Quest™ Operation style twist Quest™ helpline +44 (0)20 7523 8493 quest@canaccordgenuity. com Nigel Sedgley +44 (0)20 7523 8497 [email protected] 24 th May 2012
Mar 26, 2015
Quest™Operation style twist
Quest™ helpline+44 (0)20 7523 [email protected]
Nigel Sedgley+44 (0)20 7523 [email protected]
24th May 2012
Page 2
Operation style twist: Summary and conclusions
2008-2009 all over again?
There are lots of similarities between events in 2008/9 and recent patterns.
During the 2008/9 trough style performance was volatile but Value ultimately dominated.
The trough in Value in 2008/9 was before the market bottom.
Value rallies tend to be short/sharp events (2-3 quarters) – if you are late, its easy to miss them.
Although the market does not look especially cheap, valuation divergence is high.
Lots of stocks are trading near their trough valuation of the last five years.
The run to safe stocks has left some valuations looking overextended – more than in 2008/9.
During times of profit and cash flow volatility you need to assess Value using stable measures:eg Quest™ market to book, EV/Sales.
Similar Value approach in Nov 08 Quest™ Newsletter delivered strong performance.
Volatility means there will be opportunities. Our screens assess the risk/reward trade off .
History rhymes: Comparing 2007-2009 with 2010-2012
The troughV,Q neutral,Mmtm -ve
Crisis developingValue –ve, Qual +ve, Mmtm +ve
UK Largecap
Now(2010-2012)to 18th May 2012
Then(2007-2009)
Market rallyingValue +ve, Qual neutral, Mmtm -ve
Top quintile minus bottom quintile on each factor on an equally weighted basis. Non-financials.
Value made an absolute low in Nov 2008, but there was lots of volatility around the trough.
Page 3
Current pattern looks most like Sept 08
60
70
80
90
100
110
120
130
140
J an-10
Mar-10
May-10
J un-10
Aug-10
Oct-10
Dec-10
Feb-11
Apr-11
J un-11
Aug-11
Oct-11
Dec-11
Feb-12
Apr-12
J un-12
Aug-12
Oct-12
Value
Quality
Momentum
Market beating stock-picking tool
Company scores updated daily on
www.canaccordquest.com
Combining Value, Quality and Momentum
Quest™ metrics mixed with conventional data
Style analysis and themes
triAngle Escalator: Who’s moving up and down
Excellent 12- year track record
– 3-pronged approach improves consistency
– UK Large – 42/53 +ve quarters, +4.0% average
– Pan-Euro – 36/48 +ve quarters, +3.0% average
– UK Small – 34/42 +ve quarters, +6.3% average
– North America – 18/35 +ve quarters, -0.3% average
(Value and the Escalator dominate in the US)
Over 12 years of live experience assessing style trends.
UK large cap triAngle performance
Top quintile minus bottom quintile on each factor on an equally weighted basis. Non-financials
Page 4
100
1000
10000
Aug
-98
Feb
-99
Aug
-99
Feb
-00
Aug
-00
Feb
-01
Aug
-01
Feb
-02
Aug
-02
Feb
-03
Aug
-03
Feb
-04
Aug
-04
Feb
-05
Aug
-05
Feb
-06
Aug
-06
Feb
-07
Aug
-07
Feb
-08
Aug
-08
Feb
-09
Aug
-09
Feb
-10
Aug
-10
Feb
-11
Aug
-11
Feb
-12
FTSE 350
Top quintile
Bottom quintile
100
1000
10000
Au
g-9
8F
eb
-99
Au
g-9
9F
eb
-00
Au
g-0
0F
eb
-01
Au
g-0
1F
eb
-02
Au
g-0
2F
eb
-03
Au
g-0
3F
eb
-04
Au
g-0
4F
eb
-05
Au
g-0
5F
eb
-06
Au
g-0
6F
eb
-07
Au
g-0
7F
eb
-08
Au
g-0
8F
eb
-09
Au
g-0
9F
eb
-10
Au
g-1
0F
eb
-11
Au
g-1
1F
eb
-12
triAngle™
Value
Quality
Momentum
: What is triAngle?
Equally weighted triAngle is the most consistent, but
there have been a few short/sharp value rallies
: Factors and composition
triAngleValue Quality
Momentum
33% 33%
33%
Page 5
CFROC spread
Capital growth
Equilibrium growth
Fixed charge cover
CFROC change
Quest™ valuation
Quest™ market-to-book
EV/sales rel. LRA
Dividend yield rel. LRA
P/E rel. LRA
9m-relative trend
100/200-day switch
12m-relative range
30/90 day switch
Earnings momentum
Baskets are dynamic: They vary over time depending on what currently represents Value, Quality etc .
CFROC Spread
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
Feb 99
Aug 99
Feb 00
Aug 00
Feb 01
Aug 01
Feb 02
Aug 02
Feb 03
Aug 03
Feb 04
Aug 04
Feb 05
Aug 05
Feb 06
Aug 06
Feb 07
Aug 07
Feb 08
Aug 08
Feb 09
Aug 09
Feb 10
Aug 10
Feb 11
Aug 11
Feb 12
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
CFROC Spread* FTSE350
Three months ending at date show n*Pre Feb 04 Avg over 5 historic yrs. Post Feb 04 Avg over 4 Historic, 1 Forecast yr.
Value
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
Feb 99
Aug 99
Feb 00
Aug 00
Feb 01
Aug 01
Feb 02
Aug 02
Feb 03
Aug 03
Feb 04
Aug 04
Feb 05
Aug 05
Feb 06
Aug 06
Feb 07
Aug 07
Feb 08
Aug 08
Feb 09
Aug 09
Feb 10
Aug 10
Feb 11
Aug 11
Feb 12
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
Value FTSE350
Three months ending at date show n
Earnings Momentum
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
Feb 99
Aug 99
Feb 00
Aug 00
Feb 01
Aug 01
Feb 02
Aug 02
Feb 03
Aug 03
Feb 04
Aug 04
Feb 05
Aug 05
Feb 06
Aug 06
Feb 07
Aug 07
Feb 08
Aug 08
Feb 09
Aug 09
Feb 10
Aug 10
Feb 11
Aug 11
Feb 12
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
EPS momentum 3m FTSE350
Three months ending at date show n
Quality
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
Feb 99
Aug 99
Feb 00
Aug 00
Feb 01
Aug 01
Feb 02
Aug 02
Feb 03
Aug 03
Feb 04
Aug 04
Feb 05
Aug 05
Feb 06
Aug 06
Feb 07
Aug 07
Feb 08
Aug 08
Feb 09
Aug 09
Feb 10
Aug 10
Feb 11
Aug 11
Feb 12
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
Quality FTSE350
Three months ending at date show n
Fixed Charge Cover
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
Feb 99
Aug 99
Feb 00
Aug 00
Feb 01
Aug 01
Feb 02
Aug 02
Feb 03
Aug 03
Feb 04
Aug 04
Feb 05
Aug 05
Feb 06
Aug 06
Feb 07
Aug 07
Feb 08
Aug 08
Feb 09
Aug 09
Feb 10
Aug 10
Feb 11
Aug 11
Feb 12
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
Fixed charge Cover* FTSE350
Three months ending at date show n*Live triAngle factor since Feb 04. Previously Ex post backtest. 3m to Feb 04 N/A.
triAngle
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
30%
Feb 99
Aug 99
Feb 00
Aug 00
Feb 01
Aug 01
Feb 02
Aug 02
Feb 03
Aug 03
Feb 04
Aug 04
Feb 05
Aug 05
Feb 06
Aug 06
Feb 07
Aug 07
Feb 08
Aug 08
Feb 09
Aug 09
Feb 10
Aug 10
Feb 11
Aug 11
Feb 12
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
triAngle FTSE350
Three months ending at date show n
Longer term context: triAngle quarterly backtest
Best for 3 yrs
3rd Best in a decade
9 neg quarters in a row
2nd best in a decade
3rd Worstever
Worst for 3 yrs
Equal weightings dangerous at turning points
Top quintile minus bottom quintile on each factor on an equally weighted basis. Non-financials.
Quarterly backtests place recent trends in long-term context – Quality has been strong, Value weak.
Value rallies tend to be short/sharp events (2-3 quarters) – 2010/11 saw 9 negative quarters in a row.
Page 6
-40% -30% -20% -10% 0% 10% 20% 30%
triAngle
Value
Quality
Momentum
Quest™ Valn
Quest™ Mkt to Book
EV/Sales rel LRA
Div Yield rel LRA
PE Rel LRA
CFROC Spread*
Capital Growth
Equilibrium growth
Fixed charge Cover
CFROC change
9m relative trend
100/200 day switch
12m relative range
ST Indicator
EPS momentum 3m
UK end Nov 08-end Feb 09: Value rallied before the market
More stable value measures leading the way
Fixed charge cover: Feb-May 2009 -13%, May-Aug 2009 -7%
A sign of rotation
Quality held up
Page 7
80
100
120
140
160
Mar
09
Apr
09
May
09
Jun
09Ju
l 09
Aug
09
Sep
09
Oct
09
Nov
09
Dec
09
Jan
10F
eb 1
0M
ar 1
0A
pr 1
0M
ay 1
0Ju
n 10
Jul 1
0A
ug 1
0S
ep 1
0O
ct 1
0N
ov 1
0D
ec 1
0Ja
n 11
Feb
11
Mar
11
Apr
11
May
11
Jun
11Ju
l 11
Aug
11
Sep
11
Quest valuation Quest market-to-book Revenue multipleDividend yield P/E ratio
UK Value
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
Jan 9
0
Apr
90
Jul 9
0
Oct 90
Jan 9
1
Apr
91
Jul 9
1
Oct 91
Jan 9
2
Apr
92
Jul 92
Oc
t 92
Jan 9
3
Apr
93
Jul 9
3
Oct 93
Jan 9
4
Apr
94
Jul 9
4
Oc
t 9
4 60
70
80
90
100
110
120
130
140
150
160Value (Composite)
P/E
Price/Book
DY
DJSTOXX (RH)
Kept outperforming after the other value measures waned.M&A, just –in-time capexsupport a sustained rally
Which value measures?
2003-6
1992-4Price to book worked well (Pan Euro)
2009-11Market to book headed the Value charge
and sustained performance
Mkt troughMarch ‘09
Mkt peakFeb ‘11
80
100
120
140
160
180
Mar
03
Apr
03
May
03
Jun
03Ju
l 03
Aug
03
Sep
03
Oct
03
Nov
03
Dec
03
Jan
04F
eb 0
4M
ar 0
4A
pr 0
4M
ay 0
4Ju
n 04
Jul 0
4A
ug 0
4S
ep 0
4O
ct 0
4N
ov 0
4D
ec 0
4Ja
n 05
Feb
05
Mar
05
Apr
05
May
05
Jun
05Ju
l 05
Aug
05
Sep
05
Oct
05
Nov
05
Dec
05
Jan
06F
eb 0
6M
ar 0
6
Quest valuation Quest market-to-book Revenue multipleDividend yield P/E ratio
UK Value
During times of profit/cash flow volatility you need to assess Value using stable measures:
eg Quest market to book, EV/Sales.
Page 8
What is Quest™ market to book?
Total market capitalisation (equity + debt + quasi debt)
Quest™ market-to-book = ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Estimated replacement cost of assets
Quest™ market-to-book
● A variation on Tobin’s Q which compares market value of a company to the replacement cost of assets. (EV/Invested capital)
● Profits, sales, cash flows and dividends are all unpredictable at present.
● Valuation relative to the asset base is more stable.
● Excellent track record at market turning points.(“Time to get into the Q” note – November 2008)
Page 9
Quest default valuation
-50%
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
May-
01
Nov-
01
May-
02
Nov-
02
May-
03
Nov-
03
May-
04
Nov-
04
May-
05
Nov-
05
May-
06
Nov-
06
May-
07
Nov-
07
May-
08
Nov-
08
Upper qtlMedianLower qtl
Equities Expensive
Equities Cheap
EV/Sales rel. to trailing 10yr avg
0.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
May-
01
Nov-
01
May-
02
Nov-
02
May-
03
Nov-
03
May-
04
Nov-
04
May-
05
Nov-
05
May-
06
Nov-
06
May-
07
Nov-
07
May-
08
Nov-
08
May-
09
Nov-
09
May-
10
Nov-
10
May-
11
Nov-
11
Upper qtlMedianLower qtl
Equities Expensive
Equities Cheap
Quest Mkt-to-book (ex goodwill)
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
May
-01
Nov
-01
May
-02
Nov
-02
May
-03
Nov
-03
May
-04
Nov
-04
May
-05
Nov
-05
May
-06
Nov
-06
May
-07
Nov
-07
May
-08
Nov
-08
May
-09
Nov
-09
May
-10
Nov
-10
May
-11
Nov
-11
Upper qtlMedianLower qtl
Equities Expensive
Equities Cheap
But how much is now priced in?... market valuation charts Median valuation not far off the trough but close to the ‘new normal’
Stock dispersion is high – lots of cheap stocks and expensive stocks look dearer than in 08/09
Corporate action, policy response less likely to be as helpful this time, but less solvency risk
Page 10
Prices as at 9th May
New Normal?
New Normal?
Earnings yield rel. to trailing 10 yr avg
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
May
-01
Nov
-01
May
-02
Nov
-02
May
-03
Nov
-03
May
-04
Nov
-04
May
-05
Nov
-05
May
-06
Nov
-06
May
-07
Nov
-07
May
-08
Nov
-08
May
-09
Nov
-09
May
-10
Nov
-10
May
-11
Nov
-11
Upper qtlMedianLower qtl
Equities Cheap
Equities Expensive
Quest market to book (yr avg)
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
1987
1988
1989
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
+12
Current 0.79LRA 0.90
Quest market to book (yr avg)
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
+12
m
Current 0.67LRA 0.80
Quest™ market-to-book: What is the opportunity? Level + dispersion
Europe ex UK smallUK Large capAs at May 24
16% below LRA12% below LRA
Market levelUses average market cap for the year
Dispersion
Page 11
“Time to rejoin the Q”
“Who is still left in the Q?”
“Slowly moving up the Q”
“Jostling about in the Q”
CITN/ Newsletter articles“Time to get into the Q”
As at May 24
There are as many cheap stocks as summer 2009.
Quest™ market-to-book strategies 1) Buy cheapest companies on market-to-book
2) Consider pricing relative to a long-term view of asset’s productive capacity over their lifetime. Take Value AND Quality into account.
3) What if no mean reversion? – need to consider valuation relative to the ‘new normal’
Desire to avoid Value traps: Solvency, asset write downs (badwill)
Quest™ market-to-book
Q-discount (10yr) = ------------------------------------------------------
Cyclical average CFROC / WACC
Quest™ market-to-book
Q-discount (+12m) = ------------------------------------------------------
+12m CFROC / WACC
Page 12
Value screen I: UK Quest™ market-to-book – Time to rejoin the Q?
Updated weekly on Q-files.
Page 13
Our favourite screen which links Valuation with Quality – worked well in 2008
Value screen II: Trough valuations
Stocks trading with 10% of five-year trough valuation on Quest™ market to book
Ranked by
mkt cap
Priced 9th May
A potential source of ideas: Some stocks will be cheap for
a reason. Others will be genuine
opportunities
Screen also available for
EV/sales and other triAngle
metrics
Page 14
Value screen III: Superscreen Criteria
Page 15
Mkt to book below LRA
Quality filters (optional)
triAngle Value score
Upside on Quest and cheaper than usual
15% more upside than 10y average
A broad based value screen using the Quest website screening function
Value screen III: Value supererscreen stocks
Ranked by
mkt cap21 May
AA-B B
>5>0>15Criteria <0.8 Quality
Quality filters.1) Lots of
debt/quasi debt .2) Negative EPS
momentum. Signal of risk of a profit
warning?
Full screen on www.canaccordquest.com
Page 16
Over-extended valuations: The other side of the Value trade
Page 17
Outperformed
Lacks value support
Other risks
Compare with EV/sales
Companies which have outperformed but now lack value support
Over-extended valuations: The other side of the Value trade
Page 18
<13/33>15 >0
21 May
>1 >1
If EV/sales is higher than historic (long-run average), is that justified by higher margins. If so, is that margin sustainable?
Performance of the Q-discount screen from Nov 08-
Source:Datastream
Rel to WIEROP$
Q discount screen worked well
In 2008.
Source: Quest Newsletter
Nov 2008
Page 19
Appendices
What is Quest™?
Decision support tool for equity investors
Impartial corporate financial analysis
Idea generation and idea validation
Combines conventional and proprietary metrics
‘Glass box’, not a black box
Web-based products – www.canaccordquest.com
Helping investors make money since 1996
Page 21
What is Cash Flow Return On Capital?
Cash Flow Return On Capital (CFROC)
– Real (replacement cost)
– Post-tax
– Return On Gross Invested Capital
Better insight into corporate performance and valuation (takes into account all the capital used, asset life, asset mix, return of capital)
IRR calculation not A/B
(A) Gross cash flow = €10
(D) Asset life = 14 years
(B) Gross invested capital = €100
(C) Non-depreciationasset release = €15
Cash Flow Return On Capital (IRR) = 6.0%
Wealth creation Screening
Risk managemen
t tools
Value tools Performance M&A
Stocks & Products
Page 22
Quest™ valuation overview
Cash Flow Returns in a DCF model
Use consensus forecasts – 2-years forward
Forecast gross cash flows – existing assets wind-down
Forecast growth rate – reversion to mean
Forecast Cash Flow Return On Assets – future investment returns (reversion to
mean)
Forecast net cash flows – implicit
Discount back using WACC for Enterprise Value
Reversion to the mean
High CFROA Low CFROA High growth
Page 23
A broad-based view
Five Value factors:
Quest™ valuation
Quest™ market-to-book
EV/sales rel LRA
Dividend yield rel LRA
P/E rel LRA
Mix of absolute and relative measures
Value
Tesco: Quest™ valuation
Centrica: Dividend yield relative to market and history
Page 24
Aim to emulate the Quest™ Strategy page
Is it a good or a bad company?
High return/ growth stocks
Five Quality factors:
CFROC spread (5-year average)
Real capital growth (3-year average)
Equilibrium growth (3-year average)
Fixed charge cover (solvency FY1)
CFROC change (FY1)
Measures ability to generate shareholder value
: Quality
Tesco PLC: Cash flow returns
Tesco PLC: Invested capital and equilibrium growth
Page 25
Combination of price and earnings
Five Momentum factors:
Nine-month relative trend
100/200 day switch
12-month relative range
30/90 day switch
Earnings momentum (consensus)
Mixture of long, medium and short-term measures
: Momentum
Page 26
Each stock is compared to its universe
All 15 factors ranked in deciles
– 10 = ‘good’, 1 = ‘bad’
Add the five measures in each category and divide by
1.5
– Gives scores for Value, Quality and Momentum (/33)
Add together category score to get overall triAngle
score
Rank all the stocks in the universe, then re-decile
How the triAngle score is calculated
Page 27
triAngle history: Value, Quality and Momentum
12 years of live triAngle history
Value works in short sharp burst – normally when valuation dispersion is high.
During the credit crunch, and in H2 2011, Quality and Momentum were the main drivers
Top quintile minus bottom quintile on each factor on an equally weighted basis. Non-financials.
Page 28
Pan-Euro market-to-book performance
Page 29
Quality filters don’t help when the market takes
off
To 23 May 2012
But, will there be a ‘dash for trash’ this time?
Q discount has lagged
behind
Or did we see it in January?
Performance: Global Style Matrix: Risk off gainWealth creation Screening
Risk managemen
t tools
Value tools Performance M&A
Stocks & Products
Data to 18th May 2012Source: Top quintile minus bottom quintile on each factor on an equally weighted basis. Non-financials.
Page 30