8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
1/49
PROGRAM
BOOK
NATIONAL
UNIVERSITY
DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP
(NUDC)
SRIWIJAYA STATE POLYTECHNIC,
25 31 AUGUST 213
MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND CULTURE
DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF HIGHER EDUCATION
DIRECTORATE OF LEARNING AND STUDENT AFFAIRS
2013R!"#$% &$'" ! D*$!+'$ &'$ L!#$*- #. S/.!
A&*$0 '& DIKTI
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
2/49
Assalamualaikum warama!ullaiwa"araka!u#
D$ar %$"a!$rs#
I am %$li&!$% !' $(!$)% m* warm$s! w$l+'m$ a)% !'
+')&ra!ula!$ *'u all ,'r -ar!i+i-a!i)& i) !is .$r* i)s-iri)&
$.$)!/ T$ Na!i')al U)i.$rsi!* D$"a!i)& Cam-i')si-
NUDC as a% a -r$s!i&i'us a)% su++$ss,ul is!'r* a)%# !is
*$ar w$ ar$ %$li&!$% !' ')+$ a&ai) +')!i)u$ !a! !ra%i!i') i)
al$m"a)& w$r$ -$'-l$ +a) !as!$ !$ )i+$s! "l$)% ', !ra%i!i')
a)% i)!$r)a!i')al !'u+/ I) !$ -as! ,i.$ *$ars# !$ NUDC as
$)a"l$% !'usa)%s ', u)i.$rsi!* s!u%$)!s !' &$! i).'l.$% i) a
u)iu$ a)% r$war%i)& +'m-$!i!i')/ Tis *$ar s$$s !$ NUDC
a%.a)+i)& i) m'r$ wa*s !a) ')$/ 4i! !$ +')s!a)! "a+ki)& ',
!$ Mi)is!r* ', E%u+a!i') a)% Cul!ur$# w$ ar$ ')+$ a&ai)ru))i)& !$ w$ll5-r$-ar$% +'m-$!i!i')# wi! %$"a!$rs "$i)&
s$l$+!$% ', !$ir r'u)%s !r'u& !w$l.$ r$&i')al s$l$+!i')s/
4i! s$.$) -r$limi)ar* r'u)%s# !is *$ar NUDC k$$-s
+all$)&i)& %$"a!$rs !' s'w !$ir $)%ura)+$ ', i)!$ll$+!uali!*/
M'r$ !a) a m$r$ .$r"al 'r -$r,'rma)+$ skill# !$ NUDC$m"'%i$s !$ i%$als ', r$as')$% ar&um$)!# !'l$ra)+$ ,'r
%i.$r&$)! -'i)!s ', .i$w# a)% ri&'r'us s$l,5$(ami)a!i')/ Tis is
!$ "$s! wa* !' &$ar u- s!u%$)!s6 +ri!i+al !i)ki)& as w$ll as !'
mai)!ai) %$m'+ra+* !$ &'.$r)m$)! m's!l* +')+$r)s ')/
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
3/49
T$r$,'r$# I s!r')&l* "$li$.$ !a! !is +'m-$!i!i.$ %$"a!$ )$$%s
!' !ak$ -la+$ imm$%ia!$l* i) !$ w'rl% ', $%u+a!i') !' "$ !$
sa,$&uar% ', !$ ,u!ur$ &$)$ra!i')s/
A s-$+ial !a)k &'$s !' all -ar!i$s i).'l.$%/ Al!'u& mu+
w'rk r$mai)s a$a% ', us# w$ a.$ ') 'ur si%$ s!r')&
+'ll$+!i.$ %$sir$ !' w'rk !'&$!$r ,'r !$ +'m-$!i!i.$)$ss ', 'ur
+'u)!r* w$r$ "rillia)! +r$a!i.i!* )'w$r$ !' "$ s$$) "u! $r$
i) 'ur .$r* 'w) +'u)!r*/ Ha.$ a )i+$ %$"a!$7
4assalamualikum warama!ullaiwa"araka!u/
8akar!a# Au&us! 2013
Illa Saila
R$mark ,r'm !$ 9i+$ Dir$+!'r ,'r S!u%$)!s A,,air ', OLSRI
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
4/49
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
5/49
R$mark ,r'm !$ C').$)$r ,r'm DI:TI
D$ar D$"a!$rs#
O) "$al, ', all !'s$ i).'l.$% w$ wis *'u a .$r*
warm w$l+'m$ !' !is *$ar;s NUDC/ As !$ "i&&$s! a)% "$s!
+'m-$!i!i') ', i!s ki)% i) I)%')$sia wi! '.$r 1000 s!u%$)!s
-ar!i+i-a!i)& i) r$&i')al s$l$+!i')s !is *$ar w$ ar$ sur$ !a!
$.$r* ')$ ', i!s %$"a!$s will "$ a) $)
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
6/49
i)+r$asi)& *'ur k)'wl$%&$ ', a "r'a% ra)&$ ', im-'r!a)! issu$s
a! !$ sam$ !im$/
4$ '-$ !a! !is *$ar NUDC &i.$s *'u .alua"l$ skills
') 'w !' +')s!ru+! +as$s a)% $l-s %$.$l'- *'ur s$l,5
+'),i%$)+$ i) *'ur %$"a!i)& a"ili!*/ 4$ a.$ +'m$ !' s'w 'ur
!w' !um"s u- !' 'li!$k)ik N$&$ri Sriwi
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
7/49
T#! '& C'!0
R$mark ,r'm !$ Dir$+!'r ,'r L$ar)i)&
a)% S!u%$)!s A,,air ', DI:TI
/ i
R$mark ,r'm !$ 9i+$ R$+!'r ,'r
S!u%$)!s A,,air ', OLSRI
/ iii
R$mark ,r'm !$ C').$)$r ,r'm DI:TI / i.
Ta"l$ ', C')!$)!s / .i
I/ NUDC AT 213 GLANCE / 1
II/ RULE O4 CONDUCT O4
THE TOURNAMENT
/ 2
III/ 4ORMAT O4 THE
TOURNAMENTA O6!$6*!7 '& ! 4'$"#
B P$!*"*#$8 R'/.0
C S!!+*' '& T!#"0 &'$
! !*"*#*' $'/.0
D T! M#* C'"9!**'
!*"*#*' $'/.0
/
/
/
/
/
3
3
3
B
I9/ NUDC SCHEDULE /
9/ ADJUDICATION BOARD /
9I/ PARTICIPANTS /
9II/ INTRODUCTION TO
BRITISH PARLIAMENTARY
SYSTEM
/ 22
9III/ POLSRI AT GLANCE / 3
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
8/49
I NUDC AT 213 GLANCE
Dir$+!'ra!$ G$)$ral ', Hi&$r E%u+a!i')# Mi)is!r* ',
E%u+a!i') a)% Cul!ur$ +')%u+!$% !$ ,irs! I)%')$sia5wi%$
%$"a!$ !'ur)am$)! ,'r u)i.$rsi!* l$.$l i) 200/ Tis
)a!i')al l$.$l %$"a!i)& +'m-$!i!i') "$+'m$s a) a))ual
)a!i')al -r'&ram/ I! is !$ Na!i')al U)i.$rsi!* E)&lis
D$"a!i)& Cam-i')si-7 Usi)& ?ri!is arliam$)!ar*
s!*l$# wa! mak$s !$ !'ur)am$)! u)iu$ is i!s ,as!5-a+$%
a)% i& %*)ami+ a!m's-$r$/
Tis *$ar ', 2013 i!s !$ !NUDC# us$% !' "$ NUEDC
!a! is -r'
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
9/49
.arsi!i$s i) !$ r$&i')/ Tis *$ar NUDC w'ul% &a!$r
!$ams ,r'm 12 r$&i')s i) I)%')$sia/ F'r sur$ !is will "$ a
!'ur)am$)! !a! +').$)$s !$ "$s! a)% "ri&!$s! I)%')$sia
9arsi!i$s %$"a!$ !$ams/
S!$--i)& !' i!s !*$ars# !$ NUDC us$% !' "$ NUEDC
+')sis!$)!l* mai)!ai)s i!s i& uali!* ', %$"a!$ "*
i).'l.i)& !$ "$s! a%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
10/49
a!!$)%i)& !$ NUDC a)% "* '!$r i)%i.i%uals
au!'ri@$% "* !$ NUDC +'mmi!!$$ 'r !$ !'ur)am$)!
's!/
B/ D$+isi') +'),i%$)!iali!*/ I! is u- !' !$ %is+r$!i') ',
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
11/49
A O6!$6*!7 '& ! 4'$"#
1/ T$r$ sall "$ ,i.$ -r$limi)ar* r'u)%s ', %$"a!$#
i).'l.i)& all !$ams $li&i"l$ !' %$"a!$ i) !$
Cam-i')si-s/2/ F'll'wi)& !$ ,i.$ -r$limi)ar* r'u)%s# !$r$
sall "$ a) $limi)a!i') r'u)% +')sis!i)& ', !$
!'- 32 !$ams ,r'm !$ -r$limi)ar* r'u)%/
B T! P$!*"*#$8 R'/.0
1/ All !$ams $li&i"l$ !' %$"a!$ a! !$ Cam-i')si-s
+'m-$!$ i) !$ -r$limi)ar* r'u)%s
2/ C'm-'si!$ 'r swi)& !$ams mus! "$ a%%$% "* !$!'ur)am$)! Dir$+!'r !' u)%$r !$ ,'ll'wi)&
+ir+ums!a)+$s>
a/ i, !$ )um"$r ', !$ams $li&i"l$ !' %$"a!$ i)
!$ -r$limi)ar* r'u)%s is $ual !' a )um"$r
%i.isi"l$ "* ,'ur# )' +'m-$!$ !$ams ar$
all'w$%= 'r"/ i, !is is )'! !$ +as$# !$) +'m-'si!$ !$ams
ma* "$ a%%$% u)!il !$ )um"$r ', !$ams i)
!$ -r$limi)ar* r'u)% is $ual !' a )um"$r
%i.isi"l$ "* ,'ur/
3/ I, a !$am wi!%raws ,r'm +'m-$!i!i') "$,'r$ 'r%uri)& !$ -r$limi)ar* r'u)%s !$) !$* sall "$
r$m'.$% ,r'm !$ %raw a)% $i!$ra/ r$-la+$% wi! a +'m-'si!$ !$am= 'r
"/ !$ )um"$r ', +'m-'si!$ !$am is r$%u+$% !'
$)sur$ !a! !$ )um"$r ', !$ams i) !$
+'m-$!i!i') is s!ill $ual !' a )um"$r%i.isi"l$ "* ,'ur/
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
12/49
B/ F'll'wi)& $a+ r'u)%# !$ams sall "$ ra)k$% "* !$a%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
13/49
1/ A! !$ +')+lusi') ', $a+ ', !$ O+!'5Fi)als#Juar!$r Fi)als# a)% S$mi Fi)als# !$ a% R$&is!ra!i') a)% C$+k5i)
5 12/00513/00 > ISHOMA
5 13/0051B/00 > D$"a!i)& S$mi)ar a)% A% ?r$ak
5 1/3051/00 > O-$)i)& C$r$m')*
5 1/005 20/00 > Di))$r
5 20/005 > ?a+k !' H'!$l
D#8 2: A/- 2;5 0/3050/30 > ?r$ak,as!
5 0/3050/00 > L$a.i)& ,'r S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ',Sriwi R'll Call
5 0/3050/B > Ma!+ u- a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 0/B50/B > r$limi)ar* R'u)% 1
5 0/B510/1 > Ta"ula!i') a)% C',,$$ ?r$ak
5 10/1510/B > R'll Call
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
14/49
5 10/B511/00 > Ma!+ u- a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 11/00513/00 > r$limi)ar* R'u)% 2
5 13/0051B/00 > ISHOMA
5 1B/0051B/30 > R'll Call5 1B/3051B/B > Ma!+ u- a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 1B/B51/B > r$limi)ar* R'u)% 3
5 1/B51/00 > ?a+k !' H'!$l
5 1/0051/00 > Fr$$ Tim$
5 1/00 > Di))$r
D#8 3: A/- 2
5 0/3050/30 > ?r$ak,as!5 0/3050/00 > L$a.i)& ,'r S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ',
Sriwi R'll Call
5 0/3050/B > Ma!+ u- a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 0/B50/B > r$limi)ar* R'u)% B
5 0/B510/1 > Ta"ula!i') a)% C',,$$ ?r$ak
5 10/1510/B > R'll Call
5 10/B511/00 > Ma!+ u- a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 11/00513/00 > r$limi)ar* R'u)% 5 13/0051B/00 > ISHOMA
5 1B/0051B/30 > R'll Call
5 1B/3051B/B > Ma!+ u- a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 1B/B51/B > r$limi)ar* R'u)%
5 1/B51/1 > Ta"ula!i') a)% C',,$$ ?r$ak
5 1/151/B > ?a+k !' H'!$l
5 1/B51/00 > Fr$$ Tim$
5 1/00 > Di))$r
D#8 ?r$ak,as!
5 0/3050/00 > L$a.i)& ,'r S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ',
Sriwi R'll Call
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
15/49
5 0/3050/B > Ma!+ u- a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 0/B50/B > r$limi)ar* R'u)%
5 0/B511/00 > C',,$$ ?r$ak a)% Ta"ula!i')
5 11/00512/00 > ?r$aki)& T$ams A))'u)+$m$)!5 12/00513/00 > ISHOMA
5 13/00513/1 > R'll Call a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 13/151/00 > Mai) Draw O+!',i)alsKN'.i+$Juar!$r,i)als
5 1/0051/30 > C',,$$ ?r$ak a)% Ta"ula!i')
5 1/3051/B > R'll Call a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 1/B51/B > Mai) Draw Juar!$r,i)als
5 1/B51/1 > ?a+k !' H'!$l
5 1/151/00 > Fr$$ Tim$5 1/00 > Di))$r
D#8 5: A/-2>5 0/0050/30 > ?r$ak,as!
5 0/3050/00 > L$a.i)& ,'r ?:?
5 0/0051/00 > Musi T'ur a)% Ci!* T'ur
5 1/00 1/B > L$a.i)& ,'r S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ',
Sriwi r$-ara!i') ,'r N'.i+$ S$mi,i)als
5 1/005 1/00 > N'.i+$ S$mi,i)als
5 1/00 5 1/30 > ?a+k !' '!$l
5 1/3051/00 > Fr$$ !im$
5 1/005 > Di))$r
D#8 ; : A/- 35 0/3050/00 > ?r$ak,as!
5 0/0050/30 > L$a.i)& ,'r S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ',
Sriwi R'll Call a)% M'!i') R$l$as$
5 0/005 10/00 > Mai) Draw S$mi,i)als
5 10/005 10/30 > ?r$ak
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
16/49
5 10/30 511/00 > r$-ara!i') ,'r NO9ICE GRAND
FINAL
5 11/00513/00 > NO9ICE GRAND FINAL
5 13/0051B/00 > ISHOMA5 1B/0051B/1 > r$-ara!i') ,'r GRAND FINAL
5 1B/151/1 > GRAND FINAL
5 1/151/30 > ?r$ak a)% Ta"ula!i')
5 1/3051/00 > ?a+k !' H'!$l
5 1/0051/30 > L$a.i)& ,'r S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ',
Sriwi Di))$r 5 1/30 21/00 > Cl'si)& C$r$m')*
D#8 : A/- 315 0/00 12/00 > C$+k Ou!
V ADJUDICATION BOARD
P#$' > Dir$+!'r G$)$ral ', Hi&$r
E%u+a!i')
P$'-$#" D*$!+'$ > 5 Dr/ Illa Saila# M/S/ Dir$+!'r ',L$ar)i)& a)% S!u%$)! A,,airs ',
DI:TI
5 R/D/ :usuma)!'#S/T/# MT 'lsri
Dir$+!'r
5 r',/ Dr/ ?a%ia $ri@a%$/# M/?A/
R$k!'r U)i.$rsi!as Sriwi
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
17/49
A/Tawa
S!+$!#$*!0 > S*aril
Fir%ausMu)a Masli)a S$m"iri)& Dik!iS'l,a)aria
C'6!!$ > Ra+ma! Nur+a*'Tiur Sima) D'ra A)&$li)a Arua)Nur Ri,ai Aksa)
M#!$*# #. M!!*-0 > Alam Nasra Iklas Dik!i
N',ia)s*a
S!+$!#$*#0 > H$)$ria T*ar Dik!iA@i@a Dik!i
Marlia)a Dik!i
E.ilia)a
9$ri))a Ri@ki U!ami
L'-*0*+0 #.
#++'""'.#*'
> Iwa) S$!*awa) Dik!iSu%irma) Dik!i
Yusu- Dik!i?$"$) Dik!i
?ram
Suwar!i
Li)aA# Na)a)& Tau,ik
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
18/49
M!.*+# !9 > Tim D'k!$r
T'/$ +''$.*#'$ > Darmi)i*a)!i
LO > M/ Hasa)u%%i) Cs
E?/*9"!0 > Su*a)!'T$#09'$#*' > Rusli# M/ Yusu,P/*+#*' > A%i S*ak%a)iS!+/$*8 > ra)%'k'V!/!0 > Su&i*a)!'
VI PARTICIPANTS
R!-*' I
N' N#"! C'!-! A.@/.*+#'$:D!#!$
1. Els*am Maula)aU)i.$rsi!as
Suma!$ra U!ara2. Fr$%$ri+k Samu$l
3. Yu%a S*a-u!ra
4. Muamma% Ra,ii
'li!$k)ik U)&&ul
L3M
5. S$lama! Hus)i
Hasi"ua)
6. A*u 4ula) Sari
Tam-u"'l')
7.4i%'-' Ha)l*
'li!$k)ik N$&$ri
M$%a)
8. Cris! 8'r%a)
Sia&ia)
9. Iria)+$
10. Elisa ram')' STIE I),'rmasi
T$k)'l'&i
?is)is
11. H$ri*a)!'
12. M$i))* Ri@k*
13. El)'.iam* U)i.$rsi!as N$&$ri
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
19/49
M$%a)
14. Fi!ri Mar%ia)a
Sir$&ar
15. Sukma S$-!ia)
Nasu!i')16. Amsal Irmalis
U)i.$rsi!as S*ia
:uala
17. M/ Sa,)a)
Mar%a!illa
18. Yulia)a
A)&&r$i)i SF
19. Irma A%$U)i.$rsi!as
Muamma%i*aSuma!$ra U!ara
20. Rama%a)i
S*a-u!ra
21. Ri@ki Har%i*a)!i
22. R'+k* ar%$%$U)i.$rsi!as
Darma A&u)&23. Swar%i Hu!a
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
20/49
al$m"a)&15. D$wi Sri# SE# M/Si A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
21/49
4
Sul!a) A&$)&
Tir!a*asa
14. R$@@a Dwi
?ramma%i!aD$"a!$r
15. Fir%a Malik D$"a!$r 16. Maara)i R'!ua U)i.$rsi!as
:a!'lik
I)%')$sia A!ma
8a*a
A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
22/49
I)%')$sia11. D$)a Am"ar Sar* D$"a!$r
12. R$s!u 4i"'w' A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
23/49
Ama% Dala)11. :ar
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
24/49
A)%ika
S$mara)&9. I)%ri Giri*a)!i A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
25/49
3. Yus)a) Ha%i
M'+!arA%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
26/49
20. 8'r&* All$)
ur)'m'D$"a!$r
21. :$.i) Susa)!'
G'l*A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
27/49
U%a*a)!i
16. Ni Ma%$ Aria)i STI?A
Saraswa!i
D$)-asar
D$"a!$r
17. Hilarius La)%uk D$"a!$r
18. D$ll* Elim A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
28/49
Riau7. Eka U!ami u!ri U)i.$rsi!as
La)+a)& :u)i)&
D$"a!$r
8. Ak@ir Fi!ri A,ia)i D$"a!$r
9. :ris!i$ O)asis U)i.$rsi!asI)!$r)asi')al
?a!am
D$"a!$r
10. I.')$ D$"a!$r
11. uri Awa)%aU)i.$rsi!as Riau
D$"a!$r
12. Mur*a!i D$"a!$r
13. Ni)%*a S'ra*aU)i.$rsi!as 8am"i
D$"a!$r
14. Y'a) ?$)$%$!a D$"a!$r
15.
A,)$sa
N'.$ria)a Ca)& U)i.$rsi!as N$&$ria%a)&
D$"a!$r
16. 4i%*a F$"ri)a D$"a!$r
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
29/49
R!-*' I
N' N#"! C'!-! A.@/.*+#'$:D!#!$
1. 8$,,r$* Har!a)!''li!$k)ik
T')&&ak Eua!'r
')!ia)ak
D$"a!$r
2. Ir.a) A)%ria)
4illiamD$"a!$r
3. Ar%i M$isa A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
30/49
23. Ni)%ia Ma*sara D$"a!$r
24. Er)a Yuli Ya)!i A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
31/49
M/E%/ CS
19. Fi+a ra%ia)a
Mar!a
U)i.$rsi!as
Musamus M$rauk$
D$"a!$r
20. askalis:ai-ma)
D$"a!$r
21. Mar!a
?$!au"u)# S/%#
M/Hum
A%1/1/3 M$m"$rs will %$li.$r su"s!a)!i.$ s-$$+$s i) !$
,'ll'wi)& 'r%$r>
1 rim$ Mi)is!$r=
2 O--'si!i') L$a%$r=
3 D$-u!* rim$ Mi)is!$r=B D$-u!* O--'si!i') L$a%$r=
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
32/49
M$m"$r ,'r !$ G'.$r)m$)!= M$m"$r ,'r !$ O--'si!i')=
G'.$r)m$)! 4i-=
O--'si!i') 4i-/
O-$)i)& G'.$r)m$)!>
rim$ Mi)is!$r 'r Firs! G'.$r)m$)! m$m"$r a)% D$-u!* rim$ Mi)is!$r 'r S$+')% G'.$r)m$)!
m$m"$r=
O-$)i)& O--'si!i')>
L$a%$r ', !$ O--'si!i') 'r Firs! O--'si!i') m$m"$r
a)%
D$-u!* L$a%$r ', !$ O--'si!i') 'r S$+')% O--'si!i')m$m"$r=
Cl'si)& G'.$r)m$)!>
M$m"$r ,'r !$ G'.$r)m$)! 'r Tir% G'.$r)m$)!
m$m"$r a)%
G'.$r)m$)! 4i- 'r F'ur! O--'si!i') m$m"$r=
Cl'si)& O--'si!i')> M$m"$r ,'r !$ O--'si!i') 'r Tir% O--'si!i')
m$m"$r a)%
O--'si!i') 4i- 'r F'ur! O--'si!i') m$m"$r/
12 M!"!$0 7* .!*6!$ # 0/0#*6! 09!!+ '& 0!6!
"*/!0 ./$#*' #. 0'/. '&&!$ 9'*0 '&
*&'$"#*' 7*! "!"!$0 '& ! '99'0*- !#"0 #$!
09!#%*-
13 T! "'*'
1/3/1 T$ m'!i') s'ul% "$ u)am"i&u'usl* w'r%$%/
1/3/2 T$ m'!i') s'ul% r$,l$+! !a! !$ Na!i')alU)i.$rsi!* D$"a!i)& Cam-i')si- is a )a!i')al l$.$l
!'ur)am$)!/
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
33/49
1/3/3 T$ m$m"$rs s'ul% %$"a!$ !$ m'!i') i) !$ s-iri! ',!$ m'!i') a)% !$ !'ur)am$)!/
1< P$!9#$#*'
1/B/1 T$ %$"a!$ s'ul% +'mm$)+$ 1 mi)u!$s a,!$r !$
m'!i') is a))'u)+$%/1/B/2 T$ams s'ul% arri.$ a! !$ir %$"a!$ wi!i) ,i.$
mi)u!$s ', !$ s+$%ul$% s!ar!i)& !im$ ,'r !a!
%$"a!$/
1/B/3 M$m"$rs ar$ -$rmi!!$% !' us$ -ri)!$% 'r wri!!$)
ma!$rial %uri)& -r$-ara!i') a)% %uri)& !$
%$"a!$/ ri)!$% ma!$rial i)+lu%$s "''ks#
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
34/49
1// T$ m$m"$r w' is s-$aki)& ma* ask !$ -$rs')',,$ri)& !$ 'i)! ', I),'rma!i') !' si! %'w) w$r$
!$ ',,$r 'r as a% a r$as')a"l$ '--'r!u)i!* !' "$
$ar% a)% u)%$rs!''%/1// M$m"$rs s'ul% a!!$m-! !' a)sw$r a! l$as!
!w' 'i)!s ', I),'rma!i') %uri)& !$ir s-$$+/
M$m"$rs s'ul% als' ',,$r 'i)!s ', I),'rma!i')/1// 'i)!s ', I),'rma!i') s'ul% "$ ass$ss$% i) a++'r%a)+$
wi! +laus$ 3/3/B ', !$s$ rul$s/
1// 'i)!s ', Or%$r a)% 'i)!s ', $rs')al ri.il$&$ ar$ )'!
-$rmi!!$%/
1; T*"*- '& ! 09!!+!0
1//1 S-$$+$s s'ul% "$ s$.$) mi)u!$s i) %ura!i') !is s'ul%
"$ si&)al$% "* !w' s!rik$s ', !$ &a.$l/ S-$$+$s '.$r
s$.$) mi)u!$s a)% 1 s$+')%s ma* "$ -$)ali@$%/
1//2 'i)!s ', I),'rma!i') ma* ')l* "$ ',,$r$% "$!w$$)
!$ ,irs!5mi)u!$ mark a)% !$ si(5mi)u!$ mark ', !$s-$$+ !is -$ri'% s'ul% "$ si&)al$% "* ')$ s!rik$
', !$ &a.$l a! !$ ,irs! mi)u!$ a)% ')$ s!rik$ a! !$ si(!
mi)u!$/
1//3 I! is !$ %u!* ', !$ S-$ak$r ', !$ H'us$ !' !im$
s-$$+$s/
1//B I) !$ a"s$)+$ ', !$ S-$ak$r ', !$ H'us$# i! is !$ %u!*', !$ Cair ', !$ A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
35/49
1//1 T$ %$"a!$ s'ul% "$ a% T$ A%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
36/49
+ )'! "$ !im$ s$! 5 !is m$a)s !a! !$ %$"a!$mus! !ak$ -la+$ i) !$ -r$s$)! a)% !a! !$ %$,i)i!i')
+a))'! s$! !$ %$"a!$ i) !$ -as! 'r !$ ,u!ur$= a)%
% )'! "$ -la+$ s$! u),airl* 5 !is m$a)s !a! !$ %$,i)i!i')+a))'! r$s!ri+! !$ %$"a!$ s' )arr'wl* !' a -ar!i+ular
&$'&ra-i+al 'r -'li!i+al l'+a!i') !a! a -ar!i+i-a)! ',
!$ !'ur)am$)! +'ul% )'! r$as')a"l* "$ $(-$+!$% !'a.$ k)'wl$%&$ ', !$ -la+$/
22 C#!-*- ! .!&***'
2/2/1 T$ L$a%$r ', !$ O--'si!i') ma* +all$)&$ !$
%$,i)i!i') i, i! .i'la!$s +laus$ ', !$s$ rul$s/2/2/2 T$ L$a%$r ', !$ O--'si!i') s'ul% +l$arl* s!a!$
!a! $ 'r s$ is +all$)&i)& !$ %$,i)i!i')/
2/2/3 T$ L$a%$r ', !$ O--'si!i') s'ul% su"s!i!u!$ a)
al!$r)a!i.$ %$,i)i!i') a,!$r +all$)&i)& !$ %$,i)i!i') ',
!$ rim$ Mi)is!$r/
23 A00!00*- ! .!&***'# +#!-!
2/3/1 T$ a%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
37/49
2/3/B 4$r$ !$ %$,i)i!i') ', !$ O-$)i)& G'.$r)m$)! isu)r$as')a"l$ a)% a) al!$r)a!i.$ %$,i)i!i') is
su"s!i!u!$% "* !$ O-$)i)& O--'si!i')# !$ Cl'si)&
G'.$r)m$)! ma* i)!r'%u+$ ma!!$r wi+ isi)+')sis!$)! wi! !$ ma!!$r -r$s$)!$% "* !$
O-$)i)& G'.$r)m$)! a)% +')sis!$)! wi! !$ %$,i)i!i') ',
!$ O-$)i)& O--'si!i')/2/3/ I, !$ O-$)i)& O--'si!i') as su"s!i!u!$% a
%$,i)i!i') !a! is als' u)r$as')a"l$# !$ Cl'si)&
G'.$r)m$)! ma* +all$)&$ !$ %$,i)i!i') ', !$
O-$)i)& O--'si!i') a)% su"s!i!u!$ a) al!$r)a!i.$
%$,i)i!i')/
2/3/ I, !$ Cl'si)& G'.$r)m$)! as su"s!i!u!$% a%$,i)i!i') !a! is als' u)r$as')a"l$ i) a%%i!i') !'
!$ u)r$as')a"l$ %$,i)i!i')s ', !$ O-$)i)&
G'.$r)m$)! a)% O-$)i)& O--'si!i')# !$
Cl'si)& O--'si!i') ma* +all$)&$ !$ %$,i)i!i')
', !$ Cl'si)& G'.$r)m$)! a)% su"s!i!u!$ a)
al!$r)a!i.$ %$,i)i!i')/
P#$ 3 M#!$
31 T! .!&***' '& "#!$
3/1/1 Ma!!$r is !$ +')!$)! ', !$ s-$$+/ I! is !$ar&um$)!s a %$"a!$r us$s !' ,ur!$r is 'r $r +as$
a)% -$rsua%$ !$ au%i$)+$/3/1/2 Ma!!$r i)+lu%$s ar&um$)!s a)% r$as')i) $(am-l$s# +as$
s!u%i$s# ,a+!s a)% a)* '!$r ma!$rial !a! a!!$m-!s !'
,ur!$r !$ +as$/
3/1/3 Ma!!$r i)+lu%$s -'si!i.$ 'r su"s!a)!i.$ ma!$riala)% r$"u!!al ar&um$)!s s-$+i,i+all* aim$% !' r$,u!$ !$
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY DEBATING
CHAMPIONSHIP-2013
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
38/49
ar&um$)!s ', !$ '--'si)& !$ams/ Ma!!$r i)+lu%$s'i)!s ', I),'rma!i')/
32 T! !!"!0 '& "#!$
3/2/1 Ma!!$r s'ul% "$ r$l$.a)!# l'&i+al a)% +')sis!$)!/
3/2/2 Ma!!$r s'ul% "$ r$l$.a)!/ I! s'ul% r$la!$ !'!$ issu$s ', !$ %$"a!$> -'si!i.$ ma!$rial s'ul%
su--'r! !$ +as$ "$i)& -r$s$)!$% a)% r$"u!!al
s'ul% r$,u!$ !$ ma!$rial "$i)& -r$s$)!$% "* !$
'--'si)& !$ams/ T$ M$m"$r s'ul% a--r'-ria!$l*
-ri'ri!i@$ a)% a--'r!i') !im$ !' !$ %*)ami+ issu$s ', !$
%$"a!$/3/2/3 Ma!!$r s'ul% "$ l'&i+al/ Ar&um$)!s s'ul% "$ %$.$l'-$%
l'&i+all* i) 'r%$r !' "$ +l$ar a)% w$ll5r$as')$% a)%
!$r$,'r$ -lausi"l$/ T$ +')+lusi') ', all ar&um$)!s
s'ul% su--'r! !$ m$m"$r6s +as$/
3/2/B Ma!!$r s'ul% "$ +')sis!$)!/ M$m"$rs s'ul%
$)sur$ !a! !$ ma!!$r !$* -r$s$)! is +')sis!$)!wi!i) !$ir s-$$+# !$ir !$am a)% !$ r$mai)%$r ', !$
m$m"$rs ') !$ir si%$ ', !$ %$"a!$ su"
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
39/49
3/3/1 T$ ma!!$r -r$s$)!$% s'ul% "$ -$rsuasi.$/ PT$ $l$m$)!s
', ma!!$r6 s'ul% assis! a) a%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
40/49
a)% a)* '!$r $l$m$)! wi+ ma* a,,$+! !$$,,$+!i.$)$ss ', !$ -r$s$)!a!i') ', !$ m$m"$r/
B/2/2 E*$ +')!a+! will &$)$rall* assis! a m$m"$r !'
-$rsua%$ a) au%i$)+$ as i! all'ws !$ m$m"$r !'a--$ar m'r$ si)+$r$/
B/2/3 9'i+$ m'%ula!i') will &$)$rall* assis! a m$m"$r !'
-$rsua%$ a) au%i$)+$ as !$ %$"a!$r ma* $m-asi@$im-'r!a)! ar&um$)!s a)% k$$- !$ a!!$)!i') ', !$
au%i$)+$/ Tis i)+lu%$s !$ -i!+# !')$# a)% .'lum$
', !$ m$m"$r6s 'i+$ a)% !$ us$ ', -aus$s/
B/2/B Ha)% &$s!ur$s will &$)$rall* assis! a m$m"$r
!' $m-asi@$ im-'r!a)! ar&um$)!s/ E(+$ssi.$ a)%
m'.$m$)!s ma* 'w$.$r "$ %is!ra+!i)& a)% r$%u+$!$ a!!$)!i.$)$ss ', !$ au%i$)+$ !' !$ ar&um$)!s/
B/2/ La)&ua&$ s'ul% "$ +l$ar a)% sim-l$/ M$m"$rs w' us$
la)&ua&$ wi+ is !'' .$r"'s$ 'r +'),usi)& ma*
%$!ra+! ,r'm !$ ar&um$)! i, !$* l's$ !$
a!!$)!i') ', !$ au%i$)+$/
B/2/ T$ us$ ', )'!$s is -$rmi!!$%# "u! m$m"$rs s'ul% "$
+ar$,ul !a! !$* %' )'! r$l* ') !$ir )'!$s !'' mu+
a)% %$!ra+! ,r'm !$ '!$r $l$m$)!s ',
ma))$r/
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
41/49
-r$s$)!a!i')/ T$ su"s!a)!i.$ s-$$+ ', $a+ m$m"$rs'ul%>
B/3/3 T$ ma!!$r ', !$ !$am mus! "$ s!ru+!ur$%/ T$ !$am
s'ul% 'r&a)i@$ !$ir ma!!$r !' im-r'.$ !$ $,,$+!i.$)$ss', !$ir -r$s$)!a!i')/ T$ !$am s'ul%>
a +')!ai) a +')sis!$)! a--r'a+ !' !$ issu$s "$i)&
%$"a!$%= a)%" all'+a!$ -'si!i.$ ma!!$r !' $a+ m$m"$r w$r$
"'! m$m"$rs ', !$ !$am ar$ i)!r'%u+i)& -'si!i.$
ma!!$r= a)%
+ i)+lu%$> a) i)!r'%u+!i')# +')+lusi') a)% a s$ri$s ',
ar&um$)!s= a)%
% "$ w$ll5!im$% i) a++'r%a)+$ wi! !$ !im$limi!a!i')s a)% !$ )$$% !' -ri'ri!i@$ a)% a--'r!i')
!im$ !' ma!!$r/
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
42/49
la)&ua&$ su"
a C'),$r u-') a)% %is+uss !$ %$"a!$ wi! !$ '!$r
a%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
43/49
!w' -'i)!s# !ir% -la+$% !$ams s'ul% "$ awar%$%')$ -'i)! a)% ,'ur! -la+$% !$ams s'ul% "$ awar%$%
@$r' -'i)!s/
/2/2 T$ams ma* r$+$i.$ @$r' -'i)!s w$r$ !$* ,ail !' arri.$ a!!$ %$"a!$ m'r$ !a) ,i.$ mi)u!$s a,!$r !$ s+$%ul$%
!im$ ,'r %$"a!$/
/2/3 T$ams ma* r$+$i.$ @$r' -'i)!s w$r$ !$ a%
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
44/49
s!a)%ar% *'u w'ul% $(-$+! !'
s$$ ,r'm a !$am a! !$ S$mi
Fi)alKGra)% Fi)al l$.$l ', !$
!'ur)am$)!/ T$ !$am as mu+s!r$)&! a)% ,$w# i, a)*#
w$ak)$ss$s/
? 10 1 A"'.$ a.$ra&$ !' .$r* &''%/ T$
s!a)%ar% *'u w'ul% $(-$+! !' s$$ ,r'm
a !$am a! !$ ,i)als l$.$l 'r i)
+')!$)!i') !' mak$ !' !$ ,i)als/ T$
!$am as +l$ar s!r$)&!s a)%s'm$ mi)'r w$ak)$ss$s/
C 1B0 5 1 A.$ra&$/ T$ !$am as s!r$)&!s a)%w$ak)$ss$s i) r'u&l* $ual
-r'-'r!i')s/
D 120 5 13 ''r !' "$l'w a.$ra&$/ T$ !$am
as +l$ar -r'"l$ms a)% s'm$
mi)'r s!r$)&!/E 100 5 11 9$r* -''r/ T$ !$am as ,u)%am$)!al
w$ak)$ss$s a)% ,$w# i, a)*# s!r$)&!s/
533 M#$%*- ! "!"!$0 5
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
45/49
9'*0 '& ! !#" "!"!$0 *0 7** ! #-$!!. -$#.!
&'$ # !#"
53< I.*6*./# "!"!$0 "#$%0 0'/. ! -*6! !&''7*- *!$9$!#*'
G$#.! M#$%0 M!#*-
A 05100 E(+$ll$)! !' ,lawl$ss/ T$ s!a)%ar%
', s-$$+ *'u w'ul% $(-$+! !' s$$
,r'm a s-$ak$r a! !$ S$mi
Fi)alKGra)% Fi)al l$.$l ', !$
!'ur)am$)!/ Tis s-$ak$r as mu+s!r$)&! a)% ,$w# i, a)*# w$ak)$ss$s/
? 05 A"'.$ a.$ra&$ !' .$r* &''%/ T$s!a)%ar% *'u w'ul% $(-$+! !' s$$
,r'm a s-$ak$r a! !$ ,i)als l$.$l
'r i) +')!$)!i') !' mak$ !' !$
,i)als/ Tis s-$ak$r as +l$ar s!r$)&!s
a)% s'm$ mi)'r w$ak)$ss$s/
C 05 A.$ra&$/ T$ s-$ak$r ass!r$)&!s a)% w$ak)$ss$s a)%
r'u&l* $ual -r'-'r!i')s/
D 05 ''r !' "$l'w a.$ra&$/ T$ !$am
as +l$ar -r'"l$ms a)% s'm$ mi)'r
s!r$)&!/
E 05 9$r* -''r/ Tis s-$ak$r as
,u)%am$)!al w$ak)$ss$s a)% ,$w#i, a)*# s!r$)&!s/
5< V!$# #.@/.*+#*'0
5
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
46/49
5
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
47/49
MISSION
1/ F's!$ri)& uali,i$% $%u+a!i') i) !$ ,i$l%s ',
$)&i)$$ri)& a)% )') $)&i)$$ri)& "as$% ') uali!*assura)+$ s*s!$m=
2/ D$.$l'-i) %iss$mi)a!i) a)% a--l*i)& s+i$)+$#
!$+)'l'&*# a)% ar! as w$ll as !$ uali!* ', a--li$%
r$s$ar+ r$sul!s !' "$ us$% i) -r'%u+!i.$ a+!i.i!i$s a)%im-r'.i)& !$ uali!* ', +'mmu)i!* li,$/
3/ D$.$l'-i)& 'r&a)i@a!i') a)% im-r'.i)& !$ uali!* ',uma) r$s'ur+$ ma)a&$m$)! !' a+i$.$ $,,$+!i.$#
$,,i+i$)!# a)% sus!ai)a"l$ -$r,'rma)+$=
B/ E)a)+i)& mu!ual -ar!)$rsi-s wi! '!$r -ar!i$s i)
'r%$r !' im-r'.$ !$ uali!* ', Tri Darma/
S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ', Sriwi
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
48/49
A++'u)!i)& a)% ?usi)$ss A%mi)is!ra!i')/ E(-$r!s w' $l-$%i) !$ %$.$l'-m$)! ', $)&i)$$ri)& ,i$l% w$r$ ,r'm Swiss
C')!a+!# wil$ $(-$r!s ,'r ?usi)$ss ,i$l% w$r$ ,r'm Aus!ralia/
I) !$ *$ar 2002K2003 !w' )$w %$-ar!m$)!s5 C'm-u!$r
E)&i)$$ri)& a)% I),'rma!i') Ma)a&$m$)! w$r$ $s!a"lis$%/
Tis $s!a"lism$)! was s$! "* !$ Dir$+!'r G$)$ral ', Hi&$rE%u+a!i') l$!!$r N'/ 200KDKTK2001/ I) !$ a+a%$mi+ *$ar
2002K2003 ma)* $%u+a!i')al %$.$l'-m$)!s w$r$ u)%$r!ak$) "*
!$ 'l*!$+)i+# su+ as !$ '-$)i)& ', !$ Di-l'ma III
a,,ilia!i') -r'&ram/ El$+!ri+al E)&i)$$ri)& a)% M$+a)i+al
E)&i)$$ri)& w$r$ a,,ilia!$% wi! T/ ?uki! Asam a)% Di-l'ma
r'&ram I9 R'a% a)% ?ri%&$ la))i)& w$r$ a,,ilia!$% wi!:im-raswil D$-ar!m$)!/
I) !$ a+a%$mi+ *$ar 200BK200# S!a!$ 'l*!$+)i+ ', Sriwi
8/13/2019 Program Book Nudc 2013 Rev
49/49
IMORTANT CONTACTS
1/ C').$)$r# Mr/ Ra+ma! Nur+a*'> 0 2B 02
2/ T'ur)am$)! Dir$+!'rs>
5 Ms/ D'ra> 012 0
5 Mr/ Ama% Ri,ai> 01330020
3/ Tra)s-'r!a!i')# Mr/ ?ram> 013 BB BBB1B/ SD# Ms/ Mu)a 013 3 B03
/ H$al! Di.isi')# Ms/ Sukma> 0115 B1
/ LO C''r%i)a!'r# Ms/ Darmi)i*a)!i> 021 11 023