Top Banner
Implementing a Goal-Based Servicing Model to Help Investors Achieve Retirement Goals Andrew Rudd, Chairman and CEO, Advisor Software, Inc. Eric M. Teal, Chief Investment Officer, First Citizens Bank Capital Management Group Wealth Management Retirement Planning Forum
63
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

Implementing a Goal-Based Servicing Model to Help Investors Achieve Retirement Goals

Andrew Rudd, Chairman and CEO, Advisor Software, Inc.

Eric M. Teal, Chief Investment Officer, First Citizens Bank Capital Management Group

Wealth Management Retirement Planning Forum

Page 2: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

2 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Introductions

! Dimensions of Advice: A Description of the Challenge! Understanding the Client’s Problem

! Organizational Challenges

! Case Studies

! Holistic Wealth Management

! Key Takeaways

! Q & A

Agenda

Page 3: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

3 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Andrew Rudd! Founder, Chairman and CEO of Advisor Software

! PhD in Operations Research, MBA in Finance at UC Berkeley

! Co-founder and former chairman and CEO of Barra, Inc.

! Finance Professor at Graduate School of Business, Cornell University

! Co-Author of "Modern Portfolio Theory: The Principles of Investment Management" and "Option Pricing"

Advisor Software, Inc.

Page 4: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

4 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Organization Background! Founded in 1995 by Andrew Rudd, co-founder, and former chairman

and CEO of Barra

! Privately held

! Experienced management team: Barra, Morningstar, Wells Fargo, Oracle-PeopleSoft, Bloomberg, Financial Engines, etc.

! Approximately 60 employees based in Lafayette, California

! Mission! Provide competitive advantage for financial services institutions,

empowering them to focus on core competencies and deliver more personalized advice for maximizing client relationships and increasing assets under management

! Method! Bring institutional-caliber analytics to the financial advice market

Advisor Software, Inc.

Page 5: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

5 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Eric M. Teal, Chief Investment Officer, Capital Management Groupsince 2003

! Investment management and oversight of approximately $7 billion in assets under management

• Oversees asset allocation, overall investment strategy, and equity as well as fixed income portfolio management for the Bank

• Actively conducts and oversees research and management of all structured equity investment products

! Director of Equities, managing active investment strategies for Wachovia’s mutual fund company, Evergreen Investments

! M.B.A in Finance from the University of Memphis

! Attended London School of Economics

First Citizens Bank Capital Management Group

Page 6: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

6 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Background: The Capital Management Group is the investment division of First Citizens and IronStone Bank, servicing the investment and financial needs of institutional and high-net worth markets. We offer a wide range of products and services tailored for:

High-net Worth Market Charitable Organizations Unions Health Care Institutions

Corporations Governmental Bodies Educational Institutions

The Capital Management Group and First Citizens and IronStone are performance and service-driven organizations. We believe three key elements are critical to success in meeting the needs of our clients: Focus, Talent, and Discipline.

Assets: Total Assets Under Management ($mm)Equity 4,260.0Fixed Income 1,436.0Manager of Managers 832.6Total 6,528.6

Professional 1 Chief Investment OfficerStaff: 2 Equity Managers

2 Fixed Income Managers4 Portfolio Strategists4 Research Analysts4 Systems Analyst

Products: Internal and External Investment OfferingsComprehensive Wealth Solutions

First Citizens Bank Capital Management GroupGroup: Quick Facts

Third Quarter 2007

Capital Management Group Raleigh, NC

IronStone Bank Offices in Missouri, Oklahoma and Kansas opening 4th quarter 2007

Page 7: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

7 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

First Citizens BankFirst Citizens BankInvestment Products and Services

Internal Investments – Non-Taxable and Tax Aware Strategies Manager of Managers Programs – SMAs and Funds

Large CapEquity Strategies

Tax Aware

Passive IndexStrategies

Fixed IncomeStrategies

Mid CapEquity Strategies

Tax Aware

Small Cap Equity Strategies

Tax Aware

External InvestmentStrategies

Page 8: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

8 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Dimensions of Advice:

The Challenges from the Investor’s Perspective

Page 9: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

9 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

The Perfect Storm

! Early this decade, corporate treasurers faced the Perfect Storm! Stocks and interest rates dropped precipitously

! Pension portfolios, typically equity biased, dropped in value

! Pension obligations grew dramatically

! Corporate plans became severely under-funded

! Accounting standards require (part of) this shortfall to be recognized on the corporate books

Page 10: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

10 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

The Perfect Storm Rages

! Issue: Portfolios managed in asset-only framework, largely disregarding the liabilities! Pension liabilities have little “equity” exposure

! Instead inflation and interest rate exposure dominate

! Solution: Structure the pension portfolio to match the liabilities

! Asset-Liability Management (ALM) or Liability Driven Investment (LDI) now an integral part of institutional asset management

Page 11: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

11 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Households save and invest to fund:! Their essential expenses (living costs, mortgage

payments, etc.)

! Their expected expenses (e.g., retirement expenses)

! Their aspirational goals (e.g., vacation home)

! These categories represent the claims against the household resources (just as pension liabilities represent claims against pension assets)

! The household’s challenge is to balance the claims that they face against their resources

What Does This Have to Do with Me?

Page 12: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

12 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Maine Takes A Cautious Path On Its Pensions By MARY WILLIAMS WALSH

23 April 2004(c) 2004 New York Times Company

! After being hammered in the financial markets for the last few years, many pension funds are turning to riskier investments, hoping that hedge funds, venture capital and the like will fuel returns and cover recent losses. But Maine has drawn a different lesson from the recent pension woes. Instead of shooting high, it is deliberately aiming for low, but guaranteed, investment income to pay for the retirement benefits of its workers.

! Maine's pension fund recently put a portion of its money into very conservative bonds. The bonds pay a low interest rate, but their values will rise or fall in tandem with the value of the pensions the state must pay its retirees, no matter what the markets do. The bonds' durations match the scheduled payouts to retirees. It is a contrarian approach, but one that Maine thinks best serves its retirees and its taxpayers. ''It's a source of puzzlement to me that so few people have come to the same conclusion,'' said Rex W. Holsapple, chief investment officer of Maine's system of pension funds for public workers. He said he knew of no other United States pension fund doing what Maine was doing, a strategy known as matching.

! Pension officials who dared suggest matching in recent years were scoffed at. Thomas Flanigan, formerly the chief investment officer at California's big pension fund for teachers, was dismissed in 1997 after pushing the idea at a time when stocks were red hot. But academics have said the strategy, adopted early enough, could have prevented the recent collapse of the pension funds at US Airways, Bethlehem Steel and other companies. Had those companies matched their pension funds in the late 1990's, their pilots, steelworkers and other retirees would probably still be collecting full benefits. Not only could it have saved those pension funds from failure, but it could have kept the recent pension crisis from erupting across corporate America, prompting Congress to ease requirements for funding pensions. In a properly matched pension fund, asset values cannot move down when benefit values go up.

! In Britain, the Boots Company, a retail drugstore chain, applied the strategy to its pension fund in 2000 with spectacular results – Boots locked in a surplus and its pension fund rode out the bear market unscathed. But United States pension officials have dismissed Boots' achievement as a product of British accounting rules, with nothing to offer pension plans in this country.

! Still, the concept of pension matching may be starting to gain currency. Earlier this year, the government agency that guarantees pensions announced it was matching its investment portfolio, to reduce the risk of a taxpayer bailout.

! Now Maine appears to be the first pension fund in the United States to embrace matching since the long bear market began in 2000, raising questions about whether companies and governments are investing their employees' retirement money in the most prudent way. Maine made the conversion late last year. Before the change, the investment returns on Maine's assets varied from year to year, as with most pension funds, ranging from a gain of 25.7 percent last year, when the stock market rose, to a loss of 10.4 percent in 2002, when stocks fell. These swings will not be totally eliminated, because Maine is not using bonds to match its entire investment portfolio. So far, it has matched about a third of its assets. The remainder is still invested in stocks, on the assumption that over time, the stocks will grow faster than the conservative bonds. Maine is doing this because it has a pension deficit, and an allocation of stocks may close it over time.

! But even by matching a third of its investments, Maine has made an important break with the rest of the industry. ''It's a step in the right direction,'' said Jeremy Gold, an actuary who advocates matching for both corporate and public pension plans. ''Every pension plan would benefit from having more bonds. But there is considerable advantage in taking those bonds that you do have, and matching them.''

! To explain the new approach, Mr. Holsapple drew a comparison between the pension business and personal financial planning. Good personal planners do not urge their clients to shoot for big investment returns for the returns' own sake, he said. Rather, they find out what their clients are saving for, determine when they will need the money and then tailor investments to meet those goals.

! But the pension business works the other way around. For several reasons, pension professionals are geared to think in terms of investment returns and of peer-group rankings. The amount of money owed to retirees, and when it must be paid, do not typically enter into investment decisions.

! At corporate pension funds, this single-minded focus on asset growth is fueled in part by accounting rules. The rules reward and encourage aggressive investing, by allowing companies to project their pension returns a year in advance, then use the projected returns to bolster the corporate bottom line. If companies matched their pension funds, using conservative bonds, they would miss out on this opportunity for a paper gain.

The Perfect Storm

Page 13: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

13 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! State and local pension funds use different accounting rules, but they may have other incentives to shoot for big investment returns. For one thing, the outside money managers who assist pension funds earn larger fees if they invest more aggressively. Also, many public pension officials are elected, and they know that a strong year-to-year investment performance is easy to grasp, and likely to impress pensioners, who vote. The virtues of a well-matched pension fund are nowhere near as immediately apparent.

! In fact, it should not make much difference to retired government workers whether their pension fund's investments soared or shriveled in a given year. Their benefits cannot be cut; governments are required to pay them the pensions they have earned, in good markets and bad. If a public plan's investments sour, and cash runs short, then the taxpayers have to chip in.

! That is happening in some places. The mayor of San Diego, Calif., has suggested a tax increase to fill that city's $1.1 billion pension shortfall. Colorado pension officials have asked the Legislature for an increase in the state's contributions, which are financed by taxpayers. The mayor of Syracuse has warned that the demands of New York State's pension funds could drive up city property taxes 45 percent. Other governments are engaging in financial gymnastics to avoid such tax increases. Texas officials have considered taking out life insurance policies on teachers, and using the payouts on those who die young to help finance retirement benefits for those who live well into old age. Many states and towns are selling bonds to generate cash for their pension funds. Still others are camouflaging their pension shortfalls by amending their funding laws.

! Mr. Holsapple's approach runs counter to such techniques. He acquired his point of view 20 years ago, when he worked in the corporate treasury department of Phillips Petroleum. First T. Boone Pickens, then Carl C. Icahn, mounted back-to-back takeover battles, and preserving the company's independence was extremely costly. Mr. Holsapple usually handled foreign-exchange transactions and short-term debt, but during the raids he was brought into the pension team, which was removing a $400 million surplus from the pension fund to pay down debt related to takeover defenses.

! Doing this did not change the employees' benefits, Mr. Holsapple said. But his dealings with the pension fund introduced him to a startling fact: while all short-term debts are measured more or less the same way, there are many ways to measure pension debts to the work force, and seemingly small variations between them can make the benefits balloon, shrink or practically anything in between. And make-or-break decisions could depend on which method was chosen. If Mr. Holsapple's team measured the benefits owed in the way the financial markets did, the benefits looked small relative to the value of the assets; that meant there was a $400 million surplus to be retrieved. But if they measured the benefits the way actuaries did, they were much larger, and there appeared to be little or no surplus at all.

! Given the company's dire circumstances, the perils of measuring the pensions incorrectly were glaring. ''I learned the ropes then, and it just made sense to me that you had to look at a pension plan that way,'' Mr. Holsapple said. ''That lesson has stayed with me.'' That was the lesson he brought to Maine, when the state pension fund hired him as its first chief investment officer early in 2002. Soon, he initiated a broad review of investment policy. ''This was many hours' worth of meetings and discussions,'' recalled Kay R.H. Evans, the executive director of the system, which consists of a few large pension funds for Maine's teachers, judges and other state employees and more than 100 small pension funds for municipal employees. Much of the talk was about Mr. Holsapple's ideas on the need to focus on the size of the benefits to the work force, and the timing of the payouts.

! The long discussions eventually brought Maine's trustees to the conclusion that they should not think about their investment portfolio in a vacuum. ''It's there to fund the benefits,'' Mr. Holsapple said. That may sound obvious to a nonspecialist, but in pension practice, it represents a watershed. It meant Maine would no longer think about its investments the way most of the industry does -- striving for high returns, and avoiding a low peer-group ranking. Instead, Maine would strive for returns commensurate to its obligations, and it would avoid drawing more tax dollars. It also means, of course, that in some years Maine is likely to look bad next to other pension funds, because the rest of the industry still charts its health, and competes, in terms of investment returns. The trustees tried to picture what it would be like, in the inevitable quarters when their selection of long-term, inflation-indexed Treasury bonds landed them at the bottom of the peer-group rankings. They wanted to be sure they would not waver and sell out at the bottom of the market. After much soul-searching and discussion, they decided their resolve was firm.

! The trustees then set about commissioning an asset-liability study, a standard tool that most big pension plans use every few years to reassess their investment strategies. That proved problematic at first, because virtually the entire industry does such studies in a way that applies one statistical method to the assets, and another to the obligations. ''I don't know how to sugarcoat this,'' Mr. Holsapple said. ''Most asset-liability studies are done incorrectly.'' He thought the flaw was severe, and likely to bias the study in favor of riskier investments. As it turned out, Maine's pension consultant, Richard M. Ennis, also had doubts about the way pensions were being measured. He brought in a new actuary who was willing to apply the same rigor to projecting the benefits as to projecting the assets. When the study was done, it confirmed the trustees' hunch that matching would be the most prudent course.

! ''It showed that if they invested in bonds that had characteristics that were more like their liabilities, the risk of having an underfunded plan in the long run would be reduced,'' Mr. Ennis said. Not only was the risk of shortfalls lessened, he said, but in many instances Maine's cash contributions would be reduced too.

The Perfect Storm

Page 14: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

14 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Asset-Liability, Not Asset Only

! Household: Not Individual – Multiple Entities

! Human Capital is a resource

! Taxable and Tax-Deferred accounts

! Multiple Goals

! Dynamic Not Static Single Period

! How Much Debt?

Characteristics of the Client

Page 15: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

15 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

An impossible task?

! To provide consistent and robust advice, we need to:

! Quantify the household’s resources:

• Financial assets

• Illiquid assets (real estate, human capital, etc.), social security, etc.

! Identify and value household claims:

• Financial liabilities

• Present value of expenses

• Value of the household goals

! In other words, we develop a household balance sheet

Page 16: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

16 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! The Rockwells

! Overview: Affluent Family with $998,000 in investable assets, not including home equity.

! Members:

• Anthony: 50-year-old mid-level financial services executive

• Julie: 48-year-old high school teacher, full-time mom

• Two children:

- Kerry (13)

- Jake (10)

Connect the Theoretical with the Real World

Page 17: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

17 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Connect the Theoretical with the Real World

Page 18: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

18 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! The Rockwells

! Circumstances

• Live in a five-bedroom, single family home in the suburb of Scarsdale New York with 10 years left on the mortgage.

! Family’s Goals

• Kerry wants to go to Cornell. She loves horses and dreams of being a vet one day.

• Jake: too soon to tell

• Anthony: planning to retire at 65.

• Julie wants to move to a smaller house in Scottsdale, Arizona when Anthony retires.

• Mortgage needs to be paid

• Julie would like to remodel their home in a few years

• Insurance is a consideration

Connect the Theoretical with the Real World

Page 19: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

19 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

ASI Wealth Manager: Comprehensive Balance Sheet View

Essential

Expected

Aspirational

Resources & claims about on par� not a lot of room for error

Human capital is a significant partof the Rockwell�s resources�

Balance sheet view enables Goal-directed risk management

Page 20: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

20 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

ASI Wealth Manager: Comprehensive Balance Sheet View

Focus on primarygoals

Components of primary

goals

Essential

Margin of Safety: Can lose up to 56% of resources and still remain fully funded However, not

much room for error on the

additional goals

Human capital dominates the

Rockwell’s resources –

Consider insurance? More

on this later…

Reality check!

Living expenses are more than 80% of their essential goals. At age 50, the cost of their pre and post-retirement

expenses are about the same…

Page 21: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

21 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Dimensions of Advice:

First Citizens Bank

Organizational Perspective

Page 22: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

22 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Individual and Organizational ChallengesIndividual Complexities

Integrated investment management must be comprehensive and goal based. Investments cannot be viewed in isolation.

Taxes

BusinessDevelopment

RiskManagement

Trust

RelationshipManagement

Investments

HNW

Page 23: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

23 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Key Departmental ObjectivesIncentive Structures

Different incentive structures make the organizational problem challenging.

Investments Taxes Trust

•High Alpha •Minimum Taxes •Fiduciary/Legal Requirements

Risk Management

RelationshipManagement

BusinessDevelopment

•Risk Minimization •Effective Communication

•Increase Sales

Page 24: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

24 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Comprehensive Wealth Management

IdentificationDevelopment

Goal PlanningPortfolio

ManagementWealth

Transfer

•Client profiling•Prospecting/marketing•Referral tracking•Client contact

•Risk profiling•Asset allocation•Financial planning•Product selection•Order execution

•Market monitoring•Investment Management•Reporting•Client communication

•Estate Planning•Succession

Planning

Wealth ManagementLife Cycle Review

Page 25: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

25 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Representative Architectureof a Wealth Management Platform

Advisor Productivity/Client Profitability

Advisor/Client Advisor/Home Office

CR

M/

Co

nta

ct M

an

ag

em

en

t

Acc

ou

nt

Ag

gre

gati

on

Clien

t P

rosp

ect

ing

/S

ale

s To

ols

Fin

an

cial P

lan

nin

g/

Ad

vic

e

Perf

orm

an

ce

Measu

rem

en

t

Po

rtfo

lio

Co

nst

ruct

ion

(An

aly

tics

& M

od

eli

ng

)

Mo

del A

dm

inis

trati

on

Co

mp

lian

ce (

Ale

rts

syst

em

)

Do

cum

en

t S

tora

ge

Cen

tral

Data

Rep

osi

tory

Source: Celent Communications

Page 26: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

26 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Representative Architectureof a Wealth Management Platform

Advisor Productivity/Client Profitability

Advisor/Client Advisor/Home Office

CR

M/

Co

nta

ct M

an

ag

em

en

t

Acc

ou

nt

Ag

gre

gati

on

Clien

t P

rosp

ect

ing

/S

ale

s To

ols

Fin

an

cial P

lan

nin

g/

Ad

vic

e

Perf

orm

an

ce

Measu

rem

en

t

Po

rtfo

lio

Co

nst

ruct

ion

(An

aly

tics

& M

od

eli

ng

)

Mo

del A

dm

inis

trati

on

Co

mp

lian

ce (

Ale

rts

syst

em

)

Do

cum

en

t S

tora

ge

Cen

tral

Data

Rep

osi

tory

Source: Celent Communications

Page 27: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

27 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Financial planning

tools

Asset Allocation

Analytics: Fund

Statistics,Simulations,

Comparatives

Select Investment

Products

Generate CustomProposal

Portfolio Compliance

Rebalance/Monitor

Accounts

Source: Celent Communications

Representative Workflowof an Investment Management Platform

Page 28: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

28 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Financial planning

tools

Asset Allocation

Analytics: Fund

Statistics,Simulations,

Comparatives

Select Investment

Products

Generate CustomProposal

Portfolio Compliance

Rebalance/Monitor

Accounts

Source: Celent Communications

General Organizational Competencies

Page 29: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

29 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Risk Tolerance Measures

! Proposal Generation

! Asset Allocation

! Model Administration

! User Entitlements

! Portfolio Compliance

! Investment Product Architecture

! Investment Commentary

! Investment Management

! Accounting

! Compliance

! Performance Measurement

! Portfolio Modeling

! Reconciliation

! Reporting

! Risk Analytics

! Trading

! Tax Management

Asset Management Resources Advisor Program Requirements

Platform DesignResources and Requirements

Page 30: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

30 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Incentive Structures Investment-Centric vs. Advisor-Centric

Investment-Centric Approaches Offer Analytical Benchstrength:

! Goal – develop optimal investment solution for a given client case.

! Client experience – risk/return expectations met or exceeded.

! Tools – risk questionnaire, asset allocation selection, model portfolio and investment product selection, style and sector analysis including look-through capabilities, simulation of returns

(security level), mean-variance optimization, tax-lot optimization, rebalancing support.

! Result – (tactical) investment proposal, implementation plan / trade list.

Advisor-Centric Approaches Support the Client Relationship:

! Goal – client acquisition / maintenance / retention.

! Client experience – consistently high quality of service and advice.

! Sample Tools – CRM including task lists and alert system, comprehensive and goal-oriented

financial planning, risk questionnaire, asset allocation selection, simulation of cash flows and returns (asset class level), collaboration tools.

! Result – plan discussing client goals and needs, strategic direction, advice.

Our goal was to develop the best of both structures.

Page 31: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

31 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

First Citizens Bank

Organizational Case Study

Page 32: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

32 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Organizational Size

Smaller institutions generally utilize a core-satellite approach to hybrid architecture, while larger banks tend to employ a best of breed platform approach.

Source: VIP Forum Open Architecture Survey 2007 VIP Forum research.

Less Than $10Billion

$10 Billion - $50Billion

More Than $50Billion

Core-SatelliteBest of Breed100%

25%

50%

50%

75%

Page 33: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

33 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Proprietary Management

Source: VIP Forum Open Architecture Survey 2007 VIP Forum research.

30.0

40.0

16.713.3

ExtremelyProprietary

Mostly Proprietary Fairly Open Very Open

Assets are still largely managed internally, how can we do this better?

Page 34: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

34 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Portfolio ConstructionStyle Box Strategy

Small Cap

Growth

Small Cap

ValueSmall

Mid Cap

GrowthMid Cap

ValueMid

Large Cap

Growth

Large Cap

ValueLarge

GrowthCoreValue

Style Box Structure may result in:

DiversificationDivides equity exposures by size, styles, geography, and investment approach.

Institutional Portfolio DesignMay be unwieldy and inefficient for individual.

Due Diligence/MonitoringCostly labor intensive.

Best of BreedFocused predominantly on active management.

CostElevated Manager, transition, and tax costs.

Page 35: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

35 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Structured Equity ProductsTax-Aware Investment Philosophy

Challenge

Risk • The avoidance of selling securities to defer taxes has been the standard of trust departments for years while charging active management fees. Result is a high risk pseudo-passive portfolio versus the firm’s intended investment strategy.

Complexity • Trade-offs and complexities are considerable. Each account is different, requires tax lot by tax lot considerations, and is a multi-period problem.

• Impact of taxes on active equity management can be dramatic.Pre-tax returns and after-tax returns are almost unrelated.

U.S. Asset ReturnStocks 4.8%Municipal Bonds 1.3Government Bonds 0.8Treasury Bills -0.9

Annualized Compound Returns1925 – 2006

(Net of Taxes and Inflation)

Page 36: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

36 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Approach • Our solution measures tradeoffs between expected returns, portfolio risk and taxes. Objective is to enhance portfolio expected returns while controlling for taxes.

Custom Solution

• Successful individual account management requires the ability to manage individual accounts, individually. Tax-aware investing can significantly improve after tax return of portfolios, and allow significant deferral, reduction and possible elimination of capital gains taxes for clients.

Objective • Our goal is to actively offset realized capital gains with realized capital losses, not to reduce turnover. Expected returns shouldbe greater than fees, transaction cost, and taxes to trade securities.

Structured Equity Tax-Aware Investment Philosophy

Page 37: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

37 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Core/Satellite Structure Allows for:

Unique Uncorrelated StrategiesIncreases asset allocation breadth.

Fewer ManagersEasier to administer and lower manager fees

Tax EfficiencyTax management within the core may help lower and delay taxes for the overall portfolio.

Reduced CostsLower-turnover core results in less frequent trading for overall portfolio despite high turnover satellites.

Portfolio ConstructionCore Satellite Strategy

Real Assets

Non-US FixedIncome

EmergingMarkets

High Yield

REITs

Hedge Funds

International Equity

PrivateEquity

FCBStructured

EquityProducts

Page 38: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

38 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Core/Satellite StrategyAdvantages

• Benchmark Flexibility – Tax-efficient separate accounts can be benchmarked to virtually any standard or customized index. For Example:

Large Cap: S&P 500

Mid Cap: S&P Midcap 400

Small Cap: S&P 600

• And can include the following advantages:Return Enhancements – incorporates alpha insights.

Based on Client Tax Aversion Profile – based on client tax aversion fine tuned.

Risk Management – diversification and completion portfolio to handle concentrations.

Transitioning – efficient manager changes.

Gifting – source to make low-basis stock gifts.

Page 39: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

39 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Optimal Core Allocation

Core allocations range from 50% to 90% and are generally contingent on the following factor relationships for optimality:

! Expected market returns - generally ↑ returns; ↑ core allocation.

!Satellite alpha and information ratios - generally ↑ alpha; ↓ core allocation.

!Satellite manager turnover - generally ↑ turnover; ↑ core allocation.

Page 40: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

40 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Proposed Asset Allocation and Holdings

Page 41: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

41 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Holistic Wealth Management

Page 42: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

42 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Holistic Wealth Management, I

! Build upon the Balance Sheet view of the household

! Recall the Balance Sheet encapsulates

• Characteristics of the household, including the various entities

• Description of resources and claims, including goal priorities

! First question:

! Is it feasible? Can we afford it without going into (more) debt?

! Is the household “asset rich, cash poor?”

! Perform cash flow analysis

! Reduce client expectations, if necessary

Page 43: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

43 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Holistic Wealth Management, II

! Next step:

! Formulate investment strategy for meeting cash flows of achievable goals

! An asset-liability management problem: resources are the assets, claims are the liabilities

! Requires ensuring that the complete risk structure is modeled, not just equity and fixed income

! Optimal strategy is determined which for each year of the client’s life shows

• the expenses to be funded and

• the level of investment risk conditional on resources available

Page 44: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

44 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! Apply optimal strategy to current year! Joint solution of the strategic asset allocation and asset

location problems

! Plan for near term liquidity

! Communicating the advice

! Portfolio Monitoring and Reporting

Holistic Wealth Management, III

Page 45: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

45 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Five key feature areas:

Household balance sheet orientation

Multiple-goals orientation

Financial plan risk analysis

Investment recommendations

Monitoring and recalibration

1

2

3

4

5

ASI Wealth Manager

Page 46: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

46 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Rockwell’s Have a Healthy Balance Sheet: What About Cash Flows?

How much would it cost to hedge longevity risk?

A few years after retirement, the Rockwells are no longer able to

fund their aspirational goals

Page 47: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

47 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Cash Flow Analysis – Key Transition YearsPotential “liquidity trap” as

several goals come together in a period of a few years…

Maybe a good idea to hold-off on the remodel for a few years…

Page 48: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

48 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Cash Flow Analysis Key Transition Years

Mortgage paid-off

Anthony retires, then Julie

Page 49: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

49 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Holistic Investment Recommendations: Investment Structure

! The investment structure problem is one of picking strategic asset allocations and rebalancing policies for each account so that the “household portfolio” achieves the best possible performance.

Page 50: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

50 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Investment Recommendations: Julie’s IRA, Anthony’s 401(k), and Joint Brokerage Account

! Investments are spread among multiple accounts. Accounts differ in terms of taxability (e.g. an RIA account versus a regular brokerage account), ownership (joint versus separate property), and purpose (general funds versus dedicated to a specific purpose - i.e. segregated funding pools.)

Page 51: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

51 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Investment Recommendations: Multiple Account Tax Efficient Investment Selection

! Asset Selection – Fund selection methodology that emphasizes avoiding mistakes asa first order of business and pursuit of performance as a secondary objective. Mistakes to be avoided include selection of funds with poor risk control, excessive fees, funds which are overly aggressive relative to the efficiency of the markets in which they invest and tax inefficient funds.

Page 52: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

52 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

What If….

If Anthony’s career experiences a downturn

Page 53: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

53 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Cash Flow Analysis: Anthony’s Career Downturn

Page 54: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

54 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

What If…

If Anthony were to become disabled

Page 55: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

55 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Cash Flow Analysis: What if Anthony Were to Become Disabled?

Page 56: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

56 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Key Takeaways

Page 57: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

57 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

!The organizational problem is alleviated by incorporating institutional best practices into individual portfolio management.

!Efficiency and scale are requirements for business and economic success requires mass customization to tailor solutions for the taxable client.

!The approach helps ensure streamlined quality of service that is consistent with our high fiduciary standards and organizational competencies.

Key Takeaways, IOrganizational

Page 58: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

58 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

!A core/satellite structure is an optimal structure for the taxable clients.

!Actively managing the core portfolio allows for efficiency and higher after-tax returns.

!The solution requires extensive system, data, and automation design but investors and organizations will achieve superior returns to the traditionally partitioned design.

Key Takeaways, IIInvestment Management

Page 59: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

59 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! It is not sufficient to concentrate on the client’s financial assets alone, we also have to focus on what these assets are going to be used for.

!Understanding the client’s goals and the priorities of those goals is a fundamental step towards building a trusted relationship.

!The Household Balance Sheet is a useful and intuitive tool to encapsulate the essential characteristics necessary for giving robust advice.

Key Takeaways, IIIUnderstanding the Client

Page 60: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

60 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

! The investment strategy is dynamic, and must be responsive to the client’s personality and risk budget.

! Strategic asset allocation and asset location are not separable but jointly determined.

! Without appropriate communication and reporting, the optimal value of a holistic approach is rarely obtained.

Key Takeaways, IVInvestment Strategy

Page 61: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

61 CONFIDENTIAL © 2007 Advisor Software, Inc.

Advisor Software and First Citizens Bank

Questions & Answers

Page 62: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

Thank YouAndrew Rudd(925) [email protected]

Eric Teal(919) (919) 716-2650 [email protected]

Advisor Software, First Citizens Bank

Page 63: Microsoft PowerPoint - WMConf20071026750PMAC_PRES_Final-v3

To Request an Electronic Copy of this Presentation:

Contact:Andrea CorryAdvisor Software, Inc.(925) [email protected]

Advisor Software, First Citizens Bank