Moneyball: A Quantitative Approach to Angel Investing (DC - Sept 2012)

500.co/challenge #moneyball4startups

IT’S NOT SPRAY AND PRAY. IT’S A PROCESS.

MONEYBALL STARTUPS+

PAUL SINGH

500 Startups

@paulsingh・[email protected]・angel.co/paulsingh

mailto:[email protected]



500 STARTUPSGETTING TO KNOW

BECAUSE WE’RE KIND OF A BIG DEAL

PAUL SINGH





API TO VENTURE CAPITAL & FUNCTIONAL EXPERTISE

THE BIG OPPORTUNITY IN EARLY STAGE TECH INVESTING:

(FOR FOUNDERS. FOR INVESTORS. FOR GOVERNMENT.)


BUILD SOMETHING PEOPLE WANT

FOUNDERS:


WRITE CHECKS AND ADD VALUE

INVESTORS:


MAKE LIFE EASY FOR INVESTORS & FOUNDERS

GOVERNMENT:


VENTURE CAPITAL IS OPEN TO ATTACK BY DISRUPTIVE NEW BUSINESS MODELS AND TECHNOLOGY.

“

-- NAVAL RAVIKANT (@naval)


(R)EVOLUTION IN THINKING


EARLY STAGE STARTUPS

HAVE CHANGED


STARTUP COSTS LOWER THAN EVER

BUT SCALING STILL COSTS MONEY

CLOUD, OPEN SOURCE AND ONLINE DISTRIBUTION DRIVING


WEB GETS BIGGER.WORLD GETS SMALLER.


TRACTION IS THE NEW INTELLECTUAL PROPERTYPLATFORMS (SEARCH, SOCIAL & MOBILE) PRIMARILY DRIVING THE CHANGE.

NO LONGER “GOOD ENOUGH” TO DEPEND ON TECH DIFFERENTIATION.


CAPITAL INCREASINGLY COMMODITIZED

RISE OF THE ANGELS, YO!


NEW REALITY: MONEY FOLLOWS

FOUNDERS


SIGNALS ARE EVERYWHERE

BIG DATA + OPEN SOURCE ANALYTICS = NEW TECHNIQUES FOR VC


WALL STREET BEAT US TO IT



UBS PROPRIETARY SATELLITE PARKING LOT FILL RATE ANALYSIS POINTS TO AN INTERESTING CADENCE INTRA-QUARTER AND POTENTIAL UPSIDE TO OUR VIEW.

“


WALL STREET ISN’T ALONE

THESE TECHNIQUES ALREADY USED TO UNDERWRITE IN-VITRO FERTILIZATION LENDING, PAYDAY LOANS, SUBPRIME AUTO LENDING, HOME/PERSONAL/AUTO INSURANCE AND MORE.


WE CAN DO IT, TOOSURPRISE!

IT TURNS OUT,


+ “GUT” + TRUSTED MENTORS + MUCH, MUCH MORE DATA.


SENTIMENT ANALYSIS

WHAT IS THE TEAM THINKING? WHAT DOES THE MARKET THINK? WHAT DO MY PEERS/MENTORS THINK?


NEEDLE IN THEHAYSTACK

REAL USE CASES: SIGNS THAT A FUNDING ROUND IS ABOUT TO OCCUR AND/OR SIGNS THAT A PRODUCT IS ABOUT TO EXPLODE.

VERY HARD TO DO ACCURATELY BUT PAYOFF IS BIG & FAST.


FASTER PORTFOLIO TRENDS

CURRENT SYSTEMS OF QUARTERLY/AD-HOC REPORTING IS BROKEN -- SELF REPORTED DATA IS OFTEN BIASED.

THE RAW DATA IS THERE, THE SYSTEMS TO COLLECT IT AND THE ALGORITHMS TO ANALYZE IT ARE MISSING.


CURIOSITY

500 CHECKLISTProduct solves a problem for a specific target customer

Capital-efficient businesses - operational @ <$1M funding

Primarily internet-based distribution - search, social, mobile, local

Simple revenue models - transactions, subscriptions or affiliate

Functional prototype before investment (or previous success)

Small but measurable usage - some customers, early revenue

Small but cross-functional team - engineer, design/UX, marketing


EARLY STAGE VCIS CHANGINGHAS CHANGED


STATE OF THE ART IN EARLY STAGE INVESTING IS NOT

VERY SOPHISTICATEDTRUST REFERRALS. MOVE FAST. KEEP LEGAL/FINANCE SIMPLE.

BUILD RELATIONSHIPS WITH OTHER INVESTORS, SYNDICATE EVERYTHING.


MONEYBALLIT’S NOT SPRAY AND PRAY. IT’S A PROCESS.


BUY WINSMY PRIMARY GOAL IS TO

NOT NECESSARILY BUYING INTO THE HOTTEST DEALS.

FOCUS ON TEAM, EXECUTION, TRACTION & DATA.(STICK AROUND... I’M GOING TO SHOW YOU HOW)


INITIAL BET DESIGNED TO GIVE US MORE DATA FOR

SUBSEQUENT BETS


QUANTITATIVEPORTFOLIO APPROACH

BENEFITS: CONTROLLED RISK + OUTSIZED RETURN POTENTIAL


0

1.25

2.5

3.75

5

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30

Monte Carlo Simulation of Angel Investing

Exit

Mul

tiple

# of Deals

mean median std dev


RISK MITIGATION THROUGH

DIVERSIFICATION

MODERN PORTFOLIO THEORY:


HIGH VOLUME INVESTING ALLOWS

FOR HIGH ERROR RATE


TRACK IRR & VALUATIONS WITHIN

YOUR PORTFOLIOAT LEAST YEARLY. RECOMMEND QUARTERLY.


CONTROLLED RISK:OUTSIZED RETURN

POTENTIAL


PORTFOLIO IRR QUICKLY POSITIVE

(WITH SMALLER EARLY EXITS AND PROMISING DEALS GETTING FUNDED)


EVEN “SMALLER” EXITS CAN MOVE

THE NEEDLEDON’T FORGET: YOU CAN SELL POSITIONS TO DOWNSTREAM OR SECONDARY BUYERS TOO.


LAW OF LARGE NUMBERS FTW!


INDIVIDUAL BETS ARE SMALL

MUCH EASIER TO RUN AN EXPERIMENT ON A $50K INITIAL CHECK INSTEAD OF $250K+


BAD BETSFAIL FAST

SMALLER CHECK SIZES FORCE COMPANIES TO PROVE THEORIES FASTER. ALLOWING INVESTORS TO QUICKLY ITERATE OUR FORECASTING/FUNDING

MODEL. FEWER “LIVING DEAD” AND QUICKER RETURN ON RESULTS.


FAILURE RATESARE HIGH

DIVERSITY OF HIGH VOLUME INVESTING ALLOWS FOR HIGH ERROR RATE. FUND IRR QUICKLY POSITIVE WITH SMALLER, EARLY EXITS AND PROMISING

DEALS GETTING FUNDED.

DILIGENCE HAPPENS IN THE REAR VIEW MIRROR, NOT THE CRYSTAL BALL.


ALLOCATE FOR FOLLOW-ONS

(...OR “HOW TO AVOID GETTING SQUASHED”)

30% Capital - Initial Betstarget 10-20 deals

70% Capital - Follow Onfilter out failures, follow-on the top 20%


DEAL TERMSSO YOU FOUND A STARTUP YOU LOVE?


DEBT VS EQUITY


CONVERTIBLE NOTES ARE OK (REALLY!)

LOWER LEGAL FEES, LESS DOCS, QUICKER TO EXECUTE. WHEN CAPPED, THEY FUNCTION SIMILAR TO PRICED ROUNDS.


STANDARD DOCS ARE YOUR FRIENDS

WHEN IN DOUBT, DO NOT INNOVATE IN FINANCE OR LEGAL


PRO RATA & INFO RIGHTS

ALWAYS. ALWAYS. ALWAYS. ALWAYS. ALWAYS. (GET IT?)


FOCUS ON VALUATION & MULTIPLES

OWNERSHIP % MATTERS MUCH LESS. FOCUS ON REQUIRED EXIT SIZE RATHER THAN SOME MYTHICAL OWNERSHIP TARGET.


IT’S HARD TO MAKE MONEY ON

VALUATIONS > $5M(PRO TIP: CONSIDER MIN. RETURN REQUIREMENTS FOR DOWNSIDE SCENARIOS)


LET FOUNDERS GET BACK TO WORK

YOUR PRIMARY GOAL

THIS IS A LONG GAME: AVOID LOSING YOUR REPUTATION OVER 1%. WHEN IN DOUBT, LEAN TOWARDS THE ENTREPRENEUR.


AVOID BOARD SEATS


MOST BOARDS PROVIDE MINIMAL

VALUE-ADD


BEST DEALS USUALLY REQUIRE LIMITED BOARD SUPPORTSPEND YOUR TIME SOURCING NEW DEALS. LIMIT TIME ON SIDEWAYS DEALS. LET THE WINNERS KEEP ON WINNING (AND ANSWER YOUR PHONE WHEN THEY NEED YOU).


DO NOT INNOVATE IN FINANCE OR LEGAL


INVESTINGIS A PROCESS

DABBLING IN INVESTING IS (AT BEST) GAMBLING. BETTER TO WALK AWAY OR PURSUE INVESTING NEARLY FULL TIME OR

FIND SOMEONE TO MANAGE YOUR MONEY


BE AN ACTIVE INVESTOR

PORTFOLIO EFFECTS & THE LEAN STARTUP MOVEMENT ARE YOUR FRIENDS

YOU CAN EXPECT FAVORABLE WITH 10 DEALS BUT IT TAKES 20+ TO BE SAFE


BE A SMART INVESTOR

FOCUS ON INFORMATION ASYMMETRY & PRICE/MULTIPLES.


BY ITS NATURE, THE INTERNET UNDERMINES ANYONE WHOSE STATUS DEPENDS ON PRIVILEGED ACCESS TO INFORMATION.

“

-- MICHAEL LEWIS


API TO VENTURE CAPITAL & FUNCTIONAL EXPERTISE

THE BIG OPPORTUNITY IN EARLY STAGE TECH INVESTING:

(FOR FOUNDERS. FOR INVESTORS. FOR GOVERNMENT.)


500.co/challenge


IT’S NOT SPRAY AND PRAY. IT’S A PROCESS.

MONEYBALL STARTUPS+

PAUL SINGH

500 Startups




Moneyball: A Quantitative Approach to Angel Investing (DC - Sept 2012)

Economy & Finance

venture capital

challenge

functional

big opportunity

investors

government

founders 500

process