Top Banner
35

pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

Jan 18, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

������������������ � !"�#�%$

&('*),+.-0/21354"6�798;:2<>=?:0@2@2@

A BDC(EGF�HIF"C(J�C(K FMLONPF�QRC�SUT�LWVRX�C(J

Y[Z\��Z\�^]_]`�a�5b*]c]_d%ef�gb,h`d^i�?jk�mln�a][oR�^Z*pqh_�ap*r*sa�utvd�h`wyxfdz�^p,jcdZR�^efhc]`h{��|gsIsad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah_j�~]`�*���,�ap*�ah{�^x?�>iye��^]_e}d�Z��(p*�gefZ*efj_]`hk��]`efdZ�e}jusadZ*j_efp*�ah`efZ*��j`d�ln][t(�^h`�5]`�0��]Wt?dr*xfp��^r,]`d^��\��]`efs��^xfxfo%��x}��h`](sad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah_j�]_d%b2d]_�aZy]`e��^xGsad�xfx}efj_e}d�Z*j?�0�a][t?�a�aZ�b*x��^Z*�aj����Zyoqr*j_�{lnr*x��^xf�d�h`ef]`�,���qr*j`]��� Y[p,�aZy]`e�lno��^xfx>b2d]_�aZy]`e��^x��0ef��y][�[b0��]`�RsadZ��0efsa]`jIefZR]`ef�g��lnd�h�]`�,�WsadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah�]`dgh_�{�j_dxfi�I]_�*�a���� Y[Zy]_�ah[l���sa�ct(ef]`�I]_�*�csad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ahGefZW�?t(��o�]`�2�^]Gef�gb*h_d^i�aj2�*efjG�{|gsaef�aZ,saoIdhGh`��p*r*sa�aj�,e}j(t?dh_wyx}dy�^p>���d���id�e}pIsad�Zylnr*j_efdZ>~�t?�ct(efx}x^r,j`�?]`�*��lndxfxfd^t(efZ*�cp*���0Z*ef]`efdZ,jGlnd�h"�^�q�,e}��r*dr,j0t?dh_p*j�����;�}��,� t(efx}x��^xft(��ozj(h_�{ln�ahu]`d\�5���ad�5�a]`h_e}sId���{�asa]Wp,�{�0Z*�ap��yoR]`�*� j`b0��Z�d�lv][t?di��asa]_dh`j�~2�� �0�#]`�*�% 2¡��[b*x��^Z,����¢I£¥¤�¦2�}���*� t(efxfx>h_�{ln�ah ]`dR]_�0�^]It?dZ*p*��h�d�l;�5dyp*�ah`Z�]`�as{�*Z*d�xfd�o�t(�*efsk��t?�%�*d�b0�]_dqb*h`d�]`�as�]����§©¨����*ª9«z���­¬���®���¤ t(efx}x�h`�{l9�ahc]`d�]`�*�(j_�ah`efd�r*j`Z*��j`jcd�l0]`�*�?�2e}���y][�[b0�^]_��s�dZy�0efsa]�]_�0�^]t(efxfxGp*�ai��axfdb5e¯lc�^Z��^efh_b*x��^Z*�{�[b0��e}h?efjvef��Z*dh_�apRe}Z,p*�{�0Z*ef]_�axfoz��±°{²%² �{¬£���ªn��¬���®��¤ t(e}xfx�h`�{ln��hc]`dI]`�,�vp*���h`���(]`dIt(�*efs{�³�©sadZy�2e}s�]"�qr,j`]>�2�(p*����xf]t(ef]_�\ef�5�q�ap*e��^]_�axfoz~�efZgd�h`p*�ah�]`dg��i�defpqp*efjk��j`]`��h����´u��®���¤ ~2t(�*��Z�r*j`��p�t(ef]`�*d�r*]��W�5dyp*e��0�ah�~yt(efxfxGh`��ln�ah�]_dqj`d��g��s�d�q�*efZ0��]`efdZ dhZ,dZ*j_b0�as�e¯�2sWsadZ,�xfd�5�ahk��]`efdZqd�l"�2d]`�Rj_�aZ*j`��jO���0d^i���

µ ¶5·RT>F�QRC(T�¸ULWKRE#¹�ºRC(T�HIF"¹�LWKRE

��jRef]gj_�a�a�gj5xfe}w��axfo�]_�0�^]R�^Zyo�t?dh_]`�yt(�*efxf���^xf�d�h`ef]`�,�»�qr*j`]qs�dZ*j_e}p,�ah��^xfx�b0��efh`jgd�l�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj?t(ef]`�*efZg�u�efi�aZ5id�x}r,�g�?d^l>j`b2�^sa�~,tv��s��^Z,Z*d](�*d�b0�©lndh?sad��gb*xf�a½yef][oW�2�a]`]_�ah]`�0��Z³¾À¿nÁGÂaÃ�~^t(�*�ah_�;ÁÀe}j#]`�*�?Zyr*�q�2�ah>d�l,��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj��#�(�yr*j�~^j_efZ*sa�?dr*h��^xf�d�h`ef]`�*�ÄZ*�a��p*j]`d h`r*Z5efZqh`����xG]`ef�g�~�e}]��qr*j`]c�2�W�^�*xf�(]_d%p*��]`�ah_�gefZ*�(j`t(e�ln]_xfo%t(�*��]`�*�ah��u�efi��aZqb0�^efhcd�l

Å�����qÆId^lc�

Page 2: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj?b*h`��j`�aZy]��up0�^Z*���ah?]`d dZ*�I�^Z*d�]`�*�ah����(]v]_�*�Ijk���g�(]`ef�5�~^ef]cefjvZ,d]?j`ry|gsaef�aZy]]`d5sadZ*j_efp*�ah�d�Z*xfog]_�*�%�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj��*p*efj_]k�^Z,sa�Wl9h`d�DdZ,�%�^Z*d�]`�*��h��(�*d�h��a½*���gb*xf�~*� b0��efhd^l;��efh`b*x��^Z,�ajI�*���^p,e}Z,�gp*efh`��sa]`xfo��^]I����sk��d]_�*�ah�lnh_d���qp,e}j_]k��Z*sa� d^lc�0i��%�5efx}��j��^h`� efZp0�^Z,��ah�d^lcsadxfxfefp*efZ*� t(e}]_�*efZ��^�2dr*]�][tv�aZy][o5j`�asad�Z*p*j�~Gt(�*efxf��][t?dq�*����p*efZ*�\��t(��o lnh_d����^s{��d�]`�*��h��^]�� p*efj`]{�^Z*s��Wd^lc� �g�ah_�%Æ�����Oln�a�a]�b*h`��j`�aZy]IZ*d p0�^Z*���ah���]��^xfx��n�^xf]_�*dr*���]`�*��o\�R��o%�2��i��p,dZ*�Ij`dqefZR]`�,��ef�5�g�ap*e���]`�?b0�^j_]��a�

Z�� �*r*j`oRp0��oy~yef](�\��o �0�uZ*dq�*�axfbR]`dqj_e}�5b*xfo%b,h`�aj_�aZy]O��Z��^efh(]`h{��|gsIsadZy]_h`dxfxf�aht(ef]`� ��xfefj`]qd�lu��efh`b*x��^Z,�{��b2�^efh`jqt(�*efs{�±t(efx}x(�2��i�R�0ef���z] ��b2�^]`� sadZ��0efsa]`jRefZ±]`�*��Z,���^hlnr*]_r*h`��±�,dh �a½*�^�gb,x}��~�b*h`�aj_�aZy]`efZ*����j`ef�gb,x}� xfefj`] d^l�]_�aZ±b*h`d��*xf�a�gju]`�0��]%t(efxfx;��h`efj`�efZ\]_�*�WZ*��½z]�]`�aZ��gefZyr*]`�aj?]`dR�^Z��^xfh_���^p*o��[�0�^h_h`ef�apRsad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah(efj(xfefw�axfoq]_d lnhk���axf�W�*ef��ai��ZÄlnr*h`]_�*�ah�~�b2dj_j`ef�*xfo±x}���^p*efZ*� ]`d±h`�ap,r*sa�apU�{|gs�e}��Z*sao ��Z*p � �h_���^]_�ahRsk�2�^Z*sa��d�lp*efjk��j`]`��h��vÅ�h`efdh_e}]_e aefZ*�I]`�*�(b*h_d�*xf�a�5j���b,h`�aj_r*�\���*xfoW�yo%j_d�g�?�g��]`�*dyp sad�q�*efZ*efZ*��]`�*�b*h`d^½yef�gef][oW�^Z,pqe}�5�q�ap*e��^s�o�d^l>]_�*��b,h`d��{��sa]`�ap5�aZ*sad�r*Zy]`�ah_j��?efjcxfefw�axfoW]_dW�dW�Ixfd�Z*�It;��o]`d^t(�^h_p*j%h_�ap*r*s�e}Z,��]`�*efj �zr,�\�^Z�]_�aZ*p*��Z*saoG�g]_�*�RsadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah Z*d^t�Z*���ap*jqt?dh`h_o�dZ*xfo�^�2dr*]�j`dxfiyefZ*�W]_�*�(b*h`d��*xf�a�gj�e}Z ]`r,h`Z>~yh{�^]`�,�ahv]_�0�^Zqj_b0��Z*pRe}Zyi��x}r2�^�*xf�c]_e}�5�v]_h`oyefZ*�W]_db*h`efd�h`ef]`e a��]`�*�a� �*ef�gj`��x¯l{���yr*s{�\�ub*h_e}d�h`ef]`e ���]`efdZq�R��oItv�axfxGef�gb,h`d^i�?�{|gsaef�aZ,saoz~*��j;��Zr*Z0��e}p,�ap�s�dZy]`h_dxfxf�ahItvd�r*xfp�xfe}w��axfogj_dxfi� j`r*s{��b*h_�aj`j_efZ*�Rb*h`d��*xf�a�gj�e}Z�]`�*�qd�h`p*�ahI]_�0�^]�*� Z*d]_e}s��ap�]`�,�a��~,hk�^]_�*�ahI]`�2�^ZR]`�*���_sadh_h`�asa]��³d�h`p*��h�efZ�t(�*efs{�R]`�*� sad�5b*r*]_�ah(tvd�r*xfpb*h`��j`�aZy] ]`�*�a���W�(�yr*jWef]It?dr*xfp��2�qZ*efsa� e¯l(dr,hO��xf�dh_ef]`�*�Dsadr,x}p�j`��Z*j`ef�*xfo�hk�^Z,w�]`�*�ef�g�g��p*e��^]`�?p0��Z*��ah_j�b*h_�aj`��Zz]_�ap��zoqp,e��G�ah_�aZy]��^efh_b*x��^Z*�{�[b0��e}h_j��

� � E#E>·RJ��5F"¹�LWKgEUHuK\º�������LIF"QRC(E>C(E

��I�\�^w��(]`�*�Olndxfxfd^t(efZ*�W�^j`j_r*�gb,]`efdZ*j?efZ\��]`]k��s{wzefZ*� ]`�,�Wb*h`d��*xf�a���� ��xfxsad�x}xfefj`efd�Z*j0�2�a][t?�a�aZq�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj>��h`�c��!yr0��xfx}oI�^Z*pOlnr*Z*p0���g�aZy]{�^xfxfocr*Z*p*��j`efhk���*xf��� � �,�k��¤W² £�¬#"`��£�¤�$&%^�¥�}£ 'a£(%�� ��j`d��g�a]_ef�g�ajcs��^xfxf�ap\� �*�{��¤�² £ '&' �?efj(p*�{�0Z,�apR�zo5]`�*��������^jg�^Z efZ*saefp*�aZy] e}Z t(�*efs{��][t?d ��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j%b0��j`jqt(ef]`�,e}Z����� ln�a�a]qd�l�dZ*���Z*d]_�*�ah���)+*����^h��gefpy�`�^efh�sadxfxfefj`efdZ*j(�^h_�Wr*Z*p,�aj`efhk���*xf�I�*r*](b*h_�{ln�ah{�^�*xf�W]_dg�^sa]_r0�^xs�dxfxfe}j_efdZ*j��

� �(�,�³��e}h_j`b0��sa�q�\��o5�0� h`��b*h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap±�yo��5sadZyi��½�j`r*�,j`�a]Wd�l-,/.a~GefZ�t(�*efs{��tv�h_�ab*h_�aj`�aZy]W]_�*�Wi��ah`]_e}s��^x>p,e}h_�asa]_e}d�Z��yo105�^Z*pRdh_]`�*d��d�Z0�^xG�*d�h`e ad�Zz]{�^x#p*efh`�asa]_efdZ*j�yoR \��Z*p�¡*�

� ��efh[�[]`hk�m|gs(sadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah_jv�0��i��(�aj`]{�^�*xfefj`�,�apgb*h_d]_dzs�dxfjc]`dub*h`�ai��aZy];��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj�lnh_d�s�dxfxfe}p,e}Z,�Wt(�*�aZ�s�h`dj_j`efZ*�g��e}h_j`b0��sa�I�0d�r*Z*p0��h`ef�aj�e}Z5db*b2dj_ef]`�Ip*efh`�as�]`efdZ*j��� ���s��^Z �g����j`r*h_�v]_�*�?b0d�j`ef]`efdZ �^Z*p i�axfdysaef][oId^l0��i�ah_o³��e}h_b*x��^Z*��e}Zu]`�*�(�^efh`j_b0�^s��~��Z*pW]_�*�c�ah_h`dh_jcefZI]`�*�aj_�(�g����j`r*h_�a�g��Zz]_j>�^h_�cZ*�a��x}ef��e}�,x}��sad��gb0��h`�apI]_d�]`�,�c�&�G�asa]`jd�l"]_r*h`�*r,x}��Z*sa��

�32 i�ah_o��^efh`b*x���Z*�%�2�^jWj_ry|gsaef�aZy]`xfo�Z*�a�xfef�ef�*xf�%��sasa�axf�ah{�^]_e}d�Z�]`�0��]WxfefZ*���^hu�gdyp*�axfjl9dh�ef]`j>�5d^i�a�5�aZy]0t(efxfxy�\��w��j`�aZ,j`�(d^i��h���]�x}���^j`]�]_�*�vZ,�a½y]"][t?d��5efZzr,]`�aj#r*Z*xf�aj`j��4658797-:<;�=

�����?> d^lc�

Page 3: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

� Y[]�efj��^s�sa�axf�ahk��]`efZ*�qr*Z,p*�ah�]_�*�Wp*efh_�asa]`efd�Z\d�lc]`�*�Isad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah�~*efZRt(�*efs{�gs���j`��*�W�0��j��^xfh`���^p*oqp*��]`�ah_�gefZ*�ap��^Zyo5sadZy�2e}s�]`j(t(�*efs{�R]`�*efj��^s�sa�axf�ahk��]`efdZR�R��os��^r,j`��

� Y[]�efj(]k��wye}Z,�qd#�c~*efZgt(�*efs{��s���j`�Wef](efj(Z*d�](e}Z�� b0��h`]�d^lc]`�*� �^efh`j_b0�^sa�ur*j`�ap�yogsah_r*efj`efZ*�g�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj��� Y[]gefj\��]`]_�a�gb*]_efZ*��]`d�x��^Z,p>~(efZ±t(�*efsk� s��^j_��ef]qefjgZ*d�]gefZ���b0��h`]5d^lW]`�*��^efh`j_b0�^s��Wr*j`��p��yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z,�g�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj��

� ��xfx>�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj��^h_�Is��^b0���*xf�Id^l���sasa�axf�ah{�^]_e}Z,�q]`�*h_dr*��� �+>m���5efZzr,]`�(]`r,h`ZRefZg�2d]`�s�x}dys{wyt(efj`�W�^Z*pRsad�r*Zy]`�ah_saxfdyskwyt(efj`�up*efh`�asa]_efdZ*j�b0�^h{�^xfxf�ax0]_dq]`�*�  0¡m��b*x���Z*�� �� �(�,��i��j`]?�\�a��dh`ef][oWd�l���e}h_b*x��^Z*��j;��h`�I]`h{��i�axfefZ*�Wt(ef]`�,e}Z5dZ*��d^lc�Iln��t�i�ah_]`efs���x}xfot?�axfx���j_�ab0��hk�^]_�ap�b*x���Z*�ajqb0��hk�^xfxf�ax(]_d�]`�,�  2¡��[b*x��^Z,�� ���(�*�aj_� ��h`�Rd^l9]`�aZ�s��^xfxf�ap�_sah_r*efj`efZ*���^xf]`ef]_r*p*�aj����<���±��t?d\�^efh_b*x��^Z*�ajIt(�*efs{����h`� ]`hk��i��axfefZ*�gt(ef]`�,e}Z�j`�ab0��hk��]`�j_r*s{��b*x��^Z,�aj(b0d�j`�IZ*dqp0��Z*���h(]`dqdZ,�O��Z*d]_�*�ah��

� ��xfx"�^efh_b*x��^Z*�ajI�^h_�Ws��^b2�^�*xf�Wd�l���sasa�axf�ah{�^]_e}Z,�\�^]I� �efi��Z��\��½zef� r*�Mh{�^]_�%efZR]`�*�p,e}h_�asa]_e}d�Z�d^lc]_�*�aefh�i��axfdzs�e}][oy���¥Y[Z�b0��h`]`efsar,x¼��h�~2�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj�p,dqZ*d]�sah`r*efj_�³��](]`�*�aefh�R�^½yef�%r,�Mj`b2�a�ap#� �

� ��t?d��^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj �^h`�5jk��e}p�]_d�b*h_�aj`�aZy]g��Z��ai�aZy]_r0�^x(p0��Z*���h%t(�*��Z>~�e�l�]`�*�aefhWi��{�xfdysaef]`ef�aj���h`�W�^xfxfd^t?�apq]`dq��d%r*Z,sk�2�^Z*���apRe}Z,p*�{�0Z*ef]_�axfoz~*��Zzoqd�l"]_�*�Ilnd�x}xfd^t(efZ*�It(efxfx�2�^b*b2�aZ�efZg]_�*��lnr*]_r*h`��

� �(�*�aoRsad�x}xfefp*��� �(�*�aoRb0��j`j(Z*����h(���^s{��d�]`�*��h��^](j`d��g��]`ef�g��� �(�*�aoRb0��j`j(]`�,h`dr,��RZ*����h`�yogb2defZy]`j(efZgj_b0�^s��%�^](Z*���^h`�yo5]`ef�g�aj��

��b*b*h_db*h_e¼��]`�5i�^xfr*�ajWd�l �_Z*����h �gt(efxfxc�0�5p*efj`sar,j`j`��pP�,h`ef�{�0o�efZ�j`��sa]`efdZ,jg*~��*~��*~��Z*p�ÆÆ�� �,�

� S LWE>E#¹�VRX�C��³LuX�·5F"¹�LIKREÄF"L F"QRC HWK��WC(T SUT"LuV\X�C(J

Y[Z��^]`]_�a�gb,]`efZ*� ]`d p*�a]`��h`�gefZ*�I]_�*�Ip0�^Z*���ah(]`�2�^](][t?dg�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj?b*h`�aj_�aZy]�d�Z*�%�^Z,d]`�,�ah�~][tvd�sadZ*j_efp*�ahk��]`efdZ,j%j_�a�a�»p*d��gefZ0��Zz]��I]`�*�qb,h`d^½yef�gef][oR]`�*�ao�t(efxfxv��]`]k��efZ�]_d�dZ*�R�^Zy�d]_�*�ah�~#�^Z*p�]`�*� ]`ef�5��h_�a�\��efZ*efZ*�%r,Zz]_efx"]_�*�ao�p,dgj`d2� ]`�*�ahIsad�Z*j`efp*��hk�^]_efdZ*j�~Gj`r*s{���^jd�*j_]k��saxf�aj%b,h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap±�yo��0��p�tv����]`�*��h�~�b*h_d�0���*xfo�s��^Z,Z*d]W�2�gs�dZ*j_e}p,�ah`�ap �a½ysa�ab*] efZ]`�*�q�5dj_]�j`ef�5b*xfe}j_]`efs�d�l;t(��oyj��(e�l(tv�q�^]_]`�a�5b*]�]_dgp*dRd�]`�*�ah_t(efj`�~#tv� h`efj_w�xfdj`efZ*�5]`�*��^�*efxfef][o%]_dqp*�a]_�ah`�5e}Z,��p2�^Z*���ah(efZ\h_���^x��[]`ef�g���

�� b*h`�aj_�aZy]Wj`��i�ah{�^x?b0d�]`�aZy]`e���xcj`d�x}r,]`efdZ*jI]_d\]_�*efjIb*h`d��*xf�a���� >�^]_�ahWj_�asa]`efd�Z*jWt(efxfxp*�aj_sah`ef�2�%]_�*�a�De}Z5�gd�h`��p,�a]k��e}x[��(�*�I�2h`j`]Iefj��q]_h`efiye��^x>�5dyp*�axGt(�*efs{���^]_]`�a�5b*]`j(]_dgb*h_d^iye}p,�Wo�aj�dh�Z*d\��Z*j`t?�ah`jI]_d

]`�*�+!yr*��j`]`efd�Z*j �9 �efxfxG]`�,�³��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�s�dxfxfe}p,��� � ��Z*p �9 �efxfxG]`�,�ao��0��i��³�ÀZ*���^hI�5e}p�� ��e}hsadxfxfefj`efdZ�� ���� 58797-: � =� 58797-:��8=���;��

�����W� d^lc�

Page 4: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�(�*�?j`�as�dZ*p5e}j�]_�*���h`d��0�^�,e}xfefj`]_efsc�gdyp*�ax[~�t(�*efs{�qp*�a]_�ah`�5e}Z,�aj�h`efj`w �0�^j_�ap r*b0d�Zq]`�*�b*h`d��0�^�,e}xfef]`ef�aj?d^l�sadxfxfefj`efdZ,j;��Z*pRZ*���^h(�5efj`j`��j���(�*��]`�*efh`pqefj?]`�*���?xfdj`������b*b*h`dy�^s{�g�5�a]`�,dzp#�>Y[]v��]`]_�a�gb*]_jv]_dW�g���^j`r,h`��p2�^Z*���ahv�yo

s��^xfsar,x¼��]`efZ*� ]`�*�Isaxfd�j`�aj_]��^b,b*h`dy�^s{�g][t?d³��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj(t(efx}x2�\��w�(]_d%����s{��d]_�*�ah�~*��Z*pR]`�*�]`ef�g��r*Zy]`efxGef]vt(efxfxGdysasar*h���(�*�RZ*�a½y]5�gdyp*�ax(efjq]`�,� �yb0��sa�{�[�(e}�5�R�g�a]_�*dyp>�±Y[]\��]`]`���gb*]_j%]_d��g���^j`r,h`�R]`�*�

p0�^Z,��ah�lnh`d��M]_�*��saxfd�j`�aj_];��b*b*h`dy�^s{�q]`�,���^efh`b*x���Z*�ajct(efxfxy�\�^w��vefZqj_b0�^sa����]_e}�5�~��Z*pq]`�*�]`ef�g��r*Zy]`efxGef]vdysas�r*h`j���(�*� x��^j`]I�5dzp,�ax�e}jI]_�*� Gd��z�^h_ef]`�*�5e}s����ah_e}i��]`efi���WY[]W�^]_]`�a�5b*]`jI]`dR�5���^j_r*h`� ]`�*�

ef�g�g��p*e��^]`��p0�^Z*���ahc�yo b*x��^saefZ*�%�Ox}d^t?�ahc�2dr,Z*pqdZq]_�*��]_e}�5�vr,Zz]_efx­�Is�dxfxfe}j_efdZWdysasar,h`j��

� � � T"¹��g¹�HWX� LqºRC(X

��� ��������������������(�*�q�2h`j`]q�5dyp*�axv��j`j`r,�g�ajW]_�0�^] �&�G�asa]_jqj`r*s{�P��j%t(efZ*p#~��g����j`r*h_�a�g�aZy]Ir*Z*s��ah`]{�^efZy][oz~dh(b*efxfd]_efZ*�%ef�5b0�ah ln�asa]_efdZ>~yt(�*efs{�Rtvd�r*xfpg�R�^w�I�^Z��^efh_b*x��^Z*��� j(�^sa]_r0�^x#sadr,h`j`�up*�aiye��^]`�lnh`d���]`�,�Wxfe}Z,���^h?�gdyp*�axG��efi�aZ5�zo5ef]`j(sar*h_h`�aZy]�b0d�j`ef]`efdZR�^Z*pRi��axfdzs�e}][oy~�p*dqZ*d](��½zefj_]��Y[Z�]_�*efj�j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z>~2]`�*� dZ,x}o !yr*�aj`]_efdZ�]`�0��]��\��]`]_�ah`j�e}jIt(�*��]`�*�ahI]_�*�ah`�qt(efxfx>�2�q�

sadxfxfefj`efdZ#~z� Z*���^h(�gefj_j�~�dh(Z*�aef]_�*�ah�� >��h`���qsad�5�g�ah_sae��^xc�^efh`s�hk��l9]Wd^ln]_�aZ��0��i��qx}��Z*�]_�*j³��Z*p�t(efZ*�j_b0�^Z,jWefZ�]`�*�5Z*�aef��y�

�0d�h`�*dydyp±d^l >���� ln�a�a]�� �(�yr*j�~(��sad�xfx}efj_e}d�Z��R��o�dysas�r*hqdZ*xfo�e�l�]`�,�\s��aZy]`�ah_jgd^lI]`�*��^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj�b0�^j_j�t(ef]_�*efZ >����uln���a]Id^lcdZ*� �^Z*d�]`�*�ah�~G�^Z*p��ÀZ*����h��gefj_j(t(�*�aZ�]_�*�ao�b0��j`jt(ef]`�*efZ �����Àln���a]��RY9l(tv�qs��^Z�p*�a]_�ah`�5efZ*�q�*d^t saxfdj_�axfo�]`�*�R�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajIt(efxfxcb0�^j_jW����sk�d]_�*�ah�efZ5]`�*�Il9r*]`r*h_�~*t?�It(efx}x2�0��i��O��Z��^Z*j_tv�ah(]_dq]`�*��!yr*�aj_]`efdZ����0d^i���

�yr*b,b0d�j`�\��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj�! �^Z*p#" �0��i�5b0d�j`ef]`efdZ���Z*p�i��x}dysaef][o�i�as�]`dh_j�$&%(')$�*+'-,.%�'�^Z*p/,.*����y�a]0$213$&*/45$&%��^Z*p/,�1�,.*/46,.%(~�]`�*�Ib2dj`ef]_e}d�Zg�^Z*pqi��axfdysaef][o%d�l"�^efh`b*x���Z*�"Dh`�ax���]`efi� ]`d��^efh_b*x��^Z*�7!%� �(�*�aZ�]`�,�qp*efj`]k��Z*sa�qd�lvsaxfdj_�aj`]q�^b*b,h`dz��s{��efjIj`ef�gb,x}o5]`�*��^xf]`ef]_r*p*��lnh`d��8!±]`d�,*~y�^j�efZu�0�r*h_��Æ��>Y[]_jcxf�aZ*��]`� e}j�saxf����h`xfoW��!yr0��x*]`d29 $:9<;�=?>+@�1BA CED&FGAA FGA ��(�yr*jcd�r*hv�5dyp*�ax*b*h_�ap*efsa]_j��Isadxfxfefj`efdZ e�l>]`�*��p*efj`]{�^Z*sa��d^l>saxfd�j`�aj_]��^b*b*h_dz��sk�qefj?xf�aj`j]`�0��Z�>����?ln�a��]�~*�^Z,p³��Z*����hc�gefj_j>e�l­ef]�efj�x}��j`jc]_�0�^Z �����?l9�a�a]��0H(�^j_�apgd�Z%]_�*efj��gdyp*�ax[~�tv��^h_��Z*d^t��^�,x}�(]_dWp*�{�2Z*�W�I�g����j`r*h_�(d^l>]_�*���ai��aZy]`r0��x0p2�^Z*���ah;��j�lnd�x}xfd^t(j��G]`�*���g����j`r*h_�]k��w�ajIdZR]_�*h`�a� p*efj`s�h`�a]_�qi�^xfr*�aj��,~"Æ�~0��Z*p � �)I5JLK��(sad�h`h_�aj`b2dZ*p,e}Z,�g]`dR� sadxfxfefj`efdZ#~�qZ*���^h��5efj`j�~2�^Z*pRZ*d5p0�^Z,��ah��(�(�*�Wi��x}r,�Wd^lv� efj��2�aj`]Ip*��]`�ah_�gefZ*�ap����gb*efh`efs���xfx}o�M�tv�sadZ,j`efp*�ah�]`�*efj(�gd�h`��e}Z5]`�*�uZ*�a½y](�gdyp*�ax[�

���N O��&�&PRQ�S��&TU��V:QUWX��PYV0��QUPY�E�EPY��(�*efjv�5dyp*�ax2e}j(�uj`ef�gb*xf�(�^Z*p5�{|gsaef�aZy](�g��]`�*dypqd^l>b,h`�ap*efsa]_efZ*�qt(�*�a]_�*�ah��usadxfxfefj`efdZ dhZ*����h(�gefj`jct(efxfx2dzs�sar*h�efZ5]`�*��lnr*]_r*h`���0Z�d^t?�ai�ah�~y]`�*efj(�5dzp,�ax­��j`j_r*�g�aj?]`�2�^]?Z*d%r,Z*sa�ah �]k��e}Zy][o�efjWb,h`�aj_�aZy]%efZ�]`�,�q�aZyizefh_dZ*�5�aZy] �¥j`d���efh`b*x��^Z,�ajW�^xft;��oyjI]`h{��i�ax(�^]W�Rs�dZ*j_]k�^Zy]j`b2�a�apRefZg�Wj_]`h{�^ef��y]cxfefZ*� ���>�(�*efj(�^j_j`r*�5b*]`efdZ j`ef�5b*xfo�p,dz��jvZ*d�]v�,dxfp>�#��efh`b*x���Z*�ajct(efxfx[~lndhI�a½*���gb*xf�~G�2�q�*r �G�a]_�ap��yo�s{�0��Z*�efZ*�5t(e}Z,p*j�~��^Z*p�]`�,�aefh%�^sa]_r0�^x�]`hk���{�asa]_dh`ef�aj t(efxfx[ 58797-: \ =

������]qd^lc�

Page 5: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

BpA

v

θ

C

�#e}��r*h`�RÆ�©�(�*�%b2dj_ef]`efdZ���Z*p�i�axfdysaef][oRi�asa]_dh_j�d�l;�^efh_b*x��^Z*� "À~Gh`�ax���]`efi� ]`dR�^efh`b*x���Z*�!%�

i�^h_o%j_e}��Z*e��0s���Zz]_xfo%�^Z*pqs{�0��d]_e}s��^xfxfoIlnh`d�� ]`�*d�j`��b,h`�ap*efsa]_�apg�yoq�IxfefZ*���^h��gdyp*�ax[�G�(p*p,e¯�]`efdZ2�^xfxfoz~�]`�*efj(�5dzp,�axGdZ*xfoqsad�Z*j`efp*��h`jI]`�*�u�ai�aZy]_r0�^x#p0�^Z*���ah(h`��j`r*xf]`efZ*�Àlnh`d���� b0��e}h(d�l�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj�~0Z,d](�*d^tÄj`dydZ��^Z�ef�g�q��p*e��^]`�(p2�^Z*���ah�t(efxfx>�2�Wb*h_�aj`�aZy]����(�*�u�gdyp*�axG�R��o�0�u�a½y]`�aZ*p,�ap�]`dqh{�^Z*w5sadxfxfefj`efdZ,jcdh(Z*���^h(�gefj_j`�aj(�0��j`�apRd�Z\ef�5�q�ap*e��^]_�(p0�^Z*���ah(r*j_e}Z,�]`�*�Olndxfxfd^t(efZ*�Ib*h`efdh_ef][og�^xf�d�h`ef]`�*���Æ��vs�dxfxfe}j_efdZ*j?t(ef]`�*efZg]_ef�g�(b2�ah`efdyp�]?�fl9dh?�a½*�^�gb,x}��~] � > �gefZyr*]`�aj&�>,�vZ,���^h(�5e}j_j`�aj(t(ef]_�*efZg]`ef�5��b2�ah`efdypR]�,�vs�dxfxfe}j_efdZ*j?t(ef]`�*efZg]_ef�g�(b2�ah`efdyp >^]]2�vZ,���^h(�5e}j_j`�aj(t(ef]_�*efZg]`ef�5��b2�ah`efdyp >^],�vs�dxfxfe}j_efdZ*j?t(ef]`�*efZg]_ef�g�(b2�ah`efdyp��^]�,�v��]`s���xf]_�ah`Z0��]`efi��x}oy~y�W�5dzp,�ax0�R��oW�2��p,�ai�axfd�b0�ap�t(�*efsk�5sad�q�,e}Z,�ajc�g���^j`r,h`�aj(d�l"�ai��aZy�

]`r0��x�p0��Z*���hg�^Z*p±]`���gb2dhk��xvs�dZ*j_e}p,�ahk��]`efdZ*j5efZz]_d ��j_efZ*�xf�g�5���^j_r*h`�Rd�l�ef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�p0�^Z,��ah��M�(�*��saxfdj`��� ��b*b*h`dy�^s{���5dzp,�ax�p*efj_sar*j`j_�apÄe}Z j`�asa]_efdZ � e}j5dZ*���g�a]_�*dypP�yot(�*efs{�\]_�*efj(s��^ZR�2�%�^s{�*ef�ai��ap>�

� � SUT�LWVRHWVR¹�Xa¹�E�F>¹�� �³¹�J»·RX�HIF>¹�LuK � LqºRC(X

���� ��������������������(�*�Wb*h_d�0���*efxfe}j_]`efsIj`ef�qr*x��^]_efdZ �gdyp*�axG�a½yb0��Z*p*j�dZR]`�*�u]`h`efiye��^xG�5dzp,�axG�yo\]{�^wyefZ*� �aZy�iye}h_dZ*�5�aZy]k��x0r*Z,sa�ah`]{�^efZy][ogefZy]`dg��sasadr,Zz]����8����Ms�d�gb,r*]`�ah?b*h_d�h{�^�Dt;��jvt(h_ef]`]`��Z>�]`�*efj b*h`d��h{�^� s��^xfsar,x¼��]`�aj ]`�,�gb*h_d�0���*efx}ef][oR]`�2�^]q�R�efi��Z�j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ�t(efxfxch_�aj`r*xf] efZ��

�����W d^lc�

Page 6: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

sadxfxfefj`efdZ dh�Z*���^h��gefj`j�~^r*j`efZ*� ��� dZy]`�+�(��h`xfdWj`ef�qr*x���]`efdZI�g��]`�*dyp>�G��dIp*dWj_d0~�ef]cb0��h[�lndh_�gj(� x��^h`���IZzr,�q�0�ah?d^lch{�^Z*p*d���]`h_e��^xfj?������s{��d^l�t(�*efsk�R�R��o%h_�aj`r*xf]�e}Z��usadxfxfefj`efdZ#~Z*����hW�gefj`j�~2dhWZ*��e}]_�*�ah&�a�+*�d^tMxf�a]Ws p*�aZ*d�]`�q]_�*�q]`d�]k�^x�Zzr,�q�0�ahId�lvsadxfxfefj`efdZ,j�~Gxf�a]I�p*�aZ*d�]`�q]_�*�q]`d�]k�^x�Zyr*�q�2�ahId^lvZ,���^hW�5efj`j`��j�~>��Z*p�xf�a]WZ�p*�aZ*d�]`�q]_�*�%]_d]{�^xcZyr*�q�2�ah�d�l]`h_e¼��xfj��5�(�*�aZ�]_�*�qb*h_d�h{�^� s���x}s�r*x��^]`��jW]`�*�5b*h`d��0�^�,e}xfef][oRd^l(sadxfxfefj`efdZ,j �¥½ �W�^Z*p�Z,���^h�gefj`j_�aj+��o �a�I½ � Å �¥sadxfxfefj`efdZ � � s��^Z>~��^Z,p�o � Å �¥Z*���^hu�gefj`j&� � ���^Z#�W�>efZ0��xfx}oy~2ef]sad�5b*r*]_�aj�� �5���^j_r*h`�Id^lc�ai��aZy]`r0��x>p0��Z*���h��?p0�^Z,��ah ����� ½ � �  oz����j�e}ZR]_�*�W]`h_efize���x�gdyp*�ax[~�tv�Ij_�a] �  1 KW�^Z,p ���� K� ��qZ*d^t �a½yb*x��^efZ�]`�*�5j`ef�qr*x��^]_efdZRb*h`dysa��j`jqefZ��gd�h`�qp*�a]{�^efx[�\�#efh`j_]�~�h{�^]`�,�ah%]_�0�^Z�^j_j`r*�5e}Z,�q]`�0��]�����sk��b*x��^Z*��� j�j`b2�a�ap��^Z*p�p,e}h_�asa]_e}d�Z��^h_�I�0½y�ap>~2t?�³��j`j_r*�g� �W��r*j`j_e¼��Zp*efj`]_h`ef�*r*]_e}d�Z*jRd^lW]`�,�aj`� !yr0��Zz]_ef]`ef�aj�~I�^xfxfd^t(efZ*��]`�*��r*j`��h\]_d�j_b0�as�e¯l9o�]`�*���g���^Z ��Z*pj`]{�^Z*p0��h`p5p*�aiye��^]`efd�Zqd^lG���^s{�>�c�,dhc���^s{�g]_h`e��^x[~y�IZ*dh_�\��x}xfo�p*efj`]`h_ef�*r*]`��pghk��Z*p*d���i��xfr*�d^lI���^s{� !yr0�^Zy]`ef][o�efj%s{�*d�j`�aZ>~?]_�*�aZ±�0d�]`� b*x��^Z*�aj���b0�^]_�*jq�^h`�R�a½y]_hk�^b2dx���]`�ap±xfefZ*���^h_xfo��r*j_efZ*�±]`�*��lndh_�qr*x��Rl9dhg�5efZ*ef�%r*� p*efj_]k�^Z,sa���2�a][t?�a�aZU]_�*��][t?d�b,x¼��Z*�ajR�^jRefZ�]`�*�]`h_e}iye��^xG�5dyp*�ax(��]`dqp,�a]`�ah_�gefZ*�It(�*�a]_�*�ahI� sadxfxfefj`efdZ>~�Z*���^h��gefj`j�~d�h(Z*�aef]`�,�ah�dysasar,h`j��

�y�ai��ahk��x>d�]`�*�ah(�5�a]`�,dzp,j?lndh?h`�ab,h`�aj_�aZy]`efZ*�Rr*Z*sa��h`]k��efZz][oR�^xfj`d �a½yefj`]��v�,dh?�a½*�^�gb,x}��~���^s{��]_h`e��^x�sad�r*xfp��0��i��%�2�a�aZ p*efiye}p,�ap�efZy]`dR�5x¼��h`���%Zyr*�q�2�ah�d�l;p,e}j_sah`��]`�g]_ef�g�Wj_]`�ab*j�~t(ef]`�±hk��Z*p*d���^xf]_�ahk��]`efdZ*jq]_d�����s{��b*x��^Z*��� jqi��axfdysaef][o��2�aefZ*��b0��h[lnd�h`�g��p �mln]`��hg����sk�]`ef�g�(j_]`�ab#�c��xf]_�ah`Z0��]`efi��x}oy~y�W�5dh`�I�^Z0��xfoz]_efs��^x0��b*b*h_dz�^s{�Rsad�r*xfpg�2��r,j`�apR]`d s���x}s�r*x��^]`�]`�*�ub*h`d��0�^�*efxfef][o%p,e}j_]`h_e}�,r*]`efdZRd�l"����sk�Rb*x���Z*��� j(xfdzs��^]`efd�Z\�^j��Olnr*Z,sa]`efdZRd�l"]`ef�5�~]_�0�^Zsad�5b*r*]_��]`�,��d^i��h`x��^bq�2�a][t?�a�aZR]`�*��j`�Ih`�a��efdZ*j����(�*�aj`�I�5�a]`�*dyp*j?�^xfj`dq�^h_��b2d]`��Zz]_e��^xfxfor*j`��lnr*x[~*�*r,]�b*h_d^i�apR]`dyd5p*e�|gsar*xf]v]_dqef�gb*xf�a�5�aZy]cefZ\]_�*�%��i��e}x����*xf�(]`ef�g����(�,�Wb*h`d��0����*efxfe}j_]`efs�j_ef�qr*x��^]`efd�Z%�5�a]`�*dyp5sk�,dj`��ZRlndh?]`�,e}j(b,h`d��{��sa]��0��jvj_�ai��hk�^xc��p*p*ef]`efdZ2�^x0��p*i�^Zy�]k����aj?d^i�ah�]`�*�aj_�I�g�a]_�*dyp*j����#e}h_j`]�~ef]cefjch_�ax��^]`efi��axfo%j_e}�5b*xf�c]`d s���x}s�r*x��^]`�(]_�*��h_�aj`r,x}]_jvd�l���^s{��]`h_e¼��x�Myd]`�,�ahI�g�a]_�*dyp*j(�\��oq�2�W]`dydqsad��gb*r,]k�^]_efdZy�[efZz]_�aZ*j_e}i���]_d\�^xfxfd^t�h_���^x��[]`ef�g�j`ef�qr*x��^]_efdZ d^lv� x��^h`����Zyr*�q�2�ah(d^l�b0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xGsadZ��0efsa]�b0��efh`j��-���asadZ,p>~*]_�*�%�^�5dr*Zy]cd�lr*Z*sa��h`]k��efZz][o�b*h_�aj`�aZy] efZ �Rb,x¼��Z*��� jI�h_dr*Z*p�j`b2�a�ap ]`�aZ,p*j%]_dR�0�qj_e}��Z*e��0s���Zz]_xfo\�,e}���*�ah]`�0��ZR]`�*�W�^�5dr*Zy]cd�l"r*Z,sa�ah`]{�^efZy][ogefZgef]_jvb0��]`�>~yb2�ah_�0�^b*j��0��s��^r*j_�%� b*efxfd]�� j��dz��x0efj(]_d�0oqefZg�I�efi��aZ%b2�^]`�R�^]c]_�*���R�^½yef�%r,� j{��ln��j`b2�a�ap>���(�*efjcp*e �­��h`�aZ*s���efZqr*Z,sa�ah`]{�^efZy][oqefj�aiyefp*�aZy]I�zo5sad�5b0�^h_efZ*�%]_�*�Wj_]k�^Z,p0�^h_p*j�lndh(�*d�h`e ad�Zz]{�^x#j`�ab0��hk��]`efdZ���Z*p�xfdZ,�ef]`r*p,e}Z2�^xj`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZR�0��j`�apRd�Zg]`ef�5��>�^s�sadh_p*efZ*�q]`d����^�2�^xfefZ*�z�����{~y][t?d³��e}h_b*x��^Z*��jvj_�*dr*xfpRZ*d�]sah`d�j`j(]_�*��j{�^�g�?b2defZy]ct(ef]`�*efZ�Æ�O�gefZyr*]`�aj �¥]`�*efj?sadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p*j(]`d �^�2dr*]IÆ >���Z,�1�a~�o�a]b*x��^Z*��jvefZqp*e �G�ah`�aZy](b0��]`�*j?�^h`�I�^xfxfd^tv��pq]`dWh_�a�\��e}Zq���`IZ*����b0�^h_]��c�#efZ0�^xfxfoz~�]_�*��xfefZ*����h�a½y]`h{�^b2dx��^]_e}d�ZWd^l>�^Zue}Z,e}]_e��^xr,Z*sa�ah_]k�^efZy][o i�^xfr*�c�R��o��2�v]_�*dr*���y]"d�l­�^jc���at?dh_j`]�s���j`���efZq]`�ah_�gjcd�l>p*�aiye��^]`efd�Z lnh`d��M]`�,���g���^Z i�axfdysaef][oz~�j`efZ*s���efZq�gdyp*�axfj�t(ef]`�qp*efj_sah`�a]_�I]`ef�g�j`]_�ab*j�~2]_d]k��x0r,Z*sa�ah_]k�^efZy][ogefj(xf�aj_j(]`�0��Zgj`r,��d�l>]`�*�I�gd��g�aZy]{�^h`our*Z*sa�ah_]k��e}Zy]_e}��j�p*r*�I]_d]`�*�Ix���t(jcd�l"��i�ah{�^���j����(�yr*j?dr*h?�gdyp*�ax,�ah`h_j�efZq]`�*��p*efh`�as�]`efdZ5d^l"s��^r*]_e}d�Z>~�b*h`d^iyefp*efZ*�� �*r*efxf][�[efZgjk�mln�a][oq�*r �­�ah©lndh(]_�*�Ij`ef�qr*x��^]_efdZ h`�aj_r*xf]`j��

����N O��&�&PRQ�S��&TU��V:QUWX��PYV0��QUPY�E�EPY��(�*�?b*h`d��0�^�*efxfefj`]_e}s�j`ef�qr*x��^]_e}d�Z(�gdyp*�ax�j`ef�Z,e¯�2s��^Zy]`xfo�e}�5b*h`d^i��ajGr*b2dZ ]`�*�?]`h_efize���x�gdyp*��x�yo ��sasad�r*Zy]`efZ*� lnd�h(r*Z*sa�ah_]k��e}Zy][oRefZR]`�*�W��Zziyefh`d�Z*�g��Zz]������^]`�,�ah�]_�0�^Z�j_ef�gb*xfo �a½y]`hk��by�dx��^]_efZ*��]_�*�R�efi��Z�i�^xfr*��j%]_d�b*h`�ap,e}s�]qt(�*�a]`�,�ah\��sad�xfx}efj_e}d�Z>~�Z*����hq�gefj`j�~�dhqZ*��e}]_�*�ah� 58797-:��8= ;���� �

����� � d^lc�

Page 7: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

dysasar*h_j�~0�Ox¼��h`���(Zzr,�q�0�ah�d^lG]`h`e���x}j?�^h`��h`r*Zqt(ef]_� �W�^r*j_j`e��^Zqp,e}j_]`h_e}�,r*]`efdZ,jcsa�aZy]`��h`�ap�d�Z]`�*�5�efi��Z�i��x}r,�aj��R�(�*efjW�^xfxfd^t(jIr*j ]`dRsadZ,j`]`h_r*sa]g�Rp2�^Z*���ahW�g���^j`r,h`�q]`�2�^]�~#efZ*j`]_���^pd^l�]k�^wyefZ*� dZ5dZ*xfog�Oln�atÄp*efj`sah_�a]`�Wi��xfr*�aj�~y��efi�aj(efZy]`�ah_�g�ap,e¼��]`�(�5���^j_r*h`�aj(�2�^j`��p\d�Z��tv��e}���y]`�apg��i��ahk����?d^lG]`�*�aj_��i��x}r,�aj�~��xfx}d^t(efZ*�(r,jc]`dW�y�^efZ%���2�a]`]_�ahvefp*���Id^lG]`�*�(h_�ax��^]_e}i��p0�^Z,��ah�b*h`�aj_�aZy]�efZgp,e}j_]`efZ*sa]_xfogp*e �G�ah`�aZy]�j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,j��

Gefw��c]`�*�(]_h`efiye��^x�5dyp*�ax[~�]`�*�?b*h`d��0�^�,e}xfefj`]_efscj`ef�qr*x��^]_efdZ��5dyp*�axs�dZ*j_e}p,�ah`jc]_�*�(�ai��aZy�]`r0��xyp0�^Z*���ah �¥Z*d]#]`�*��e}�5�g�ap,e¼��]_�>p0��Z*���h��Gd�l0�(�efi��aZIj`ef]`r0��]`efdZ#�G�(�*dr,��W�(�5e}Z,e}� r*�]`ef�g�I]_dgsad�x}xfefj`efd�Z\d�h�Z*���^hI�gefj`j(efj�sad�5b*r*]`��p>~2]`�*efj�]_ef�g�Iefj�Z*d�]�]k��w�aZ�e}Zy]_d\�^s�sadr*Zy]efZ�]`�,�q�0Z0��xv�5���^j_r*h`�5d^l�p0��Z*���h�� Z*�Rb0d�j`j`ef�*xf�5j`dxfr*]_efdZ�t?dr*xfp��2�g]`d�p*�aj_ef�ZP��Z�^xf]`��h`Z0��]`efi�Wp2�^Z*���ahI�g�a]_h`efsI]k�^wyefZ*�q]_�*efj�efZy]`dg��sasad�r*Zy]�� ��W�0��i�usk�,dj`��Z�efZ*j_]`����p�]_dp*�aj_e}��Z�]`�*�qj_ef�qr*x��^]`efd�Zgb*h_d�h{�^� t(e}]_� ��Z�d�b*]`efd�Z0�^x�r*j_�ah[�[j`b2�asae��0�ap±�R�^½yef�%r*� ]`ef�g���j_d�]`�0��]�~Ge�lv][t?d��^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajIp*dRZ*d�]�h_���^s{��]_�*�aefhI�gefZ*ef�%r,��p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�q�yo�]_ef�g�W]�~G]`�*�p*efj`]{�^Z*sa� �^](]`ef�5��](efj�sad�Z*j`efp*��h`�ap�efZ*j_]`����p�d^l�]`�*�u�gefZ*ef�%r,�Mp*efj`]{�^Z*s�� �a�?�(�*efj��^xfxfd^t(jr*j�]_dgef�Z,dh`�Isad�Zy�0efsa]_j�]`�2�^]�dysas�r*h�l��^h(efZR]`�*�Olnr*]`r,h`�~,lndysar*j_efZ*�gd�Z\�5dh_��ef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�p0�^Z,��ah_j�� �RY��?� � j_]k��]`�aj ]`�0��]Wj`�,dh`]u]`�ah_�»sadZ��0efsa]%�^Z2�^xfoyj`efjI]`dydxfjIt(�*efs{���a½y]`hk��by�dx��^]_�W�0��j`�ap�dZ�s�r*h`h_�aZy]%�^efh`s�hk��l9]�]`h{�a�{�as�]`dh_ef�aj��_db2�ahk��]`� d^i�ahI�qj`�,dh`]I]_e}�5�I�*dh_e �dZ>~��aZ,�ahk��x}xfoRxf�aj`jI]_�0�^Z�][t?dg�5efZzr,]`�aj����(�(�,e}j�j`r*����aj_]`jI]`�2�^]�xfef�gef]_e}Z,�W]`�*� ]`ef�5���,dh`e ad�Zefj�� h`����j`dZ2�^�*xf�I�g�a]_�*dypgd�l"p*����xfe}Z,�%t(ef]`�Ref�g�q��p*e��^]`�(p2�^Z*���ah(r*Z*p*��h(r*Z*sa�ah_]k��e}Zy][oy�

Z*��Z,d]k���*xf��t?���^wyZ*��j`j(d^l�]`�*efj?j`ef�qr*x��^]_efdZWefjcef]`j?h`��x}e���Z*sa�IdZR�I][tvd p*ef�g��Z*j`efdZ2�^x�gdyp*�axyd�l0]`�*����efh`j`b2�^sa��#]`�,�(�gdyp*�ax*�^j_j`r*�5�aj�]`�0��]�]`�*�?xfdzs��^]`efd�Z*j�d^l0]_�*�(][tvdW��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�aef]`�*��h(�0��i�W�^b,b*h`d^½yef�\��]`�axfoIefp*�aZy]`efs���x>�^xf]`ef]`r,p*�aj���efZgt(�*efs{�gs��^j`�I]_�*�ao\��h`�I]`h_���^]_�ap��^j�0��e}Z,�WefZq]`�*��jk�^�5� ���b*x���Z*� ��d�hcj`r*�,j`]k��Zy]`e��^xfxfoWp*e �G�ah`�aZy](�^xf]`ef]_r*p*�aj��¥efZqt(�*efsk�qs��^j`��]`�*�p0�^Z,��ah�e}j���j`j_r*�g�ap5]`dq�2�WZ*�a��xfe}��ef�*xf� �a�#�(�*efj(sah`���^]`��jO� b,h`d�,x}����t(�*��Z\]_�*�W�5dzp,�axGefjl��^s��ap�t(ef]`��][t?dg�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj(t(ef]_���gdyp*�ah{�^]_��p,e��G�ah_�aZ*sa�ajue}Z���x}]_ef]`r*p*��~*dh(t(�,�aZ�d�Z*�Idh�0d�]`�g��e}h_b*x��^Z*��jcs{�0�^Z*�����^xf]`ef]_r*p*�(j`r,�*j`]{�^Zy]`e��^xfxfoWd^i��ahc]`ef�5�~��*r*]c]_�*��j_e}�qr,x¼��]`efdZIsad�r*xfp�0�u�a½y]`�aZ*p,�ap�]`dqp,���^x#t(e}]_�g]_�*�aj`�us��^j_�ajIt(e}]_�gh_�ax��^]`efi��axfoqx}ef]_]`xf��]_h`dr,�*xf���8����Uef�gb,x}���g�aZy]k��]`efd^Z d^l"]_�*efj(efj���i�^efx��^�*xf�(efZgj_�asa]`efd�Z H��

� � QRC»¸UX�LuE>C�� ��� �\T�LWH �"Q � C?F"QRLqº

� �� �������������������Y[Zy]`r*ef]`efi��axfoz~�tv�I�a½yb2�asa]I]`�,����i�aZy]`r2�^x>p2�^Z*���ah(]`dq�2�WefZyi�ah_j`�axfogh_�ax��^]_�apR]`dq]`�,��s�x}d�j`�aj_]�^b*b,h`dz��s{�\]_�*�W�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj(t(efxfx­��s{�*ef�ai�It(ef]`�5���^s{��d�]`�*�ah�~0��Z*pg]_�*�Ie}�5�g�ap,e¼��]`�?p0�^Z,��ah]`d5�0�WefZyi��h`j`��x}oRh_�ax��^]`��p�]`d5]`�*�W]_ef�g�Ir*Zy]`efxG]`�2�^]�s�x}d�j`�aj_]W�^b*b*h_dz��sk�#�v�(�yr*j�~2tv�W�2��i�~�^j��u�0h_j`]I�^b*b*h_d^½ye}�R�^]_e}d^Z#~

2 i�aZy]`r2�^x>p2�^Z*���ah�� K¿�p*efj`]{�^Z*s��Wd^l�saxfdj`��j`]���b*b*h_dz�^s{�0Ã�

Y[�g�5�ap*e��^]_�vp0��Z*���h�� K¿¥p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�Id�l�s�x}d�j`�aj_]���b*b*h`dy�^s{�0à � ¿�]`ef�5��r*Zy]`efxGsaxfd�j`�aj_]��^b,b*h`dy�^s{�0Ã�

�yefZ*sa��p0�^Z,��ah?tvd�r*xfpq�0�I��i�ah_]`�ap5�yog�^sasa��x}��hk�^]_efZ*�%]_�*����efh`b*x��^Z,�ajv��t(��oWlnh_d� ����sk�d]_�*�ah�~y]_�*����½z]_hk�uj`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZg��s{�*ef�ai�apqj_�*dr,x}pq�2��b,h`db2dh_]`efdZ2�^x*]_dW]`�*��j9!yr0��h`��d�l>]`�*�

� 58797-:���=�� �����; \

����� � d^lc�

Page 8: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

]`ef�g�Ip*r,h`efZ*�gt(�,e}s{��]_�*�ao���h`�q�^sas��axf�ahk��]`�ap>� �yefZ*sa�W]_�*� ]`ef�g�IefZ�t(�*efs{��]`�,�³��e}h_b*x��^Z*��js��^Z���sasa�axf�ah{�^]_�gefjI�0d�r*Z*p*�ap��yo�]`�*�q]_ef�g�Wr*Zy]_e}x�]_�*�aefhWb*h_d��{�asa]_�ap�s�x}d�j`�g��b*b*h`dy�^s{�>~#ef]j`�a���gjIh`����j`d�Z0�^�*xf� ]`d5j`�a]��#1����?����j�h{�^efj`efZ*�q]_d\��ZzoRb2dj_e}]_efi�Wb2d^tv��h�t?dZ � ]I���G�asa]dh_p*�ah`efZ*�2~ct?�gs���Z�j_�a]�� 1����^Z*p�� 1 K� �yr*s{�P��j`ef�5b*xf�Wlnd�h`�qr*x��,~Gt(�*efxf�qr*j`�{l9r*xefZ�]_�*�q��aZ,�ahk��xvs���j`�~#h`r,Z*jWefZy]`dR]`h_dr*�*xf� efZ��2dr*Z,p0�^h_o�j`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z*j�� *�dR�R�^]`]_�ahI�*d^tl��^h(��t(��oq]`�*�I�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj?t(e}xfx2�0�W��]v]_�*�aefh(saxfdj_�aj`]���b*b*h`dy�^s{�>~y]_�*�Isad�5b*r*]k��]`efdZg���0d^i��j`�*d^t(jR]_�*��ef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�qp0�^Z*���ahg��defZ*��]_d�efZy�0Z*ef][o±�^jg]_�*�ao ��b*b*h_dz�^s{�±]`�2�^]gs�x}d�j`�aj_]�^b*b,h`dz��s{�>����xfj`d2~ye�l"]`�,�W][tvdq�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj���h`�IdZ��usadxfxfefj`efdZ5sadr,h`j`��~*]`�,e}j(s�d�gb,r*]k��]`efdZ�efi��j�efZy�0Z*ef]_�Wef�g�g��p*e��^]`��p0�^Z,��ah�~0Z,dg�\��]`]_�ah��*d^tU�qr,sk�R]_e}�5��h_�a�\��e}Z,j�r*Zy]`efx#]`�*�aefhsadxfxfefj`efdZ#�"�#efZ0�^xfxfoy~e�l"]_�*�%��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j(�0��i�IZ*����h`xfogefp*��Zz]_efs��^xGi��axfdzs�e}]_ef�aj�~,]`�*efj(hk��]`�aj�]`�*�ef�g�g��p*e��^]`�up0�^Z*���ah%��jWi�ah_o�saxfdj_�q]`d a��h`d ��r*Z*xf�aj_j%]_�*�\��efh`sah{��ln]%��h`�qb*h{�^sa]_efs��^xfxfo�d�Z]`d�bqd^lGdZ*����Z*d]_�*�ah���~t(�,�aZqef]"j_�*dr,x}p efZy]`r*ef]`efi��axfo��2�(efZyi�ah_j`�axfo b*h`d�b0d�h`]`efd�Z0�^x*]_dI]`�*�aefhsar*h_h`�aZy]Ij`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZ#�� ��(�0½5]`�*�Il9dh`�qr,x¼�I��j?lndxfxfd^t(j��

Y[�g�g��p*e��^]`�?p0��Z*��ah 1 �¿ p*efj`]k��Z*sa�Wd�l"saxfd�j`�aj_]��^b,b*h`dy�^s{���� Ã�¿ ]`ef�g�(r*Zy]_e}xGs�x}d�j`�aj_]���b*b*h`dy�^s{����� à �� ���sar,h`h`��Zz]�j`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZt(�*�ah_� ��� ' �  �^Z,p � . �^h_�Ib0d�j`ef]`efi��sadZ,j`]k��Zy]`j�~2b*h_d�0���*xfo%�2�aj_]�p*�a]_�ah`�5efZ*�apR�a�gb,e}h �efs��^xfxfoz�

*�d^t�t?�I�qr*j`]?sad�5b*r*]_��]`�,�Il��^s�]`dh_j��^�2d^i��-��r*b*b2dj`�It?�%�^h_�I�efi�aZ5b0d�j`ef]`efd�Z*j�$&%�^Z*p7$&*±�^Z*p5i�axfdysaef]`ef�aj�,.%��^Z*p/,.*�lnd�h;��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj�!U�^Z*p/"q���(�*�aZ7$21#$�*/42$&%���Z*p,21 ,.*#4#,.% ��h`�W]_�*�%b2dj_ef]`efdZ���Z*p�i��axfdzs�e}][oRi��asa]`d�h`jId^l(�^efh`b*x���Z*��"�efZ��Àh`�{ln��h`�aZ*s��lnhk���g� t(�*�ah_�g�^efh`b*x���Z*� ! e}jur*Z*�gd^iyefZ*�g��]�]_�*�gd�h`ef�efZ>~G��jWefZ��0��r*h`��Æ�q�(�,�qi�asa]_dhsadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p*efZ*�R]`dq]_�*�Wsaxfd�j`�aj_]O��b*b*h_dz�^s{�Rd^lc]_�*�W][t?dg�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj�efj(]_�*�%�^xf]_e}]_r*p*��lnh_d�!M]_d2,*~*t(�,e}s{���2�^j(xf�aZ*��]`�R��!yr0�^x#]`d�$�; =?>+@�1BA CED�FGA

A FGA�cY9lc]`�,e}j(p,e}j_]k��Z*sa�Wefj�j_ry|gsaef�aZy]`xfo

x��^h`���~�jk��o �h`���^]`��hv]_�0�^ZÀ�0i�(Z0��r*]`efs���x0�5efx}��j���~]_�*�aZ5tv�(�R��o�s�dZ*saxfr*p,��]`�2�^]?]`�*efjcb0��efhd^l>�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajcb2dj_�(Z*dI�g����Z*efZ*�^l9r*x�ai��aZy]`r0��x0p2�^Z*���ahc]`dId�Z*���^Z*d�]`�*��h�~y�^Z*p �gd^i��cdZq]_d]`�*�uZ*�a½y]�b0��efh��cY9lc]_�*�%�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj(t(efxfxGb0��j`j�s�x}d�j`�W]_dqdZ*� �^Z*d�]`�*�ah�~ ]`�*�aZ�tv�WZ,d^t �0��i��� hk��]`efZ*�ulndh(�ai��aZy]`r0��x>p0��Z*���h�� A F AA CED&FGA ��(�*� ]`ef�g�u]`�0��]�t(efxfx��ax��^b*j_�%�2�{lnd�h`�q]_�*�qsaxfdj_�aj`]%��b*b*h_dz�^s{��efjO��]`]{�^efZ*�ap�efj�j_ef�gb*xfo]`�*��]`ef�g��r*Zy]`efx*�^efh`b*x���Z*� "Äh_���^s{�*��j(b0d�e}Zy]��q~^d�h 9����*�� 9A FGA �#�(�*�(Zyr*�g�ah{�^]_dh��*�ah_�(e}j���!yr0�^x]`d 9 $:9���� ; @ 1 C� FA FGA ~�j_d�]`�*�5]`ef�g�qefj ��!yr0�^x(]_d C� FA F A � ��Y9l�]_�*efj%]_e}�5�qefj%Z*���z�^]_efi�~�]`�*�aZ]`�*��j`�R][tvd���e}h_b*x��^Z*��jW�0��i�g��xfh`����p*o�j`r,h`iyefi�ap ]`�*�aefhWs�x}d�j`�aj_]³��b*b*h_dz�^s{�>~��^Z,p�b*h`�aj_�aZy]Z*d p0�^Z*���ah(]`d dZ,���^Z,d]`�,�ahvefZ5]`�*��lnr*]_r*h`����Y9l"]`�,��]_ef�g�?e}j?b2dj`ef]_e}i��~yt?��s���Zgs���x}s�r*x��^]`�]`�*�ue}�5�g�ap,e¼��]_�(p0�^Z,��ah(�yogb,x}r,��efZ*�u�ai�ah_oy]`�*efZ*�qefZ\��Z*pRj`ef�gb,x}e�lnoyefZ*�2�

Y[�g�5�ap*e��^]_�vp0��Z*���h�1 9 , 9 !¿ 9 $#" , 9 � 9 , 9 � � Ã%$�$�& , � 9 , 9  � Â�' Â

� � .9 $09)(

�(�*efj>oyef�axfp*jc�#** e}Zu]`�*�?�0h_j`]�j`r,�g�\��Z*pIt(�*�aZ5,�1,+*~^e[� ��f~�t(�*�aZ ]`�*�?][tvdW��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�^h_�q�0oyefZ*�R�a½*�^sa]_xfo�b0�^h{�^xfxf�axc]_d�dZ*�g��Z*d]_�*�ah��gY[Z�]_�*efj�s��^j`��~�tv�qj_�a]%]_�*�qef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�p0�^Z,��ah���!yr0�^xG]_d ���

A C A�

- 58797-:��8=���;���� ������W� d^lc�

Page 9: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

� ��N O��&�&PRQ�S��&TU��V:QUW�� PYV0��QUPY�E�EPY��(�*� �\�^efZRj`]_h`�aZ,�]`��d�lc]`�*efjI�gdyp*�ax#efj�]_�0�^]�ef]�efjI�a½y]`h`���g�axfoRj`t(e�ln]��(]`�*� p0��Z*��ahIb*h_�{�j`�aZy]_�ap��yo��5b0�^efhId^l;��efh`b*x��^Z,�ajIs��^Z��0�qs�d�gb,r*]`�ap�t(e}]_�³��r*j`]Id^i��h��,ln][o��0��j`efs%d�b0��h[��^]_e}d�Z*j dZ�wyZ*d^t(Z�h_���^x(Zyr*�q�2�ah_jWe�l��ai��aZy]`r0��x(p0�^Z*���ah �a½ye}j_]`j�~v�^Z,pP�^�2dr,]W�0�^x�l�]_�0�^]]`dqsad�Z*saxfr*p*�u]`�0��]�ef](p*dy�aj�Z,d] My]_�yr*j��ai��aZ�� �5dzp,�ah`Z5b0�ah_j`d�Z0�^x�sad��gb*r*]_�ah(j`�,dr*xfpR�0����^j_efx}oq�^�,x}��]`dW�2�^Z*p*xf�(]_�*efjvsad��gb*r,]k�^]_efdZIlnd�hcj`��i�ah{�^xG]`�,dr*j{�^Z*pR�^efh`b*x���Z*�{�[b0�^efh`j��ai�ah_oj`�as�dZ*p>~2d�h��^�2dr*](����q�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj?�ai�ah_oR][tvd �gefZyr*]`��j���(�*�q�5dj`]Ij_�ah`efdr,jWtv���^wyZ*�aj_jqd^l(]`�*efjW�5dzp,�ax�tvd�r*xfp ��b*b0���^h ]`d��2�q]`�0��]Wef]Wp*dy�aj

Z*d](�^]_]`�a�5b*]c]_dWtvd�h`h_og�^�2dr*]v��efh`b*x��^Z,�ajv]_�0�^]�b0�^j_j(Z*���^h?����sk�5d]_�*�ah?e}Zq]_ef�g�(�*r*]?Z*d�]efZ�j_b0�^sa���\�,dhI�a½*�^�5b*xf�~Gef]Is��^Z,Z*d]Ip*efj`]_efZ*�r*efj_���2�a][t?�a�aZ�][t?d��^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj��0oyefZ*�R]`�*��a½*�^sa]ujk�^�5�%h_dr*]_�q]`�*h_dr*����j_b0�^s��gt(ef]`���5]`ef�g�{�[j`��b0�^h{�^]`efd�Z�d^l?�*ln]_�a�aZ�j`��sadZ*p,j³��Z*p][tvd��^efh`b*x���Z*�aj��0oyefZ*�Rb0�^h{�^xfxf�axc]`d�dZ*�g��Z*d]_�*�ahWt(ef]`���5b*�yoyj`efs���xvj_�ab0��hk�^]_efdZ�d^l(][t?d�gefxf�ajGefZWj`d��g��p*efh`��sa]`efdZudh`]_�*d��dZ0��x]_d�]`�,�aefh"i��axfdysaef][o M�]_�*�c�2h`j`]�j_e}]_r0�^]_efdZ%��b*b0���^h`j�]_d�0���qr*s{�%�5dh_�vp0��Z*���h`dr,j����(�*�(Z*��½z]?�gdyp*��xzt(efxfx0��]`]`���gb*]�]`dup*e �­�ah_�aZy]`e��^]_���2�a][t?�a�aZ]`�*��j`�q�^Z*p5j`ef�gefx��^hcj_ef]`r0��]`efdZ*j��

� � QRC �+�RH �vC��&� ¹�J�C � C?F"QRLqº

���� ��������������������(�*�?�yb0��sa�{�[�(e}�5�v�5�a]`�,dzpqr,j`�aj(j_e}�5efx¼��h>h_���^j_dZ*efZ*� ]`d ]`�*���?xfdj`������b*b*h`dy�^s{�g�5�a]`�,dzp#~�*r*]�sad�Z*j`efp*�ah_jc]`�,�;��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j ��b*h`d^½yef�gef][o(efZWj_b0�^sa����]_e}�5�~^h{�^]`�,�ah�]`�0��Z%j_e}�5b*xfo(efZWb*�yoyj[�efs��^xGj_b0�^sa���c�(�yr*j�~,efZz]_r*ef]`efi��x}oy~�tv�I�0��i���

2 i��Zz]_r0�^x#p0�^Z,��ah � Ksaxfdj`��j`]���b*b*h_dz�^s{�RefZgj_b0�^sa����]_e}�5�

Y[�g�5�ap*e��^]_�vp0��Z*���h�� K¿¥saxfdj_�aj`]I�^b*b*h_dz��sk�RefZgj_b0�^s��{��]_ef�g��ÃG¿¥]`ef�g��r*Zy]`efxGsaxfdj_�aj`]I�^b*b,h`dz��s{��Ã

�(�*�Ijk���g��sadh_h`�asa]_efdZ*j©lndh(�2dr*Z,p0�^h_ogsad�Z*p*ef]`efdZ,jvt(efxfx­��b*b*xfoy~yx}����izefZ*�Y[�5�g�ap*e���]`�?p0�^Z*���ah 1 �¿ saxfd�j`�aj_]��^b,b*h`dy�^s{�Re}Z5j`b0��sa�{�[]`ef�g� �� Ã�¿ ]`ef�5��r*Zy]`efxGsaxfd�j`�aj_]��^b*b*h_dz��sk���� � à �� � �sar*h_h`�aZy]�j_b0�^s��{��]_ef�g�Ij`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZ

�(�*�aj_� !yr0�^Zy]`ef]_e}��j���h`�?�0�^h_p*�ahc]_dIsad�5b*r*]`�?]`�2�^Z e}Z ]`�,� �?xfdj_�{�[��b*b*h_dz��sk�q�5�a]`�,dzp#��yr*b*b2dj_�;��efh`b*x��^Z,� I�efjGb2dj`ef]_e}d�Z*�ap%��]G]`�*��dh`ef��e}Z#~��^Z,p+$I�efi��j>]`�,�cb0d�j`ef]`efd�Z�d�l0�^efh`b*x���Z*�� t(e}]_��h_�aj`b2�asa]R]`d���efh`b*x��^Z,� I2~v��Z*p±]`�0��]q]`�*�ao �0��i�Ri��axfdzs�e}][o�i��asa]_dh`j/,�����Z*p ,^~h`�aj_b0��sa]`efi��x}oy���(�*�aZutv���\��o(h_�ab*h_�aj`�aZy]�]`�,��lnr*]_r*h`�cd�l0�^efh`b*x���Z*�ajYI���Z*p � �zo�hk��oyj>efZ ,���~b0�^h{�^�5�a]`h_e ��apq�yo� �,�������&' ,�������E'-,��������E'����������Z*p� ,����� ' ,����� ' ,�����.'��������'����E'��� +*~t(�*�ah_���Iefj��©sadZ,j`]k��Zy]"s{�*d�j`�aZ j`dI]_�0�^]c�(p,e}j_]k��Z*sa�?d^l0d�Z*�vr,Z*ef]>efZW]`�,�v]_e}�5��sadydh`p,e}Z2�^]`�efjv��!yr0��xfx}o p0��Z*��ah_dr*j?]`d �Wp*efj_]k�^Z,sa��d�Z*��r*Z,e}]�e}Zqd�Z*��d�l>]`�*�I�*d�h`e ad�Zz]{�^x*s�dzd�h`p*efZ0��]`�aj�����^�2�^xfefZ*�z���! I��!yr0�^]_�aj%�³�*ln]`���aZy�[�gefZyr*]`�Wj_�ab0��hk�^]_efdZ�e}Z�]`ef�5��t(ef]_� �³�0i�{�[Z0��r*]`efs���x¯��gefxf�gj_�ab0�^h{�^]_e}d�Z�efZ�j`b2�^sa� MIt?��t(efxfx���j`j`r,�g�R]`�0��]g]_�*efjgj`s��^xf�aj�� �(�*�aZ"�±��!yr0�^xfjRZ0�^r,]`efs��^xG�5efx}��jvb2�ahWÆ� �5efZzr,]`�aj�~d�h��^�2dr*]�� ]Wln���a]�b2�ah(j`��sadZ*p#�# 58797-:��8=�� ;���� �

�����%$ d^lc�

Page 10: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�,dh(�^Zyo � � '�� ~*]_�*�Ij`b0��sa�{�[]`ef�g�Ip*efj`]{�^Z*s����2�a][t?�a�aZ�]_�*�Wb2dj_e}]_efdZgd�l���e}h_b*x��^Z*��Ig��]]`ef�g� ���%��Z*pg]_�*�Wb2dj_e}]_efdZgd�l���e}h_b*x��^Z*� � �^](]`ef�5� ��(efj(�efi��Zg�yo

� ¿ ���E'���kà 1��� ,��������E'-,�������E' ,�� � �-I '������ � 4 ,���� ' ,����� ' ,���� � '����� � �� ���(�*efjvoyef�axfp*j¿ � ¿ � � '�� Ã`à  1 ! �kÂ� � " � � � � � �k ��� � � ��� � � 9 $:9  ~yt(�*��h`�! 1 �* � 9 ,��&9 Â" 1�4 � �*Â(4 � ,�� &.,� 1 �* � 9 , 9 Â� 1�4 � $�& , �� 1 � $�&.,

*�d^tÄ]`�,�%�5e}Z,e}� r*� j`b2�^sa�{�[]`ef�5�Wp*efj`]{�^Z*sa� dysasar*h_j%�^] ���q�^Z*p ���t(�,e}s{���5efZ*ef�qe ��]`�*efj �a½yb*h`��j`j`efd�Z>~�]`�0��]%efj�~>t(�*��h`���2Â21 +,�R�(�*efjWdysasar*h_j³��] � � 1  � � � *��* � � � % � '�� 1 % � � *��* � � � % � �? ��ud�*j_�ah`i��q]`�0��]�]`�,e}jIefjItv��x}x��[p*�{�0Z,�ap�t(�*�aZ,�ai�ah ]`�,�%i��axfdzs�e}]_ef�aj���h`�qZ*d�]��!yr0�^x[~^�^jY"u 4�� ! ��1�� $ ¿),�� & ,aà  4 9 ,��&9  9 , 9  � � �, ,���& , 4 �*Â(9 ,��&9  4 �,Â�9 , 9  ' ��(�*�(�2h`j`]?][t?d�]_�ah`�5jv�^p,pq]`dWxf�aj_jv]_�*�aZ���ah`d �yo �(��r*s{�zo��9�ys{�yt;��h9~y�^Z*pq]_�*�(x��^j_]c]`�*h_�a��yoP���5� � ��~�t(ef]`�±��!yr0��x}ef][o�efZ±�0d�]`��s��^j`��j\d�Z*xfo�t(�*�aZ�]_�*��i��axfdzs�e}]_ef�ajg�^h_����!yr0�^x[����(�*� s���j`� t(�*�aZ�]`�*� i�axfdysaef]`ef�ajI�^h_�%��!yr0��x�e}j��0�^Z,p*xf�ap��gd�h`�Wj_ef�gb*xfoG�c�*d�h��ai��ah`o � � ~]`�*��h`�Wefj��ur*Z*e !yr*� � jk��]`efj[l9ozefZ*�5" � � � � � � ��� 1 + �¥j`efZ*sa� � e}j���xft;��oyj?b0d�j`ef]`efi���t(�*efs{��oyef�axfp*jW]`�,�\�5efZ*ef�%r*�Dj`b2�^sa�{�[]`ef�5�gj`��b0�^h{�^]`efd�Z>�<�Ä�(�*�g�5e}Z,e}�qr,��j_b0�^sa����]_e}�5�j`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZÄefjg��e}i��aZ±�yo�#¿ � � '�� Ãa� �(�*��]_e}�5�Rr*Zy]`efx�]_�*efj\j_�ab0��hk�^]_efdZ�efjg��efi�aZ��yo� =?>�� � � '�� �� ��(�*�Ws�r*h`h_�aZy]�j`b2�^sa�{�[]`ef�5��j_�ab0��hk�^]_efdZ�t?dr*xfp��^b,b0����h(]`d5�0�W]_�*�W�5e}Z,e}� r*� d^lc]`�*�j`b0��sa�{�[]`ef�g�?j`��b0�^h{�^]`efd�Z*jc�2�a][tv���aZq]`�*�(s�r*h`h_�aZy]vb2dj_e}]_efdZ d^l­��e}h_b*x��^Z*��IW��Z*p%]_�*�?lnr*]_r*h`�d^l>�^efh`b,x¼��Z*� � ~z��Z*p ]`�*�(sar,h`h`��Zz]?b2dj`ef]_e}d�Z%d�l � ��Z*p ]`�*�?lnr,]`r*h_�(d^lYI0���(�,�?�0h`j_]cd^lG]`�*��j`�dysasar*h_jWt(�*�aZ ��+1 ��� 1 4 � � ~2]`�*� j`��sadZ*p�t(�*�ah_�%���71 ���/1 4 � % � �(*�d�]`� ]`�0��]�~2efZ]`�*�Is���j`��t(�*�ah`�I]_�*��i��axfdzs�e}]_ef�aj;��h`�(��!yr0��x[~�����efjv]_�*� � ��j`j_dzs�e¼��]`�ap5]`d � � 1 +,�<�IY9l>dZ*�d^lc]`�,�aj`�q]_e}�5�aj?e}j�Z*�a�y�^]`efi��~*t?�Wh`��b*x��^sa� ef](t(e}]_� �*~*t(�,e}s{��efj(Z*d�]�efZR]`�*�ub0�^j_]��(�(�yr*jtv�I�0��i���

�?r*h_h`�aZy]�j`b0��sa�{�[]`ef�g��j`�ab0��hk��]`efdZ21 � =?>���! �#"%$ * � � ¿ ����'�+Ã�' � ¿�+&'����,Ã�' � ¿�+&'�+à ��(sa]_r0�^x#p*�a]`��h`�gefZ0��]`efdZ5d^lcp0��Z*��ah�efj(p*dZ*� �^j(efZR]`�*�Ws�x}d�j`�{�`�^b,b*h`dy�^s{���gdyp*��x�~��a½��

sa�ab*]u]`�0��]W]`�*� ]`ef�5�aj���j`j`dysae���]`�ap�]_d\s�x}d�j`�aj_]%�^b,b*h`dy�^s{���qr,j`]��2�qsad��gb*r*]_�apR�0h_j`]��qY9l�aef]`�*��h(e}j�Z*�a�z��]`efi��~]_�*�aZ\��Zyo%p0��Z*���hvb2dj_�apg�yoq]`�,e}j?�^efh`b*x���Z*�{�[b0�^efhc�0��jv�^xfh_���^p*o �2�a�aZ��id�e}p,�ap>~��Z*pqj`dI]`�,���ai��aZy]`r0��x0�^Z*pqef�5�q�ap*e��^]_�"p2�^Z*���ah`j(�^h_�(j`�a]c� !zr2�^x*]_d?a�ah_d0���(�*�aZ]`�*�Ij_b0�^sa����]_e}�5�(j`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZ5d^l>]_�*�Isaxfdj`��j`]��^b,b*h`dy�^s{�qefjvsad��gb*r,]`�apYM�e�l>ef]vefj?]`dydWx��^h_��~jk��o���h`����]`�ah ]`�2�^Z��0i� Z0�^r,]`efs��^x��gefxf�aj�~,tv�qsad�Z*saxfr*p*�q]_�0�^]I]_�*�aj`�R�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajIb2dj`�qZ,dp0�^Z,��ah ]`d�dZ*�R�^Z*d�]`�*��h���Y9l{~�dZ�]`�,�\d�]`�*��h%�0��Z*p>~�]_�*�ao�p*d�b2dj_�Rj`ef�Z*e��0s��^Zy]W�ai��aZy�]`r0��x�p0��Z*���h�~?]`�*���ai�aZy]_r0�^xI�^Z*p±ef�g�5�ap*e���]`�qp0��Z*���h`j\��h`�Rsad��gb*r*]_�ap±�yo�b*xfr*���efZ*��ai��h`oy]`�*efZ*�5efZ>�

����N O��&�&PRQ�S��&TU��V:QUW�� PYV0��QUPY�E�EPY�Y[]�efj(saxf����h�]`�2�^](]`�,e}j�efj�� �gdh_��]_e}�5efpq�g����j`r*h_�Wd^l�p0�^Z*���ah�]_�0�^ZR]_�*�Wsaxfdj_�{�`�^b*b*h_dz��sk��g�a]_�*dyp>� 2 i�ah_o\��e}h_b*x��^Z*����b0��efhch`�as��aefi�ajI�^](xf���^j_];��j(�*ef��qef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�{�>�^Z*pR�ai��aZy]`r0��x¯�

Å�����qÆ �ud^lc�

Page 11: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

p0�^Z,��ah#�g����j`r*h_�aj2lnh`d�� ]_�*�cj_b0�^sa����]_e}�5���g�a]_�*dyp��^j2l9h`d�Ä]`�,�csaxfdj_�{� ��b*b*h_dz�^s{�I�g��]`�*dyp>~t(�*efxf�%ef]Ih`�as�d�Z,e ��aj³��jIp0�^Z*���ah`d�r*jWj_d�g� s���j`�ajWt(�,e}s{��]_�*�qsaxfdj_�{� ��b*b*h_dz�^s{���g�a]_�*dypp*dy�aj?Z*d]����(�*efjcj`r*����aj_]`j?]`�0��]cef]cefjcb*h_d�0���*xfo%�5dh`�?r*j_�{lnr*xG�^jv�Ob*h`�ap,e}s�]`dh?d^l>p2�^Z*���ah�~j`dIxfdZ*�I�^j�]`�,�vef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�{�[p0�^Z*���ah2hk�^Z,wzefZ*��j�sadZy]`efZyr*�?]`d��\�^w��cj`��Z*j`���Y9lGdZ,�;��sasa�ab*]_j]`�*� b*h_�a�gefj`�u]`�0��]�p0��Z*��ahI�^h_e}j_�aj�t(�,�aZ�][t?dg�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj�b0�^j_j�]_�*h`d�r*���Z,���^h_�zo�b0d�e}Zy]_jefZ�j`b0��sa���^]WZ*���^h`�yo�b2defZy]`jWefZ�]_e}�5�~��^jWj_�a�a�gj �a�5e}Z,�aZy]`xfo�h`���^j`d�Z0�^�,x}��~�]`�*�aZ ]`�*��j`��g����j`r*h_�ajIefZRl��^s�]��\��w�I�gd�h`�Wj_�aZ*j_�q]`�0��Z�]`�*d�j`� ��aZ,�ahk��]`�ap��yoR]`�*� saxfdj_�{�`�^b*b*h_dz��sk��gdyp*�ax[�GY[]?efjcj`d��g�at(�2�^]c�*r,]vZ*d�]cj`ef��Z*e��0s��^Zy]_x}o j`xfd^t?�ahc]_dWef�gb*xf�a�5�aZy]�~�h`��!yr*efh_e}Z,�WdZ*xfo�^�2dr*]RÆ �����2�^j`efs5db2�ahk��]`efdZ*j ]`d�sad��gb*r*]_�g]_�*�g�ai��aZy]`r0��x��^Z*p ef�g�g��p*e��^]`�up0�^Z*���ah`j���(�yr*jqef]%j_�*dr*xfp �0���^�,x}�5]`d��0��Z*p*xf�\���0d�r*] �0�^x�lO��j%�R�^Zyo��^efh`b*x���Z*�ajq�^j ]`�*�Rsaxfdj_�{��^b*b,h`dz��s{�\�5dyp*�axGefZR]`�*�Ijk���g�W�^�5dr*Zy]cd�l"]_e}�5� My]`�,e}j(efj(����j`efxfoql���j`](�aZ,dr*���\]_dqtvd�h`wefZ\h_���^x��[]`ef�g���

Z±]`�*�Rd]_�*�ahq�0��Z*p>~�]`�*efjq�gdyp*��xvefjq�qr*s{���gd�h`�5db0��!zr,�g]`d���Zyo��zr,�\�^Z�t(�,d�qr*j`]I]_h`o�]_d�tvd�h`w�t(ef]_��ef]�� ��Z��^efh[�[]`h{��|gs sadZy]`h_dxfxf�ahW�^]_]`�a�5b*]`efZ*�À��e}Z�h`���^x?]`ef�g�I�]`d5b*xfd]�� sad�r*h`j_�%sad�h`h_�asa]`efd�Z�t(�*efs{�R�gefZ*ef�ge a�aj?]`�*�up0�^Z*���ah��5���^j_r*h`��j��efi��aZR�zo5]`�*efj�gdyp*�ax�sadr*xfp����^j_efx}o��0Z*p��,e}�5j`�ax�lcl9h`r*j_]`hk��]`�ap±�^Z*p�sad�Zylnr*j_�ap�i��ah`o !yr*efskwyxfoy�5Z�r*�R�^Z�0��e}Z,�j�~�Z*dq�\��]`]`��h��*d^tÄ�h_���^]Idr,h�efZy]`�axfxf�asa]_r0�^x#r*Z*p*�ah_j`]{�^Z*p*efZ*�Rd�l�j_r*s{��]_�*efZ*�j�~G�^h`�d^ln]_�aZRj`ef�gb,x}o Z*d�](��!yr*efb*b0��p\]_dq]`�*efZ*w5efZg]`��h`�gj(d�l"�a½y]_hk� p*ef�g��Z*j`efdZ,j��

� � QRC���L �WHWT�¹�F"QRJ�¹ � C(T"¹���HOF"¹��%C

�(�*��xfd��z�^h_ef]`�*�5e}s�p*��h`efi�^]_e}i��(�gdyp*�axyefjcp*e �G�ah`��Zz]�lnh_d�M]_�*dj_��t(�*efs{�q�0��i��(�dZ,�(�0�{l9dh`�efZ�]_�0�^]Wef]Idh_ef�efZ0�^]_�aj�lnh`d���p*e �G�ah`��Zz]ud�*j_�ah`i��]`efdZ*j �^Z*p�efZz]_r*ef]`efdZ,j�� Y[]WefjIb*h`d��0�^�*xfo]`�*�q�5dyp*�ax>]_�0�^]I�5dj`](s�x}d�j`�axfo���b*b*h_d^½zef�R�^]`��j(t(�0�^]I�^Z��^efh�]_hk��|gs sad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah�tvd�r*xfpp*d0~,efZg]`�,�O���*j`��Z*sa� d^l"b,h`�ap*efsa]_efi�Wj_d^ln][t(�^h_��

���� ��������� � ��������(�*���gdyp*�ax���h`efj`�aj5lnh_d� ]`�*��d�,j`�ah_i�^]`efd�Z�]`�0��]�~(e�lW]`�,��i��axfdzs�e}]_ef�ajgd�l³�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj5!�^Z*p#"Dh_�a�\��efZ�sadZ,j`]k��Zy]�~#]`�*�Àlnr*Z*sa]_efdZ��� � ¿¥p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�I�2�a][t?�a�aZ��^efh`b*x���Z*�aj(!M�^Z*p "WÃefj��gd�Z*d]_dZ*efs���xfx¯o e}Z,sah`����j`efZ*�qt(ef]`�R]_e}�5�/�¥r*Z*xf�aj`jI]_�*�%�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj���h`�W]_hk��i��axfe}Z,�%efZR]`�*�jk���g�Ixfe}Z,�~*efZ�t(�*efs{�Rs��^j_�%ef](efj�s�dZ*j_]k�^Zy]&����Z*pRefj��2dr*Z*p,�ap��2d]`���^�2d^i�%��Z*pR�0�axfd^tW��(�yr*j�~�4 �� � ¿�p,e}j_]k��Z*sa�W�2�a][t?�a�aZ���e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�!M�^Z*p "WÃÀe}jq�5dZ*d�]`d�Z*efs��^xfxfo�p,�asah`���^j`efZ*�2~�^Z*p34 p*efj`]{�^Z*sa� ������ ¿ p,e}j_]k��Z*sa� Ã

~G�ai��xfr0�^]_�ap ��] � * ~>��efi�ajW�5xfd^tv�ah��0d�r*Z*p�d�Z�]`�*�q]_ef�g�W�2�a][t?�a�aZ� * �^Z*pR�^Zyo lnr*]_r*h`�I]`ef�5� �;��]vt(�,e}s{�5]`�*�W�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj(�^h_�Ij`�ab0��hk��]`�apR�yog�Wp,e}j_]k��Z*sa�Ixf�aj`j]`�0��Z��%�(�yr*ju]`�*�qh_�asaefb*h`dys���xvd�lv]`�,e}j !zr2�^Zy]`ef][oy~Y4 ��� ¿ p,e}j_]k��Z*sa� Ãp*efj_]k�^Z,sa� ���� �gef���z](t?dh_w��^j ��g����j`r*h_�Id^l"ef�5�g�ap*e���]`�?p0�^Z*���ah�� G�a](r,j(e}Zyi��aj`]_e}�y�^]_��]_�*�I�0���0��iye}d�h(d^l�]`�*efj?lnr*Z,sa]`efdZ#�

�yr*b,b0d�j`� ]`�0��]��^efh_b*x��^Z*��" �0�^j�b0d�j`ef]`efdZ���Z*p�i��x}dysaef][oRi��sa]`d�h`j�$���Z*p�,*~2h_�aj`b2�as{�]`efi��x}oy~^efZWj_d�g��lnh{�^�g��d^lGh`�{ln��h`�aZ*s���t(�*�ah_�+!±efj�j`]k��]`efdZ2�^h`o �^]c]_�*�vd�h`ef�efZ>~��^j�efZW�0��r*h`�>*��*�d^t

�� � $ 9 $09  ' 1��?= �� � *

9 $ ��� , 9  4 9 $:9 � 1�� = �� � *

� � $�& , ��� �9 , 9 � 1,� $�&.,

������� 5 5���� � 795"! 5�! � 7$#�%'& 7�(*),+ � %'- � ! � & �,.0/ 71- �,2 % ! �,2 73 �%�50! � 74),+ � % - � ! � & �,.5/ 76- �,2 % ! �,2 70+875%�79��# . ! � + #: � 5 / 7;5##7 / !�+=<�7>! � 7 / 76- �,2 %'! �,2 74+87 � !85?),+ � %'- � ! � &A@CBDFE DE1G

Å�����qÆÆ�d^lc�

Page 12: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

������

BA

v

θµp

target

λ

�#e}��r*h`�?>,���(�*�Ix}d��z��h`ef]`�*�5efsvp*��h`efi�^]_e}i��

Hvr,] �� � $ 9 $:9  ' 1 �U9 $09?�� � 9 $09¯~�j_d��� � 9 $:901 C� FA C A 1 9 , 9 ��� ; @y���(�,e}jue}j h`��b*h`�aj_�aZy]`�apÄefZ�0�r,h`��>R�yo��c~G]_�*�gb,h`d��{��sa]`efdZ�d^l(dZ,�q]`ef�g�{�[r*Z*ef]�d^l(i�axfdysaef][o�dZy]_d $#�5��efiyefp*efZ*�g�yo9 $:9 4 g�efi��jW]`�*�5Zyr*�q�0��hWd^l�]_e}�5�{�[r*Z*ef]`jIZ*�as��aj`j{�^h`o �0��lndh_�\]_�*�gb,h`d��{��sa]`efdZ dZy]`d $efZz]_�ah`j_�asa]_j�]`�,��saefh`s�x}��d^l>h{�^p*efr*j ��^�2dr*] !%��Y9l��efjvs{�*d�j`�aZ5]`d h`�ab,h`�aj_�aZy](j`d�5�(p0�^Z,��ah]`�*h_�aj`�,dxfp>~�]`�*efj��\��w�aj#e}Zy]_r*ef]`efi�cj_�aZ*j_����?d�Z*j`efp*�ahc��x}j_d�]_�*�(�0���0��iye}d�h>d�l­]_�*efj>l9r*Z*sa]_e}d�Z�^jW]_ef�g� b0�^j_j`�aj��%Y9l+" t(efxfx�b0�^j_jW]`�,h`dr,���]`�,�gsaefh`s�x}�qd�l;h{�^p*efr*j �~#]`�,�g]k��h`���a]Wb2defZy]sadZyi��ah`���aj�]_dq]`�*�IefZy]`�ah_j`�asa]_efdZ�d�l "+� j(]`h{�a�{�as�]`dh_oRt(e}]_�g]_�*�Wsaefh`s�x}��~0�^Z,pg]`�,�W�g����j`r*h_��dy�aj?]`dIefZy�0Z*ef][o%��j�"U�^b,b*h`dy�^s{�*�aj?]`�*�(s�e}h_saxf�~�]`�*�aZ5�0��sad�5�ajcZ*�a�y�^]_e}i��vd�Z*sa��e}]�b0��j`j_�ajefZ*j`efp*��#Y9l�vefj�j`ry|gs�e}��Zz]_xfo%j_�\�^xfx ��xfefw�~^j{��oz~ �����©ln�a�a]�~]_�*�(]`�,h`�aj_�*dxfp lnd�h���Z*���^hc�5e}j_j���~]`�*efjcefj��2Z*�� Z,sa��]_�*�(][tvd �^efh`b*x���Z*�ajc�^h_�(t(e}]_�*efZ (d^lG����sk�qd�]`�*��h�~yef]�e}j�e}Z j`d��g�?j`�aZ,j`��^xfh`���^p*o ]`dyd x¼��]`��#Y9lk~�dZq]_�*��d�]`�*�ah?�0��Z*p>~E"Ut(efxfx*Z*d]�b0�^j_jvt(ef]`�,e}Z �d^lY! ~]_�*��]{�^h_��a]b0d�efZz]u�dy�aj ]`d�efZy�0Z,e}][o��^ju]`�*�/"��^b,b*h`dy�^s{�*�aj ]`�*�5b0d�efZz]ud^l�xf���^j_]%j_�ab0��hk�^]_efdZ�lnh_d�!%~*��Z*pg]_�*���5���^j_r*h`��j`ef�qr*xf]k��Z*�adr,j`xfoW�dy�aj?]`d a�ah_d0~y]_�*�aZR�0��sad�5�ajvZ,�a�z��]`efi����jv]_�0�^]b0d�efZz] efjqsah`d�j`j_�ap>���(�,e}j efj³��xfj`d��0Z*� M���xfx(p0�^Z*���ahqefj%b2�^j`]qd�Z*sa�R]`�,�\b2defZy] d^l�xf����j`]j`�ab2�^hk��]`efdZRefj(h`���^s{�*�ap>�

����N O��&�&PRQ�S��&TU��V:QUW�� PYV0��QUPY�E�EPY��(�*����h`����]`�aj_]vj_]`h_�aZ*�]_�gd�l­]_�*efjc�gdyp*�axyefj�ef]`jcj_e}�5b*xfefsaef][o M�]_�*�(ef�g�g��p*e��^]`��p0��Z*���hc�g���m�j`r*h_�%s��^Z��2�Wsad��gb*r*]_�apRt(ef]`�RdZ*xfoR�^�2dr*](]_�aZ��0��j`efsWdb2�ah{�^]`efd�Z*j M2]`�,e}j(efj��ai�aZ l��^j_]`�ah]`�0��Zg]_�*�Isaxfdj`��� ��b*b*h`dy�^s{�g�5dyp*�ax[�>�,r*h`]_�*�ah`�5dh_�~yef]cd#�G�ah`j(d�]`�*��h(r*j`�{l9r*xGefZylndh_�\��]`efdZ>�]`�*�5h`�as�e}b,h`dys��^x(d�l�]`�*�5�g����j`r*h_�qefjW�a½*�^sa]_xfo��*d^t �qr*s{��]_e}�5�%]_�*�gs�dZy]`h_dxfxf�ahW�0��j%]_d�^sa]�~y�0��lndh_��]`�,e}j?b0��e}h�d^l"�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj�t(e}xfx*�2��i�(b*x���o��pqdr*]ct(�2�^]`��i�ah?p0�^Z,��ah?]`�*��o l��^sa�lnh`d���dZ,�%�^Z*d�]`�*��h����Z,d]`�,�ahIj`]`h_�aZ*��]`��e}j�]`�0��]�]_�*efj��g���^j`r,h`�W�2�a�0��i��ajIsadh_h`�asa]_xfo�efZ�][t?dqd^lv]_�*� j`ef]`ry�

�^]_e}d�Z*j(t(�*�ah_�%]_�*�Wb*h_�aiyefdr*j�][tvdq�5���^j_r*h`�aj�h`��!yr*efh_�ap�r*��x}oÀ�0½y�aj��?Y9lv]_�*�W][t?dg�^efh`s�hk��l9]

Å�����qÆ >ud^lc�

Page 13: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

������

������

������

������

��������

� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �

������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

���������������������������

p BA

v

target

B’

p’

target’

p BA

p’B’

v

target

target’

λ

λ

�>ef��r*h`�W�*� � d]`efd�Zgd^l�]`�*�u]k�^h_��a](b2defZy]?d^i�ah(]_e}�5� M�][tvdqs���j`�aj

�����q��ud^lc�

Page 14: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�^h_�%d�Z�dh�i�ah_o\Z,���^hW� sad�x}xfefj`efd�Z\s�dr*h_j`�~Gef]I�^sa]_jO��j�� sad�r*Zy]`p*d^t(Z�]`dg]_�0�^]�sadxfxfefj`efdZ#~t(�*efs{��efjWsad�h`h`��sa]q�0���0��iye}d�h��RY9l�]_�*�\��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j%�^h_�gZ*����h%]_�*�aefh b0d�e}Zy]Wd�l;s�x}d�j`�aj_]g�^by�b*h`dy�^s{�>~,e}]?���]`j(x��^h_���d�Z*xfoqe�l"]`�,�ao\��h`�W�^sa]_r0�^xfxfo saxfdj`�I]_dqdZ*�W�^Z,d]`�,�ah�~*��Z*pRh`�a�R�^efZ*j�^b*b,h`db,h`e��^]_�axfogj`�R�^xfx*d�]`�*�ah_t(efj`��

Z*�u�­��tMefj�]_�0�^]I]_�*efj��5���^j_r*h`�q�^xft(��oyj��efi��ajW�^Z�ef�g�5�ap*e��^]_��p0��Z*���h�Z,���^h?��ah`dt(�*�aZ�]_�*���^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajq�0��i��gZ*���^h`xfo e}p,�aZy]`efs��^x(i��axfdysaef]`ef�aj��±��jg�2�{lnd�h`�~?t?��� pPxfefw�5]`�*�p0�^Z,��ah�e}Z5]`�*efj(s���j`�W]_dq�0�Ih_dr*���*xfogefZyi�ah_j`�axfogb,h`db2dh_]`efdZ2�^xG]`d ]`�,�aefh�j`��b0�^h{�^]`efd�ZYMytv�s��^Z�j`d�xfi� ]`�*efjIb*h`d��*xf�a� �yo��^p,p*efZ*�\�À]`�ah_� d�l �

A C A]`dR]`�,�%�5���^j_r*h`� M#r*Zyl9dh`]_r*Z0��]`�axfoy~

p*defZ*�uj`dW�axfef�gefZ0��]`�aj�]_�*�(Z*efsa��h_�ax��^]_e}d�Z*j`�,e}bq�2�a][t?�a�aZ5]`�*efj?�g����j`r*h_���^Z*pq]_�*��]_e}�5�vxf�{l9]lndh(]_�*�IsadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah(]_dg�^sa]��� b0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xfx}o±�5dh`��j`��h`efdr*j�b*h`d��*xf�a� efjR]`�*��efZ0���*efxfe}][o±d�l%]`�*efj���xf�dh_ef]`�*��]_d

b*h`d��{�asa]5l���hgefZy]`d�]`�,�Rlnr*]_r*h`�� Y[]gt(efxfx(p*�a]_�asa]��^xf�5dj`] Z*d p*e �­�ah_�aZ*sa���2�a][t?�a�aZ>~©lnd�h�a½*�^�5b*xf�~�][tvd�b0��e}h_j%d�lO��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j%t(ef]`� ]`�*�Rj{�^�g�5h`�ax���]`efi�5i�axfdysaef]`ef�aj�~c]`�,�g�2h`j`]qd�lt(�*efs{� ��h`�qdZ��qs�dr*h_j`�g]_dRsadxfxfefp*�WefZ��2i� �gefZyr*]`�aj��*]_e}�5�~G�^Z*p�]`�,�qj`�asad�Z*p�]`dRb0��j`j���^s{��d�]`�*��h(t(e}]_���W�5e}xf�(d�l�j_�ab0��hk�^]_efdZ>�

A�� ��C(EGF�¹�K�� F"QRC J�Lqº\C(X�E

���� O���� P �EV���� P �E�����+VR�&��� Q+� ��cb2dj`]_r*x��^]_�cj`�ai��ahk��x0�^efh_b*x��^Z*�{�[b0��e}h_jGefZO�©i�^h_e}��][o�d^l2j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,jGt(�*efsk� �^h`��j`d�5�at(�0��]�a½ysa�ab*]_efdZ0��xGe}Z5]`�ah_�gjcd�l"]_�*��!yr0��x}ef][o d^l>b2�ah`efxGb2dj_�ap>�-�yefZ*sa�Id�r*hvi��h`efdr,jcj`oyj`]_�a�gj�lnd�hp*�a]_�ah`�5e}Z,e}Z,��e}�5�g�ap,e¼��]`�5p0�^Z*���ah\��xfx�b*r*h_b0d�h`]R]`d �0���g���^j`r,h`efZ*��]`�,��j{�^�g�R]_�*efZ*�0~tv� �*d�b0�q]_�0�^]I]`�,�ao�t(efxfx"�^��h`�a�qd�Z�t(�*efs{��j_ef]`r0��]`efdZ*j�b0d�j`�q]_�*�%��h`����]`�aj_]Wef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�p0�^Z,��ah��cY[](t?dr*xfp\��xfj`d �0�IZ*efsa�We�l�]`�*�aoR�^��h`�a�ap�t(e}]_�gd�r*h(efZz]_r*ef]`efdZ,jvd�Z\]_�*�Ij`r*����asa]��Y[Z ]`�*�©lndxfxfd^t(efZ*�(j`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z*j�~��xfx0�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj��gd^i��ct(ef]`�qj_b0�a��pg��!yr0��x*]`d�]y����wyZ*d]_j�~

dhc�^�2dr,]��,Æ �;ln�a�a]cb2�ahcj_�asad�Z*p>����efh_b*x��^Z*��I � j�efZ*ef]`e��^x�b0d�j`ef]`efdZue}jc��x}t(��oyj"��]"]_�*�?dh`ef��e}Z#���efh`b,x¼��Z*� � � jvb2dj_ef]`efdZ>~yefZÀln�a�a]�~0�^Z,pg]`�,�O��Z*�xf�aj���j`j_dzs�e¼��]`�apR]_dq]`�*�Ii��x}dysaef]_e}��j(t(e}xfx2�0��efi��Z\�2�axfd^tW�Æ��� ������������������������! #"$�&%'"�(�(��*)+�,"-�/.G��e}h_b*x��^Z*��II�*���^p*efZ*� +10��#��efh`b*x���Z*� � �*����py�efZ*�/K32�+10©lnh_d� � �������,~ ���a�

>,�� ����������������4"�5�(��*6$7��4%8"$(�(,�9):��"$��.G��efh`b,x¼��Z*��II�,���^p*efZ*�<; +=0^�>��efh`b*x��^Z,� � �*����py�efZ*�/K ��+10©lnh_d� �n�������,~ ���a�

�,��>?����(,�$��@A�,����."��efh`b*x��^Z,�+I �*���^p,e}Z,� +=0�#��efh`b,x¼��Z*� � �*����p*efZ*� +10©lnh_d��� > ] ���*~<�����]2��BC(�DE���F�G��(�"����E):�9����.I��efh_b*x��^Z*�5I��,���^p*efZ*� +=0� ��efh_b*x��^Z*� � �*����p*efZ*� +10ulnh_d�

�8�*~<>G] �����a�,�HE�����I��"�����@=J�������K85�D�@A������.(��e}h_b*x��^Z*��IÀ�*���^p,e}Z,� +10��v��efh`b*x��^Z,� � �*���^p,e}Z,�

L�+10�l9h`d� � >G] ���,~ �`��>������a��,�HE�����I��"�����@=J�������K85�D�@A������.(��e}h_b*x��^Z*��IÀ�*���^p,e}Z,� +10��v��efh`b*x��^Z,� � �*���^p,e}Z,�K � + 0 l9h`d� � ] ] ���,~ �9>*Æ������a�

Å�����qÆ ] d^lc�

Page 15: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�,��� ��)A)+�,��� ��@ � ���*)+@3�-��%'�$."��e}h_b*x��^Z*��I �*����p*efZ*� + 0 ����efh_b*x��^Z*� � �*���^p,e}Z,� KA2 + 0l9h`d� �`��������*~ � ���������a�

�,��B!��KA �� 7�@A7�K8���������! #"$� %8"$(,(��9):��"��C.>��efh`b*x��^Z,�+I �*���^p,e}Z,� +10��>��efh`b*x��^Z,� � �*����py�efZ*�/K32�+10©lnh_d� � �����������*~<���a�

$,��BC(�DE���F� ����K8��(�(,��( .���efh`b,x¼��Z*� I��*���^p*efZ*� +=0� ��efh`b*x���Z*� � �,���^p*efZ*� +=05lnh_d��8�*~fÆ����������a�

Æ �,��� �,�$��@ �����$(,��)'.���efh_b*x��^Z*� I��,���^p*efZ*� +=0�Ä��e}h_b*x��^Z*� � �*����p*efZ*� ����+10Àlnh_d��_Æ��������,~<���a�

ÆÆ���� ��%8�����,����.>��efh`b,x¼��Z*��I��*����p*efZ*� +=0�#��efh_b*x��^Z*� � �*���^p,e}Z,��K32 +=0�l9h`d� � �,~ �����������Æ >,��� ��%8�����,����.­��efh`b*x��^Z,� I��*���^p*efZ*��K ��+10��G��efh`b,x¼��Z*� � �*���^p,e}Z,�; +10"lnh`d�� �n�������,~<���a�Æ��,��� ��%8�����,����.>��efh`b,x¼��Z*��I��*����p*efZ*� KA2 + 0 �>��efh`b*x��^Z,� � �*����p*efZ*� + 0 l9h`d� � �������*~<�����

����<N � V0Q+��� Q�S8�&TUP O�VF� ��PR� ���s���Zgb*r,]��^ZqefZy]`r*ef]`efi��(b0�^h_]`e��^xGd�h`p*�ah_efZ*�%d�Zq]`�*�Ief�g�5�ap*e��^]_�cp0��Z*��ah(b,h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap��yo]`�*��j`��j_e}]_r0�^]_efdZ*j�� �yiyefdr*j_x}o�]`�,�\][t?d�ef�gb2�aZ*p,e}Z,�\s�dxfxfe}j_efdZ*j%��h`�5tvd�h`j`]�~ct(ef]`� ]`�*��*����py��d�Zqsadxfxfefj`efdZ �2�aefZ*�W�ai��aZgt?dh_j`��]_�0�^Zq]_�*��d��*xfe !zr,�vsad�xfx}efj_e}d�Z>~��jc�\��Z*�ar*i��ah`efZ*�IefZ]`�*��lnd�h`�5�ahcs���j`�It(efx}x2��i�^efx*]`�,���^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj?xf�aj`j����(�*�IZ*�a½y]?�gdj_]cp0��Z*��ah_dr*j?j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Zefj(]`�*�IdZ,��]_ef]`xf�apg�c��e}xf�y�^]`efZ*� M^e�l"j_d�g��]`�*efZ*�Ws��^r*j_�aj���e}h_b*x��^Z*� � ]`d j`xfd^t�p*d^t(Z5j`ef�Z*e��*�s��^Zy]_x}oy~�]`�*�ah_�Wefjvi��ah`oqxfef]`]_xf��]`�2�^](�^efh`b*x���Z*�+I s��^Z5p*d ]`dq��idefpg�usadZ��0efsa]����(�*��lnd�r*h`]_�j`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z�efjIj`ef�gefx��^h(]_dR]`�*�q]_�*efh`p>~#�a½ysa�ab*]ut(e}]_���5dh_�%�R�^Z*�ar,i�ah{�^�*efxfef][oz���(�*�qZ*�a½y]][tvd5j`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z*j?ln����]`r*h_�³�Àj`efZ*�xf�Ib2defZy]�]`�,h`dr,��Rt(�*efs{���0d�]`����efh`b*x��^Z,�aj�b0��j`j�t(e}]_�*efZdZ*��j`�as�dZ*pRd^l����^s{�5d]`�,�ah Mye�l>�2d]`�5j`b2�a�ap*jI�^Z*p5p*efh`�as�]`efdZ*j(�^h_����x}]_�ah`��p\efZq]_�*�It(h`dZ,�t;��oy~y]`�,�ah`� sadr,x}p��0�Wj_�ah`efd�r*j�]_h`dr,�*xf�� �yef]`r0��]`efdZ�� t(efxfxG]`hk��Z*j[l9dh`�DefZy]`dqj`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z�Æe�l;ef]IefjWef�Z*d�h`�ap�lndhI]_dzdRxfdZ,�0�q��h`d�r*�*xf� sadr*xfp��0�^b,b0�aZ�efZ�j`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z*j ���^Z*p $5dZ*xfoe�l��0d�]`���^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj �^h`�g��xfx}d^t?�ap�]`d�i��a�ah j`ef�Z,e¯�2s��^Zy]`xfo�efZ�]_�*�gt(h_dZ*��p,e}h_�asa]_e}d�Z*j��RY[Zj`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z�Æ �,~*�^efh`b,x¼��Z*� � tvd�r*xfpqZ*����h`xfoq�0��i�I]_d%]_r*h`Z��^h_dr*Z,pg]`d �\��w�(]_h`dr,�*xf�~0��Z*pefZ�]_�*�%x���j`]�]_�*h`���qj`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,j�~G�2d]_� ��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�t?dr*xfp��0��i��W]`dR]_r*h`Z��^h_dr*Z*p�lnd�h��^Zyop0�^Z,��ah�]`dq�^h`efj_� �¥e[� ���}~y]_�*�ah_�Wefj(Z*d%p2�^Z*���ah���];��x}x[�<�

�����xfj`dq�ai��x}r2�^]`��p\]_�*�Ief�g�g��p*e��^]`�(p2�^Z*���ah(b*h`��j`�aZy]`��p��yog���^s{��j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z>~yr*j_e}Z,��^xfx>d�lv]`�,�%�^xf�d�h`ef]`�,�gj?b*h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap�efZ�]_�*� b*h`�as��ap*efZ*�Rj`�as�]`efdZ*j�~G�a½ysa�ab,]�l9dh�]_�*� j`b0��sa�{�]`ef�g���^xf�d�h`ef]`�*��~�lnd�hgt(�*efs{�Äe}]5t;��jgefZyln���^j`ef�*xf��]_d �0Z*pU�^b*b*h_db*h_e��^]`��sadZ*j_]k��Zz]_j�efZ]`�*����x}xfd�]`]`��p�]_e}�5��R�(�*�5hk�^Z,wzefZ*��j%]_�*�ao�b*h_dyp*r*sa�ap±�^h_�gh`��b0d�h`]`��p�efZ�]k�^�,x}��Æ����(�*�b*h`d��0�^�,e}xfefj`]_efs��g��]`�*dypg�,�ah`�Wr,j`�aj�]`�*�W�5�a]`h_efs

p0��Z*���h 1 sadxfxfefj`efdZ*jK +�+ +�+W]_h`e��^xfj � K��+ Z*����h(�gefj`j_�ajK + + +�+I]`h_e��^xfj(

�(�*�?saxfdj`��� ��b*b*h`dy�^s{� �g�a]_�*dyp��,�ah`�?r*j`��jc]`�*��sadZ*j_]k��Zz]_j � � 1��+uln�a�a]^~ �  1�Wj_�asad�Z*p*j~� . 1 ( +�� Z�  ~��n��Z*p�p,e}j_b*x���oyj�]`�,�%ef�g�q��p*e��^]`��p0�^Z,��ahIi�^xfr*�ue}Z�r*Z*ef]`j�d^l � *�*�*�* Z �ln] �<��(�*�aj_�WsadZ,j`]k��Zy]`j�j_�a�a� ]_dq�efi��h`����j`dZ2�^�*xf�Ih`�aj_r*xf]`j��

��RZ*d]_��ef�5�g�ap*e���]_�axfo�]_�0�^]R�2d]`� ]`�*��b,h`d�2�^�*efxfefj`]`efs���Z*p±]`�*��saxfdj_�{�`�^b*b*h_dz��sk��gdyp*�axfjc�R�^]_sk�5r*bgi��ah`oqt?�axfxGt(ef]`�5dr*h?efZz]_r*ef]`efi��hk��Z*wye}Z,�j�~�]`�,dr*���gZ*d�]vb0��h`]_e}s�r*x��^h`xfo

�����q�ud^lc�

Page 16: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�yef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z Y[Zy]`r,e}]_efdZ ��h`efi Å�h`d�� �?xfdj`������b*b Gd��z��h`ef]`�*�5efsÆ Æ > �)I � Æ+� $�$G] ��� >�� �*��� ��� �*� +�_�<> ���> > > �)I � > � ��� ����� Æ/�9�*� ����� �*� +�_�<> ���� � $*� � ��� ] �n� ����� �*� � >*�<����� Æ �,� +� ���] ] $*� � ��� � � $���� �*� � >*�<����� Æ �,� +� ��� ,� ]0� �`Æ � � ] � $�� ��_Æ� �*Æ�� > �`�<>���� ,� ]0� �`Æ � � �`Æ��*Æ���� ���_Æ�fÆ >�� Æ �`�<> $��� �,� $*� � ��� ÆÆ � ��� $��8�*�<> ��� �`�<����� � > �)I � � � > ���� Æ � �`�<���,Æ � � �`�<�������$ �,� $*� � ��� � �`Æ���� ���8�*�<> � ��� Æ �,� +� ���Æ�� Æ�� $*� � ��� ÆÆ � ��� ���8�*�<>����� � �`�<���Æ�Æ Æ�> $*� � ��� ÆÆ � ��� Æ > � ��� Æ �,� +� ���Æ�> Æ�> $*� � ��� ÆÆ � ��� Æ > � ��� Æ �,� +� ���Æ�� Æ�> $*� � ��� ÆÆ � ��� Æ > � ��� Æ �,� +� ���

�c�^�*xf�gÆ��v�(�,�Wp0�^Z,��ah_j�efZ�]_�*�Wj_e}]_r0�^]_efdZ*j�b*h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap�efZ�j_�asa]_e}d�ZPÆ��*�fÆ~*��j�h{�^Z*w��ap��yo]`�*�ui�^h`efd�r*j;��xf�dh_ef]`�*�5j��

j`d t(ef]`�qdZ,���^Z*d�]`�*�ah����(�*��]_h`efiye��^x*�5�a]`�*dypq�^Z*pq]_�*��xfd��z�^h_ef]`�*�5e}s�p*�ah`efi��]`efi�?�g�a]_�*dyp�0d�]`�5sad�5b0�^h_�v�qr*s{� xf�aj`j�l���id�hk���*xfoz�2�(�*efjcefjcZ*du�h`���^]?j`r*h_b*h`efj`��~*�^jct?���0��i����^xfh`���^p*oZ*d]_�apg]_�0�^]�]`�*�(]_h`efiye¼��xy�g�a]_�*dyp%efjv�Ih{�^]_�*�ahcb2dydhc�5���^j_r*h`����Z*pq]`�0��]c]`�,�(x}d��z��h`ef]`�*�5efsp*�ah_e}i��]`efi�up*dy�ajIb0dydh_xfogt(�*�aZ��2d]`���^efh`b*x���Z*�aj��2��i�WZ*���^h`xfoR]`�,�Wjk���g�Wi��axfdzs�e}]_ef�aj M2efZ]`�*h_�a�Wd�l"]`�,��]_�*efh`]_�a�aZ�j_e}]_r0�^]_efdZ*j?r*Z*p*��h(�a½*�^�gefZ0��]`efdZ#~^�0d�]`���^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj?�0��i����a½*�^s�]`xfo]`�*��jk�^�5��i�axfdysaef][oz� ��,�aZW]`�,dj`��j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,j>�^h`��h`�a�5d^i�ap>~{]_�*�cxfd�y�^h_e}]_�*�gefsGp*��h`efi�^]_e}i��sadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p*j�!yr*ef]`�It?�axfxG]`dq]`�,��efZy]`r,e}]_efi��h{�^Z*wyefZ*�2�

��gZ,d]`���^jqt?�axfx�]`�2�^]q]`�,��saxfdj_�{� ��b*b*h_dz�^s{���5dyp*�ax(�^�h_�a�ajRt(ef]`�±dr,hqe}Zy]_r*ef]`efdZ�^xf�gd�j`]c��½���sa]`xfoy~y�a½ysa�ab*]©lndh(j_t(ef]`s{�*efZ*� ]`�*�Wh{�^Z*wyefZ*��jvd�l"j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z*j(�q�^Z*p�Æ �,�>��j(tv��a½yb0��sa]Wi��h`oRxfe}]_]`xf�I�ai��Zz]_r0�^x�p0��Z*���h(lnh_d�Dj`ef]`r0��]`efdZ�Æ��*~0��Z*p�i��ah`oRxfef]`]`xf�Ief�g�5�ap*e��^]_�p0�^Z,��ah#lnh_d�Uj`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�ZW�*~�]`�*efj�efj>b2�ah`�2�^b*jcZ,d]>j_d��*ef�I�(p*����x[�>Y[ZW]_�*�aj_�(j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,j�~�]`�*�saxfdj_�{� ��b*b*h_dz�^s{���5dyp*�axGp*dy�ajIi��h`oRtv��x}x#�yogdr,h�efZy]`r*ef]`efd�Z>�- ��IZ*d�]`�WefZRb0�^j_j`efZ*�q]_�0�^]]`�*�qj_b0�^s��{��]_ef�g�W�5dzp,�ax�tvd�r*xfp�b*h`d��0�^�,x}oRp*dR�ai��aZ��2�a]`]_�ah��IY[]It?dr*xfp�sa�ah`]{�^efZ*xfo�h{�^Z*wj`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z����^jW�5dh_�%p0��Z*���h`dr,j%]_�0�^Z�j_e}]_r0�^]_efdZ�]3�9�^�h_�a�aefZ*��t(ef]_��dr*hWefZy]`r,e}]_efdZ ��~�^Z*p#~>�^j�e}]Iefj�i��ah`o�saxfdj`��x}oRh_�ax��^]`��p�]`dg]_�*� saxfdj`��� ��b*b*h`dy�^s{���gdyp*�ax[~*�5ef��y](tv��x}x�h{�^Z*w�^xfxG]`�,��d�]`�*��h�j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z*j?e}p,�aZy]`efs��^xfxfoy�

AWA B�C��?LWJ�J�C(KRºRHIF"¹�LWKgE

� �� � TU���&TBWUV0Q�S�PR� � ��WUP���ET+�?��W ��P �U� P�� ��I�0��i�Ib*h_�aj`�aZy]_�ap>~GefZR]`�*�ub*h`�as��ap*efZ*�Rj`�as�]`efdZ*j�~,�0i�Ij`��b0�^h{�^]`� �gdyp*��x}j?]`�2�^](s���Z��0�r*j`��p�lndhIb*h_�ap*efsa]`efZ*�R]_�*�qp0�^Z,��ahIb2dj`��p��zo��5�efi��aZ��^efh_b*x��^Z*�{�[b0��e}h�~G�^Z*p��efi��Z��*h_ef�{lp*efj`sar,j`j`efd�Z*j(d^l�]`�*�aefh?j`]_h`�aZ*��]`�*jI�^Z*pqt?����wzZ,�aj`j_�aj��?Y[Zgd�h`p*��h(]`d d�*]{�^efZg��!yr0�^Zy]_e}]{�^]_e}i���g����j`r*h_�qd^lv]_�*�g�^s�sar*hk��sao�d^l(����sk���5dyp*�ax[~2tv� sah`���^]`��p�]`�,e}h_]`�a��Z�jk���gb*xf�Ws��^j`��j³��Z*p

Å�����qÆ �ud^lc�

Page 17: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

sad�5b0�^h_�ap�����s{� �5dzp,�ax � j hk��Z*wyefZ*��d�lO]_�*��h`�ax��^]_efi��p0��Z*���h\d�lW]`�*�aj_��s��^j_�ajR]`d dr*hd^t(ZRe}Zy]_r*ef]`efi�Ihk��Z*wyefZ*�%d�lc]`�*�Wp2�^Z*���ah(d^lc����sk��j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ#���(�*� � � �g��h`h`d�h��2�a][t?�a�aZ]`�*� �gdyp*��x>hk��Z*wyefZ*�jI�^Z*p�efZy]`r,e}]_efi�Ihk��Z*wye}Z,�j�t(�^j�sad�5b*r*]_�apRlnd�h�����sk���gdyp*�ax[�(�(�*���h`efiye¼��xc�^Z*p �d�z��h`ef]`�,�gefs ���ah`efi��]`efi� �gdyp*�axfjI�2d]`���2�^p � � ���ah`h_dh i�^xfr*�aj%���0d^i���*�<�*~yj_r*����aj`]_efZ*�q]`�0��]v]_�*�aj_�W�gdyp*�axfj?�0��i�Ij_e}��Z*e��0s���Zz]?p*e �G�ah`�aZ,sa�aj�lnh`d���dr,hvefZy]`r*ef]_e}i��Z*d]_efdZgd�lcp0�^Z*���ah��

�� p*dRZ*d]Ih`��sad�5�g�aZ*p�]`�*�q]_h`efiye¼��x��gdyp*�ax[~2p*r*�q]_d\]_�*�q�\��Z*e�ln�aj_](l���x}j_�a�*dydyp�d�lef]`j(�gd�j`]c�2�^j`efsW�^j_j`r*�5b*]`efd�Z �n�^Z5�aZyiye}h_dZ*�5�aZy]ct(ef]`�5Z*dqr*Z*sa��h`]k��efZz][o �(��Z*pgef]`j�l���e}xfr*h_�]`dqb2�ah[l9dh`�Djk��]`efj[l[�^sa]_dh`efxfoqdZR]_�*�Ijk�^�5b*xf��j_�a]��

��v��x}j_d�p*d�Z*d]�h_�asad�5�g�aZ,p�]_�*�?x}d��z��h`ef]`�*�5efs>p*�ah_efi�^]`efi��c�gdyp*�ax[~��*r*]�dr*h�h_���^j_dZ*j�^h_�q�gdh_�%s�d�gb,x}��½­�u�(�*�qxfd�y�^h`ef]_�*�gefsIp*�ah_e}i��]`efi� �gdyp*��x"efZ�ef]`jIb*h`��j`�aZy]ulndh_��p*dy�ajZ*d]ub0�ah lndh_��t?�axfx�dZ�]`�*�qj{�^�gb,x}�uj`�a]��q��xf]`�,dr*����t?�%�2��i� �*h`ef�{�0o�p*efj`s�r*j`j_�ap�t(��oyj]`�0��](]`�*��xfd�z��h`ef]`�,�gefsvp,�ah`efi�^]_efi�(�gdyp*��x0sad�r*xfpg�2�Ie}�5b*h`d^i��ap>~^ef]?s��^Z5�0�W��h`�r,�apg]_�0�^]]`�*� �gdyp*��xGtvd�r*xfp\j_]`efxfxG�0� xf�aj`j�p*�aj_e}h{�^�*xf�W]_�0�^Z�d]`�,�ah`j��(�(�*�Wxfd�y�^h_e}]_�*�gefs(p*��h`efi�^]_e}i���gdyp*�axG�^b,b0����h`j?]`dW�2�a�0��i��Ie}Zq�qr,sk� ]`�,��j{�^�5�v�R�^Z*Z*��hv�^j?tvd�r*xfpg�I�yr*�\��Z%d�b0��hk�^]_dht;��]`s{�*efZ*� dZ*xfog�u�h{�^b*�*efs���x0p,e}j_b*x���o�M]_�zr,j��^Zyo%ef�5b*h`d^i��a�g�aZy]�t?dr*xfpqj`]_efx}xGh_�aj`r,x}](efZR��gdyp*�ax2]`�2�^]?�aj`j_�aZy]`e��^xfxfo%�2�a�0��i��apRxfe}w����Wi��ah`o l[�^j`]?�yr*�\��Z%d�b0��hk�^]_dh��� ��(�a½yb0�as�]��^Zyo�gdyp*�ax�]`dR�0��i�qj_d�5� �_�*xfefZ*p�j_b0d�]`j���~#wye}Z,p*jWd^l(p0��Z*��ahut(�*efsk��ef]Wt(efxfx#l��^efx�]`d�p*�a]`��sa]lndh(xfd�Z*��ah�]`�0��ZR�\�^Zyo d]_�*�ah��5dyp*�axfj���Y[Z\���aZ*�ah{�^x[~0��Z��^xf�ah_](�yr*�\��Zgdb2�ah{�^]`d�h�sad�r*xfpsad�5b*xf�a�g��Zz]2]`�,�c�gdyp*�ax^�yo�p*�a]`��sa]`efZ*��j`d�5��p0�^Z*���ah`j#efZ�]_�*�aj_�c�*xfefZ*pIj`b2d]`j��>�(�,�c�*xfefZ*pj`b2d]_j�d�lc]`�*� xfd�z��h`ef]`�,�ge¯s�p*�ah_e}i��]`efi�I�5dzp,�ax[~yr*Zylnd�h`]`r,Z0�^]_�axfoz~,t(e}xfxG�2�%j_�0�^h_�ap��yoR]`�*��yr*�\��Zqdb2�ahk��]`dh�~0��Z*pRj`dq�*�Is���Z*Z*d](s�d�gb,x}���g�aZy]�ef]vefZR]`�*efj?�\��Z*Z*�ah��0Z�d^t?�ai�ah�~ytv�p*d�h_�asad��g�g��Z*pIj`]`r,p*oWd^l*]_�*�vxfd��z�^h_ef]`�*�5e}sGp,�ah`efi�^]_efi�c�5dzp,�ax[~ab0��h`]`efsar,x¼��h`xfo�efZWh_�ax��^]_e}d�Z]`dqd�]`�*�ah��gdyp*�axfj�����Z*p,�ah`j_]k�^Z,p*efZ*�gef]`j?�G��t(jvj_�*dr*xfpR�*�axfbRxf���^pR]_d³��Z\r,Z*p*�ah_j`]k��Z*p*efZ*�d^lc�yr*�\��Zqdb2�ahk��]`d�h`j �,tv���^wyZ*�aj_j`�aj��

���p*d(h`��sad�5�g�aZ*pI�^Zyo(d^l*]_�*�cd]_�*�ah#]`�*h_�a�v�5dyp*�axfj�~{�*d^t?�ai��ah��#�(�*�aoW�^h_�v�^xfx^�0��j`�apdZWj_�aZ*j_e}�,x}�(�^j_j`r*�5b*]`efd�Z*j�~��^Z*pW�2d]_�W]`�,�vb*h_d�0���*efxfe}j_]`efsc�^Z*pu]`�*�?saxfdj_�{� ��b*b*h_dz�^s{�W�5dypy��axfjq�\��]`s{�*�ap�t?�axfxvt(ef]_��dr,h%efZy]`r*ef]_e}d�Z�t(�*�aZ±t?�g]`��j`]`��pP]_�*�a� dZ ]`�*�5jk�^�5b*xf�qj`�a]�~oye}��x}p,e}Z,� � � � ��h`h`d�hvi��xfr*�ajc�2�axfd^tMÆ� ,� ��(�0��i�(Z,d%h_���^j_dZgZ,d]c]_d%�2�axfef�ai�(]_�0�^]?]`�*�j`b0��sa�{�[]`ef�g�u�g�a]_�*dyp\t?dr,x}pR�0��i��Wb2�ah[lnd�h`�5�ap��^]�xf����j`]I�^j�t?�axfx[~*�0��p�ef]��2�a�aZ�ln����j`ef�*xf�]`d �0Z,p ��b*b*h_db*h_e¼��]`�Isad�Z*j`]{�^Zy]`j�e}Z5]`�*�u�efi�aZ5]`ef�g���Y[Z�b0��h`]`efsar,x¼��h�~�t?�q�gd�j`]W�*ef���*xfo�h`�as�d�g�5�aZ*p�]`�*�5saxfdj_�{� ��b*b*h_dz�^s{� �g�a]_�*dyp>�RY[]`j

hk��Z*wye}Z,�jqd^lIef�g�q�ap*e���]`� p0�^Z*���ahq�\��]`s{��r,bPb2�^h`]_efsar*x��^h_x}o�t?�axfx(t(e}]_�±dr*h efZz]_r*ef]`efdZ#~oye}��x}p,e}Z,�\�^Z � � ���ah_h`d�hWi�^xfr*�Wd�l;d�Z*xfo�Æ�<>�,�WY[Z��^p*p*ef]_e}d�Z>~2]`�*efjI�g��]`�*dyp�sad�5b*r*]`��jp0�^Z,��ah(�5���^j_r*h`�aj���](�*xfefZ*p*efZ*�xfoIl[�^j`](j_b0���ap*j�~G��x}xfd^t(efZ*�Ief]v]_dqsadZ,j`]k��Zy]`xfogr*b2p0��]`�I]`�*�p0�^Z,��ah �g����j`r*h_�ajIlnd�hW�ai��ah`o���e}h_b*x��^Z*����b0��efh�efZ�h_���^x��[]`ef�g��5�>efZ0��xfx}oy~2ef]`jW�5�as{�0�^Z*efj_�gj�^h_�%efZy]`r*ef]_e}i��%�^Z,p�saxf���^h�~Gj`dR]_�0�^]�sadZy]`h_dxfxf�ah`jI�R��ogefZy]`r*ef]`efi��axfoq]k�^w��%ef]�e}Zy]_d\�^s�sadr*Zy]t(�*�aZ�b,x}d�]`]_e}Z,�%sad�r*h`j_�aj��

� ��<N � TUPYQX�ET+��� �WX�&T+P �&����PR� ��Q �&PY����PRQ+P�� ��I�0��i��b*h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap�j`�ai��ahk��x>�g��]`�*dyp*j?lnd�hv�5���^j_r*h`efZ*�up0�^Z*���ah MyefZR���Z*�ahk��x[~yt(�*�aZR]`�*�p0�^Z,��ahcefj�]`dydI�*ef��#~^]`�*�(]_d^tv��h"�qr,j`]>efZy]`��h`i��Z*����(�*h_�aj`�*d�xfpqi�^xfr*�aj#lnd�h"p2�^Z*���ahct(�*efs{�j`�*d�r*xfp�lndh_sa�c]`�,�c]`d^t?�ah>]_d(efZz]_�ah`i��aZ*�ct(efxfx^d�yiyefdr*j_xfo(i�^h`o(�2�^j`��pWr*b2dZIt(�*efs{�W�g����j`r*h_�efj(r*j`�ap#� ��d�g��d^l�]`�*�aj_�%�5dyp*�axfjvd��­��h(t;��oyj(]`dq�5���^j_r*h`�I�2d]_�\��i�aZy]`r2�^x>p2�^Z*���ah���Z*pef�g�g��p*e��^]`��p0��Z*���h�~�d]`�,�ah`jcd�Z*xfoWdZ,�vd�hc]`�*�(d�]`�*��h��� ��*��Z*�ai��hc�0d�]`�q�5���^j_r*h`�aj��a½ye}j_]�~

�����q��ud^lc�

Page 18: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

]`�*���ai��aZy]`r0��x�p0��Z*��ah5efjg]`�,��dZ*��]`�0��]gj`�,dr*xfp±�0��r*j`�ap#��Y9lW]`�*���ai��Zz]_r0�^x�p0�^Z,��ahefjq�*ef��*�ahq]_�0�^Z±j_d�g�R]_�*h`�aj_�*dxfp±i�^xfr*��~c]`�,�aZ�]`�,��]`d^t?�ahqt(efxfx?�O��i�aZy]`r2�^xfxfo��%�0��i��]`d�efZy]`�ah_i�aZ,����(�*efjqp*dy�ajqZ,d]qZ*�as��aj`j{�^h`efxfo±�g����Z�]`�0��]q]`�*��]`d^t?�ahq�qr*j`] efZy]`�ah_i�aZ*�ef�g�g��p*e��^]`��x}o�~y�*d^tv��i�ah��%Y9l(]`�,�%ef�g�5�ap*e��^]_��p0��Z*���hWefj�xfd^tU�aZ*d�r*��>~#]`�,�%]_d^tv�ahI�R��o�n��Z*p�j_�*dr*xfp �O]k�^w��q]`�*�5]`ef�g� ]`d�p*���^x?t(ef]`���5dh`�qb,h`�aj_j`efZ*��b*h`d��*xf�a�gj��0h_j`]�� ��*�aZ�5�g����j`r*h_�q�a½ye}j_]`jIl9dhIdZ*xfoRdZ,�qd^lv]_�*�q][tvdRwyefZ*p*jId^l(p0��Z*��ah�~>]_�*�aZ�d�yiyefdr*j_x}oR]_�0�^]�g����j`r*h_�I�qr*j`]?�0�Ir*j_�ap>��,dh?���^s{�Rd^lcdr,h(�gdyp*�axfj�~�t?���qr,j`]?p*�a]`��h`�gefZ*�I]_�*�Ih`�axf�ai��Zz](]_�*h`��j`�*d�x}pRi��x}r,�aj��Y[Z�]_�*��]_h`efiye¼��xv�5dyp*�ax[~�]`�*��dZ*xfo�i�^xfr*�ajg��h`� �*~fÆ~ ��Z*p#I2� �yiyefdr*j_xfo�]`�*�R]`d^t?�ah

s��^Z,Z*d] �0�R�a½yb2�asa]_�ap�]`d�efZy]`�ah_i�aZ*�5lnd�hW�ai��ah`o±�^efh`b*x���Z*�{�[b0�^efhWt(ef]`��p2�^Z*���ahq�g����j`r*h_��*� Z�]`�*� d]_�*�ah��0�^Z*p#~0ef]��qr*j`](efZy]`�ah_i�aZ,�%]_dgb*h_�ai�aZy]W�qZ,���^h ���5e}j_j�~,]`�0��Z*wyj�]`d5]`�*�j`�as�dZ*p���j`j_r*�gb*]_efdZgefZ5j`�asa]_efdZ��,���(�zr,j(]`�*�I]`�,h`�aj_�*dxfp�p0��Z*���h(i�^xfr*��efjWÆ��Y[Z�]_�*��b*h_d�0���*efx}efj_]`efsR�gdyp*�ax[~ct?��d�Z*xfo��0��i������5���^j_r*h`�5lnd�hg�ai��aZy]`r0��x�p2�^Z*���ah��

�(�0�^Z,wzj ]`d�]`�*�5j`ef�qr*x��^]_e}d�Z*j�efZ�j_�asa]`efd�Z Æ �,�fÆ~#tv�qs���Z���r*�aj`j ]`�2�^] �gdj_]Ij`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,jt(ef]`�RZ*d e}Zy]_r*ef]`efi�(p0��Z*���h(�efi�I�Wp0��Z*���h(hk�^]_efZ*�%xf�aj_j(]`�0��Z �� *�*�*�* ~*��Z*p��^xfx2j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,jt(ef]`���*ef���efZy]`r*ef]_e}i��Wp0��Z*��ahu�efi�%�5p0��Z*���h�h{�^]_e}Z,�\t?�axfx��h_���^]_�ahW]`�2�^Z �� *�*�*�* �W�(�yr*j�� *�*�*�* j`�a���gjWxfefw�q�5�dydyp �`j{��ln�&�q]`�,h`�aj_�*dxfp�i�^xfr*� M�e}]It(efxfx�s��^]_sk�±�^xfx��*ef��y�[efZy]`r*ef]`efi��{�p0�^Z,��ah�s��^j_�aj�~2�^j(t?�axfx>�^j(s���j`�ajIj`r,sk����j(j`ef]`r0��]`efdZ $ efZgj`��sa]`efdZ Æ �*�fÆ��Y[Z�]`�*�qsaxfd�j`�{�`�^b*b,h`dz��s{� ��Z*p�j_b0�^s��{��]_ef�g� �gdyp*�axfj�~2]_�*�ah`�5efjO�5Z0��]`r*h{�^xc�R�^b5lnh_d�

]`�*�q��i�aZy]`r2�^x�p0�^Z,��ahI]`dRp*efj_]k�^Z,sa�1�¥�efi��Z��yoR]k��wzefZ*�5]`�*�qh_�asaefb*h_dzs��^x(�a�uY9lv]`�*�qs�dh`h_�{�j`b2dZ*p,e}Z,��p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�5efjWxf�aj`j ]`�0��Z�j`d��g� h`����j`dZ2�^�*xf�gxf�aZ,�]`�#~>]_�*�aZ�]_�*�q]`d^t?�ah j`�*d�r*xfpefZz]_�ah`i��aZ*�� ���^�0��x}efZ*�y�^� )��#�^h_�r*�aj�]`�0��]���efh`b*x��^Z,�aj>j_�*dr*xfp �0�(�,dh`e ad�Zy]k�^xfxfo�j_�ab0��hk�^]_�ap�yo��qZ0��r*]`efs���x��gefxf�aj����c�^wyefZ*�q�*ef���^]��*efj�t?dh_p>~2tv� s���Z�j_�a]W]`�,�%]_�*h`�aj_�*dxfp�p0�^Z,��ahi�^xfr*��lndh��2d]_�%d�l­]_�*�aj`���gdyp*�axfj#��!yr0�^x*]_d �

. Z*� �>�(�,e}j�sadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p*j?]`dIefZz]_�ah`i��aZ*efZ*�Ie�l]`�*�I�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajct(efxfxy�ai��Zz]_r0�^xfxfo sad�5�vt(ef]`�,e}Zq�IZ0��r*]`efs���x*�gefxf�aj#d^l>dZ,���^Z*d�]`�*�ah�� �(*�d]`�]`�0��]ce�l­]_�*�ao sad�5�v]_d���a]`�*��hvefZ ]`�*��b0�^j_]�~�]`�*�aZq]_�*�(p0��Z*��ah��g����j`r*h_�(t(e}xfxy�2��Z*�a�y�^]_e}i���^Z*pRt?�Itvd�Z�� ]v�0��i��I]`dqefZy]`�ah_i�aZ*��� �Y[Z�]_�*�qxfd�z��h`ef]`�,�gefs�p*��h`efi�^]_e}i��W�gdyp*��x�~,tv� �0��i��%d�Z*xfo �5�5���^j_r*h`�Wd�lvef�g�5�ap*e��^]_�

p0�^Z,��ah��c�(�*�ah_�Ie}j��uZ0��]`r*h{�^x>�R�^b lnh_d��]_�*�Ief�g�g��p*e��^]`�?p0��Z*��ah(]_d%]_ef�g�/�9�^xfj`d �efi��aZ�yoq]k�^wyefZ*�W]_�*�Ih`�as�e}b,h`dys��^x(���c�(�yr*j?e¯l>]_�*�Isadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p*efZ*�q]_e}�5�(efjvxf�aj_jv]_�*�aZRj`d��g�(h`�����j`d�Z0�^�*xf�Wj_b0�^Z#~*t?�Wj`�*d�r*xfpRe}Zy]_�ah`i��aZ*���RY��?� )�)I�^h`��r*�aj�]`�0��]�> �gefZyr*]`�aj(efj�� Z0��]`r*h{�^x]`ef�g�?efZy]`�ah_i�^x[~^j`dIt?�(j`�a]?]`�,�(]`�*h_�aj`�*d�xfpg��!yr0��x*]`d �

 �5efZ �#�(�*efjcsadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p*j(]_d�efZy]`��h[�i�aZ,e}Z,�gdZ,x}o5e�l�]_�*�%��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�t(efxfxGsad�5��t(ef]_�*efZ �����uln���a]�d�lv]`�*��e}h�saxfdj_�aj`]W�^b,b*h`dy�^s{�t(ef]`�*efZg]_�*�WZ*��½z](][t?dq�gefZyr*]_�aj��

� ���� ����� �E����EP���� � ��� �E����EP���(]vj_d�5��b2defZy]�~�tv���qr*j`]�l[�^sa��]`�*��!yr*�aj_]`efdZ>~#� Z�d^t saxfdj`��s��^Z5][tvdq�^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj?���]v�2�{�lndh_�WefZy]`�ah_i�aZy]`efd�ZRlnh`d���]`�,�%]_d^tv�ah(s��^Z*Z*d�]�j{��i�W]_�*�a�Dlnh_d� �^](xf���^j_]�� Z*���^h[�[�gefj_j � �a��(�*�g�^Z,j`t?�ahW]`d�]`�*efj�!yr*�aj`]_efdZ�efjIsaxf���^h_x}o�h`��x¼��]`�ap�]_dR]`�*�qb0��]`�*judZ�t(�*efsk��]_�*�ao��^by�b*h`dy�^s{�ÄdZ*����Z*d]_�*�ah�� ���t(efx}x�b*r*]��^ZÄ�^b*b*h_d^½ye}�R�^]_�g�2dr*Z*pÄdZ ]`�*���^Z*j_tv��h\�yoh`��!yr*efh_e}Z,��]`�0��]g]`�,���^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj��cdh_ef�efZ0�^x?]`h{�a�{�as�]`dh_ef�ajRb*h`�ap,e}s�]\���*����py�[dZ±sadxfxfefj`efdZ#� ��*efxf�R]`�*�ah_���\��o��2��j`d��g�g]_hk�a���asa]`d�h`ef�aj5lnd�hqt(�*efsk�±]_�*���^Z,j`t?�ahqefjqx¼��h`���ah�~?ef]qs��^ZZ*�ai��ah��2�W�qr*s{�qx��^h_��ah��4�� :��8=�� ;�� � �4 4 :���=�����;��

�����q��ud^lc�

Page 19: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

��j_j`r*�5�R]`�0��]q���^s{���^efh`b,x¼��Z*�g�2�^jqi��x}dysaef][o i�ln�a��]qb0�ah5j`�as�dZ*p>~��^Z*p±]`�2�^]q����sk�s��^Z�]`r,h`Z %h{�^p*e��^Z,j�b2�ahIj`��sadZ*p#�? ��I�0Z,p�]_�*�%p,e}j_]k��Z*sa�qp3�¥e}Z�ln�a��]��I�^]�t(�*efsk������sk��^efh`b,x¼��Z*���qr,j`]cj_]k�^h_](]`r*h_Z*efZ*�0~y]_d%��Z*j`r*h_�W]`�2�^]?]`�*�W�^efh_sahk�mln]vp,d%Z*d�](b0�^j_jvt(ef]_�*efZg����sk�½qln���a]�d�l"����sk�Rd�]`�*�ahI�^](�^Zyog]_ef�g����d�p*d�j`d2~^tv���0h_j`]cZ*d�]`�?]`�0��]����^s{� ]`r*h_Z1�9�^j`j_r*�gefZ*��sadZ,j`]k��Zy]"]_r*h`Z,e}Z,��hk��]`� �"lndh_�gj

�^Z��^h_sqd^l;�5saefh`s�x}��� ��a]WhIp*�aZ,d]`�q]_�*�qsaefh`s�x}��� juhk�^p,e}r,j��/��e}Z,sa�q]`�*�qxf�aZ,�]`��d^l(�^Z��^h`sj`r*�,]`�aZ*p,�ap��yoR�^Z��^Z*��xf� @ efjv��efi�aZR�yogj � h @y~2tv�I]k��w�I]`�,�Wp*�ah_e}i��]`efi��]`dqd��*]k��e}Z5h ������8� ������8� � � i �#��*���½z](t?��Z,d]`�I]_�0�^](½ �¥]`�*�Ij`�,dh`]_�aj`]�p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�I�2�a][t?�a�aZ�]_�*�I][tvd saefh`saxf�aj&�(efj?��!yr0�^x]`dq]_�*�Ij`r*�Dd^l�]`�*�Ip*efj`]{�^Z*s���w5�0��][tv�a��Z�]`�*�Isa��Zz]_�ah`j�d^l�]`�*�W][t?d saefh`saxf�aj���Z*pR]`�*�I][t?dhk��p*efe��#w � ½ � >^i �#�

r

r

r

r

x/2

x/2d/2

d/2

θ

θ

�#efZ0�^xfxfoz~�tv��d�*j_�ah`i��W]`�0��]v]_�*�IefZ*ef]`e��^x2xfe}Z,��d^l#�0ef��y]cd�l"]`�,��][t?d b*x��^Z*�aj(efj?]k��Z*��aZy]]`d �0d�]`�5saefh`saxf�aj�~0�^Z,pg�*�aZ,sa�I][tvd h`ef��y]c]_h`e��^Z,�xf�aj(�^h`�©lndh_�g�ap#�"�,dhc���^s{�R]`h`e���Z*�xf�~�]`�*�xf�aZ*�]_�*j?d^l>]`�,��][t?dWxf�a��j;��h`��h � i �����Z*pgp ��>*~y�^Z*pq]_�*���yoyb2d]`��Zzr,j`�Iefjvw ��> � i �#�½ ��>*���(�yr*j(t?�W�^b*b,x}o ]`�,�%Å�oy]`�0���d�h`����Z\]_�*�ad�h`�a�D]`d d�*]{�^efZ�¿ ��� �Ã_ � ¿), � 0 �   � �Ã`Â��¿), � 0�Ã`Â����(�*efj(�efi�aj(r,j(p ��    � �� F� �*�d^t t?�gsad�Z*j`efp*��hq][tvd��^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajWt(ef]_��i��x}dysaef][o ]z���RwyZ*d]_j � �*Æ �,� � �Àln�a�a]qb2�ahj`�as�dZ*p>~*��Z*pq]`r,h`Z*efZ*�Wh{�^]_���Ip*���h`���aj � � � ����hk��p*e��^Z*j�b0�ah?j`��sadZ*p �n�Ij_]k��Z*p0�^h_p?�`][t?d^��gefZyr*]`�I]_r*h`Z �9�a�©Y[Z\d�h`p*��h�]_dq�aZ*j_r*h`� ]`�0��]�]_�*�%�^efh_sahk�mln]�p*dqZ,d]�b2�^j`j�t(ef]`�*efZ�����uln�a�a]d^l%���^s{��d]_�*�ah ��]`�,��j_]k�^Z,p0�^h_p ������p,�{�0Z*ef]`efd�ZPd�l³� �aZ,���^h5�gefj`j�� �a~�tv���^j`j_r*�g���t(efZ*�j_b0�^Z�d�l >����ul9�a�a]�~G��Z*p�]`�yr*j�]`�*�usa�aZy]`�ah_jWd^lc]_�*�³��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj(�qr*j`](�2�%���� � >����� ������ln���a]��^b0��h`]?]`d �aZ*j_r*h`�W]_�0�^]��OZ*���^h(�5efj`jcefj(��idefp*��p>� �Oe}i��aZg]_�*�aj_��i��xfr*�aj?d^l"½G~

Å�����qÆ $ud^lc�

Page 20: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

iG~0�^Z,p1�~0t?�Is��^xfsar,x¼��]`�Wp � � ��>*Æ©ln�a�a] � Æ�<� $uZ*�����(�yr*j�efZ\d�h`p*��h�]`dg��i�defp\� Z,���^h�gefj`j�~G�2d]`��b*efxfd]_j��qr,j`]�j_]k��h`]%�5]`r,h`Z��^]%�Àp*efj`]k��Z*sa�5d^l�Æ�� ��$qZ*� lnh`d�������s{��d�]`�*�ah���(�*efjcef�gb*xfef�aj#]`�0��]c]`�*��sadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah��qr*j_]"efp*��Zz]_e�lnoW]`�,��b*h_d�*xf�a� �^Z*pqsad��g�qr*Z,e}s��^]`���*efjsad�5�\��Z*p�]`d�]`�*�5b*efx}d�]`jWj_ef�Z*e��0s���Zy]`xfo��2�{lndh_�g]_�*efj%b2defZy]��5��j_j`r*�5e}Z,���R�\��½ye}� r*�p*�ax���oqd^lvÆ�Wj_�asad�Z*p*j(�2�a][tv���aZ�t(�*�aZ5]`�*�Isad�Zy]`h`d�xfx}��h � jvp,e}j_sad^i��h`oqd^l>]_�*�Ib*h`d��*xf�a����Z*p]`�*�Ib*efxfd]�� jch`�aj_b0d�Z*j`�u]`d e}]�~]_�*efjv��efi�aj?r*j(� ��jk��l9�a][oqp*efj`]{�^Z*sa� ��d�l��^b,b*h`d^½yef�\��]`�axfo��0i�Z0�^r,]`efs��^xG�5efx}��j�~�dhWÆ $uj`��sadZ*p,j�~2r*Zy]`efx>� �*����py�[dZRsadxfxfefj`efdZ#�

A�µ � C(HuE>·RT�¹�K���¸ULWJ��RX�C��g¹aF �

Y[Z d�h`p*��h�]`d �g����j`r*h_��]_�*��s�d�gb,x}��½zef][o d^l%]_�*��t?dh_wyx}dy�^p±l[�^sa�apÄ�yo �^ZÄ�^efhg]_hk��|gssadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah?�¥�c�+� �a~�tv�IZ*���ap�� �0�^j_e}s�r*Z*p*��h`j`]{�^Z*p,e}Z,�qd^l"]_�*�I]k��j`wyj(b0��h[lnd�h`�g��pg�yoq]`�*��c�+� �^Z*p��*d^t �*efj%���*efx}ef][oR]`dRb2�ah[l9dh`� ]_�*�aj`�R]{�^j`wyjWefj%� �­��sa]`�ap �yo�]_�*�qZyr*�q�0��h�d�l�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj�efZ%]_�*���^efh_j`b0��sa�(j`�as�]`dh��c��d�]_�0�^]��aZ*p>~�tv�?b*h_�aj`�aZy]?]`�*�?l9dxfxfd^t(e}Z,���^xf�d�h`ef]`�*��^jg���gdyp*�ax�lnd�h%]_�*�Rp*�asaefj`efd�Z�b*h_dzs��aj`j5r*Z*p*�ah_]k��w�aZ±�yo��^Z±�c�+� efZ�p*��]`�asa]_efZ*�P��Z*pj`d�x}iyefZ*� sadZ��0efsa]`j��

�c�+� ���asaefj_e}d�ZR��xf�d�h`ef]`�*��� ��s��^Zq]_�*�vh{�^p0��h�j`sah_�a�aZ �9�^Z*pqd�]`�*��h"j_dr*h_sa�aj?d^lGefZylndh_�\��]`efdZ ��lnd�h���efh`b*x��^Z,�aj>]_�0�^]��h`� xfdzs��^]`��p�saxfd�j`� ]`dg���^s{��d�]`�*��h�d�h�sar,h`h`��Zz]_xfo ��]��qj{��ln� p*efj`]{�^Z*s��%�*r,]�t(�,dj`�b,h`d��{��sa]`�ap�b0��]`�*j(t(efxfx0s�h`dj_j��

>,�vY9l��qb2�^efh ���h`d�r*b�d�l;�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajW�^]I�5�efi�aZ�]`ef�g�IefZ*j`]{�^Zy]W�^b*b2����h�s�x}d�j`� ]`dR����sk�d�]`�*��h�~��ai�^xfr0��]`�ci��axfdzs�e}][oW��Z*pW�*����p*efZ*��efZyl9dh`�R�^]_e}d�Z�]_d�p*�a]_�ah`�5efZ*�vt(�,�a]`�*��hc]`�*���efh`b*x��^Z,�ajWt(efxfx"�5d^i� �0��x}d^t��5�gefZ*ef� r*�Dj`�ab0��hk��]`efdZ�p*efj_]k�^Z,sa�gd�l;����s{��d]_�*�aht(ef]_�*efZg]`�,�WZ*����h?lnr*]`r,h`���8>W�5e}Zyr*]_�aj �#���

�,�vY9lc�Wb2d]_�aZy]`e��^xGs�dZy�0efsa]?efj(p*�a]_�asa]`��p>~2j`s���Z\�,h`ef�{�0oq]_d%j_�a�We�l>]`�*��h`�%��h`�W�^Zyo �gdh_�b,h`�aj_j`efZ*�gs�dZy�0efsa]_j(]`�0��](Z*�a�ap�]`dq�2��]{�^w��aZRs��^h_�Wd^l#�0h`j_]��

]2�vY9l�]`�*��h`�W�^b*b2����hv]_dW�0�IZ*dud]`�,�ah(sadZ��0efsa]`j?]`�0��]vZ,�a�apR]`dW�2�I]k��w�aZqs���h`�Id^lG�2h`j`]�~]_�*�aZ��^xf�ah_]�]`�,�%b*efxfd]_j(d^lc]`�,�³��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�p*�a]_�asa]_�ap�efZ�j`]_�ab > d�lv]`�,�aefh�j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z��Z*p5lndh_�qr*x��^]_���^xf]`�ah_Z0�^]_�Ih`dr,]`�aj©lndh?]`�*����]_dq]k�^w���

,�v��j`j_�aj`jct(�,�a]`�*��h"]_�*�(�^xf]`�ah_Z0�^]_�ch`d�r*]`��j"p,�aj`ef�Z2�^]`��pWefZ�j_]`�ab7]�t(efxfx^s���r*j`�?sadZ��0efsa]`jt(ef]_�\]_�*�Ib*h`d��{�asa]_�ap�h_dr*]_�aj(d^lcZ*���^h`�yoR�^efh`sah{��ln]��

�,�vY9lG]`�,���^xf]_�ah`Z0��]`efi�?h`d�r*]`��jvt(efxfxys��^r*j_�(sadZ��0efsa]`j�~yh`�{lnd�h`�qr*x���]`�v��x}]_�ah`Z2�^]`efi��vh_dr*]_�ajl9dh(]`�,�O��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj(efZgsad�Zy�0efsa]��

�,�vY9lI]`�*��h`���^h_�gZ*d�ef�5b0�aZ,p*efZ*�RsadZy�2e}s�]`j�~�dh e�l�]`�*�5�gdj_]Wh`��sa�aZy]qsadZ��0efsa]`jq�0��i���2�a�aZ�h`�aj_dxfi�ap�j`r*sas��aj`j lnr*xfxfoz~,]`�*�aZ�]k�^w��Is��^h_�Wd^l�d]`�,�ah�]{�^j`wyj(j_r*s{���^j(x��^Z,p*efZ*�j�~]{�^w��ad#�Gj�~��^j_j`�aj_j`�g��Zz]ud^lvt?���^]_�*�ah sadZ,p*ef]`efdZ*j�~>�^Z,p�saxf����hk��Z*sa�qd^l��^efh_b*x��^Z*�ajI]_d��Zz]_�ah ���a½yef]��^efh_j`b0��sa�Ij`�asa]_dh��

�,� �*�aZ�]_�*��j`��sadZ*p2�^h`o±ef]`���gjqefZ±j`]`��b ���0��i��R�0�a��Z �^p*� !zr2�^]`��x}o±p*���^xf]qt(ef]`�>~h_�a]`r,h`Z�]_dqj`]`��b�Æ�

�����?>��ud^lc�

Page 21: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�(�*�Idh_p*�ahId^l�]`�*�uj`]`��b*jIe}ZR]_�*�Wb*h_�asa�a�ap,e}Z,� ��xf�dh_ef]`�*��efj(p*h{��t(Z5lnh`d�� � j_ozZy]_�*�{�j`efjWd�l;h_�ab0d�h`]_j%d�Z�]`�*� l���sa]`d�h`jWefp*��Zz]_e��0�ap��yo��a½yb2�ah`ef�aZ*s��ap��^efhW]`h{��|gs sadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah_j%�^jh`�axf�ai��Zy](]`dqsad�Zy�0efsa](b*h_�ai�aZy]_e}d�Z>� ) ���jutv�qj_]k�^]_�ap�efZ�d�r*h%��j`j`r,�gb*]_e}d�Z*j�~�]`�*�g��sa]`r0��xvh_dxf� d^l(]`�*�Àl��^sa]_dh_jW�g�aZy]_e}d�Z*�ap

efZPj_]`�ab ���qr*j_]W�2�\j_r*�2dh`p,e}Z2�^]`��p�efZ�dh_p*�ahq]_d�j`ef�gb*xfe�lno�]_�*�R]k��j`w�d�l�p*��]`�ah_�gefZ*efZ*�sad�5b*xf�a½yef][o³��j;�Olnr*Z*s�]`efdZ5d^l���efhv]_hk��|gsI�^Z*p5]`�*�Ib2d]_�aZy]`e��^x2lnd�hvs�dZy�0efsa]_j(]`d p*�ai��axfdb>�

�ef]`��]`�,e}ju�gdyp*�ax�l9dhW]_�*�gp*��saefj`efdZ�b*h_dysa�aj`jqr,Z*p*�ah_]k�^w��aZ��yo�]`�*�5�c�+�I~Gt?�qs��^Z�a½*�^�5e}Z,�g�*d^tD]`�*��Zzr,�q�0�ah d^lIb*x��^Z*��jgefZ�]_�*���^efh_j`b0��sa�~(]_�*�RZzr,�q�0�ahqd�l�b2d]_�aZy]`e��^xsadZ��0efsa]`j�~�]`�*� Zyr*�q�0��h�d�l;b,x¼��Z*�ajI�aZy]`��h`efZ*����Z*p���½zef]_e}Z,�g]`�,�g�^efh`j_b0�^sa�g��]W�^Zyo��efi��aZ]`ef�g��~"��Z*p�]_�*�Ridxfr*�5�%d�l�]`�*�R�^efh j`b0��sa�����G�asa]q]`�,�gsad��gb*xf�a½yef][o�d^l�]_�*���^efhW]_hk��|gstvd�h`wyxfdz��p>�

0N�� ����� ��P��+����� ����O(� P�� �y]`��b ÆqefZ�]`�*�5�c�+�8���asaefj_e}d�Z���xf�d�h`ef]`�,� e}Zyi�dxfi�ajIj_s��^Z*Z,e}Z,��]`�*�R�^efh`j_b0�^s�� lndhWb2d^�]`�aZy]_e¼��x�sadZy�2e}s�]`j��©�(�*�W�c�+�I~,dh��ÀsadZ��0efsa]�p*��]`�asa]_efdZ��^xf�d�h`ef]`�*��~�5ef��y]cp*d5]`�*efj��yo�a½*�^�5e}Z,e}Z,���ai��ah`o5b0�^efhcd�l���e}h_b*x��^Z*��jvefZq]`�,���^efh_j`b0��sa��]_dWj`�a�Ie�lG]`�*�aefh?p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�I�^b0��h`]?efjxf�aj`jI]`�2�^ZRj`d��g�Ib*h`��j`b2�asae��0�ap�jk�mln�Wi�^xfr*���cY9lc]`�*��h`�q�^h`�usar*h`h_�aZy]`xfo�Á��^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj(efZR]`�*��^efh`j_b0�^s��~]_�*�aZq]_�*�ah`��t(efx}xy�2� ��  �+1 ��� � � � �^efh`b,x¼��Z*�cb0��efh`j�lnd�h�]`�*�(�c�+� ]`dIsad�Z*j`efp*�ah���(p*p*ef]`efd�Z0�^xfxfoz~�]`�*�?]k��j`wWd�l­efp*��Zz]_e�lnoye}Z,���^efh`b*x���Z*�aj�t(�*dj_�vb2�^]`�,jct(efx}x�b*h`d��0�^�,x}oIsah_dj_j;��]j`d��g�(x��^]_�ahc]`ef�5�ch`��!yr*efh_�aj(�\��wzefZ*�(]_�aZy]k��]`efi�(b*h_d��{�as�]`efdZ*j�lnd�hc�ai��h`oqb0��e}h�d�l"�^efh`sah{��ln]_j�~j`dq]_�*efj(db2�ahk��]`efdZ��^xfj_d%�0��j(sad�5b*xf�a½yef][o%d�l"dh_p*�ahI¾q¿nÁGÂ�Ãa�

*���]`r*h{�^xfxfoz~��5���^j_r*h`efZ*�Isad��gb*xf�a½yef][oWj`]_h`efsa]_x}o �yoq]`�*�(Zyr*�q�2�ahcd�l>b0�^efh_jcd^l"��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j]`�*�q���+�Ät(e}xfx#�0��i� ]`d5�ai�^xfr0��]`�Ilnd�hIb*h`d^½yef�gef][oqiyefdx��^]_e}d�Z*j��^Z,p�b*h`d��{�asa]_�ap�b0�^]_��efZy�]`�ah_j`�as�]`efdZ*j5p*dy�aj Z*d] sad�5b*xf�a]`��x}o�s��^b*]_r*h`�R]_�*�gb*h_dysa�aj`jq�yo�t(�*efs{��]`�,�g�c�+� �z��]`�y��ah`jue}Z�lndh_�\�^]_efdZgd�hI]`�*�qr*Z,sa�ah`]{�^efZy][o�d^l(�a½y]`h{�^b2dx��^]_efZ*�gsar,h`h`��Zz]ub0�^]_�*jW�gj_ef�Z*e��0s���Zy]�^�5dr*Zy]�d^l>]_e}�5�vefZy]`du]`�*�©lnr*]`r,h`��-�yb2�asae��0s��^xfxfoz~�ef]c�gef��y]#�0�I�gd�h`�?h`����xfe}j_]`efs�]_dWp*efiyefp*��^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajqefZ±]`�*����e}h_j`b0��sa����]³����e}i��aZ�]_ef�g�gefZy]`d�saxfr*j_]`�ah_j ��Z*p��^Z0��xfo ��g]`�,��sad�À�b*xf�a½yef][o ��j`j_dzs�e¼��]`�ap�t(ef]`�����^s{��s�x}r,j`]`��h��W�(�,�%b*h_dysa�aj`jud^lvp*efiyefp*efZ*�q]`�,�³��e}h_j`b0��sa� e}Zy]_dsaxfr*j`]_�ah`j�s��^ZR�2�W�^sasad��gb*xfefj`�,�apg�^r*]_d�R�^]`efs���xfx}oI�yoqdZ,��d�l>j`�ai��ahk��x"��x}��dh_e}]_�*�gj�~^t(�*efs{��^h_�Wb0�^h_]`efsar*x���hclnd�h`�5jvd�l"]`�,��l9dxfxfd^t(e}Z,�W��aZ,�ahk��x>]`���gb*x��^]_��

�?xfr*j`]_�ah`efZ*�q��xf�dh_ef]`�*�Æ�� *�r*�q�2�ah(]`�*�W��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j?lnh`d���Æ�]_dgÁ��>,� ���{�2Z*� ��������� ¿���'��ÃI]`dR�2�q]`h`r,�qe���]_�*� p*efj`]k��Z*sa�q�2�a][t?�a�aZ��^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj��(��Z*p��Refjxf�aj_j�]_�0�^Z��ub*h`�{�[j`b2�asae��0��p�p*efj_]k�^Z,sa�W]`�,h`�aj_�*dxfp>�

�,�;�,dh(���^s{���^efh`b*x���Z*� I2~yb2�ah[lnd�h`� d�Z*�Id^l"]_�*��lndxfxfd^t(efZ*�Wd�b0�ah{�^]_e}d�Z*j���n���ÀY9l�Z*d�saxfr*j`]_�ah`j �0��i�5�0���aZ�lnd�h`�5�ap�o��a]�~�d�hWe�l ��������� ¿ I '��ÃWefjul��^xfj_� lndh%��xfx�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj��;]_�0�^]G�0��i����0�a��Z%b*x���sa�apWefZIsaxfr*j`]_�ah`j�~^]`�,�aZWsah_���^]_�;�?Z*��t�saxfr*j`]_�ah

t(ef]`�R]`�*�W��e}h_b*x��^Z*�W��j(j`dxf�I�g���q�0�ah��4�� 58797-: � =

�����?>*�d^lc�

Page 22: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�¥� � ]`�*�ah_t(efj`�~yt(�*efxf� ��������� ¿ I '��Ãv��Z*p � ����� � ¿)I '��*Ã��*d�xfpWlnd�hc�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj��O��Z*p!�efZ\p,e��G�ah_�aZy]�saxfr*j_]`�ah_j�~2sad�q�,e}Z,��]`�,��s�x}r,j`]`��h`jIsadZy]{�^efZ*efZ*�q�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj �À��Z*p�G�

�¥s �5�(�*�aZ>~#dZ,sa�%s�x}r,j`]`��h`j �0��i� �0���aZ�sad�q�,e}Z,�apRj`r*s{��]`�2�^] ��������� ¿ I '��ÃI�*d�x}p,jlndh(d�Z*xfog�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj �%efZR� j`efZ*�xf��saxfr*j`]_�ah�~G�^p,p ��efh`b*x��^Z,� Iq]_d%]_�*�Wsaxfr*j_]`�ah��Y9l­]_�*���^efh_sahk�mln]>efZq����efi�aZ%��efh`j`b2�^sa�(s���Z%�2�(p*efiyefp*�apWefZy]`d���p*efj_]`efZ*sa]c�^Z,p%efZ*p*��b0�aZ,p*�aZy]saxfr*j`]_�ah`j�~*]_�*�aZg]_�*�(]`d�]k��x0Zyr*�q�2�ah � d^l>b*h_d^½ye}�5ef][o��ai��x}r2�^]`efd�Z*j�]`�*���c�+��t?dr*xfpq�0��i��]`dqb2�ah[l9dh`�Defj(�efi��Zg�yo

� 1�� � � � Á

�¿9Á�4 K�Ã� '

t(�*�ah_�%Á�e}j(]_�*�IZyr*�q�0��hvd�l��^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj?efZgsaxfr*j_]`�ah �`���(�,���5d]_e}i��]`efdZulnd�hv]_�*�Isaxfr*j`]_�ah

�^b*b,h`dz��s{�\efj?]`�0��]�~yt(�*��Z\j_s��^Z,Z*efZ*�³�uhk��p0�^h(j_sah`���aZ>~G�^Z5�c�+�±d^l9]`�aZ5�g�aZy]k��xfx}ou�h`d�r*b*jsa�ah_]k�^efZ�j_�a]`jId�l��^efh_sahk�mln]`j�]`d���a]`�,�ah�efZRdh_p*�ah(]`d5h`�ap,r*sa�W]_�*�%�^�5dr*Zy]?d^l��g�aZy]k��xGtvd�h`w�*����j`�*�5�0�^jI]`dRp*dR]_d ��j`j_�aj`j ]`�*�qZyr*�q�2�ah�d^l(b0d�]`�aZy]`e���x"b,h`d^½yef�gef][ogiyefdx��^]_efdZ*j��IY[]Wefjh`����j`d�Z0�^�*xf�~2]_�*�ah`��lndh_�~G]`dqs�dZ*j_e}p,�ah�]_�*�%s�x}r,j`]`��h��^b,b*h`dy�^s{���^j��À�gd�h`����sasar*h{�^]_�%h_�aby�h`�aj_�aZy]k��]`efdZ5d^lG]`�*�(Zyr*�q�2�ah�d^lGsad�5b0�^h_efj`dZ,j>]`�,�(�c�+���qr*j_]��\�^w��ct(�*�aZqb2�ah lndh_�gefZ*��^ZRefZ*ef]`e��^x2j`s��^Z�d�l"]`�,�%�^efh`j_b0�^s��Wj`�as�]`dh��-*�d]`�u]`�0��]�~0��xf]`�*d�r*��5]`�*�Isaxfr*j_]`�ahW�^b,b*h`dy�^s{�efjg¾q¿nÁGÂ�Ãa~�]`�*��i��xfr*�aj ]k�^w��aZ±dZ±�yo � lndhg��ZP�^efh_j`b0��sa��t(ef]`�±Á ��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j%t(efxfx(�0�sadZ,j`efj`]_�aZy]`xfoRx}d^t?�ah?]`�0��ZR]`�*�Wi��xfr*�aj?d^l �  � ���(�*efj?lnd�x}xfd^t(j�l9h`d� ]`�*�Il[�^sa]?]`�0��]� Á ��� 4 � 1 Á�¿9Á 4 K�Ã� 4

�� � � � Á�¿9Á�4 K�Ã�

1 ÁGÂ� 4 Á � 4�� �� � � � ÁGÂ�� 4

�� � � � Á��

1 ÁGÂ� 4�� � � � ÁGÂ

��

1 ¿�� �� � � Á � Ã_Â(4 � �� � � ÁGÂ�� + (

�,dhW�^Z���e}h_j`b0��sa�qt(ef]`� � �h_dr*b*jud^l���!yr0��xcj`e a�~#l9dhWefZ*j_]k�^Z,sa�~�]`�,�qhk�^]_efd�d^l(]`�*�][tvdq�5���^j_r*h`��j(e}j

� � Â �

1 Á54 ��À¿nÁ 4 K�Ã�� K�lndh � K�#�(�*efjGe}xfxfr*j_]`hk��]`�ajG]_�*�cp*e �G�ah`��Z*sa�?e}ZI]_�*�c�\���Z*ef]_r*p*�aj2d^l*]`�,�aj`�c][t?d(�g���^j`r,h`�ajlndh(j_]`�ab Æ�sad��gb*xf�a½yef][oy�

�����?>�>ud^lc�

Page 23: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

0N��<N �=���+V � ������� �&��� ��� Q � PR�&V � �&����QX��Q O��&P�� ������� �P��+�������xf]`�,dr*����]`�,�g�g���^j`r,h`� � efjq�Rh`���^j`d�Z0�^�,x}�5�g�a]_h`efs lnd�h%j_]`�abUÆqsad��gb*xf�a½yef][oy~Gef]Ws��^Z�0�Ref�gb,h`d^i��pRlnr*h_]`�*�ahq�yo�]k��wzefZ*��e}Zy]_d��^sas�dr*Zy]q�^p*p*ef]_e}d�Z0�^x�l��^sa]_dh_j%]_�0�^]%� �­��sa]q]`�*�Zyr*�q�0��h�d�lvj`]_�ab�Æ{�[xf�ai��x"s�d�gb2�^h`efj_e}d�Z*j(b2�ah[lnd�h`�5�ap��yo�]_�*� �c�+�UefZ�]_�*�q�c�+�8���as�e¯�j`efdZ���xf��dh`ef]_�*��� Z*�qj_r*s{��l[�^sa]_dhIefj�]_�*� �&�­��sa]%d�lvefZy]`�ah{�^sa]_e}d�Z*jI�0��][tv�a��Z�j`�ab0��hk��]`�saxfr*j`]_�ah`j�� �?dZy]`h{�^h_o�]_d\]_�*�gj_ef�gb*xfe�lnoye¯Z*�g��j`j_r*�gb*]_efdZ��R�^p*�%���0d^i��~#saxfr*j`]_�ah`j d^l��^efh[�b*x��^Z*��jg�^h`��Z*d] sad�5b*xf�a]`��x}o�efZ*p,�ab0��Z*p*�aZy]gd�l�����s{��d]_�*�ah�~(��Z*p±p*�asaefj`efd�Z*jq�\��p*�g]_d��i�ah_]�b*h_d�*xf�a�5j(efZ\d�Z*�Isaxfr*j`]_�ahI�yogh`��h`dr,]`efZ*�q�2e}���y](b0�^]_�*j��5e}���y]cb0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xfx}oR���G�asa]]`�*�R�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajIefZ��^Z*d�]`�*��hWsaxfr*j`]_�ah�� Z*�qt(��o�d�l��^sasad�r*Zy]`efZ*�5lnd�hWj`r*s{��efZy]`�ah{�^sa]_efdZ*jtvd�r*xfpg�2�W]`dg��p*p\� ]_�ah`�D]`d � ]_�0�^](h_�ab*h`��j`�aZy]`jI]_�*�WZyr*�q�2�ahvd�l"b0��efh`j(d^l��h_dr*b*j��

������� ��� 1�� � � � Á

�¿nÁ�4 K�Ã� � �q¿ � 4 K�Ã� (

�(�*efj%�^p,p*ef]`efdZ0��x�]`�ah_� ��Z*sadyp*�ajq]_�*� l��^s�]W]`�0��]�~�lndhI����s{��b0��e}hId�l;��h`dr,b*j�~#]`�*�5�c�+��qr*j`]�sad�Z*j`efp*��hv]_�*�(xfe}w��axfef�*dydzpu]`�0��]ch`�ah_dr*]_efZ*�W]`h{��|gs?lnh_d� dZ*�(t(efxfx*���G�asa]?]`�*�(d�]`�*�ah��

0N���� � PRV0� �U�&��Q S O(� P�� N�� V0Q S�PY���b ]`dR]`�*efjWb2defZy]�~#t?�q�0��i� lndysar,j`�ap dZ*xfo�d�Z�]`�*�5sad�5b0d�Z*�aZy]Id^l(sad�5b*xf�a½ye}][oR]_�0�^]�^h_e}j_�aj lnh_d� j`]_�abUÆqd^l�]_�*�R�c�+� ����saefj`efdZ���x}��dh_e}]_�*��~�t(�*�ah`�R]_�*�R�c�+� e}p,�aZy]`e��0�aj�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj?]`�0��];��b*b2���^h(]_dzdusaxfdj`�I]_d���]`�*�ah���]v]_�*��s�r*h`h_�aZy]�]`ef�5�vd�hvt(�*d�j`�Ib*h_d��{�asa]_�apsadr,h`j`��jW�gef��y]?xf���^p�]`�*��� ]`d\��Z��ai��aZy]`r0��xcsadZ��0efsa]�e�lvZ*d�]�sad�h`h_�asa]`��p>�W�(�*� b*h_e}�R�^h_ob0�^h_]%d�l;j_]`�abÄÆqefjW]`�,� lndh_�g�ahI]k��j`w�d^l�efp*�aZy]_e¯l9ozefZ*�R�^efh`s�hk��l9]Wt(�*dj_�gsar,h`h`��Zz] j`��b0�^h{���]`efdZ5p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�Iefj?x}��j`j(]`�2�^Zgj_d�5���^b*b*h_d^½ye}�R�^]_�vj{��ln�Ii�^xfr*��~j_e}Z,sa�Ib*h`�aj_r*�\���0�^�,x}oq�^Zyoj`r*s{� b0�^efhI�0�^j ]`�,�qb0d�]`�aZy]`e���xc]`d��2�asad��g�g�5p0��Z*��ah_dr*j j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z>� �Iefi��aZ ��Zyo�b0��efhd^l���e}h_sahk�mln] e}p,�aZy]`e��0�ap�efZ�j`]_�abUÆg�^j �2�aefZ*��]_dyd�saxfdj_�g]`d����^s{��d�]`�*��h�~cj_]`�ab >Rd�l�]`�*��c�+�8���as�e}j_efdZ���xf�d�h`ef]`�*� ]{�^w��ajW�*����p*efZ*���^Z*p�i��x}dysaef][o�efZyl9dh`�R�^]_e}d�ZgefZy]`d��^s�sadr*Zy]]`d����aZ*�ah{�^]_�gj`d��g�W��j`]`ef�R�^]`� d^l�]_�*�qb2d]`��Zz]_e��^x�lnd�hW�gs�dxfxfe}j_efdZ>~GZ,���^hW�5efj`j�~2d�hWxf�aj`j_�ah�^efh`j_b0�^s��Wiye}d�x��^]`efd�Zqs��^r*j_�ap��yoq]`�2�^]��^efh_b*x��^Z*��b0�^efh��Y[Z�]`�,�\s��^j`�Rd�l�j`]`��b Æ�~�tv�R�^h_�r*�ap ]`�0��]%s�d�gb,x}��½zef][o�p,�ab0��Z*p*jqdZ ]`�*�5Zyr*�q�0��h

d^lIb0�^efh`ju]`�*�R�c�+� �0��p�]`d��ai�^xfr0��]`�ql9dhWb*h_d^½ye}�5ef][o\iyefdx���]`efdZ*jW��Z*p��ai��aZy]`r0��xvb2�^]`�sadZ��0efsa]`j��v�,dh�j`]_�ab1>,~]_�*��sad��gb*xf�a½yef][oId^lG]`�*��]k��j`wul��^saefZ*�u]`�*�(�c�+� p*��b0�aZ,p*j(efZ%b0��h`]dZ�]`�*� xf�ai��xcd^lvr,Z*sa�ah_]k�^efZy][o�e}Zyi�dxfi�apRefZ�b*h`�ap,e}s�]`efZ*�R]`�*� xfdys��^]_e}d�Z�d^l?]`�*�q�5�a�q�0��h`jd^l%�^Z���e}h_b*x��^Z*�5b0�^efh dhqsaxfr*j_]`�ahRefZ�]_�*��Z*���^h lnr*]_r*h`������xfj_d0~(���g����j`r*h_�gd�lOj_]`�ab >sad�5b*xf�a½yef][oqj`�*d�r*xfp�]k��w�WefZy]`dg��sasadr,Zz]I]_�*�Wxf�ai��x"d�lcp0�^Z*���ah�ef�5b*xfe}s�e}]�e}Z�]`�*�Wi��h`efdr,jj`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z*jIe}p,�aZy]`e��0�ap�efZ�j_]`�ab�Æ��W�(�*�q�5dh`�uj`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,j�]`�,�ah`�R�^h`� ]`�2�^]Ih`�ab,h`�aj_�aZy]g��*ef��qxf�ai��ax*d^lGp0��Z*��ah�~]_�*���5dh_�vsad��gb*xf�a½I]_�*�(]k��j`w d^l>]`�,�(�c�+���2�asad��g�ajc�2�as���r*j`�I�*�efjch`��!yr*efh_�apg]_dW�\��w�c�5dh`�?sah_r*sae��^x2p*�asaefj_e}d�Z*jcb2�ah?r*Z*ef]c]`ef�5��G�(�*�(efZ*sah_���^j_�apRp*�a�R�^Z*pdZW�5�aZy]k��xh`��j`dr,h`sa�aj�~efZW]_r*h`Z#~^h`��!yr*efh_�aj�]`�*�?�c�+��]`d�b2��o�xf�aj_jc�^]`]_�aZy]`efdZu]`d(j`��sadZ*p2�^h`oj`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z*j(]`�0��](sadr,x}pRp*��i�axfdb5efZz]_dqb*h`d��*xf�a�gj�e¯l�xf�{ln](r*Z0��]`]_�aZ*p*�ap#�c�(�*efj(b*h_d�*xf�a�Defjsad�5b0d�r*Z*p*��p��zo�]_�*�ql[�^sa] ]`�0��]%j_�ai��h`�Rb*h`d��*xf�a�gj�~�j`r*s{�±�^j b0d�]`�aZy]`e���xvsad�xfx}efj_e}d�Z*jIdhZ*����h(�gefj`j_�aj�~�p*�a�R�^Z*pg��x}�5dj_]"]_d]{�^x>�^]_]`�aZy]_e}d�Zgr*Zy]_e}x2]`�,�aog�^h_��h_�aj`d�xfi�ap>~*��Z*p\��h`�IZ*d�]h`�aj_dxfi��p�sad�5b*xf�a]`��x}oqr,Zz]_efx-��efZRb0�^h_]`j+]�� ���?]`�*�u�c�+�±p*�a]_�ah`�5efZ*�aj�]_�0�^](]_�*�%��x}]_�ah`Z2�^]`�b0�^]_�*j��,���2�^j(p*efh`��sa]`�ap�]`�*�Wb,e}xfd�]c]`dq]{�^w�Ip*dqZ,d]?s��^r*j_�%�^Zyo5d]`�,�ah(sadZ��0efsa]`j��

�����?>�ud^lc�

Page 24: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

Y[Z�dh`p,�ah%]_dRsadZ*j_]`h_r*sa]q�R�dydyp��5�a]`h_efsWlnd�hI]`�*�5sad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o5d^l(j`]_�ab >,~>t?�%Z,�a�ap���dydyp��5�a]`h_e}sÀlndhq]_�*�Rp0�^Z,��ahqh_�ab*h`��j`�aZy]`��pU�zo�����efi�aZ±�^efh`sah{��ln]qb2�^efh�~��efi�aZ ]`�*�b0d�j`ef]`efd�Z³��Z*p%i��axfdysaef][o�d�l­�2d]_�³��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj��#�(�*���0h`j_]cb0d�h`]_e}d�Z%d�l0dr,h"b2�^b2�ahcefj�p*�aid�]`�ap]`d�sah`���^]`efZ*��j`��i�ah{�^x(t?dh`w���*xf�g�^xf]`��h`Z0��]`efi�ajulnd�h%j_r*s{�P���g�a]_h`efs~��^Z*p tv�5r*j`�R]`�,dj`�h`�aj_r*xf]`j��*�ah`�����Z0��]`r*h{�^x*t(��oW]_dWefZ*sadh_b0d�hk��]`��]_�*�(p0��Z*��ah?b*h_�aj`�aZy]_�apR�zou���^s{�\��efh`sah{��ln]cb2�^efh�e}Zy]_d

� p0�^Z,��ah(�5�a]`h_e}s©lndh(]_�*�W�^efh`j_b0�^s��%�^j��ut(�*dxf�It?dr*xfpg�2�I]`dqsad��gb*r,]`��]_�*�W�5���^j_r*h`�

� 1 ������������ �

��� ' �_Æ �

t(�*�ah_�q]`�*�q�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�ajIefZ�]`�,�³��e}h_j`b0��sa�q�^h`� Zyr*�q�2�ah`�ap lnh`d��»ÆW]`d�Á���Z*p #¿ � ' � Ã�h_�aby�h`�aj_�aZy]`jW]_�*� i�^xfr*�Wd�l�d�Z*� d^lc]`�*� p0��Z*��ah��g�a]_h`efsaj��aj`]{�^�*xfefj`�*��p�����h`xfef�ah/�¥]`h_e}iye��^x[~,saxfdj`��^b*b,h`dz��s{�>~�j`b0��sa�{�[]`ef�g��~�x}d��z��h`ef]`�*�5e¯sWp,�ah`efi�^]_efi�~�d�hWb*h`d��0�^�,e}xfefj`]_efs ��lnd�hW]`�*�R�^efh`s�hk��l9]b0�^efhg¿ ��' � Ãa�q�(�,�q�*ef��*�ahu]`�*�qj_r*� d^l(]`�*�qi��x}r,�ajWd^l(]`�,�qe}Z,p*efizefp*r2�^x��g�a]_h`efsajIefj�~#]`�*��gd�h`�Ip0�^Z,��ah_dr*j�]`�*�q�^efh`j_b0�^s��Wsaxf���^h_xfo\efj�� �Rdh_�ad^i��h�~G�^Z��^p,i�^Zy]k����Id^lc]`�,e}j�p0�^Z,��ah�g�a]_h`efs�efj?]`�0��]vef]?s��^ZR�2�Isad�5b0�^h_�apg�^sah_dj_j��^efh`j_b0�^sa��j�d^l>p,e��G�ah_�aZy]�j`e a��j(�0�as��^r*j_�W]`�*�efZ*p*efiye}p,r0�^x#p0�^Z*���ahW�5�a]`h_e}s�j�]k��w� efZz]_d��^sasad�r*Zy]I]`�*�qp*efj_]k�^Z,sa�%�2�a][t?�a�aZ±�^efh`sah{��ln]W��Z*pj`d��g���5���^j_r*h`�Id�l"]`�,�W]`ef�g�(r,Zz]_efxG]`�*�Wb2defZy]?d^l"�R�^½yef�qr*�Up0��Z*��ah��Y[p*����xfx}oy~^d�Z*�Itvd�r*xfpgt(�^Zy]v]_d%p,�a]`�ah_�gefZ*�I]`�,��h{�^Z*����d�l"i�^xfr*��jclnd�h(]`�*�I�5���^j_r*h`� �

]`�0��]�sadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*pq]`dI�^efh`j_b0�^sa��jct(ef]`�W�*ef���>~��g�ap*efr*��~a�^Z*pux}d^t�p2�^Z*���ah��#�(�*efj>t?dr*xfpWh_�{�!yr*efh`��lnr,h`]`�,�ah��a�gb*efh_e}s��^x^j`]_r*p*oIsad��gb0��h`efZ*�?]`�*��l9h`��!yr*�aZ,sao%�^Z,p�][oyb2�vd�l0�^sasaefp*��Zz]_j>]_�0�^]dysasar*h efZ�p*e �­��h`�aZy]q�^efh`j_b0�^sa��jWt(ef]`��]`�*�qi��x}r,�ajId�*]{�^efZ*�ap�lndh � e}Z�]`�,dj`�g��efh`j`b2�^sa�aj�� Z*�gt(��o�d�l;�R�^]_sk�,e}Z,�gi�^xfr*��jWd^l�]_�*� � �g��]`h`efsqt(ef]`��]_�*�qdysasar*h_�aZ*sa��d^l��^sasaefp*��Zz]_jdh(d�b0�ah{�^]_e}d�Z0�^x2�ah_h`dh_j��yoq�c�+�?j(t?dr*xfpq�2�I]`dq�g���^j`r,h`��]_�*�Ix��^]`]_�ah��^Z,pg�a½*�^�5efZ*�(]`�*��a½y]`�aZy]W]_dRt(�*efsk���*ef��,�ahW�^sasaefp*��Zz] �^Z*p��ah`h_dhWh{�^]_�ajW�\��]`s{�R�*ef��*��h��qr,x}]_efb*xf�aj(d^l(]`�*�j`]{�^Z*p0��h`p�p,�aiye¼��]`efdZR�^�2d^i��]`�*�W�5���^Z l9dh(]`�,���5�a]`h_efs � �� p*efjk��p*i�^Zy]{�^��qd�lW]`�*efjq�g��]`h`efs5e}jq]_�0�^]�~c�yo�]_�*�a�5j`�axfi��j�~?i�^xfr*�aj ]k��w�aZ±d�ZP�yo

� �2��i�gZ,d����^j_efx}o�efZy]`��h`b*h_�a]k���*xf�\�5���^Z,e}Z,�0�R�(�*efj s��^Z �0�Rh`���g�ap*ef�ap�efZ ][tvd�t(��oyj���(�*�q�2h`j`]qefjW]_d�p,�a]`�ah_�gefZ*�~#l9dhWt(�*efs{�*�ai��ah e}Z,p*efs��^]_dh ±efjW�2�aefZ*��r*j`��p>~c�Rl9r*Z*sa]_e}d�Z � � 1 ¿�#¿ ��' � Ã`à ]_�0�^]�~>��efi�aZ��Ri��xfr*�qd^l(]`�*�5�g�a]_h`efs #~�h`�a]_r*h`Z*jq]_�*�gb,h`d�2�^�*efxfef][o]`�0��]���Z\r,Z*p*�aj_e}h{�^�*xf�W��i�aZy]Ij`r*s{����j��qsad�xfx}efj_e}d�Zgd�h(Z*���^h��gefj`j(t(efxfxGdysasar*h�� �Iefi��Z� ~tv�Isad��gb*r,]`�I]`�*�I�5���^j_r*h`�

� � ��� 1 ������������ �

¿ ��' � à '

t(�*efs{��h`�ab,h`�aj_�aZy]`jW]_�*�%��½zb2�asa]_�ap�Zyr*�q�2�ah(d^lcr*Z*p,�aj`efh`���^�*xf� sadZy�2e}s�]`j�]_�0�^]�t(efx}xGdysas�r*hefZ%]_�*�;��efh`j`b2�^sa�(t(ef]`�,e}Zu]`�*�?]`ef�g��b0�ah_efdzp ��]_�*�?Z*���^h�lnr*]`r,h`� ��lnd�h"t(�,e}s{�Wi��xfr*�aj�d^l� �^h`�j`b2�asae��0�ap#�I�(�*efj(�g����j`r*h_�Wd^lcp0��Z*��ah�efj��^b,b0����xfe}Z,� lnh`d���]_�*�Wj`]{�^Z*p,b0d�e}Zy]�]`�0��]�~2j`efZ*sa�ef](e}j(p,�aj`efh`���^�*xf�I]`dqj_b0�as�e¯l9o\� �\��½ye}� r*� �a½yb0�as�]`�ap�Zyr*�q�0��hvd�l"sad�Zy�0efsa]`j�]`�0��](j`�*d�r*xfpdysasar*h?b0��hvr*Z,e}]�]_e}�5�cefZg�^Zyo%��e}h_j`b0��sa�~�tv�(�2��i�(�Itvd�h`w���*xf�v�5�a]`�*dypIl9dhcp*��]`�ah_�gefZ*efZ*�t(�*�a]_�*�ahIh`����xG�g����j`r*h_�aj?lnd�h��^efh`j_b0�^sa�Ij{��ln�a][oR�^h_�Wiye}d�x��^]`��p>��(�*�cj_�asad�Z*pqt;��o�]`dIef�gb*h_d^i�#dZW]_�*�v�5���^j_r*h`���efi�aZu�zo 2 !yr0��]`efdZ5Æcefj"�©i�^h`e���]`efdZdZq]_�*�(b*h`��sa�a�ap*efZ*�qefp*���*�#Y[Z*j`]_���^pqd�l>p*�a]`��h`�gefZ*efZ*��]`�*���a½yb0��sa]`�ap5Zyr*�q�0��h"d�l>sadZ��0efsa]`j

]`�0��]�t(efxfxGdysasar*h�e}ZR]_�*�³��efh`j`b2�^sa�Wd^i��ah(]`�,�W]`ef�g��efZz]_�ah`i��xGlnd�h(t(�*efs{�� efj(sad��gb*r*]_�ap>~

�����?>G] d^lc�

Page 25: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

tv�Isad�r*xfpRp*�{�0Z*� �^ZRefZ*p*efs��^]_dh?i�^h_e¼���*xf��*¿ ��' � à 1 K�e�l >¿ ��' � à ����

1 +ue�l >¿ ��' � Ã�� ���t(�*�ah_� � � h_�ab*h_�aj`�aZy]_j���]`�*h_�aj`�,dxfp�i�^xfr*�Àlndhq]_�*��p0��Z*���hq�g�a]_h`efs �t(�*efs{�>~?t(�*�aZ�a½ysa�a�ap,�ap>~2h`��!yr*efh_�ajvefZy]`��h`i��Zz]_efdZq�yoq]`�*���c�+�I�# �ef]_�q]`�*efj�lnd�h`�qr*x���]`efdZ>~�]`�*��Zyr*�q�0��hd^lcj`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Z*j?e}ZRt(�*efs{�g]_�*�W�c�+� �qr*j`]?efZz]_�ah`i��aZ*�Wefj(��e}i��aZg�yo

� �� 1 ������������ �

�*¿ ��' � à (��Z���p*i�^Zy]{�^��Id�l�]_�*efj��5���^j_r*h`�Wd^i��ah � � ��� efj�]`�2�^](]`�,�%i��x}r,�aj(d^l � � s��^Z��2�Wp*��]`�ah ��gefZ*�ap efZ%b2�^h`]��zou]`�*���c�+���0��j`�apqd�Z��{r*p*���a�g��Zz]c��Z*p%��½zb2�ah_e}��Z*sa�~,t(�*�ah`���^j � � ��� ��]]`�*��i�ah_o%xf����j`]?h`��!yr*efh_�aj;�Oh`����x}efj_]`efs(b*h`d��0�^�,e}xfefj`]_efsvj_e}�qr,x¼��]`efdZI]_dW�aj`]{�^�*xfefj`�qj_d�5�(h`�ax����]`efdZ,j`�*efbR�0��][tv�a��Z�]_�*�%b,h`d�2�^�*efxfef][oqd^lc�gefj`�2�^bg�^Z,p�]`�*�ui�^xfr*�Id^lc]`�,�Wp0�^Z,��ah��g�a]_h`efs>����xfj`d2~y]`�*efj(�5���^j_r*h`��]k�^w��aj��u�gd�h`��p*efh`�asa]���b*b*h_dz�^s{�R]`d p*�a]_�ah`�5efZ*efZ*�%]_�*�IZyr*�q�0��hd^lGs��^j_�ajct(�*��h`�(]`�,�v�c�+� t(efx}x��0��i�?]`dIefZy]`�ah_i�aZ,�~j_efZ*sa�?]`�*�(�c�+��p,�asaefp*�ajct(�,�a]`�*��hcdhZ*d]?]`d efZy]`�ah_i�aZ*�Id�Zg�Ws���j`�I�yoqs��^j_���0��j`efj?hk�^]_�*�ah(]_�0�^Z5�zoqs�d�gb,r*]`efZ*�I]`�,���a½yb2�asa]`��pZyr*�q�0��h(d^l"�5efj`�0��b*j��

*�d^t±]_�0�^]?tv���0��i��b0d�j`ef]`��pgj`��i�ah{�^x>h_���^j_dZ0���*xf��t(��oyjc]`d �g����j`r*h_��p0��Z*���hclnd�h;��Z�aZy]`efh`�R�^efh`j_b0�^s��\�^j �5lnr*Z*s�]`efdZ�d�l;]_�*�gp0��Z*���h%b*h_�aj`��Zz] efZ����^s{� e}Z,p*efizefp*r2�^xc�^efh`s�hk��l9]b0�^efh�~*t?��]_r*h`Z�]`dq]`�,�Wsa�aZy]`h{�^x�!yr*�aj_]`efdZ>���*d^tÄe}j(]_�*�Wsad��gb*xf�a½yef][oqd^lc]_�*�W�c�+��� j?]k�^j_wh`�ax���]`�ap�]_dq]`�*�Ip0��Z*���h(b0d�j`�ap��yoqb2d]_�aZy]`e��^x��^sasaefp*��Zz]_j �

0N��� ���&�?� O��&P��BN � V0Q�S(PY���&� O��&P��BN ������� �P��+������(�*�Ib*h`efZ*s�e}b2�^x2�g����j`r*h_�(d^l"p2�^Z*���ahvt?��t(efxfx*r*j_�Ie}Zq]_�*efjvj_�asa]_e}d�Zgefj � �� ~y�2�as��^r,j`�I]`�*efj�g�a]_h`efsq�gd�j`]W�^s�sar*hk��]`�axfo�s���b*r*]_r*h`�ajq]_�*�qZyr*�q�2�ahWd^l�efZy]`��h`i��Zz]_efdZ*jW]_�*�g���+�M�qr,j`]�\��w�WefZ�]`�*� Z*����hIlnr*]_r*h`�� ��j�p,e}j_sar*j_j`�ap ���^h_x}ef�ah�~G]`�,�qsad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o5d^l(]`�*� j`ef]_r0�^]_e}d�Zl��^s�e}Z,�q]`�*�W���+��efZgj_]`�ab > efj(saxfdj_�axfogh`��x¼��]`�ap�]`dq]`�,�Wp0�^Z,��ah�d^l"]_�*�Wj_e}]_r0�^]_efdZ>� *�d^t]`�0��]Itv�q�0��i��%b,h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap±�gt?dh_w�^�*xf�W�5�a]`h_efsIlndhIj_]`�ab3>5p0��Z*��ah�~Gt?�qt(e}xfx#�a½yb*xfe}s��^]`��*d^tM]_�*� sad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o5d^lvj_]`�ab3>Àp*�ab2�aZ*p*judZ�]`�*� �g����j`r*h_�%d�lvp0��Z*��ah � �� t?�%�0��i��p*�{�0Z,�ap>���d���j`j`��j`j(]`�,�(Zzr,�q�0�ah#d^lGp*�asaefj_e}d�Z*jc]_�*�(�c�+� �0�^j�]_dW�\��w�cefZ j`]`��b*j >I]_�*h`d�r*�� �*~

tv���qr*j`]Gp*��]`�ah_�gefZ*��]`�*�?Zyr*�q�2�ahGd^l*b2dj`j_ef�*efx}ef]_e}��jGdb2�aZW]`d(]_�*�?�c�+��]_d(h`�aj_dxfi�(�?�efi��aZsadZ��0efsa]q�0��][tv�a��Z Á �^efh`b*x���Z*�aj�� �"d�p*d�j_d0~�tv�5sadZ*j_efp*�ahq]`�,�gl9dxfxfd^t(e}Z,�gh`���^j`d�Z0�^�,x}��^xf�d�h`ef]`�,��lnd�h>j_dxfiye}Z,��sad�Zy�0efsa]`j��Gl9dh>���^s{�%b2�^efh>d�l0sadZ��0efsa]`efZ*�I�^efh`b*x���Z*�aj>efZW]_�*�?�h`d�r*b>~j`d�x}i���]_�*��sad�Zy�0efsa]Rt(�*efxf���\��wye}Z,��j_r*h`��]`�*��j`d�xfr*]`efdZ p*dy�ajRZ*d]5sadZy�2e}s�]\t(ef]_��]`�*�sadZ,j`]`h{�^efZy]`jW���aZ*�ah{�^]_�ap��yo ��Zyo\b,h`�aiyefdr*j_xfo�j`d�x}i��ap�sad�Zy�0efsa]_e}Z,�\b2�^efh��I�(�yr*jIt?�%�0��i����b*h_d�*xf�a��efZ�t(�,e}s{�±����sk�Äd^l ]`�*� ��� � � � s�dZy�0efsa]_jRsadZ*j_]`h{�^efZ*jgt(�2�^]gs{�*d�efsa�ajRtv�s��^Z��\��w�I]`d5h`�aj_dxfi�u���^s{��d^lv]_�*�%d�]`�*��h�sad�Zy�0efsa]`j.M>efZRj`d��g�Ws��^j`��j�~>�mln]`�ahI]_�*�W�2h`j`]IwsadZ��0efsa]`jv��h`�?j`d�x}i��ap>~�Z*d�j`dxfr*]_efdZIlnd�h>sad�Zy�0efsa] � � Kc�R��o��a½yefj`]�r*Z,p*�ah�]`�*�?sad�Z*j`]_hk�^efZy]`j�~�^Z*p±]_�zr,jg�0��skwy]_hk�^s{wyefZ*���\��o��2��Z*�asa��j`jk��h`oy�UY[Z±d]_�*�ahgt?dh_p*j�~?]_�*efjgb*h_d�*xf�a� efjg�lndh_� d^lc]`�,�W��aZ,�ahk��xcsadZ,j`]`h{�^efZy]�j{�^]`efj l��^sa]_efdZRb*h`d��*xf�a��~,t(�*efs{��efj(wzZ,d^t(Z�]`d5�0�?*IÅ#�sad�5b*xf�a]`����) � �(�yr*jIt?�%b2dj_]`r*x��^]_�W]`�2�^]I]`�*� t?dh`j_]�s���j`�qsad��gb*xf�a½yef][oqd^l?]`�*� b*h`d��*xf�a�4�� : =

�����?>ud^lc�

Page 26: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

i�^h_e}��j��a½yb2dZ*�aZy]_e¼��xfx}o5t(ef]`�R]`�*�uZzr,�q�0�ah(d�lcb0�^efh`j��(¾q¿ � ��� � � � �  Ã;lndh(j_d�5��s�dZ*j_]k�^Zy]�G����dIp*�a]`��h`�gefZ*�(]_�*efjcsad�Z*j`]{�^Zy]�~yt?�(sadZ,j`efp*�ah?]`�*��b*h`d��*xf�a� lnh`d����Ij_xfe}���y]`xfoWp*e �G�ah`�aZy]b0��h`j`b2�asa]_efi��

��Z,p*�ah ]`�*�R�^j`j_r*�gb,]`efdZ�]`�0��]W]`�,�\�^xf]_e}]_r*p*�qxf�ai��axvd�l;]_�*�gb,x¼��Z*�aj efjWZ*d]udb2�aZ�]_d�gdyp*e��0s���]`efdZ#~^ef]cj`�a���gj?l���e}h_xfoWh`����j`d�Z0�^�*xf�I]`duj`r*b*b2dj_�W]`�2�^]?]`�*���c�+�±s���Zg�aef]`�,�ah(]`�axfx�0d�]`��b,e}xfd�]`j?]`dg�2�^Z*w5]`dq]`�,�Wh`ef��y]��flnh_d�D]`�*��e}h�b0d�efZz](d�l"iyef�at��(d�h(]`dq]_�*�Wxf�{ln]��c�(�*�aZlndh��ai�ah_oqb0�^efh�d^l>�^efh_sahk�mln]c]`�2�^]cefjcefZ sadZy�2e}s�]�~�]`�*�ah_�W�^h`�(][t?dIb0d�j`j_e}�,x}��j`d�x}r,]`efdZ*j�d�b0�aZ]`dq]_�*�W�c�+� l9dh���i��h`]`efZ*�q�usadxfxfefj`efdZ5dh(Z*����h(�gefj`j��

��j_efZ*�R]`�*�q]_�*�g�5�a]`h_e}s � �� ]_d\p,�a]`�ah_�gefZ*�q]_�*�qZyr*�q�0��h�d�l;j_ef]`r0��]`efdZ*jIefZ�t(�*efs{�]`�*�I�c�+� t(e}xfx2�0��i�I]_d%efZy]`�ah_i�aZ,�~0��Z*pgj_r*b*b2dj`efZ*�q]_�0�^]�lnd�hv����s{�\d�l"]_�*�aj`�uj`ef]`r0��]`efdZ,j]`�*��h`����h`�?][tvd�b0d�j`j_e}�,x}�(j_dxfr*]_e}d�Z*jGl9dhc�^xf]`��h`efZ*��]_�*�(�*����p*efZ*�j�d�l0]`�*����efh`sah{��ln]#e}Zyi�dxfi�ap#~tv�I���a]�]_�0�^](]_�*�ah`� �^h`�

� 1 � ����� �b0d�j`j_e}�,x}��j`dxfr*]_efdZ*j lnd�hq]`�*�Rj_ozj_]`�a��� lWsad�r*h`j_�~(efZ±]`�*��Z*���^hÀlnr*]_r*h`�~?t?���^j_j`r*�5�]`�0��] � �� h`��ln�ah`ju]`dg]_�*�W�5���^j_r*h`�Wd�lvsad�Zy�0efsa]�t(ef]_�*efZ��q��e}i��aZRsaxfr*j`]_�ah�~��^Z,p�sadZ,j`efp*�ah]`�*� ]`d�]k��x"s�d�gb,x}��½zef][og��j�]`�,�%j_r*� d^lv]_�*� sad�5b*xf�a½ye}]_ef�aj(t(ef]`�*efZR���^s{��saxfr*j`]_�ah�� � dh`�b*h`��saefj`�axfoy~*t?�Wxf�a] � ¿��9Ã�1,� ��� ��

�� ~,t(�*�ah_� � �� ¿��née}j(]_�*�Ip0�^Z,��ah��g����j`r*h_��l9dh?saxfr*j`]_�ah

�`~2�^Z*pRp*���0Z*�

� ��� �� ��E=�����1�� � � � � ¿��9Ã�1 �� � � � � � � ��

�� ' �8>��

t(�*�ah_� �Äefjc]_�*��]_d]{�^x*Zyr*�q�2�ahcd�l>saxfr*j`]_�ah`j����Iefi��Z%d�r*h;��j`j_r*�gb*]_efdZ*j�~^]`�*efjcb,h`d^iyefp*�aj(�h`����j`d�Z0�^�*xf�IefZ*ef]`e��^x2�g���^j`r,h`�(l9dh?]`�*�Ws�d�gb,x}��½zef][oWefZyid�xfi�apqefZgh_�aj`d�xfizefZ*�q]_�*�IsadZ��0efsa]`jp*�a]_�asa]`��p�efZRj`]_�ab >ud^l"]_�*�W�c�+� ����saefj`efdZR��xf��dh`ef]_�*���

*���i�ah_]`�*�axf�aj_j�~#ef]�efjId�yiye}d�r*j(]`�2�^]I]`�*�uln����j`ef�*efxfef][ogd^l?]`�*� �c�+��� j�p*��saefj`efdZ��,e}Z,��ajr*b2dZR]`�*�I�&�G�asa]��*efjvb,h`�ab2dj_�ap�j`d�xfr*]`efdZ5t(efx}x2�0��i���dZ5Z*����h`�yo\��e}h_b*x��^Z*��jvefZg]_�*�Ij`�*d�h`]]`�ah_�»�^Z*p��mln]`�ah_t;��h`p*j��g��d5e}�5b*h`d^i��Wdr,hW�g����j`r*h_�%d�l;j_]`�ab >5sad�5b*xf�a½ye}][oy~2tv�q�qr,j`]]k��w�gefZy]`d���sasadr,Zz] ]`�,�gsad�Z*saxfr*j`efd�Z*jWd^l�]_�*�g���+�MefZ�j_]`�ab*j7]�]_�*h`d�r*�� �*�RY[Z�d]_�*�ahtvd�h`p*j�~t?�(�qr*j_]"��j`]`ef�R�^]`�?�*d^t �\�^ZyoIdb2�ah{�^]`efd�Z*jv�^h_�(efZzi�dxfi��p%efZ sk�,�as{wzefZ*�ut(�*�a]`�,�ah�I]`��Zz]{�^]_e}i���h_�ah`d�r*]`efZ*�Wp,�asaefp*�ap5r*b0d�ZqefZqj`]`��b2]��¥�0�^j_�apgd�ZqsadZ*s�x}r,j`efdZ*j?�\��p*�?e}Z j`]_�ab>��?t(efxfx­� �­��sa]�]_�*�Wh`d�r*]`��j�d^l�d]_�*�ah��^efh_b*x��^Z*�aj(efZ5]`�*�WZ,���^h?lnr,]`r*h_���(�*�?�\��e}Z�l���sa]`d�h�tv�(Z*���apq]`dIp*�a]_�ah`�5efZ*�vefj�]`�,�(Zzr,�q�0�ah#d^l>�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj#]`�0��]cj`�*d�r*xfp

�0��sadZ*j_efp*�ah`��p �_saxfdj_�&�\]_d��^Z��^efh`s�hk��l9]qb0�^efhq]`�2�^]qZ*�a��p*jR]`d��2��h`�ah_dr*]_�ap>� ��Rr*j`�]`�*�qs{�0��hk��sa]`�ah_e ��^]_e}d�Z�d�l �`s�x}d�j`�&�gp,�{�0Z*�ap���jWb0��h`]Id^l(]`�*�2�?xfr*j_]`�ah_efZ*����xf��dh`ef]_�*� tv�b*h`��j`�aZy]`��pq���^h_x}ef�ah�� �Oe}i��aZW�^Z%��efh`j`b2�^sa�cp,e}iyefp*�apue}Zy]_d ��s�x}r,j`]`��h`j�~�t(ef]`�WÁ � h`�ab*h_�aj`��Zz]_efZ*�]`�*��Zyr*�q�0��hcd^l>b*x���Z*�aj?e}Zqs�x}r,j`]`��h �`~�ef]�lndxfxfd^t(j�]`�0��]v]_�*�ah_�O��h`��Á

�4 �Wd�]`�*��h;��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j

]`�*�?�c�+���qr*j`]2sad�Z*j`efp*�ah�t(�*��ZWh`�aj_dxfiyefZ*���(sad�Zy�0efsa]#�0�a][t?�a�aZ ][t?d��^efh`b*x���Z*�ajGefZIsaxfr*j`]_�ah�`���(�yr*j(]`�*��h`�%��h`�+�n��b*b*h`d^½yef�\��]`�axfo �

�*¿nÁ � 4 ��Ãa¿ � �� ¿��9Ã`ÃefZz]_�ahk��sa]`efd�Z*jq]`�0��]%]_�*�g���+� �qr*j`]usadZ*j_efp*�ahqefZP�R��efi�aZ saxfr*j`]_�ah �`� �(]%]_�*efj%b2defZy]�~ef]W�0��sad�5�ajWsaxf����h%]_�0�^]W]_�*�gZyr*�q�2�ahId^l�efZy]`��hk�^s�]`efdZ*j �^p*p*��p��yo�]_�*efjW�g���^j`r,h`�qp*dy�ajZ*d]Is{�0��Z*�� ]`�*�ul���sa]I]`�0��]�]_�0�^]I]_�*�%s�d�gb,x}��½zef][o5d^lvj_]`�ab3>Àe}jW¾q¿ � � � � � � � Â{Ãa�u�(�yr*j�~tv� �^h`��r*�W]_�0�^]�]`�*�W�5�a]`h_efs�l9dh(j`]_�ab >Àsad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o �efi��aZ��^�2d^i�W�yo 2 !zr2�^]`efd�Z > efjI�jk��]`efj[l���sa]`d�h`o5b*h`d^½yoql9dh?dr*h(b*r,h`b2dj`��j��

�����?> �ud^lc�

Page 27: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

0N��< ��WUW+���&� ��Q+V� ��V � � � �&� ����Q �&�&��� ���&��Q S �&� � ���&�� ��V0W ���?���� �P �+�<���

��b�r,Zz]_efx>]`�,e}j�b0d�efZz]�~*t?�%�2��i��lndysar*j_�ap�d�Z�p*�{�2Z*efZ*�q][tvd5][oyb0�ajId�l��5�a]`h_efsaj?lndh�sad�À�b*xf�a½yef][o­�³�0h`j_]�~v���g��]`h`efs5h`�ax��^]_�ap�]_d�]_�*�RZyr*�q�0��hWd^lIsad�5b0�^h_e}j_dZ*jIh_��!yr*efh`�ap±d^lI]`�*��c�+�UefZ�j_]`�ab�Æq��Z*p�]k��wye}Z,�gefZy]`dRsadZ,j`efp*�ah{�^]`efd�Z�]_�*�%b,h`dysa�aj_j`�ajqefZyid�x}i��apRefZ�j_]`�ab*j ]]`�*h_dr*��� �,~^�^Z*pWj_�asad�Z*p>~y�(�g��]`h`efsc]_�0�^] !yr0�^Zy]`e��0��j>]`�,�vh_dxf�vd�l*p0�^Z*���ahc�^Z*pue}Zusah`����]`efZ*�sad�5b*xf�a½yef][oz�G�(�,��x���]`]`��h(�g�a]_h`efsIj`]`���gj?�gdj_]`xfoulnh`d���j_]`�ab > sad�Z*j`efp*�ah{�^]_e}d�Z*j���(�*�aj_���5�a]`h_e}s�j"s��^b*]_r*h`��]`�*�(�5dj`]#ef�gb2dh`]{�^Zy]"��j`b2�asa]_j(d^lG]`�*����e}h�]_hk��|gs(t?dh_wyx}dy�^p

sad�5b*xf�a½yef][oz� *��ai��h`]`�,�axf�aj`j�~*sad��gb*xf�a½yef][oWefj;��xfj`d%� �­�as�]`�apR�yoWl[�^sa]_dh`j?j`r,sk����jv]_�*��h{�^]`�d^l;��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj��aZy]_�ah`efZ*���^Z,p��a½yef]`efZ*�q]`�,�³��e}h_j`b0��sa�~G]_�*� idxfr*�5��d�lv]`�*�q�^efh_j`b0��sa�~>��Z*p]`�*�ub*h`�aj_�aZ*sa�qd�lv�^p*p*ef]_e}d�Z0�^xGj_d^ln][t(�^h_�I]`dydxfj(]`dR�^r*]_d�R�^]`efs���xfx}oub*h`�ap,e}s�]�sad�Zy�0efsa]`jW��Z*p�^xf�ah_](]`�*�W���+�I��(�*���0h`j_]cd^lG]`�,�aj`�?l���sa]`d�h`j�p*�ab2�aZ*p,jvd�Z%]_�*�(hk��]`�?d^lG�aZy]`h`oq�^Z,pW�a½yef]"d�l­b,x¼��Z*�aj#lnh_d�

]`�*�I�^efh`j_b0�^s����^]v��Zzou�efi�aZq]_ef�g�����Z*p*�ah�]`�*� ��h`���^j`d�Z0�^�,x}���c�^j_j`r*�5b*]`efdZ ]`�2�^]cef]�]k��w�aj]`�*���c�+���Is��ah`]{�^efZg�*xfdys{w%d�l>]`ef�g�?]`du�0�^Z*p5d^i�ah��ai�ah_o\��e}h_sahk�mln]c�a½yef]`efZ*�u]`�*�I�^efh`j_b0�^sa��^Z*pRh_�asa�aefi�I�ai��ah`oR�^efh`s�hk��l9]v�aZy]_�ah`efZ*�q]_�*�W�^efh`j_b0�^sa��~*t?���0��i���]`�2�^](]`�,��s�d�gb,x}��½zef][oWd�l]`�*efj(]{�^j`w5s��^ZR�2�Wh`��b*h`�aj_�aZy]`�ap��yo

�U=?; ���� ����= � > � � 9 2 Zy]`h_o�����]`� � 2 ½yef] ���^]_� 9 't(�*�ah_� � h_�ab*h`��j`�aZy]`ju]`�*�q�^�5dr*Zy]cd�lv]`ef�g� �n��j`j`r,�g�ap��^b,b*h`d^½yef�\��]`�axfoq��!yr0��x �?]_�0�^]�ef]]k��w�aj�]`�*�I�c�+�±]_dq�0�^Z,p*xf���aZy]`h_ef�aj���Z*pR�a½ye}]�lnh_d��]_�*�%�^efh_j`b0��sa����(�*�Isad��gb*xf�a½yef][o%d�l]`�*efj(]{�^j`w5efj(x}efZ*���^h���(�*�5idxfr*�5�qd^lI]`�*�R�^efh`j_b0�^sa��~vt(�,e}s{� �0�^jq�2�a�aZ±]k��w�aZ±efZy]`d�s�dZ*j_e}p,�ahk��]`efdZ±ef�q�

b*xfefsaef]`xfo��yo�dr*hq�5���^j_r*h`�ajqd�l�j_]`�ab >�sad��gb*xf�a½yef][oz~����G�asa]_jR]`�*�W�{d���d^lI]`�*���c�+� efZd�yiyefdr*jWt(��oyj��R�*d�h%�5�0½y�ap Zyr*�q�0��h�d�l�b*x��^Z*��j�~#j`�\��xfx}��hO��efh`j`b2�^sa�aj t(efxfxc�0�5�0�^h_p*�ah]`dR�0��Z*p*xf�W]`�2�^Z�x��^h_��ahI�^efh`j_b0�^s��ajI�0�as��^r*j_�q]`�*� Zyr*�q�0��h�d^l?b*x��^Z*�aj�b0��h�r,Z*ef]�id�xfr*�g�t(efx}x#�0�u�*ef��*�ah�~2j`dg]_�*�Wp0��Z*���h��g��]`h`efsaj�p*�{�0Z,�ap�efZR]`�,�Wb*h`��izefd�r*jIj`�asa]_efdZ*j�t(e}xfx#]`�aZ*p]`d5�0� �*ef��*��h�� *I�^]`r,hk�^xfxfoy~yp*���^xfefZ*�qt(ef]`���ai�aZy]_r0�^x#sadZy�2e}s�]`j+�n��j�p*efj`s�r*j`j_�ap����^h_xfe}��h�efZ]`�*�ub0�^b2�ah��©t(efx}xG]{�^w�����i�aZ��5dh_��d�l�� j_�asadZ,p0�^h_o\h_dxf�W]_dqh`�aj_dxfiye}Z,�%�5dh`�Ief�g�qefZ*��Zz]sadZ��0efsa]`j����Iefi��Zq]`�0��]v�R�^ZyoWd^l�]`�*��db2�ahk��]`efdZ2�^xG�ah_h`dh_j(�\��p*�(�yo%�c�+�?j?h`��j`r*xf]?lnh_d�ef�Z*d�h`efZ*�Rj`�as�dZ*p0��h`o�sadZ��0efsa]`julndhI]_dzd�x}d�Z*� )� ~>]_�*efjW�g���^Z*jI]`�2�^]I]`�*�5b0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��x�lnd�h�^sas�e}p,�aZy]`j e}ju�*ef��*�ahut(�*�aZ�]_�*�gZyr*�q�2�ahId^l(b*x��^Z,�aj%b2�ah r*Z*ef]Iid�x}r,�g� d^l��^efh`j_b0�^sa�5efj�*ef��*��h����(�*�Wx���h`���hv]_�*�Wid�xfr*�g�(d�l��^ZR�^efh`j_b0�^s��Wefj�~y]`�,���5dh_��r*Z*s��ah`]{�^efZy][og]`�,�W�c�+�l��^s��ajgefZ�b*h_�ap*efsa]_e}Z,���ai�aZy]_r0�^xIsad�Zy�0efsa]`j5�*r*]5]`�*���5dh_�gxf�a�at(��o��*���0�^j5]`d�h`��h`dr,]`��^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj(]_�0�^]���h`�IdZRsad�Zy�0efsa]`efZ*� b0��]`�*j��

Z*�(d^l2]`�*�(�R�^efZWj`��sadZ*p2�^h`oul���sa]`d�h`jc]_�0�^]�p*�aj_�ah`i��aj?sadZ*j_efp*�ahk��]`efdZqefj�]`�,�(�&�­��sa]vd�lj`d�ln][t;��h`��]`d%��e}pq]_�*�����+��efZ b*h`��p*efsa]`efZ*� sadZ��0efsa]`j����(�*����p*i�^Zy]k����(d�l­j_r*s{�gj`d�ln][t(�^h`�efjq]`�0��]�~?�yo�efp*�aZy]`e�lnoyefZ*��s�dZy�0efsa]_j\��Z*p±dh`p,�ah`efZ*��]_�*�a� �zo ]`�*���^�gd�r*Zy]Wd^lIp0�^Z,��ah]`�*��oPb2dj_�~�e}]qh_�ap*r*s��aj�]`�,���axf�a�g��Zz]qd�lWsad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o�]_�0�^]g��h`efj`��j\efZ±j`]_�ab ÆRd^lW]`�*��c�+�8���as�e}j_efdZ���xf�d�h`ef]`�*����*��ai��h`]`�,�axf�aj`j�~�]`�*�qb*h_ef�\�^h_ogsad��gb*xf�a½yef][ogd�lv]`�,�q�c�+��� j�{d� sad�5�ajulnh`d�� ]_h`oyefZ*��]`dR�0��r*h`�Rd�r*]%�,d^t�]`d�j`d�x}i��gsad�Zy�0efsa]_j%d�Z*sa�R]`�*��oP�^h_efj`�~?�l��^s�]vt(�*efs{� lnd�x}xfd^t(j#lnh_d�M]_�*��p,e}j_sar*j_j`efdZ5e}Zq]_�*��b,h`�aiyefdr*j?j`��sa]`efdZ,j �9¾q¿nÁGÂ�Ã#lnd�hcj`]_�ab�Æi�ah_j`r*j?¾q¿ � � �� � � � � Â{Ã2lnd�h>j`]_�ab�>����G�(�*efj�j`r*����aj_]`j�]`�2�^]�~�t(�*efx}���*�axfbylnr*x�efZWh`�ap,r*saefZ*�IdZ*�4 [ 58797-:��� =

�����?> �ud^lc�

Page 28: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

][oyb0� d^lcsad��gb*xf�a½yef][oz~�b*h_d�h{�^�5jvp*��j`ef�Z*��p�]_dqp*�a]`��sa]Wsad�Zy�0efsa]`j��gef��y]?Z*d]��0� �^�*xf�W]_dsad�q�2�^]G]`�,�vb*h_ef�\�^h_o(j`d�r*h`sa�(d�l*sad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o©l��^s��apW�yoI]`�*�?�c�+�I�a�(�,�vb*h_ef�\�^h_o(p0�^Z,��ahd^lcj`d�ln][t(�^h`�Ip*��j`ef�Z*��p\]_dqefp*�aZy]`e�lnoqsad�Zy�0efsa]_j(lnd�h(]`�*�I�c�+� efj(]`�0��](e}]?sad�r*xfp\s��^r*j_�W]`�*��c�+� ]`d�]k��w�����gdh_�gb0��j`j_e}i����^]_]`ef]`r,p*�Re}Z j`����h`s{�*efZ*� lndh b0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��x�sad�Zy�0efsa]_jgZ*d�]efp*�aZy]`e��0�ap��yoR]`�*� j`d�ln][t;��h`��IY[��Z*dh_efZ*�qj`�as�dZ*p0��h`o ��d�h��ai��aZy]`r0��x ��sad�Zy�0efsa]_j�r,Zz]_efx"]_dydx��^]`�5efj³�Rb,h`ef�\��h`o�j_dr*h_sa�Rd^l�db2�ah{�^]`efd�Z0�^x?�ah`h_dh_jqe}Z���efh%]_hk��|gs5sadZy]_h`dx[~c��Z*p�]`�*��h`�efj³��b0d�j`j_e}�,x}efxfef][o�]_�0�^] j`d�ln][t(�^h`�R�^efp*j sadr,x}p tvd�h`j_�aZ�]_�*efjqb*h`d��*xf�a������jg�Rb2defZy]%d�lj`oyZy]`�*��j`efjgh_�a�z��h`p*efZ*��]`�*�Rr*j_�Rd^l�j`d�ln][t(�^h`�5efZP�^efh ]`h{��|gsgs�dZy]`h_dx[~ct?�gj_r*����aj`]q]_�0�^]b*h`d��h{�^�gjqp,�aj`ef�Z,�ap ]_dP��e}p±]_�*�����+�De}Z e}p,�aZy]`e�lnoyefZ*��s�dZy�0efsa]_jR�0��p*�aj_e}��Z*�apU�^jR��r*efp*��]`d ]`�*�I�c�+��� jcd^t(ZI�{r*p*���a�g��Zz]�hk�^]_�*�ah(]_�0�^ZR�Wt(��o%d�l"�^r*]_d�R�^]`efZ*�W��Zzo d^l�]`�*�lnr*Z*s�]`efdZ*j(b2�ah lndh_�g�apR�yoq]`�*�u�c�+�I�

0N�� � ����Q �E �U� � ��QY[Z�]`�,e}j(j_�asa]_e}d�Z>~*t?�I�0��i�Ip*��h`efi�ap�j`�ai��ahk��x"�5�a]`h_efsaj?lndh?]`�,�Wsad�5b*xf�a½yef][o%d�l�]_�*�Wb*h_d�y�xf�a�gj?l���saefZ*�q]`�,�W�c�+�ÄefZR�*efj��^]_]`�a�5b*](]`dqefp*��Zz]_e�lno\��Z*p�sad�h`h`��sa]Ib0d�]`�aZy]`e���x>b*h_d�*xf�a�5j�0��][tv�a��ZP�^efh_sahk�mln]�efZ��qp*oyZ0���gefsI�aZyizefh_dZ*�5�aZy]��I��dgsax���h`e�lnoR]`�*�qb,h`d�,x}����~*t?� e}Zy]_h`d^�p*r*sa��p�]`�*�W���+� ����saefj`efdZ���xf�dh_ef]`�*� �^jW�q�5dyp*�ax2lnd�h�]`�,�%p*e �G�ah`��Zz]I][oyb2�ajId^lv]{�^j`wyjsadZ�lnh`d�Zz]_efZ*�g]_�*�%���+�I� ��W]_�*�aZ��a½*�^�gefZ*��p\]_�*�W][t?dgb*h_ef�\�^h_og][oyb2�ajId^lcsad�5b*xf�a½yef][o]`�0��]�tv�ah_�vj_r*����aj`]_�ap �zoI]_�*efj"�^xf��dh`ef]_�*��~{Z0���g�axfo�j`]`��b\Æ?�^Z*pWj_]`�ab+>(s�d�gb,x}��½zef][oy�*�(�*��0h`j_]�d^l0]_�*�aj`�(s�dh`h_�aj`b2dZ,p*jc]`d�]`�*�?p*e�|gsar*xf][o�e}Zyi�dxfi�apIefZIefp*�aZy]`e�lnoyefZ*���^efh_sahk�mln]>�2�a][t?�a�aZt(�*efs{���Rb0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xcsad�Zy�0efsa]W�5e}���y](dzs�sar*hq�^Z*p���e}h_sahk�mln]It(�*dj_�gsar,h`h`��Zz] ]`h{�a�{�as�]`dh_ef�ajj`r*����aj_]W]`�,�qb0d�j`j`ef�*efxfef][oRd^l;��Z��ai��aZy]`r0��xcsad�Zy�0efsa]�� �(�*�qj_�asad�Z*p�][oyb0�qd�lvsad�5b*xf�a½yef][oh`�{l9�ah`j?]`dW]_�*�(p*e�|gsar*xf][oIefZyidxfi��apWefZ%p,�a]`�ah_�gefZ*efZ*�2~^�efi��ZW]`�0��]c][t?dO��efh`b*x��^Z,�ajc�^h`�(Z,���^h���^s{��d�]`�*��h�efZ�]`�,�%�^efh`j_b0�^s��~*t(�*��]`�*�ahI]_�*�aoRb*h`��j`�aZy]W�qj_e}]_r0�^]_efdZgefZRt(�*efs{��]`�,�W�c�+�j`�*d�r*xfpgefZy]`�ah_i�aZ,��]_d³��i�defpg�usadxfxfefj`efdZ>~�Z*���^h(�5efj`j�~�dh?xf�aj`j_�ah��^efh_j`b0��sa�Iizefd�x¼��]`efdZ#� ��p*�a]_�ah`�5e}Z,�apg]_�0�^]cj_]`�ab�Æ(s�d�gb,x}��½zef][oIefjvd�l>dh_p*�ah(¾q¿nÁGÂaÃ?�^Z,pq]`�0��]vj_]`�ab >Isad�5b*xf�a½yef][oefj(d^lcdh_p*�ah�¾q¿�� � � � � � � Â{Ãa~,t(�*�ah_�%ÁRh`��b*h`�aj_�aZy]`jW]_�*�WZyr*�q�2�ah?d^l���efh`b*x��^Z,�aj(efZ\� �efi��aZsaxfr*j`]_�ah d^lv]_�*�g�^efh`j_b0�^s��� Y[]�efjIb2dj`j_ef�*xf�~Gd^l(sad�r*h`j_�~>]_�0�^]It?�%s�dZ*j_e}p,�ahW]`�,�g�^efh`j_b0�^sa�ef]`j`��x¯l?]`dR�0� dZ,�Wsaxfr*j`]_�ah�~#efZ�t(�*efs{��s���j`� ]`�*�q�^�2d^i�W�5���^j_r*h`��j�h_�ab*h_�aj`�aZy]W]_�*� j`]`��b�Æ�^Z*p�j_]`�ab3> dh`p,�ah`jWd�l;s�d�gb,x}��½zef][oRd^l(]`�,�q�aZy]`efh`�R�^efh`j_b0�^sa���qY9l�]`�*�g��efh`j`b2�^sa�qs���Z��0�p*efiye}p,�ap�efZz]_dg�5dh`� ]`�2�^Z�dZ,�qsaxfr*j`]_�ah�~�t?�%�2��i�qj`�,d^t(Z�]_�0�^]Il9h`d� ]`�*�qb2�ah_j`b2�asa]`efi��d^lc]`�,�W�c�+� �n��Z*pR]`�*�uZzr,�q�0�ah(d�lch`��!yr*efh`��p�p*�asaefj_e}d�Z*j ���^j_j`�aj_j`�g��Zz]_jIh`��!yr*efh`��p�efZR]`�*��c�+� ���asaefj`efdZ���xf�dh_ef]`�*� �(]`�,�qsad�5b*xf�a½ye}][oRd�l�]`�*�q�aZy]_e}h_�\��e}h_j`b0��sa�gefjI]`�,�gj`r,� d�l]`�*�usad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o �g���^j`r,h`��lndh?]`�,�WefZ*p*efiye}p,r0�^x*s�x}r,j`]`��h`j���(�*��b*h`ef�\��h`o sadZ,j`efp*�ah{�^]`efd�Zqlnd�hvj_]`�ab >usad�5b*xf�a½ye}][oOlndxfxfd^t(j�lnh_d� �a½y]`�aZ,p*efZ*�q]`�*�

h`�aj_r*xf]`j�h_�ax��^]_e}Z,��]`dP��j`j_�aj`j_e}Z,�P]_�*��p0�^Z*���ahR�0��][tv�a��Z ]_�*� ��efh`b*x��^Z,�ajgefZ ��Z �^efh`s�hk��l9]b0�^efh�� �(�,h`�a���g�a]_h`efsaj lnd�hg�^j_j`�aj_j`efZ*�±p0�^Z,��ah5tv�ah_��b*h_�aj`�aZy]_�apM�^Z*p±p*efj_sar*j`j_�ap>~W��Z*ptv���^h`��r*�ap±l9dh � �� ~?]_�*��Zyr*�q�2�ahqd^lWefZy]`�ah_i�aZy]`efd�Z*jgh_��!yr*efh`�ap�d�lW]`�*�����+���0��j`�apdZ�]`�*�q��½zs��a�ap*efZ*��d^lvs��ah`]{�^efZ�p0�^Z,��ahWs�h`ef]`�ah_e��*~��^jI]`�*�q�2�aj_]W�g����j`r*h_�qd^lvp2�^Z*���ahIlnd�hp*�a]_�ah`�5e}Z,e}Z,��]`�,�vsad��gb2�a½yef][o�d�l0j`]_�ab�>*����j�lnd�h>j_]`�ab�Æ�~^tv�?sad�Z*j`efp*�ah_�apq]`�,�;��Z0�^xfoyj`efj>d�lj`]_�ab�>(sad��gb*xf�a½yef][o���j�e}]#h`�ax���]`�ajc]_d�p*���\�^Z,p*j>b*x���sa�ap dZW]_�*�v���+���yoIj`]`��b*j�]�]_�*h`d�r*���*~y�^Z*p �gdyp*e��0��pW�0d�]`�q�5���^j_r*h`�aj�]`dI]k��w�(]`�,�(e}Zy]_�ahk��sa]`efdZ,jc�0��][tv�a��Zgsaxfr*j_]`�ah_j;��Z*pq]`�*�efZz]_�ahk��sa]`efd�Z*jg�2�a][t?�a�aZ�]_�*�RsadZy�2e}s�]gb0��e}hq�^Z,pPd�]`�*��hg�^efh`b*x���Z*�ajqefZ±]`�*�Rsaxfr*j_]`�ah5e}Zy]_d�^sas�dr*Zy]���(�*�Isad�Z*Z*�asa]_efdZ��2�a][t?�a�aZ�]_�*�IZzr,�q�0�ah(d�l���e}h_b*x��^Z*��j(e}Z5]`�*� �^efh`j_b0�^sa�W��]��^ZyoqdZ*�

�����?>�ud^lc�

Page 29: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

]`ef�g�R�^Z*p±]_�*��sad��gb*xf�a½yef][o�d�lW]`�*���^efh_j`b0��sa��efjqef�gb*xfefsaef]I]`�*h_dr*���*dr*]5dr*hg��Z0�^xfoyj`efj���(�*�qZyr*�q�2�ahId^l��^efh`b*x���Z*�ajIb*h`��j`�aZy] p*r*h`efZ*����Zzo��efi�aZ�e}Zy]_�ah`i��xcd^l(]`ef�g� ���G�asa]`judr*hsad�5b*xf�a½yef][o��^Z0��xfozj_efjWefZ��qr*s{��]`�,�gjk���g�qt(��o ��j%]_�*�RZyr*�q�0��hWd^l���e}h_sahk�mln] b*h`�aj_�aZy]�^]g��Zzo �efi��Z�]`ef�5�~�efZP]_�*�Rj`�aZ,j`��]`�0��]q]`�*����i��hk�^���RZzr,�q�0�ah d^l%��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j%efZ±]`�*��^efh`j_b0�^s��³��]��^ZyoR�efi��aZ�]`ef�5��]_�0�^]I�^h_�%b0��h`]�d^l;�Àx¼��h`���ah�saxfr*j_]`�ahIefj�]_�*� b*h`ef�\��h`oÀl��^s{�]`d�hqe}Z p*�a]_�ah`�5e}Z,e}Z,��sad��gb*xf�a½yef][oy���(�,�\d�Z*xfo�h`����x(p*e �­��h`�aZ*s���]_�0�^] ]`�*efjqp*efj_]`efZ*sa]_e}d�Z�\��w�ajcs�d�g��j�lnh`d�� sadZ*j_efp*�ah`efZ*�g�Oj`ef]`r0��]`efdZqt(�,�ah`�I]`�,�O��i��ahk����(]_e}�5�(���^s{�R�^efh`b*x���Z*�j`b2�aZ*p*j�efZg]`�,���^efh_j`b0��sa�Ie}j?j`�R�^xfx[~�j`efZ*sa�IefZg]_�*efjvs���j`�Ij`]_�ab >��9�^Z*p ]%]_�*h`d�r*�� ����sad�À�b*xf�a½yef][oql���sa]`d�h`j/�¥efp*�aZy]`e�lnoyefZ*� b*x��^Z*�aj(t(ef]_�\j_�*dh_]�]_�ah`� b0��]`�Rsad�Zy�0efsa]`jI�^Z*pRh_�ah`d�r*]`efZ*�]`�*���1��t(efxfx*�2��h`��x¼��]`efi��x}o �gd�h`�?ef�gb2dh`]{�^Zy]�j`efZ*sa��]`�*�©�0ef��y]cb0��]`�*j?d^l>d�]`�*��h;��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�^h_�g�0��h`p*�ah ]`d�b*h`�ap,e}s�]³��Z*p�]`�*�R�^efh`j_b0�^s��qe}jub0d�]`�aZy]`e���x}xfo�j_�\��x}xf�ah��g��xfj`d0~#]`�,�gdh_p*�ah¾q¿nÁ�b2�ah�r*Z,e}]?]`ef�5��Ã?s�d�gb,x}��½zef][oWp,r*�I]`d saxf���^h_e}Z,�%b*x���Z*�aj(]`d �aZy]`��h��^Z,pg�a½yef]v]_�*�Ij`�as��]`d�h�t(efxfxG�0�W�,e}���*�ah��0�as��^r*j_�%]_�*�Whk��]`�ajId�l���Zz]_h`o��^Z,p\��½zef]I�^h`�ux}efw��axfoq]`dq�2�W�*ef��*��h�efZ]`�*efjcj_ef]`r0��]`efdZ>���#xfr*sa]`r2�^]`efd�Z*j�e}Zq]_�*���^efh�]`h{��|gs(d^i��ahv��>G]I�*d�r*hcb2�ah`efdyp ) �~_�{r*p*��e}Z,���yob0�^]_]`�ah_Z*j(�a½y�*ef�*ef]`��pgefZg�R�a�{dh 2 r,h`db2����Z\�^h_���^j�~*sad�Z*j`efj_]vd�l>x}d^t±Z*ef���z]�]`ef�g�(b*x���]`����r*j�~�qj_�0�^h_b�h`efj`��~­��Z*p�� �*ef���*�ah��5efp*p0��oqb*x��^]_���^rRt(ef]`�R]_�*�%Zyr*�q�2�ah(d�l���efh`b*x��^Z,�aj�efZR]`�*��^efh`s�hk��l9](j`�asa]_dh��c�(�*�Isad��gb*xf�a½yef][o%d�l"����s{�\d�l"]_�*�aj`�ub0�ah_efdzp,j(p*�ab2�aZ*p*j�e}Z5]`�*�I�R�^Z*Z*��hp*efj`sar,j`j`��p\���^h`xfef�ahcd�Zq]`�*�(Zyr*�q�2�ah�d^lGb*x��^Z,�ajcb*h_�aj`�aZy](efZ ]`�*�I�^efh`j_b0�^sa����]v���efi��Zq]`ef�g��^Z*p5]`�*�I�a½y]_�aZ*j`efd�Z\d�l>]`�*�Ip0��Z*���hv�5���^j_r*h`�aj?l9h`d� ]_�*���0h`j_](b0d�h`]`efd�Zgd^l>]_�*�Ib0�^b2�ah(]_d]`�*�usad�5b*xf�a½ye}][oq�5�a]`h_efs�d^lcb0��h`]�> e}ZR]_�*�W�c�+�����asaefj`efdZR��x}��dh_e}]_�*���#Y[ZR]`�*�ub0�ah_efdzpd^l(j`�0��h`b�h`efj`�g��Z*p�j`�0��h`b�p*�as�x}efZ*��~Gsaxf���^h{�^Z*s��g�&�G�asa]_j%t(efxfx>�2�q�gd�h`�Wef�gb2dh_]k��Zz](]_�0�^Zr*j`r2�^x[~0��j�t(efxfxGj`]`��b > �&�G�asa]`jIt(�*��Z�ef](e}j��gd�h`��p,e¯|gs�r*xf]?lndh(]_�*�W�c�+� ]`dg��j`j`��j`jI�*d^t]`d5p*���^x#t(ef]`�Rb0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xGsadZ��0efsa]�j_e}]_r0�^]_efdZ*j��v�,dh(]`�,�W�*ef��*��h(b*x��^]`���^r>~,j`]`��b�ÆI�&�G�asa]`jt(efx}x,�0���*ef��*�ah�]`�0��Zg]`�,�(d]`�,�ahvb2�ah_e}dyp*j?d^l>]_hk�m|gs�>Y[Z5j`r*��~^t?�(�0�axfef�ai���]`�,��sad��q�*efZ0���]`efdZ�d^lv]_�*�qsad�5b*xf�a½yef][oq�g�a]_h`efsajItv� �0��i��Wp*�ah_e}i��ap�]k�^w��ajI]`�*� b2d]`��Zz]_e��^x�sad�5b*xf�a½yef][olnh`d���j_�*dh_]���Z*pRx}d�Z*�q]`��h`�DsadZy�2e}s�]`jIefZz]_d³��sasad�r*Zy]�h`���^j`d�Z0�^�,x}o5tv��x}x�lndh���xfxGd^lc]`�*��j`�b0��h`efdyp*jqd^l(efZz]_hk��p0��o�i��h`e��^]_efdZ��zo�sad�Z*j`efp*�ah_efZ*��]_�*�gb,h`ef�\��h`o5l��^s�]`dh_j³� �­��sa]`efZ*��]`�*�j`b2�asae��0s j`]{�^���j(d^lc]`�*�I�c�+��� j?p*�asaefj_e}d�ZRb*h`dysa�aj_jId^i�ah�� ��e}i��aZgb2�ah_e}dypRd^l�]`ef�g���

� �q·RJ�J�HWT ��NLuT �RT"C(E#C(K F"HIF�¹�LuKDF"LD¶/��� HWºRJ�¹�KR¹�EGF"T�H �F�LWT

Y[Z\��Z\�^]_]`�a�5b*]c]_d%ef�gb,h`d^i�?jk�mln�a][oR�^Z*pqh_�ap*r*sa�utvd�h`wyxfdz�^p,jcdZR�^efhc]`h{��|gsIsad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah_j�~]`�*�R�����De}jusadZ*j_efp*�ah`efZ*��j`d^l9][t;��h`�q]`�2�^]Wt?dr*xfp��^r*]_d�R�^]`efs���xfx}oR�^xf�ah_]WsadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah_j%]_db0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xcsad�x}xfefj`efd�Z*jI�0�a][t?�a�aZ b*x��^Z*��j��5�"dR�^j_j`efj`] efZ�]_�*�qp*�ai��axfdb*�5�aZy]�d�l;]_�*efjWj`d�ln][�t;��h`�~�tv�u�0h`j_]Isah`����]`�ap±�^Z*p�]`�aj_]`�ap��0i��%�5dyp*�axfj�~,���^s{��d^l?t(�*efsk���efi�ajW�À�g�a]_h`efsIlnd�h]`�*�qp2�^Z*���ahWb*h_�aj`�aZy]_�ap��yo�][t?d��^efh`b*x���Z*�aj��0oyefZ*�Re}Z�j`b2�^sa��5�*d�hO��xfx"�5�a]`h_efsaj�~G�,e}���*�ah�g����j`r*h_�aj�sadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p ]`d��5dh_�"ef�5�gefZ*�aZy]*p0��Z*���h"�2�a][t?�a�aZ ]`�*�?][t?d�b*x��^Z,�aj�~^�^Z,pW]`�yr*j���^s{�q�5�a]`h_e}s�j`r*����aj_]`jv��b*h_e}d�h`ef][oIdh_p*�ah`efZ*�I�yoWt(�*efs{� ]`�*�?sadZy]_h`dxfxf�ah�j`�,dr*xfpq�^]`]_�aZ*pq]_db*h`d��*xf�a�gj.M*�^p*p,e}]_efdZ0��x}xfoy~^sad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah(efZy]`��h`i��Zz]_efdZ5lndh�� b2�^h`]_efsar*x��^h(sad�Zy�0efsa]�e}j(Z,�asa�aj �jk��h`oqt(�*�aZ5]`�*��j`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z�� j"p2�^Z*���ahv�5���^j_r*h`�(�2�asad��g�aj?�*ef��,�ahc]`�2�^Zqj`d��g�(b*h_�ap*�{�2Z*�ap]`�*h_�aj`�,dxfp�i�^xfr*��� ��\b,h`db2dj_�5�0i���5dyp*�axfjWl9dh j`dxfiyefZ*��]`�*efjqb*h_d�*xf�a���g]_�*��]`h_efi�e��^x>�5dyp*�ax �¥t(�*efs{��j_e}�5b*xfoqs��^xfsar,x¼��]`�aj�t(�*�a]_�*�ah%�Àsadxfxfefj`efdZRdh�Z*����h��5efj`j(t(efxfx>dysasar*h�~4 � 58797-: � =

�����?> $ud^lc�

Page 30: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

�^j_j`r*�5e}Z,��xfe}Z,���^hW]_hk�a���asa]`d�h`ef�ajqt(ef]`��Z,d�r*Z,sa�ah`]{�^efZy][o �a~c]_�*�gb,h`d�2�^�*efxfj`]_e}sqj_ef�qr*x��^]`efd�Z�gdyp*�ax���t(�,e}s{� �0Z*p*jq]_�*�Rb*h`d��0�^�*efxfef]`ef�ajWd�l���s�dxfxfe}j_efdZ�dh Z*����hq�gefj`j�~>�yo���j`j`r,�gefZ*��W�^r,j`j`e���ZPb2�^hk���g�a]_�ahqp*efj`]_h`ef�*r*]_efdZ*jq�^Z*p±b2�ah[l9dh`�5efZ*� ��x���h`��5Zyr*�q�0��hqd^l�h{�^Z*p,d�]`h_e¼��xfj��a~2]_�*�Wsaxfdj_�{�`�^b*b*h_dz��sk���gdyp*�ax ��t(�*efs{��s���x}s�r*x��^]`��j�p0��Z*��ahI�^jI� lnr*Z,sa]`efdZ�d^lc]`�*�][tvd���efh`b*x��^Z,�aj ���5e}Z,e}� r*� p*efj`]k��Z*sa����Z*p�]_�*��]_e}�5�gr*Zy]_e}x(]_�0�^]q�5efZ*ef�%r*� p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�efj�h_���^s{�*��p �a~G]_�*� j`b0��sa�{�[]`ef�g�W�5dyp*�ax �¥t(�*efs{���a½y]`�aZ,p*jW]`�,�%saxfd�j`�{�`�^b*b,h`dz��s{���5dzp,�ax>]_dlndr,hWp*ef�g�aZ,j`efdZ*j��yo�s���xfsar*x��^]_e}Z,�\�R�5e}Z,e}� r*��j_b0�^s��a]`ef�g� ��p*efj`]{�^Z*sa� �q�0��][tv�a��Z�][t?d�^efh`b,x¼��Z*�aj&�a~��Z*pI]`�*�?xfd�z��h`ef]`�,�gefsGp*�ah_e}i��]`efi���gdyp*�ax �¥t(�*efsk�us��^xfsar*x���]`�ajc�(xfd^t?�ahG�2dr*Z*pdZR]`�,��]_ef�g��r,Zz]_efxGsaxfdj`��j`]���b*b*h_dz�^s{� ���

��*efxf�����^s{�Wd�l*]`�*���2i�cb*h_db2dj_�ap%�5dyp*�axfj0�2�^j"��p*i�^Zy]{�^���j>�^Z*pWp,e}j{�^p*i��Zy]k�^���aj�~�tv�p*�a�5dZ*j_]`hk��]`��]`�0��]v]_�*�Isaxfdj`��� ��b*b*h`dy�^s{�g�5dyp*�ax2e}j?b0��h`]`efsar,x¼��h`xfo j`r*sas��aj`j lnr*x�efZqb*h`d�b0d�j[�efZ*� � p0�^Z*���ahq�g��]`h`efsqt(�*efs{��efj �0d�]`�±�^sasar,hk�^]_���^Z*p �{|gsaef�aZy]%]_d�s��^xfsar*x��^]_�� ��*�aZ]`�*���gdyp*��x}jqt?�ah_��]`�aj_]`�apUd�Z�i�^h_efdr*jqj{�^�gb,x}�5s��^j_�aj�~I]_�*��saxfd�j`�{�`�^b*b,h`dz��s{���g�a]_�*dypsad�5b*r*]_�ap�h_�ax��^]`efi��gp0��Z*��ah i�^xfr*��j%]_�0�^] sadh_h`�aj_b0d�Z*p*�ap saxfdj`��x}o t(ef]`��dr,h%efZy]`r*ef]_e}i��r*Z*p*��h`j`]{�^Z*p,e}Z,��d�l;]_�*�qj`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z*j�~#d�*]{�^efZ*efZ*�5]`�*�qxfd^t?�aj`] � � ���ah`h_dh t(e}]_��h_�aj`b2�asa]]`d±�^Z�efZy]`r*ef]_e}i��Rhk�^Z,wzefZ*��d�lW]`�aj_]\s��^j`��j\�yo±p*e�|gsar*xf][oy�Ä�(�*��b*h_d�0���*efx}efj_]`efsRj`ef�qr*x����]`efdZ��5dyp*�axv��x}j_d�b2�ah[lnd�h`�5�ap�tv��x}x?dZ�]_�*�g]_�aj`]qs��^j`��j ��]`�,dr*����j`xfef��y]`xfo�t?dh_j`�g]_�0�^Z]`�*�usaxfdj`��� ��b*b*h`dy�^s{���5dzp,�ax(�a~y�^Z*p��^xfj_dq�0�^j(]_�*�%�^p,i�^Zy]k�����d�lcp*���^xfefZ*� t(ef]`�Rj`d��g��d�l]`�*�qr,Z*sa�ah_]k�^efZy][o�b*h`�aj_�aZy]%efZ�]`�*�q��Zziyefh`d�Z*�g��Zz].MGef]Ie}jI�5dh`�usad�5b*r*]k��]`efdZ2�^xfxfogefZy]`�aZy�j`efi�I]_�0�^Z5]`�*�Isaxfdj_�{�`�^b*b*h_dz��sk�R�5�a]`�*dyp>~��*r*](Z,d]?r*Z*h`���^j`d�Z0�^�,x}oqj_d0���(�*�Ij_b0�^sa����]_e}�5��g�a]_�*dyp±�\��o��2���5dh`����sasar*h{�^]`��]`�2�^Z�]_�*��s�x}d�j`�{�`�^b,b*h`dy�^s{���g��]`�*dyp>~?�*r*]5efj\�^xfj_dj`xfd^t?�ahW]`dRsad��gb*r,]`�~G�5dh_�Wp*e�|gsar*xf]�]_dRe}�5b*xf�a�g��Zz]�~0��Z*p��5dh_�Wdb0��!yr*�%]_d�]`�,�%sad�Zy�]`h_dxfxf�ah����#e}Z2�^xfxfoz~�]`�,�(x}d��z��h`ef]`�*�5e¯s�p*�ah_efi�^]`efi��v�5dzp,�axye}j�xfefw�axfoI]`dIsaxfd�j`�axfo%��b*b*h`d^½yef�\��]`��5�zr,�\�^Z5d�*j_�ah`i��ah`j�� jWefZz]_r*ef]`efdZ,j�d^lc�*d^tÄl[�^j`]I][t?dgb*x���Z*�aj���h`�q�^b*b,h`dz��s{�*efZ*�0~2�*r*]I�^j��h_�aj`r,x}]qef]Wxfd�j`�ajq�^Z±�^sasar,hk�^]_�R�g����j`r*h_�gd^l�t(�,�a]`�*��hq]`�*�R][t?d�b*x��^Z*��j%t(efxfxv�^s�]`r0��x}xfosadxfxfefp*��±�#e}Z2�^xfxfoz~#tv�5]k��w�5l��^s�]`dh_jqj`r*s{���^jqb,x¼��Z*�g�R�^Z*��r*i�ah{�^�*efxfef][o��^Z,pPh_�aj`b2dZ,j`�]`ef�g�(efZy]`d �^sasad�r*Zy]vefZqd�h`p*�ah(]_dWd�,]k�^efZg��Z*d]_�*�ah(�g���^j`r,h`�(d^l>�5efZ*ef�%r*�Uj{��ln��p*efj`]{�^Z*sa�lndh(][t?dq�^b*b*h_dz��sk�,e}Z,�%b*x���Z*�aj��

*���½z]�~ytv�I�a½yb0��Z*pRdZR]`�,��][t?d^�[b*x��^Z,��s���j`�I�yogsad�Z*j`efp*�ah_efZ*�q]`�*�Isad��gb*xf�a½yef][o d^l���Z�aZy]`efh`� �^efh`j_b0�^sa�Ij_�asa]`d�h(t(ef]`�Rh`�aj_b0��sa]�]_dq]`�*�IZyr*�q�2�ahvd�l���e}h_sahk�mln](�^Z*p5]`�*�IZyr*�q�2�ahvd�lb0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xysadZy�2e}s�]`j�����d�p*dIj`d0~�tv�cb,h`�aj_�aZy];��Z%�^xf�d�h`ef]`�,� ��j��©�gdyp*�ax�lnd�h>]_�*�vp,�asaefj`efdZb*h`dysa��j`j(r*Z*p,�ah`]{�^w��Zg�yo³��Zg�^efh�]`h{��|gs(sad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah�e}Zqp,�a]`�as�]`efZ*�q�^Z*p j`d�x}iyefZ*�Isad�Zy�0efsa]`j�� ��I�a½*�^�gefZ*�����^s{��j_]`�ab�d^l"]_�*efj���x}��dh_e}]_�*� efZ*p*efiye}p,r0�^xfxfo%]_dqd�*]{�^efZ\� �5���^j_r*h`�Id�l"ef]`jsad�5b*xf�a½yef][oz�GY[Z5b0�^h_]`efsar*x���h�~y]`�,��j`]_�ab�d�l>j`s���Z*Z*efZ*�ulndh?b0d�]`�aZy]_e¼��xGsadZ��0efsa]`j(t(�^j�lndr,Z*p]`d�i��h`o !yr0�^p*h{�^]_e}s��^xfxfo�efZ�sad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o���j%�5lnr*Z,sa]`efdZ�d�l;]_�*�gZyr*�q�2�ahWd�l©��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj�~�aef]`�*��hW�0�^j_�ap�p*efh`�asa]_xfo�dZ�]_�*� Zzr,�q�0�ah�d^l;��efh`b*x��^Z,�Wb0�^efh_j�~2dh��gdh_�%�^s�sar*hk��]`�axfo���jW�j`r*�Dd^l�sad�5b*xf�a½yef]`ef�aj?d^l"efZ*p,e}iyefp*r0��x0s�x}r,j`]`��h`j�d�l���e}h_b*x��^Z*��j���*���½z]�tv�Ib*h_�aj`��Zz]�j`�ai��ahk��x�g�a]_�*dyp*j(l9dhIs��^xfsar,x¼��]`efZ*�g�5p0��Z*��ahI�5�a]`h_e}s�lnd�hI]`�*�q�^efh`j_b0�^s��³��jO�Àt(�*dxf�~2�0��j`�ap�d�Z]`�*�qj_r*� d^l(j`d��g�W�5���^j_r*h`� ��p0��Z*���h�~#Zzr,�q�0�ahId�l;sad�Zy�0efsa]_j�~#�a]`s�<�±d^i��ahW�^xfx�b0d�j`j_e}�,x}�b0�^efh_j�dh�saxfr*j`]_�ah`jud^l;��e}h_b*x��^Z*��j�� ��WZ,�a½y]�sad��gb*r*]_�W]`�,�Wsad�5b*xf�a½yef][ogd^lcsad�Zy�0efsa]Ih`��j[�dxfr*]_e}d�Z�lndh �R�efi��Z�saxfr*j_]`�ah d^l�Z b*x��^Z*�aj��q]`�,e}jue}jq�^Z *IÅ#�[sad�5b*xf�a]`�5b*h`d��*xf�a� t(e}]_�tvd�h`j_]qs��^j_�\s�d�gb,x}��½zef][o � ��� � ��� � Â����#efZ0��x}xfoy~>t?�Rp*efj`sar,j`jgd�]`�*��h l��^sa]_dh_j%sad�Zy]`h`ef�*r,][�efZ*�g]_dqsadZy]`h_dxfxf�ah�t?dh_wyx}dy�^pRsad��gb*xf�a½yef][oz~�efZ*saxfr*p*efZ*�g��efh`b*x��^Z,�aj��aZy]_�ah`efZ*�R�^Z*p���½zef]_e}Z,�]`�*� �^efh`j_b0�^sa��~*t?���^]_�*�ah(sad�Z*p*ef]`efdZ,j�~0��Z*pg]_�*�Wb*h_�aj`��Z*sa� d^l"j_d^ln][t(�^h_�I]`dydxfj?lnd�hvsad�Zy�0efsa]b*h`��p*efsa]`efdZ#�

�����W���ud^lc�

Page 31: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

� SUT�LWVRHWVR¹�X�¹aE�F>¹ � �q¹�J»·RX�HOF"¹aLWK�SUT�L �uT"HuJ�(�*efj(b*h`d��h{�^��ef�gb,x}���g�aZy]`j�]`�*�WÅ�h_d�0���*efx}efj_]`efs�j_e}�qr,x¼��]`efdZ �gdyp*��xGp*�aj`s�h`ef�0��p�efZ ���������� ������������� ��� ����� ��!��������� �������"���#�$� ��!��������� ��������� �����&%$� ��!� ����'��&����(�)+*,�.-./0-&1 2#3 4 1 * 1#2�&�#�65 7�8�9�-&: 3�/�;=<�&�#�?>"@�A�B�C�9 D ;#;=<�&�#�?>"@�A�B�E�9 3 ;#;=<�&�#�6��9�-�; ; ; ;=<'��#� ���F�"-&9 1#;=<'��#� ���F�3 9 1G<'��#� ���F�* 9 ;H�I; 1=<'��#� ���KJ ����LM'�� � ���+N�OP Q Q

7 % �����"��R��&�#S�TUB�����V #�63#4,�I3,��-�2'�� � ��

�0-W96;,�X;�/�2 : 4#D *�/�D ;GY��3K96;,�X; 3�- -./Z-&; ; 4�-"Y��*K96;,�X; ; * 3 D#D 4 3 4 *GY� /U96;,�X; ; ; ; *#: ; ; * 4GY��1K96;,�X; ; ; ;�/�: : 2 ; 4GY��4K96;,�X; ; ; ; ;#1 * : * ;G<

'�� � ��K�69K'���%���LMN�O�<'�� � ����F9[-Z�I;K\K��]�L^�0-�\ ��]�L^��3 \ ��]�LM��* \ � ]�L^� /#\ ��]_L^� 1#\ ��]��#4�O O OO O�<Q Q

���`-&4�� �KJ��R�����F]9?�H<a�F]9K�H<a�F]9?�b<a�c]9��H<�U9d-Z�I;

QL^��\���O_<

Q Q� ����e�)�f g"B`-&4�� �

�&'hL^NU! 96;"Oi�F9`-?jW�H<����� #� ���H<k

'��#� ���KJ ��� ��� l=L^'��#� ���mJ�OP

Q Q@������KTUC l������G�n-&2 D�/o�p7�B?D#;,�q7 J J��������UB��������������� �G�r3 *Hst2#4�j�2 D

'�� � ��J�;K9cj�;H�I* 3 3 3#* 3�/�*�-�; : :=Y

�����W�*�d^lc�

Page 32: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

J0-W9cj�-��I;=YJ�3K9cj�;H�I*�/�3 3/�3 ; : :#1�/�D=YJ�*K9cj�;H�I; 3 ;�/�3 *�-&3�-�; 3�/�1=YJ /U9cj�;H� /�1 * 4/�3 3�-&;_-./�:�C�j /HY� ;K9 ;H�I; 2 2 */�:�/�4 3#4 ; 4 ;=Y� -W9 ;H�I1 : : 1#:�-&1 D ;/�2 1=Y� 3K9 ;H�I1 *�- -�; *�/�4 3#* 4 4=Y� *K9 ;H��-&; * 1#* D D 1 3#: 1 ;=Y� /U9 ;H�I* : 1 4#; D ; ; 4#*�/ C�j�30YJ JHY��HY N JH<

�&'hL^JU�6;,�X1�OiJ JU9?JH< �#���� J JU9d-�jmJH<�&'hL^J JU�d- C�j�-&3�O

N JU962 2G<� ���� P�F96� � �#�=L � ��VGL-

QL^J#J�]�J J�OO O�<

N JU9�� \ L#L L L��F]mJ /F\�J�*"O?]��F\�J�3�O�]��F\�J0-�O�]��U\KJ�;�OQ

L#L L L��F] � /F\ � *"O?]��F\ � 3�O�]��F\ � -�O�]��U\ � ;�O�<k

�&'hL^JU�6;,�X1�Oi����� #� �Fj&N Jb<� ���� ����� #� � N JH<

k'��#� ���KV���� ����� �=L^'�� � ���W��HY '�� � ���6���&V��"��OP

'�� � ���K��9����� �=L�O�\ ;,�I1G<����� �#� ���\�J#��� �&� lGL^�

Q* 3#D 4 :�O�]���&V�"� <

k�&�#�?�"�����=L�OP

'�� � ���NHY�HY ��l0-�YX��l�3=Y.��lZ-�Y.��l�30YX�"�_-�Y ��� 3=Y.����-�Y.��� 3=<'�� � ���l0-�Y l�3=Y^��-�YM� 3=Y l NbY l�H<'�� � ��������HYI��������JbY ��������lHYX�0�&��������HY �Z�&� ���^�"�=<�&� �K%�����9 ;=Y R������ 9 ;GY R���������9 ;0<'�� � �� �0�&�0-�9�j�-�YX�Z�&��3 9�j�-�YX�0�&�#* 9�j�-�<�&� �U���.�Z�&�H<��� �U� ���&C#� �����`�&��������� � NbY�F�� ��� �_�&���������W��'UJ�� �����?3Hs �_<���&�U! !�NH<���&�U! !��H<��l0-&9���l�3 9 :_- -�<

Q Q���#�K� ����C � �����m�"� ���Kl�� �#�����&�������m��'KJ�� ������ -W��� �F3Hs �_<Q Q

�����K! ! ��l0-�<Q Q�����K! ! ��l�3=<

��l0-&9���l�3 9�/�;=<Q#Q

��� �U� ���&C#� �����F���&V�"� l�� �#�����&�������m��'KJ�� ������ -W��� �F3Hs �_<

�����W��>ud^lc�

Page 33: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

Q Q�����K! ! ��l0-�<Q Q�����K! ! ��l�3=<

��� �U� ���&C#� �������"� ��K��� V��#���+��'KJ�� �������F-W���#�F3,s ��<���&�U! ! �"��-"<���&�U! ! �"� 3G<���-&9��� 3 9�-"<

Q Q��� �U� ���&C �#�����F���&V����?�� V�� ��� ��'KJ�� �������F-W���#�F3,s ��<Q Q

�����K! ! ����-�<Q Q�����K! ! ��� 3=<

���.�0����9�j�-�<Q Q

���#�K� ���&C � �����K���.�"�K���.�Z�&�hL�j�- '����K��������O s ��<Q Q�����K! !6�"�.�0�&�H<

��������J�9�� � �#�=L^N�]�N�\ ��] ��O�<'����hL��&�#�c��9 ;=<&����H<&��\ \"OP

l0-&9V���� ���� �=L ��lZ-�Y.��l0-�O�<l�3 9V���� ���� �=L ��l�3=Y.��l�3�O�<��-&9V���� ���� �=L �"�_-�Y.����-�O�<� 3 9V���� ���� �=L �"�#3=Y.��� 3�O�<l N�90L^l0-�] ������L ��-�]�(�)

Q-&: ;�OO j�LMl�3�]#�����LM� 3�]�(�)

Q-�: ;�O#O�<

l��90L^l0-�] ���&�=L ��-�]�(�)Q-&: ;�OO j�LMl�3�]#���&�=LM� 3�]�(�)

Q-�: ;�O#O�<

������9�N�]�l N�\ ��]�l�b<�������l�9�� � � �=L^l N"]�l N#\�l��]�l ��O�<�0�&�#��������9��������J"]���������J�j�LI�����"]�� ��

QL^�#������l�]������� l_O O�<

�&'hL �0��� ��������� ;�O �0��� ��������9 ;=<q� ���� �0�&�#��������9�� � � �=LI�0�&� ��������O_<�0�&�#���.�"� 9�����

QLM��������l�]���������l_O�<

�&'hL �0��� ���.�"�#� ;�OP

�0�&�#���.�"� 9#;=<�0�&�#��������9��������Jb<

k�&'hL L �"�.�0�&���X9�j�-�O T T LI�0�&� ��� �"� ! ��� �0�&��O OP

�0�&�#���.�"� 9#���.�0�&�b<�0�&�#��������9�� � � �=L#L^N�\ ���^�0�&�"]�l�N_O�]�L^N#\ ���.�_�&��]�l N�O�\ L���\���.�0� ��]�l ��O�]_L���\ ���.�0�&�"]&l�_O O�<k

�&'hL L �Z�&� ����������5 7�8ZO T ThL �Z�&� ��������! 9�>"@�A"B�C�O OP

%�����\ \=<��' L#L �0�&�0-�9 9�j�-�O����WL �0�&� �_�.�"� ���Z�&�0-�O Ot�0�&�Z-&9��0�&�#���.�"�=<k

�&'hL L �Z�&� ����������>"@�A�B�C�O T ThL �0�&� �_������! 9�>"@�A"B�E_O OP

R������� \#\=<��' L#L �0�&��3#9 9�j�-�O����WL �0�&� �_�.�"� ���Z�&��3�O Ot�0�&��3 9��0�&�#���.�"�=<k

�&'hL �0��� ����������>"@�A"BE�OP

�����W��ud^lc�

Page 34: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

R���������\ \=<�&'hL L �0�&��* 9 9�j�-O ���mL �0�&�#���.�"� ���0�&��*�O#Op�0�&��* 9��0�&� ��� �"�=<

kk���#�K� ���)�� ��� ���U� ���W'��"�&V � ���m� ������� R�����,s �m� �K��� ���=<���#�K� �?R��������U� ������ � �"���������"� �W� �K��� ���=<���#�K� �?R�������K� ���W��� �����0�� ���� �m� �K���#���=<���#�K� �?%����U� ��� l����#� ���������� �n� �6���#���K� �K��� ���=<���#�K� ����e��&���.����K���.��� ��� ��� � �����������$s �m� ���0�&��*K� �K���#���=<���#�K� ����e��&���.����K���.��� ��� ��� �����0��� �Gs �m� ���0�&��3K� �K���#���=<���#�K� ����e��&���.����K���.��� ��� l_��� � ���_�����$s �m� ���0�&�0-W� �K���#���=<l N�90L ��l0-�]#�����L ����-�]�(�)

Q-&: ;�O Oj�L ��l�3�]#�����L �"� 3�]�(�)

Q-&:�;"O O�<

l��90L ��l0-�]#���&�=L ����-�]�(�)Q-&: ;�O Oj�L ��l�3�]#���&�=L �"� 3�]�(�)

Q-&:�;"O O�<

������9�N�]�l N�\ ��]�l�b<�������l�9�� � � �=L^l N"]�l�N�\�l��]�l��O�<�0�&�#��������9��������J"]�� �����J"j�L^������]�����

QLM�������#l�]���������l_O O�<

�&'hL �0��� ��������� ;�Ot�0�&� �������9 ;=< � ���� �0�&�#��������9�� � � �=LI�0�&� �"������O"<�0�&�#���.�"� 9�����

QLM�������l�]���������l"O�<

�&'hL �0��� ���.�"�#� ;�OP

�0�&�#���.�"� 9#;=<�0�&�#��������9��������Jb<k

�&'hL L ��� �0�&���I9"j�-�O T T L �Z�&� ���.��� ! ���.�Z�&��O OP

�0�&�#���.�"� 9#���.�0�&�b<�0�&�#��������9�� � � �=L#L^N�\ ���^�0�&�"]�l�N_O�]�L^N#\ ���.�_�&��]�l N�O�\ L���\���.�0� ��]�l ��O�]_L���\ ���.�0�&�"]&l�_O O�<k

��� �U� ���.8���� V����m�"� ����#���`-Zs ��� �dL �0��� ��������� D ; ;�On� �K��� ���=<��� �U� ���.8���� V����m�"� ����#���K3,s �

� � -QL L �0��� ���.�"�#\��"-�O�]"L �0��� ��� �"� \���-�O�]�L �0�&�#��������\��3�O On\ ��*

Q�������JK� �U��� ���=<

��� �U� ���.8���� V����m�"� ����#���K*,s �� ������

QL^�������J�]���������J�O �#�6��� ���=<

����� #� �K;=<k

B�C?NC(T�C(K �?C(E� Æ�� �����0�^xfefZ*�y�^��~��G�y��efh(�"h{��|gs��?dZy]`h_dx[� *��at ���axf�*e[���W��i�ah_e�Hvdydwyj�~>Æ $�$ $,�� >��%�,�ap*�ah{�^x#�>iye��^]`efd�Zg�(p*�5e}Z,e}j_]`h{�^]`efd�Z>~

� � � JosQ Q

R R#R$�I��� �o� '��#�,� V#��lQ��� � �&� ����� �����

Q���'���� ������

Q���'�������o� � ���

� ��� ���aZ*w��ah�~��d��*Z �G�f~ �{��� %� °kª����}£�� ' ~� � � Jos

Q QR R#R$� �"�������#� �$�I����

Q��� �&�

Q����R

Q� ���

Q�"�����#l����$� � ���"�

�����W�G] d^lc�

Page 35: pi.math.cornell.edupi.math.cornell.edu/~mermin/papers/MCM2000paper.pdfad Zz]{^x#p*efh`asa]_efd Z*j yoR \Z*p ¡* ... ^efh`j_b0^s Wr*j` p yoqsah`r*efj_e}Z, g^efh`b*x Z*aj ...

�����������

� ] �W��e}h_�*r*j(Y[Z*p,r*j`]_h`ef�aj�~ � � � JosQ Q

R R#R$�I���&�#%���G�^�����Q�.�#J����������,� � �����

� ��? �ef�aZ,�ah�~ 2 �m��Z*p � ��*�����ax[� Z�r*�\��ZW�0��sa]`d�h`j�efZW�>iye��^]_e}d�Z>� �,�^Z ��ef�a�d2�2�(s��^p*���gefsÅ�h_�aj`j�~�Æ $���*�� ��� �R��Y��?�%���gdyp*�axfefZ*�v��Z*p%�^Z2�^xfoyj`efjGd^l*]`�,�cef�gb0��sa]0d�l*sk�2�^Z*���aj>efZI�c� ��~��"h{�^Z*j_b0d�h`]

�©�aj`����h`s{� � �,Æ�� ��� �RY��?� � � 2 �Äef�gb*h_d^i�a�5�aZy]>l9dh(sad�Zz]_h`d�x}xf�ah���efp*j�~y��hk��Z*j`b2dh_] �(�aj_���^h_s{� � ��>,�� �����v��h`p*e[~ ��� �a�(�,��p,�aj`sah_efb*]`efi�usad�5b*xf�a½ye}][o d^l�sadZ,j`]`h{�^efZy](jk��]`efj[l���sa]`efd�Z �~yY[�5b*xfe}s�e}]

�?d��gb*r*]{�^]_e}d�Z0�^x �?d�gb,x}��½zef][ogÆ$ $�$*~� � � Jos

Q QR R#R$�^� �=� �.� �_�����#�,�I���

Q���#�2�2

Ql���� ��� � ����"�

� $�� 2 Z,p*j`xf�aoy~ ���>��Z*p ��� �(dyp*���ah`j�� � ��e}]_r0�^]_efdZR�ct(�^h`��Z*�aj`j Y[Zylnd�h`�R�^]`efd�Z��(� !zr,e}h_�{��5�aZy]`j�lndh 2 Z �©dr*]_����efh(��hk�m|gs��?dZy]`h_dx �~E� � �������������5��$G] ��> �*~2Æ $ $ ]0�� Æ ��� 2 Z,p*j`xf�aoy~ ���G�^Z,p ��� �©dzp,��ah_j�� � ��efj`]_h`ef�*r*]_e}d�Z�d^l(�^]`]_�aZy]`efdZ#~Gj`ef]`r2�^]`efd�Z���t;��h`�{�Z*��j`j�~#�^Z*p�tvd�h`wyxfdz��p\efZ��5b0��j`j_e}i��³��efh�]`h{��|gs sadZy]_h`dx�]{�^j`w ��~ � � ��������^���5�

$ ���*Æ��*~2Æ $�$ �*�� ÆÆ���Z � �Ih`�a�5�ah(�a]I�^x[� ��Å�h_d�0���*efxfe}j_]`efs�iyj�~ �I�ad��g�a]_h`efs �?d�Zy�0efsa]IÅ�h`d��*efZ*� ��~ *��^]_efdZ0��x

�(�ah_dj_b0�^sa�� >�^�2dh{�^]_dh`o * �W~GÆ $�$ �,�� Æ >�� �� � � >��r*p*�ah_�\�^Z±�a]R�^x[� �.��ozZ2�^�gefs2���aZ*j_ef][o­����Z���efhq��hk�m|gs ���^Z2�^����g�aZy]

�R��]`h`efs���~ *�� �y� ~ *�� �����^� �\��Æ$ $�m��Æ�Æ >�>�> �,~*Æ $�$�,�� Æ���� ��� �(dyp*���ah`ju�a]³��x[� �a�(�*� �(�ax���]`efdZ*j_�*efb�d�l ���asa]`d�h2�?�0�^h{�^sa]_�ah`efj_]`efsajq]`d b2�ah{���

]_e}d�Z0�^x 2 h_h`dh_j���~ � � ��������^���5��$���,Æ ]2~0Æ$ $�,�

�����W�ud^lc�