7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
1/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 6
#$%#$&'
!"#"!$"% ' ()%* #+,!"#!- "
.""/ 01)234+5 6"74$6 "$6+5! '
.""/ 81+##29+:7$+*9 "$6+5! ;
.""/ ;1"$6+5! *< $6" "4,"%4= >
.""/ >1!$79,7%, *< 57%" ?
.""/ ?162#79 "96795"#"9$ @
.""/ @1$%79!)479$ 744*57$+*9 A
.""/ B1%"!"7%56 "$6+5! 0'
.""/ A1!23!$+$2$" ,"5+!+*9C#7/+9DE76,F"*4 0;
.""/ 0G15*9
.""/ 0?1)7$+"9$ F)%*
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
2/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 3
"##$ %&'()*+,- .#/+0. #0.,-1
()*+,-'.%/+$0'
C 12%2 .%/+$0 "3 %#$,4% 5"5)+/$,"# !"#$"%"$&'( *"+,-. (/.. "012*-'#-3 .0'((/* '&-2#2045
C 6()*+,-7 89%/#,#:&;< =2 >)9%4,-/+ ?2 ("+,$,-/+ @2 !"99)#/+
o >)9%4,-/+'()*+,-< A$,+,$/4,/# B,%C $0/$ %/-0 ,#D,B,D)/+ -")#$& /& = E "#+F =2
! G$0,-&< H"-)& "# I)&$,-% 80/'.&*/0/#- 0/-,2$. 6 "#-/*1*/-'-"2# 7*&7"'(;"J"/+< #%$ 0%/+$0 *%#%3,$&
3"4 5"5)+/$,"#
! G2:2 ."C D" C% D%3,#% 5"5)+/$,"#K ."C D" C% -"95/4% :/,#& ,# +,3% %L5%-$/#-F C :/,#& ,# 0%/+$0M
4%+/$%D N"OK P0"&% B/+)%& &0")+D *% )&%D 3"4 Q)D:9%#$&K
o
("+,$,-/+ ()*+,-< J"B%4#9%#$ 0/& -"++%-$,B% 4%&5"#&,*,+,$F /& %+%-$,B% 4%54%&%#$/$,B% "3 -"99)#,$FR -"95%++%D $"
54"9"$% 0%/+$0 "3 $0% 5%"5+%R -/##"$ ,#B/D% ,#D,B,D)/+S& 4,:0$& ,# #/9% "3 -"99)#/+ :""D 8J"&$,#;
! G$0,-&< I)&$,3,-/$,"# "3 )&% "3 &$/$%S& 5"C%4&R +,9,$& "3 :"B%4#9%#$/+ -"%4-,"#R D)$F "3 &$/$% $" $4%/$ /++
-,$,T%#& %U)/++F ,# %L%4-,&,#: 5"C%4
! O,*%4/+ 5+)4/+,&$,- D%9"-4/-F "-"%4-,B% E 5"+,-,%& #%%D $" *% Q)&$,3,%D *F 9"4/+ 4%/&"#& $0/$ 5)*+,-
-/# 4%/&"#/*+F /--%5$
o !"99)#/+ ()*+,-< V++ 3"49& "3 &"-,/+ E -"99)#,$F /-$,"# /33%-$,#: 5)*+,- 0%/+$0
! G$0,-&< W%F"#D 5"+,$,-/+ 5)*+,-2 (%"5+% 8")$&,D% "3 :"B%4#9%#$ E C 54,B/$% 3)#D&; 0/B% :4%/$%4 34%%D"9
$" )#D%4$/X% 5)*+,- 0%/+$0 ,#$%4B%#$,"#& "#" #%%D $" Q)&$,3F /-$,"#& $" 5"+,$,-/+ 5)*+,-
! V-$,"#& &)*Q%-$%D $" 9"4/+ 4%U),4%9%#$& 84%&5%-$ 3"4 ,#D,B,D)/+ /)$"#"9FR +,*%4$FR 54,B/-F E
-"#3,D%#$,/+,$FR $4/#&5/4%#-F ,# -+"&)4% "3 -"#3+,-$& "3 ,#$%4%&$;
C Y0,3$ ,# 3"-)& "3 5)*+,- 0%/+$0< ,#D,B,D)/+ "5)*+,-Z 5"5)+/$,"# 0%/+$0R [L "(4%B%#$,"#2 .%/+$0 "3 $0% 5)*+,- ,& $0%
54,9/4F %#D &"):0$ E $0% 54,9/4F ")$-"9% 3"4 9%/&)4,#: &)--%&&o 1#$%4B%#$,"# B,&,*+% /$ 5"5)+/$,"# +%B%+
o (4%B%#$,B% ,#$%4B%#$,"#&< (%4B/&,B% 80%/+$0 4,&X& %B%4FC0%4% "/++"C 5%"5+% $" 9/X% $0%,4 "C# 9,&$/X%& E
54%B%#$ #/##F &$/$%;R ,#B"+B% *)4D%#&Z 4,&X& 8#"$ %B%4F"#% *%#%3,$&;
o \/4:%$ :4")5 9/F *% 0%/+$0F 5%4&"#&R C,$0")$ -"95+/,#$& "-"#-%4# C "B%4MD,/:#"&,& 6,#-,D%#$/+"9/&7 "
#%%D $" *% 5%4&)/D%D 854%&&%DZ 3"4-%D; "%#&)4% /-$)/+ *%#%3,$&
o 1#D,B,D)/+ 0%/+$0 8W,"%$0,-&;< .)9/# 4,:0$&Z -,B,+ +,*%4$,%&R ,#D,B,D)/+ /)$"#"9FR -"#3,D%#$,/+,$FZ 54,B/-F "
5%4&"#/+,T%D
o ("5)+/$,"# 0%/+$0 8()*+,- 0%/+$0;< A$,+,$/4,/#R 5/$%4#/+,&$,-R &"-,/+ E +%:/+ 4%&5"#&,*,+,$F $" 54"$%-$ 5)*+,- 0%/+$0
-"99)#,$F "4,%#$/$,"#R :"B%4#9%#$/+ 4%&5"#&,*,+,$F "-"++%-$,B%
o \%#&,"# *%$C%%# ,#D,B,D)/+ 4,:0$& E 34%%D"9 B&2 5)*+,-S& 0%/+$0 E -"99"# :""D
C J4"C$0 ,# 5)*+,- 0%/+$0< GB%4F"#% 0/& $0% 4,:0$ $" / &$/#D/4D "3 +,B,#: /D%U)/$% 3"4 0%/+$0 /D C%++M*%,#: "3 0,9&%+3 /#D "3
0,& 3/9,+FR ,#-+)D,#: 3""DR -+"$0,#:R 0")&,#: E 9%D,-/+ -/4% E #%-%&&/4F &"-,/+ &%4B,-%& %$-2 8A].[; ".%/+$0 3"4 /++o J+"*/+ 0%/+$0< D%B%+"5,#: -")#$4,%&R ,#$%4#/$,"#/+ +%B%+
o H)4$0%4 ,#3%-$,")& D,&%/&% -"#$4"+ 8YV[YR 5/#D%9,-&R *,"$%44"4,&9;
o H)4$0%4 0%/+$0 54"9"$,"# 8&9"X,#:R /+-"0"+R #)$4,$,"#;R &-4%%#,#: 54":4/9& 8-/#-%4;R Q)&$,-% E %U),$F ,# 0%/+$0
o [L "(4%B%#$,"#R ,#D,B,D)/+ "-"++%-$,B%
()*+,-'.%/+$0'G$0,-&'
C [%B,%C "3 (.< ,#3+)%#-,#: /D)+$& $" -0/#:% $0%,4 *%0/B,"4 8%$0,-/+ E 5"+,$,-/+ ,&&)%;R /#/+FT% %33,-/-FR 0)9/# 4,:0$&R
-)+$)4/+ 4%&5%-$R %U),$FR ,#D,B,D)/+ -0",-%R )$,+,$/4,/#,&9 E -"99)#,$/4,/#,&9R -"95/$,*+% C +,*%4/+ 5+)4/+,&9
C J+"*/+ "+"-/+< ^*+,:/$,"# $" 54"$%-$ 0%/+$0 "3 $0% 5"5)+/$,"#
o J+"*/+< &$/$%9%#$& "3 0)9/# 4,:0$&
o >/$,"#/+ :"B%4#9%#$&< 4/$,3F A> D%-+/4/$,"#
o >/$,"#/+ E &$/$% :"B%4#9%#$< 5"C%4& $" +%:,&+/$%R $/LR &5%#DR 4%:)+/$%R 5)#,&0 8&%/$ *%+$ +/C& E &9"X,#: _
4%&$4,-$,"# "3 5%4&"#/+ E *)&,#%&& +,*%4$,%&;o 1#U),4%&Z -")4$ D%-,&,"#< 5)*+,- &-4)$,#F E /--")#$/*,+,$F
o G-"#"9,- E &"-,/+ ,95/-$& "3 ,#$%4B%#$,"# B&2 #"#M ,#$%4B%#$,"# 8,#%U),$,%& "3 5""4 E 4)4/+ 4%&,D%#$&;
C G$0,-/+ V,9&< ()*+,- .%/+$0 -"D% "3 G$0,-& _ ()*+,- 0%/+$0 &0")+D 54"B,D% -"99)#,$,%& C,$0 $0% ,#3"49/$,"# $0%F 0/B%
$0/$ ,& #%%D%D 3"4 D%-,&,"#& "# 5"+,-F "4 54":4/9&R /#D &0")+D -"#$/,# $0% -"99)#,$FS& -"#&%#$ 3"4 $0%,4
,95+%9%#$/$,"#
o [,:0$ $" 0%/+$0 -/4% 8&"-,%$F E ,#D,B,D)/+;
o A$,+,$F 89/L,9,T% *%#%3,$& "B%4 0/49&;
o ],&$4,*)$,B% Q)&$,-% 83/,4 D,&$4,*)$,"# "3 *%#%3,$& E *)4D%#&;
o W/+/#-% 5%4&"#/+ E -"99)#,$F :""D B&2 4%&5"#&,*,+,$F
o (4"-%D)4/+ Q)&$,-% 8%#&)4% 5)*+,- E /33%-$%D 5/4$FS& 5/4$,-,5/$,"#;
o V)$"#"9F 8-0",-%Z /-$,"#;R 54,B/-F E -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F
o
\4/#&5/4%#-F 8D,&-+"&,#: ,#3"49/$,"#;o \4)&$
C [%&"+B,#: %$0,-/+ -"#3+,-$&< =2 !0,+D4%&& ?2 Y$%C/4D&0,5 `"D%+ C $0% 1#$%4B%#$,"# O/DD%4
=2
0,+D4%&&'M'\%&$'3 4
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
3/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: :
,2 1#34,#:,#: =Z 9"4% 9"4/+ -"#&,D%4/$,"#& C,++ 54"*/*+F 54"$%-$ 5)*+,- 0%/+$0
,,2 ("+,-,%& $0/$ ,#34,#:% 9"4/+ -"#&,D%4/$,"#& ,# #/9% "3 5)*+,- 0%/+$0R *)$ 0/B% +,$$+% -0/#-% "3 4%/+,T,#:
5)*+,- 0%/+$0 :"/+&R /4% %$0,-/++F )#Q)&$,3,%D
,,,2 GB%# ,3 5"+,-,%& D" #"$ ,#34,#:% "$0%4 9"4/+ -"#&,D%4/$,"#& *)$ /4% &,95+F )#+,X%+F $" *% %33%-$,B%"
,#34,#:% 9"4/+ 4%U),4%9%#$& 8%33,-,%#$ 5)*+,- %L5%#D,$)4%R %33"4$& C"4$0C0,+%;
,B2 (+/,# 5/-X/:,#: "3 -,:/4%$$%& "V&&)95$,"#< !/55%/+ -/)&%& !-"#&)95$,"#"WA\< D,&-")#$,#:""
-"#&)95$,"# 8#" [%:)+/$,"# 195/-$ Y$/$%9%#$;2 !/B%/$< D,&5)$%& /*")$ &$/$,&$,-&Z -"#3")#D%4& 8$/L
-0/#:%&;
*2 (4"5"4$,"#/+,$F
,2
(4"*/*+% 5)*+,- 0%/+$0 *%#%3,$& a ,#34,#:%D 9"4/+ -"#&,D%4/$,"# 8*4%/-0%D /)$"#"9FZ 54,B/-F E +"C
5)*+,- 0%/+$0 ,95/-$;
,,2 [,&XZ *%#%3,$& 4/$," 8("&,$,B% B&2 >%:/$,B% 3%/$)4%&R *%#%3,$& B&2 %33%-$&;
-2 >%-%&&,$F
,2 >"$ /++ %33%-$,B% E 54"5"4$,"#/$% 5"+,-,%& /4% #%-%&&/4F $" 4%/+,T% 5)*+,- 0%/+$0 :"/+
,,2 Y$4"#: 9"4/+ 4%/&"# $" &%%X /+$%4#/$,B%R +%&& 9"4/++F $4")*+,#: 5"+,-F 8\W E 199)#,&/$,"#< ,#-%#$,B%& a
3"4-,*+% D%$/,#Z -"95)+&"4F B/--,#/$,"# 5"+,-F;
,,,2 (4"5"#%#$& "3 3"4-,*+% &$4/$%:,%& #%%D $" 0/B% &$4"#: 9"4/+ 54""3R &)55"4$/*+% %B,D%#-%Z 4%/&"#&
D2 O%/&$ 1#34,#:%9%#$
%2 ()*+,- I)&$,3,-/$,"#
?2
Y$%C/4D&0,5'` D%+'8Ab;
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
4/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 8
"##$ %2',33)4,5/0,64 #0.,-1
()*+,-': D'B',#D,B,D)/+': D'
C (/4%#$/+ /)$"#"9FR -"#&%#$R 4,:0$& E ,#$%4%&$ B&2 5)*+,- E ,#D,B,D)/+ :""D"!"#&%#$ 3"4 -0,+D4%# 81# *%&$ ,#$%4%&$R 4%+F
"# 0%4D ,99)#,$F ,3 0,:0 %#"):0 %B%# $0"):0 ,$ 9/F #"$ *% ,# -0,+DS& W1; "/DD4%&& 5/4%#$&S 4,&X 5%4-%5$,"# ,&&)%& 84,&X&
a /DB/#$/:%&R 4,&X& a B,&,*+% $0/# D,&%/&% C0%# B/--,#/$,"# 4/$%& 0,:0Z D,&%/&% 4/$%& +"C;
C O"C ,99)#,T/$,"# 4/$%& HL< &"-,/++F D,&/DB/#$/:%DZ 5""4R 34%U)%#$ 3/9,+F 9"B%&R &"+% 5/4%#$&Z 3/9,+F D,&4)5$,"#R
9"$0%4Z -0,+D4%# -04"#,-/++F ,++R D%9":4/50,- 3/-$"4& "W/44,%4& $" ,99)#,T/$,"#< &"-,/+Z ,++#%&& 3/-$"4&R /#$,MB/--,#/$,"#
-/95/,:#R &)&5,-,"# "3 -"#B%#$,"#/+ 9%D,-,#%Z 0%/+$0 -"#&)9%4,&9 E 4,&% "3 /+$%4#/$,B% [L2
C .%4D ,99)#,$F _ / $F5% "3 -"99"# :""D 80,:0 B/--,#/$,"# 4/$%&")#B/--,#/$%D *%#%3,$ CZ" 4,&X&;2 \.G[GH^[GR H/,+)4%
$" ,99)#,T%"0/49 $" "$0%4&K
o ],4%-$+F 0/49,#: /#"$0%4 ,& )&)/++F &%%# /& 9"4% &%4,")& $0/# 3/,+,#: $" *%#%3,$ /#"$0%42 WA\ ,3 54"$%-$,"# 34"9
0/49 ,& &%%# /& / */&,- 85"&,$,B%; 4,:0$R 3/,+,#: $" *%#%3,$ ,& /4:)/*+F / &,:#,3,-/#$ 0/492
o H/,+)4% $" ,99)#,T%"!0%4D ,99)#,$FZ 5)*+,- :""D "!54"$%-$,"# 34"9 0/49 84,&X& $" "$0%4 -0,+D4%# Z
)#*"4#;
C 199)#,T/$, #'5/4/D L'854,& #%4S&'D,+%99/;< B/(9C"#-/*/.- 12."-"2#8,$S& *%&$ $0/$ %B%4F"#% *% B/--,#/$%D %L-%5$ 9%; "
5)*+,- :""D C"4&% "33 ,3 $"" 9/#F *%+,%B% $0,& "0"5%3)++F #" "#% %+&% $0,#X& +,X% F")R &0"4$M$%49 %33%-$ "#+F "-,/*/ '*/
+22$ 1*&$/#-"'( !./(9C$"*/7-/$5 */'.2#. -2 02$/*'-/ ./(9 "#-/*/.-3 '. ;/(( '. 1&:("7 ,/'(-,@ '(-*&".-"7 */'.2#.
C !"95)+&,"# '[%:)+/$, #< Ab_ >" +%:,&+/$,"#R #" 9/#D/$"4F 54":4/9Z &-0""+M %#$4F 54":4/9
o 95)+& 4F< Y+ B%#,/_ `/#D/$"4F 54":4/9 3"4 h ,#3/#$Z %/4+F -0,+D0""D D,&%/&% 8#" #%%D 3"4 &-0""+ %#$4F
4%U),4%9%#$&;R "#+F 9%D,-/+ %L%95$,"#&2 `/#D/$"4F &F&$%9 -"95+%9%#$%D *F #"M3/)+$ -"95%#&/$,"# &-0%9%
8-"95)+&"4F B/--,#/$,"# ":"B%4#9%#$ "*+,:/$,"# $" %#&)4% B/--,#% &/3%$F;
o
N)/&,M 95)+& 4F< AYV_ Y-0""+ %#$4F B/--,#/$,"# 4%U),4%9%#$& 9/,#+FR B/4,/$,"# *%$C%%# &$/$%& 8%#$4F54"B,&,"#R D"-)9%#$/$,"#R %#3"4-%9%#$ E %L%95$,"#&;2 YF&$%9 0%+5& ,# 4/5,D %L-+)&,"#& D)4,#: D,&%/&%& D)4,#:
")$*4%/X&2 !4,$,-,&9 _ 9/F -/)&% D%+/F%D B/--,#/$,"#2 >"$ ,# 3"4-% ,# VAYR WA\ 0/& *%%# )4:%D *F V)&$4/+,/#
`%D,-/+ V&&"-,/$,"#
o 6 95)+& 4F7' 0 ,-%< [%&5"#&% $" >.`[! 4%-"99%#D/$,"#&2 (4"B,&,"#%D &$4%#:$0%#%D ,# >YP< GL%95$,"#&
,3< J( /DB,-%& $0/$ ,$ C")+D *% 9%D,-/++F 0/493)+ ^[ 4%+,:,")& ^[ ,& "# / 4%-":#,T%D -/$-0M)5 54":4/9 80/D *%%#
,++R *)$ #"$ ,& -/$-0,#: )5 "# B/--,#/$,"#;i (/4%#$& #%%D& $" *% -")#&%+%D *F ][ /*")$ 4,&X& "3 #"$ B/--,#/$,#: 2'
NO]M'# '3 49/+'&-0 +'%#$4F'4%U),4%9%#$'+%:,&+/$, #R'-0,+D-/4%'-%#$%4&'4%U),4%D'$ '4%- 4D'B/--,#/$, #'&$/$)&R'
&-0 +'%L-+)&, #'54 B,&, #&2'
! O"C 4/$%& ,# J!R ,##%4 W4,&*/#%R Y)#&0,#% -"/&$ E >""&/
! J"B%4#9%#$ &$4/$%:F< %L5/#&,"# "3 50/49/-F B/--,#/$,"# $4,/+ $" ,#-+)D% /D)+$ 83+)R 5%4$)&&,& E
9%/&+%&;R %M4%9,#D%4& 3"4 5/4%#$& 4% D)% D/$%& 3"4 -0,+D0""D B/--,#/$,"#&
o
1#-%#$,B% `"D%+< >" I/*R >" (/F Y$4/$%:F 8?g=j; _ 4%&$4,-$,"# ,# &-"5% "3 -"#&-,%#$,")& "*Q%-$,"# $" =2 ^*Q%-$,"#*/&%D "# /33,+,/$,"# C 3"49/++F "*Q%-$,#: 4%+,:,")& :4")5& ?2 `%D,-/+ -"#$4/,#D,-/$,"#
! WA\< 3,#/#-,/+ ,#-%#$,B%& C"#S$ ,#3+)%#-% /++R 5"+,$,-/+ -/95/,:# 8K;R 5)#,$,B% /554"/-0 9/F -/)&%
4%&,&$/#-%R #"#M/$$%#D/#-% /$ D/F -/4% 8K;R /+,%#/$%& 69%4%+F -/)$,"#&7 5/4%#$& *F 4%9"B,#: ,#-%#$,B%
3"4 D,&-)&&,"#
C ()*+,- 3)#D,#:< J/5 *%$C%%# *%&$ 54/-$,-% E 5"+,$,-/+ %L5%D,%#-Fi 1&&)% "3 -"95+/-%#-F %". ' %".5/4$,/+ -"B%4/:% *F
B/--,#%i ,&&)%& "3 %U),$F E 4%&")4-% /++"-/$,"#
C G$0,-/+ 34/9%C"4X 3"4 ,99)#,T/$,"# 54":4/9& 81&//-&R ?g=?; _ -,". ". 2#/ 1*212.'( 2#(4
o \0% 54":4/9 &0")+D *%#%3,$ $0% ,#D,B,D)/+ /#D $0% -"99)#,$F
o \/4:%$%D D,&%/&% &0")+D *% &)33,-,%#$+F &%B%4% E 34%U)%#$ $" Q)&$,3F $0% 4,&X& /#D %L5%#&% "3 $0% 54":4/9
o c)+#%4/*+% :4")5& C,$0,# $0% 5"5)+/$,"# &0")+D *% $/4:%$%D
o ^*+,:/$,"# $" 9"#,$"4 3"4 /DB%4&% %B%#$& /#D 3"4 D,&%/&% ,#-,D%#-% $" &)4% &/3%$F /#D %33%-$,B%#%&&
o
P0%# ,99)#,T/$,"#& /4% B"+)#$/4FR B/--,#% 4%-,5,%#$& "4 $0%,4 5/4%#$& "4 -/4%4& &0")+D *% :,B%# &)33,-,%#$,#3"49/$,"# $" 9/X% /)$"#"9")&R ,#3"49%D D%-,&,"#&
o 1#-%#$,B%& $" 5/4$,-,5/$% ,# 5)*+,- 0%/+$0 ,99)#,T/$,"# 54":4/9& &0")+D #"$ *% -"%4-,B%
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
5/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 7
o ()*+,- 0%/+$0 ,99)#,T/$,"# 54":4/9& D%5%#D "# 9)$)/+ $4)&$R C0,-0 9/F *% $04%/$%#%D *F -,4-)9&$/#-%& &)-0
/& %L-%&&,B% 9%D,/ 5)*+,-,$F /*")$ /DB%4&% %B%#$& /&&"-,/$%D C,$0 B/--,#%&2
"##$ %7'#0.,-1 68 0.# #+9#:+;
[%& )4-%'V++ -/$, #Z'O,9,$,#:' /4%'
C GL5%#D,$)4% "# %+D%4+F 0,:0 E 9,:0$ 0/B% +%&&Z #" *%#%3,$ E 5""4%4 ")$-"9%&
o H/,4 ,##,#:& /4:)9%#$ 8!/++/0/#;< +,9,$ -/4% $" &F95$"9 4%+,%3 /3$%4 &%$ /:% E 4%/++"-/$% &/B%D -"&$"B/4,/*,+,$F
,# 0%/+$0 &$/$)& 9%/#& $0/$ -)$ "33 ,& /4*,$4/4F2 ."C 9)-0 &0")+D C% &/B%K
o W/+/#-% *%$C%%# :"B%4#9%#$Z 3/9,+FZ ,#D,B,D)/+ 4%&5"#&,*,+,$F 3"4 -/4% "$4%#D $" ,#-4%/&% ,#D,B,D)/+
4%&5"#&,*,+,$F 8"-/4%4 *4%/X D"C#;R ,#-4%/&,#: 4%$,4%9%#$ /:%R &)5%4/##)/$,"# E 0%/+$0 ,#&)4/#-%2
o O,9,$& $" -/4% $" 54%B,")& E #%L$ :%#%4/$,"#R 0%/BF *)4D%# "# ?MQ"* 3/9,+,%& E C"9%# 4%9/,# 9/Q"4 -/4%4&
C V:% ],&-4,9,#/$,"# V-$ ?ggd
o A#+/C3)+ $" D,&-4,9,#/$% "# $0% :4")#D "3 /:%
o ],&-4,9,#/$,"# "# $0% :4")#D "3 /:% -/# *% D,4%-$ "4 ,#D,4%-$
o A#+/C3)+ $" D,&-4,9,#/$% "# $0% :4")#D "3 /:% ,# 4%+/$,"# $" C"4X E -%4$/,# "$0%4 /4%/&
o A#+/C3)+ $" D,&-4,9,#/$% "# $0% :4")#D "3 /:% ,3 / 5/4$,-)+/4 %L%95$,"# 1& /55+,-/*+%
o 1$ ,& /# "33%#-% $" D" -%4$/,# $0,#:& 4%+/$%D $" /:% D,&-4,9,#/$,"#
o A#+/C3)+ 3"4 / 5%4&"# C0"R C0%$0%4 3"4 5/F9%#$ "4 #"$R 54"B,D%& :""D& "4 &%4B,-%&R "4 9/X%& 3/-,+,$,%&
/B/,+/*+%R $" D,&-4,9,#/$% /:/,#&$ /#"$0%4 5%4&"# "# $0% :4")#D "3 $0% "$0%4 5%4&"#S& /:%
o J%#%4/+ %L%95$,"#&
! GL%95$%D 0%/+$0 54":4/9& E 5%4&"#& D%+,B%4,#: $0%9 #"$ /-$,#: )#+/C3)++F 8("&,$,B% D,&-4,9,#/$,"#%:+,:%#-% -+/,9&< -"99"#+F &%$$+%D *F 5/4$,%& $" $0% D,&5)$% 8D%3%#D/#$ ]Z 0%/+$0 &%4B,-%; *F 3,#/#-,/+
-"95%#&/$,"# 8`%D,-/+ ,#D%9#,3,%4&Z ,#&)4%4&Z `%D,-/+ ]%3%#&% ^4:/#,T/$,"#&M `]^&;R %&52 C0%# D/9/:% 34"9
*4%/-0 "3 Y^! 8,2%2 5/$,%#$ 5+/,#$,33 ,& +,X%+F $" C,#;C ],/:#"&$,- Y$4/$%:F 8`)4$/:0R J( =hhj;< =2 (4"*/*,+,$F D,/:#"&,& ?2]" #"$ 9,&& &%4,")& D,&"4D%4& @2(,$3/++& d2\0% m
`/&U)%4/D%& 8!"#D,$,"#& $0/$ 9/F #"$ 0/B% $%L$M*""X 54%&%#$/$,"#< ]%54%&&,"#R ]`R ]4):&R V#%9,/R \0F4",D ],&%/&%R
Y5,#/+ DF&3)#-$,"#R A\1; f21& $0% 5/$,%#$ $4F,#: $" $%++ 9% &"9%$0,#:K
C b,#D& "3 9%D,-/+ #%:+,:%#-%%:+,:%#-% [%B,%C%:+,:%#-% 4%-"99%#D/$,"#& 8][& $" 4%$)4# $"
Y^! *)$ $" /B",D D%3%#&% 4%+F,#: "# ,D,"&F#-4/$,- "5,#,"#& E %#&)4% /--%5$%D "5,#,"#& /4% &")#D+F */&%D;< R 8# :2($" "#% C,++ 4%Q%-$ 54%B%#$,"#&Z $4%/$9%#$& $0/$ 0/B% /+4%/DF *%%# /-0,%B%D
! (4%3%4%#-% 3"4 &$/$)& U)" ,& /# ,44/$,"#/+ *,/&
C I)&$,-%< %U),$FR 3/,4#%&& E /--%&&
o G#0/#-%9%#$& /4% / C%&$%4# ,#D)+:%#-%R C,++ ,#-4%/&% $0% ,#%U)/+,$F :/5Z D,&5/4,$,%& "5"$%#$,/+ 54"*+%9& "3
B,-$,9,T/$,"# E %#&+/B%9%#$ "3 0)9/#& *F 65"&$M0)9/#&7R ,#-4%/&%D D,&5/4,$,%& $04%/$%# D%9"-4/$,-
,#&$,$)$,"#& E D%9"-4/-F 5%4 &% ".%/+$0 &F&$%9& -/##"$ /*&"4* %L$4/ %L5%#&%& 4%+/$%D $" %#0/#-%9%#$&R *)$
54,B/$% 5/F9%#$ 4%3+%-$& E %L/-%4*/$%& ,#%U),$,%&
o
[GY(^>YGY< #/$)4/+ :%#%$,- D,33%4%#-%&Z /DB/#$/:%& :%#%4/++F #"$ -"#&,D%4%D )#3/,42 P% /+4%/DF 0/B% C,D%
&"-,/+ D,&5/4,$,%& /#FC/F2 ]%9"-4/$,- ,#&$,$)$,"#& /4% &)33,-,%#$+F 4"*)&$ $" 9/#/:% D%B%+"59%#$& E 9,#,9,T%
0/492 G#0/#-,#: $0% +%&& :,3$%D 9/F 4%D)-% $0% 5%4-%,B%D :/5
! W+)44,#: "3 %#0/#-%9%#$Z 54%B%#$,"#Z $4%/$9%#$ *")#D/4,%& &)::%&$ $0/$ &,:#,3,-/#$ :/,#& 3"4
54%B%#$,"# E $4%/$9%#$ 3"4 /++ 9/F *% 0/D B,/ %#0/#-%9%#$&R %B%# 3"4 &"9%
C Y/3%$F
o Y$/#D/4D &,D% %33%-$ -"#&,D%4/$,"#&R &"9% %#0/#-%9%#$& 9/F -/)&% D%3,-,%#-FZ 0/49 ,# /#"$0%4 /4%/R ,&&)%& "3
54,B/-F ,# %L$%4#/+ &"3$C/4% %#0/#-%9%#$ "Y/3%$F -"#-%4#& &0")+D *% 9)-0 :4%/$%4 C0%4% %#0/#-%9%#$ ,&
#"#M$0%4/5%)$,- *)$ ,954"B,#: "# #"49/+< +%&& 4,&XZ*%#%3,$ $4/D%M"33
o [GY(^>YG< )$,+,T% &$/#D/4D ,#3"49/$,"# D,&-+"&)4%R D/#:%4")& &)*&$/#-%& /4% -)44%#$+F 9/4X%$%D 8%2:2 /+-"0"+;
C +,9,$%D &/3%$F C/4#,#:&R $4/D,$,"#/+ %D)-/$,"#Z $4/,#,#: /55+,%D $" F")#: C0" -/##"$ 4/$,"#/++F 4%&5"#D 8#"#M
D%+,*%4/$%D /*&"45$,"# %2:2 0,DD%# -)44,-)+)9;2 O"C -"&$R &/3% %#0/#-%4& -/# -"#$4,*)$% $" 5)*+,- /& C%++ /&
,#D,B,D)/+ :""D&
T*'$"-"2#'( ,"+,/* /$&7'-"2# 0'4 "#7*/'./ -,/ *".K 29 :/720"#+ ' 1*29/..2* 2* "%/*."-4 $2# U ' 1*29/.."2# 7,'*'7-/*"A/$ :4
M*"/$/(( '. "#%2(%"#+ L' .(2; 0/-':2(".03 ' .(&++"., :2;/(3 ' 1/#7,'#- 92* +*'$&'(".- $27-*"#/.3 '#$ 1/$'#-*4N
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
10/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 65
"##$ %@'0:/41(+/40 /++6-/0,64
OGV[>1>J'[GY^A[ G'_'`%D,-/+'V554 /-0%&'$ ']%/$0'E']F,#:'
C ]%/$0 ,& #"$ */D _ /&&)9,#: #" &)*Q%-$ +%3$ $" 6%L5%4,%#-%7 cY2 ]%/$0 ,& */D _ D%54,B%D 34"9 5"&,$,B% :""D "3 +,3% 8)#+%&&
+,3% -%/&% $" 0/B% #%$ 5"&,$,B% B/+)% 34"9 )#,3"49+F */D %L5%4,%#-%Z *+%/X ")$+""X; "54%3%4%#-% $" D,% >^P
C .,&$"4,-/+ V&&)95$,"#< V554"/-0%& $" D%/$0 D%$%49,#%D *F -)+$)4/+ E 9%$/50F&,-/+ B,%C& V>] `%D,-,#% ,& 5/4$ "3
-)+$)4/+ 0%4,$/:% E ,#3+)%#-% )5"# ,$
o ]%/$0 /& / #/$)4/+ %B%#$R 4%+,:,")& E 9%$/50F&,-/+ E 5&F-0"+":,-/+ %B,+R >^\ 9"4/++F %B,+ "H/$/+,&9 4%Q%-$%DR
9"4/+ "*+,:/$,"# $" )&% /B/,+/*+% 9%/#& $" /B%4$ D%/$0 8C0,-0 ,& %B,+;R ][& #"$ -"#&,D%4%D 3/,+)4%& ,3 5/$,%#$&
D,%D "?g$0
!%#$)4F< 13 C% -/# /-$ $" /DB/#-% $0% &/#-$,$F "3 +,3%R $0%# C% "):0$ $" /-$
C
`%D,-/+,T/$,"# E D%#/$)4/+,T/$,"# "3 D%/$0 "&$4"#: 9"4/+ ,95%4/$,B% $" 54"+"#: +,3% "9%D,-/+ 3/,+)4% #"$ $" "
[%&5"#&%& $" D%M9%D,-/+,T% D%/$0"$ /D"5$%D *F NO]'
C
]"#/$,"# /3$%4 -/4D,/- D%/$0 8]!];< 4%#%C%D /$$%#$,"# D)% $" +"C D"#/$,"# 4/$%&R ,954"B%D C/F& "3 4%D)-,#: ,&-0%9,- E
D/9/:% $" "4:/#& 3"++"C,#: -/4D,/- D%/$0 8/#$%9"4$%9 0%5/4,#;"G$0,-/+ ,&&)%&< -"#&%#$R 0/49 $" 5/$,%#$& 34"9
/#$%9"4$%9 ,#$%4B%#$,"#'
O,B%'] #/$, #'
C O,B,#: D"#"4< 4%D)-,#: /& 9"4% X,D#%F& 34"9 D%-%/&%D D"#"4& #"C
C VDB/#$/:%&< =2 VB",D +"#: C/,$,#: $,9% 3"4 D%-%/&%D D"#"4& 8W+""D :4")5 _ ,#%U)/+,$F ,# C/,$,#: +,&$R J4")5 V *+""D
D"#"4&a ^;2 ?2 !/# *% D"#% /& 5+/##%D 54"-%D)4% @2 O"#:%4 :4/3$ &)4B,B/+ 4/$%M *%$$%4 4%&)+$&
C ],&/DB/#$/:%&^\ +,9,$%D $" 9%D,-/+ ,#$%4%&$& "#+F _ ,#-+)D%& 9%#$/+ E %9"$,"#/+ ,#$%4%&$
o
.[G!< /DB"-/-F 3"4 4%&%/4-0%4& E &)*Q%-$&! ]%-+/4/$,"# "3 .%+&,#X,< &/3%:)/4D& 4%&%/4-0 &)*Q%-$&R ,#3"49%D -"#&%#$R 9,#,9,T,#: 4,&XR /D0%4,#: $"
/554"B%D 4%&%/4-0 5+/#Z54"$"-"+
C G$0,-/+ 4%B,%C #%%D%D C0%#< =2 W%3"4% 4%&%/4-0 -/# *%:,# ?2 W%3"4% 3)++ 3)#D,#: 3"4 / 54"5"&/+ ,& 4%+%/&%D "Q)D:%9%#$
$0/$ 0)9/# 4%&%/4-0 54"5"&/+ 9%%$& 4%U),4%9%#$& "3 $0% >/$,"#/+ Y$/$%9%#$ E ,& %$0,-/++F /--%5$/*+% "O%:/+
4%U),4%9%#$& 3"4 .)9/# E V#,9/+ 4%&%/4-0
C ([1> 1(OGY] !"#&%#$
>.`[ 'Y$/$%9%#$'8VAY;'
C 1#$%:4,$F 8&")#D %$0,-/+ 4%&%/4-0 54/-$,-%;< W%3"4%R D)4,#: /#D /3$%4 -"#D)-$ "3 4%&%/4-0i (4"3%&&,"#/+ ,#$%:4,$F E ]/$/
,#$%:4,$F M -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F
C [%&5%-$ 3"4 5%4&"#&< ],:#,$F E /)$"#"9Fi P%+3/4%R 4,:0$&R *%+,%3&R -)&$"9&"!"#&,D%4 ,3 $0% 4%&%/4-0 ,#B"+B%& 5%"5+% C
,95/,4%D -/5/-,$F 8N!V\;2 .)9/# 5/4$,-,5/#$& 8B"+)#$/4F */&,&; ,#&$%/D "3 0)9/# &)*Q%-$&"5"C%4 &0,3$ "3 4%&%/4-0%4 B
&)*Q%-$
C W%#%3,-%#-%< `,#,9,T% 0/49 E D,&-"93"4$i 1D%#$,3F 4,&X $" 5/4$,-,5/#$&R &,T% "3 4,&X& E 54"*/*,+,$F "3 4,&X& %B%#$)/$,#:
C I)&$,-%< VB",D :4")5& C0" /4% &)*Q%-$ $" "B%4M4%&%/4-0,#: 8V\Y1 -"99)#,$FR &-0""+ -0,+D4%#;R )#+%&& Q)&$,3,%D 4%&%/4-0 $"
*% ,95"4$/#$ $" $0/$ :4")52 ]%&,:# 4%&%/4-0 &" $0/$ &%+%-$,"#R 4%-4),$9%#$R %L-+)&,"# E ,#-+)&,"# ,& 3/,4
C ],:#,$F E C%++*%,#:< \/X%& 54%-%D%#-% "B%4 $0% %L5%-$%D *%#%3,$& "3 X#"C+%D:%2 [,&X& E *%#%3,$& #%%D $" *% 3)++F
,D%#$,3,%D E %B/+)/$%D
F".K< W2-/#-"'( 92* ,'*03 $".72092*- 2* "#72#%/#"/#7/?
C
./49%:+,:,*+% 4,&X _ #" 3"4%&%%/*+% 4,&X "3 0/49 "4 D,&-"93"4$R #" 9"4% $0/#
,#-"#B%#,%#-%
S/#/9"-.< */./'*7, ". /-,"7'((4 '77/1-':(/ XOYZ ;,/# "-. 12-/#-"'( :/#/9"-. Q&.-"9"/. GOZ *".K. "#%2(%/$ "# -,/ 4%&%/4-0 "%2:2 J/,#&
,# X#"C+%D:%R ,#&,:0$ E )#D%4&$/#D,#:R 1954"B% &"-,/+ E ,#D,B,D)/+ C%+3/4%R YX,++Z %L5%4$,&% 3"4 4%&%/4-0%4&Z ,#&$,$)$,"#&
F".K. % S/#/9"-.
C
P%,:0 )5 /-$)/+ E 5"$%#$,/+ 4,&X B&2 /-$)/+ E 5"$%#$,/+ *%#%3,$C [,&X& E *%#%3,$& $" ,#D,B,D)/+ E -"99)#,$F< c/4,%& *%$C%%# 5%"5+%R %$0,-& -"99,$$%%&2
C V+$4),&$,- #/$)4% 85+/-% "3 /)$"#"9F B&2 %$0,-& -"99,$$%% 5/$%4#/+,&9;
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
14/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 68
C ],4%-$ 5/4$,-,5/#$ *%#%3,$ )#+,X%+F ,# 9/#F &$)D,%&R D,33,-)+$ $" C%,:0 )5 4,&X $" ,#D,B,D)/+ B&2 *%#%3,$& $" -"99)#,$F 834"9
4%&%/4-0 ")$-"9%;
1>H^[`G]' ^>YG>\'
C c/+,D -"#&%#$
o (/4$,-,5/#$& 9)&$ #"$ *% -"%4-%D "4 ,#D)-%D _ -"95%#&/$,"# 9)&$ *% 4%/&"#/*+%
o (/4$,-,5/#$& 9)&$ X#"C $0/$ $0%F /4% 5/4$,-,5/$,#: ,# 4%&%/4-02 6 `)&$ X#"C ,# D%$/,+ C0/$ ,& *%,#: /&X%D "3
$0%9 /#D C0/$ C,++ 0/55%#
o !"99)#,-/$% /#F 4,&X& 8-+%/4+F ,D%#$,3,%D;R /#F -"95%#&/$,"#
o (/4$,-,5/#$& #%%D $" X#"C 0"C $0% 54"Q%-$ C,++ *%#%3,$ $0%9&%+B%&R "$0%4 5%"5+%R "4 $0% C"4+D /$ +/4:%
o
6`)&$ X#"C $0/$ $0%,4 D/$/ C,++ *% X%5$ -"#3,D%#$,/+ 8-+%/4+F &$/$% $0/$ D/$/ C,++ *% D%M,D%#$,3,%DR #" ,#3"49/$,"#
/&&"-,/$%D C $0%,4 D/$/ C,++ ,D%#$,3F $0%9;
o (/4$,-,5/#$ 9)&$ X#"C ,3 F") 5+/# $" 5)*+,&0 D/$/ 34"9 $0% 54"Q%-$ ,# C0,-0 $0%F /4% 5/4$,-,5/$,#: 8V&&)4% $0%9
"3 -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F;
C Y,$)/$,"#& C0%# &)*Q%-$& `AY\ >^\ *% 4%-4),$%D _ C0%# &)*Q%-$&^< :)/4D,/#&0,5
o (4"B,&,"# "3 ,#3"49/$,"# ",#-+)D%< 9%$0"D&R D%9/#D&R 4,&X&R -"#B%#,%#-%&R D,&-"93"4$R 5"&&,*+% ")$-"9%& E
5)*+,-/$,"# "3 4%&)+$&
o c"+)#$/4F $" 5/4$,-,5/$%"#" -"%4-,"#R -/# C,$0D4/C /#F $,9% C,$0")$ 5%#/+$F 8%2:2 4%3)&/+ "3 [L;
o >" -"%4-,"# "5/F9%#$ $" 5/4$,-,5/$% &0")+D "#+F -"B%4 -"&$ 4%,9*)4&%9%#$
AN'Y^`'
C VOO 4%&%/4-0 $0/$ ,#B"+B%& 9"4% $0/# +"C 4,&X #%%D& 3)++ 4%B,%C %2:2
o
1#$%4B%#$,"#& E $0%4/5FZ -+,#,-/+ $4,/+R 6+,B% 4")$,#% -"++%-$,"#7 "3 0)9/# $,&&)%R 0)9/# :%#%$,-& E &$%9 -%++&R5%"5+% C ,#$%++%-$)/+Z 50F&,-/+ D,&/*,+,$FR V\Y1 E B)+#%4/*+% :4")5&R 5%"5+% ,#B"+B%D ,# ,++%:/+ /-$,B,$F
o AN H"49 ^[ >/$,"#/+ G$0,-& V55+,-/$,"# H"49 8>GVH;M 3"4 9)+$,-%#$%4 54"Q%-$&R /554"B/+ 3"4 /++ 5/4$,-,5/$,#:
,#&$,$)$,"#& "# $0% &/9% 54"Q%-$
C 6J/$%X%%5%47 V554"B/+&
o J/$%X%%5%4Z 5%49,&&,"#M :,B%4< 5%4&"# /)$0"4,T%D $" C4,$% / O%$$%4 "3 V)$0"4,$F E [%-":#,$,"# 34"9 /#
"4:/#,T/$,"# "3 /#F $F5% ,#B"+B%D C,$0 $0% 4%&%/4-0R C0,-0 :,B%& 5%49,&&,"# $" $0% 4%&%/4-0%4 3"4 /--%&& $" $0%
5"5)+/$,"# )#D%4 $0% 6:/$%X%%5%4S&< "4 65%49,&&,"#M:,B%4S&7 /)$0"4,$F
o G2:2 4%&%/4-0 ,# &-0""+& ":/$% X%%5%4 /554"B/+ l 4%+%B/#$ %D)-/$,"# /)$0"4,$F 8GD)-/$,"# N)%%#&+/#D; E
Y-0""+ 54,#-,5+%&
C (4,#-,5+%& "3 V)$0"4&0,5< c/#-")B%4 4)+%& _ /)$0"4&0,5 &0")+D *% */&%D "# &)*&$/#$,/+ -"#$4,*)$,"# $"^\ =&$
/,DR #"#M
,#$4)&,B% D,/:#"&$,- %L/9,#/$,"#&R ^\! 9%D,-/$,"#&R 3)$,+% $4%/$9%#$&'
C O,3% &)&$/,#,#: `%/&)4% _ 0%/+$0 -/4% ,#$%#D%D $" &)&$/,# "4 54"+"#: +,3% $0/$ &)55+/#$& "4 9/,#$/,#& $0% "5%4/$,"# "3
B,$/+ *"D,+F 3)#-$,"#& $0/$ /4% $%95"4/4,+F "4 5%49/#%#$+F ,#-/5/*+% "3 ,#D%5%#D%#$ "5%4/$,"# %2:2 !([R /&&,&$%D
B%#$,+/$,"#R /4$,3,-,/+ #)$4,$,"# E 0FD4/$,"#R >^\ *+""D $4/#&3)&,"#2 [%#/+ D,/+F&,& 8K; '
C P,$0D4/C/+ "J""D `%D,-/+ (4/-$,-% 84%-":#,T%D &$/#D/4D&R 54/-$,-%& E 54"-%D)4%& "3 $0% 9%D,-/+ 54"3%&&,"# E %$0,-/+
&$/#D/4D&; "(4,#-,5+%&' 3'P,$0D4/C/+'E'/-$,B/$, #' 3'V.]',#'NO]< '
o G$&(- ,'. -/*0"#'( "((#/..@ 72#$"-"2# -,'- ". "#7&*':(/@ "**/%/*.":(/ 6 -,&.3 "# -,/ 21"#"2# 29 H3 0'4 */'.2#':(4 :/
/>1/7-/$ -2 $"/ ;"-,"# [ 4/'* XF
o G$&(- ". "# ' 1/*.".-/#- %/+/-'-"%/ .-'-/ "?/? 72#$"-"2# "#%2(%"#+ ./%/*/ 6 "**/%/*.":(/ :*'"# $'0'+/ ;,"7,3
,2;/%/*3 '((2;. .20/ 2* '(( 29 -,/ 1*"#7"1'(I. %"-'( :2$"(4 9-"2#. -2 72#-"#&/ /?+? ,/'*- :/'-@ :*/'-,"#+ XF
o G$&(- ". 1/*0'#/#-(4 H#.7"2&. "?/? 72#$"-"2# "#%2(%"#+ :*'"# $'0'+/ .2 ./%/*/ -,'- -,/*/ ". #2 */'.2#':(/
1*2.1/7- 29 -,/ 1*"#7"1'( */+'"#"#+ 72#.7"2&.#/.. XF
o
G$&(- ,'. '# "((#/..@ "#Q&*4 29 .&7, ./%/*"-4 -,'- -,/*/ ". #2 */'.2#':(/ 1*2.1/7- -,'- ,/ ;"(( */72%/* -2 -,/ />-/#-
-,'- -,/ '$&(-I. ("9/ 7'# :/ .&.-'"#/$ ;"-,2&- -,/ 72#-"#&/$ '11("7'-"2# 29 ("9/C.&.-'"#"#+ 0/'.&*/.
o GOH "93 92* '*-"9"7"'( #&-*"-"2#@ ,4$*'-"2#3 "- ". 72#."$/*/$ -,'- 7200/#7"#+ 2* 72#-"#&"#+ "- ;2&($ :/ "#72#.".-/#-
; P\W
o GOH "93 1/*.2# ,'. #2 */'.2#':(/ 1*2.1/7- 29 */+'"#"#+ 7'1'7"-4 92* ,/'(-, 7'*/
C H"4 VD)+$& C ,95/,4%D -/5/-,$F< V.] "VD)+$S& :)/4D,/# 8N!V\M /55",#$%DZ 5)*+,-; "VD)+$S& /$$"4#%F 8G#D)4,#: ("C%4
"3 V$$"4#%FZ V.] ,#D,-/$%D /$$"4#%F 3"4 5%4&"#/+ 9/$$%4&; "VD)+$S& Y$/$)$"4F .%/+$0 V$$"4#%F 8)#D%4 .%/+$0 V$$"4#%FS&
V-$ "/ 5%4&"# D%-+/4%D *F +%:,&+/$,"# $" *% / 5%4&"# C /)$0"4,$F $" 9/X% D%-,&,"# /*")$ 0%/+$0 9/$$%4& 3"4 /# /D)+$
C0" D"%& #"$ 0/B% -/5/-,$F $" 9/X% $0%,4 "C# D%-,&,"#&R a=ke^R 4%/D,+F /B/,+/*+% E -)+$)4/++F /554"54,/$%;'
o ^4D%4 "3 (4,"4,$F 3"4 Y.V< &5")&%Z 5/4$#%4 8-+"&% E -"#$,#),#: 4%+/$,"#&0,5; a #"#M5/,D -/4%4 8^[ !/4%4
V++"C/#-%; a -+"&% 34,%#DZ3/9,+F a()*+,- J)/4D,/#'
C ],&5)$%&< (J -/# 9/X% 0%/+$0 D%-,&,"# %B%# ,3 $0%4% ,& / :)/4D,/#Z /$$"4#%F C0%#< =2 ],&/:4%%9%#$ *%$C%%# $0%
:)/4D,/#& $0/$ -/#S$ *% 9%D,/$%D ?2 J)/4D,/#Z /$$"4#%FS& D%-,&,"# ^[ 4%3)&/+ $" 9/X% / D%-,&,"# ,& -"#$4/4F $" $0% .%/+$0!/4% (4,#-,5+%
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
16/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 6;
o \0% /D)+$ 0/& 9,#,9/+Z #" )#D%4&$/#D,#: "3
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
17/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 69
o [%B,%C E 4%B,&,"#< 4%:)+/4 4%B,%C "3 V.] /#D 9/X% /DQ)&$9%#$& $" -0/#:,#: -,4-)9&$/#-%& 8%B%4F ? F%/4&R /3$%4
/#F +"&& "3 3)#-$,"#R 0"&5,$/+,T/$,"#R "#&%$ "3 D%54%&&,"#;
o J%#%4/+,$FZ &5%-,3,-,$F^\ &)33%4,#:
34"9 /#F -"#D,$,"# C0,-0 C")+D /33%-$ (S& -/5/-,$F $" )#D%4&$/#D $0% $0,#:& #%-%&&/4F $" 9/X% $0% V.] E $0% (
)#D%4&$/#D& $0% #/$)4% E +,X%+F %33%-$ "3 $0% D%-,&,"#& ,# $0% V.]2
o 195+%9%#$,#:'8r;^< ^*$/,# -"#&%#$Z 4%3)&/+ H"49 ,2%2 V.]R ,3 +,9,$,#: -"#D,$,"#& 9%$
"13 V.] D"%& #"$ -"B%4Z >^ V.] "!"#&)+$ J)/4D,/# 8,3 = ,& /55",#$%D *F N!V\; "13 >^ J)/4D,/#"!"#&)+$
/$$"4#%F /55",#$%D )#D%4 /# G(V "13 >^ /55",#$%D /$$"4#%F"!"#&)+$ Y$/$)$"4F .%/+$0 V$$"4#%F ",3 >^
^>G /B/,+/*+%"!"#&)+$ $0% ^33,-% "3 $0% ()*+,- J)/4D,/#
"##$ &%'-648,9#40,/+,0; /49 (:,N/-;
#0.,-1
#3,D%#$,/+,$F
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
18/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 6/$,"#/+ (4,B/-F (4,#-,5+%& 3"4 N.S& 0/#D+,#: "3 5%4&"#/+ ,#3"49/$,"#
8b1c !S$0 (4,B/-F V-$;R -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F E 54,B/-F ,# 54,B/$% 9%D,-/+ &%-$"42 (4,#-,5+%& -"B%4 $0% -"++%-$,"#R
&$"4/:%R )&%R D,&-+"&)4%R $4/#&3%4 "3 E /--%&& $" D/$/ ,#-+)D,#: 0%/+$0 ,#3"49/$,"#R 4,:0$ $" /9%#D
,#/--)4/$% 4%-"4D&
,B2 .%/+$0 (4/-$,$,"#%4 [%:)+/$,"# >/$,"#/+ O/C V-$R J`( 8!"D% "3 !"#D)-$;< (/$,%#$& 0/B% 4,:0$ $" %L5%-$
$0/$ ] E $0%,4 &$/33 C,++ 0"+D ,#3"49/$,"# /*")$ $0%9 ,# -"#3,D%#-%R )#+%&& 4%+%/&% "3 ,#3"49/$,"# ,&4%U),4%D *F +/C "4 5)*+,- ,#$%4%&$ -"#&,D%4/$,"#2
B2 [,:0$ $" 1#3"49/$,"# V-$ ?ggh 8NO];< 4,:0$ "3 ,#D,B,D)/+& $" /--%&& ,#3"49/$,"# 0%+D "4 -"#$4"++%D *F $0%
:"B%4#9%#$ B,/ H^1 54"-%&&
B,2 V--%&& $" 9%D,-/+ 4%-"4D& #"$ 4%-":#,T%D ,# -"99"# +/CR 8W4%%# B P,++,/9& _ 4%-"4D& /4% 54"5%4$F "3
][Z ."&5,$/+R #" 4,:0$ "3 /--%&&;R 4%U),4%& +%:,&+/$,B% 54"B,&,"# "3 /--%&& "V--%&&Z 4,:0 $" /9%#D
4%-"4D& /B/,+/*+% B,/ &$/$)%& 81(VZ[1V;
#OIPQRHSMT RS UPPQHMV -SMWHLPMRHJGHRX
=2 O%:/++F `/#D/$"4F ],&-+"&)4%
/2 >"$,3,/*+% -"#D,$,"#& E "$0%4 &$/$)$"4F #"$,3,-/$,"#&< ()*+,- .%/+$0 V-$R >"$,3,/*+% !"#D)-$Z >/$,"#/+
[%:,&$4/$,"# Y-0%9% 8&%L)/+ ,#/554"54,/$%#%&&R ,95/,49%#$R ,#$"L,-/$,"# /$ C"4XR 5""4 -+,#,-/+ &$/#D/4D&;R
.%/+$0 1#&)4/#-% V-$ 8`%D,-/4% 34/)DR (Y[;R \4/33,- V-$ 85"+,-% ,#B%&$,:/$,"#;
*2
!")4$ "4D%4&< &)*5"%#/ 8"3 4%-"4D&R "3 ] $" /55%/4;R C4,$ "3 #"#M5/4$F D,&-"B%4F 8&)55+F ,#3" "# 5/4$,-)+/4 %B%#$R#"$ $0% %#$,4% 4%-"4D; ,2%2 ] $4%/$& &"9%"#% ,#B"+B%D ,# $4/33,- /--,D%#$R +/CF%4 -/# 4%U)%&$ ] $" &)55+F 9%D,-/+
4%-"4D&Z /55%/4 ,# -")4$2
-2 ],&-,5+,#/4F 9/$$%4& 8,#3" :,B%# $" 0%/+$0 54/-$,$,"#%4 *"/4D ,# -")4&% "3 ,#B%&$,:/$,"# ,#$" -"95%$%#-%R -"#D)-$
"4 ,95/,49%#$;
D2 Y)*&$,$)$% ]%-,&,"# 9/X%4& 8/$$"4#%F& 0/B% /--%&& $" ,#3"49/$,"# 3"4 DM9 )#D%4 (^V V-$ =hhkR /+$0"):0
$%-0#,-/++F / C/,B%4 "3 -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F *F 54,#-,5/+;
?2 (/$,%#$ -"#&%#$Z ,95+,%D -"#&%#$
/2 `%D !%4$& 85/$,%#$ C/#$& F") $" *4%/-0 0,& -"#3,D%#$,/+,$FZ ,95+,%D -"#&%#$;R 4%3%44/+R 54%&-4,5$,"#& 8-0%9,&$
X#"C& F")4 -"#D,$,"#;R 4%5"4$& $" @4D
5/4$,%& 8,#&)4/#-%R /+&" %L5+,-,$ C4,$$%# -"#&%#$;"!"#&%#$ $" D,&-+"&%
"#+F -%4$/,# 9/$%4,/+ 8@4D
5/4$,%& 0/B% D)$F "3 -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F;
*2 ]%&,:#/$%D 5%4&"#& ,#-+)D%& 9%D,-/+ &$)D%#$&
@2
`%D,-/+ [%&%/4-0< +%:,&+/$,"# 54"$%-$& 5%4&"#/+ D%$/,+& 8(4,B/-F V-$; n ]%M,D%#$,3,-/$,"# "3 D/$/ n G$0,-& -"99,$$%%4%&%/4-0 /554"B/+ 4%U),4%& /D0%4%#-% $" >.`[! :),D%+,#%& 3"4 54"$%-$,"# "3 54,B/-F E 4%U),4%9%#$&
d2 !"#3,D%#$,/+,$F E :%#%$,-& 8:%#%$,-/++F $4/#&9,$$%D D,&%/&% ,#B"+B,#: 4%+/$,B%&; ">/$,"#/+ Y$/$%9%#$ ?ggmM D,&-+"&)4%
/++"C/*+% CZ" -"#&%#$2 VO[!ZV.G! 4%-"99%#D& -"#D,$,"#/+ D,&-+"&)4% C0%4% $0%4% ,& &%4,")& 4,&X2
f2 N)/+,$F V&&)4/#-%< ,#3"49/$,"# &0/4%D 3"4 NV 5)45"&%& *)$ -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F 4%U),4%D *%F"#D -"99,$$%% 54"-%&&
j2 ()*+,- 1#$%4%&$ GL-%5$,"#< &$/$)%& 4%U),4% *4%/-0%& E 54"$%-$ D"-$"4& ,# 9/#F *)$ >^\ /++ -/&%&2 >" 3/,+M&/3% :),D/#-% /&
$" 0"C $" C%,:0$ ,#$%4%&$& %2:2 ,# V`V !"D% "3 G$0,-&Z /#F "$0%4 +/C& "!"#&,D%4 / -/&% "3 54"*/*+% ,#3+,-$,"# "3 &%4,")&
0/49 "# /#"$0%4 *F / 5/$,%#$ "%2:2 D"9%&$,- B,"+%#-% _ ] 3%%+& -"95%++%D $" *4%/-0 -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F "O%:/+
Q)&$,3,-/$,"# 3"4 *4%/-0,#: -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F lZl O%:/+ D)$F $" C/4#
/2 ])$F $" C/4#< ,95"&,$,"# "# ] C0,-0 54"B,D%& / @4D
5/4$F C */&,& 3"4 &),#: ] C0" 3/,+%D $" C/49 $0%9 "3
&,:#,3,-/#$ 4,&X 8AY \/4/&"33 54%-%D%#$;">^ VAY 54%-%D%#$R >^ %&$/*+,&0%D +%:/+ D)$F $" C/4#
*2 O%:/+ Q)&$,3,-/$,"# 3"4 *4%/-0,#: -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F9(: '
-S[[PKIHJGH\JRHSM
M !"45"4/$,T/$,"#< !S$0 ,#-%#$,B%& 3"4 &9/++Z&"+" 54/-$,-%& $" /9/+:/9/$%":""DC,++Z ,#-"9%Z 3+%L,*,+,$FZ +%&& 4%D $/5% /&
,#-%#$,B%& $" J(&"V++%:%D 54"*+%9& "3 4%D)-%D 54/-$,$,"#%4 ,#D%5%#D%#-%R "B%4M&%4B,-,#:R 4%D)-%D J(& 3"4
4)4/+Z4%9"$% /4%/& E 0"9% B,&,$&R -"#&)9%4 9"D%+ /33%-$,#: 54"3%&&,"#/+ &$/#D,#:Z 4%5)$/$,"# E -"99%4-,/+
%L5+",$/$,"#
o
!"#3+,-$& "3 ,#$%4%&$< -+,#,-/+ 54/-$,-% :),D%+,#%& D%B%+"5%D *F 5/#%+ 9%9*%4& C -"##%-$,"#&R :0"&$ C4,$,#: *FD4): -"95/#,%&Z 5u54"3%&&,"#/+ C4,$%4&R \c %#D"4&%9%#$& *F D"-$"4&
M @ !%#$)4,%& "3 -0/#:%
o =k$0
!< #" )#,3"49 %#$4F $" 9%D,-,#%R #" 9%D,-/+ %D)-/$,"#Z +,-%#&,#:R -"#$4/-$)/+ ]([R 54,9/4,+F &%+3M,#$%4%&$"
I"0# J4%:"4F 8=mm?;< D)$F "3 -/4%Z $4)&$Z -"99,$9%#$< 3,D)-,/4FR -"99%4-,/+ 9%D,-,#% ,#-"95/$,*+% C *%&$
,#$%4%&$ 8D4,B%# *F &-,%#$,3,- /DB/#-%9%#$&"/)$0"4,$F "3 ]& "$4)&$;"$4)$0 $%++,#:R -"#3,D%#$,/+,$F
o =h$0
!< &-,%#$,3,- */&,& 3"4 9%D,-,#%R "4:/#,T%D 9%D,-/+ %D)-/$,"# E &,:#,3,-/#$ &"-,/+ &$/$)& /--"4D%D $" 9%D,-/+
54"3%&&,"# "9%D,-/+ +,-%#&,#: 8&"-,/+ -"#$4/-$;R "&$4/-,T,#: 6U)/-X&7 E 4%Q%-$,#: /DB%4$,&,#: "]( -"#$4/-$& "4
C/,B%4 "3 3%%& 3"4 5""4
o ?g$0
!< (4"3%&&,"#/+ &%+3M4%:)+/$,"#R %L-+)&,"#& */&%D "# &-,%#-%R 4%&$4,-$%D -"95%$,$,"# E 4%&$4,-$%D /DB%4$,&,#:
"3%% 3"4 &%4B,-% 8] /& ,#D,B,D)/+ ( /DB"-/$%&; "50F&,-,/# ,#$%4%&$ 854"3%&&,"#/+ C"4+D; l 5/$,%#$ ,#$%4%&$
8-"99%4-,/+ C"4+D;2 OV\G[< 0%/+$0 -/4% 9"4% %33%-$,B%R *)$ -"&$+F C ,#&)4/#-% &F&$%9R 3%%M3"4M&%4B,-% E 0,:0
5/$,%#$ D%9/#D"&$4/,# "# 5)*+,- 3)#D,#: "#%%D ,#-%#$,B%& $" 4%D)-% &%4B,-%& *F< D%-4%/&,#: 54"B,D%4
#)9*%4&R 3%% 4%&$4,-$,"#& E &$)D%#$ #)9*%4 4%&$4,-$,"#& 8*)$ #"C A#,Z-"99%4-,/++F D4,B%#;
! >"C< D"-$"4&Z 0%/+$0 &F&$%9& %L5%-$%D $" *% 54/-$,-,#: ,# -"&$ &%#&,$,B%Z -"&$M/C/4% C/F "*%&$
,#$%4%&$ E 4%/&"#/*+% -/4% /-U),4% / -"&$ -"95"#%#$ 8(WYR -"95%$,$,"# 5"+,-F E 9/#/:%D -/4% ,# AY;
"*)$ #"$ %L5+,-,$+F /-X#"C+%D:%D
M ]%4%:)+/$,"# E /DB%4$,&,#:< >/$,"#/+ [%:,&$4/$,"# E V--4%D,$/$,"# Y-0%9% 8?g=g; ,2%2 >/$,"#/+ O/C_ 8>/$,"#/+
!"95%$,$,"# ("+,-F;0%/+$0 54"3%&&,"#/+& "*%F& +/C "3 -"95%$,$,"# 89"4% -"#&)9%4 -0",-% )#+%&& 5)*+,- ,#$%4%&$
Q)&$,3,-/$,"#R ,95+,-/$,"#& 3"4 %D)-/$,"# /#D $4/,#,#:R /DB%4$,&,#:; "&=@@ VDB%4$,&,#: 8.%/+$0 (4/-$,$,"#%4 [%:)+/$,"#
>/$,"#/+ O/C V-$ ?ggh;"
o >"$0,#: $0/$ ,& 3/+&%R 9,&+%/D,#:R D%-%5$,B%R "33%4& :,3$R D,&-")#$ "4 ,#D)-%9%#$& $" /$$4/-$ 5%4&"# )#+%&& $%49&
E -"#D,$,"#& "3 $0% "33%4 /4% &$/$%D2 >"$0,#: $0/$ )&%& $%&$,9"#,/+&R -4%/$%& /# )#4%/&"#/*+% %L5%-$/$,"# "3
*%#%3,-,/+ $4%/$9%#$ "4 %#-")4/:%& ,#D,&-4,9,#/$%Z )##%-%&&/4F )&% "3 4%:)+/$%D 0%/+$0 &%4B,-%&2
o W%#%3,$&< -"&$ %33,-,%#-,%&R 4%D)-$,"# ,# 9%D,-/+ 9"#"5"+,%&R *%$$%4 ,#3"49/$,"# 54"B,&,"# 3"4 5/$,%#$ D%-,&,"#M
9/X,#:R /DB%4$,&,#: 4%D)-%& 9%D,-/+ 5/$%4#/+,&9R 54"$%-$,"# /:/,#&$ )#3/,4 $4/D,#:o (4"*+%9&
! [%:)+/$"4F 9%-0/#,&9& #%%D%D $" 54"$%-$ ( 34"9 5"C%4 D,33%4%#-%&
! !"99%4-,/+,T/$,"# a /+$4),&$,- B/+)%&M 9%D,-/+ -/4% /& 54"D)-$ ",#-4%/&%& D%9/#D /#D C,D%#& &-"5%
"3 9%D,-,#%
! VDB%4$,&,#: -4%/$%& D%9/#D& "C/#$& ,#&$%/D "3 #%%D&R 9/4X%$ 9"D%+& ",#%U),$,%&
! !"45"4/$,T/$,"#Z 5)*+,- +,&$,#:Z 9/#/:%D -/4%< 54"3,$& #"$ 0%/+$0i +,9,$& "# -/4%2 !+,#,-/+ D%-,&,"#& 9/D%
*F $%4$,/4F 5/F%4& "&0,3$ ,# -+,#,-/+ /)$"#"9F
! O%:/+ /DB%4$,&,#: -/# *4,#: 54"3%&&,"# ,#$" D,&4%5)$%2
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
24/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 38
"##$ &7'(/0,#40 1/8#0;'
(JRHPMR 1JWPRX
M Y/3%$F l &$/$% ,# C0,-0 4,&X 0/& *%%# 4%D)-%D $" /# /--%5$/*+% +%B%+
M .)9/# %44"4 _ @ +%B%+& "3 0/49^\ ,#$4,#&,-/++F */D "4 9"4/++F C4"#: WA\ 0%/+$0 -/4% 54"3%&&,"#/+& %L5%-$ ,#D,B,D)/+ 5%43%-$,"#Z
54"3%&&,"#/+,&9 /#D ,#&$,$)$,"#/+ -)+$)4% $%#D& $" *+/9% $0% ,#D,B,D)/+ C,$0")$ $0% *,::%4 5,-$)4% 8,2%2 0"C U),-X+F F")
"C# )5K Y/3%$F E D,&-+"&)4% ,&&)%&K [%5"4$,#: -)+$)4%K;"(4"$%-$,"# 9%-0/#,&9< %$0,-& -"99,$$%% $" 54"$%-$ $0%
D"-$"4 C0%# 0/49 0/& *%%# ,#-)44%D "# / (R D%/+& C,$0 $0% 3/9,+F E B,-$,9R *)$ 4%U),4%& ] $" -""5%4/$%
o G44"4 D)% $" H/$,:)% _ X#"C,#: C0%4% F")4 +,9,$& /4%< .VO\ 8.)#:4FR V#:4FR O/$%R \,4%D;
M G44"4 D)% $" YF&$%9 ]%&,:#< &F&$%9 ,& "#+F /& &/3% /& ,$ ,& D%&,:#%D $" *%
M VDB%4&% GB%#$& -"99"#+F "--)4 D)% $"< -"99)#,-/$,"# 3/,+)4%R 5""4 $%/9C"4XR .VO\ E 54"3%&&,"#/+ -)+$)4% !:('0"#+
7&(-&*/< /**2*. %"/;/$ '. 9'"("#+. -,'- .,2&($ :/ :('0/$3 72**/7-"%/ '7-"2#. 927&. 2# "#$"%"$&'( 02*/ -,'# .4.-/0.?
X*+'#"A'-"2#'( 7&(-&*/ %'(&/. 1*2$&7-"2# c .'9/-43 $2/. #2- .&112*- .'9/-45">"*+% E Q)&$ -)+$)4% 8C0%# 0/49 0/55%#&M
,& $0% 5/$,%#$ &/3%K ."C ,& $0% D"-$"4K P0/$ #%%D& $" *% D"#% #%L$K ."C D,D $0% &F&$%9 -"#$4,*)$% $" $0,&K 1& $0% ]S&/-$,"# /--")#$/*+% $" 0,& -"++%:%S& %L5%-$/$,"#; "YF&$%9 #%%D& $" *% 0%+D $" /--")#$ /& C%++R &$4,X,#: / */+/#-%
*%$C%%# -"&$ "3 0%/+$0-/4% 54"D)-$,"# /#D 5/$,%#$ &/3%$F
o V)&$4/+,/# >/$,"#/+ G9%4:%#-F $/4:%$< /++ 5/$,%#$& /D9,$$%D $" G] #%%D& $" *% ")$ "3 $0% G] C,$0,# d0 _
/D9,$$%DZ D,&-0/4:%D"VDB%4&% GB%#$& 89"&$+F ,# +/&$ ?g9,# "3 $0% d0;
o (^Y\ _ 5/$,%#$ ")$ "3 &$4%$-0%4 $,9% 8NO]Z J"+D !"/&$; &$"55%D 4/95,#: /9*)+/#-%& 8/9*)+/#-%& C 5/$,%#$&
"# &$4%$-0%4& 9/#/:%D ")$&,D% $0% G] D)% $" +/-X "3 *%D &5/-%; "W)$ /9*)+/#-% U)%)% C/,$,#: ")$&,D% G]
o NO] 0%/+$0 *)D:%$,#: ,#-4%/&,#: $"" %L-%&&,B%+F _ 0,:0 &/+/4,%& $" ]& / 54"*+%98`^!Vd _ `%D,-/+ ^33,-%4&
!"#$4/-$ V:4%%9%#$;
0S ,[QKS]P (JRHPMR 1JWPRX
=2 YC,&& !0%%&% `"D%+
?2
1#&$,++ -)+$)4% "3 &/3%$F 8/$$,$)D%& E *%0/B,"4;@2 Y/3%$F `/#/:%9%#$ YF&$%9 8%#-")4/:% 4%5"4$,#: E
VDB%4&% GB%#$ /#/+F&,&; _ 3"-)& "# +%/4#,#: 34"9
9,&$/X%&
/2 VDB%4&% GB%#$ /#/+F&,& l U)/+,$F ,954"B%9%#$
$""+ $0/$ )&%& / &F&$%9& /554"/-0 $"YGNAG> GY
7/24/2019 Medical Ethics SEM 2
26/27
!"#$% '$()* +,$%#- ./0%/1 !/(2 34 3567 8397:::: 3;
o >%B%4 )&,#: F")4 54"3%&&,"#/+ 5"&,$,"# $" %&$/*+,&0 "4 5)4&)% / &%L)/+R %L5+",$/$,B% "4 "$0%4 ,#/554"54,/$%
4%+/$,"#&0,5 C /#F*"DF )#D%4 F")4 -/4%R ,#-+)D,#: $0"&% -+"&% $" $0% ( 8-/4%4R :)/4D,/#R &5")&%R 5/4%#$ "3 -0,+D
5/$,%#$;"Y%L)/+ *")#D/4,%& */&%D "# ]([ E $4)&$R 5"C%4 ,9*/+/#-%R +"&& "3 "*Q%-$,B,$F E 5/$,%#$ &/3%$F
o VB",D %L54%&&,#: ]S& "C# 5%4&"#/+ *%+,%3& $" ( ,# C/F& $0/$ %L5+",$ $0%,4 B)+#%4/*,+,$F "4 $0/$ /4% +,X%+F $" -/)&%
$0%9 D,&$4%&&
M [%5"4$,#: ^*+,:/$,"#< ] 0/B% &$/$)$"4F "*+,:/$,"#& )#D%4 $0% >/$,"#/+ O/C $" 4%5"4$ B/4,")& 54"-%%D,#:& "4 3,#D,#:& $"
$0% `WV E 54"3%&&,"#/+ "*+,:/$,"#& $" 4%5"4$ $" $0% 9%D,-/+ *"/4D /#D $0%,4 %95+"F%4 ,3 $0%F 0/B% 0/D /#F +,9,$/$,"#&
5+/-%D "# $0%,4 54/-$,-%"1#-+)D%&