is calculated so
that customers can be sure that they will be able to take their
money out of the bank if they want to.Cash deposit ratio is with
reference to a bank's the ratio of average cash balance held
against total deposits of a particular branchCash deposit ratio=
total cash balance/depositsCash deposit ratio plays a crucial role
in banking operations. The banks try to fine-tune it. They do not
want to hold more than necessary cash reserves because in that case
they lose some of the profit, which they can otherwise earn.
Similarly, they cannot afford to have a lower than necessary cash
reserve ratio because that can result in their failure to meet
their payment obligations. If a bank false to honour its commitment
to pay in time, the customers lose confidence in its ability (or
willingness) to pay. As a result, all of them rush to the bank and
demand payment. And the bank, by the very nature of its balance
sheet, is never able to meet this demand in full. It can go
bankrupt.
Cash deposit ratios from 2007-2011:-Table 4.3:-cash deposit
ratioSR NO.BANKS NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI6.228.298.377.568.96
2ICICI6.9910.1210.1410.7211.32
Figure 4.3:- Cash deposit ratioInterpretation:-The cash deposit
ratio of ICICI is better than SBI. In 2007 there did not have too
much differences between two bank but after that cash deposit ratio
of ICICI went at rapid pace as compare to SBI. 4) Investment
deposit ratio:-This ratio shows the comparison of investments and
deposits. This is calculated asInvestment deposit
Ratio=Investment/deposits
Table 4.4:-investment deposit ratioSr no.Banks
name20072008200920102011
1SBI38.2234.8136.3836.3333.45
2ICICI41.1542.6846.3553.2859.77
Figure 4.4:- investment deposit ratioInterpretation:-From above
table and graph it is very much clear that ICICI are using their
deposit very efficiently. And earning high profits. The ratio has
an upward trend, which shows theperformance of ICICI is very good.
But in the case of SBI the trend is downward since 2009 so they
focus on long term goals rather than earnings high profits. 5)
Interest paid to total revenue:-It shows the interest paid over the
total revenue earned by both the banks. Interest paid to total
revenue=interest /total revenueTable 4.5:-interest paid to total
revenueSR.NO.BANK NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI8.278.828.888.528.39
2ICICI9.5510.609.828.828.41
Figure 4.5:-interest paid to total revenueInterpretation:-In the
year of 2007-2009 the interest paid to total revenue were high in
the case of ICICI but after that in 2010 and 2011 there were not
too much difference between both the banks. 6) Salaries to total
revenue:-This ratio shows the relation between the salaries and the
total revenue.Table 4.6:-salaries to total revenueSR.NO.BANK
NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI8.468.968.998.628.48
2ICICI9.6510.829.908.908.41
Figure 4.6:-salaries to total revenueInterpretation:-It shows
that the salaries to total revenue of SBI is better than ICICI in
2011 but in the year of 2007-2010 ICICI is much better than SBI .7)
Operating expenses to total revenue:- The operating margin is
another measurement of managements efficiency. It compares the
quality of a companys activity to its competitors. A business that
has a higher operating margin than others in the industry is
generally doing better as long as the gains didn't come by piling
on debt or taking highly risky speculations with shareholders'
money. The most common reason for high operating margins relative
to competitors is a low-cost operating model, which means that a
company can deliver merchandise or services to customers at much
cheaper prices than competitors and still make moneyTo calculate
the operating margin, divide operating income by the total revenue.
Operating Income Sales = Operating MarginOperating expenses, or
OpEx, are the recurring expenses and costs associated with the
day-to-day activities of the business, such as research and
development expenses and sales and administration expenses that are
essential to the continuous operation and maintenance of a property
but not directly associated with production. In short, this is the
money the business spends in order to turn inventory into
throughput Operating expenses are also called non-manufacturing
expenses and are usually subdivided into Research and Development
Expenses, Selling, General, and Administrative expenses and
Depreciation and Amortization. In general it includes expenses such
as payroll, sales commissions, employee benefits and pension
contributions, transportation and travel, amortization, rent,
repairs, and taxes, etc. Operating expenses do not include items
such as mortgage payments and capital expenditures, but do include
depreciation of plants and machinery used for business purposes.
"Operating expenses" as shown in a Company's Financial statements
(Income Statement) corresponds to the sum of the company's
operating expenses for a certain period of time, such as a
month(usually a quarter) or year(annual operating expenses). The
annual operating expenses shown below are the actual costs it takes
to run the property, such as property tax, insurance, maintenance,
repairs, management fees, utilities, and supplies(as mentioned
above) for the corresponding fiscal year.
Table 4.7:-Operating expenses to total revenueSR.NO.BANK
NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI28.924.1322.9127.6131.51
2ICICI28.8726.0026.2229.0524.81
Figure 4.7:-operating expenses to total
revenueInterpretation:-The operating expenses to total revenue
ratio is higher in case of SBI as compare to ICICI in 2011 but from
2007-2010 the operating expenses to total revenue is higher in case
of ICICI as compare to SBI.8)Gross margin ratio:- A company's total
sales revenue minus itscost of goods sold, divided by the total
sales revenue, expressed as a percentage. The gross margin
represents thepercent oftotal sales revenuethat the company retains
after incurring the direct costs associated with producing the
goods and services sold by a company. The higher the percentage,
the more the company retains on each dollar of sales to service its
other costs and obligations.GROSS MARGIN RATIO=REVENUE-COST OF GOOD
SOLD/REVENUEThis number represents the proportion of each rupee of
revenue that the companyretains as gross profit. For example, if a
company's gross margin for the most recent quarter was 35%, it
would retain Rs 0.35 from each rupee of revenue generated, to be
put towards paying off selling, general andadministrative expenses,
interest expenses and distributions to shareholders. A company
should be continuously monitoring its gross margin ratio to be
certain it willresult in agross profit that will be sufficient to
cover its selling and administrative expenses.The gross profit
margin ratio measures how efficiently a company uses its resources,
materials, and labor in the production process by showing the
percentage of net sales remaining after subtracting the cost of
making and selling a product or service. It is usually expressed as
a percentage, and indicates the profitability of a business before
overhead costs. A high gross profit margin ratio indicates that a
business can make a reasonable profit on sales, as long as
overheads do not increase. Investors pay attention to the gross
profit margin ratio because it tells them how efficient your
business is compared to competitors. It is sensible to track gross
profit margin ratios over a number of years to see if company
earnings are consistent, growing, or declining.For businesses,
knowing your gross profit margin ratio is important because it
tells you whether your business is pricing goods and services
effectively. A low margin compared to your competitors would
suggest you are under-pricing, while a high margin might indicate
over-pricing. Low profit margin ratios can also suggest the
business is unable to control production costs, or that a low
amount of earnings are generated from revenues.
Table 4.8:-Gross margin ratioSR.NO.BANK
NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI16.3518.0918.4815.8815.93
2ICICI11.4112.9912.3615.0621.06
Figure 4.8:-Gross margin ratioInterpretation:-From 2007-2010 the
gross profit margin ratio of SBI is high as compare to ICICI but in
the year of 2011 the gross profit margin ratio of ICICI is high as
compare to SBI. Thus we can say that from 2007-2009 SBI can make a
reasonable profit on sale but in 2010 & 2011 SBI not able to
generate the earning from revenue. In the case of ICICI the gross
profit margin ratio increased every year so ICICI make a reasonable
profit on sale.9) Net profit margin:- For a business to survive in
the long term it must generate profit. Therefore the net profit
margin ratio is one of the key performance indicators for your
business. The net profit margin ratio indicates profit levels of a
business after all costs have been taken into account. It is worth
analyzing the ratio over time. A variation in the ratio from year
to year may be due to abnormal conditions or expenses. Variations
may also indicate cost blowouts which need to be addressed. A
decline in the ratio over time may indicate a margin squeeze
suggesting that productivity improvements may need to be initiated.
In some cases, the costs of such improvements may lead to a further
drop in the ratio or even losses before increased profitability is
achieved. The calculation used to obtain the ratio is: Net Profit
Margin = Net Profit x 100/ Sales
Table 4.9:-Net profit margin
SR.NO.BANK NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI10.1211.6512.0310.548.55
2ICICI10.8110.519.7412.1715.91
Figure 4.9:- Net profit marginInterpretation:-From the year of
2007-2009 the net profit margin ratio of SBI was increased whereas
the net profit margin ratio of ICICI decreases so we can say that
from 2007-2009 SBI indicates higher profit after deducting all the
expenses as compare to ICICI but in 2010 & 2011 the net profit
margin ratio of ICICI increases while in the case of SBI it
decreases. So previous two years ICICI generating higher profit.
10) Debt equity ratio: - A measure of a company's financial
leverage calculated by dividing its total liabilities by
stockholders' equity.
A high debt/equity ratio generally means that a company has been
aggressive in financing its growth with debt. This can result in
volatile earnings as a result of the additional interest expense.
If a lot of debt is used to finance increased operations (high debt
to equity), the company could potentially generate more earnings
than it would have without this outside financing. If this were to
increase earnings by a greater amount than the debt cost
(interest), then the shareholders benefit as more earnings are
being spread among the same amount of shareholders. However, the
cost of this debt financing may outweigh the return that the
company generates on the debt through investment and business
activities and become too much for the company to handle. This can
lead to bankruptcy, which would leave shareholders with
nothing.Table 4.10:- Debt equity ratioSR.NO.BANK
NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI13.9110.9612.8112.1914.37
2ICICI9,505.274.423.914.10
Figure 4.10:- Debt equity ratioInterpretation:-This ratio
indicates what proportion of equity and debt the company is using
to finance its assets. From above diagram we can say that SBI has a
high debt-equity ratio means it is aggressive in financing its
growth with debt. Than after ICICI has a low debt-equity ratio as
comparison with SBI in debt-equity ratio.
11) Capital adequacy ratio:- A measure of a bank's capital. It
is expressed as a percentage of a bank's risk weighted credit
exposures. This ratio is used to protect depositors and promote the
stability and efficiency of financial systems around the world. Two
types of capital are measured: tier one capital, which can absorb
losses without a bank being required to cease trading, and tier two
capital, which can absorb losses in the event of a winding-up and
so provides a lesser degree of protection to depositors. Table
4.11:-capital adequacy ratioSR.NO.BANK NAME20072008200920102011
1SBI12.3413.4714.2513.3911.98
2ICICI11.6913.9715.5319.4119.54
Figure:-4.11:-capital adequacy ratioInterpretation:-From the
above table it is clearly state that the capital adequacy ratio of
ICICI is much better than SBI. So ICICI is more capable to protect
depositors and promote the stability and efficiency of the
financial system4.3:-Findings:-From this research report I have
found that-
1) ICICI is much capable bank to protect their capital against
bank depositors as compare to SBI.2) Lending function of ICICI is
better than SBI but in last 3 years SBI increases their lending
function.3) Cash deposit ratio of ICICI is much better than SBI.4)
The focus of ICICI is to earning high profit whereas SBI focuses on
long term goals rather than earning high profit.5) The interest
paid to total revenue is almost same of both the banks in last two
years.6) Salaries to total revenue of SBI is better than ICICI.7)
From 2007-2009 SBI can make a reasonable profit on sale but in
2010-2011 SBI not able to generate the earning from revenue.8) From
2007-2009 SBI indicate higher profit after deducting all the
expenses but in 2010-2011 ICICI generate higher profit.9) SBI is
aggressive in financing its growth with debt as compare to
ICICI.10) ICICI is more capable to protect depositors and promote
the stability and efficiency of the financial system.
CHAPTER-5LIMITATIONSThe ratios analysis is one of the most
powerful tools of financial management. Though ratios are simple to
calculate and easy to understand, they suffer from serious
limitations. 1. Limitations of financial statements: Ratios are
based only on the information which has been recorded in the
financial statements. Financial statements themselves are subject
to several limitations. Thus ratios derived, there from, are also
subject to those limitations. For example, non-financial changes
though important for the business are not relevant by the financial
statements. Financial statements are affected to a very great
extent by accounting conventions and concepts. Personal judgment
plays a great part in determining the figures for financial
statements. 2. Comparative study required: Ratios are useful in
judging the efficiency of the business only when they are compared
with past results of the business. However, such a comparison only
provide glimpse of the past performance and forecasts for future
may not prove correct since several other factors like market
conditions, management policies, etc. may affect the future
operations. . 3. Lack of adequate standard: No fixed standard can
be laid down for ideal ratios. There are no well accepted standards
or rule of thumb for all ratios which can be accepted as norm. It
renders interpretation of the ratios difficult. 4. Limited use of
single ratios: A single ratio, usually, does not convey much of a
sense. To make a better interpretation, a number of ratios have to
be calculated which is likely to confuse the analyst than help him
in making any good decision. 5. Personal bias: Ratios are only
means of financial analysis and not an end in itself. Ratios have
to interpret and different people may interpret the same ratio in
different way. 6. Incomparable: Not only industries differ in their
nature, but also the firms of the similar business widely differ in
their size and accounting procedures etc. It makes comparison of
ratios difficult and misleading.
CHAPTER-6CONCLUSIONRatios make the related information
comparable. A single figure by itself has no meaning, but when
expressed in terms of a related figure, it yields significant
interferences. Thus, ratios are relative figures reflecting the
relationship between related variables. Their use as tools of
financial analysis involves their comparison as single ratios, like
absolute figures, are not of much use.Ratio analysis has a major
significance in analyzing the financial performance of a company
over a period of time. Decisions affecting product prices, per unit
costs, volume or efficiency have an impact on the profit margin or
turnover ratios of a company. Financial ratios are essentially
concerned with the identification of significant accounting data
relationships, which give the decision-maker insights into the
financial performance of a company. The analysis of financial
statements is a process of evaluating the relationship between
parts of financial statements to obtain a better understanding of
the firms position and performance. The first task of financial
analyst is to select the information relevant to the decision under
consideration from the total information contained in the financial
statements. The second step is to arrange the information in a way
to highlight significant relationships. The final step is
interpretation and drawing of inferences and conclusions. In brief,
financial analysis is the process of selection, relation and
evaluation. Ratio analysis in view of its several limitations
should be considered only as a tool for analysis rather than as an
end in itself. The reliability and significance attached to ratios
will largely hinge upon the quality of data on which they are
based. They are as good or as bad as the data itself. Nevertheless,
they are an important tool of financial analysis.
BIBLIOGRAPY
Web sites:
1)www.sbi.com 2)www.icici.com 3)www.investopedia.com
Books referred:
Basic Financial Management- M Y Khan P K Jain Financial
Management-Prasanna Chandra
ANNEXUREBalance sheet(ICICI)Mar ' 11Mar ' 10Mar ' 09Mar ' 08Mar
' 07
Sources of funds
Owner's fund
Equity share capital1,151.821,114.891,113.291,112.68899.34
Share application money0.29----
Preference share capital--350.00350.00350.00
Reserves &
surplus53,938.8250,503.4848,419.7345,357.5323,413.92
Loan funds
Secured loans-----
Unsecured
loans2,25,602.112,02,016.602,18,347.822,44,431.052,30,510.19
Total2,80,693.052,53,634.962,68,230.842,91,251.262,55,173.45
Uses of funds
Fixed assets
Gross block9,107.477,114.127,443.717,036.006,298.56
Less : revaluation reserve-----
Less : accumulated
depreciation4,363.213,901.433,642.092,927.112,375.14
Net block4,744.263,212.693,801.624,108.903,923.42
Capital work-in-progress----189.66
Investments1,34,685.961,20,892.801,03,058.311,11,454.3491,257.84
Net current assets
Current assets, loans &
advances27,630.4129,997.2334,384.0631,129.7723,551.85
Less : current liabilities &
provisions15,986.3515,501.1843,746.4342,895.3838,228.64
Total net current
assets11,644.0614,496.05-9,362.37-11,765.62-14,676.78
Miscellaneous expenses not written-----
Total 1,51,074.281,38,601.5497,497.561,03,797.6280,694.15
Notes:
Book value of unquoted investments-----
Market value of quoted investments-----
Contingent
liabilities9,31,638.847,33,546.208,40,670.634,01,114.911,99,771.41
Number of equity sharesoutstanding
(Lacs)11517.7211148.4511132.5111126.878992.67
(Rs crore)
Profit loss account(ICICI)Mar ' 11Mar ' 10Mar ' 09Mar ' 08Mar '
07
Income
Operating
income32,369.6932,747.3638,250.3939,467.9228,457.13
Expenses
Material consumed-----
Manufacturing expenses-----
Personnel expenses2,816.931,925.791,971.702,078.901,616.75
Selling expenses305.79236.28669.211,750.601,741.63
Adminstrative
expenses4,909.007,440.427,475.636,447.324,946.69
Expenses capitalised-----
Cost of sales8,031.729,602.4910,116.5410,276.828,305.07
Operating profit7,380.825,552.305,407.915,706.853,793.56
Other recurring income7.26305.36330.6465.58309.17
Adjusted PBDIT7,388.085,857.665,738.555,772.434,102.73
Financial
expenses16,957.1517,592.5722,725.9323,484.2416,358.50
Depreciation562.44619.50678.60578.35544.78
Other write offs-----
Adjusted PBT-10,131.51-12,354.42-17,665.985,194.083,557.95
Tax charges1,609.331,600.781,830.511,611.73984.25
Adjusted PAT5,110.213,890.473,740.624,092.122,995.00
Non recurring items41.17134.5217.5165.61115.22
Other non cash adjustments-2.17--0.58--
Reported net profit5,149.214,024.983,757.554,157.733,110.22
Earnigs before
appropriation8,613.596,834.636,193.875,156.003,403.66
Equity dividend1,612.581,337.951,224.581,227.70901.17
Preference dividend-----
Dividend tax202.28164.04151.21149.67153.10
Retained earnings6,798.735,332.634,818.073,778.632,349.39
Balance sheet(SBI)Mar ' 11Mar ' 10Mar ' 09Mar ' 08Mar ' 07
Sources of funds
Owner's fund
Equity share capital635.00634.88634.88631.47526.30
Share application money-----
Preference share capital-----
Reserves &
surplus64,351.0465,314.3257,312.8248,401.1930,772.26
Loan funds
Secured loans-----
Unsecured
loans9,33,932.818,04,116.237,42,073.135,37,403.944,35,521.09
Total9,98,918.868,70,065.438,00,020.825,86,436.604,66,819.65
Uses of funds
Fixed assets
Gross block13,189.2811,831.6310,403.068,988.358,061.92
Less : revaluation reserve-----
Less : accumulated
depreciation8,757.337,713.906,828.655,849.135,385.01
Net block4,431.964,117.723,574.413,139.222,676.91
Capital work-in-progress332.23295.18263.44234.26141.95
Investments2,95,600.572,85,790.072,75,953.961,89,501.271,49,148.88
Net current assets
Current assets, loans &
advances43,777.8535,112.7637,733.2744,417.0325,292.31
Less : current liabilities &
provisions1,05,248.3980,336.701,10,697.5783,362.3060,042.26
Total net current
assets-61,470.54-45,223.94-72,964.30-38,945.27-34,749.95
Miscellaneous expenses not written-----
Total
2,38,894.222,44,979.032,06,827.501,53,929.481,17,217.80
Notes:
Book value of unquoted investments-----
Market value of quoted investments-----
Contingent
liabilities7,90,386.795,96,366.417,67,567.528,29,740.483,29,954.73
Number of equity sharesoutstanding
(Lacs)6349.996348.836348.806314.705262.99
Profit loss account(SBI)Mar ' 11Mar ' 10Mar ' 09Mar ' 08Mar '
07
Income
Operating
income95,525.5885,909.3674,880.7656,821.5543,860.57
Expenses
Material consumed-----
Manufacturing expenses-----
Personnel expenses14,480.1712,754.659,747.317,785.877,932.58
Selling expenses257.88224.05251.23173.2388.43
Adminstrative
expenses15,702.3311,029.667,361.985,970.474,628.38
Expenses capitalised-----
Cost of sales30,440.3824,008.3517,360.5213,929.5712,649.38
Operating profit16,217.2414,578.5414,604.9410,962.907,774.36
Other recurring income1,065.141,051.15894.26901.331,008.35
Adjusted PBDIT17,282.3915,629.6915,499.2011,864.238,782.71
Financial
expenses48,867.9647,322.4842,915.2931,929.0823,436.82
Depreciation990.50932.66763.14679.98602.39
Other write offs-----
Adjusted PBT-32,576.07-32,625.4514,736.06-20,744.838,180.32
Tax charges5,709.546,166.626,115.123,929.203,083.77
Adjusted PAT8,283.039,176.519,124.186,718.084,529.18
Non recurring items-912.68-10.46-2.9511.0412.13
Other non cash adjustments-----
Reported net profit7,370.359,166.059,121.236,729.124,541.31
Earnigs before
appropriation7,370.699,166.399,121.576,729.464,541.65
Equity dividend1,905.001,904.651,841.151,357.66736.82
Preference dividend-----
Dividend tax246.52236.76248.03165.87125.22
Retained earnings5,219.177,024.997,032.385,205.943,679.61