7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
1/59
U [ ^ [ S G D
D`o`y : 9=6 / Umn$S{s / 9575 / UD IH^
NKOM LKGNMHGD IKYNGSGYLGD LK^[AGDGD ]GDB OGAG KSG
Ukdbgnmhgd Dkbkym Ihm~gy }gdb okokymlsg ngd okdbgnmhm ukylgyg umngdg
nkdbgd gcgyg ukokymlsggd imgsg nghgo ukygnmhgd ~mdblg~ uky~gog ~khga okdjg~{algd
u{~{sgd skigbgm ikyml{~ nghgo ukylgyg ~kynglrg :
Dgog Hkdblgu : Nys$ S[OGNJM Imd U@D^J@ LY@O@
^koug~ Hgamy : Ihm~gy
[o{y/^gdbbgh Hgamy : ;> ^ga{d / = @l~`iky 7=;6
Jkdms Lkhgomd : HglmhglmLkigdbsggd : Mdn`dksmg / Jgrg
^koug~ ^mdbbgh : Y^$53 / YR$M / Nksg Smygogd( Lkcgog~gd
Lksgoikd( Lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy
Gbgog : Mshgo
Uklkyjggd : UDS
^kynglrg nm~gagd ikyngsgylgd Ukdk~gugd Ukdgagdgd :
7$ Ukd}mnml ~gdbbgh :
9$ Ukd{d~{~ [o{o skjgl 6 Guymh 9575 s/n 9; Guymh 9575$
3$ Aglmo Ukdbgnmhgd Dkbkym ~gdbbgh 7; Guymh 9575 s/n 7> Okm 9575$
>$ Lk~{g Ukdbgnmhgd Dkbkym ~gdbbgh 7; Okm 9575 s/n ~gdbbgh 73 J{hm 957
;$ Ukyugdjgdbgd Lk~{g Ukdbgnmhgd ^mdbbm S{ygig}g skjgl ~gdbbgh 7> J{hm 9575 s/n
79 Gb{s~{s 9575$
^kynglrg nmngoumdbm hka Ukdgskag~ A{l{o$ = hkoigy l{m~gdsm {gdb }gdb nmikymlgd lk ikdngagyg ngym ngdg SIOU
Yu$73$>25$555(
;$ 79 hkoigy l{m~gdsm {gdb }gdb nmikymlgd lk ikdngagyg ngym ngdg I@S
Yu$66$;55$555(
6$ 7 i{l{ HUJ / SUJ ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU gdbbgygd 955>/955; igbm SOU UBYM
59 Lksgoikd igbmgd i{hgd Jgd{gymFkiy{gymOgyk~Guymh 955> ! lg~kb`ym ikh{o
skhksgm- nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka ukokbgdb Lgs ngd Lkughg Skl`hga$
2$ 75 i{l{ HUJ/SUJ ukdbb{dggd ngdg I@S 955;/9556 igbm SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd igbmgd i{hgd Sku~koiky 955; s/n Jgd{gym 9552 !Lg~kb`ym ikh{o
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
3/59
3
skhksgm- nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka Nys$S[OGNJM$
1$ I{l{ yklkdmdb ^gi{dbgd Igdl Jg~mo D`$57>952515> Gd$SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd / S{ognjm
=$ I{l{ yklkdmdb ~gi{dbgd Igdl Jg~mo d` ykl$ 5>69572556 Gd$SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd / ^[OU[L
75$7 i{l{ i{l~m ukdbkh{gygd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga Nys$S{ognjm ngd ikdnkh
l{m~gdsm/ukoikhgdjggd ukdbkh{gygd dmhgm Yu$72$375$69;( !i{l{ sgou{h imy{-
77$7 hkoigy d`~g ~mdngsgd g~gs ukoikhmgd 79 i{ga ugugd ~ky~gdbbgh 35569556 `hka
SND 59 Lksgoikd !rgydg okyga o{ng-
79$7 ikdnkh S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd I{ug~m Ihm~gy D`o`y ;37 ~ga{d 9553 ~gdbbgh
72 Nkskoiky 9553 ~kd~gdb Ukdk~gugd Ukdbkh`hg Uy`bygo Ukoikymgd S{ismnm
Img}g Omdmogh Ukdnmnmlgd ngd hgoumygdd}g
73$3 hkoigy SUUI !S{yg~ Ukyjgdjmgd Ukoikymgd Igd~{gd- ULUS IIO/I@S
7>$7 ikdnkh S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd I{ug~m Ihm~gy D`o`y 36; ~ga{d 9556 ~gdbbgh
93 Gb{s~{s 9556 ~kd~gdb Ukoikd~{lgd Sklyk~gymg~ Uy`bygo L`oukdsgsm
Ukdb{ygdbgd S{ismnm Igagd Iglgy Omd}gl !ULUS IIO- Imngdb Ukdnmnmlgd nm
Lgi$Ihm~gy ~ga{d 9556
7;$7 ikdnkh YGUIS ngdg USIOU ~ga{d 955>
76$7 ikdnkh f`~`c`u} YGUIS ~ga{d 955; SOU UBYM 9 LKSGOIKD
72$7 ikdnkh f`~`c`u} YGUIS ~ga{d 9556 SOU UBYM 9 LKSGOIKD
71$7 ikdnkh YGUIS ~ga{d 955;/9556 ukym`nk J{hm s$n Nkskoiky 955;
7=$7 ikdnkh YGUIS ~ga{d 9556 ukym`nk i{hgd Jgd{gym s/n J{dm 9556
95$7 ikdnkh l{m~gdsm ngd d`~g ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU Jgd{gym 955> s/n J{dm 955;
ngd I@S ukym`nk J{hm 955; s/n Nkskoiky 9556$
97$7 hkoigy l{m~gdsm ukd}kygagd {gdb ~gdbbgh 995=9552 skiksgy Yu$75$555$555(
99$7 !sg~{- ikdnkh FC s{ismnm ngym ukokymd~ga
^k~gu ~kyhgoumy nghgo ikylgs ukylgyg$
93$[gdb SIOU ngd I@S Yu$72$119$;>9( nmygougs {d~{l Dkbgyg$
6$ Okdk~gulgd s{ug}g ~kynglrg nmikigdm {d~{l okoig}gy img}g ukylgyg skiksgy
Yu$ ;$555( ! hmog ymi{ y{umga -$
^khga okdnkdbgy ukyo`a`dgd ngym ~kynglrg skcgyg hksgd }gdb ugng
u`l`ld}g oko`a`d a{l{ogd }gdb skymdbgdymdbgdd}g
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
4/59
>
Igarg mg ~kynglrg Nys$ S[OGNJM IMD U@D^J@ LY@O@( skhgl{ Lkughg
Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( Ihm~gy ikyngsgylgd S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd Lk~{g
UUHU UBYM Uy`umdsm Jgrg ^mo{y D`o`y : 76 / C$7 / SOU / M / 955> ~gdbbgh
7; Jgd{gym 955>( ugng i{hgd Jgd{gym 955> sgougm nkdbgd i{hgd Nkskoiky 9556
g~g{ sk~mngl~mngld}g ugng rgl~{ ~ky~kd~{ nghgo ~ga{d 955> sgougm nkdbgd
~ga{d 9556( iky~koug~ nm SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( Ihm~gy g~g{ sk~mngl~mngld}g
ogsma ~kyogs{l nghgo ngkyga a{l{o Ukdbgnmhgd Dkbkym Ihm~gy( skcgyg okhgrgd
a{l{o okhgl{lgd ukyi{g~gd okoukylg}g nmym skdnmym g~g{ `ygdb hgmd g~g{ s{g~{
l``yu`ygsm }gdb ngug~ oky{bmlgd lk{gdbgd Dkbgyg g~g{ ukykl`d`omgd dkbgyg(
nmhgl{lgd ~kynglrg nkdbgd cgyg skigbgm ikyml{~ :
Igarg nghgo ~ga{d gdbbgygd 955> / 955; SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ~khga
okdngug~lgd igd~{gd ngdg ngym ukokymd~ga iky{ug ngdg SIOU !S{ismnm Img}g
Omdmogh Ukdnmnmlgd- }gdb ikyj{ohga skiksgy Yu$ 39$695$555( !~mbg u{h{a n{g
j{~g kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a ymi{ y{umga-( ngd lko{nmgd nghgo ~ga{d gdbbgygd
955;/ 9556 okdngug~ igd~{gd ngdg ngym ukokymd~ga iky{ug ngdg I@S ! Igd~{gd
@ukygsm`dgh Skl`hga- }gdb ikyj{ohga skiksgy Yu$ 19$;>3$762( !nkhgugd u{h{a
n{g j{~g hmog yg~{s koug~ u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga-$
Igarg sks{gm nkdbgd Ukn`ogd ^kldms Ukh
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
5/59
;
ngd sko{g b{y{( dgo{d nghgo ukoi{g~gd / ukd}{s{dgd YGUIS ~kyski{~(
^kynglrg ~mngl ukydga okhmig~lgd L`om~k ngd sko{g b{y{$
Igarg {d~{l ukdcgmygd ngdg SIOU og{u{d ngdg I@S ~kyski{~ skagy{sd}g
nmhgl{lgd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga ikysgogsgog nkdbgd Ikdngagyg( dgo{d {d~{l
ukhglsgdggdd}g nghgo ukdcgmygd ngdg nmogls{n nmhgl{lgd skdnmym `hka ^kynglrg
skhgl{ Lkughg Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( nkdbgd cgyg ^kynglrg
okomd~glgd ~gdng ~gdbgd shmu ukdbgoimhgd lkugng Ikdngagyg !sglsm ^{ou{l
Mdnyg}g~m- ngd skhgdj{~d}g ngdg ~kyski{~ ~kynglrg goimh !nmcgmylgd- skdnmym nm
Igdl IUN / Igdl Jg~mo$ Sk~khga ngdg SIOU nmgoimh / nmcgmylgd `hka ^kynglrg
skiksgy Yu$ 39$695$555( !~mbg u{h{a n{g j{~g kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a ymi{ y{umga-(
lko{nmgd `hka ^kynglrg nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg skiksgy Yu$ 73$>25$555(
!~mbg ikhgs j{~g koug~ yg~{s ~{j{a u{h{a ymi{ y{umga-$ Skngdblgd {d~{l ngdg I@S
skiksgy Yu$ 19$;>3$762( !nkhgugd u{h{a n{g j{~g hmog yg~{s koug~ u{h{a ~mbg ymi{
skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga- `hka ^kynglrg nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg
skiksgy Yu$ 66$;55$555( !kdgo u{h{a kdgo j{~g hmog yg~{s ymi{ y{umga-$
Igarg smsg ngdg SIOU !S{ismnm Img}g Omdmogh Ukdnmnmlgd- ngd ngdg I@S
!Igd~{gd @ukygsm`dgh Skl`hga- ogsmdbogsmdb skiksgy Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd
skiksgy Yu$ 76$5>3$762( nkdbgd j{ohga lkskh{y{agd skiksgy Yu$ 3;$7=3$762(
}gdb gng ugng kynglrg( ~khga ^kynglrg ukyb{dglgd gd~gyg hgmd {d~{l :
7$ Lrmd~gsm d` > {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955>
skiksgy Yu 9$735$555( ! n{g j{~g skyg~{s ~mbg u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
9$ Lrmd~gsm d` ; {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ ~{hms lgd~`y SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
3$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 1 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdbd}g ~mngl gng$
>$ Lrmd~gdsm d` = {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd i{l{ smhgigs skiksgy
Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
;$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 75 {d~{l img}g ukhgu`ygd skiksgy Yu 6;$52;( ! kdgo u{h{a
hmog ymi{ ~{j{a u{h{a hmog y{umga - ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd ukn`ogd {o{o I@S$
6$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 77 {d~{l ukoikhmgd 9; u`~`db lgmd ig~ml b{y{ skiksgy
Yu 69;$555( ! kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a hmog ymi{ y{umga - ~mngl nmikdgylgd
okd{y{~ i{l{ ukn`ogd okd{y{~ SIOU$
2$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 95 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ugdn{gd [DGS lhgs 3 ! IMD( IMB(
O^L - skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
6/59
6
1$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 97 {d~{l lkbmg~gd hmdbl{dbgd UUHU UBYM skiksgy skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
=$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 93 {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd `hga
ygbg skiksgy Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
75$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 9> {d~{l ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd ! i{l{ O^L(
Ugdn{gd [GD Lhgs 3 - skiksgy Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{
y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
77$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 37 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ugy~msmugsm Mjgsga skiksgy Yu ;=$555(
! hmog u{h{a skoimhgd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
79$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 3> {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukd}k~`ygd ngf~gy s{s{hgd 9= smsrg lk
S{ygig}g skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
73$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 36 {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ghg~ hms~yml skiksgy Yu 7>$555( ! koug~
ikhgs ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
7>$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 32 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd ukoikhgjgygd ngd
i{l{ smhgigs skiksgy Yu =55$555( ! skoimhgd yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~ mngl
gng / fml~mf
7;$ Lrmd~gdsm d` >5 {d~{l ukoig}gygd m{ygd Uygo{lg skiksgy Yu 721$555(
! skyg~{s ~{j{a u{h{a nkhgud ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
76$ Lrmd~gdsm d` >7 {d~{l ukoig}gygd Ukdbgrgsgd y{gdb {hgdbgd skoks~ky M
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
72$ Lrmd~gdsm d` >9 {d~{l ukoig}gygd OLLS nm NMLI[N Ihm~gy skiksgy
Yu 9;5$555( ! n{g yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
71$ Lrmd~gdsm d` >> {d~{l ukoikhmgd 79 i{ga ugugd Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s
hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
7=$ Lrmd~gdsm d` >; {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ u`hm`( lgu{y ~{hms( i`hu`md( ~md~g
u`hmdky( ~md~g ugyiky skiksgy Yu 7$=73$555( ! sg~{ j{~g skoimhgd yg~{s ~mbg
ikhgs ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
95$ Lrmd~gdsm d` >6 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukdbgrgs y{gdb [GD ngd ~ygdsu`y~
skiksgy Yu 655$555( ! kdgo yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
Igarg {d~{l uky~gdbb{db jgrgigd ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S(
ogsmdbogsmdb `hka Ikdngagyg skl`hga ngd ~kynglrg skhgl{ Lkughg Skl`hga SOU
UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( ~khga okoi{g~ SUJ / HUJ skdnmymskdnmym( }gdb ogdg SUJ /
HUJ }gdb nmi{g~ Ikdngagyg nmhgoumym nkdbgd d`~gd`~g ukoikhmgd( ngd
skigbgmd}g( dgo{d ~kyagngu ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S }gdb gng ugng ~kynglrg
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
7/59
2
nghgo ukoi{g~gd SUJ / HUJ d}g ~mngl nmhgoumylgd i{l~mi{l~m ukdn{l{db
ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ ! d`~g( ngd hgmdd}g -$
Igarg nkdbgd nmb{dglgdd}g ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S `hka ~kynglrg
}gdb ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd uky{d~{lgdd}g ~kyski{~( oglg Dkbgyg Cw$ Ukokymd~ga
Lgi Ihm~gy ~khga nmy{bmlgd skiksgy Yu 3;$7=3$762( ! ~mbg u{h{a hmog j{~g skyg~{s
skoimhgd u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga - g~g{ sk~mngld}g
ikyj{ohga sklm~gy m~{
Ukyi{g~gd ~kynglrg skigbgmogdg nmg~{y ngd nmgdcgo umngdg nghgo ugsgh 9
!7- J` ugsgh 71 !7- [[ YM D`$ 37 ^ga{d 7=== skigbgmogdg ~khga nm{iga nkdbgd
[[ YM D` 95 ^ga{d 9557 ~kd~gdb Ukoikygd~gsgd ^mdngl Umngdg L`y{usm$
S[ISMNGMY :
Igarg mg ~kynglrg Nys$ S[OGNJM Imd U@D^J@LY@O@ skhgl{ Lkughg
Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ikyngsgylgd S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd Lk~{g UUHU
UBYM Uy`umdsm Jgrg ^mo{y D`o`y : 76/ C M / SOU / M / 955> ~gdbbgh 7; Jgd{gym
955>( ugng i{hgd Jgd{gym 955> sgougm nkdbgd i{hgd Nkskoiky 9556 g~g{ sk~mngl
~mngld}g ugng rgl~{ ~ky~kd~{ nghgo ~ga{d 955> sgougm nkdbgd ~ga{d 9556
iky~koug~ nm Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd g~g{ sk~mngl~mngld}g ogsma
~kyogs{l nghgo ngkyga a{l{o Ukdbgnmhgd Dkbkym Ihm~gy (skcgyg okhgrgd a{l{o
okhgl{lgd ukyi{g~gd nkdbgd ~{j{gd okdb{d~{dblgd nmym skdnmym g~g{ `ygdb hgmd
g~g{ l``yu`ygsm( okd}ghga b{dglgd lkrkdgdbgd( lkskoug~gd g~g{ sgygdg }gdb
gng ugngd}g lgykdg jgig~gd g~g{ lkn{n{lgd }gdb ngug~ oky{bmlgd lk{gdbgd
Dkbgyg g~g{ Ukykl`d`omgd Dkbgyg( nmhgl{lgd ~kynglrg nkdbgd cgyg skigbgm
ikyml{~ :
Igarg ~kynglrg skhgl{ Lkughg Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
ikyngsgylgd S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd Lk~{g UUHU UBYM Uy`umdsm Jgrg ^mo{y D`o`y :
76/CM/SOU/M/955> ~gdbbgh 7; Jgd{gym 955> ~kyagngu igd~{gd ngdg I@S ! Igd~{gd
@ukygsm`dgh Skl`hga - okou{d}gm ~{bgs ngd ~gdbb{db jgrgi skigbgm ikyml{~ :
g$ Okhgl{lgd vkymfmlgsm j{ohga ngdg }gdb nm~kymog nkdbgd ng~g smsrg }gdb gng$
Imhg j{ohga ngdg okhkimam ngym ngdg }gdb skoks~md}g oglg agy{s skbkyg
okdbkoighmlgd lkhkimagd ngdg ~kyski{~ lk yklkdmdb Sg~lky Uy`umdsm nkdbgd
okoikym~ga{lgd lk ~mo ULUS IIO Lgi / L`~g$
i$ Ikysgogsgog nkdbgd l`om~k Skl`hga( okdbmnkd~mfmlgsm smsrg omslmd }gdb
glgd nmikigslgd ngym skbghg jkdms m{ygd$
c$ Okdbkh`hg ngdg I@S skcgyg iky~gdbb{db jgrgi ngd ~ygdsugygd$
n$ Okdb{o{olgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg I@S okd{y{~ l`ou`dkd ngd iksgy ngdgd}g
nm ugugd ukdb{o{ogd skl`hga$
k$ Iky~gdbb{db jgrgi ~kyagngu ukd}mougdgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg nm skl`hga$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
8/59
1
f$ Okoikymlgd ukhg}gdgd ngd ukdgdbgdgd ukdbgn{gd ogs}gyglg~$
b$ Okhgu`ylgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg I@S lkugng ^mo ULUS IIO Lgi / L`~g$
Igarg nghgo ~ga{d gdbbgygd 955> / 955; SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
~khga okdngug~ igd~{gd ngdg ngym ukokymd~ga iky{ug ngdg SIOU ! S{issmnm Img}g
Omdmogh Ukdnmnmlgd - }gdb ikyj{ohga Yu 39$695$555( ! ~mbg u{h{a n{g j{~g kdgo
yg~{s n{g u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - ngd lko{nmgd nghgo ~ga{d gdbbgygd 955; / 9556
okdngug~ igd~{gd ngdg ngym Ukokymd~ga iky{ug ngdg I@S ! Igd~{gd @ukygsm`dgh
Skl`hga - }gdb ikyj{ohga skiksgy Yu 19$;>3$762( ! nkhgugd u{h{a n{g j{~g hmog
yg~{s koug~ u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga -$ Igarg sks{gm
nkdbgd ukn`ogd ~kldms ukhglsgdggd uy`bygo ukoikymgd S{ismnm Img}g Omdmogh
Ukdnmnmlgd ! SIOU - ~kyski{~ nmogls{nlgd {d~{l okoikymlgd img}g lki{~{agd
okdngsgy ngd u`l`l igbm smsrg SN / OM( SOU / O^s$ Dkbkym ngd Srgs~g nghgo
ikd~{l {gdb }gdb nmikymlgd lkugng hkoigbg( }gdb iky~{j{gd {d~{l okdb{ygdbm
j{ohga smsrg u{~{s skl`hga ugng jkdjgdb ukdnmnmlgd ngsgy SN / OM( SOU / O^s$
Dkbkym ngd Srgs~g okoigd~{ smsrg okhgdj{~lgd lknghgo jkdjgdb }gdb hkima
~mdbbm igml }gdb nmskigilgd `hka l`dnmsm bk`bygfms( kl`d`om og{u{d ghgsgd
s`smgh hgmdd}g( ngd {d~{l okdmdblg~lgd gdblg ugy~msmugsm lgsgy$
Skngdblgd ngdg I@S sks{gm nkdbgd ~kldms ukhglsgdggd}g uy`bygo ukoikymgd
Img}g @ukygsm`dgh Skl`hga ! I@S - ~kyski{~ nmogls{nlgd {d~{l okoikigslgd
img}g ukdnmnmlgd igbm smsrg ~ mngl ogou{ ngd okymdbgdlgd igbm smsrg }gdb hgmd(
gbgy okyklg okouky`hka hg}gdgd ukdnmnmlgd ngsgy }gdb hkima ikyo{~{ sgougm
~gog~ nghgo ygdblg ukd{d~gsgd rgjmi ikhgjgy = ~ga{d$
Igarg skikh{o ngdg S{ismnm Img}g Omdmogh Ukdnmnmlgd ! SIOU - ngd
Img}g @ukygsm`dgh Skl`hga ! I@S - ~{y{d / ~kykghmsgsm nmrgjmilgd igbm skl`hga
}gdb okdngug~lgd igd~{gd ngdg ngym ukokymd~ga ~kyski{~ {d~{l okoi{g~ YGUIS
!Ykdcgdg Gdbbgygd Ukdngug~gd Img}g Skl`hga -$ Nmogdg nghgo ukoi{g~gd /
ukd}{s{dgd YGUIS nmogls{n skagy{sd}g nmagnmym `hka Lkughg Skl`hga( L`om~k
ngd sko{g b{y{( dgo{d nghgo ukoi{g~gd / ukd}{s{dgd YGUIS ~kyski{~
^kynglrg ~mngl ukydga okhmig~lgd l`om~k ngd sko{g b{y{$
Igarg {d~{l ukdcgmygd ngdg SIOU og{u{d ngdg I@S ~kyski{~ skagy{sd}g
nmhgl{lgd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga ikysgogsgog ikdngagyg( dgo{d {d~{l
ukhglsgdggdd}g nghgo ukdcgmygd ngdg nmogls{n nmhgl{lgd skdnmym `hka ~kynglrg
skhgl{ Lkughg Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( nkdbgd cgyg ~kynglrg
okomd~glgd ~gdng ~gdbgd shmu ukdbgoimhgd lkugng ikdngagyg ! sglsm ^{ou{l
Mdnyg}g~m - ngd skhgdj{~d}g ngdg ~kyski{~ ~kynglrg goimh / cgmylgd skdnmym nm Igdl
IUN / Igdl Jg~mo$ Sk~khga ngdg SIOU nmgoimh / nmcgmylgd `hka ~kynglrg skiksgy
Yu 39$695$555( ! ~mbg u{h{a n{g j{~g kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a ymi{ y{umga -
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
9/59
=
lko{nmgd nmskygalgd ikdngagyg skiksgy Yu 73$>25$555( !~mbg ikhgs j{~g koug~
yg~{s ~{j{a u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - skngdblgd ngdg I@S skiksgy Yu 19$;>3$762(
! nkhgugd u{h{a n{g j{~g hmog yg~{s koug~ u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a
y{umga - sk~khga nmgoimh / nmcgmylgd `hka ~kynglrg okhgh{m Igdl IUN / Igdl Jg~mo
nmskygalgd lkugng ikdngagyg skiksgy Yu 66$;55$555( ! kdgo u{h{a kdgo j{~g
hmog yg~{s ymi{ y{umga -$
Igarg smsg ngdg SIOU! S{issmnm Img}g Omdmogh Ukdnmnmlgd - ngd ngdg
I@S ! Igd~{gd @ukygsm`dgh Skl`hga - ogsmdbogsmdb skiksgy Yu 7=$7;5$55(
! skoimhgd ikhgs j{~g skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - ngd Yu 76$5>3$762( ! kdgo
ikhgs j{~g koug~ u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga - nkdbgd j{ohga
lkskh{y{agd skiksgy Yu 3;$7=3$762 ! ~mbg u{h{a hmog j{~g skyg~{s skoimhgd u{h{a
~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga - skngdblgd }gdb gng ugng ~kynglrg
nmukyb{dglgd {d~{l :
7$ Lrmd~gsm d` > {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955>
skiksgy Yu 9$735$555( ! n{g j{~g skyg~{s ~mbg u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
9$ Lrmd~gsm d` ; {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ ~{hms lgd~`y SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
3$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 1 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
>$ Lrmd~gdsm d` = {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd i{l{ smhgigs skiksgy
Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
;$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 75 {d~{l img}g ukhgu`ygd skiksgy Yu 6;$52;( ! kdgo u{h{a
hmog ymi{ ~{j{a u{h{a hmog y{umga - ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd ukn`ogd gdgl I@S$
6$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 77 {d~{l ukoikhmgd 9; u`~`db lgmd ig~ml b{y{ skiksgy
Yu 69;$555( ! kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a hmog ymi{ y{umga - ~mngl nmikdgylgd
okd{y{~ i{l{ ukn`ogd okd{y{~ SIOU$
2$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 95 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ugdn{gd [DGS lhgs 3 ! IMD( IMB(
O^L - skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
1$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 97 {d~{l lkbmg~gd hmdbl{dbgd UUHU UBYM skiksgy skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
=$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 93 {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd `hga
ygbg skiksgy Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
10/59
75
75$Lrmd~gdsm d` 9> {d~{l ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd ! i{l{ O^L(
Ugdn{gd [GD Lhgs 3 - skiksgy Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{
y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
77$Lrmd~gdsm d` 37 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ugy~msmugsm Mjgsga skiksgy Yu ;=$555(
! hmog u{h{a skoimhgd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
79$Lrmd~gdsm d` 3> {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukd}k~`ygd ngf~gy s{s{hgd 9= smsrg lk
S{ygig}g skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf
73$Lrmd~gdsm d` 36 {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ghg~ hms~yml skiksgy Yu 7>$555( ! koug~
ikhgs ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
7>$Lrmd~gdsm d` 32 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd ukoikhgjgygd ngd i{l{
smhgigs skiksgy Yu =55$555( ! skoimhgd yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf
7;$Lrmd~gdsm d` >5 {d~{l ukoig}gygd m{ygd Uygo{lg skiksgy Yu 721$555(
! skyg~{s ~{j{a u{h{a nkhgud ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
76$Lrmd~gdsm d` >7 {d~{l ukoig}gygd Ukdbgrgsgd y{gdb {hgdbgd skoks~ky M
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
72$Lrmd~gdsm d` >9 {d~{l ukoig}gygd OLLS nm NMLI[N Ihm~gy skiksgy
Yu 9;5$555( ! n{g yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
71$Lrmd~gdsm d` >> {d~{l ukoikhmgd 79 i{ga ugugd Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s
hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
7=$ Lrmd~gdsm d` >; {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ u`hm`( lgu{y ~{hms( i`hu`md( ~md~g
u`hmdky( ~md~g ugyiky skiksgy Yu 7$=73$555( ! sg~{ j{~g skoimhgd yg~{s ~mbg ikhgs
ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
95$Lrmd~gdsm d` >6 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukdbgrgs y{gdb [GD ngd ~ygdsu`y~
skiksgy Yu 655$555( ! kdgo yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
Igarg {d~{l uky~gdbb{db jgrgigd ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S(
ogsmdbogsmdb `hka Ikdngagyg skl`hga ngd ~kynglrg skhgl{ Lkughg Skl`hga SOU
UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( ~khga okoi{g~ SUJ / HUJ skdnmymskdnmym( }gdb ogdg SUJ /
HUJ }gdb nmi{g~ Ikdngagyg nmhgoumym nkdbgd d`~gd`~g ukoikhmgd(ngd
skigbgmd}g( dgo{d ~kyagngu ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S }gdb gng ugng ~kynglrg
nghgo ukoi{g~gd SUJ / HUJ d}g ~mngl nmhgoumylgd i{l~mi{l~m ukdn{l{db
ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ ! d`~g( ngd hgmdd}g -$
Igarg nkdbgd nmb{dglgdd}g ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S `hka ~kynglrg
}gdb ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd uky{d~{lgdd}g ~kyski{~( oglg Dkbgyg Cw$ Ukokymd~ga
Lgi Ihm~gy ~khga nmy{bmlgd skiksgy Yu 3;$7=3$762( ! ~mbg u{h{a hmog j{~g skyg~{s
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
11/59
77
skoimhgd u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga - g~g{ sk~mngld}g
ikyj{ohga sklm~gy m~{$
Ukyi{g~gd ~kynglrg skigbgmogdg nmg~{y ngd nmgdcgo umngdg ngho ugsgh 3 J`
71 !7- [[ YM D`$ 37 ^ga{d 7=== skigbgmogdg ~khga nm{iga nkdbgd [[ YM D` 95
^ga{d 9557 ~kd~gdb Ukoikygd~gsgd ^mdngl Umngdg L`y{usm$
Okdmoigdb( igarg ~kyagngu nglrggd ~kyski{~ ~kynglrg okdbg~glgd
okdbky~m ngd ~kynglrg j{bg ~mngl okdbgj{lgd lkikyg~gd !klskusm-$
Okdmoigdb( igarg {d~{l okoi{l~mlgd nglrggdgdd}g Ukd{d~{~ [o{o
~khga okdbgj{lgd sglsmsglsm }gdb ogsmdbogsmdb ~khga nmnkdbgy lk~kygdbgdd}g
nmukysmngdbgd skigbgm ikyml{~ :
7$ Sglsm OGAKDNYG( hglmhglm( {o{y >3 ~ga{d( lyms~kd( srgs~g/jgig~gd skigbgm b{y{
SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd Lgi$ Ihm~gy( Mdn`dksmg/jgrg( ~koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh 97
Gb{s~{s 7=6>( ghgog~ nm Jh smdb`h{ny` D`$ 97 lkh Ykoigdb Lkc$ Sgdgdrk~gd l`~g
Ihm~gy( S7( nm igrga s{ouga okdkygdblgd sii 3$762(
Igarg ikdgy sglsm okdbky~m gngd}g lkjgnmgd ~kyski{~ sk~khga nmikym~ga{ `hka
sglsm ^[OU[L MDNYG]G^M( SUn$ ]gdb okdjgig~ skhgl{ ikdngagyg SOU
UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( skigi {gdb }gdb ~khga nmcgmylgd ngym igdl ikh{o
skh{y{ad}g nmskygalgd lkugng ikdngagyg$
Igarg ikdgy lkjgnmgd ~kyski{~ ~kyjgnm l{y{drgl~{ nm~kymogd}g gdbbgygd SIOU
ngd ngdg I@S ikylmsgy ~ga{d 955;9556$
Igarg ikdgy ukyi{g~gd ~kyski{~ nmhgl{lgd `hka sg{ngyg Nys$ S[OGNJM nkdbgd
cgyg igarg sk~khga ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ~si nmcgmylgd ngym igdl IUN/
igdl Jg~mo oglg ~mngl skh{y{ad}g ngdg m~{ nmskygalgd lkugng ikdngagyg {d~{l
nmlkh`hg skigbgm lkukyh{gd skl`hga dgo{d gng ngdg }gdb ogsma nmigrg
~kynglrg S{ognjm sks{gm nkdbgd cg~g~gd ukymdcmgd }gdb nmi{g~ ikdngagyg$
Igarg ikdgy sks{gm nkdbgd cg~g~gd ikdngagyg }gdb ~mngl nmskygalgd lkugng
ikdngagyg gnghga ngym ngdg SIOU skdmhgm Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd ngdg I@S
gnghga skdmhgm Yu$76$5>3$762($
Igarg ikdgy skamdbbg g~gs ngdg skl`hga }gdb nmigrg `hka Lkughg skl`hga
Nys$ S[OGNJM ~kyski{~ oglg lgom skigbgm umagl B^^ ngd ugyg U^^ ~mngl
okdkymog ukoig}gygd a`d`y }gdb skagy{sd}g nm~kymog( skngdblgd lkgnggd
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
12/59
79
ikhgjgy okdbgjgy skl`hga okdbghgom lgcg{ skigi okdjkhgdb ukhglsgdggd
[jmgd/[GD$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm skigbgm b{y{ ~mngl ukydga nmhmig~lgd nghgo ukd}{s{dgd
YGUIS$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ngd umagl SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd okdbghgom lky{bmgd
skigd}gl Yu$3;$7=3$555($
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm( nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
9$ Sglsm GIN[H AGLMO( hglmhglm( {o{y ;7 ~ga{d( Mshgo( b{y{ SOU UBYM 59
lksgoikd( mdn`dksmg/ jgrg( ~koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ghgog~ nksg lksgoikdY~$57/57
lksgoikd Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy ska{i{dbgd gngd}g n{bggd ukyi{g~gd ukdbbkhgugd
{gdb }gdb nmhgl{lgd `hka Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m gnghga igarg sglsm ukydga nm~gd}g sgog ~kogd
~gogd B^^/U^^ ~gd~gdb ukdbk~mlgd SUJ/HUJ ukdbb{dggd ngdg I@S$ Ngd ikdgy
okogdb sglsm }gdb okhgl{lgd ukdbk~mlgd$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ikynmdgs skigbgm UDS nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd okdbgjgy
skigbgm b{y{( oglg sglsm ~khga nms{y{a `hka lkughg skl`hga Nys$ S[OGNJM
{d~{l okhgl{lgd ukdbk~mlgd SUJ/HUJ ngdg I@S ngd ngym agsmh lkyjg ~kyski{~
sglsm okdngug~lgd jgsg ukdbk~mlgd$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm okdkygdblgd igarg sglsm lkdgh nkdbgd Nys$ S[OGNJM
lgykdg skigbgm lkughg skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ~mngl okdbky~m gngd}g ukyi{g~gd Nys$ S[OGNJM ~khga
okhgl{lgd ukyi{g~gd okdbb{dglgd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm agd}g nms{y{a okoigd~{ okoi{g~ g~g{ okdbk~ml SUJ/HUJ
ngym {gdb ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S }gdb ~khga nm~kymog( sk~khga skhksgm
ukdbk~mlgd m~{ oglg }gdb iky~gdbb{db jgrgi gnghga lkughg skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ~mngl ikyagl okdkymog ngdg I@S g~g{ SIOU ~kski{~ skigi
sglsm skigbgm UDS }gdb okdbgjgy nmskl`hga ~kyski{~ skngdblgd ngdg SIOU ngd
ngdg I@S {d~{l ukd}khkdbgyggd skl`hga igbm B^^/U^^$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l jgsg ukdbk~mlgd sglsm nmikym moighgd img}g skiksgy
Yu$ 2;$555( uky i{l{ nmukyb{dglgd {d~{l jgsg ngd ukoikhmgd lky~gs$
Igarg ikdgy okdbkdgm okdbgug ugyg B^^ ngd U^^ ikh{o ~gdng ~gdbgd ugng
lrm~gdsm SUJ/HUJ oglg sglsm j{bg ~mngl okdbky~m skigi agd}g okdbk~ml sgjg ngd
}gdb iky~gdbb{db jgrgi gnghga umagl lkughg skl`hga$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
13/59
73
Igarg ikdgy sglsm okoi{g~ 6 ikdnkh i{l{ skjgl ~ga{d 955;9556( skngdblgd
{d~{l hgu`ygd }gdb hgmd sglsm ~mngl okdbk~ga{m$
Igarg ikdgy nghgo okoi{g~ / okd}{s{d SUJ / HUJ ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU
ngd ngdg I@S ~si( sgg~ m~{ ~mngl nmhgoumylgd i{l~m9 ukdn{l{db ukdbb{dggd
ngdg ~kyski{~$
Igarg sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m SUJ / HUJ }gdb nm~{dj{llgd
nmukysmngdbgd$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ~khga ukydga okd}{s{d YGUIS
nghgo ukdkymoggd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~ sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm
ngd }gdb sglsm ~ga{ agd}g YGUIS ~kyski{~ nms{s{d ngd nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka
lkughg ngd l`om~k skl`hga( skngdblgd sglsm ~mngl ukydga nmgjgl / nmml{~lgd
nghgo ukd}{s{dgd YGUIS ~si$
Igarg ikdgy gugimhg SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ~khga okdkymog ngd
okdbb{dglgd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ~kyski{~ oglg agy{s okouky~gdbb{db
jgrgilgd ukdbb{dggdd}g ngd {d~{l oklgdmsokd}g igbgmogdg sglsm ~mngl ~ga{
sgog sklghm$
Igarg ikdgy sks{gm nkdbgd uy`skn{y sko{g ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S( }gdb
ogdg skigbmgd ngdg SIOU skiksgy Yu$7=$7;5$555( ngd ngdg I@S Yu$
76$5>3$762( }gdb nmn{bg nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm lkughg skl`hga
SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd }gm~{ Nys$ S[OGNJM agy{s nmb{dglgd {d~{l
lkukd~mdbgd lkbmg~gd ikhgjgy okdbgjgy nm skl`hga$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
3$ Sglsm NGY]@D@( hglmhglm( {o{y >3 ~ga{d Mshgo b{y{ SOU 7 N`l`( Mdn`dksmg/
jgrg( ~koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh 93 sku~koiky 7=6>( ghgog~ Nsd$ ^kugs Y~$ 59/57
Lkc$ Lksgoikd Lgi$ Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgd s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd ukd}ghgab{dggd ngdg SIOU
~ga{d 955>955; ngd ngdg I@S ~ga{d 955;9556 nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ogsghga ngdg SIOU ~ngd ngdg I@S ~ga{d nm SOU UBYM 59
lksgoikd ~si sglsm skdnmym ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghmukdbb{dggdd}g glgd ~k~gum
sglsm ukydga nm~{bgslgd okdjgnm ukdbgrgs [DGS nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
~kyski{~ ugng ~gdbbgh 5651 j{dm 955;$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga okhglsgdglgd ~{bgsd}g skigbgm ukdbgrgs skhgdj{~d}g
sglsm okdkymog {gdb skigd}gl Yu$ 9;$555( skigbgm a`d`y ukdbgrgs ngd {d~{l
skhkimad}g hgbm ~mngl ukydga okdkymog {gdb ~goigagd hkima ngym Yu$9;$555(
~kyski{~$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
14/59
7>
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga sglsm hmag~ nm lrm~gdsm ukoig}gygd }gdb nmgj{lgd `hka
^nr$Nys$ S{ognjm }gdb ugng sgg~ m~{ okdjgig~ skigbgm lkughg skl`hga ~kyd}g~g
sg}g ~khga okdkymog 9 lghm a`d`ygym{o ~kyski{~ glgd ~k~gum {d~{l ~gdng ~gdbgd
ugng lrm~gdsm / i{l~m ukoig}gygd ~kyski{~ sko{gd}g i{lgd ~gdng ~gdbgd sglsm
!ughs{-$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l {gdb }gdb ~khga nm~kymog skigbgm a`d`y ukdbgrgs [DGS
~kyski{~ ngym ogdg ngdgd}g sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
>$ Sglsm ^[OU[L MDNYG]G^M S$Un( Ukykou{gd( {o{y 3> ~ga{d( Mshgo( Srgs~g/
ikdngagyg SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( Mdn`dksmg/ jgrg( ^koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh
9> Gb{s~{s 7=2>( Ghgog~ Nksg Lksgoikd Y^$ 59/57 Lksgoikd Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd
sko{g lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd gngd}g lkjgnmgd
ukdbbkhgugd {gdb ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S nm skl`hga SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd Ihm~gy nmogdg sglsm skigbgm ikdngagyg ukokbgdb lgs$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb nmn{bg skigbgm ukhgl{ gnghga Nys$ S[OGNJM jgig~gd skhgl{
lkughg skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd Ihm~gy( sglsm lkdgh ~gum i{lgd fgomhm$
Igarg ikdgy ukyi{g~gd ~kyski{~ nmhgl{lgd nghgo agym ~gdbbgh h{ug l{y{d rgl~{
~ga{d 955;9556 }gdb hgh{ sks{gm nkdbgd ~{y{dd}g gdbbgygd ngdg SIOU ngd
ngdg I@S$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm skhgl{ ikdngagyg sk~mgu okhgl{lgd ukdcgmygd ngdg igml
SIOU og{u{d ngdg I@S skhgh{ ~gdng ~gdbgd shmu ukdgymlgd dgo{d sk~khga ngdg
cgmy ngym igdl IUN/igdl jg~mo oglg {gdb ~mngl skh{y{ad}g nmikymlgd lkugng
sglsm dgo{d gng }gdb nmigrg `hka ^kynglrg S{ognjm$
Igarg ikdgy sks{gm nkdbgd cg~g~gd }gdb gng ugng sglsm igarg sglsm okdcg~g~
ngdg SIOU ngym ukokymd~ga ~ga{d 955>955; skigd}gl Yu$ 39$695$555( ngd
}gdb nmskygalgd lkugng sglsm gnghga skigd}gl Yu$ 73$>25$555( skngdblgd
skigd}gl Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ogsma nmigrg lkughg skl`hga ikydgog
Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy ngdg I@S }gdb ~khga nmcgmylgd ugng ~ga{d 955;9556 gnghga
skdmhgm Yu$ 19$;>3$555( }gdb nmskygalgd lkugng sglsm {d~{l lkukyh{gd skl`hga
gnghga agd}g skiksgy Yu$66$;55$555( skngdblgd }gdb skigd}glYu$76$5>3$762(
ogsma nmigrg `hka ^nr$ Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy gng ikikygug hkoigy lrm~gdsm }gdb nmjgnmlgd i{l~m `hka ~kynglrg
skdnmym nmogdg ukdbkh{gygd {d~{l SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd Ihm~gy( okd{y{~
sglsm ~mngl nkdbgd skikdgyd}g / fml~mf nmgd~gygd}g lrm~gdsm d`o`y
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
15/59
7;
>(;(1(75(9>(>5(>3(>>(>;(ngd >6 ngd o{dblmd ogsma gng lrm~gdsm fml~mf }gdb
hgmdd}g$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ogsghga ~kynglrg ugng ~ga{d 955>955; ngd 955;9556
ukydga okoikymlgd {gdb sgl{ lkugng ugyg B{y{ E Yu$ ;5$555( ngd o{ymn E
Yu$ 75$555( lk~mlg okhgl{lgd ^`{y / yklykgsm m~{ ~mngl ikdgy lgykdg }gdb
okdbkh{gylgd ngdg ~kyski{~ gnghga umagl skl`hga skdnmym ngd gng nghgo
ukoi{l{gd sglsm sky~g ~kynglrg skdnmym ~ mngl ukydga okoikym ~goigagd a`d`y
lkugng 9> `ygdb B{y{ ngd 3 `y`db U^^ ngd j{bg {d~{l ukoikymgd a`d`y lkugng
ukdbgrgs [GD/[DGS s{nga gng img}gd}g skdnmym ngym ukokymd~ga ngd i{lgd
nmgoimh ngym [gdb SIOU g~g{ I@S ~kyski{~$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ukdbkh{gygd }gdb sglsm hgl{lgd ~kyski{~ ~kycg~g~ nghgo
i{l{ lgs$
Igarg ikdgy nkdbgd gngd}g lkjgnmgd ~kyski{~ oglg umagl sglsm ngd umagl
skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd okygsg nmy{bmlgd skigi skhgog ngdg nmigrg
`hka lkughg skl`hga oglg umagl B^^ ngd U^^ ~mngl nmikymlgd agld}g g~g{
a`d`y okdbgjgy / iklkyjg$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga nms{y{a okdgdng~gdbgdm lrm~gdsm ngd SUJ / HUJ
{d~{l ukoik~{hgd lgykdg ng~gd}g ~mngl sks{gm !gr{gr{- / ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd
lkd}g~ggd oglg sglsm ~mngl okdgdng~gdbgdm SUJ ~kyski{~$
Igarg ikdgy nkdbgd lkjgnmgd ~kyski{~ oglg sm~{gsm skl`hga SOU UBYM 59
lksgoikd okdjgnm lgcg{ lgykdg okdbagngum {jmgd/ [GD$
Igarg ikdgy umagl SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd okdbghgom lky{bmgd ikygug
dmhgmd}g sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ ukysms glgd ~k~gum sks{gm ng~g }gdb gng ngd cg~g~gd sglsm
igarg ngdg SIOU }gdb nm~kymog sklm~gy Yu$ 39$695$555(ngd }gdb nmskygalgd
lkugng sglsm skiksgy Yu$ 73$>25$555( ngd }gdb ogsma gng ugng ^kynglrg
S{ognjm skiksgy Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd {d~{l ngdg I@S }gdb nm~kymog sklm~gy
Yu$ 19$;>3$555( ngd }gdb nmskygalgd lkugng sglsm skiksgy Yu$ 66$;55$555( ngd
}gdb ogsma gng ugng ^kynglrg S{ognjm skiksgy Yu$76$5>3$762( sks{gm nkdbgd
i{l{ lgs skl`hga( ngd o{dblmd {d~{l j{ohga ngdg }gdb gng / nm~kymog imsg hkima
ngym m~{$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m sko{g skl`hga agy{s okoi{g~ YGUIS glgd
~k~gum skhgog okdjgnm ikdngagyg mg ~mngl ukydga nmgjgl {d~{l okd}{s{d YGUIS
ukdkymoggd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l okdcgmylgd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ~si skagy{sd}g
nmhgl{lgd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga !^nr$ S{ognjm- ikysgog Ikdngagyg !sglsm
skdnmym-( dgo{d nghgo ukhglsgdggdd}g nghgo ukdcgmygd ngdg ~si sglsm ~mngl
ukydga nmgjgl nghgo okdcgmylgd / okdbgoimh ngdg nmogls{n( nmogdg ~kynglrg$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
16/59
76
S{ognjm agd}g okomd~g ~gdng ~gdbgd shmu ukdbgoimhgd lkugng sglsm ngd
okomd~g L^U gshm omhml sglsm$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ~mngl okdbk~ga{m SUUI USIOU / ULUS IIO !I@S- glgd
~k~gum sk~khga nmikym ~ga{ ngd nm~{dj{llgd `hka ukokymlsg ~kyd}g~g skikh{o ngdg
igd~{gd ~kyski{~ m~{ ~{y{d oglg nmi{g~ ~kyhkima nga{h{ SUUI }gdb
nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka umagl ngym nmdgs U ngd L lgi{ug~kd ngd lkughg skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m {d~{l SUUI I@S }gdb okdgdng~gdbgdm ngym
nmdgs U ngd L lgi{ug~kd ~kyski{~ gnghga U[JM ^GRGD RMN@N@ }gdb ogdg
SL ukd{dj{lgdd}g gnghga ngym I{ug~m Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy imhg SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ~khga okdkymog ngdg SIOU ngd
ngdg I@S ngd skhgdj{~d}g nmukyb{dglgd ~kyski{~ skagy{sd}g okhgu`ylgd
ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ lk nmdgs U ngd L lgi{ug~kd nkdbgd okd{dj{llgd
i{l~mi{l~m }gdb sga nghgo ikd~{l SUJ/HUJ$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ~khga okhgu`ylgd ukdbb{gdggd
ngdg ~kyski{~ g~g{ ~mngl ( sglsm sgog sklghm ~mngl ~ga{$
Igarg ikdgy sks{gm uy`skn{y }gdb gng skagy{sd}g ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S
}gdb nmn{bg {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm lkughg skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
}gdb ikydgog Nys$ S[OGNJM agy{s nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkbmg~gd ikhgjgy okdbgjgy
~kyogs{l ngdg {jmgd( ukdngf~gygd smsrg igy{( lkbmg~gd lksmsrggd( lkbmg~gd o{~{
b{y{ ngd skigbmgd {d~{l ukdbgnggd sgygdg ngd uygsgygdg sky~g }gdb hgmdd}g
}gdb sks{gm nkdbgd YGUIS$
Igarg ikdgy mg ~mngl ~ga{ okdbk~ga{m SUJ/HUJ ~kyski{~ {d~{l lrm~gdsm ngd
d`~g ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ~kyski{~ agy{s nmhgoumylgd glgd
~k~gum }gdb nmhgoumylgd gnghga lrm~gdsm hgmd }gdb ogdg ~gdng~gdbgdd}g j{bg
nmughs{lgd$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ogsghga {gdb Yu$ 75$555$555( !sku{h{a j{~g y{umga- }gdb mg
~kymog ngym sny$ S[OGNJM ~kyski{~ gnghga g~gs ukysk~{j{gd ngym lkughg skl`hga
}gdb igy{ ikydgog sny$ S[]GNM$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l {gdb ~kyski{~ sklgygdb mdm ogsma nmsmougd umagl skl`hga
ngd ikh{o nmukyb{dglgd {d~{l lkbmg~gd gugu{d lgykdg ogsma gng ukyogsghgagd
ngd sklgygdb ogsma nm~gdbgdm `hka umagl lku`hmsmgd$
Igarg ikdgy i{l~m ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S gnghga iky{ug
7 !sg~{- lrm~gdsm ngd d`~g sky~g i{l~m ukdkymoggd ngdg ngym sny$ S[OGNJM
gnghga iky{ug sg~{ hkoigy lrm~gdsm ~gdbbgh 99=9552$
Igarg ikdgy nghgo ukokymlsggd sglsm okdkygdblgd nkdbgd skikdgyd}g skuky~m
lk~kygdbgd }gdb skhkdblgud}g nghgo ikym~g gcgyg ukokymlsggd$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
17/59
72
;$ Sglsm S[UGYOGD( hglmhglm( {o{y >> ~ga{d( mshgo( lk~{g l`om~k SOU UBYM 59
lksgoikd/ lgnks ~kugs( mdn`dksmg/ jgrg( ~koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh 37 j{dm 7=6>(
ghgog~ y~$ 57/5; Ns$ ^kugs lkc$ Lksgoikd lgi$ Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd gngd}g n{bggd
okoukylg}g nmym skdnmym / l`y{usm skigbmgd ngdg SIOU ~ga{d 955>955; ngd
ngdg I@S ~ga{d 955;9556 nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd }gdb nmn{bg nmhgl{lgd
`hka lkughg skl`hga }gdb ikydgog Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm okdjgig~ skigbgm lk~{g l`om~k nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
o{hgmm ~ga{d 9559 sgougm sklgygdb }gdb nm~{dj{l `hka sko{g b{y{( rghm o{ymn
ngd lkughg skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m ~kd~gdb SIOU ngd ngdg I@S gnghga igarg
ngdg ~kyski{~ gnghga igd~{gd ngym ukokymd~ga {d~{l skl`hga( }gdb skhgdj{~d}g
sk~khga ngdg ~kyski{~ nmukyb{dglgd agy{s nmhuky~gdbb{db jgrgilgd hgbm nkdbgd
okoi{g~ SUJ/HUJ$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm agd}g okdnkdbgy lghg{ SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ~khga
okdngug~ ngdg SIOU ngd okdngug~ igd~{gd ngdg I@S $
Igarg ikdgy skhgog okdjgig~ lk~{g l`om~k skl`hga( nghgo agh okdngug~
igd~{gd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ~si( nmymd}g ~mngl ukydga sgog sklghm nmgjgl /
nmhmig~lgd `hka lkughg skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd !^nr$ S{ognjm- nghgo
agh ukd}{s{dgd YGUIS ( skamdbbg nmb{dglgd {d~{l gug sgjg ngdg igd~{gd
SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ~kyski{~ nmymd}g ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm }gdb ogdg
YGUIS m~{ skdnmym agy{s nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka lkughg skl`hga ngd sglsm skigbgm
lk~{g l`om~k skl`hga sky~g ugyg b{y{$
Igarg sglsm okdbk~ga{m lghg{ skikh{o ngdg ~kyski{~ cgmy agy{s gng SUUI }gdb
nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka lkughg skl`hga ngd umagl U ngd L sk~khga nmikym~ga{ ngd
nm~{dj{llgd `hka ukokymlsg iky{ug SUUI ULUS IIO g~g{ hkima nmlkdgh nkdbgd
I@S( skngdblgd {d~{l }gdb SUUI SIOU nmymd}g ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm$
Igarg ikdgy gugimhg umagl SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ~khga okdkymog ngdg
SIOU ngd ngd I@S ~kyski{~ oglg rgjmi okhgu`ylgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~
lkugng nmdgs Ungd L Lgi$ Ihm~gy nghgo ikd~{l SUJ/HUJ ngd i{l~mi{l~m }gdb
gng$
Igarg ikdgy ]gdb sglsm lk~ga{m skagy{sd}g ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S }gdb
nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm lkughg skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
}gdb ikydgog Nys$ S[OGNJM ~kyski{~( skagy{sd}g nmb{dglgd {d~{l
lkukd~mdbgd ikhgjgy okdbgjgy( okymdbgdlgd ikigd smsrg sky~g lkbmg~gd skl`hga
hgmdd}g$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
18/59
71
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm( nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
6$ Sglsm U[JM ^GRGD RMN@N@ S$Un$OO$ hglmhglm( >7 ~ga{d( Lyms~kd( UDS/ s~gf
nmdgs UngdL lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy( Mdn`dksmg/ jgrg( Hgamy Ihm~gy ~gdbbgh 76 Ogyk~ 7=66(
ghgog~ I^D gsgiym Ih`l J D`$97 Lkh$ Bkn`l( Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd gngd}g n{bggd
okoukylg}g nmym skdnmym / l`y{usm skigbmgd ngdg SIOU ~ga{d 955>955; ngd
ngdg I@S ~ga{d 955;9556 nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd }gdb nmn{bg nmhgl{lgd
`hka lkughg skl`hga }gdb ikydgog Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy ngdg ~kyski{~ ngym ukokymd~ga ~khga nmcgmylgd lkugng SOU UBYM
59 lksgoikd okhgh{m lgd~`y nmdgs U ngd L lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy( nmogdg nmlgd~`y
~kyski{~ sglsm }gdb okdgdbgdm uy`sksd}g$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm okdbk~ga{m gngd}g lkjgnmgd mdm skigi skikh{od}g ~khga
nmng~gdbmm `hka umagl SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd okdbkdgm gngd}g ukdcgmygd ngdg
SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ~kyski{~ ngd sglsm okdkygdblgd lghg{ ngdgd}g s{nga
nmcgmylgd / nm~{y{dlgd skh{y{ad}g$
Igarg ikdgy sks{gm nkdbgd ng~g }gdb gng igarg SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
okdngug~lgd ngdg SIOU skigd}gl Yu$ 39$695$555( ngd gdbbgygd I@S
skigd}gl Yu$ 19$;>3$762(
Igarg ikdgy ukdcgmygd ngym nmdgs Ukdnmnmlgd lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy lk SOU UBYM 59
lksgoikd okhgh{m Igdl Jg~mo/ IUN$ Lko{nmgd }gdb okdcgmylgd gnghga ummagl
lkughg skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ngd ikdngagyg skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ~mngl okdbk~ga{m gngd}g ukd}khkrkdbgd skigbmgd ngdg
~kyski{~ ngd sglsm igy{ ~ga{ sk~khga nmikym ~ga{ `hka ikdngagyg ^[OU[L
MDNYG]G^M }gdb ukydga ng~gdb lklgd~`y sglsm( okdgd}glgd ~kd~gdb gngd}g
ukdcgmygd ngdg ~kyski{~( ngd sglsm lg~glgd lghg{ ngdg s{nga nmcgmylgd
skh{y{ad}g$
Igarg ikdgy nkdbgd gngd}g ukd}khkrkdbgd ngdg ~kyski{~ oglg umagl SOU
UBYM 59 lksgoikd agy{s iky~gdbb{db jgrgi skigi {gdb ngdg ~kyski{~ gnghga
{d~{l lkukyh{gd skl`hga ngd i{lgd {d~{l lkukyh{gd uymignm ngym lkughg skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l hgu`ygd uky~gdbb{dbgd jgrgi/ s{yg~ uky~gdbb{dbgd jgrgi
ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ umagl lkughg SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ikh{o
okoi{g~ ~k~gum ukydga nm~{dj{llgd lkugng sglsm ngd lgykdg ikh{o okokd{am
s}gyg~ oglg sglsm s{y{a okoi{g~ {hgdb( skamdbbg sgg~ mdm ikh{o okd}kygalgd
SUJ/HUJ$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
19/59
7=
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ogsghga SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd ~khga okoi{g~ YGUIS
}gdb ~khga nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka lkughg skl`hga ngd l`om~k sglsm ~mngl
okdbk~ga{m ugs~m$
Igarg ikdgy skikh{o ngdg ~{y{d oglg skikh{od}g nmi{g~ SUUI }gdb
nm~gdng~gdbgdmm `hka lkughg skl`hga ngd ~mo ngym I@S lgi{ug~kd skigbgm g~gs
dgog ukokymd~ga }gdb okoikymlgd igd~{gd$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m {d~{l SUUI USIOU ~ga{d 955>955; nmi{l{
uk~{dj{l ~kldms ikh{o gng ngd {d~{l I@S ~ga{d 955;9556 s{nga gng ngd }gdb
okdgdng~gdbgdm gnghga Nys$ MSIGA SGHMOM ngym umagl nmdgs U ngd L
Lgi{ug~kd Ih~gy( skngdblgd nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd }gdb okdgdng~gdbgdm
gnghga lkughg skl`hga Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l SL ukd{dj{lgd sgg~ uy`bgo USIOU sglsm ~mngl mdbg~ gng
g~g{ ~mngl skngdblgd {d~{l }gdb I@S ikdgy gng SL ngym I[UG^M Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy skigbgm ukys`dmh }gdb nm~{dj{l skigbgm okdgbky ULUS IIO Lgi$
Ihm~gy ikysgog nkdbgd gdbb`~g }gdb hgmd ~khga okhgl{lgd ~{bgs ngd lkrgjmigd
o{hgmm ukdng~ggd( okds`smghmsgsmlgd uy`bgo( okoi{g~ ukdk~gugd gh`lgsm(
o`dm~`ymdb ngd okdbgnglgd imoimdbgd ~kldms ukd}{s{dgd hgu`ygd$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga okdkymog igd~{gd ~kyski{~ oglg SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
rgjmi {d~{l okhgu`ylgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ lk nmdgs U ngd L Lgi$ Ihm~gy
ngd oklgdmsokd}g gnghga nkdbgd okd{dj{llgd i{l~mi{l~m ukdbb{dggd }gdb
sga nghgo ikd~{l SUJ / HUJ$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m {d~{l SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd nghgo uy`sks
ukhgu`ygdd}g ~mngl ~ky~mi lgykdg }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m nghgo ukdcgmygd ngdg
~kyski{~ skagy{sd}g lkughg skl`hga okomd~g ykl`o lk nmdgs U ngd L glgd ~k~gum
}gdb nmhgl{lgd `hka lkughg skl`hga agd}g okomd~g ykl`o lk cgigdb nmdgs }gdb
gng nm lkcgog~gd sgjg skamdbbg uy`sks ukhgu`ygdd}g ~mngl ~ky~mi$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m skagy{sd}g ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S }gdb
nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm lkughg skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
}gdb ikydgog Nys$ S[OGNJM ~kyski{~ agy{s nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd
ikhgjgy okdbgjgy( okymdbgdlgd ikigd smsrg sky~g lkbmg~gd skl`hga hgmdd}g$
Igarg ikdgy lghg{ agh ~kyski{~ ~kyi{l~m oglg jkhgs lkughg SOU UBYM 59
lksgoikd ~khga oky{bmlgd o{ymno{ymn ngd umagl ukokymd~ga$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
2$ Sglsm S[UGYOM S$Un( Ukykou{gd( ;5 ~ga{d( Mshgo( B{y{ SOU M N`l`( mdn`dksmg/
jgrg( ~koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh 76 sku~koiky 7=;2( ghgog~ Nsd lkomymbknk Ns
^kugs Y~$ 5;/ M lkc lksgoikd Lgi$ Ihm~gy$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
20/59
95
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd gngd}g n{bggd
okoukylg}g nmym skdnmym / l`y{usm skigbmgd ngdg SIOU ~ga{d 955>955; ngd
ngdg I@S ~ga{d 955;9556 nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd }gdb nmn{bg nmhgl{lgd
`hka lkughg skl`hga }gdb ikydgog Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ogsghga ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S nm SOU UBYM 59
lksgoikd m~{ sglsm skdnmym ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm ukdbb{dggdd}g glgd ~k~gum
sglsm ukydga nm~{bgslgd okdjgnm ukdbgrgs [DGS nm SOU UBYM 59 lksgoikd
~kyski{~ ~gdbbgh 5651 j{dm 955;$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga okhglsgdglgd ~{bgsd}g skigbgm ukdbgrgs skhgdj{~d}g
sglsm okdkymog {gdb skigd}gl 9 lghm }gdb sglsm mdbg~ agd}g okdkymog
Yu$ 2;$555( skigbgm a`d`y ukdbgrgs ngd {d~{l skhkimad}g hgbm ~mngl ukydga
okdkymog {gdb ~goigagd hkima ngym Yu$ 2;$555( ~kyski{~$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga sglsm okhmag~ nm lrm~gdsm ukoig}gygd }gdb nmgj{lgd `hka
Nys$ S[OGNJM }gdb ugng sgg~ m~{ okdjgig~ skigbgm lkughg skl`hga ~kyd}g~g
~khga okdkymog 9 lghm a`d`ygym{o ~kyski{~ glgd ~k~gum {d~{l ~gdng~gdbgd ugng
lrm~gdsm / i{l~m ukoig}gygd ~kyski{~ }gdb sg~{ hkoigy i{lgd ~gdng~gdbgdd}g
! ughs{ - ngd }gdb 7 hkoigy hgbm omymu nkdbgd ~gdng~gdbgdd}g$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l {gdb }gdb ~khga sglsm ~kymog skigbgm a`d`y ukdbgrgs [DGS
~kyski{~ ngym ogdg ngdgd}g sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
1$ Sglsm J[RGY^M S$Un( ukykou{gd( 31 ~ga{d( Mshgo( B{y{ SOU 57 Lksgoikd(
Mdn`dksmg / jgrg( ^koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh 9> Jgd{gym 7=25( Ghgog~ Nsd$
Ogdbl{ykj` Ns ~guglykj` Y~$ 57/MM Lkc$ Lksgoikd Lgi$ Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd gngd}g ukd}ghgab{dggd
ngdg SIOU ~ga{d 955>/955; ngd ngdg I@S ~ga{d 9556 nm SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ogsghga ngdg SIOU ~ga{d 955> / 955; ngd I@S ~ga{d
955; / 9556 nm SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd nmymd}g ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm
ukdbb{dggd}g( glgd ~k~gum sglsm ukydga nm~{bgslgd okdjgnm ukdbgrgs [DGS nm
SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ugng ~gdbbgh 56 51 J{dm 955;$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga skhksgm okhglsgdglgd ~{bgsskigbgm ukdbgrgs( skhgdj{~d}g
sglsm okdkymog {gdb skigd}gl 9 lghm ngd }gdb sglsm mdbg~ agd}g okdkymog
Yu$ 2;$555( skigbgm a`d`y ukdbgrgs ngd {d~{l skhkimad}g hgbm ~mngl ukydga
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
21/59
97
okdkymog {gdb ~goigagd hkima ngym Yu$ 2;$555( ~kyski{~( ~k~gum agd}g
okdkymog skiksgy Yu$ 7;$555($
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga snglsm hmag~ lrm~gdsm ukoig}gygd }gdb nmgj{lgd `hka
Nys$ S{ognjm }gdb ugng sgg~ m~{ okdjgig~ skigbgm Lkughg Skl`hga ~kyd}g~g sglsm
~khga okdkymog 9 lghm a`d`ygym{o ~kyski{~( glgd ~k~gum {d~{l ~gdng ~gdbgdd}g
ugng lrm~gdsm i{l~m ukoig}gygd ~kyski{~ sko{gd}g i{lgd ~gdng ~gdbgdd}g
!ughs{-$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l {gdb }gdb ~khga sglsm ~kymog skigbgm a`d`y ukdbgrgs [DGS
~kyski{~ ngym ogdg ngdgd}g sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
=$ Sglsm AGYM]GD^@( S$Un( Hglmhglm( [o{y >> ~ga{d( Mshgo( UDS !B{y{ SN
Lghmogdms 59 / ogd~gd B^^ SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd-( Mdn`dksmg / Jgrg( ^koug~
hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh 7= J{dm 7=63( Ghgog~ Nsd$ Ngr{db Ns$ Ugbkyr`j` Y~$ >; / QM
Lkc$ Lksgoikd Lgi$ Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd ukd}ghgab{dggd ngdg
SIOU ~ga{d 955>/ 955; ngd I@S ~ga{d 955; / 9556 nm SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd $
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okdjgig~ skigbgm Ikdngagyg nm skl`hga ~kyski{~
agd}g skhgog 3(; i{hgd }gm~{ o{hgm i{hgd Ogyk~ sgougm J{dm 9552( }gdb ogdg
ugng sgg~ m~{ nm ~{dj{l hgdbs{db `hka Lkughg Skl`hga }gdb ikydgog
Nys$ S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm okdbk~ga{m lghg{ SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ugng ~ga{d 955>
/ 955; okdngug~ ngdg SIOU ngd ~ga{d 955; / 9556 okdngug~ ngdg I@S ngd
{d~{l ikyguglga iksgyd}g sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ ukysms( ngd ugng sgg~ m~{ }gdb okdjgnm
Ikdngagyg Skl`hgad}g gnghga snym$ ^[OU[L MDNYG]G^M$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ~mngl ukydga okdkymog ngdg skiksgy Yu$ 7$=73$555(
~ky~gdbbgh 97 Nkskoiky 9556 {d~{l ukoikhmgd G^L iky{ug i{l{ u`hm`( lgu{y
~{hms( i`hu`md( ~md~g u`hmdky ngd ~md~g ngylky skuky~m lrm~gdsm }gdb nm i{g~ `hka
Nys$ S[OGNJM ngd ~gdng ~gdbgd }gdb ~ky~kyg nm nghgo lrm~gdsm ~si i{lgd ~gdng
~gdbgdd}g$
Igarg ikdgy ugng ~gdbbgh 9> Ukiy{gym 9552 sglsm j{bg ~mngl ukydga
okdbkh{gylgd ngdg {d~{l lkukdbgrgsgd y{gdb {hgdbgd skoks~ky M lgykdg ugng
rgl~{ m~{ sglsm ikh{o nm~{dj{l skigbgm Ikdngagyg skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy nkdbgd gngd}g 9 hkoigy lrm~gdsm ~kyski{~ sgog sklghm ~mngl ikdgy
lgykdg okogdb ~mngl ukydga okdkymog ngd okdbkh{gylgd ngdg ~kyski{~$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
22/59
99
Igarg ikdgy skhgog okdjgnm Ikdngagyg l{ygdb hkima skhgog 3(; i{hgd( nmymd}g
ukydga nms{y{a `hka ^nr$ Nys$ S{ognjm {d~{l okdcgmylgd {gdb okhgh{m Igdl
IUN nm Lksgoikd skigd}gl 9 !n{g- lghm ngd {gdbd}g ~khga nmb{dglgd {d~{l
lkukd~mdbgd skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy sks{gm nkdbgd }gdb sglsm nkdbgy ngym Lkughg skl`hga
Nys S[OGNJM( SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ~khga okoi{g~ YGUIS nghgo
ukdkymoggd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S$
Igarg ikdgy YGUIS ~kyski{~ nmi{g~ ngd nm ~gdng ~gdbgdm `hka Lkughg Skl`hga
ngd L`om~k Skl`hga nkdbgd ~{j{gd {d~{l okykdcgdglgd ukdkymoggd ngd
ukdbkh{gygd skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga nmikym~ga{ ngd nm~{dj{llgd `hka ukokymlsg skhgdj{~d}g mg
igy{ okdbk~ga{m lghg{ skikh{o ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~ ~{y{d agy{s nm
i{g~lgd SUUI }gdb nm ~gdng ~gdbgdm `hka umagl ngym Nmdgs U ngd L Lgi{ug~kd
ngd Lkughg Skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ukys`dmh }gdb nm ~{dj{l okdgdbgdm uy`bygo igd~{gd SIOU
ngd I@S nm SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd agd}g U[JM ^GRGD RMN@N@ ngd gng
SL ukd{dj{lgd g~g{ ~mngl sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ ukysms$
Igarg ikdgy Lko{dblmdgd SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ~khga okhgu`ylgd
ukdbb{dggd ngdg$ SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~ nghgo ikd~{l SUJ / HUJ lgykdg
{d~{l okdngug~lgd ykl`o ukdcgmygd ngdg ~kyski{~ agy{s okoi{g~ SUJ / HUJ
~kyhkima nga{h{$
Igarg ikdgy okd{y{~ sglsm sks{gm uy`skn{y }gdb gng skagy{sd}g ngdg$ SIOU
skiksgy Yu 7=$7;5$5553$762(}gdb nmn{bg
nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm Lkughg Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
}gdb ikydgog Nys S[OGNJM agy{s nmb{dglgd {d~{l Lkbmg~gd USI( [hgdbgd(
Lkhkdblgugd ikhgjgy okdbgjgy( lkbmg~gd lksmsrggd( ukdmdblg~gd o{~{ b{y{(
oglgd omd{o agymgd ~kyogs{l oglgd omd{o ygug~( ukygrg~gd ymdbgd skl`hga(
okoikhm ukyhkdblgugd skl`hga( Kls~ygl{yml{hky( [d~{l ~ygdsu`y~ smsrg omslmd(
ukoikhmgd i{l{ ngd lkbmg~gd @SMS$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
75$Sglsm D[DML U[YRGDMDBSMA( Ukykou{gd( [o{y 36 ~ga{d( Mshgo( Srgs~g !S~gf
UUHU Ngsgy ngd Okdkdbga UBYM Lgi$ Ihm~gy-( Mdn`dksmg/Jgrg( ^koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy(
~gdbbgh 57 J{hm 7=27( Ghgog~ Jh$ Shgok~ Ym}gnm Hl$ MMM Y~$ 57 / MMM Lkh$ Skd~{h( Lkc$
Lkugdjkdlmn{h L`~g Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd ukd}ghgab{dggd ngdg
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
23/59
93
SIOU ~ga{d 955>/ 955; ngd I@S ~ga{d 955; / 9556 nm SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd$
Igarg ikdgy ^{bgs ngd ~gdbb{db jgrgid}g gnghga okoigd~{ ~{bgs Ikdngagyg(
lgykdg okou{d}gm jgig~gd ygdblgu skamdbbg lghg{ gng ukoig}gygd sglsm }gdb
okhg}gdm ngd skhgdj{~d}g ~k~gu nmhgu`ylgd lkugng Ikdngagyg UUHU Ngsgy ngd
Okdkdbga UBYM ~kyski{~$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm mdbg~ {d~{l SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd okhgl{lgd
ukoig}gygd agd}g {d~{l ukoig}gygd Dgslga [hgdbgd Skoks~kygd ngd m{ygd
rgjmi 3 / ; + ngd {d~{l hgmdd}g ~mngl gng$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l UUHU Ngsgy ngd Okdkdbga UBYM Lgi$ Ihm~gy ~mngl ukydga
okofgsmhm~gsm / okdbkh{gylgd I{l{ Ukn`ogd L{yml{h{o 955> lkugng skl`hga
ngsgy og{u{d okdkdbga$ ]gdb ogdg gng lrm~gdsm SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
}gdb okoikhm i{l{ skiksgy Yu$ 9$735$555($
Igarg ugng lrm~gdsm ~ky~gdbbg7 9=39556 j{bg ~mngl ikdgy lghg{ SOU UBYM
59 Lksgoikd ~khga okoikhm i{l{ l{yml{h{o ~ga{d 955> skiksgy Yu$ 3;5$555(
lgykdg lkbmg~gdd}g ~mngl gng$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ukoikhmgd 9; u`~`db skygbgo ig~ml skiksgy Yu$ 69;$555(
okogdb ikdgy gng ngd sglsm }gdb okdkymog( glgd ~k~gum m~{ ~mngl nmagy{slgd
lgykdg ~kyskyga ngym uymignm ogsmdbogsmdb b{y{( ngd skagy{sd}g ukoikhmgd
~kyski{~ ~mngl i`hka nm goimhlgd ngym ngdg SIOU g~g{ I@S lgykdg ngdg ~kyski{~
{d~{l lkukd~mdbgd skl`hga ngd i{lgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm b{y{$
Igarg ugng lrm~gdsm ~gdbbgh 9=539556 j{bg ~mngl ikdgy lghg{ SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd ~khga okoikhm i{l{ ugdn{gd [DGS Lh$ 3 ! IMD( IMB( O^L - lgykdg
UUHU Ngsgy ngd Okdkdbga UBYM Lgi$ Ihm~gy ~mngl ukydga okdbkh{gylgd i{l{
~kyski{~$
Igarg ugng lrm~gdsm ~gdbbgh 9;539556 j{bg ~mngl ikdgy lghg{ SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd ~khga okoig}gy {d~{l h`oig Ogukh Hmdbl$ UUHU UBYM skiksgy
Yu$ 3;5$555( lgykdg {d~{l ukoig}gygd ~kyski{~ nmjgnmlgd sg~{ nkdbgd
ukdbgnggd dgslga {hgdbgd skoks~ky }gdb imgsgd}g agd}g skiksgy Yu$ 7$555(
nmlghmlgd nkdbgd j{ohga smsrg }gdb gng$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l ogsghga gngd}g ~gdng~gdbgdd}g( sglsm imsg okdjkhgslgd
igarg lrm~gdsm ~kyski{~ grghd}g gng 3 hkoigy( }gdb ogdg {d~{l 7 hkoigy sglsm
~gdng ~gdbgdm skdnmym ngd dgog ~kygdbd}g( skngdblgd {d~{l }gdb 9 hkoigy
ogsma lrm~gdsm l`s`db agd}g ~gdng ~gdbgdd}g sgjg ~gdug dgog ~kygdb ngd
s~koukh }gdb skhgdj{~d}g nm skygalgd lkugng Lkughg Skl`hga ugng sgg~
ukoig}gygd Dgslga [hgdbgd Skoks~kygd {d~{l nm lk~ml skdnmym b{dg
okoukyckug~ uy`sks ukhgu`ygd$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
24/59
9>
Igarg ikdgy 9 hkoigy lrm~gdsm m~{hga }gdb nm sghgab{dglgd `hka Lkughg
Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd !Nys$ S[OGNJM -( }gdb sk`hga`hga
lkbmg~gdd}g gng$
Igarg ikdgy nkdbgd gngd}g lkjgnmgd ~kyski{~ oglg ~khga oky{bmlgd Dkbgyg
ngd SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd lgykdg ~khga okdbb{dglgd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S
{d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
77$Sglsm UM[S RMN@N@( hglmhglm( [o{y 36 ~ga{d( Mshgo( Srgs~g/ ^ygdsu`y~gsm(
Mdn`dksmg/ jgrg( ^koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbg' 7 Okm 7=27( Ghgog~ Jh$ Ymg{ Hmdbl$
Lkdmdbgygd Lkh$ Igjgdb Y~$ 57/ MMM Lkc$ ^gh{d Lgi$ Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd ukd}ghgab{dggd ngdg
SIOU ~ga{d 955>/ 955; ngd I@S ~ga{d 955; / 9556 nm SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd $
Igarg ikdgy Nys$ S[OGNJM ~khga okoikhm ikikygug i{ga ugugd lkugngd}g
}gm~{ 6 i{ga ugugd giskdsm( 3 i{ga ugugd ~g~g ~ky~mi skl`hga ngd 3 i{ga ugugd
~g~g ~ky~mi smsrg$
Igarg ikdgy agybg sk~mgu ugugddvg skiksgy Yu 32$;55( skamdbbgg ~`~gh
lkskh{y{agd 79 i{ga ugugd skiksgy Yu$ >;5$555(
Igarg ikdgy ugng sgg~ okoikhm ugugd lkugng sglsm ~kyski{~ {d~{l d`~g
ukoikhmgd gnghga {d~{l SND 59 Lksgoikd ngd i{lgd {d~{l SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd( lgykdg }gdb sglsm mdbg~ nm s~koukh d`~g ukoikhmgd ~si gnghga
s~koukh ngym SND 59 Lksgoikd$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
79$Sglsm Nys$ MSIGA SGHMOM( hglmhglm( [o{y ;5 ~ga{d( Mshgo( UDS / Nmdgs U ngd L
Lgi$ Ihm~gy S{i$ Nmd$ Imdg Uy`bygo( Mdn`dksmg / Jgrg( ^koug~ hgamy Ihm~gy( ~gdbbgh
95 Ogyk~ 7=;1( Ghgog~ Y~$ 57/Hl$ Iy{i{a Lkh$ Lghmugdb Lkc$ S{~`jg}gd Lgi$
Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd gngd}g n{bggd
okoukylg}g nmym skdnmym / l`y{usm skigbmgd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S nm SOU UBYM
59 Lksgoikd }gdb nmn{bg nmhgl{lgd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga }gdb ikydgog
Nys$ S[OGNJM$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
25/59
9;
Igarg ikdgy skikh{o ngdg SIOU g~g{ I@S ~kyski{~ ~{y{d oglg agy{s nm i{g~
YGUIS ! Ykdcgdg Gdbbgygd Ukdngug~gd Img}g Skl`hga - }gdb oky{uglgd
gc{gd {d~{l ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m igarg YGUIS ~kyski{~ nmi{g~ ngd nm ~gdng
~gdbgdm `hka umagl Lkughg Skl`hga ngd L`om~k Skl`hga }gdb skhgdj{~d}g
nmgj{lgd lk Nmdgs U ngd L {d~{l nm ~gdng ~gdbgdm gbgy ngdg igd~{gd ~kyski{~
~{y{d$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ~mngl ukydga okdbk~ga{m lghg{ SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
~khga ukydga okd}{s{d YGUIS ~kyski{~$
Igarg ikdgy skikh{o ngdg ~kyski{~ ~{y{d ikdgy gng SUUI ! S{yg~ Ukyjgdjmgd
Ukoikymgd Igd~{gd - }gdb nm i{g~ `hka umagl Nmdgs U ngd L ngd Lkughg
Skl`hga( {d~{l SUUI I@S gng ngd sglsm }gdb okdgdng~gdbgdm skigbgm Ogdgbky
ULUS IIO Imngdb Ukdnmnmlgd Lgi$ Ihm~gy$
Igarg ikdgy {d~{l SUUI SIOU }gdb sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm lgykdg ugng
sgg~ m~{ sglsm ikh{o okdjgig~ skigbgm Lgs{inmd Imdg Uy`bygo ngd ogsma nm
jgig~ `hka Nys$ A$ S[BM^@$
Igarg ikdgy sglsm nm~{dj{l skigbgm Ukys`dmh ULUS IIO ~kyski{~ sks{gm nkdbgd
SL I{ug~m Ihm~gy D`o`y 36; ~ga{d 9556 ~kd~gdb Ukoikd~{lgd Sklyk~gymg~ }gdb
s{s{dgdd}g gng 76 `ygdb$
Igarg ikdgy skigbgm Ukys`dmh }gdb nm ~{dj{l ngd skigbgm ogdgbky ULUS IIO
Lgi$Ihm~gy ikysgog nkdbgd gdbb`~g }gdb hgmd ~khga okhgl{lgd( ~{bgs ngd
lkrgjmigd o{hgmm ukdng~ggd( okds`smghmsgsmlgd uy`bygo( okoi{g~ ukdk~gugd
gh`lgsm( o`dm~`ymdb ngd okdbgnglgd imoimdbgd ~kladms ukd}{s{dgd hgu`ygd ngd
~khga okhglsgdglgd ukhgu`ygd skcgyg ~ky~{hms lk Sg~ Lky I@S Uy`umdsm$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga okdkymog igd~{gd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~
skhgdj{~d}g umagl skl`hga rgjmi okhgu`ylgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ lk Nmdgs
U ngd L nghgo ikd~{l SUJ / HUJ iksky~g i{l~mi{l~m ukdbb{dggd( skngdblgd
}gdb sglsm lk~ga{m {d~{l SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ukhgu`ygdd}g ~mngl ~ky~mi
}gdb ogls{nd}g gnghga {d~{l okdbgoimh / okdcgmylgd ngdg ~kyski{~
skagy{sd}g okdbgoimh ykl`o lk Nmdgs U ngd L glgd ~k~gum }gdb nmhgl{lgd `hka
Lkughg Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd Nys S[OGNJM okdbgoimh ykl`o nm
Cgigdb Nmdgs U ngd L }gdb gng nm Lkcgog~gd$
Igarg ikdgy sks{gm nkdbgd uy`skn{y }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m {d~{l ngdg I@S agy{s
nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkbmg~gd USI( [hgdbgd( Lkhkdblgugd Ikhgjgy Okdbgjgy(
Lkbmg~gd Lksmsrggd( Ukdmdblg~gd O{~{ B{y{( Oglgd omd{o agymgd ~kyogs{l
oglgd omd{o ygug~( a`d`ygym{o b{y{( ukygrg~gd ymdbgd skl`hga( okoikhm
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
26/59
96
ukyhkdblgugd skl`hga( Kls~ygl{yml{hky( [d~{l ~ygdsu`y~ smsrg omslmd( ukoikhmgd
i{l{ ngd lkbmg~gd @SMS$
Igarg ikdgy skagy{sd}g ngdg SIOU skiksgy Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd I@S skiksgy
Yu$ 76$5>3$762(}gdb nmn{bg nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm Lkughg
Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd }gdb ikydgog Nys S[OGNJM agy{s
nmb{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd skl`hga$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
G~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm nmikdgylgd `hka ^kynglrg$
73$Sglsm Nys A S[BM^@( hglmhglm( [o{y ;2 ~ga{d( Mshgo( U{ydg UDS( Mdn`dksmg/ jgrg(
^koug~ hgamy Lhg~kd( ~gdbbgh 71 Okm 7=;7( Ghgog~ Jh$ Yg}g Omdbbmygd D`$ 795 Lkc$
Ugugy Lgi$ Lknmym
Igarg ikdgy sglsm ukydga okoikymlgd lk~kygdbgd nm Ukd}mnml U`hmsm ngd sko{g
lk~kygdbgdd}g s{nga ikdgy }gm~{ ska{i{dbgd nkdbgd gngd}g n{bggd
okoukylg}g nmym skdnmym / l`y{usm skigbmgd ngdg SIOU ~ga{d 955>/ 955; ngd
I@S ~ga{d 955; / 9556 nm SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd }gdb nmn{bg nmhgl{lgd `hka
Lkughg Skl`hga }gdb ikydgog Nys S[OGNJM$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m agd}g ogsghga ngdg SIOU sgjg lgykdg {d~{l
}gdb I@S }gdb okdgdbgdm gnghga Nys MSIGA SGHMOM$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m ngdg SIOU ~kyski{~ ikygsgh ngym Ukokymd~ga
^mdblg~ M skiksgy 25+ ngd Ukokymd~ga ^mdblg~ MM skiksgy 35+$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m {d~{l SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ~khga okdkymog
ngdg SIOU ~ga{d 955>/ 955; skngdblgd {d~{l iksgyd}g ikygug sglsm ~mngl
mdbg~ hgbm$
Igarg ikdgy skcgyg Uy`skn{ygh SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ~khga okoi{g~
YGUIS lgykdg {d~{l okdngug~lgd ngdg SIOU og{u{d I@S ~kyski{~ agy{s
okoi{g~ YGUIS ~kyhkima nga{h{ skigbgm uky~gdbb{db jgrgigd ukdbb{dggd
ngdg ~kyski{~ }gdb nm~gdng ~gdbgdm Lkughg Skl`hga ngd L`om~k Skl`hga(
skngdblgd lkd}g~ggd nm hgugdbgd ~khga nmi{g~ g~g{ ~mngl sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ sgog
sklghm$
Igarg ikdgy skikh{o ngdg SIOU g~g{ I@S ~kyski{~ ~{y{d j{bg nm i{g~ SUUI
}gdb nm ~gdng ~gdbgdm `hka sglsm skigbgm Ogdgbky USIOU ngd Lkughg Skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm mdbg~ {d~{l ukd{dj{lgd ukys`dmh USIOU ~kyski{~ gng
S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd ngym I{ug~m Ihm~gy D`o`y ;37 ~ga{d 9553$
Igarg ikdgy skigbgm ukys`dmh }gdb nm ~{dj{l ~kyski{~ sglsm ~khga okhglsgdglgd
~{bgsd}g }gdb nmgd~gygd}g okds`smghmsgsmlgd uy`bygo( okoi{g~ ukdk~gugd
gh`lgsm( okdbgnglgd imoimdbgd ~kladms ukhgu`ygd ngd sk~khga m~{ lkrgjmigdd}g
gnghga okhgu`ylgd agsmh ukhglsdggd ~{bgsd}g lk I{ug~m ngd B{ikyd{y$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
27/59
92
Igarg ikdgy gugimhg SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ~khga okdkymog ngd
okdbb{dglgd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~( oglg umagl SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd ikyagl {d~{l okhgu`ylgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ nghgo ikd~{l
SUJ / HUJ lk Nmdgs U ngd L Lgi$ Ihm~gy( ngd lkd}g~ggd nm hgugdbgd ~khga
okoi{g~ SUJ / HUJ ~kyski{~ g~g{ ~mngl sglsm ~mngl ~ga{ sgog sklghm$
Igarg ikdgy skcgyg Uy`skn{ygh ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~ nmb{dglgd {d~{l(
sgsgygd }gdb nmgd~gygd}g Ukdmdblg~gd uy`sks ikhgjgy okdbgjgy( Ukdmdblg~gd
uy`bygo lksmsrggd( ukdmdblg~gd l{ghm~gs ~kdgbg ukdnmnmlgd( ukdmdblg~gd sgygdg
ngd uygsgygdg ukdnmnmlgd ngd ukdmdblg~gd o{~{ ukdnmnmlgd$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb sglsm lk~ga{m skagy{sd}g ngdg SIOU skiksgy
Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd I@S skiksgy Yu$ 76$5>3$762( }gdb nmn{bg nmb{dglgd
{d~{l lkukd~mdbgd uymignm Lkughg Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd }gdb
ikydgog Nys$ S{ognjm ~kyski{~ agy{s nmb{dglgd {d~{l ; sgsgygd ~kyski{~$
Sglsm okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
Okdmoigdb( igarg g~gs lk~kygdbgd sglsm ~kyski{~ ~kynglgrg okoikdgylgd$
Okdmoigdb( igarg nmukysmngdbgd ~khga nmnkdbgy lk~kygdbgd ~kynglrg }gdb
ugng u`l`ld}g skigbgm ikyml{~ :
Igarg ukyms~mrg ~kyjgnm ugng l{y{d rgl~{ gdbbgygd ~ga{d 955>/955; {d~{l Ngdg
SIOU ngd gdbbgygd ~ga{d 955;/9556 {d~{l Ngdg I@S$
Igarg ugng l{y{d rgl~{ ~kyski{~ ~kynglrg okdjgig~ skhgl{ Lkughg SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd ikyngsgylgd SL$ D`$ 76/C$7/SOU/M/955> ~gdbbgh 7; Jgd{gym 955> ngym
UUHU Ngsgy ngd Okdkdbga UBYM Jgrg ^mo{y$
Igarg {d~{l Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd( Ihm~gy ~khga okdkymog ngdg SIOU
ngd I@S ngym Nmdgs Ukdnmnmlgd Lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy }gm~{ ngdg SIOU skiksgy
Yu$ 39$695$555( ngd ngdg I`s skiksgy Yu$ 19$;>3$762( j{ohga Yu$ 77;$763$762(
Igarg skikh{o SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd okdkymog igd~{gd ngdg SIOU g~g{ I@S
oglg agy{s okoi{g~ YGUIS !Ykdcgdg Gdbbgygd Ukdngug~gd Img}g Skl`hga-$
Igarg skagy{sd}g YGUIS ~kyski{~ nm s{s{d `hka Lkughg Skl`hga( Nkrgd B{y{ ngd
L`om~k Skl`hga( dgo{d nghgo ukhglsgdggd YGUIS ^kynglrg s{s{d /g~g{ skdnmym$
Igarg YGUIS nm i{g~ ; !hmog- ikdnkh nkdbgd ymdcmgd }gdb > !koug~- ikdnkh {d~{l
Nmdgs U ngd L Lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy ngd 7 !sg~{- ikdnkh nmlkoighmlgd lk Skl`hga {d~{l
Gysmu$
Igarg skikh{o ukdkymoggd igd~{gd ~kyski{~ j{bg nm i{g~ SUUI !S{yg~ Ukyjgdjmgd
Ukoikymgd Igd~{gd - gd~gyg umagl skl`hga nkdbgd Nmdgs U ngd L Lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy(
skigd}gl ; !hmog- hkoigy nkdbgd ymdcmgd > !koug~- hkoigy {d~{l Nmdgs ngd 7 !sg~{-
hkoigy {d~{l skl`hga$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
28/59
91
Igarg }gdb okdgdng~gdbgdm nm SUUI {d~{l umagl ngym Nmdgs U ngd L Lgi{ug~kd
Ihm~gy gnghga Ogdgbky I@S Lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy }gdb ikydgog Nys MSIGA SGHMOM
ngd ngym SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd gnghga ~kynglrg skdnmym skigbgm Lkughg Skl`hga(
skngdblgd {d~{l SUUI SIOU ~kynglrg ~mngl mdbg~ gng g~g{ ~mngl$
Igarg sks{gm Ukn{o g~g{u{d uk~{dj{l ~kladmsd}g igarg {d~{l ukdcgmygd ngdg
SIOU og{u{d ngdg I@S ~kyski{~ nmhgl{lgd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga ikysgogsgog
Ikdngagyg ngd ngdg g~g{ {gdbd}g agy{s nmsmougd `hka Ikdngagy ngd ~mngl
nmukyi`hkalgd nmigrg g~g{ nmukbgdb `hka Lkughg Skl`hga$
Igarg nghgo ukdcgmygd ngdg SIOU og{u{d I@S ~khga nmgoimh g~g{ nmcgmylgd
skdnmym `hka ~kynglrg nkdbgd cgyg ~kynglrg okomd~g ~gdng ~gdbgd g~g{ shmu
ukdbgoimhgd ~kyhkima nga{h{ ngd okomd~g L^U gshm lkugng Ikdngagyg$
Igarg ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~ skcgyg iky~gagu ~khga ~kynglrg goimh g~g{
cgmylgd nm Igdl Jg~mo g~g{ IUN ngd sk~khga {gdb cgmy skcgyg iky~gagu ~gnm oglg
skigbmgd ~kynglrg skygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg ^[OU[L MDNYG]G^M ngd
skigbmgd ^kynglrg igrg smougd skdnmym$
Igarg ngym lkskh{y{agd ngdg SIOU }gdb nm~kymog skiksgy Yu$ 39$695$555( }gdb
nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg skiksgy Yu$ 73$>25$555( skngdblgd {d~{l ngdg I@S
}gdb nm~kymog skiksgy Yu$ 19$;>3$762( }gdb nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg skiksgy
Yu$ 66$;55$555( }gdb ogdg ngdg SIOU skiksgy Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd ngdg I@S
skiksgy Yu$ 76$5>3$762( nkdbgd j{ohga skiksgy Yu$ 3;$7=3$555( }gdb gng ugng
~kynglrg ~khga nmb{dglgd {d~{l :
7$ Lrmd~gsm d` > {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 9$735$555( ! n{g j{~g skyg~{s ~mbg u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
9$ Lrmd~gsm d` ; {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ ~{hms lgd~`y SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
3$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 1 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
>$ Lrmd~gdsm d` = {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd i{l{ smhgigs skiksgy
Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
;$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 75 {d~{l img}g ukhgu`ygd skiksgy Yu 6;$52;( ! kdgo u{h{a hmog
ymi{ ~{j{a u{h{a hmog y{umga - ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd ukn`ogd gdgl I@S$
6$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 77 {d~{l ukoikhmgd 9; u`~`db lgmd ig~ml b{y{ skiksgy
Yu 69;$555( ! kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a hmog ymi{ y{umga - ~mngl nmikdgylgd
okd{y{~ i{l{ ukn`ogd okd{y{~ SIOU$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
29/59
9=
2$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 95 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ugdn{gd [DGS lhgs 3 ! IMD( IMB(
O^L - skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
1$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 97 {d~{l lkbmg~gd hmdbl{dbgd UUHU UBYM skiksgy skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
=$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 93 {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd `hga
ygbg skiksgy Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf$
75$Lrmd~gdsm d` 9> {d~{l ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd ! i{l{ O^L(
Ugdn{gd [GD Lhgs 3 - skiksgy Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga -
igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
77$Lrmd~gdsm d` 37 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ugy~msmugsm Mjgsga skiksgy Yu ;=$555(
! hmog u{h{a skoimhgd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
79$Lrmd~gdsm d` 3> {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukd}k~`ygd ngf~gy s{s{hgd 9= smsrg lk
S{ygig}g skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf$
73$Lrmd~gdsm d` 36 {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ghg~ hms~yml skiksgy Yu 7>$555( ! koug~
ikhgs ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7>$Lrmd~gdsm d` 32 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd ukoikhgjgygd ngd i{l{
smhgigs skiksgy Yu =55$555( ! skoimhgd yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
7;$Lrmd~gdsm d` >5 {d~{l ukoig}gygd m{ygd Uygo{lg skiksgy Yu 721$555( !skyg~{s
~{j{a u{h{a nkhgugd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
76$Lrmd~gdsm d` >7 {d~{l ukoig}gygd Ukdbgrgsgd y{gdb {hgdbgd skoks~ky M
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
72$Lrmd~gdsm d` >9 {d~{l ukoig}gygd OLLS nm NMLI[N Ihm~gy skiksgy
Yu 9;5$555( ! n{g yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
71$Lrmd~gdsm d` >> {d~{l ukoikhmgd 79 i{ga ugugd Yu >;5$555( ! koug~yg~{s hmog
u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7=$Lrmd~gdsm d` >; {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ u`hm`( lgu{y ~{hms( i`hu`md( ~md~g
u`hmdky( ~md~g ugyiky skiksgy Yu 7$=73$555( ! sg~{ j{~g skoimhgd yg~{s ~mbg ikhgs
ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
95$Lrmd~gdsm d` >6 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukdbgrgs y{gdb [GD ngd ~ygdsu`y~ skiksgy
Yu 655$555( ! kdgo yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
Igarg ikdgy }gdb skagy{sd}g ngdg ~kyski{~ nmuky{d~{llgd SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd }gm~{ nm b{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd lkbmg~gd ikhgjgy okdbgjgy(
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
30/59
35
ukdmdblg~gd o{~{ b{y{( ukdmdblg~gd o{~{ smsrg( lkbmg~gd kls~ygl{yml{hky ngd
sgygdg uygsgygdg
Igarg ikdgy ^kynglrg okdbky~m igarg ngdg ngym ukokymd~ga }gdb nm~kymog
~kyski{~ skagy{sd}g skh{y{ad}g {d~{l lkukyh{gd skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd(
ngd ^kynglrg }gdb iky~gdbb{db jgrgi skigbgm Lkughg Skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga umagl skl`hga okdbb{dglgd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~
skhgdj{~d}g okouky~gdbb{db jgrgilgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ lk Nmdgs U ngd L
Lgi$ Ihm~gy nkdbgd okoi{g~ SUJ/ HUJ$
Igarg ikdgy nkdbgd gngd}g ukdbb{dggd {gdb SIOU ngd I@S ~gnm oglg ~kynglrg
s{nga okoi{g~ SUJ/HUJ dgo{d ikh{o skh{y{ad}g skhksgm nm~gdng ~gdbgdm lrm~gdsm
ukdbb{dggd {gdb ngym b{y{b{y{ skigi ~mngl nmikymlgd sks{gm agld}g( skamdbbg SUJ
ngd HUJ }gdb og{ nmskygalgd lkugng Nmdgs Ukdnmnmlgd hkrg~ sglsm U[JM ^GRGD
RMN@N@ nm~`hgl {d~{l nmukyigmlm$
Igarg ikdgy ngym ngdg skj{ohga Yu$ 3;$7=3$555(( }gdb grghd}g gng ugng
^kynglrg( skiksgy Yu$ 75$555$555( ~khga ^kynglrg lkoighmlgd lk skl`hga SOU
UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ngd skiksgy Yu$ 72$119$;>9( ~khga nmsm~g uk~{bgs / Ukd}mnml ngd
nmjgnmlgd igygdb i{l~m$
Igarg ikdgy iksgyd}g ngdg / {gdb }gdb ogsma gng ugng ^kynglrg l{ygdb hkima
skiksgy Yu$ 1$555$555($
^kynglrg okoikdgylgd igygdb i{l~m nmukysmngdbgd$
Okdmoigdb( igarg nmukysmngdbgd ~khga nmgj{lgd igygdb i{l~m iky{ug :
7$ 7 ikdnkh / 6 hkoigy F`~`c`u} i{l{ yklkdmdb Igdl IUN / Igdl Jg~mo d`
57>95215> Gd$SH^U UBYM 59 Lksgoikd / S[OGNJM
9$ 7 hkoigy yklgum~{hgsm ngdg SIOU }gdb nmglsks ngym I{l{ yklkdmdb ngdg ogs{l(
dmhgm ukdgymlgd ngd dmhgm }gdb nmikymlgd lk ikdngagyg nkdbgd ukdn{l{db l{m~gdsm
dmhgm skhmsma Yu$7=$7;5$555(
3$ 7 hkoigy yklgum~{hgsm ngdg I@S }gdb nmglsks ngym I{l{ yklkdmdb ngdg ogs{l( dmhgm
ukdgymlgd ngd dmhgm }gdb nmikymlgd lk ikdngagyg nkdbgd ukdn{l{db l{m~gdsm dmhgm
skhmsma Yu$76$5>3$762(
>$ = hkoigy l{m~gdsm {gdb }gdb nmikymlgd lk ikdngagyg ngym ngdg SIOU
Yu$73$>25$555(
;$ 79 hkoigy l{m~gdsm {gdb }gdb nmikymlgd lk ikdngagyg ngym ngdg I@S
Yu$66$;55$555(
6$ 7 i{l{ HUJ / SUJ ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU gdbbgygd 955>/955; igbm SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd igbmgd i{hgd Jgd{gymFkiy{gymOgyk~Guymh 955> !lg~kb`ym ikh{o
skhksgm- nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka ukokbgdb Lgs ngd Lkughg Skl`hga$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
31/59
37
2$ 75 i{l{ HUJ/SUJ ukdbb{dggd ngdg I@S 955;/9556 igbm SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
igbmgd i{hgd Sku~koiky 955; s/n Jgd{gym 9552 !Lg~kb`ym ikh{o skhksgm-
nm~gdng~gdbgdm `hka Nys$S[OGNJM$
1$ I{l{ yklkdmdb ^gi{dbgd Igdl Jg~mo D`$57>952515> Gd$SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd / S{ognjm
=$ I{l{ yklkdmdb ~gi{dbgd Igdl Jg~mo d` ykl$ 5>69572556 Gd$SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd / ^[OU[L$
75$7 i{l{ i{l~m ukdbkh{gygd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga Nys$S{ognjm ngd ikdnkh
l{m~gdsm/ukoikhgdjggd ukdbkh{gygd dmhgm Yu$72$375$69;( !i{l{ sgou{h imy{-
77$[gdb SIOU ngd I@S Yu$72$119$;>9(
79$7 hkoigy d`~g ~mdngsgd g~gs ukoikhmgd 79 i{ga ugugd ~ky~gdbbgh 35569556 `hka
SND 59 Lksgoikd !rgydg okyga o{ng-
73$7 ikdnkh S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd I{ug~m Ihm~gy D`o`y ;37 ~ga{d 9553 ~gdbbgh 72
Nkskoiky 9553 ~kd~gdb Ukdk~gugd Ukdbkh`hg Uy`bygo Ukoikymgd S{ismnm Img}g
Omdmogh Ukdnmnmlgd ngd hgoumygdd}g
7>$3 hkoigy SUUI !S{yg~ Ukyjgdjmgd Ukoikymgd Igd~{gd- ULUS IIO/I@S
7;$7 ikdnkh S{yg~ Lku{~{sgd I{ug~m Ihm~gy D`o`y 36; ~ga{d 9556 ~gdbbgh 93 Gb{s~{s
9556 ~kd~gdb Ukoikd~{lgd Sklyk~gymg~ Uy`bygo L`oukdsgsm Ukdb{ygdbgd S{ismnm
Igagd Iglgy Omd}gl !ULUS IIO- Imngdb Ukdnmnmlgd nm Lgi$Ihm~gy ~ga{d 9556
76$7 ikdnkh YGUIS ngdg USIOU ~ga{d 955>
72$7 ikdnkh f`~`c`u} YGUIS ~ga{d 955; SOU UBYM 9 LKSGOIKD
71$7 ikdnkh f`~`c`u} YGUIS ~ga{d 9556 SOU UBYM 9 LKSGOIKD
7=$7 ikdnkh YGUIS ~ga{d 955;/9556 ukym`nk J{hm s$n Nkskoiky 955;
95$7 ikdnkh YGUIS ~ga{d 9556 ukym`nk i{hgd Jgd{gym s/n J{dm 9556
97$7 ikdnkh l{m~gdsm ngd d`~g ukdbb{dggd ngdg SIOU Jgd{gym 955> s/n J{dm 955; ngd
I@S ukym nk J{hm 955; s/n Nkskoiky 9556$
99$7 hkoigy l{m~gdsm ukd}kygagd {gdb ~gdbbgh 995=9552 skiksgy Yu$75$555$555(
93$7 !sg~{- ikdnkh FC s{ismnm ngym ukokymd~ga
igygdb i{l~m ~kyski{~ ~khga nmsm~g sks{gm nkdbgd lk~kd~{gd a{l{o }gdb ikyhgl{ ngd
~kynglrg og{u{d sglsmsglsm ~khga okoikdgylgdd}g skamdbbg ngug~ nmuky~moigdblgd
skigbgm igygdb i{l~m }gdb sga nghgo ukylgyg mdm ~gdbbgh 7; Jgd{gym 955> ngym
UUHU Ngsgy ngd Okdkdbga UBYM Jgrg ^mo{y$
Igarg ugng rgl~{ ~kynglrg okdjgig~ skigbgm Lkughg Skl`hga SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd( Ihm~gy ~khga okdkymog igd~{gd ngdg SIOU ngd ngdg I@S ngym Nmdgs
Ukdnmnmlgd Lgi{ug~kd Ihm~gy skigbgm ikyml{~ : ngdg SIOU skiksgy Yu$ 39$695$555(
!~mbg u{h{a n{g j{~g kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a ymi{ y{umga- ngd ngdg I@S skiksgy
Yu$ 19$;>3$762( !nkhgugd u{h{a n{g j{~g hmog yg~{s koug~ u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s
kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga- skamdbbg lkskh{y{agd ngdg }gdb nm~kymog ~kyski{~
ikyj{ohga Yu$ 77;$763$762( !skyg~{s hmog ikhgs j{~g skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~mbg ymi{
skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga-$
Igarg skikh{o okdkymog ngdg igd~{gd igml SIOU og{u{d I@S agy{s s{nga
nmi{g~ YGUIS ! Ykdcgdg Gdbbgygd Ukdngug~gd Img}g Skl`hga- }gdb nm s{s{d `hka
Lkughg Skl`hga ikysgog nkdbgd Nkrgd B{y{ ngd L`om~k Skl`hga ~k~gum nghgo
ukhglsgdggdd}g YGUIS nm s{s{d skdnmym `hka ^kynglrg$
Igarg nghgo ukdcgmygd ngdg SIOU og{u{d ngdg I@S sks{gm nkdbgd Ukn{o g~g{
uk~{dj{l ~kladms {d~{l ukdcgmygdd}g nmhgl{lgd `hka Lkughg Skl`hga ikysgogsgog
nkdbgd Ikdngagyg ngd {gdbd}g agy{s nmsmougd `hka Ikdngagyg ngd ~mngl
nmukyi`hkalgd nmigrg g~g{ nmukbgdb `hka Lkughg Skl`hga$
Igarg nghgo ukhglsgdggdd}g ukdcgmygd ngdg SIOU og{u{d ngdg I@S }gdb
okdbgoimh g~g{ okdcgmylgd gnghga ~kynglrg skdnmym nkdbgd cgyg ~kynglrg okomd~g
~gdng ~gdbgd shmu ukdbgoimhgd ngd okomd~g L^U gshm lkugng Ikdngagyg ^[OU[L
MDNYG]G^M( skhgdj{~d}g sk~khga ngdg cgmy skcgyg iky~gagu `hka ~kynglrg }gdb
skigbmgd nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg ^[OU[L MDNYG]G^M ngd skigbmgd
hgmdd}g ~kynglrg igrg g~g{ smougd skdnmym$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
33/59
33
Igarg ikdgy ngym ngdg SIOU }gdb nm~kymog skiksgy Yu$ 39$695$555( }gdb
nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg skiksgy Yu$73$>25$555(( skngdblgd {d~{l ngdg I@S
}gdb nm~kymog skiksgy Yu$ 19$;>3$762( }gdb nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg skiksgy
Yu$ 66$;55$555(( }gdb ogdg ngdg SIOU skiksgy Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd ngdg I@S
skiksgy Yu$ 76$5>3$762( nkdbgd j{ohga skiksgy Yu$ 3;$7=3$555(( }gdb gng ugng
^kynglrg ~khga nmb{dglgd {d~{l :
7$ Lrmd~gsm d` > {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 9$735$555( ! n{g j{~g skyg~{s ~mbg u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
9$ Lrmd~gsm d` ; {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ ~{hms lgd~`y SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
3$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 1 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
>$ Lrmd~gdsm d` = {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd i{l{ smhgigs skiksgy
Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
;$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 75 {d~{l img}g ukhgu`ygd skiksgy Yu 6;$52;( ! kdgo u{h{a hmog
ymi{ ~{j{a u{h{a hmog y{umga - ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd ukn`ogd gdgl I@S$
6$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 77 {d~{l ukoikhmgd 9; u`~`db lgmd ig~ml b{y{ skiksgy
Yu 69;$555( ! kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a hmog ymi{ y{umga - ~mngl nmikdgylgd
okd{y{~ i{l{ ukn`ogd okd{y{~ SIOU$
2$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 95 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ugdn{gd [DGS lhgs 3 ! IMD( IMB(
O^L - skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
1$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 97 {d~{l lkbmg~gd hmdbl{dbgd UUHU UBYM skiksgy skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
=$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 93 {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd `hga
ygbg skiksgy Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf$
75$Lrmd~gdsm d` 9> {d~{l ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd ! i{l{ O^L(
Ugdn{gd [GD Lhgs 3 - skiksgy Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga -
igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
77$Lrmd~gdsm d` 37 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ugy~msmugsm Mjgsga skiksgy Yu ;=$555(
! hmog u{h{a skoimhgd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
34/59
3>
79$Lrmd~gdsm d` 3> {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukd}k~`ygd ngf~gy s{s{hgd 9= smsrg lk
S{ygig}g skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf$
73$Lrmd~gdsm d` 36 {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ghg~ hms~yml skiksgy Yu 7>$555( ! koug~
ikhgs ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7>$Lrmd~gdsm d` 32 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd ukoikhgjgygd ngd i{l{
smhgigs skiksgy Yu =55$555( ! skoimhgd yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
7;$Lrmd~gdsm d` >5 {d~{l ukoig}gygd m{ygd Uygo{lg skiksgy Yu 721$555( !skyg~{s
~{j{a u{h{a nkhgugd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
76$Lrmd~gdsm d` >7 {d~{l ukoig}gygd Ukdbgrgsgd y{gdb {hgdbgd skoks~ky M
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
72$Lrmd~gdsm d` >9 {d~{l ukoig}gygd OLLS nm NMLI[N Ihm~gy skiksgy
Yu 9;5$555( ! n{g yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
71$Lrmd~gdsm d` >> {d~{l ukoikhmgd 79 i{ga ugugd Yu >;5$555( ! koug~yg~{s hmog
u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7=$Lrmd~gdsm d` >; {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ u`hm`( lgu{y ~{hms( i`hu`md( ~md~g
u`hmdky( ~md~g ugyiky skiksgy Yu 7$=73$555( ! sg~{ j{~g skoimhgd yg~{s ~mbg ikhgs
ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
95$Lrmd~gdsm d` >6 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukdbgrgs y{gdb [GD ngd ~ygdsu`y~ skiksgy
Yu 655$555( ! kdgo yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf
Igarg ~kynglrg okd}gngym lghg{ ngdg ngym Ukokymd~ga }gdb nm~kymog skagy{sd}g
skh{y{ad}g {d~{l lkukyh{gd skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd }gm~{ nmb{dglgd
{d~{l lkukd~mdbgd lkbmg~gd ikhgjgy okdbgjgy( ukdmdblg~gd o{~{ b{y{( ukdmdblg~gd
o{~{ smsrg( lkbmg~gd kls~ygl{yml{hky ngd sgygd uygsgygdg$
Igarg nkdbgd gngd}g ukdbb{dggd {gdb SIOU ngd I@S oglg ~kynglrg s{nga
okoi{g~ SUJ/HUJ dgo{d ikh{o skh{y{ad}g skhksgm nm~gdng~gdbgdm lrm~gdsm
ukdbb{dggd {gdb ngym b{y{b{y{ skigi ~mngl nmikymlgd sks{gm agld}g( skamdbbg SUJ
ngd HUJ }gdb og{ nmskygalgd lkugng Nmdgs Ukdnmnmlgd hkrg~ sglsm U[JM ^GRGD
RMN@N@ nm~`hgl {d~{l nmukyigmlm$
Igarg ngym ngdg skiksgy Yu$ 3;$7=3$555( !~mbg u{h{a j{~g skyg~{s skoimhgd u{h{a
~mbg ymi{ y{umga- }gdb grghd}g gng ugng ~kynglrg skhgdj{~d}g skiksgy
Yu$ 75$555$555( !sku{h{a j{~g y{umga- ~khga ~kynglrg lkoighmlgd lk skl`hga SOU
UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ngd }gdb skiksgy Yu$ 72$119$;>9( ~khga nmsm~g ukd}mnml ngd
nmjgnmlgd igygdb i{l~m$
Igarg ngdg }gdb ogsma gng ugng ~kynglrg skj{ohga Yu$ 1$555$555( !nkhgugd j{~g
y{umga- $
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
35/59
3;
Okdmoigdb( igarg ikyngsgylgd fgl~gfgl~g a{l{o ~kyski{~ nmg~gs( oglg
Ogjkhms Aglmo ~kyhkima nga{h{ glgd okouky~moigdblgd guglga ukyi{g~gd }gdb
nmhgl{lgd( ~khga okokd{am {ds{y{ds{y ~mdngl umngdg skuky~m }gdb nmnglrglgd `hka
Ukd{d~{~ [o{o3$762( nkdbgd j{ohga skiksgy Yu$ 3;$7=3$555(( }gdb gng ugng
^kynglrg ~khga nmb{dglgd {d~{l :
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
38/59
31
7$ Lrmd~gsm d` > {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 9$735$555( ! n{g j{~g skyg~{s ~mbg u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
9$ Lrmd~gsm d` ; {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ ~{hms lgd~`y SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
3$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 1 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
>$ Lrmd~gdsm d` = {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd i{l{ smhgigs skiksgy
Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
;$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 75 {d~{l img}g ukhgu`ygd skiksgy Yu 6;$52;( ! kdgo u{h{a hmog
ymi{ ~{j{a u{h{a hmog y{umga - ~mngl sks{gm nkdbgd ukn`ogd gdgl I@S$
6$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 77 {d~{l ukoikhmgd 9; u`~`db lgmd ig~ml b{y{ skiksgy
Yu 69;$555( ! kdgo yg~{s n{g u{h{a hmog ymi{ y{umga - ~mngl nmikdgylgd
okd{y{~ i{l{ ukn`ogd okd{y{~ SIOU$
2$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 95 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ugdn{gd [DGS lhgs 3 ! IMD( IMB(
O^L - skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
1$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 97 {d~{l lkbmg~gd hmdbl{dbgd UUHU UBYM skiksgy skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
=$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 93 {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd `hga
ygbg skiksgy Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf$
75$Lrmd~gdsm d` 9> {d~{l ukoikhmgd og~kymgh ukd{djgdb lkbmg~gd ! i{l{ O^L(
Ugdn{gd [GD Lhgs 3 - skiksgy Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga -
igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
77$Lrmd~gdsm d` 37 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ugy~msmugsm Mjgsga skiksgy Yu ;=$555(
! hmog u{h{a skoimhgd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
79$Lrmd~gdsm d` 3> {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukd}k~`ygd ngf~gy s{s{hgd 9= smsrg lk
S{ygig}g skiksgy Yu 7;5$555( ! skyg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl
gng / fml~mf$
73$Lrmd~gdsm d` 36 {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ghg~ hms~yml skiksgy Yu 7>$555( ! koug~
ikhgs ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7>$Lrmd~gdsm d` 32 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd ukoikhgjgygd ngd i{l{
smhgigs skiksgy Yu =55$555( ! skoimhgd yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
7;$Lrmd~gdsm d` >5 {d~{l ukoig}gygd m{ygd Uygo{lg skiksgy Yu 721$555( !skyg~{s
~{j{a u{h{a nkhgugd ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
39/59
3=
76$Lrmd~gdsm d` >7 {d~{l ukoig}gygd Ukdbgrgsgd y{gdb {hgdbgd skoks~ky M
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
72$Lrmd~gdsm d` >9 {d~{l ukoig}gygd OLLS nm NMLI[N Ihm~gy skiksgy
Yu 9;5$555( ! n{g yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
71$Lrmd~gdsm d` >> {d~{l ukoikhmgd 79 i{ga ugugd Yu >;5$555( ! koug~yg~{s hmog
u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
7=$Lrmd~gdsm d` >; {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ u`hm`( lgu{y ~{hms( i`hu`md( ~md~g
u`hmdky( ~md~g ugyiky skiksgy Yu 7$=73$555( ! sg~{ j{~g skoimhgd yg~{s ~mbg ikhgs
ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
95$Lrmd~gdsm d` >6 {d~{l ukoig}gygd ukdbgrgs y{gdb [GD ngd ~ygdsu`y~ skiksgy
Yu 655$555( ! kdgo yg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
Igarg ikdgy }gdb skagy{sd}g ngdg ~kyski{~ nmuky{d~{llgd SOU UBYM 59
Lksgoikd }gm~{ nm b{dglgd {d~{l lkukd~mdbgd lkbmg~gd ikhgjgy okdbgjgy(
ukdmdblg~gd o{~{ b{y{( ukdmdblg~gd o{~{ smsrg( lkbmg~gd kls~ygl{yml{hky ngd
sgygdg uygsgygdg
Igarg ikdgy ^kynglrg okdbky~m igarg ngdg ngym ukokymd~ga }gdb nm~kymog
~kyski{~ skagy{sd}g skh{y{ad}g {d~{l lkukyh{gd skl`hga SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd(
ngd ^kynglrg }gdb iky~gdbb{db jgrgi skigbgm Lkughg Skl`hga$
Igarg ikdgy sk~khga umagl skl`hga okdbb{dglgd ngdg SIOU ngd I@S ~kyski{~
skhgdj{~d}g okouky~gdbb{db jgrgilgd ukdbb{dggd ngdg ~kyski{~ lk Nmdgs U ngd L
Lgi$ Ihm~gy nkdbgd okoi{g~ SUJ/ HUJ$
Igarg ikdgy nkdbgd gngd}g ukdbb{dggd {gdb SIOU ngd I@S ~gnm oglg ~kynglrg
s{nga okoi{g~ SUJ/HUJ dgo{d ikh{o skh{y{ad}g skhksgm nm~gdng ~gdbgdm lrm~gdsm
ukdbb{dggd {gdb ngym b{y{b{y{ skigi ~mngl nmikymlgd sks{gm agld}g( skamdbbg SUJ
ngd HUJ }gdb og{ nmskygalgd lkugng Nmdgs Ukdnmnmlgd hkrg~ sglsm U[JM ^GRGD
RMN@N@ nm~`hgl {d~{l nmukyigmlm$
Igarg ikdgy ngym ngdg skj{ohga Yu$ 3;$7=3$555(( }gdb grghd}g gng ugng
^kynglrg( skiksgy Yu$ 75$555$555( ~khga ^kynglrg lkoighmlgd lk skl`hga SOU
UBYM 59 Lksgoikd ngd skiksgy Yu$ 72$119$;>9( ~khga nmsm~g uk~{bgs / Ukd}mnml ngd
nmjgnmlgd igygdb i{l~m$
Igarg ikdgy iksgyd}g ngdg / {gdb }gdb ogsma gng ugng ^kynglrg l{ygdb hkima
skiksgy Yu$ 1$555$555($
Okdmoigdb( igarg ikyngsgylgd {ygmgd uky~moigdbgd nmg~gs( ~khga skcgyg
d}g~g gng {ds{y lkskdbgjggd ngd nmsgngym `hka ~kynglrg {d~{l ~mngl okdbkoighmlgd
{gdb ngdg }gdb ogsma nmsmougd ~kynglrg skigbgm Lkughg Skl`hga skiksgy
Yu$ 3;$7=3$555( !~mbg u{h{a hmog j{~g skyg~{s skoimhgd u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ y{umga- nmogdg
lkskh{y{agd ngdg }gdb nm~kymog igml ngdg SIOU og{u{d ngdg I@S gnghga skiksgy
7/30/2019 PUTUSAN Nomor: 296/Pid.Sus/2010/PN.BLT
40/59
>5
Yu$ 77;$763$762( !skyg~{s hmog ikhgs j{~g skyg~{s kdgo u{h{a ~mbg ymi{ skyg~{s kdgo
u{h{a ~{j{a y{umga- skngdblgd ugng rgl~{ ukdcgmygd skcgyg iky~gagu }gdb nmskygalgd
lkugng Ikdngagyg ^[OU[L MDNYG]G^M igy{ skiksgy Yu$ 2=$=25$555( !~{j{a u{h{a
skoimhgd j{~g skoimhgd yg~{s ~{j{a u{h{a ymi{ y{umga-( ngd ukyi{g~gd ~kynglrg ~kyski{~
gnghga oky{uglgd ukyi{g~gd okhgrgd a{l{o ( }gdb nghgo n`l~ymd a{l{o umngdg ngug~
nmgy~mlgd skigbgm ukyi{g~gd }gdb iky~kd~gdbgd nkdbgd ukyg~{ygd uky{dngdb{dngdbgd
!a{l{o ~ky~{hms- ngd/ g~g{ ygsg lkgnmhgd g~g{ d`yogd`yog lkamn{ugd s`smgh
ogs}gyglg~25$555(( skngdblgd {d~{l ngdg I@S
}gdb nm~kymog skiksgy Yu$ 19$;>3$762( }gdb nmskygalgd lkugng Ikdngagyg skiksgy
Yu$ 66$;55$555(( }gdb ogdg ngdg SIOU skiksgy Yu$ 7=$7;5$555( ngd ngdg I@S
skiksgy Yu$ 76$5>3$762( nkdbgd j{ohga skiksgy Yu$ 3;$7=3$555(( }gdb gng ugng
^kynglrg ~khga nmb{dglgd {d~{l :
7$ Lrmd~gsm d` > {d~{l lkbmg~gd ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 9$735$555( ! n{g j{~g skyg~{s ~mbg u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng /
fml~mf$
9$ Lrmd~gsm d` ; {d~{l ukoikhmgd ghg~ ~{hms lgd~`y SOU UBYM 59 Lksgoikd
skiksgy Yu 755$555( ! skyg~{s ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
3$ Lrmd~gdsm d` 1 {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukn`ogd l{yml{h{o 955> skiksgy
Yu 3;5$555( ! ~mbg yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga - igygdb ~mngl gng / fml~mf$
>$ Lrmd~gdsm d` = {d~{l ukoikhmgd i{l{ ukdbkoigdbgd i{l{ smhgigs skiksgy
Yu >;5$555( ! koug~ yg~{s hmog u{h{a ymi{ y{umga